Your Website Performance


About this episode
The first of its kind, 2023 Nonprofit Website Performance Report reveals startlingly disappointing performance across nonprofit websites. RKD Group’s Charles Lehosit explains the shortcomings and how to make the advances needed, so your site’s vital signs improve.
My Guest
Here’s the transcript
Tony MartignettiHello and welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. I am your aptly named host and the podfather of your favorite hebdomadal podcast. Oh, I'm glad you're with us. I'd be thrown into crymodinia if you pained me with the idea that you missed this week's show. Here's our associate producer Kate with what's coming.
Kate MartignettiHey Tony, your website performance— the first of its kind 2023 Nonprofit Website Performance Report reveals startlingly disappointing performance across nonprofit websites. RKD Group's Charles Lehosit explains the shortcomings and how to make the advances needed so your site's vital signs improve on Tony's Take Two.
Tony MartignettiThank you.
Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by DonorBox. Outdated donation forms blocking your supporters' generosity this giving season? DonorBox, the fast, flexible, and friendly fundraising platform For nonprofits, donorbox.org. Here is your website performance.
Tony MartignettiIt's a pleasure to welcome Charles Lehosit to Nonprofit Radio. He has been described as an entrepreneur, solutions architect, strategist, technologist, and futurist. He's got a lot of people describing him. That's, uh, it's admirable just that you got that many people thinking about what you are. Cheers. As Vice President for Technology at RKD Group, Charles develops solutions that answer nonprofits' business needs. He's a leading expert in application development, email marketing, lead generation, mobile development, website development. We're gonna talk a lot about mobile versus website and artificial intelligence. He's on LinkedIn and the company is at RKDgroup.com. Welcome to Nonprofit Radio, Charles.
Charles LehositThanks, Tony. Nice being here. Nice to meet you.
Tony MartignettiI'm glad you are. I'm glad you are. Thank you. We are talking about the 2023 Nonprofit Website Performance Report. I'm sure you believe this report is important. We needed it, right? I'm not gonna ask you, you know, but what, what, why should we be paying attention to, uh, the speed with which websites load?
Charles LehositSo, um, 2 things. One, organic traffic is such an important source for, uh, traffic to your website and ultimately for your online revenue, right? There's probably no nonprofit on earth would like to say, yeah, I'm fine to give up some, not some organic traffic from search. And so because of organic search's critical role in that valuable traffic, a lot of nonprofits are paying for SEO to optimize their website. And so this is a critical component in that optimization. And it's something that nonprofits that are paying for SEO should doubly pay attention to because You know, the, it's very easy to wipe out your SEO investment if you are, you know, you pay for SEO and optimize a page. It's, it's not frozen in time as updates are made to that page, as updates are made to your site, you're making impacts that are impacting your, your Core Web Vitals. That's some jargon. And, and ultimately your, your page speed scores.
Tony MartignettiAll right. We got a few things there. Now, what's the jargon you said? You said it so fast, I didn't even catch it.
Charles LehositSo, uh, Google, Google has coined the term Core Web Vitals.
Tony MartignettiAnd Core Web Vitals.
Charles LehositYeah,
Tony MartignettiCWVs, of course. Yeah, it's common knowledge. Your CWVs, it's like EKG. You need an annual EKG. Uh, you, you gotta watch your CWVs.
Charles LehositExactly. A little bit, uh, more frequently than annually, but, um, not every day. Not every day. We do have some people that just obsess And I love you all that obsess over it. Just don't obsess over it every day. So Core Web Vitals describe the end user's experience with your website, and it's completely defined by Google. And if we think about, like, Google has a pattern of doing this, right? Google has told us over the years that security matters. And if you don't have an SSL certificate, if your website doesn't have HTTPS support in it, then that's gonna impact your ability to rank and be found in search results. If your website doesn't support mobile, then that's gonna impact your ability to be, to rank in search results.
Tony MartignettiI remember those being issues that we have to pay attention to mobile now because whatever it was, 85% of users are opening page websites, uh, on mobile. So now we have to be mobile optimized. That was like,
Charles Lehosityeah, that
Tony Martignettiwas like the, uh, there was a cry for a year or so, you know. Um, accessibility was another one.
Charles LehositExactly.
Tony MartignettiAccessibility is important. Um, and I remember the HTTPS too, the, uh, S. Oh, we all got to get an HTTPS. All right, this is the, this is the, uh, it's the, it's the, that's the banner call for the year now. We all got to be Secure sites. I remember these things.
Charles LehositExactly. So Google's definitely ratcheted up. Like, you know, think of like security is important. No one's going to argue against that. You know, mobile optimized is, is, you know, and accessibility is important. No one's going to argue against that. But you think of the stairway of complexity, and now it's almost like they're saying you've got to leap 3 or 4 steps on this next one because they've really combined, um, there's more than one metric in the Core Web Vitals. where security was really binary, right? Is you either have, you know, an SSL certificate or you don't. You are secure, you're not. And mobile optimized, you could argue, is the exact same way. And so Core Web Vitals are definitely more complex metrics for really all organizations.
Tony MartignettiAll right, so it's more technical. We're refining, I'm not sure, you know, Except to me, accessibility is a big thing. Security, very big thing. Mobile optimized, very big thing. I mean, these are important. I'm not saying, I'm not saying the report is frivolous, but I wouldn't have you on if I thought it was frivolous subject. You know, we, I'd be talking to someone else naturally. So, and so you would be too right now. So, so, Exactly. No, so I'm not saying that, but we're like, we're getting More degrees of refinement, some maybe more precise degrees of refinement of the, the, our internet experience.
Charles LehositExactly. Experience. Google is trying to define what a good user experience is. And that's so hard, right? And so what Google is trying to say is that a good user experience starts with How quickly does your content load? How quickly is the most amount of content available? And when your content is available, does it shift around? So when someone starts to read something on your page, does the content jump to another area and they have to go look for it like an Easter egg? And so that describes at a high level the Core Web Vitals. And Google is really trying to say, this is what This is what makes up a good user experience.
