Sarah Allen, Julia Molinaro & Michelle Shen: Your Emergency Marketing Plan
Our panel helps you prepare for, and respond to, emergencies with your digital marketing and fundraising. They also help you steward your new donors. They’re Sarah Allen from BRAC USA, along with Julia Molinaro and Michelle Shen, with The Purpose Collective. (This is part of our coverage of the 2025 Nonprofit Technology Conference.)
Jonathan Meagher-Zayas: Your More Diverse Board
Board diversity remains a challenge and Jonathan Meagher-Zayas wants to support you in diversifying. See the difference between, “We welcome everyone” and “We created this space with you in mind.” He’s got recruitment and retention strategies and explains how you can leverage technology. Jonathan is at Equity Warrior Strategies. His shared resources are Change Model; 5 Domains of Anti-oppressive Leadership; and DEI research. (This is also from our #25NTC coverage.)
We’re the #1 Podcast for Nonprofits, With 13,000+ Weekly Listeners
Board relations. Fundraising. Volunteer management. Prospect research. Legal compliance. Accounting. Finance. Investments. Donor relations. Public relations. Marketing. Technology. Social media.
Every nonprofit struggles with these issues. Big nonprofits hire experts. The other 95% listen to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio. Trusted experts and leading thinkers join me each week to tackle the tough issues. If you have big dreams but a small budget, you have a home at Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio. View Full Transcript
And Welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. I’m your aptly named host and the podfather of your favorite hebdominal podcast. Oh, I’m glad you’re with us. I’d be thrown into neurochoroiditis if I saw that you missed this week’s show. Here’s our associate producer, Kate, to tell us what’s up this week. Hey Tony, we’re wrapping up our 2025 nonprofit technology conference coverage. First, Your emergency marketing plan. Our panel helps you prepare for and respond to emergencies with your digital marketing and fundraising. They also help you steward your new donors. They are Sarah Allen from BAC USA along with Julia Molinaro and Michelle Chen, both with the Purpose Collective. Then Your more diverse board, board diversity remains a challenge, and Jonathan Mahars Dias wants to support you in diversifying. See the difference between we welcome everyone. And we create this space with you in mind. He’s got recruitment and retention strategies and explains how you can leverage technology. Jonathan is at Equity Warrior Strategies. On Tony’s take 2. Thank you and 10, and Kate and I are together this week. So I’m, she is in the, she’s actually in the Podfather seat because she does most of the talking for this, these, uh, this part that we put together, uh, into the show together. So I’m standing and so I probably, I probably don’t sound so good, but, uh, I’m here, we’re here together, together. Here is your emergency marketing plan. What Hello and welcome to Tony Martignetti nonprofit radio coverage of 25 NTC. This interview is kicking off the 3rd day, Friday, of the conference. We’re at the Baltimore Convention Center, and our coverage of 25 NTC is sponsored by Heller Consulting technology services for nonprofits. With me now are Sarah Allen, Julia Molinaro, and Michelle Shen. Welcome. Thank you. Thanks for having us pleasure. Uh, Sarah is communications manager at BA BA BAC USA. Julia Molinaro is digital marketing director at the Purpose Collective, and Michelle Shen, digital marketing consultant at the Purpose Collective. All right, welcome. Thanks again. I know I said. You’re very welcome. Glad to talk to you in the morning. We’re talking about, uh, emergency marketing plans. Your session title is one less thing to worry about in a Crisis Prep your emergency marketing plan. Um, let’s start close here. Sarah, why don’t you just give us an overview of the topic you’ve done your session already? Yeah, we were first session of the week. give us an overview. Yeah, so, um, I work at Brack we’re a big international NGO um focused on poverty related programs and recently we ran a big emergency campaign this past summer, um, in response to some really devastating floods in Bangladesh that were some of the worst floods they’ve had in 3. Decades um so we worked really closely with uh the purpose collective Julia and Michelle to kind of launch a really comprehensive marketing plan um work on you know trying to attract new donors and also um kind of convert them steward them and keep them in our world and so our session kind of went through that case study. Um, did a little bit of background on, you know, how you could set up your emergency marketing strategy, and we shared a checklist with all the resources and the processes that we used, um, in order to kind of launch our emergency response. So OK, let’s be sure to email me the link in the show notes. OK. Um, so Sarah, is this a plan that you had prepared in advance? Did you have an emer this is, uh, one less thing to worry about in a crisis. Did you have this set up in advance? Yeah, so, um, a few years back we had, you know, another emergency, um, the Rohingya refugee crisis that impacted our work and, um, brought in a ton of donors, not. You know, kind of on accident we didn’t really do anything but we got this big mention in the New York Times totally broke our donation systems. So in response to that we kind of set up this emergency marketing strategy over the last few years and this past summer was really like the first big test of that checklist and that strategy and so. Um, you know, it was our first time testing it. We’ve kind of been refining it since then and um used it a couple of times since, so, um, we’ve kind of, we’re starting to not perfect it but you know, we’re getting, getting to use it more and kind of refining it over time. OK. Um, Julia, let’s, I’m just kinda going through your, uh, your session description, um, so basically we’re talking about preparing for emergency. So an emergency marketing plan, why don’t you kick us off with what what belongs in your emergency marketing plan. Yeah, so just to to back up a step and frame it, we wanted to bring this session because emergencies are. They’re happening a lot more they’re increasing in frequency but then also intensity so because of climate change, especially and then also political climate, economic disasters, global conflicts, um, we’re seeing a lot more of these crises and they’re more intense and we’re more aware of them, right, because we have our phones, news 24/7, social media, we’re so aware that they’re happening. And so of course it’s a big challenge for nonprofits because there’s 300 million people right now who need humanitarian aid but then also this huge opportunity to connect those people who are finding out about the crisis on social media and the news with an opportunity to do good and so the parts of the marketing plan. We start by preparing um the things you can get done now before any crisis is even on the horizon so thinking about yeah where people are finding you so that’s Google ads Facebook ads, news articles, social media people learn about the crisis exactly yeah where are people learning about that crisis yeah so yeah news, social media, Google ads Facebook ads, what else would you add to that? Yeah I mean yeah advertising I mean billboards, it could be news coverage, it can be partner organizations it can be events it can really be anything for your organization um I think it’s important for every organization to think about their reach, how they’re connecting or how supporters are learning about any emergency that they have going on um and to ensure that they have a presence on each of those in each of those places. OK, right, you wanna, you wanna be where your folks are I mean hopefully you already are. But you wanna I guess reinforce this in your in your emergency plan, right. And when you’re kind of thinking about those channels where folks are, you know what you can kind of do in advance is set up some templates maybe you know you have a really big email list and that’s where most of your gifts come in maybe set up an emergency email template where you could drop in photos you could drop in stats, um, same with ads or maybe you wanna have some emergency graphics that you could adapt on social or other channels. So those are some of the kind of checklist items that we have in that pre-plan section. Um, that you can kind of get started on ahead of time. OK, right, uh, let’s, I don’t want to just keep going, uh, you know, Sarah, Julia, Michelle, Sarah, Julia, Michelle, because that’s the way they’re seated. So I’m gonna go to Michelle. Um, what else? All right, so, uh, once we know what, what platforms, what apps, etc. what, what channels are folks are gonna be in, so those are the ones we’re gonna use in our emergency plan as we’re executing the plan in a, in the midst of a crisis, right? That’s where we’re gonna, you know, that’s where our folks are, that’s where we’re gonna be. And presumably we already, like I said, presumably we already are there. But the crisis are the channels we’re OK now. Yeah, so I think we covered um when when an emergency happens that’s a little bit unpredictable but we know organizations are going to face are going to face crisis um so while the the when we may not know that exact moment, um we do know that it’s going to happen and we can plan ahead based on some of these templates or um preparing some content uh that’s ready to go or easy to. Um, prepare once that emergency does strike, um, the where, uh, where we’re connecting with our audience hopefully we have a presence here already and we’re just prepared for, um. Using assets when that emergency does happen um and to make our audience as aware as possible I would say the last piece of this is like what? what are you sharing with that audience um hopefully you’re keeping your audience as informed as possible about the situation unfolding with whatever crisis you’re responding to. Um, it’s really important to be, uh, accurate in what you’re sharing, um, telling stories that you have permission to tell, um, emergencies in nature are hectic, they’re stressful, um, they’re unfolding really quickly and for the folks or you know whoever is experiencing that emergency it’s a really challenging time and we wanna make sure that we’re not contriving or exaggerating an emergency but in fact. We’re um sharing an accurate uh depiction of what’s happening uh because likely your supporters are um they’re coming to you for information you might be their first touch point in what’s happening in any specific area uh so it’s it’s crucial that it’s as accurate as possible and it’s yeah with permission uh to share all of these stories and all of these updates from from that emergency responding to. And I think the second half of what is um how you’re following up with your supporters so once they have taken action, once they’ve made a donation, once they’ve joined in to support uh in responding to this emergency um how are you stewarding them? How are you following up? How are you keeping them informed um we’re gonna we’re gonna get to that because we don’t wanna just raise it as a question we’re gonna get answers because I don’t want you holding out on nonprofit radio. So we’re gonna, but thank you. I’m, I’m sorry, Michelle, um, for ticking off things and we’re gonna go into more detail. Um, I want to ask, turn to you, Julia about permission. So Michelle mentioned, you know, what do you have permission to share? How are you, how do you get permission? Sarah said, you have some, hopefully you have some elements prepared. I mean, that’s hard too though. You don’t know where a flood’s gonna happen. You don’t know. I mean, it could be Bangladesh, it could be Cambodia, you know, so I don’t, maybe we’ll come back to that. How do you know what to have in advance? But what about permission? How do you get this permission that Michelle’s referring to in the midst of a crisis? Yeah, so permission from people whose stories you’re telling. Yeah, so it’s really tricky, of course, because it’s this vulnerable situations and we don’t wanna exploit people who are in a really tough um situation so a lot of the times we’ll rely on like an organization staff. On the ground staff members who already set up um like in Brack’s example in Bangladesh and they were experiencing this crisis but you had a presence in Bangladesh, yeah, we’re actually headquartered in Bangladesh um and yeah it’s kind of an interesting flipping the typical model upside down. So here in the US I’m at Brock USA we’re kind of the 501c3 affiliate, but we are much smaller and mostly fundraising and. Um, advocacy and communications, so headquartered in Bangladesh in Dhaka, yeah, and then we have a presence kind of all over the country as well as 13 other countries around South Asia and Africa. OK, so then Julia, I guess the permission wasn’t too hard to get. Right, if it’s a staff member, they are often likely to give you permission and it’s a really they can still share it. The organization is if it makes sense for them to respond to that emergency um sharing even sharing photos a photo can tell a story so if you don’t have those um direct connection set up and. You don’t want to go up to someone who just lost their home in a flood and ask them to be sharing in those vulnerable moments so but um yeah maybe they’re OK with the photo or um when you don’t when you’re not feeling good about sharing um people’s faces and names you can take photos of the situation and um tell the stories through the updates graphics I mean can you get permission. that might be there like yeah we’ve done that before done kind of like the Getty images or things like that but um also you know a big challenge we have is maybe the staff that we have there they are, you know, front line humanitarian workers they’re not coms people their priority isn’t getting stories or photos and so we found a couple like creative ways to work around that, um, and kind of asked our. Our staff to even just send us like grainy phone photos of like the scenery or phone photos of people you know delivering some aid even if participants aren’t in it and that kind of helps us you know not have to get that participant permission not have to get these more elaborate stories um and then right at the beginning of the crisis when you’re first fundraising that kind of content can still be really useful you know we can turn it into a lot of different things um we have some of these ideas in our you know emergency. marketing plan resources but you know we did like 10 striking photos of the Bangladesh flood emergency as a blog and then we packaged it as a gift and put it on social media and sent it as an email and it was all really like photos of scenery, not so much necessarily photos of participants and you could just see kind of the devastating impact of the floods on homes and infrastructure and that was really effective even though we didn’t really have that ability to necessarily collect really nice stories at the get go. Um, I think that’s one way you can kind of get around that challenge. OK, OK, um, what else, what else, what else belongs in, well, no, Sarah, you had your chance. So, uh, Julia, Michelle, what else belongs in our emergency marketing plan before we get to the follow up and stewardship that Michelle mentioned? What else should be in here? What, what should we be thinking about in advance? Think you can be in advanced thinking about how you’re gonna make a really compelling ask so after you’ve captured people’s attention they found out about this emergency news all those places we talked about you have a a very short window of an opportunity to convince them to give to your organization to to respond, to take action. And so the way we think about making that ask is in three components you need to be building that sense of urgency and the fact that it’s a crisis is building a lot of urgency for you as long as you’re sharing information and updates and then um create some empathy in your reader and so that is that storytelling piece even through photos um getting people to get that emotional component of I care about this I care that people are experiencing this I wanna help. And then um the third point that is crucial in making your fundraising ask is having one clear call to action and it needs to be super specific, super simple, easy to understand we’re not asking people to do one of 5 actions we’re just asking them to do one thing, donate, and here’s how and here’s why. Yeah, exactly right, and that landing page it should be written at a. 6th to 8th grade reading level so it’s a 6th grader can understand what you’re asking of them and it uses a lot of you focused language. It’s talking directly to your reader. It’s not saying we’re doing this, we’re responding, we’re helping. It’s you have the power to help. You can make a difference. You have a place in this response. Michelle I could have asked Sarah, but she had a lot of a lot of mic so I’m trying to spread these things out um um. So Brack had to create the landing page on on the fly, right in the in the midst of the crisis because it’s a landing page devoted to the Bangladesh flood, right? So you gotta, I don’t know, is that what the purpose collective come through or? Yeah, I mean you can’t you? Yeah, I think what you’re saying is that there is a lot of things that you have to get through during an emergency. There’s this long checklist of things that you need to work through and whether it’s the direct team or the purpose collective team, I think we all take a part in tackling all of these things to to get live and to uh present to supporters that may be coming into our website or seeing our ads or whatever it might be. Um, yeah, I mean it’s urgent and I mean this this checklist gets as detailed as like set your budget in advance, you know, if you know you’re going to run ads during a time of emergency, that’s something you can do early on. You can get approval for um ad budget that your organization might want to spend because the last thing you want during an emergency is contacting uh. to make sure that a certain amount of spend is approved so you can start running these ads we go to accounts payable, you know they’re not gonna approve. OK. So all these things you’re talking about are the resources that one of you will send me for our listeners. OK, OK this is good this is good detail. Yeah, so, uh, alright, let’s go back to you Sarah then uh what other what other assets have to be created on the fly landing page. Yeah, I mean it’s really thinking about like every single channel and then what can you do there so home page on the website maybe a pop up or conversion design on you know all the other pages on the site um thinking about yeah. Sorry, conversion design would be like either a pop up or you know some sort of bar that’s at the top or bottom of the page um that kind of overlays on top of your normal web page that will have you know some sort of message and link so it’ll have you know a call to action to go to the donate page or going to go to the landing page for the emergency so that you know setting that up on your site. Um, thinking about, you know, your actual donate platform, making sure you have then a donate form set up it’s connected to your, um, you know, CRM platform, whatever that may be, um, and then also, you know, looking at all of your social media channels that we like to do is, uh, change our bios and links on all of the platform. And even our header images for the platforms that do have a header image uh notifying people about the emergency so when you look at our page it’s clearly you know kind of branded for that emergency and then doing one post that’s sort of like the master post maybe on each channel that has a really compelling graphic. Showing the emergency and really clearly just tell supporters how they could support and get to the landing page um usually we try to pin those posts on whatever channels we can so those are some of the areas setting up an email template for an appeal um maybe if your organization has like a media officer. Um, you can work with them to be sending out pitches or alerting journalists, um, that you’re working, so there’s lots of different areas you can work. You said you said Brat got very good coverage in the New York Times for your, for your response that yeah we did this was a few years back, um, a different emergency, but it’s definitely can be really impactful and so you know this time we were trying to work with journalists and. Send out just updates, you know, here’s what Brack is doing here’s our landing page a lot of things places like CNN and others will often publish lists that are, you know, how to help if the emergency does get enough media pick up and so you can reach out to those places and try to get your organization listed as, you know, a way people can help so there’s lots of channels you could work and it all kind of comes. That’s why the checklist, it’s helpful to have that checklist we’ll share the checklist. OK, alright, let’s move on now after, you know, this is, this is the very unfortunate part of disasters that press moves on, the world’s attention moves on and the people are suffering for years, you know, recovering for years and, um, but we, we, so you do move away from an emergency phase. I don’t know. So how long did you stay? I, I guess I’m, I’m going to Sarah again. Uh, how long, how long did you make Bangladesh, the flood a focus of, let’s say just the home page. Let’s just use that as a, as a proxy. How long did that I think. Maybe you know 2 months or so when the most urgent immediate needs um and the timing of it was, you know, as we were shifting into the year-end fundraising season this happened in August, so maybe 2 months later as we were starting to shift into the year-end fundraising season. We took that down but we were continuing to, you know, even last month we posted a new update, you know, 6 months on here’s what’s happening here’s what we accomplished, and here’s, you know, the people that still need long term support so we’re still trying to make sure we get it out there and for people who did support um that they know that we’re still thinking about it um and I I guess. In in during the crisis, I mean you’re assuring people that can you say 100% of your donation goes to Bangladesh relief can you say that? Yeah, so I think that’s something that you need to kind of negotiate with your organization in advance as well and it’s definitely important to have that kind of like go no go to even know can you start fundraising um is your organization responding to the emergency? Um, for us we were able to do, you know, directly grant all of that money straight to the Bangladesh Relief Fund, so we had it restricted like that, but depending on your organization, um, you might choose to do it differently. OK, so let’s go after now, Michelle, you brought up the, uh, stewardship. now presumably we’ve got thousands. donors, uh, new to the organization, um, how do we start to keep them engaged in a in a journey I guess your your CEO, I know, likes to, I’m gonna say the same thing. She’s coming. 9:45. So she’s right after you all. You, you are overexposed. You got 5 don’t you have 4 members are there to be right now it’s just 30, so it’s 100%. We’re so lucky. Is the purpose, but in any case, um, so yeah, um I use her name synonymous with email. I was trying to say Patty by email. That’s her middle name. Um, Patty talks about the email journey. I know we’ve, she and I have talked about that previous NTC, uh, but so you don’t have to take the email journey path, Michelle, but, um, in fact, I think it’s kind of, it’s overplayed. I think it’s tired. I think it’s no, it’s not. It’s still important. Um, what, uh. What do we do to keep these folks engaged? Yeah, that’s a great question. I think you have this flood of new donors you want to um thank them first and foremost for their support when you um had a specific need uh they showed up and I think gratitude is the first message that you want to share as soon as possible um we talked about yeah this this. journey, but the the the first part of this journey is um making sure that they feel appreciated. They feel seen that you’ve acknowledged their, their gift and their contribution and assuming it’s that’s gonna be I think a receipt can be instant and automatic that is. Yeah, how they’re set up and I think within 24 hours um you can send a thank you email either either immediately within the first hour or instantly sometimes if it’s immediate, it gets mixed with that donation receipt so you may want to give it a little bit more space um but a a thank you email um from the organization someone at the organization. Um, even better if it’s a plain textile email it looks like it was really personalized um for the supporter, almost like someone opened up a Gmail, uh, email, and composed it themselves. Exactly. Um, I think that that first part is just making sure that someone feels seen and that they support has not gone gone unnoticed. 24 hours, right, but you’re, you’re caution, you know, maybe not immediately because, well, then it also kind of defeats the, the urgent, you know, like I, I personally composed it, you know, it comes within 2 minutes. OK. 24 hours looks uh looks personally composed, doesn’t have graphic elements. It’s just a sincere. I don’t know who did it come from, it was from our director of communications I believe the first email, yeah, and to make it even more convincing, we’ll put a filter or we recommend putting a filter that it only sends Monday to Friday from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. Because if somebody, if the way that they donated on a Friday night and it’s a little bit unconvincing if they get a personalized email on Saturday at 10 p.m. so that filter in trying to make this. OK so it’s a good first step and then we recommend um following up pretty consistently after that first email so maybe a story of impact from the emergency responding to maybe an update again we talked about. Um, a lot of these supporters, maybe their first touch point in, uh, what’s happening and unfolding in this emergency is you, so being able to share um a pretty robust update or just like a firsthand experience from a team member or what you’re seeing. Um, it’s happening, um, that’s a great message to to send, um, for Brack, uh, they also use this as an opportunity to learn more about the supporter, um, so understanding how the supporter found out about Brack through this emergency, so was it news coverage, um, was it, was it one of the ads that they were running? Was it uh through a partner organization? And this was done through a survey, uh, creating a survey and saying, you know, how did you learn about Brock during this time, um, and also in that survey was an opportunity to, uh, share more areas of work, um, that that Brack covers so the the the different programmatic areas, um, of the organization asking supporters, you know, which of these are of interest to you, um, and I think that’s a gentle uh but clear way to um. To open, open that supporter up to kind of the breadth of Brack’s work. And uh Julia, what kind of open rates do we see for these um maybe not the, the very first one that’s probably near 100% I would think OK, but as the, as the journey continues, I don’t know, are the open rates declining, you know, like the second is. We tend to see overall you see a slight decline from emails if there’s 5 emails, emails 1 to 5, you’ll see that start to come down a little bit towards the end because people are most excited right when they make their donation and the day after they’re still pretty fired up about you and this cause and. And it’s as we move on with our lives a little bit that tends to fade, but they’re still almost about double the open rates that you can expect from a typical email solicitation or newsletter so it’s between 30 and 50% is typically what we see from these email welcome journey emails. Um, uh, Sarah, something else occurred to me. What, when do you start? and I’m going back in the emergency now, uh, when do you start to ask for donations? Is it, is it with your very first messaging about the crisis, uh, if, if you want to rush rush immediate support, or do you delay a few hours or how do you manage that. It really depends on your situation, but for us, you know, we are the US arm the headquarters is in Bangladesh and so it’s really up to the headquarters and you know the country where whatever emergency might be happening to make the call um you know a that they’re actually responding and B that they need outside funds you know from. The US or whatever other countries that we’re fundraising in so sometimes it takes a little bit of time to actually get that approval and so you know if you’re in that situation where you can’t immediately start fundraising what we like to do is start still at least sharing some updates and posts you know on our social channels or other channels saying you know. Such and such emergency is happening. um, our thoughts are really with our participants and our staff at this time who are impacted, you know, so sharing some things that might not be a fundraising ask but still putting it top of mind for people so that they know, you know, we’re aware of what’s going on, um, we’re there and we’re we’re a source of information for you and you know to kind of stay tuned for, you know, the next steps OK thank you alright um alright so going back to after now, Michelle let’s. Follow up on um something that on what on our journey um you had made the point that uh you’re you’re doing some simple surveying like how did you hear about the crisis first from us what what channel, um, what, what, and then later in the journey, what parts of our work, you know, is most are most interesting to you? I want to make the point that when you’re surveying, you need to be preserving the responses and then using the information, right? If somebody says. That uh the Middle East is actually more important to me than than Central Asia, but I, I gave to the Central Asian crisis, but in Bangladesh, but I’m actually more interested in the Middle East. You need to honor that going forward, right? Totally, yeah, we don’t want to ask any survey questions that aren’t going to be used at all or just kind of resting there, um, that wouldn’t be helpful for the organization, nor would it be a good use of your supporters time to to fill something out that it’s actually counterproductive I guess they may remember. I checked the Middle East, you know, why do I get, why do I keep getting these Asians Central and South Asia, uh, appeals, you know, and information. OK, so, um, yes, you need for me and I, I do plan to giving fundraising that comes up a lot with birthdays. People like to ask. I see a lot of organizations like to ask for birthdays, but and then and they save it in their CRM then they don’t do anything with it. They’re not sending birthday, birthday reminders or even month of or certainly day of, you know, they just preserve it’s like, OK, now we know they’re. and their age we can and to what end so when you survey the data to favor to the right yeah absolutely and you know it’s an opportunity to to build a stronger relationship, even asking communication preferences and things like that um that’s all a way that hopefully builds a really like a long term