The High Growth Nonprofit


About this episode
Matt Scott returns to talk us through his new book, “The High Growth Nonprofit.” He urges you to shed the 5% growth mindset and plan for exponential growth with your rapid growth plan. Matt is CEO of CauseMic.
My Guest
Here’s the transcript
Tony MartignettiHello and welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. I'm your aptly named host of your favorite hebdomadal podcast, and oh, I'm glad you're with me. I'd get slapped with a diagnosis of jeromorphism if you made me lose my mind because you missed this week's show. The High Growth Nonprofit. Matt Scott returns to talk us through his new book, The High Growth Nonprofit. He urges you to shed the 5% growth mindset and plan for exponential growth with your rapid growth plan. Matt is CEO of CauseMic. On Tony's Take Two, 23 NTC shows coming. We're sponsored by DonorBox. With intuitive fundraising software from DonorBox, your donors give 4 times faster. Helping you help others. donorbox.org. Here is The High Growth Nonprofit. It's my pleasure to welcome back Matt Scott to Nonprofit Radio. He is CEO and co-founder of CauseMic, a Portland, Oregon-based consultancy helping nonprofits leverage best-in-class for-profit methods to grow their organizations. Before CauseMic, he was a fundraising leader on the inside of numerous young and fast nonprofits. One of which he helped take from $275,000 to $51 million in 7 years. We'll be talking about that one. He's the author of the book The High-Growth Nonprofit: Proven Steps to Quickly Double Your Revenue and Drive Impact. The company is at causemic.com, and Matt's book is at CauseMic.com/book. Matt Scott, welcome back to Nonprofit Radio.
Matt ScottThank you for having me. Saw this on the calendar and was feeling pretty stoked about it.
Tony MartignettiOh, thank you. Oh, you just looked 5 minutes ago? Like you weren't— you haven't been anticipating it for the past month?
Matt ScottUh, I absolutely looked, uh, last night and was very
Tony Martignettiexcited. All right, all right, I'll accept, uh, 12 hours of excitement is, is fine. That's terrific. Thank you. Uh, congratulations. Congratulations on the book, The High-Growth Nonprofit.
Matt ScottThank you. Yeah, I think, uh, if any of your— if any of your listeners has ever— have ever written a book, uh, they, they will probably relate. It took me twice as long as I thought it would to write this.
Tony MartignettiYes, I've heard that numerous times. Right. All right. But you— it's done. Congratulations.
Matt ScottThank you.
Tony MartignettiUh, let's talk with, uh, With a 30,000-foot view, you, you reference different, uh, degrees of views in the book, and one of them is 30,000-foot. What, what's a high-growth nonprofit? I
Matt Scottthink a high-growth nonprofit is an organization that is looking to go beyond incremental growth, um, an organization that's looking to double their revenue and impact over the next 2 to 3 years. Um, and it's an organization, yeah, that's, that's willing to take bold calculated risk and also follow some, some process and systems to get there. Um, yeah, it's an organization ready to invest in growth.
Tony MartignettiOkay, uh, that's audacious, doubling in, uh, 2 to 3 years growth, uh, revenue and impact. All right, so One of the early chapters, uh, makes it clear that if we're going to achieve high growth, we need to outgrow our 5% mindset. Yeah, help us through.
Matt ScottYeah, this is, this is my favorite exercise or tip or, uh, out, you know, just learning from the book, um, because it's worked time and time again. Big, small, it scales at every size organization. It's quite simple. It's Most organizations, especially fundraisers, are guilty of this. They set these really low revenue targets and then they like to wildly exceed them. At least that's what I did when I was a frontline fundraiser. But really—
Tony MartignettiClassic under— overperform, under—
Matt ScottUndersell.
Tony MartignettiUndersell and overperform. Yes.
Matt ScottYeah, yeah, exactly. So Outgrowing the 5% Growth Mindset is this idea that Most organizations look to grow, say, 5, 10, 15%, you know, and the reality is you don't actually have to do anything differently in order to grow that incremental growth. You just have to do what you're currently doing and do it a little bit better. And so what we encourage folks to do is to kind of gather around a whiteboard with their team and say, answer this question: what if we had no choice but to double our revenue with half the resources over the next 3 years? What would we do? And it's awesome because in a resource-constrained environment, you're forced to get creative. Innovation comes to life, and you're forced to ruthlessly prioritize. And that's usually how you can begin to set a path towards exponential growth. And we've we've seen this. We've seen this work at lots of clients, and I think it's something that. That is an easy thing for a leader to do.
Tony MartignettiAnd in addition to having an audacious growth goal mindset, you need to have a plan for achieving audacious goals, which is what I— to me, this is what the book is all about. Yeah, it's not enough to just be audacious in goal setting. We need to have—
Matt Scottright,
Tony Martignettiyou need to have a method of getting there. That's gonna be different than what we've been doing.
Matt ScottYeah, exactly. I could say I would like to be 50 pounds lighter by my birthday, but if I don't actually have any plan to, you know, to replace, to drink green tea and eat more vegetables, I probably am not gonna get there.
Tony MartignettiI love the idea of exponential growth. Let's talk about the North Star. And why don't you, yeah, talk about the North Star. What's our North Star?
