Skip to content
EP 664October 29, 2023

CRM Selection & What To Ask Before Your New Website

Tony MartignettiRubin SinghStephen Tidmore
Nonprofit Radio
Episode 664
0:00 / 0:00

CRM Selection

Rubin Singh returns to help you focus on what matters in CRM selection. To keep you safe from a serious misstep, he also shares his thoughts on what else might be the problem, besides your CRM database. Rubin is CEO of One Tenth Consulting.

What To Ask Before Your New Website

Stephen Tidmore from Mighty Citizen built his first website in 1999, and hasn’t stopped. He shares the questions you need to ask up front, before you embark on a new website project. These both originally aired on June 14, 2021.

Here’s the transcript

Tony MartignettiHello and welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. I am your aptly named host and the Podfather. We'll just start again with this take. Hello and welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. I am your aptly named host and the Podfather. of your favorite hebdomadal podcast. Oh, I'm glad you're with us. I'd come down with hypo-esophoria if I saw that you missed this week's show. Here's our associate producer Kate with what's up this week.

Kate MartignettiHey Tony, this week it's CRM selection. Rubin Singh returns to help you focus on what matters in CRM selection. To keep you safe from a serious misstep, he also shares his thoughts on what else might be the problem besides your CRM database. Rubin is CEO of One Tenth Consulting. Then, what to ask before your new website. From Mighty Citizen, built his first website in 1999 and hasn't stopped. He shares the questions you need to ask upfront before you embark on a new website project. These both originally aired on June 14th, 2021. On Tony's Take Two.

Tony MartignettiLoving the donors.

Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by DonorBox. Outdated donation forms blocking your supporters' generosity this giving season? DonorBox, the fast, flexible, and friendly fundraising platform for nonprofits. donorbox.org. And by Keela. Grow revenue, engage donors, and increase efficiency with Keela, the fundraiser's CRM. Visit keela.co to join the thousands of fundraisers using Keela to exceed their goals. Here is CRM Selection.

Tony MartignettiWelcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio coverage of 21NTC. You know what that is, it's the 2021 Nonprofit Technology Conference. With me now is Rubin Singh, CEO of One Tenth Consulting. Rubin, welcome back to Nonprofit Radio.

Rubin SinghHey, thanks so much, Tony. Thanks for having me.

Tony MartignettiMy pleasure, my pleasure. Your topic this year is CRM selection when you don't know what you don't know, which is kind of related to what we did, uh, talked about last year, which is don't get played by the product demo. That was— listeners can go back to listen to that. That was, uh, when we talked about the, uh, the flashbang demo that doesn't turn out to be so— Right. You can't replicate the— of which you cannot replicate the wizardry When you're post-install. It just doesn't seem to fly quite as fast as that product demo. So that was what we talked about last year. This year, what's the trouble around CRM selection and these unknown unknowns?

Rubin SinghYeah, yeah, no, thanks, Tony. And this seemed like a good way to springboard off of last year's presentation with the demos, because still, you know, with all the organizations, with so many of the organizations that I work with, the selection process is just such a challenge. And I even took the opportunity during the conference itself to ask, you know, what is it? What is it so challenging about these CRM selection processes? Is it that there's just too many options in the market? Too few options? Is it, you know, just confusion about the features they offer? Is it just, you know, if you're Or is it more on the internal side, you know, decision-making? As I suspected, I guess it's across the board. There's all kinds of reasons that people are really struggling right now when it comes to selecting CRMs. So that's why we wanted to look at this topic, is really try to unpack some of the reasons that make it so challenging and also give some advice on what can make the process go a little bit smoother.

Tony MartignettiOkay, the one thing that you ticked off that I imagine the problem is not is that there's too few CRMs available. I don't think that's a problem, is it?

Rubin SinghUh, well, I, I think, yeah, I wouldn't say there's too few, but then once you get into— you kind of dig in a little bit past the surface and really look at, you know, the types of functions that you need. So, um, you know—

Tony MartignettiOh, okay, yeah, you might have too few options based on your specific use case.

Rubin SinghExactly, like, you know, everybody will have, you know, the, the constituent management side of things, everybody will have, you know, basic activity management, donation management, so no shortage of solutions in the market there. But then you say, hey, you know, is there a solution out there in the market that does outbound funds management really well? Okay, well, now you're down to like 2. So I think, so there is too few, but yeah, there is a nuance there for sure.

Tony MartignettiOkay, I understand. Yep, yep. All right. So, you know, how do you help folks? Where should we start with this? How do you help folks make sense of this confounding landscape?

Rubin SinghYeah, you know, there's a few things I think that folks can do, and the first and foremost is really When you have a selection process, you know what I think you can do to make the most of it is, is first make sure that you have the right team internally. Because, you know, oftentimes I walk into situations like this where we do selections and, you know, I'm told, okay, you know, IT is going to make the decision here, or leadership is going to make the decision here, and neither of those really work out particularly well. So I think really having a cross-functional team, not only in terms of where they sit in the organization, you know, across the organizational hierarchy, but also looking at the diversity The team, and this is something that I personally feel is very important, you know, even, even diversity in terms of race, ethnicity, age, you know, technical, technical skill capability, ability, everything, you know, all those things are going to matter, you know, even if you work with external constituents, perhaps even engage some of your program participants in the process. The more diverse that you can have your team, you're really going to have a solution in the end that really represents what they need. So I think really assembling a team. The right team is a key part and often gets overlooked. Another thing is really just being honest with the expectations of the system. So, you know, I have some organizations that I work with that say, ah, you know, well, we don't have much budget and we don't have any resources that can manage this system really ongoing. We need something that we can plug and play that's gonna work. So tell me about Salesforce or, you know, tell me about Razor's Edge. And I'm like, wait, wait a second. You know, those are not the only, you know, 2 products in the market. There's a lot of other tools that are out there that are more aligned for you that you can— that is more plug and play. And then, you know, now granted, you might be trading off some opportunities to— it may not be as customizable or it may not be all the depth of functionality you need in certain areas. But going the other direction and having a highly customizable system that needs a lot of maintenance, and when you don't have the team and the resources and the budget to maintain it, it can really put you in a tough spot. So those are kind of a couple of things. I have more, but those are a couple of things that I think that often get overlooked is really starting in with those right expectations and having the right team to help make that decision.

