Misinformation & Disinformation


About this episode
Amy Sample Ward returns with their insights into what to do about these maladies plaguing our world. They reveal smart internal tactics to reduce the odds of your nonprofit’s info being misused by bad actors; what to do if it is; how to avoid your org itself being a source of misinformation; and a lot more. They’re the CEO of NTEN and our technology and social media contributor.
Here’s the transcript
Tony MartignettiHello and welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. I am your aptly named host and the podfather of your favorite hebdomadal podcast. Oh, I'm glad you're with us. I'd bear the pain of noctilbuminuria if you dampened my spirits with the idea that you missed this week's show. Here's our associate producer Kate with the highlights.
Kate MartignettiHey Tony, this week it's misinformation and disinformation. Amy Sample Ward returns with their insights into what to do about these maladies plaguing our world. They reveal smart internal tactics to reduce the odds of your nonprofit's info being misused by bad actors, what to do if it is, how to avoid your org itself being a source of misinformation, and a lot more. They are CEO of NTEN and our technology and social media contributor on Tony's Take Two.
Tony MartignettiDecember good wishes.
Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by DonorBox. Outdated donation forms blocking your supporters' generosity this giving season? DonorBox, the fast, flexible, and friendly fundraising platform for nonprofits. DonorBox.org. Here is Misinformation and Disinformation.
Tony MartignettiIt's always a pleasure to welcome Amy Sample Ward back. To Nonprofit Radio. You know who they are, for Pete's sake. Nonetheless, they deserve the proper introduction. Of course, CEO of NTEN and our technology and social media contributor. They were awarded that 2023 Bosch Foundation Fellowship from just this past summer, and their most recent co-authored book is The Tech That Comes Next with Afua Bruce. about equity and inclusiveness in tech development. They're still at amysampleward.org and @amyrsward. Welcome back, Amy. What a pleasure.
Amy Sample WardThanks for having me. I'm excited. I appreciate an intro that doesn't list the number of years or episodes I've joined Nonprofit Radio. That always makes me take, take a bit of a pause.
Tony MartignettiWell, we regale you on the anniversary shows, right, each July, Coming up.
Amy Sample WardYeah, exactly.
Tony MartignettiThis next July will be the 700th.
Amy Sample WardWow.
Tony MartignettiBut only then will we remind folks.
Amy Sample WardOkay, that's fair.
Tony MartignettiWhich show you began in.
Amy Sample WardYes, I can accept these terms.
Tony MartignettiClose listeners will remember, but, but the others who may not remember, you'll have to wait till the 700th show to learn what Amy's first show was. All right. So we're talking about misinformation. Disinformation. Why don't we just start with a basic explanation of what the differences are between mis- and dis-?
Amy Sample WardYeah, I appreciate starting at the beginning because I do see, especially in this, you know, world of tweet or Instagram-sized language where people kind of write mis/disinformation, but they're not interchangeable. They mean very different things. And The implications for your organization, or even the potential that your staff do one of these things is very, very different, right? A good way to remember it is misinformation is a mistake. So misinformation is you or a staff person or a community member even saying the wrong thing. You know, they said 73% instead of 37%, or something where it doesn't have— Right. an intentional agenda, right? It's not, it's not created or distributed as a way of trying to do something, whether nefarious or just, you know, against what you're trying to do. And misinformation, unfortunately, like, we can still talk about this, is something we need to think about as organizations, especially when we think about trying to have staff out in the community, being present, sharing their thought leadership, all of these places. We are humans. We do make mistakes. Yeah. Mistakes. We do say 73 instead of 37, right? But that means we maybe just said that to, you know, and we're here at a big donor recognition event, and we say the wrong percentage, and all those people then, they want to be informed, they want to look like they know things. So then they repeat the same wrong stat, right? So it is something we want to think about. And there's some tactics for making sure Staff have all of those resources to fact-check themselves and to share things. But I think the more concerning one of these 2 is disinformation. And that's not to say that your staff don't intentionally or unintentionally create or participate in disinformation, but especially want to talk about what it looks like for your organization's images, content, data, website, etc., to be used as part of someone else's disinformation campaign. And that means, again, people who are creating or sharing or distributing information with the intention that it is, you know, going to change people's mind and that they know that what they're doing is not factually correct.
Tony MartignettiYeah, the intentionality is the distinction.
Amy Sample WardYes.
Tony MartignettiI like misinformation, mistake. Very good. All right.
