Skip to content
EP 649July 16, 2023

Communications & Development Teams Working Better Together

Tony MartignettiMisty McLaughlinAlice Hendricks
Nonprofit Radio
Episode 649
0:00 / 0:00

About this episode

Misty McLaughlin and Alice Hendricks close our 2023 Nonprofit Technology Conference coverage, as they reveal how these two teams can avoid the common conflicts and tensions, to come together collaboratively. They’re the principals and founders of Cause Craft Consulting.

Here’s the transcript

Tony MartignettiHello and welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. I'm your aptly named host of your favorite hebdomadal podcast. Oh, I'm glad you're with us. I'd suffer the embarrassment of monoaphasia if you uttered the word fail because you missed this week's show. Here's Kate, our new associate producer, just promoted from announcer, with highlights of this week's show. Kate, congratulations on your promotion.

Kate MartignettiThank you, Tony. I'm happy to be here. And now, communications and development teams working better together. Misty McLaughlin and Alice Hendricks close our 2023 Nonprofit Technology Conference coverage as they reveal how these 2 teams can avoid the common conflicts and tensions to come together collaboratively. They're the principals and founders of Cause Craft Consulting on Tony's Take Two.

Tony MartignettiI finally have someone to blame. Woohoo!

Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by DonorBox. With intuitive fundraising software from DonorBox, your donors give 4 times faster. Helping you help others. donorbox.org.

Tony MartignettiWelcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio coverage of 23NTC, the 2023 Nonprofit Technology Conference in Denver, Colorado, where we are sponsored by Heller Consulting, technology strategy and implementation for nonprofits. With me now at the conference are Misty McLaughlin and Alice Hendricks. They are both principals and co-founders of Cause Craft Consulting. Misty, welcome back. Thank you, Tony. Alice, welcome to Nonprofit Radio. Thank you so much, Tony. Pleasure to have you both, the co-founders, the principals.

Kate MartignettiLikewise.

Tony MartignettiGood to be here. Thank you. Your session is Communications and development teams working better together. Alright, Alice, since you're the first time Nonprofit Radio, why don't you give us an overview of what's out there between these 2 teams and why this is important?

Alice HendricksYou know, Tony, it's a really important topic because over the 20 years that I've been in the sector working on both development and communications teams' projects from a technology perspective, We've noticed that there's often inherent conflict between those 2 teams, primarily because their missions are very different. Development departments need to raise the money. Communications departments need to get the word out. And so nobody's doing anything wrong. They're all living their jobs in the right way, doing the right thing. However, because of the inherent conflict, friction occurs between people. And teams often don't get along. They fight over resources. They don't have good processes, and that can lead to a feeling of discord between staff and organizations.

Tony MartignettiInteresting. Okay. I was very interested to read this because I've not seen this, but I've been a consultant for so many years, I could see why I wouldn't know about it. I do planned giving consulting, so that's a narrow niche within one of the 2 silos we're talking about. Well, hopefully not silos, within one of the 2 teams that we're talking about, you know, in development. So yeah, I'm not aware of it. Misty, how does this conflict sometimes play out?

Misty McLaughlinWell, Tony, that's a great question. So we have been seeing it for years, but then we saw an article a few years ago in the Chronicle of Philanthropy kind of talking about what the implications of this phenomenon are, because it is kind of— I think it's reasonably well acknowledged that this happens sometimes to the point that those 2 teams don't work together at all. And so you have kind of 2 separate pieces, and they just decide, we're not going to work together. And then there are times that it's actually—

Tony MartignettiThat's a disaster.

Misty McLaughlinExactly.

Tony MartignettiWe can't raise money if we can't get the message out.

Misty McLaughlinExactly. And we can't get the message out if we don't have this kind of core audience on board, right? I mean, fundraising represents a significant audience of importance for the organization. So the Chronicle of Philanthropy did a piece about this, and then we've just continued to see it, continued to see it, see it play out in all these ways, and we decided to do some research about this. So our session is actually kind of presenting some of the results of that research. We heard from 85 organizations about what this looks like in their organizations and how it plays out, from, I would say, dynamics that are mildly ineffective and involve some minor friction to complete breakdowns.

Tony MartignettiBreakdowns like we're not talking to each other, or we're not, we're not going to send your messages, or we're not going to support your message, support your messaging?