Matt ScottYeah, I think what's— what comes to mind for me is, is unlike a mission statement, a North Star is sort of this, this guiding light for your organization. It's more about the why. And it, you know, the analogy kind of comes to mind, like, as you're a kid and you're exploring, and, you know, or any explorer really, and the thought is that this North Star can kind of take you in a certain direction. It can always guide you and point you there. And It's something that when I was at Team Rubicon, nonprofit that repurposes the skills of military veterans to assist folks who have been affected by disaster.
Tony MartignettiThat's the organization that you grew, referred to in your bio.
Matt ScottYeah, exactly. I was a part of our rapid growth there and fundraising, and there was a lot of people involved in that, but the organization was ran by this guy named Jake Wood, a former Marine. If there's any Marines listening, I apologize. There's no such thing as a former Marine.
Tony MartignettiRight, right.
Matt ScottA Marine, I should say.
Tony MartignettiLike Eagle Scout. Yeah. Yeah, exactly. Marine for life, Eagle Scout for life. Yeah,
Matt Scottyeah, exactly, exactly. I hope I still make his Christmas card list for making that error. But yeah, Jake pounded the North Star in our head to be the best disaster relief organization in the world. And we were really encouraged to take these bold, calculated risks. And it was, it was that guiding star to say, hey, when we're, when we're at a decision point, when we're trying to figure out what to do, look to that North Star and say, is this going to get us closer there? Is it going to guide us towards that direction? And I think it's important for an organizational leader to set the organization's North Star and to communicate that frequently. So. You know, at CauseMic, we, we're laser-focused on helping, uh, fully fund every nonprofit organization. Um, that's a pretty big, bold, audacious thing. It's like being the best disaster response org in the world. And throughout the journey to get there, you're gonna, you know, you're gonna have all these decision points, and it helps you, I think, filter through them.
Tony MartignettiI like that the book is filled with examples of Basically, you, you're walking your walk. You, uh, use a lot of examples from, uh, from CauseMic.
Matt ScottYeah, from CauseMic, from clients. Like, um, honestly, the book is filled with, with just as many lessons that were learned from trying something and it not working. But one of our cultural principles is success is not final, and another one is the future belongs to the curious. And I think The combination of those 2 things are what, what allows an organization to try, try new approaches. But then when something works well, to examine it, to look at it, understand why it worked or why it didn't work and what's still missing about it, and to refine it. And so I try to share examples from our experience because I'm so goal-oriented. And sometimes I share with, with Bobby, someone who's like my thought partner, my operational partner here at CauseMic. Just, just the other day I shared with her, I was like, gosh, you know, I was like, I wish we were growing faster. And she said, Matt, we more than doubled our, you know, last year ourselves, and we helped 22 clients double at the same time. Like, let's take a breath and like look at what, what worked and what didn't and what we accomplished. And I think that, that That, that's what I tried to include in the book was the stories from those lessons learned. And I hope it, I hope it comes through.
Tony MartignettiIt does. It does. And true to your walking your talk, I said you, I said you walk your walk, you walk your talk. True to walking your talk, your North Star, or one of them, is to fully fund every nonprofit. You know, you do know there's about 1.5 million of them, right?
Matt ScottYeah, there's, there's far too many probably to realistically reach. And I gotta be honest, like, we've refined that over the years to be those that align with our values. Like, I actually, I hope that there's certain organizations that don't have access to my book and don't actually put to use these practices. But
Tony Martignettiyou're scaling back or scaling down a little bit. All right, that's perfectly reasonable with a universe of 1.5 million or more. But true to your North Star, you are giving this book away.
Matt ScottYeah.
Tony MartignettiFolks, just go to causemic.com/book and give a name and an address, and you'll ship the book for free.
Matt ScottExactly. Yeah. Uh, why are you—
Tony MartignettiI have— I, I'm not gonna ask why you're doing that, because it's your North— it's your North Star. That's why.
Matt ScottYeah. Exactly. I think, yeah, we give away free strategy calls too. And I'm gonna be honest, like a lot of the calls are folks that aren't necessarily in the right mindset or in the right place to benefit from the approach that we take, but we still wanna help them. So we've developed a free curriculum. Like we've, you know, I just wanted to capture some of the lessons that I've learned and so many, I've gotten so much free advice over the years. that I'm so grateful for that we wanted to put some of those thoughts down on paper and share those with folks and yeah, just help people grow and scale. And it's the easiest way to distribute our knowledge out there.
Tony MartignettiYou have a chapter on— and all your chapters are short. This is quick. This is a— it's a quick read but valuable. And I mean, it has to be valuable. You get it for free. So if it has just infinitesimal value, then you have— if it's just infinitesimal value, then you have a positive ROI because Cosmic is paying for the shipping. So culture, you talk— so one of your— one of the many chapters, culture is the glue. How do we I think folks probably understand why that's important, but how do we create the culture that we want?
