Skip to content
EP 648July 9, 2023

10 Easy Ways To Boost Your Fundraising On A Budget & Personalized Fundraising At Scale

Tony MartignettiRosalind ZavrasJulia ToepferJoe FryePeter Yagecic
Nonprofit Radio
Episode 648
0:00 / 0:00

10 Easy Ways To Boost Your Fundraising On A Budget

Relationships; storytelling; thanks; impact; consistency; and more. Rosalind Zavras and Julia Toepfer share tactics you can use right away to increase your fundraising impact without busting your fundraising budget. Rosalind is CEO of Aropa Consulting and Julia is from the National Immigrant Justice Center. (This was recorded at the 2023 Nonprofit Technology Conference, hosted by NTEN.)

Personalized Fundraising At Scale

Here’s the 11th easy way to boost your fundraising! First, adopt a better definition of personalization, beyond first-name emails. Then, understand the many types of personalization available. The advice comes from Joe Frye and Peter Yagecic, both with Town Hall Agency. (This is also from 23NTC.)

Here’s the transcript

Tony MartignettiHello and welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. I'm your aptly named host of your favorite hebdomadal podcast. Oh, I'm glad you're with me. I'd suffer the effects of Jeromerasmus if you dragged me down with the idea that you missed this week's show.

Kate Martignetti10 easy ways to boost your fundraising on a budget. Relationships, storytelling, thanks, impact, consistency, and more. Rosalind Zavras and Julia Toepfer share tactics you can use right away to increase your fundraising impact without busting your fundraising budget. Rosalind is CEO of Aropa Consulting, and Julia is from the National Immigrant Justice Center. This was recorded at the 2023 Nonprofit Technology Conference hosted by NTEN. And personalized fundraising at scale. Here's the 11th easy way to improve your fundraising. First, adopt a better definition of personalization. Beyond first-name emails. Then understand the many types of personalization available. The advice comes from Joe Frye and Peter Yagecic, both with Town Hall Agency. This is also from the '23 NTC. On Tony's Take Two—

Tony MartignettiGot feedback?

Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by DonorBox. With intuitive fundraising software from DonorBox, Your donors give 4 times faster. Helping you help others. donorbox.org. Here is 10 Easy Ways to Boost Your Fundraising on a Budget.

Rosalind ZavrasWelcome back to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio coverage of 23NTC, the 2023 Nonprofit Technology Conference. We are sponsored here at the conference by Heller Consulting, technology strategy and implementation for nonprofits.

Tony MartignettiWith me now are Rosalind Zavras, who is CEO of Aropa Consulting, and Julia Toepfer, who is Senior Marketing and Digital Engagement Strategist at the National Immigrant Justice Center. Rosalind, Julia, welcome to Nonprofit Radio.

Rosalind ZavrasThank you for having us. Thanks for having us.

Tony MartignettiAll right, it's a pleasure. Your session is 10 Easy Ways to Boost Your Fundraising on a Budget, and it's already in your past. You can relax. You can relax. Alright. Let's see, Rosalind, why don't you get us started with just, you know, some like 30,000-foot overview of why this is an important topic?

Rosalind ZavrasWell, I will. And one thing that we really emphasized is there technically are no easy ways to boost your fundraising, but our strategies were how to make your fundraising easier and your processes, especially for small teams. How can you leverage different tools so that you can fundraise effectively even if you are resource-strapped?

Tony MartignettiOkay, so 10 easier ways. There is no easy way. There is no panacea. Okay, okay. Julia, do you want to— you have— I'm just looking at the learning objectives or learning outcomes, I think they call them. List of fundraising tactics you can start right away. Do you want to— we have 10, right? We don't necessarily— it's not ping pong either. We're not going to go Julia, Rosalind, Julia, Rosalind, Julia, Rosalind. But Julia, do you want to kick us off with some, some of the strategies?

Julia ToepferYeah, I mean, one of the things that we talk a lot about in the session is relationship building and how important it is to establish a strong relationship with your donors. And some of that comes from talking directly to them. comes from thanking them often, knowing what their needs are, and why they are connected to your organization, why they're passionate about what you do. And so a lot of the tips and tools that we talk about really stem mostly from some of that initial relationship building.

Tony MartignettiRelational instead of transactional.

Julia ToepferYes.

Tony MartignettiTreating our donors like ATMs.

Julia ToepferYeah, right.

Tony MartignettiOnly communicating when we want something.

Julia ToepferYes.

Tony MartignettiAll right, so I'm going to make you drill down. I want to hear the 10. So start us off with number 1.

Julia ToepferDo you remember what exactly? Number 1.

Tony MartignettiI'm not going to know. You can say number 7 first.

Julia ToepferThe number 1 one that we talked about in the session was thanking your donors and doing it in creative and different ways. So making sure that you particularly thank them after the transaction receipt, you know, an auto-response email is not a thank you. So making sure that you really build that relationship through thanking them and using some really creative methods to continue that conversation with them and thank them for their donation. Roz had a great tip of writing letters to them and doing it through method called PunkPost, which sends letters.

Tony MartignettiSo Rosalind, you have some of these creative— see, I don't want you to just say, we talked about creative ways. I want to hear what the creative ways are. So Rosalind, go ahead. What's PunkPost? PunkPost.

Rosalind ZavrasIt's a really interesting service that has cards, and then they employ artists to give creative designs and handwritten notes within the cards. So especially if you're not an artist, and you— or maybe you don't love your penmanship, You can use PunkPost to send these really beautiful cards, and they'll do the stamp, they'll do everything for you. So you just pick the card, type in your message, and they'll send it. And you can do big groups of these for donors as well. So

Tony Martignettipunkpost.com?

Rosalind ZavrasYes.

Tony MartignettiIs that easy? Okay.

Rosalind ZavrasYes.

Tony MartignettiOkay. All right. If you don't like your own handwriting.

Rosalind ZavrasYeah.

Tony MartignettiAll right. But people do like handwritten notes.

Rosalind ZavrasThey love them.

Tony MartignettiBut if they can't read them, then they're not very valuable. So if your handwriting is that bad, get PunkPost. But people do love— respond to handwritten notes.

Rosalind ZavrasThey really do.

Tony MartignettiOkay. Another creative way, Rosalind, creative way of saying thank you?

Rosalind ZavrasWell, and this also goes back to our second strategy, which is segmenting your donors. So understanding who your donors are and why they got connected to you, and then creating a thanking strategy from there. So you wouldn't thank someone the same way for coming to your house for dinner as well as giving you a birthday present, right? Those are 2 different interactions, so your donors should also have 2 different types of thank-yous depending on how they come into your organization or maybe what they're interested in.

Tony MartignettiOkay, okay. So thank you segmenting, segmenting, I guess, you know, also by what their interests are, what they've given to. Okay. And technology helps with these things, right?

Rosalind ZavrasOf course.

Tony MartignettiTags, attributes, we can segment in your CRM. You can segment in your email app. Okay, okay. Why don't you keep going, Rosalind? Some more, some more of the 10? We're going to hit all 10. We're not letting you hold out on Nonprofit Radio listeners. Go ahead. What else do we have?

Rosalind ZavrasAnother great tip is to talk to your donors. And this is one of my favorites, so that's why I'm jumping to this one. A lot of us are nervous. to speak to our donors. Don't really know, oh, should we call them? Yes, call them, text them, email them. Get to know your donors because they are excited about the cause that you're working on and they want to get to know you, and they're excited if you want to get to know them as well. As we were saying earlier, fundraising is relational, so build a relationship the same way that you would build a relationship with a friend or a colleague.