Misty McLaughlinExactly. Or we're going to We're gonna circumvent the approval process, and we're just gonna send something out before you can stop us. Right. And if it contradicts the mission, or it contradicts, for example, like a shared messaging hierarchy, oh well, as long as I got my message to my audience. And it happens on both sides. It's— no one's at fault. I mean, people really, in general, people aren't devious. They want to work together. They sometimes just can't figure out exactly how to make that happen. And then, you know, often what is just a kind of personal conflict blows up to be something happening more at a team level or more at a departmental level. Leaders have a huge role to play in this, and if 2 leaders between those 2 departments don't get along, it's difficult for staff to kind of figure out how to navigate those situations.

Tony MartignettiRight, 2 directors or 2 vice presidents or something?

Misty McLaughlinExactly.

Tony MartignettiIs there a— do either of you have— well, you work in the same company, you know all the same, you have the same clients. I mean, is there a— I don't mean to focus on the inflammatory, but is there a Like a story of conflict? Maybe like a good story of conflict and then later on we could tell the epilogue where it came out well after Cause Craft Consulting intervened. Is there a story like that? Who wants to share? All right.

Misty McLaughlinYeah.

Alice HendricksI mean, I think there's lots of stories like that. What we see often dynamics that happen because of this is delayed getting emails out the door or vetting processes.

Tony MartignettiLike deliberately delaying?

Alice HendricksJust, it's going to take me 4 days to get back to you to approve the content or choose the photo, or complaints about just the lack of collaborative working together. We also often see the leaders might not get along of these 2 departments, but staff themselves develop and forge relationships of trust amongst each other, which is great. You really want to have good, strong, personal one-to-one relationships. In fact, in our research results, one of the ways that we saw People who responded that mitigate the fact that the teams themselves weren't getting along is that just they made friends with someone on the other team. So if they needed a file update or some piece of collateral, they would ask their friend, which is wonderful because you have a trusted friend. But for us as process design consultants, we see that as a dysfunction. We see that as a lack of people really understanding what their role is, who's supposed to be doing what, what lane they should stay in. Right. stay in, what you can expect from someone on another team. So really, the solution to all of this is good, strong leadership building trust and good process. So everyone is clear about what you're supposed to do, what happens next, and that helps mitigate the conflict. But yeah, I mean, it can be very hard to work in an organization where you don't get along with others.

Misty McLaughlinOne organization that we came across, International Relief Organization, so obviously a big A big part of their work is fundraising and engagement in times of crisis, right? So rapid response, emergency response is huge for them, and it's kind of the core source of their fundraising. The development department and the communications department sort of went through this period of years where they just couldn't figure out how they were going to message in these moments. And it would sort of be a simmering tension. And when it was a non-conflict—

Tony MartignettiThis is an essential function for them.

Misty McLaughlinExactly. It's a core function of the organization. Core. And so it would be a kind of a problem, but they would sort of come to some sort of an agreement But then a crisis would happen, and they couldn't get a message out the door in order to be able to fundraise around that message. And so they would miss the moment again and again and again in these moments that they should have been coming together and pulling together as a team. So in that case, they, they brought us in to say, how can we get these 2 teams to work together? We want to message in completely different ways, particularly in these moments of crisis. We want to use the channels, so the digital channels in particular, with this kind of hotspot of Well, who's gonna say what in email, and who gets to press the send button? Who gets to have the final word on how we're gonna talk about this? And we went through a whole initiative to try and solve this and get them talking to each other. And it was a lot about getting them to use the same language and recognize each other's expertise, that they just come from different worlds. Somebody who responded to our survey said, communications is all about saying what the message that the organization needs to get out, and development is all about trying to say what the donors want to And those are just 2 completely different worldviews. And so when you can put those together and say, where's the common ground in this? How can we represent our organizational priorities and at the same time really translate that to words and language that really resonates with donors and causes them to act?

Tony MartignettiOkay. So let's start to get to some specifics that we can recommend if you are suffering the symptoms that the 2 of You were talking about 5 minutes ago, disharmony and antagonism, frustration. All right. Because we're striving for harmony. We're going to leave disharmony behind and striving for harmony. All right. You talk about clear message prioritization. So deciding in advance, I guess, instead of me trying to guess. Alice or Misty, you're better at this. Yeah. Alice is waving to Misty, so deferring to Misty.

