Donor Surveys & People-Powered Movements





Donor Surveys
You’ll make the most of the donors you have by discovering their potential through surveying. Crystal Mahon and Christian Robillard talk principles, best practices and goal setting. Crystal is with STARS Air Ambulance and Christian is at Beyond The Bake Sale. (Originally aired August 7th, 2020.)
People-Powered Movements
This team helps you build more effective and inclusive movements, by encouraging you to think about communications, power and privilege. They're Celina Stewart from League of Women Voters U.S. and Gloria Pan with Moms Rising. (Originally aired August 7th, 2020.)
Here’s the transcript
Tony MartignettiHello and welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. I'm your aptly named host and the podfather of your favorite hebdomadal podcast. Oh, I am glad you're with us. I'd suffer the effects of enthesitis if you inflamed me with the idea that you missed this week's show. Here's our associate producer, Kate. What's going on this week?
Kate MartignettiHey, Tony. We've got 2 convos from 2020. Donor surveys. You'll make the most of the donors you have by discovering their potential through surveying. Crystal Mahon and Christian Robillard talk principles, best practices, and goal setting. Crystal is with STARS Air Ambulance, and Christian is at Beyond The Bake Sale. Then, People Powered Movements. This team helps you build more effective and inclusive movements by encouraging you to think about communications, power, and privilege. There's Celina Stewart from League of Women Voters U.S. and Gloria Pan with MomsRising. These both aired on August 7th, 2020. On Tony's Take Two.
Tony MartignettiHappy Thanksgiving! Unbelievable.
Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by DonorBox. Outdated donation forms blocking your supporters' generosity this giving season? DonorBox, the fast, flexible, and friendly fundraising platform for nonprofits. donorbox.org. Here is Donor Surveys.
Tony MartignettiWelcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio coverage of 20NTC, 2020 Nonprofit Technology Conference. NTEN made the excruciating decision to cancel the nonprofit technology conference, but we are continuing virtually. You'll get just as much value. We don't have to all be close to pick the brains of the expert speakers from, from NTEN. My guests now are Crystal Mahon and Christian Robillard. Crystal is manager of annual giving at STARS Air Ambulance. Air Ambulance, and Christian is founder and chief podcaster at Beyond The Bake Sale. Crystal, Christian, welcome. Welcome to Nonprofit Radio.
Kate MartignettiThanks, Tony.
Christian RobillardThanks, Tony. Great to be here.
Tony MartignettiIt's a pleasure to have both of you. You are both in Canada. Crystal, you are in Alberta, and Christian, remind me where you are.
Christian RobillardI'm in beautiful, sunny Ottawa, Ontario.
Tony MartignettiOttawa. Ottawa, the capital. Yes, of course.
Christian RobillardThe nation's capital, not to be disputed with Toronto, who likes to think they're the capital.
Tony MartignettiI know. Well, and many Americans think it's either Montreal or Toronto. Yes, but Ottawa, capital. All right. I'm glad to know that you're both well and safe, and glad to have you both with us. Thanks. We're talking about donor surveys, your NTC topic. Is donor surveys your untapped data goldmine? Crystal, why are surveys a data goldmine?
Crystal MahonWell, we had the fortune of launching a survey. We'd never done one prior to 2016, and when we did it, we were amazed at what we found. So we learned a lot about our donors and their communication preferences. We made money, like easily made net on that. And on top of that, we actually ended up learning a lot about planned giving prospects, and turns out that there were a lot of donors that we had no idea had named us in their will or were interested in naming us in their will. So there was a lot of revenue, like hidden revenue, that we were finally getting access to. So that's sort of where that line is alluding to or what it's referring to.
Tony MartignettiInteresting. I'm looking forward to drilling into that more because I do planned giving fundraising as a consultant, and I'm sometimes asked by clients about doing surveys. So I'm interested in what you're doing as well. And, and you're getting gifts. You said you've made money back from them, so people do send you gifts of cash along with their surveys?
Crystal MahonYes, like this year we did— or I guess last year, 2019, our STARS Ally Survey made $300,000. And then on top of that, all the new people that we found for planned giving, like we're looking at millions of dollars coming in through the door in the future for STARS. So It's— yeah, to not do a survey just seems like a huge missed opportunity at this point.
Tony MartignettiYeah, my good— did you say billions with a B?
Crystal MahonNo, millions with an M.
Tony MartignettiMillions, okay.
Crystal MahonIt would certainly be nice though.
Tony MartignettiWell, the audio is not perfect, so it almost sounded billions, so I wanted to be sure because I'm sure the listeners have the same question. Okay, millions. Millions is still very, very good. Christian, anything you want to add to about why these are such a goldmine for nonprofits?
Christian RobillardI mean, besides the fact that you're using data obviously to reinforce certain decisions and to highlight certain wealth elements, I would say in terms of your sponsorship potential, I know that a lot of organizations are looking more so into the corporate sponsorship, corporate engagement side of things. And I think with your donor surveys, you can really reveal a lot around where people are working, their levels in terms of positions within a certain company or organization, and that can lead you down some interesting paths from a corporate sponsorship perspective.
Tony MartignettiHmm, okay, okay. Your description of the workshop said that you make the most of the donors you already have, and it sounds like you both obviously are going there. Is there anything you want to add about sussing out the value that's in your— that you don't know you have among your current donors?
