Skip to content
EP 670December 11, 2023

Lessons From The Sam Altman & OpenAI Headlines

Tony MartignettiGene Takagi
Nonprofit Radio
Episode 670
0:00 / 0:00

About this episode

Our legal contributor, Gene Takagi, returns to first, unravel the story in his clear, plain language way. Then he shares his wisdom on the takeaways for nonprofits including good governance, proper documentation, gift acceptance, commercial co-ventures, and more. Gene is managing attorney of NEO, the Nonprofit & Exempt Organizations law group.

Here’s the transcript

Tony MartignettiHello and welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. I'm your aptly named host and the podfather of your favorite hebdomadal podcast. Oh, I'm glad you're with us. I'd get slapped with a diagnosis of lordosis if I had to shoulder the burden of knowing that you missed this week's show. Here's our associate producer Kate with what's up this week.

Kate MartignettiHey Tony, this week we have lessons from the Sam Altman and OpenAI headlines. Our legal contributor, Gene Takagi, returns to first unravel the story in his clear, plain language way. Then he shares his wisdom on the takeaways for nonprofits, including good governance, proper documentation, gift acceptance, commercial co-ventures, and more on Tony's Take Two.

Tony MartignettiHow I can versus why I can't.

Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by DonorBox. Outdated donation forms blocking your supporters' generosity this giving season? DonorBox, the fast, flexible, and friendly fundraising platform for nonprofits. DonorBox.org. Here is Lessons from the Sam Altman and OpenAI Headlines.

Tony MartignettiIt's always a genuine pleasure to welcome Gene Takagi back to Nonprofit Radio. You know who he is, but he deserves a proper introduction nonetheless. He is our legal contributor and managing attorney of NEO, the Nonprofit and Exempt Organizations Law Group in San Francisco. He edits that wildly popular nonprofitlawblog.com, and he's a part-time lecturer at Columbia University. His firm is at neolawgroup.com. And Gene is @GTak. Gene, welcome back to the show. It's a pleasure to see you, pleasure to have you.

Gene TakagiIt's great to see you as well, Tony. Thank you very much for having me.

Tony MartignettiAbsolutely. Let's start our discussion, uh, about the, uh, the Sam Altman and the OpenAI and the, the potential implications for, uh, for our listeners in small and mid-sized nonprofits. With— if you could just sort of summarize what happened between Sam and his nonprofit entity and his for-profit— not his, but the nonprofit entity, the for-profit entity, and what inspired you to think about this and write a 2-part blog post at nonprofitlawblog.com.

Gene TakagiYeah, I mean, it's a great story, Tony. It gets a little convoluted, but, you know, it was dominating our headlines for a few days.

Tony MartignettiYeah.

Gene TakagiAnd I think a lot of people sort of lost sight about, like, one important fact is that the whole organization started out as a nonprofit public charity. So this is, you know, a charity with charitable assets that decided, hey, we're gonna, develop AI in a way that's gonna like impact the world. But we're not gonna do it for the benefit of for-profit investors. We're gonna do it for the good of humanity, right? So that's the way the charity was developed and why they thought, hey, let's develop it in a charity. Let's not develop this in a for-profit. Let's do it in a charity.

Tony MartignettiSo just to be explicit, OpenAI is a 501.

Gene TakagiOpenAI Inc. That's

Tony Martignettiimportant. Yeah, right. That's important. It becomes important in the story. OpenAI Inc. Is a— is the charitable entity, the 501.

Gene TakagiThat's right.

Tony MartignettiWhich Sam Altman is the founder of.

Gene TakagiRight. Founder and board member. Just as an aside, Elon Musk was one of the initial board members as well and might have tried to take it over, but didn't— wasn't able to do that. But that's another story. So they were formed in 2015, and they probably took a year or so to get going. And I don't know that they expected to develop into such a prominent player in the field, the dominant AI player with ChatGPT, right? So GPT, ChatGPT, I think a billion users within just like months or even, you know, several weeks is the fastest growing application, I think, in history. So an amazing thing. Now, before we got to that stage, the nonprofit sort of realized, yeah, we're developing this and, you know, we raised I don't know, like $100 million or so to develop this AI technology, but we need a lot more if we're really gonna like produce something substantial. And

Tony Martignettithat's their original goal was $1 billion.