Tony MartignettiOkay. And just make explicit for us why Google gets this credibility. I mean, how much of search is still done on Google versus the alternatives?
Charles LehositYeah, like all of it. No, not all of it. Is
Tony Martignettiit like 99% and then 1% for Bing and You know, we're—
Charles LehositI think a lot of people in the search business are paying attention to AI agents and what they're possibly doing to Google's business. But the reality is that Google Search, Amazon Search, Bing Search, these are, these are, this is where people go to seek information, get questions answered still today. And so Google dominates that space. And so that allows them and has allowed them for years to dictate the terms to say, You know, hey, if you want, this is what you need to do to, you know, be found by Google's users, right? So what Google wants to do, what they want to avoid is for, for you, whenever you're searching for something and you go to a result that Google's put in front of you, they don't want you to go to that result and then have such a poor experience that you come right back and you then maybe give up on Google and go somewhere else. Go to Facebook or go, go somewhere else. And so Google is, is, you know, letting people know by these metrics, the folks that are, that have better Core Web Vitals, that have better, they're performing better, they will outrank you if it's one for one, you know, if you have the same similar content and you think about like cancer research. So similar content, similar like health-related articles. The article that has better Core Web Vitals is going to— should outrank the other.
Tony MartignettiOkay. All right. Thank you. Just want to make this— make it explicit why this is important. And clearly, there's some Google self-interest too. They don't want people to get results that they're not satisfied with. Because, you know, that'll hurt their own Ranking, their own, their own experience, uh, people's experience with them, I should say.
Charles LehositYeah, they have to provide value so they can provide more advertising.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Yes, we're very concerned about their, their bottom line. All right. So these core web values, is that what, is that the, uh, the, the multiple factors that are measured, uh, in the, in the report? These are the core web values?
Charles LehositThat's absolutely right.
Tony MartignettiLike overall. Okay. So cool. Let's start with Just following your report. Let's, let's first tell folks, because I may forget later. So you have a lackluster host. I'm sorry about that. I may forget later to tell folks where to get the report. So where can they get the full report?
Charles LehositOh gosh. So,
Tony Martignettiwell, it's at the rkdgroup.com. I know that.
Charles LehositThis is our 2023 nonprofit website performance report. And if you Google nonprofit website performance report, we will be the first result. And I certainly hope—
Tony MartignettiI certainly hope so.
Charles LehositWe also have a blog post that I wrote called Website Performance Matters and You're Probably Failing at It. Very cheeky there. Sorry. And that links to this research, which is, you know, freely available for everyone.
Tony MartignettiRight. And the research also links to the blog post. We're gonna talk about both. Because the blog post has the, the what to do about the poor performance that you are, that odds are you are experiencing. All right. So it just gave away a little bit, but let's get into the details of the first core value. No, vital core value, core web vitals. They are like vital signs, right? Your blood, you have to measure your, your oxygen saturation, your blood pressure, your heart rate. And your overall performance of your website.
Charles LehositExactly.
Tony MartignettiWhat is, what is overall performance?
Charles LehositSo it's a cumulative score that's based off of a lot of jargon. So let's, let's, let's mention the jargon names and then we can unpack those. But the cumulative score is based off of First Contentful Paint. That's 10% of your score. Speed Index, that's another 10% of your score. Largest Contentful Paint, that's 25% of your score. Total Blocking Time, that's 30% of your score. And then Cumulative Layout Shift, that's 25% of your score. Hopefully that answers the question.
Tony MartignettiWe are gonna, we're gonna talk about some of these, the, the content, especially the Contentful, uh, ones. Yeah. The first, the largest, we're gonna, we're gonna break these down. So not to worry. Uh, Charles is not in jargon jail because, uh, We're gonna— we are gonna define these and talk about them.
Kate MartignettiIt's time for a break. Are you looking to maximize your fundraising efforts and impact this giving season? DonorBox's online donation platform is designed to help you reach your fundraising goals, from customizable donation forms to far-reaching, easy-share crowdfunding and peer-to-peer options. Plus, Seamless in-person giving with DonorBox Live Kiosks. DonorBox makes giving simple and fast for your donors and moves the needle on your mission. Visit donorbox.org and let DonorBox help you help others. Now back to your website performance.
Tony MartignettiSo overall performance is a, is a an amalgam of the factor, the vitals that you just mentioned. I love this. Vital signs, you know, it's the health, it's the health of your, you know, just like the health of your body is based on your weight and body mass index and like blood pressure, etc. The vital signs of your website. All right.
Charles LehositSame thing.
Tony MartignettiOverall performance. I'll leave the headline for you. How are we doing overall performance?
Charles LehositSo overall performance, you know, 80% of nonprofits are failing at their Core Web Vitals. And I think many are— many more are paying attention this year than ever before. But I think many are still— this is an area that's new to them and where they need some help with awareness and education here. And, you know, to kind of develop like new habits, new good habits, as you mentioned. How do you keep your healthy body, your body healthy? You know, the same, same kind of starts to apply to your website when it comes to adding, adding new content. What are you eating? What are you putting into your website? Well, is that new image optimized for the web or is it, you know, a giant 5-megabyte file? That type of thing.
Tony MartignettiOkay. And now for each of these vital signs, they're evaluated in mobile. You evaluated them. You're You— did you do the study or did you just, uh, were you actually doing the— there were 2,000 websites that you evaluated. Did you actually do the work? Did you actually do the work, put the— put them in?