Alice HendricksIn terms of doing a content strategy where it's clear about what we're trying to do and having things planned in advance, so we know what— how we will behave in any given situation. It's governance. It's a process governance project of understanding when this crisis is going to occur. If you're an international relief organization and there's a tsunami, what do you do? Having those plans already laid out so it's clear about what you're supposed to do, what the other people on what other team is supposed to do, and that's a process design. In our research, we asked, is there any governance over the messaging? And most of the respondents said no. There might be some process or a shared calendar, but we really don't have a way of knowing how to behave when something happens.

Tony MartignettiOkay. What does this governance look like?

Misty McLaughlinThat's a great question. So governance can happen at a lot of different points in working together, a lot of different points in the sort of relationship lifecycle. So for example, when you have a project, making sure that if those teams are going to be working together on, for example, a campaign or a long-term body of work, or maybe there's a new programmatic area that's rolling out, you always start with a tool like a project charter or terms of reference. In international organizations, they call a charter terms of reference. Right. But the idea is that you're sitting down together and you're saying, okay, How are we going to talk about this? What is our organizational positioning? Not just messaging, but positioning. What is our relationship to this thing that's happening, part of the social problem? What's our unique value proposition? And how are we comfortable talking about this as an organization? How are we not? That's the content strategy piece that Alice was speaking to. What do we think are going to be the best channels to do that? And how, when something happens around this, when there's a big news event, when there's something to respond to, how are we going to work together? And that's, you know, forever, how are we going to work together? But in this specific case, on this topic, how are we going to work together?

Tony MartignettiSo having these workflows, essentially a workflow, a process.

Misty McLaughlinExactly.

Tony MartignettiBut all shared and agreed in advance.

Misty McLaughlinExactly. And that everybody on the team knows, right? It's not just an agreement that 2 leaders make. Everybody, individual contributors, need to understand what they're supposed to do. How do they feed into the system overall so that they're working hand in hand together? And a lot of the time, there are certain teams, for example, digital teams, they, they are forced to operate between communications and fundraising. Wherever they sit, they're controlling channels that all these different parts of the organization need to use. A lot of the time, that's a starting place for forming some shared working agreements or some principles that are used in moments like this. Okay. There are a lot of other tools too. So for example, shared Shared calendars so that there is one shared view of every external communication that's happening, whether it's a fundraising ask or it's a media piece coming out or it's some sort of campaign, broad marketing campaign, that there is one shared view and everyone gets a view of the whole of what the audience is seeing instead of a kind of micro departmental specific view.

Tony MartignettiOkay. Others? Other processes that you can share that Are gonna create harmony?

Misty McLaughlinYeah, so we have a whole list in our presentation of hard tools, and I would say something like the calendar and the workflows, those are hard tools. There are also soft tools, and I will just say for fairness purposes, these soft tools like work in any 2 departments that are having a breakdown. We were here 2 years ago, or we were online 2 years ago at NTC talking about Fundraising and IT teams and frictions between those teams. There are lots of places, obviously. It's not just limited to development and communications, but some examples of some of the soft tools would be, you know, doing shared planning activities. So doing your annual plans together, not doing separate departmental plans, but saying, what do we want to accomplish this year?

Tony MartignettiOkay.

Misty McLaughlinWhat does that look like?

Tony MartignettiThis is where I'm shocked that this is not happening.

Misty McLaughlinIt's mostly—

Tony MartignettiI'm an outside I'm a planned giving consultant, so what do I know from shared, collaborative calendars? I thought this, especially communications and fundraising, I would have thought that this was all happening routinely.

Alice HendricksYou really would have thought, yes. But think about even pre-internet. Fundraising departments were doing planned giving, major gifts, and direct mail, and they were doing their own thing. I mean, direct mail is kind of its own bespoke thing. It's still kind of done the same way it was about about 25, 30 years ago, right? When you enter— when all of a sudden digital happened, everyone— the email list is really a file of all the supporters. Communications often feels like there's an audience about just awareness and brand engagement and marketing, and all I want to do is engage those supporters in that way. Development looks at that list and says, these are prospects, or they're already donors that I need to feed and nurture. And so part of it was the The shared technology often created the conflict around whose list is whose, who gets to message to who about what message, right? So what is the content of the message that's a fundraising message versus an educational message or what the organization is doing? Part of that has been— I think that most of the conflicts are around ownership of the— they believe they have different audiences. But supporters of an organization don't have a hat on and say, I'm a donor, or another hat on and say, oh, I'm interested in this content. That's not how it really works. But that shift is slowly happening, and we're seeing more collaboration around that because of the proliferation of channels that everyone is engaging on— social, email, text.

