Skip to content
EP 666November 13, 2023

Fundraising 401

Tony MartignettiLaurence Pagnoni
Nonprofit Radio
Episode 666
0:00 / 0:00

About this episode

That's Laurence Pagnoni's latest book. When this first aired, it was his new book, but Laurence’s strategies and tactics are timeless. It's a series of masterclasses for all levels and a collection of revelations he gained over 35 years in nonprofit management and fundraising. (This originally aired May 29, 2020.)

Here’s the transcript

Tony MartignettiHello and welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. I am your aptly named host and the podfather of your favorite hebdomadal podcast. Oh, I'm glad you're with us. I'd be hit with Wegener's granulomatosis if you pained me with the idea that you missed this week's show. Here's our associate producer Kate with the highlights.

Kate MartignettiHey Tony, this week it's Fundraising 401. That's Laurence Pagnoni's latest book. When this first aired, it was his new book. But Laurence's strategies and tactics are timeless. It's a series of masterclasses for all levels and a collection of revelations he gained over 35 years in nonprofit management and fundraising. This originally aired May 29th, 2020. On Tony's Take Two.

Tony MartignettiGo live and in person.

Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by DonorBox. Outdated donation forms blocking your supporters' generosity this giving season? DonorBox, the fast, flexible, and friendly fundraising platform for nonprofits. DonorBox.org. Here is Fundraising 401.

Tony MartignettiIt's a real pleasure to welcome back Laurence Pagnoni to Nonprofit Radio. He's got 35 years in the sector as executive director and fundraising counsel. His latest book published this year is Fundraising 401: Masterclasses in Nonprofit Fundraising That Would Make Peter Drucker Proud. The company is at lapafundraising.com and @lapafundraising. Welcome, LAP. If the firm was LAPA, you're LAP, right?

Laurence PagnoniYeah, we tripped upon the acronym, uh, years and years ago. Uh, we always used the full Laurence A. Pagnoni and Associates.

Tony MartignettiYes, I remember.

Laurence PagnoniOne day we, uh, just had written LAPA and they said, oh, that had good alliteration, we should use that.

Tony MartignettiOkay, so you went the way of, uh, AAA and, uh, and AARP. You know, they don't— you're not, you're not Laurence A. Pagnoni Associates anymore, you're, you're LAPA.

Laurence PagnoniThat's right.

Tony MartignettiOkay. All right. It's the, it's the 21st century now. All right.

Laurence PagnoniThere's also a mini lesson there for nonprofits about branding. Trying to get it right at the beginning is important, but good brand— the difference between good branding and great branding is the width of the Grand Canyon. And so I didn't ever want to venture into rebranding it without great counsel, which I've never been able to afford.

Tony MartignettiSo you stumbled on LAPA and we evolved, you know. Yes, it's proof that the greatness doesn't come out in the beginning. You can't plan all the greatness in the beginning. It has to, it has to organically come about. All

Laurence Pagnoniright.

Tony MartignettiSo it's been like 6 and a half years. You were on the— you were for your first book, The Nonprofit Fundraising Solution. You were on Nonprofit Radio on November 8th, 2013.

Laurence PagnoniWow.

Tony MartignettiWhen that book was new, 7 years ago. And now you're second. So let's, let's get into it. Why does, why does management consultant Peter Drucker belong in the title?

Laurence PagnoniAh, an homage to Peter Drucker, who taught me how to think. Well, I guess the Jesuits would take the first bow for that, but Peter Drucker— I was a Peter Drucker Fellow in the 1990s here in New York City. And it was Peter who taught me how to integrate fundraising into organizational development. Besides just being a great human being, he was a brilliant strategist and thinker. He, of course, wrote the original book on re-engineering General Motors. And— But he spent the last years of his life focused on the, what he called the higher profit sector, what we call the nonprofit sector, but he, he thought that if there wasn't a coalescing of the nonprofit sector's values with the business sector, that society would be deficient for, for that not happening. So, Actually, when I started writing this book, um, I didn't realize the degree to which Druckerian thinking had dominated my own thinking. And it was about a dozen chapters in that my editor said, you use Drucker an awful lot. I said, tell me how many times. And then I was like astounded and And then I added that little homage to him.

Tony MartignettiAnd Drucker had the book Managing the Nonprofit Organization. So he was committed to the sector, to what he called— what did he call it? The higher profit? Is that what he called it? The higher profit?

Laurence PagnoniHigher profit sector, yes. Peter Drucker.

Tony MartignettiThere it is.

Laurence PagnoniManaging the Nonprofit Organization. It's been on my desk since 1991, I think. And I read and reread it, as I hope you will do my book. Fundraising 401, uh, coming forward.

Tony MartignettiYes, I've, and I've replayed, uh, your show on the, on the first book, uh, 3 times since, uh, 2013. So I'm— I, I

Laurence Pagnonimean,

Tony Martignettiit's a, it's a go-to for— still is for people who ask me, how do I get to the next level? I get that question every, I don't know, maybe a couple times a month, maybe not that often sometimes, but I recommend the book for how to get to the next level. It's a, it's a It's a very systematic and sensible approach.

