Skip to content
EP 671December 17, 2023

Lessons From The UPenn President's Resignation

Tony MartignettiDoug White
Nonprofit Radio
Episode 671
0:00 / 0:00

About this episode

Two weeks ago, the president of the University of Pennsylvania resigned, in large part because major donors to the University harshly criticized her publicly, withdrew their donations, and encouraged others to do the same. Can you prevent an uprising at your nonprofit? How do you manage one if your nonprofit’s core values are at stake? Doug White has been studying ethics for decades and he returns to share what can be learned.

Here’s the transcript

Tony MartignettiHello and welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. I'm your aptly named host and the podfather of your favorite hebdomadal podcast. Oh, I'm glad you're with us. I'd come down with somasthenia if you weakened me with the idea that you missed this week's show. Here's our associate producer Kate with what's coming.

Kate MartignettiHey Tony, this week it's Lessons from the UPenn President's Resignation. 2 weeks ago, the president of the University of Pennsylvania resigned. In large part because major donors to the university harshly criticized her publicly, withdrew their donations, and encouraged others to do the same. Can you prevent an uprising at your nonprofit? How do you manage one if your nonprofit's core values are at stake? Doug White has been studying ethics for decades, and he returns to share what can be learned. On Tony's Take Two.

Tony MartignettiI'm thinking about you.

Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by DonorBox. Outdated donation forms blocking your supporters' generosity this giving season? DonorBox, the fast, flexible, and friendly fundraising platform for nonprofits. donorbox.org. Here is Lessons from the UPenn President's Resignation.

Tony MartignettiIt's a pleasure to welcome Doug White back to Nonprofit Radio. He returns as a longtime leader and scholar in our nation's philanthropic community. He's an author and advisor to nonprofits and philanthropists. One of his books, Abusing Donor Intent, chronicling the historic lawsuit brought against Princeton University by the children of Charles and Marie Robertson. We talked about that here, and it's Doug's recent book that is the one that's most relevant to today's conversation. To frame things, the president of the University of Pennsylvania was forced to resign by donors, faculty, and politicians last weekend. She resigned 4 days after testifying before Congress about what constitutes antisemitism at Penn. There had been calls for her resignation before her testimony. Enormously wealthy donors who had made 7, 8, and 9-figure gifts to Penn withdrew their gifts and their support of President Elizabeth McGill. The board chair resigned the same day. We want to examine the role of the donors in the forced resignation. of the nonprofit's president. What should you expect? How can you prepare? How do you manage a similar crisis? What lessons are there for you and your nonprofit where a major gift may be 4, 5, or 6 figures? Doug White, thank you for coming back to Nonprofit Radio to talk about this.

Doug WhiteYeah, it's good to be with you again, Tony. Really is.

Tony MartignettiWhat's, uh, what's your take? Well, did I leave out anything, uh, essential to the, to the framing that, that, uh, that you think needs to be filled in? And what's your take on the— what we've seen over the past week?

Doug WhiteWell, I think everybody knows the major headlines of the past week. The 3 presidents of Penn— the University of Pennsylvania, I should say— MIT and Harvard went to a committee in Congress to answer questions about their policies on free speech on campus. And as you— as we all know, many congresspeople are upset with not only that testimony but also in general what they think is going on in the campus world. And so the question became, what kind of policies do you have And what are you doing to, to change them, if anything? And in a nutshell, the outcome was fairly negative for the presidents because they basically equivocated. They did not answer the questions directly. And that, I think, as you're implying, created a groundswell of criticism, and many people asked for the resignations of those 3 people as we're speaking right now. And as you mentioned, the president of NTEN, uh, her name is Elizabeth, um, McGill, resigned along with the, the president of the, the president of the board this past weekend. And just today, Harvard University affirmed their support, or the board did, their support of Claudine Gay. And I don't believe that the MIT president's position is, is in any danger at this point. And as you're also saying, a lot of that criticism is coming from politicians and some of the constituencies at the universities. And one of those constituencies, and an important one, is the donor base. And so the question I think that you're asking is what, uh, what role the donors have played in all of this. So I think you've, you've set it up here. I don't think there's anything you missed, but it's a, it's a unique time in, I think, the world of, of higher education.

Tony MartignettiAnd, and I think nonprofits generally, you know.

Doug WhiteYes.

