Quiet Quitting & Email Accessibility



Quiet Quitting
Let’s start with what it is. Because it’s not quitting a job. From our coverage of #23NTC, Delaney Mullennix explains the increasing phenomenon, how we got here, and what to do to prevent it. She’s executive director of NonprofitHub.
Email Accessibility
Our #23NTC coverage continues as Coralie Meade Rodriguez, from Firefly Partners, shares strategies that enable the 26% of Americans living with a disability, to fully access your email messages.
Here’s the transcript
Tony MartignettiHello and welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. I'm your aptly named host of your favorite hebdomadal podcast. I'm traveling this week, so I don't have my good studio-quality mic, so I may not sound as good as usual. That just means you can look forward to better sound next week. Oh, I'm glad you're with me. I'd be hit with horripilation if you gave me goosebumps because you missed this week's show. Quiet quitting. Let's start with what it is, because it's not quitting a job. From our coverage of 23andMe, Delaney Mullennix explains the increasing phenomenon, how we got here, and what to do to prevent it. She's executive director of NonprofitHub. And email accessibility. Our 23andMe coverage continues As Coralie Meade Rodriguez from Firefly Partners shares strategies that enable the 26% of Americans living with a disability to fully access your email messages. On Tony's Take Two, it isn't what it is. Redux. We're sponsored by DonorBox. With intuitive fundraising software from DonorBox, your donors give 4 times faster, helping you help others. DonorBox.org. Here is Quiet Quitting. Welcome back to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio coverage of 23NTC, the 2023 Nonprofit Technology Conference, where we are sponsored by Heller Consulting. technology strategy and implementation for nonprofits. My guest now is Delaney Mullennix. She is Executive Director at NonprofitHub. Delaney, welcome to Nonprofit Radio.
Delaney MullennixThank you so much. It's exciting to be here.
Tony MartignettiPleasure to have you. I neglected to ask your pronouns. Did I— is she the right pronoun for you?
Delaney MullennixYes.
Tony MartignettiOkay. I should have asked it. I forgot to ask in advance, but I don't want to perpetuate a mistake. All right. Session topic is quiet quitting in the nonprofit sector.
Delaney MullennixThat's correct.
Tony MartignettiAll right. Let's first make sure that everybody knows that quiet quitting does not mean quitting. Please define quiet quitting so folks my age and older know exactly what we're talking about.
Delaney MullennixThat's right. I'm impressed. How did you know that? Did you attend my session yesterday?
Tony MartignettiNo, but I know what quiet quitting— maybe it's more pervasive.
Delaney MullennixOh, no, no, no.
Tony MartignettiDo a lot of people think quiet quitting is actually quitting?
Delaney MullennixYes, 100%. Yeah.
Tony MartignettiOh, well then it's not only people my age and older. Because I'm a young baby boomer at 61.
Delaney MullennixNo, majority of the people did not know what it was. Oh, really? And I think that the assumption is that it is someone leaving a position, like taking a leave from their organization or their job. But, and I think that—
Tony MartignettiWell, in a way, it's taking a leave. You could say it's a mental leave.
Delaney MullennixYes.
Tony MartignettiBut you define it. I'm not trying to talk around it.
Delaney MullennixNo, that's okay. That's exactly right.
Tony MartignettiYou define it.
Delaney MullennixAnd the words are misleading, quiet quitting. Like, you can assume based on those words and how you know those words that it means someone's leaving a position.
Tony MartignettiRight. It sounds like you just skulk out and stop showing up for work.
Delaney MullennixSo if someone has heard the term quiet quitting, and they see their employee, like, taking time off of work, or they know they're looking for other jobs, or they think that they're going to a doctor's appointment, but they're actually interviewing for another position, they say, my employee is quiet quitting. But that's actually not what it is. So it's more of, like, the silent withdrawal, the, like, taking an emotional and, like, engagement step back from your job. And that could be for a lot of other reasons, like not doing more work than what you feel you're getting paid for. It could just be that you're placing a higher value on your time. It's really meeting your job requirements and doing no more, no less.
Tony MartignettiRight. Bare minimum. Yes. You're not volunteering. You're not the one raising— volunteering for the—
Delaney MullennixRight.
Tony MartignettiOrganize the holiday party.
Delaney MullennixRight. Flying under the radar.
Tony MartignettiYou might not even show up at the holiday party.
Delaney MullennixRight.
Tony MartignettiBare minimum.
Delaney MullennixExactly.
Tony MartignettiQuiet quitting. Yes. Okay. All right. I thought only older folks would not know what that is, but everybody who attended your session didn't know what they were—
Delaney MullennixNo, no. Not very many. No.
Tony MartignettiHow did the session go?
Delaney MullennixVery good. Very good. Yeah. People had a lot of questions afterwards.
Tony MartignettiYeah. I want to ask you some of the questions you got. Yeah. All right. So we'll lead into the topic. You believe that nonprofits have incubated quiet quitting?
Delaney MullennixYes.
Tony MartignettiFor decades.
Delaney MullennixI don't know that it's just nonprofits, but I think it has existed in the nonprofit sector naturally for a lot of reasons. So like nonprofit boards have been quiet quitting, you know, since before it was cool. Since before it was a corporate buzzword.
Tony MartignettiDoing the bare minimum.
Delaney MullennixDoing the bare minimum. And I wouldn't even say they're quiet quitting. I like struggle to see— I struggle to see them even doing the bare minimum. But yes.
Tony MartignettiWe need a new term.
Delaney MullennixBut yes.
Tony MartignettiFor doing less than minimum, but still showing up.
Delaney MullennixYes, maybe.
Tony MartignettiLess than the bare minimum? Yeah. Like below par, subpar performance, but still a warm body somewhere working.
Delaney MullennixYes, medium volume quitting.
Tony MartignettiMedium, okay, right. All right, so boards, you want to flesh that out a little bit?
Delaney MullennixAnd it might not be totally fair to compare a volunteer board member to, like, a paid staff member, but I mean, we see this all the time. Like, board members are just taking, like, that step back before their term is over. EDs are sending emails into the abyss. They're having board meetings without quorum. Like, board members aren't showing up. I mean, this is all the definition of quiet quitting, and it's been happening forever.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Other examples of How nonprofits may have been, you say incubating, may have been incubating this? Other examples?
Delaney MullennixI think the other examples that I can think of are just like a premature leadership, and that it's represented by a lot of different things. But for instance—
Tony MartignettiThere was just a very loud NTC noise.
Delaney MullennixOh yeah.
Tony MartignettiNonprofit Radio perseveres as long as the ceiling is not coming down. I don't know. All right, just listeners, I mean, we're on the exhibit floor. At NTC. So there was just a loud noise in the background.
Delaney MullennixYeah. Well, apparently there's a red flag warning in Denver right now, which I didn't know what that was. And apparently it's like high risk for high winds that start fires.
Tony MartignettiHigh winds and— oh, not tornadoes. Fires.
Delaney MullennixYeah, that start fires because it's been hot.
Tony MartignettiAll right. Well, I assume we have smoke detectors throughout the building. Yeah, I think we do. Okay.
Delaney MullennixYeah.
Tony MartignettiWe're trusting.
Delaney MullennixI'm sure they're prepared.
Tony MartignettiThis looks like a pretty fire— I don't know about fireproof, but it looks like a pretty safe building. Okay. We'll persevere. Leadership, you were talking about.