Laurence PagnoniThe fundraising— the Nonprofit Fundraising Solution was the prose of fundraising, but Fundraising 401 is really the poetry. It's more the art of fundraising, whereas the other one was the science.

Tony MartignettiYeah, you say that, and there's— you talk about the art and the science in one of your chapters, but you talk about growing into answers. And moving to a better set of problems, which both of which sound artistic. Talk about that, growing into answers and better set of problems.

Laurence PagnoniWell, oftentimes nonprofits, there, there, there's not enough room in scope of service. You know, you hire a fundraiser to fundraise and you define a scope of service. But a really advanced fundraising system, once it gets going, it has to look carefully at what the donors are saying, what the institutional funders are saying, what is working in social media and what's not. For one of our large clients connected with Johns Hopkins University, They weren't able to raise any money online, and we changed the way they approach social media, and within the first year they had an extra $100,000 from their social media program. So figuring out as you go along more efficient ways and building that creativity in is, is very important. And And defining it too rigidly shuts that down.

Tony MartignettiI did like A Better Set of Problems. You know, you tell an anecdote, you, you, for some reason a board was getting involved in whether to buy a fax machine. Let's not get into whether a board should even be deciding whether to buy a fax machine, but you know, you just went out and bought the damn thing yourself. And so now the fax machine is not communicating with our donors. Back when fax— this was many years ago— now communicating with our donors and our funders is not a problem. So that, that was for me, that was okay, better set of problems. Let's not deal with the damn fax machine. I'll buy it. And now let's deal with communications.

Laurence PagnoniRight. But here's a, here's a more sophisticated, better set of problems. Let's say right now you don't know who your monthly donors are or your planned donors are. And you do research to figure out— maybe a lot of nonprofits don't know the date of birth of their donors. So let's say you do research and you integrate just the date of birth into your donor database and you're able to segment. You know, suddenly you discover, as, as is the case with one of our clients, and I remember your rule about the difference between active and a Passive planned giving program, they discovered they had 750 people over age 65. They were, they were not aware of that until they had their date of birth. And so now they have a better set of problems. They're able to think about planned giving because they know they have a donor segment that is, that matches that. So that is my definition of organizational growth to But a lot of, of, of us, we have the same problem over and over again, and that is being stuck. And I wrote this book to tease out ways to get unstuck and to try some new things within your thinking first and foremost. This is a book about how to think about fundraising.

Tony MartignettiA series of revelations.

Laurence PagnoniA series of revelations.

Tony MartignettiSo what— so we'll talk about a bunch of them. You, you talk about Fundraising as analogized to dating, dating relationships. Yeah, say a little about that.

Laurence PagnoniSure. So when 2 people meet, they have to learn what the other person's up for. They have to learn their values, their mutual sexual attraction, their ability to work on and solve problems together. Now, absent the mutual sexual attraction, the same applies to getting to know your donors, putting your donors first, listening to your funders, pushing back a little bit with your funders about what your real needs are, having conversations that are thoughtful. And so getting to know The, the revenue streams that you're working through is just similar to dating but without the sexual romantic energy.

Tony MartignettiListening. Listening is critical.

Laurence PagnoniYou

Tony Martignettimentioned listening.

Laurence PagnoniAnd, and if you're not sympathetic— simpatico— if you're not simpatico, like one donor who Who I was trying to get a 6-figure gift from for a teenage pregnancy prevention program. I've been telling this story for years, so pardon if you've heard it, but it was such a rich experience for me. You know, right early in the conversation he said, you know, I don't believe teenagers should be having sex. And I just let the silence sit there. Of course, inside myself I'm thinking, oh God, you know.

Tony MartignettiYeah, you're seething.

Laurence PagnoniI just lost the gift, but I, I just listened in a posture of tell me more. And then he said— and that's honest to Pete, Tony— about 2 minutes must have passed. I, I really was starting to sweat a little bit. And then he said, but I thought that's not the situation and that the clients you serve need the kind of program that your agency is recommending. So let's talk about how that would work. And so he was up for it, but he was starting from a place of his own, you know, position, but showing flexibility about thinking. So he was up for the dating relationship.

Tony MartignettiWell, well, maybe it was a one-night stand, but that— you have that, you have that story in the book, and he ended up giving $25,000. Right, because you were, you were a good listener. So maybe that was a one-time gift. So I analogize—

Laurence PagnoniNo, no, he gave for 3 years.

Tony MartignettiHe did? All right, all right. So it was a short-term relationship. All right, all right. Um, our product, our product is impact. What's that about?