Gene TakagiYeah. And they couldn't get there. So they said, you know, this faces some other nonprofits as well when they want to do something at scale and they learn, you know, we actually need to sort of partner up or collaborate with for-profit investors here, and they're interested in this technology as well. But we have to remember the whole idea was we're doing this for humanity and not be controlled by a for-profit investor that tells us what to do. So they decided to drop down a subsidiary. They formed a subsidiary, and then they took in investments in the subsidiary. But by forming the subsidiary, presumably they contributed some amount of technology that they had developed to this point. So they raised over $100 million and they developed technology and they contributed down to the for-profit. Now other investors are investing in it. And, you know, it got to the point where I think Microsoft's investment— and Microsoft is the 2nd biggest company in the world, so talking about a big player— I think Microsoft's investment was in the realm of $8 billion, I think, in total. So, I mean, there's a lot of investment. Of course, not all at once, but And they created the subsidiary, which was a limited liability company or LLC. So I'll just refer to it as the LLC. And so OpenAI Inc., the nonprofit, has now contributed charitable assets to an LLC and is in partners, in essence, with all of these other for-profit investors who've invested a lot more money than OpenAI did. But because OpenAI had charitable assets contributed into the LLC, which it created, it sort of said, before we bring in investors, let's set the rules. And the rules are we're going to make the LLC, you know, provide in the operating agreement and provide to any investors that invest in us that this technology is going to, you know, be developed for the benefit of humanity. And this is what the operating agreement said, and that is a private document, so we can't see the full thing. But this is on OpenAI Inc.'s website, and it says that the operating agreement of the LLC provides, it would be wise to view an investment in the LLC in the spirit of a donation, with the understanding that it may be difficult to know what role money will play in a post-AI world. And the company's duty to this mission, the LLC's duty to this mission, will take precedence over any obligation to generate a profit. The company may never make a profit, and the company is under no obligation to do so. So before Microsoft put in any money or any other investors put in money, this is the operating agreement that they are signing and accepting. So that's the thing. The other thing they did was they said, The nonprofit's board is effectively going to be the fiduciaries, essentially the board of the LLC as well. So they're gonna determine what is in the best interest of the LLC. So they're wearing 2 hats now. One is as the hat of the board members of the nonprofit, and one is as the board members that sort of govern the LLC. And at some point, the board and Sam Altman, or majority of the board and Sam Altman, the founder, who is also the CEO of the LLC, were in conflict. And the board decided that they didn't want to keep Sam on as CEO. Now, they gave a reason for it, and it was essentially that he wasn't open and sharing.

Tony MartignettiThat's the board of the LLC?

Gene TakagiCorrect, which is the same as the board of the nonprofit.

Tony MartignettiSo It's right, but it's not the nonprofit entity board that I understand. They're the same people, but they operate in 2 different—

Gene TakagiRight.

Tony MartignettiThey operate as 2 different entities.

Gene TakagiWearing 2 different hats.

Tony MartignettiJust like a person could be an individual and a trustee or an executor and an individual. So the LLC board and Sam Altman were in conflict.

Gene TakagiYeah. And so let me say that there They made the structure much more complicated than that. So there are other entities that are acting as partners. But for, for, for like, let's call this a hypothetical. We're simplifying it. So this may not all be accurate because we don't get to see all the private documents involved. But essentially the same people are involved in both as the governing body or the fiduciary. So the board members of the nonprofit seem to be the same as the board members of the LLC from a practical perspective.

Tony MartignettiSo, right.

Gene TakagiI'll go along with you kind of just using that analogy, but with that sort of caveat or disclaimer.

Tony MartignettiYes, absolutely. Because there was a third-party entity, a managing entity in between the two, but—

Gene TakagiAnd a holding company as well.

Tony MartignettiYeah, right. But for simplicity, let's keep it to two. And it's not, it's not a distortion of the story. It's just, it's for our purposes, it's, it's not a significant detail.

Gene TakagiYeah. So again, this is not the news for, for everybody, but this is trying to learn some lessons here from what went on.

Tony MartignettiOf course.

Gene TakagiSo yeah, wearing their hats as the fiduciaries of the LLC, they decided they were going to remove or terminate Sam Altman as CEO. Now, this alarmed a lot of people, and particularly because I think it's widely viewed that this was a PR blunder as well, that the board members of the LLC, the same board members of the nonprofit, And said basically we're firing him because he wasn't sort of open to what he was really, you know, doing. Or they didn't say that there was any fraud or any unlawful conduct. But I think, you know, the presumption was that he wasn't really looking after the mission of the nonprofit that was built into the operating agreement and therefore the purposes of the LLC as well. He was really looking to advance the AI from a commercial context. Let's expand it and grow the scope of the business. Just like in the for-profit world would traditionally do. But the board members kind of had this background, you know, some of them anyways, academics and kind of people who kind of understood the charitable context of it and were more concerned with the ethical issues related to AI. And I think, you know, you've probably discussed that with some guests in the past as well, of artificial intelligence and what that might mean beyond just making the world easier for all of us because we can talk to machines, there are some dangers with that as well. And I think the board didn't— felt like Sam was like progressing on like, let's make this, this, you know, huge company and let's dominate the space, and not thinking as much about the ethical considerations that the board had.