Tony MartignettiAny— it goes beyond the free speech conversation because a major donor at any nonprofit could be upset about any direction that they see, or even maybe, you know, so granular to be a particular program or the administration of a particular program. So that, you know, it's, it's It's a conversation about how we manage our donors' influence, expectations, so that we don't end up in this kind of a crisis where, you know, all right, maybe it doesn't rise to calling for the CEO or executive director's resignation, although it certainly could. But, you know, the influence generally that is, you know, beyond what they're giving relates to. So, you know, these donors at the University of Pennsylvania, one of the sort of instigators is an advisory board member to the Wharton School. which is the Penn Business School. Now, his giving, and I'm going to assume this, I think it's safe, but at least for our conversation, I'd like to assume that his— and he was one of the 9-figure donors, so we're talking about $100 million or more gift, probably doesn't relate to free speech. It relates to programs at Penn. And he's concerned, he expressed concern about the direction that he saw in the business school. So it's— Yes. So again, assuming beyond it, assuming that it's beyond what their giving relates to, what do we do when donors exercise influence?

Doug WhiteWell, you're bringing up, I think this is the meat of the question. You're bringing it up. And for me, It's almost— it's really a fundamental question. The person you were speaking about, I believe his name is Marc Rowan. He's either the head of or he was on the Wharton Advisory Board. Now, University of Pennsylvania, there's a university, then the business school is Wharton, and Wharton has its own advisory board. They're not a governing board, they're an advisory board, but they're very influential, as many advisory boards are. But at universities, it's the governing board that is going to make a decision about whether the president is fired or hired. So he, he was not in a position to say, okay, I want her, I want her, Elizabeth McGill, to be fired, but at least statutorily. But he did start a campaign that lasted for several like several weeks actually saying that she's got to go, she's got to go. And you're right, he was one of the— I think it was $100 million. It was a $100 million

Tony Martignettidonor. Yeah. And he started to withdraw that gift and encourage other major donors to do the same.

Doug WhiteOne of those major donors was Jon Huntsman, who has a foundation out in Utah. He's a former governor. And a former diplomat. He was very upset. Dick Wolf, the creator of the show Law and Order, a graduate of UPenn, also said that he was upset. So Mark Rowan, the way I understand it, the people I've spoken with have said that he wrote to all of the trustees, kind of like bombarding them on a daily basis, saying she's got to go, she's got to go, and she's got to go. And this was well before the testimony on the 5th of December. It started the day after Hamas attacked Israel. So he was very, very upset. And to say that you're going to not give $100 million even to a place like Penn, that's a big threat. And so Penn's going to listen to it. And I think where you were just heading a moment ago, if I'm reading this correctly, is that what kind of influence should that kind of a donor have over this kind of a question at a place like Penn or any other university or any other charity? And my answer is complicated. One is we have to understand one of the highest levels of philanthropy is that a donor in the United States anyway, a donor has the right to give or not give to any organization he or she wishes. That's just a personal decision. He can't be— the person can't be made to think that the gift has to be made or can't be made. So it's a personal decision. And in that context, Mr. Rowan had every right to say, you do not have access to my checkbook if you do this. So I think that's, that, that's a guiding principle for me, Tony, when it comes to philanthropy. That said, universities and many other charities, but right now we're talking about universities here, they are in the spotlight when it comes to current affairs. And it's been a decades-old controversy where universities have been thought to be much more liberal than many conservatives would like to see them. And so the accusations have been that there have been conservatives who have not been able to make their speeches, or people who have been invited who are conservatives have been kept from speaking. And that's been, that's been a mantra of the conservative voice in the United States. And quite frankly, I see where that's coming from. I do see where that's coming from. So what you've got here is these 3 presidents are saying, look, we think what happened, what Hamas did was terrible. They all said that, by the way. And then when asked more directly whether you would condone that kind of speech on campus that says that Israel is basically engaged in genocide. Should that be condoned? Should that speech be condoned? And they were saying basically no. And the answer was supposed to be yes.

Tony MartignettiYeah, well, they equivocated. Certainly Elizabeth McGill did at Penn, but they were giving sort of legal scholarly answers to a political panel that doesn't engage in academics and, you know, and pedagogy.

Doug WhiteOr nuance for that matter.

Tony MartignettiBut, or nuance, right.

Doug WhiteBut, you know, so— I was gonna say one other thing though, in terms of that, the legalese question. I don't know if you're old enough to remember this, but I am. When Mike Dukakis ran for president back in 1988, he was asked a question at one of the debates about rape. And the question was framed about his wife being raped, which would really, in anybody's reality, the person would say, of course, you know, Mike Dukakis relied on a very legalistic answer and there was no emotion in it. And I think the— and he lost points. I mean, that was a moment in his campaign where it was not a highlight, where he just didn't say, golly, we got to get the guy. This is what was missing last week with these presidents. They didn't just say, we got us— we can't have that. We have to condone— we have to condemn that kind of language.