Delaney MullennixYeah, I think there happens to be a lot of premature leadership, and I think that's because, for a lot of reasons, but one, people are typically not offering salaries to attract talent that is as skilled or as experienced as they need. I've volunteered on a lot of committees and boards where they have an executive director step down, and instead of doing a search, they kind of promote someone from either on the board or from a committee. to step into that leadership position, but it's not necessarily that they have experience leading teams. And so, there's a lack of things that happen, like people aren't getting reviews. Like, executive directors go years without ever receiving a performance review, and that's like, that's kind of, that's almost the norm, and it shouldn't be. But other things, just like failing to know how to inspire your team, and I think that's sad because we are the nonprofit sector. Yeah. A big part of my presentation was based on Davin Salvagno's talk at CauseCamp, which is the conference that NonprofitHub puts on every year. And he was talking about finding someone's purpose point. And so, questions that employers should be asking now compared to in the past was, how am I helping you to fulfill your personal purpose? And then employees are asking, how am I fulfilling my personal purpose by volunteering my time to your organization? And that's kind of missing, I think, in leadership. And I think leaders still assume that people are looking for money or a flexible work environment. And yes, these things are needed, but I think if you really want to attract someone to your nonprofit, you need to be able to do those things.
Tony MartignettiI was also— and that kind of leads to something that I was wondering about, see if you have insight into this more than I do. You're talking about quiet quitting, accepting Mediocre performance from your teams or from individuals as okay. Maybe mediocre performance gets rated high because—
Delaney MullennixLike, at least you're doing your job. Yeah.
Tony MartignettiAnd well, we have a lower salary range than you would get elsewhere. I can't expect you to do anything above that. My expectations are lower for you, none of which is acceptable. I'm not advocating this at all, but you think that's out there too? Accommodating mediocre performance.
Delaney MullennixWow. Like, allowing mediocre performance because of the total compensation package.
Tony MartignettiTo perpetuate. Yeah. Leadership's expectations are lower.
Delaney MullennixI've never thought about it that way, but I 100% could see that being true. Yeah. And I think sometimes I even, like, I can't say that I feel super proud about how much my staff are making. I would love if they were making more. And I think I've had that conscious thought, like, how much can I really ask of them? Like, if I was in their position, like, I might not want to go above and beyond. And I've, I've been a quiet quitter before. I worked at an organization where it was like you were up for raises, you were up for your performance review. They were like kind of hyping you up that you were going to take on like a higher level of leadership. And then you get like pennies, right, for performance. Like, I get like a 25-cent raise, but I'm taking on managing another person. I'm taking on additional job responsibilities. My job title has changed. Yeah. And that's just, that's when you start saying, if my employer isn't taking care of me and they're not stepping up to the plate, then I'm stepping back.
Tony MartignettiWhat's the point? Why should I bother? I'll just do what it takes. All right. Interesting. All right. So maybe something for you to think about, that accommodating, accepting mediocre performance as the norm.
Delaney MullennixThat's a great point.
Tony MartignettiAnd I think we do that sometimes. It's not right. You know, either— here I am preaching to an executive director, but you need to do what you can to get those salaries to where they— to where you think your folks ought to be paid.
Delaney MullennixYes.
Tony MartignettiAnd that requires a revenue plan, which may or may not be fundraising, but it requires a revenue plan. Yes, a strategy plan.
Delaney MullennixPut it in your budget, like plan for it.
Tony MartignettiYeah. All right.
Delaney MullennixYeah. One of the questions though that I think is interesting is, and I laugh because prior to my presentation I asked several people this question, I said, is it okay to require your employees to go above and beyond? And prior to coming here, everyone said, yeah, yeah, that's totally fine. Like, yeah, I would expect that. And then everyone in the room yesterday though said no. And I said, you guys are right. Like, absolutely no. You can't require your staff to go above and beyond their job expectations. But there are ways that you can maybe inspire them to do that.
Tony MartignettiIncentivize.
Delaney MullennixRight.
Tony MartignettiAnd a lot of that I think is team building too. You know, maybe a lot of, I don't know, maybe some Quiet quitting comes from poor team cultures, you know, not cohesive teams. So, you know, if you don't feel a part of something, why would you contribute more to it than you need to?
Delaney MullennixYeah. And that's the whole thing. Like, does my job have a purpose here? Like, what am I really doing for this company? There's also a lot of research on why quiet quitting has happened. And yeah, team culture is a big part of that, but there's a lot of new research on matching personalities to the position. I guess 64% of Americans are poorly matched to their job based on their personality.
Tony Martignetti2/3, really?
Delaney MullennixAnd like coincidentally, like Gallup did the poll on how many Americans are quiet quitting, it's 50%. And so, there's a lot of research right now based on like using personality quizzes in like your interview process or even like your job application. And even if you don't do that, what I like encourage the audience to do is at least know the personality that you know is going to succeed in this job. Like, even if you're not figuring out the personality of the other person, at least have that conscious, like, I'm aware of what I'm looking for. Um, because I think that's a big deal. Like, we had— I had an experience one time where one of NonprofitHub's core values is, uh, unabashedly ambitious. And that's like one of my favorite ones.
Tony MartignettiYeah, dude, it's good.
Delaney MullennixAnd we had a staff member quit, and I was doing her exit interview, and we were trying to figure out why she did because it was like kind of surprising to us. And she was like, Delaney, I love working with you. You're a great manager. Like, I have, have had so much fun. I've learned so much underneath of your guys's leadership. Like, NonprofitHub has a great mission. I absolutely adore it. But I see you and Katie, like the previous executive director, just go, go, go all day long. Like, so fast-paced. Like, tackling all these new projects. Like, doing all of these new things all the time. You, you live rich lives out of work. Like, you You are volunteering all the time. You're constantly busy. She's like, it's not me. She's like, I'm not thriving in this environment. And that was a personality mismatch, I think.
Tony MartignettiHuh. Why did she feel that she needed to be a high achiever like you and have that high energy that you and your predecessor had had? Yeah. Why? But why would she? I mean, if she's, if she's a contributing member of the team, you were surprised. It's not like somebody you were looking to. You were not disappointed to have leave. Why did she feel that she needed to measure up to what you do?
Delaney MullennixI don't know that it's that she felt she needed to measure up. I think that she was maybe doing that or working at a pace that was like burning her out. And I think that sometimes if you are even in an environment, like, there's an article from Nonprofit HR that describes 5 dysfunctional leaders in nonprofits, and one of them is like the workaholic. And I think what her perception of Katie and I was maybe that we were workaholics because we were like putting in overtime. But like, Katie and I just loved like our job. And yeah, like maybe at times it wasn't healthy. Like we probably did burn ourselves out sometimes. Like I'm not gonna lie and say that in a never burn out by working at this company. But I think for her, when you're in that environment, everything feels like a crisis. And you kind of instill this sense of panic if you're working at that pace and it's not natural for someone else. And to that point, I'm actually an introvert, but I can turn into an extrovert very easily. And I've learned how to do that very well. But I need my space. For instance, this morning I just took my time and I didn't come out and like do any networking prior to this. And like, I might go back and take some intermittent breaks, but that's because I know that in order to be an extrovert, I need to like refresh and like renew.
Tony MartignettiWell, thank you for doing that. Yeah. And thank you also for being self-aware.
Delaney MullennixYes.
Tony MartignettiYou needed to do that.
Delaney MullennixYes.
Tony MartignettiTo like bring your best to Nonprofit Radio. So thank you. No, thank you for that. Thank you.
Delaney MullennixAnd I love that the staff member was self-aware. Like, she knew that it wasn't like working for her, and eventually her performance probably would have dwindled. Right, if she was continuing to put herself in this environment.
Tony MartignettiBut wouldn't you have rather she had talked to you instead of just left? Because you could have reassured her that her performance is very good. You know, you don't need to— you don't need— you could have reassured her that she didn't need to measure up to what you do. Yeah. But, you know, the way she's working now, and maybe even just a little less, would still have been a very good employee.
