Brand Democracy & What To Avoid When Selecting Your Next CRM





Brand Democracy
What To Avoid When Selecting Your Next CRM
John Coogan of CharityEngine and J. Michael Fisher at the Army Historical Foundation, pose the key questions to answer internally before you go shopping, reveal must-have functionality, and share insider secrets, all to help you avoid the common pitfalls of CRM system purchases. This is also part of our 23NTC coverage.
Here’s the transcript
Tony MartignettiHello and welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. I'm your aptly named host of your favorite hebdomadal podcast. Oh, I'm glad you're with me. I'd be forced to endure the pain of acute flaccid myelitis if you made me nervous because you missed this week's show.
Kate MartignettiBrand Democracy. Continuing our coverage of the 2023 Nonprofit Technology Conference, a conversation about letting go and democratizing your brand so it's collectively owned. The whys, whats, and hows are explained by Claire Taylor Hansen of Big Duck, And Jennifer Daw Holloway with Ipas. And what to avoid when selecting your next CRM. John Coogan of Charity Engine and J. Michael Fisher at the Army Historical Foundation pose the key questions to answer internally before you go shopping, reveal must-have functionality, and share insider secrets, all to help you avoid the common pitfalls of CRM system purchases. This is also part of our '23 NTC coverage on Tony's Take Two.
Tony MartignettiI'm available.
Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by DonorBox. With intuitive fundraising software from DonorBox, your donors give 4 times faster, helping you help others. DonorBox.org. Here is Brand democracy.
Tony MartignettiWelcome back to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio coverage of 23NTC. You know what that is. You know it's the 2023 Nonprofit Technology Conference and that we are at the Colorado Convention Center in Denver. And you also know that we are sponsored here at 23NTC by Heller Consulting, technology strategy and implementation for nonprofits. What you don't know now, but you are about to, is that my guests right now are Claire Taylor Hansen, who is creative director at Big Duck, and Jennifer Daw Holloway, director of communications at Ipas. Claire and Jen, welcome to Nonprofit Radio.
Jennifer Daw HollowayThank you. Thank you.
Tony MartignettiPleasure to have you both. Your session is coming up, so this is a good preparation, on brand democracy. So I'm going to say, Claire, as the agency representative of the agency-client relationship, representing Big Duck Agency, what is brand democracy?
Claire Taylor HansenSure. Well, first, at Big Duck, we think of brand as the impressions that you're forming in your audiences, the impressions that your nonprofit creates out in the world. And so when we think about brand democracy, we're shifting our orientation to the history of branding, which is about single ownership. It's about signaling value. It's about tightly controlling the impressions that you're making. It's about regulating who's communicating on behalf of the brand. And you're switching your thinking to instead being about collective ownership of the brand. And so you're equipping your community of supporters to communicate on behalf of the brand and to really be the brand and inhabit the brand. So it's really about sharing power and sharing the power of brand in a way that's aligned more with many nonprofits these days that are thinking more about how can we share and distribute power. Right. And how we can communicate and build a brand that's more representative of who we are as a nonprofit and a mission-led organization.
Tony MartignettiAlright, and Jen, as the nonprofit representative, this all sounds very scary, like it's anarchy, that we're going to lose control, the brand is going to be diluted, that people aren't going to use the right colors. There's Farra Trompeter! Farra Trompeter offstage. Hello, how are you, Farra? Good to see you.
Farra TrompeterMy paparazzi.
Tony MartignettiI love the purple highlight too. Farra from Big Duck in Brooklyn, right? The agency's in Brooklyn, isn't it?
Farra TrompeterWe're now distributed across the country and beyond.
Tony MartignettiDo you have an office in Brooklyn?
Farra TrompeterNo, we don't. We're now fully distributed.
Tony MartignettiYeah. Fully distributed? Yeah. All right. Used to be Brooklyn-based. Okay. Yep. So, Jen, now I'm concerned the colors aren't going to be right. People are going to write Ipas with I period, P period, A period, S period. They're going to dilute the name, the brand. Everything is going to be anarchy. And everything that we have invested in our brand is going to be lost. Why is that not true if we democratize our brand?
Jennifer Daw HollowayRight, right, right. No, it is totally not true. And like Claire said, we're an INGO, so we're fairly large. We work in about 18 countries. We have offices in 18 countries. We work in about 30 countries around the world. So brand democracy for us is really important because our core values are justice, equity, right? So—
Tony MartignettiYou may as well explain what the work is before we go further.
Jennifer Daw HollowayWell, the work—
Tony MartignettiIpas.
Jennifer Daw HollowayGood. We are an organization that is working to expand abortion and contraception access around the world. We are working toward global reproductive justice.
Tony MartignettiYour work is cut out for you in the United States.
Jennifer Daw HollowayOh, it is.
Tony MartignettiFor about the past 12 months or so.
Jennifer Daw HollowayIt's true. Right now, today, news happening. Yes. So brand democracy for us is really important because we are actually— our structure is changing. So we're not— we will no longer be kind of a hub-and-spoke organization with power centered in the United States. We are shifting it, pushing it out, decision-making authority shared leadership to the places that are closest to our work and closest to the people we aim to serve. So brand democracy allows more engagement. It's about representing the brand in a way that is best for the communities that you're serving and that you are part of. So, and it's about trusting our teams to know what is best. All right.
Tony MartignettiCan you go further and allay the fears of your fellow directors of communications, maybe CEOs, that everything we've invested in the brand is now going to be torn asunder?
Jennifer Daw HollowayOh, no, no, no.
Tony MartignettiHow can we trust our community to do the brand the justice that we want them to?
Jennifer Daw HollowayWell, I think because in brand democracy, when you're thinking about the brand, you're thinking about the people who are going to be using it. you're refreshing it, or you're doing a kind of brand checkup, what you're doing is engaging your community in defining and refining the brand so that you're kind of living it. You understand the brand. The brand represents your core values, represents your mission and vision. So those are common threads throughout our country offices around the world. The mission and the vision are the same. The way that— the colors that you might use, they may vary a little bit. It's okay. It's okay.
