Skip to content
EP 656September 5, 2023

A Post-Fellowship Conversation With Amy Sample Ward

Tony MartignettiAmy Sample Ward
Nonprofit Radio
Episode 656
0:00 / 0:00

About this episode

What did they do over their Bosch Foundation Fellowship, who did they meet and what did they talk about for three months abroad? For a tease: How tech could save an island nation, and the future of the internet. Trivial topics like that. Amy is our technology contributor and the CEO of NTEN.

Here’s the transcript

Tony MartignettiHello and welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. I'm your aptly named host and the podfather of your favorite hebdomadal podcast. Oh, I'm glad you're with us. I'd be thrown into toxicosis if you poisoned me with the idea that you missed this week's show. Kate, give us the highlights, please.

Kate MartignettiOkay, Tony, we have a post-fellowship conversation with Amy Sample Ward. What did they do over their Bosh Foundation fellowship? Who did they meet? And what did they talk about for 3 months abroad? For a tease, how tech could save an island nation and the future of the internet. Trivial topics like that. Amy is our technology contributor and the CEO of NTEN. On Tony's Take Two.

Tony MartignettiShare, share, that's fair.

Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by DonorBox. Outdated donation forms blocking your supporters' generosity? DonorBox. Fast, flexible, and friendly fundraising forms for your nonprofit. donorbox.org. And by Keela. Grow revenue, engage donors, and increase efficiency with Keela, the fundraiser CRM. Visit keela.co to join the thousands of fundraisers using Keela to exceed their goals. Here is a post-fellowship conversation with Amy Sample Ward.

Tony MartignettiIt is a pleasure to welcome back Amy Sample Ward to Nonprofit Radio. They are the CEO of NTEN and our technology and social media contributor. Their most recent co-authored book— and frankly, I think another one is due shortly— Uh, is The Tech That Comes Next, about equity and inclusiveness in technology development. They're at amysampleward.org and @amyrsward. Welcome back, Amy.

Amy Sample WardThanks for having me. I'm excited to chat about so many things today.

Tony MartignettiYeah, it's a genuine pleasure because it's been several months because you were on this, uh, highfalutin fellowship. Bosch, the Bosch Fellowship, the dishwasher company fellowship, which is so much more than dishwashers, of course, and vacuum cleaners. So you were in the Bosch Foundation Fellowship abroad, based in Berlin. Catch us up from there. What is it? Sure. So what does that look like for a summer?

Amy Sample WardTotally. The Bosch Foundation is the shareholders of the Bosch company. So I think fewer foundations and companies have this model in the US, but maybe more common in Europe where there is a commercial company, and instead of having lots of shareholders and publicly traded stocks, the foundation is the owner. And the foundation is a grantmaking organization. They provide grants for all kinds of, you know, nonprofits all around the world, actually. And one of their programs is called the Bosch Academy. where they have for 9 years now a fellowship program that brings folks from truly all different industries and sectors to Berlin for a period of time. I was only there for 3 months, but other folks are there for 6, 9+ months to really— I mean, I couldn't believe it even up until the last day. I was waiting for them to say, and here's what you have to deliver. There was nothing. You're really there to pursue opportunities that you wouldn't otherwise have kind of the mental space to do in your day-to-day, you know, work. So I was there for 3 months and all the fellows are on their own timeline. So it was a little bit confusing because I think maybe at least in the US, when I think of a fellowship, I think it's like a cohort of people. We're all doing like a program together. Yeah.

Tony MartignettiYeah.

Amy Sample WardIt's much more of what we would call a residency. So people are on their own timelines. There's no overarching programming. Everyone is— and I think it would be hard to do that because people really are from very diverse backgrounds. So while I was there as a fellow, some of my other fellow fellows, you know, there was a GP from England who works in the NHS and had been leading their digital health work. There was a former president of Costa Rica. There was someone from the State Department that now works at Brookings researching industrialization that, you know, so there were people from all, all different backgrounds and interest areas and specialties. And I would say the main kind of anchor that, that we did have together was Twice a week, we all had lunch together, which feels like okay. You just have you know lunch together, but really opportunities to sit at us you know a table that's small enough you really could have a conversation with everyone. You know ten or fewer people over lunch to talk about things with people who are working all different industries. It's just not something we normally have the privilege and opportunity to do, nor do I think we actively create those opportunities very much for ourselves, you know. And the, the kind of twice a week getting to sit together, share a meal, talk about what is interesting to us, um, they often brought in speakers. So, um, you know, maybe it's a journalist from one of the newspapers who's coming in and sharing, you know, trends they're seeing, um, in certain whatever that, you know, in the political section or, or whatever topic. Maybe it's, um, folks from EU or German policy, uh, houses sharing, okay, these are policies we're recommending, you know, all different opportunities just to learn and like sit together in conversation. So it was really powerful.

Tony MartignettiFormer president of Costa Rica. What is he or she looking into?

Amy Sample WardSo the fellow that was there with me, that's the former president of Costa Rica, Carlos Alvarado, was pursuing— now is a teacher at the Fletcher School, and his fellowship was focused on designing a new framework for diplomacy that would support folks entering into this world of, of policy and politics with a mindset on collective wins and kind of personal integrity, and that each of our stories do matter and influence how we can build relationship to make more inclusive and hopefully better for our planet and our people policies. So really thinking about, you know, how do we teach people to be in this, in politics in ways that don't just recycle and repurpose the same kind of oppressive systems that got us to today?

Tony MartignettiVery lofty. All right. Yes, of course, we're going to talk about what Amy Sample Ward was thinking about, investigating, talking to people. This all sounds It all sounds very freeing.

