Skip to content
EP 636April 18, 2023

#23NTC! & Building An Inclusive Board Culture

Tony MartignettiAmy Sample WardRenee Rubin Ross
Nonprofit Radio
Episode 636
0:00 / 0:00

#23NTC!

Amy Sample Ward kicks off our coverage of the 2023 Nonprofit Technology Conference, hosted by NTEN. They cover the Conference details, and delve into weighing the benefits and risks of the fast-moving technology, artificial intelligence. They are the CEO of NTEN and our technology and social media contributor.

Building An Inclusive Board Culture

Let us explore the signs and symptoms of your board’s current culture, and strategies to be more inclusive and equitable, if that’s something your nonprofit needs to pursue. Let us also dive into how to manage toxic people on your board. Renee Rubin Ross is founder and CEO of The Ross Collective.

Here’s the transcript

Tony MartignettiHello and welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. I'm your aptly named host of your favorite hebdomadal podcast. We're beginning our '23 NTC coverage this week. And oh, I'm glad you're with me. I'd have to undergo counter-immuno-electrophoresis if you opposed me because you missed this week's show. 23 NTC. Amy Sample Ward kicks off our coverage of the 2023 Nonprofit Technology Conference hosted by NTEN. They cover the conference details and delve into weighing the benefits and risks of the fast-moving technology artificial intelligence. They are the CEO of NTEN and our technology and social media contributor. Also, building an inclusive board culture. Let us explore the signs and symptoms of your board's current culture and strategies to be more inclusive and equitable if that's something your nonprofit needs to pursue. Let us also dive into how to manage toxic people on your board. Renee Rubin Ross is founder and CEO of the Ross Collective. On Tony's Take Two, 23 NTC thanks. We're sponsored by DonorBox. With intuitive fundraising software from DonorBox, your donors give 4 times faster, helping you help others. And I'm sorry, my voice is a little hoarse because I did spend so much time capturing interviews at 23 NTC. Here is 23 NTC with Amy Sample Ward. Welcome back to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio coverage of 23 NTC. You know that it's the nonprofit Technology Conference hosted by NTEN. This is not our first interview today, but I'm sure that this is going to be the kickoff of Nonprofit Radio's coverage of 23 NTC, where we— and you'll find out why very shortly— where we are sponsored by Heller Consulting, technology strategy and implementation for nonprofits. The reason that we're going to do this interview The first of the many, 20 to be exact, interviews from 23NTC is because with me now is Amy Sample Ward. You know who they are, the CEO of NTEN and our technology and social media contributor, which makes them the grand imperial wizard and grand poobah of the 2023 Nonprofit Technology Conference. Thank you. Amy Sample Ward, it's a real pleasure to see you in person.

Amy Sample WardIt is wild to get to see you in person after all this time. I know, I am touching you.

Tony MartignettiWe're patting each other's arms and shoulders.

Amy Sample WardAnd I think I need to update my business card. I have a whole string of titles now, I guess.

Tony MartignettiOh, well, to the extent you're willing to put on your business card—

Amy Sample WardI will not be putting those on my business card. This was all a joke.

Tony MartignettiOh, thank you. All right, thank you very much. But nobody uses business cards anymore anyway, so I'm not offended. Although there's this little stack of cards I'm trying to get rid of still. Some people take them. There are some— maybe they're—

Amy Sample WardIn rare moments when it's really helpful.

Tony MartignettiMaybe they're all boomers. I don't know. But somebody's— there are people who would rather not just scan a code, would rather take a physical card. So I have cards out front.

Amy Sample WardI actually don't even have business cards.

Tony MartignettiYou don't?

Amy Sample WardI don't have business cards. I couldn't even give you one if I wanted to.

Tony MartignettiNo longer. Okay, that's fine. Well, then don't add it to your business card. We're at 23 NTC. Congratulations. Yay!

Amy Sample WardCongratulations. It's really happening. We are looking around at a big old hall. There are booths, there are people, there are snacks.

Tony MartignettiHow many people? How many people are here with us in Denver?

Amy Sample WardWe have 1,600 people here in Denver, 400—

Tony Martignetti1,600 people?

Amy Sample WardThat's a lot of people to manage. Online.

Tony Martignetti400 virtual, 1,600 in person.

Amy Sample WardYes, yes, yes.

Tony MartignettiAll right, we're feeding 1,600 people.

Amy Sample WardYes.

Tony MartignettiWe are toileting for 1,600 people.

Amy Sample WardYes. We have— We have lounges. We have mini parks. We have everything.

Tony MartignettiYes, there's a quiet room. Yes. There's birds of a feather rooms. There's yoga.

Amy Sample WardYes. Oh my gosh, did you see the everybody yoga out downstairs earlier? I did see it. Oh, it was beautiful. Everybody was doing it? 50 people, and it was yoga. You don't need to have ever done yoga before. You don't need experience. For everybody, you know, there are folks who were in chairs versus sitting on the floor, you know, and everybody was just doing it all together out in that big foyer downstairs.

Tony MartignettiYeah, that's a big space.

Amy Sample WardYeah, it was beautiful.

Tony MartignettiThere's light maybe streaming in. Exactly. Because there's a huge wall of windows streaming in. So

Amy Sample Wardyeah, yeah, I mean, we can be at a technology conference, but I think You know, we've talked about this lots of times, whether it's the NTC or just how we think about technology in general. It's actually not about the technology, right? It's about people and people being able to meet the needs they have and honoring that those needs are different for different people. You know, like there have to be a lot of different lounges because you maybe want a different lounge than I want, right? Like somebody wants to not be talking. Tony Martignetti wants to be talking, you know.

Tony MartignettiI like to talk. Yes, indeed. Right. So you take care of the whole person. You, the NTC collective, the NTEN collective. Yes, the collective. Absolutely. Today's keynote. I don't know which of the 3. I was interviewing early, so I didn't see today's keynote.

Amy Sample WardThis morning was supposed to be a no-ball.

Tony MartignettiOkay. What was their message?