Tony MartignettiWhat are some things you could talk to folks about if you're picking up the phone and talking?

Rosalind ZavrasHow they got involved, how they found out about your organization, things that they're interested in. You could tell them about the programs that you're working on and things that are coming up. And also, it's a great way to gauge what they're interested in. And maybe they'll say in that conversation, oh, I didn't realize you do this. I'd love to hear more about it. And then now you know which emails to send them because they're most interested in this one particular program.

Tony MartignettiOkay, okay. And even I think even if you're calling and even just leaving a thoughtful message, right?

Rosalind ZavrasExactly.

Tony MartignettiYeah. Even if they don't call back, you've still made a valuable touchpoint.

Rosalind ZavrasYes.

Tony MartignettiA valuable contact, I think.

Rosalind ZavrasAnd we also talked about you could potentially use volunteers to help out with this as well. Like, you don't have to be the only one calling all of these individuals, but just make sure that whoever is calling knows the verbiage that you want to use, knows how to talk about your programs the way that you want them to.

Tony MartignettiThat can be a good exercise too for boards.

Rosalind ZavrasYes.

Tony MartignettiI mean, it's an easy— I've made lots of thank you calls. I do planned giving fundraising. Nobody's ever turned down or been upset at a thank you call. Sometimes you have to reassure them, actually a lot of times, I'm only calling to say thank you. That you're not going to ask. Thank you, yeah, yeah. I work with planned giving donors to the nonprofits But sometimes they make an outright gift too. And since I might be the relationship manager, I'm calling to say thank you. They think, you know, but I just gave, you know, and I might say, it's Tony Martignetti from so-and-so charity. I just gave, or something like that. No, I'm calling to say thank you for that. Yeah. And then they let their guard down, like instantly. But sometimes you do have to reassure folks. But for boards, that's a really easy thing to do. Yeah. And

Rosalind Zavrasit makes everybody feel good. So especially if you have a board that doesn't exactly know how to fundraise, or maybe they'll say, we're uncertain, start with thank-yous. You know, just—

Tony MartignettiThey're easy. Yeah. Once they do the first one, they'll see how easy they are. And who wouldn't love to hear from a board member too? Right, exactly. Of an agency that they just gave to or volunteered for. So, all right, Julia, let's go to you. What else?

Julia ToepferYeah. So one I really like a lot is telling personal stories. So sharing the victories of your clients, your staff, really creating a personal connection between your donors and the cause that you, that your organization represents or the service, the services that you provide. Yeah. We talked about making sure that, you know, if you're sharing a human's story, to make sure that they have control over the way that story is told, to make sure that they have consented to the way that you're sharing that story. But it's a really great way to really connect donors to the actual impact that And

Tony Martignettitell the stories in what ways?

Julia ToepferYeah, so we shared a few examples actually on, you know, you could do it through written stories, right, on emails or in letters, but also on social media and through images and videos. Roz has some great examples of organizations that might not provide direct services to people, but can still share pictures on social media platforms that still really tell a story of the work that their organization does. In this particular case, it was food in the back of a minivan from an organization that does food reclamation and delivers food to organizations that then distribute it. And it was still really sharing the story of the work, but didn't necessarily involve people. So we really stress that, like, there are lots of different ways that you can share and tell stories. They don't have to involve people or animals, that it's possible for all organizations to do that effectively.

Tony MartignettiRosalind, it sounds like you— it looks like you may want to amplify that some. Definitely. Say some more about that, yeah, please.

Rosalind ZavrasWell, and this woman also, after the session, came and asked a similar question. You know, she has an advocacy organization, so a lot of what she was working on is, how can I tell a story when our story is numbers? And one of the things that I spoke with her about was I've seen organizations in similar spaces tell the story about why the advocacy is so important. So you can connect your organization to, okay, we're working on this issue. in pedestrian safety. So maybe we tell stories around why pedestrian safety is so important and how people have felt walking on roads without sidewalks and, you know, doing short videos and things like that. The other point that I like to emphasize is only use platforms that you're comfortable with and that your donors use. You don't have to be on a specific social media platform to share these stories if that's not where your donor base lives. And if they're all If email is really effective, then you can do a video and send it in an email.

Tony MartignettiOkay. Meet them where they are, not where you would like them to be at.

Rosalind ZavrasYeah.

Tony MartignettiOkay. All right. Anything more on that one, on personal stories? I mean, the point is everything, all the work we do affects, impacts people somehow.

Rosalind ZavrasExactly.

Tony MartignettiClimate change, you could say, well, how do I reduce that to a story. But that's a great example too of an advocacy organization that's personalizing, able to personalize. Anything more on that one before we move on?

Rosalind ZavrasNo, I think we can go forward.

Tony MartignettiWhat's next, Roz?

Rosalind ZavrasWell, another good one is to convince—

Tony MartignettiRoz, is Roz okay? Yes. Rosalind?

Rosalind ZavrasBoth.

Tony MartignettiI like them both. Okay. Now I'm using both. All right. Thank you. Thank you.

Rosalind ZavrasAnother great one is to convince. Convey impact. And so, and convey impact in everything that you're doing, not just your emails, but your social media campaigns. When a donor does give, how can you connect their gift to the impact of their dollar, right? And that's more than just saying, thank you for your gift. You donated $5 to the education program. It's rather, this $5 allowed kids to come in and, you know, gain access to to new books so that they can now read after school, right? And a huge part of that is donors are excited about the cause. It's not about your organization. It's about your community and the work that you're doing. So center them in what you're talking about so that they know that they're a part of the solution. Their donation affected change in an area they're excited about.

Tony MartignettiThat could even go back to personalizing the story. Right. Enabled a student like Tony to buy a book, attend a school, whatever, you know.

Rosalind ZavrasYeah, exactly. And a lot of our tips work together.

Tony MartignettiOkay, very good. Yes, they do not stand alone.

Kate MartignettiIt's time for a break. DonorBox. It's the fundraising engine of choice for 50,000 organizations from 96 countries. They've got something new. Now you can accept cashless donations Anytime and anywhere with DonorBox Live Kiosk. Turn your iPad or Android tablet into a kiosk to boost in-person giving. And with their new additions to DonorBox Events, you can sell tickets in 43 currencies and ask your buyers to cover fees. Put these 2 together and your in-person events will take off. DonorBox, helping you. Help others. donorbox.org. Now back to 10 easy ways to boost your fundraising on a budget.

Tony MartignettiRosalind, let's stick with you. Give us another one.

Rosalind ZavrasAnother good one is to test your online donation experience. And so a lot of us, especially in the fundraising space, we know what an online form looks like. We've filled them all out. We know them really well. We don't really have an outsider's perspective into what it looks like to donate. Yeah.

Tony MartignettiAll right.

Rosalind ZavrasSo a really good— and I think this one is actually pretty easy and simple— ask somebody who isn't in fundraising to try and make a donation and give you feedback. And even give them a little rubric to say, you know, here are some questions that we would like you to answer as you're trying to give this donation, and let us know how it looks and feels, and if there are ways that we can improve the experience.

Tony MartignettiOkay. Easy. Yeah. And do it from the outside. Yeah. Easy. Okay. Julia, you got something? It's getting harder now because we're down like number 7 or so.

Julia ToepferYeah.

Tony MartignettiSo there are fewer and fewer left for you to choose from.