Crystal MahonWell, from our perspective, like, it's given us an opportunity to get to know our donors better in terms of what, what are they actually interested in learning about in our organization, or why are they choosing to give. And it allows us to tailor our messages and just be a lot more personal with them and act like we really know them, as opposed to them just being a number in our database. So it really gives us an opportunity to really cultivate that relationship and just continue Bringing them on board and continuing that relationship with
Tony Martignettithem. Yeah. Okay. Is most of your content in the workshop around best practices for surveys? Is that what we're going to be exploring mostly?
Crystal MahonChristian, feel free to jump in. I would say that we were looking a lot at best practices, but then also case studies, so people would have some tangible examples of how to actually launch one, what to consider, and What they would actually need to do once they go back to their nonprofit to actually do it themselves.
Tony MartignettiOkay. All right. Well, let's, let's start with like, where, where do you get started? Who, who, who are the best people to send surveys to? Or what types of information are, are you finding are most responded to? Or what types of questions are most responded to? How can you help us Sort of frame an outline of what we— where to get started?
Crystal MahonWell, Christian and I talked a lot about building the proper scope of your survey. So figuring out like, why exactly are you doing the survey? What are you trying to find out? And once you kind of, I guess, tailor down exactly what you're trying to learn or what you're trying to achieve, that can sort of help you figure out who you need to actually reach out to and what demographic or audience. You need to build that survey for.
Tony MartignettiOkay, so like starting with your goals. What's the purpose of the darn thing?
Crystal MahonYes.
Tony MartignettiOkay, okay. Christian, you want to jump in around, you know, starting to get this process started?
Christian RobillardYeah, absolutely. And I think as Crystal and I were kind of building this piece out, whether you're talking about more of a philanthropic focus for your surveying or whether you're talking about more of a corporate kind of sponsorship focus of it. You ultimately want to ask yourself a number of different questions before you even get going. Things around what do you ultimately want to know about your donor base or about this particular audience population that you're ultimately looking for more information on? Why are you doing this in the first place? Is this more responsive? Is it more of a proactive type survey to explore new avenues? What do you ultimately need to know? I think that's an important element to focus on is not asking everything, but asking the right things. Who do you need to ask? So who is the actual population that you're targeting at the end of the day? What will you do with the information? So don't just collect information for information's sake, not that that's not important, but what's the actual actionable pieces for that? And how are you going to protect that information? I think with today's sensitivities around data privacy, it's really important for charities and nonprofits to steward that data as they would any type of gift that they ultimately get.
Tony MartignettiYeah, in terms of the data stewardship, That, that might constrain what you ask as well, because now you have conceivably a higher level of security that you need to maintain.
Christian RobillardAbsolutely, Tony. And even just in terms of sensitivities of phrasing certain questions, I think it's important for you to think about how you phrase certain things and how intimate you're ultimately getting. And if you do get that intimate, like you said, how do you protect that data? But also, what's the purpose for collecting that particular piece of data aside from Well, it might be a nice-to-have someday instead of this actually contributes towards our bottom line.
Tony MartignettiNow you're doing surveys around corporate sponsorship, right? That's the example you mentioned. So you're getting to know where people work so that you might use that information for potential sponsorships?
Christian RobillardYeah, I mean, when you look at sponsorship, ultimately it's very much a business transaction. If you look at how Forbes defines sponsorship, it's very much the cash and/or in-kind paid to a property, a property being whether it's a charitable run, or some type of event, or a conference in this case, in return for access to the exploitable commercial potential associated with that property. So when you think of any other type of exploitable commercial potential, which is the most buzzworthy definition you possibly could—
Tony MartignettiRight, right.
Christian RobillardIf you think of any type of advertising medium, whether it's TV, radio, print, you want to know ultimately who's in your audience, and one of the best and most effective ways to do that is to conduct some type of survey to really tease out who are some of your very specific or niche audiences. In Canada, we say niche, so it's a bit of a cringe for us up here in the north.
Tony MartignettiRight.
Christian RobillardBut having a survey to really tease out who's in your audience and some of the more behavioural, psychographic, demographic features of that audience are particularly important to have to really make a compelling case to corporations looking to use sponsorship. with your organization.
Tony MartignettiOkay. What format are you using, Christian? And Crystal, I'm going to ask you the same thing shortly. How are these offered to people?
Christian RobillardYeah, so we— so in the experiences I've had, we usually use a SurveyMonkey survey of some kind that allows for a lot of crosstab analysis, so being able to say that people who are in between the ages of 18 and 29 have this particular set of income, they have these particular purchase patterns, They care about your cause to nth degree. They are engaged with your cause or with your property, whether it's through social media or through certain print advertisements or whatever that might be. And we usually collect around 30+ data points on all of those elements ranging from, again, the behavioral to the demographic to psychographic to some very pointed specific questions around the relationship between your cause and the affinity for a certain corporation based on that caring for that cause. Okay.
Tony MartignettiYeah, so you said collecting around 30 data points. Does that, does that mean a survey would have that many questions?
Christian RobillardAbsolutely.
Tony MartignettiOkay, now I've heard from guests in the past, may have even been NTC guests, not this year, but that, you know, the optimal number of questions for a survey is like 5 or 6 or so, and people bail out beyond that point.