relationship with their supporters if you honor that data that you’re you’re receiving. That’s a good point. Um, what, what else? So we, we kind of talked about the, the 5 emails and, uh, well, let’s space them out a little bit again, Patty and I did talk about this, I think probably 2 NTCs. She has definite like uh frames for the for the journey. Can you remind us? Yeah, so you can have. Emails as you want in this journey we often see them being between 3 and 5 emails in length from that first gratitude email all the way to the last and our general recommendation is to send them all within 2 to 4 weeks of when that initial trigger or when that initial action took place. um like Julia said, we don’t want to wait until too far after that donation in this case. Um, because folks are, you know, uh, not losing interest, but their initial enthusiasm for the cause that they support, we really want to maximize that, that time frame as much as possible. OK, OK, um, we can still spend some more time before, uh, Patty is scheduled and then we’ll have to of course cut it short immediately her time is precious. I don’t wanna, I don’t want to delay her a second more than necessary. No, we’re fine, uh, because we started early, so we still have some more time. What else? Uh, maybe some questions that came from, about some of the questions that came from your session? Any, uh, interesting memorable, provocative questions you want to share? Um, someone asked about, so the last email of the journey we typically include another donation ask and so you had mentioned Tony earlier the need for long term support because people care a lot when the disaster happens but it can take years and years to fully recover um and so we like to include that last that last email in the welcome series is often an ask for them. Become monthly donors and and it it starts with a lot of gratitude. It’s a month ago you made this really generous donation you fueled recovery efforts and it’s gonna take a long time for this community to rebuild. Will you donate just $5 or $10 a month to fuel this ongoing recovery efforts and so we really and that is also a plain text email so it feels really personal and um. A lot still a lot of gratitude in that ask, um, recognizing that they gave a month ago and somebody had asked about what the conversion rate is of that email and to be honest it’s it’s a big ask to a monthly donation so it is not that high, but we still really recommend including it because it’s super valuable to get a monthly donor who might stay with you for years and years um and. Maybe this is too, I, I like detail though. I, I, I hope listeners do too. I think they do. They, they’ve been listening for a while. Um, I hope they do. When, when you, so obviously there’s a link or QR maybe to to get to the to the donation page. Does that donation page does that page from that email asking for sustaining sustain or giving, does that still give the option of making it a one time gift or go to a landing page that’s only prohibit only permits monthly. Still giving them the option to one time donate, but it’s. Defaulting to monthly, so it helps encourage. OK. Yeah, we had one good question that was around, you know how many of these people actually stick around because we know that emergency donors, uh, you know, they’re. More likely to give one time they’re less likely to you know keep a long term relationship with you and your organization um so I think it’s a really valid question definitely we saw you know I mean it’s still early but with our past emergencies that we’ve done we’ve seen you know much less much lower retention rates so I think that’s why obviously the welcome journey is important. Um, but also continuing to kind of feed those people a little bit of a tailored diet, you should, you know, have them segmented in your email system and be sending them maybe throughout the year and season, uh, you know, a couple of months after the emergency we sent them more Bangladesh focused stories, more climate change focused stories, um, things that we thought might. Be a little bit more interesting to them as a past donor of these slots in Bangladesh rather than kind of sending them you know a story on financial inclusion from Rwanda that we might be sending to other members of our broader list um so I think that really helped us we saw actually quite a few people convert to become unrestricted donors during the year end season who had only ever given. You know, as one time emergency donors, so I think it’s something that, you know, to your point they’ve kind of showed you this interest in this one area and maybe if you also have survey data you could kind of incorporate that you want to kind of continue to feed them that and slowly introduce them to your other work rather than just letting them do this really nice welcome journey and then dumping them on your regular list where they’re just gonna get everything. OK. Any anything more about uh the the stewardship, you know, the what it what you said it’s very low. Folks joining, I don’t know, so a year later, what do you do you know what the percentage of initial donors from the Bangladesh flooded with you. Well, it hasn’t been a full year. It’s been a, you know, it was last August, so I think this year end season will be really interesting to see. We’ve already seen a lot of them convert since then. Um, especially during the year end season, um, make a second gift, um, either unrestricted or maybe a follow-up gift to the floods. So this coming year it’s really gonna be interesting to see how much they stick around, um, for, you know, the next season. So that’s something we’ll definitely be tracking encouraging so far. You know there’s other other emergencies in the past where we’ve not done quite as comprehensive of a response or comprehensive of, you know, follow up and stewardship after where we see the vast majority of people, you know, never make a gift again, um, especially an unrestricted gift so you all need to start sponsoring this show. I want to talk to Patty Breach about that. Uh, I’m tired of doing this free, uh, free, free promotion. You all know what’s going on, um, all right, we can still spend some more time together, um. Any other questions that Michelle go ahead Julia. I somebody asked you, Michelle afterwards about uh what an emergency would look like for them because they were uh a nonprofit that responded to legal changes and I just want to note that for listeners maybe they are not in a place where they’re set up to respond to natural disasters like we’ve been talking about. But crisis fundraising still applies and we encourage listeners to think about what their emergency that is real and they’re in a position to respond to could be, so maybe it’s a pandemic and they’re in a place to be giving healthcare providers resources or maybe they’re an animal shelter and they can save fluffy from the. Shelter or um yeah, maybe they’re a legal organization and can take some actions. So we are talking about natural disasters but the same rules apply to any emergency that your organization might be in a position to respond to. Yeah, I like comparing it to almost. A like a SWOT analysis uh if folks have done that before like strength, weaknesses, opportunities threats for an organization if you kind of zoom in on the threats for your organization, I that’s almost like the preliminary prep for what you can anticipate like what could happen to your organization that you need to respond to and how would you message that to an external audience? How would you share that more broadly and bring folks into the fold so that they’re able to. Um, join your organization and responding to that. Um, so yeah, if we’re looking at it like before the disaster happens, before the emergency happens, before the crisis happens, um, what are those potentials exactly, exactly. We will be sending you those freebies. is also in addition to that checklist, we have an email welcome journey template so you can use that and tailor it to your emergency. OK, why don’t you just take out a little. Motivating because you’re here you know you have a have a plan in place uh just remind you of that. Yeah, for sure I mean I think the results end up speaking for themselves, you know, past emergencies we responded to. Maybe we got a lot of interest at first but we couldn’t retain those folks and you know we’re seeing such a stronger response this time around with an emergency that got you know a lot less media coverage and left so I think it’s really valuable it’s a really valuable opportunity to generate new leads and and connect new people with your mission who might be interested in supporting more broadly so. Um, even though it can be a big time investment to respond to an emergency and fundraise around an emergency, um, it’s definitely worth the investment and I think having partners like Purpose that can, you know, jump in, um, when it’s a really busy time to help was really invaluable and just having that plan set up in advance. And prepping everything in advance so um even if you know you can kind of squeeze in a little bit of prep here and there over the next few months, um, you’ll be that much more ready for when an emergency inevitably probably will affect your organization. thank you. That’s Sarah Allen, communications manager at BACSA. We also heard from Julia Molinaro and Michelle Shen both at the Purpose Collective, Julia digital marketing director and Michelle digital marketing consultant. All right, thank you. Thank you very much. Thank you, thank you so much and thank you for being with Tony Martignetti nonprofit radio coverage of the 2025 nonprofitology conference where we’re sponsored by Heller Consulting technology services for nonprofits. It’s time for Tony’s take too. Thank you, Kate. Sitting in my seat, uh, I have to stand now, I guess, uh, uh kneel, uh, it’s like I’m proposing cause we’re together. So we’re we’re at the same desk. Uh, she’s in my seat, and here I am kneeling next to her. Thank you, Nan. We’re wrapping up our coverage of the 25 NTC, the 2025 nonprofit Technology Conference, year after year. This is our 11th year with N10 bringing nonprofit Radio to the nonprofit technology conference, wherever it is throughout the country. As you know, last year, uh, well this year, earlier this year, it was, um, it was Baltimore. I’m grateful that. N10 recognizes the value that nonprofit radio brings. Uh, so I appreciate the partnership. You know, they understand that we’re expanding the reach of their Speakers, their, their session speakers by playing their interviews on the show with our 13,000 plus listeners each week, so that expands every speaker’s audience who, who sits down for an interview with me. And, and I appreciate the value that N0 brings because they give us a great space, visibility for the show in front of uh uh uh a conference of 2, 2500 people. So we appreciate the value that each of us brings. To the partnership. And uh there’s, there’s value in working with people who see your value, and including year after year. So, my thanks to CEO Amy Sample Ward, who we all know very well. And the entire team at uh at N10 for partnering with us. Year after year, I’m looking forward to 26 NTC which is Oh gosh, I forgot where it is. Well, I’ll be there. Uh, well, the show will be there wherever, wherever the heck it is. I just can’t remember where it is right now. Thank you, Anton. Very grateful. That is Tony’s take too. Kate, swinging the mic back to you. I just want to say I’m not forcing him to kneel on the floor. He offered up his Podfather chair and I was like, Oh, it is such an honor to be in the podfather space. In person We’ve got boo but loads more time. Here is your more diverse board. I Welcome to Tony Martignetti nonprofit radio coverage of 25 NTC, the 2025 nonprofit Technology Conference. This interview actually, uh, closes out our 25 NTC coverage. We’ve been sponsored during the conference by Heller Consulting Technology Services for nonprofits. With me now is Jonathan Maharza. He’s founder and chief strategist at Equity Warrior Strategies. Jonathan, welcome to nonprofit radio. Thanks for having me, Tony. You’ve been listening for many years, yeah, when I first, I think, uh, in graduate school many years ago was finding like spaces, I think 2015 and resources for uh nonprofit professionals and this was popped up and I remember listening. Very often of just all the great speakers that you had on the content just process how to continue my leadership growth in this field. Thank you so much. I’m so glad we’ve been with you for 2015, 10 years that’s outstanding. I’m glad. I create the podcast and people who are nonprofits. Oh. I’m glad that’s happening for you. Awesome, yeah, definitely many episodes over the years where you send it to clients or colleagues to give them ideas like, hey, go listen to this. This will help you process what’s going on with your organization at the moment right now. So thank you again, so honored to be here. I’m glad it’s a that’s what that’s that’s my goal. Alright, we’re talking about, uh, diversity on the board. Your session topic is why your board is not diverse and how to recruit in equitable ways. Uh, share a 30,000 ft view of, of your session first. Sure, so we board diversity is probably the number one issue that many boards face over time like the composition of the board, you know, board source regularly does research reminding themselves that board diversity is the issue and We wanted to really uh go full forward and let people know what the true issue is and it’s about really personal change mindsets so people um are really struggling with this topic and advancing with this because of their own mindset that might have related to how they should go about it too. So we take that approach and help them think about like changing their own personal mindset and then using anti-oppressive leadership framework on how to actually recruit more equitably. What, um, what’s the best way to to begin? Is it, should we, should we start with the changing of the personal mindsets of the, when we’re talking about personal mindset, we mean of board members, board members and leaders. OK, can we start there on the personal level I think so because, um, well, we have a great meme that we show in the presentation where you know a speaker asked this group of. Crowd and it’s like who wants change and everyone raises their hand and then the bottom says who wants to change and no one raises their hand too and it’s a great reminder that you were mentioning this tough topic of that too yet what are we doing internally to reshape our biases, think about how to approach this differently or change our mind, you know, shift our thinking to like why don’t people have diverse backgrounds. Why can’t we find them to why don’t they want to find us, you know, and kind of creating spaces on the board that intentionally uh welcomes people in mind. Um, that’s borne out in something you say in your session description that uh there’s a difference between we welcome everyone and we created this space with you in mind. Yeah, so, and we’re seeing that too. There’s a lot of great good intention people and they’re like, we love everyone, we’re so welcoming and I welcome those. I’m so grateful for those spaces. However, you know, there’s a difference when You’re saying that and you haven’t done the work intentionally to think about how are you uh restructuring uh your board so like the power is distributed equitably so like the new folks coming on don’t feel just like tokens, they actually have a voice on the board or you’re thinking about your meeting structures and agendas to actually make it engaging and fulfilling for people to be a part of it. Um, or you’re just like looking outside traditional spaces of what you’ve done so it challenges the mindset of like who actually is gonna be great on your board and we’re not just going for the folks that have access to wealth or access to um certain connections or just our own bias and perception of what an ideal board member is. Um, just to, uh, alert listeners, that you may hear some, uh, cacophony behind us. Uh, 25 NTC is coming down around us. There’s carts of, uh, furniture being wheeled away. Uh, they’re not gonna take out our electrical drop until, uh, until we finish with Jonathan, but, uh, there’s a little noise in the background, uh, as the, the, uh, the commons, it’s called the commons, this open area where that we we have our studio in. Uh, gets taken down around us, but that’s OK. Nonprofit radio perseveres doesn’t make a difference to us doesn’t make a difference to you, right? You don’t, no, not at all distracted might be distracted by a lackluster host but not by the furniture being that’s that’s what’s bringing me in and I’m just focusing in on it excellent, thank you. All right, so as a longtime listener, you know I’m, I’m digging into the details. So how do we start to, what what do we need to do. Maybe on on for ourselves and maybe what does the organization need to do to help change the personal, the personal mindset, not the organizational culture yet but what can the organization and the people do to change the personal mindsets on the board and the C-suite. Uh, my colleague Chrissy who couldn’t make it, uh, she has developed a personal change mindset framework, uh, literally labeled change, and it’s, uh, an acronym that kinda helps think about the process of going about internal change. So first is the confrontation to, you know, really. Acknowledge that you need to do things differently, you know, not all of us wake up and say, oh, we need to change our mindset tomorrow, you know, like we have to face that confrontation of what that looks like too, then we have to handle the feedback, bring awareness of the issue, do internal negotiations. Uh, going identify ways of going forward and then enact what we’re doing. So, um, we have, she has a great framework that we use to kind of just help walk people through to like process the initial like confrontation of like maybe I need to change and then processing the steps to go forward so that uh the change is inactable too, you know I see often where people are like oh I need to change and they jump forward to a solution and haven’t sat with the process. Uh, and understanding of their background of what’s happening or done the awareness building of like what they truly are are are are building on to sometimes we think we need to change and we’re, uh, changing, you know, the band-aid but not the true issue at hand, so really making sure that process. Includes uh tackling and addressing the true either bias or potential area of oppression or past experience that someone has that shaped you so that you are best prepared to then go about and use some tools to kind of recruit in more equitable ways. was that um was that uh or a strategy was that a resource that you could you email me the link, um, of course, yeah, um, bragging about Chrissy because she developed it has a great graphic called and literally it’s a process of personal change, um, and it uses, you know, change as an acronym to kind of spell out the steps on that tube, so happy to share that. OK, yeah, yeah, of course I’ll put you um. Alright, so that will help us with the, with the personal mindset, my personal mindset change. Um, how about the, uh, sort of the Like the board culture. So now, now if we’ve done our personal work, we’re now a board of, I don’t know, it could be anything from 4 to 25, um, how do we start to make this, uh, at the board at the board and organizational level? Yeah, um, so I use an anti-oppressive leadership framework to help us first identify where some of those issues might impact. our board and our organization so this comes from uh how we uh and I pose a series of questions that help us think about the various different ways. So I think about learning, I think about how your community talks about you, I think about how your board is structured, I think about just the personal relationships and dynamics that you have and then I think about how we personally, you know, show up and think about ourselves too. So usually those are ways to kind of help identify to say oh what is. Uh, the true, like where are we struggling in some areas and then what might an intervention be for that too? So do we need better training for the board because I don’t know any. There’s lots of great board resources out there, but not every board member comes in fully trained on what’s going on or understanding so that or is it uh being better prepared to be an ambassador for the organization so they’re going out to the community and understanding how the community talks about the organization or do we need to restructure or update our bylaws or uh rethink our strategies um or just improve relationship building. And you know, help people strengthen how they can better connect with individuals. Unfortunately we’ve seen a decline in people’s interpersonal relationship skills over the last several years of just being able to talk to someone about anything, yeah, in that way too as well and you know, um, any conflict comes up, you know, you might be risk avoidant or you might ignore it or it might be, you know, traumatic and you not want to address it. So how are we. Potentially, you know, embracing the diversity that comes in but supporting them to actually have the conversations, learn how, and structure some procedures in some way. So, uh, yeah, I’m happy to share that framework too because then it goes into identifying each of those different five domains and how you can think about, uh, some better strategies to develop your board to attract and retain the the the people representing your community you want to be on the board, yeah, OK. Um, let’s talk through the recruitment and, and we can probably get the retention strategies too, but you know, how are you, you know, part of your session topic is how to recruit in equitable ways. What what’s your advice there? Yeah, um, first, uh, empowering and activating your current board to be ambassadors, um, and not just saying, hey, go find people like really taking some time and some intentionality to say, OK, what are the strengths, passions, and connections of our current board members and how do we want to see that. Uh, be able to connect with new people too as well, so you know, understanding all that too and then using a board matrix and understanding the gaps on your board and then connecting board members to empower them to find the network connect in that way, build on that. Um, I also really think organizations should be really intentional about their community partnerships too, like if you’re doing referrals or. Uh, sharing shared resources with other nonprofits too. How are you connecting in the network is then expanding what that might look like for yourself to, uh, you know, broaden and expand your base to, um, in that way, um, and then as a formal fundraiser too, I think a lot of folks might overlook some of their donor data unless the donor is. You know, a high level one too like there could be a lot of. Uh, I, I, I, I don’t like the term mid-level, but like people who haven’t give at the high high level who haven’t had the opportunity to be invited into your organization yet that might have some of those characteristics you’ve already been engaged with too that you might be able to cultivate engage and help drive that engagement too so that might be, you know, um, some other ways. And kind of thinking about that too is sometimes they overlook the people already connected in your area too like how often have you looked at really the demographics of the people who following you on social media or who’s attended your events or who’s given to your annual campaign too and look at some of those folks and say they already know about you, how can you potentially either. Uh, tap them for future or be very clear on the type of people you’re looking for with that network too and help expand and empower them to kind of uh be ambassadors for you. These are great tactics you’re packed with in a in a very dense, uh, excellent, you know, listeners are gonna have to go back and like rewind, but that’s fine. There’s value there to hear it another time because there’s so much, um. Uh, leveraging tech, your, your session description says that using technology for equitable board recruitment. Yeah, um, I think in a bunch of more people can probably talk about accessibility engagement about tech a little bit better than me at this conference, but, um, we, you know, learning all the great ways that we’ve seen technology be able to utilize for better effective engagement, better effective um recruitment or organization or empowerment of folks too. Um, as well, like, for example, um, I think a lot of board meetings need to be redesigned of how they’re really structured in that way because I, the boards I’m working with what they really want their meetings to walk away with is better community building, better, uh, uh, information and better opportunities for the important generative discussions in that way too. Um, and if you have even more than 5 people sometimes and only have 15 minutes on the topic too as well, how are you gonna effectively gauge? So can you use a tool like Mentimeter or or Zoom to collect thoughts from everyone. In the limited time too so everyone still feels there a chance to be heard in that way, um, or share, uh, kind of that information in that sense. So stuff like that, um, I also think like uh being creative with uh sharing resources with your board on what makes sense, so if it’s your board port. Like using your website for board portals to organize to give autonomy for the board members to have access to the information or if it’s a Google Drive or Dropbox folder in that way, um, or you know using project management tools with your board, uh, cause they’re all volunteers so however they. Yeah unless they’re pretty organized themselves too, they might need, you know, support from the staff or the leadership on continuing their task too. So are we setting up like a SANA project board so that each board member is assigned what they’re supposed to do, it’s reminded and it kinda ensures some of that accountability that might be missing from just saying oh happening in between meetings in that sense. You mentioned one. that came up in another panel. It’s M E N T I M E N T I M E T E R. Yeah. Yeah. What do you, what, what can you do with that? Um it’s mostly a presentation um platform. I actually we use it in our session too, so like live presentations, people can feedback, you do polls and what that looks like, but you can set up meeting agendas in that way, especially if it’s virtual. Even in person too, I’ve used it in personal where you know you might pose a question to the board and you know a few board members might be the ones really eager to talk so they do that too but uh a couple of ones might need a little bit more time processing so they’ll they could pause a little bit and then share their answer after too as well or or they don’t want to speak up too so you can collect even live feedback. Um, during the time too, so people can build on that, um, or I’ve seen too is like using a tool to do like a ranking poll. So if you’re posing a decision for your board and say, hey, how much do you agree with this decision right now? Like this is what we’re voting on too on a scale of 1 to 5, you know, do that and and then vote 2 and then you can say, hey, who voted 3 right now? Can you share your perspective in that way too so people get a sense to, you know, hear from. Uh, different ones, so, um, just thinking about like ways to reimagine how you can better inform your board, empower them with the information that they need to make decisions and then lead into discussions to have effective decision making that’s a little bit more inclusive and reducing the dynamics of just a few people making that area. OK, um, what else did you cover in your session that that we haven’t covered here? Uh, that’s a good question. Um, I, we always share, uh, and we’ve done this session a few times. We’ve always shared like some trends or best practices, but I think knowing the NTC audience, everyone is pretty on board with some of this. So we shared a handful of resource, a research resource to just prove and remind ourselves too about how. Uh, there’s studies that show board diversity leads to better organizational performance. There’s, uh, studies that show that DEI, even with the political climate is still more popular and still centered recently, like, uh, a university in Wisconsin I believe earlier this year just did a study saying DEI is still favored, most people are doing it as well, um, or even kind of helping with um. Sharing some state resources too on like uh attorney generals or legal guidances and reminding people like hey this is still important, this is still. Legal embracing really positive for your organization so um and I don’t think any of our attendees or the folks here like question that too however we realize the part of change is we’re getting other people on board, so giving other folks to um a sense to uh be able to uh change our you know minds or or spark that confrontation for them too. nonprofit that you can have the 5, yeah, and then we’ll share the data. OK, 3 things you’re promising now. Yeah, of course. listener, so don’t let yourself down. Oh no, no, not at all. You don’t let your peers down. I wear many hats and one is social worker and giving resources like a key part of my identity. So like I have to bring that up to make sure. OK. You OK? Yeah, great. Thank you so much for having me. Thank you. That’s Jonathan. Founder and chief strategist at Equity Warrior Strategies, thank you very much again. Yeah, thanks for having me and thank you for being with Tony Martignetti nonprofit radio coverage of 25 NTC. Uh, the hall just got quiet, like, uh, it’s still coming down, but there is a lull in the cacophony right now. But no matter, we’re wrapping up our coverage. Thank you for being with us, and we have been sponsored here at 25 NTC. By Heller Consulting technology services for nonprofits. Next week, storytelling with an award-winning crime fiction author. If you missed any part of this week’s show, Swing that mic over here. I beseech you. Find it at Tony Martignetti.com. Being like possessive with the mic, just share. Our creative producer is Claire Meyerhoff. I’m your associate producer Kate Martignetti. The show social media is by Susan Chavez. Marc Silverman is our web guy, and this music is by Scott Stein. Thank you for that affirmation, Scotty. Be with us next week for nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. Go out and be great.
Nick Grono: Nonprofit Leadership For Current & Aspiring
There’s a new compassionate, inspiring and valuable guidebook on nonprofit leadership. It’s aptly named, “How To Lead Nonprofits.” The author, Nick Grono, shares his thinking on the role of the CEO, your team and diversity, equity and inclusion (DEI), because the success of the people leading throughout your nonprofit, now and in the future, is essential to your mission success. Nick is CEO of Freedom Fund.
Donorbox: Powerful fundraising features made refreshingly easy.
We’re the #1 Podcast for Nonprofits, With 13,000+ Weekly Listeners
Board relations. Fundraising. Volunteer management. Prospect research. Legal compliance. Accounting. Finance. Investments. Donor relations. Public relations. Marketing. Technology. Social media.