Tony MartignettiAlice, what's your advice around who should be in these conversations? We're doing the annual calendar. Is it— I imagine it's not only the 2 heads of each team, but how deep do we go? All the members of both teams? I mean, our listeners are small and mid-sized nonprofits, so we're not talking about 25-person fundraising or communications teams. But still, there could be 6 or 8 people on each or even combined. What's your advice around who does this planning?

Alice HendricksTransparency. Transparency is super important, especially to employees now. You know, we live in an age where feeling aligned with the mission and your work and coming to work and really having a good experience at work is very helpful. So our advice is usually be as inclusive as possible with everyone who can participate in a planning exercise, bring them in. Because, you know, we live in an age where people are quitting and quiet quitting. And if you are working in an environment where there's tension, Right. with other teams, that's a good sign— that's a problem. I mean, it might be a retention issue there for organizations. So when you do strategic planning together or redesigning a process or anything that will enable a change to happen, it's best to be as inclusive as possible. Okay.

Tony MartignettiOr if everyone's not included in the actual meeting, then bringing it back to your team incrementally. Exactly. It's not like it's all going to be decided in an 90-minute meeting, bring it back, feedback, representing that feedback to the working group or the collaboration team.

Alice HendricksYep, a committee, a working group.

Tony MartignettiRight, right, right. Okay, okay. Anything else we should be talking about? Work processes, planning, besides— well, you were starting to talk about soft. You didn't really flesh out the soft. We got digressed. I digressed you into more discussion of the hard tools.

Misty McLaughlinYou digressed us.

Tony MartignettiYeah, I'm a lackluster. We're suffering a lackluster host. More on the soft tools, Misty.

Misty McLaughlinYeah, there's a lot. There's a lot. And this is, I think, where I was going with that, was to say these are tools that work in other breakdowns. They work in any breakdown in a human system. But for example, saying we're taking the whole team away twice a year for 1 day or 2 days, and that means development and communications. That might also be a marketing group. That might also be a digital team, or it might be sub-working groups, but we're going to do these 2-day intensive retreats where we really try and understand each other's expertise and map solutions together. And those could be process solutions, or that could be campaign planning. It could be anything. It could be exploring new audience opportunities. And there's all of the piece— we've just heard so many clients say this year, you know, this wasn't working well before the pandemic, but now we're just broken down by the side of the road. Our ropes have frayed between these 2 teams and even within our own We've onboarded new staff. They've never met each other. And so what is it that we're going to do? So understanding, for example, when you need to pick up the phone, when email is not enough, or Slack is not enough, or texting is not enough, we need to actually pick up the phone and work together in a human way towards a solution. That those kinds of pieces, as obvious as it sounds, they're not pieces that people have necessarily incorporated into their ways of working, particularly younger staff. Right. So understanding that there's a whole range of those kind of tools that you can use and sort of working norms that you can establish with those teams if you were a leader or even just a manager of a small team. I think one of the most interesting things we found in this survey is that this tends to be less of a problem at small organizations, particularly when you have like a one-person development and communications team. You have to work together. You don't have a choice. This is a problem that happens often with growth and scaling, that relationships that once worked, it's just harder to figure out how to do that the more humans you have in the mix.

Tony MartignettiOkay. Retreats. I love the idea of retreats. Plus there's social time built in.

Misty McLaughlinExactly.

Tony MartignettiWhat about, can that be a soft tool? Just social time that we're not doing any planning, but we're doing, I don't know, you know, one of the mystery places, solve the murder mystery places, or, you know, whatever, or just drinks, a game room. Yeah, yeah. Right? Yeah. I mean, just get to know each other outside our marketing and communications roles.

Misty McLaughlinThat's exactly right.

Tony MartignettiOr fundraising communications. Yeah.

Misty McLaughlinYeah. I mean, this can be very social, but the idea of like, after we do something, we have to do some retrospection together. I think that often gets lost in these teams because people are moving so fast. You move from one campaign to the next campaign or one ask to the next ask. And now so many teams have the data to sit down together after doing something, even something that maybe didn't go very well, and saying, well, what worked here? Is there something we can learn together? And kind of using the data as a way to have an independent objective view you can all analyze together and say, what does this mean for the future? How do we do it? And you can do those in a fun social way. It doesn't have to be a boring sort of like, now we're gonna do a postmortem and we're all gonna look at it. You can, you can sort of make this a part of the way that you work together.