Amy Sample WardOh, sure. Had so many different things to talk about. And one thing that I want to call out and then encourage people to maybe think about themselves and go follow, go find— she's written books, she has lots of ways that you could follow her content. But this morning we talked a lot about technology as a social, economic, and political practice. It is, it is happening, you know? It's not static. It isn't just there. Yeah. These are ways that certain economic issues, classes, dynamics are actively being managed. These, through technology, power, social dynamics are being managed, right? Like, those things have been baked in from the beginning. So, when we think of And we've certainly talked about this before, like bias that gets built into a tool. Mm-hmm. It isn't just, I like orange and you like blue or something, right? It's bias that some people will forever be able to better use that tool. It's bias that some people maybe never access that tool. That the idea that we are in surveillance systems all of the time, and we are kind of being told, These are utilities. We must all use these tools, right? They're convenience. They're making our lives better. But they're actually surveillance tools.

Tony MartignettiWhen you're talking about surveillance, yeah, safety and security are often used as justifications.

Amy Sample WardYes, yes. And even if it does feel— this is a point that Safiya made this morning— maybe it does feel kind of casually better that the ads you're getting are things maybe that you actually would consider buying versus something that's totally unrelated to you, that is not worth you, your data being sold, used, misused, and deciding who you are, right? Some of our data being sold and being used by other Well, anyone that isn't us is deciding, can you get a loan? Right? Can you do— are we even gonna like actually believe that you can graduate from college? Are we gonna let you in? Are we gonna hire you for this job? Hire you, yeah. Right? So it isn't just this like, I think we kind of animize it or make it so generic that it loses a little bit of its Harsh reality when we think, oh, the data's out there, but whatever. It's like my purchase history, and I like that they recommended a good product to me, right?

Tony MartignettiYeah, we think of it as very benign.

Amy Sample WardRight, but that same dataset is determining if, you know, like Sophia said, in the UK, banks are looking at social media to decide if they're going to give you a loan. Does it look like all the people that you're connected to are Like, historically separated from any access to wealth? Well, we're not going to give you a loan. Well, then that means we're not using— we're not predicting anything. We are deciding with that technology, right? This isn't predictive analytics. This is restrictive analytics, right? Yeah. We're using this to gatekeep and to continue to oppress people. And I think a really big part of that conversation too was, We, everybody here at the NTC and folks that are listening to Nonprofit Radio, are folks who are both the users impacted by that and organizations in a position to maybe not realize they're playing a part in that. You know, like maybe you're sending all of your users into those tools because it was easier or you thought they were already on Facebook or even if it's not social media, you're using a certain product and You didn't realize that—

Tony MartignettiData share, what their data sharing practices were because you didn't do your due diligence around their privacy rules. Exactly. Jeez, you gave me chills. I'm getting my synesthesia kicked in, and I'm sure it's not the air conditioning. No, that's— it's— all right, we need a show about this.

Amy Sample WardYeah, there's just a lot of layers to this, right?

Tony MartignettiWe could be contributing ourselves

Amy Sample Wardinnocuously,

Tony Martignettiwell, unknowingly.

Amy Sample WardRight.

Tony MartignettiUnknowingly.

Amy Sample WardRight. And she works as faculty and leading a department at UCLA and brought up an example from the academic world of years ago when there was the tool that was being sold, marketed to professors and universities, that you could upload all of your students' papers into it. And then it would tell you if they had plagiarized from the internet, you know, oh, oh, that's something else that already exists. And she and her colleagues immediately said, oh, this is not good. This is actually not good. And a lot of other folks were like, what do you mean? This means like we're catching the students who were trying to plagiarize. Of course, we all know that means that small, successful company got bought. Yeah. By a bigger company who knew what they could do with a big old dataset. Oh. Right? So what— just think, if you wrote a paper in college when you're still trying to like figure out your ideas and you're still learning, like the paper is meant to be a learning practice. It's not meant to be published for the world. And now 15 years later, You're applying for a job and that shows up, you know, as part of your data record, right? And maybe it has ideas that you fundamentally don't believe now or even ever, but didn't really know what you were saying. And now you can't get a job because people see this and say, oh, you wrote this paper.

Tony MartignettiIt's part of your archive.

Amy Sample WardRight.

Tony MartignettiYour personal archive.

Amy Sample WardRight.

Tony MartignettiOh

Amy Sample Wardman. So, as organizations, when we think we're saving time or we think that we're We're doing something by letting the robots do it so that we ourselves are not subjectively making decisions, right? We might actually be making even harder subjective decisions down the line for those people, right? We might be setting them up into systems where their data and their issues are not ever in their control again.

Tony MartignettiAnd this is so enormously timely with all the The talk about artificial intelligence. Exactly. ChatGPT, the other ones I can't name off the top of my head.

Amy Sample WardRight, right, right. BS.

Tony MartignettiAnd our use of them. Look, there was a guest on maybe an hour and a half ago who said, we're not going to be able to— no, it was Maureen Wallbeoff, I think. Oh, yes. We can't stop this. It's like trying to stop the innovation around automobiles. Right. You know, or the phone. Or trying to stop airlines, airplane flights. It's not possible. But our smart use of it and our constrained use of it. So I shared with— this is another thing you and I—

Amy Sample WardInformed use.

Tony MartignettiYou and Gene and I need to talk about this, the 3 of us together. Informed. Yeah. Informed and thoughtful. I'm concerned about the— less the due diligence, but just the thought that goes into it. My concern is that, and I shared this with Maureen, and,

Amy Sample Wardum,

Tony Martignettithe advice, a lot of the advice that I see is use artificial intelligence as a first draft.

Amy Sample WardRight.

Tony MartignettiAnd then, so you're not, you're no longer facing the blank page. Sure. Put a pin, I'll come back to that in a sec. And then you, uh, put your own tone to it.

Amy Sample WardRight, it's easier to edit than it is to create.

Tony MartignettiYeah, that's exactly my Yes. You're reducing yourself from creative thinker working from a blank sheet, blank screen, to, to relegate it to copy editor. And I don't mean to insult any copy editors.

Amy Sample WardNo, copy editing is a very valuable job.

Tony MartignettiBut it's not nearly as creative a process as looking at a blank screen and working from nothing.

Amy Sample WardI think the really big piece of that is we have seen plenty of evidence. We do not need more evidence to know that what these artificial intelligence tools are providing to us is misinformation. The tool is not only giving us quote unquote facts, right?

Tony MartignettiThat's another layer.