Julia ToepferYeah. So testing your assumptions is an important one. Not assuming that you know what works well with people and with your supporters and donors. Making sure that you really use hard data to look at what it is that works for you.

Tony MartignettiAssumptions like what? What assumptions are people, organizations commonly making?

Julia ToepferYeah, so I think like the way that they—

Tony MartignettiRos, feel free to jump in.

Julia ToepferThe way that they interact with your donation page, I think, was something that we touched on. And A/B testing different messages, different ways that people respond to your messaging, but also not testing, trying to test too many things at one time, but doing some A/B testing with messaging and subject lines and things like that.

Rosalind ZavrasYeah, so really to piggyback off that, if you're going to test, do A/B testing on emails, change one thing per email, right? Change the subject line. Maybe have a subject line with emojis and one without emojis and see which one gets opened more. And same with your social media, right? Post on a Monday and then maybe next week post on a Tuesday and see if you're getting different engagement. It doesn't have to be fancy. You don't need to use all these analytics tools. Just create a plan and say, okay, we're going to test this thing now and we're going to test something else later.

Tony MartignettiAnd is there a minimum size that you should have before you're testing, or minimum, let's say, number of emails for validity?

Rosalind ZavrasThere are plenty of content specialists that will probably tell you yes and give you a number. I think you could test with 5 people personally. You can always understand your donors more and understand how they communicate. So I'm a big proponent of no matter your donor base, how big it is, how small it is, you can test and get valuable information.

Tony MartignettiOkay. Go ahead, Julia. You were ticking off some. It's getting harder now. Yeah.

Julia ToepferAre we going to remember

Tony Martignettiall 10?

Julia ToepferI think so. I think we can remember all 10. Timely calls to action is a really important one that is actually really pretty rich because there are a lot of different ways that you can use that effectively. A lot of it relates to urgency and making sure that you're conveying urgency with donations, whether that is around a campaign deadline or an event or a holiday or something, really tying it back to urgency and making sure that people know that it's very important that they give right now and creating that sense really helps to to encourage people to donate.

Rosalind ZavrasIt really also helps with donor acquisition when you have a current event that is directly affecting your cause to then try and create a campaign and language around that as well. The Classy Why America Gives report is really interesting, and according to their survey and their data collection, 60% of donors were likely to give when asked in In relation to a current event.

Tony MartignettiSo using a news hook or something related to your work?

Rosalind ZavrasExactly.

Tony MartignettiOkay. Did you all have stories or cases that you shared, like examples of these in real life? Any of these?

Julia ToepferYeah, I mean, we showed some examples in particular of the way that we show the— or Quantify and show the impact that donations will have, like on a donation page, really equating the way that people's donations, what they'll actually fund and the impact that they'll really have. So we showed some examples of how— Roz mentioned this too, but how, you know, For our organization, $35 provides translation services for a refugee, or $100 provides a legal consultation for a family. So we showed some examples of how you can come to those numbers and conclusions and figure out how to determine the value that donors will see of what they're giving. Okay. their donation actually does. And that really is about starting with numbers and making sure that you can see what it is that— what value as relates to your mission and services, what dollar value might equate to something.

Tony MartignettiTo some impact or some program.

Julia ToepferExactly.

Rosalind ZavrasWell, and also within your organization, you've been able to do timely calls to action because you work in immigration, and unfortunately immigration has been in the news quite a bit, right? So do you see also that cycle of when a news cycle happens, you're getting more engagement?

Julia ToepferYeah, yeah, for sure. And I think the, you know, when not only using the sense of urgency, but when you ask people is also really important. Yes, using things that are happening in our communities and in the news is something that we do quite a lot because our organization does respond directly to some of those— on some of those issues. So yeah, that's something that's really important. We also pretty effectively can use lightboxes and notification bars to really amplify messaging that we're sending out. And making sure that people really see that it, you know, when there's a particular campaign, not all the time, but in a rapid response situation, that can be a really effective strategy for not only donor acquisition but also donor retention.

Tony MartignettiOkay. Who's up to naming the last one or two? I have not been counting, but who's up to naming another one or two that

Rosalind ZavrasConsistent communication is definitely

Tony Martignettiremaining. Yeah.

Rosalind ZavrasAnd again, when I was reading different surveys of donors, you can range anywhere from 53% to 75% of donors will not give again if they receive inconsistent and unclear communication. So it is— this is incredibly important to get right, and it doesn't have to be complicated. One of our best strategies is You know, create a calendar for communicating with donors, and it doesn't have to be on, you know, fancy social media planning calendar. It can just be in your Google Calendar, your Outlook calendar, and share it with everybody on your team that communicates with donors, because this is also really important. If someone in the program team communicates with all of your volunteers who are also probably, a good number of them are donors, and sends them a bunch of emails in a row, and then you tack on and the last email is about a giving campaign, Right. they're going to have email fatigue, right? And so let's make sure everyone in the organization who does talk to donors are on the same page about what our calendar is, and that everybody's using key language that you want. Another really good strategy is to look at all of your platforms online and make sure that the language and the logos are all the same. You know, I can't tell you how many organizations that I start working with, this is one of the first things I do, And then maybe I'll go to a Facebook page and it has the old logo and it has language that doesn't correspond to their website at all. And the nonprofit says, oh well, that was just someone in development and we lost the password and we're, we're not, you know, we're not on Facebook, so we're not going to change it. And I say, you need to change it because it is a public part of your persona. And because these social media platforms are all SEO-linked, They're going— donors are going to find it, and you want to make sure you control the narrative.

Tony MartignettiOkay, excellent. Is there more? Any other strategies? Yeah.

Rosalind ZavrasWell, we had a bonus tip. If we're at—

Tony MartignettiOh, so it was— you got 11 for 10? Yeah. Oh, cool. All right, give us the bonus. Yeah.

Rosalind ZavrasWell, so it wasn't counted in the original 10 because it's not as quote-unquote easy to do, but it can be very effective, and it's creating a peer-to-peer fundraising campaign. And one of the reasons it's not necessarily easy is because it requires a tool, right? It's not necessarily— a lot of our tips and strategies you can implement without needing some sort of fancy technology. You can use the systems you already have. But peer-to-peer really relies on having a peer-to-peer fundraising tool that people can easily access, set up their own campaigns, and get ready to go. It's also, though, really important to arm the To give the donors that are participating in this campaign a ton of marketing material and a ton of training on what it looks like to fundraise for your organization. Just as I was talking about consistently communicating, you want to make sure that your wonderful, well-meaning donors are using the same language that you would use when they're going out to talk about their— your organization with their friends and family.

Tony MartignettiSo give them resources. Yes. We're talking about brand consistency. You were saying, so give them the logo and the colors to use.

Julia ToepferToolkits, messaging.

Tony MartignettiMessaging, right. We were talking about consistent messaging. Yes.

Julia ToepferYeah. And we've even done, starting off really with a small core group of folks. We started it with our board, but even doing a webinar with them to make sure that they understand the process of setting up the peer-to-peer page. And how they see in the system who donated to them and how they thank them and how they keep track of all of that. So really, one of the things that makes it a little bit more of a complicated tip is that it does require quite a lot of effort, at least to get off the ground.

Tony MartignettiOkay. And as Ros said, you need a platform.

Julia ToepferSure.

Tony MartignettiIs there a platform that the two of you like to use? Is one of them preferred over the others? You could shout it out. What's the difference?