Amy Sample WardYeah,
Tony Martignettihelpful, helpful. And disinformation, of course, intentionally. Interesting. Yeah, right. Yeah, let's definitely talk about What happens if you're essentially a victim included in disinformation, disinformation post, article, campaign? Right. Okay, excellent. All right. So some basic things, you know, we could be like on an individual basis as well as an organizational basis. Some simple things to help you avoid on either level. Misinformation and disinformation. I think, you know, basic news literacy, you know, let's, let's flesh this out, flesh this out a little bit for folks. And maybe, and maybe covering things that are obvious, but I, I think there's value in the, in the basics, you know, just—
Amy Sample WardYeah. And, and some of it really is kind of a, a journalism, like, go back to the basics.
Tony MartignettiYeah.
Amy Sample WardUm, place that we don't all have that kind of training or background, so it's not I'm not saying this to say, oh, everybody, you know, knows this and isn't doing it. No, a lot of people have never had the privilege to get this information or to be trained to do— to operate in this way. But I think as organizations, we already see that there's silos. There's certain staff who know certain things and other staff who don't. So that's going to still be the case when it comes to organizational data or information reports that you're putting out. Et cetera. But creating kind of an information center for all staff, and again, not thinking, well, only these 3 people on the communications team who are the ones who do our presentations need to know it. Put it in a place where all staff can see, here's the deck that explains our organization and our, you know, latest numbers of impact or how many people we've reached this year, right? That's a number that many people on staff maybe have an occasion to say, and you want them saying the correct number. Yeah. the correct number, right? Having— we used to create a cheat sheet, for example, where NTEN puts out lots of different reports, and they have so many different data points in them. But what are the ones that we know the community is most interested in, regardless of which report it was in? Let's make one cheat sheet for staff that says, okay, this is the trend on this topic. And here's the number of organizations, you know, that responded in this way on this other topic in one place. That way, anybody who's presenting or answering a question from a community member is all pulling data from one place. If a new year goes by, a new version of that data, it's updated in that document. People are still going back to the same place. They're not like, oh, let me find this year's version of this, right? They're always going to the same place. And what that looks like externally, which is where the kind of misinformation to the disinformation gets connected, is making sure, just as a good journalist would cite their sources, Organizations need to be comfortable citing their sources too. But I think part of this has come from feeling like we need to be the authority on everything we say. And what that means is that organizations don't. You don't have the latest information on every topic under the sun. That's fine. What you're an expert on is your mission. So cite the source for the data on your page where you're making the case for what you do. Mm-hmm. Is it from the census? Is it from a partner organization? Is it from a state department, you know, that you work with? Actually putting in where that 37% came from is going to mean that if someone out there has an agenda and they're saying, oh yeah, I've heard that 37% of people XYZ, they're not able to reference your website as part of their disinformation campaign because your website really does list, here's the link to the census where this came from.
Tony MartignettiOh, that's sexy.
Amy Sample WardRight? They're not able to modify what you are saying. You've made clear where you got your information. Otherwise, that website, you know, that article where you don't link to any sources, you don't list how that data was collected, is really ripe for interpretation. And that's really what disinformation campaigns look for, something that's coming from a legitimate website. You are a legitimate organization. You have a legitimate website. And if it's not clear, they can use that however they want, right? They can reposition it.
Tony MartignettiYeah. Yeah. Cite your sources, and you might be the source. Of course, it might be maybe your own data, maybe your own research, might be your own annual report. But right citation citation. Yeah, very smart. Right? So you can't be you can't be linked back to as the source because you're giving the source of the correct information.
Amy Sample WardYes.
Tony MartignettiExcellent. Yes. Is there is there more? This is
Amy Sample Wardwell, I think that yeah, there is. I don't think there needs more. I just wanted to stop.
Tony MartignettiBut okay.
Amy Sample WardYeah, no, there is more, and I think. You know, just as we are suggesting you cite your sources for that 37%, maybe written on your website, a place where organizations often don't think about adding their logo or their website or anything else is other pieces of content they're sharing. But creating almost like a watermark, you know, your logo in the corner, or maybe if you made a little infographic to share online and it says in the corner, this is from, you know, NTEN's 2020 report on X, right? Because creating content that's meant to be shared off of your website is even, even more likely to be picked up, right, and used conveniently in disinformation when it doesn't— when it's— when it has no anchor, right? When it doesn't have the watermark, it just looks like a fancy stat that somebody else posted. So making sure you think about anything that, that you're sharing externally where it isn't on your website and you're controlling it. Can you add this watermark? Can you make sure that a, a source or a reference is written inside the graphic, not just in, you know, maybe the caption that you put with it?
Tony MartignettiRight inside that graphic. Yes. Yeah. All right. Awesome. What else? What else should we be doing?