Tony MartignettiYeah, I want to— I want to focus on Something that you said about the donors, you know, they have a right to give or not give where they would like to or not. So does that bring things down to, you know, for our listeners where major gifts are, like I had said, 4, 5, 6 figures, does that bring it all down to the money talks? And you either accede to the wishes of the donor's influence or you suffer the consequence?

Doug WhiteWell, this is what I was going to say earlier when I— what I said is kind of a complicated answer. And I think you're going into that second level of my answer there, what would've been my answer then. And that is that I would answer to your question in a direct way to say no, they shouldn't be acceding all the time to a donor's whims. But I'd like to make the distinction between a donor that has given money with certain expectations and a person who has not given money, and also the donor who has given without expectations but who might be upset with the organization. So let me begin with the donor who's made a gift with expectations, and that is an example of that. It would be the Princeton gift, where the donor was giving $35 million in 1961 to establish the graduate— to endow the graduate program of what was then the Woodrow Wilson School of International Relations. And the lawsuit that came about in the late— early 2000s, that went to the late 2000s, that said that the school, Princeton, wasn't doing what the donor wished. We won't rehash that whole scenario, but I will say this, that the case was one of saying, I made you— I made this gift and you're not following what we agreed upon. And in that case, I believe the university or the charity has an obligation to follow what it said it would do. I believe wholeheartedly that the university or the charity needs to do what it said it was going to do. It's in many states, it's becoming, uh, there's beginning to be some, some history, legal history on this, uh, and so many states are taking a closer look at it than they were back 25 years ago. But, uh, from a moral perspective, if nothing else, charities need to do that.

Kate MartignettiIt's time for a break. Are you looking to maximize your fundraising efforts and impact this giving season? DonorBox's online donation platform is designed to help you reach your fundraising goals. From customizable donation forms to far-reaching EasyShare crowdfunding and peer-to-peer options, plus seamless in-person giving with DonorBox Live Kiosk. DonorBox makes giving simple and fast for your donors and moves the needle on your mission. Visit donorbox.org. And let DonorBox help you help others. Now back to Lessons from the UPenn President's Resignation.

Tony MartignettiThat's the one that we talked about on, on the show when, when your book Abusing Donor Intent was published. Just to distinguish that from what's happening, I think, at these universities, but we're, we're broadening the conversation beyond them. Donors are exerting influence beyond the— likely beyond the terms of their gift and their gift agreements and all the documentation. I don't— I'm, as I had said earlier, I'm assuming that these donors, Marc Rowan, Huntsman, Ron Lauder was another one. Yes. Of the Estée Lauder fortune. That their giving doesn't relate to freedom of speech on the campus or conversations about antisemitism.

Doug WhiteSo I think there were—

Tony MartignettiI know you have 3 different examples that you want to talk through. Just— I just want to distinguish that the Robertson case was around the terms of their specific gift. Right.

Doug WhiteThat's correct. And that's why that's in that one category. But you're bringing into the other, in the current situation, this other category where the donors aren't really supporting that as an issue. They're not giving in response to this issue. In fact, I believe, and I don't have it in front of me, but Ross— excuse me, um, Mark Rowan's gift was to establish a a financial kind of institute within Wharton. And so yes, it had nothing to do with the free speech question. But when you get to the question that is at hand at this university, at Penn and Harvard and MIT, you're talking about a fundamental purpose behind the organization's existence. And so any donor who is giving for whatever other reason has the likelihood to have an opinion about the university's position on this rather fundamental question, the free speech question.

Tony MartignettiYeah.

Doug WhiteAnd so you're right, they're giving, their philanthropy over the years hasn't had anything to do With, with, uh, I'm sorry about the— my dog in the background.

Tony MartignettiYou have a dog in the background? That's all right, we're family-friendly at Nonprofit Radio. We've had babies, dogs. Your dog is relatively quiet compared to some.

Doug WhiteYeah, well, it's just when somebody walks in the yard or something. Uh, but no, you're right, it has nothing to do with the, the issue at hand. So does this donor Should this donor have any sway in the university's examination of this fairly large and fundamental question? I believe that these donors have gone further than what they should. I don't believe that— quite frankly, I believe in the sanctity of a university. And what it does in terms of fulfilling its, its core obligations. And one of its core obligations is to provide a— what— an environment on campus that allows people to feel like they can express themselves, and at the same time feeling comfortable doing it, not only expressing themselves but hearing other people express themselves. And that tension is— we have seen develop over these last decades, but I think it's really coming to a head right now. That tension is not going to be resolved one way or the other. The best that can happen is that it gets managed, in my view. And the managing of that isn't up to a donor. It's up to the administration of the university. So I do feel, even though I said earlier— this is why it's kind of complicated— even though the donor should not feel an obligation to make a gift or not make a gift. It's up to him or her. It's a personal decision. But at the same time, I feel that donors need to have a higher regard than what I'm seeing right now for how the university would deal with these questions on its own, rather than having a donor take, take a shot at this. And I feel the same way about politicians, by the way.