Christian RobillardYeah, and, and usually before I had actually sent out a survey of that magnitude, I would agree with you, Tony, and I would agree with most. I think the important differentiators, one is that you frame it as it's very much for improving the relationships and the ability for the cause properties, whether that's your run, your gala, whatever that might be, to raise money. And usually the audience that you're sending that to is very receptive to that. I think you want to frame it also as you're only collecting the most important information. And you're also looking at, again, like you're incentivizing it in some way, shape, or form. So usually when you tailor it with some type of incentive, be it a $50 gift card opportunity to win something Like that, usually people are a lot more receptive. And in the time that we've done surveys, whether it's in my past days consulting in this space, or now doing a lot of work with charities and nonprofits, we've sent it to tens of thousands of respondents, and we get a pretty strong response rate, and a really nominal, if negligible, amount of an unsubscribe rate. So people are not unsubscribing from getting those questions, and in fact, they're answering a lot of them. And an important element as well is making them optional. So not forcing people to have to fill out certain pieces, but Giving them the freedom to answer whichever questions they feel compelled to. But when you're doing it for the cause, people are pretty compelled to respond to those types of questions.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Crystal, how about you? What format are your surveys offered in?
Crystal MahonWe do both offline and online. So our donor base tends to skew a little bit older. So for us, a physical mailing is absolutely mandatory because a lot of our donors respond that way. But we do also produce an online version for, I guess, other parts of our donor base that are in a different demographic or just based on that person's preference, just giving them that opportunity. But what we did find is that in terms of our offline responses, we had a lower response rate in terms of responses to the survey, but exponentially more donations coming through offline as opposed to online. And then for online responses, so the online survey, we had a lot more responses to the online survey, but far fewer donations. So we found that there was an inverse relationship there, and I thought that was very interesting.
Kate MartignettiIt's time for a break. Are you looking to maximize your fundraising efforts and impact this giving season? DonorBox's online donation platform is designed to help you reach your fundraising goals. From customizable donation forms to far-reaching EasyShare crowdfunding and peer-to-peer options, plus seamless in-person giving with DonorBox Live Kiosk. DonorBox makes giving simple and fast for your donors and moves the needle on your mission. Visit donorbox.org and let DonorBox help you help others. Now back to donor surveys.
Tony MartignettiDo you subscribe to the same opinion about the length, that there can be up to 30 questions in a survey, as Christian was saying?
Crystal MahonWe personally haven't practiced that. We usually keep ours between 5 and 10 questions, and sometimes we even tailor it if we know that somebody is interested in particular programs. We might take out a certain question and put in something else related specifically to them. So there is some variability in the surveys, but generally we keep them quite short. But I do agree with Christian for sure in terms of really framing the purpose of the survey and each of the questions around— this is the whole purpose of this, is to build our relationship with them and to better serve them and to get to know them better. And I think that really makes a huge difference. And then we also do the incentivizing Approach as well, so I think that also inspires people too.
Tony MartignettiAh, I was just gonna ask about incentivizing. Okay, something similar like a drawing for a gift card, something like that?
Crystal MahonYeah, we give a STARS prize pack because we wanted to do something that would be specific where they couldn't get something that they could get elsewhere. So yeah, we, we have STARS merchandise, so that's one of our prize packs for sure.
Tony MartignettiOkay, I'm gonna thank Christian for not having a good, uh, a good video, uh, appearance because this video I've done 10 of these today, and they're all going to be— all the videos are going to be preserved except this one because Christian has a very extreme background. He's really just like a silhouette. It's a head with headphones is really about all I can see. But I'm grateful because my background just fell. I have a little Tony— I have a Tony Martignetti— if you watch other of these videos, which are going to be available, there's a Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio Sort of easel, you know, what's that, foam core, you know, sign. And it was behind me. It was, and it just fell while Crystal was talking. So thank you, Christian.
Christian RobillardI was just so surprised that you could ask 30 questions on a survey and get some type of degree of response.
Tony MartignettiTotally. So it shook my house that I'm—
Christian Robillard30 data points. What madness is this?
Tony MartignettiI'm so aghast at it. Yes. And then also the fact that the two of you disagree. All right. So, but I'm shouting myself, calling myself out as having a flimsy background. It lasted through, lasted through like 7 hours of this.
Christian RobillardI love it. I'll also say that we don't necessarily disagree, but I think different surveys serve their different purposes. So I agree with Crystal that in that particular case, you only need to send one that has 5 to 10 questions, whereas In this case, you're probably sending it to— in a sponsorship case, you're probably sending it to a larger population of people, and you only need a certain amount of people to fill it out.
Tony MartignettiSo, Crystal, I had asked you, and you probably answered, but I got distracted by my collapsing background. What kinds of incentives do you offer?
Crystal MahonWe offer STARS prize packs, so it's STARS merchandise. So we wanted to offer something a little bit different other than like a gift card that they could get through any other kind of
Tony MartignettiYeah,
Crystal Mahonall right. So that's a different angle for us.
Tony MartignettiYeah, personalized to STARS. Okay, gotcha. Okay, now was yours specifically a planned giving survey, or did you just have a couple of planned giving questions and that's where you discovered this data goldmine of future gifts and all the wills that you found out that you're in? Was it—
Crystal MahonYeah,
Tony Martignettiit
Crystal Mahonwas not specific to planned giving, so it was more just a general survey And then we did have a question about planned giving, and then we were stunned by the response that we saw. Yeah. In subsequent years, we kept asking that, and right now we're sort of in the middle of doing a whole planned giving strategy and trying to really build that out now that we know that there is this whole core of people that are interested in this and that our donors are open to it. So it's really opened up a lot of opportunities for us as an organization overall.