Amy Sample WardWell, I think the other piece of this is So that's proactive, right? Let's make sure staff have the resources to say the right things. And also the content we're putting out on our website and our email out into social is cited, has the right information. That's all proactive from our side. But what do we do for everything we can't control? Right. So the other side of this is monitoring. And often an organization only finds out that they, their content, their data, their imagery is part of some disinformation campaign because they got tagged or recognized by a community member who saw that content somewhere else. Right. And they were like, wait a second, you know, I recognize that photo or whatever. So we've said this probably on the first episode I was on, which was too many years ago, you know, when we were talking about any other type of social or online listening. But it's still the case, setting up alerts to track your organization's names and mentions online. Folks think, oh, this is great, because, you know, we'll know when we're in the news. You'll also know if somebody is, you know, trying to misuse your content. So, so not overlooking that, especially within certain systems. So, you know, maybe you work with a certain community. That uses Instagram a lot, for example, or TikTok, and you don't really use your full written out, you know, maybe have a 5-word name, you know, making sure you're setting up notifications or following hashtags on those tools that use the kind of name or abbreviation or acronym or even, you know, maybe tag that would be most likely used if you were getting pulled into something, because it's really going to be Through that type of listening that you find your content being used. And then, of course, what do you do if you see that? I think some folks feel like, like any other type of potential trust breakdown, you know, okay, we should come out really strong. We're gonna make some big statement like, we do not support, or like, don't worry, your data has not been stolen. That doesn't necessarily convey that you understood what was happening there, right? So I think instead, if you see your content's getting picked up and misused, maybe, you know, and this isn't like at the level of, of an international scene, this could be locally, maybe some of your event photos and, and talking points are being misused by a local representative, right? This doesn't need to be huge scale. It should still be meaningful.
Tony MartignettiYeah,
Amy Sample Wardright.
Tony MartignettiAnd so maybe on the scale of the Israel-Hamas war.
Amy Sample WardBut it's just—
Tony MartignettiBut it's important to you. It's still your name, it's still your reputation, and it's a perversion of your content.
Amy Sample WardExactly.
Kate MartignettiIt's time for a break. Are you looking to maximize your fundraising efforts and impact this giving season? DonorBox's online donation platform is designed to help you reach your fundraising goals. From customizable donation forms to far-reaching, easy-share crowdfunding and peer-to-peer options, plus seamless in-person giving with DonorBox Live Kiosk. DonorBox makes giving simple and fast for your donors and moves the needle on your mission. Visit donorbox.org and let DonorBox help you. Help others. Now back to misinformation and disinformation.
Amy Sample WardSo one tactic that folks have used when that is the case, when, okay, your stuff is getting, you know, twisted a little bit, one option— there's a couple here— one is to flood the system. So instead of trying to add more attention to that person and try to say, no, that isn't what we said, or that isn't what that graphic is for, right? Ignore them. And flood the system. So make sure that you have a correct, fully sources-cited blog post on your website so that if people Google what that person just said, they're finding your correct blog post, that you have a recent social post that points to that, that clarifies this information. Again, you don't need to tag them. You don't need to say anything about them, but make sure that if people are reading what's out there and are like, what is this? And they do a search for you, they are seeing what you want them to see and not that. Right? So there's one option, flood the system, make sure it's all, all correct insofar as you can do it. And then the second is really not gonna be seen by a lot of people, and that's contacting the, the folks who are posting this.
Tony MartignettiYes.
Amy Sample WardOften in disinformation, the folks doing the posting are not the ones who created the content for them to post. Um, and so they are also in a little bit of a more precarious position than whoever gave them the content, especially on a local level where it's harder to hide, like, you know each other locally. So contacting them and saying, hey, this is not good, right? Whatever the case may be, and engaging with them, especially saying, could we have a public engagement around this, this conversation? Folks, organizations have turned that around and been able to Great, we had a town hall because our, you know, recent report was of interest but wasn't understood. And now you're getting positive attention because you were able to engage that person and turn it around. Of course, if they say, no, you're wrong, we're right, our content is good. Well, you know where you stand, and you can move to a maybe option 2B, which is then to, you know, go into the process of reporting those accounts, reporting that content. The challenge there, just so folks are already thinking about it, is when we are reporting content on, on the, on the greater internet across social media, etc., folks are gonna see if that content has already been used by other users, if it's been shared or posted.
Tony MartignettiOh.
Amy Sample WardAnd so if what they're posting and you're now reporting is very similar even to your own content or to content that others have posted, It likely will not get taken down because, you know, the content review process will say, oh no, this is like widely used, widely known, right? Versus thinking that it's this one account's content. And it's kind of a catch-22 when it comes to managing and reporting disinformation.