Amy Sample WardAnd so it isn't even that you need to add a copy editing layer. If you were to do that, you would need to go back and actually say, is any of this real? Like Safiya said this morning, they had received You know, other people in academia are making this point of, you know, oh, this is leveling the playing field, right? Because now folks who maybe aren't naturally confident or comfortable writing and they communicate better in other ways, now they could use artificial intelligence to help them get a jumpstart on the paper and then they edit it and, you know, whatever. But they have reviewed papers written And in this way, all of the footnotes are not real articles. They're not real books, right? Because artificial intelligence made up a book to reference. So—

Tony MartignettiThe footnotes are not real?

Amy Sample WardRight. Because artificial intelligence was told to make a footnote. So it notated words in the format that it learned online is what a footnote looks like, right? Damn. The idea that it is there, like you're saying, you know, the idea that, oh, it gets us started and then we go in and like we zhuzh it up. No. I mean, unless you're using it for the outline structure of I want an intro paragraph and then I want, you know, but what then is left that is viable? We are not helping people get a jumpstart. We are actively creating more misinformation. Yeah. It's

Tony Martignettitime for a break. Stop the drop with DonorBox. They're the online donation platform. How many possible donors drop off before they finish making the donation on your website? You can stop that drop and break that cycle with DonorBox's ultimate donation form. You add it to your website in minutes. There's no coding required. When you stop the drop, the possible donors become donors. It's 4 times faster checkout, easier payment processing, no setup fees, no monthly fees, no contract required. You'll be joining over 40,000 US nonprofits that use DonorBox. DonorBox, helping you help others at donorbox.org. Thank you. Now back to 23 NTC. There's another layer on top of that because you mentioned the footnote specifically. LinkedIn post, someone I follow a lot on LinkedIn, he follows me. I think I can mention George Weiner at Whole Whale. Whole Whale.

Amy Sample WardWho's maybe here.

Tony MartignettiIs George here? Is George here?

Amy Sample WardI don't want to be part of misinformation, but I think I think that George might be here.

Tony MartignettiOh, wow. His concern was he did a search of something that Whole Whale is very well known for. I guess it was, I think it was SEO, basically. SEO, basically. And he did a search in artificial intelligence. So he was using an AI tool for search. And it came up with a top result that was taken from Whole Whale's resource page or something. And it credited— it did credit Whole Whale.

Amy Sample WardYeah.

Tony MartignettiHis concern was that the next step would be it would take from Whole Whale's resource page and not credit Whole Whale.

Amy Sample WardRight, of course.

Tony MartignettiBecause there was no requirement for it. So in this case, it was a legitimate footnote, but his concern is that it's going to be stealing his intellectual property And not crediting him in whole way.

Amy Sample WardOf course, because if you think about what artificial intelligence is doing is like,

Tony Martignettiyeah,

Amy Sample Wardwe're at scale able to read all of the internet, right? We're not able to read all the internet. It's reading not technically all of it, but like, you know, so much more of it than we could read without the kind of human context that we're able to put on something. I know that on the Nonprofit Radio website, there are pieces of content where you've said, Amy said, quote, blahdy blahdy blah, right? I work at NTEN. My name is Amy Sample Ward. The idea that artificial intelligence would know to read the next sentence to know that I said the thing when that thing is all that mattered because it was relevant to what it was trying to create.

Tony MartignettiYeah.

Amy Sample WardAnd even if it did create a footnote, it would likely be Nonprofit Radio, right? But the radio show doesn't talk, right? It wouldn't be crediting you. So it's already set up to fail.

Tony MartignettiAnd even the greater likelihood is that it's not going to credit anyone. It's just going to take the intellectual property.

Amy Sample WardRight, of course. And so, you know, I think we're overestimating what it could do and putting human expectations on onto artificial intelligence that it can't and shouldn't. It doesn't need to be human, right? But we are blurring the lines of what is best for humans to do and what is best for a data-crunching tool to do, right?

Tony MartignettiWe

Amy Sample Warddid talk about hopeful things, but you know.

Tony MartignettiI feel like I'm drowning in the ocean that I live across from. Look, all right, so we know we need to talk about this again, but I mean, I guess, you know, what we're talking about is thoughtful use.

Amy Sample WardYes.

Tony MartignettiBut I don't— I'm not convinced that humans are thoughtful enough to thoughtfully use this wave, this tsunami that's gathering such speed that even Elon Musk signed something that said, Let's take a 6-month pause.

Amy Sample WardI mean, which is ridiculous. We're not talking about Elon Musk. I can't.

Tony MartignettiBut the idea that there'd be a pause, an artificial pause in technological growth is absurd.

Amy Sample WardRight. No. Because even what we know of is not actually accurate to what has currently been developed. That just hasn't been released yet.

Tony MartignettiRight. We just don't know. Or it's happening nefariously and the Washington Post The Washington Post will uncover it in 6 months or something when it's already too late.

Amy Sample WardRight. Well, and I think there's a piece of this—

Tony MartignettiThe point is it's not stopping.

Amy Sample WardNo.

Tony MartignettiAnd we need to be thoughtful, but I'm not— I don't have a lot of confidence that we're thoughtful enough beings to not take advantage of this.

Amy Sample WardBut I don't think it's about necessarily that we're not thoughtful and we need to be more thoughtful. I think what I see at least and hear in the community is that folks feel like There wasn't a choice. This was the only tool that was available. And we are sitting in the middle of a giant exhibit hall, right, with like 120 people. And there are people in here that do the same things as each other. You know, there's no other nonprofit radio in here. That's true. But there are people, you know, who do the same thing. And the illusion that we don't have choice as individual nonprofit organizations or as individual users of technology is a myth that is being over and over and over told to us so that we don't go looking, right? That we don't unsubscribe, that we don't opt out, that we don't say, no, you cannot have my data, right? Because it's the same story of, you need this. This is useful to you. This is improving your life. Yeah. And don't look behind the curtain. There's nowhere else to go. There's no one else, you know? Because that's the power. That is that political, social, economic practice that's happening by technology to keep us as we are, right? And so, breaking out of that is not, okay, everybody here has to go make their own tools. That's not what I'm saying either. Hmm. Even just knowing that there are Options pushes you into thoughtfulness because now you're saying, oh, well, how would I decide between these? Oh, let me ask some questions, right? And when we think there's no choice, we don't bother asking the questions. We don't know what they're going to do when we sign up for their product, right? So even just thinking, well, let me like shop around, already sets us up to be so much more mindful of what we're doing with technology, the decision, the investments we're making, you know, what products we're Putting our community's data into, you know.