Tony MartignettiYeah, interesting. Okay. All right. So you've learned from the first time. This is— you're in a lot more states than you had any idea.
Crystal MahonLately.
Tony MartignettiYeah. Let's talk about some more good practices for surveys. Crystal, is there something you can— one or two things you want to recommend? And then we'll come to— go back to Christian.
Crystal MahonYeah, one of my major things is that if you're going to ask a question, you have to know what you're going to do with that data after. Like, a pet peeve of mine is where people just ask a question to ask a question for whatever reason, but then they don't action anything out of it. Like, to me, it's very important that if our donors are going to spend the time to actually read through your survey and take the time to respond or mail it in or submit it online, that we actually do something with that information. So whether that's tailoring future messaging or changing their communication preferences or whatever it is that they're asking us to do or telling us, I think that's— Yeah. So important is that you have to have a follow-up plan in terms of once these responses come back in, what are we going to do with them? Who is going to take action? How are we going to resource this? How are we going to use this information?
Tony MartignettiI think of date of birth as a good example of that. If you're gonna, if you're gonna develop a plan to congratulate someone for their birth on their birthday each year, then that can be a valuable data point. But if you just, you know, if you're just asking because you, you know, you don't have a purpose, you're just interested in what their age is for some vague reason, then, then there's no, there's no value in asking. And if it's just a follow-up, if it's just to know their, you know, when you want to send a card, maybe you don't need the year. Maybe you just need the day and the month. But if there's value to your database for knowing their age, Then you would ask the year.
Crystal MahonExactly.
Tony MartignettiOkay.
Crystal MahonHelps you filter down to what do we need to know and why are we asking these questions. Why? What is the purpose?
Tony MartignettiChristian, you have a best practice you want to share?
Christian RobillardYeah, I would say consider the— not just the population size that you're— or not just the population that you're serving, but also the representative makeup. So if you know that your database is predominantly on more of the senior side of things, but you're getting a disproportionate amount of more individuals who are on the younger side of things in terms of respondents, that's something important that you have to take into account. So the makeup of the actual population is more important, I would argue, than the amount of responses. You could get a crazy amount of responses, but if it doesn't represent the population that you're serving and that who make up your donors, it's not going to be valuable data to you. I remember one time we had an instance where an organization wanted to do I want to do a survey for sponsorship purposes, and in other cases it's been for more donor-specific, like, oh, we'll just put it out on Facebook or Twitter or something like that. It's not necessarily your population, it's not necessarily the group that you're looking— that you're actively engaged with in a fundraising perspective. You get information to the otherwise, and then obviously reflect on that and use that, but be really clear about the breakdown that you need to have in order to make the information actually representative. What
Tony Martignettikinds of response rates, like what's a decent response rate to a survey?
Christian RobillardI think it depends what type of survey you're sending. I'll let Crystal speak to this more, but I'd say if it's philanthropic, it can vary. On the sponsorship side of things, you're looking for a response rate that coincides with a 95% confidence interval with a 5% margin of error. That's good market data. If you're sending out a survey to your donor base, you're looking for a response rate that's To calculate that, there's a bunch of big complicated formulas that we probably have all repressed from our time in statistics in university. Statistics. There's a company called SurveyMonkey that actually has a calculator for it. So if you go to the SurveyMonkey website, you can actually just plug in what the sample size or what the actual size of the database you're sending it to, and you can plug in what confidence interval that you want and then what margin of error that you'd like, and it'll pump out a number of a minimum that you need to have. I would say that's a good starting point. But again, as I talked about before, make sure you have the representative breakup— breakdown of who's actually within your audience reflected in the survey results and don't have it disproportionately skewed towards a particular demographic that might be just more inclined to respond to surveys.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Okay. Crystal, anything you want to add about the confidence It's different, but, but yeah, I withdraw that. That doesn't make sense for you because you're doing individual philanthropic surveys, so each response you get is valuable. You find out that someone is interested in planned giving or already has you in their will, that one response has, has great value.
Crystal MahonYes.
Tony MartignettiOkay,
Crystal Mahonthe purpose of our survey is a little bit different, so we don't worry so much about that, but I completely echo In terms of actually needing to calculate that and being mindful of who you're actually reaching out to with your survey to make sure that they're representative of the group that you're trying to question
Tony Martignettior survey. What kind of response rate do you shoot for though, Crystal? Because still, you know, these things take time and you're doing— some of them are offline, so there's postage and printing, etc. What kind of response rate do you consider Good for, for an effort like that.
Crystal MahonIn terms of a financial response rate, so what I would clarify is that for us, a response to the survey doesn't necessarily mean a gift, and a gift to the survey doesn't necessarily mean that they've responded to the survey. So in terms of actually number of gifts, we usually aim for between 6% and 10%. But in terms of actual response to the survey, we've seen as low as a 2%, but then as high as 7% depending on the year or the channel. So either way, like, we have— we're quite lucky, we have quite a large database. So any of these bands could be 50,000 people or more. So even 2% gives us a pretty decent sample and gives us a lot of work to do and a lot of information to build off of.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Okay. For your online surveys, Crystal, are you using SurveyMonkey also, did you say?
Crystal MahonI've used a couple. We used SurveyMonkey last year. It is very user-friendly. What I would caution people on is to always read the fine print about whatever price package they're signed up for, because like we discussed for our surveys, a big focus is the financial return on it. So we needed to pick a price plan that involved being able to redirect right from the SurveyMonkey page to our donation form. So you have to be really mindful of things like that. So In some of the basic packages, they don't allow you to redirect to a donation form, and that if you can't do that, that'll really negatively impact your financial return or the number of donations you're going to receive in.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Is there another online tool that you like also?