Matt ScottYeah, yeah. So I kind of already shared with you 2 of our cultural principles at CauseMic, right? And I could still remember and recite all 7 cultural principles at Team Rubicon. But I've also worked at 2 other places in my career where I actually cannot recite even one of the cultural principles because they, they were a poster on a wall. Right? So when I think about cultural principles, they need to be what guides your team in the absence of your presence. So just a few years ago, when it was myself and Bobby and one full-time person here at CauseMic, Franny, who still works with us, I remember gathering her and saying, sharing with her, there's gonna be a time when we're not in the room, you are gonna be alone in the room, and we're gonna make a decision about how we need to move forward. People are gonna question that decision and we won't be there to answer it. And I need you to look to these cultural principles to guide you and to provide them with context as to why this decision is made so that we can all be aligned and so that we can all move forward together. So I think when, you know, to address your question, I feel like I have 2 parts. One is like, what is the importance? The critical part is, that you have, that your team has something that they can fall back on to filter through their actions, their ideas, to understand your decisions, all those things in the absence of your presence. It's really important how to get there. It's as basic as sitting down and writing down, like, think about yourself, think about your top-performing people on your team, the best people you've ever worked with. If you're just building your team from scratch, What are the characteristics of those folks? What is it that they have in common? Where is their overlap? And start to write those things down. Don't go with these lofty, like, integrity and things like that. That's kind of baseline, I hope, wherever it is that you're working, right? But go with, like, what is uniquely you, and then you can actually refine them. And that's how we come up with fun stuff. Like, at Team Rubicon, one of my favorite cultural principles was Your mother's a donor. So when we think about how we're gonna reinvest the money that is given to Team Rubicon to serve folks affected by disaster, think about it as if your mother gave us that money. Mm-hmm. And that was a really cool, right, way to frame that up. And so at CauseMic, we've, we've got fun ones too, right? Like sleeves up. At Team Rubicon, it was get shit done. So the— you could start to put a fun spin on it, and then How you move it into action, I found, is you repeat it all the time and you call it out all the time. Are you familiar with StrengthsFinder, Tony?
Tony MartignettiNo, don't know that.
Matt ScottIt's a Gallup kind of generated thing where you fill out this survey. Millions of people have filled it out and it kind of identifies what are your top 5 strengths of all these different strengths, right? And a lot of folks use StrengthsFinder. But they'd go to a half-day session and then they never talk about it again. And the same is true about cultural principles. They take a day, a week, a month to define these cultural principles. They're passive, they're on a poster, and they're not ever talked about. And so you have to, like, when you see sleeves up, when you see success is not final, whatever yours are, you have to call attention and call it out and say, hey, Franny, that was amazing. Yeah. You know, that was a success is not final moment for you. This is— thank you. You know, this is what works about it. I think that's what I would say about cultural principles is define them, but, but revisit them often. That's how you're gonna be able to fully leverage them.
Tony MartignettiWhat guides your team in the absence of your presence? I love that. It's time for a break. Stop the drop with DonorBox, the online donation platform. How many potential donors drop off before they finish making the donation on your website? You can stop the drop and break that cycle with DonorBox's ultimate donation form. Add it to your website in minutes. There's no coding required. When you stop the drop, the potential donors become— Donors. Donors. 4 times faster checkout and more convenient ways to give from leading payment processors. There's no setup fees, no monthly fees, no contract required. You'll be joining over 40,000 US nonprofits. DonorBox, helping you help others. donorbox.org. Now back to The high-growth nonprofit. Say a little more about yours. Success is not final. What does that mean to CauseMic?
Matt ScottYeah, to CauseMic it means we actually do— I learned again, I learned this kind of thing at Team Rubicon. We did this thing called an after-action report, which sort of came out of the military culture where we would evaluate, hey, we just responded to Hurricane Harvey. What worked, what didn't, what was missing, what was confusing, right? And so what we do here at CauseMic is we actually evaluate, like, literally we did a retrospective on writing this book. You know, I think it was a success. Can't wait to come out with a second volume, but I'm like, okay, what are all the things that need to be, that need fixing, you know, that could be better about? Yeah. How we approached this. Um, and there was a ton of them. And then how taking the lessons that we learned about the, the editing process, like the outlining process, um, the boiling it down to 2, like you said. I mean, it was written in a way for to be, to be, you know, kind of digested on a domestic flight. But we, we try to put like the key lessons up front. Well, that actually came out of Another project that we worked on where the, the audience of, of our curriculum said, you know, the, the just like the lesson learned upfront was really helpful. So it's taking that success from one thing and applying it to what worked well this time, and also looking back and saying, what didn't work? What did not go well about that fundraising campaign that we just ran? What, what didn't go well about that digital transformation that we just did? And how do we address that for the next go-around? So that we can improve upon how we deliver, you know, services to clients and, and impact to the world.
Tony MartignettiAs you said, each chapter has 2 takeaways up front, right under the title of the chapter. There's 2 shaded boxes that are going to tell you what that chapter is all about.
Matt ScottYeah, you can skip the chapter if you, if you're really short on time or not intrigued by what it says, or No, you
Tony Martignettishould. I think you make this point. If one doesn't appeal to you, that you should read it all the more to find out what it is that you're missing about the takeaway that you're not getting. You know, what it is you don't understand about the takeaway that makes it uninteresting to you. So read the couple of pages and come away enlightened.
Matt ScottYeah.
Tony MartignettiUm, you talk some about, um, well, actually, let's go get a little deeper in your, in your own life. The, this Team Rubicon sounds like it was, I don't know, transformational for you, you know, so grounding. You, you took away a lot from your time at Team Rubicon.
Matt ScottYeah, I sure did. Uh, the The opportunity, you know, for, for your more established leaders who are listening to this, uh, 22-year-old Matt was given way too much responsibility.