Delaney MullennixYeah.
Tony MartignettiYou would have rather, I think— I'm putting words in your mouth, but would you rather have Had a real heart-to-heart before she resigned.
Delaney MullennixAnd to that point, we actually had told her several times that her level of calmness and the way that she was so intensely introverted, she actually added a ton of value into conversations because she was always seeing a different angle—
Tony MartignettiThe counterbalance.
Delaney MullennixThan what we had been seeing. Or she would ask questions that we might have not been going slow enough to address or like, you know, preemptively try to avoid like problems in the future.
Tony MartignettiYeah.
Delaney MullennixAnd so, she was great at that. Like, we adored that aspect of her and it was really valuable to our team. But to another point, I think some people are ready to challenge themselves and some people aren't. And an example that I can think of is when Katie left, I had to take over hosting the NonprofitHub Radio podcast. And I did not want to. I did not ever want to present. I never wanted to host anything. Like, I'm more of like a background person. Like, the integrator, not like the visionary. And I can do it again, like I can turn myself on, but that level of energy and that type of activity is more draining to me. So I can do it in smaller quantities. And you just have to be aware of that. And so I think when— my whole point is that when someone ever approached me to be on stage or present or talk to someone that needed an interview for like media or anything like that, I— my whole body would immediately reject that, right? Like, my— literally, my physical body would instantly respond, no, I'm not gonna do it. I'll find someone else for you. I'll be the coordinator. Like, who are you trying to talk to? Like, I'm not the one you want to talk to, but like, I'll figure it out, right? Even though I'm like highly capable of doing that. But like, naturally, my body rejects it. And I think that some people can fight their body's natural like rejection of something. And, but again, it's requiring more energy of them. And I think that's a big part of like burnout. So if she's constantly pushing herself, it's not a natural part of how she operates, it's going to lead to her burning out.
Tony MartignettiWhat ended up happening with the NonprofitHub podcast?
Delaney MullennixIt's going great.
Tony MartignettiOh, it is? And are you doing it?
Delaney MullennixYes. All right.
Tony MartignettiSo we've talked around it like half a dozen times. Why don't you explain the work of NonprofitHub? I just— full disclosure, I did a a webinar for you. You said off mic, 3 months before you started, I did a planned giving webinar for NonprofitHub. But describe the work of NonprofitHub.
Delaney MullennixYeah, of course. So NonprofitHub is a 501. We consider ourselves an educational collective, and a majority of that is digital and online, as well as being 100% free for nonprofit professionals. I actually had the pleasure to kind of revamp like our mission, our vision, and our values, um, when I started as executive director under 6 months ago. Um, but our, our vision is to create a thriving nonprofit sector founded on nonprofit excellence. And I don't know if you've heard the term business excellence before. That's like a much more common, I think, um, thing that businesses are striving for, especially like small businesses or like entrepreneurs. And there's like 5 pillars to business excellence. And so I kind of looked at that and I said, What are the 5 pillars of nonprofit excellence? Because they are a little bit different, or at least you have to say them a little bit differently. And then we do that by creating a connected ecosystem of people, resources, and learning. So we provide educational experiences and content almost every day of the week. Monday, we provide a downloadable guide. Tuesday, we do our newsletter. Wednesday, we always do a live webinar, which you are on with us. Thursday, we do a blog article. And Friday, we publish a podcast episode. And so we're just constantly working with people in the sector. It's not always what we know, like we're not the thought leader here, right? Um, but more again that like connected ecosystem. And like, I can't tell you like how many resources are available on NonprofitHub. If you have any type of nonprofit management, if there's like a pain point that you're dealing with, like you need to learn how to even like even the simplest things, right? Like, and the whole point of NonprofitHub is that it's so tactical and easily digestible that you're supposed to be able to look at like an article and read the paragraph that you need and then move on with your day, right? Like, I don't want you to study. I don't want you to be in a course for like 5 hours, although we do have courses available for you. Like, I know that as an executive director, like, you're searching something on Google every day, um, and like you just need to find that answer and like move on, right? Like, I need a template, I need a downloadable checklist, like, I need to know what I'm not missing, and then you need to move on. So that, that's like our kind of like our passion.
Tony MartignettiOkay. NonprofitHub.org?
Delaney Mullennix.org, yes.
Tony MartignettiAll right. All right. And how many staff?
Delaney MullennixWe have 5 staff.
Tony MartignettiDistributed over the country?
Delaney MullennixYes. Yep. So I'm from West Michigan. I have a team member in Ohio, Alabama, my Bama girl, and then I have a gentleman who kind of splits his time between New Jersey, Chicago, and Atlanta.
Tony MartignettiAll right. 5. All right.
Delaney MullennixOh, and then an intern. Lauren. Yes.
Tony MartignettiNonprofitHub.org for the Hub. The hub of resources. Yes. It's time for a break. Stop the drop with DonorBox, the online donation platform. How many probable donors drop off before they finish making the donation on your website? You can stop the drop and break that cycle with DonorBox's ultimate donation form. Add it to your website in minutes Literally. When you stop the drop, probable donors become donors. 4 times faster checkout, easy payment processing, no setup fees, no monthly fees, no contract, and you'll be joining over 40,000 US nonprofits and over 50,000 throughout the world, the whole earth, 50,000. DonorBox, helping you help others. donorbox.org. Now back to quiet quitting with Delaney Mullennix. You coined something in your, like, learning objectives, uh, quiet firing. What is this?
Delaney MullennixSo if we were to define quiet firing in the same way that we define quiet quitting, it's not the intentional act of trying to push someone out of their job or the organization. Quiet firing is, again, kind of those consequences of premature leadership, I think, but also like a burnout leader or a leader who themselves are quiet quitting. So, this is like a very passive management style. So, not providing their reviews, not engaging with your staff members, not providing affirmation.
Tony MartignettiThis is so toxic.
Delaney MullennixYeah.
Tony MartignettiAbsolutely.
Delaney MullennixYeah.
Tony MartignettiAre you seeing a lot of quiet firing? You see examples of— well, you see examples, or is it trending?
Delaney MullennixI think what happens is that I think I've seen more of like the intentional trying to push someone out than I have seen quiet firing. But I think when you see the behavior of quiet quitting at the board level, that executive director is probably leaning towards like a quiet quitting behavior if they're not having a board that's— if they have a board that's quiet firing them. And then it just like trickles down.
Tony MartignettiTrickles down from the board quiet firing to the CEO quiet firing to the employees quiet quitting.
Delaney MullennixYeah. And you feel a lot less guilt, right? Like doing that when you see your leaders doing it. Yeah.
Tony MartignettiOkay. All right. So, what do What should we be thinking about? What should we be conscious of to— well, I think we've talked about what it looks like, identified the symptoms of quiet quitting. What does a CEO, executive director do in the face of this? Maybe it's just one person. Maybe it's— hopefully it's not throughout your teams. You see a quiet quitter, you suspect quiet quitter. What does a CEO do? Yeah.
Delaney MullennixYeah, I think there are a couple of things and a lot of my recommendations that I—
Tony MartignettiOr other supervisors. Sorry, I'm trying to think of all our listeners or other supervisor of the person. It doesn't have to be the CEO.
Delaney MullennixYeah, a lot of my recommendations, I think, try to prevent the quiet quitting from happening. But there's also a lot of conversation around, and we can kind of tell that the quiet quitting phenomenon isn't necessarily all negative. Like, there's a shift in like the power dynamic between like the employee and the employer. Like, employees are now like valuing their time. There's a healthier work-life balance. People are actually intermittently quiet quitting to avoid burnout. And wouldn't the employer want you to do that? Like, burnout is so toxic, especially when it's in leadership.