Charles LehositUh, both. Um, I came up with the, the concept and, um, I do a lot of this work, uh, for individual, uh, nonprofits like our, our clients at RKD. And so, um, you know, we Started with, I think, a list of 3,000 nonprofits, and that got whittled down a bit. But we had a really good representation of the industry and the different sectors within our industry. And so absolutely, I was part of this study. Okay. And you're right, there is a desktop version of these scores and a mobile version of these scores. If you're paying attention, you know your desktop scores are a lot more forgiving. They're probably a lot better than your mobile scores, and your mobile scores, you probably wish, uh, you could ignore those. But
Tony Martignettiwhy? Yeah, we're going to talk about each of these factors, as I said. But why is it that overall mobile, uh, performance on, on mobile devices is much poorer than on desktop devices? Why is that?
Charles LehositSo it is primarily the amount of content that we're putting into our pages, right? And so think of anyone's homepage, and there's almost no end to what people feel like I need to— this is the front page of our online experience, of our user experience. And so there's so much there. Yeah. And we often want it to be interactive. And so maybe we want video to it. And so video on desktop is more forgiving because most people have broadband connection. Video on mobile, you know, Google will judge you over like a 4G connection. And, and so it's less forgiving to have all of this like really heavy interactive experiences and content. on mobile. And so I think that's a good spot to say, like, achieving 100 isn't the end goal here. You know, we want to have positive scores, we want to have good scores so that we rank well. But sacrificing what you need to communicate a message shouldn't be the goal. Meaning like, here is a a dark page with light text. Here's a light page with dark text and that's it. Like, that's, we're not, no one's arguing that we'd go there to that extreme, although that would, you would score really well.
Tony MartignettiWell, that was, yeah, but that was back in dial-up and DSL days when before we had images and everything was text and page load speeds were like 30 seconds.
Charles LehositYeah. And so, and some of the mobile scores are still impacted by that, like a 4G connection time. And so we know that's not everyone on mobile. And so we just have to be aware of that's part of how Google is kind of ranking and judging our mobile scores.
Tony MartignettiAnd the report breaks it down by sector. You have Probably 8 or so sectors for each of these vital signs. We're not going to go into them. Folks can get that kind of detail if it's arts and culture versus education, et cetera, versus human services, et cetera. But we're doing poorly in mobile. I mean, the percentage of— Across the board. Yeah, across the board, right? It doesn't matter what your sector. The percentages of pages that either failed or were poor or needed improvement is very much higher than the ones that were rated good.
Charles LehositYeah, unfortunately.
Tony MartignettiOn mobile. On mobile. On mobile.
Charles LehositYeah, very true.
Tony MartignettiOkay. And desktop, much different desktop scores. Much better across all sectors.
Charles LehositIt does. And one of the reasons for that is Google doesn't put the same threshold of 4G on desktop like it does on mobile. And so it's easier to score higher on desktop. And part of the reason that is also, if we think about like, where do we often start when we're designing? So many are still starting from desktop and then thinking, well, this, all of this will just Kind of scale for mobile, but it's, it's still quite a bit for mobile there. And it's, it's why, you know, if we, we think about what might it take to score better in mobile, it's gonna probably take a lot more folks starting with a mobile design and scaling that up.
Tony MartignettiInteresting. Okay. Okay. Okay. So let's move to our, our next vital sign. First, First, I, I, the layman's term is first piece of content.
Charles LehositYeah, that's exactly right.
Tony MartignettiYeah, but you have a fancy, you have a fancy term. What was it?
Charles LehositSo first contentful paint, first contentful paint. It's a mouthful.
Tony MartignettiContentful or contentful? It's con— I guess it's gotta be contentful.
Charles LehositIt, it is. Uh,
Tony Martignettiit's not paint. First, first contentful paint.
Charles LehositExactly.
Tony MartignettiWhy don't they just call it first piece of content? Uh, what, you know, Why do these MIT engineers need to, need to complicate things? All right. It's the first piece of content that loads on your site, right?
Charles LehositExactly right.
Tony MartignettiSo it could be a text block or it could be an image or it could be, I don't know, your header or what, right? Any of those things could be first.
Charles LehositAnd so this is really, this metric measures the first point at which the user can see anything. Anything. And the first paint, a fast first paint should happen in, you know, 1.8 seconds or less, which today sounds reasonable. But, you know, we start adding doodads and video, and we start looking at maybe a 3-second first paint, and then all of a sudden you've got a lower score.
Tony MartignettiRight, over 3 was poor, isn't
Charles Lehositit? Exactly, exactly.
Tony MartignettiRight. So between 1.8 and 3 was needs improvement. And then over 3 was poor. Where did we get so attention-deficit that 3 seconds is a long time?
Charles LehositThat's it.
Tony MartignettiMaybe that's
Charles Lehosita— when did we— when did the goldfish beat us on our attention, on an attention span?
Tony MartignettiRight, right. That's a metaphysical question. Maybe more for a neuroscientist or something. So, but all right, so 3 seconds is poor for the first piece. And then we're not talking about the whole— we haven't gotten to the whole site yet. This is all the content. We're talking about the first piece, longer than 3 seconds, poor.
Charles LehositExactly.
Tony MartignettiAll right.
Charles LehositThe largest, the largest pain is probably a natural place to go next, right? So
Tony Martignettiyeah, I just want to, I just want to make clear that we're uniformly bad. First, first piece, uniformly bad on mobile, uniformly better at desktop.
Charles LehositYeah, it's so much easier to score better on desktop. Yeah. Right.
Tony MartignettiRight. Okay. Yeah. Largest, go ahead.
Charles LehositLargest paint will be the, the point at which the largest content is loaded. So that, that You know, maybe just dropping Contentful and just call it First Paint, Largest Paint in your head. And so Largest Paint would be when is the majority of your content available for your end user, your visitor, your prospective donor or supporter. And this is, you know, shockingly fast, right? This needs to be shockingly fast. You think about if a good score is 1.8 seconds or less for First Paint, A fast largest paint is still 2.5 seconds or less. And so it, it, the majority of your content cannot take too long to follow the first part of your content in Google's eyes.