Kate MartignettiIt's time for a break. Are you looking to maximize your fundraising efforts and impact this giving season? DonorBox's online donation platform is designed to help you reach your fundraising goals. From customizable donation forms to far-reaching EasyShare crowdfunding and peer-to-peer options, plus seamless in-person giving with DonorBox Live Kiosk. DonorBox makes giving simple and fast for your donors and moves the needle on your mission. Visit donorbox.org. And let DonorBox help you help others. Now back to Lessons from the Sam Altman and OpenAI Headlines.

Tony MartignettiI saw this sort of captioned in something I was reading, or maybe it was even a video that I saw just, you know, a week or 10 days ago when this was all capturing headlines. It was basically a Altruism versus accelerationism.

Gene TakagiI won't go too much down the rabbit holes because there is this whole effective altruism movement that was embraced, I think, by one or more board members that's associated with Sam Bankman-Fried, sort of the whole other area. But avoiding that rabbit hole for the moment, yes, that I think that's right, that there's kind of like, are we doing this for a charitable reason? Because this is an LLC with outside investors who put in most of the money, but they agreed that, hey, this is the operating agreement. We are gonna be operating really for the benefit of humanity, and we may not expect a profit. And in fact, we were told, don't expect a profit. Think of this as a donation. But then when you terminate somebody, we thought, this makes no sense. And then I think, you know, from the perspective of some investors, even though some of them, you know, were involved in the signing of this operating agreement, And the employees of OpenAI, who are probably a lot of engineers and others who were involved in the tech world that probably weren't involved in nonprofit technology, so not really thinking about the charitability of it, they had a huge uprising against this move that the board did. And so within days, you've got Microsoft being upset and saying, you know, we may desire just to hire Altman and run the AI division within Microsoft itself, because by this time OpenAI and Microsoft are now very embedded together. Microsoft being the, you know, the primary or the biggest investor in OpenAI, I believe. And a lot of their sort of programs that we're, or apps that we're familiar with, like Word and Outlook, now have OpenAI sort of structures built into them. And I don't know if you remember, Tony, another aside. Do you remember Clippy from Microsoft's old, like, AI help? This is from the '90s where you could say help and Clippy, an animated paperclip, would pop up on your screen.

Tony MartignettiI didn't know Clippy by name. Sorry. I'm sorry, Clippy, to the designers of Clippy. I didn't know him. I mean, I don't know. Clippy could be a woman too. Who knows the gender of Clippy? Anyway, I didn't know Clippy by name, but I certainly remember the little animated paperclip. Yeah.

Gene TakagiYeah, so that was Microsoft AI. OpenAI and ChatGPT is like a huge evolution from that, right? Now it's embedded in Microsoft's stuff and it's like a powerhouse ChatGPT program that Microsoft can make available for users of its programs. And that's a big deal that, you know, if somebody threatens what that might end up being, they had kind of a— I think from their perspective, reason to say, hey, why are you firing the CEO who's been, you know, growing OpenAI LLC at like an incredible rate and incredible impact? And it's really you know, jeopardizing our business at Microsoft beyond our investment, which maybe we don't expect money back, but we've been like using the technology. And if there's some threat to the technology because you're not going to follow the lead of your CEO, then maybe we need to sort of see what our legal recourse might be and maybe other strategies like hiring Sam Altman away from you. And what he's terminated is just hiring Sam. And I think close to 90% of the employees of OpenAI said, we're going to, if you don't bring back Sam as CEO. At that point, and a lot of media coverage. So everything, the New York Times, the Washington Post, the New Yorker, the Atlantic, like everybody writing all about this, probably not from the legal perspective that, that I might want to see, but—

Tony MartignettiYeah.

Gene TakagiAnd understandably so. But yeah, I think there was pressure on the board to say, yes, we know what our fiduciary duties are. We know that the operating agreement says that, you know, the LLC is going to be, you know, operating the programs for the benefit of humanity, not for the benefit of our investors. But in light of all of this, we are going to bring back Sam. So Sam Altman is now CEO. There were other conditions to it, including some board members who who led the termination of Altman to leave the board, but other board members who are thought, you know, at least this is how the press release from OpenAI read, some board members or some of the outgoing board members, I should say, that the new board members were strong enough to stand up to Sam Altman. Like, so we put in fiduciaries that are strong enough. So should he go off, you know, kilter and really, you know, pursue a commercial and not a charitable purpose, or over the charitable purpose, I should say, and the benefit to humanity, that there are board members that will hold him in check. So that's kind of in a nutshell what's happened here. So nonprofit board also in charge of the for-profit joint venture. So it's a joint venture because the nonprofit has some ownership of it and other for-profit investors have ownership of it. And there are all sorts of rules that we can talk about in those types of collaborations. But nonprofit board is essentially in charge of both. And they made a decision with charitable purposes in mind that didn't go well with the other stakeholders. They got threatened with something that could have really harmed or just eliminated large part of the value of the LLC. And now we're back to where we kind of started, but with a slightly different board. And I think the questions are, what have we learned from this? And where are we now with nonprofits and for-profits collaborating this way?