Tony MartignettiOkay, it might be a couple of hexadecimals off.
Jennifer Daw HollowayI mean, the logo is set, but you can use it in different ways. You can use it with a tagline. You can use it without a tagline. But it's still the logo.
Claire Taylor HansenCan I build on that?
Jennifer Daw HollowayYeah.
Claire Taylor HansenWell, I think we were talking about last night, Jen, at our happy hour moment, About really questioning, like, what's at risk, like, you know, and exploring also, frankly, we're exploring, like, what this could look like and what the limits are. So a brand is important so that you have brand recognition and so that you're signaling, you're building on the reputation of the entity. But if your primary motivation as an organization is really to get folks invested and feel it like it's rooted authentically in the organization, Well, maybe there's a greater risk in having folks feel that there's sort of a top-down or Western imposition of what a brand or quality looks like. Yeah. Maybe that's a bigger risk for you organizationally than having a color, a slight color shift. And so also it's about having lots of education. So Ipas does all this amazing work having webinars, having downloadable tools. So things that are truly important for brand recognition like your logo and like your vision and your mission. Ideally, you are building in tons of education around those parts of the brand, but then also leaving room for if you're in a South America where a color has a very different meaning than it does in America, well then, if that color really resonates, allowing folks to enfold that color within the brand and use that brand and have a little bit more— not a little bit more, a lot more regional autonomy with what Ipas looks and sounds and feels like in the culture.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Okay. What do we— you know, something just occurred to me. I have to get something off my mind. I'll talk to my wife, production assistant, for a sec. Susan, because we are live tweeting that you're with us, but Susan needs the names of these 2 guests in the spreadsheet. Does she know them? Yes. Because they got added last minute. Okay, thank you. Okay, now you have my complete attention. If you give me 30 seconds.
Claire Taylor HansenWe thought you were going to ask her for a stumper.
Jennifer Daw HollowayYeah, I was like, is she going to ask us a trick question?
Claire Taylor HansenI was like, oh, I'm ready.
Tony MartignettiWhat is this? We're starting to talk about what this looks like, but I have a very neophyte question because I've been studying this for about 11 minutes. And you've been working on this for months, and your presentation is coming up. Years. Years, and your presentation is coming up. What are we allowing folks to do? What are we allowing the community to do? What does this democracy look like? Jen?
Jennifer Daw HollowayWell, it looks like a little— a lot of what Claire said, in that you are able to represent Ipas in the way that is best So what does that
Tony Martignettimean? Suppose I want to tweet about— how do I, as a newly empowered brand owner, co-owner of the Ipas brand, treat the brand or tweet differently now than I did for the other nonprofit where it's a top-down model, but I wanted to shout out that nonprofit too? Right. Because I still love that one, even though I'm not a co-owner in their brand. How does my tweet look different for Ipas than it does for the more traditional brand, traditionally branded nonprofit? I think that was a pretty eloquent question. That was great. I must say, I was pleased with myself for that one.
Jennifer Daw HollowayI don't know if my answer will be half as eloquent, but I'm going to try. But I think 2 things. At Ipas, we have various Twitter handles, right? So if you're Ipas Nepal, you may have your own Twitter handle. You may have all your own social media handles. You may have a website that's Ipas Nepal. You have Ipas in the U.S. doing tweeting. So I think the thing is that you're again bound by your values. So are you talking about reproductive freedom and reproductive justice? Are you thinking expansively and inclusively inclusively about who is impacted by abortion, right? Are you— is that coming through in what you're saying, whatever channel? You might be tweeting in French. You might be tweeting in Spanish from Ipas. But I think it's the personality and the mission and the core values that are coming through in whatever medium you're speaking. Okay.
Tony MartignettiYou're centered around the values.
Jennifer Daw HollowayExactly. All right. Exactly.
Claire Taylor HansenCan I build on that?
Tony MartignettiYeah, Claire, go ahead. I have a question for you, but yeah, go ahead, please.
Claire Taylor HansenI think also we worked really hard with Jen, and by we I mean Big Duck, and by Jen I mean Ipas, to— we also just developed this brand, so it's a new brand, and so we worked really hard when we created that fundamental over— you know, that overarching layer of their logo and the main color to make them have community input from all of the different countries to make sure that folks could get on board with those aspects and those elements. Right. So I think a big shift now is in your analogy of the nonprofit that was before and the nonprofit that was after. Before, it felt— it could have felt like, okay, we've got this logo that's a kind of one-size-fits-all and it has to work for literally every country across the world. where every country across the world didn't help pick the logo or define the logo. Mm-hmm. Now you've got a logo where everyone literally did help figure it out, so it feels a sense of ownership. And there's flexibility built in and encouragement built in to say like, okay, so this is the base layer, this is the fundamental thread that is consistent through all, and now adapt as it makes sense for you. So it's sort of working with a set of tools that were designed for this purpose, and with the flexibility and the spectrum of flexibility kind of built in and communicated and Reinforced for folks.
Kate MartignettiIt's time for a break. DonorBox. It's the fundraising engine of choice for 50,000 organizations from 96 countries. It's powerful enough to double donations and simple enough to be used by everyone. Black Girls Code increased donations by 400%. Upward Scholars increased donations by 270%. Maya's Hope saw a 100% increase in donors. The DonorBox donation form is 4 times faster checkout, no setup fees, no monthly fees, no contract, and 50,000 orgs all over the world. DonorBox, helping you help others. donorbox.org. Now back to Brand democracy.
Tony MartignettiTalk about brand anarchy.
Jennifer Daw HollowayWell, I know we have a lot to say, but brand democracy and like Claire was saying, this flexibility. So our teams in different countries know their audiences better than— Sure. I mean, that's about not being this kind of hub in the United States. I can't tweet something that is meant for, let's say, people in a health system in Kenya, for example, or for advocates working on law change in Mexico. So that allows you to, again, have the flexibility to know your audience, know your community, community, you know, talk directly to them, which is kind of Comms 101, right? Know your audience.
Tony MartignettiYeah, yeah. And, and give them the freedom to speak to their audience who they know better than, than you. Exactly. You do. All right, go ahead.