Julia ToepferWell, I think one of the things that we talked about that's really great is if you are just getting started, to piggyback off of foundations or other organizations in your community that are doing giving days. They often will provide the infrastructure for you to use, and you can test out the tool and, you know, a peer-to-peer tool in the process that way. So you don't necessarily have to have your own in order to participate in those ways through a community giving day or something. So that's a really great one.

Rosalind ZavrasAnd I like to stay as platform agnostic as possible because it depends on your team and your donors as to which one makes the most sense. Do you have very tech-savvy donors? who are really excited to go in and make changes? Or do you have donors that want something that's plug and play because they don't really understand how to use these tools and they're just excited to go out and fundraise for you? So, you know, there are amazing platforms out there, but I really always start with who is your team and who are your donors?

Tony MartignettiOkay. Do you think we hit all 10 plus the bonus one?

Julia ToepferI did remember one about matching.

Rosalind ZavrasOh, that's right.

Julia ToepferMatching grants and matching gifts. And so we talked about how, you know, a lot of— it's not great to leave money on the table. We talked about employer, particularly employer matching gifts, but then also if you are— again, this is a little bit more complicated, but if you are a for kind of recruiting matching grants from donors or companies or foundations, that that's another thing that can work really, really well, particularly in a campaign situation where you can say, you know, all donations up to $20,000 will be matched dollar for dollar until midnight, thanks to XYZ donor.

Rosalind ZavrasAnd when we say leave money on the table, according to Double the Donation, they've researched this, and $4 to $7 billion a year goes unclaimed in matching gifts. And that is money that is just left on the table by all of us.

Tony MartignettiJust let the company, let your employer know that you donated and fill out their simple form.

Rosalind ZavrasExactly.

Tony MartignettiAnd they'll send the same, or whatever their match ratio is.

Rosalind ZavrasYeah. And even I've seen reports that up to 40% of Fortune 500 companies now have a volunteer match program as well, which means if you have a volunteer base, and maybe they haven't donated, but they work for one of those bigger companies, you should also talk to those volunteers and see if they can talk to their company and if they'll match some of the time that they've donated.

Tony MartignettiOh, so it's the company providing another volunteer to piggyback on the employee That's already volunteering for the organization?

Rosalind ZavrasNo, it's the company writing a check equivalent to that person's time.

Tony MartignettiOh, oh, it's giving cash equivalent to the volunteer time? Oh, wow.

Rosalind ZavrasAnd this has been a very effective strategy for one of my clients because they have a mentor program, and all of their mentors are volunteers from large tech companies. And so they get often written checks from those employers saying, oh, I'm so happy my employee participated in your program. Here's a check for their time.

Tony MartignettiDamn. So 20 hours in a month or something, or 20 hours in a year, it was more like somebody donated 20 hours in a year and the employer will pay the nonprofit the value of that 20 hours.

Rosalind ZavrasRight.

Tony MartignettiOkay. Excellent. All right. Never heard of that. What is that called? Volunteer— Volunteer matching. All right. It's aptly named. All right. Okay. So anything else? Anything? We probably— well, I don't want to let you off the hook. We may have named all 11, but did we?

Rosalind ZavrasI think so.

Tony MartignettiConfident?

Rosalind ZavrasWell, like I said, they're all super intertwined. Yeah. So we covered them all. I don't know if we named them.

Tony MartignettiIn one way or another. Okay. All right. All right. Fair enough, Ros. All right. You're— one of your outcomes, tried and true fundraising tips. From other nonprofit professionals. Do those come from the audience, or— I mean, you two are already in a nonprofit, so is that redundant? I don't know. Are the tips coming from you two or from the audience?

Rosalind ZavrasBoth and. We had really good audience participation, and they gave some of the tips that they use.

Tony MartignettiSo let's bring them in. So share some, please.

Rosalind ZavrasWell, one organization mentioned that they have a threshold at over $350. That's when they start calling people. And that for them has also been incredibly effective. They just pick up the phone and they give donors a call if they've reached that amount. And that also helps them manage it a little bit because then they're not necessarily calling everybody, but they know that that's their threshold. My recommendation though is even under that $350, take a sampling maybe and occasionally call them as well.

Tony MartignettiOr like whatever you, whatever you think you have the bandwidth for.

Rosalind ZavrasExactly.

Tony MartignettiIf $50 is a big donation for you, then maybe that's your threshold if you can manage it. If you can— okay. All right. You got another one that came from the audience?

Julia ToepferYeah. Another one that somebody shared was that they crowdsource stories from their participants and collect them and share them out in monthly emails. And they share a few stories in each email. In that, the person's words who submitted the story, and it might include a photo, but it's all coming pretty much directly from the participants themselves. And they mentioned that they put a fundraising, a donate button, not even a hard ask, but just a donate button in the bottom of those emails, and it generates quite a lot of donations just from this one email that shares these stories. That's great. impact stories from folks who have participated in the services. And even with a soft ask, they get a great return on those.

Rosalind ZavrasThat also reminds me, another tip, and an audience member echoed this, was around lapsed donors. So going back to segmenting your donors, if you can segment who has lapsed, then reaching out directly to them and talking to them and saying, hi, we've missed you, or, you know, here's information about our programming again, Targeting lapsed donors specifically has had great returns, both for my clients as well as the woman that came and spoke.

Tony MartignettiAnd targeting them more digitally or email?

Rosalind ZavrasYeah, just having direct language to them that says like, thank you for your support, we, we miss you, can you come back, or here's what we've been up to. Especially if you have lapsed donors that have been away for 5 years, 10 years, you can use that as a great opportunity to say, This is everything that's changed in the organization in that time. And sometimes they just forgot that they haven't donated. And so reaching out to them and communicating with them in that way will help jog their memory and say, oh yeah, I love what you're doing. Yes, I'll donate again.

Tony MartignettiAnd I didn't realize that I had stopped. Right. And you found success even going back that far? Yes. Going back 10 years?

Rosalind ZavrasVery successful, actually.

Tony MartignettiOkay, interesting, because that's typically— I think folks will like do 1 or 2, maybe 3 years lapsed, but you found success going back as far as 10? Mm-hmm. Okay, okay.

Rosalind ZavrasAnd again, it's about targeting the communication, right? So you would target a 10-year lapsed donor differently than a 1-year lapsed donor. The 1-year lapsed donor might have just— their credit card expired or something changed, and that's why they haven't given. Whereas the 10-year lapsed donor, they're probably aware they're not giving to your organization anymore, so use this as an opportunity to talk to them again about What maybe their life has changed? What are their priorities? Again, get to know them and say, hey, you know, we loved your support. Is there something that we can do to get that back?

Tony MartignettiOkay, awesome. All right, any other, any other pros from, um, tips from either one of you two professionals or that came from the audience? Trying to immerse listeners in the, in the session experience. Okay.

Julia ToepferThose are the ones that are— Okay.

Tony MartignettiI don't want to put you on the spot. Rosalind, why don't you leave us with inspirational thoughts around easier ways to boost your fundraising, the value of all these things we just talked about?

Rosalind ZavrasWell, and again, donors are excited about the work that you're doing. So when we talk about to boost your fundraising. It's about honestly just connecting with them and having them connect with your organization in fun, interesting, and personalized ways.

Tony MartignettiRosalind Zavras, CEO, Aropa Consulting, and Julia Toepfer, Senior Marketing and Digital Engagement Strategist at National Immigrant Justice Center. Rosalind, Roz, Julia, thank you very much. Thanks for sharing. Thanks for sharing.

Julia ToepferIt was fun.