Laurence PagnoniWell, too many people confuse that they're giving to your nonprofit, you know, the Bread for the World or Partners in Health or whatever the name of the nonprofit is. Donors don't give to your nonprofit. They give for the mission and the impact. And, and you have to be clear about, you know, with your gift, we'll be able to have more of an impact. Here's the impact we've had. Here's the aspirational impact that we're looking for. Bill Shore from Share Our Strength has been a real role model in the nonprofit sector for talking about the real overhead costs that we should be advocating for to really get the job done. He asked the provocative question, if— would you be satisfied if my overhead were 5%, but I didn't feed all the hungry people? Right. that came to me versus if it was 35% and I did feed them all, which would you prefer? And that, that is a good question. And you could— each agency could have their version of that to talk about aspirational goals. And, and, and, and if— because if you don't define them, no one, no one else is. Yeah.

Tony MartignettiAnd you talk about the importance of measuring impact. Yes. Knowing what your return on investment is, your ROI, and communicating, sharing that. It's critical.

Laurence PagnoniYes. So having not just an evaluation program that complies with the funder's requirements, as so many government contracts do, but having an evaluation program that Helps the staff make management decisions about what programs are working and what are not. When I was the nonprofit CEO of Harlem United for 6 years, our data showed us that our substance abuse case management program did okay. But what really kept people in sobriety was our pastoral counseling and pastoral care program. Mm-hmm. Because the clients— it was, it was non-denominational, it was a healing experience, and it had twice the amount of sobriety retention as our substance abuse counseling program did. If we hadn't been looking at the data, we wouldn't have known that. And so we took that news to religious-oriented funders and hired 3 more pastoral counselors. And built a partnership with Hospital Chaplaincy, Inc., who trains pastoral counselors. And we had, we had a strong spike in sobriety amongst our clients. It was really quite beautiful. And it's lasted for years.

Tony MartignettiAll from understanding what your data is revealing, what your true impact is.

Kate MartignettiIt's time for a break. Are you looking to maximize your fundraising efforts and impact this giving season? DonorBox's online donation platform is designed to help you reach your fundraising goals. From customizable donation forms to far-reaching EasyShare crowdfunding and peer-to-peer options, plus seamless in-person giving. With DonorBox Live Kiosk. DonorBox makes giving simple and fast for your donors and moves the needle on your mission. Visit donorbox.org and let DonorBox help you help others. Now back to Fundraising 401.

Tony MartignettiYou mentioned staff. Um, we're jumping around a little bit, but, uh, I— you, you highlight that, uh, You used to think that clients should come first, but now you feel it's staff should come first. Retention strategies, professional development. I don't know if you mentioned mentoring, but that always comes up. You know, talk about investments and investments that are— that need to be made in staff and why you think staff is number one now.

Laurence PagnoniBoy, have I come a long way as a As an advocate for the poor from being a teenager, when I worked in a— volunteered in a soup kitchen myself, thanks to my good old Teamster Union dad, I never wavered from, you know, clients first. And— But it's not that I'm saying clients take a back seat. I'm saying that if we make staff primary clients will be better served. Mm-hmm. Staff retention at nonprofits is alarming, and worse yet, younger generations leave the sector faster than our generation, those of us in, in our 50s. They leave the, the sector faster Because they have a bad experience with a board or the, the poor compensation is not livable for their family. So, but it's not just about the conditions of employment. It's also about, is the nonprofit a learning environment, a learning organization? Here at LAPA Fundraising, we have just half a dozen shared values within our firm, and professional development and advancement is, is one of them. And we pay every year, every staff person has a professional development plan.

Tony MartignettiRight.

Laurence PagnoniAnd we pay for it, and we're happy to do it because people, our staff, will tell you, you know, we aspire, whether we succeed at it, Completely, I don't. You'd have to ask them, but we aspire to be a learning organization—not just learning on our accounts, but learning from best practices in the field and colleagues. We bring colleagues in. We're big into what's called the Enneagram in our workplace. It's an it's a it's an emotional intelligence system for the workplace that. That helps people understand how their— our clients are viewing the world, how they're built. And the enneagram.institute.org, I believe, um, would introduce you to it. It has some videos there.

Tony MartignettiSo we need to overcome, leave behind this idea that, uh, professional development technology to support staff, you know, that these are luxuries. You know, we— being a couple of operating systems behind is okay because it's more important that we spend our money on the, on the people or the programs. You know, that's, that's, that's outdated thinking. Yeah. And, and what we're seeing in terms of younger folks leaving the sector Is, is bearing out that— bearing that out. That's evidence that we're not providing what they're looking for. So they try one or two jobs and then they leave. That's, that's not— talk about not sustainable.

Laurence PagnoniI could just hear some of your audience members saying, ask Laurence to tell me where to find money for technology improvements or Or professional development.

Tony MartignettiAll right, well, good. You're channeling the audience like I do. So ask the answer, answer them.