Crystal MahonI used a platform called Responster. I believe they're based out of Sweden or somewhere in Europe, and they were very good, to be honest. So there are some limitations as well with them in terms of what they're packages offer, but right now we're using SurveyMonkey and that's what we're sending out our, like, for example, like event surveys we're sending out through SurveyMonkey or any of our stewardship-based ones. So that's what we're using actively.
Tony MartignettiOkay. How about you, Christian? Is there another one besides SurveyMonkey that you could recommend?
Christian RobillardI think it just depends on what you're looking for, Tony. So if you're looking for a lot of, let's say, more qualitative answers, I'd say even a Google Form would be more than acceptable. It really just depends on what functionality you want to get out of. I use SurveyMonkey pretty religiously just because it's, like Crystal said, it's very user-friendly. It has the functionality that I need, and it's relatively reasonable in terms of price point for what you get. It's ultimately going to depend, and it's up to you to do due diligence on what types of functionality you need. Do you need it to integrate with your database versus other software? Do you need certain functionality? Do you actually know how to use a lot of those things? Is there going to be support? And again, like, what, what are they going to do with your data? Like, do they have access to your data, whether it's metadata or otherwise? Are there other rules or jurisdictions you have to consider with that data privacy? So I use SurveyMonkey, but lots of considerations to make.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Okay. Thank you. And so, Christian, why don't you, why don't you lead us out with some— take us out with some, I guess, motivation, closing thoughts? What would you like to end with?
Christian RobillardAbsolutely. I would say from a sponsorship perspective, whether you're a large organization or small organization, the riches are in the niches. So to do good sponsorship, it requires good data, and it requires those 30+ data points. But whether you're a big group or a small group, you can compete at the same scale, especially with the amount of money that's being spent on cause sponsorship, over $2 billion worldwide, which is no small amount of money that you can get access to, whether you're a $100,000 a year org or $1 million plus requires good data. So make sure you're collecting good data, make sure you're clear on what you want to use your information for, and yeah, just be diligent in making sure that the data is actually protected.
Tony MartignettiOkay, I was, I was, I was gonna let Christian end, but since the two of you have such divergent purposes, which is fabulous for It's great for a discussion. Divergent purposes around your surveys. Crystal, why don't you take us out on the philanthropic, the individual donor side?
Crystal MahonYeah, absolutely. So like we were discussing, don't be afraid to fundraise. Like, just because it's a survey doesn't mean that you can't make money off of it. If people are supporting you enough that they're willing to fill out a survey and respond to you, they may be willing to donate as well. And then on top of that, like I said, be You have to know why you're asking these questions and what you're going to do with that information after. It's really important in terms of respecting your donor's time and the fact that they're giving you this information. You need to be able to use it and store it properly and safely. And then lastly, I'd just say please, please, please test your survey before you actually send it out. Send it out to people in other departments or other people that are not in the midst of building the survey so that you can find out That you phrase things appropriately, you're actually learning what you want to, or that the functionality is appropriate. I think that's just so important because you only have one chance at sending it out, so just make sure that it works appropriately.
Tony MartignettiOkay, excellent. Thank you very much. That's Crystal Mahon, Manager of Annual Giving at STARS Air Ambulance, and with her is Christian Robillard, founder and chief podcaster at Beyond The Bake Sale. Crystal's in Alberta. And I'm sorry, Crystal. Did I just say Crystal? Yeah, I know. Crystal. Did I say Crystal or Christian? Crystal. Crystal, I know, is in Alberta.
Christian RobillardWe don't make it easy on you, Tony.
Tony MartignettiAnd I got through 25 minutes so well, and now it's a lackluster host. I'm sorry. This is who you're stuck with. Christian is in the capital city of Ottawa. Thank you so much, Christian, Crystal. Thank you very much.
Christian RobillardThanks, Tony.
Crystal MahonThanks, Tony.
Kate MartignettiIt's time for Tony's Take Two.
Tony MartignettiThank you, Kate. Happy Thanksgiving, a week late. Can you believe that your lackluster host forgot that last week's show should have included Happy Thanksgiving? We were doing the show the week before. And it never occurred to me. And I would say parenthetically, it did not occur to our associate producer either. That's the end of that parenthetical. I've always wanted to have an intern so I could have somebody to blame. You've heard me say it. Give me an intern. I need somebody to blame, but just leave it right there. I have to wish you Happy Thanksgiving a week late. I hope you enjoyed past tense. Hope you enjoyed your Thanksgiving last week. That's the best I can do on Tony's Take Two. There's a nice little, uh, whimsical little rhyme. That is Tony's Take Two. Kate?
Kate MartignettiWell, um, thank you for putting it on me, but, uh, we all know that it was your mistake, and it's okay. We forgive you. Tony, for forgetting Thanksgiving.
Tony MartignettiYeah. All right. I'm not sure that you're quite gonna get away with that. It wasn't on you. I put it in parentheses.
Kate MartignettiIn parentheses? Oh, I need an intern so I can blame them on everything.
Tony MartignettiYeah, well, you're not an intern. You're the associate producer. I put you in parentheses. I put the blame statement in parentheses. I thought that would be good. All right, let's go.
Kate MartignettiWell, we've got beaucoup but loads more time. Here is People-Powered Movements.