Tony MartignettiMakes you mindful, raises your consciousness.

Amy Sample WardRight. So I don't think it's hard to like turn that, to go over that hump. And it's not like we're asking everyone to become enlightened on a topic that they've never heard about. We're saying, just ask questions, know that there is more than one option, right? And that already gets you moving the power back onto your side, right? They're answering to you now versus you feeling like, well, I just signed up and now we're using this tool.

Tony MartignettiYou have options. You have options.

Amy Sample WardYes.

Tony MartignettiNTC is one place to find out what those options are. NTEN is.

Amy Sample WardYeah.

Tony MartignettiThoughtful use of technology, NTEN, the courses. I mean, you can do them for certification, for God's sake, if you need certification, if you need a diploma.

Amy Sample WardRight.

Tony MartignettiThey have them.

Amy Sample WardYes. Okay.

Tony MartignettiUh, 24 NTC.

Amy Sample WardYes.

Tony MartignettiPortland, Oregon.

Amy Sample WardPortland, Oregon. All right, we really thought when we had the NTC in Portland in 2019, um, and we thought, oh, everybody loved it. We just got so much great feedback from the community that the city was fun and accessible, that restaurants were good, you know, um, people had a great time. And we're like, okay, well, we can come back to Portland, let's really put this a long time from now. And now it will be, you know, we just had Denver and now we're back in Portland again.

Tony MartignettiIt's 2 after.

Amy Sample WardBecause we had 3 years of not being offline. So yes, back in Portland. Everyone on the team is super excited just to be back at a place we've been before, and it makes all the decisions easier. We already have ideas for making it better. So, and, you know, we're in Denver here, but we're also online. And there are sessions that are only in Denver, there are sessions that are only online, and then there are sessions that are simultaneously in both places. And let me tell you, we are learning a lot.

Tony MartignettiThere's a lot of— that takes a lot of technology support, especially the ones that are here and virtual.

Amy Sample WardYes, I would say in-person stuff, you know, fine, under control. Yeah. You know, the regular Snapmeez. We've done that.

Tony MartignettiWe've been doing this for decades.

Amy Sample WardThe totally online stuff, also totally fine. You know, every once in a while somebody logs into the wrong Zoom or, you know, whatever, but that's fine. It's the hybrid sessions where we have really asked a lot of technology and technology Seems to still be deciding how it feels about us in these hybrid sessions.

Tony MartignettiWhat does it look like in those rooms? Can we— so there's a camera? Can we see the audience members who are virtual? Yes. There's a screen with all of them?

Amy Sample WardYeah, so there's— so both places can see, you know, back between.

Tony MartignettiYes.

Amy Sample WardAnd we have an NTEN staff person or one of our trained volunteers is host on both sides so that there's somebody who's not the speakers or the attendees themselves trying to say, somebody has a question, or the question's over here, or, you know, like those 2 hosts can talk one-to-one and like own their side, right?

Tony MartignettiYeah, yeah, yeah.

Amy Sample WardSo we have those 2 hosts, we have the actual like Zoom, and then we have all of the technology that needs to be in the Denver room to make sure that the microphones are syncing in real time to the stream, to the video, to everything else.

Tony MartignettiDamn.

Amy Sample WardYeah.

Tony MartignettiAll right. Well, it's bold. It's a bold initiative to take it on.

Amy Sample WardIt is. And honestly, so far, I mean, knock on wood, I think we had a snafu this morning where, you know, and it's like the perfect worst thing to happen. You know, the bad thing that happened was volunteers wanted to make sure that their sessions were great and tried to log in early to set them up early. And so they booted the session that was already happening. Wow. So it wasn't like nobody came or nothing ever happened. Yeah, right. You know, the captioners have all been there, and it's the normal caption team we work with who are just so great and consistent. All the volunteers have been early, if not on time, you know. So the pro— and then we realized, oh, the problem is that that volunteer logged in. Oh, that's why we all got booted. Oh, they were able to figure it out, send a message to everyone and say, if your shift starts at 9:15, we mean 9:15. We do not mean 9:13. Yes. So it was an easy-to-fix challenge.

Tony MartignettiAnd it was conscientious. You have conscientious volunteers, not lazy, lackadaisical volunteers.

Amy Sample WardRight. But so we are learning a lot about like what prep do the folks on both sides really need to pull that off? Like maybe, maybe, you know, Ash and Jeremy and Drew will have a session with you in the summer and talk about doing hybrid virtual events and how to make them really successful. You know, people are still doing— I mean, so many folks fundraising galas have kept the hybrid piece where they're like, oh, we could have 100 people at home donating that we didn't buy food for? Yes, please. You know, so I think we're really going to see hybrid stay around. People are going to want to keep doing that. And you know us, we're happy to share all of our mistakes so that you can learn from them. Yes. All

Tony Martignettiright. All right. So 24 NTC— so I would expect 24 NTC is also going to be Yes,

Amy Sample WardI think

Tony Martignettiso. That sounds— you wouldn't abandon that, all the learnings, right? I mean, yeah, all the— 400 attendees. Yeah, so next year it'll be 800.

Amy Sample WardYeah.

Tony MartignettiVirtual.

Amy Sample WardRight.

Tony MartignettiAll right, thank you. All right, we're looking forward to 20— well, we're in— we're loving 23 NTC here in Denver. Looking forward to next year. You and Gene and I, I think we just have picked, identified probably 3 different Subjects that the 3 of us could spend an hour talking about.

Amy Sample WardYes.

Tony MartignettiI'm glad, you know, I'm glad I'm not the only one who's concerned. Even George Weiner, kind of, you know, he was more leaning toward, well, the risks aren't, you know, I don't think they're that great.

Amy Sample WardYeah.

Tony MartignettiBut I need George to be a little more thoughtful before he comes down on one side or the other.

Amy Sample WardWell, and I think that from any position—

Tony MartignettiThe Georges. Let me just not put it on George Weiner. I need the Georgians to be more thoughtful.