Claire Taylor HansenBut I would gently, I gently push back on the anarchy thing because I don't think it— the tent is not anarchy.
Tony MartignettiOh, it's anarchy here. No, on this podcast. It's democracy. This podcast is anarchy.
Claire Taylor HansenBut that's good. I'm okay with that.
Tony MartignettiOh, that's the podcast.
Claire Taylor HansenI just don't—
Tony MartignettiI don't— Anarchy. Yes.
Claire Taylor HansenI'm okay with that.
Tony MartignettiI'm going to make sure. So we're talking about an international NGO, Ipas. What if we're a local state, I mean, you know, small town, whatever agency? Is there value in democratizing our brand? Is there?
Claire Taylor HansenWell, I think if your organization is is really interested in sharing power and kind of authentically rooting your brand in your community, then for sure, yes. And then Ipas was an amazing opportunity for us because it was the most obvious and clear, you know, of course when you're dealing with international autonomous, you know, culturally sensitive work, this is a great solution. But now it's interesting to use some of the thinking that we worked on and developed in this project and to think about how does this look for a regional nonprofit that's got a small staff? Like, what does this look like? And I think some of the ideas about, okay, well, let's deeply listen to stakeholders that maybe we didn't historically listen to when we developed the brand. How do we pressure test the brand during brand development and see what folks are thinking about it? How do we train the community and the staff? How do we— Yeah. Maybe open up some parts, like maybe there's a toolkit that we can offer for folks. So I think there's aspects of it and elements of it that for mission-aligned, for organizations where it makes sense for them and that are interested in these ideas, would definitely— we're incorporating into our projects right now that are very different than Ipas.
Tony MartignettiInteresting. It sounds like an example that folks may be more familiar with would be like Giving Tuesday, right? I mean, don't they have tools? They do have tools and resources and, you know, take the logo, use the brand. Totally. Completely decentralized. Yeah, that's a great analogy. Just trying to think of another analogy.
Claire Taylor HansenWe're going to bring that into our talk.
Tony MartignettiFolks might be more— oh, there you go. Be more familiar with than Ipas. Mm-hmm. Okay.
Claire Taylor HansenAnd you're right, probably in the world of campaigns, like now this is bringing it into brand, which maybe feels a bit riskier, but this is a common strategy for campaign work. Because you're trying to recruit and advocate. And so this is interesting. It's like taking some of the same ideas and approaches that have been used for campaigns and thinking about, does some of that make sense for brand as well?
Tony MartignettiClaire, do you think if someone, some nonprofit wanted to explore this, does it need to be part of a rebranding exercise? Because you said there's a new brand for Ipas, or I mean, can their existing brand be democratized?
Jennifer Daw HollowayI do want to say it is a— it's fresh and dynamic and new and everything, but we're still Ipas. Our mission didn't change. So the way that we're working is changing. So we called it kind of a super brand refresh.
Tony MartignettiRight. Right.
Jennifer Daw HollowayYeah. So I'd say that may be a better description.
Tony MartignettiA brand refresh than a rebrand, but still, I mean, does it—
Jennifer Daw HollowayI mean, it was verging on rebrand. But we're still Ipas, so it was a big deal. I don't mean to minimize that.
Claire Taylor HansenNo, but it's true. I think this is really like a shift in thinking, and then actually when you look at the actual brand assets and tools, it's not that, you know, it's not a shocking change. It's just thinking about how you share and distribute and, you know, communicate the brand in different ways.
Tony MartignettiLet's talk a little about brand ambassadors.
Jennifer Daw HollowayYeah.
Tony MartignettiHow do you identify these folks? Maybe it's easier, I mean, maybe easier for Ipas than for the typical US nonprofit that is not international. Right. But go ahead, explain, Jen, brand ambassadors.
Jennifer Daw HollowayWell, we kind of view anyone who really sort of has an external-facing role, right? If you may be talking to the media, that may be, that's different. You might be talking to donors, you might be talking to partners, you're still an ambassador for Ipas, for the brand, right? And we have some ways that we're in, on my communications team at the network level, that we're really trying to build the platform and create the support. Claire mentioned toolkits, that sort of thing. So what we view our role is, is to help our brand ambassadors be as effective as they can be. So it's, You're speaking to community members. It's your, you know, you're speaking, you're giving a speech at a conference, or you're doing a presentation representing Ipas and our work. That's ambassadorship.
Tony MartignettiHow do you pick these people?
Jennifer Daw HollowayI don't know that we necessarily always pick them.
Tony MartignettiThey surface.
Jennifer Daw HollowayI think they surface, and I think that anyone in an organization who, again, is talking with people outside with their community members should be able to represent the brand. And if they have the right tools and they're, you know, they understand the mission, which everyone at Ipas is clearly committed to our mission, they can be good brand ambassadors.
Tony MartignettiThat wasn't a good question. How do you pick them? Because that suggests a top-down model. You're appointed.
Jennifer Daw HollowayRight,
Tony Martignettiexactly. So I just made the sign of the cross and giving up my religious background that no longer applies.
Jennifer Daw HollowaySome people are more popular. Anointed. Right. They're more popular.
Tony MartignettiThe Pope's canonized. No. It's not a process of canonization. No. That's what I was looking for. Okay. No, right. They emerge. They want to have lunch and talk to some of their friends about Ipas. Yeah. Or they want to do an online campaign. Give up their birthday, you know, whatever. Exactly.
Jennifer Daw HollowayA donor who feels strongly about why they support Ipas, they're an ambassador.
Tony MartignettiThey're empowered, they're supported, they— okay, they just emerge. Yeah, right. They're not canonized.
Claire Taylor HansenAnd I think the idea of a brand ambassador, that's not a new concept, you know, in the nonprofit world. Like, we've been incorporating that role in our trainings for a long time. But really, it's— I think it's acknowledging and creating tools and resources and approaching this community of folks in a deeper way. So you're saying, you're acknowledging that, especially in the nonprofit world where maybe you don't have infinite dollars to, you know, work on your marketing. You know, instead you're saying, you're capitalizing on the power of your community and you're saying, okay, we have all these folks that care about us and are communicating on behalf of us. And so rather than try and like control the message or, you know, only have designated spokespeople, let's kind of release a little bit more and kind of embrace that and capitalize— well, capitalize is the wrong word, but, you know, really lean into the power of our community.