Every nonprofit struggles with these issues. Big nonprofits hire experts. The other 95% listen to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio. Trusted experts and leading thinkers join me each week to tackle the tough issues. If you have big dreams but a small budget, you have a home at Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio. View Full Transcript
And welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. I’m your aptly named host and the podfather of your favorite hebdominal podcast. Oh, I’m glad you’re with us. I’d be thrown into dysteiasis if I saw that you doubled down on the idea that you missed this week’s show. Here’s our associate producer Kate with what’s going on. Hey, Tony. We’ve got Nonprofit leadership for current and aspiring. There’s a new compassionate, inspiring, and valuable guidebook on nonprofit leadership. It’s aptly named How to Lead Nonprofits. The author, Nick Grono shares his thinking on the role of the CEO, your team, and diversity, equity and inclusion, because the success of the people leading throughout your nonprofit now and in the future is essential to your mission success. Nick is CEO of Freedom Fund. On Tony’s take 2. Gratitudes. We’re sponsored by DonorBox. Outdated donation forms blocking your supporters’ generosity. Donor box, fast, flexible, and friendly fundraising forms for your nonprofit, DonorBox.org. Here is nonprofit leadership for current and aspiring. It’s my pleasure to welcome Nick Groo to nonprofit Radio. Nick has decades of experience leading and chairing nonprofits. He is CEO of Freedom Fund. A charity dedicated to ending modern slavery around the world. His book, which brings him to the show is How to Lead nonprofits Turning Purpose into Impact to Change the World. You’ll find Nick on LinkedIn. Nick Roo, welcome to nonprofit Radio. Tony, it’s great to be here. Thanks for having me on. The pleasure. Thank you for joining. Congratulations on your book published, uh, just last year, very recently last year, right? Yeah, published mid last year, so still kind of reasonably fresh off the presses. Good, congratulations again. Uh, leading nonprofits, why do you feel the, the how to lead nonprofits? Why do you feel the book is essential? Uh, you kind of, you say you’re filling a void between sort of business and nonprofit leadership. Please fill in that gap. Why, why this book now? Well, there are thousands of books on business leadership, right, you see new books every day, if you go to the airport, you see books on the shelf from prominent leaders, etc. Um, but, um, there’s not a lot on non-profit leadership. Um, so, you know, I kind of, when I was thinking about this, there were, there were 3 things that kind of were playing in my mind. The first is that leadership is different, and I’ve worked in the for-profit world. I’ve worked in the past for Goldman Sachs and as a corporate lawyer and I worked for government. And it really struck me that there are quite significant differences in many ways between kind of leadership in the, the business world and the government world, and, and, and that in a non-profit world, so that was one issue. um, another was there just wasn’t a lot of stuff out there, um, to my mind, uh, and had a look around. Um, and the third is that there is a real, um, desire for it, right? Whenever you get to a group of non-profit leaders together, we’re always talking about the challenges we face and the particular issues, and I’m sure on your podcast, you know, there’s kind of endless cycle of people saying, well, these are some of the real challenges and the hard things about leading non-profits. So kind of felt to me like there was, there was a, there was a gap to fill. You, uh, you said you, you’ve had a background in, uh, in law, in government, uh, in nonprofits. How did you find your way to, uh, to Freedom Fund? You fill in a little of the gaps of your, your, your history. It was a it was a it was a general path, you know, I started my, my professional career as a corporate lawyer in Australia, um, and then, um, at that time I’d done a bit of volunteering for a, a non-profit, a sail training non-profit, you know, one of these big old sailing ships that take, um, underprivileged youth out, so I had some non-profit experience, but I certainly wasn’t thinking of non-profits as a career. Um, but I, I was fortunate enough in my first couple of years as a lawyer to have something I think was a transformational experience, and that was my law firm offered to send one young lawyer to go work for the Legal aid commission for 6 months, so that was their pro bono efforts, right? We’ll, we’ll, we’ll offer you one of our young inexperienced lawyers. We’ll offload the pro bono on one, exactly, yeah, yeah. And so I applied for that and we had a big law firm. I thought lots and lots of people would be fighting for this position because you know, it’s a fascinating experience and I was the only one. Um, so I went off to work for Legal aid where you’re representing, you know, clients who can’t afford legal advice, um, so the, the some of the most, the least privileged in our society, um, often facing horrendous charges and, um, and it was just a real eye-opener to me about um how the system can really discriminate against people who are vulnerable and don’t have access to, Money, lawyers, etc. so that was quite interesting, after that, even though I continued as a corporate lawyer, I started volunteering commercial legal centers and, and my career went on for a little while, but um, I went to government. It was a kind of general progression, right, from corporate law into policy. I worked for the Attorney General, uh, the, the Federal Attorney General in Australia ended up being his chief of staff, so lots of interesting engagement on legal issues and legal policy, and I decided then that I wanted to kind of change my career, so I came to the US, I did a master’s degree in the US in public policy. And got my first job coming out of that, working for a, an amazing nonprofit based in Brussels called the International Crisis Group, which worked on conflicts around the world, like Afghanistan and Syria and Sudan and all those kinds of things. So that was the, the general path it took, took a little while, but I got there in the end. Interesting that, uh, at, at the big law firm, you were the only person to apply for the, for the 6 month pro bono position. That that’s kind of eye-opening about where you were versus what your real interests were. It, it probably tells you a few things about the incentives in these firms, right, you know, as in you’re on a track and, and the perception is that you need to kind of do certain things. Um, I, I had a slightly unusual upbringing, and maybe that made me more open to, um, to kind of jumping over to pro bono. My, my dad was a ship’s captain, so we spent 3 years while I was growing up on a 100 year old sailing ship sailing around the world. Um, so I kind of, Was more exposed to my parents taking risks, leaving their jobs, changing careers and all the rest of it, not that I’m saying this is the same thing, but I, I don’t know if that was, it’s always hard, I don’t know how it is with with the other guests that you get on, but you’re often in the non-profit space, you’re often, You want to tell a nice neat story, and there isn’t a nice neat story, there’s a whole lot of things going on here, isn’t there, but, but it was certainly one of the most influential decisions of my professional career, cos it just did open my eyes to different pathways and. And now I spend my whole time working on an issue of, you know, human trafficking one slavery, where, where it’s an issue where that’s illegal everywhere in the world, but the law doesn’t work. The rule of law is failing tens of millions of vulnerable people, so there’s still a connection with law, rule of law and all the rest of it. It’s just, uh, it’s just much more, um, it’s much more powerful. So your dad was a ship captain and, and your first nonprofit experience was volunteering on the three-masted 180 ft tall sailing ship uh for uh vulnerable under with training, training kids to work together, who came from underserved populations. So that, there, there’s a, there’s a little bit of a through line from your dad’s work to your first volunteer experience. Say a little more about the, was it pronounced the the Lewin was the name of the the the as in like Leeward is that Leeward versus win in um no, it’s actually Dutch for lion and, and it was named after Kate Leeuwin which was named by some of the early Dutch sailors who came out and they, I don’t know where it was, the 1700s and got blown off course, so yeah, so the Leeuw. Oh, OK. I didn’t have to do with Leeward and Winward. But now, interesting through line from your dad’s professional work to your first volunteer experience. Yeah, it, well, so he um so he was a, a ship’s captain, uh, you know, he worked for the merchant navy and all the rest of it, then did this job sailing the ship around, and then he became um the captain of this sail training ship. So I came over during my holidays and volunteered during my holidays because there was opportunities, so there was a very direct connection, um, and it was something that, you know, I found, um, really um powerful and moving and enjoyed it immensely, so. I was fortunate to have that opportunity. And your career has uh culminated in uh uh leadership of nonprofits. Yeah Uh, so the, the book focuses on, um, on, on three areas of, of leadership and organizational development, I guess, uh, organizational structure. And the purpose of your three P’s, the purpose of the people and the partners, um, why don’t you give an overview. I’d, I’d like to focus on the people, but give the overview of, of all three, the, the, how essential they are. Sure. I mean, so the, the, the, the central point of my book is that non-profits have this really powerful motivating cause, their purpose, right, to change the world in big ways or small, and by changing the world it could be changing your community, changing your, your, your country or working globally, but you’re there to make positive change, um, and your 662 and so is your impact, right? Um, and you need both, you need a powerful cause, and then you need to deliver on it, cos I think there are lots of non-profits that kind of have, The best of intentions, but may not be as good as delivering delivering on those intentions. So, so the central thesis is, purpose, turn it into effective impact, and then the framework I set up, which is um a pretty straightforward one is, is around purpose, people and partners, purpose is your um direction of travel. Uh, and I talked there about the mission of your organization and the impact and how you measure it, and the strategy being the connection between your um your mission and your impact. People is looking inwards, that’s looking at first and foremost, the CEOs, what are the priorities for the CEO? It’s looking at your team, um, and culture and all the things that go with team, it’s looking at your board. And then the third PE partners is looking outwards, you know, it’s, it’s your. If we use the lingo, it’s it’s your external stakeholders, but that, you know, that’s kind of jargon, isn’t it? So for me, it’s the communities you serve, first and foremost, right? Why do you exist? You, you’re serving a population, a community, um, they should be at the center of your work. Uh, it’s about your funders, about your funders, then it’s very hard to do the work. And also, I think a really important areas around peers and networks and those that are in the space with you and how you mobilize them. So, so those are the three Ps. That’s the quick, quick, quick gallop through the. Yeah, thank you very much. Thank you. Um. So you’re the uh the section on, on people uh in the middle of the book starts with the CEO and the only thing I’d like to read is just uh uh uh this, this quote really struck me about leadership, uh, opens the, the, the, uh, the CEO chapter. Uh, from Mary Parker Follett, uh, uh, a 1924 book, Leadership is not defined by the exercise of power. But by the capacity to increase the sense of power among those led. The most essential work of the leader is to create more leaders. It’s inspirational. I, I, I, I, it’s aspirational and inspirational at the same time, um. Give us your, your, you know, I have some specific things I want to ask you about, but give us your overview of, of your, your role. You are the, you are the CEO of Freedom Fund. Um, give us your, um, give us your overview of what, what you’re supposed to be about. Sure, um, and I’ve, I’ve had the, I think it’s the benefit of being the CEO from day one of the organization. So we set up the organization 11 years ago, I was the first employee. Um, and there are advantages and disadvantages. The advantage is I, I, I had a fair say in what was gonna happen. Um, um, and then we build out the team and now we have, um, about 80 staff, um, so, um, some 10 years later, um. It’s How do I describe the role? I mean, there, there are many things going on, you know, I think there are many priorities and the priorities that I say for the CEO are the priorities I think for myself, you know, it’s about holding the vision for the organization, and the CEO, I think, I think what I would say to a lot of people is the CEO is often the only person in the organization that is looking over the horizon. And everyone else is kind of focused on specific tasks, you know, you’re running programs or you’re running your finance or dealing with HR, uh, working with volunteers, whereas CEO is always looking what comes next. Uh, I think of that particularly right now with everything that’s going on with kind of international finance and aid and all the rest of it, it’s a really turbulent time, so looking over there, um, it’s about motivating staff, it’s about kind of leading on strategy. Um, it’s, it’s making sure you focus on the stuff that really matters, not the stuff that you want to do or the stuff that you’re comfortable with, but the stuff that no one else can do, because I often feel like, if you run your team well, then the only decisions that come up to you are the really hard decisions because everyone else deals with the decisions that are easier to, to make, right? Um, so. That’s the way it should run, uh, and, and then finally the, the point is, if you’re fortunate enough to have a team, a leadership team, and so on, then, then it’s just really key as a leader to, to support that team and make sure it’s powerful and engaged and, and that you’re a a a a a really effective member of that team. And there’s lots to unpack on all of that, but, Um, they, yeah, that’s a quick run through of that. Yeah, we’re gonna get to a good bit of it. You, you, you, you devote a chapter to the team, which we, which we’ll talk about, uh, but, uh, just focused on the CEO and holding the vision. You, you said it, it was something I wanted to ask you about, expand on that a little more about hold the vision. So, I, I, I keep on talking about purpose being the central point of the organization. I mean, non-profits have lots of challenges, right? And we can talk a little about that with fundraising and the fact that you don’t earn income, people give you money and all the rest of it, and it’s really complicated. They have this superpower. Of purpose. It’s really powerful, right? I am deeply moved and inspired by the work we do to support some of the most vulnerable people that are being exploited, uh, you know, for, or at risk of sex trafficking or forced labor, or bonded labor or forced marriage. And, and so the vision that we have is about how do we have the biggest impact on those communities that we’re serving. And, and I think if you harness that, it’s really powerful for the team and the work, and particularly when things are challenging or difficult, I kind of keep on reminding people of the power of what we do and the importance and the privilege of what we do, um. They’re difficult times, or or when COVID hit, right, and when COVID hit and the organization’s reeling and there’s a lot of uncertainty, it was really powerful to say to the team, but look at the communities we serve, they are hit so much harder than we are, and we have such an important role to play in supporting them during this completely uncertain time and it was a really good. Way of mobilizing the team and get everyone focused at a difficult time, and I think it can be really powerful. So, so that to me is the vision. What are we always about? Bring it back to that. Always, if you have problems at work or if there are staffing issues or internal discord, you start with, what are we here for? And then we’ll work on everything else. It’s time for a break. Imagine a fundraising partner that not only helps you raise more money, but also supports you in retaining your donors. A partner that helps you raise funds both online and on location so you can grow your impact faster. That’s DonorBox, a comprehensive suite of tools, services, and resources that gives fundraisers just like you a custom solution to tackle your unique challenges, helping you achieve the growth and sustainability your organization needs, helping you, help others. Visit donorbox.org to learn more. Now back to Nonprofit leadership for current and aspiring. Are you, uh, facing a lot of that, uh, a lot of challenge now with the, the, uh, USAID funding cuts and uncertainties and I imagine a lot of the organizations you fund are also funded by USAID. So this is all you’re living through this again, it’s COVID 5 years ago to the month actually, um, now 5 years later, you know, this, this funding uncertainty and, and turmoil. Yeah, there’s a huge amount of uncertainty, and it’s not just US government funding, you know, the Brits have announced that they’re cutting their foreign aid funding, the um the Dutch have cut their foreign aid funding, the Swiss have announced cuts to there, so there’s a, there’s a, um, we, we get um some funding from, it wasn’t USAID, it’s from the State Department, which was frozen for about 3 weeks but has been unfrozen. Um, and that we use to fund some 30 organizations on the ground, so we’re, we’re very fortunate compared to many, um, and historically trafficking has been largely a bipartisan, anti-trafficking work’s been largely bipartisan, so, so we hope that that will continue to be the case. Um, um, but it creates massive uncertainty, particularly on the ground where we don’t work in isolation, we work with local partners, so we fund some 150 local partners, but if, if, Um, aid is cut from any government that supports frontline organizations. Everyone becomes a bit more vulnerable, right? So, and for work on trafficking and slavery, vulnerability is the proxy for slavery. It’s vulnerable populations that are preyed upon, so if communities become more vulnerable because aid has been cut from various quarters, um, then the risk of trafficking and slavery grows, so even if we’re not directly impacted on the aid cuts, The demand for what we do is only going to grow because there is going to be increasing vulnerability um as, Rich countries withdraw somewhat from the aid space, at least temporarily. Are you finding yourself having to reassure your own staff of 80 some, again, you know, holding the vision for them? Yeah, absolutely, and, and, and reminding them, you know, one where we’re, we’re in a solid financial position, um, and so we’ve been able to continue supporting partners and the work will continue. Um, but, um, talking to staff about these scenarios, and it’s not so much just reassuring them, it’s, it’s giving them renewed purpose, right, because everyone struggles when they see what’s happening on the ground and greater vulnerability and you know, this work is emotionally very, very draining, and when you see um, Groups of people that are even more vulnerable to trafficking, it can be really tough, so it’s getting everyone aligned around the purpose and saying right, here’s our chance to have even greater impact, uh, doing the stuff that we care about. It kind of leads to, uh, leading on strategy, which, uh, you, you, you have several interviews through the book which I, I appreciate they, they add, they add color and, and, and depth and, uh, you one of your interviews is with, uh, uh, a man named LeFevre who says that, uh, leading uh they sort of expressing strategy is more of an inspirational sketch than a blueprint. So please uh say more about the, the CEO’s role in, in, you know, take from holding the vision to execution, to leading on strategy. Yeah, sure, so strategy, I kind of see strategy as the, the pathway, the route, the, the map that you set out that gets you from your, your vision, your purpose to the impact that you want to achieve, right? You kind of say, well, we’re here to end modern slavery or make a big measurable difference to modern slavery in the regions we work, and we can kind of say what that means in terms of percentage reductions and all the rest of it. So how do we get there? Um, and I think, I think in our space, there’s often a lot of overthinking of strategy, and I, I’m still trying to articulate this more clearly. I think, I think one of the big things that non-profits struggle with is that we don’t have the feedback mechanisms and the price signals that you have if you’re a business. Uh, if you’re a business and you’ve got a plan. And it’s not working, you know, pretty quickly because your customers are leaving you or your income is falling, and you have very strong price signals and feedback mechanisms that non-profits don’t really have, right? Um, because you’re doing a program and you think it might achieve something and it may or may not be, but it’s often very messy, and so, so, um, so strategy is important because you’ve gotta be really thoughtful about the plan that you have. And you’ve got to find ways of, of reflecting on it and changing or adapting as, as, as things progress, and so that’s what Matthew means about, You know, kind of sketching out a way of challenging, and I, I have another quote in there about a guy who kind of talks about, you know, it’s more of strategy is more a kind of a GPS sat-nav, you know, than map, because you have to adjust as you move along. um, and I think nonprofits too often can kind of think, OK, there’s a magic in a strategy and we’ll spend a year and um investing in a strategy and we’ll come up with a really detailed plan. And we’ll stick to that plan because we’ve all signed off on it, even if the world changes, uh, and I, I talk in the book about, you know, imagine, imagine you’re working on, Mental health issues, um before COVID, and you’ve got a nice plan and your income’s been going up each year for the last 4 or 5 years and you’ve got a good strategy to engage companies to become sponsors and partners. And then COVID hits. And two things happen, right? One is, the demand for your services just skyrockets, right, if you’re involved in mental health during COVID and all. And the other is your funders are probably initially at least running 100 miles an hour because, you know, the companies are really worried about their own financial bottom line, so often we’re drawing back from, from funding commitments and so on. So demand goes up, your income goes down, your strategy is out the door, right, and not every component of it, but I mean any detailed year by year plan is out the door. Now hopefully, And, and I talk about one of the things that I think is really key in the strategy is your theory of change. And, and theory of change often sounds very jargonistic, and I don’t like jargon, but theory of change is your insight. It’s like, what is special about what we do that is going to translate into the change that we want to see. And, and I, I think it’s really important because often, The work that we do doesn’t directly deliver the results that we want to see. Um, and I think one example might be working for a think tank, right, now if you work for a think tank and you’re producing research reports, Your objective is not to publish reports, usually, right, that’s a, that’s a, that’s an output, that’s a tool to achieve. Usually your objective is to change policy or to change behavior in some way. And so your theory of change is not our think tank exists to publish 100 reports a year and to get 20 opinion pieces and papers. It’s our theory of change is that the most effective way to change policy is to produce thoughtfully well reduced, uh, well, well researched reports and go and advocate on those reports to policy makers and influence them to change what they do. And, and because that’s your theory of change, while you may not be able to guarantee all of the results, you can at least try and track whether or not it’s working. Are your reports influential? Are people referring to them? Are they being covered in the press? Do policymakers refer to them? Do they change policy? And so, so for me, strategy is kind of trying to get the fundamentals in place. What is your purpose, what is your, what is your, your insight that will get you to your objective and what is your objective? And then keep on, keep on looking at that and thinking about that as times and things change. You also spend time talking about the CEO’s role in in fundraising. Which can, ah, can be fraught with, with some, some founders especially who, uh, may have a lot of passion. And zeal about the work that they’re doing, but not really have a solid plan for how to fund it. So, share your thinking on the, the CEO’s role and, and need to embrace fundraising. Yeah, well, the thing about nonprofits is. For most nonprofits, You, your income comes from people giving you money, you know, you raise it from individuals or grants or governments. I mean sometimes you provide services and have a contract with government, but leaving that aside, you know, most of it is raising money from people who are giving to you, um, and, and that can be really tricky. Um, again, I kind of, you know, an example I use is, imagine if you’re a business, And you have a really good strategy and you execute really well and you’ve worked out your niche and you’re operating much more effectively than your competitors, you probably have people coming and wanting to invest, right, because it’s like, wow, this is a great business and it’s doing really well and we can make lots of money and all the rest of it where, I imagine you’re in a nonprofit and you’re doing really well on your strategy and, Um, you’re kind of more effective than your peers and your competitors. Well, you’ll often have donors, particularly foundations, say, mate, you’re doing just fine, you don’t need our support anymore, we can go fund others because look, you’ve done such a good job. And so it’s almost as if your success can be a, a contribute to reduced income. I know these are particular circumstances, but in my world, this is very real. Um, and so I think it’s part of one of the interviews where someone says that it’s easy to find funding in the first few years because there’s excitement and you have a, you have a, a new plan, a new model, but, but it becomes difficult after like year 5 and on. Yeah. And, and that’s often the case, you know what I mean, and it, and it kind of varies in various ways, but certainly, you know, when we started the Freedom Fund 10 years ago, initial enthusiasm and great interest, uh, and lots of people, and it’s new and it’s interesting, and, and it certainly helped us mobilize great funders, most of whom have stayed with us. So full credit to them. Um, so, but the way I look at it from the CEO is, you know, your organization can’t do anything without funding. And so it is an absolute priority for the CEO to make sure that you are getting the funding that you need, um, and increasing it over time if that’s what you want. Now, it doesn’t mean you have to do it yourself personally, but to be honest, usually the best spokesperson for an organization, a non-profit is the CEO. Um, and again, particularly if you’re raising grants from, from high net worth funders or from foundations, um, people want to hear from the CEO. Uh, and there are some CEOs who kind of think, well this is beneath me, right? I’m really interested in the, the programs and, and the, the, the real nitty gritty of the work. Well, sure, if you’ve built a team and you’re managing to raise the funding, great, but you won’t have programs if you don’t bring the funding in. So to my mind, the role of the CEO is to make sure all of the relevant bits are working and if fundraising is key. Then that’s where you spend your effort, and I would spend over 50% of my time doing fundraising and outreach because that’s where I can add the most value to my organization. I’ve got amazing program people. I’ve got people who know much more about modern slavery and human trafficking than I do, who’ve spent their lives working on these issues. I’ve got, you know, wonderful, Kind of finance teams and HR teams and all the rest of it, where I can add is selling the vision, building relationships, explaining to people why they should give us a chunk of funding, and for this issue, rather than to either a peer organization or a completely different issue. Um, so I think, um, it doesn’t always mean the CEO has to do it all, but the CEO is responsible. Uh, cos there’s nothing worse than being all virtuous about, well, I’m gonna focus on this work and find that you’ve got less and less money and you’re doing less and less work. So you devote, you think it’s more than half your time to, to fundraising? Fundraising, talking about the work, selling the message, it’s not all you know, it’s not all meetings, meetings with donors, right, it’s, it’s, it’s talking about the power of the issue, going to conferences where, where it’s appropriate, um, yeah, yeah. By the way, you, you, uh, mentioned your disdain for jargon, uh, here on nonprofit radio, we have jargon jail. You’re not likely to be, uh, you’re not likely to be subject to because if we’re, uh, we’re we’re, we’re simpatico on not liking it. It’s time for Tony’s steak too. Thank you, Kate. Gratitudes. I’ve been doing more of this gratitude practice. Well I’m actually saying out loud things that I am grateful for in my life. I do it usually in the mornings when I’m waking up, and not every morning, but A bunch of mornings and occasionally at night. Uh, and I just, I, I’m sharing that I do it because I’m encouraging you to do the same. It’s kind of especially with all the anxiety and chaos and turmoil and. The storm around us, not only in the nonprofit community, but just in our country. I think it helps to ground, at least it helps me ground myself, that there are things to be enormously grateful for. So I Say out loud, I’m grateful for my family. Except the the part where Kate lives in New Jersey, that that there’s an exception, but uh other other family, all, all, all other fam, no, no, of course, all my family, um, my wife Amy. The beautiful place that I’m privileged to live in uh on the beach, my clients, uh, friends, you know, and I name friends that are that are on my mind when you start doing this. The list grows long, and you realize that there’s so much in your life to be grateful for. I guess, again, I, I should say that’s what happens to me. I, I hope that that will happen for you also, that you start naming people and the names just keep coming and the uh the other, the other folks and and maybe even companies, you know, whatever it is that you’re grateful for, uh, just keep coming and coming and and that’s what I find so. It’s really valuable to me. I encourage you to try it. It’s quite simple, just saying out loud the things that you’re grateful for. And that is Tony’s take too. Kate I think that’s a great way to start your day and even end it. Do it both in the morning and the evening, cause then you’re starting on good thoughts and then you’re also ending on good thoughts. Excellent. I, I agree. All right. You could do both. Absolutely. The more, the more gratitude that you recognize, uh, the better. You could, sure, book into your day with gratitude. And, yeah. We’ve got Boou but loads more time. Here’s the rest of nonprofit leadership for Current and aspiring with Nick Groo. You spent some time on leadership styles, and I’d like you to share what your uh what your advice is around soft power. Yeah, so there are lots of different styles of leadership as anyone who has worked for anyone or anyone who has led will understand, um, and, and certainly I’ve been on a journey with my own leadership style, um, and I think often lots of new non-profit leaders are. Um, you know, I, I’m sometimes asked what’s the, what’s, what’s the one of the best pieces of leadership advice that you could give someone, and, you know, one of my pieces of advice will be the, the skills and the behaviors that get you into leadership positions aren’t often the skills and behaviors that make you a really good leader. Uh, and in my case, you know, I was very happy to make decisions, and when I was a #2, my boss kind of loved it because she would throw things to me and I’d sort them out and kind of barrel through. But if you bring that approach when you’re the CEO you’re not building a team, you’re not bringing people along with you, you’re not, you’re not giving people the space to kind of be their best selves, um, and so my learning over time has been, and it’s still an ongoing process, you know, the kind of approach that I think for them, in most cases, not always, that’s really effective as a leader is bringing a coaching approach to leadership. Uh, kind of giving people the space to work out how they can do the job most effectively, asking questions, listening, providing some guidance, but not just charging in and making decisions. Um, and with new non-profit leaders in particular, you know, particularly if you’re a bit insecure, it’s your first time in a CEO job, you’ve, you’ve maybe been recruited from, from the organization internally and so you’ve moved a step above your peers and, you know, you can, it can be really tough, and you’re kind of, and again, speaking from experience, you sometimes respond by like micromanaging everything and, you know, kind of making sure that you’re on top of everything and, Second guessing everyone’s decisions, that’s not good leadership. Uh, if you, if you start jumping in and making decisions for everyone, you know what happens very quickly, no one makes decisions, because it’s like, well, Nick’s gonna decide this, so why should I spend all this time working out the very best approach on this issue, be it how to approach a fun a funder or, How to design a program if Nick’s just gonna jump in and make up his own mind, and then everything ends up being elevated to Nick. Yeah, and then suddenly you say, well, I’m the only person that can do this, because look, it’s all coming up to me, you know, it’s a kind of self reinforcing cycle of, of, uh, narcissism. Um, you share a good story, uh, uh, one that was revealing to you, uh, also from, uh, from the pandemic about when you were at uh International Crisis Group. Why don’t you share that little story, yeah. So that was, it wasn’t um it wasn’t the pandemic, it was the financial crisis, so another great recession, sorry, yeah, yeah, so, so, but, but, but similar, similar and you know, what happened was that basically we knew that our income was going down by at least 10%. Um, and I worked with it, so I was number 2 there, and I worked with the CEO and we went to the board and said we need to cut by at least 10%. The board said, yep, off you go. And we, um, we were heading, so we had about 120 staff then maybe, uh, spread all around the world, you know, Crisis Group’s are an amazing organization. And once a year we’d bring the top 30 staff or so together at a senior staff retreat, and this just happened to be about a week after the board meeting. And so my boss said, OK, well, we need to now work out how to deliver on these cuts, and, and I, um, and he gave me a lot of responsibility for this, and I thought, well, there’s a couple of things we wanna do. One is we need to move fairly quickly with cuts because the quicker we make cuts, the quicker we’ll enjoy the savings, right? If you take a year to implement your cuts, well, there’s a year you’ve spent the money that you could otherwise save. And then the other thing I thought was, you know, instead of just squeezing everywhere and making, we should, Use this opportunity to cut a couple of areas deeply that are just perhaps less effective or not the same priority, and both of those acceptable propositions, you know, in and around, but, so I then just decided where this was gonna happen and I kind of briefed my boss and then I kind of went up to the division heads and said, hey, you know, we had to the cut, so here’s what we’re gonna do. And surprise, surprise, they, they, they weren’t very happy about the process, um, and you’ve got this convening now, everybody gets together and they start to conspire. So, so I managed to, I, I, I did achieve one thing which they managed to unite pretty well everyone against me, you, um, you know, so it was great morale building because there was a coherence, um, and, and they actually called a meeting that night that me and the CFO weren’t invited to and the um, And the next morning, we, we had our staff rebellion, and they said, well look, we, we don’t want you, the CEO to run this process because obviously it’s not being run very well, and my boss, who’s a former Foreign Minister of Australia, who wasn’t not noted for his patience, handled this remarkably well, and he was smart enough to understand, OK, well let’s just play this cool, and so he said fine, let’s do this, and, and the staff said right, we wanna do this properly and we wanna workshop, you know, we’ll sit down and program teams and, We’ll sit down with Nick and we’ll sit down with the CFO and see if, if there are better ways of making savings. And so it was somewhat humiliating, um, and but it was also really informative in a number of ways. And first of all, everyone accepted the need to make cuts, so it wasn’t like saying we don’t need to make cuts, you’re, you know. And then of course, the wisdom of the group between them could identify areas where we could make easy savings. That had very little impact. I mean, to take one example, we used to publish about 100 reports a year and we used to send them out to, you know, each report to targeted audience, maybe 2000, 3000 copies. We didn’t need to send that many out, but we’d just been doing it for years, and that cost $400,000 a year. And by cutting it down to maybe 20 copies per to absolutely essential and putting a bit of more work, we saved $350,000 right? I hadn’t thought of it. I haven’t thought of it. Um, um, and so we did some other things, I mean, the organization did get squeezed because people offered up salary and all the rest of it, but perhaps the most striking thing about it was, OK, we came out with a plan, and we ended up cutting by 15% because people had offered up instead of the kind of 10, 11% that we’d we’d targeted, which served us very well at that time. Um, and 2 years later, our income was significantly higher than when we’d gone then pre-cuts. So we cut deeply, um, we rallied around together, and then over the next 18 months or so, we managed to raise significant additional funding, so we ended up being in a better position than we had been at the time when we, when we were worried about the funding cuts. So, I learned, I mean, you learn from your mistakes, don’t you, more than you, you learn from your successes, ah. And I just learned that um you know, powers of teams need to proper process, need to consult, and, and, and don’t mistake these things, you know, consultation doesn’t mean surrendering necessarily uh decision making authority to the crowd, unless you handle it really badly. It just means giving people an opportunity to provide input and feel heard and and often, and usually they have really good things to say. That story of what not to do just uh sort of exemplifies why I, I admire the book. There’s a lot of introspection in the book. You, you routinely say, you know, you’re still learning, you’re a work in progress, uh particularly uh with the, the chapter I want to talk about with, uh, diversity, equity and inclusion. But throughout, you know, you’re, you’re, you’re honest, you’re open. You’re vulnerable. Uh, uh, I admire that. Uh, uh, uh, a lot of folks see vulnerability as a weakness, and I’ve always thought it, it, it’s a, a sign of, uh, a strong leader. Well it’s very kind of you and it, it, it also, you know, on the feedback, and I’ve got lots of lovely feedback on the book and and probably the feedback that resonates most and the most consistent feedback is, well, we really appreciate it because you know, you’re not saying that CEO has to be this perfect, you know, infallible model, right, because we know it’s really hard and hearing other people say that they struggle with this is a real gift. Uh, and again, for, for young or new non-profit leaders, I think that’s often the thing they’re struggling with the most. It’s like damn, I’m in charge of this organization, it’s really hard and I don’t have anyone to turn to and I’m terrified I’m gonna make mistakes, and I can’t admit that I get anything wrong because everyone will judge me, um, so. You spend time on, uh, self-care too for the CEO, you know, it’s, it’s, it’s