Tony MartignettiYeah, absolutely. And those are our broader lessons, which we'll get to imminently.

Kate MartignettiIt's time for Tony's Take Two.

Tony MartignettiThank you, Kate. I've been thinking recently about the contrast between thinking about how I can do something versus why I can't. And this has always been my philosophy, to think about the the positive rather than the negative. I feel like if you're looking for reasons why you can't do something, you'll find plenty. They're easier. They're much easier to identify. They come to the surface so much quicker than the how you can. So I don't like to start with the why I can't because they're too easy and they'll just block you up. They'll jam you up. Yeah. I like to start with the how I can. And I've been thinking about this in terms of bringing on a new client, opening a door to a new donor relationship, visiting donors when I take my trips up to New York City. This is how it's been showing up for me. So for you, I'm urging you to start with the How you can, just because the why you can't is so much more abundant, so much easier to find. It's definitely tougher to find the way forward rather than identify the roadblocks. I fully understand sometimes there may be reasons why, very good reasons why you just can't do something, but I urge you to not start with. that thinking. Figure out the how you can instead of the why you can't first. And then hopefully you can, you'll find a way forward for whatever it is that is maybe giving you some pause in your work or personal life. The how you can Instead of the why you can't. That is Tony's Take Two. Kate.

Kate MartignettiThat's a very optimistic look, uh, thinking that way. You know how people make a pro and con list? Why not just make a pro list and manifest good things that you can do what you want to do? I like that.

Tony MartignettiOkay, okay. Uh, well, sometimes there are legitimate cons. So I wouldn't ignore them. But yeah, I don't, I don't like to start there. Definitely don't, don't want to start there. All right. You sounded a little surprised. Were you surprised that this is an optimistic way of looking? Like, I would be optimistic?

Kate MartignettiI feel like when I, like, talk about maybe like an event coming up, and I'm like, oh, I shouldn't go because con, con, con versus, well, I should go because pro, pro, pro. And I can go do all these things. You know, I, I don't know. I liked your philosophy. I think it works very well, not just nonprofits, but like in life in general.

Tony MartignettiOkay, cool. I just, I was afraid that you thought you, you sounded like surprised that Tony would have an optimistic outlook on things. What a shock. All right, you're not shocked. So that's good.

Kate MartignettiWe've got beaucoup, but loads more time.

Tony MartignettiYes, we do.

Kate MartignettiLet's go back to Lessons from the Sam Altman and OpenAI Headlines with Gene Takagi.

Tony MartignettiTo me, this is a positive story for nonprofits. I mean, the humanitarian mission overcame the desire for accelerationism in In profit, in potential profit-making. Maybe it's too early to tell, but at this stage, I mean, I'm not saying this is gonna be the ultimate, but at this stage, I don't know, I was pretty optimistic. Maybe you disagree, but I felt that with the guardrails in place, that overall it was a positive story for the nonprofit entity.

Gene TakagiWell, I think the positive story is in the creation of OpenAI and when they first developed the LLMs. Like that, that was certainly a positive. It's like nonprofits and then for-profits collaborating to make something really good at scale. And that goes outside of AI in the technology world. You know, one good example of this is National Geographic. That's a joint venture, which is now between Disney and the nonprofit National Geographic, where Disney owns a About 73%, I think, of the stock of that joint venture, and the nonprofit owns 23%. But each of them put 4 people on the board of that LLC. That's also an LLC, so that the nonprofit has an equal say, essentially. And there are sort of guardrails there as well as to what the nonprofit must allow and not allow the LLC to do. So because charitable assets are involved, Mm-hmm. Again, the nonprofit needs to have control over those charitable assets and how they're used. So that would have held true here as well. And that's why we have— part of the reason why we have that operating agreement of the LLC giving, you know, the board of the nonprofit to be the board essentially of the LLC and all these provisions saying that investors may not make money from this. It's, you know, really about the benefit of humanity and in 501 terms, the charitability. of the LLC. So yeah, the lesson is, yeah, there are some good laws that create these guardrails, and there are some people who were involved that really were interested in doing, you know, doing AI right, the right way. But I think on the, on the other hand of it, and sorry to be the pessimist in the holiday season, but the other hand, or the other side of the coin, is the money always wins. Hmm. You know, so—

Tony MartignettiWell, but we don't know. We don't know if that's going to happen, do we?