Tony MartignettiRubin, unfortunately, you're stuck with me as a lackluster host. I should have asked you initially, how do you know if you need a new CRM before you even wade into these waters? Maybe CRM, maybe your CRM is not your problem. How do you make sure it's a CRM that is your problem and not your processes or your leadership or something else?

Rubin SinghThat's a great question, Tony. I

Tony Martignettiwish I had asked it 5 minutes ago.

Rubin SinghNo, no problem. And, you know, I've worked for product companies in the past where, you know, we have a specific methodology, specific product to come and solve your problem. And I'll be honest with you, Tony, over the years I've implemented CRM solutions You know, on time, on budget. We're sitting there after go-live, everybody's celebrating, and I walked out of those clients thinking to myself, this is not gonna end well. This is not— they are not set up for the success, and it really has nothing to do with the CRM.

Tony MartignettiAnd you felt that way even on your champagne high? After

Rubin Singhyou

Tony Martignettidrank their champagne, ate their hors d'oeuvres, you still walked out feeling unsatisfied?

Rubin SinghOh, I tell you, walking to my car in the parking lot, I sit there in the car and I'm like, oh boy, this I'm going to hear from these folks in 2 months, and I don't know what I could have done differently, you know. Yeah. And it's really for the things that you said, that it's really making sure that, do they have the right support ongoing? Do they have the right governance structure? Do they have good decision-making processes when things come up? Do they have the right executive buy-in? Are the processes really well aligned to help them be successful in the new system, or did they bring their own sort of broken promises into the new system— sorry, broken processes into the new system? Or even their data. You know, oftentimes these, these projects kind of run overboard and then they just say, ah, well, let's just— we don't need to clean the data. Let's just push it into the new system and, and we'll figure it out later. These are not— these are things that are not going to lead you to success. And oftentimes when things go awry, it's like, ah, you know, we shouldn't have gone with this CRM or we shouldn't have gone with this. And it's really, you know, and that's one thing at One Tenth we've— is really one of our key principles is It's the people, process, and technology. It's the strategy. It's having everything aligned in order to make your technology successful. So it is, it is, yeah, it's a little bit science, a little bit art to make that, to make sure that balance is there.

Kate MartignettiIt's time for a break. Are you looking to maximize your fundraising efforts and impact this giving season? DonorBox's online donation platform is designed to help you reach your fundraising goals. From customizable donation forms to far-reaching, easy-share crowdfunding and peer-to-peer options, plus seamless in-person giving with DonorBox Live Kiosk. DonorBox makes giving simple and fast for your donors and moves the needle on your mission. Visit donorbox.org and let DonorBox help you help others. Now back to CRM selection.

Tony MartignettiAfter an 18-month or maybe 24-month conversion, you know, the whole process of search and then narrowing down and, you know, the things we talked about last year, and then, and then for it not to be the success that everybody's expecting. Um, let's spend a little more time with this. What, I mean, Where else should we look? You know, if we suspect our CRM is the problem, but where else should we be looking? We've talked about processes, leadership, buy-in, but drill down a little bit. You know, you have the experience. What have you seen that is often the cause, not the— it's not the software?

Rubin SinghYeah, you know, definitely the buy-in is key. And that's something that starts from the very beginning. And I've seen, you know, I don't wanna sound super negative here because I've seen some organizations do this really well. You know, where, you know, before they, you know, let's say they've made us, you know, they're kind of getting close to a selection or they're, they've done sort of the initial vetting of solutions. They really bring the leadership in and have them have a stake in the matter. I think that's key. You know, so when I even talk about assembling a diverse team, that also includes leadership and management. You know, they're not just— they shouldn't just be spectators to the process. They should be very engaged in the process because that's when I see things kind of fall off the rails a little bit is the moment something goes wrong and everybody just, you know, throws their hands up in the air and says, oh, well, you know, I never really, you know, subscribed to this, or I told you you should have gone with, you know, such and such tool anyways. So that executive buy-in is, is just super important. And that really is, you know, it's the project team sitting with leadership and making sure they understand what is the business case for CRM in the first place? What needs to make us successful? So if that means additional resources, like we need a part-time or full-time administrator, or we need to have a tool to, you know, manage tickets and ongoing incidents, so we have a way of tracking things that we need to improve with the CRM, or we need a governance process that we can make decisions more effectively. And I think, Tony, that the governance is key. Because oftentimes, like, you go live and then sure enough, as folks are using the system, There's all kinds of requests. There's, there's bugs, there's enhancement requests, there's, you know, fundamental problems that need to be addressed. And oftentimes it's like, okay, well, let's just, you know, go to the person who's, you know, clamoring the loudest and solve their problem. But that's not really the right way to do it. You want to be methodical and think about, okay, well, you know, let's prioritize, let's evaluate the urgency of the issues, the severity of the issues, let's put together a roadmap so everybody knows what's coming when. And so it sort of, you know, goes to that point that this, that CRM is not a project. It is definitely an ongoing journey. And so, you know, when those kinds of expectations are aligned, I see a lot more success. So yeah, the solution— and that is completely solution agnostic. Yeah.

Tony MartignettiYeah. All right. Thank you for that digression. But I think it's important. I think, I think there's a lot of orgs that blame their software.

Rubin SinghYeah.