Tony MartignettiYeah.
Delaney MullennixAnd so, It's not necessarily a good or bad thing. Like, it's going to exist, I think, forever. And it's been happening in generations well before the workforce right now. And there's lots of, like, evidence on that as well. Like, if you look at it, if you look at the US employee engagement trend compared to the rapid shift in generations in the workforce, the engagement has been exactly the same. The same level of employees are engaged since 2000 as they are in 2022. Wow. and the same level of employees are actively disengaged in the 2000s as they are now in 2023. Huh. So, that hasn't changed at all regardless of how much millennials have now skyrocketed. And in 2022, they'll be— or in less than 2 years, they'll be 75% of the entire workforce. And the second biggest generation is going to be Gen Z. But again, that engagement isn't actually changing. So, like, quiet quitting wasn't like a generational thing. Um, it's always been happening.
Tony MartignettiYeah, we're just— we've, we've identified it, we put a label on it. All right, all right. So, all right, so, uh, something of a silver lining. I— it's not— it's not always— 100%.
Delaney MullennixIt's not always toxic. Yeah, this is like the silver lining is that like we're gonna right-size jobs. Um, people are going to be in the right seat. There's going to be a higher level of happiness and engagement. Like, at the end of the day, if we, if we address it in the right way. Um, and I think Yeah, again, like the things that I recommend are, I feel like, almost basic like HR practices. But again, like leaders aren't always equipped to have that skill set. Like they don't know best practices of HR or how to like lead and inspire a team. Like they're premature leaders. Like they need to learn these things. And like, I mean, all the way from like the onboarding experience of your employee to like your job description and your expectations. And again, like trying to match personality to the position. Like these are all things that you can do to try to Make sure that the staff that you're putting into a position is going to be engaged and happy.
Tony MartignettiAll you can do is minimize the likelihood. What about going back to my original question? If you do think you see it, how do you engage the employee with the understanding that it's not always negative? The person might be engaging in just some self-care that they feel that they need. But as the person's supervisor, You're seeing less engagement, maybe poorer performance for some. How do you as the supervisor engage with the employee?
Delaney MullennixYeah, I think when I see people kind of like being asleep at the wheel, I guess, if you will, like you're kind of starting to see like more mistakes in their work, you're like, what is going on? Like, why does this keep happening? I think it is really important to just have like a very open conversation. And I guess it depends on like your comfort level doing that, but I typically will address it from like a very professional standpoint, right? Like, you're not like— and you have to kind of sandwich it in a way that doesn't sound like too— you don't want to like violate anyone's privacy. You don't want to make them feel bad in any way. That's not the point, right? The point is like to help them succeed.
Tony MartignettiBut from a factual basis.
Delaney MullennixYes, but from a factual basis.
Tony MartignettiI've seen your performance declining. Here's 2 examples of what I've seen in the past 6 weeks.
Delaney MullennixYes, and I love how someone once said to me, one of my first, one of the first people who I loved as a business professional, he said, if you're addressing a problem with someone, you need to frame it as, if you continue to do A, B, and C, Then, like, these are the consequences type of a thing. So, you're kind of saying, like, this is the facts, this is what I'm seeing. And actually, I think he starts it as, maybe I feel that something's going on because I see A, B, and C, and these are the consequences if A, B, and C continue to happen. Yeah. And then that employee has to take ownership of saying, okay, I don't want these consequences to happen. And like, let me address like how you're feeling and like what's actually happening. And I think that actually works. Like, I've certainly tried it before, um, and you're taking like a very like unemotional approach to like the situation, um, but it's still kind of getting to the underlying like root cause of that, that employee's like behavior and performance.
Tony MartignettiYeah, that's good. Um, valuable.
Delaney MullennixAnd almost always the employees say, you know, like, this has been going on. Um, I've had employees out during like performance improvement plans and say, like, this is what I've been dealing with for a while, and like I recognize the issues, and like this is like valuable to have this performance improvement plan because this is something I can focus on, like these are my goals to focus on, versus like everything else in their minds that's probably like taking their brain space.
Tony MartignettiAnd that's a great outcome from a meeting or a couple of meetings around this. Yeah.
Delaney MullennixBut I think some questions too that that I'm not sure I am ready to ask my employees. But to the whole purpose point thing, again, the question is, how am I helping you fulfill your personal purpose? Literally, it's a question you could ask verbatim.
Tony MartignettiAll right. Let's turn to your session. You said you had some interesting questions that came out of the session. Like what? What stays with you?
Delaney MullennixSome people were curious I had a woman who seemed like pretty frustrated that it was neither a good or bad thing. I didn't know what to tell her. It just is what it is, but you can like mitigate the negative consequences of it.
Tony MartignettiWhat side was she on? She thought it was good or bad?
Delaney MullennixI don't know.
Tony MartignettiOh, you couldn't tell?
Delaney MullennixShe asked me this question like 5 minutes into my presentation, so—
Tony MartignettiOh yeah? Oh really?
Delaney MullennixI was like, I will get to the pros and cons.
Tony MartignettiOkay, but you had just defined it and said that's not as good.
Delaney MullennixShe's like, I'm confused. And I was like, I know, sometimes it seems a little weird.
Tony MartignettiAll right. You reassured her that we're going to talk about it. All right.
Delaney MullennixYeah.
Tony MartignettiWhat else?
Delaney MullennixOne of the other really curious questions I had was, is trying to match personalities going to create inequity?
Tony MartignettiWell, she's right to be equity-focused on not just hiring somebody who looks like you and spends their social time like you and, you know, That's valuable. She's equity concerned, he or she, equity, with an equity lens. Yeah, it's valuable.
Delaney MullennixYeah.
Tony MartignettiOkay.
Delaney MullennixBut I think that's actually, and I, I really like that question because I've been reading a book called Quiet, and it's the, um, the power of introverts. And it talks about kind of like the history of introverts and how they've been so influential to the workforce and like the values that they bring and like real like stories of these people. Um, and some of like the most influential people that we know today, like, were introverts. And I love this book, but it also says That there was like a shift in America where like the best virtue used to be like integrity, and then it kind of like had this crazy shift to your highest virtue is like your charisma and like your ability to like be social, and it kind of became like the highest rate of currency. Mm-hmm. And so, those people were the ones succeeding in the workforce because that became like the new best thing versus like your integrity, like your loyalty, and like You're like everything else. Super interesting. So, like, I love that question because I've definitely read about that before. So, like, yeah, if you are, but then the question is, not every, like, is every job best fit for an extrovert? Not necessarily.
Tony MartignettiYeah, right.
Delaney MullennixSo, yeah.
Tony MartignettiThere are a lot of jobs where extroverts will be frustrated. All right. Anything else? Anything else on the topic, quiet quitting, that we haven't talked about? I don't want you holding out on Nonprofit Radio listeners from your session yesterday. Anything we— you talked about yesterday that we didn't talk about today?
Delaney MullennixI guess like one thing that I think might be helpful is when you are doing— and again, these are all things that you kind of learn the hard way, but I was always in positions where I was again not getting reviews, or I felt my reviews were important to my manager. So my reviews either were never scheduled, and I had to be like, when's my review? I think it's been a year. Am I going to get a review? Like, when's my review? And you had to like remind that person, remind that person, remind that person to schedule a review. And they're always like, yeah, I'm gonna do it. Yeah, I'm gonna do it. And they never do it, right? I can't tell you how many people have this like similar experience. And then when you get to like the interview, or like when the interview, or when the review is scheduled, maybe they like postpone it. They have to keep rescheduling it because they're not prepared. And then you get into your review and they're like, all 5s, amazing job, see ya.