Tony Martignettifree speech being, as you said, a fundamental value of a university and in other nonprofits, they all have fundamental values, whether it's valuing— might be free speech, valuing people, a commitment to diversity, equity, and inclusion, commitment maybe to Their environmental impact, reducing that, you know, whatever, whatever their core values are, we all, all nonprofits have them. Yes. So, so, you know, how to manage the instance where donors start to exert influence over the, over the management of your, your core reasons for being? And, and is there a way to prevent a donor from overreaching? I'm, I'm, uh, I, I'm not— I can't envision one, but I'm interested in your opinion. So is there a way to, to safeguard ourselves from the kind of crisis that these 3 nonprofits are finding themselves in?

Doug WhiteMany organizations have gift acceptance policies. And my thinking is this, that this issue needs to be part of that process. I sometimes ask organizations if they have a separate, in addition to the gift acceptance policy, a separate policy for ethics. And I would put this question into that ethics category, whether it's part of the gift acceptance policy or whether it's in its own policy. that they address this, because there are a lot of other issues where donors can be a problem in the development of the fundraising process. And last week I spoke in Indianapolis about donors who became problems. I would use Harvey Weinstein and Bill Cosby as examples of that. But here we're not talking about that kind of a problem. We're talking about a problem where A donor is going to exert some influence. So I think it's up to the charity to anticipate that there could be issues that donors have problems with at that charity. We'll just use Penn as an example, or the 3 that spoke last week as an example, and say, look, we have our core fundamental values. We don't, we don't claim to have all of the answers, but it is part of who we are as an organization to address this question. Yeah. As best we can, and there's going to be tension over time, and we expect you to permit us to deal with that tension without interference. And I'm talking about the donor who's made the gift so far, the guy who says, look, I gave you $10 million and now you're doing something that I don't like, and I'm going to kind of raise my voice in opposition. And that voice has purchase because of that $10 million. And what the charity is saying before that all happens is saying you don't have purchase, you don't have the authority, and you're making that gift knowing that fact. Now charities so far are— would be very reluctant to do that. They'd say, well, why would we want to create an enemy before we get started? I get that. But my, my concern is you don't have any, you don't have any real argument once this is all played out and you haven't established that as a part of the ground rules. Then you don't have any real ability to say, look, we have this, we have this quest within our own world here, and you're not part of that argument, at least in terms of what you've given us. So my suggestion is for charities to look at this. This is a tremendously important learning moment for the charities to say, what can we do to prevent not so much the different— the problem that comes on campus here or whatever problem that comes with any charity, because you can't know, but you can put donors on notice saying, we are who we are and your money isn't going to change our fundamental values.

Tony MartignettiAll right, let's hypothesize the, the forward-looking charity that, that has an ethics statement that accompanies their gift acceptance policy, and the donor has signed the ethics statement that they, they agree, and it says that they will abide by it. And Something gets under their skin and they just ignore the agreement and do exactly what Mr. Rowan did at Penn, and they pull their own donation and they start to encourage other major donors to do the same. Where are we left? Just where we have an ethics policy that the donor signed on to. That doesn't, doesn't feel very, uh, reassuring in the face of losing a, a major donor who's encouraging others, other major donors to go with him or her.

Doug WhiteWell, that, that was another part of this, by the way. I'll get to the substance of the response, and I don't mean to delay it, but, but I do have to interrupt.

Tony MartignettiI'll hold your feet to the fire, academician.

Doug WhiteI, I do believe that, that That campaign, really, to— a daily campaign, uh, to doghouse the trustees at Penn was low-handed. I, I don't think that was a very, very high-handed, uh, maneuver on his part. And that's a little bit connected to some frustrations I have with some of of high net worth individuals who think that because of that net worth, they have kind of an ability or an intelligence or an experience that they really don't have. And they're just shoving it into somebody else's, some charity's world. I guess that comes with having the ego that it takes to make $100 million. So, you know, that's not me, but—

Tony MartignettiMake even more because you have $100 million that you can give away.