Tony MartignettiRight. So still under, we're under 3 seconds.
Charles LehositYeah.
Tony Martignetti2.5 seconds.
Charles LehositYeah.
Tony MartignettiAll right.
Charles LehositYou know, there's a lot of studies in the e-commerce world that show that the cost of doing business if your e-commerce site, you know, if you could shave a second off of your e-commerce site, what that normally does to, uh, to, um, revenue and conversion rate. And we don't like to think of donors and, and nonprofit constituents in the same way, but they're the same people. The same people that are shopping on Amazon are on your website.
Tony MartignettiRight. Amazon and its ilk have raised the bar for For all websites.
Charles LehositExactly.
Tony MartignettiPeople expect that kind of seamless performance experience because they get it from Amazon. So they're ticked off when they don't get it from your nonprofit.
Charles LehositExactly.
Tony MartignettiWhich is not really fair. If Amazon can do it, why can't you? Well, okay, because Amazon has, I don't know, trillion-dollar research budgets and tens of thousands of engineers and you don't. But everybody's, let's face it, everybody's not that forgiving when they evaluate their experience with your nonprofit.
Charles LehositYeah.
Tony MartignettiI see that even especially among, I'm thinking about board members who have their own businesses. They're a lot more forgiving of their own businesses than they are of the nonprofit board that they sit on. All right. All right. So let's, let's take a break from— we're gonna get to the next one after largest content. But folks can evaluate their own websites.
Charles LehositOh, yeah.
Tony MartignettiThe same, the same way you did, right? With the 2,000 that you put in. Where, where do, where do people go to evaluate their own site and, and have it measured quickly?
Charles LehositYeah, great question. So in Google, Google PageSpeed Insights. The URL is pagespeed.web.dev. You don't have to remember that. If you just Google PageSpeed Insights, this PageSpeed, one word, Insights would be the second word. This should be the first result for you. And then put in your URL. And keep in mind, when you put in that URL, that's just one page you're testing. You're not testing your whole site. And so just keep in mind, like— Right. And probably when you've got people giving you opinions on this, like a board member, they might, if they took a peek at your scores, it's probably just your homepage, which is probably the most content-heavy page. And you have, you hopefully know your top landing pages that drive, you know, your most valuable traffic and this, that, and the other. So don't just look at your homepage. Don't just look at a donation form. Take a look at your top landing pages and see how you're doing overall.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Right. So that perfect sense. Yeah. Right. If you just put in your .org and end there, right, it's just the homepage. But you can drill down to those top pages that are, that get the most hits that are most important to you and put those URLs in. And it, I did, I went to the tool. It's very simple. It's just like a Google, it's just like Google search.
Charles LehositExactly.
Tony MartignettiJust put a URL in and, and click and you'll get scores on all these, uh, and all these factors, the vital signs. I don't know what it's called, but all the vital signs will be evaluated for your, for whatever URL you put in.
Charles LehositI like that. I'm gonna just start calling them vital signs as well.
Tony MartignettiVital signs. Yes. Like, like I said, like respirations and, and blood pressure. All right. Um, next one is our speed index score. What is this vital measuring?
Charles LehositSpeed Index, how quickly your content is visibly populated. So this is just ultimately how quickly does everything load. I know this sounds like it should already be captured in First Paint and Largest Paint. It's a separate metric for whatever reason in Google's world. And a fast speed index should be, you know, 3.4 seconds or, or less.
Tony MartignettiAll right. This is the whole page though.
Charles LehositThis is the whole page.
Tony MartignettiYeah. Initially we were measuring first piece of content, largest piece of content. This is the entire page.
Charles LehositThis is the whole page. And do you think about the progression from first, first paint in 1.8 seconds or less, largest paint in 2.5 seconds or less, and now the whole page in 3.4 seconds. It's a, It's not, you know, you're talking about hundreds of a second, milliseconds. It's not a lot of time in between these things happening.
Tony MartignettiAll right. So 3.4. So the, the, for the whole page, they're letting you go over 3 seconds, but not, you can't have 3.5.
Charles LehositRight.
Tony MartignettiOver 3.4 is needs improvement. Right?
Charles LehositExactly.
Tony MartignettiAll right. And what was poor? What, what above what score is, or above what time was poor? For the, the Speed Index score?
Charles LehositOh gosh, let me actually look at the report on that one.
Tony MartignettiOkay. I just, uh, I'm just amazed by the lack of, lack of attention or lack of patience that we all have. I'm not saying— it's not like I'm saying I wait, I'm willing to wait 30 seconds for a page to load. So
Charles Lehosita poor score is—
Tony MartignettiWe're all in this together.
Charles LehositBut no, you're actually right. A poor score is, um, So needs improvement is— sorry, I was actually reading the darn wrong thing. It should be over 4 seconds for needs for— Oh,
Tony Martignettiso it gives you 4 seconds for the— it gives you 4 seconds.
Charles LehositYeah.
Tony MartignettiFor
Charles Lehositgood or for poor.
Tony MartignettiOh, over— wait, over 4 is poor?
Charles LehositYeah.
Tony MartignettiOkay. That's not a lot of time for an entire page, 4 seconds. And,
Charles Lehosityeah.
Tony MartignettiAnd there's, so there's research that, that, that if people have to wait too long, they will, they'll just go away.
Charles LehositSo, yes. And so what Google, you know, what Google's saying is they're seeing is like you click on a link and you come back, or maybe you clicked on what a lot of people probably do, you click on 4 links and, you know, you're, you know, you, you aren't engaging with them or you're not engaging with them long enough so that Google goes like, okay, You spent so many seconds here and it wasn't enough. You know, this is quick tangent, you know, but in Google Analytics 4, there is a metric called an engaged session. And the default Google has deemed the default time for an engaged session is 10 seconds. And I think that most of us—
Tony Martignetti10 seconds, that's engaged?