Tony MartignettiSo the more widely it's been used, the less likely it is that you'll— that the originator that you're talking to would remove it?
Amy Sample WardWell, they wouldn't be the ones removing it. You're— if you're reporting it, you're asking, you know, Meta to take it down or something. And then that point, they are— you're essentially reporting that user, and that user and their content is all part of whatever Meta would be looking at to say, oh, is this a nefarious thing? Is this bad? You know, and a lot of folks don't have success getting it taken down because there's— the content is similar to content that's already up. Maybe they weren't the ones that created it anyway. So that— I just want folks to know it's not just a one-click, oh great, it's removed. Yeah, that's why it's not step one, because it is very difficult for a lot of folks to get disinformation accounts stopped.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Okay. I
Amy Sample Wardknow you did a little reading and thinking about disinformation too. What are your thoughts?
Tony MartignettiI did. Well, I was on a different level. I was thinking about folks trying to validate something that they might— that they—
Amy Sample WardYeah, that's— let's talk about that.
Tony MartignettiAll right. Well, you're being very gracious. Look, so it's all right. But I don't want to deviate from our best practices that you're enumerating. Like, you're down to level 2B already.
Amy Sample WardAll
Tony Martignettiright, well, all right, I know you want to— you, you probably feel like you've been talking a while, but everything you're saying is valuable, and you got more insight into it than I do. That's why you're our technology contributor. So don't— you don't, you don't need to be humble. But all right, so we— I want to know if there's a step 3 after 2B, but we'll come back to it. Yeah, no, there's just sources like, you know, if, if something seems a little unusual to you or I mean, you can't— we cannot fact-check everything we read. There's just too much. But so if something seems, as David Letterman used to say, a little hinky, because I was just in Indiana with my wife, so hinky is on my mind because that's where Letterman was from. You know, there's a place like PolitiFact.
Amy Sample WardRight.
Tony MartignettiPolitiFact, they have their Truth-O-Meter.
Amy Sample WardYeah.
Tony MartignettiIt's green, red, or yellow, and it usually They're green or red. There's, there's not a lot of yellow.
Amy Sample WardYeah.
Tony MartignettiSo PolitiFact, I mean, that, you know, you want to go to a bona fide source. PolitiFact. Snopes has been around for a long time.
Amy Sample WardYes.
Tony MartignettiAnd they are legitimate fact-checkers. If you're— this may come up if you're, if you're creating content that's not, that's not based solely on your own data, but you're relying on other people's data. Mm-hmm. There's, there's something called the CRAAP test. It's C-R-A-A-P. And it is, it's, it's quite bona fide. Now, I was not aware of it, but it got links from— it's linked to by Texas A&M University, even Central Michigan University, New Jersey Institute of Technology, Oregon State University for you, Amy. Yeah. Southern Utah University, University of Chicago. So there are respected universities, and some of them seem to be library systems of those universities, though, that recommend the CRAAP test for their students. So you can just Google CRAAP, C-R-A-A-P. It's an acronym for currency. You know, how— what's the timeliness of the information? Relevance, authority, what's the source, the accuracy of this, of that source overall, and the purpose for which the, the data, uh, the data was posted, or the purpose for which the source exists. You know, is there some nefarious agenda? So currency, relevance, authority, accuracy, purpose, uh, the CRAP test to, to take a look at. And there are a lot of factors within each one of those
Amy Sample WardYeah,
Tony Martignettifor determining whether data that you're relying on is valid.
Amy Sample WardRight. I really like that. A couple, um, reactions coming up for me, especially thinking about nonprofit staff who are trying to do this or, or muddle through this. One is when you're creating content or, you know, trying to put up a blog post or a page, whatever letter you're writing, and you're looking for sources. If you aren't comfortable writing right there in the letter or right there on your website, you know where that fact came from, then it's not a fact you can use. I know we've definitely talked with organizations where, you know, they're like, oh, it's the perfect stat and like the perfect just what we want. But it's kind of like a sketchy organization, or like it's not an organization that's mission-aligned. And, you know, so let's just use the stat. And like, we don't need to— if you're not, you know, if you can't cite the source, then it's not a stat you can use, right?
Tony MartignettiThat's intellectual dishonesty.