Tony MartignettiMy guests now are Celina Stewart and Gloria Pan. Celina is Senior Director of Advocacy and Litigation at League of Women Voters U.S., and Gloria is Vice President for Member Engagement at MomsRising. Celina, Gloria, welcome.
Crystal MahonHello.
Tony MartignettiI'm glad we were able to put this together virtually. It's good to see both of you. And I'm glad to know that you're each well and safe and in either D.C. or just outside D.C. Celina, you're in D.C. And Gloria, where are you outside Washington, Gloria?
Gloria PanI am actually near Dulles Airport. You know, some people commute from here, but because MomsRising is a virtual organization, I don't. And so when people ask me for lunch, I'm always like, okay, it takes a little bit more planning. I have to bend my mind about it. I have to get my body into D.C.
Tony MartignettiInto D.C., okay. Your NTC topic is A Revolution Is Coming: Top Tactics to Build People-Powered Movements. Celina, would you get us started with this? What, what was the need for the session?
Celina StewartWell, I think, I think one of the things is right now it's all about people power. You know, there's— everything is so politicized right now, and I think that there is often a conversation about how people are involved in what, what government actually represents or what the government is representing. So I think that that's really, really important. We also saw, like, in 2018, more voter turnout, more voters turning out to vote and things like that. So I think that that also is part of this people conversation, like, what is compelling people to participate even more or at a greater extent in their democracy? But all of these things kind of work together to figure out not only do we have people engaged now, but what is important? Right. What does community, as more people become engaged, how does our definition of our community and communities in general change as more people are included and participate in all of those things? So I think that we're at a very interesting and crucial moment in time. And so people-powered and people-involved movement, I think it's always happened, but it's just a coined phrase, I think.
Crystal MahonI think that's especially prevalent right now.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Gloria, even though participation is very high, we're also largely polarized. So how do we overcome the opposite ends of the spectrum to try to bring people together and organize?
Gloria PanAre you talking about everyone, or are you talking about voters?
Tony MartignettiWell, I'm talking about the country. I don't know whether people are voting, but I'm talking about our political polarization. I don't know if they're necessarily voting. They act like they are.
Celina StewartI talked about voting, so I probably threw it off a little bit, Gloria.
Tony MartignettiThey act like they are.
Gloria PanI'm asking for clarification only because, like, some of the most talented and I think unifying politicians in recent memory, for example, Barack Obama, Did not succeed in unifying all of us, right? So there are some segments of our citizenry that will just not do it. We will not be able to come together with them. But I think that for people who really do want the best for our country and who are open-minded enough to want to hear from other people who have different You know, slightly different ways of looking at the world. It is possible to do it. And that goes back to what Celina was saying about people-powered movements. I think that one of the reasons why that's become more and more of a catchphrase is that, you know, we are in an era of information overload. We are in an era of polarization and not believing everything that we're seeing. Right. on the internet and in the news. And so being able to actually really connect with people on the ground, in person, over the phone, but directly and not going through the filter of social media or news movements, is— it's increasingly important. And that will be one of the main channels for us to unify as many people as possible.
Tony MartignettiSo we're talking about creating these both online and offline, right? People-powered, people-centered movements. How, Gloria, how do we want nonprofits to think about, or what do we need to think about in terms of doing this organizing, creating these, these movements?
Gloria PanFirst of all, it's about Inclusivity. Okay, so at least from where we sit, MomsRising and me speaking on behalf of MomsRising right now, we want to make sure that whatever we do benefits the most people and harms no one at all if possible. Got it. So that's one part of it, how we speak, how we communicate, to make sure that what we're speaking and how we communicate does not reinforce bad stereotypes that creates divisions. Okay, that's one way. Another way— not way, but another thing to consider are also the tools that we're using. Are we using— you know, people are on different kinds of communication tools. Some people only do Facebook, other people only do email, and there are also like text messaging. There are all of these new communication tools coming on, and being on top of the different tools is super important because we need to meet people where they are. Those are just a couple of thoughts.
Tony MartignettiOkay. So, Celina, so we're talking about diversity, equity, inclusion. Let's drill down into a little bit of like, what do we need to do around our communications that is more equitable and non-harming?
Celina StewartSo I think that's an important question, and that's definitely something that has been centered in the League's work over the last, I would say, 5 years, but more intentionally over the last 2.
Tony MartignettiI'm sorry, I mean, who's— I'm sorry, whose work?
Celina StewartThe League. I'm sorry, I always refer to it—
Tony MartignettiThe League of Women Voters? Okay, the League of Women Voters U.S. Okay, the League's work.
Celina StewartYeah, so at the League. Sorry, folks, our full title is just too long for me to keep saying, so I just
Tony MartignettiI got you
Celina Stewartnow. So DEI is very, very important for us. You know, our organization has historically been older white women. We've always had members of color, but I don't know that they were always at the forefront. So for us, our work is really centered in 2 questions in everything that we're doing: who's at the table and who should be at the table? Who's missing? So I think starting all of our conversations, any efforts that we're doing with those 2 questions allows us to center our work in diversity, equity, inclusion, and also use our power as people who have had access to legislators, stakeholders, etc. How do we use our power in a way that allows access and inclusivity for more people? Yeah. So I think that that is really important and something that— DEI, diversity, equity, inclusion work is hard. Let me just say first, it's not easy. You know, it gets very uncomfortable a lot of times when you're talking about privilege, patriarchy, and all of that. Talk about as it relates to DEI, but it's so important to get comfortable in being uncomfortable and having these conversations. The only way I think that we can start to build a bridge towards unifying communities. Because at the end of the day, we may be politically— but at the end of the day, we all share many of the very same values which has historically united this country. Like right now, we're in the midst of the coronavirus. The coronavirus doesn't care whether you're Republican, Democrat, Black, white, female, male. It doesn't matter. At the end of the day, we all have to make sure that we're doing what we can to be safe as individuals, but also our actions greatly impact the people around us. So it's more of a— it's more of a community mindset that's required in order to tack this down. So I know that that's like a little offset, offshoot from what we're talking about, but I think it all plays together in some way, shape, or form.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Gloria, how about for MomsRising? I mean, how do you ensure that you're Communications are equitable and non-harmful?