Kate MartignettiIt's time for a break. DonorBox, it's the fundraising engine of choice for 50,000 organizations from 96 countries. They've got something new. Now you can accept cashless donations anytime and anywhere with DonorBox Live Kiosk. Turn your iPad or Android tablet into a kiosk to boost in-person giving. And with their new additions to DonorBox events, you can sell tickets in 43 currencies and ask buyers to cover fees. Put these 2 together and your in-person events will take off. DonorBox, helping you help others. donorbox.org. It's time for Tony's Take Two.

Tony MartignettiThank you, Kate. How, how are you?

Kate MartignettiI'm Doing well. How are you?

Tony MartignettiUh, she's— uh, I'm great, I'm great. So I'm glad you're with us, and, uh, and congratulations again on your promotion. That's— so that's Kate. Uh, she's not an intern, she's our associate producer, but I have someone I can blame now. I've been saying for years, where's the intern? Yeah, I wish I had an intern Every time I make a mistake, who— I would say, who writes this crappy copy? I wish I had an intern to blame. Well, I don't have an intern, but I have an associate producer. Now I have an associate producer that I can blame. It's beautiful. So any flubs— well, I'll just leave them at flubs. I won't go more, uh, I won't, I won't be more extreme with another F-word. With any, with any, with any flubs. I've got an associate producer that is, is, is now going to be responsible. I'm thinking just— this is today's news— I'm just thinking I'm glad that, uh, Kate is not a member of, uh, SAG-AFTRA yet. Otherwise, uh, I would have lost her. She'd be, she'd be on the lines, so we wouldn't have her. But, uh, not a member yet. It's relieving. It's sort of, uh, there's a burden lifted from my shoulders that I no longer have to bear The responsibility of my own mistakes. That's the beauty of it. I don't have to be responsible for my own flubs any, any longer. Very relieving. That is Tony's Take Two.

Kate MartignettiNot what I was expecting, and I'm not sure what I've gotten myself into here. But whatever, we've got just about a buttload more time. Now back to communications and development teams working better together.

Tony MartignettiWhere else should we go with the topic? We still have some time together. You know, I haven't talked about yet.

Alice HendricksWhen you— if there's something broken that needs process, that needs healing, you know, you think about these conflicts in any Whether it's between communications and development, between IT and development, any kind of processes that are broken and cause frustration and friction within teams, it's useful to have another event happening and that needs change. And then you can overlay process improvement during another change. So a good example that we often find is that if someone is migrating from one software tool to another, it's a great opportunity Because people are going to use a different technology when they come to work every day. The common thing between development departments and communications departments is that they all use digital tools. They use CRMs. They use email marketing tools. They are always tied to technology. And so if the technology is changing, it's a great opportunity to think about what role do we need doing what activity in this tool, and then you can take that that one step further and say, how should all these roles work together? What's the workflow? What's the process here? Who's supposed to be doing what? And what you find in a lot of organizations is there's often individuals that they're just willing to learn everything, so they'll take on any project and they can use the tools really easily and they end up doing more than their job description. Then you have others who just really don't have their Roll clear about what they're supposed to be doing. So you have an opportunity in something as— something like a CRM migration. You can also take a look at the staffing and the staffing structure and the processes and improve some of these frictions almost under the guise of, as we go through this technology migration, let's take a look at how we're actually doing our work. And That's useful because sometimes new technology has different features. So you need a skill set of a subject matter expert in a particular skill. How does that person fit in? Which means, how do other people's jobs change? So if you look at the human component around technology—

Tony MartignettiAnd sometimes technology is not the sole solution. Right. The people and the processes could very well be contributing to the problem that we're looking at.

Alice HendricksUsually the tech— I would say almost all the time when we hear about a technology problem, the technology is working as intended. It's a people and process and workflow problem. Sometimes tools are older and they need to be renovated, or an organization has developed a new strategy. An organization that mostly does high-touch engagement or gets corporate gifts or grants wants to start a mass marketing program. They need technology that can better accommodate those different strategies. Those are all opportunities to stop and look at process. How are we looking— how are we working together? What organizational structure do we have? Is everybody the most— is— or do we have all the right roles in our team? And it's a great opportunity. We find that a lot of the time we do a lot of change management and process design around the human component of the technology, and it really has nothing to do with the tech itself.