Tony MartignettiAnd thank you for being with Nonprofit Radio coverage of 23 NTC, where we are sponsored by Heller Consulting, technology strategy and implementation for nonprofits. Thanks for being with us.

Kate MartignettiIt's time for Tony's Take Two.

Tony MartignettiThank you, Kate. Have you got feedback? You know, I'm always interested in your opinion of Nonprofit Radio. It might be an individual show or a guest or topics that resonate with you, or some topic that you think was off topic, didn't, didn't really belong on the show. You know, it might be this week's show, it might be next week's, next month, next year, anytime. I'm, I'm interested. In your opinion, I'm interested in your feedback. I welcome it. Positive, negative, good, bad. I can take it. It'll be okay. I'll be fine. I am genuinely interested in what you think about what you're listening to week after week. And the best way to get feedback to me is either the contact page at tonymartinetti.com. Or just email me tony@tonymartignetti.com. Kate?

Kate MartignettiThat is Tony's Take Two. We've got beaucoup but loads more time. Here is Personalized Fundraising at Scale.

Tony MartignettiWelcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio coverage of 23NTC, our continuing coverage of the 2023 Nonprofit Technology Conference at the Colorado Convention Center in Denver, where we are sponsored by Heller Consulting, technology strategy and implementation for nonprofits. With me now is Joe Frye, Account Group Director for Nonprofit and Cause at Town Hall Agency, and Peter Yagecic, Vice President of Innovation at Town Hall Agency. Joe, Peter, welcome to Nonprofit Radio.

Peter YagecicThanks for having us. Thanks, Tony.

Tony MartignettiAnd my welcome also to the, to the teams at Town Hall Agency. What, Peter, what is Town Hall Agency about?

Peter YagecicTown Hall Agency is an agency that is focused on the nonprofit and higher education sectors, and it's a full-service digital agency. We have been kind of evolved and grown out of our parent company, which is Situation Group. And Town Hall, we have really brought a lot of folks on board to grow that brand for us, and Joe can speak a little bit more to that, but it is an outgrowth of the work that we've been doing for a lot of our clients that care about creating passionate communities and really making sure that we're making impact in the work that we're doing.

Tony MartignettiYour session topic together is Personalized Fundraising at Scale, a How-To Discussion. So we're going to talk about the how-to of personalized fundraising at scale. Joe, what could nonprofits be doing a little better, it sounds like, with personalization?

Joe FryeYeah, it's a great question. I mean, you know, I think when we look at the data, already about 60% of nonprofits are doing some sort of personalization, right? It's the at scale that we're really talking about. talking about. And it really, to me and to Peter, we were talking about this, it doesn't necessarily start with the tech stack. It's more of a mindset. And how do we break down the silos within nonprofits so that we're not personalizing one channel at a time, but we're personalizing a whole ecosystem?

Tony MartignettiOkay. And so you're encouraging us to go beyond the hello, first name email, and Assuming that, oh, we've— we're personalizing, right? We use people's first names in emails.

Peter YagecicIt's not a bad place to start, but, but it's really growing from that and kind of thinking about the subtle ways that you can do personalization across multiple different channels. So not just saying, okay, one and done, we do it here, we've ticked that box, but how can we always be thinking about increasing that level of personalization? Because we see that constituents respond to that. They, they actually— they have a tendency to give more when personalization is

Tony MartignettiSo, Peter, how far can we go? What's a better definition of personalization?

Peter YagecicWell, I think there's a lot that's coming out right now in thinking how this is going to impact every single part of our lives. I think we're being personalized to in ways that we don't even realize every single day. And one of the things that we talked about in our panel was how can we make sure that we're always doing a feedback loop of the data that we have. We have first-party data about the people we're communicating to, and then that— the second piece is really making sure that all of that data is consistent, cleaned up, deduplicated. Not the, the most fun part of the job, but that really allows you to then take action on what you know and then always be listening when you're continuing that conversation with your constituents. They're giving you feedback on how they open their emails, when they do that, And the kinds of things, the things that they're reading on your website. So always make sure there's a feedback loop to not just rest on your laurels about what you think you know, but how are you continuing to learn about those people as you evolve in that relationship with them.

Tony MartignettiYou mentioned that we're always being personalized too. I mean, I'm thinking of any of the online retailers. Yep. You know, customers who looked at what you looked at, looked at these other things, people who bought what you bought, bought these other things. People who bought what you bought, bought these other things with those. I mean, these things pair together.

Peter YagecicRight.

Tony MartignettiWe know this is your preferred address, you know, so in those types of ways, is that what you mean?

Peter YagecicYeah, the example that we used in our—

Tony MartignettiThat's just one example, retail, online retail.

Peter YagecicYeah, the example we used in our presentation was about kind of online streaming platforms. They're all vying for our $8 a month right now, and the ones that are making sure that they know what we like and giving us those recommendations from their content library, those are the ones that are going to have that competitive edge. So I think we see it a lot in the for-profit world that that personalization is kind of survival of the fittest. But then, you know, the challenge is how do we adapt that for nonprofits when we're not putting those up against each other in a competitive way, but we're hoping that we can just make sure that we have the best relationship with our constituents?

Tony MartignettiI just got an email yesterday that HBO Max is becoming

Peter YagecicI saw that.

Tony MartignettiThat's an interesting branding. I would've thought HBO Max would be better, keeping their name front and center, but let's—

Peter YagecicThere's people in a room that have paid a lot of money to make that decision.

Tony MartignettiOkay, fine. So look for that big change. So do we need some infrastructure? I mean, we need to be able to capture and preserve and then coalesce the data that you're talking about? Either one of you. Yeah, absolutely. We need some infrastructure backend before we can personalize at scale?

Joe FryeI mean, I think one of the things that Peter and I have spent a lot of time thinking about is what you do actually need, right? You need data, you need a tech stack, you need a website, you need an email platform, you need something like that. But really, it's organization, right? It's a little bit of time. And in our panel, I talked about an example with a client a couple years ago where we spent 2 hours a month tagging their data for 4 months, and we had enough data to then personalize everything to them.

Tony MartignettiThat's not much time, 2 hours in a month?

Joe FryeYeah, it wasn't much time at all, right? And we didn't ask them for new technology, we used what they were using. And so I think there are ways to do it. It's why we like to say that yes, it can be a tech stack, but really it's a mindset.

Peter YagecicAnd I think unless you've built your own technology from the ground up, chances are there are features within the tech that you use today that you don't know how to use or that you're just not using to the extent because those platforms are always improving.

Tony MartignettiTags, attributes.

Peter YagecicSegments. Yeah,

Tony Martignettisegments. What else are these things commonly called across different platforms? Anything else

Peter Yagecicthat— There's a lot that falls under like marketing automation. You know, I think there are More and more platforms that can identify the best time to send, not just for your entire audience, but based on you. You know, when do you tend to engage with those emails? And then when I hit send for that, you know, maybe it'll hold that email until it knows when Tony is going to open it, and it'll deliver to you at the right time. So it's just at scale being able to—

Tony MartignettiThat exists?

Peter YagecicIt does exist.

Tony MartignettiYou didn't just describe something that you're dreaming of developing?

Peter YagecicI think it exists. Otherwise, I'm going to go off and trademark something. But no, that exists today. Absolutely.

Joe FryeAnd they exist in tools kind of upstream and downstream, right? Like, not just the really expensive tools, but also the more achievable, approachable tools.

Tony MartignettiOkay. So folks may already have this, these resources. You just have to exploit them.

Peter YagecicThat's right.