Amy Sample WardRight. It's just like, it's like a gut check, right? Um, so there's that. The other kind of reaction that's coming up for me is I know, you know, nothing is simple. It is complex to say, okay, well, this needs to come from quote unquote authoritative source, but there is no authoritative source in this kind of white dominant. Are they a university or are they a newspaper or whatever? Maybe on the topic you work on. That's okay, you know. But for example, in Oregon, we found I was on the board of an organization that did gender equity work, especially policy work to support gender equity organizations, and found that there was not a report or a survey or a government census on certain data related to all kinds of factors— gender, domestic violence, etc.— on certain topics. For over 20 years. So yeah, maybe there was a stat you could find from 1989. We're not using that stat, you know? Um, and so instead of saying, okay, well, there's like nothing good, so we don't, don't have anything to sort, uh, to, to cite, or what we have is so old, we'll just reference it. No, that's how they framed a lot of their content. These stats are so old we can't even use them. Yeah. Right? And that became a talking point that made them an authority, right? So we are going to do research because it isn't out there. And it created an opportunity for their website to become the authoritative source other organizations could link to. Hey, here is their report. Maybe it's not the same as a census, but at least it's something. The state didn't even care to report on this, right? So an opportunity to think about Not just, okay, there's a real lack of data and your organization is at a disadvantage. Maybe naming that really clearly on a web page will mean that when folks go to fact-check, oh, this local representative said that it's 37%, they find your website where you say, don't trust anyone who tells you there's a number. There hasn't been a survey in 40 years, right? Like, wow, now you're educating people. You know,
Tony Martignettithat's, that's a very savvy turnaround.
Amy Sample WardYeah, and having, you know, quick facts on our— on your mission's topic, you know, on Portland Land Conservancy, whatever it is that you do, having that quick reference page means you will come up when people do an internet search, and maybe you'll get to frame how they think about any stat or talking point they come across from somebody else.
Kate MartignettiIt's time for Tony's Take Two.
Tony MartignettiThank you, Kate. December, I know it's a critical month right at the end of Thanksgiving and Giving Tuesday comes that important month where I know you can be looking for 25, 30, I've seen like 40% of your annual fundraising from this single month. Sometimes. So if that's your situation, you have my good wishes. I'm thinking about you. I'm rooting for you. I hope you're— Giving Tuesday, if you were in Giving Tuesday, not that you needed to be necessarily, you could sit it out. But if you were in, I hope you did well. If you didn't do well, or as well as you would've liked, brush that off. Yeah. Don't let your Giving Tuesday impact what you're thinking about. You know, don't don't second guess yourself for your your December strategy. Giving Tuesday stands alone. I hope you were very successful. If not, don't let it impact the coming month. You've got my good wishes. I'm like I said, I'm rooting for you. If you do everything you can, then you have nothing to be ashamed of. That is Tony's Take Two. Kate?
Kate MartignettiGood wishes to everyone from Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio. Well, we've got beaucoup but loads more time, so let's go back to misinformation and disinformation with Amy Sample Ward.
Tony MartignettiI'm gonna take us back to your best practices.
Amy Sample WardSure.
Tony MartignettiConversation. What, what else? You've, you put a lot of thought into this. What else should, should we be doing if we discover that our content is misused?
Amy Sample WardYeah. One thing that's specific to, you know, social media profiles or accounts that you'd have that aren't on your website that I've seen some organizations do and I really like, um, is they have put in their bio, and of course that's limited, you know, some accounts, you have 5 characters and an emoji or something. But like, where you can have this information, organizations have referenced really concisely, you know, we don't post stats, or we only post infographics from our own research, or something that kind of gets out ahead of if their organization's account is then getting tagged in some TikTok You know, videos, comment thread where people think they're referencing their stats. Anybody that then clicks through to that organization's bio will see, oh, they, they couldn't have posted that because they only post X, you know, whatever it might be. So that's another place to think about how you frame what your content might be is, you know, here, your profile on whatever TikTok, I guess the Portland Land Conservancy maybe would have a TikTok. I don't know. But, you know, putting in your bio, like, we are sharing tips and strategies. If you want research data, contact this email, or, you know, however you might frame that, but making it so that even in the course of the kind of fast action of social media where people are tagging or commenting or whatever, your organization gets thrown in the mix. Anybody that sees that and clicks through will know whether to Think you were really part of that content or not, even just by what they land on your account with. You know?
Tony MartignettiYeah, your account bio. Okay.
Amy Sample WardYeah.
Tony MartignettiAnd is that something? It sounds like that belongs on your website as well.
Amy Sample WardOh, absolutely.
Tony MartignettiMaybe on the footer of every page where you have your whatever, your tax ID number and your address.
Amy Sample WardRight.
Tony MartignettiMaybe a disclaimer because because this the trouble is so ubiquitous. I, I think it deserves, you know, it sounds like this deserves to be on every page.