funny you, uh, you open that section, and you talk about, uh, overwork, micromanagement, your loneliness, and I’m thinking this, why would I keep, why, why would I aspire to leadership? This sounds like a suicide path to, or a path to self-destruction. Um, so, so, but there are way, you know, of course, methods of overcoming strategies for overcoming. The the negatives like, like mentoring and peer, peer groups and coaching, um, and your own mental health. So say, say something about the, the, the essential self-care uh uh uh uh for a CEO to before you can care for others. Uh, well, the starting point is. It’s a tough and lonely job. I mean, it’s a wonderful job. I love my job, right, and I love being in charge, and I love working with a team, but it is tough and lonely, and I, I thought about it, uh, particularly when crises happen, right? And so COVID was an obvious one, but even now with kind of turmoil with financial assistance all around the world and all the rest of it. And there’s this, and, and, and you feel a sense, an intense sense of responsibility. Like if I get this wrong, and if I do badly, It impacts on the lives, first and foremost of the 80 or so staff that we have, very directly, right, who’s, it’s their jobs and their livelihoods and all around. I feel a huge sense of responsibility, but then it, it packs on the 150 grassroots organizations that we work with, and then the millions and millions of people that are served by those. So, you, if you sit back and think about this, it can, can be somewhat overwhelming, um, and, And then also there are these drivers, so one is, Leadership can be lonely in any organization, not just non-profits and business, uh, because, The buck stops with you and so you’ve got to make the final decision and um and even if you don’t make decisions, that’s a decision, so you know, you, you, you’ve you’ve got the responsibility, um, um, you often don’t have people that you feel comfortable turning to and but that’s something we, we can talk about, um, and so, so it can just be really, really challenging. Um, and then, again, particularly working with non-profits, there’s always this sense of, well, we exist for a, for a bigger purpose and so if I just work harder, we can achieve more. I mean, how, how do you stand by, I think of people working, In Humanitarian disaster zones in Sudan or where we’re just seeing, you know, horrendous things happen right now. And malnutrition, babies dying and all the rest of it, and how, how do you um, How do you not kind of think, well, if I just work a bit harder, um, we can do more. So, so lots of reasons why it can be overwhelming, and I think the starting point is for CEOs to think, OK, well, I do no one any favors if I burn out, right, so stop trying to prove yourself when it’s not being effective, right, if you’re working 80, 90 hours, weeks consistently, you’re not gonna do anyone any good, you’re not doing your job properly, you just aren’t, because you’re not effective. Um, so stop making yourself into a martyr, work out how you can support your own mental health, wellbeing so that you are just a better leader. Um, and then there are strategies for it, right? You can establish, I think one of the best things that’s happened in my non-profit career is kind of small peer groups. Uh, I have a wonderful friend, she was, she was #2. At a um at an organization, um, and she kind of said, why don’t a few of us come together once every 9 months or so and just share some of the challenges that were going on. And, and we just got, initially we set these kind of days and we’d kind of have a tight program of what we were gonna talk through and all the rest of it. In the end it just became a sharing opportunity and we’d go out for dinner and we’d just be sharing all of the challenges and, you know, these are the challenges we’re all kind of around the number 2 level, so often it was like these are the challenges we had with my boss, right, um, but also, you know, have you had this problem with funders or impact or whatever, and it’s just a huge relief to be able to share, um. And then personally, I also, you know, I try and meditate, I try and stay fit and healthy, I try and exercise, um, all as a way of just dealing with, with the pressures and, and stresses of running an organization. You spend time, uh, you have a chapter devoted to the team as part of the, the, the people, there’s the CEO and then the team, uh, you, I think a lot of insightful advice around culture and so talk about culture, psychological safety, how important that is as a part of culture for the, for the team that uh that that you’ve built that you invested in. Please share there. Sure, so, I think one of the things with teams that, Some non-profit leaders don’t, some leaders don’t understand is. Teams are an amazing resource. It’s not that teams exist for you to issue commands and then just to execute, right, because if that’s what, if that’s how you see your team and that’s how you’re doing it, you’re missing out on the real richness and power of a team. And to me, the best thing about a team is that I get access to really smart ideas from smart engaged people and can pick and choose these ideas and work together, but you know, and come up with better decisions. And, and it is so helpful for me when I say, hey, I was thinking about this, and, you know, I’m gonna do this. Now if, if the team wasn’t engaged, they say, Sure, Nick, great, whatever, off you go. Whereas, in fact, they’ll say, oh, that’s interesting, but what about this or what about this? And then I can step back and say, well, actually that’s a really good idea, let’s explore that. And, and as a leader, it’s just a huge benefit because I’ve got other people’s wisdom, and then we’ll work together. Uh, and I just don’t understand why people don’t understand the value of being able to draw on all of this expertise if you run your team well and build an effective team. But that won’t happen unless you build an effective team. So if you run it in a hierarchical way and you just, as we said earlier, make all the decisions, and no one’s gonna offer up any ideas because Nick’s gonna say, uh, you know. Um, so that’s one point, but it’s not enough just to kind of not, not listen to people’s ideas. You actually got to actively create a space for ideas to come up because you may say you’re really, you may say to your team, give me your ideas, I really want to hear them, and we’re gonna, but if you can’t. poo poo a couple of those ideas. Nice try, but really, you know, they’re not going to offer up their ideas in the future. So this is the idea of psychological safety, right? Fancy word, jargons, but, but the idea is pretty straightforward. It’s you, you show that you are actually willing to hear ideas and be contradicted. Right? So you start off a conversation by saying, well, I got this wrong last time we did this. Anyone got any idea, you know, so you’re admitting, you’re admitting that you don’t get it right all the time, it creates space. Someone puts up an idea and you say, this is really, you don’t have to say it’s brilliant and all the rest of it, but say I really appreciate that. And let’s draw in some more ideas. You don’t have to grab everyone’s ideas. You create a, so, and this is all about culture as well. So, you know, a culture of psychological safety means the leader signaling very clearly that they are open to people expressing views and a range of views. And I thought, I referred to it in the book, a study that this all comes, well, it it it it’s all demonstrated very powerfully in a, in a research um study that Google did when it was trying to work out what are the most effective functioning teams, and it, Google has more information on its staff than anyone ever has on their staff, right? It’s a data company. And so he was trying to work out, OK, we’ve got these really high performing teams, we know they’re really high performing, what makes them distinct from other teams, and now we’re trying to work it out, is it where all the team members are are alike, are homogeneous, or is it where all the team members are really diverse and different, or is it where the team members like hanging out, not just at work, but after work, or is it where the team members are all acutely focused. And none of these really predicted the effective teams, it was the teams that had psychological safety. Um, that, and so they kind of helped popularize this concept of basically just giving people space to input and contribute and be thoughtful and drawing on the wisdom of the group. Um, so, so that’s what I see as a really important part of culture, and I think if you’re going to be intentional about it and culture across the organization, you know, as a leader you have to think about culture all the time. Uh, and to me, culture for companies is like character for individuals, um, and it just doesn’t happen, it’s developed, right, and I think one of the ways you develop culture, and it can’t just be the leader, but the leader obviously sets the tone, uh, is there are values that you, as an organ that the organization cares about. Um, for individuals, their virtues, they’re good values, right? Values that advance the purpose of the organization, it’s not just enough to say we care about these things, you have to turn them into habits or into norms. And so it’s turning values into norms, and you do that by identifying things that matter and then consistently implementing or behaving accordingly, and that becomes a norm or a habit, and, and it’s values and norms that make up culture. Um, and so our staff. You you say behaving accordingly. And you, you talked, uh, throughout the book about modeling the behaviors that you know are important in, in yourself doing, as you said, you know, being open, for instance, being not, not uh negating ideas when you ask for people’s ideas, but you know, throughout, you talk about modeling behaviors. Everyone watches the CEO, right, and it always surprises me how much they watch the CEO, right, and I shouldn’t be surprised, I’ve been a CEO now for 12 years, but it’s still, everyone watches the CEO, so everything you do, and it’s pointless saying this is what kind of organization we are and we’re, I have an open door policy when in fact you’re slamming a door on everyone, uh, and people work it out pretty quickly, right, uh, I treat people well when I don’t, or whatever, um, and so, you know, I mean one thing that I do, That I think is quite useful um for us in building culture. I used to do quarterly CEO calls where I’d just have an all-staff call and I’d update everyone, and I’d be pretty open about what happened at the board, and I thought, OK, well this is a good way of keeping people informed. And then I’d ask for questions at the end and I’d get no questions, right, no one was gonna put up their hand virtually in front of 70, 80 people and ask questions and, and, And so I thought we’re not using this as effectively as possible, so then we changed the system where one staff member gets to interview me on these calls. And they’re allowed to ask anything they want, and they know they are because they’ve seen other people have been allowed to ask me anything that they want, and I will ask the questions. And more importantly, they can solicit questions from any of the staff that come into them, so I don’t know where the questions are coming from. That’s the part that I love, that you don’t know the questions in advance. It’s, it’s total vulnerability. Yeah, and, but, but people generally, one they respect it and even if they, you know, I mean I I just did one a couple of weeks ago, and, you know, there were questions about, um, Impact of the financial crisis and are, are we gonna be making people redundant, what impact does it make on partners? There are questions about my mental health and how is, how is I managing the stress and all the rest of it. Um, and these are great questions, because then I can, I can then share my thoughts, and it’s not me just kind of delivering from on top what I think people want to hear, it’s being responsive to questions. There are questions about, um, you know, our culture or learning and development within the organization. And I think it’s just super helpful to have that conversation, uh, and hopefully contributing to a culture where people feel like, OK, well we can ask these questions. Time. The DEI work. You, uh, you say you were initially, uh, nervous about. And, uh, and you make the point here, as I said, said earlier, it’s it’s, it’s a work in progress and, and we’ve had a good number of uh guests through the years, um, you know, emphasizing that it’s a journey, it’s not a check box, um, but, you know, talk a little about your own, uh, again, some introspection, some vulnerability, which again, I admire, uh, your own initial, uh, anxiety about You know, embarking on a, on a, on a process to, to be more diverse, equitable, inclusive. Yeah, so, Freedom Fund started 11 years ago, so, um, you know, when we started and we were recruiting, and we were based in London, initially, even though we work in countries like Ethiopia and Kenya, and Bangladesh and Brazil, um, and recruiting really talented staff, and it turned out at the end of year one or so, we had half a dozen staff and they were all white. I think all were university graduates, all deeply expert and knowledgeable. Um, and, and, you know, hugely talented, but it wasn’t a particularly diverse, um, kind of group of people, um, and particularly given that, as I said, we’re working with and partnering with organizations in Ethiopia, and Brazil and elsewhere, uh, and raising money and getting it to frontline partners and, um, and, This is before Black Lives Matter and before a lot of the debates happened, and in fact my initial kind of focus on DEI was more on my board, where we had a board of 8 and there were 2 women and 6 men. And so I thought, well, you know, we need a, a more balanced gender breakdown on a board. So I was trying to recruit the board, and the board is much more diverse, um, in various ways, and the organization was always diverse on gender, but, you know, often, often gender was a, and still is an aspect of diversity that seems to be overlooked these days when we’re looking at other characteristics. Um, and then, um, when, uh, there was a lot more focus on, On issues around, um, race and ethnicity and so on, particularly after George Floyd and, you know, the Freedom Fund works on slavery and, and there’s arguments about structural racism and being a legacy of slavery, and staff were just saying, well, what are we doing about this? And so my nervousness was in part because I could see that, um, some of these debates, Were being badly handled internally around um how, what does diversity, equity inclusion, or what does it mean to be more diverse and more inclusive as an organization. Some of them were being really badly handled and were tearing organizations apart. Um, and, and that was happening for a lot of reasons, and, and it could happen for the best of intentions, right, that people care about these issues and just can’t converse. But often, you know, leadership people might say, well, you know, we’re doing amazing work, so why are you looking internally, right? Look at what we do, we’re serving all of these underserved populations, stop, you know, it’s not about being internally focused, it’s about doing the work, and then, Staff could legitimately say well hold it, you know, we’re not representative and we don’t, and we’re not particularly inclusive and so I think, but, But also, and this is, OK, this is, we, we can have this discussion, I think, you know, it’s not just about leadership failing. I think, I think there were aspects of the way this was handled where staff who didn’t have a lot of power thought that they could use this as a very powerful tool to engage on issues that they wouldn’t otherwise do. And, and that can be really destructive, like if you kind of insist that, I don’t know, we have to change all of our policies because this is what we think. You should be doing in terms of pay policy or recruitment policy and you’ve got no responsibility for running the organization as a whole, and if you don’t manage this debate well, it can just be extremely destructive. We um, we had a a long internal discussion about this, uh, and so lots of working groups because I thought we’ve got to live our values and talk it all through and um and it wasn’t easy, um. But, but through the process, I, you know, I, I started doing my own reading and, and, and a few things were pretty obvious. One is, um, yeah, I keep on talking about teams and drawing on a pair of teams, well, if your team isn’t, if you’re drawing your team from a fairly narrow pool or not a broad enough pool, you are not accessing the best talent, right? You are not accessing the people who might know the most about the issues and when you’re working on slavery, people who know most about what is the living experience of exploitation are those that have, Been through it or come from the communities that are hugely vulnerable to it. And so if you’re just talking about a position, a situation of expertise, then you have to be drawing from the communities you serve more effectively, and you have to be drawing from the regions that you work that are closest to, uh, the places you serve, and that was just a no-brainer, so, um, and, and then again, there’s an issue of being reflective of, Um, the community you live in. Um, so we went through a process, I think that we ended up in a very good place where it was just clear that we could do better in drawing from all of the people who could help us be a better organization and be more effective, um, and be more knowledgeable about the partners we’re working with, the communities we’re working with, the issues that we’re working with. Um, and so I’m quite happy where we’ve gone, but I think, I think it’s really, Tragic that people have turned DEI into a punching bag, and they’ve turned it into a, an identity issue in a way that is not helpful, and this is people on all sides of the debate where your starting point should be, Who’s expert, how do we have the best possible team, how do we have the greatest impact by bringing in the people who know the most about the issue, uh, without being pro forma about identity one way or another. Um, so I don’t know if that’s clear and, you know, as you can see it’s something I still kind of, yeah, working my way through, but what do you see as the CEO’s role in this? how do you best facilitate? Well, it took me a while to work this out, but the way you facilitate it is exactly the way I started this whole conversation. How does this advance our purpose? Right, how, how do we, how do we become a more it doesn’t advance our purpose to say we must recruit from certain populations or other just for the sake of it. How do we get better or we’re an anti-slavery organization, right? How are we better at our anti-slavery work? Well, by having people who are deeply knowledgeable about what that means. Now, that means a whole bunch of things, right, it can mean people from the communities or the countries that we’re working, but it also can mean the best anti-slavery experts who may or may not come from particular regions, but it’s bringing a whole team together, not just kind of having a single lens of what it means. How does that advance? So, and and framing the discussions when they get heated. How does this advance, you know, it’s not about your ideology or your views. Tell me how this advances what we’re trying to do. And then let’s work backwards from that. Um, and so that’s, that would be my biggest learning was like, start with purpose, always. Tell us how this gets us there. Tell us why this will make us a better organization and a more effective organization. You say it’s the right thing to do, well, obviously, if it’s the right thing to do, it advances our purpose, how does it advance our purpose? Nick, that’s a beautiful 360 from where we began, purpose and, and holding the vision. Thank you. Thank you. So folks, the, the book is how to lead nonprofits, turning purpose into impact to change the world. Um, I think it’s a, it’s a very compassionate, uh, introspective guidebook for, for leaders and aspiring leaders. So check, check the book, please. Uh, Nick Grono, you’ll find him on LinkedIn. Nick, thank you so much for sharing all your thinking, your wisdom over uh over all these years. Very grateful. Thank you. Tony, thanks for having me on, thanks for a really wonderful rich discussion. It’s my pleasure. Next week, your improved messaging. If you missed any part of this week’s show, I beseech you. Find it at Tony Martignetti.com. We’re sponsored by DonorBox. Outdated donation forms blocking your supporters’ generosity. Donor box, fast, flexible, and friendly fundraising forms for your nonprofit, Donorbox.org. Our creative producer is Claire Meyerhoff. I’m your associate producer Kate Martignetti. The show Social Media is by Susan Chavez. Mark Silverman is our web guy, and this music is by Scott Stein. Thank you for that affirmation, Scotty. Be with us next week for nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. Go out and be great.
Over his years working with nonprofits, Dan Johnson has developed four mindsets, or principles, which he encourages leaders to embrace, and spread throughout their teams. He invites us to get comfortable with: The point is impact; the sustainable impact cycle; donors are partners, and, how volunteers get paid. He shares the touching story of his friend, Christina, who was murdered, doing the work she loved. Dan is chief consultant at Next Level Nonprofits.
Donorbox: Powerful fundraising features made refreshingly easy.
We’re the #1 Podcast for Nonprofits, With 13,000+ Weekly Listeners
Board relations. Fundraising. Volunteer management. Prospect research. Legal compliance. Accounting. Finance. Investments. Donor relations. Public relations. Marketing. Technology. Social media.
Every nonprofit struggles with these issues. Big nonprofits hire experts. The other 95% listen to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio. Trusted experts and leading thinkers join me each week to tackle the tough issues. If you have big dreams but a small budget, you have a home at Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio. View Full Transcript
And welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. I’m your aptly named host and the podfather of your favorite hebdominal podcast. If your host wasn’t so damn lackluster, he would have acknowledged Valentine’s Day last week. Just like last week, I had forgotten to acknowledge the 725th show the previous week. You would, you would think that this is, you might think these are planned, but they’re not. I, I just don’t, I don’t look ahead. So I hope you had a Valentine or more in your life last week and I will try to be more scrupulous about looking at the calendar for the coming week. But still, I’m glad you’re with us. Because I’d suffer the effects of African trippanosomiasis. If you bit me with the idea that you missed this week’s show. Here’s our associate producer, Kate, to introduce it. Hey Tony, I’m on it. The 4 mindsets. Over his years working with nonprofits, Dan Johnson has developed 4 mindsets or principles which he encourages leaders to embrace and spread throughout their teams. He invites us to get comfortable with the point is impact, the sustainable impact cycle. Donors are partners, and how volunteers get paid. He shares the touching story of his friend Christina, who was murdered, doing the work she loved. Dan is chief consultant at Next Level nonprofits. On Tony’s take 2. The kindness of a stranger. We’re sponsored by DonorBox, outdated donation forms blocking your supporters’ generosity. Donor box, fast, flexible, and friendly fundraising forms for your nonprofit, Donorbox.org. Here is the 4 mindsets. It’s a pleasure to welcome Dan Johnson to nonprofit Radio. He is chief consultant at Next Level nonprofits. He’s a 4-time nonprofit founder, former impact evaluator, and nonprofit coach. He grew his first nonprofit to 10,000 volunteers nationwide in 3 years and has created federal and state policy changes on numerous issues. He’s on YouTube at Next Level nonprofits and his company is atexlevel nonprofits.us. Dan, welcome to nonprofit radio. Thank you so much for having me, Tony. It’s a genuine pleasure. Let’s jump in. these four mindsets you have. What’s the evolution of these mindsets, you know, give us sort of a high level overview before you start the, uh, the indoctrination and uh uh uh uh uh uh process of of changing our mindsets. It does, it probably does qualify for the dictionary definition of indoctrination. I’m I’m being fair then. Not an overstatement. Alright. So I think that to put it simply, uh, the wrong mindsets keep small nonprofits small. That in all of my time, both in nonprofits, you know, having some of the wrong mindsets myself and founding my own and struggling through that, um, and working with other nonprofit founders. Um, I have found that if we skip the mindset portion. And we just jump into the skills, and we teach new nonprofit leaders, you know, certain skill sets, you know, fundraising, marketing, whatever. Then it actually doesn’t have the transformative effect it needs to have on their organization. But if we start with mindset and we spend some time in how people should think about their own nonprofit, how people should think about donors, how people should think about volunteers, things change. And a good example of that is uh one of my first clients since I launched my firm, um, is Christa at Battle to be. Which is an organization that helps first responders and members of the military who are struggling with PTSD. And uh uh when we started working together, Krista had about a $50,000 revenue per year, so considered a small nonprofit, and she was fearful of talking to donors like, heck, I even stutter when I’m reaching out to people I’ve been doing this for a long time. Um, but, uh, we worked together probably for about a month and a half or so, and a lot of that was on mindset, on her nonprofit being worthwhile on how to think about donors. And uh we did a little bit of vision work too, and, and those two elements took her nonprofit to $200,000 in revenue the next year. That’s all we did. And uh I just think that any conversation around what it takes to take your small nonprofit and make it a bigger nonprofit or make it a legacy nonprofit or make it a high impact nonprofit has to start with mindset and that’s why I suggested that as a show. OK, all right. There are 4 mindsets. Uh, let’s, uh, I’ll just reveal them quickly and then of course, you know, we have plenty of time. The, the point is impact. The sustainable impact cycle. Donors are partners. And how volunteers get paid. So let’s begin with, uh, the point is impact. What’s, what’s your, what’s your message here? How do you wanna revise our thinking, uh, so we, we are, we are on beginning our journey to the, uh, cult of Johnson, uh, for mindsets. Uh, does that sound? It’s it’s a self-help book or it’s Kool-Aid at the end. Yeah, it’s a little ethereal, but we’re gonna break it down so people know that there is a genuine there is substance here. All right. The point is. Share your message Let’s start with a charity that pretty much everybody knows, the Salvation Army and the Red Bells, that represents how charity, Salvation Army probably represents the best of how charity uh has primarily worked up until the 2000s. When you have the red buckets, the red buckets and the bell ring the bells are typically brass, I believe, brass bells just like it takes brass balls to start and grow a sustainable and fruitful nonprofit. All right, so the brass bells and the and the red buckets, yes, we’re we’re all well acquainted. rass bells and brass balls. I like it so. Uh, let me ask you a question, Tony. I generally don’t like uh guest questions this early, but go ahead, anarchist. All right, most cult leaders are, you know, are not anarchists. Well, I guess they are. They just don’t, they don’t prefer anarchy within the membership. But yes, go ahead. You’re welcome to ask a question, of course, please, anarchist, go ahead. OK, so uh when you walk out of Walmart. And you give your change to the bell ringer. Let me ask you, let’s make it my Food Lion. I’m not. I’m not much of a Walmart shopper. Yeah, works for me. Food Lion down here. So you walk out of your local Food Lion and you see the Salvation Army bell ringer around Christmas time. And uh he asks you for your change and you give him that change. Do you primarily think about the impact that that’s going to make? Or do you just think, I really hope that does some good. Yeah, I’m, yeah, I’m not even sure I’m giving it either of those. I’m just, you know, I, I got a couple of singles, so I put them in the bucket. Uh, you know, I’m not thinking about the salva, you know, I just know overall they have a good reputation. You know, we see them every year. It’s purely for me, that’s, that’s purely a transactional charity. I see them in holiday time. That, that, that’s as deep as it goes. And that is how most nonprofits run their charity. Their donors give because they have extra money. Their people give them extra stuff that is garbage, that is leftover. I don’t have any use for this, so I’m going to give it to this nonprofit. Volunteers volunteer for the organization because uh they have extra time and they want to donate to somebody and that happens to be a nonprofit or they have a friend there that they like. For the vast majority of charities and absolutely the vast majority of small ones. They have a charity mindset. We are the source, we make uh gems out of everyone else’s garbage. That would be the way to put it. And uh this is how nonprofit leaders of new nonprofits usually think. They’re thinking primarily about how you hear them all the time in fundraising calls or in conversations, talk about how frugal they are, how little they spend, how, you know, much they push their team to do more than they possibly can do. You hear them talk about all of this stuff from what I would consider to be a charity mindset that the primary thing that they are out to do. Is make people feel good. And that is also the mindset that holds them back in pretty much every area of becoming a bigger nonprofit. Say a little more about that. They, they, they want to make people feel good. Expand on that. So for a lot of nonprofits, you know, I’ll use an example, um, a guy helped out uh in Texas, uh, he started a nonprofit to help homeless individuals, um, and the way he started it was, uh, him and his mom don’t like anything at Thanksgiving dinner. They’re just not a fan of the spread at Thanksgiving. So, they started taking when they would be invited to these dinners, they started taking the dinners to the local homeless encampment. And they felt really good about it. And so they did it again, and they felt really good about it, and they did it again. And this is how the majority of nonprofits start is I have some extra time or have some extra something um or I feel really good when I help this person or when I do something for this person and I want to do that more, and I want more people to get involved with me doing that. So it actually starts with the founder and how they, they looked at it. And everyone else around them is just used to nonprofits being like this. You volunteer for a nonprofit because it makes you feel good. You donate money to a nonprofit. What did the thing we always talk about with donors is uh uh you know, they, we want to reach their heart, want to make them feel good. All of this is about feel good, right? And there’s nothing wrong with that, right? There’s, there’s nothing that is bad about the the local bridge club and making people feel good and have community. There’s nothing bad about making donors, um, you know, feel like they’re, they’re making a difference and, you know, sharing stories and there’s absolutely nothing wrong with any of that. But the thing is, when we do things to feel good. We only put our extras there. And when we don’t have extras, we don’t use it to feel good. And that I think is really important for nonprofit leaders to understand. If you run an organization like many do, like a charity, that is primarily based on making people feel good, then you will accept impact that makes you feel good but isn’t actually helping the people you serve. You will accept donors who primarily want to give to your organization because of how it makes them feel. Your volunteers will choose to show up or not show up. Everybody talks about how flaky volunteers are. They’ll choose to show up or not show up because they do it because it makes them feel good. And that pins a nonprofit in a basically impossible to grow stage because you’re constantly relying on everybody’s feelings about the organization. Instead, what I encourage a nonprofit leader to do. I think about the difference. Why is it that people can should start a nonprofit. As opposed to a for-profit or go work for the government. And the reason is simple. The government is very, very good. At requiring people to do things. If there is a problem that needs to be solved by requiring someone to do something about it. The government is where you should go. The for-profit sector is very good at meeting the needs of people who can afford it. If you are serving people who can afford all of the food as a nonprofit, you might not be in the right area. You might start that as a for-profit. What nonprofits are uniquely good at. Is making an impact on the lives of people. Who requiring them to be better is not going to help. And having them pay for a service is something they cannot afford. That is the niche, if you will, that nonprofits do well. That is different and better than just making people feel good. Nonprofits change lives. They change lives, they change communities, they change cities where they can, and that is worth something. And this is not only valuable for uh startups or people launching nonprofits but also well established. You, you want people investing in your work because of the impact you create in the community, your state, your province, the nation. The environment, the globe, however you define your community, may be the oceans, or it may be your small town. Uh, so, yeah, I, I just, I don’t want folks to be astray that this is only for, uh, you know, launching. This is, this is, and this, so this kind of, you know, these, these mindsets, I think are just generally gonna have to come from. The top down, I mean we need our CEO to be speaking often about the impact that we make in the community, not that we just want people to, uh, feel good because we’re so we’re frugal, so that makes people feel good that. We, we save money instead of investing in the community, we’re saving expenses. So, so this is gonna trickle down from all these mindsets that you want to inculcate in us, uh, uh, or inculcate us to. No, inculcate in us, I think. Uh, you have to be from the CEO level down. Absolutely, they absolutely have to be from the top, because if the top is saying. That, uh, you know, it’s about no like and trust and it’s about uh saving money and you know, look at all the money that we, you know, spend on our program and we never spend anything on our staff and we never grow our organizations the organization is not worth growing. If that attitude comes from the top, everybody else will immediately buy into it because that’s the normal attitude of nonprofits. In fact, nonprofits are so used to. Operating on a lack mentality and who you are not that it’s literally in the name. Nonprofit. Yeah, yeah, yeah, so if I can. Let me give an actionable step for anyone listening to this as to what it takes. And then we’ll move to the to our mindset. But yeah, actionable steps are very, very welcome. I don’t mean to give short shrift at all. Yeah, good. So what does it take for you to realize the impact your organization is making and what that’s worth? Start implementing this mindset at your organization. I want you to sit down and determine the economic value of what you provide. Start there, right? Give you an example. Um, a lot of people who I work with, they are running like youth entrepreneurial organizations. Um, so they’re helping you understand how to be entrepreneurs and start their own businesses, including one recently in the, um, in the global South, actually lost a friend, uh, who was taken by the violence there who was doing this. In what country? In Honduras. But I work with a lot of uh organizations doing this. And uh you know, I asked him, OK, I want you, you’re you’re concerned about asking for money, you’re, you’re concerned about, you know, talking to donors about what you offer and a lot of that, it’s not all, but a lot of the fear of asking for money is just lack of confidence in your product. You’re talking to people about what you’re doing. I want you to think about the value of what you provide. Let’s say that you help 100 young people learn to be entrepreneurs, right? And let’s say that out of them, only 20 of those young people actually go out and start their own business, decent success rate for that kind of program. And out of those 20, only 6 create companies in the area that provide 10 or more jobs. Well, at a very minimum, a company that’s providing 10 or more jobs is probably bringing in a million a year. So your work with 100 kids is worth $6 million. Isn’t it worth asking for 1000? Isn’t it worth asking for 20,000? Isn’t it worth asking for 5000? Sit down with your team. And ask yourself, what is the economic impact of what we do and that’s just direct economic impact. That’s not talking about the values you teach them, the people, the employees, how they’re furthering their lives and their children’s lives, etc. and and the economic impact that they each have because they have a regular income. Yeah, order effects, but. Uh, I want to keep us moving because I don’t wanna, I don’t wanna end up giving our last mindset, you know, 30 seconds, short trips. I, I, I, I’m not being cruel. I, I want everybody to get the full value of all, all four of the, uh, All four pillars of the. The, the mindsets, the, I was gonna, I was gonna go back to the cult, the cult metaphor, but we’ll, we’ll pass on that this time. It’s time for a break. Imagine a fundraising partner that not only helps you raise more money, but also supports you in retaining your donors. A partner that helps you raise funds both online and on location so you can grow your impact faster. That’s Donor Box, a comprehensive suite of tools, services, and resources that gives fundraisers just like you a custom solution to tackle your unique challenges, helping you achieve the growth and sustainability your organization needs, helping you, help others. Visit donorbox.org to learn more. Now back to The 4 mindsets. Uh, your next one is the sustainable impact cycle. You make a difference between Uh, corporate, uh, commercial selling and nonprofit revenue generation. Go ahead. The quarter, quarter in the slot here. Go ahead. Yeah, absolutely. So this was a probably a little bit easier to, to wrap your mind around, but it’s something important, so. In my experience, and I don’t know how this relates in the data, um, I think I saw a statistic recently that 79% of nonprofit leadership reported being burnt out. Um, and, uh, it might be higher than that, particularly among small nonprofits, because what you guys are doing, this is your passion project, this is the impact, the legacy you want to leave on the world. There is no such thing as too much time spent on the legacy that you want to make on the world. The people you want to help, right? Um, but it is also the number one cause in my experience of nonprofit failure. Absolutely it is the founder, particularly in the 1st 3 years of the organization. The founder gets burnt out. They give their all, everything they’ve got, everybody loves it and then they realize it’s not sustainable and they keep it going until something breaks, their health, their relationship with their, you know, kids, their relationship with their partner, um, and then when that thing breaks, the nonprofit dies. And I, I’d always ask myself, why is this? Why, why do we keep running into this? And uh I’m the kind of person who always looks for the fundamentals and so I, I. Determined that I think the reason for this is. People who come into nonprofits typically only have experience in for-profits prior, whether as an employee or a business owner or whatever with an organization. And uh uh they know what works there. In fact, a lot of these are just, they have a for profit mindset and they don’t understand the nonprofit side. Um, And in for profits, you have a single phase revenue cycle. Sell transactional sales, that is your revenue cycle because every new sale you make means more money for your organization. In fact, most new clients that you serve mean more money for the company, which you can then invest in getting more clients. You have a one track revenue cycle that millions of books have been written on sales. And uh in nonprofits, you have a two phase revenue cycle. You not only have to make an impact because with the nonprofit, every new client you serve is actually less money for the organization than more. So, every single time you serve more people, you actually have to then go fundraise to raise that money in order to make that sustainable. And when someone doesn’t understand that when they, you know, how do, how do most new nonprofit leaders and maybe even existing nonprofit leaders select a project, they go, I see a need, you know, we need a food pantry in this area. There’s no food pantry in this area. I see a need, let’s figure out what it takes to put the food pantry together, let’s put the project plan together, let’s, you know, figure out how we’re going to do this. Let’s go implement the food pantry. But they didn’t ask the question. Is it sustainable? Will donors fund it? Because as a nonprofit, if you want to make the impact you have in your head as a nonprofit leader, you have to make it a sustainable impact. So every single so the the sustainable impact mindset is going from. I want to make this impact, so we’re going to figure out how to make this impact. 