Gene TakagiWell, we know Sam got rehired, right? Altman got rehired as the CEO of the organization. And yes, they said there's going to be more controls because the board members are the new board members are able to hold him in check. But the new board members are also kind of for-profit people, right? They're not other sort of nonprofit leaders or like they're more well known for their investment expertise and what they do in the for-profit world. technology world, which is important too. And, you know, we can sort of go into, you know, some people wanted to write an immediate reaction kind of in the nonprofit law world that I reside in is, hey, these are charitable assets. They did what they thought was the right thing to do. You've got to protect those charitable assets, and those charitable assets always have to be used for charitable purposes unless they're sold for fair market value in return, which I don't think is the case here. Right. So charitable assets involved got to be used for charitable purposes. But I think there's a bigger question too. And the question is, if the fiduciaries just held true and said, yep, we're not changing, we're not hiring Sam back because we want to do this the ethical way. And Microsoft went and hired Altman and 90% of the staff of OpenAI and OpenAI's other investors lost confidence in the organization. Let's say the organization tanked. There was, you know, about the $100 million investment that might have been made by the nonprofit that might be worth billions of dollars right now, that nonprofit could have all seen wiped away, and all of those assets would be bound by charitable trust that had to be used for charitable purposes associated with it. So, you know, on one hand, it's like, yes, you know, we have to stay true to our mission, but on the other hand, it's like, We own a really valuable asset, and if we do something that tanks the value of that asset to where it doesn't have very much value anymore, is that consistent with our fiduciary duties? So I think there's really sort of tougher questions in there. And again, because we don't know all of the private documents that exist with the complex corporate structure, we don't know exactly if it's that simple. But I think that's one of the considerations to have and why we're not completely sure. I guess Between your optimism and my pessimism, it is, we're gonna have to wait and see what happens.

Tony MartignettiOkay. All right. Let, let, maybe we'll come back to it in 6 months or we'll see, we'll see what's, we'll see what's developed. It may not even be, who knows, the way things move so fast. But in any case, we, we'll, I'm sure we'll revisit this. Let's, let's broaden to some of the, some of the lessons for Not for a smaller mid-sized shop having a for-profit subsidiary governed by a managing entity. But there are takeaways for our routine sort of contracts with and partnerships with for-profit companies that Around fundraising, around some of the other charitable— well, the commercial co-venturing. Let's talk about some of the lessons that we can take away.

Gene TakagiYeah, I think that's a great way to sort of take some lessons out of this OpenAI structure and make it real for our listeners here. I think one, maybe the first one, is not just for-profit companies when you're partnering with individuals as well. Let's start with your kind of realm of the world, And the nonprofit sector, Tony, in fundraising. Let's say you're representing a charity, has $1 million in gross revenues and is, you know, doing great work. And a donor comes along and says, I will give you $2 million. That's twice your annual gross revenues. But you must do this with my $2 million. Now, would you automatically accept it no matter what their conditions are? Or would you say, hey, we actually have to see what those conditions actually are?

Tony MartignettiYeah, of course. You know, what are you asking us to do? And is it consistent with our mission, with our organizing documents? So I'm certainly happy to have a conversation.

Gene TakagiAnd isn't that kind of the OpenAI issue as well, right? You've got for-profit investors that say, hey, we're going to give you a ton of money. And yeah, we're not going to ask very much from you because we said, you know, this was all like, this is what we all want. But when you fired your CEO, now we're upset. Now we want to know what we can do to change that. And donors can be the same way, right? I mean, so super major donors that are very demanding up front when they put their conditions on, it might be something that the nonprofit might be able to accept, but You should actually know what the history of that donor is as well. Like how, you know, once they made their gift, legally that relationship should be, you know, over unless there are other contracts involved. But if it's a gift, they made their gift, they get a deduction, you know, from the gift, and the control of that gift lies with the nonprofit. And generally speaking, the donors really can't sue the nonprofit If they misuse the gift, it belong— that lawsuit would belong to the attorney general. So the donor would complain to the attorney general, and the attorney general would say, hey, you're not using it for the restrictions that were imposed by the donor that you agreed to. You know, we're gonna step in and make sure that that happens. And we'll, you know, we'll go to court if you're not complying with it, and we might fine you as the attorney general of the state or the state charity official. Donors can sometimes have rights in some states by contract if they entered into a contract. But largely it's with a regulator that, that's going to deal with it.

Tony MartignettiAll right.