Amy Sample WardWell, and it's interesting that you say the ubiquitous comment because, you know, I think it's pretty similar to conversations we have with organizations, especially smaller or medium-sized organizations, who, uh, about security, where they're like, no one cares about us, no random hacker, you know, thinks we're important, like we're not on anybody's radar, nobody's coming for us. And so they don't plan and they don't think about any of that until all of a sudden, do we have cyber insurance? Like, what do we do when there's been a breach? Like, they think that it doesn't apply to them because they think like they're not an important, fancy, famous organization. But that's not why a security breach would happen, right? Just from a kind of accidental breach of staff doing something. Yeah. Or from ransomware. It's because you care about your content, not because the person hacking you does. You know, they just know that you'd pay to get it back.
Tony MartignettiYeah.
Amy Sample WardSimilar, similar mindset with disinformation is, yeah, who— no one, no one knows about us. No one would try to do whatever, you know. Oh, that disinformation is just for the war or just for some government whatever. Yes, for everything. There's a reason that people have, you know, malicious intent to shift, you know, perception locally or nationally on all kinds of issues. And whether you work in homelessness or food security or animal rights, like, every topic has its issues and its folks who want to take down, you know, organizations or want to shift whether money goes to that sector or not. So I'm not trying to be like, A fearmonger, but it is, it is worth spending some time making sure that you do have these practices in place and that you do know what you would do if something happened. You know,
Tony MartignettiI think it's naive. Unfortunately, it's regrettably, uh, in the culture over the past probably 10 years or so, it's become naive to think that your organization is too small or your work is too benign. Your work could be incendiary to anybody.
Amy Sample WardRight.
Tony MartignettiAnd look at the pizza shop in Washington, D.C. It's a pizzeria. Well, you know, who's going to attack a pizzeria?
Amy Sample WardWell, people.
Tony MartignettiYeah. Including the guy who went there or went to— I don't know if he got to the store, but the guy who went to D.C. armed and he was— I think he was stopped before he got to whatever the Pizzagate place was called. I forget. But yeah. So there is nothing so benign. I mean, You know, animal welfare, like a no-kill shelter. There could just be people who think that— not that only— not— they may not be so incendiary to think that animals ought to be killed. But why is that? Why are they getting money? But my— but my, you know, my— I just got laid off. But the no-kill shelter just expanded their building. Got a grant. Just— they just had a campaign and raised $500,000 and expanded their building. But I just got laid off. Right. Any, any cause is fodder for, for any kind of, you know, irrational criticism, but that criticism could run pretty deep and, and be dangerous.
Amy Sample WardAnd I know that you have had some smart and insightful recent conversations about AI with Afua and Beth and George and all these different people.
Tony MartignettiYeah.
Amy Sample WardAnd I want to make one bridge over to those conversations. as we're talking about disinformation, that some of it is also created by AI. AI is great. Generative AI specifically is great at coming up with content. That's why it was created, to make it. It also is making up fake sources. It is, is making up fake information. And so the more that people start getting used to AI tools being out in the, in the wild here and are using them themselves, The more people are going to be hopefully looking for sources, and they might see something and click on it and see that it's fake, because, you know, this generative AI tool made it all up. And then they come to your website and they click on a source and they see it's real. So they are going to trust that more, you know. And it just really, I think, underscores the need to make sure the content on our websites or out in our emails, etc. is really what we mean it to be. It is fact-checked, it's correct, it cites its sources, because we're now putting that website up in a, in a sea of content where a lot of it is gonna be created by a robot and not, and not correct. You know,
Tony Martignettiyou're talking about the show from June 5th, 2023. It's called Artificial Intelligence for Nonprofits. We had Beth Kanter, Afua Bruce, your co-author, George Weiner, and Allison Fine.
Amy Sample WardGreat.
Tony MartignettiThat's the, that's the show. Listen and then listen back to it. Yeah.
Amy Sample WardYeah.
Tony MartignettiThat was a full explanation, uh, conversation about the risks, the opportunities, uh, bad practices, uh, potentially good practices. Um, my, my bias comes out when I say— yeah,
Amy Sample WardI know.
Tony MartignettiYeah, I say bad practices, potentially good, actually
Amy Sample Wardgood.
Tony MartignettiI qualified the good, but the bad I left, I left.
Amy Sample WardYeah, that's just like bold and underlined, you know, unvarnished,
Tony Martignettiright? Bad and maybe good. My bias comes out. My bias comes out in that conversation too. So June fifth, the show is called Artificial Intelligence for Nonprofits. I am very concerned. I'm very concerned. Yeah. Anyway, we don't need to rehash that conversation. We were just so all right. All right. This is this is valuable. This is valuable stuff. Nobody is, um, nobody's immune. No cause, as good as you think your cause is, imagine somebody who thinks it's as evil as you think it is good,
Amy Sample Wardright?