2, I want to make this impact. So we’re going to figure out how to make this impact and if it can be funded. And it sucks that you have to do both sometimes because there are some ideas you have that would be really helpful for people you serve and you can’t find the funding for it. But what that means is you will get 65% of the way into making the impact you want to make and then it will die. And if your organization is based on that, the organization will die. You have to figure out as a nonprofit founder, not just how to sell, how to make impact in nonprofits. You have to figure out how to get it funded and every single time you go to make an impact, you should be thinking impact funding impact funding. They are pairs, they work together. If you have too much impact and not enough funding, you will start losing your impact. If you have too much funding and not enough impact, you will start losing your funding. The sustainable impact cycle is 2 phases and everything you do as an organization leader, you need to think about both the impact it will make and how you’re going to fund it. In established nonprofits, that means uh new programs. What everything you just said would apply to a subset of your work rather than your, you know, your, your, your full mission. Exactly. All right. Uh, Yeah, you know, I see a lot of strategic planning. That is, is, is very widely often unfunded. So we have this 3 to 5 year plan. And the, the funding for it is like an afterthought. Well, we’ll, we’ll just have to ask the, well after the development often it’s the development person, not even the team, we’ll have to ask the development person to just, you know, she’ll have to take on a little more, she have to do more. Well, we need, we need more grant applications because we had to fund this. So rather than funding being an integral part of a strategic plan, so you know, I’m, I’m positing a, a more established nonprofit. Uh, but same, same principle. We have a, we have a plan. How are we going to fund the plan? The funding is, is an integral part of the plan, not an afterthought. Well, then we can take this a step deeper too. You need an organization to make impact. End of story. Well, that’s number one. The point is if you could do it by yourself. You would start your own podcast. You, you would just be doing it. You would just go out and do it. Exactly. And so this. Part of the sustainable impact cycle is understanding. That I have to have an organization to make this work, which means I need to be willing to spend money. I need to be willing to hire the right people. I need to be willing to spend on infrastructure. Your lack of technology at your organization is killing you in your ability to make an impact. Because you’re not investing in the organization along with investing in the impact. If you want to make social change, social change is hard. If it were easy, everybody would do it. I know because I was in politics for 10 years prior to uh with nonprofit work, but prior to working with community nonprofits, and everybody in politics thinks they can fix everything in 2 years and that’s why so many of the solutions suck. A social change is hard. When you are going and making your impact, build out your organization with it. Invest in that team, invest in your organization, find those donors, bring in that funding, because that’s what it’s going to take to change the lives of the homeless people that you’re serving of the children you’re serving of the women you’re serving. What ended up happening with the, uh, was it mother and son, the anti-turkey, anti cranberry sauce, anti-stuffing, was it a mother and son team? It was the anti-ryptophan or what uh, what happened with that mother son enterprise just briefly go, did it, did, did it expand or it just ended up delivering 6 meals each year? Yeah, it was a bit more than 6 meals each year, but they never really got Mindset one. That was one of the ones where we jumped to tactics, they never really understood Mindset one and so what happened was the founder got really successful in his business and decided to focus on that and the nonprofit died out, because again, there wasn’t that impact value, right? I assume his business was not turkey farming. It was not. Or cranberry bogs. He did not own a cranberry bog. Did not grow green beans. No, all right, potatoes for stuffing. No, not. All right. OK. Um, all right, so before, so we’re halfway through the, the, uh, indoctrination, uh, uh, the mindsets, um, let’s spend a couple of minutes, uh, can we honor your, your friend in Honduras? What, what happened there? What was that situation? Thank you. I appreciate that. Um, I could tell it was poignant for you or is still. Yeah, um, so her name was Christina Palmer. And uh she was a corporate executive at a fairly big um tech firm. Who decided to quit her job. And moved down to Honduras. Because her husband her um her husband is Honduran and as is her son. And she saw the plight of the kids there and she had this incredible idea. To create instead of all the other organizations there that were offering pieces and piecemeal, you know, we’ll teach you how to start your own tortilla business or whatever, because she worked at in big tech, she had access to all of these resources for high tech tools. And she was developing an innovation center in Honduras, where we bring all of this tech from the United States to Honduras, whether it was AI drones, windmill technology, and introduce these young people to this tech, so that they could learn it, they could, you know, get jobs elsewhere they could improve their economic situation, they could build a business in Honduras and help overcome that economic situation there. And um she. Uh She died doing what she loved. She lost her life from one of the same people that she was trying to help. Um, she was robbed and she was killed, uh, on the day. The day before Christmas Eve. Um, And It It brings home the. Importance Of what we do, um, I. She ignored mindset too. It’s all I can say. She ignored mindset too, and she kept digging herself into a desperate situation. And not being sustainable in what she did. And it put her in a position where that could happen. And what? And that’s that’s part of why some of this stuff is so important to me. this is real work. Like I don’t, I’m not involved in not, you know, I could go work for for-profits. I have a branding and marketing background. I could go work for a bunch of different for-profits, but I’m not doing that. Because this is real work. That we’re doing here. These are lives we’re transforming, we’re developing methods for solving some of the most challenging social problems in this country. I talk about we as the nonprofit sector, right? as nonprofit. This is why we do what we do. And this stuff matters. And uh Yeah, we’re I, I’m so glad you gave me the opportunity to bring her up because uh her her vision for. What young people could achieve that they couldn’t in in the global South, what young people could achieve that it wasn’t just, you know. They can have their own tortilla shop or or they can um. You know, create cute little Honduran art things, but that young people, no matter where they were in the world. Had the ability to be. Uh, incredible players in industry and in technology and uh you know. They had the ability to compete with young people from anywhere else. That was, that was her vision, that was her dream and. Um, Well, we, yeah. I’m sorry that happened to you, your friend, to you and and to your friend Christina, you know, it, it shows the desperation. Of the folks that she was helping, she whose lives she wanted to improve. It sounds like that person was just so desperate, um, but she was doing the right thing, just. I didn’t, I just didn’t quite manage her safety and I, I’m sorry, I, I, I think that if she were watching me right now, she would probably, you know, slap me a little bit and be like, get to the point. Um, and, uh, I think the point is. It’s OK to quit your nonprofit for a little while sometimes. The problems that we take on in this world as nonprofit leaders are really hard to solve, really hard. This is not easy work that we do. That’s why it’s worth so much. It’s not easy. The, the, everybody thinks you can solve homelessness in like two months and give them a shelter. The most effective program I know is in San Diego, California called Solutions for Change. They deal with family homelessness. It takes them 5 years. To get a family out of homelessness, like permanently. It’s hard work that we do. And I think the lesson that she would want me to pass on to you guys is It’s just OK to recognize you didn’t do it right the first time. It’s OK to go back, it’s OK to get a job. It’s OK to get paid. It’s OK to put yourself in a better position all the while researching, talking to the people that you’re, you’re looking to serve, figuring out how you do this again. It’s OK to stop. So that you can start again, so that you can be better, so that there’s so much more impact you can do. But if you’re driving yourself to the point of financial desperation, if you’re driving yourself to the point of not being able to do this work anymore, where you’re mentally not able to do this, where you’re burning yourself, if you’re doing that. It’s OK to just walk. And then come back when you’re better, when you’ve learned more, and the sector could use more of that. And there’s so many more people who will be helped because you took care of yourself. And then came back and pursued your dream with the new knowledge that you had. I think that would probably be the lesson that She’d want me to pass on. Very worthy, it is essential to take care of yourself before you can take care of others. And if that means stepping aside, Whether you’re CEO or or further down, you know, uh employee in, in nonprofits and you, you’re You know, you know, you’re not, you’re not feeling right. Right. Sustained. Healthy in, in, in practices uh or or just your own, your own being, um. It’s, it’s so much smarter to step aside. And maintain your passion and, and hopefully come back, or maybe not. But either way it’ll be it’ll be better for you and better for the people who that institution is, is serving. Um, it almost seems trite now, but I have to ask, uh, do you, it does seem trite. Uh, is there an action step for our sustainable impact cycle mindset before we move on? Identify how you are not currently sustainable. So you know what you need to do. So look at a couple key areas. That’s some deep introspection. Look at your volunteers. Do you have enough volunteers to do the work you’re doing? If not, stop growing. Stop. Go get volunteers to help you fill those roles. Do you have enough staff? Do you need more than volunteers in some of those roles? If, if you need more than volunteers, stop, go get them. Where are you at as far as revenue? Are you skimping and buying the freest software in existence and you know, everybody’s using OpenOffice on their Nokia, uh, and is that harming your ability to actually carry out your program? And in a lot of cases, it is, you know, talk to people how frustrated and how difficult that is. So many nonprofits I know are still using paper, not even using anything electronic. No millennials, that’s super weird to me. But uh regardless, evaluate your personnel, evaluate your funding, and evaluate your marketing. If you’re not doing anything as it relates to marketing and getting your word out there and you need new people. That’s part of being sustainable. People have to know you exist. To know you exist is know what you do. Sit down and think, what does it take to get us to be sustainable? And go focus on that before you grow again. So this is something that you can still be doing and be passionate about and be excited about and your family can be excited about in 5, in 10, in 20 years. It’s time for Tony’s Take two. Thank you, Kate. I have a story about the kindness of a stranger. This was uh just a month or so ago, I got back to my car in a hotel parking lot. And there was a note on the windshield, which I thought was a ticket at first, but I was like, it’s, it’s a hotel parking lot. I can’t, how can I get a ticket. Uh, so, um, take a look at the note and it says, I am very sorry, my eight year old son flew our car door open and dented your rear passenger door. And, and she left her name, her email and her phone number, and, you know, very sorry. And sure enough, you know, there was a, there was a dent. It was uh like 1 inch and a half or so, and the paint was, uh, was scraped off, but it’s something that I never would have noticed. It would have taken many, many months cause I don’t have passengers and I certainly don’t have passengers getting in the, the, the passenger side in the rear seat, right? Any passenger I might have, which is like, I don’t know, 3 a year or something, they sit up front with me. So I never, it would have been a long, long time. And I was just so grateful that she did the right thing when nobody was looking, you know, it was probably her and her eight year old son. So as a parent, she taught her son the right thing to do. And with no other adults around looking, she certainly could have got away with it. She could have just ignored it. But she didn’t. She offered to pay for all the repairs, which she did. I offered to thank her by reducing the cost of the repair for her, taking $200 off. And she said thank you, but no, she, she uh sell me the full amount of the repair. So, very thoughtful woman. Did the right thing when nobody else was looking, so I’m very grateful to her. And that is Tony’s take too. OK. Yeah, that’s really sweet, and that’s also like, you know, teaching. To take accountability. Teaching their son, yeah. There was, there was one just reminds me real quick. I. I’m a really bad driver and I I don’t feel very confident parking. I was pulling into my university parking lot next to someone. I went to go get out of my car and I didn’t realize how um. They were crooked in the spot. And over into my line, but I didn’t realize pulling in and so I dinged their door. I was like, oh my god, it’s a really nice car. So I got out. I went to my passenger side to go see if like I had like a napkin or something cause I had to go to class. And then as soon as I open up my passenger side door I’m on the other side, they pull out their spot and they zoom away and then so I never got to, you know, like I’m sorry, I didn’t know to do the right thing. You didn’t even see them. You didn’t see them get in their car. No, they were in the car and their windows were, they had one of those like tinted cars. It was a really nice car and there was or anything, but like I still felt bad for, you know, dinging them a little bit. But they sped off, so I’m guessing they heard that I hit them and they were just like, ah, then they drove away. Wow, well, you were gonna do the right thing. That’s the point. That’s the point you’re going to do the right thing, didn’t. We’ve got Boou but loads more time. Here’s the rest of the Four Mindsets with Dan Johnson. Mindset number 3, why don’t you uh introduce this one, please. I have two posters on my wall. One you can see in this video, I know it’s mostly audio, but when you can see over your right shoulder, it says charity. Charity is crossed out and charity. Charity is crossed out and is beneath it. Yes, all right, thank you. And I have another poster on the other side over there. That crosses out donor and replaces it with partner. Why? Because I need nonprofit leaders to understand. That uh because the point is impact. And because you need both money and impact to survive. You provide the impact and your donors provide the money. They’re partners in what you do. Everybody says, oh well, I don’t want to go sell to donors, so it’s easier to sell to somebody when you’re selling them something that they could use. And my response to that. Is uh you think the donors aren’t getting anything out of this? Really? You, you, you think you, if you truly think that donors to your organization aren’t getting anything out of it, shut down the organization because you’re a waste of funds and there are 1.7 million other nonprofits working on things that could be funded instead, and I’m dead serious about that. The reason that we I think that our organizations are not delivering to our donors as we have not sat in their shoes. Why do donors give? There was a, there’s one of my favorite books, the, um, it’s by William Sturdivant, and it is the Artful journey. And it goes through the process of developing a major donor, major gift donors written in the 90s. You sound a little unsure about the book and the title. Are you sure this is a book you’ve read? It is. It sounds a little unclear. OK, I was, I was unsure about the title. Yeah, I yeah, I was just a little fog, but this is a legitimate that you have. Yes, I believe you. So, uh, the artful journey, one of the things in it is he has a study where they asked donors, why do you give? Why do you support nonprofits? And unsurprisingly, if you’ve been in the nonprofit expert space for a while, the top answers were not the tax deduction and because I feel guilty. So, you know. But the top answer was not the team. It was not no like and trust. That is a bad model. The top answer was the vision. I give to the organization because of. What I believe they will achieve. See the donors who give you, particularly donors who give you any amount of money with a comma in it. They kind of wish they were in your shoes. What I mean by that is they kind of wish they were on the front lines, helping people that you help. They wish they were there and able to serve the people that you serve, but they can’t be. Hm, interesting. And uh and that’s why stories work so well, by the way, like, quick aside, that’s why stories in donor conversations work so well. You are telling them what it’s like to be there. Yeah, you’re, you’re drawing them into the work. Right? They they can almost envision themselves. Hm, yeah, exactly. So the way they can be there, quote unquote is with their money. That is what they can provide in this relationship. And what that means is uh. Nonprofits primarily treat their donors like ATMs. I go to you when I need money, and we all know you got to thank them and you got to reach back out to them and and whatever. But I want you to think of them instead. As partners, as people who are essential in helping you do this work. So the primary way they support you is their money, but they also have a lot of knowledge, and they also have a lot of connections, and they also might even want to volunteer sometimes to, you know, help out the organization. And don’t our partners offer all of those back to us besides their money. It’s also their influence and their networks. Uh, and their own values and yeah, so, uh, uh, a, a, a real partnership. Is, is more much deeper than just financial. Exactly. And that’s how I want organizations to start treating their donors. If you are linking up with a business partner, are you pitching them before you even know whether they would be a good partner for you? No. You’re having a conversation. Hey, what do you, what do you invest in? What’s your mission? What, what, what are you trying to do with your money? Why do you like my organization? Why do you want to talk to us? Why do you give us money? If you have partners after they give you a contribution or they contribute, do you like never talk to them for 36 months, a year, whatever, or are you consistently reaching out up what’s going on, giving them advice, you know, getting advice from them, uh, seeing if they have ideas. If you treat your donors like they fund our mission and that’s what we do, that’s what you’ll get, and then you won’t even get that. But if you treat your donors like partners, like people who wish they could be on the ground with you and want to do everything they can to help you make this work. Your donor retention rate will go through the roof. And you will spend a lot less time and money and effort, prospecting and trying to bring in new donors to fund what you’re doing. I spend a lot more time and effort just getting a whole lot more money from the people that you’re working with. We know that the donor attrition rate is very high. Over 75% of first year donors don’t come back to a second gift, and that, and it’s so much more costly to attract a new donor than it is to retain an existing one. It, it’s a it’s also more fun. It is, it is, absolutely. It’s not just sales all the time. It’s relationships and every relationship can’t be a personal one, but it can, it can feel, you know, if, if, if you’re embracing this mindset number 3 that your donors are your partners. It’s a, it’s a different way of looking at the relationship. It’s a different way of messaging to folks, you know, again, everybody can’t be someone that, that you have a handshake and a hug with and a lunch every month. That’s not sustainable, but it’s the way you think about folks. The way you bring them to you, the way you message to them will be very different if you’re thinking of them as, as the kind of partnership that that you’re proposing. Exactly. Is there an action step for donors or partners? Yes, there is. I want you to reform your, this, this should be fairly quick. Um, and I do have a uh tool to do this. It’s at the very bottom of my website at Next Level nonprofits.us. There is a link to the, I think it’s called the Donor Progress packet. Um, but if you click on that, it’ll take you to Google Drive and it actually has templates in it, but what I want you to do. I want you to uh implement. Um, a 4 star donor thank you system. This comes from Trevor Bragdon’s seven figure fundraising. See, I remember the name of that book. That was that that sounds much more credible than Sturdivant. So the 4 star thank you system is I just want you to think about. These donors are used to getting, especially your bigger ones, are used to getting really high tier customer service. Um, you know, they’re platinum at Delta, they are gold at Marriott, they are whatever. So what would it look like to give a donor top tier customer service when they give a donation to your organization? And there are at least 4 things to look at. One is a thank you call. Immediately as soon as possible. Another is a thank you letter. Another is a thank you text. And uh the final is the donor acknowledgement letter. You do at least those four things, at the very minimum for every donor who comes into your space. I love pick up the call, pick up the phone for effusive thanks. And I’m also a big proponent of handwritten notes. Absolutely. There’s there’s 2 of 24, yep. All right. So the resources, uh, is at the bottom of the page, bottom of the home at next nonprofits. Implementing something. Uh, high touch for your, your, your larger donors, your major, however you define major donors, some organizations, $150 may be a major gift. Others may be $10,000. That’s right. And actually, I, one correction, this is for all your donors, you implement this for every single donor because the mindset is donors are partners. The, the, um, Charity Water, which is a very famous uh nonprofit for those in the space. Um, they found that the vast majority of their kind of inner giving circle of their top donors started by giving them a $25 donation. Do not forget that your donors are your partners, treat them all to the extent you can like that, and you will see how they level up. Mindset number 4, we’re focused on our volunteers. So, so we’ve, we’ve just talked about how donors benefit, how our donor partners benefit. Now we’re looking at how our volunteers benefit and, and you frame it as Uh, how volunteers get paid. Understanding the volunteer paycheck. So please carry on. So uh. There are 3 kinds of organizations and how they treat their volunteers. Actually, there’s really only 2 major ones. We’ll talk about the 2 major ones. Top down and bottom up. And everybody thinks the latter one is better. So you have top down, top down is I tell you what to do, where to stand, how to do it, you know, when to do it, and you have to get approval from me in order to do that, right? Um, and that is how a lot of corporate America works. So that is the framework that a lot of us are used to using. And then you have another model, which is bottom up. And bottom up looks a little bit different. So instead of all the ideas and everything coming from the top. You have a lot of ideas and things coming from the bottom. But Bottom up always has a feature where the top has to approve it. So even if the bottom comes up with the idea, so you have your, uh, you know, line worker at the pantry, so I think we really need to have better boxes or whatever, that goes up to their volunteer chief who passes it to the department head, who eventually gets it approved by whoever needs to be at the top. Um, and both of them suffer from the same problem in managing volunteers, which is Volunteers look to you to be told what to do. And uh when you are a nonprofit leader, I’m willing to bet you don’t have a ton of extra time. Uh, there’s not exactly free spots in your calendar laying around for everything and everyone talks about volunteers like herding cats. If you adopt a top down or bottom up model. You are going to be herding cats. Because both of those are hierarchies. Where you called me an anarchist earlier, you might not realize how close to that I am. Both of those are hierarchies. Where volunteers are just kind of waiting on somebody else to tell them what to do. And as long as they’re doing that. You will struggle with volunteers. You will have to, they won’t show up, you have to call them to get to do the thing, to follow up all the time, yada yada, etc. That is the failure of providing volunteer ownership. I prefer a 3rd model. Uh, which was outlined, uh, in Working swarm wise by Rick Falkvier. Now Rick Falkvia is, if you’ve never heard of him, is the founder of the Swedish Pirate Party. Which became the largest third party in the world in 8 years. In fact, it was so large that they took a majority in Swedish parliament. And all of their positions were adopted by every major party in Europe. The he developed the concept of the swarm, which is we’re going to trust our volunteers to do what needs to be done. And then we’ll check on it. That is one of the 3 keys to the volunteer paycheck, and the one that nonprofits miss the most. So here’s your volunteer paycheck because I know we’re running out of time. Volunteers don’t get paid money. But they do get paid in 3 different ways. Purpose, ownership, and mastery. Volunteers get paid because they are contributing to what? the impact that you’re making. They see themselves being a part of that impact and they want to be part of something bigger. Volunteers get paid the second way and they are a part of that impact. Any person who tells you they don’t want the credit on your team doesn’t want to be seen getting the credit. They do actually want to know they individually are making a difference and that is why they must own the area that they operate in. And 3rd is mastery. Volunteers want to get better at a particular task. I’m volunteering for organization because I want to get better at web design, and I’m going to start by working with you. I’m volunteering your organization because I want to get better at X, I want to get better. If you are constantly delivering to your volunteers, purpose, ownership, and mastery, they will work for you like employees. And they will be thrilled about it. I had volunteers in my organization. Move states and moves scaled, but your first nonprofit 10,000 volunteers nationally in 3 years. Yes. Uh, I had my volunteers move states and move their entire family to a different state to be more effective at what we did. Wow, you had volunteers change residences, moves, moved to continue volunteering for you? Yes, your work, not the cult, not you, the cult leader. This is where I got everybody moved to Courd’Alene, Idaho. Uh no one fact, it was actually Idaho they moved to, but that’s hilarious. Coeur d’Alene has a rich history and uh and uh I think it’s white supremacy actually, but um it’s unfortunate. OK, yeah, uh. All right, so, all right, say a little more, you know, we can, we, we saw a few minutes. I, I don’t wanna, again, I don’t want to give a short trip to the volunteers, but you know, this purpose ownership man is like Palm POM like Palm I’m thinking of the palm that you’re the, uh, this is the pomegranate juice, uh, that’s a good analogy. OK, yeah, the POM, the company, the right, the pomegranate juice, uh, volunteer management strategy you have. All right, so say some more. Go ahead. So, uh, you had people move, you had people changing their homes to continue volunteering for the organization? Yes, go ahead, I interrupted you twice. No, it’s OK. It actually sometimes creates a bit of a burden to have people believe that much in the organization, but anyway. It’s a responsibility. It is, it is a responsibility, um, and it won’t always go your way. So the Volunteer paycheck. How you implement this with your volunteers. I, you know, first of all, you understand what of these are they most interested in when they come into your organization. Most volunteers want all three, but for every volunteer, not every paycheck is the same. Some people are more interested in getting better at a skill set than they are in, you know, owning that area or whatever. Some people are more interested in. Um, having being a part of your purpose, than they are in, you know, learning a skill set. So the first thing I want you to do. I, I want you to ask every single person who volunteers for your organization, why? They want to volunteer. That is not already a part of your process, implement that in your onboarding process now. Because you need to know if you just like employees aren’t gonna show back up at your company, if you’re not paying them, at least not usually. Volunteers aren’t gonna show back up. If you’re not paying them. So you need to know what’s your volunteer salary. And that question will help you understand what is that volunteer’s salary. Now you and your volunteer coordinator, whoever manages your volunteers, what they want from their volunteer work. Correct. What is their volunteer paycheck? So that’s number one. And number 2, I include all three in a volunteer onboarding. How do you do that? One Every single volunteer who comes on board, by the way, I always do a 20 to 45 minute onboarding with every new volunteer, always. Nonprofits bring on people too fast. They hire too quickly and they fire too slowly, put it that way and the wrong volunteer who doesn’t fit your culture can wreck it. They can drive 1020 volunteers away, right? So, number one. is we’re gonna talk about the organization’s vision. Ideally a transformational vision. We’re gonna talk about the organization’s vision, the impact we’re looking to make, and what our values are. Every volunteer gets that. Number 2 is, uh, I have a couple areas in mind that I want that I think you’d be good at as a volunteer, you know, whether they you indicated on the form, I’m interested in admin, I’m interested in helping out on the ground, I’m interested in whatever. I have a couple ideas in mind of where you can own in this organization. And uh are we still on because you froze on me. Oh, there we go. You’re just frozen like a statue. I’m captivated it’s. So anyway, it’s valuable. um, so I have a couple of areas in mind that I think that they might be interested in helping out with, let’s say, you know, website and you know, sending emails, they’re marketing persons website, sending emails and uh you know, designing our physical newsletter in graphic design. And I asked them, which of those would they be most interested in. Which a lot of people do. OK, fine. And then they they pick one that they they want to do. And then I do something different. I say uh awesome. So, uh, I’m gonna give you uh a task to do in that area. This is the thing we’re looking for. And um what I’d like from you is to carry that out, but also bring me a little bit of a plan of how you think this area could be better. In our organization because the way we work after you spent some time doing the work, yes, I’d like to meet with like I’d like to meet with you again in 6 or 8 weeks. Yeah, I usually let them pick because uh they have their own time still, right? So 2 weeks. OK, great, meet in 2 weeks. Um, and what I tell them is because we’re the kind of organization where, uh, we. Uh, won’t really tell you all that much what to do. Um, but we will hold you responsible for the outcome of your role, and we will provide support to you as much as we can. Instead of this being an organization that you contribute to, we are an organization that supports you in your volunteer work. And that will both tell you, are they a potential leader in any way, shape or form if they come back with that plan? And are they actually going to do anything at your organization if they come back with a task done. They don’t, it’s a filtering mechanism to filter out bad volunteers and it is a powerful mechanism for reframing the volunteer relationship. Where you own your area and you make decisions on your area and if I don’t like the decisions that you’re making and I think they’re bad for the organization, I will remove you rather than removing your decision ability because volunteers have to be able to own what they do or they will just be sitting ducks and wait for you to come tell them. And the last thing I asked them What would you like to get better at? Is there anything you want to learn while you’re here? Right, that mastery element. And, oh, you know, I’ve always wanted to learn grant writing. I don’t know why, but I’ve always wanted to learn grant writing. OK, cool. Um, and you know, somewhere down the line, we’re gonna have a grant writer come and speak to our volunteer team. And they’re going to learn about grant writing, and it’s gonna take me 30 minutes to set up and it’s going to make their day for 3 months. Whenever volunteers do not work, this is the mindset, volunteers do not work for your organization for free, period. They don’t work for your organization because they like you. They might do that for a little bit of time. They don’t work for your organization just because they feel good if they’re going to be committed. They work for your organization because they get a paycheck. You know what that paycheck is when you bring those volunteers on and you need to deliver on that paycheck. And then. You will stop having as many complaints of, oh, they didn’t show up. oh volunteers are unreliable, oh this, oh that, pay your volunteers with their paycheck and they will work for you like you pay them and that is really intensely valuable for organizations who can’t yet do that with the full staff. And the action step for identifying the paycheck, the purpose, ownership or or mastery is asking these questions in the onboarding process. That’s right. Hi, Dan, uh, this, it’s pretty, yeah, this is the first time someone thought I froze on them when I, when I hadn’t, uh, but no, you, I mean, you really captured me, uh, talking about the volunteer paycheck. Uh, we haven’t spent a lot of time. And, uh, we, we’ve had guests through the years to talk about volunteer management, but not so much the, you know, making sure they get out of it what they want and asking them what it is they, what it is they want. All right, that valuable. So that’s why I froze on you. Uh, I was just I was just listening patiently, that’s all. Um, it’s very good. It’s an interesting moment. All right, valuable, valuable shit, really. Um, why don’t you wrap it all up? I, I’ll give you, you know, take a moment, wrap it all up before, uh, the before mindsets. Well, first of all, uh thank you to everyone for listening to this. Um, it has been a long time since I have been on the podcast circuit. So Tony, you were one of my uh first uh usually, usually everything leads to nonprofit radio. We are the, we’re the pinnacle that everyone is working there the denouement is nonprofit radio. Since you’re an avid reader, you’re, well, you, you only you cited nonfiction books, but Uh, you, you, you understand what I’m talking about. So we’re just getting you started now. I’m, I’m a little disappointed at that. You might just cut it off. Now you’ve already, you’ve reached the pinnacle. You just didn’t know it. That’s fair. Maybe this is the last show. Maybe this should be for the next, yeah, until the next, you know, wait 18 months. Take a, take a step aside as we, as we suggested might be appropriate in, uh, mindset number one, it might be time for you to move aside and then bring yourself back, you know, starting again. All right. Well, at the very least, I have a habdominal. I now know what that means. Um, so, uh, but I want to thank everyone for, for listening to this, and if you do have feedback on the mindsets, because it’s my first podcast back after, after several years, it’s been like 2017, um, uh, then I would appreciate that. That would be awesome. Maybe you can send it to Tony and he can pass it on to me. That would be great. Um, I want to end with what I think would be most valuable for any organization that feels like they are not sustainable. So you do that assessment and you’re like, oh man, we don’t really have enough money, we’re pushing our people too hard. You know, we’re we’re just not in a place where. You know, your kind of test is, does this organization run normally or does it feel like you are burning the candle at both ends all the time to do this and to make it work and people aren’t listening to you and they’re not getting on board, whatever, right? That’s the first phase of nonprofit growth. If you’re struggling in that area. One of the things that we’ve developed over the past couple of years with our clients is the 5 steps, or the 5 levels of sustainability as a roadmap for how do you actually get a nonprofit? That has the money that has the, you know, everything you need to run one program and make an impact. How do you do that? Um, and we’ve broken down those five steps on my website, so I have a giveaway that is the sustainable nonprofit Roadmap on my Next Level nonprofits.us website. It’s the 5 steps that take you from where you are to being a sustainable organization. And uh uh if you put in the reference, nonprofit radio, I’ll know you came from here, and uh uh you can get, you can also get on my calendar in addition to just getting that roadmap, but I want to make sure you guys have that roadmap, so you’re not sitting there, you’re not wondering what does it take to make this nonprofit work, man? Why doesn’t it actually work? Why am I putting in all this effort and time and energy and it’s just, I feel like I’m burning a candle at both ends all the time. This is your roadmap to get out of that, so you can focus on making an impact instead of just making the nonprofit work. It’s on my website, Next Level nonprofits.us. Put a nonprofit radio in the reference. I know you came from here. If you do that, then I’ll also send you a link to my calendar. We can hop on and kind of diagnose where you’re at and see if I can give you some, some helpful tips to walk away with. Well, thank you for that generous offer for our listeners. Thank you. Thank you, Dan. Dan Johnson, uh, who now realizes that his, uh, podcast gusting is all gonna be downhill from here. It can only get worse Because you’re at the pinnacle. Uh, Chief consultant at Next Level nonprofits, again, Next Level nonprofits. and you will find him on YouTube also at Next Level nonprofits. Dan, thank you very much. Thank you for sharing and, and the story of Christina and, and your thinking on the, on the mindsets. Thanks so much for sharing all of this. Thank you for having me on, Tony. Next week, Jean and Amy return for a light chat about the devastations facing our nonprofit community. If you missed any part of this week’s show, I beseech you. Find it at Tony Martignetti.com. We’re sponsored by DonorBox. Outdated donation forms blocking your supporters’ generosity. Donor box, fast, flexible, and friendly fundraising forms for your nonprofit, Donorbox.org. Our creative producer is Claire Meyerhoff. I’m your associate producer Kate Martignetti. The show’s social media is by Susan Chavez. Mark Silverman is our web guide, and this music is by Scott Stein. Thank you for that affirmation, Scotty. Be with us next week for nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. Go out and be great.