Charles LehositYeah, I think most—
Tony Martignetti10 seconds is engaged? I thought like 30 minutes is engaged. No,
Charles Lehositno, I think, and I think most of us would actually go like, 10 seconds is, um, somebody just kind of window shopping. It's just kind of like, what, where's your phone number? What, where's your address? Like, 10 seconds is— and so in Facebook and Google's world, 10 seconds or more is an engaged session. Uh, but I think for a nonprofit that's trying to make meaningful connections, You know, your metric should be a minute. You know, it should be.
Tony MartignettiYeah, come on. I mean, I think Google needs more baby boomers and great generation because we would say like 20 minutes is an engaged session. All right.
Charles LehositExactly.
Tony MartignettiAll right. Anyway, engaging with a person anyway, but even a website, 10 seconds. All right. Yeah, a minute. It just doesn't seem like a lot of time. I don't know. I mean, you're reading things. I mean, videos, I understand videos are supposed to be 90 seconds or less. All right. What a world we're living in. To flesh it out like this. I mean, we're all living it every single day. But to talk about these speeds, it's almost surreal. It is. Yeah, it's surreal. It's hard to imagine this being true.
Charles LehositNow, for our nonprofit friends out there, and you know, when you're ready, you can change your, you can customize your definition of an engaged session. And so your engaged session doesn't have to be Google's, you know, 10-second definition. You can, in the future, you can change it to be 30 seconds to a minute, 20 minutes. You can do that. But if you have Google Analytics 4 off the shelf with that Uh, default setting, it's 10 seconds.
Tony MartignettiOkay. All right. But it's changeable. All right. At least, at least the thing is forgiving, uh, to, uh, by human, by at least by my human standards anyway. All right. Um, let's deal with accessibility. We're doing, this is a good one. We're doing, we're doing, we've improved over the past many years and this one is the, the best of all the scores that we've talked about, all the vital signs that we've talked about so far.
Charles LehositI agree with you. I agree with you. We've, in our physical locations, we have made our physical locations more accessible and inclusive. It's important that we make our online content more accessible.
Tony MartignettiCharles is showing the thickness of his glasses. Charles has bad eyes. All right.
Charles LehositAnd so I'm not the only one. And so we— Google has definitely made accessibility a factor. And so this is not a hard one to get right. And you want to get this right as it actually 100% overlaps with SEO. So, you know, the alt text on an image, well, that's part of accessibility and that also is needed for SEO. Your good, good page headlines, good page titles, good contrast so that people can read. So we're not doing— Tony, let me, let me hear your thoughts on gray font on a, like, really light gray font on a white page. Is that— Is that—
Tony Martignettino, that sounds terrible. I mean,
Charles LehositI'd be like 61.
Tony MartignettiI would be squinting. I would be squinting at
Charles Lehositthat. Why does this have to be so hard to read? So yeah, that contrast is important and because it makes it easier to read. And so Google just has seen from people that where things are hard to read, where they're not accessible for folks, they leave and they don't come back.
Tony MartignettiAll right. Those are the vital signs that I'd like to cover because I want to spend the rest of our time talking about What to do about these issues that you will have discovered when you go to PageSpeed Insights tool, the Google tool. All right. So you have some advice about what, how to prioritize, because, you know, we want to, we want to have a good experience for our users. We also want to rank as high as possible in Google search results. So how do we approach the remedy to what we are likely to discover because we're all doing so poorly?
Charles LehositYeah.
Tony MartignettiEspecially in mobile.
Charles LehositSo the, I guess I would say step 0 is make sure that this is a priority for your whole team. You know, if you have a partner, either it's like an SEO specialist or an agency that's working with you, It can't just be a priority for them because if you have different team members or even different teams that are creating content, uploading content, updating content on your website, you know, your website is rarely a static set-it-and-forget-it thing. It's always being updated and touched. And so any investment that you make, really, you have to have Step 0 would be everyone on your team, everyone with your organization that touches the website has to be, you know, following your own guidelines for your healthy vitals, to have your, you know, healthy and positive vital signs. Once you've got that, because that's really going to be whether or not, hey, you know, I spent so much money I invested in improving this and Is it going to be just as good as it was when the investment was delivered, the work was delivered, or is it eroded? We really want to avoid wasting that investment. So once you're past step 0, recommend that you do an audit of your website tags. And so these used to be hardcoded pixels. You know, people used to put a Facebook pixel and a Google pixel and every other pixel like hardcoded into their site. And we were taught, all right, that's not the best way to do it. We moved all of our tags to Tag Manager, like Google Tag Manager or Tealium. Most nonprofits are using Google Tag Manager, so we'll stick with that. And so that's a good thing. Google Tag Manager makes it easier to control, like, where a pixel loads, where an advertising tag loads or doesn't load. What I think too many people do is they add tags and then they, but they're not actually going back and saying what shouldn't be here anymore. And so here's a little question for the audience is how many of you out there have Google Analytics 3 tags still loading in your Tag Manager? As Google Analytics 3 isn't capturing, isn't collecting data for you anymore. And I bet, I bet it's more than zero. So the tags, and this is a, here's a, here's another neat trick to try. I call it a trick. It's not, it's not a trick. If you have the ability to have a, like a staging environment for your site, and I hope that you all do. So if you mean, if you have a developer environment where you can make changes and it doesn't impact your site visitors' experience. Do your PageSpeed Insights with no tags, like no tags on your staging site and see, and then take a look at what the same PageSpeed score is with your production site with the tags on. That's the cost of all of the, you know, conversion tracking, your digital analytics. That's the cost of that. And I'm not arguing like we need that knowledge, we need that information, but there's a cost to it. There's an expense, and it's going to impact your vital signs. It's gonna ultimately impact the page speed as the time to load the page will be like, do you have 200 tags, 300 tags in Tag Manager? And it's all of those are loading. And so it's good for you to see the total cost of those. So you can know, well, how often do I need— can I, can I just do spring cleaning once a year? Do I need to have a program where we are looking at retiring tags and removing tags every quarter? It's probably not— doesn't need to be that frequent as every quarter. But if you're not looking at it at least once a year, chances are you've got like dozens of tags that could be retired and removed and that are Adding to your that are lowering your score.