Tony MartignettiBecause, because that person could very well exist, probably does. It's just a matter of how incendiary that person is,
Amy Sample Wardright? And I think that there's 2 pieces related to this that, of course, a lot of what we've just talked about are actions nonprofit staff can be taking to post content in a certain way, or, you know, create resources internally, etc. But I also think there's 2 opportunities here to build better, closer relationships with other organizations so that even if you're not all working on the same issue, maybe you all work in the same community, or maybe you all have a similar funder, or, you know, whatever the relationship might be. But using this as saying, hey, I know that we all want there to be accurate information out there. We did a survey and we have this, you know, here's the data. I'm happy to share it with you so that you can trust it. Can we all agree to say it's 37% so that we are, you know, getting out the word in a more consistent way to proactively fight any disinformation that comes out later, right? People will see 3 different organizations are all citing the same source, all agreeing that this is the content, right? Similarly, using potential, using the potential for disinformation as an entry point for conversations with a funder to say, we know this is a topic that not everybody supports. You support us, we're so glad that you do. And how could you support us making sure that there's accurate reporting or more research than the limited amount we've been able to do, you know, so that more information out there for the public. And again, we're proactively cutting off the influence of disinformation on this topic. So I think that's an important entry point for those conversations, even if nothing comes of it, the funder doesn't give you more funds. I wish they would, truly. Maybe they don't, but it's part of— it's something that you've planted with them that, hey, this is a role you need to be playing. If we need accurate information out here, if we want these missions to be successful, right? Yeah. So 2 places where this conversation we've just had about disinformation maybe helps you start new or different conversations with partners or funders.
Tony MartignettiYeah, yeah. And that brings to mind the information gaps that you were talking about earlier. Turn that around into something positive and try to get funding for the research that hasn't been done since 1989.
Amy Sample WardRight, exactly. Exactly.
Tony MartignettiWhat about the tech companies? Let's shift a little bit. I'm interested in your opinion of their responsibility. They are absolved from the responsibility that media companies, news organizations have under the Communications Act that was— I forget, it's Article 230 or something like that.
Amy Sample WardMm-hmm.
Tony MartignettiUh, of the, of a, of a communications, a federal, a federal statute. They're exempt from, from that because they, they claim that they're, they're merely like a bulletin board. They're not, they're not a content creator. They're a content disseminator.
Amy Sample WardDistributor.
Tony MartignettiPoster distributor. So they're not responsible. That this is where the, this is where I think their argument breaks down. Therefore, they're not responsible for what gets posted on their billboard. Well, when I was in 7th grade, there was a billboard monitor.
Amy Sample WardRight.
Tony MartignettiWe took down— if it was from last week's, it was advertising last week's 7th grade dance, we took it down because we don't need that anymore. That's old versus disinformation. But obviously, I believe they ought to be held to a much higher standard. I'm not opposed to the journalistic standard or something very, very close to that.
Amy Sample WardRight.
Tony MartignettiYeah.
Amy Sample WardI mean, I think this is a—
Tony MartignettiBut I'm also interested in your opinion.
Amy Sample WardYeah, this is, this is unfortunately not a, a new point of frustration, of course, right? Folks feeling like whether it's Facebook or Twitter, whoever else, you know, sure, you, the company didn't create that content, but you are allowing it to be disseminated. And it is wrong. You know, we get disinformation is, is kind of a Venn diagram in this context with hate speech. There's, there's this kind of out-of-proportion understanding or reference to freedom of expression that is, that is being used often to cloud whether or not there's accountability to be taken. And I think, of course, I think that the platforms need to have a level of responsibility to either prevent or then address harm when it happens because they have allowed this content to, to exist and be disseminated. I think similarly, organizations should really think about, are you prepared to be responsible for harm that comes from content that you may post? And that's not to say that, you know, every time you've been posting on Facebook, it was malicious and you were doing something. But, you know, are, are you maybe going to start using certain tools that are generative AI or something else? And are you ready for what content maybe comes out of there? Or do you want to say, Hey, we're only— our humans are writing our content about our advocacy because we know it is very important that it is 100% accurate, you know, and, and, uh, we need our experts to do that. Or, um, you know, we are only going to post parts of our research when it can be posted in full, and these parts of our research are able to be posted as an individual infographic. There are definitely reports that easily are misinformation can be disinformation if they're posted without the full context of that report, right? And so maybe you want to say, we can't just have this random thing going on Facebook, because it will easily turn into something that we, we aren't necessarily ready to be responsible for. So let's post ourselves. It's not to say someone else couldn't take a screenshot and post it. But you as the organization didn't start that, right? You are saying we are posting this in full context as a full report document. So just some places to think about guidelines or at least guardrails for staff in how they post and where they post that content.