Tony MartignettiMilitary, that, that comes, that comes right from your, your founder Jake. The military does that.
Matt ScottYeah,
Tony Martignetti18-year-olds are given incredible responsibility right out of, right out of high school.
Matt ScottExactly. If you give people clear direction, Commander's intent, as Jake would call it, and and and as and and a sense of connection with one another, a sense of codependency with one another. Then you know, even if you fail, if you're failing forward, you're going to do okay, right? So for me at Team Rubicon, all of the places that I've worked, I've you know have taught me a lot. But I learned about, I think, the 30,000-foot at Team Rubicon, the power of having a really strong direction that we're headed at the horizon level, and then how to operationalize it is really critical. So I was given the opportunity to— by given the opportunity, I mean there was a problem and someone let me just Tackle it, right? To lead 2.5 digital transformations in my 7 years, but I had never done that before. And so learning a lot from that or developing a mass market fundraising program, building out a fundraising team, you know, partnering with marketing, all of these different things that were so, so important to who I am today and how I lead today and how I help others lead is, is because of the lessons that I learned. And I'm going to be honest, a lot of stuff did not work at all. And so I'll share an example that maybe will resonate with folks. Like, one of the things we do, and I talk about it in the book, is that the strategic planning process is completely broken at most organizations, right? It takes 3 to 6 months, it costs over $200,000 in staff time and consulting. And usually it ends up with this 50-page strategic planning document that nobody reads and is completely inactionable. And at Team Rubicon, what we would do is we would actually develop strategic plans every 6 months. We were putting new ones out there and we would look back and laugh at where we thought we would be. Sometimes we thought we were like going to the moon and actually we ended up at Mars, or sometimes we overshot, sometimes we fell way short. But the plan was like a good place to deviate from. It was a, it was a It was something to guide us, but it was not a destination. The planning process, you know, what's it— I'm gonna mess up which general this was, but one of these famous generals talks about how a plan is useless, but the act of planning is really what is really useful because it brings people together and gives people a common understanding. And so at Team Rubicon, like, we would fail all the time at our strategic plans. But, but we always had a bias for action over a bias for documentation. We always had a bias for getting things done. And yeah, I'm very grateful for the time that I had there because I don't think I would be able to support so many organizations today if it weren't for the opportunity to fail early and succeed early, you know. Yeah.
Tony MartignettiGSD gets shit done, right? You talk like you were in the military, like operationalize commander's intent. You know, you say you sound like you were a Paramarine yourself.
Matt ScottOh gosh, I have 3— I have 3 brothers who serve in the military, uh, but, uh, I did not have any military jargon or discipline whatsoever before going to Team Rubicon. So It's 100% a byproduct of my— as my time as a gray shirt, and it has nothing to do with, uh, with, uh, my level of service stops at the nonprofit sector, unfortunately.
Tony MartignettiAll right. And gray shirts, of course, were the Team Rubicon volunteers, right? Exactly. Those were the gray shirts. Yeah. All right, so let's explore a little more the strategic plan. You, you spend a couple chapters on it, uh, having an adaptable strategic plan. And yeah, and why don't you bring in another organization, the, uh, you talk about the, uh, SFP, the Salamta Family Project.
Matt ScottYeah, Salamta Family Project.
Tony MartignettiTheir adaptable strategic plan.
Matt ScottYeah, so what I, what I favor is, is, is action over, over documentation, right? But documentation is important. So capturing your strategy on a single page It's like, what are we trying to achieve? What are the key— how are we going to do that? What are the key strategies on how we're going to do that, right? So Salamta Family Project, when they first started working with us, they actually pair marginalized children— or women, rather. So just women who are largely ignored in the community with orphaned children, and they create what they call these forever families, where they are not just a temporary placement for orphans. But rather a wraparound care service, a long-term commitment. A family goes well beyond, you know, a kid graduating from high school, say, right? You could still call your parents well into life, and then you care for one another. And so when they were thinking about how to grow, and they really needed to grow, we started to identify, okay, well, if we were gonna double revenue, how would we go about doing that? What are the key areas we're gonna focus on? So we capture that. Right. In a strategic plan. And then you essentially look at, okay, one of them was gonna be, we were gonna really lean into peer-to-peer fundraising, 'cause that was, there was an opportunity there for them. And another area was cause marketing and really thinking about how to leverage corporate marketing dollars instead of corporate philanthropic dollars. Most nonprofits go after donations, but those are very limited versus marketing dollars are kind of infinitely scalable. So those were just 2 of the strategies that made sense. Then we developed all these tactical things like if we're going to focus on fundraisers, we need to have little things like we need a good peer-to-peer fundraising platform. But more importantly, like let's think about donor segmentation or, or supporter segmentation— donors, volunteers, fundraisers, advocates within the fundraisers— like Are these people network mobilizers? Can they get a lot of people to attend the event and donate on their behalf? Sharing a ton of context, but my point is that there were all these little ideas like, we need to coach people who are passionate about Salamta but who are not professional fundraisers on how to ask people for money. So a fundraising coaching series made it in there. So big ideas, little ideas, they all get added in, and we scored those based on impact. How much impact would they have on our ability to double revenue against that key strategy? How? With cost, you know, time and money. Like, a fundraising platform costs money. It takes time and money to draft an email series and build out an engagement flow, right? And so by doing this more action-oriented strategic planning process, what we did was we started to develop— we were clear on direction and we were clear on how we were gonna get there. And we really thought about what should be done first. And, and as a result, the organization was able to, you know, leverage all kinds of cool stuff, a Travelocity grant to film, to build brand awareness. Like we built a really big peer-to-peer program. But also kind of what I was sharing about Team Rubicon and at CauseMic is like our identities shift over time. And what, to Marissa, the executive director's credit, she saw an opportunity in actually the connection between family, the forever family, and the faith-based community in the US, the donor base, and that there was a strong connection there that they weren't really maximizing or taking advantage of because they weren't directly connecting the two. So that's that a plan is a good place to deviate from. that I was talking about is, as you move through the process of growing, you need to— success is not final. Stop and evaluate what's working, what's not, what's missing. And she found that opportunity and leaned into it with these frameworks, and they've been very successful. They've, they've grown a— they've doubled more than, more than once. So yeah, just a little bit more about, about Salamta and how they leverage that growth strategy.