Kate MartignettiIt's time for Tony's Take Two.
Tony MartignettiThank you, Kate, and thank you for listening to Nonprofit Radio. I am grateful that you support the show, that you're listening to the show, and I understand you might not listen every week, right? You might see a topic doesn't work for you, but overall you're subscribing and listening. And I am grateful. I'm channeling you. I'm thinking about what topics interest you, guests interest you, even while I'm talking to a guest, the questions that you would want to ask. So I'm doing what I can to encourage you to listen. And I'm glad that you're there. I guess that's all to say, I don't take our listeners for granted. I'm grateful that you're listening. And I'm working hard along with Kate each week to, uh, keep you along. We want you listening. So thank you. Thanks for being with us. And that is Tony's Take Two. Kate.
Kate MartignettiThank you so much, nonprofit family, for sticking with us and for staying with the Podfather at Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio.
Tony MartignettiThank you. All right. Yes, absolutely grateful for our listeners.
Kate MartignettiWell, we've got beaucoup but loads more time. Now back to Your Website Performance with Charles Lehosit.
Tony MartignettiAre tags getting added incrementally as content updates? Is that what happens? To me, I thought tags were, were Well, I had a misunderstanding about tags. I thought they were just to describe overarching, you know, what the page is about.
Charles LehositOh, so no, no, that's— so there's a tag in like WordPress can describe the content or the, like, you know, describe maybe an image.
Tony MartignettiAre we talking about page? Are we talking about page level? Or
Charles Lehosittalking about The page level, but it's not in the, not in like your content management system. This would be like a Facebook pixel so that your, so that Facebook can know whether or not this person converted on a Facebook ad or Google level where Google can know this person converted on a Google ad or, and that type of thing. So all of that. Those are all pixels and tags that end up getting loaded on your site. And so those, you know, we— they were originally called a pixel, which sounds like a really innocuous thing, but really anymore they're a bit— a piece of code that can load more pixels. And so it's a bit of JavaScript that can load more code and ultimately impact the The how fast or how not fast your site loads.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Okay. That's for our, for our listeners and for me, that, that's sufficient level of detail on tags. Pay attention to your tags, audit them. Sounds like semiannual, you know, twice, twice a year, or somebody should be paying attention to them at least once a year.
Charles LehositI would, I would say at least once a year if you have, you know, under 100 tags. If you have, Like, like 300 tags or more, then this should be a semiannual routine for you all.
Tony MartignettiOkay, excellent. Thank you. Sliders. You're concerned about sliders. Now, sliders, is that— these are these images that when you open them, I guess they're mostly on a homepage. Yeah, no, they could be other pages too. That's true. I mostly see them homepages though. The, the images slides and there's 5 or 6 dots. for you to know how many, how many images there are going to be, or you can select them. Is that a slider?
Charles LehositThat's exactly right. That's a slider.
Tony MartignettiThese things, uh, they're not so— they're not, they're not so vogue anymore.
Charles LehositThey're not. Um,
Tony Martignettithey're a
Charles Lehositlittle out
Tony Martignettithere. I still see them around. I didn't know.
Charles LehositUh, people have a hard time letting go of their sliders, right?
Tony MartignettiOkay, why, why are they not as popular as they were, like, What, 3 years ago or just or so? Was it
Charles Lehosit3, 4
Tony Martignettiyears ago?
Charles LehositYeah, you're right. No, they were the standard 3 or 4 years ago for sure.
Tony MartignettiWhat happened? What happened to sliders?
Charles LehositSo user experience experts and Google folks like Google have really been steering us away from sliders where you have one space that has 5 messages, 7 messages. And it's, you know, when you're talking about that, That main hero spot on your homepage that first loads. There's— I completely understand why you want to have, well, here's message 1 and here's message 2. Totally understand why. That is the— that's going to result in the biggest loss in your health vitals, your Core Web Vitals. Especially if you have you know, 3, 5, 7 images. It's not the text that loads in it. It's the, the images, because all of those images load on your site in the slider. And so it's adding to the overall weight of the site. And kind of a, a good little sidebar on sliders is that not enough nonprofits are optimizing the images for the web. And so, you know, it's very common to see a one, like every image to be 1 megabyte or larger. And so then, all right, you've got 3 images, that's 3 megabytes, 5 images, 5 megabytes, and you're talking about over a 4-second load time on mobile for sure.
Tony MartignettiOkay.
Charles LehositAnd so here's a little secret for anybody. It's free. TinyPNG. TinyPNG. You drop, drag and drop your images into TinyPNG, and they will— it's a free service, and it will give you an optimized version. So if you're working in, I don't know, Photoshop, you're playing around with how much compression should I do or don't do, don't do that. Just drag and drop your images to TinyPNG and use that free service to Make sure the images on your site are optimized for the web.
Tony MartignettiCool. Well, I love free resources. tinypng.com.
Charles LehositYep.
Tony MartignettiThat's it. All right.
Charles LehositYep.
Tony MartignettiAll right. So sliders. So I get for, for, for folks that never implemented sliders when they were popular, when they were vogue. So now you're ahead. You, you, you're, you're so far behind, you're ahead. You didn't, you never did the sliders. Now you're ahead. So it was valuable. It was worth it to not be cutting edge. Now you're ahead.
Charles LehositThat sounds like my approach to fashion. So yes, that is—
Tony MartignettiSo far behind, you're ahead.