Tony MartignettiIs there another example, Alice, that you can share around an event that merits this kind of attention and planning and introspect— really, it's introspection. I think it's organizational introspection. Something else non-tech?

Alice HendricksOftentimes a new leader will come in. So a new leader can come in and have a new idea or a new program, like the example of now we're going to start doing a new strategy. Any type of external force of change, if there's a moment of critical change that requires the opportunity to take a step back and look at how things are working, you're absolutely right. It takes a very self-actualized executive director to say, here, I'm getting complaints from my development director and complaints from my communications director. I need to bring in an outside consultant and figure out a better process so people can work together. That doesn't often happen. Right. Usually there's some other pressing external event, like a new person comes in who's a leader, a new development director, a new comms director, a new executive director, who says, wait a minute, this doesn't seem right. Why are people complaining and not getting along? Let's take a look at that. Or it's a technology thing. It's like our tools aren't working together.

Tony MartignettiOkay. Those are good examples. Thank you. All right. Cool. I put you on the spot. Thank you. All right. No, you're Cause Craft Consulting. You're not flustered. I put you on the spot and you rose to the moment. Of course. What is— no surprise.

Misty McLaughlinThat's our job.

Tony MartignettiNo surprise. Yeah, that's right. All right. We still have some time if there's other stuff you want to— I mean, we talked through your 3 learning objectives, stated learning objectives for the session, but what else are you going to share with folks that we haven't talked about?

Misty McLaughlinMaybe we could talk a little bit about our survey results. I think we learned some—

Tony MartignettiSome more motivation type? Okay.

Misty McLaughlinWell, one of the things we asked about was—

Tony MartignettiYou have value beyond motivation?

Misty McLaughlinBeyond motivation. The subject of structure, because we were curious about, and we've observed a lot, there's not a perfect structure. There's not a perfect organizational way of structuring this work or these teams that works well every time. But what we really noticed is there are big differences in the way that these breakdowns happen that are a result of structure. So when you You have a development and a communications team in one department. It's not that that's a perfect structure. It's just harder to have a lot of conflict where people don't work together, right? Sure. But as an organization grows, you tend to have 2 separate functions. People specialize and they pull apart. That's one moment where a lot of conflict can happen. Where digital lives in an organization, that's a big differentiator in terms of— so if digital lives in communications, sometimes there's a real breakdown between development and comms, digital are the ambassadors that go back and forth, are the emissaries between those teams, and are the ones that are trying to connect the ropes even when those ropes fray.

Tony MartignettiAlice, you suggested that earlier too. You said something similar.

Alice HendricksYeah, they have to be the mitigators. You know, they have to— they're getting the pressure from both sides, and they actually have to serve both departments. So oftentimes the attitude and approach of the digital team can be one of either exacerbating conflict or bringing people together.

Tony MartignettiWhat about the existence or not of the same leader over 2 different teams? So, but they're not the same team, they're 2 separate teams, but same director or vice president. Does that make a difference in terms of likelihood or not of conflict?

Misty McLaughlinThat's a good question. I would say it depends. Sometimes that leader themselves really has a career that aligns with one function or another. We've seen, I have an example actually recently. of a department that's development and communications, but the leader is really a long-term career fundraiser, and communications always feels a little left out. It's like kind of the child that has the parent that's really aligned with the other child. So if you have a strong leader who's really equally invested in both sides and really thinks from the perspective of both sides, that actually can work very well as a structure. We've seen a lot of that.

Tony MartignettiInteresting, because odds are they come from a background of one of those two things. Right. So they're going to be much more fluent with one function than the other.

Misty McLaughlinExactly. Something else we saw that I thought was really fascinating is we asked how many of these organizations have a dedicated marketing or engagement team. That's not exactly comms, and it's not exactly development. It's a marketing function. And a huge portion, I think almost 70%, said that they have marketing teams. When we would have these conversations 10 years ago, marketing was Marketing is still a very dirty word in organizations. If you said marketing, people would say, well, I'm a nonprofit. We don't do marketing. That's changed hugely.

Tony MartignettiI always railed against that. I always bristled against that. But it has changed. It has changed. Marketing and promotion. Now we talk about promotion. Promotion used to be sales promotion, like selling Lay's potato chips at a point of sale in a supermarket. That was sales promotion. There are things we can learn from the for-profit sector, right? Everything corporate is not dirty.

Misty McLaughlinExactly. And

Tony Martignettimarketing and promotion, I think, are examples.