Tony MartignettiExplain about the one-page strategic plan, the OPSP. You talk about this in the book too.
Matt ScottYeah, this is, this is like my favorite, my favorite thing because it aligns everybody and it's the simplicity. It's hard to get down into a single page, right? But, but essentially at the very top, it's what are we trying to achieve? Okay, let's say we're trying to double our revenue. How are we gonna do that? I talked about that already. What are the key strategies? Okay, then who should we be targeting? Like, who should we be going after? Let's say one of your key strategies is to, to take an audience-led approach, right? So one of our clients is Surfrider. Well, who they're going after is mass market, major donors, you know, certain corporate partners, etc. And then what motivates them? Well, they have 4 programmatic pillars. So that's really like, what are we talking about?
Tony MartignettiWhat do they do? In their case, Surfrider, what do they do?
Matt ScottSurfrider is a group of, a collection of chapters. There's over 80 across the country. And what they do is they, they work collaboratively to, to put forth legislation to protect beach access, to protect clean water, to reduce plastic pollution, and to reverse the impacts of climate change. And why people support Surfrider are different. Somebody who's interested in plastic pollution might not be interested in beach access. Right. So what we, what we want to capture on that page is who are we going after? How, what, what's the core message? What are the, what are the major drumbeats? What are the times when everybody— so World Water Day, super important for them. Some of them are planned and some of them are unplanned. So the rainfall that we just experienced in California really damaged coastal communities. But that was an unplanned drumbeat. So the ability to look at this one-page strategic plan and say, should we respond to this disaster? Does it align with our, our strategy towards doubling revenue? It gives people a filter who are executors and who are operationalists and leaders to look at and glance at and say, yeah, we need to lean into this opportunity. And it means that we're gonna have to stop doing these other things. Temporarily or otherwise to get there. So, uh, yeah, that's a little bit about what's captured in the one-page strategic plan. It's sort of the, what are we trying to do and how are we going to do it and who are we targeting and where should we focus our efforts?
Tony MartignettiIt's time for Tony's Take Two, a week before the 2023 Nonprofit Technology Conference, and already we've got a dozen interviews booked. Who I'll be talking to, uh, conference presenters about. Oh, like data-driven storytelling with Julia Campbell, inclusive culture on your board, oh, using your voice to lead, quiet quitting, perhaps personalized fundraising at scale. You might see these and lots of other shows are coming up in the months ahead. If you are at the Nonprofit Technology Conference, swing by booth 424. I'll be there talking to all these future smart guests along with Heller Consulting, our '23 NTC sponsor. Thank you again, Team Heller, for sponsoring. That is Tony's Take Two. We've got beaucoup buttloads more time For the High Growth Nonprofit with Matt Scott. You talk about intentional discoveries, these sort of internal interviews that are, that are valuable. Explain what that's all about.
Matt ScottYeah, for this, I'll use an example. When we were working with Mercy Corps, nonprofit, large established organization, they provide humanitarian services across the world in over 100 countries. some of the most difficult places. And their fundraising and marketing team is about 65 people. So big department. Within that, they got lots of senior leaders. And we were helping their, their 4th CDMO in 4 years get the team aligned. So she was relatively new in the seat. And so what we encouraged is to do stakeholder interviews with each person. In, in her case, she had Within the department, there was about 12 directors just in the department, senior leaders for her. And it was about interviewing each of them and figuring out, hey, what's working, what's not, what's confusing, what's missing. You see that kind of common theme. And gathering all this input from your team on the regular, revisiting it with them once a year is really effective because it allows you as a leader to do these stakeholder interviews even though you already You already know who those people are and what they face. Well, chances are by just slowing down, taking a pause, and actually having a conversation with your team, you know, if you're go— if you're truly doubling, if, if you— when you, when you grow revenue by 25%, 100% of your systems will break. That's been our experience. So by pausing and slowing down and doing interviews with the various stakeholders on your team, and understanding what's working, what's not, what's missing, what's confusing, you can begin to prioritize where your clarity needs to— where you need to provide more clarity, where things need to be reprioritized, where, uh, where you need to address problems that are popping up that are new problems that you weren't expecting because you just moved through a different phase of growth.