Doug WhiteExactly. He's got billions, I'm sure. But getting back to your question, you're right. It's only a piece of paper and it's not a legal commitment or anything of that nature. But what it does, and it doesn't solve all the problems, I will grant you that, Tony. And I think the listeners have to know that there is— I don't have the magic bullet, but what it would do is tell the donor that you've thought about this. In fact, I think it's actually a cultivation tool, because if you tell donors that you've thought about this, you're also telling them that you're an intelligent, caring, thoughtful charitable organization, and that as a result, your money is going to be well stewarded once it gets to us. But that's just the way I look at it. At the end of the day, you're right, it is just a piece of paper. Yeah. And at the end of the day, the donor doesn't have to abide by it at all, and he, and he makes the fuss, just like as has happened at Penn and Harvard too, by the way. We're focusing on Penn probably because Ms. McGill did resign, but you know, the Harvard problem was as severe. There were many, many, many donors who said she should resign. So. Yeah. It's not just Penn, but that paper, you're right, it's not going to say— it's not going to stop anything if the donor is really bent on making sure that a resignation takes place. But it would allow, I believe, the charity to say, look, we have thought this through. We think this through with our— in our world of philanthropy, and we not only care about it, we respect our donors so much, we want to share this thinking with them. So there's a, there's a high ground there in doing that, even if the donor doesn't really respect it in the end.

Tony MartignettiYou have a book on nonprofit ethics, one of your earlier ones. Before I, before I knew you, you, uh, you were publishing, uh, and so we haven't— we didn't talk about that one on Nonprofit Radio, but you, you published a book on nonprofit ethics.

Doug WhiteYes, it was called The Nonprofit Challenge. Back in 20— gosh, 2010, 2011, something like that. And I looked at what was going on at the Red Cross after 9/11, and they had this— they had accepted a lot of gifts after 9/11, on 9/11, and shortly after. And, you know, the Red Cross, its job is to take care of people who are victims of of tragedy like hurricanes and fires and things like that. And I don't want to sound too brutal here, but there weren't a lot of living victims after 9/11. And so the world of the Red Crosses, it wasn't the right fit, if you will. They got a lot of money, but they couldn't put it to what they would traditionally use it for in that kind of a situation. Everybody gave money that I know of anyway. Everybody tried to give blood. It was a moment of— Yeah. of a national importance. And so of course you'd want to go to the Red Cross and give, but they didn't have enough places to put the money. So they, they put it elsewhere. And a huge case came up afterwards because they had established a trust and the money didn't go to the victims. And the people who gave the money wanted them to go to the victims. So the question was, not that anybody was stealing the money, but ethically, what should the, what should the Red Cross have done? They have since changed their their policy there. I, I think what— the Red Cross is a great organization, uh, and that they mishandled that at the time is part of growing. I think, uh, we'd never had a 9/11 before. The outpouring was huge. But that was just one example in, in the book on ethics. And the question there was, how, how can we look at our— ourselves? I think of I think of charities, I think of the charitable sector, Tony, as the ethical sector of our society. We oftentimes talk about ourselves as being the third sector, business and government being the other two. So we're the third sector, but I also think we're the ethical sector. We don't have political pressures. Don't stop laughing. I understand there's lots of politics at places like Penn and other charities. And we also don't have the same need to make money for shareholders as is true in the for-profit world. And so we have a cleaner runway to look at ethical questions. And I've taken a lot of time these last several decades now examining the role charities play in society and their ethical motive behind what they need to be doing. And so, yes, I feel like this, what you had just asked about a moment ago in terms of a, or what I mentioned a moment ago about the ethics document or the agreement that the charity would have with the donor, and if the donor doesn't really abide by that, what happens? I think at least the charity would have the moral high ground to say, we have thought this through, we have talked about it with the donor. Yeah. And we can't, we can't make the donor do one thing or the other at this point, but we can say that we've talked about it. And by the way, even at that point, if you take that down the road as you just did a moment ago, and the donor is making a fuss, the charity would still say, we respect the donor, we understand where he's coming from or she's coming from. This is not an us against him kind of a thing, but it's a matter of saying, okay, here's a, here's a problem. That has developed, and we're dealing with it the best way we can. And we can only hope that our donor sees that fact and tries to not use his or her financial ability to sway us in making decisions about our core purposes.

Kate MartignettiIt's time for Tony's Take Two.

Tony MartignettiThank you, Kate. It's December giving. I know how critical it is for you. I'm thinking about you. I'm on your side. I know I said a couple weeks ago, but I want to tell you again, if you do your best, then you can stand proud on January 1st knowing that there's nothing more you could have done. I'm thinking about you this— these last few weeks of December. I'm with you. I'm with you. Do the best you can. That's Tony's Take Two. Kate.

Kate MartignettiHappy holidays and happy New Year, everyone. We've got beaucoup but loads more time, so let's go back to Lessons from the UPenn President's Resignation with Doug White.