Laurence PagnoniIt's hard. I know what, what we do is we build it into our overhead rate. And where we can, we try to get— so many nonprofits have such a low overhead rate. And that's again, back what Bill Shore was talking about. Some government contracts actually curb you at 10%, and most nonprofits have an overhead rate at least at 23%, 24%, and arguably it should be probably closer to 35%. Right. I think all the major universities are somewhere north of 50% overhead. So trying to get it into your overhead, and then of course looking for more general operating support. By identifying donor advised funds, which by definition, as you know, Tony, are hidden. There are profiles you could use to assume that somebody probably has a donor advised fund. We do that in our prospect research. And then of course we ask directly when we're talking to them or surveying them. So people who have donor advised funds are very friendly to, you know, odd costs, or what, you know, what the— as contrasted to institutional funders where you get a grant for your program. Sometimes in those grants you can add a computer, you can say we need, you know, 40 hours of professional development. So integrating it into all your fundraising and into your overhead rate has worked With many of our clients. And then of course there's rare occasions when an RFP is issued where you can ask for things like that.

Tony MartignettiMm-hmm. You did some work with sterile needle exchange. Just talk about that a little bit. That sounds like a good story.

Laurence PagnoniYeah, harm reduction. Again, a better set of problems. It's better to have needle— needle users use clean needles than to have them keep using dirty needles because it reduces the spread of HIV and STDs and bloodborne infections. So that's a better— harm reduction is a better set of problems with science behind it. And this is true not in the— just in the United States, but in all throughout the world and European countries who have harm reduction policies. Harm reduction is still needed. It's, it's kind of fallen out of fashion. There's just a handful, maybe 2 or 3 funders who are interested in it. The drug Policy Alliance is still interested in it. And the Comer Foundation, if they're still around.

Tony MartignettiWhat was, what was your work in harm reduction?

Laurence PagnoniAh, well, I had, I helped the New York harm reduction educators in the Bronx form a hotline so that people could reach them. And We went to check cashing stores where the poor— the poor in the Bronx generally don't use a bank. They pay to have their check cashed, which is a scandal unto itself. But—

Tony MartignettiYeah, it's exorbitant.

Laurence PagnoniIf we would expand the United States Postal Services to what it was in the 1950s, they, they wouldn't have, have that. There's a direct link between the reduction of the role of the U.S. Postal Service in its role with money orders and check cashing and the upswing of these for-profit sleazy check cashing places.

Tony MartignettiOh, interesting. All right. Well, we're—

Laurence PagnoniBut anyway, we went to the check cashing places and asked— we paid them, we had to pay them when they cashed a check to put our business card for the the New York Harm Reduction Educators with the 1-800 number on. And we saw on average 800 new enrollees into the nonprofit to get access to HIV prevention and treatment services.

Tony MartignettiYeah, I did, I did work in Philadelphia when I was in law school with an organization called Prevention Point Philadelphia. It was a, it was a grassroots sterile needle exchange. Excuse me. They were going to parks in areas where they knew drug activity was high on weekends and literally distributing marked sterile needles, marked so that they knew when they got their own back, so they could— they had some— they had a measure of effectiveness, how many sterile needles were coming back and how many unmarked needles, so dirty needles, they were getting off the streets. And that was incredibly rewarding. It was an internship, but just to see the, the fathers walk up or drive up with a, with a young child in tow and, you know, taking half a dozen needles and giving us half a dozen, you know. But I know the statistics are there that it reduces, and this was 1989, 1990. You know, HIV was much more dangerous than, than it is now.

Laurence PagnoniAnd here you see in our— in the conversation right now between Tony and I, how a fundraiser discovers his or her product to sell. This is what fundraisers do at the highest level. We listen to the caseworkers, to the clients, To the statistics, to the best practice studies. For example, with an affordable housing program that I'm starting to work with in Orlando, Florida, the executive director was blown away because the first thing we've— we're starting to do is we've read 10 years worth of completely boring but totally relevant thinking from the the Orlando Housing Authority about their needs assessments. They do them, they're required to do them every 10 years. And those documents are chock-full with, with really good data. I mean, that's something to be proud of in our country is we still have some semblance of these local civic governments that are doing their due diligence about community need. But this is how fundraisers then get a very powerful case for support developed, and that's why there's a chapter about impact and the, the product is your program and its impact.

Kate MartignettiIt's time for Tony's Take Two.

Tony MartignettiThank you, Kate. This week I was at a live, in-person, face-to-face, in-real-life conference in Oklahoma City. It was hosted by the Sarkis Foundation, which funds Oklahoma nonprofits. The joy of getting back in person That's really what I want to focus on. It's just so good to shake hands and to be able to have conversations without a little Zoom or Teams delay, you know, that lag time that prevents you from sometimes getting something in, you know, that just needs special timing. You know, you end up biting your tongue because it's not going to sound right and you have to explain what you were saying and then If you have to explain something, it doesn't make any sense. You shouldn't even bother doing it if you got to explain what it was supposed to mean on the virtual platforms. But in person, the conversations are just easier. They're more personable. I can shake hands. I can hug somebody that I haven't seen for a long time. Or even I made some new friends. I made friends on the first day of the conference. It was a 2-day conference. When it was over the next day, I was hugging people to say goodbye. That's what I want to celebrate. The joy of being in person, in real life, face-to-face, whatever you call it. Zoom and their ilk are distant, distant second-place runners to being in person. Yeah. There's nothing like it. Nothing even comes close. So if you have opportunities in the coming year to go to something in person, I hope you'll do it. I hope you'll take the extra time and the extra money and do it. It makes a big, big difference. It's a so much— it's a so much more joyous occasion. To be in person, even at a conference. I'm not even talking about a party. It's a conference. Please, I hope you'll take the opportunities that you get to be in person. That is Tony's Take Two. Kate.