Sarah Wood reminds us of the value in telling good stories to your stakeholders. Also, how do you tell them? Where do you tell them? Which ones are worth telling? What’s ethical storytelling? And, what’s the right engagement or call to action? We pull some lessons from her children’s favorite stories, the “Narwhal and Jelly” series and “Dandelion Magic.” She graciously shares her own story of solo motherhood by choice. Sarah’s company is Sarah Wood Communication.
Donorbox: Powerful fundraising features made refreshingly easy.
We’re the #1 Podcast for Nonprofits, With 13,000+ Weekly Listeners
Board relations. Fundraising. Volunteer management. Prospect research. Legal compliance. Accounting. Finance. Investments. Donor relations. Public relations. Marketing. Technology. Social media.
Every nonprofit struggles with these issues. Big nonprofits hire experts. The other 95% listen to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio. Trusted experts and leading thinkers join me each week to tackle the tough issues. If you have big dreams but a small budget, you have a home at Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio. View Full Transcript
Welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. I’m your aptly named host and the podfather of your favorite hebdominal podcast. Oh, I’m glad you’re with us. I’d be thrown into dextrogastria if you upset my stomach with the idea that you missed this week’s show. Here’s our associate producer, Kate, to tell us what’s going on this week. Hey, Tony, I’ll be happy to. Storytelling. Sarah Wood reminds us of the value in telling good stories to your stakeholders. Also, how do you tell them? Where do you tell them? Which ones are worth telling, and what’s the right engagement or call to action? We pull some lessons from her children’s favorite stories, the Narwhal and Jelly series and dandelion magic. She graciously shares her own story of solo motherhood by choice. Sarah’s company is Sarah Wood Communication. On Tony’s take 2. Thank the folks who nobody thanks. We’re sponsored by Donor Box. Outdated donation forms blocking your supporters’ generosity. Donor box, fast, flexible, and friendly fundraising forms for your nonprofit, DonorBox.org. Here is storytelling. It’s a pleasure to welcome Sarah Wood. She is the founder and chief communication consultant at Sara Wood Communication LLC. A lifelong voracious reader, Sarah has been helping individuals and organizations identify and effectively share the stories of their good work for her entire professional career, and she still loves a good story. We’re gonna talk all about stories and storytelling. You’ll find Sarah on LinkedIn and her company is at Sarah with an H Wood communication. Dot com. Sara Woodcommunication.com. Sarah Wood, welcome to nonprofit Radio. Thank you for having me. I’m excited to be here today. Oh, I’m glad, pleasure. Storytelling. You’ve been doing this for a long time. Why, uh, why are, why are we still talking about storytelling? We’ve been talking about storytelling for years now. What, what brings this, what makes this so timely for us? Well, storytelling has become the the term, right, that we’re using now, uh, and people are very into, you know, they talk about storytelling, they talk about narrative, they talk about all that. In reality we’ve been doing this. The entire human existence, right? Uh, I mean, you can go back to caveman days, um, before we even had a written language. People were telling stories, sitting around the campfire, telling stories, uh, and that was how they were teaching people. It was how they were remembering things. It was how they were communicating with each other. Um, and so in some ways, nothing has changed, right? Uh, we still know that there’s a lot of research out there that shows that’s one of the best ways for humans to pass on information. It’s what we do with small children, right? We read to them, we tell them stories. If they’re getting ready to do something new, we talk about like, oh, here’s a children’s book for it, that’s gonna help them kind of like understand and process and go through it. And the same is true for adults, and we still love a story, even those of us who don’t get to read that often. I used to be a voracious reader. I still have that in my bio, but I’ve got two small kids and, you know, a business and everything else, and so I don’t read as much as I would like to anymore. You’re reading. I am. I’ve read so many of them. You’re a voracious reader of children’s stories. What age are your children? Um, they’re 2 and 6. Oh, the 22 year old, do you? I don’t have children. Do you read the 2 year olds or is that too early? You you when they’re like newborns. It’s a it’s a good thing I don’t grow up illiterate because I wouldn’t know I wouldn’t know. Hopefully somebody would have told me. Uh, OK, so you start at, uh, at birth or, you know, we’re hearing our whole lives, right? Whether they’re books, whether it’s radio, whether it’s television, whether it’s, you know, just some story that your parent made up to help you go to sleep at night, you know, we’re telling stories the entire time and we’re listening and we’re learning and that’s how. We learn about humans and we feel connected to each other. So we’ve been, we’ve been doing it the entire time, but there’s a rise of interest in it as far as nonprofits go recently. All right, but before we get to nonprofits, so give a shout out to your six year old’s favorite book. That’s a tough one. You know, he really likes the, um, trying to think of the name of it, Narwhal and Jelly series. It’s a kind of comic graphic novel type thing, and the main characters are a narwhal and a jellyfish. Um, and so there’s all these different titles in the series, and, and he really loves those. OK. So there are, so they may they may be sympathetic or maybe they’re in need of a title or. To, to, to broaden their own voracious reading children’s books. Yeah, and I mean the good thing, good thing they’re they’re kind of out of the, I want to read the exact same thing like over and over and over again. My 2 year old, you know, we’re definitely like, we can read the same book like 10 times in a row and she’s still fascinated. have a favorite? Uh, she likes it. It’s right here next to me. It’s called Dandelion Magic, and she likes it because it instructs you to like blow on the magic dandelion. So, you know, she gets to like, and, and blow, um, and make magic things happens. It’s an engaging. There’s some, there’s some engagement that we may talk about, uh, hopefully we’ll be talking about donor engagement with their stories. So she likes the act of blowing on blowing on the dandelion. Yes, she does, she does. She’s a big fan of that. All right, so we can pivot back to the less interesting but maybe more relevant nonprofit storytelling. All right. Well, some of the same things apply, right? You still want to make it interesting and ideally you’re making it interactive in some sort of way. Um, you know, a son and daughter, you know. Uh, what about feedback or or volunteer feedback or just whoever readers reader feedback on our stories? How do we get feedback? How do we know which is the favorite stories? Well, it depends on how you’re presenting the stories, what stats you have available, right? Different platforms are gonna have different ways for you to measure kind of what’s happening, who, who’s interacting with it and, and who’s not. Um, I mean, you also have kind of Behind the scenes ways of doing that, you know, you can kind of set up some separate URLs or landing pages, you know, so that you can kind of track specific interests of like, you know, who’s coming from this place and who’s coming from that place. Um, so it really kind of depends on what your setup is and kind of how you’re presenting your story. OK, if you’re, if you’re presenting it to a list and if you’re, I guess if your list is big enough, uh, you could test, you could test different stories, right? If you, if you have a large enough list to have a valid test or a simple AB test of different stories, OK. All right, I’m making you jump around, but, uh, I, I know, I wanted to launch off the uh the children’s children’s reading because that’s what you’re a voracious reader of children’s stories. So, yes. Well, and you know, I mean, some, some storytelling does happen in person, right? So if you’re at an in-person event, if you’re at an event for your donors or an event with uh potential donors, right, you can kind of catch up on all the cues, right, of are they interested or not, you know, you’ve got the nonverbals then. Um, but you know, it really depends on kind of how you’re presenting it. That’s, that’s a very interesting ones on that thread a little bit. The in storytelling, like having your cache of, uh, I don’t know, one program or, you know, whatever, you know, you’ve got some stories in mind that when people say, you know, oh I love your Uh, the hospice work you do really moves me, you know, then maybe you’ve got a hospice story or it’s the, uh, you know, it’s the fact that you’re a no-kill shelter. Oh, that really, now I’ve pivoted now. Now that’s not a human no-kill shelter. That’s an animal I’ve pivoted from human to human uh hospice, although you get a pet hospice too, but I wasn’t thinking of that. So we’re not talking about animal urine you’re a no kill shelter. I love that, you know, that aspect because you’re the only one in our state that’s a no-kill shelter or something like that, so. You know, so yeah, I mean I I never thought of in storytelling. Yeah, I always encourage anyone. I mean this is any organization doesn’t have to do with what industry you’re in, but you have to have your elevator speech down first, right? What is your organization? What’s the main thing that you do? Why should people care? You know, you need that kind of one minute spiel, right? Um, that you can give to anyone. And I always tell people, listen, don’t just get your executive director who’s able to do that. Every single. Employee in your organization should be able to give a one minute elevator speech about your organization, what it is, what it does, and why it’s important. Uh, if not, you’re just missing so many potential opportunities because think about how many more people every single staff person of yours interacts with on a daily basis than just, you know, your executive or your C-suite or or what have you. You know, you really wanna make sure that everyone’s on the same page. Um, so that’s one. But also, yes, absolutely, you should have like your back pocket full of like. Pack full stories. I mean, people want to do business with people. We know that there are companies, we know there’s organizations, but the more we can humanize and personalize those and we can put a face to what we’re doing and why it’s important, the more successful a nonprofit’s gonna be. I mean, it’s, it really lays the foundation for anything that you might want to ask those people later, right? Because if you just come up to someone and you say, hey, give me some money to do X, they’re gonna be like. Why? You know, like, what, what impact is this gonna have? Like, and people love other people, right? So, I mean, and it is not, even if your nonprofit doesn’t work with people, like you were just saying, like, the, the dogs, right? Or the no-kill shelter, you know, the dogs or the cats. We wanna like personalize and humanize the dogs and the cats, so that people feel close to them. They feel connected. The more connected someone feels, the more likely they are to. Invest in your organization and in your mission. Right. Now, how about uh disseminating these stories to, let’s say board members or volunteers it could be, could be non board member volunteers, you know, they’re, they’re great spokespeople because they, they devote time. They give several hours a week or whatever, you know, time, time is great value, especially now, time and attention. So. So volunteers could be great storytellers and as well as your board, but how would you, how do you pass these stories on to them? Like, so let’s take, um, let’s take the harder case first, like volunteers. So these folks are spending maybe 45, I don’t know, 10 hours a week or something. How would you arm them with stories about your work? I think volunteers are going to have their own stories, so it’s more about helping them share them in a way that is helpful to the organization they’re gonna share what their work is right, they’re gonna talk about their personal experiences, um, and, and their personal interactions or or and you know what they get out of it and what they feel like they’re doing. Um, so like I said, it’s more about helping them learn how to share that in a way that is effective, um, and that helps the organization overall. So how do you, how do you help them effectively? I think you have to arm them with the facts, right? You want them not just to have their personal experience, but to give them the the bigger picture, right? of how does their personal experience fit in with the bigger picture. I think if they have a particular thing that they want to talk about and they let you know that, I think that you can provide them with the background. Yeah, I mean, if you’re a big enough organization, you can even do media training for your volunteers, um. And you can pitch them as speakers as kind of ambassadors and out into the community, uh, that does take, you know, some, uh, staff effort on the, on, on the inside, but I think take advantage of the opportunities, you know, if you have a volunteer, particularly if you have a volunteer that is very well connected in the community, make sure that they have the information that you want them to have. And if they want to take that opportunity to kind of like practice what it is they want to say, give them that opportunity. OK. All right. And uh board members, that’s a little easier. I mean you could, you could write some story, you could write some anecdotes, you could share, have people come and tell their own personal story at board meetings, right? How important your work is not to the community, but to me, me, my family, my child, me personally, my spouse, whatever, right? And board members and the same thing with volunteers like that are already there if they’re already there. They’re already kind of committed, right? They already know about your organization. They are, they’ve already drank the Kool-Aid to, you know, throw an adage in there, um, you know, they’re, they’re already on board with what you’re doing. You don’t have to convince them. It’s not a hard sell, right? It’s just about showcasing the impact that you are having and nonprofits do so many good things and if they don’t talk about them. They’re just kind of lost, right? I mean you might impact a few people, a handful of people that directly know what happened, right? But if you can’t share those stories and amplify them and put them out into the world, you’re gonna hit a plateau for your organization where you’re not able to get the volunteers or to get the donations or to expand the programming or bring people in that that you could help, right? Because they don’t know about you, they don’t know about what’s happening so the more you can tell your stories, the more you can put it out into the. World, the better off your organization is gonna be because you’re gonna be able to have this foundation of support you’re gonna have this relationship with your audiences because you’ve been consistently telling them what you’re doing so that way when you ask them for money or you come out with big news, they’re already primed to listen to what you have to say because they’ve already decided, OK, this is a valid source and this is a source that is doing important things and so I’m gonna pay attention when they are saying something to me. Right, get good folks out. Um, let’s get folks out storytelling and finish, finish my thought. Um. Yeah, don’t overlook your ambassadors. Any, you know, anyone who is willing to be an ambassador for you and to talk you up, you know, give them the tools to do that. It’s time for a break. Imagine a fundraising partner that not only helps you raise more money, but also supports you in retaining your donors. A partner that helps you raise funds both online and on location so you can grow your impact faster. That’s Donor Box, a comprehensive suite of tools, services and resources that gives fundraisers just like you a custom solution to tackle your unique challenges, helping you achieve the growth and sustainability your organization needs, helping you help others. Visit donorbox.org to learn more. Now back to storytelling. How about engagement? We, we, we, we talked about uh your daughter’s engagement with the dandelion, dandelion story. She loves to blow on the little on the dandelion pages, I guess you can blow on the pages. Yes, OK. Like they can’t still be dandelion seeds. There’s nothing really blowing. It’s not a dandelion, it sounds like she’s so many times. I mean she does really blow and of course, you know, like you know it is not a slot like dandelions in the book. OK. What’s the name of the book. And magic magic, OK. So let’s let’s continue there. So what about engagement with your stories? Is there, is there a parallel for for nonprofits, folks engaging not so much, yeah, not so much the metrics, but the engagement. The old mode of communication was much more one way communication, right? It was kind of we say it. You hear it, and there wasn’t really an an ability to interact, certainly not in real time, right? I mean, you could conceivably like write a letter and mail it, you know, and, and all those kind of things. Um, but there wasn’t really the ability to interact in real time that we have now, right? And so now we have much more ability to get instant responses or instant reactions, and we can do, we can even do live things, right? Um, and we can get them like right away. Um, so I think. Things that your audience is interested in and that they want to interact with are very important because you don’t want it, you don’t want people to feel like they’re being lectured to, right? You want them to feel like part of the community, part of the conversation. And part of the way you do that is just having interest interesting content, right? But and humanizing it and personalizing it and all the other things that we’ve talked about, um, because that makes people feel more involved. But other ways you do it is, you know, you ask them questions, you give them ways to get involved. You don’t just kind of like put it there. And then drop off the face of the earth, like, um, what do they want to see? You know, what does this make them feel like? Are they going to take action? Here’s the actions we’d like you to take. Would you do any of these things? Like, I think all that kind of engagement is, is important, and It depends on where your audience is, how you’re going to interact with them the most, you know, maybe, maybe your main audience is on email, maybe it’s on social media, maybe it is these in-person events, maybe you do a lot of local in-person meet and greet type things. I mean, it, it really is gonna depend on. The organization and the specific people that they are trying to reach. Um, but yeah, you, I mean, you have to be engaging. I mean, I think we’ve, there are so many people trying to catch your attention. That you have to be engaging or. You’re you’re forgetful, right? I’m not forgetful, you’re forgotten, um. And it’s, it’s hard to catch people’s attention. I, you’re forgotten or you’re forgettable. Yes, yes. And you know, I feel like there was that old adage that You know, you have to hear things 3 times before you would take an action. And I was like, well, that’s very outdated, right? You have to hear things way more than 3 times now. I was on a webinar the other day and someone dropped it, it’s now 25 times. And I was like, well, they didn’t actually cite that. So I don’t know if that’s research based, but it kind of feels true, right? It feels like it, it passes the smell test, right? Because there is just so much information out there and we’re bombarded with it, like all the time. So it’s an and everyone can sell their story now, right? That’s the main thing that’s different about storytelling in the past versus storytelling today. The storytelling in the past was, you know, you kind of had a few people who were able to tell the stories and able to get that out and it was like your major national television networks, you know, your radio channels, that kind of thing, and now everybody has a platform, right? authors, journalists, yes, yes, there was kind of like gatekeepers, right? There were people you had to go through and now everybody can tell their story. It’s really been democratized, you know, we can all tell our story. It’s a what’s important now is being able to choose the stories and determine how to present them in the ways that best reach and resonate with your audience. And another thing that’s come to light is not a lot of, I won’t say just nonprofits, a lot of organizations in general. I feel like back in the 90s we’re doing this a lot and it was kind of the um poverty porn, um for lack of a better term, stories, right? Where you were putting these kind of sob stories of these people that were in this terrible situation and you know, the organization came in and they really like changed their lives, right? And, and up and did it. And, and that may very well have been true. um. But I think there’s more of a recognition today of the importance of telling stories ethically, right? And part of that ethical storytelling is really making sure that telling the story benefits everyone involved, you know, and that we’re not taking advantage of someone who we were able to help in order to kind of. You know, make ourselves look better or to to get more for that, right? We have to be very careful about how we tell these stories, particularly, you know, when people are involved, um, not exploiting a situation or, you know, a tragedy. Exactly and making them aware kind of of the the potential repercussions of sharing their story that maybe they haven’t thought through um because particularly, you know, you might have someone, you know, maybe they’re maybe they’re young and you know they haven’t necessarily thought through that they can tell the story and they can literally follow them their entire lives, right? Um, because of the internet, because of social media, because of the ability to like find information now in, in ways that were not present, you know, in past, in past areas. Um, so I think just making sure that you’re telling the story in a way that benefits everyone, and that might involve, you know, being anonymous, it might involve, you know, changing the way that you’re doing it. It certainly involves making sure that you have The appropriate releases, you know, to, to tell the story and making sure that you’re kind of educating people who may be, who are doing you a solid, right? We’re doing you a solid by sharing the story of how your organization impacted them, that, that they’re actually getting something out of it as well, and that they’re not gonna get negative repercussions from doing so. Let’s talk about what makes a good story, uh, a good ethical story, of course, and uh I wanna use the uh the Norwhal and jellyfish example. What, what do you think makes that a good story? For your, for your son, is that why is that you said it’s a, yeah, what is it what is it about the uh the Norfish that we can, we can extrapolate for good storytelling nonprofits? Well, one, it’s very visual, right? It, it is a graphic novels. I don’t even know. I don’t know if there’s a length to be called a graphic novel because they’re not super long, but I’m going to say they’re graphic novels. OK. Children’s graphic children’s novel. Right. And like most children’s books, right? Most children’s books are super visual. So I think, um, you know, you have to catch people’s attention, you know, and it’s not always visual, but you have to think about what is it that’s gonna catch and keep people’s attention. So that’s not only the story itself, right? So it’s the actual storyline and that being interesting and these particular books have a lot of comedy, right? They’re, they’re funny and they’re cute, um, and there’s a lot of puns. He’s very into word puns, um. So, you know, there’s the things that make the content itself engaging, so the words themselves are engaging. Also the visuals, right? It it’s very visually engaging, there’s lots of pictures for him to look at, um. In his case, there’s not a huge amount of words per page, that’s important when you’re 6, right? Because you’re you’re kind of done with it and you’re ready to move on. But aren’t we supposed to do we supposed to do like we’re like grass grade or something? I, ideally, yes, I mean. You don’t know everyone’s education level, right? And particularly depending on your audience, you know, or if it English as their first language or anything along those lines, right? So, um, you need to keep it easy for that, but also people don’t want to work that hard, right? Um, don’t make people work for it. Make it easy for them to do what it is that you want them to do, you know, and if that’s be invested in your organization in whichever way, if it’s volunteering, if it’s donating, if it’s doing whatever. Make it easy for them to do it, and don’t make them work hard to understand the story and what you’re saying. There’s a lot of industries that jargon is very common, and they tend to throw around acronyms or terms that make a lot of sense to the people involved, you know, like inside baseball, if you will, right? Um, but don’t mean anything to the general audience, and I think that’s one thing we have to try to catch. It’s like, you know, you aren’t speaking to yourself, you aren’t speaking to someone who has the same background and the same details and the same information that you do, uh, and you need to recognize that and you need to use a conversational manner and you need to use language that people are familiar with and that doesn’t mean. You know, you don’t co-opt, you know, you don’t need to kind of co-opt something and be someone who you are not. Still be who your organization is and have that consistent voice. But, you know, you don’t need to speak at like PhD level. I’m writing a dissertation style way to, you know, Joe from down the block, right? Uh, you need to speak in a way that your audience reacts well to and that they understand. You reminded me of, uh, when I was in law school, first year of law school. I hate, I, I, I, I hated practicing law, by the way. I don’t do it anymore, but I was very glad that I went to law school. I still am very glad I went, but your first year of law school, uh, now I went in, uh, 1989, so you, you’d be reading cases and I had literally my dictionary. My Black’s Law Dictionary by my side because every, you know, every paragraph there’s a word I don’t understand. There’s, you know, Latin phrase or something, you know, you don’t, you don’t want need people to be going, going to an online dictionary to get, you know, you don’t need to show off your extraordinarily literate vocabulary in your professional. Storytelling. Keep that to your friends. Because we, we kind of train people to do one thing in school and then you need another thing in real life, right? So in school, we kind of train people over time. You write longer, you use bigger words, you, you know, you do this, this, this, and so you start off, you know, I mean, my kid is in kindergarten, right? He’s writing like I saw. Sue run, you know, like that’s what he’s working on writing, you know, and then by the time you know you’re in college or you’re in grad school or law school or whatever it is, you know, you’re writing these long papers, right? You’re writing a dissertation, you know, and you use the, the big words and use the academic language and you use the insider terms because you have to do, you have to, that’s what you’re trained to do. That’s right. And then once you get out into like the real world. And I was like, I haven’t written anything that’s more than like 4 pages and I don’t even know how long, right? Because nobody wants to read all that. Like people want it short, succinct, like get to the point, what’s the summary, you know, if, if we do write something along, we always have that one page executive summary in the front, right? Because a lot of people are just like they don’t have the time for it and they don’t have the interest and their capability they don’t, you know, they’re not that invested in it that they’re gonna spend all this time. Digging through to find the gem that they need, right? They really need, they need some bullet points. They needed an executive summary. They need a story that they can remember and that sticks with them and makes sense, you know. And I mean, sure, you could do, I mean, when we talk about storytelling, there’s so many formats, right? I mean, you could really do a really long term, you could write, you could write a book, you could do a long term. Documentary, you know, those type of things. But most of the time when we’re talking about storytelling in this context, we’re talking about, you know, short hits, right? We’re talking about things that are, you know, like under 3 minute video, you know, that you can read in less than 10 minutes, a podcast, right, that you can listen to in a half hour. I mean, we’re really talking about shorter, more succinct, getting to the point. Stories. So you have to kind of like capture someone’s interest from the beginning, and keep it. I mean, the good thing is, I feel like that that is easier to do in a shorter time frame, right? But you have to get to the point faster. You don’t have a lot of runway to kind of meander around the point. I hope there’s still a place for longer form podcasting because we run like 45 minutes to an hour. But uh the good thing about podcasts to