Tony MartignettiOkay. I like the word exploit. It's not a pejorative. Exploit the— yeah, you're taking advantage. Yes, you're exploiting. I mean, we exploit resources, but not to the detriment of the resources, I don't think.
Claire Taylor HansenMaybe leverage.
Tony MartignettiWe'll say leverage. I'm tired of leveraging.
Jennifer Daw HollowayAmplify.
Tony MartignettiAmplify. I like amplify. Amplify, okay. I grew up just using things. Now I have to leverage them. It sounds like more work.
Jennifer Daw HollowayIt does.
Tony MartignettiMany more syllables. Like I learned in 5th grade, like simple machines. There's a fulcrum and a power. It sounds like too much energy expansion. I see, and I'm trying to apply this more generally. I see how it fits perfectly with an international NGO. You're 18 different countries, right? Right. Okay. But for the more typical listener, I mean, you could be approaching this, but maybe not a full-on democratization, but empowering your ambassadors, letting ambassadors emerge, let people use your brand for an event or something they want to do, you know, a peer-to-peer campaign or something. Right. Right? I mean, so like, you know, but you have a toolkit for them. There's some Google Docs or something, shared resources where you can grab our logo here, grab some of our key talking points there.
Jennifer Daw HollowayTotally.
Tony MartignettiRight? Right?
Jennifer Daw HollowayYep. Yes.
Claire Taylor HansenAnd then also there's— so that's the brand assets, but there's also kind of brand feedback. We like to think of brands as like living and evolving things. So, you know, if you reach out to your community for feedback on your brand and to kind of include them on how is it performing in the world, are there ways we could shift or adapt? So then you're really, through how you walk and talk and every— through signaling to folks that, hey, this is yours too. Like, this is our community's brand. How
Tony Martignettido you get that feedback, Claire?
Claire Taylor HansenGoogle surveys. You could have listening sessions. You can offer free gift certificates to have folks show up and kind of share their feedback on some questions and hear how folks are responding to statements like your mission statement, your vision statement, show them some recent materials, you know. And also just full acknowledgment, we are as an agency really like thinking about this, wrestling with this, kind of playing around with different ideas. Like this is kind of a new framework and way of thinking about branding for us too. Like as recently as, you 5 or 10 years ago, my goal in life was to make the brand as consistent and shut down anything that could potentially erode the brand as possible.
Tony MartignettiEverything I asked Jen to respond to earlier.
Claire Taylor HansenYeah. And now I'm questioning that. I'm questioning— I'm not— in some ways, I'm just wrestling with like, well, what if your primary motivation is instead to embody the brand in your entire community? How do you get people engaged and passionate about what you're doing? How important is it really if your hex value is consistent across— I mean, and it is. I'm a designer. It's very important that your website appear correctly across certain ways and that you have accessible colors. So it's just thinking about at every touchpoint, you know, questioning the way things have been done. You know, is there a different approach that could be taken that would be more in service to the mission? And thinking about being maybe a little bit less tightly controlled about some things that have historically been very locked down.
Tony MartignettiThat's cool. All right, Jen, I'm going to leave you with the last encouraging words of encouragement, words of empowerment around loosening up, loosening up, maybe not approaching full-on the way Ipas is. is able to and really suited for, as you both agreed, but empowering the rest of the folks around loosening up their brand.
Jennifer Daw HollowayI think it serves many purposes, right? If you're loosening up in the sense that you are actually practicing or leaning into brand democracy, you are empowering your staff, your community, opportunity, like Claire said, to speak, to represent the brand. And you're not— it was this top-down comms or marketing controlled the brand in the past. And in a smaller organization, you don't have a lot of comms and marketing people, right? So you really need more brand ambassadors. You You need people to be sort of living what the brand means, to be able to represent it and to sort of share those core values. And I think, you know, any size organization, your supporters or your community want to feel a part of something. And this is another way to help do that.
Tony MartignettiThat's Jennifer Daw Holloway, Director of Communications at Ipas. And also with me is Claire Taylor Hansen, Creative Director at Big Duck. Jen, Claire, Claire, Jen, thank you very much. Thank you for sharing.
Jennifer Daw HollowayThank you.
Tony MartignettiI'm glad this worked out kind of last minute.
Jennifer Daw HollowayIt was fun. Thank you. Thank you.
Tony MartignettiMy pleasure. And thank you for being with Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio coverage of 23NTC, where we are sponsored by Heller Consulting, technology strategy and implementation
Kate MartignettiIt's time for Tony's Take Two.
Tony MartignettiThank you, Kate. Are you planning a conference or maybe some other training for later this year or in 2024? I'm available if planned giving can fit into whatever it is you've got coming up. I'd love to talk to you about it. Training-wise, then I'd be grateful if you would give me the opportunity to be a part of your program. I'm typically talking about launching planned giving at small and mid-sized nonprofits. That's my target audience. So if that's your audience for whatever you've got coming up, again, I'd be grateful if you'd, uh, give me the opportunity. I'd love to talk to you about it. You could use the contact page at tonymartignetti.com or just email me tony@tonymartignetti.com.
Kate MartignettiThat is Tony's Take Two. We've got beaucoup buttloads more time. Here is what to avoid when selecting your next CRM.
Tony MartignettiWelcome back to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio coverage of 23NTC, the 2023 Nonprofit Technology Conference. We're in Denver, Colorado, and we are sponsored by Heller Consulting, technology strategy and implementation for nonprofits. With me now are John Coogan, who is Vice President of Client Services at Charity Engine, and J. Michael Fisher, who is Vice President of Development at the Army Historical Foundation. John, Mike, welcome to Nonprofit Radio.
John CooganThanks for having us. Thank you.
Tony MartignettiPleasure, pleasure to have you both. Your session topic is 5 Pitfalls to Avoid When Selecting a CRM System. John, let's start with you. Just high level, why is this an important topic?