Tony MartignettiThe other dimension is that That donor is hurting the very beneficiaries that the nonprofit exists to help. In the case of the universities, it's students and faculty. In the case of an animal shelter, it's the animals that are housed in a no-kill shelter. In the case of a food bank, it's the— Yeah. It's the folks who come in twice a week to fill grocery baskets and maybe come for lunches. It's not only a question of surrendering the core values, but it becomes an issue of being detrimental to the people we exist, or the people or entities, however you— Yeah. I mean, some charities exist to help the environment. Whatever we're about to help, donor, major donors pulling their gifts hurts the cause that we exist for.

Doug WhiteWhat you're pointing out right now is something I was listening for or looking for among the people at Harvard and Penn and MIT. And that is to say, You may disagree with this, but by withholding your support, you're really, you're really hurting the entirety of our organization. You're hurting what you want to see us do, and you've already given us support to do what we're doing. And so clearly you think that we're doing that correctly. And so if you're going to take a position on this other issue, and we all agree it's important, nobody's trying to say it's not important, but if you do, hold your money back because of that, then what you are interested in is less likely to be successful. And so you're really, really taking away a lot of what we can do that you want to have happen. So the argument can be brought back to the donor saying, you're hurting yourself by doing this, you're hurting your own interests by doing this. And I think there's an argument there, and I haven't heard that. from any of these. I don't know if they have been talking about this internally among the board members or among their staffs or whatever. I haven't heard that. But you're right, they are hurting themselves. The donors are hurting their own interests when they, when they take that position. See, it would be one thing if the donor— if, if we'll just use Marc, since we're— Marc Rowan, since we've talked about him. Yeah. He could write an editorial in the New York Times or the Philadelphia paper or the student paper saying how much he opposes this, which is his right and quite frankly his obligation if he feels that way. But that would be a separate activity from withholding his money.

Tony MartignettiYeah, that was not sufficient for him. The coverage I read said that he did Have an op-ed in the Penn newspaper.

Doug WhiteOkay. Well, I'm not surprised. Thank you for telling me that. I didn't know. That doesn't surprise me. And clearly you're right, it wasn't sufficient for him. But this tug of war, you know, a lot of times we talk about conflict. This is another thing I wrote about in the book that you just referenced, The Ethics. Now, it's not a question of avoiding conflict or making sure it gets resolved to everyone's satisfaction. That doesn't happen in real life. What does happen in real life among people who care about a resolution is that we understand this tension. And I think the free speech question is a good example. Yeah. Probably the perfect example of this. And that is, we're not going to solve this. This is one thing that both sides don't— I don't feel, I don't see it anyway— understand. And that is that there should be this one solution where everybody's going to understand the rules. And with free speech, if I say Hamas is a terrible group because look at what they did. And they are, and I will say that they are terrible. But then, uh, if someone who supports the Palestinian cause and has taken a look at what's been going on there for the last several decades, lifetimes, uh, uh, they could say, look, you know, Israel's a bad actor in this whole thing. Both of those things can be true. Both of those sentiments can be within one person. And what I think the university's goal is to tell people that that's what it is, an ethical decision. When we talk about an ethical dilemma, the reason we use the word dilemma is because there's no black and white answer. There's no clarity to— there's no clean way to get from where we are in a dilemma to where everybody's happy. And oftentimes there is no way at all. So you manage it. You say, look, this is going to come up and it's going to come up and it's going to come up. And we're not going to come up with a rule that says this is the way it's going to be all the time. When a conservative person comes to campus, we're not going to say he can always say what he wants to. And the same is true for a liberal person or whatever the argument might be. What we've got to do is say, look, we understand that there are conflicting viewpoints here. And where I do believe the president residents got it right. They said it's context. This is just the worst place to say this, but it was context dependent. And Elise Stefanik, the person who was doing the grilling at that point in Congress, was saying, are you kidding me? Yeah. And quite frankly, she had the hearts of America when she said that. And me too. I think, you know, I have differences with Ms. Stefanik, but They couldn't say, "No, this was wrong." They we would condemn this on on campus. So, but the policy itself is true. You have to take a look at at the context of what's going on in this. And if you're really saying, "Look, we're going to make you feel unsafe, you Israelites, because you guys have been beating down the Palestinians for the last." 50, 75 years, then that's wrong because you can't make anybody else, you can't threaten anybody else. In my view, you can say, I support the Palestinians. You can't say, I believe you can't say that. And I believe that's what the presidents of these universities were saying. And but they were also saying that the Israelis have a position too. And what, what, what fuels this conversation right now is the atrocities that Hamas committed against the Israelis. That, that, that is, you, you, you know, one of the steps that I've created when it comes to ethical decision-making, because everybody thinks it's, you know, kind of squishy. And, you know, I, I know ethics because my mama told me what's ethical, or I know it's in my gut. That's what a lot of people think. But when you're trying to deal with someone else who has a different mama or has a different gut, you've got to have some common, some common language, or you don't go anywhere. And so, you know, you've got to say, look, you're going to be uncomfortable. We're not going to try to take away the discomfort of being on campus. We're not going to try to take away the discomfort of hearing something you really, really, really don't like. That's where I think colleges have gotten it wrong. This question of saying we're going to make everybody comfortable so everybody's happy all the time, that's a recipe for disaster.