podcasts, people are frequently multitasking, you know, so I feel like you get a little more leeway for. Yeah, I hope. You know, I hope they’re not, I hope they’re not doing crossword puzzles or sudoku while they’re listening to Tony Martin and nonprofit radio because then you’re not gonna get the, you’re not gonna get the, the genius of Sarah Wood and other guests if you’re, if you’re too engaged in you’re multitask. So, you know, let’s dumb down the other, the, uh, the, the other part of the, the other tasks while you’re listening to. Nonprofit, you know, if you digest of the impressive. I bet there’s somebody out there who’s done it. I hope so. Oh, if there is, I’d love to know. Well listens to it. That’s what we should do a picture of your nonprofit and you can be a star. I’ll I’ll listener of the pages. Um, let’s talk, you know, the narwhal and the jellyfish. What’s the relationship between those two? Let’s talk about relationships. They are. OK. OK, BFF. It’s time for Tony’s Take 2. Thank you, Kate. The people who nobody thanks, you know, they kind of. silently breathe by us, and they are ignored by most people. I am encouraging you to give a simple thank you, a simple, have a good day. You know, it costs nothing, it’s, it’s, it’s a second. Um, and I’ve been trying to be conscious of this in my own. Mostly, mostly in traveling, uh, so, you know, I’m thinking about. Airport bathroom attendants. They’re keeping these bathrooms clean and like I said, they just come silently in and out, nobody gives them any mind. Say a quick thank you. That’s it. Just, thanks. They’ll get it, they’ll get it. Um, in hotels where you, when you get the, the free breakfasts, now this is not the breakfast that’s served to you, but, you know, I’m thinking of like the, uh, I use Marriott a lot. So like Fairfield, Resident Inn, Spring Hill Suites, you know, they have the free breakfasts, uh little tiny buffets. The folks that put that food out for you, thank you for breakfast. I, I, they’re so grateful to be thanked. Um, flight attendants, you know, flight, I, I, flight attendants, um, they come around and they offer you something and Lots of people don’t even remove their headsets or their AirPods, whatever, earbud, whatever, you know, whatever you got in your ear. And then, and then, and then you, you gotta ask the person, what did you say again, you know, you see them coming like remove the device from your ears so they don’t have to repeat themselves and then, and even some people don’t even give them the courtesy of that, they just They just kind of guess what’s being said, you know, you can usually tell if the court is there with, with the beverages, obviously, you know, it’s time for beverages and snacks, so they, they don’t really even hear and give the person the courtesy of Being listened to. Because they won’t, you know, the passengers won’t remove their devices. So you have a little courtesy, like pause your music or your movie and and actually listen to the person, hear them. Another one, restaurant, um, in restaurants now I think servers are, you know, waitresses, waiters, they’re, they’re generally thanked, I think. What about the people who fill your water in your coffee? They come around sometimes, it’s not the server that you’re, that you’re tipping. And we ignore them, you know, I see this when I see it with friends, I see it with donor lunches, but nobody says thank you for the, for the coffee refill or the water refill. A simple thank you, you know, like the arm is extended in, you know, and it’s just, it’s like it’s not even a person, it’s just an arm reaching in with a pitcher of water. These are people, say thanks and then carry on your conversation. It’s, it’s just that simple. Um, and also in restaurants, uh, the bus staff, people take your plates away. You know, again, it’s an arm, a couple of arms reach in and and and disappearing. They’re not disembodied. These are people. Thank you. Thanks for taking my plate. So, I’m being more conscious of this. Uh, I’m encouraging you to be. Maybe there are folks in your lives who come in and out and, you know, we’re treating them almost like they’re not human, like they don’t even exist, but they do. But you know, so it’s, it’s it’s uh, it’s not very thoughtful, it’s not at all generous to. They giving to to people who. You don’t have to say anything to, but I, I, I think we should. That’s Tony’s take too. Kate, I’m just gonna add a few to the list from my own life, um, Boston guards, we live near a school and you know they’re out there. Uh, making sure our kids are safe. Now, give them a very good one, right, and especially now, freezing out there for an hour or so. Crossing guards, excellent. Wait, you got others. And then also I was thinking shuttle staff, whether that’s like your buses, your trains, that also kind of has to do with your flight attendants, but the people transporting you to and from, give them a little wave. Yeah, yeah. My shuttle driver was actually really nice yesterday because I got off at the wrong stop, or I was going to get off at the wrong stop, but then I stayed on with her. She was like, you got off at the wrong stop, but you can stay with me and I’ll recircle. So she was really nice. See, they, they were people, yes, people are generally thoughtful and helpful and Uh, see, there, there was a very generous thing she did. So there you go, yeah, those are excellent, thank you. Excellent additions. Well, we’ve got Bou butt loads more time. Here’s the rest of Storytelling with Sarah Wood. Relationships, so, you know, how do we? How do we make sure these stories aren’t, you know, so complex? Like you’re, you’re, you were just talking about the length, you know, but. How do we make sure that we’re not including so much detail that the important things get buried? I mean, they’re in there, but they’re not coming out because we’ve got detail about the make another human story, you know, the person’s background or something we need to, we need to edit down, right? Absolutely, yeah, uh, I mean, I am a I always start with more than what I need, right? Um, because I’m like, I’m gonna have everything that I could possibly need when I’m, when I’m kind of crafting this and when I’m thinking about this. And also because I tend to be, even when I tell, even when I tell my stories, right? I, my personal stories, you know, I’m always putting too much information in too many details, and then sidetracking and be like, well, let me explain this part, you know, um, and so it really is, it really is the editing process, and you really do have to have a A standard process, I think for doing that. Um, and you can set that up in lots of different ways depending on your organization, but I think, you know, you can’t necessarily just have your first cut be a final product. Now, sometimes you can, sometimes you can catch some candid, you know, I mean, that’s become very popular now, right? Candid kind of just like impromptu, put your, put your phone up and, and grab a, a quick snippet of something. Um, so I’m not saying that you can’t do that, but I’m saying when you come to your more formal stories and the things you’re gonna be using for a longer period of time. That you’re gonna want us to kind of think that through, right? You might want to storyboard it out, um, you know, think about what your goals are going in, what are, what are the goals, what are the key topics that you want to hit, and then, you know, think further about how are you gonna do that, you know, what’s what best exemplifies what you were trying to share. You know, I mean, you also can, you can start from the story. You can have a great story, and then you can figure out how to use it. But I personally feel like it’s easier if you kind of start with your goals and then think through, OK, what kind of story best fits this? Who would be the best spokesperson, what is it that we want them to talk about? What are the key points that we want to get across. I think if you know that going in, it’s, it’s easier than kind of going back after the facts, um, and kind of shaping it, but it is possible to do it after the fact as well. All right, I’m gonna take a chance here because you said you, you, you tend to wander in your own storytelling, but you have something in your bio that’s very interesting that uh that you’re a single parent. So I’ve never seen that. chose to have children on their own. Um, so both of my children were conceived using donor sperm. Um, and they, they do not have a, a father in their life. Um, I have other family members, obviously, who kind of step up and friends and whoever and lots of loving people in their life. But, um, you know, I was a person who, I mean, this has something to do with communication, but I was a person who always I felt like my life would be unfulfilled without having children, and I did not feel that way about a relationship and or marriage or, or anything along those lines. Um, and so I opted to have them, you know, on my own and and raise them on my own. Um, and they are amazing little humans, and it was the best decision of my life because like they are the best thing I have, I have done, you know, I’ve created these amazing humans to kind of go out and make the world a better place. Um, and so that’s an, that’s an awesome experience. I mean, I was gonna say, I was gonna say, you know, I don’t try to talk people into doing things, right? But I will say if you are interested in in potentially doing it, I would advise you to explore it, right? And to look into your options because science is great. I, I work with a lot of health. Science nonprofits. And 11 of the reasons is I just like really think that there’s so many neat things that are happening now, right? That you couldn’t even potentially do years ago. I mean, I think the first, I think the first IVF baby was born around the time I was born. Um, so that’s give or take 40 years ago. Um, so it’s only potentially, I mean, my kids were not born through IVF. I used IUI, um, which is insider term, right? But because we have jargon jail on nonprofit, yes, but it doesn’t matter we’ll just say it’s less medically invasive. IUI IUI is interuterine insemination, um, and so it’s not as, uh, it’s not as technical. I didn’t have to have eggs frozen and retrieved and, and, and all of that. It just, you know, it’s kind of. They put some sperm on up there and right, right, yeah, yeah. And you double down on this now, so you have two children, 2 and 6. I do, I do. Yes. So one was one was not fulfilling your first, your son was not fulfilling enough. Well, I wouldn’t say it that way, right? I mean, if I had been unable to have another child, then yes, I would have been fulfilled with my son. But, uh, I had always wanted two children, and, um, I was at a spot where I could do that or try to do that. And Was able to be successful with that and so yeah, they. They’re awesome and I’m I’m like traditional spouse or partner is not a, I mean, I hope they would say I’m successful. I feel like I’m doing all right. I’m sure, yeah, we can’t yeah yeah yeah you know it’s interesting. I’ve never seen anyone that way as a Yeah, there’s a growing, there’s a growing community of us. There’s a growing community, you know, I think times are changing, right? And, and you can do things now that you couldn’t do in the past both with technology but also kind of being more socially accepted and you know, being a more tolerant society and. To, to families that are shaped differently and created differently. Um, and I think that’s an amazing thing. Um, I mean, you know, um, my sister is, um, married to a woman, and, uh, they obviously had to use sperm to, to have their child as well, use donor sperm, and, um, you know, they actually had to use a surrogate as well, uh, for health reasons. And so, you know, the. It’s just amazing that we get to have these children in our lives in these in these ways that, like I said, would not have been possible. You know, a couple decades ago, so in the adoption process, did, did you see any bias against a single parent? Well, I didn’t do adoption. I am saying? Oh no, no, I’m sorry. So in the, uh, yes, of course, of course. I’m sorry, that’s embarrassing. Um, but in so in the, in the, in the the process of being approved as a As a parent, whatever that requires, was, did you see any bias against being a single parent or we are in the fertility industry are are kind of well aware of, um, you know, kind of the single mom by choice, you know, it’s not, it’s not new to them. Uh, uh, they’re like they’re probably the in in the in group. I, you know, I will say, you know, it. You have to kind of be clear at like medical appointments and things like that, that you’re the only legal parent, you know, um, and all those kind of things, but I, I don’t think that’s really any different than Anyone who say had had, you know, a spouse pass away or, um, you know, otherwise was like not available in their life, um. But yeah, I mean, I don’t know. I don’t know what people are thinking in their head, but I will say that, you know, I haven’t felt bad about it and I haven’t had anyone like try actively try to make me feel bad about it. So I think that’s a plus, right? I mean, people might have their own thoughts, but if so, you know, if you don’t have anything nice to say, keep it to yourself, right? Yes, I was. I was wondering about like institutional bias or something, but it sounds like we’re past that. We’re we’re we’re past that. Well, I wouldn’t say that we are past that. I would say I have not personally experienced it or knowingly experienced it. Um, I think that, you know, it, I would not go so far to say that it does not exist. I mean, I think it certainly still exists and, uh, you know, probably maybe more dependent on, you know, the areas that you were in and your, and your localities and kind of, uh, their perspectives there, um. May play in a bigger part yeah. Um, so let’s let’s go back. Thank you for sharing the story. I thought that was a poignant part of your, right? Right. Well, you might say, well, I only third party, not my own, but it’s harder to tell, right? I mean, I think, you know, People tell stories all the time and I, it’s easy for me to look at someone else and think, OK, here’s the angle, here’s what makes you different, unique, here’s what we can kind of, you know, talk about, here’s what we can, you know, get some leverage, here’s, you know, all of that kind of thing. And when you try to apply it like to my own business, right? It’s, it’s much more complicated to do it with your own business and yourself, right? Because you, you kind of overthink it and. And impostor syndrome kind of pops up and, and also you kind of think like, oh, well, I can’t do it unless I’m really good at it, because, you know, I am in the field, like I feel like there, you know, there’s a benchmark that you kind of have to get over, right? You have to be like at least X is good about and really it’s not. Like you can try things out the same as anybody else and and do things in a different way, but it’s really getting out of your own way and getting out of your own head, um, and having enough mental energy left after you serve your clients to kind of apply the same principles to your own business. And you even you devolved into jargon in your own story. I did you spotted it. You did, you did self-identify too, but I, I would, I would have called you out because we do have jargon jail, but I didn’t, I didn’t need to. Um, so you, something you mentioned, uh. We we were earlier, uh, consistency, messaging consistency, like I think like tone of your stories, you, you know, you said the, uh, the narwhal and the jellyfish, like they have, there’s clearly a pattern. You, you expect the puns, etc. Let’s talk about the value and, and, and how you ensure consistency in, in nonprofit messaging. Yeah, I always tell people, you need to know who you are first, right? And you need to decide as an organization, this is who we are, this is what we do, and this is how we talk about it, um, because it’s gonna be confusing for your audience if your emails are written in one way in one tone, and then your website is a copy is in a completely different tone and your social media is in, in, in, you know, a third one, and just, you need to pick one which is realistic, which feels like it. Works for you, which feels honest, um, and also want a voice that resonates with your audiences, and then you need to stick with it, um, because you don’t want to have mismatch between what you’re saying in one place versus another. And also you need to. When we talk about consistency, it’s not just being the same but it’s consistency and kind of the cadence, right? It’s I we’re consistently telling our stories we’re consistently talking about what we’re doing we’re consistently, you know, emphasizing what are the most important parts for us. So it’s both how often you’re doing it, and it’s making sure that it’s kind of similar, that there’s a similar vein, right? Of course you’re gonna alter things depending on like what format you’re doing it in. If you’re writing a case study, it’s gonna be different than, you know, if you’re doing. And Instagram reel, right? Uh, you’re not gonna do those the same way. They’re not gonna exactly have the same vibe and the same language and and all of that because they’re very different styles for different audiences, but you want overall your voice to be consistent. Your key messages across the board should be consistent. Your values should be evident and consistent across wherever you happen to be. And then like I said, you know, telling people. You have to tell people over and over and over again what you do. It is really hard to overcommunicate with people as a nonprofit organization. I mean, you’re inside, you’re embedded in it, you’re you may be tired of talking about it, right? You may be like, oh, we’ve done this so many times or, or we’ve told this story and so many times in so many ways and and all of that, but the reality is, you know, you see every message your audience does not. They’re gonna miss a lot of the messages that you’re putting out. Yes, that’s a very good point. They’re not seeing every message that you send. Exactly. And they’re not seeing it kind of the way you are, right, where, you know, it shows up like, you know, back to back to back to back, right? All the message you might send, like, here’s, here’s all your emails in a row of what you’ve sent or here’s all your, like, you know, when you’re looking at the back end of it, they don’t see it like that, right? It’s, it’s all this other stuff in between, you know, that they’re seeing. So I, I try to tell people I I feel like. Nonprofit organizations in particular, they’re worried about like annoying people, right? They’re worried about, um, kind of irritating them and then, oh, they’re just gonna like, you know, unsubscribe or unfollow us or they’re not gonna wanna do this, that and whatever. And I was like, it is really hard to annoy someone so much that they’re gonna opt out unless you are really just spamming, right? And like you’re, but if you’re providing content that is of value, and you, I mean, they might. See 1 in 10 of the things you do, right? I mean, I, I don’t have the actual data on that, right? Like, you know, but they, they are certainly not gonna see every single message that you send out. And then if they do, great. I mean, and if they are seeing every single message and they come to you and they say, you’re sending too many. I’ve seen all of these or whatever, like, let’s figure out a way so that that that particular individual, you know, doesn’t maybe doesn’t get quite so much of it. But I mean, I think that’s, it’s hard to do and. That’s something that nonprofits kind of have to get out of their own way on, is they’re worried, like, oh, we’re gonna annoy them, they’re gonna unsubscribe. If, if they’re gonna unsubscribe because, you know, they got Or end of year email like fundraising ask, then they weren’t someone who should have been on your list in the first place, right? Because they aren’t someone who’s like regularly invested in your organization. If they’re gonna be, you know, I mean how many emails does Target send me? Like how much like I haven’t unsubscribed from them yet, you know, like, I mean, now, do I delete most of them without opening them? Yes. But I mean, I, most nonprofits are not saying anywhere near the volume, right? That, you know, a target or or someone along those lines is sending. That’s consistent with uh advice around boards and utilizing your board, being afraid that you’re asking your board to do too much. If, if that happens, they’ll they’ll let you know. But odds are you’re not asking them to do enough and they’re feeling like they’re, you know, kind of a lackluster board member because they’re, they’re not engaged enough with. hopefully the right kinds of tasks you know they don’t know what to do, right? I mean, I think, I think that’s common, right, is that, you know, when someone joins a board and they’re very, or a volunteer or or or however they’re joining, however they’re, you know, being involved with the organization, they want to help, but they don’t necessarily like know how to go about that or they don’t want to step on someone’s toes, you know. And, or kind of take over what someone else is doing. And so I think the more information that you can provide internally as well, right? Not just externally, um, about what is most helpful, like, you know, don’t just leave people hanging. Like, ask them for what you need. And I know it feels awkward. We all hate, like, you know, we all hate asking for things and, um, That’s why some people who are like, you know, major fundraisers who really are OK with it, get, get paid more, right? Um, but it can feel awkward until you get used to it, right? And once you do it, and you see like, OK, you see the reaction, you see that it is a positive reaction. You know, you’re not getting the negativity that you thought you were gonna get. Um, I think that it’s easier to do it the next time, right? And, and it becomes, it becomes routine, and it’s no longer hard for you to do. Don’t be afraid of your board members. Don’t be afraid of your, your volunteers, your donors, whether they’re your major donors or your audience in general, right? Don’t, don’t be afraid of them and don’t be afraid to talk to them and to ask them things and you know, you might get crickets, they might not respond back, but, um, give them the opportunity, you know, give them the opportunity to engage and and to connect with you and to communicate and to let you know what it is they’re most interested in. Um, and, and not hearing back doesn’t mean that they don’t like you, means that they, they’re time constrained and, you know, they didn’t, they didn’t read that particular ask or they didn’t, they didn’t have the time to respond to it or they just chose not to. You know, it doesn’t mean that they don’t like you when, when they start unsubscribing, that’s when they don’t like you. Yeah, so they don’t, don’t default to thinking negatively, right? You know, um, if no one responded, then it’s just as just as likely that they responded positively as they did negatively, right? Probably more likely because I think people are more likely to actually let you know if they have a negative reaction to something than if they have a positive reaction to something. Um, I mean, we see that in online reviews all the time, right? Uh, the people who leave the review a lot of times are the people who have like a really bad experience for whatever reason, um, because most people who have like an OK or positive, you know, experience are just kind of like going about with their day. What else do you want to talk about around storytelling that uh either I haven’t asked you or we didn’t go deep enough. What else is out there? What’s on your mind? What’s on your mind? We’ve covered a lot of, um. I think maybe talking a little bit about kind of like how you pick the stories. I mean, we touched on this a little bit about how You know, how it’s important to kind of go in knowing what you want to get out of it. Um, but you may, if you aren’t used to storytelling, you may kind of be looking at your organization. I’m like, well, I don’t have any stories to tell, and that is like. Oh, that’s, that’s definitely wrong. You shouldn’t be, you shouldn’t be in business if you don’t, if you can’t come up with half a dozen stories, like sort of off the top of your head. Well, I mean, let’s not say it like that because for some people, you know, they just haven’t learned how to see it in that way yet, right? It’s the, the stories are there. You have, maybe I was being harsh, but you have. You just have to identify them. All right, so help us, help us, help us do that. All right. So I think you, I think you’re gonna, like I said, you can start with your kind of the goals of like, you know, this is what I really would like to have a story talking about or this is what I would like to have a story that there’s an example of. Um, and having that in mind can kind of help you when you’re looking at it can kind of like frame it and kind of shape how you’re looking at what you’re doing. Um, so that’s one way to go about it. I think another way to go about it is, um, to kind of train yourself and your staff to think about things through the lens of a story, right? So, so many times we’ll have, uh, you know, people they’re like, Oh, I don’t have enough, I don’t have enough content for social media, or I don’t have this. And I was like, OK, well, What does your staff say? You know, what is your staff doing like day to day, you know, are you asking them like, OK, what is there we could take a picture of? What is there we could take a video of? Could we do a behind the scenes of like what their day is like, you know, um, when someone comes in, have you asked them like what to give a testimonial of some sort? Have you asked them for their feedback, you know, those are always That you can kind of gather things that can kind of turn into stories. Uh, I think, uh, I worked for an organization for a while and they had been around like 90 years, right? And they’ve been running these programs for like 90 years. And, you know, so in all that time, there’s so many people that had been involved with it, right? And we really had to kind of create a program where they were like reaching out to like alumni of this program, right? Um, and kind of talking to them and doing blogs, a blog series and, you know, using that to then spin off and repurpose into like other, other storytelling content, right? But they just hadn’t thought about it, right? Like no one had just sat and thought like, OK, well, we should reach out to, you know, it’s been this amount of time, like they’ve done all these like different things. Like, it’s not like they’re still in high school. This was particular program was aimed at like middle and high school kids, um, you know, and, and some of them were like famous. So, you know, it was a matter of just like letting people know to think about it in that way, you know, because the stories are there. That’s one of the reasons I really like working with nonprofit organizations is because there are so many good stories that are just like right there for the bank, right? It’s not like you’re having to like create it. Anything else that you want to share? I don’t want you to give uh give nonprofit radio listeners, you know, like short shrift, I would want to just encourage everyone that everyone can be a storyteller and that the and that everyone has a story, right? So when you’re looking at your organization, think about what stories would be most effective for you, um, and how you can share them in a way that will resonate with your audience the most. And that’s the way I think you can best approach it, because otherwise it can feel overwhelming, and you want it to feel approachable, and you want it to feel like something that you can accomplish. Sarah Wood Founder and chief communication consultant Sarah Wood Communication, you’ll find Sarah on LinkedIn. You’ll find her practice at Sarah with an H, Sara Woodcommunication.com. Thank you very much, Sarah. Thanks for sharing your own personal story as well as all the uh valuable advice on. Nonprofit storytelling. Thank you very much. I hope somebody goes out and tells a story because of this. Many folks will, I’m sure. Next week, your grant maker relationships. If you missed any part of this week’s show, I beseech you. Find it at Tony Martignetti.com. We’re sponsored by DonorBox, outdated donation forms blocking your supporters’ generosity. Donor box, fast, flexible, and friendly fundraising forms for your nonprofit, Donorbox.org. Our creative producer is Claire Meyerhoff. I’m your associate producer Kate Martignetti. The show’s social media is by Susan Chavez. Mark Silverman is our web guy, and this music is by Scott Stein. Thank you for that affirmation, Scotty. Be with us next week for nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. Come out and be great.
Gene Takagi & Amy Sample Ward: Looking To 2025: Is It Paranoia Or Prudence?
Our esteemed contributors share what they’re looking to next year, with the uncertainty of a new president and administration. On the table is HR 9495, which some call the NonprofitKiller; government agencies no longer given deference by the federal courts, with the Supreme Court overruling the long-standing Chevron Doctrine; and, uneasiness around the economy rippling out to preemptive nonprofit budget cuts. Our legal contributor is Gene Takagi at NEO Law Group. Amy Sample Ward, CEO of NTEN, is our technology contributor.
Donorbox: Powerful fundraising features made refreshingly easy.
We’re the #1 Podcast for Nonprofits, With 13,000+ Weekly Listeners
Board relations. Fundraising. Volunteer management. Prospect research. Legal compliance. Accounting. Finance. Investments. Donor relations. Public relations. Marketing. Technology. Social media.