Gloria PanWell, MomsRising has very intentionally built an organization that tries to bring different voices to the table. We are intersectional and we are multi-issue. And so from our staff, we're very diverse in many, many different ways. And from the way that we choose which issues to work on, we also take into consideration which communities are being impacted and how we communicate about those. And then the way that we campaign is that our campaigns always overlap. And so there are different people within the organization as well as the policy partners from different issue areas. They help us vet our issues and the way that we communicate with them. To make sure that you know there are we're not communicating in a way that that that excludes communities reinforces bad stereotypes and raises red flags makes make make people feel bad in ways that we don't understand because of where we individuals as campaigners know. So everything we do is very thoroughly vetted through many different filters.
Tony MartignettiOkay, so vetting. Yeah, all right, so please. Yeah, Celina.
Celina StewartI totally agree with, um, what Gloria said, and I think that's really important because the League is also multi-issue and kind of has that— you have to compete when you have multiple issues. You sometimes have to think a little differently about how you present yourself on each issue in order to not negatively impact the whole set of what you're trying to accomplish. And so for us in the communication space, expressly is thinking about whether it's appropriate— who's the appropriate messenger when we're communicating? So is it appropriate for the League to be a leader in this space, or do we need to take a step back and be a supporter? So I think that's one of the things that's very important for us communication-wise, is we're figuring out what is— what space are we going to take up in the communication space and how we're going to communicate this issue. And then the other piece is Who's talking? Who is the person that we're putting in front to actually speak about a particular issue? And is, is that the right person? And are they speaking from the lens that's most appropriate for that particular issue? That's going to be impacted most as a result of what you're saying or doing. So I think that's very important what Gloria lifted up.
Tony MartignettiHow do you manage the conflicting issues? If, you know, I guess it's— I guess there are issues where you have a large constituency on one side of one issue, but something else may seem contrary to that, to that large constituency, a different issue that you're taking a stand on. Is that— is that my understanding right when you say, you know, potential issue conflict?
Celina StewartYeah, well, when you have 500,000 members, Supporters and you're in every congressional district, everybody's not going to agree on, on how to approach an issue. But I think what grounds the League is our mission. Our mission is to empower voters and defend democracy, empower people, defend democracy. So I think as long as you stay rooted in what your mission values statement is, then you can find some reconciliation across, you know, the most seemingly divergent issues.
Tony MartignettiOkay, climate change, I think, would probably be a good example. I was just—
Gloria PanI was gonna add, okay, that just to step back a little bit, the one thing that I am super, super proud of is that at least for progressives, I think that we're actually pretty consistent in about our agreement on issues. We may have different levels of intensity in what we agree with, but I think that there are very few conflicts. We may not agree on how to get somewhere, but we all agree on where we want to go. Okay, so in that way, I rather feel, at least from MomsRising standpoint, we rarely get— I can't even think of a single instance where we have conflicts because we are not agreeing with each other or with policy partners on the most important thing, where we're heading.
Celina StewartSo I think that's a difference because our— the League is, is not left or right leaning. We're kind of in
Gloria Panthe
Celina Stewartcenter. We have members who are both conservative and liberal.
Gloria PanYeah.
Celina StewartHave some of that conflict more in that, but I think you're absolutely right. Do we all want the same things and a healthier, more vibrant democracy? Absolutely. So you have to find some common ground in that space, but we definitely have members who are who want to handle things one way versus the other. We have to find common ground.
Tony MartignettiYeah, that's the challenge I was trying to get at. Yeah, okay. It helps, at least it helps me to think of an example like climate change. You know, some, there are some people who don't even believe that it's, it's human impacted. And there are others who think we're decades behind and in our inaction to, to reverse the effects of Human-induced climate change. So it's a— that's, that's quite a challenge, really, Celina. Okay, well, where else, where else should we go with these people-powered movement ideas? You, you, you, you two spend a lot more time studying this than I do. So what else should we be talking about that we haven't yet?
Gloria PanI would actually love to hear from Celina. How the League is dealing with doing your work remotely.
Celina StewartI know you guys are already virtual. This is like no sweat for you guys, right?
Gloria PanWell, you know, I mean, we do have, you know, our plans range from virtual all the way down to the grassroots, right? And I think especially for organizations like yours, Celina, we share the common goal this year of voter engagement. I am very sorry.
Celina StewartThis is real life.
Gloria PanI don't know what to do. It's like if I open the door, my kids might come in. I'm gonna let her out. I'm very sorry.
Tony MartignettiOkay. All right, Celina, in terms of remote working, but yeah, but how it relates to this topic of people power.