Kate MartignettiNot only are we in person, but we don't have those masks hiding our face anymore. We can see people and see their emotions and their feelings and really connect more without like a piece of cloth on our mouth. I mean, of course, we have to stay safe at that time. But like, when I was in school for 2 years, I didn't see my best friend's face until we were graduating. Like a whole 2 years, I never saw their face. And then I finally saw them and who they are as a person. So yay, in person.

Tony MartignettiAll right. You know, I agree.

Kate MartignettiWe've got beaucoup buttloads more time. Now back to Fundraising 401 with Laurence Pagnoni.

Tony MartignettiYou talk about the donor as hero. What, uh, what are you thinking there?

Laurence PagnoniWell, uh,

Tony Martignettiall right, share your thinking because I know what you're thinking because I read your, I read your book. So listen, you just got to get the book if you want to flesh out the Sure. Laurence will introduce you to his thinking as donors as heroes.

Laurence PagnoniSo many appeal letters or annual reports or newsletters, they make the client the hero. There's, there's wisdom to that. They make the organization itself the hero. But in fundraising, the donor is the hero. And I grew up in a nonprofit sector that ignored The ascent— they ignored the donor. The essential message to the donor for most of my life has been give and shut up. But today's donor wants to be heard. They want to be acknowledged. They will give more. They will become more involved. It was Terry Axelrod, the founder of the Benevon model of fundraising, that started to give me a hint that donors wanted to be engaged, and then the data bore that out. I started to take on clients who would tell me, oh, we could never ask our volunteers for money. I haven't heard that question in the past 5 years or so. Better set of problems. I think I think people are more convinced that they realize their donors want to give. And hello out there, if you think your— if you still think your donors, your volunteers don't want

Tony Martignettito

Laurence Pagnonigive, please evaluate that. Read my book and evaluate that because your volunteers want to give.

Tony MartignettiYou, uh, one little quote you say as you're writing, you know, as you're writing to your donors Tell the story as if the donor were sitting before you over a cup of coffee. You suggest, you know, see their smile, speak their name. You make it a conversation. You know, this idea of stilted language, you have to fill an 8.5 by 11 page sheet of paper, you know, maybe sometimes you do, but if you don't need to, then don't. Handwriting. Handwritten solicitations can be probably more sincere than something you produce on Word and feel constrained to, compelled to fill a page around. So, you know, get close and talk to people like you would like to be talked to.

Laurence PagnoniI learned from Tom Ahern about some of the nuances about making the donor the hero, and it actually influenced My book cover, uh, you could see, you know, Laurence is holding his book.

Tony MartignettiFor those listening, Laurence is holding up his book cover. Okay.

Laurence PagnoniGoing below, there's a hook with a dollar sign going below the surface of the water, because the point is to raise the big money, you have to think more deeply about fundraising and what's motivating the donor. Um, but, uh, we start making the case Right on the COVID of a newsletter or a case for support. We recently did a case for support for an animal welfare agency where we put a picture of the cutest cat on one case and the cutest dog on the other with their owners who had just adopted them holding them.

Tony MartignettiYeah.

Laurence PagnoniBut right underneath it, we put the question, how can we ever say no? So we're, we're saying to the donor—

Tony MartignettiIt wasn't— how can you, how can you say no? Isn't it?

Laurence PagnoniYou ever say no?

Tony MartignettiYeah, right. How can you say no?

Laurence PagnoniYou ever say—

Tony Martignettigotta get the you, you gotta get the you and yours in there.

Laurence PagnoniGotta get the you in there.

Tony MartignettiOkay. See, I read the book. You, you missed the— you blew the whole— the whole point is you got to have the you in there, not how can we, how can you. All right.

Laurence PagnoniSorry.

Tony MartignettiUm, Um,

Laurence Pagnoniyou, yours, it's all about you.

Tony MartignettiYes, using yours. I know Tom Ahern stresses that. He even has a calculator on, on the web somewhere. It might be ahern.com or something where you can put your text in and it'll evaluate how many yous you have versus how many wees or something like that,

Laurence Pagnoniright?

Tony MartignettiUm, but I'm constantly, I'm constantly rewriting, you know, the— can we change the to you? The donor, you, you, your donors. I mean, as I'm writing to clients Instead of the donors, your donors. You know, you're talking now to the— in the second person instead of the abstract third person, the donor. That could be anybody's donors. No, we're talking about your donors, your donor. That's just not in the abstract. I think it brings— it makes it more concrete than using that second person.