Tony MartignettiBut they have much more inherent problems That, as you said, no application is going to solve because that's not the pro— those aren't the problems. That's not the problem. All right.

Rubin SinghYeah.

Tony MartignettiUm, you mentioned prioritization. I want to get to that. I wanted to get to that because you, you alluded to different features and, you know, but how do you decide what you really need versus what you, you could, you could use but you don't really need it, you know, to try to winnow down your, your alternatives in this vast landscape?

Rubin SinghYeah, that's a really important question, Tony, because, you know, especially as I've sat through, as perhaps you have too, just sat through so many demos of systems, and I think oftentimes the organizations I work with, they are very impressed with the breadth of functionality.

Tony MartignettiBut you have the— well, I haven't sat through as many as you have, but you also have the experience of having done the demos.

Rubin SinghI've been on both sides of it.

Tony MartignettiDone whatever, thousands. I think we talked last year, you know, you had done thousands of these things, and you were the whiz-bang You were the guy flying through the— flying the cursor through and showing everybody how easy it was.

Rubin SinghSure.

Tony MartignettiHow easy it'll be for you. It'll be just like this. Your experience is going to be identical to mine. You know, give yourself 24 hours with the system and then you'll be as good as me. All right. So, I'm making you out to be a huckster.

Rubin SinghYou're not that. Well, I'll tell you a little story, Tony, and I shared this. Oh, yes,

Tony Martignettigo

Rubin Singhahead. I shared this with the folks at the NTC. You know, a couple years ago on my last trip to India, I went on a shopping trip with my wife and we went to this garment store, clothing store, and she walks in there and she says, I'm looking for something specific. I want this dress that is turquoise. And the shop owner said, oh, okay, yeah, no problem. And then he starts showing all these different dresses and it's just like, you know, unpacking and showing and demonstrating. He has 2, 3 assistants unpacking different garments and showing different things. You know, some of them are light blue, some of them are dark blue, some of them are shades of green, some of them are teal. And, you know, about maybe 30, 40 different dresses into this, I kind of figured what was going on here. And I whispered to my wife, I said, I think he's going to show you everything in this store before he tells you he doesn't have a turquoise dress. And I feel every time I sit in some of these system demos, I kind of think of the same thing that, you know, the— and no disrespect to the account executives out there, they're doing their job and trying to present the best elements of the products they have, but they are going to show you everything. They're going to show you everything, whether there's breadth or depth, it doesn't really matter. They're going to impress you with all the features and functionality that the system offers. So what I try to encourage my clients and prospective clients to do is, you know, you kind of take control of the demo. Say, you know, I'm not really interested in, you know, I know all these solutions do fundraising. I know all these solutions, you know, can send out an email. I know all these solutions will track activities, but here are my 3 or 4 priorities You know, I need to do long-term case management because we're a human services nonprofit, or, you know, we get grants that we regrant to other smaller nonprofits, so we want to do outbound regranting, or, you know, we focus heavily on the social listening or the volunteer management. Pick those 4 or 5 areas that mean the most to you, and you want to see the real depth in those systems there, because I think once you do that, you're going to find there's fewer options than you might have thought. And really kind of, you know, rather than just getting into this demo, process. Demos are nice, but what you really want is a working session to say, here are my use cases, and, you know, show me how we can solve very specific problems in these 4 or 5 areas. And I— and, you know, there are some vendors that will say, you know, I don't have time for that, you know, I'll give you my canned demo, you know, that's the best I can do. And you probably don't want to work with those partners. You really— You know, there are other vendors that say, oh, thank you, like, thank you, I don't have to waste my time on this canned demo. And we can really focus on the things that matter to you. There's some that really, really thrive in that situation. So, so I think it's really looking at what are those 3 or 4 things, those 5 things that really matter to you, that, that is not only something that you need to maybe replace in your current process, but looking 3 to 5 years down the line, you know, you really want to get into program management or you really want to get into more direct mail. You think about what those 3 or 5 things are and really focus the sales process on that.

Tony MartignettiIs that hard to do, focus on these 3 to 5 when you've got 10 people from an organization clamoring for their use to be a top priority?

Rubin SinghYeah.

Tony MartignettiYou know, the event folks are saying, well, we need better ticketing, but it doesn't feel like ticketing is really a priority, but we do ticketing. You know, how do you manage these internal There are

Rubin Singhalways— there's always going to be that battle. There's always going to be that healthy debate and contention there. So, you know, what I try to frame up is, as an organization, you definitely have to prioritize. You surely have to prioritize. And I know everybody expects it, but they just don't want to be on the losing end of that prioritization. So, so I think what I try to encourage folks is, even though you may not get everything, you want to make sure that you're selecting a tool that Does not preclude you or did not prohibit you from getting the features that you want. So maybe event management is not a priority right now. But let's pick a solution that if, even if it doesn't have very strong event management capabilities, perhaps it can integrate with other tools that are out there that have very strong event management capabilities. So, so it's— So you definitely want to focus on the key priorities you have, but you also want to make sure that you're selecting a tool 3 to 5 years out. Can still support what you need. So that's— it's a little tricky. And, you know, it kind of goes to one of my— you know, I gave a lot of suggestions and a lot of tips and tricks on how to really make the selection process work for folks. But, you know, one of the last points I did is it may take a trusted advisor to help in this process because the nonprofits I work with, they're very busy, you know, doing good for the world and don't always have time to keep in completely aware of what all the latest technologies and trends are. So sometimes it takes bringing in a trusted advisor, whether that's in a pro bono capacity or a paid consultant, who can really help get you through some of the fluff and say, all right, well, I know that program management is not a key priority for you right now, but it is something you want to do in the future. And here's 3 or 4 tools that you might want to consider that can get you there at a later point.