Tony MartignettiBecause I'm thinking of, I use Mailchimp for my company emails and blasts for the podcast. There are, there's like send time optimization. I don't know if it's including optimizing for me, but it's including optimizing for the folks I'm sending to. And I'm not even thinking about segments. I could segment the audience and then segment and then send time optimization for the different segments. I'm just doing it in one group. All right.

Joe FryeAnd right, that's part of when we define personalization, that's part of what we're talking about, right? Like a lot of people think personalization one-to-one. Ultimately, we'll get there. But like, let's start in a smaller phase of personalization, one to a persona. One to a group of people. Yeah. And let's build our confidence there. And I think a lot of it is kind of— it sounds so big and intimidating, and, you know, we have all this data and we're going to get lost in that data. But when we break it down and we really try to crawl, walk, run a personalized approach, we can do it in ways that everybody gets on board. We can start to break down some of those silos and barriers inside of organizations and bring everybody to the table.

Tony MartignettiNo, clearly. And then it doesn't become awareness because we're reassuring folks that a lot of what they need is already in place. Yeah, it's just exploiting it.

Joe FryeYeah,

Peter Yagecicyeah. And, and I think the, the subtlety of how you approach it and how you start that, that crawl phase— I think we've all gotten that email that was personalized to us, but maybe it had the wrong name, or it had the first name tag instead of our actual name. And you may— I equate that to, uh, if a romantic partner calls you by the wrong name, you might forgive that, but you're never gonna forget that moment. So So how can we be thinking about personalizing things in a subtle way where it's just enhancing what we know about you, but we're kind of mitigating that risk of maybe, you know, as all technology does from time to time, you know, makes a mistake. But that's really where that second stage we were talking about before of making sure that your data is constantly sanitized, up to date, clean, and consistent.

Tony MartignettiAre there other examples that we can give folks of different types of Personalization?

Joe FryeYeah. So I, like, I think there are a couple of things we can do personalization-wise. One is we can personalize to the content. So, um, right, HubSpot came out a couple years ago now with the stat, uh, that they have dynamic CTAs built into their platform. Uh, and so essentially the CTA changes based on your data. Uh, and they came out and said it converts 202% better than a static one. That's a huge number. But what are we actually personalizing that to? Is it the story that it appears underneath, right? So our ask is based on whatever the blog post topic is and like what was able to help that person in that impact story? Or are we personally personalizing it to the fact that Tony donated $100 last month, now we want him to donate $120 because we want him to donate 20% more? So what are we really personalizing to is a good, good place to start.

Tony MartignettiOkay.

Joe FryeYou know, one of the things that I've spent a lot of time with is working with organizations that have gift catalogs and how to activate a gift catalog across a blog to then have a CTA that isn't even dynamic, it's static, but it's written in the same way that the ask in the gift catalog is. So that way everything ties together. So regardless of which channel somebody is engaging with you with or what the ask is, everybody is on the same page about what that actual ask is going to be, and it feels more personal. Okay.

Tony MartignettiPeter, other examples?

Peter YagecicYeah, well, I think one of the things that Joe and I were having some conversations around, and I know he's done some campaigns with this, personalized video is something that's becoming more and more attainable without, you know, breaking the bank really. There are a lot of services that you can work with to have different videos stitched together. They could include things like your donation history, or just an appeal to you, or really just include segments, you know, as part of that B-roll of things that we know that are important to you. So when you're thinking about a video campaign or an end-of-year appeal, you can actually start to use more and more tools that every piece of that campaign have some level of personalization going on.

Tony MartignettiAre there any video platforms that you can shout out or recommend as a potential resource?

Joe FryeWe like Idomo.

Tony MartignettiAll right, spell it please.

Joe FryeI-D-O-M-O-O.

Tony MartignettiI-D-O-M-O-O. Idomo. Yeah, idomo.com.

Joe Fryeidomo.com.

Tony MartignettiOkay.

Joe FryeThey do a great job, uh, really connecting in, um, to a database, uh, or uploaded Excel docs.

Tony MartignettiAnd so the, the video— so Peter, you're saying that like the B-roll can change based on the data that's in your CRM?

Joe FryeYep. Yeah,

Tony Martignettithat's incredible.

Joe FryeThe B-roll, the music, The ask, everything, right? So everything is a data point. And it doesn't really change your production process that much. Their system has an After Effects plugin that a lot of producers and editors are already using After Effects to produce videos. And so you define what the personalization is, what the element is, and then you create all the different assets to that.

Tony MartignettiBut to your point, both of you, you could start with maybe, maybe start with first name.

Joe FryeYeah.

Tony MartignettiAnd maybe giving history or something like that. Start simple. Don't, you know, you don't have to be Martin Scorsese to produce your first one.

Joe FryeYeah.

Tony MartignettiBut explore it. Okay, I do move.

Joe FryeAnd I think like also, right, if you even wanted to explore it at a higher level, when somebody makes a donation, right, you know what they clicked on before they donated typically, right? You're going to know if they came from an email article, from a blog post, from something. And so if you take that and you say, you know what, I'm going to follow up with a personal thank you from somebody that benefited from a donation like this or from our president and CEO or from somebody on our team, and I'm only going to show them stories and content around the topic that they actually donated to, it's a nice way to personalize in a very subtle way. So it's not actually saying, thanks, Tony, for your donation of X, but it's saying, thank you for your support. With a personalized aspect, and then also showing them other stories, other impact that you have in that segment.

Tony MartignettiRelated to what they gave to. Yeah. These are great examples. What other examples have we got?

Peter YagecicWell, on the media buying side, there's a lot of conversations we're having around dynamic creative. So this idea of dynamic creative that when you're building out your, let's say it's your display ad, you have a few different versions that you upload into a system, and then that system can, based on targeting as media has always done, but it can also, you know, know where you are geographically, and it can say, you know, here's an opportunity for you in your area, and it will show you something different because you've set up the rules to do that. It takes a— it does take a change of workflow. The tools are getting cheaper, but it does require your team to maybe work in a way that they haven't done in the past, in a non-waterfall way of saying, okay, we're going to put this ask out to the designer to get back the assets, and then we're not going to talk to them again. Well, we may need to go back to that designer and say, you know what, we need another variation that can achieve this thing that we're trying to target, so can we get a few more from you? And it's just really about making sure that the team is having that communication, and there's a muscle within the organization to be able to adapt to that.

Joe FryeYeah.

Tony MartignettiAnd you were talking about media buying. What are some What are some examples you're thinking of, Peter?

Peter YagecicWell, just like the ads that we see.

Tony MartignettiSearch buying? Search ads?

Peter YagecicSearch ads, display ads, yeah.

Tony MartignettiOkay.

Joe FryeAnd search ads, it's built into Google Ads from the start, right? They have the dynamic ads and they optimize for you using AI, but you can also optimize by location and some platforms allow you to kind of put together other assets.

Tony MartignettiOkay.

Joe FryeI mean, I also think about, As just another example, thinking about communication channel preference and frequency. For some reason, I don't know why, my mom will not text me, but she Facebook messages me. And I can't get her to text me, but her preferred channel is Facebook Messenger. And so, you know, with donors, they all have a preferred channel and a communication frequency that they want to hear from you, and it's okay to ask for that.

Tony MartignettiYeah, simple surveys. Yeah. How do you, how do you like us to be in touch with you?

Joe FryeYeah.

Peter YagecicAnd you mentioned Mailchimp a little while ago, Tony, as something that you use.

Tony MartignettiYeah.