John CooganWell, for me it's an important topic. Prior to Charity Engine, I was with I've worked with nonprofits for about 15 years, and in each of my 4— 3 of my 4 nonprofits had to migrate from one system to another for various reasons. And in each case, it was very difficult for me because I went in blind, not knowing which questions to ask, and, you know, ran into a lot of implementation delays and, you know, misunderstanding of the product. So we wanted to put We put together a quick session to help people who are shopping around for CRMs ask the right questions, understand the perspectives, understand who to get involved from an executive buy-in within the organization, you know, insist on things like transparency, understand data and the migration process, so they're walking in with the right, I guess, overall perspective, so that the buying process is a lot easier, and the implementation process and going live is even that much easier. Yeah.
Tony MartignettiMike, is this something that the Army Historical Foundation has been through?
J. Michael FisherActually going through it right now.
Tony MartignettiIs this a client-vendor, client-consultant relationship currently? Currently, no.
John CooganHe's been a client of ours with 2 other nonprofits. He's moved on to a new one that's not yet a client.
Tony MartignettiNot yet? We'll get there. And so you're going through a CRM selection now at the foundation?
J. Michael FisherIt was already done before my time. there's been some implementation issues, if you would. I see. And, you know, after I was talking to Charity Engine, you know, I was just telling them some of the things we're going through, and they're like, would you share that? People would like to know because you've done it 2 times before, and you'll probably do it again in your career. And I said, of course, because the only way you can really help others is showing what you've learned. You know, it is free advice, so you get a full refund. And it's, you know, that's one of those things. But it's, Yeah, I'd like to share that information just because you do a lot of digging as a nonprofit executive. You know, there's no book, there's no manual, and you— and I've done a lot of digging, and I have some ideas of what I think is good, and happy to share that.
Tony MartignettiAnd some— sounds like some lessons learned as well. Yes.
John CooganYes. One of the big things is 10 years, 15 years ago when I was shopping for my first CRM, there were not a lot of options out there. And nowadays there's just so much noise. There's so many different levels of CRM, you know, smaller, bigger, all-in-one, very specifically focused CRMs. If you Google nonprofit CRM, you're going to be overwhelmed with the options. And I think that's a big problem, especially for smaller nonprofits that neither have the time nor maybe the sophistication with technology to kind of wade through all the noise and really kind of come up with a product or a list of products. that would make sense for them. So we want to help out with that.
Tony MartignettiJohn, let's stay with you. You alluded to questions.
John CooganYes.
Tony MartignettiQuestion 5, I think between the two of you— oh, well, it's 5 pitfalls to avoid, but you have a bunch of questions to ask. One of the pitfalls is not asking the right questions?
John CooganYeah, not being prepared. Not being prepared for your— and so asking the right questions and understanding your current environment and who's going to be using the system and what they need it for. Having the right people at the table when interviewing a potential partner in a CRM, because you need to represent everybody in the organization. You need to make sure this product is going to effectively give all those people what they need to do their job on a day-to-day basis. So if you're coming in and you're listening to a sales pitch, and every sales pitch is going to be similar— we've got these great features, this great functionality, we do all these great things, and we're going to double or triple your fundraising in a year. But at the end of the day, you want to move past that. You want to— is this product the right product for me in terms of everyday use, my ability to understand it, my ability to leverage it in the right way, my ability to grow with it? And so you move past the sales and you start getting into talking to people like me that run client services and actually install the product and get it going so you can ask those deeper questions and get real answers.
Tony MartignettiSo let's drill down. So what are some questions that should be And what stage are we now? Are we evaluating choices?
John CooganIs that the stage we're at now? I think a lot of the people in the room are probably, hey, we need to get out of what we're in right now because either we need to grow or we don't get what we need out of this or it's too expensive. So they're kind of just searching around. So you're at the pre-RFP stage.
Tony MartignettiPre-RFP. So you're asking these questions internally. You're not asking them of the vendors.
John CooganNo, not yet. And then when you get the questions internally answered, then you can shop around and weed off.
Tony MartignettiOkay. So what are some of these internal questions?
John CooganSo for me, one of the biggest questions that I want people to ask is, how is your customer support? And do you have a customer support team that's going to stay with us as partners?
Tony MartignettiWell, that's a question you're asking the vendors.
John CooganYeah, but internally, the question has to be, what kind of support do I need?
Tony MartignettiOh, what do we have internally? Yeah, so do I need a CIO?
John CooganDo I need support with like reporting? Do I need support with running queries or building different cuts of data so that I can do segmented emails and things like that?
Tony MartignettiSegmented.
John CooganSegmented. That's important. Let's write that one down.
Tony MartignettiYou got to have segmented.
John CooganYes, you got a lot of segmented data. But I think if you don't know what you need, if you don't know what questions you need to answer for yourself internally, then how can you even expect to ask the right questions of a vendor. And I think that's the big thing. So planning, sitting down planning, okay, what do we need? What are the questions we need to ask? What are the questions we need to answer for ourselves so that we can go out and look at products and eliminate those we know are not correct just based on our own needs?
Tony MartignettiWhat else should we be doing introspectively?
John CooganLook at your data. I mean, I think one of the biggest things that trips up nonprofits when they're migrating is not understanding their data. Where they sit right now, whether they've got a single database or multiple databases, are they using spreadsheets, what information is important, are you managing duplicates the right way? Because what happens when you migrate, first order of business is get your data into the new platform in the right way so you can build everything on top of it. And 9 times out of 10, if you're not understanding your data and keeping it clean and doing the things you need to do to prepare yourself to move into a new platform, you're going to end up adding a ton of overhead to the implementation timeline itself, and that's a big deal.
Tony MartignettiMike, in your experience, now I know currently you joined the foundation after this stage, but in your previous 2 times, do you feel like, or what was your experience around the internal questions being asked?
J. Michael FisherI think one of the hardest parts at this stage for a nonprofit of of this, putting the deal together, is you actually have to go back and make the new piece different than the old database. So a lot of times, people will sit around the table and they'll recobble this thing together, and then you look at it and you're like, this is exactly what we already have. And then you have to logically think, well, if we're really just going to build the same thing we already have, then why do we bother?