Charles LehositThat's exactly right.
Tony MartignettiYou're waiting for bell-bottoms to come back? I am too. I know I am. I'm waiting to take out my bell-bottom suits again. All right. Sliders, not so popular, not a good idea. The technology changes, I guess, because they were, they were the, seemed to be the standard for website design for, for, I don't know how, for how long, but I'm thinking like 4 or 5 years ago, they were, they were very popular. Lots of, lots of sites converted to the big, big bulky slider files. All right.
Charles LehositIt was innovative at the, at the, when they first came out, it was innovative because like my, my, it solved a problem. My problem is I, I need to highlight more than one thing.
Tony MartignettiYeah.
Charles LehositOkay. Here. Yeah.
Tony MartignettiAll right. What else? Well, we talked image optimization. I know that's—
Charles LehositImage optimization, I snuck in there. TinyPNG, a really great resource. TinyPNG for WordPress users has a WordPress plugin. They have a paid service and TinyPNG also will let you put in a URL for your, like, similar to PageSpeed Insights, you can put in your the page URL, and it'll analyze all of the images on that page, and it'll let you know where you can do better, and then it'll offer you a download to have all of those images fully optimized. It's— I mean—
Tony MartignettiOh my gosh, what a valuable free service.
Charles LehositIt's— yeah, we love it. We love it.
Tony MartignettiAll right, tinypng.com. You have something to say about lightboxes?
Charles LehositLightboxes. So these are pop-ups, these are modals. We're gonna call it—
Tony Martignettiyou can see, but you can lightbox, you can see through it, right? Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
Charles LehositLightbox where it's, uh, semi, uh, semi-transparent, semi-opaque.
Tony MartignettiThese also had their moment. I think, I think lightboxes came before sliders, I think.
Charles LehositYeah, well, the definitely the, like, the advertising pop-up that kind of, I think, introduced this idea of like, hey, Why not do that on my own site? Like, I'm not— I'm trying to say this is what I want you to focus on right now. This is the most important thing for you. So yeah.
Tony MartignettiJoin our newsletter, sign our petition. Okay. Lightboxes, are they out like sliders or they're just— you need to be judicious about their use or what?
Charles LehositWe need to be really judicious. Google has—
Tony MartignettiReally judicious to the point of don't use them?
Charles LehositIf you are—
Tony Martignettiall right, Charles, I'm trying to nail you down. All right, you don't have to be so definitive,
Charles Lehositbut— If you're in a competitive market, if so, if you're, um, if you're a food bank, use them. You're— if you're a food bank, you're probably not competing with another food bank in your immediate area. Use them. Uh, if you're in a competitive market, let's say, let's call it cancer research for it to be easy. You could, you could say disaster relief. Uh, if you're in a competitive market, Google has said lightboxes are a no on mobile. Lightboxes are a no on mobile. So if you are using lightboxes in mobile, that's a problem. And Google is saying that translates to a poor user experience. And so lightboxes, that means if you're in that space where you have more competitive peers, we might not be saying that you directly compete with them, but there's a lot of competing options. Yeah. Then lightboxes, you should focus on lightboxes on desktop only. And if you're in a space where you're the only one focusing on animal welfare in Lawrence, Kansas, you're fine to do, because then you're not really competing for ranking in animal shelters in Lawrence, Kansas. And so you're fine to use lightboxes on mobile and desktop. Just know ultimately there is a cost to that. And your Core Web Vitals, but it's lightboxes in mobile for competitive markets, really, really risky to your organic search traffic.
Tony MartignettiHelp me understand lightboxes versus popups. Are they now the same? When you're saying lightboxes, are you including popups?
Charles LehositNo.
Tony MartignettiI was distinguishing, but again, lackluster host, I don't work in tech. I work in planned giving fundraising. So to me, a lightbox was, was a pop-up that you could see through, and a pop-up was a pop-up that was opaque, couldn't see through.
Charles LehositOh, okay. I was talking about a pop-up that was— so my, my, my definition of a pop-up was more of the, the lightbox that was opaque. But I guess because I think there's—
Tony MartignettiOh, yours is— You know the, you know the definition.
Charles LehositYeah. So let's describe it as if it's a popup and it doesn't block any of the background behind it. I mean, it doesn't have any shroud, then Google's okay with that. If you have a popup that has, or a lightbox that has a shroud, meaning it's semi-opaque, it's semi-transparent, but it blocks content in the background or your access to it, then that's what Google is saying. That's a no on mobile if you're in a competitive market.
Tony MartignettiOkay. All right. And clearly, my definition and my understanding is outdated. Don't be surprised. So pop-up, pop-up is what we, we refer to them as pop-ups. I mean, I'm sorry, we refer to them as light boxes.
Charles LehositYeah, yeah, yeah. Sorry.
Tony MartignettiLight boxes. That's what— sorry, I'm sorry. All right. Light boxes, light boxes. Stop saying pop-ups. That's the last time I'm gonna use that word. They're light boxes. All right. No, not, you know, I'm not following this the way you are. What else should we focus on, Charles? You got some more, a little more in there.
Charles LehositIn order to make sure your content loads the fastest, you should be using what's called a CDN, which is a content distribution network. You really want to seek hosting solutions that are integrated with a CDN so that you don't have to try and solve for this separate. But, you know, so a hosting solution for those of you on WordPress, WP Engine has a built-in CDN for you, and you should take advantage of that. For anyone that needs a separate solution, Cloudflare. Cloudflare has a really great and really, really cost-effective CDN for you to help essentially deliver your content faster. So the concept— this, what this used to describe is that your server might be in California and your site visitor might be in DC. And so the CDN will host images and on their servers closer to DC so that that request doesn't have to go all the way to California to go get the content to go all the way back to DC. And so instead, a CDN like Cloudflare might have your images on your site hosted in like a North Virginia data center so that it's— that site visitor accesses your site content faster. CDN, faster content.