Tony MartignettiAll

Doug Whiteright. And my feeling is that, you know, as long as you don't threaten anyone or imply that there's a threat to anybody individually and physically, that you're taking a position on policy Then, then anybody should be able to speak. And people who are— and you've, you've seen this a lot more where a conservative comes and the liberals kind of shout them down. I think on campus, the shouting down thing, you shout me down, you're out of here. I mean, you don't have a right to be in the room if you're going to shout someone down.

Tony MartignettiWell, that goes— all right, and that, of course, then that goes to the, the core values again, you know.

Doug WhiteYes.

Tony MartignettiEach nonprofit supporting its own core values, what it stands for, even in the face of potentially losing major support. I want to look at another dimension of this, that these 3 university presidents are all women. And at least at Penn, that's the one we know the most detail about, all the major donors are men. So I don't, I don't know that that's true at the other 2 universities. But, but again, I want to take it out of the university context. Do you think there's a, there's, there's a gender bias here that it's, it's a bunch of— is it a bunch of rich men picking on a bunch of female CEOs?

Doug WhiteI can't believe you're bringing this up because this is the conversation I had with my wife a few days ago. And she brought that to my attention. And I'm thinking, first of all, that the Ivy League has 7 out of its 8 presidents as women, which is, I think, an astonishing thing given the history of the schools. An astonishing and a good thing. Dartmouth just got its new president, a woman, for the first time this past fall. And so I'm thinking, this is great. I'm not looking for a woman necessarily. That's not how I look at—

Tony MartignettiNo, but let's deal with—

Doug WhiteThis is a good thing.

Tony MartignettiLet's deal with the— this— the, the— what, what seems to me to be a, a gender, a gender overreaching.

Doug WhiteYes. And I, I, I think the answer— okay, so I will answer your question. I think yes, I think that's a factor, uh, and, uh, but I don't think it's, it's, it's I don't think that the donors at Penn have said, we want to get this woman out of there. Now, there have been some donors at both Penn and Harvard. I think I was reading the other day about Harvard, Claudine Gay. People were against her even before she was, she was there. And one of the— I think it was Bill Ackman, or one of the financiers who supports Harvard, who said, That when you limit your choices to a woman of color, then you're taking a lot of people off the table, and that was wrong as a process. And, and he can believe that, and people would think he's right. It's not a fact, it's an opinion. So I don't think you're taking a lot off the table. You might be taking a lot off the table, but you're leaving a lot on too. So. Yeah. I don't think that was a really accurate— I don't believe that was an accurate criticism. But was there gender bias in here? All of these women, all of these presidents are women. All of the men, all of the criticizers were men, at least the most vocal. But there were some women I know at Harvard who were on staff who felt uncomfortable with Claudine Gaynes. His leadership. But you can't, you can't ignore it, can you? I mean, you bring it up. My wife brought it up. I don't think it's something you could ignore. And I think it should be kind of part of the conversation. If I were a reporter, I would go to some of these really, really wealthy people and ask that question. Now, they might deny it, but I would like to hear them deny it because I do.

Tony MartignettiYes, I'd like to hear their, their answers to that also. Final dimension that I'd like to bring up, because we just have a couple minutes left. Board support seems to be key here. At Penn, the board support eroded for Dr. Elizabeth McGill. At Harvard, as you said, just yesterday or today, today, the Harvard board has said we are behind President Gay. Board support. So I know, knowing your board members, that you're not going to be able to anticipate how they're going to react in, in the event of, of a crisis, but knowing them, having their support overall, seems to be a distinguishing factor here.

Doug WhiteOne of the points that was made in the news articles that I read about Elizabeth McGill She being fairly new, was that she didn't have time to create, uh, relationships, uh, really deep relationships with individual board members. Uh, to your comment a moment ago, yes, board support is crucial. Uh, in fact, I mean, just— I'm sure your listeners know this, but just to get this on the, on the table, the board is the president's boss. Mm-hmm. And so the board hires and It fires the president.

Tony MartignettiYes.