Every nonprofit struggles with these issues. Big nonprofits hire experts. The other 95% listen to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio. Trusted experts and leading thinkers join me each week to tackle the tough issues. If you have big dreams but a small budget, you have a home at Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio. View Full Transcript
And welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio. Big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. I’m your aptly named host and the pod father of your favorite abdominal podcast. This is our last show of the year. I’ll have more to say about that. Oh, I’m glad you’re with us. I’d bear the pain of a para nia if you pointed out to me that you missed this week’s show. Here’s our associate producer, Kate with what’s up this week? Hey, Tony, we have looking to 2025. Is it paranoia or Prudence? Our esteemed contributors share what they’re looking to next year with the uncertainty of a new president and administration on the table is hr 9495, which some call the nonprofit killer government agencies no longer given deference by the federal courts with the Supreme Court overruling of the long-standing Chevron doctrine and uneasiness around the economy rippling out to pre-emptive nonprofit budget cuts. Our legal contributor is Gene Takaki at Neo Law Group, Amy Sample Ward CEO of N 10 is our technology contributor on Tony’s two. Our last show of the year and timely holiday wishes were sponsored by donor box outdated donation forms blocking your supporters, generosity, donor box, fast, flexible and friendly fundraising forms for your nonprofit donor. Box.org here is looking to 2025. Is it paranoia or Prudence? It’s a pleasure to welcome back Gene Takagi and Amy Sample Ward for our final show of 2024. Gene is our legal contributor and principal of Neo, the nonprofit and exempt organization’s Law Group in San Francisco. He edits the wildly popular nonprofit law blog.com and is a part time lecturer at Columbia University. The firm is at Neola group.com and he’s at GTC A AMP award, our technology contributor and CEO of N 10. They were awarded a 2023 Bosch Foundation fellowship and their most recent co-authored book is the tech that comes next about equity and inclusiveness in technology development. They’re at Amy Sample ward.org and at Amy RS Ward Gene and Amy. Thank you for your contributions through the year and welcome to the final show of 2024. We made it sounds like drudgery. No, I’m just saying like it, you know, here we are, we made it all the way to the end of 2020 four. All right, thanks. OK. She says it, they say it with a smile. So thank you. Thank you. It sounded like uh it might have been a laborious chore, but no, hopefully not. I’m I’m sure not. All right. And one thing maybe Tony that, that will spur talking about what we might foresee in the future is that change in social media handles. As many of us are migrating to blue sky and to other. Exactly. But just thought, I chime in with that quickly, we can, we can talk about the, the, the seasonal migration. I, I am slow to adopt new networks. But uh yes, I, I’ve started being active on uh on blue sky as well. Indeed. All right. Uh We wanna start with something that, uh, both of you have seen me post about and has been getting a lot of attention, uh, for months before I joined, before this, uh, came within my ken if you will, uh, which is ho House Resolution hr 9495. Uh, in the Senate. It is, uh, 4136. It is the stop terror financing and tax penalties on American Hostages Act. Uh, J uh, I don’t know, terror financing and not penalizing people who were held hostage for paying their taxes late. I mean, those, those both sound like very worthwhile endeavors for the government to do. Uh, especially I’m thinking of hostages who may not have filed their 1040 on time. I mean, I think, I think being held hostage is, uh, uh, a legitimate reason for not having paid your taxes and then the penalties that would have ensued on top of that. So, II, I think that’s a fair, uh, but it’s the, uh, it’s the stop terror financing part that is, uh, rankling nonprofit organizations, the nonprofit community generally. Um, what, what is it about this house resolution? It passed the house. It’s now in the Senate, I guess I’ll just set up the, the, the, the, uh, timing of the thing. So, uh, it’s unlikely to be taken up in the current Senate. I mean, it’s possible but it’s not likely, uh, having passed the house. Uh, but we have a new Senate, uh, beginning on, um, January 3rd and, uh, that Senate could very well take up hr 9495 Senate 4136. What’s, uh, what, what’s the, uh, what’s the issue here for the nonprofit community? Gene? So, II, I think when we take a look at the name of the bill, this is the game of politics that some of us get frustrated with. Right. So who could be against stop terror financing? Of course, nobody wants to, it’s worthy and it’s worthy and benign. But what does it actually say about how we stop terror financing? What are the checks and balances? Can anybody just say you are supporting terror and that’s it. You are like, shut down. Do you get executed for doing that? I mean, so we, we need to look into the bill and I think the first time this bill came across was actually, um, late last year, Tony, it was under a different name. Uh, it was hr 64 08 in the house and it passed 382 to 11. So I don’t think a lot of the legislators got past the name of the bill and then they decided, hey, we’re going to pass this because how can our constituents see us oppose a bill against supporting terror? Of course, we are, are for, you know, stopping terror financing and the hostages too. Don’t forget the, the, the late, the late filings for the, for the hostages. And that’s the other part of politics, right? Is we bundle things together so that you’re trapped, right? There’s no kiss to, to, to promoting that bill. But here’s, here’s why it’s, it’s scary for, for the nonprofit sector. The addition in the bill, the, the part that’s not to do with hostages is about the Secretary of the Treasury having the discretion alone to strip the tax exempt status of an organization because they feel like they are supporting a terrorist organization, they are providing material support or resources to a terrorist organization. And if they deem that to be the case, they give 90 days notice to the organization, they should supply some evidence of that support um, or resources unless it’s a national secret or it’s not in the best interests of the government to do so. In which case, it could all be done in secret. It could just be, we’re taking away your 501 C three status because we’ve decided that you are supporting terror a terrorist organization, give us 90 days to prove that you’re not in return any money that, that, you know, you sent out to the terrorist organization that we might not really tell you much about. Um, and what is all of that mean? I mean, so now as we sort of dig into how this might be impacted and how, uh, an executive branch might use this particular bill to attack organizations or even if they don’t use it broadly how it will just chill free speech across the sector. There’s already organizations terrified with this bill and afraid to speak up on things like, um, the Palestinian people in Gaza, which is sort of what prompted the bill in the first place. Right. But, you know, now they’re thinking, oh my gosh, can we speak about reproductive rights? Can we speak about other things? Are we going to be called a terrorist organization or a supporter of a terrorist organization? And what if the organization we were supporting wasn’t branded a terrorist organization at the time, but later was declared by some other entity or some other agency to be a terrorist organization. Now, do they go back and do they ding us on that as well? And I won’t go too far down the line. But humanitarian aid is another huge issue to, to talk about later. But let me, let me stop there. Well, even even on the domestic side, suppose you are supporting the, uh, the civil rights or the legal rights of people who protest openly in the streets, uh, about anything that, that we have a right to seek redress from our, from our federal government around. So you’re, then those protesters are perhaps arrested, um, and charged and you give legal support, you give material legal support to those, to those charged. Are, are those, are those folks deemed domestic terrorists? That’s another thing, the bill does not distinguish between federal or domestic, sorry, between domestic or foreign. Uh, are you now giving material support to domestic terrorists who were exercising their first amendment rights of assembly and speech in the streets? And so now you’re, now you, this legal aid society are a, uh, terrorist supporting organization. So there’s an opportunity. Um, it’s just the, the, the bill is vague on standards. In fact, I think it’s, it’s silent on the standards for being deemed a terrorist supporting organization. It’s, it’s at the Secretary of the Treasury’s uh discretion, what is deemed a terrorist supporting organization? And that vagueness is critical. I don’t want to overstate it, Tony, because I’ve seen on various other podcasts. People are making more into this bill than is actually there. So to be a terrorist supporting organization that could be subject to being stripped of tax exempt status. You have to be accused, uh, or, or charged with, um, the designation that you are supporting a terrorist organization. And the terrorist organization is defined in other sections of the bill, the bill is very hard to read because it starts to refer to other places in the code where you could be described as a terrorist organization. So if you give support, material support or resources to that terrorist organization that’s typically been defined by somebody else, some other branch of the government, um, usually with a little bit more, you know, some people have been mistaken about this saying that the legislature had to define you as a terrorist organization. That’s not quite true. There are other sort of members of the executive branch that could still define you as a terrorist organization. If they have, then the secretary of the Treasury has the ability to say you supported them, but they’ve got to be on some list of a terrorist organization. So protesters on the street, if you’re supporting them in their legal aid, unless they are deemed part of a terrorist group that’s been identified as a terrorist organization, then that won’t apply. It’s time for a break. Imagine a fundraising partner that not only helps you raise more money but also supports you in retaining your donors, a partner that helps you raise funds both online and on location. So you can grow your impact faster. That’s donor box, a comprehensive suite of tools, services and resources that gives fundraisers, just like you a custom solution to tackle your unique challenges, helping you achieve the growth and sustainability. Your organization needs helping you, help others visit donor box.org to learn more. Now, back to looking to 2025 is it paranoia or prudence? Suppose they’re supporting Black Lives Matter in their local city and Black Lives Matter has been deemed a terrorist support, a terrorist organization. I mean, we, we, uh, by some, by some other agency as you’re, as you’re describing, that doesn’t seem outside the realm of possibility. The, the claim could be that Black Lives Matter members as if there’s as if there’s like a, a strict membership list or something. But let’s just use the, the worst possible instincts of uh the federal government uh are, are, you know, they, uh they, they uh they create crime in mayhem and they burn buildings. Well, it sounds like a domestic terror organization to us that other agency has determined. And now the, the uh the legal aid society uh is providing uh material support to a terrorist organization. Doesn’t that, isn’t that within the realm of possibility and plausibility? It kind of is Tony, it’s not really kind of projected right now that this is going to be focused on domestic terrorism. It seems like the executive branch doesn’t actually want to identify domestic organizations as terrorist organizations because many of them support the, the, the current administration, uh those who, who were responsible for the insurrection, for example, on January 6th. So the focus here right now is on foreign terrorism. That’s sort of the identified groups, um, that, um, if you support foreign terrorist organizations that seems to be the focus but it doesn’t mean that they couldn’t go down the route that you’re talking about. Terror. Does the, does the bill? I thought the bill was silent on foreign versus domestic terror. It doesn’t define it except through references to other sections of the code which are focused on foreign terrorist organizations. So, you know, it doesn’t mean they can’t expand it. It doesn’t mean that maybe the Secretary of the Treasury couldn’t interpret terrorist supporting to, to give themselves a little bit more power to say, hey, this is a terrorist group as well. But I, I think that would be something that, that would not be, I, there’s, there’s lots of law already where the executive branch can do far worse than under what they have in 9495. So the first thing to know is 9495 takes away tax exempt status. It does not stop you from operating, it just takes away 501 c three status or 5014 C four, whatever. But doesn’t stop you from operating, they have tools that can stop you from operating. They can criminalize you if they say you’re terror supporting same words, terrorist supporting. There are other laws which is why we go, well, why this law, why did this law come up? There’s already other laws that prevent you from supporting terror and the reason in my mind is they’re going to use this not as the hammer but as the chisel to silence dissent. So they’re gonna chisel away at certain organizations scare everybody else at it. And that’s, that’s gonna be the impact. So rather than like take down all these protesters or like a whole movement of civil rights organizers think they’re going, what they’re going to do is they’re going to the target. Why this bill came about was because of what’s happening in Palestine and Gaza and the support that um some of those organizations have given to the Palestinian cause they’re gonna use that and they’re gonna scare everybody else from, from speaking out on it. And I think that is the danger, the real danger of 9495 because there are other laws where they can strip away your 501 C three status for acting against public policy. There are other laws that say, hey, we can criminalize your leaders for supporting terror. There’s a whole bunch of worse things they can do. This is the lighter touch, which is a terrible light touch, but this is the lighter touch that might be more useful to an administration that wants to attack dissent, prior restraint on speech, self censorship, correct. Amy. What, what are you, what are you thinking? Yeah, I think that we’ve seen a lot of organizations feeling concerned about this. Um Actually for Gene’s point, not necessarily for the, you know, your organization is or eradicated and no longer exists. But what does this mean for how organizations position themselves, talk to their community, who they talk to, you know, the, the feeling that this is kind of um chilling the sector on building power and trying to work together. Versus um as jean said, there’s, there’s already options that if, you know, the government wanted to completely remove an organization, there are already ways that they could do that. Um But this feels both the, the timing where it’s come from, you know, how, how it came in response to organizations really trying to make more visible conversations about um Palestine, even not about Palestine, but even just organizations trying to say, you know, our, our government is complicit in so many harms around the world. Um And that, what does that mean for nonprofit organizations who felt like that is maybe not their explicit mission? Like to your example before they’re not a legal aid organization, they’re not a humanitarian aid organization, but they wanted to be um in the conversation with their community and acknowledging that there’s a lot going on in the world and even trying to acknowledge that maybe feels like it’s risky for them or what does it mean to be in a partnership with a lot of other organizations? Again, even on a different topic? But what does that association mean? And, and are we not able to collaborate across the sector because of perceptions, you know, gene, anything more we wanna say about uh 9495. Maybe, actually, instead of the substance, maybe some things that some of the organizations that are speaking out against the Bill Council on foundations, uh independent sector, the National Council on nonprofits. Those three and one other organization have a joint statement against the Bill. The advice that I’ve seen a lot is contact your senators. Thanks Tony. It’s since it’s passed the house, I think that’s sort of where the immediate fight is, is with the Senate. And um even if the the majority of the Senate changes, um uh next year, as you, as you noted, Tony, um there are, you know, possibilities of a filibuster by the democratic senators if they so feel like this is something that they can stand up on again again, the rhetoric and the naming of the bill. Um and how much constituents are paying attention to the actual details. I know a lot of nonprofit folks are, but, you know, the general population may not be looking past the title of the bill. And so if their representative is saying I’m voting against this when the exact same bill was there before with like a 95 or 97% vote for it, trying to, to explain that um might be hard. So while there’s hope for, you know, for some that the Senate uh might have a filibuster and not approve this, um or listen to the public if there’s enough of an uproar um across party lines, um, that, that, that maybe they don’t do it. So the, the immediate thing is yes, advocate against the bill. The second thing is make sure you’re informed about what this bill does and doesn’t, again, really a lot of misinformation out there right now and people are scrambling, they’re like trying to create subsidiaries, they’re trying to create LLC S to throw, you know, assets in just in case they lose their 501 C three status because they’re thinking that this bill will shut them down completely. Uh Again, not just lose 501 C three status and prevent them from operating, freeze their assets. That’s not what this bill does. Again, there’s other tools that, that the federal government or even state government already have that can do that, but they haven’t used it in the past. So it’s hard to say Tony, we, we may be in for New Times and really just egregious uses of these, these laws. Um but it may be premature to make huge decisions unless you’re really well informed about them. So I, I would say for, for people looking at this bill, don’t just listen to all the sort of the talk that’s out there right now, like sit down and really get well informed about this, listen to nonprofit radio because we will thank you because we will continue talking about it. Of course. Yeah. All right. Um, good, thank you. Context, context understanding. Let’s talk about, uh, something else that’s on your mind for, uh, watching in 2025 something that came out many months ago. Uh, Gene, which was the, uh, overruling of what, what’s commonly called the, the Chevron Doctrine where government agencies get a lot of deference in the courts when the issue is interpretation of regulations, uh, rules, uh, that, that doctrine of, of deference to those government experts uh was overruled by the Supreme Court was the middle of this year or so. Can you uh explain why this is concerning? Yeah, so it doesn’t, it’s kind of this sort of lawyer geeky thing that goes on, but it’s, it’s important to take a step back and say, hey, the legislator makes statutory laws, right? But the laws are full of like empty spaces for there to be, there needs to be regulation about how to implement these laws. And so like the different agencies including like the Treasury Department and the IRS um start to make regulations. Um and these regulations interpret the law in ways to enforce the law in a practical way. And it’s a lot of law uh and agencies like the EPA the Environmental Protection Agency will take kind of the meaning of the law and sort of all of the legislative history behind it and try to create regulations. They put out the regulations for notice and public comment and then they draft final regulations after that, taking into account those comments, hopefully taking those into account. The courts feel like these regulatory agencies use scientists like the EPA or, or experts, policy experts in creating these regulations. Um And now when a company like Chevron wants to sue uh and say these regulations are unfair, the court used to have to defer or provided deference under the Chevron deference doctrine that hey, we are going to defer to the expertise of the agencies when they created those regulations. And that’s why that is the deference. You have to prove to us if you’re the company saying, hey, no, this doesn’t really pollute or this doesn’t really affect our public health. Let’s let’s like con continue to produce this stuff um because we need it for other things. Um So now this deference is lost. So the courts can’t give deference and now they have to just weigh everything out in balance. The courts are not scientists, right? They’re not scientific experts, the scientific experts were consulted with in creating the regulations, which is why you defer to them. Now, we’ve lost that. So this is a big thing. Another reason why people were very concerned about the composition of the Supreme Court because there seems to be more or or less deference to kind of what, what public agencies see and more susceptibility to what corporations and people of wealth have, who can actually fight these and go to court all the way to the Supreme Court because they have a huge litigation war chest to work behind. It’s time for Tony’s take two. Thank you, Kate. Here we are. End of December. It’s the last show of 2024. It, it, I don’t know, it doesn’t creep up. It just, it just comes fast. I think end of the year, I hope your end of the year fundraising all important is, uh going well. Hope you have a bang up last couple of weeks of the year. I hope you get where you need to be fundraising wise. And then I hope you can take time off for family friends and yourself, you need rest. Here comes the finger wag. Take care of yourself. You gotta take care of yourself before you can take care of others. So I hope you will do that over the holidays, whatever that looks like for you, do it, take care of yourself so you can come back refreshed in the new Year this time. Uh Unlike Thanksgiving, good holiday wishes, whatever holiday you celebrate Happy New Year, these holiday wishes come on time. Not uh not the week after like uh like we saw with Thanksgiving. Unbelievable. I hope you enjoy your time off. I hope you enjoy your holidays. Happy New Year and we will see you in 2025 K happy holidays. Everyone spend it with family and we’ll see you in 2025. We’ve got VU but loads more time, here’s the rest of looking to 2025. Is it paranoia or prudence with Gene and Amy? The presumption of expertise in the, in our vast federal agency bureaucracy uh is, is no, is no longer. And so that it’s, it’s interesting, the, the standard uh one standard was, is arbitrary and capricious that uh that the interpretation or that the regulation is arbitrary and it’s so arbitrary that it, it, it uh is contrary to what Congress intended. And so that regulation should be ignored. And you know, we the company challenging it shouldn’t be held to its standards. Now. It seems like arbitrariness is, is welcome because any interpretation uh has potential validity in the courts, if you can persuade a judge and maybe in some cases, a jury, I think a lot of these would be bench trials with Ju ju with judge judges. But whatever, if you can, if you can persuade the finder of fact that uh that your interpretation, however arbitrary it might be is more appropriate than you could prevail. So it’s bringing arbitrariness and capriciousness into it’s welcoming arbitrariness and, and uh fringe theories as having potential merit. Now, they may not prevail but they’ll, they’ll, they’ll at least get a hearing. Now. Think about this too, Tony. The company that wants to bring the lawsuit to challenge the validity of the regulation might get to choose the court in which to file the complaint right. So they often go to Texas, um and they get a court that is favorable to, to maybe to, to corporate powers and, and uh not believers of climate change and, and you know, so they can choose the forum and forum shopping can be really problematic and, you know, with, with the end of Chevron deference, more arbitrariness, you can, you can file your case in any of the federal districts throughout the country that you think would be most favorable. That’s absolutely correct. Amy’s head, their head is bobbing with disbelief and I mean, I can only hit it against the desk so many times per day, you know, without a crude, the bumps aren’t showing a hat on, you know. Well, you have your hat protection but it’s also, it’s early in the pacific time, still several hours left in the day. Like the Grinch right now, Tony. No, there, there’s, there’s cause for concern. Um, the, the, the, uh, the composition of the court, the Supreme Court has enormous sway over, uh, over our, our laws, our culture just, you know, our, our lives. So these are a couple of instances we’re gonna turn to Amy. I’m probably not going to make anything sound better than g, well, it’s not a competition. I know I just, all arbitrary. I thought you were like wanting to pick up the tone, you know, but all arbitrary and capricious opinions are welcome. Your, your opinions are not neither arbitrary nor capricious. Um but uh you are hearing from folks about their concern about the, the, the potential of a, of a, a changed economy, uh marketplace and uh potential fundraising impacts. What, what are you, what are you hearing from folks? You, you have your ear to the ground? Yeah, I mean, you know, I think everyone, at least in the US, I’m sure you have listeners elsewhere thanks to the internet but have spent, I don’t know how much of our lives over the last election cycle. Constantly hearing about the economy, constantly hearing about tariffs, constant, all of these things about the market. And it doesn’t matter if any of them are real or not or have already happened or maybe one day gonna happen, it doesn’t matter. It means there’s now a real air of uncertainty about what’s gonna happen to the economy. And unfortunately, in the nonprofit sector, we know that the winds of the economy shifting also shift philanthropy and how they may have a more conservative view over their own um corpus and, and what they want to spend. And of course, that means then for the nonprofits, you know, are we competing even harder for fewer funds? Are funders kind of back to the first piece of this conversation in 9495 are funders not wanting to be seen resourcing organizations who talk about certain political situations. Um, you know, it just has created a lot of uncertainty and what, you know, we’re hearing from organizations is, um, of course, when there was a lot of uncertainty in 2020 the pandemic was shifting, everything, organizations didn’t, you know, know how to adjust organizations were laying staff off or sh you know, all of those big shifts meant the things that were really quick to go was no professional development spending, no technology spending, no training. And those were also the resources that would have allowed organizations to adjust and to be nimble and to know how to continue moving through these really um confusing or, or unpredictable times. And so I think because folks who already experienced that once they’re starting to feel like, oh my gosh, if funding is uncertain, if how we’re operating is uncertain, we can’t let go of some of our tools and training and resources that allow us to think and adjust and, you know, make really, really maybe quick but strategic choices instead of reactionary choices that maybe we experienced before, you know, and had to learn the hard way that, oh, we don’t just do everything on zoom or whatever it might be, you know. Um And I think coupled with that, with some of these uh talked about threats to a lot of different communities. Organizations are also feeling like, you know, are our system secure. Do we know what data we have and which communities, it might compromise if it was either demanded of us from the government. Or hacked and stolen from us? You know, what, what duties do we have as an organization that serves communities who are in the process of, you know, getting documentation or a path to citizenship? What if we have data on these folks because they’re in our services and in our programs, are we vulnerable as an organization? And also are we maybe making them vulnerable by having their data? And how do we think about that? You know, how do we prepare our systems to be um ready to navigate maybe threats or challenges that come up? So I think it’s a lot, it’s also December and everybody is tired and wants to put up that out of office on their email and just like take a break, which absolutely you should do, you are entitled to, to take that break. But I think folks are feeling really worried about what’s ahead and not totally prepared, you know, to know how to, how to navigate it yet. Yeah, uncertainty. We, we don’t, we don’t, we don’t do well in uncertain environments whether they’re financial, physical, whether, you know, we don’t uh it doesn’t matter. We, we um uncertainty is unsettling. Um I will say some of what you described. I, I don’t, I don’t want to uh promote paranoia, but some of that introspect, introspection and self evaluation, you know, it has value too, 0 100% and data security resilience, right? And those are not new things you know, any day of the year, any year it is. If you came to N 10, we would say, hey, do you know what data you have on your community? And do you know where it’s stored? And do you know if it’s secure, you know, these aren’t new things for us to talk about. But I think they are very new things for some organizations to think about in their systems and actually like put into place, you know, even if they’ve maybe had a more theoretical conversation about, oh, you know, do we wanna answer community questions through Facebook D MS? You know, that’s probably not safe, let’s not do that but didn’t then have the rest of the conversation of OK, well, what data do we have on those folks? What, which systems is it in? Do we know how we’re maintained? You know, and the uncertainty of what’s the common kind of threats to so many different communities that, you know, are maybe part of a lot of different missions is forcing I think folks to think about the whole rest of the equation instead of just that first part that that’s maybe where they focused in the past. I thought a lesson that came from the the pandemic was that we, we not make financial decisions that are short sighted, like, you know, cutting professional development and technology, but rather that we go to our supporters with our needs and how the, how the uh the, the missions may have grown, the, the program work may have expanded because of, in that case, the pandemic. Uh and you know, our need is so much greater rather than making the, the short sighted, you know, cuts. I think that we could say there are a lot of lessons from 2020 that we should still have and that we can point to people on learning investments in racial equity investments in equitable practices, investments in staff. Yes, absolutely. I heard many promises in 2020 about all of these things. I heard many folks say they learned those lessons and here we are folks, you know, one of, one of the biggest job areas that has turned over is any equity related title, right? People have eliminated those positions or eliminated the people in those positions. Like there are lots of lessons that I wish were deeply learned and you’re talking about one of them. But I think what we’re hearing is that organizations haven’t deeply learned that and folks are already feeling the crunch of ok. Well, we probably can’t come to the conference. We probably can’t do that course we pro because we know that’s gonna be what gets eliminated from the budget. What are you, what are you thinking? I would just add kind of on the funding issue. You know, we’ve got um um Lan and Vivek who are supposed to like get rid of $2 trillion of the federal budget, they want to eliminate head, smart head start. Um And uh just so many other programs they want to cut down on Social Security and Medicare. So, you know, there’s a lot of people who um justifiably are scared right now and um and know that their missions will, that are already operating in more demand than they can meet, it will only accelerate. Yeah, and not a lot of answers yet. So, um I, I offer everybody my own. Not that it means anything but a little bit of grace at this period because it’s, it’s, it’s tough times right now and a lot of, lot of fear and I think I don’t have a solution necessarily. I don’t think that Gene or you Tony are trying to say there’s a solution or one right path through all the uncertainty just to acknowledge like if you’re maintaining a lot of plates of anxiety, we see you, we also are spinning those plates and like it’s really difficult that actually the only thing is to wait and see what we need to do with them. You know, there, there isn’t some magic ball that tells us. Oh, actually, this is gonna be the one thing that happens. We just don’t know and that’s not comforting or helpful when we’re trying to be thoughtful in our organizations and anticipate what all of those options might be, you know, OK. Uh uh somber but uh but justified, you know. Um there there is a lot of uncertainty and on the legal side, on the uh economy and fundraising side, uh I mean, you said it, I mean, you know, we, we don’t know but it’s the uncertainty that is uh unsettling. Yeah, we know as a sector we can do hard things. We have faced hard situations, we know that we can do it. The, the real, I think tension in the air for the sector now is that we don’t know what the hard thing is we’re gonna have to do, you know. And so we’re like, you, you’re packing for a trip where you don’t know where you’re gonna go and you’re like, well, do I need a swimsuit? Do I need a hat? Like, I don’t know, I don’t know what resource to put in here because I don’t totally know what’s ahead and I think that’s what makes it really difficult, not that we’re not gonna be able to do it, you know. Yeah, I mean, look at what we have overcome uh September 11th, uh a pandemic. Uh well, before the pandemic was the great recession. And then the next milestone that I can think of is the pandemic. Um And I, I know that we are stronger as a community. If we are United, if we stand up for each other and for the community at large, we, we can overcome whatever uncertainties and challenges are ahead of us when, when we remain united, steadfast you know, all, all for 11, for all that’s uh it, it comes from the three musketeers, but it uh it applies in lots of uh lots of situations and, and this is certainly one of them. Um We’re strong, we’re strong when we’re united. I think community power building is kind of what the my optimistic hope is. Um as we face tough times, um nonprofit leaders and their supporters, um they band together, they, they work through the problems as you mentioned to, we worked through many before. Some of them have been super challenging when we look back generations before us um going through wars and other crises and nonprofits. We’re really like the, the strength and the humanity of the country when they look to the people they served. And hopefully we’re, we’re getting to that again. We’re not making decisions without the community. We’re, we’re making it with the community now. All right. Any other closing thoughts? The last thing I wanted to say because, you know, me, I’m always compelled to have recommendations um for things that people can do. And I too am a human that likes a to do list. Um And I will offer that to others. But yeah, I know we’ve talked about this so many times, Tony, you and I over the years about community committees and you know, ways of building transparency around your technology projects or, you know, having a tech committee that helps you prioritize But to Gene’s point, if you don’t already as an organization have a mechanism, whatever that might be to hear feedback from your community, not like an evaluation for somebody that was in a program or something like that. But I mean, a community committee, a committee of community members that you talk to once a quarter or a town hall event or whatever type of process you might wanna have, this is the time to have it because I think when things are really difficult, we can as staff feel like every single thing that is in the news or every single thing that could be on our community members, minds are on their minds and that they are like judging us for it. But if you have a way to, to really be in conversation with your community directly, you’ll be able to say, ok, the only thing our community wants to know from us is this and we can answer it and we can tell them or hey, our community is really worried about this thing that has nothing to do with us, but they’re really worried about it. So maybe that’s an opportunity for us to partner with an organization that does work on that and show that we’re listening and that we’re part of helping them have access to the resources they care about or whatever it might be, right? Um Because it’s a lot harder to call on a community that doesn’t exist when you’re in need than it is to be in community with people all the time. Um So, you know, if, if there’s anything to put on your January to do list while so much is still uncertain, it’s really to make sure you have some space to be in conversation directly with your community in me. Simple word. They’re at Amy Sample ward.org and at Amy Rs Ward and Jan Takagi, the firm is at Neo Law group.com and he’s at GT and we will convene again. Uh maybe not January, mid February, mid to late February, I think. Uh Well, let’s see what, let’s see what happens in the month of January, but certainly uh latest, you know, February, we will convene and uh and be in community again. Thanks Tony for always making this space. Big hugs Jean. Thank you, Tony right back at you, Amy. Happy New Year. Happy New Year. Happy Holidays. Next week, there’s no show and there’s no show the week after. We’ll be back fresh on January 6th, 2025. Happy New Year. If you missed any part of this week’s show, I beseech you find it at Tony martignetti.com. Happy New Year were sponsored by donor box, outdated donation forms blocking your supporters, generosity, donor box, fast, flexible and friendly fundraising forms for your nonprofit donor. Box.org. Happy New Year. Our creative producer is Claire Meyerhoff. I’m your associate producer, Kate Martignetti. The show social media is by Susan Chavez Mark Silverman is our web guy and this music is by Scott Stein. Thank you for that affirmation, Scotty. You with us next week. No, you won’t be with us next week. You’re with us in January 2025 for nonprofit radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95% go out and be great. Happy New Year.