Misty McLaughlinYeah, and marketing, a lot of those teams see themselves as engagement functions, as thinking across all the ways that an organization might engage and thinking about the full funnel, the kind of full end-to-end relationship, even for non-donors, right? Like volunteers, activists, lots of other folks, service recipients even. How do they play Well,

Alice Hendricksthe for-profit world has kind of nailed this with the idea of customer experience management. Now you have big companies that have CXOs, chief customer experience officers. So when you think about the donor experience or the supporter experience, thinking about it from that perspective, it's about the curation of an entire holistic experience. The for-profit world has nailed that. When you look at nonprofits, It's important to actually, for all of the teams, to consider their audience as one audience and how do we— what do we want that experience of our audience to be? And that, like I said before, you don't put your hat on as a donor and a hat on as someone else. So thinking from all of the new knowledge we have from customer experience management, applying that to how we're going to engage our supporters, we have seen organizations combine their development and communications teams, like you said before, into a public engagement, external affairs, other names of teams that have a single leader. The benefit of that is also there's a single source of making a decision or setting priorities, which is really helpful. Right. To have compete— right now, the teams have competing priorities, and there's no arbitrator besides maybe the executive director or the executive committee to say, yes, we're going to focus on this, and we're not going to focus on that.

Tony MartignettiYeah, we talked about message priorities.

Alice HendricksYep.

Tony MartignettiOkay. Right. Single decision maker.

Alice HendricksYep.

Tony MartignettiAll right. Anything you want to leave us with? I let Alice open, so Misty, you want to leave us with something harmonious and uplifting? Empowering and happy?

Alice HendricksThat's her job, the harmonious and uplifting one.

Tony MartignettiEncouraging and empowering?

Misty McLaughlinWell, one of the things that gave me great relief in analyzing these survey results was to realize that I think most people know that these 2 teams actually have more in common than many of the other teams in the organization. There are some, there are some natural points of harmony built in, right? They both really care about results and outcomes. They are very focused on reaching audiences. They think from outside in and not just an inside out perspective. And by that I mean they think about these audiences and what do these audiences need. They're curious about how to reach They want to message right and represent the organization well. They want to get it right. And they see themselves as bringing the work of the organization to the world at large, making it relevant and meaningful. So there's a ton of common ground. I think that just gets obscured a lot of the time by these persistent thorny dynamics. And when you could help people to see the common ground, people are relieved and excited to work together almost universally. We've seen that. We've seen that over and over again. The will is there. People just sort of need to be given permission and shown the way.

Tony MartignettiMisty McLaughlin, Alice Hendricks, both principals and co-founders of Cause Craft Consulting, thank you very much.

Alice HendricksThank you, Tony. Thanks, Tony.

Tony MartignettiThank you, Misty. Thank you, Alice. And thank you for being with Nonprofit Radio coverage of 23andMe, where we are not sponsored by Lay's potato chips, even though I gave them a shout-out. We are sponsored, in fact, by Heller Consulting, technology strategy and implementation for nonprofits. Thanks for being with us.

Kate MartignettiNext week, Giving Circles with the woman who popularized them, Sara Lomelin. If you missed any part of this week's show,

Tony MartignettiI beseech you, find it at tonymartignetti.com.

Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by DonorBox. With intuitive fundraising software from DonorBox, your donors give 4 times faster, helping you help others. donorbox.org. Our creative producer is Claire Meyerhoff. I'm your associate producer, Kate Martignetti. The show's social media is by Susan Chavez. Marc Silverman is our web guy. And this music is by Scott Stein. Thank you for that affirmation, Scotty.

Tony MartignettiBe with us next week for Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. Go out and be great.

Nonprofit Radio

More Episodes from 2023 Nonprofit Technology Conference

View All
Rosalind ZavrasJulia ToepferJoe FryePeter Yagecic
EP 648July 9, 2023

10 Easy Ways To Boost Your Fundraising On A Budget & Personalized Fundraising At Scale

with Rosalind Zavras, Julia Toepfer, Joe Frye, and Peter Yagecic

Claire Taylor HansenJennifer Daw HollowayJohn CooganJ. Michael Fisher
EP 647July 2, 2023

Brand Democracy & What To Avoid When Selecting Your Next CRM

with Claire Taylor Hansen, Jennifer Daw Holloway, John Coogan, and J. Michael Fisher

Julia Campbell
EP 646June 26, 2023

Data Driven Storytelling

with Julia Campbell

1 / 4