Tony MartignettiThere's also the importance of leadership that you stressed. You know, it's incumbent on the CEO to decide what the priorities of the organization are.

Rubin SinghYeah, absolutely, absolutely. And, you know, when I was sort of working more on the vendor side and, you know, with specific products, I wasn't— you didn't really have the flexibility to have these discussions. But, you know, now, you know, running our own practice, we have the ability to kind of start Start selection processes with very different questions. So, you know, the questions I'll ask is, okay, well, let's talk about your fundraising strategy. Well, you know, let's talk about, you know, your organizational goals. Let's talk about where you are now and where you want to be 3 to 5 years from now. You know, what's the— what are the kind of decisions, let's say, you know, speaking to the executive director or the leadership team, you know, when you walk into work Monday morning and you turn your computer on, you log into your CRM, What do you want to see on your dashboard? What is it? What are those key decisions or key insights that you need to help you make decisions for that day, for that week? Let's start there. And then from there, we start figuring out what are the right tools, what are the right solutions and all that. But, but, but really, you're absolutely right. It starts with the strategy and it starts, starts from the top.

Tony MartignettiYou have some tools and resources To help folks make better decisions?

Rubin SinghYeah, absolutely. You know, making better decisions means, means a lot to us at One Tenth. You know, whether you work with us or not, we feel it's best for the nonprofit sector and best for the nonprofit tech sector to— for everyone to really have and be making informed decisions when they go for a solution. So on our website, on onetenth.consulting, you will be able to see we have webinars, we have blog posts, all to really help you in that process. Also on our social media, we do have from time to time we're either posting articles, sharing articles, other content that we think is really going to help people make good decisions. So I would, I would suggest, and all our webinars are all on demand free. So we encourage folks to take a look at our website and really take advantage of all the content that's out there, you know, combined with Myself and others that we work with. I mean, it's many, many years of experience, the good, the bad, the ugly. So we try to put as much as we can in that content on our website to make it available to everyone.

Tony MartignettiIt's onetenth.consulting?

Rubin SinghThat's correct.

Tony MartignettiAll spelled out, onetenth.consulting.

Rubin SinghYeah, that's right.

Tony MartignettiAre you familiar with the Tech Impact reports, the surveys that they do across different systems? Yes. They agnostically survey and study different elements of lots of different applications. Those can be valuable too, right? That Tech Impact survey?

Rubin SinghAbsolutely. I think Tech Impact does a great job on that, and that's one of the things that we often share around on our social media when it becomes available or new revisions of that is posted. I'm a big fan of their work. There's just so much out there, like I said, and you really don't— I don't expect any of the nonprofits I work with to be knowledgeable about everything that's out there. So I really do like what Tech Impact puts out, and it really gives you like a baseline of what are the different tools out there, what are the key, you know, from a pricing perspective and all that. So, you know, strengths and weaknesses, pros and cons. So I think that's like always a good place to start. And then, you know, sometimes when you need to get where it gets a little bit more complicated is when you are like— so for example, if you are thinking about CRM or it's— this is like a first step for you and, you know, you want to move off of spreadsheets You know, the Tech Impact Guide might be all you need to kind of make a first decision. What gets more complicated oftentimes is if you're switching from system A to system B, and you want to kind of know what that migration might look like. That's where the guide may not help you as much, and you might need to look at other resources that are, that are available.

Tony MartignettiOkay.

Rubin SinghYeah.

Tony MartignettiOkay. What do you say we leave it there, Ruben? Does that sound like we've hit this? Anything that we've omitted that you think is important?

Rubin SinghNo, no, that sounds great. I think I enjoyed the conversation very much. Always appreciate the opportunity to speak with you, Tony, and have a chance to engage with your audience. So thank you so much for the time.

Tony MartignettiMy pleasure. Rubin Singh, CEO at One Tenth Consulting. Again, onetenth.consulting. And thanks so much for being with Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio coverage of 21NTC.

Kate MartignettiIt's time for a break. Keela. Increase donations and foster collaborative teamwork with Keela, the fundraiser's CRM. Maximize your team's productivity and spend more time building strong connections with donors through features that were built specifically for fundraisers. A fundraiser CRM goes beyond a data management platform. It's designed with unique needs of fundraisers in mind. And aims to unify fundraising, communications, and donor management tools into one single source of truth. Visit keela.co to sign up for a coming group demo and explore how to exceed your fundraising goals like never before. It's time for Tony's Take Two.

Tony MartignettiThank you, Kate. I just had 10 days of donor meetings. I was in New York City, Met with lots of donors and potential donors to a client there, and it just reminds me how much I love doing the donor meetings. Just the face-to-face. Some are in people's homes. Some are over lunches or coffee. Not too many breakfasts and dinners in. In planned giving. The older folks, 80s and 90s, they don't really want to get out early in the morning for breakfast, and they don't really want to have dinner out either, especially in the winter. Maybe in the summer, summertime, you know, longer nights, you might get more dinners, but not, not so many this time of year. Not any, actually, for me. So lunches and coffees and meeting in people's homes. But it's just, it's such a pleasure, you know, getting to know folks. Listening to their stories about their— well, in most cases, it was their husbands who have died, their children, grandchildren, and of course, why they love the work of the nonprofit that I was representing while I was there. It's, you know, it's moving. They're just— they're fun. The donor meetings are fun. You know, that's the That's the beauty of fundraising is the meetings with donors and potential donors. So thankfully, as a consultant, I don't get bogged down in a lot of administration. There are not a lot of meetings people want me to go to, clients, occasional, but not so often. So I hope for you that you can, or you have, you know, freed yourself from a lot of the administrative work that is not anywhere near as stimulating as the meetings, the face-to-face meetings with folks. I hope you can unburden yourself from administration and get to the heart of fundraising, which around major giving or of course planned giving, is meeting folks, meeting them and talking to them, getting to know their stories. I have a natural curiosity about people. So I find these meetings just delightful and fun and fun. So I hope you can enjoy that part of fundraising, whether you're a full-time fundraiser or maybe you're a CEO, perhaps you're on a board. I urge you to embrace that really fun part of fundraising. That is Tony's Take Two. Associate producer Kate.