Celina StewartYeah, so I think that's really, really important, and we're definitely So it's one thing to convert to teleworking, right? That's one thing. But when your work is so much advocacy, and especially the leaders on the ground who are doing voter registration, which requires you to be on the ground talking to people, you know, that has shifted our work. So one of the examples that we have is we have our People-Powered Fair Maps campaign, which is basically trying to get redistricting reform For across the country in a positive way so that we don't have another situation like we had in North Carolina, where you're from, Tony, and also in Maryland. In Baltimore. We want to, we want to make sure that, you know, people are represented appropriately. But a lot of the states that we're working in, they have signature collection campaigns going on right now. So how do you do signature collection when you can't actually be within 3 or 6 feet of people? So now many of our Leagues are converting to digital signatures and going through their legislature to make those adjustments so that they can still collect signatures and meet that need, etc. Our lobby— we have a lobby corps, which is 21 volunteers that goes to the Hill every month. Obviously, with the Hill being also teleworking, it created what we thought might be a barrier, but now our lobbyists are doing virtual coffee meetings on Zoom just like this. And having those conversations with legislators, legislative staff, and all of those things. So I think that the coronavirus has forced us to do our work in a different way, but it's also been great to innovate and be creative and do the work that people love just in a different way. So we— it's not perfect. I don't even want to make you think that this is perfect because it's definitely not, but I think that there's a lot of positive energy about doing our work and finding ways to do our work in
Tony MartignettiWhich, okay, thinking creatively, you know, I, for our, for our listeners, and I don't want to focus just on MomsRising and League of Women Voters U.S., I want them to recognize how what we're talking about can be applied by them, how they, how they, what they need to go back to their CEOs or whatever, vice presidents, whoever, and What kind of like discussion items they need to be putting forward that the organization is not now thinking about, uh, in terms of, you know, again, people-powered— you say a revolution is coming. Um, yeah, you know, how, how, how can our listeners help create it?
Celina StewartI think just becoming involved. Like when you're talking about people-powered anything, it's really about base building. And for me, the goals of base building are always to grow a base of volunteers who have a shared value of some sort, and you're coming together in order to make some progressive movement on that. It's also about leadership development, communities and constituency who turn out, who are players in this issue or what have you, and then putting issues to the forefront. So I think that wherever you What is— what do you value? What's important to you? It could be as simple as, hey, there's a pothole on my street that hasn't been fixed in the last year. Can we come together as a community and really talk with our local election officials about making sure our streets are in a position that's not going to wreck our cars or have someone get endangered in some way? So I think it comes down to, as on an individual level, what is important to you? What do you value? And finding and connecting with those people who also value something similar. And what do you want to change? What is it that you're trying to change or that would make your life better? And who are the people who can support you in getting that done?
Tony MartignettiOkay, and that's consistent with what you said on an organizational level too. It's the same, you know, what are the core values? That's what, that's what drives all the work and brings people together, just finding that commonality around Whether it's the pothole in the street on the individual level or your—
Celina StewartOr your mom's, right? Whatever, whatever you're— whatever is important to you.
Tony MartignettiYeah, Gloria, what, what, what's your advice for how people can contribute to this revolution?
Gloria PanUm, I think that right now, um, we're all sitting in our homes and we're rethinking the way that we do our work. And even as individuals, um, we're rethinking the way that We are doing our activism. I think that a very important message right now for activists personally and for organizations that organize activists and try to recruit and build the base is that now is not the time to step away. Now, more important than ever, it is important to stay on top of the issues, to sign those petitions, to speak up, and to share your stories. Because I will give you a very, very specific example. Right now, Congress is Negotiating, arguing over all of these different critical needs in the coronavirus relief bills, right? Well, MomsRising has been on the forefront of trying to influence those negotiations, and the most powerful weapon we have are your stories, people's stories. What's going to happen to your childcare center that has to close down? What's going to happen to domestic workers who suddenly don't have a paycheck? Paid family leave. This is something— this is a signature MomsRising issue. We've been working on that forever, ever since our founding. It's one of our signature issues. But now, because of the stories that we have gathered and we are hearing from our members about the need for paid leave and the fact that if we had had paid leave all this time, the burden of coronavirus would have been much lighter, this is something that we are powerfully bringing to the negotiating table. And we're actually seeing movement on paid leave. Great. So all organizations and all individuals, whatever issues that you're working on, do not step away. Continue to share your stories because those stories have to be brought to the negotiating table for policy. And that's the only way we're going to get the policy that we need.
Tony MartignettiOkay, we're gonna leave it there. That's quite inspirational. Thank you. That's, that's Gloria Pan, Vice President of Member Engagement at MomsRising. And also Selena Stewart, Senior Director of Advocacy and Litigation at the League of Women Voters U.S. So Gloria, Selena, thank you very much. Thanks for sharing.
Celina StewartThank you, Tony.
Kate MartignettiNext week, the Thanksgiving show. If you missed any part of this week's show, I beseech you.
Tony MartignettiFind it at tonymartignetti.com.
Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by DonorBox. Outdated donation forms blocking your supporters' generosity this giving season? DonorBox, the fast, flexible, and friendly fundraising platform for nonprofits. donorbox.org. Our creative producer is Claire Meyerhoff. I'm your associate producer, Kate Martignetti. The show's Our social media is by Susan Chavez. Marc Silverman is our web guy, and this music is by Scott Stein.
Tony MartignettiThank you for that affirmation, Scotty. Be with us next week for Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. Go out and be great.
I love our sponsor!