Amy Sample WardI think it's important to also remember that when we're thinking of what are those risks, we're filtering that through what do I think those risks are? And I, or you, you as the listener, whoever, the one asking that question cannot be the one assessing risk for everyone. You have not experienced the same harm that everyone has experienced. technology, you maybe don't have the same view of what you need that technology to do. So, the idea that any one of us could say, oh, the risks aren't that bad, or these are the definitive list of risks, we just can't. You know, it's too dynamic of a constantly changing situation to say that the risks— the risk list stops, or that it is or is not too much to care about, right? Yeah. Yeah. Because for some folks, there are people who are not online because of these risks, right? They are choosing to not even have access to some of the utilities that we all can benefit from, working remotely, having access to education remotely, because these risks are too harmful, right? So I just wanna caution any of us from saying this is it or this is the view, right? The view is changing every day when all the people in this room release a new version of their product, right? Or buy each other and decide to do different things.

Tony MartignettiAnd it's also very personal.

Amy Sample WardYes.

Tony MartignettiIt has to be personal, organizational, you know.

Amy Sample WardAnd that's the place from which I want everybody here to take their duty, right? Is that it is personal, and you have a duty as an organization to honor that personal level of choice and risk for every community member that you are expecting to give you their data, right? That you're expecting to trust you. And that's kind of an entry point too to that mindfulness around technology is like, it's not yours, it is theirs. And are you allowing them to have choice? Are you allowing folks to decide how much data they give you and not, or what you can do with their data? Like, it just opens up a whole 5 more shows of what we talk about, right?

Tony MartignettiAll right, good. We have some things. This is not her last— this is not their— this is not their last appearance.

Amy Sample WardRight. Let's talk about, Gene, about the, the legal piece of that too, right? Because there's a social conscience of what you do with your community members' data, and there's actual legal pieces of it too, right?

Tony MartignettiYeah, we will. We will. All right. There's Amy Sample Ward, the CEO of NTEN, the grand high exalted mystic ruler of 23 NTC. I was surprised to see them walking on the street today. I thought I'd see them in a chauffeured limousine.

Amy Sample WardOh my gosh.

Tony MartignettiWhen you bring 1,600 people to the city of Denver, I thought you'd get the penthouse suite, concierge, bellman.

Amy Sample WardNot me.

Tony MartignettiNot me. Okay. Thank you very much. So good to see you.

Amy Sample WardThank you.

Tony MartignettiAnd thank you for being with our 23 NTC coverage where we are sponsored by Heller Consulting, sharing the booth with us, doing technology strategy and implementation for nonprofits. Thank you. It's time for Tony's Take Two. First, I need to thank Heller Consulting. So thank you, Heller Consulting. For your sponsorship of Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio at the 2023 Nonprofit Technology Conference. Very grateful that we shared a large booth together, that I was able to make lots of interviews to Heller after each interview, bringing folks over to meet the Heller team. Uh, that was Kaya and Paige and Jet. And I also met the CEO, Keith Heller. Thank you. Thank you, Heller Consulting, for partnering with me, sponsoring Nonprofit Radio at the 23 NTC. Thanks so much. Thanks to the listeners who came by. But a bunch of folks come over, say, oh, you're the— you're that radio guy, you know, the Nonprofit Radio guy. One guy said it in a bathroom. But in any case, I got a chance to meet lots of listeners, so that's very gratifying. Thank you to those folks that came over. I'm not going to name who came over in the men's room. We'll just leave that to lay right there. But thanks, listeners who joined us at 23 NTC. And thank you, NTEN! NTEN! Supporting Nonprofit Radio, I'm grateful for our partnership. Thank you to the team at NTEN. Congratulations to the staff for a successful, fun, valuable conference. My thanks, my congratulations out to NTEN. That is Tony's Take Two. We've got beaucoup buttloads more time. Here is Building an Inclusive Board Culture. Welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio coverage of 23NTC, the 2023 Nonprofit Technology Conference. We're at the Colorado Convention Center in Denver, Colorado, where we are sponsored by Heller Consulting, technology strategy and implementation for nonprofits. With me now is Renee Rubin Ross. She is founder and CEO of the Ross Collective. Renee Rubin Ross, welcome to Nonprofit Radio.

Renee Rubin RossThanks so much. Great to be here.

Tony MartignettiAbsolute pleasure to have you. Your topic is building an inclusive culture on nonprofit boards.

Renee Rubin RossRight, right.

Tony MartignettiI think I have some sense But I'm going to let you articulate, because you'll do it better, why we need this session.

Renee Rubin RossOh, wow. Well, so many things, but I think that I do a lot of different things. I do strategic planning and board development facilitation, and I also teach board development at Cal State University East Bay. And so I've had so many— I identify as a white person and consultant. I've had so many people come up to me who are on boards saying, wow, we are really struggling to build a positive culture. And what do we need to do? How can we make things different? And I mean, I would say people of all different racial backgrounds, people who are, you know, people who might just be joining the board who don't know what's going on. And so in having these conversations, I've developed a way of thinking about, all right, what are some practices that support boards to do better work? Because I think that many of us, you probably know someone who's joined a board and says, gosh, you know, it seems like everybody else knows what's going on here, and I'm trying to catch up, but I just don't feel like I'm part of this. And that might be around information, it might be around the culture in terms of racial equity, it might be around Relationships. So really thinking about what are some great practices that boards can keep in mind.

Tony MartignettiGender equity as well.

Renee Rubin RossYes, absolutely.

Tony MartignettiI hear there are a bunch of middle-aged white men on a board.

Renee Rubin RossYes.

Tony MartignettiAnd there are 2 women and one's a woman of color.

Renee Rubin RossYes.

Tony MartignettiAnd we, you know, we feel minimized. Yes, I've heard things like, you know, we feel patronized, minimized, all the power is in the middle-aged white guys.

Renee Rubin RossI start with the assumption that we all, that we each have something to contribute. And going back to this idea of equity, that the people who are closest to the problems should be weighing in on the solutions. So that we really need to design, consciously design boards and organizations in a way where all voices are heard and affirmed. And that's a good thing. That's not anybody losing anything. That's actually all of us getting to do better work. That supports everybody.

Tony MartignettiYeah, that zero-sum game where, well, if she has a voice, then I'm losing that much of mine. But it's ludicrous.

Renee Rubin RossRight, right. Power is infinite. There's enough for everybody. Voice and power are infinite. Absolutely.