Laurence PagnoniYeah, and it also— it's not just a linguistic shift. There's research science behind it. psychology science— psychological sciences behind it that the donors feel like, oh, he really is talking about me. And, and so we raise more money with that approach.

Tony MartignettiBy the way, did I, did I mispronounce your name when I introduced you?

Laurence PagnoniNo, you always get it right.

Tony MartignettiI didn't. Oh, I had hoped that I had mispronounced your name. Because I had hoped that by now, 6 and a half years later, you had changed the pronunciation to Pagnoni. Why are you still defacing your beautiful Italian name with Pagni?

Laurence PagnoniIt's worse than that. The whole name on the birth certificate is Lorenzo Antonio Pagnoni.

Tony MartignettiYes, Pagnoni. Why are you still—

Laurence PagnoniIt's like a little dirty opera, you know.

Tony MartignettiI know. You, you, in 2013, you mentioned your grandmother.

Laurence PagnoniYeah, it was my grandmother's, uh, She loved the opera and that she'd tell me that all the time. Your name's a little opera.

Tony MartignettiI would rather you take the G out and make it Pagnoni or switch it to panini or something, please. But you're, you're, you're killing the beautiful pronunciation. Pagnoni. All right.

Laurence PagnoniI'll try, Tony. I promise to try.

Tony MartignettiAll right. It's worth, it's worth the investment. It's worth the investment in changing the pronunciation. Not the spelling, just the pronunciation. People will still be able to find you on the web. All right, you say all donors are major donors, and following from that, all gifts are major gifts. Why is that? To me, you know, we're stratifying. We have our modest donors, which, because we're too afraid to call them small donors, so we say they're modest, and then we have our mid-level and then major and then, you know, maybe ultra. But you say all, all donors are major donors.

Laurence PagnoniYes, because nobody has to give a dime to you. Nobody has to give their hard-earned money to you. Nobody has to. And because of that, they all should be treated in a major way. Now, of course, in, in the systems of fundraising, we might have automation in place I hope it's thoughtful automation for donors who are, you know, from $1 to say $5,000. For major donors or transformational donors at the higher levels, you know, we have more personal touch. It's expensive. Major gift officers who know what they're doing are— have come at a higher salary because their skills are honed over years. And they know how to deeply listen and use the data to ask for transformational gifts, multi-year gifts, legacy gifts. But, but, but I'm trying to convey that we shouldn't take any dollar, no matter the size amount, for granted, that, that they don't have to give. And people are giving, you know, Jesus pointed out in scripture The widow's mite was greater than the Pharisee's giving because she gave from her heart and she gave from her want. And so I had to learn again, just like with professional development, I had to learn this the hard way. My development— I bellyached about a donor giving less than I thought he could have. Hmm. My development director quietly closed the door, sat down with that white flustered look on his face like, Laurence, Jesus, Mother of God, you know, what am I going to do with you? You're supposed to be our leader. And he said to me, Laurence, every gift is a major one, and he didn't have to give that gift. And that's a real story. And I went silent and I thought about it and I thought, you know, that's That's damn true.

Tony MartignettiYeah.

Laurence PagnoniEventually that donor, because of the way my development director treated him so kingly, he did give at much higher levels later on. But nobody has to give us a dime.

Tony MartignettiThe Jesuits would be proud of you. Still quoting scripture. That influence, that's with you forever, I'm sure.

Laurence PagnoniYeah.

Tony MartignettiSomething else you— seems provocative that you One of the things you devote a chapter to is revenue diversification. You, you tell us it's overrated. Flesh that out, would you?

Laurence PagnoniFor smaller organizations, diverse revenue diversification is really essential. I'm not naive about that, but it's expensive to do well. Most smaller organizations barely have a Well, the profile of most organizations is that they don't even have a development office. They, they have the program director and the executive director, you know, writes the grants or manages the gala. They might bring in a gala event consultant. But, um, when, when Stanford University did a study of I think it was 130 major nonprofits who had gotten over $50 million annual revenues. They discovered that diversification of revenue went down, and that study was a seminal piece of research that changed our thinking about diversification. So as a nonprofit grows to a better set of problems, Um, uh, its revenue streams should become deeper, not wider. And deeper, deeper in what's—

Tony Martignettideeper in what's most successful.

Laurence PagnoniThat's right, and most lucrative. Uh, for example, Habitat for Humanity, they started with, um, in-kind donations as their biggest source of revenue that they Stuff that they needed for the houses that they were building. Good stuff, not just, you know, poor quality stuff.

Tony MartignettiYeah.