Tony MartignettiHow could you have possibly thought that your review was not important to them?
Delaney MullennixYeah, crazy.
Tony MartignettiHow could you come up with that conclusion?
Delaney MullennixSo, and it's— it bothers me because reviews are important to employees. Like, I've been on both sides of the thing. And so now as a leader, I will— when any employee starts, I schedule every single one of their reviews, like, literally for a lifetime. Even if that employee is no longer with me, I'm— it's in my schedule, um, and I can take that out of my schedule.
Tony MartignettiPut it in your calendar, like, repeat. Yes. Annual. Annually. Yes. I mean, repeat it all.
Delaney MullennixRepeat. Indefinitely.
Tony MartignettiRight, indefinitely. And never. Yes.
Delaney MullennixSo, I do a 30-day review, a 90-day review, and an annual review. And like, I have those immediately once that— when that employee onboards. And I think that's super important. And like, I try my very, very hardest to never reschedule those meetings. Um, like, you have to look ahead and you have to prepare for that meeting. Um, and it's—
Tony MartignettiYou know what, can I take a little digression from that? That is eminently doable. Yeah. If you put some If you put something in your calendar, you can preserve it. You just tell other people that you're not available that time.
Delaney MullennixExactly. It's just as important as any other obligation that you have on your schedule. Absolutely.
Tony MartignettiUnless it's a crisis, an immediate crisis, or— well, crisis, anything personal, anything large personal could be a crisis. Just the point is, if you put something in your calendar, it can be protected. It's up to you to protect it. Boundaries, and with very few exceptions. You say, no, I'm sorry. Let's find another time. So this idea that I couldn't keep the appointment. Well, you didn't want to keep it for whatever reason. I may not know, but yeah, I mean, it's easy to preserve things. Just set the boundaries and enforce them. Obviously a pet peeve of mine. No, yeah, of course. Digress to.
Delaney MullennixI love it. Someone told me one time that you can't put meeting blocks in your schedule. You have to put meeting locks. A
Tony Martignettimeeting walks.
Delaney MullennixOkay. Yes. And I love that.
Tony MartignettiSo, you're valuing your folks by holding these meetings. Yes.
Delaney MullennixBut when you say someone— when you clearly didn't put any time into a review, like, you think your leader's not paying attention anyways, and this makes it easy to fly under the radar. Like, I'm not gonna put in more effort if, like, you, like, whatever, like, I'm doing great. Okay, good.
Tony MartignettiAnd that was your total feedback.
Delaney MullennixI think the next time I come to my review, you're gonna tell me I'm doing great too, but I've been doing, like, half of what I did before. But we use something called a 5x5x5 template, and it's like one of Gino Wickman's tools under the Entrepreneurial Operating System.
Tony MartignettiWhose tools? You said it very fast.
Delaney MullennixGino Wickman. Gino? Gino Wickman.
Tony MartignettiWickman. Okay.
Delaney MullennixYes, he is the creator of the Entrepreneurial Operating System. A lot of people just say EOS, but we use a couple of his strategies, not all of it. Some companies like completely like go into every part of EOS, but some things we have found to be beneficial, and one of them is the review format. And so, the first column is your core values and behaviors and actions that represent those core values. The second column is a rating. So, you rate this employee on a scale of 1 to 5. The third column is what's working, and the fourth column is what's not working. And you can definitely have things in both of those columns, like, at the same time.
Tony MartignettiFor a particular core value?
Delaney MullennixYes.
Tony MartignettiRight.
Delaney MullennixYes.
Tony MartignettiOkay.
Delaney MullennixAnd so there might be one core value, but there might be 4 actions or behaviors that exhibit that core value for that specific employee's position. And then the 5th column is my favorite. It's the comments column. But there's a very important aspect of this column, and it's supposed to be, what can you do? What can I do? And employee engagement and performance is a 2-way street. And if you're managing this employee, there's always going to be something that you can do and something that they can do to fix what's not working. And that should always happen in that comment section on a review.
Tony MartignettiOkay. All right. Anything you want to leave us with around quiet quitting?
Delaney MullennixI don't think so.
Tony MartignettiHow about some inspiration? Just maybe just— well, I'll say it's a reminder that it's not good or bad. It's neither. But some inspiration around what folks can look out for and how they can help their teams?
Delaney MullennixYeah, I think maybe something inspirational, and I really truly feel this, is that, um, I think nonprofit, the nonprofit sector, even though they— everyone keeps saying that we're losing like the most talent and like the most employees than anyone in like the great resignation, um, that needs to be changed. But I think it— I think that we have the biggest advantage out of any sector to change that. Because we are the purpose sector. Like, we are not-for-profit, all for purpose. And so I think we have, like, a hand up here, and so I think we can do better.
Tony MartignettiDelaney Mullennix, Executive Director of NonprofitHub. You'll find them at nonprofithub.org, an outstanding resource for nonprofits. Delaney, thanks very much for sharing.
Delaney MullennixThank you so much.
Tony MartignettiYou had a lot of valuable advice. Thank you. And thank you for being with Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio coverage of 23NTC, the 2023 Nonprofit Technology Conference, where we are sponsored by Heller Consulting, technology strategy and implementation for nonprofits. Thanks for being with us. It's time for Tony's Take Two. I need a redux on last week's, it isn't, it is what it is. I think I stressed the wrong thing when I made the point that it is what it is absolves blame, and rather we should be accepting blame or accepting responsibility, accountability, either accepting it for ourselves or assigning it. Okay, that was the point I made last week. That was my major point. And there's something that I just mentioned Which really is the bigger point. So that's why I need the redux. I just mentioned that if you assign, ah, it is what it is to something, then you're accepting it and you're not looking at possibilities for changing the thing, the situation, the problem. You're just throwing up your hands and saying— Yeah. It is what it is. It can't be changed. So really what I want to focus on is not, not accepting that. Is there some way that the thing, the situation, the problem, the issue could be changed? And to know if it could be changed, we need to figure out who's responsible. So that's really That's really the, the flow of my thinking. Don't just throw your hands up with it is what it is and give up on a situation. If it's important enough, look for ways that you can change it. That is Tony's Take Two. We've got beaucoup buttloads more time. Here is email accessibility. Hello and welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio coverage of 23NTC. It's the 2023 Nonprofit Technology Conference, and this is our first interview of the conference where we are sponsored by Heller Consulting. technology strategy and implementation for nonprofits. With me to kick off our coverage is Coralie Meade Rodriguez. She is Senior Production Specialist at Firefly Partners. Welcome, Coralie.
Coralie Meade RodriguezThank you. I really appreciate the ability to be here and speak with you today.
Tony MartignettiIt's my pleasure, and I'm very much looking forward to the Firefly pizza dinner and beer celebration tomorrow night, right?
Coralie Meade RodriguezI am as well. It should be a really good time.
Tony MartignettiOkay, cool. We'll see you there again. All right. Your session topic here at 23 NTC is how to make your organization's email messages accessible. Why did you think we need this topic? What are we not doing quite right?
Coralie Meade RodriguezThat's a really good question. And it's something that I myself have been learning a lot about over the past year. And have determined that there's all kinds of different things that we can do to make email accessible, from the content that we are writing to the images that we use, the branding colors that we have, and the design elements pulling everything together. It's been a fascinating process to learn.
Tony MartignettiAnd there are a lot of people in the U.S. who have disabilities, right?
Coralie Meade RodriguezVery many, yes, in all wide ranges of areas you wouldn't even expect.
Tony MartignettiI think you cited in your description over 26% of the U.S. population?
Coralie Meade RodriguezYes, exactly. And it's not only physical limitations, but language barriers and temporary disabilities. All kinds of different things are covered.