Kate MartignettiWell, it sounds like you had a very fun week, and I'm sure the people that you met up with were having fun as well, you know, getting out, doing something, not being stuck in the home. So it's very sweet to, you know, go grab a cup of coffee with the old people, you know.

Tony MartignettiWell, it's okay. Yeah, it's a little more, a little more than grab a cup of coffee with old people. But, uh, yeah, I, I got you. Yes, it is. Some of them do like getting out, um, and I, I believe they enjoy our meetings too. At least, at least that's what they say. We'll, we'll leave it at that. That's what they all say.

Kate MartignettiWe've got beaucoup but loads more time. Here is What to Ask Before Your New Website.

Tony MartignettiWelcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio coverage of 21NTC, the 2021 Nonprofit Technology Conference. My guest now is Stephen Tidmore. He is VP of Technology at Mighty Citizen. Stephen, welcome to Nonprofit Radio.

Stephen TidmoreThanks so much for having me.

Tony MartignettiPleasure, pleasure. Your session topic is 8 Questions to Ask Before You Start a New Website.

Stephen TidmoreCorrect.

Tony MartignettiAnd you, you, um, you describe yourself as a technical savant.

Stephen TidmoreI don't know if I describe myself as that, but, um—

Tony MartignettiOh, that one, that, that's in your bio. That's not—

Stephen TidmoreOur marketing folks may have added that to my bio.

Tony MartignettiThe marketing, marketing phrase. Okay. All right. I won't ask you to define a technical content architect.

Stephen TidmoreI'll just say I've been involved in technology and websites for a long time, probably about 20, a little well over 20 years now of experience building websites and for various size organizations.

Tony MartignettiYeah, indeed. That same marketing team written bio says you built your first one in 1999.

Stephen TidmoreThat's correct, yes.

Tony MartignettiWhat did websites look like in 1999? What did it mean to build a website in 1999 or 2000?

Stephen TidmoreOh, that's a good question. I guess in some ways it was a lot simpler, depending on the type of website you were building. Small websites, you know, you didn't have to worry about all the extra learning that comes these days from trying to figure out if you're gonna build a single-page application or if you're gonna use this JavaScript framework or that JavaScript framework, or, you know, really complex hosting setups. So that was simpler, but to do more complex things, At times were a bit harder. I started at Dell back in 1999, and I remember I kind of got into the web world because they were transitioning Dell.com to a new technology— well, not a new technology, but a new build process using XML. And so coding back then was writing this whole custom XML code that they had come up with that then nightly would go through a big spider and spit out HTML and everything else. And so that was more complicated, I guess, in some ways than— at least we have standards now and can do more dynamic things in a standards-compliant way. Back then, a lot of it was all custom.

Tony MartignettiWas that— was 1999, uh, remind me, was that the— the— was those the years of, uh, dial-up service where we'd hear that crackling?

Stephen TidmoreDo you— it still existed, um, but probably was a little more popular before that, you know, in the— in the late— in the You know, a little bit earlier in the late '90s, but dial-up still existed. I remember I still had dial-up in '99, but a lot of people had already moved on to DSL or, you know, whatever.

Tony MartignettiThat's right, that was the follow-on. Yes, okay, digital subscriber line, DSL.

Stephen TidmoreYes.

Tony MartignettiOh, that's interesting. Okay, so you got 8 questions to ask before you start a new website. Um, are these, are these internal questions that you should be asking before you go to maybe an outside provider? Because there Our listeners are small and mid-sized shops, so the likelihood of them having a development team, you know, is small. So, so let's assume they use outside help for this. Are these internal questions you're asking, or you're asking of the provider outside too?

Stephen TidmoreEither or. So, so the goal really of the 8 Questions presentation was to just to get people thinking about some of these questions that we ask typically on a web project. So we've been doing lots of projects, you know, for a long time, and so we've gotten better about identifying these questions we need to ask up front on the technical side to avoid some pitfalls that we've seen on a lot of projects over the years. And so these questions are questions that you may have to go to, you know, if you have an IT firm you work with, or if you have, you know, developers either in-house or partner, you know, partner agency like ourselves, or other developers you work with, contract developers, you may have to talk to them about it. But some of the questions aren't really that technical at all. You know, a lot of the things that seem technical at first may be organizational questions around content, whether you're going to migrate content, who's going to be in charge of publishing content. And some of those could have a technical answer, but oftentimes we found that there may be organizational processes in place that are causing some of the barriers more so than the technology itself. Yeah. People tend to blame the CMS for, you know, it's really hard to get content published on our website. And while the CMS could make that easier, most likely, um, you know, turning to a new CMS immediately to solve that problem probably isn't the first step. You need to figure out organizationally what you need to do in order to publish content and then find a CMS that fits, you know, that need, as opposed to trying to fit your process into something the CMS is going to force you into.

Tony MartignettiI've had other guests say the exact same thing as recently as earlier today.

Stephen TidmoreOh, really?

Tony MartignettiYou know, software is often blamed for lackluster leadership, poor processes, people not understanding what the limitations of the software are. So they look for something else that's going to have similar limitations, but they think it's going to be, you know, the grass is always greener and it's going to solve all their problems. And so it sounds like your 8 questions— let's get into your questions because it sounds like some of them are going to probe whether software, whether a new website is really going to solve the problems that you've got.