Laurence PagnoniBut then they realized that the people who donated that stuff were willing to donate. And so they started an individual donor program that eventually grew as they did donor research to major, major gift program. And they went deeper and deeper into that source of revenue, individual giving. They, they formed monthly giving. They formed eventually online giving. They, they formed legacy societies. So within each revenue stream, you can create enormous depth. And instead of expanding outside, could Habitat have taken government monies, probably. Some of them eventually did in localities that where the local government said, hey, we want to help because this is part of our community development program. And so they got some.

Tony MartignettiThis is also an example of where you need to invest in staff. You know, if you want to, if you want to go deeper in the, in the, in the channel, the fundraising method that's, that's most lucrative for you, you're gonna have to do it with, with a professional who's got an experience— who's got experience in that, in that channel and maybe others as well. But, you know, it can't continually be the executive director trying to deepen fundraising in the most— from the most lucrative source and manage the organization, oversee the programs, ensure compliance. I mean, this is where you have to invest if you want to be among those few charities that gets to the whatever $50 or $55 million level. You know, it's doable, but you need to invest in growth.

Laurence PagnoniWhen I last talked to you in 2013, our firm talked a good game about prospect research services, and we did, we did deliver some services, but we got honest with ourselves that we had to invest 7 years later, we have, you know, a 6-person team. Mm-hmm. And when we do donor research now, we find— I mean, we found 108,000 new donors, value-aligned donors for Lutheran Social Services. We found 8,000 new donors for the food bank in New Jersey. We found 42 new board member candidates for St. Christopher's Inn in Garrison, New York. I mean, our donor research—

Tony MartignettiAll from investing in prospect research?

Laurence PagnoniYeah. And also the field itself has matured and developed. And it's not just about the data, it's about using, how to use the data. When you marry the data vendors with a trained fundraiser, that's where you have the alchemy.

Tony MartignettiAnd you have a whole— you have a chapter devoted to not underfunding advancement or development. You know, it's called development for a reason. You make the point, you know, it needs to grow, and if you're gonna grow it, you got to invest in it. So don't underfund your development.

Laurence PagnoniAnd by the way, I just gave you the tip for my The book, the next book, How to Find New Donors, which will be out sometime in 2021.

Tony MartignettiAre you doing a prospect research book?

Laurence PagnoniYeah. Interesting you call it that. I'm not sure. It's funny. I'm professionally, I'm a fundraiser. I'm not a prospect researcher.

Tony MartignettiYeah.

Laurence PagnoniAnd I use the tools. I know good prospect researchers. Obviously, we have them here at the I, and I know I'm not one of them, but I'm a fundraiser who uses the data. So that's what the book's about. It's a nuance, maybe a distinction without a difference, but, but there are very wonky, very good prospect research books out there that I couldn't possibly write.

Tony MartignettiOkay, okay. Let's, um, I still have some other things I want to cover with you. We got like another 10 minutes or so left, but Let me throw to you. What, what do you, what do you want to talk about from the book?

Laurence PagnoniWell, right off, I'd like to invite the reader to, to, to actually read it. I talked to a lot of fundraisers, and I'm not convinced—

Tony MartignettiThat sounds like— I think that's sound advice for a book, a book author.

Laurence PagnoniYeah, it can't be assumed.

Tony MartignettiMy book, for God's sake.

Laurence PagnoniWell, I actually learned this from a terrific fundraiser who headed up the Heyman Institute at New York University.

Tony MartignettiYeah,

Laurence PagnoniNaomi Levine.

Tony MartignettiYeah, I had her on the show years ago.

Laurence PagnoniYes, I remember Naomi, you know, kicked my butt around Lawrence. You know, you have to read not just in our field extensively, but you have to read In the field of economics, in the field of sociology, in the field of, of science, because the donors are expert in those fields. I remember going into a meeting with an engineer on a planned gift, and he mentioned something that I had read because of Naomi's suggestion about the field of, of environmental engineering. And I said to him, you know, I know enough to be dangerous, but Are you talking about, you know, corrosive engineering protection? And his eyes lit up and said, how the hell did you know that?

Tony MartignettiAnd where'd you learn those words, that phrase corrosive engineering protection?

Laurence PagnoniAnd there's affinity. And this is our job as fundraisers. This is why it's an amazing field. You never are— you could— if you're bored as a fundraiser, holy cow, you read my book and find out You know, a way to become on board. But my point, Tony, is that so many fundraisers are staid. They're kind of— they know what they know. I could tell you at this time in my life more about what I don't know about fundraising than what I know about it and why I surround myself with good thinkers myself. And I've been told that this book— and this is my second point— Is, is, is both helpful for somebody advanced in fundraising like yourself, and it's also helpful for people who are new or mid-career, that it's a very approachable book, primarily because I tell stories that are based in reality, and I then give the, the more advanced theory behind it.

Tony MartignettiYeah, so I agree. It is. It is.

Laurence PagnoniYou found that to be the case.

Tony MartignettiIt is approachable, yeah. It's my turn again now. So you, you, you have advice for CEO decision-making and also CEO as fundraiser. So I want to, I want to put those 2 together and, and explore what, what decisions about fundraising are appropriate at the CEO level. Yeah.