Tony MartignettiYeah, that, that's a whole nother good topic because if you're experiencing this rapid growth or you're You're in the midst. Yeah, you're in the midst of it. Prioritization is key.
Matt ScottYeah. And that's actually— you talked about what is something else I want to talk about in the book. It's something we found really useful is Larry Greiner is a researcher who years ago, you know, wrote an article on HBR about the evolutions and revolutions of organizational growth. And how as you move through the stages of growth, the inevitable crisis— crises that come up as you move, the pain that you're going to experience, the solutions that you put in place to address that phase of growth is inevitably going to lead to crisis in the next phase of growth. And so we used to pass out the original article, and it was very much written from a for-profit lens, but This is HBR,
Tony Martignettiyou said Harvard
Matt ScottBusiness Review? Yeah, sorry, Harvard Business Review. Yeah. And, uh, we just received so much positive feedback from, from clients that we're taking through our rapid growth program, which is this transformational process, um, that we were like, we need to rewrite this for nonprofit-specific audience because there's some uniqueness to that. Like, it's particularly resource constrained, you know. So We did that. And it's one of the chapters in the book. I talk about like the various phases of growth and the 5 different ones and how as you move through them, you're gonna inevitably come up with new challenges. But that's how I think those, those 2 questions or the 2 topics we just talked about come together. It's like by doing those interviews, rechecking in with your team frequently as you move through the phases, you're going to be able to see more clearly from their lens, from their vantage point, when things are breaking and when the solutions that you put in place when you are moving from an entrepreneurial environment to one where you have decisive leadership is inevitably going to lead towards like a sense of, uh, I need autonomy, I'm being told what to do too much, you know. So you have to check in with your team regularly as you move through the phases of growth.
Tony MartignettiThat's like you had a lot of autonomy at Rubicon.
Matt ScottWe, we did until I didn't. And so it's funny because Jake is a friend of mine, uh, still. And one day we were talking about, you know, we were both sharing with each other, how long do you think you're gonna stay? Um, and, uh, for me it was— became so clear. I was like, my identity, I am a builder and a doer. I am not a maintainer. And so as soon as my job becomes more and more narrow and it becomes more— we're going to maintain state status as opposed to like what we've just gone through for the last 7 years. That's going to be the moment when I— when it's time for me to, yeah, to move into the gray shirt as a volunteer as opposed to a staff member role. And so, yeah, I think that's— that was my own experience and my own journey in evaluating when it was time for for me to, to kind of move on. But I was given a lot of autonomy, and then it started to get reined in, you know, because it had to. We started to have department budgets and processes, and, and I was like, yeah, this is necessary, and this is not for me. Yeah.
Tony MartignettiLet's talk a little about hiring. You say hire when it hurts. But you need to have a couple things in place before you do something that sounds reckless. So what's higher when it hurts?
Matt ScottYeah, this is some advice that I was given by now the chief operating officer at a major humane society, but came from a consulting background when he and I were talking about me building this consulting practice. And I thought about it, I was like, gosh, that is so on point even when I'm at a nonprofit, right? You always feel like you want to put more bodies in place, right? Like, if we only had more people, we could achieve more. And we were talking about it from a, hey, cash flow perspective. Don't go hog crazy on hiring too many folks because you don't want to have to lay people off. If you, you know, if it's a temporary need, you need to evaluate when you need to hire. So I'll share this because I think it's so valuable for for folks who've made it this far into the podcast episode, but—
Tony MartignettiOh, Nonprofit Radio listeners are not dropping off.
Matt ScottOkay, good, good.
Tony MartignettiOh, they're with us till the end, I'm sure of it, especially talking about high growth.
Matt ScottOkay, so yeah, help us be the best-selling book in the free book category by making it this far. So World Bicycle Relief, I share this story. This is one of our clients and And they, they're really unique because they're not just a nonprofit, but they're also a social impact business. So they ask for financial donations, but they also sell a Buffalo bicycle to communities in countries across, across the world. And they do this to help provide education and access to healthcare and jobs. And Let's just take in, in certain parts of Africa, like the terrain and the infrastructure in Kenya is really different than that of Colombia, but they operate in both places. And so their marketing team is stretched really thin because they're not just serving the donor audience, but they're also trying to serve the various social impact audiences in different countries and produce materials that will help those social businesses and the entrepreneurs that they've set up in country to sell these bicycles, to service these bicycles. And so they're stretched really thin, right? And naturally you just want to go to, I need to hire. But what we did first with them is we gathered their marketing team and we said, we want to show you how to think like an internal agency, how to think like a marketing firm internally within your organization. So this tip is something that I think nobody— most nonprofits don't even think about. I don't want to say nobody, but I haven't come across any yet. So one of the things we do at, at CauseMic, and this is common practice in any agency or consultancy, is you think about your time as billable and non-billable. And billable time is essentially time that we spend billing to clients. But as an internal agency, it's things like writing copy, building out workflows, merging contact records, whatever, all these different things. Non-billable time is Not bad time. It's things like professional development. It's things like paid time off. It's admin time, going to staff meetings, getting aligned, things like that. And so what we told— we shared is like, you need to actually evaluate where all of the time is being spent as an internal stakeholder and determine your billable time divided by your total time gives you what's called a utilization ratio. And so at CauseMic, You know, our team of 16 served 28 clients last year, and we have, we have currently over 65 work streams going on that are across all these different clients. And how in the world does that few of people do that much work? And the reality is we are very meticulous about understanding how much time it takes to do, if we get asked to create an annual report or build a landing page or build a workflow. We need to understand how much time it takes for the project manager, the content strategist, the copywriter, the designer, right? And so we taught this to World Bicycle Relief's marketing team to actually keep track of your time and to set targets for billable versus non-billable. And what they found was where they were spending time and where they weren't spending time. And then when they got requests from the major gift officer for a one-off You know, one-pager, they were able to evaluate how much time that was gonna take and the impact that it was gonna have, and they could then prioritize their work through their backlog in a way that they had never thought to do before. So that's an example of like going back to hire when it hurts. Yeah. Chances are it hurts, right? You're stretched thin. There's more to do than time to do it. Before hiring, stop and take stock of where you're actually spending time. And what can go and what needs to stay. And only when it really is like your team is running hot and consistently running hot. And if you look ahead and you're saying, gosh, we're having to turn down high-impact work because we don't have the capacity to do it, that's when you should hire. But you don't really know that unless you're actually keeping track of your time.