Stephen TidmoreYeah, I think just before you jump into those 8 questions, we— technology certainly can play a part and is to blame for a lot of issues, I think, in organizations. But the way, the way we look at it is we, we try to, you know, figure out your organizational goals, publishing goals, You know, technology goals, all that kind of, all that kind of thing first, and then find a technology solution that meets that, as opposed to just choosing a technology and trying to force your entire organization to use it when it— You know, you could build, like you said, a new website on a new content management system and still have the exact same problems if you haven't figured out what your goals are first for your organization and your, your visitors and, you know, your members or whatever else it is.

Tony MartignettiSo should we get into our questions, knowing— Yes. We just have a couple minutes to spend on each one. Let's do it. Where do you like to start? What's, what's our first?

Stephen TidmoreThe first question we had in the presentation was, do we need to migrate content? And if so, what content?

Tony MartignettiOkay, why is this important to know upfront?

Stephen TidmoreWell, so I've seen this come up on a lot of projects, is that people automatically assume oftentimes that all of their content is going to move one-to-one into a new website. They may say, okay, we want a new website, we want it to look different and perform different, but we want to just move all of our content over so we don't have to rewrite anything. And that often case, that doesn't happen most of the time.

Tony MartignettiIt doesn't work like that.

Stephen TidmoreThere may not be, you know, a one-to-one fit. So during our— we go through a fairly robust information architecture and discovery phase. And we don't want our information architects to be held back from architecting a page or an experience that meets your goals simply because they know they have this content that has to fit into the new architecture. And so you may end up with, you know, an events calendar that has new content on it that you have to go in and add. You may have to add categories or something like that so we can do fancy filtering and JavaScript filtering, or You know, the content may not need to exist anymore. So there is, you know, we see cases a lot where the it does make sense to migrate content, particularly with content that's already structured well, like press releases or blog posts. That kind of thing usually will have more or less a one-to-one fit. But there's lots of content that maybe it's just in one big WYSIWYG field, you know, which is a what you see is what you get. I'm sure you're familiar with that term, but it's just basically like a word. document your formatting inside a content management system. But now on the new site, there's a bunch of structured content for a team page that has like your title and your, um, the department you work under and your phone number and your email address. And so, you know, that content can't migrate easily. So it's something that we, we talk about way at the beginning and try to figure out, does it even make sense to migrate content or do we really need to kind of take a fresh look and enter content?

Tony MartignettiUm, like, uh, this is like moving your home. You know, changing homes. Maybe exactly bring everything you need to bring everything with you. You know, maybe, maybe you don't.

Stephen TidmoreOkay. Or you, yeah, you had 3 living rooms in your old house, so you have 3 sofas in your new house, you only have one. So what do we do with those? You're gonna try to shove them into the same one living room, or are you gonna get rid of them?

Tony MartignettiWhat's

Stephen Tidmorenext? The next question is about hosting, just where will the site be hosted? So there's some technical things you have to look at, and our recommendation was if you don't know the answer, to questions about just some, you know, basic questions about your, your analytics, hard drive space on your current web host, RAM, CPU, bandwidth, that you need to talk to either your web host or your IT vendor or someone to figure out those questions. But the important thing with hosting is that you want to make sure you don't take into account just your regular activity. You need to look for any traffic spikes, and maybe your organization once or twice a year puts out a controversial press release or something happens that just causes the traffic to jump up. You want to choose a web host that's robust enough to handle that traffic, but ideally you don't want to pay for all the resources to handle that traffic throughout the entire year. So, you know, you want to look for something that's scalable, ideally, where the resources can scale up. And the resources— you can think about it just like your computer, you know, you add more RAM or you add more hard drive space. You know, there's, there's web hosting setups where they can kind of automatically add those resources whenever the traffic increases. And that's a great solution, so you're not paying for that all the time. And then just make sure you're finding a host that supports the technology you're working with. You know, some hosts specialize in one type of technology versus another, so don't want to get stuck with a host that doesn't know your technology. And then if you are working with a web vendor, maybe someone who's building your website, then you need to make sure you have an agreement between that web vendor and your host about who's supporting which pieces of the website in the web hosting environment. You don't want to get into a situation where the site goes down and the web host says, talk to your website vendor, and the website vendor says, talk to the web host, and then no one looks at

Tony Martignettiit. Yeah, the finger pointing, right?

Stephen TidmoreYeah, so you want to work that out in advance.

Tony MartignettiAll right. It's very frustrating for the person in the middle.

Stephen TidmoreFor sure. Yeah, it's not their fault.

Tony MartignettiYou actually know who's lying and who's telling the truth, or both half right, you know. All right. What else?

Stephen TidmoreSo the third question, and I could go in deeper into hosting, but I'll probably— I'll just— we'll get to the rest.

Tony MartignettiYeah, no, we don't have time. We need Yeah, we only have a couple minutes to spend on each one. So,

Stephen Tidmoreokay, the 3rd question is, how does content get published? And this is one kind of like what I was talking about earlier, where you really first want to consider your organizational goals and your existing procedures for publishing that content first. One thing we recommend is just, just ask, is your content up to date and relevant now? And if it's not, then why is it? Is it really a limitation in the content management system or your technology, or is it an organizational issue that is causing that? So that's the first question, and oftentimes it is an organizational issue or content governance issue. And then we recommend you think pretty strongly about an approval workflow built into your content management system. What I mean by that is, do you want to force people to have to log into the CMS and then post content, and then— but they can't actually publish it? That goes to someone else to approve it. Maybe it goes to someone else after that to approve it, and then it gets published. Do you want to build that process into your CMS? Or do you want to leave that outside of the CMS? We have built sites before where it was a requirement to have an approval workflow built into the CMS, but then, you know, we find out halfway through the project that the person who's actually going to approve the content doesn't want to do it in the CMS. They want someone to email them and they want— they don't want to have to log in and manage that. So, you know, you don't want to get stuck paying for something or building in something that you don't need. Okay. As well as oftentimes, you know, nonprofit organizations and a lot of organizations, other organizations may have time-sensitive content that needs to get out there. And if you have a forced approval workflow and one person's the bottleneck and you have to post this content immediately and that person's out of the office, then that can cause issues where you've kind of roped yourself into not being able to publish timely content. And so those are just considerations we start talking about at the beginning of a project.