Tony MartignettiOkay, so let's jump in a bit. You have something called the WCAG Email Accessibility Guidelines.
Coralie Meade RodriguezYes.
Tony MartignettiWhat's that? First, I have jargon jail on Nonprofit Radio, so you have to define WCAG.
Coralie Meade RodriguezI am very happy to. These are the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines, and they go for all digital assets out there. So not just email, but web and PowerPoint presentations or anything else that is a digital asset.
Tony MartignettiOkay. And so what can we learn from WCAG? WCAG.
Coralie Meade RodriguezThese are international standards that are designed to create content that is accessible in all of these different areas. So what they do is they set the standards that we need to meet, and there's many different levels. Currently, there is the 2.1 level, and that is the one where there's both a AA and a AAA level. Most folks especially in the nonprofit world, are just learning about these, so they're all brand new. So what we need to do is figure out what they are first and then how to apply them to our everyday work.
Tony MartignettiOkay, the guidelines. So Web Content Accessibility Guidelines? Yes. WCAG. Okay. Why— just available online somewhere? I don't know. Where do we find them, first of all?
Coralie Meade RodriguezThey're part of the W3C Consortium, which is again part of the International Standards Standards around just web accessibility and everything out there. Basically, these are the folks who defined how Microsoft should be writing their code and how everybody else should be writing the code, setting the standards that they needed to meet.
Tony MartignettiOkay, so, but do we as content producers— I mean, we need to know the WCAG guidelines too, because you said it filters down to like PowerPoints.
Coralie Meade RodriguezYeah.
Tony MartignettiSo do we need to be— I mean, do we need to go and read the guidelines? Or is it just the guidelines are more higher level, like Microsoft levels, than our work?
Coralie Meade RodriguezIt's a very good question. There are a lot of different criteria, and really what you need to be aware of are the criteria that apply to your specific work. So me, with email accessibility, there are about 4 or 5 that I need to pay attention to. So if somebody's doing PowerPoint presentations, there are other ones that they would need to But these 4 are also a part of that.
Tony MartignettiSo first of all, the guidelines are online, we can find them?
Coralie Meade RodriguezThey are, yes.
Tony MartignettiOkay, web content accessibility
Coralie Meade Rodriguezguidelines.
Tony MartignettiThank you very much. Okay, all right, so what specifically to email? So we're talking about email accessibility. What do we need to learn from, from the guidelines?
Coralie Meade RodriguezYeah, what you need to learn around the guidelines is that there are 4 different criteria. The first one is around having hyperlinks that are underlined in your messages. There is also one around color contrasts that you want to have a 4.5 to 1 ratio between the different colors that you use. And for example, if you think about the color of a background of one section of the message, and there may be a button on top of that, you want to make sure that the button color contrast ratio and that background color meet that 4.5 to 1 ratio.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Okay. We're going to come back to that, the ratio. What are the other 2?
Coralie Meade RodriguezThe other 2, one of them is around the text that you use in a hyperlink, that it needs to be descriptive. So I see very often in my work with clients that people are hyperlinking and underlining read more or click more.
Tony MartignettiRight. Or here.
Coralie Meade RodriguezExactly. And that's not descriptive.
Tony MartignettiThat's no good. No.
Coralie Meade RodriguezFor somebody who is using a screen reader or another accessibility device, they're not going to know what they're being taken to. All they know is read more. And when a screen reader is reading an email message, it pulls all the links together in one spot. So it's not necessarily as you're reading through the content.
Tony MartignettiOh, that's the key. It's not in context with the sentence that the link is a part of.
Coralie Meade RodriguezCorrect. So they'll see read more, read more, read more, Click here, read more. And that's not descriptive enough to know where they're being taken.
Tony MartignettiBasically worthless.
Coralie Meade RodriguezYeah.
Tony MartignettiUntil you click every single thing to find— okay. Okay. So, all right. Yeah, I understand. All right. So the hyperlinked text itself. And then what's the final one?
Coralie Meade RodriguezThe final one is actually escaping me at the moment. I can't think of it.
Tony MartignettiAll right. That's okay. It'll come back to you, I'll bet you.
Coralie Meade RodriguezYeah.
Tony MartignettiLet's go back to color contrast. How do you know what your ratio is?
Coralie Meade RodriguezThere are luckily a lot of different color contrast checkers out there on the web. My favorite one is Color Contrast CC, and that one is where you simply go in and you enter the hexadecimal values of your colors. Yes. And that's one way of reading what the colors are, and it will tell you in comparison, like say a dark purple font on a light lavender background You've got those 2 hexadecimal values, you can compare them in the tool, and it'll tell you exactly what that ratio is. So if it's a 3.24:1, you know that you need to make your dark purple darker or your lavender lighter in order to increase that contrast ratio.
Tony MartignettiOkay, because you want to be where? Between 4—
Coralie Meade Rodriguez4.5:1.
Tony Martignetti4.5:1. Okay, 4.5:1. Okay, okay. All right, so that was color contrast. So just colorcontrastcc.com?
Coralie Meade RodriguezYeah, if you look out there, just a simple search for color contrast, that will give you a lot of different options out there. So that's just my personal favorite.
Tony MartignettiAnd your designer should know your hexadecimal numbers?
Coralie Meade RodriguezExactly.
Tony MartignettiFor the different colors you're using. Okay. Is there anything more to say about the hyperlinks underline part? Is it just that they should be underlined?
Coralie Meade RodriguezReally, because we've We've switched away from making things so accessible over the last 10 or 20 years. Really, we want to make sure that you're underlining those, and that's super important because it's going to be consistent with other people's email messages out there. That's what folks are expecting to see. So if your color contrasts, number one, are not strong enough, having that hyperlink underneath it, the text decoration, is really going to call it out so that it's very clearly identified and able to be seen when somebody is scanning through a message quickly.
Tony MartignettiOkay, and underlining, not— underlining more valuable than just boldfacing a hyperlink?
Coralie Meade RodriguezYes.
Tony MartignettiSpecifically underlined?
Coralie Meade RodriguezSpecifically underlined, yes.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Did the 4th one occur to you by any chance yet?
Coralie Meade RodriguezNo, it still hasn't come to mind.
Tony MartignettiOkay, we're going to move on then. No problem. All right. ADA. The Americans with Disabilities Act email compliance, that's another— this is another standard we need to be aware of?
Coralie Meade RodriguezIt is, and it's taken into consideration with the WCAG guidelines. So those Web Content Accessibility Guidelines pull in all of those ADA requirements as a part of it.
Tony MartignettiOh, okay. So if we're— oh, WCAG. All right, now we're in like insider WCAG, not WCAG like I was Is that what you're calling it? WCAG? Yes. All right, well, I'm trainable. Okay, I'll call it WCAG. All right, so if you're— so in other words, if you're adhering to WCAG, then you're adhering to ADA? You are. You are, necessarily?
Coralie Meade RodriguezYes.
Tony MartignettiOkay. All right, so one set of guidelines covers us.
Coralie Meade RodriguezIt does. The WCAG guidelines really took all of those accessibility things into consideration around disabilities.
Tony MartignettiAnything more you want to say about WCAG before we move Before on? we move to another topic?
Coralie Meade RodriguezNo, I, I think it's something that you really need to pay attention to. And I'd say the only other thing I'd love to add is that there are changes that are due out at the end of May 2023. So what we're setting as our standards right now may change. I don't expect them to be dramatic, but there are dramatic changes coming in the future. I just don't think that they're quite going to be released at the end of May 2023. COVID gave us a little bit of a remission space where people are putting out things a little bit slower than they used to in the past.