Gene TakagiBut if you've got a donor and you see this again, maybe outside of the normal listeners, but like in the university context and stuff where they're asking for a lot of things, and when you do something that they don't like, they start to leverage it. And maybe it's because they leverage it with future donations that they could withhold that you thought you might get. Or they leverage it with a media attack against you and the leadership. So you want to know a little bit more about that donor as well, not just the conditions, but is that donor litigious? Do they use PR to attack past relationships? You know, so learning a little bit more about that when, when you're gonna get a big gift and when it's conditioned. Heavily where, you know, and this is not sort of the typical, we want to just make sure you use it to advance children's education in Los Angeles rather than in, you know, other cities. We're talking about like a gift that is like suddenly quasi-charitable, right? Like you're not even sure if it's really charitable or not, or the condition is so strange that, you know, it should come up to the board for the board to decide whether we really want to do it. Right.

Tony MartignettiRight. Because of this, because of the conditions that are attached. And, you know, you could add another layer. I could add another layer to what you were hypothesizing, which is the person could be a board member and a major donor. So, you know, they can cause trouble for the leadership because they are a fiduciary. And, you know, they can claim that the organization is breaching its duty to its mission because it's not adhering to the terms of My agreement, which is more in line with the mission. And, you know, you can imagine an argument, you know, a long played out, a long played out difficult relationship on that level too. All right. So that's very good. You know, that's valuable. It's not only corporate or even incorporated entities of any type, profit or nonprofit. It could be a relationship with an individual that you need to be very scrupulous about.

Gene TakagiYeah, but that's—

Tony MartignettiCircumspect, right?

Gene TakagiThat's right, Tony. And not to say that, you know, we need to be super cynical about every relationship we have.

Tony MartignettiNo, but, but, but go in with eyes open. You know, you need, you need to, you need to protect what your founding documents and what your mission on your website Says.

Gene TakagiYeah, absolutely, Tony.

Tony MartignettiWhat else? What, what other, uh, lessons here?

Gene TakagiSo, you know, I think there are other sorts of collaborations that nonprofits may have, including smaller nonprofits with for-profit organizations, um, or individuals, including like, oh, we want to like fundraise together. Um, you know, perhaps it's, um, cause-related marketing. Um, so somebody's going to say, hey, you know, buy, uh, some of our goods and we'll donate You know, 1% of our proceeds to charity. And that's a, you know, a collaboration that has some importance to the nonprofit, right? So, you know, again, as a fundraiser, Tony, you'd probably want to vet what that company, you know, who that company is and how they're run before you agree to let them sort of promote the charity as sort of kind of a partner, if you will. Right. In, you know, in layman's terms, with the for-profit in raising funds. Now, you know, if you get 1% of that, that might be, you know, great money that you wouldn't have seen otherwise. But we also know that there are a lot of scams that have gone on, and sometimes those are with, like, it used to be robocalls, right? I don't think we have that so much now in our, in our world, but it's sort of email and other sort of electronic messaging now, but robocalls from, you know, charities which were actually commercial entities that are saying, hey, you know, we're fundraising for this charity that's associated with the police or with the firefighters. Support us, and, you know, you know, your proceeds will go to that charity. And it turns out, you know, maybe 1%, 2%, or some minuscule amount would go to charity, and that commercial operator of that robocall was making all the rest of the money for providing that fundraising services. And some charities would say, hey, that's 1%, you know, that's money we wouldn't have gotten anyway, so go ahead and use our name. But in the end, you know, that could really blemish the charity's reputation and, you know, its relationships with donors, because that seems pretty deceptive. And so You have to be careful. I mean, that, that's, those are extreme cases, but there are gonna be those gray areas where you say, I don't know if going into this relationship with this organization and what they're selling and how they're using our name is good. So you gotta be careful of that as well.

Tony MartignettiIf we're gonna lend our name to something like this, I mean, at the most basic level, we need to make sure that this is not just a handshake agreement. There needs to be a written agreement. As you're thinking, you know, as you're speaking, I'm thinking there has to be a way for the charity to remove itself if anything happens that, you know, just, I don't know, broadly would bring discredit to the nonprofit name or reputation or, you know, anything, something broad like that so that if the president of the car dealership is, you know, caught up in some kind of scandal, even just accused of something. Let's keep it financial and not anything, you know, lascivious. But, you know, they're accused of some kind of financial crime that brings discredit to the nonprofit and we can walk away from this.

Gene TakagiYeah. I mean, absolutely.

Tony MartignettiAnd that's just a basic, that's just a fundamental term, I would think. But there has to be a writing between the two The 2 parties that are gonna work together.