Tony MartignettiOkay.

Stephen TidmoreOkay. We also talk about, along with content, you know, you want to talk about in the future, at the beginning, if you're ever going to need multilingual content in the future, because you don't want to get stuck with a platform that makes that hard. So is your, is your website going to need to be translated into multiple languages? And if so, choose a platform now that makes that pretty similar. I mean, sorry, pretty simple.

Tony MartignettiMove us, move us to number 4, get us halfway home.

Stephen TidmoreWhat third-party systems you need to integrate with? And so this is a big technical question. Your website is most likely not an island. It is a part of an ecosystem that involves lots of other third-party tools. And this, these can be things like, you know, an event management system, a membership management system, a donor management system, a mailing list, you know, product, whatever that is, there's tons,

Tony Martignettiright?

Stephen TidmoreAnd all those have to be taken into account. And the first step really is just to sit down and make a list of every third-party system or tool that is going to interact with your website. And, you know, just think about how you handle lead forms and tracking code and social feeds and newsletter signups and events and payments and all that kind of thing, and just make a list. And then after you have that list, look at each of those and think about what type of integration do you need. And again, this may need a little bit of technical help from either someone outside or someone on your team. But there's There's, you know, sometimes people think it's going to be a complex integration where, oh, we have to integrate this third-party donor management system with our website, but really all you need is a link, or you need some piece of embed code that they give you, you know, for a donation form, and you just plop that embed code on. That's a pretty simple integration.

Tony MartignettiOkay.

Stephen TidmoreAnd then it can start to get more and more complex where, do you actually need to send data back and forth between these systems? Do you need to hire a developer to, you know, program how that's going to happen? Does your event system need to send data into your website so you can publish that in a different way? So third-party systems are a big part of our technology discoveries we do now.

Tony MartignettiThey are, right? There's a lot. I mean, all the things you ticked off— finance and events and, uh, uh, yeah, petitions and things. All right, all right.

Stephen TidmoreYeah, it can be a big list.

Tony MartignettiWhat's next?

Stephen TidmoreAnd then the 5th question is related. If you do have third-party systems, um, do any of those have websites that your visitors are going to interact with that need to be scanned? And by skinned, what I mean is that, you know, you can often customize a third-party site with design elements like logos or colors or graphics to make them match your brand, and we call that process skinning. And so you want to think about all the third-party websites that exist that someone, you know, your visitors, your website visitors, are going to need to interact with. If they can't interact with those, you want to see, can you skin that to make it match your Either your new or current website. And if so, great, you want to try to do that, but you want to figure out what the limits are. Some third-party sites may just allow you to change a color, some may allow you just to add a logo, some may give you full control over fonts and, you know, a bunch of styles. And if you can do that, then you need to figure out the responsibility. Is that something that third-party provider is going to handle? Is that something you have to handle? And when does that need to happen in your project process? So we start talking about Talking about that at the beginning, because you don't want to get to the end of a project and realize, oh, there's this major third-party website, and now it doesn't look anything like our new website. We're going to hold up launch so we can take the time to make that match.

Tony MartignettiOkay. We're 5/8 of the way through, and before we get to 3/4, I want to ask you about your 6-year journey around the world.

Stephen TidmoreYeah. What

Tony Martignettiwas that? You bought a one-way ticket to somewhere. Was it Portugal?

Stephen TidmoreUh, it was Spain. Yes. All right.

Tony MartignettiAnd so how does, uh, how does a, a technologist benefit from seeing other countries for 6 years?

Stephen TidmoreThat's a great question. I think, um, so I spent my last semester in college on this program called Semester at Sea, where I had the amazing opportunity of traveling around on a big ship around the world. And, um, After that, immediately I started working at Dell here in Austin, Texas, well, Round Rock technically, but Austin, and ended up working there for 3 years and really got a lot out of the experience. But I was kind of craving that travel again and got the travel bug. And I was young and didn't have a whole lot of responsibilities or things tying me here.

Tony MartignettiYeah.

Stephen TidmoreSo I bought a one-way ticket to Spain and quit my job and had saved up just a little bit of money. And that And that led to 6 years of kind of working my way around the world in various jobs. Lived in Spain for a while, lived in the British Virgin Islands, lived in Belize and Nicaragua, worked on some Native American reservations up in Montana, and bounced around Costa Rica a bunch and had an amazing time. I think the thing that it gave me, if we're kind of applying it to technology and more of a traditional working world, I think it's just perspective on, you know, how technology fits into the broader world. There, I think it's really easy to get stuck or hung up on something that maybe, you know, maybe isn't super important in the grand scheme of things, that maybe seems really important for a week or a day or two. Mm-hmm. And so I think I have a little bit better perspective on just the world as a whole and the importance of tasks that we end up working on. And I think just the opportunity to live in other cultures, I'd recommend it for anyone because it does give— well, it gave me, I'll say, just insight into how other people live and what's important to them. And, you know, I think I got a small taste of that, I would I wouldn't claim at all that I'm an expert in all those cultures that I lived in by any means, but just a small taste of how people around the world are different and ultimately how they're all similar and have the same needs.

Tony MartignettiYeah, thanks. Perspective. And it's a big world out there.

Stephen TidmoreIt is a big world.

Tony MartignettiYeah, we're not the center of the universe. I like to say that I am the center of the universe personally, but—

Stephen TidmoreRight.

Tony MartignettiBut our nation is not the center of the universe.