Peter YagecicThe survey tools are built into that platform as well. So you can deploy an email that links you right to a survey on the same platform, and then that survey will automatically update those tags on that constituent that you already have. That's beautiful. So it's both. You can— the tools have never been better to integrate those different tools, but some of those tools are actually adding within themselves to give you even more.

Tony MartignettiAny other examples you want to share? Did you do your session already, or is it coming up? Yeah, I just did. Any other examples that came from maybe questions, or that you shared? No holding out on Nonprofit Radio listeners.

Joe FryeYeah, yeah, no, we, you know, we talked a little bit about chatbots, a little bit about automation. Good. Or across social platforms, right? I've used in the past multiple platforms, but I really like ManyChat as an example, where you can actually set up triggers so somebody that likes a post or somebody that comments on one of your posts gets a message sent to them through WhatsApp or any of the Facebook ecosystem Messenger-wise. And it's just a nice way to kind of build that communication back and forth in that network in a not really Really creepy way, right? Like, everybody wants to be engaged with, or if they don't, they tell you they don't want to. But it's often a nice way to kind of automate some of that when we're thinking about how we can do it at scale.

Tony MartignettiThat's interesting. All right, so somebody liked or commented on a post.

Joe FryeYeah,

Tony MartignettiI don't know, just a like and then they get something?

Joe FryeThey could. I mean, you can set up whatever rules you want, right? Okay, maybe it's 3 likes, 4 likes.

Tony MartignettiThat sounds a little creepy to me. Yeah, maybe, right? Yeah, a couple, a couple of engagements.

Joe FryeYeah, and I think that's where, like, you know, I think a common theme, especially at this conference, but that we often see is always be testing. And it's, what really is that? You know, is it after 5 likes somebody is likely to want to engage with you more and they're looking for feedback from you? Or is it after 10? Like, what really does that donor journey look like? And I know everybody's is a little bit different, but—

Peter YagecicAnd I think, Joe, you alluded to this in our panel, but when you're engaging When constituents are supporting a nonprofit, they see that relationship as very personal. If they're going to give you their money, it's usually because it's something that they believe in, they support your cause. So, so we find a lot of times people are looking— you said it might seem a little creepy, but we, we find that people that are willing to give often want to engage in a dialogue. So it's just about making sure that we're engaging with them in the right way. They don't just hear from us, you know, once a year when we need money. We're making sure to to put information in front of them that we know is important for them based on what they've said to us before.

Tony MartignettiIt was just that one example of the single like, like single thumbs up, and then I get a message on WhatsApp.

Peter YagecicWell, yeah, and, you know, we touched very briefly, you know, on AI, what AI is going to be doing to the world of personalization. I was at a talk recently from Amy Webb from the Future Today Institute, and she said we used to search the internet, and we're getting to a point where the internet's now searching us. So just everybody buckle your seatbelts in terms of what's going to be happening in our worlds around the kinds of messaging that we're hearing from all the new AI that's coming online.

Tony MartignettiWhat does she mean by that, the internet searching us?

Peter YagecicWell, all the signals that we're putting out into the world about our preferences, what we like, that, you know, in the best case scenario, you have a dedicated team that's looking at those and making sense of them and figuring out a strategy that works to communicate. But when you just, you know, we're getting to a point where a lot of tools are being unleashed that haven't been tested before. So, you know, what was the micro response time from how someone moved their mouse from the bottom of the screen to the top? Oh, geez. Does that have an indication of maybe a health issue that they're dealing with? And you just, it doesn't take long to go into some really black holes Oh my God,

Tony Martignettithere's trillions and trillions and quadrillions of

Peter Yagecicdata. We're all putting out data, yeah.

Joe FryeAnd I think that's the thing, right? Like, data— the amount of data can be scary, right? Like, oh, I have to analyze all this data. Um, from a personalized standpoint, where Peter and I kind of start is you don't have to analyze everything. Let's make a hypothesis, right? Like, do people care more about where you do your work? Do they care more about the aspect of what you're doing? Like, what do they really care most about, and let's try to just collect data around that and organize that data first and see if that's actually what they care about, and then move on from there.

Peter YagecicYeah, and don't be afraid to act. I think it's possible in an overwhelming sea of information to become paralyzed, but, but know that at the end of the day, the goal is to try something and see what impact that has, see if it moves the needle, and make sure you're paying attention to those performance indicators to make sure what you want to do is actually happening.

Tony MartignettiSo staying short of the microseconds that it takes to move the mouse, but how can we collect on our own some of this, some of this, some of the data that can be then used for personalization at scale?

Joe FryeYeah. Well, to go back a little bit about the data piece, right? Like, let's take a step back and think about why personalization really matters and like why it started in the more commercial world. First, there's a data point out there that says every second it takes me to think about where I'm at on a website and to act, take the next step, there's a 10% drop-off for every second. So 10% plus 10% plus 10%, right? Yeah. And so it's easy to see how somebody can go from clicking on an ad, a search ad, a Google Grants ad, something like that, to a website that takes a couple seconds to load, to where you went from somebody who was going to give to you, to now there's a 50% chance, right? Because you're 5, 6, 7 seconds in by that time. And so personalization really started as a way to remove friction, which is what people often are looking for. And we know that people are really interacting with organizations across channels, across platforms. Maybe it starts with a friend's post on IG or LinkedIn sharing a success story, and you click on that and you're interested and you sign up for a new newsletter, and then you get a newsletter, and you kind of read another blog post, and you kind of build your relationship over multiple channels. But when we think about the data that you can collect, right, it's— what if you're collecting, like, the last step? Google Analytics has a previous step metric. So everybody that goes to your donation page that converts, what was the previous step that they were on? What was the content? Let's analyze that content. Yeah. Let's see what looks good about it. Is it a 1,000-word blog post? Is it a video that was embedded? Is it the ask itself was $50 and we know you actually only gave $25? Why did you only give $25? We can start to look at some of that data. And within email, right, we can see what you're clicking on, open rates. Platforms like Mailchimp and HubSpot and Constant Contact, they all do that on an individual email record. So you can actually start to see, and when we do these and we start tagging, we say, let's start with email, right? And let's figure out if we're tagging around topics, what tags are people clicking on? Like, are people only clicking on an article about X, or are they only clicking on articles about Y? And let's start to segment those and build out more detailed personas just from an email engagement, because they've given you their information. They've said they want to hear from you. They're going to engage with you, likely. And it's just an easy way for us to start there and then expand it out to multiple channels.

Tony MartignettiEverything you just named is eminently doable if you're using the most basic email service.

Peter YagecicYeah.

Tony MartignettiPeter?

Peter YagecicTo go back to, I think, the idea of being a good steward of that data, treating it responsibly, not only because legally you have to, and more and more laws are coming out to say, you know, This is how governments are protecting all of our data every single day, but also listening, listening to your constituents, letting them know, we alluded to this earlier, letting them know why we want that information and how we intend to use it. We really just wanna deepen our relationship with you. We wanna make sure we're landing in your inbox at the right time when we have something to say and when we think this is gonna be important to our relationship. And we're listening to you if you wanna come to us and say, you know what, I need a break. I need to, you know, I want to change our relationship. And being responsive to that. It's not— so that's not just the technology and, you know, all of the checkboxes we're all familiar with when you hit the unsubscribe button on an email and it takes you to that form and it's like, why are you leaving? That's kind of very cold. You have to do that, but also because privacy laws require outreach and you have to be listening to that. You have to have, in most states, a phone number and an email address where people can reach out to you and say, tell me what you know about me. And at our organization, we listen and we look at every single one of those and we treat them with respect and we treat them as we would want to be treated if we were reaching out to somebody else who had our data.