Tony MartignettiDid you think of something that You want to talk about that we haven't yet?
Matt ScottYeah, something else I would like to share.
Tony MartignettiAll right. Success. The only author I can remember who doesn't know what—
Matt ScottHe doesn't have more to share.
Tony MartignettiYou're overwhelmed because there's so much value in the book. You don't know what to choose from.
Matt ScottOh, that's kind. Yes. Well, I will share. I'm very grateful to be on your show again and the work that you're doing to support the community. I think we're aligned there. You're giving away this podcast constantly for free, and I know how much work it is. to produce content. So I appreciate you having us on, and I really, I hope that people find this book to be useful. And I guess I would share, please provide feedback because success is not final. And if there's elements in the book that you're like, that didn't land, or we wanted more of this, that's the only way we know, right? Like what episodes you should make on Nonprofit Radio or what chapters should make it into the next book.
Tony MartignettiAll right, all right. Challenge to listeners, you're getting it for free, so give feedback. Um, not right— I'm not ready to end yet though. There's a couple things I always still want to talk about. We— Um, you talk about a rapid growth plan, and there are 3 parts of it. We've talked about the first 2. We talked about the one-page strategic plan. Uh, you've talked about your— the project backlog. Right, which becomes these, these ideas to execute the one-page strategic plan. That's your— those are your projects and impact versus, as you, as you describe, just reminding folks, impact versus resources that need to be allocated to that.
Matt ScottYep.
Tony MartignettiRight.
Matt ScottAnd then the third, the third part—
Tony MartignettiThe third. Yes, that's for you. Yes, please.
Matt ScottThe third part is, well, a plan is great and a prioritization is great, but we have to measure how effective this thing is, right? So we develop a simple KPI tracker, key performance indicator tracker, to measure the success of the plan. And so I'll just use an example what might show up on a KPI tracker. So let's say, let's say your, your donor base is aging and your file strength, your retention rate is good, but folks are getting older, and so you need to acquire more new donors, right? Okay. Okay. How are you gonna do that? Let's say you turn towards mass market fundraising audience to get there. There's 2 things you need to do. One, you need to think about your planned giving approach, and 2, you need to think about, 'cause that's where the strength of your file is, and 2, you gotta acquire new supporters. So what KPIs matter? Well, we find with online giving that it comes down to website traffic, conversion rate, and average gift amount. If you can get more people to your website and more of those people give and they give more money, then you're gonna raise a lot more money online, right? Yeah. Then when you think about, okay, well, what's that retention rate look like? How many of our supporters are moving from one-time to monthly? What's that upgrade look like and retention rate look like? So those are all these KPIs. So for when you go back to the one-page strategic plan, you think about, well, what were our hows? Maybe one of your hows is we're gonna build a robust legacy giving program, which, Tony, I know you know more about than I do. So I don't— what do you think are the KPIs that people should measure when they're thinking about building out planned giving program?
Tony MartignettiOh, well, first of all, you're not gonna acquire new donors through planned giving. Yep. But some of the key metrics, how many conversations you've opened about the topic, how many solicitations you've actually gotten to, might be just how many meetings you've had around this topic, which is different than the conversation. You know, you may not have quite opened the conversation, but you had a meeting to suss out the possibility. So, you know, those are— so there's 3, like number of meetings, number of conversations opened, number of solicitations made, of course, number of commitments that donors are willing to make. So there's 4 early ones.
Matt ScottYeah, exactly. And so the KPI has to match up to whatever your strategy is. And it basically needs to— it needs to be— I think of KPIs as both leading— there's leading indicators and then there's trailing indicators. So the leading indicators you described are like how many conversations, you know, were opened. Meetings had would be a very early leading indicator. And then how many, you know, conversations— now you're starting to get a little bit further. The trailing indicators, you know, you start to evaluate at different phases, like, are we gonna hit our goal? Is this strategy working or is it not working? Does it need to be adjusted? So the idea is that together those 3 things, and by the way, throughout the book, I hope it becomes clear, but I'll just share my own personal experiences. When in doubt, make it as simple as possible. Create KPIs that are easily trackable, that you don't have to spend a lot of time going into a lot of different systems to get this data. You want to be thinking about how do I make this as easy as possible? I don't need to spend any time describing what it means when we say website traffic or conversion rate or average gift amount. We don't have to describe what it means, like number of lapsed donors or whatever. And you just want to have your system set up so that your KPI dashboard you can regularly look at and not have to spend a lot of time building out. People think like, oh, data-driven and You know, people, people want, want a Ferrari when what they need is a Kia, you know, and they don't even have a pit crew to like help them race this Formula 1 car around the track. Like, find the Kia, find the Kia. That's, that's, I guess, my metaphor advice on that.