Tony MartignettiSo you've got some signs and symptoms, indicators of what you're

Renee Rubin RossRight. Well, I am going— I have a story that I'm going to share. Please, we love stories. Sure. So I was on a board and I had a colleague who came and joined that board. And at the beginning, she was pretty quiet. But then over time, what happened, which I had not expected, was she started to come to the board meetings and there was always something bothering her. And she was really angry, and she became sadly this angry person in our meetings. And I didn't expect this. She was someone that I knew. She had some good things to contribute, but I started to think about what can I do? And I know that many of my students, many of the clients that I work with have the same issue, which we're going to talk about tomorrow in my session, which is what do you do about somebody who has this problem? We're going to talk about it today on Nonprofit Radio. We're talking about it right now.

Tony MartignettiWe're not holding out on Nonprofit Radio. You don't have to have been—

Renee Rubin RossNobody listening can go to your session. What do you do about somebody who has become a toxic board member? And what— so, so I suggest is this kind of 3-part framework.

Tony MartignettiAnd you knew this woman before the board service together.

Renee Rubin RossI knew this woman. And this is really what happens. This is not like, oh, we've never met this person before. Usually people who come on board, somebody knows them ahead of time. But what ended up happening was I did my checklist, which is, are the board procedures good? Yes. Are we generally building positive relationships? Yes. Are we honoring equity and listening to all voices? Yes. And then it was like, what I ended up doing was counseling my colleague off the board. And I just said to her, you know, what I've noticed is it doesn't seem like it makes you happy to be on this board.

Tony MartignettiWhat'd she say? She probably realized it herself, didn't she?

Renee Rubin RossShe realized it herself. I am somebody who's not afraid to have the tough tough conversations. I wasn't angry with her. I was stating the truth in a courageous way, and it got her to reflect on her participation and to leave the board.

Tony MartignettiWhat do you think was good? Was it anything having to do with the organization?

Renee Rubin RossOr do you think it wasn't? In this case, it wasn't. There were some other things that were going on. And so many of us have a lot of things that are happening in our homes, And with our families that maybe we are bringing to board meetings, right? So it's really a matter of how can board members act courageously and proactively so that the board— so that everybody feels like, wow, when I come to this meeting, things are going in a positive direction. Because what I've heard about boards these days is people really need to feel like Like their time is worthwhile. And if they don't, they want to do something else, especially now, you know, in this post-pandemic time. My time is really valuable.

Tony MartignettiTick off your 3 little— your 3 questions that you ask.

Renee Rubin RossRight. So I have this framework that I share with my students, with my clients, and my blog. It's all about, are you utilizing formal practices? So that's the first one is formal practices. Policies, goals, agendas, agreements, term limits. We could just have a whole— Following your bylaws. Your bylaws, right. And I have encountered organizations that will say, oh no, we don't have term limits. We have people on our board have been here for 20 years. You need to tighten that up. That is not responsible.

Tony MartignettiNotice you're saying, I notice you're saying not just have procedures, Are you following the procedures? The bylaws may have 2 consecutive 3-year terms as the max, and you've got this 20-year board member.

Renee Rubin RossSo great, you've got to be in print. You've got to enforce this and have a way of being in conversation. So first of all, formal, good meeting agendas. Following formal procedures. Good meeting agendas that are aligned with the goals of the organization.

Tony MartignettiOkay, that actually get followed. Yes, yes. Agendas get followed, time limits get followed, adhered to.

Renee Rubin RossYes, exactly.

Tony MartignettiAll those things.

Renee Rubin RossYes. Second of all, informal procedures. And this is really the relationship-building piece. And a lot— I think that in these days, if anything, people want more than ever to feel that they feel connected to other board members, they feel a sense of belonging on the board, that there's compassion, understanding, That it isn't just get the work done, but there's some sort of positive team feeling. And I will say that I shared this on a webinar, and someone said, well, how much does it cost to build real— and I'm like, it doesn't. We're talking a Starbucks coffee. Yeah, it costs consciousness. Yes, it costs presence. Presence. Right. So first, so formal Formal practices, informal practices.

Tony MartignettiFormal practices being followed.

Renee Rubin RossYes. Thank you. I'm asterisking that. Okay. Being followed. And informal practices given attention, really accounting for the fact that people process information differently, learn differently. That's another informal practice that can really support good culture and good meetings.

Tony MartignettiOn this one, before we move to the third, can other, like, Social events for the board. Absolutely. Which don't have to be expensive. Yes. The person who's concerned about spending too much money. I mean, you could, you could bring everybody in to witness, witness some of the work you're doing if you have that type of work. Right.

Renee Rubin RossBut you know what you just reminded me of is there was a board that I was invited to join and they said, we want to have all— we're having all of our meetings at 7 AM. And I was like, no, that— I'm a workaholic. I'm a working parent. 7 AM is a horrible time for me. And so it is also a matter of being aware of how can these practices of the board be as inclusive as possible.

Tony MartignettiYeah. Okay.

Renee Rubin RossSo then going on to equity, and the reason that— so, and I define equity as being committed to shifting systems and sharing power, as we talked about before. And the reason that I mention equity is that sometimes— and I do some work as part of a cross-race team where I'm leading, along with my colleague Crystal Cherry, we lead conversations for mostly historically white boards around racial equity. Sometimes there is the one person who may be Black or Latinx X who may have something really, really important to say. And that person, even if it's one person, that person needs to be heard. And so there's some stepping back that needs to happen on behalf of, you know, by white people sometimes, and some real perspective-taking to focus more on equity.

Tony MartignettiSharing.

Renee Rubin RossYeah.

Tony MartignettiSharing power, sharing voice.

Renee Rubin RossWe're all on a learning journey, but it's like, start the journey. The train is going. How can— and again, if you— when we lead these conversations, we talk a lot about how does this align with the mission of the organization? So we had an arts organization that had their location in a primarily white neighborhood. All right, how do you— what are you going to do in terms of outreach given that— Right. 45% of your city are people of color. You are not serving the mission to serve the whole community right now.

Tony MartignettiAnd you're probably perceived in the community as a white elitist organization anyway. Yes. So you're not attracting new supporters of any type, volunteers, donors, board members, whatever.

Renee Rubin RossSo this is really about how does this work of shifting systems, of listening to more perspectives, Deepen and strengthen the work of the organization.

Tony MartignettiAnything else on the culture before we talk about dealing with your toxic personages?