Laurence PagnoniYeah. So knowing the plan and understanding the plan of how to move to a better set of problems. Do you have the same fundraising dilemma year in and year out? That's the CEO's job to kick the board's butt and the development team's butt because so many fundraising programs have the same problem year in and year out. Yeah. That means it's stuck, and, and that's primarily on the shoulders of the CEO. The underfunding of the development team, that's on the shoulders of the CEO. The CEO has to find the revenue to fund the capacity to pay for development. And I offer many on my blog at lapofundraising.com. I offer, you know, thousands of suggestions about how to pay for fundraising. Um, and, um, so there's 2 examples. A 3rd example I'd give of the CEO's job in fundraising is that they have to, uh, um, box the ears or guide, uh, the boards. Did you say box? Box the ears.

Tony MartignettiYeah, box the ears of or guide. Okay.

Laurence PagnoniOr guide. Let's stay with guide.

Tony MartignettiAll right, choose, choose somewhere in that spectrum.

Laurence PagnoniSomewhere in that spectrum. They have to guide the board's way to think about fundraising because boards who know nothing about fundraising are sitting there in judgment of professional fundraisers who have, you know, 25 years of experience. There's— they wouldn't do that to the program director. Some of them do, but that's another set of problems. They would— they generally don't do it to their attorneys. They wouldn't do— they certainly don't do it to their auditors, but they feel free to do it to their fundraisers.

Tony MartignettiYeah, things they would never do in their own business, they, they do routinely, some boards, you know, to, to the CEO and the program staff of the board who's— the nonprofit whose boards they sit on. And you talk about a heavy lifting board. We've got to have a heavy lifting board.

Laurence PagnoniYes, governance is a thing. Governance is not for every volunteer. It's— governance is not just for the person who likes your mission or whose son or daughter benefited from, from your mission. Governance is a business proposition that the nonprofit sector has designed, and it has roles and responsibilities for Not just fiduciary roles, but for long-range planning. It's the job of the executive team to think about the next 3 years, but it's the job of the board to think about the next 5 to 10 years.

Tony Martignetti10 years, yeah.

Laurence PagnoniAnd most boards never really think about the long-term plan. Now, you know, planning in this day and age is— is it anachronistic? I don't think it is, but I'm a little bit old-fashioned, but I think plans should be nimble and change, but you should still have a long-range plan about what you want to look like in 5 to 10 years.

Tony MartignettiYeah, that heavy lifting board. And in terms of fundraising as well, and you make the point that campaigns can be a very good, very good vehicle for recycling board or, you know, replacing board members that aren't, that aren't heavy lifting. You know, maybe there's an advisory council they can go on or some kind of emeritus status so that they're not embarrassed but still engaged, but, but they're not, but they're not a fiduciary any longer with those obligations. And so, all right, we have just like a minute or so left. Leave us, leave us with something, but do it concisely, please.

Laurence PagnoniUh, We're in the middle of, as you and I record this, we're in the middle of COVID-19 pandemic. The nonprofits that are raising more money through this pandemic are the ones with a deep culture of philanthropy, and that culture of philanthropy is defined by resiliency, resilience. If you're serious about the next pandemic or about your own viability in the future, the 23 chapters of this book will deepen your culture of philanthropy so that you're more prepared for the future. If you're assessing yourself right now as that you were not ready for this pandemic, do not beat yourself up, but take it as a wake-up call. To start getting ready for the economic crisis that we're going to be living through for the next couple of years, and for the very much needed reform of our healthcare system so that the, the poor and communities of color are better served than what we're seeing in COVID-19. And so that's a real reason to read this right now. Tony, you and I have lived through many crises, and COVID-19 certainly has its own characteristics that are unique, but there are always crises that we face, and we have to be more resilient with a deeper culture of philanthropy, and Fundraising 401 will help you get there.

Tony MartignettiThat's the book, Fundraising 401: Master Classes in Nonprofit Fundraising that would make Peter Drucker proud. He's Laurence A. Pagnoni, LAP. Laurence, thank you very, very much.

Kate MartignettiNext week, Your Case for Support with Phoebe Volath. If you missed any part of this week's show,

Tony MartignettiI do beseech you to find it at tonymartignetti.com.

Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by DonorBox. Outdated donation forms blocking your supporters' generosity this giving season? DonorBox, the fast, flexible, and friendly fundraising platform for nonprofits. donorbox.org.

Tony MartignettiI love that alliteration. You're into it this week. Fast, flexible, friendly fundraising platform

Kate Martignettinonprofits. Our creative producer is Claire Meyerhoff. I'm your associate producer, Kate Martignetti. The show's social media is by Susan Chavez. Marc Silverman is our web guy, and this music is by Scott Stein.

Tony MartignettiThank you for that affirmation, Scotty. Be with us next week for Nonprofit Radio. I hope you will. Big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. Go out there and be great.

Nonprofit Radio