Tony MartignettiWhy do we go through this exercise?
J. Michael FisherPutting lipstick on a pig and And they just send it down the road. And the reality is technology changes so quickly now that, you know, even if you redid your database 5 or 10 years ago, there's a lot of different pieces you don't have, and a lot of pieces you could just, you know, jettison aside. And so I think that's one of the biggest pieces at this point is don't just remake your same database. That's a big mistake that a lot of people
John Cooganmake. Yeah, again, when you get back to the questions, you know, if you're asking yourself the right questions, then you're understanding why you're even looking to begin with. So we've seen some clients come in that end up expecting the same thing out of our product because they didn't ask certain questions, and they are basically trying to replace what they have for price alone. I think if you're shopping for price, you still need to understand what you're getting into, and you need to be able to think outside the box. What, you know, I have an opportunity now to change my database infrastructure. My CRM, what are the things that I don't like about my current environment? You know, what can I leverage out of a product to make my life easier, to make us more efficient, so that we can raise more money and do more things for our recipients? I don't think a lot of nonprofits will sit back and think about that if they're only shopping for price, you know, and I think that's an important one.
Tony MartignettiOkay, okay. Anything else about the planning stage before we move on to some Must-haves? Anything else?
J. Michael FisherI think we touched on it briefly, but invite all of your interested parties who can give input, who can test early, and they can see previews so they buy in. It calms the waters of this event, because to a lot of people, this is a huge event, and if you include the stakeholders early, it's not as big of a deal.
John CooganWho
Tony Martignettiare some of those stakeholders? that you see sometimes, I don't know, maybe this goes to lessons learned, but stakeholders get forgotten.
J. Michael FisherIt could be major gifts. The database managers, customer service reps, the backend guys, if you would, that are doing the actual data augmentation. And, you know, so it's just a wide variety.
John CooganBut it could also be the board member.
J. Michael FisherYeah.
John CooganThe board member that is looking at the bottom line and getting the report on a quarterly basis, you know, they need to understand the product as well, and they need to understand why, you know, you're moving into that product, or they're not going to support it going forward. So I think at all levels, if you're not having everybody at every level that's going to be leveraging the product or affected by the product, you're basically doing yourself a disservice and ultimately potentially creating downstream problems internally about the product. Yeah. out the system, even if it's perfect.
Tony MartignettiAnd including the board helps for some buy-in.
John CooganAbsolutely.
Tony MartignettiYou get that upper-level management buy-in.
John CooganYeah, so when you need to expand or you want to do certain things with the product that may cost a little bit more, whether it's a new integration that was built into the product or new functionality that they want to leverage, if the board's bought into it, it's an easier process to adopt that new functionality.
Tony MartignettiYou have some must-have functionalities that you think every nonprofit needs.
John CooganFor me, the biggest one is a single database. Like, I have lived through running nonprofits, smaller nonprofits, where we've had distributed data, and there's a lot of issues that go with that, not the least of which is you've got a contact record, or a donor, or a prospect that's living in more than one data source, which can lead to siloed So you may have a major donor. This happened to me where we had a donor that wrote a check for $5,000 for, you know, major gift, end-of-year giving, and a week later got a solicitation in the mail for $25. And he called and said, what's going on? Don't you know me? You know, why am I hearing from these people as well? I just gave you $5,000. And so it creates problems. So a single source of data for me is critical. Right. Everything needs to be built from that.
Tony MartignettiI guess that's not standard? I mean, that just seems like such a no-brainer that—
John CooganWell, what happens is this. You've got CRMs nowadays that may not have had certain components of technology, like, let's say, advocacy or events. And so, instead of building it, they've acquired another organization or integrated. And so, what they've done is they created siloed databases. I can't speak to any one particular organization, but what ends up happening is you've got duplicate records, you've got data that's inconsistent across the organization. It just becomes a frustrating thing, especially for— I was an executive director for a couple nonprofits. It's just frustrating because your reporting is not accurate, especially to the board. You know, you're not able to accurately represent the revenue or the donors' activity. In some cases, you're not acknowledging correctly at the end of the year.
Tony MartignettiYou don't even know what is accurate. Absolutely. You yourself don't even know because you've got inconsistent data across more than one database, I see.
John CooganAnd what's funny is now in my role on the for-profit side as Charity Engine overseeing professional services, we're seeing that come in because we have to bring all that data in and map it into our environment. And as we're doing that, these nonprofits are discovering, oh my gosh, I didn't realize this one donor who was our monthly donor giving $15 a month also attended these events because there was a bucketed database somewhere that they weren't looking at. Something as simple as that can be— it could really hurt an organization's ability to raise money and build relationships.
Tony MartignettiMike, do you have a must-have?
J. Michael FisherWell, I agree with that. The data points—
Tony MartignettiThe single data point.
J. Michael FisherYeah, they're missed. So you could be Anthony in my one list, you could be Tony in the other, 2 different Emails, and we could be talking to you 2 different ways, and you're going a little mad, like, what are these people doing? They talked to me this way one day, and then they talked to me this way another. And that's where I think there's a lot of mistakes that are being made when there's too many systems. And when you can consolidate them, they'll eventually— they won't catch everything 100%, but it'll be 99% much better.
Tony MartignettiAre there must-haves, must-have functionality?
John CooganI mean, you need the standard stuff. I mean, I think, you know, the CRM needs to be integrated with email marketing. You need good solid reporting, the ability to build advanced reports and customized reports. You know, I believe a great must-have is open APIs into the nonprofit—
Tony MartignettiNow explain that. We have jargon jail on Nonprofit Radio.
John CooganYeah, yeah, yeah.
Tony MartignettiWe're not coders here, so—
John CooganWell, so it's as simple as this.
Tony MartignettiOpen API.