Tony MartignettiAll right, so it's coming. This will likely air in or after May of this year?
Coralie Meade RodriguezYes.
Tony MartignettiSo if we just keep on top of WCAG, we'll have the most current whenever— I mean, Either it'll either be pre-change or post-change, but so if you're looking in May, you might want to look again in June, July to make sure because there's changes coming. Yeah. That's the point?
Coralie Meade RodriguezYeah, the, the May 2023 ones are some of the bigger ones, but there's definitely another full version that's due out after that. Right now we're at 2.1, and I think it's supposed to be jumping up to 2.3.
Tony MartignettiOkay, okay. Uh, in the background you'll hear 23 NTC kicking off, 'cause Nonprofit Radio is more efficient than the conference overall, so we started about 10 minutes. Coralie and I started about 10 minutes before the conference officially kicked off. But in the background, you may have heard that, I don't know if you could recognize the voice, but that was Amy Sample Ward, the CEO, kicking off 23 NTC here on the exhibit floor. All right, so Coralie, let's go to email accessibility best practices for designers. There's more. There's more than just WCAG.
Coralie Meade RodriguezThere is. Okay, that you really need to think about those color contrast ratios and the color contrast checkers from a designer standpoint. In addition to that, you want to make sure you have plenty of space around your call-to-action buttons. Remember, over 50% of folks are reading email on their mobile devices, and they need space to be able to click the buttons and be taken to that action without interfering with other text or other links that may be on the page as well.
Tony MartignettiSometimes it feels like people don't, don't recognize that— what is it, 80% or 80-85% of people are using the web and looking at email on their phone, right?
Coralie Meade RodriguezThey are.
Tony MartignettiSo some smaller device, and yeah, right. That's true. It makes so much— you go to push it, you have to enlarge the screen a lot of times to get to the button that you want.
Coralie Meade RodriguezExactly.
Tony MartignettiAnd only that button.
Coralie Meade RodriguezYep. Font size is also a really big important part as well. Like you mentioned with the scrolling, think about the footer of any of your messages where you've got your unsubscribe link or change your preferences. In the majority of messages that I see my clients sending out, they're using a small font And it is accessible, but sometimes I've had to myself scroll on my mobile device in order to click that unsubscribe. You want to make that easily accessible so people can get off your list and make sure that your email deliverability rates stay high.
Tony MartignettiYes, right, because if people are ignoring your emails, that hurts your deliverability likelihood.
Coralie Meade RodriguezIt does. They could be marking you as spam, and that's going to definitely affect your email deliverability.
Tony MartignettiWe don't, yeah, we don't have anybody this year on email deliverability, but we have at past NTCs. You and I are talking about accessibility, but deliverability is a whole other topic.
Coralie Meade RodriguezIt is.
Tony MartignettiAnd so one of the things is you want people who are engaging with your emails, not just ignoring them or letting them sit in spam.
Coralie Meade RodriguezYou want folks to be engaged so that they're actively participating in your organization and supporting you. They know what content you're putting out there. They're in full support of your mission, or if not, they're unsubscribing and leaving and going on to something else that they're more interested in.
Tony MartignettiBut even if they, even if they don't unsubscribe, the email providers are smart enough to know how people are treating your emails, right?
Coralie Meade RodriguezThey are. They can see that there's no activity, and that's going to affect your deliverability.
Tony MartignettiExactly. All right.
Coralie Meade RodriguezYeah.
Tony MartignettiAnything else? Best practices for designers? I mean, you don't have to be a professional email designer to be paying attention to spacing and font size.
Coralie Meade RodriguezNo, exactly. You do not.
Tony MartignettiWhat other best practices you got for us?
Coralie Meade RodriguezYou also want to make sure that you're limiting your use of all caps in your messages, because what's really happening is the all caps text comes across as very Square, and it's not easily identifiable to somebody who is looking at the message quickly. So we all have a normal pattern of looking at words and recognizing them by their shape. When you're using all caps, you're taking that away and making all of the words very rectangular, so it's harder to process what you're reading.
Tony MartignettiInteresting. So all caps is harder to process?
Coralie Meade RodriguezIt is, yes indeed.
Tony MartignettiWell, we think it stands out.
Coralie Meade RodriguezIt does stand out, but it's still going to take folks 1 second longer to really process what they're reading.
Tony MartignettiOkay, okay. Others, other best practices, please.
Coralie Meade RodriguezAnother one is not centering your text, or if you're going to center your text, use it with a very short headline. All of the other text of the main part of the message should be left-aligned, and this again goes to the readability of the message. That when you get to the end of the line, if everything is centered, it's going to take folks a little bit longer to identify where the start of the next line is as they read down the message.
Tony MartignettiOkay. So there are studies about how people read, how long it takes them to read email on a mobile device.
Coralie Meade RodriguezYeah. Right now it takes about 9 seconds for somebody to comprehend the content that they're reading in a message. Or at least that's the amount of time that they're devoting on average to reading a message. Especially if someone has cognitive disabilities, it's going to take them a little bit longer to process, but their attention span is not going to be longer than those 9 seconds. So if you want to get your message across, you want to make sure that everything is really easy for them to read, identify, and get the content out and understand what they're reading.
Tony Martignetti9 seconds. That sounds like still just enough time for my mother to create guilt for me. 9 seconds doesn't sound like much, but it's eminently doable for her. Okay, other best practices before we move on?
Coralie Meade RodriguezNo, that's really it for the design perspective. And again, like you mentioned, you don't have to be a full designer to apply these to any message that you're building.
Tony MartignettiYeah, right. These are basics. I mean, just don't use all caps. Or use them very judiciously and don't center only headlines, etc. Okay.
Coralie Meade RodriguezYeah.
Tony MartignettiOkay. I don't see a reason for all caps. Is there justification for all caps anywhere?
Coralie Meade RodriguezNo, I think from the design perspective, it does make things stand out a little bit more. But if you think about processing time of somebody reading that, that could be the negative for why not to use it.
Tony MartignettiRight. But it's just taken as shouting too, right? I mean, I still perceive it that way. Am I too 2002? Am I still Am I like a dinosaur? When I see all caps, I still think people are shouting.
Coralie Meade RodriguezYeah, I think that is a generational thing because my daughter actually does not see it the same way. She doesn't see it as shouting, and she's just 18.
Tony MartignettiShe's 18. She does not. All right. Gen Z. Okay. Do you? What do you think?
Coralie Meade RodriguezI think it's all shouting, definitely.
Tony MartignettiYeah. Thank you for representing. You don't have to be 61 like I am to think that it's all shouting. All right. Another sort of takeaway that you promised is code HTML emails with better accessibility. Yes. Now, if we're talking about coding HTML, is this higher-level design-type advice?
Coralie Meade RodriguezYou definitely have to have some understanding of what you're looking for in the messages. And again, this definitely ties back to what email platform you're using to send your messages. If they're using a drag-drop type of approach, you may not be able to get to the HTML, so this is something that you don't need to pay attention to.
Tony MartignettiLike a MailChimp?
Coralie Meade RodriguezLike a MailChimp or a Constant Contact.
Tony MartignettiRight. You're dragging and dropping. You highlight, you work on, you enter what you want, and the provider puts it in the right format, etc. You just click a button to do what you want.
Coralie Meade RodriguezExactly. They're adding all that code for you. All
Tony Martignettiright, all right. So that's— this is higher level. The HTML part is for folks who are actually getting into the code of their emails.
Coralie Meade RodriguezIt is, yes. All right. But even along with this, there are definitely some things that you can look for.
Tony MartignettiOkay, good.