Gene TakagiAnd most states require some sort of writing and some sort of provisions in that writing to protect the charity in those relationships. Under a lot of state laws, they call this commercial coventures rather than cause-related marketing, but kind of the same type of relationship where a for-profit is out there using the nonprofit's name with permission And saying to the public, if you buy some of our services or some of our goods, the car that you mentioned, then a percentage or some portion of our revenues or the funds that we get from the sale, we're gonna go to charity. And, you know, having something in writing is great and, you know, required provisions in the contract is great, but you've gotta even do more than that. 'Cause, you know, what if they give you, what if you're the head of a charity and they give you a check for $10,000 at the end of the year and say, hey, this was all we raised. We thought we were gonna raise $100,000. Right. $100,000 for charity, but we didn't sell that much. How do you know? How do you know they didn't sell a whole lot more? And what obligation did they have? You know, were they holding the $10,000 for a year? Were they holding it for a week? And there, there are laws, you know, depending upon what state you're in about how that works. So for charities, the obligation is if you're going to enter into that type of relationship, Make sure you know the laws involved as well, because there may need to be a specific type of contract that's involved. You might need to have that other party register and report on this, and you might need to build into your contract certain things that allow you to be able to audit what that organization is doing, at least, you know, on their books or their paperwork. There could still be fraud, so you have to always be cognizant of the reputation and the history that your other partner, again loosely stated, is. But, you know, you— there's a lot that goes into that. And again, just like with OpenAI and its relationship with its investors, you have to know something about that other party and you have to have this mutual understanding that should be documented in agreement, just as you said.

Tony MartignettiYou mentioned registration. A lot of the laws In states that require registration for charitable solicitation also require registration of commercial coventures.

Gene TakagiThat's right. And reporting, I mean, it might be with each form of solicitation or it might be on an annual basis. So something to pay attention to. Again, as a charity, you have a responsibility to make sure you're contracting with parties that are permitted to do the work that they say they're gonna do for you. So it's not just their fault. It would be your fault as the charity leaders if you enter into a relationship like that and it isn't compliant with the law. So be careful of that.

Tony MartignettiWhat else should we talk about, Gene?

Gene TakagiSo we can talk about a little bit about, well, partnerships where there are actually kind of nonprofits looking for a little bit of money. from for-profit investors who want to do something with what the nonprofit is doing. And it might not be, you know, in the millions or billions of dollars that we're talking about with OpenAI. It might be in the thousands of dollars. So you've got a nonprofit program, and, you know, you think that there might be some people interested in supporting it, but they don't want to give you a loan. They don't want to give you a donation, but they said, hey, let's Go into some sort of business together, and we want a piece of sort of the equity in it. And this happens again in a little bit of a bigger context all the time in low-income housing. So for for-profit developers to get low-income housing tax credits from the government, they have to be partnered with a nonprofit in order to do that. So the only way to access those tax credits is to partner with a nonprofit. So in, you know, in that case, the nonprofit again has a whole bunch of rules involved in terms of, well, you've got to protect the charitable assets that you are contributing to this joint venture that's co-owned with for-profit investors. You've got to make sure that the nonprofit purposes are being advanced by that joint venture. So again, if you're thinking about it, even in a small context, not involving, you know, A lot of money, but even in a small term, like let's start a small LLC together and, you know, nonprofit is gonna put in $20,000 and for-profit investors are gonna put in $20,000. And we're gonna do something that furthers the charitable purposes, but that is outside of maybe what 501 allows, or it's only gonna be capable of doing it at this scale because there are people who want their money back as shareholders, or they wanna have skin in the game as well, right? Mm-hmm. So if they're gonna do something like that, again, laws involved that protect the charitable assets. So you have to do it carefully. You know, $20,000, $20,000 is possible, but you, you, you're gonna have some associated costs. And of course, if you're gonna also manage a joint venture, you have to be very careful about keeping an arm's length distance with the nonprofit, even though you need to have a certain amount of control of it. So. Yeah. Again, just like the OpenAI thing, but on a much smaller scale, it gets to be complicated stuff.

Tony MartignettiYeah, this sounds like walking a tightrope between the two entities. All right. I mean, you're saying it's done, but it needs to, obviously needs to be done delicately.

Gene TakagiNow, I see this happening a little bit more often nowadays because there are like government incentives. for small businesses. Like, so sometimes it's minority-owned small businesses, sometimes it's women-owned small businesses, and there are sort of government funding to spur on these businesses. And nonprofits are sometimes excluded from that. But the work that is to be done is often, you know, in the public interest, which is why the government is funding it in the first place, right? So it's something that a charity could do. And it might be a minority led charity or a women-led charity that wants to get in on it, but they can't get in on it because those programs are designed for small businesses only. And that may not have been the intent of the legislative body that created that, that fund to exclude nonprofits that are led by those persons that face sort of economic disadvantage in certain areas. So it's interesting, some nonprofits are forming for-profits for the purpose of being able to compete. Yeah.