Tony MartignettiThat's the rapid growth plan. All right.
Matt ScottYeah.
Tony MartignettiAnd, and the one I do want to close on, know your strength.
Matt ScottKnow your strength.
Tony MartignettiThat know your strength chapter. Do you know your strength?
Matt ScottYeah, I think that this, this rings true both on an individual and an organizational level, right? And where is it that, that you are uniquely positioned to drive impact like nobody else can? I mean, you know how it is. So I think about like organizations that come to us and they think they're the only ones solving the water crisis. You're like, actually, there's a lot of people doing exactly what you're doing. And I think it's just really important to have a clear idea of, you know, what problem are we uniquely positioned to solve in a way that is unique to our culture? So I'll use— I'll go back to Team Rubicon as an example to drive this home because we talked a lot about it. Um, when you think about disaster response, there is response, the immediate response. Uh, well, there's, there's like preparedness, you know, readiness. Is the community ready for a disaster? Then there's the actual like response to the disaster, and then there's the long-term recovery, right? Mm-hmm. And Team Rubicon, when we first got started, our strength was really in the response because we were able to pull from the military culture to very quickly respond. We didn't have a lot of bureaucracy. We didn't have a lot of red tape. But it was really challenging to get into the recovery business in the early days. By business, I just mean the business of serving folks affected by disaster, not making money on recovery. But like, you know, that's a different— that was a different organization's strengths. That's a different skill set to be able to build out. rebuild communities affected by disaster, re-roof homes and all that. Team Rubicon really didn't get involved in that for a really long time in their trajectory, and it wasn't until they had clearly— they had leaned into their strengths on the response side, and they had really figured out what worked. And then they thought, okay, how— what worked in there that could work with, with how we would go about the recovery? And how does that compare to someone like the Red Cross and how they approach The rebuild effort. So knowing your strengths and knowing your sector is super important. It's like, what do you? What's that North Star? What are you trying to achieve? What's your cultural principles? What what makes you uniquely good at what you do? And lean into that relentlessly and stay focused on that, and don't try to become the latest thing in every category. I guess is what I would say at a. At a high level. Is there something that stood out to you in that chapter, Tony, that I didn't talk about there?
Tony MartignettiNo, just identifying and leveraging what you're strong at instead of trying to go broader. Yep. You know, some people and some organizations may try to improve weaknesses rather than double down on their strengths.
Matt ScottYeah, people do this all the time, right? Like, that's a good point. I'll share one more thing, and I know like more and more and more I am really comfortable with the visionary role. Like, I love starting things. I don't particularly enjoy finishing them, nor does my team like it when I try to finish things because I'm not very good at that. It's really hard for me. It's a hard muscle to kind of push through. But I have like found Bobby, my operational partner. She's the magic at 10,000 feet. She connects the executors with the 30,000-foot vision and makes project plans and makes sense of things and loves finishing projects, not starting them. So knowing your individual strength as a leader too, and figuring out like, am I more comfortable in futuristic vision planning, or am I more comfortable in operationalizing things? And figuring out what you need as an operational partner, because really nobody has it all. Like, you just don't. And you might be able to flex when you absolutely have to, but your best flex is gonna be their worst, just standard operating procedure, because that's their strength, right? So I found that we've been able to grow a lot faster in clients too. Like, we, we work with a lot of clients that are CEOs that don't have operational partners, or sometimes They get in the way, and it's like knowing when you should stop and when you're— when the operationalist should pick up is really an important thing to distinguish.
Tony MartignettiMatt Scott, the book is The High-Growth Nonprofit: Proven Steps to Quickly Double Your Revenue and Drive Impact. It's at CauseMic, which is cause, C-A-U-S-E-M-I-C, causemic.com. /book, and it is free to you, including the shipping. Shipping, shipping is covered. Matt, thank you very much. Thank you. Congratulations again on the book. Thank you for sharing your thinking.
Matt ScottYeah, thank you, Tony. I really appreciate you.
Tony MartignettiMy pleasure. Next week, I'll bring the first '23 NTC interview, and they're all going to be excellent. I'll just pick one that's extra excellent. Yeah, extra excellent. Exactly. Next week's show is going to be extra excellent, just like I said. If you missed any part of this week's show, I beseech you, find it at tonymartignetti.com. We are sponsored by DonorBox. With intuitive fundraising software from DonorBox, your donors give 4 times faster. Helping you help others. Our creative producer is Claire Meyerhoff. The show's social media is by Susan Chavez. Marc Silverman is our web guy, and this music is by Scott Stein. Thank you for that affirmation, Scotty. Be with me next week for Nonprofit Radio, Big Nonprofit Ideas for the Other 95%. Oh, go out and be great. Thank you. Ow! Thank you.
I love our sponsor!