Coralie Meade RodriguezSuch as adding alt text to your images. You want to make sure there is an alternative description for any images. We all know that Outlook is notorious for turning off an image, so the first thing you're going to see is that alternative text. A screen reader is also going to see the alternative text. So that's how you get to explain exactly what the purpose of this image is. What is it containing? What's the message you're trying to get across?
Tony MartignettiYou know, a lot of this occurs to me as just, I don't know, it's kind of thoughtfulness. If you just be thoughtful, like include alt text, make your hyperlinks descriptive, you know, more than a word or two. I mean, some of this just seems like common sense. If you're conscious, you'll be more thoughtful about accessibility.
Coralie Meade RodriguezAnd that's really what it is. One of the things I noticed that I was doing over the past 5 years was rushing through a message to get it out the door. Somebody would give me the content in 1 hour, and I had to send by 5 o'clock. And I know that that happens in a lot of nonprofits. You've got that deadline you have to meet. But if we stop and think about all these accessibility practices, It's not that much more time that we're adding on in order to get these messages able to be read by everybody out there.
Tony MartignettiOkay. I'm interested in how you got into email message accessibility. That's pretty— seems like a pretty narrow niche.
Coralie Meade RodriguezIt is, but it definitely ties into everything else out there. I've been working in email for over 20 years, working in the MailChimp I've worked in Luminate Online, Engaging Networks, Pardot, Salesforce Marketing Cloud, you name it. There are very consistent things across all of those platforms and things that you have to do. You have to write the content, the message, you have to have who it's coming from, the subject line, etc. So building upon that and diving into different things with different clients, I've learned about the email deliverability. I've learned about now within the last year The accessibility, and there's always a new layer of something that you can learn tied into email that's going to help nonprofits get their message out there and connect with the right people.
Tony MartignettiYou've spent 20 years working in email.
Coralie Meade RodriguezI have.
Tony MartignettiYou're a dedicated email professional.
Coralie Meade RodriguezI am, and it's a very unique place to be.
Tony MartignettiYeah.
Coralie Meade RodriguezBecause it's not like the web. The standards are not the same for how the email clients have to All right, say
Tony Martignettia little more about that. What do you mean?
Coralie Meade RodriguezWell, think about Microsoft Outlook as one example, and then you also have Gmail and you have Yahoo. There's no consistency in how those email tools are built to read the messages and the code that they're getting. So one will very happily accept centered buttons and another one will not. Like Outlook does not like rounded corners on buttons. And there's special coding that you have to use in order to enforce those. Background images behind messages, that's one that's really hard to do. And there's a whole bunch of little nitty-gritty details around the coding that you can force things to look one way or another, but you're never going to get that perfect picture email to look the same on all of those different platforms. There's approximately 15,000 different ways any one message could look when it's sent out into the world.
Tony MartignettiSo how do you— I think what happens for a lot of us is we just, we're not email, 20-year email professionals like you are. So we just say, oh, screw it. I'll just, I'll do something else. Forget the rounded edges. Forget the background image. You know, I'll just, I'll do something else. Yeah. But as a 20-year email professional, so all right, 15 15,000 different platforms. We're talking about different renderings, right? Rendering of email. How do you— so how do you satisfy a client who isn't going to just say, oh, screw it?
Coralie Meade RodriguezThat's a really good question.
Tony MartignettiI want it this way for 99% of the people who get my email.
Coralie Meade RodriguezYeah.
Tony MartignettiWhat do you do?
Coralie Meade RodriguezWhat I do is I look at their data lists and I see what email clients their supporters are using. And from there, I see what the top percentages are. Is it Outlook? Is it Gmail? Is it Yahoo? And I make sure that the emails look good in those top 20%. And then when we get down to the very bottom of that $15,000 list, we really can decide, you know, that, okay, maybe there's an Apple device that folks are really not using very much. Maybe that's only 1% of their audience. Okay. And that's the one that we make sure it looks good, But it's not going to match the others.
Tony MartignettiOkay. That was the hypothetical client who said, make it look right for 99%.
Coralie Meade RodriguezAnd that is a real client. They do exist.
Tony MartignettiThey do exist. All right. We won't deal with the one who says it's got to be 100%. Yeah. All right. Very interesting. All right. Anything else you want to tell us about email message accessibility? We have time together if there's anything we didn't cover that you want to talk about.
Coralie Meade RodriguezYeah. One more point that I'd like to make is around the language that we're using in our messages. There is a style of writing called plain language, which uses simplified sentences and everyday language, which really breaks down the barriers about the content that we're sending out into the world. Most of the time, you would think that writings that everybody could understand would be a best practice, naturally. Yes. But in the way that we write in the news media, through health information, and I do work with a lot of health-focused nonprofit organizations, the language gets overly complex and it's not necessarily understood by those who are receiving the messages. So if we use a plain language style of writing, that is going to really help break down the words that are used and the intent of the message so that everybody can understand.
Tony MartignettiAll right, plain language. Does that just mean try to write more like the way we speak?
Coralie Meade RodriguezYes. So it's less like what you learn in college as the professional, you know, this is the grammar style that you need to use. Yeah, all of that.
Tony MartignettiContractions could be okay?
Coralie Meade RodriguezExactly.
Tony MartignettiI can't instead of I cannot, or, you know. All right, so a more friendly, a more, more, yeah, more friendly sounding tone?
Coralie Meade RodriguezYes.
Tony MartignettiIs preferred.
Coralie Meade RodriguezIt's going to be understood by a wider audience base.
Tony MartignettiOkay. So forget what you learned in your college English course, because that was writing for academic journals.
Coralie Meade RodriguezExactly.
Tony MartignettiA lot of it, or essays and theses. But we're writing blog posts, emails, sidebars. We don't have the luxury of 15,000 words for For a research journal, you know, we're trying to get our point across in like 200 words.
Coralie Meade RodriguezExactly, with somebody who has a very short digital attention span.
Tony MartignettiBut still long enough for my mother to create guilt.
Coralie Meade RodriguezYes.
Tony MartignettiAll right, Coralie, we're gonna leave it there. Are you okay? Anything else?
Coralie Meade RodriguezThat's all I've got today. I really appreciate this.
Tony MartignettiThank you. When is your— when is you doing your— when are you doing your session?
Coralie Meade RodriguezMy presentation is this afternoon, I think 2 Alright,
Tony Martignettigood luck. I hope it goes very well.
Coralie Meade RodriguezThank you.
Tony MartignettiAlright, my pleasure. It's Coralie Meade Rodriguez, Senior Production Specialist at Firefly Partners. Looking forward to the party tomorrow night. And, uh, thank you for being with our 23 NTC coverage, where we are sponsored by Heller Consulting, technology strategy and implementation for nonprofits. Next week, data maturity and engagement and stewardship. If you missed any part of this week's show, I beseech you, find it at tonymartignetti.com. We're sponsored by DonorBox. With intuitive fundraising software from DonorBox, your donors give 4 times faster. Helping you help others, donorbox.org. Our creative producer is Claire Meyerhoff. The show's social media is by Susan Chavez. Marc Silverman is our web guy. And this music is by Scott Stein. Yeah! Thank you for that affirmation, Scotty. Be with me next week for Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. Go out and be great.
I love our sponsor!

More Episodes from 2023 Nonprofit Technology Conference
View All

Communications & Development Teams Working Better Together
with Misty McLaughlin and Alice Hendricks




10 Easy Ways To Boost Your Fundraising On A Budget & Personalized Fundraising At Scale
with Rosalind Zavras, Julia Toepfer, Joe Frye, and Peter Yagecic




Brand Democracy & What To Avoid When Selecting Your Next CRM
with Claire Taylor Hansen, Jennifer Daw Holloway, John Coogan, and J. Michael Fisher