Renee Rubin RossHmm. I think that what I would say is, when I do this work, I encourage, and I'm sure you do the same kind of thing, the first step is really assessment. How are you doing right now? And so, as people are listening, I would say, you know, put the podcast on pause for a second. Take a minute. Not too long. Okay.

Tony MartignettiOr if you do, make sure you come back. It's like, let's not get carried away with board equity.

Renee Rubin RossAll right.

Tony MartignettiI mean, board equity has its limits. No, no, I'm kidding.

Renee Rubin RossAll right. But do some reflection. And these are questions for, you know, not just for one person, for the whole board. I will say that we did one conversation with a potential client, and it was this man, this white man, and we said to him, well, are you building belonging on your board? And he said, oh, of course I am. So, and we said, well, how do you know? And he's like, well, I've asked my 3 best friends, and they all feel a sense of belonging. You know, it's like, okay, you gotta go beyond who you hear. Yeah. hear from. And maybe that means you survey your whole board or have a consultant come in and do interviews. Whatever the way that you're gathering data, you need to be more comprehensive in your learning and perspective-taking.

Tony MartignettiCan we go to toxic folks? How to deal with— I mean, you had a good sample of a good story about your friend too. Is she still your

Renee Rubin RossShe is

Tony Martignettistill my friend.

Renee Rubin RossOr did the board experience spill over? No, she's still my friend because I spoke in a caring way. I wasn't angry with her. I could see— I do— this is how I approach any kind of service or work, you know, and the same thing that I would suggest for clients, positive or negative. In her case, She was having more of a negative experience. So it wasn't the right fit for her. Other times, sometimes the situation comes up where somebody's on the board, they had a really strong relationship with the previous executive director, with the previous staff. Yeah. And then those people have left, the organization's going in a new direction, and this person's really frustrated. That is a pretty common scenario, right? And so What do you do? It's up to the new leadership to say, yes, we affirm the direction that we're taking. We're sorry that you are not with us, but we are going forward. That's okay. Again, sometimes leaders, some of the leaders that I meet, need just more courage to take this kind of action.

Tony MartignettiOkay.

Renee Rubin RossYeah.

Tony MartignettiOther advice? What about approaching someone who's toxic on a board?

Renee Rubin RossI think that's—

Tony MartignettiI mean, I think it's just— Straightforward, factual conversation. What about in the moment, in the heat of a meeting, someone is dominating the conversation or just belittling someone else's idea?

Renee Rubin RossThat's a better example.

Tony MartignettiWe're belittling someone else's ideas. We're in the board meeting right now.

Renee Rubin RossThank you for that. What are we going to do? Some of the practices that I do. One of the things that I do when I lead a meeting, I always use meeting agreements. Meeting agreements are how— it takes a minute or 2— how do we want to be together? I have a list of meeting agreements around listening to one another, curiosity, respect.

Tony MartignettiBefore you join the board or before each meeting?

Renee Rubin RossAt the beginning of each meeting, literally for a minute. And then it's a matter of depending on how the meeting is facilitated.

Tony MartignettiSo that helps frame things?

Renee Rubin RossYeah, how do we want to be together? Is there anything you need to add? But I do think that this is where some of this goes back to the framework that I mentioned before, because if there is— you want to Start with a good agenda. And it is possible to say, all right, well, we've been talking about this for 30 minutes. We said we would talk about it for 15. We're going to cut it off here because we have other things that we need to accomplish. And we're going to need to talk about this in committee. So 2 different things. One is if somebody's sort of going off, you can use some of those kinds of moves. But then the next part of it is, if someone is belittling somebody, I think that goes back to how do we want to be together?

Tony MartignettiRemind them of what we all agreed half an hour ago.

Renee Rubin RossRight. And have— maybe it's the board president, maybe it's the executive director, again going back to that person's strengths.

Tony MartignettiIt should be the board chair. Well, in the heat of the minute, in the heat of the meeting, it should be the board chair. It's their job to run the— It's their job to run the meeting.

Renee Rubin RossYeah, but it may be that that person, you want to talk to that person offline, find out what's going on.

Tony MartignettiRight, but I'm putting you right in the battle right now. We've got to defuse the situation right now because someone is feeling hurt, someone has been hurt and minimized, and someone else is trotting over them.

Renee Rubin RossI think I would—

Tony MartignettiWell, like, what did we all agree at the beginning of the meeting? This is It's not appropriate.

Renee Rubin RossRight. And I would go— and what I would do would be to go back to them, like I went back to my colleague and just said, you seem really angry in these meetings. We're all trying. We're all working to get more meals to seniors. What's going on? You know, this is really a little bit beyond. Hear what they have to say and then see what the next step for them is. But really, again, Courage, directness, and I want to say protecting everybody in the meeting by keeping a safe and caring environment.

Tony MartignettiIt's also going to depend on how the person reacts, I think, in that moment with apology. You know, I'm sorry, I got carried away versus, okay, fine.

Renee Rubin RossYeah, that's true. You're right. You're right. But some of this—

Tony MartignettiThere's all possible responses in between those, but, you know, apology, a public apology in the moment goes a long way.

Renee Rubin RossRight. I had another person who reached out to me and said, you know, we have one person who's hijacking our meetings, and he just won't stop. And so then that was where I went back to my framework and said, all right, do you have term limits? Do you have a structured agenda? Do you know what the purpose of of these meetings is. Use your checklists to have that structure. Have you talked with other board members to get clarity on what you want and how you want to be together? And once you can get that— oh, and adding the equity piece, can you confirm that this person doesn't have a perspective that— or are you sure that this person doesn't have a perspective that needs to be listened to? Because I don't want to take that off the table. Yeah. It may be that they do. Mm-hmm. In this case, the person did not, and when I talked to this client, it gave her the permission to say, all right, we understand that you want to do blah, blah, blah, but the 9 of us don't. And so we're going forward over here, and it seems like maybe this board isn't right for you anymore. That's okay, and that actually kept— it's that 20% of the people, or 5% of the people, of the people taking up, you know, so much of your time. And then the board got back on track through that. Okay.

Tony MartignettiYeah. What else? What else? We've only spent like 20 minutes together. What else are you going to share with folks tomorrow that we haven't talked about yet?

Renee Rubin RossYeah, I think that— so I've just— this is my first NTC. I'm very interested to see how it is. I would say that

Tony MartignettiCongratulations on being selected as a speaker. The community voted and chose you in your first NTC.