John CooganSo for me, to explain it in layman's terms, Charity Engine offers, you know, let's say a dozen different inherent functionality within our system. If somebody comes and says, hey, I'm using this other thing that does this thing that you guys will never do because it's something separate from your core roadmap, but we want to integrate and we want to store the information in your database so that we have that single source still. Right. We have 2-way integration, so they can bring data in through that other application, no different than a user entering it through our user interface, and they can pull data back out. So in that way, no matter what happens outside of our environment, we still have the most updated data.
Tony MartignettiSo open meaning not only the providers that Charity Engine has contracted with.
John CooganRight, right.
Tony MartignettiOther open source. Exactly. Not open source, but open APIs.
John CooganYeah, so Charity Engine, you know, we've got APIs that we built that are very specific, like Wealth Engine and QuickBooks, and Double the Donation is a partner of ours that's here this week.
Tony MartignettiDouble the Donation, Adam Wenger.
John CooganHe's been on the show. It is a great organization. The integration is easy, and we tapped into their APIs and built it so that, you know, when a donor gives to one of our nonprofits, they get a prompt essentially to double the donation, which is great.
Tony MartignettiDouble the Donation is He's referring to corporate matching, whether your company has a matching gift. That's what Double the Donation is all about.
John CooganYeah, and so we've got integrations that we build into the product based on other APIs, and I'm here shopping for partners that we want to build more integration with. But then for those that are—
Tony MartignettiYou need a podcast production partner?
John CooganYeah, let's do it. Can you build some API calls into our system?
Tony MartignettiI don't even know what they are. But I'd be happy to produce podcasts.
John CooganYeah, yeah, we can do that.
Tony MartignettiSo, open API. So, we can bring in, me as the user organization, can bring in other vendors.
John CooganOur primary goal, we want to preserve the single database source, and we want to give everybody the opportunity to bring data into our environment.
Tony MartignettiOkay, understood. Anything else? Must-have functionality? Okay, just want to make sure we covered it all. I don't want to hold out on Nonprofit Radio listeners.
John CooganNo, no, no, we're good.
Tony MartignettiHave you done this I have
John Coogannot. No, we did the session already.
Tony MartignettiOh, you did? Yeah.
J. Michael FisherOkay. Had some good follow-up.
Tony MartignettiOkay.
John CooganI thought you meant this session. I was like, no, we're in the middle of it right now.
Tony MartignettiYou really don't hold Tony Martignetti in very high esteem. The guy doesn't even know where he is from moment to moment. Okay. I'm taking this from your takeaways. Sure. Or learning objectives, whatever. Industry insider secrets to help you shop smarter.
John CooganThat's a good one.
Tony MartignettiOkay, good. What does that mean?
John CooganMove past the sales team. Like, hear the pitch, insist on talking to the head of customer service, insist on talking to somebody in the professional services team. Ask deeper questions, because the sales team will be well-equipped to talk about features, functionality, pricing, that sort of thing. But when they're asked deeper questions, oftentimes they don't know the answer, and they're going to go internally.
Tony MartignettiQuestions like what?
John CooganLike, you know, some of the things like, tell me more about the integration API and how it works. You know, is there a library that you can provide to us? Or, you know, do you have a query tool that allows for, you know, subqueries and querying across the database? You know, there's things that the sales team, there's things underneath each of the features that someone's going to dig deeper into. There's going to be a tech guy or somebody that wants to ask a better question.
Tony MartignettiOkay.
John CooganAnd so I, as the head of client services, often get on the sales calls, and I make myself available deliberately for these prospects because I need to know what they're asking too, and I want to understand. At the end of the day, it's a relationship in both directions. You know, we don't want a client that doesn't fit with us because they'll get frustrated and they'll go away at some point, and they definitely don't want a CRM that doesn't fit with them because, you know, the money's limited and it's And these processes are difficult to migrate. So, you know, we open ourselves up to— if you want to talk to our head of customer support desk to know more about how we support our SLAs, yeah, you're welcome.
Tony MartignettiSLAs, jargon jail. I don't know what the hell an SLA is.
John CooganService level agreements. So if you open up a critical ticket, how quickly do we respond to you and how quickly do we resolve it?
Tony MartignettiOkay.
John CooganThere's SLAs based on levels of criticality and impact to the business and that sort of thing. I, as a person shopping for a CRM, want to talk to all those people because these are the people that I'm living with.
Tony MartignettiThe ones who are fulfilling the SLA.
John CooganAbsolutely.
Tony MartignettiOkay.
John CooganAbsolutely.
Tony MartignettiI'm going to come back to industry insider secrets, but I want to go to Mike for some lessons learned. Some things you— well, lessons learned. What's in your past that you can help people with?
J. Michael FisherFirst off, when you're shopping if you would, for this type of group. Don't find a vendor, find a partner. And that's really, it sounds a little clichéd, but find somebody that will go in deeper with you. Just like John was saying, you know, I end up doing a lot of hands-on stuff. Like, I'm sending an email for the end of the year, it's in, you know, the end of December, I'm the only one in the office or doing it at home and I run into a snag. I can actually call somebody and not like, hey, we'll get back to you January 1st, you know, the 3rd, after all the stuff, all the emails that need to be sent out to make the end-of-year push. You know, even though you test things, I retest right before I send them again. And if I get a snag, it gives me a chance to get everything done. So when you find a partner, they'll be there for you no matter what. They're not just waiting for your check in the mail. And really, The other part that I find is find a group that is creating innovation, not chasing innovation. And so, you know, you can find like these bigger groups that are, I would call it like a Frankenstein backend where they're just bolting on, hey, here's the next best idea. We bought a smaller group, bolted on, you know, like a big bolt on Frankenstein's neck and here it is. And they don't always work together. But if you're creating innovation, you're finding ways that, hey, this is the next big idea, and we partnered with someone or we made it ourselves, and it really works.
Tony MartignettiHow could you tell if a vendor is creating versus chasing innovation? What would you look for?