Joe FryeAnd again, that's process, right? That's not necessarily technology. It's a process internally. And that's part of the reason we say personalization is a mindset.

Tony MartignettiYeah, yeah. Peter, can we go further? So Joe identified, you know, like I was saying, data that's eminently collectible. You could start tomorrow, just turn on some analytics, or just go back and look at data that's already been collected. What would be a next step in terms of data that we could collect, or methods that we could use to collect data for more personalization?

Peter YagecicWell, I think the way we think about it is, is maybe reversed a little bit. We want to start with what, what is the outcome that we're looking for and how do we get there? Because I think it can be really tempting to just say, let's plug another data source into the machine and see what happens. And I, I think that's what you're seeing a lot with a lot of the large language models that are pervading and coming out in the AI world right now. It's let's just hook up everything that everybody said on Reddit and see what happens. And I think as an organization, we don't want to be— we don't want to collect something that we don't need to have to make the relationship better. Okay. It's very tempting to say, like, oh, look, we can get 50 more data points. But if you don't have a plan for that, then you're just kind of bloating your systems, and you're risking having more than you need. So I think it's, how do we— what is the end goal that we want? How do we want that constituent to feel at the end of this relationship? And then what do we need to get there? And let's not overindulge.

Tony MartignettiYeah, very good point. All right. What else from your session that we haven't talked about yet? We still have some time if there's more we can talk about.

Peter YagecicWell, I think we were really encouraged by some of the conversations Oh,

Tony Martignettiquestions. Yeah. What questions came or what— yeah. You know, I think— Well, Peter started— wait, stop cutting Peter off, Joe.

Peter YagecicHe can cut me off.

Tony MartignettiStop that. Anytime he wants. Peter's the Vice President.

Peter YagecicNo, I'm just here to make Joe look good. That's my job today, honest to God.

Tony MartignettiI don't know. I see Director— wait, what was it? Vice President and Group Director.

Joe FryeYeah.

Tony MartignettiSo Peter's the Vice President. All right. No, I'm not trying to create any tension within the group. Town Hall Agency. I tried to start a fight. Okay, yes, right, right.

Peter YagecicIt's good podcasting.

Tony MartignettiWhat else came from— yeah, to get Joe Rogan's numbers right, I can start going to fisticuffs. What else came from audience feedback, whether questions or comments after privately? What stuck with you?

Peter YagecicI think one of the things that stuck with me was going back to what Joe was saying. It's not just about the technology and making sure I'm sure the gears are spinning, but oftentimes in organizations, it's about the human work of getting teams that are all focusing on their own individual piece of it, who are very proud of the work that they do, to come together and have a conversation and understand what the bigger goal is. Mm-hmm. So, we all have egos. We all want to be told we're doing a good job, and if my part of the machine is working, I'm going to call it a day. Don't bring me into a meeting to tell me how I have to change something. Because now so-and-so, what I'm doing is working. But to really achieve something like personalization at scale, it does require getting people into a room together and almost having kind of like a professional therapy session and saying, this is where we're trying to go with our— imagine if we had a system that looked like this. Now, we're not saying anybody in the room is preventing us from doing that, but we know that we're only going to get there together by cooperating and finding a new way to break down those silos that exist today. And how we do that needs to be respectful of everybody who wants to show up, and it's going to be key to making that happen.

Tony MartignettiOkay. Very good. Very good perspective. Anything else that struck you from the questions? Anything else audience-related? Questions, comments that—

Joe FryeYeah. I mean, I think there were really 2 things. One, kind of Piggybacking a little bit on that, we spent some time talking about making sure that when you're collecting KPIs to see if personalization is a success, right? When you're starting small, like, what are you actually looking at? If you personalize the subject line of an email, the primary KPI shouldn't be a donation. It should be an email open, right? And so when we start to have these leading indicators that are kind of micro metrics that we're looking at, we can start We start to get more people on board because we're then sharing the same language with them, right? We spend a lot of time talking about just how different people perceive different words. Awareness, for instance, right? Like, when we run an awareness campaign as an agency, we're thinking it's brand lift, right? The action is, does somebody remember your organization name and what you do? But oftentimes when organizations come to us and they say, we want an awareness campaign, They actually mean they want somebody who doesn't know them to take an action. And it's a small difference, but it does change, one, the metrics that we're tracking, and two, the type of media buy that we do and kind of how we message that. And so I think it's important, like, all teams have slightly different language or slightly different connotation of a certain word. And so getting everybody, like Peter said, in a therapy session at the beginning to kind of define everything that we're going to talk about, everything that we're going to do is a really important key step, and it starts with KPIs.

Peter YagecicAnd just because you think something may seem obvious, don't assume that everybody in that larger group when they get together is necessarily going to click on everything. And an example I often use is, in the world of technology, a developer means one thing, someone who codes software. In the world of nonprofits, development is raising money. So just that assumption, if you're going off on a tangent about something and there are people in the room who maybe haven't worked together before, don't assume that everybody's using the exact same dictionary.

Tony MartignettiI work in development.

Peter YagecicYeah, right. What kind? Oh, good. Build me a website. Yeah. No, no, no, not that kind, the other kind.

Tony MartignettiAll right, leave it there. Does that sound good?

Joe FryeYeah.

Tony MartignettiAll right. They are Joe Frye, Account Group Director for Nonprofit and Cause, Town Hall Agency, and Peter Yagecic, Vice President of Innovation at Town Hall Agency. Just to foment a little We're gonna take it off the,

Peter Yagecicoff the

Tony Martignettimic. Thank you very much for sharing.

Peter YagecicThanks. Thanks, Tony.

Joe FryeThanks for having us.

Tony MartignettiJoe, Peter, thank you very much. Yeah, it was great. And thank you for being with Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio coverage of the 2023 Nonprofit Technology Conference, where we are sponsored by Heller Consulting, technology strategy and implementation for nonprofits. Thanks for being with me.

Kate MartignettiNext week, we wrap up our '23 NTC coverage with Communications and development teams working better together.

Tony MartignettiIf

Kate Martignettiyou missed any part of this week's

Tony Martignettishow, I beseech you, find it at tonymartignetti.com.

Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by DonorBox. With intuitive fundraising software from DonorBox, your donors give 4 times faster, helping you help others. donorbox.org. Our creative producer is Claire Meyerhoff. I'm your announcer, Kate Martignetti. The show's social media is by Susan Chavez. Marc Silverman is our web guy, and this music is by Scott Stein.

Tony MartignettiThank you for that affirmation, Scotty. Be with us next week for Nonprofit Radio, Big Nonprofit Ideas for the Other 99%. Go out and be great. Go out and be great.

Nonprofit Radio

More Episodes from 2023 Nonprofit Technology Conference

View All
Misty McLaughlinAlice Hendricks
EP 649July 16, 2023

Communications & Development Teams Working Better Together

with Misty McLaughlin and Alice Hendricks

Claire Taylor HansenJennifer Daw HollowayJohn CooganJ. Michael Fisher
EP 647July 2, 2023

Brand Democracy & What To Avoid When Selecting Your Next CRM

with Claire Taylor Hansen, Jennifer Daw Holloway, John Coogan, and J. Michael Fisher

Julia Campbell
EP 646June 26, 2023

Data Driven Storytelling

with Julia Campbell

1 / 4