Tony MartignettiYeah. All right. More guardrails for making sure that you're not becoming the bad actor.
Amy Sample WardRight. Right.
Tony MartignettiAnd you may not even— you're not doing it intentionally, but context is critical.
Amy Sample WardYeah.
Tony MartignettiSo, all right. So, yeah, you gotta scrutinize policies, right? What's the role of generative AI in your organization if it has a role? What are the allowable purposes, uses, where not? You know, you don't, and you just don't wanna be embarrassed as well.
Amy Sample WardRight.
Tony MartignettiPutting aside disinformation, you know, you don't wanna, Be that— what was that college? There was a college where one of the officers posted something that was supposed to be thoughtful about a shooting at a local— in a local community. It was a university officer, and it was posted by generative AI.
Amy Sample WardYeah.
Tony MartignettiIt was it was off color and right. It was it was worse than just neutral and not was worse
Amy Sample Wardthan not saying
Tony Martignettinot persuasive. It was poor, and and it you know it and it created a whole you know it created a big problem for the a big PR problem for the university. Right. You know, so you don't want to you don't want you know it's your reputation. You just you need to be judicious about.
Amy Sample WardRight.
Tony MartignettiWho posts in your name?
Amy Sample WardYeah, exactly, exactly. And again, it's not because that means you can lock it down and control random other internet users. You can't. But anyone that goes then to fact-check what that random internet user posted about you will see thoughtful, carefully posted content and know, oh, that you didn't create that, right? Because that is clearly out of step with everything else they can see from you, or is factually not matching what you have on your quick facts page, or, you know, whatever else. I know this has been like an hour of tips and people are like, oh my God, stop giving me more tips. You know, I can only do so many things. But even if people do 2 of the things we just talked about, that's a, that's a good direction for getting into a better position.
Tony MartignettiYeah. Well, I think people are often overwhelmed when you're a guest because you have too much value. You bring too much value. Stop. Turn it off. No, no, no. It's a buffet. You take what works for you.
Amy Sample WardYes.
Tony MartignettiAnd if you don't agree that this could be a potential problem for you, then at least you're making that decision informed.
Amy Sample WardRight. And I hope that it doesn't— I hope that it isn't an issue. Yeah.
Tony MartignettiYeah, of course we wish no ill will on anyone,
Amy Sample Wardright?
Tony MartignettiUh, naturally. All right, anything that we haven't talked about, that any approaches we haven't, uh, explored, angles we haven't looked at?
Amy Sample WardYou know, the only thing that I will say is that I think this is perfect time to be talking about this. Um, you know, it's November 30th when we're recording this, not that it's live in this moment, but, uh, a year from now Not even a year from now, 6 months from now in the US, as politics kicks up its, its cycle again, every topic is potentially a topic that a person in a debate references, right? Or a candidate on TV references, or that somebody wants to put into a commercial. And that means You know, over the next 6 months, you really wanna make sure your content is in order, that you only have, you know, stats you stand behind on your website in case, you know, somebody's in a debate, they reference the food insecurity rate in your area, and you're like, I know that's wrong. Can you prove it wrong? Is it on your website, the correct number? Right? So I just wanna make sure that people not— again, there's no fear in this, no anxiety, but just The timeliness is a year from now when it's election time. We want to be ready before that. So let's make sure that you have the content on your website that you want folks to be able to reference and source, and well before the campaigns start kicking everything up.
Tony MartignettiAgain, context. You're right. 2024 is an election year. Be conscious. All right, there, Amy Sample Ward, the CEO at NTEN and our technology and social media contributor. Amy, thanks so much. What a pleasure.
Amy Sample WardThank you. Yeah, this was a good one.
Tony MartignettiThey're all good.
Kate MartignettiNext week, Gene Takagi returns with a discussion of Sam Altman, ChatGPT, and why they're relevant to nonprofits. If you missed any part of this week's show,
Tony MartignettiI beseech you, find it at tonymartignetti.com.
Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by DonorBox. Outdated donation forms blocking your supporters' generosity this giving season? DonorBox, the fast, flexible, and friendly fundraising platform for nonprofits. donorbox.org. Our creative producer is Claire Meyerhoff. I'm your associate producer, Kate Martignetti. The Production for this show's social media is by Susan Chavez. Marc Silverman is our web guy, and this music is by Scott Stein.
Tony MartignettiThank you for that affirmation, Scotty. Be with us next week for Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. Go out and be great.
I love our sponsor!