J. Michael FisherI do a lot of homework. So the short story is, you know, John, 15 years ago, did this thing with Wounded Warrior Project. I was at a group called American Veterans, AMVETS, and I sat down and I'm like, who is making the most money in this market? Wounded Warrior Project. So I went and I did as much research on them as I could. I didn't know him at the time. He had just started doing this other thing with Charity Engine. And I was like, if they're doing it, I should be doing it. So I called them out of the blue and they were just really getting going, Charity Engine. They're like, how'd you find us? You're like our 5th client and we're not even like set up to do this yet. I'm like, we're only 20 I want to see you next week. And they're like, holy cow. So they showed up at our office, and that's how our relationship started. But it was just really digging in, kind of the way you find major donors is the way you find partners. You go out and you really do the research and dig it up.
John CooganI think if I can add a thought. If you're building— if you're a CRM that's building things inherently, you're thinking through all this stuff. A good example is ChatGPT and AI. It's all the buzz now. If you're going to just slap on a component that says, okay, now I've got AI, because they want to check off a box, where Charity Engine over the years, for me at Wounded Warrior Project, built AI into the product itself to be more predictive about things like fraud and who's accessing forms, from a bot or a hacker. And so what we've already got in the product that's been inherent for a decade is artificial intelligence to respond to certain things so that we can protect the nonprofit. So I think, you know, if a CRM vendor is growing based on acquisition and slapping things together, they're probably less innovative and more reactive. And I think that's the— for me, that's kind of the litmus test.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Another lesson learned, Mike?
J. Michael FisherThat's really the big pieces. Find innovation, you know, and don't chase it.
Tony MartignettiOkay. I'm coming back to you, John, for these insider tips, insider secrets.
John CooganInsider secrets? Oh, back to—
Tony MartignettiTo help you shop smarter.
John CooganI mean, I think the biggest one is move downstream past sales, but I also think for me the biggest thing is do your homework internally before you start doing Doing your homework externally. Understand your own team, understand what you need, understand what people are using, understand what people are complaining about, understand how many different components you've got in your environment today. Because if you start shopping before you even have those answers, you're doing something wrong. You're going to— you're basically not— you don't even know what you're looking for at that point. So start internally, spend a lot of good time really understanding your current environment, and people's mentality about your current environment before you get out there and start looking around.
Tony MartignettiWhat are some of the questions you got in the session?
John CooganWell, so we ran to the end and people walked up with questions afterwards, and I think the biggest question was related to shopping around. Like, you know, where do you start? And it was a couple of smaller nonprofits asking, you know, we don't know technology. Where do I go? Do I search Google? You know, and if I do, what are the keywords that I'm looking for? And I said, you know, obviously, you know, if you're starting there, I'd say take a step back and really ask yourself your questions first, and then it's going to drive how you search. So yeah, Google is going to be a great source for a lot of people. Referrals are good as well, but most people are going to go to the web. Every CRM is doing their search engine optimization, and they're getting their rankings, and everyone's putting up their marketing messaging. But at the beginning, you need to know specifically what you need before you start searching for anything. Otherwise, it's misaligned.
Tony MartignettiAll right. So all those internal questions that we talked about.
John CooganYeah, exactly.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Mike, you want to give us parting thoughts on pitfalls to avoid? Well, just some parting encouragement for doing it the right way.
J. Michael FisherOf course. Like John said, do your homework. That's really— you're responsible for yourself in the nonprofit world because they hire you to do one job and then you end up having 5 or 10 or 20. And, you know, it's really hard to kind of slow things down and really look. But call your friends. Hey, what are you using that's good? Ask for referrals and really just go out and see. Yeah. I see who's doing things together with clients more or less than just, hey, I just added a new client. So, it's that partner piece is, to me, is the biggest on everything that I do. If you're not— I don't want a vendor. I don't want a pay-for-play, even though it does kind of break down to that a little bit. I want someone that if there's a problem, they're going to help me come through it. And John, he alluded to some things that I don't even know he knew I had this in our past, but we had a thing where we bought a bad list. You bought what? A bad list.
John CooganEmails?
J. Michael FisherIt was at another nonprofit before my time, and it was integrated by a vendor, if you would, that we were getting rid of, but they had integrated like 100,000 emails, and it just sent off a lot of alarms at Charity Engine, and they said, stop. And we see that you're not getting the response rates, and you got a little— I hate to use this word— honeypot. I don't want you to put me in jail. No, no. But it's like all these pieces where they were not great email addresses. They were going to bad dead ends and so forth. And they stopped us from really going down a slippery slope, and we had to parse out this list.
Tony MartignettiTake out those $100,000.
J. Michael FisherYeah, and it really, it saved us a lot of time and money in the long run. And if they would have just let it ride, and that we were just like another number on their list, it would have cost us money in terms of donations and in fixing. So those are the things I look for.
Tony MartignettiAll right, that's J. Michael Fisher. He's Vice President of Development at Army Historical Foundation, and also with John Coogan, Vice President of Client Services at Charity Engine. John and Mike, thank you very much. Thanks very much for sharing. Thank you so much. My pleasure. And thank you for being with Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio coverage of the 2023 Nonprofit Technology Conference, Denver, Colorado, where we are sponsored by Heller Consulting, technology strategy and implementation for nonprofits. Thanks so much for being with me.
Kate MartignettiNext week, 10 fundraising boosts on a budget and personalized fundraising at scale. If you missed any part of this week's show,
Tony MartignettiI beseech you. Find it at tonymartignetti.com.
Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by DonorBox. With intuitive fundraising software from DonorBox, your donors give 4 times faster, helping you help others. donorbox.org. Our creative producer is Claire Meyerhoff. I'm your announcer, Kate Martignetti. The show's Social media is by Susan Chavez. Marc Silverman is our web guy. And this music is by Scott Stein.
Tony MartignettiThank you for that affirmation, Scotty. Be with us next week for Nonprofit Radio, Big Nonprofit Ideas for the Other 95%. Go out and be great.
I love our sponsor!

More Episodes from 2023 Nonprofit Technology Conference
View All

Communications & Development Teams Working Better Together
with Misty McLaughlin and Alice Hendricks




10 Easy Ways To Boost Your Fundraising On A Budget & Personalized Fundraising At Scale
with Rosalind Zavras, Julia Toepfer, Joe Frye, and Peter Yagecic