Tony MartignettiCDN, content distribution network.
Charles LehositYep.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Okay. And then you have some advice specifically for WordPress since WordPress is such a popular hosting creation platform.
Charles LehositSo yeah, WordPress. So many nonprofits are on WordPress and really so many websites are on WordPress. And so if you're on WordPress, you should really be on WP Engine as your web host unless you're doing something There's a, there's a few people that maybe WP Engine isn't the best option for, but for the most part, if your website is— gosh, how do I qualify this for you? I don't know. Under 10,000 pages, WP Engine is a really great option for you. Under 5,000 pages, WP Engine is a really great option for you.
Tony MartignettiOkay. WP Engine. You want to make sure you want to ask your tech consultant or— Yeah, if you're on— If you have one.
Charles LehositGoDaddy hosting, this is not something you want to stay on GoDaddy hosting for your site. You want to eventually go, okay, if I'm— that some of the things that you would do to optimize your health scores or optimize your Core Web Vitals, you can't do without a proper host. So WP Engine is a Proper host for WordPress sites. GoDaddy, sorry, GoDaddy, not so much for you. Within WP Engine, there is an option called WP Engine's Advanced Network that is like an easy button for page performance and page speed. And so— Okay. If you're on WP Engine, you're probably not using that yet. And so definitely ask your website partner, your internal technical folks about the advanced network.
Tony MartignettiOkay.
Charles LehositThe next thing for WordPress would be Gutenberg. Gutenberg has been out for a number of years now. Gutenberg is the— this is funny to say— it's the native editor. In WordPress. So meaning like when you go, when you are on WordPress, when you are editing content, the native editor that ships with WordPress is Gutenberg. Well, it wasn't the first editor that shipped with WordPress. And so over the years, people worked with their favorite editor that came with so many bells and whistles to make it easier to edit content. Well, those legacy editors Our loads, the content loads slower than content in Gutenberg. And so people have actually, there was a button to defer, like, I don't want to use Gutenberg, and I'm gonna— there's actually a plugin they would use to defer Gutenberg and push that back. And definitely, if you're, if you're building a new site in 2024 in WordPress, It should be in Gutenberg. It is, uh, your SE— your SEO, um, uh, consultant or partner will, uh, will love you for that. And so will your page speed scores.
Tony MartignettiOkay. It's all about the vitals. All right. Gutenberg. Go to the original. Go to the original printing press. Use the Gutenberg.
Charles LehositThere you go. We've, we've come full circle with, uh, with technology there, right?
Tony MartignettiAll right. And you have one more. You got Autoptimize for WordPress. WordPress-developed sites?
Charles LehositYeah. So this is again an easy button. And so Autoptimize will— gosh, you wish you had this for your own life where your body would just sort of exercise itself and would avoid any kind of bad eating habits. But Autoptimize does a lot to advance and improve your page speed scores. It'll also improve your images and also make your site load a lot faster. It is going to be a lot less expensive to test out Autoptimize and see, did it break anything? Is it— did it improve anything than to, you know, hire a really expensive consultant to do all this work by hand? So definitely consider, if you're on WordPress, test these things, test these things in a staging or development environment, meaning not in a live environment where we might break something for a site visitor or a donor. And so when we test these things in a staging environment, we can say, okay, this doesn't break anything, and it gave us a 30% improvement to our scores or 50% improvement to our scores. We've seen some really drastic improvements to scores with Autoptimize, and it's, it feels like in some ways it's the easy button for WordPress sites.
Tony MartignettiCharles, we're gonna leave it there. All right. So the, the, the report is 2023 Nonprofit Website Performance Report. You'll find it at rkdgroup.com or just search that Report name. And I think, you know, to the— you're looking at your own scores like bone density and A1C and cholesterol and triglycerides and total cholesterol and high-density and low-density lipoproteins. You gotta look at, you know, you gotta look at your first piece of content, largest content, your speed index scores. These are all vitals.
Charles LehositAre you looking at your own health metrics every day?
Tony MartignettiRight, exactly. So is there a parallel? I mean, well, a little more often. I mean, hopefully you're doing a primary care physician visit once a year.
Charles LehositYeah.
Tony MartignettiAnd eyes and dentist should be twice a year. So some of these things are a couple times a year, right? Some things we obsess over, like you might obsess over blood pressure more than triglycerides, but we're, we're, it's all, it's all in a balance, right? Is that a fair analogy? It is.
Charles LehositI think if you're obsessing over it daily, that's an unhealthy obsession. And, and I think if you've developed good habits like you would with your own diet and exercise routines, then for your website, like that priority zero or step zero I talked about, then Then you shouldn't be surprised when you are looking at your Core Web Vitals quarterly or semi-annually. I would look at it more than once a year, but I wouldn't look at it every single day because that's just when you see a change on any given day, you know, it's, it's, I think that is a distraction.
Tony MartignettiAll right. Charles Lehosit, he's on LinkedIn. RKD Group is at rkdgroup.com. Charles, thank you very much. Loved it.
Charles LehositHey, Tony, it was a pleasure. Thank you.
Tony MartignettiAll right.
Kate MartignettiNext week, it'll be one from the archive. If you missed any part of this week's show,
Tony MartignettiI beseech you to find it at tonymartignetti.com.
Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by DonorBox. Outdated donation forms blocking your supporters' generosity this giving season? DonorBox, the fast, flexible, and friendly fundraising platform for nonprofits. donorbox.org. Our creative producer is Claire Meyerhoff. I'm your associate producer, Kate Martignetti. The show's social media is by Susan Chavez. Marc Silverman is our web guy, and this music is by Scott Stein.
Tony MartignettiThank you for that affirmation, Scotty. Be with us next week for Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. Go out and be great.
I love our sponsor!