Stephen TidmoreOf your universe.

Tony MartignettiI could say it that way. Well, no, but I like to say the universe. I get carried away with some narcissism. We just have a couple of minutes left, so let's— do me a favor, let's do it this way. Just read off questions 6, 7, and 8, and then we'll come back and go into a little more detail.

Stephen TidmoreYeah, we can do them pretty quick. So I think question 6 is, are you going to need single sign-on? Question 7 is, how are you going to handle site search, so searching inside your website?

Tony MartignettiYeah.

Stephen TidmoreAnd then question 8 is what standards are you required to follow? Okay. So I can hit this pretty quickly. The single sign-on question is just basically— yeah, yep. Do we have time to do those?

Tony MartignettiYeah. Why do we need to know this in advance?

Stephen TidmoreYeah, so the single sign-on question is a big one. So do you have— do you already have a system that holds records for your members or visitors or whatever they are? that people currently sign into in order to manage their account or do something else? And if so, do people also need to sign into your, your either current website or new website in order to do something? Most of the time that will be something like gated content where content on your site is only available to members. Gotcha. And so if you have that, you have to have those member accounts that allow you to access that content. And if so, you need to know where those member accounts are stored. And so single sign-on basically is a configuration that can allow someone to sign on to multiple different websites or web applications without having to have different accounts for all of them. And there's some standard technologies that you can use that make that fairly easy, but you just, you just need to start by asking if you need it, and if so, do those member accounts exist anywhere now that you can hook into to allow your website to let people sign in to them using the same accounts? Okay. Site search could get— we could talk for a long time about site search, but, you know, the search on your website is super important. And you want to start by asking, you know, where does the data live? Is it in multiple systems? Do you need the site search engine to pull data from a third-party site as well as from your website? Do you need a search engine that's going to search through the content of files like PDF files? Do you need to have a search engine that indexes content that's only available to logged-in users or members? And if so, you know, you want to start thinking about search solutions. There's a lot of great third-party search solutions out there. That can do a lot of advanced things while at the same time giving non-technical users the ability to configure the search. You know, someone types in a certain search term, these— a lot of these third-party solutions have a dashboard where non-technical people can say, okay, with this search term, I want this result to appear at the top no matter what, and then the rest of them are ranked by relevance. Some of the third-party search solutions we've used that are great: Funnelback, Cludo, AdSearch and Swiftype are just a few I'd recommend looking into. They do have a cost, but they offer a fantastic solution.

Tony MartignettiAll right, so search is important. And then our last question.

Stephen TidmoreStandards. What standards are you required to follow? This is something you just want to find out up front. You may not have specific standards in your organization, especially if you're a smaller nonprofit, but you want to find out things like what browsers does your website need to be compatible with. You'll have to look at historical data to see, you know, are people still coming to your website using old browsers like Internet Explorer 11, or can you ditch that and and move on to more modern coding standards. Do you have any specific security requirements or policies in place? You know, maybe you do work with federal government and you have to adhere to their security standards. You want to know that upfront. And then privacy laws are pretty big now, as they should be. Things like HIPAA, which is the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act, or GDPR, which applies to EU citizens. Maybe you do some business with EU citizens, or the newer one here in the States is called the CCPA, the California Consumer Privacy Act. I'm not a lawyer. I won't get into the details of all of those, but you know, you want to find out upfront if you need to do anything different on your website to meet those standards. And then you want to think about accessibility from the get-go. So what accessibility standards do you need to follow? Most likely, you need to follow WCAG AA. And what that means is Basically, if you're not familiar, which I'm sure you probably are, but basically accessibility is making websites, tools, and technologies that people with disabilities can use. So anyone can use them regardless of their disability. And WCAG is a set of very accepted guidelines that define how you can make technology accessible, more or less at a high level. And there's a level in there called WCAG AA that the federal government points to now and most other organizations point to. And so you want to be thinking about that from the beginning. beginning of your project, because if you wait until the end to just run an automated scan, it's going to take a lot to get your website to be compatible with those guidelines if you're not thinking about it from the beginning.

Tony MartignettiWe have at least one session from NTC on accessibility.

Stephen TidmoreYeah, yeah, there were a number of them, which is great.

Tony MartignettiI mean the guidelines. Yeah,

Stephen Tidmoreyeah. And you cannot, you cannot say that your website meets WCAG AA standards just by running an automated scan. It's It won't— it's impossible for it to check all the guidelines, and so it requires manual testing. So you want to plan for that.

Tony MartignettiAll right, we're going to leave it there.

Stephen TidmoreGreat.

Tony MartignettiAll right, Stephen, thank you very much. He's Stephen Tidmore, Vice President of Technology at Mighty Citizen. Thank you, Stephen.

Stephen TidmoreThanks for your time. I appreciate it.

Tony MartignettiAll right, my pleasure. Thank you for being with Nonprofit Radio coverage of 21NTC.

Kate MartignettiNext week, Tony is working on it.

Tony MartignettiThat's true. I am. I swear.

Kate MartignettiIf you missed any part of this week's show,

Tony MartignettiI beseech you to find it at tonymartinetti.com.

Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by DonorBox. Outdated donation forms blocking your supporters' generosity this giving season? DonorBox, the fast, flexible, and friendly fundraising platform for nonprofits. donorbox.org. And by Keela. Grow revenue, engage donors, and increase efficiency with Keela, the fundraiser's CRM. Visit keela.co to join the thousands of fundraisers using Keela to exceed their goals. Our creative producer is Claire Meyerhoff. I'm your associate producer, Kate Martignetti. The show's social media is by Susan Chavez. Marc Silverman is our web guy, and this music is by Scott Stein.

Tony MartignettiThank you for that affirmation, Scotty. Be with us next week for Nonprofit Radio. Big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. Go out and be great.

Nonprofit Radio