Renee Rubin RossIt's exciting. What I'm trying to do now is create a lot of spaciousness in the meetings that I lead, in these presentations. And by spaciousness, I mean spaciousness, interactivity. You're really giving— because people More than ever, want to talk, want to have the opportunity to talk. So how I'm how I lead these conversations, how I recommend board members should lead these conversations is really to say we want to hear from you. We want time for us to talk it through, and sometimes there may not be enough time in in the meetings themselves. That may mean that you need to go off and you know have committee meetings so that you can be more expansive and explore. Exploring a certain topic, but really understanding that with everything going on in the world, people are holding a lot, and there is a need for more processing of all of this. And that needs to go into the design. And to just come into a— you don't want to come into a room and say, let's— we're just getting down to work. It's really the opposite of that. It's really what's here in the room right now. I have— there's a book called Permission to Feel by Mark Brackett. I don't know if you've ever heard of it, and there's an app too. And it's really about how are you feeling right now? And it's such a simple question, but just to say as a check-in with your board members, how are you feeling right now? And again, it doesn't cost very much, but it's a way to say, hmm, we're all here together. What do you need to leave behind? So you can be here in the room, and that creates a lot better work.

Tony MartignettiYou were promising the folks who attend tomorrow that you'll leave them with a takeaway, a next step, a next step for building a healthier board. How do you help them identify that next step?

Renee Rubin RossMy theory of learning is what you care about, what you embrace, what you notice is what you are going to start working on. So the reason that I am handing them my handout with the Venn diagram of these 3 areas, and sorry I'm being technical.

Tony MartignettiJust repeat the 3 areas again.

Renee Rubin RossFormal practices, informal practices, equity, is because I want each person in the room to reflect on what What is working and what they want to do next, and to commit to something, right? Something that they want to change in their organization. And it might just be, hmm, I'm going to go back to my board and I'm going to share this with them, and we're going to have a group conversation about this, understanding that we are doing really well in terms of informal practices. Right. Because we all get along really well, but we actually, hmm, we don't have term limits, and that's hurting us because we're not getting new people involved with our organization. So I— So

Tony Martignettia lot of it is internalized. What you believe should be a next step, or where you believe you should work first.

Renee Rubin RossI have a longtime background in education. I have a doctorate in education and studied adult education truly believe that we are building our own knowledge and motivation from what we care about. And boards are too. What are you giving your attention to? Got it. So my goal for the session is that people give their attention to these 3 different areas and think, okay, I'm going to share many practices, but which ones What do you need to pay more attention to? Yeah.

Tony MartignettiOkay.

Renee Rubin RossYeah.

Tony MartignettiCan we leave it there? What do you think?

Renee Rubin RossSure, sure. Feel good? Yeah.

Tony MartignettiAll right. You're not feeling like, oh, there's something else we didn't talk about. He didn't ask me.

Renee Rubin RossUm, no, I think we're— I think we're good.

Tony MartignettiIt's an upbeat place to leave it.

Renee Rubin RossIt's really exciting to— I'm, you know, it's really— I'm very curious about who's going to come to this session and the challenges they're bringing. And I always— it's very energizing to see, okay, room full of people, most of them I haven't met before, and what will they, you know, what questions do they have about this, and what's working for them most, and where do they find— where do they feel like they need to do more fine-tuning? What drew you— I'm excited about that.

Tony MartignettiWhat drew you to the Nonprofit Technology Conference? This is your first one, but you've obviously been working with nonprofits You've been in nonprofits a long time. What brought you to an NTC?

Renee Rubin RossI was interested in, you know, meeting all kinds of people and connecting and, you know, learning about some of the ideas that are out there and how this conference works.

Tony MartignettiAlright, you just had never heard of it before?

Renee Rubin RossI have heard of it before. Oh, you have? Yeah, yeah. And I mean, what I've noticed in my work is I have a lot of referral partners who are fundraising consultants who are sending me work and I'm sending them work, and I'm guessing that I'll connect with some new people who could be potential referral partners. Okay. So yeah. Welcome. Yeah, no, it's funny because I did have a friend who said, wait, you're a facilitator. Why are you going to the technology conference? But I was like, well, there's a leadership track, and so—

Tony MartignettiIt's not only for technical techies, IT directors. We all know that.

Renee Rubin RossRight.

Tony MartignettiYeah.

Renee Rubin RossAll right. Great. Thank you.

Tony MartignettiRenee Rubin Ross, my pleasure. Thanks for sharing. Renee Rubin Ross, founder and CEO at the Ross Collective. Thank you for being with Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio coverage of 23andMe, where we are sponsored by Heller Consulting, technology strategy and implementation for nonprofits.

Renee Rubin RossThanks so much.

Tony MartignettiMy pleasure, Renee.

Renee Rubin RossThank you.

Tony MartignettiAll right. You're welcome. Thank you. Next week, technology governance for accidental techies. Accidental techies. Technology governance for accidental techies. If you missed any part of this week's show, I beseech you, find it at tonymartignetti.com. I'm not sure you'd want to do that though, actually, this week. We're sponsored by DonorBox. With intuitive fundraising software from DonorBox, your donors give 4 times faster. Helping you help others. donorbox.org. I'm sure my voice will sound better next week. Our creative producer is Claire Meyerhoff. The show's social media is by Susan Chavez. Marc Silverman is our web guy, and this Music is by Scott Stein. Yeah! Thank you for that affirmation, Scotty. Be with me next week for Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. Go out and be great.

Nonprofit Radio

More Episodes from 2023 Nonprofit Technology Conference

View All
Misty McLaughlinAlice Hendricks
EP 649July 16, 2023

Communications & Development Teams Working Better Together

with Misty McLaughlin and Alice Hendricks

Rosalind ZavrasJulia ToepferJoe FryePeter Yagecic
EP 648July 9, 2023

10 Easy Ways To Boost Your Fundraising On A Budget & Personalized Fundraising At Scale

with Rosalind Zavras, Julia Toepfer, Joe Frye, and Peter Yagecic

Claire Taylor HansenJennifer Daw HollowayJohn CooganJ. Michael Fisher
EP 647July 2, 2023

Brand Democracy & What To Avoid When Selecting Your Next CRM

with Claire Taylor Hansen, Jennifer Daw Holloway, John Coogan, and J. Michael Fisher

1 / 4