Tony MartignettiAnd what realms are you seeing that? Is that also mostly housing?

Gene TakagiNo, in all sorts of realms, from disaster relief, for example. So yeah, and you can find it in education as well.

Tony MartignettiHmm.

Gene TakagiOkay. So distance learning education largely was kind of a concept of joint ventures as well. You had for-profits that wanted to put up the money and you had nonprofits that had the skills and the teachers, right? A lot of distance learning. Now they're in apps and stuff and websites. But when they first started, they were often done through joint ventures between educational institutions that were nonprofits and some investors or educational providers that were for-profits.

Tony MartignettiHmm. All right. Anything else that you want us to be aware of when we're quote, partnering with some other entity?

Gene TakagiYeah, so there's a, you know, the, the big concept that everybody is concerned about from a regulatory perspective is 501s are not allowed to give prohibited private benefits to anybody, right? Not just insiders, where we call it private inurement, if like a board member benefits too much from an organization, um, but for anybody to be overcompensated by a charity for any reason can be seen as a prohibited private benefit. And if it's an insider like a director or officer, there can be penalties on that individual, and they would be required to return the money as well. And the board members who approved that transaction could also be personally liable for some penalty taxes as well if that private benefit is extended to an insider like a founder, board member, you know, high-level manager or— Okay. officer. But if it's to anybody, an outside vendor, and you didn't vet the situation well enough to know that, oh, they're actually getting more than what they contributed to us, more than what they paid for, they're getting more value from the charity. So it looks like it's a diversion of charitable assets, right? So if you overcompensate, for example, somebody who developed a website for your organization and the commercial rate would have been, let's say, $10,000 for this, And that person did the exact same service that their competitors might have done but charged you $50,000 for it. And the board just simply didn't know what the commercial rate was and approved it without any intention of doing anything wrong. That's still a private benefit transaction, and that could threaten an organization's exemption. So be careful when you sort of enter into transactions with for-profits, even if they're vendor relationships To make sure that you're not overcompensating anybody and always be super careful if it's an insider that's involved. So a board member, officer, you

Tony Martignettiknow,

Gene Takagithat has a company and they're entering into the contract and—

Tony MartignettiOr office space. I see that often. Yeah. Board members giving office space to the nonprofit. But you're talking about not giving, Or you're talking about, you know, beyond market rate.

Gene TakagiYeah. When they're trying to—

Tony MartignettiMarket rate transactions. So, all right. Well, so this goes back to the due diligence that you and I talked about years ago around private benefit transactions that were related to insiders, C-suite board members, founders, you know, so it's the same due diligence applies, just it applies to a commercial entity as to your due diligence around a commercial entity as well and what's appropriate compensation for them.

Gene TakagiYeah. And that wraps back into the OpenAI issue as well without knowing it. But I would consider that the board may have been concerned that they were extending a private benefit to its outside investors by operating for commercial purpose, even though their organizing documents or their operating agreements said, hey, we're doing this for humanitarian purposes. And you might not get any profit coming out of this.

Tony MartignettiOh, interesting, Gene. All right. All right. Well, that's savvy thinking. All right. I see. Anything else that we should take away from our potential relationships with other entities?

Gene TakagiOpen eyes is what you said earlier. And I believe that that's 100% true, Tony. So yeah, most people are good. Most, you know, most people are trying to do the right thing.

Tony MartignettiYeah.

Gene TakagiBut keep your eyes open, and not just with respect to what, you know, who you're dealing with, but also with respect to kind of what laws might apply. So stay in touch with kind of the important resources that you need.

Tony MartignettiKeep yourself safe.

Gene TakagiYeah.

Tony MartignettiKeep your nonprofit safe. Stay safe. All right. Thank you, Gene Takagi. Edits the Nonprofit Law Blog, and the firm is at neolawgroup.com. Gene is @GTak. Thank you very much, Gene. Always, always learn more than, more than I can, more than I can manage in one sitting. I have to listen back again. Thank you very much.

Gene TakagiThank you so much, Tony.

Kate MartignettiNext week, there's a 57% chance it'll be performance measurement. If you missed any part of this week's show,

Tony MartignettiI do beseech you, find it at tonymartignetti.com.

Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by DonorBox. Outdated donation forms blocking your supporters' generosity this giving season? DonorBox, the fast, flexible, and friendly fundraising platform for nonprofits. Our creative producer is Claire Meyerhoff. I'm your associate producer, Kate Martignetti. The show's social media is by Susan Chavez. Marc Silverman is our web guy, and this music is by Scott Stein.

Tony MartignettiThank you for that affirmation, Scotty. Be with us next week for Nonprofit Radio. Big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. Go out and be great. Go out and be great.

Nonprofit Radio