Doug WhiteShe kept the board from having to fire her by resigning, but it could have been different at Harvard because she wasn't going to resign and they could have fired her. But the board is crucial. And but what muddies the waters a bit here is that many of your major donors are also on the board. Yes. You have, you have that going on. That was going on at Penn too. But the board, the board really— the job of the board is to set not only a strategic direction, but also a philosophical direction for the organization. And the president is meant to be the executor of the, of that philosophy. And so when, when you see a, a, a, a president who went out— these 3 did— to Congress, they are saying what they are carrying forth, the values of the university. That's another— I'm so glad you brought this up because that's another, quite, quite frankly, another big issue for me. The board Did not have Elizabeth McGill's back. In fact, it was the opposite, and it was the opposite for a long time. It had been building up. Hamas was the the the the testimony was just the last straw. But that said, they they each of these women, each of these presidents were doing what they both they all agreed to with their boards, and so. The board walking away at that moment, uh, I felt was, was unfortunate for those people. They, they need the support of the board. If, if I were on the board and I really disagreed with what they said before Congress, I would say, let's take this behind closed doors. I would not have done what they did.

Tony MartignettiKnow your board. Know your board members. I think, I think that's another Takeaway. All right, Doug, you want to give us a closing statement?

Doug WhiteI feel so strongly about charitable organizations. Sometimes people don't realize that places like Harvard are charities and they're so wealthy, but they are, legally speaking, they're in the same place in the IRS code as the local food, shelter. And so I think we look at charities and say, there are organizations that will do the work that neither government nor business does, or for-profits do. And so we are so fortunate to have them, and we need— and they need our support. They do not live solely on their earned income. And what I mean by that is, in the case of a university, tuitions. Right. They need philanthropic support. And it just so happens that the United States has many, many good philanthropists. Now, I mean by philanthropists, people who just give any amount of money. That support to charity is crucial. And what I would hate to see is that this issue, as big as it is, take away the philanthropic support these organizations get. And I do want to make a point here. Harvard, Penn, and MIT, all those organizations represented in Congress, are all what we would call very wealthy organizations. That is to say, they have big endowments. But that said, they still need their annual support. We can't go into now as to why that is, but I can say for a fact that each of those people legitimately, each of those organizations legitimately need philanthropic support in addition to their endowment. They do great work for society. Right. And I would really not want to see this situation, as important as it is, as fundamental as it is to these organizations, I would not like to see this situation overtake our spirit of philanthropy to these 3 or any other charity in the United States.

Tony MartignettiOr any others. Those are, you know, all our listeners know the value of small gifts. Annual gifts, major gifts, foundation support. We didn't even talk about the institutional support. It didn't really— doesn't seem to have applied here. Planned gifts, recurring, the monthly, they're all important. And I hope this has helped folks to put some thought around how you might manage a crisis like this. Yeah. How you might help prevent a crisis like this. Doug, thank you very much for sharing your, your wisdom.

Doug WhiteWell, Tony, I appreciate your taking the time to have this conversation on this particular topic. It's very emotional for many people. It's emotional for me. I think of it as being fundamental to what we do, you and I, and so many thousands of others across the country, all to promote Uh, what I think is our ethical sector.

Tony MartignettiDoug White, author and advisor to nonprofits and philanthropists. You'll find him at dougwhite.net. Thank you again, Doug.

Doug WhiteMy pleasure.

Kate MartignettiNext week, no show. It's Christmas. The week after, No show. It's New Year's. We'll be back the second week in January for our 2024 outlook with our smart contributors, Amy Sample Ward and Gene Takagi. If you missed any part of this week's show,

Tony MartignettiI beseech you, find it at tonymartignetti.com. If you celebrate Christmas, I hope you have a great one. I hope you have Fun time, wonderful time with family and friends. Happy New Year, of course. Wishing you the best in the early weeks of 2024, and we will be back in the, uh, in the second week. I hope you enjoy your time off, time well deserved. And Kate, Merry Christmas. I'll be seeing you in person For Christmas week. So see you soon.

Kate MartignettiSee you soon. We're sponsored by DonorBox. Outdated donation forms blocking your supporters' generosity this giving season? DonorBox, the fast, flexible, and friendly fundraising platform for nonprofits. donorbox.org. Our creative producer is Claire Meyerhoff. I'm your associate producer, Kate Martignetti. The show's social media is by Susan Chavez. Marc Silverman is our web guy. And this music is by Scott Stein.

Tony MartignettiThank you for that affirmation, Scotty. Be with us in a couple of weeks for Nonprofit Radio. Big nonprofit ideas for those other 95%. Go out and change the world. And be great. Happy New Year.

Nonprofit Radio