Amy Sample WardIt was incredibly freeing. Yeah. And honestly, because it was in Berlin and I normally live out in Portland, Oregon, having 9 hours difference, uh, also was freeing in my calendar. I went from having, you know, my days are 8 to 4 scheduled meetings to there's a lunch and then You know, maybe I've got an early morning Pacific time check-in with a staff person, and that was it for what was scheduled. You know, really being able to have the freedom in your scheduled day to think and do work and do work and think in the ways that you want to was a huge gift.

Tony MartignettiAnd so you took time off from work, right? You reduced to 50%?

Amy Sample WardYeah, I reduced my hours, but I didn't fully step out so that there wasn't also like an administrative burden to change all of our processes, or, you know, I could still run payroll, like, you know, those types of things.

Tony MartignettiAnd, uh, is this fellowship a paying gig? Do they—

Amy Sample WardYou do get a stipend.

Tony MartignettiGet a stipend?

Amy Sample WardNo, they don't. Um,

Tony Martignettiplace to live?

Amy Sample WardThey don't give you the place. I mean, they give you the stipend so that you can cover the cost of having somewhere, and they can help you find a place, but You know, there were folks there who are single and don't have children, and then we were there as a whole family with a child, you know. So everybody has such different needs with their housing that they just support you finding what works for you. Okay.

Tony MartignettiOkay. And you and your husband Max, daughter Oren, did you— you traveled, I'm sure. You're in Europe.

Amy Sample WardYeah.

Tony MartignettiYou must have traveled.

Amy Sample WardYeah, we actually— we—

Tony MartignettiWell, I know you were in Warsaw, Poland.

Amy Sample WardYes.

Tony MartignettiBecause we got you for the 650th show from Warsaw.

Amy Sample WardYes, we did spend some time in Warsaw, um, doing some project collaboration work there. Um, and then they got to experience Warsaw, where I'd been before but they hadn't. And then, uh, the other trip that we took was to take Oren back to England where we used to live and show her around London. Um, go, you know, she got to see some proper castles. That's really what she wanted. And all the fellows and Max Noren went on a trip down to Stuttgart, which is the home of Bosch as a company and history. And that's also where the Bosch-affiliated hospital is and got to see so many other parts. It's certainly the first factory floor that I walked. Wow. And got to see, you know, this mix of, of kind of classic industry, you know, building these things in a, in a building altogether, mixed in with more of the recent tech innovations of, you know, a little robot that delivered you the parts that you needed to inspect. And if you got in the way, the robot would stop, but then get very frustrated that you were never getting out of the robot's way for it to go deliver its parts, you know. Things like that. So it was a really cool experience and getting to see really so many other sides to the world that, you know, I get stuck in my nonprofit space and think about our work. So it was really cool.

Tony MartignettiThat's the freeing. Yeah. A luxury for 3 months, you said? Yeah. You were there 3 months. All right. So what were you investigating? Thinking about? I'm sure you had meetings, you were talking to people.

Amy Sample WardYes. So many meetings, so many conversations. But my focus,

Tony Martignettiyeah,

Amy Sample Wardreally, and though, you know, of course I'm just interested in general meeting with folks who are trying to make the world better. And, you know, I had lots of conversations or questions with folks to say, you know, what are you trying and what's working? What did you try that didn't work? Like, how do we get traction? How do we succeed in making the world better? Of course. But the start of all of my conversations and my meetings with folks was this kind of one— I know you're going to say lofty, but one big question, which was, what does an internet that is actually built on safety and freedom and sovereignty look like? And can we build it? And there were a lot of people. Who, you know, didn't think it is possible that, that, that those, you know, true freedom and true safety and true sovereignty couldn't all be achieved. Like, they, they couldn't all 3 be at the same time, or that a better internet wasn't possible. But there also were people who were like, Yeah. Yes, it is possible and we can build it. And please, can we start yesterday? You know?

Tony MartignettiAll right. So I got my first interruption. So the folks who say no, it can't be done, do they feel that we missed the opportunity to have built the internet that you described? Or is it more that it was never achievable? Not that we went about it Or allowed it to develop on its own in the wrong way or unobstructed?

Amy Sample WardI think that honestly, the folks who had the most pushback in my conversations were folks who were honestly pushing back on my view of the internet now, you know, saying, oh, it already is safe, it already is free, right? And so it was less that internet isn't possible and more like discrediting the place from which the conversation, the question is being asked, you know, and that we can, we can make a few policies and like, voilà, we're good, you know, the internet's good as it is. And there were also a lot of folks who felt that my focus on those 3 aspects was maybe the issue for them, that, that safety, everybody agreed, yes, the internet should be safe. Not as many people agreed it should be free. And now I don't mean free by cost to access it, but like, what does freedom for each of us look like online? Mm-hmm. And I think that's where folks had a little bit of like, but what does that mean? And, and can it be safe if it's free, right? Which are important conversations, but I, I think, yes, it can be. But a lot of folks felt like sovereignty and these conversations about how do we acknowledge and establish sovereignty as communities was me saying it's all anarchy, nothing matters, you know, there, there are no rules, which is really honestly the opposite of sovereignty. Sovereignty is saying Mm-hmm. I want you to acknowledge that I have rules because my community has said this is what keeps us free and safe, right? Or, or whatever. And that the view is that's the role of government. But I think honestly, and I'm not trying to like take this down a, a deep rabbit hole, but I really don't think that a structure for something like a global system of the internet where we are all interacting all over the world, you know, regardless of which country's government we, we may live under, isn't enough to say that the internet could be free and safe and supportive and, you know, successful in all these ways because all these governments have issues with each other. And like, you know, there's communities within a country that are different from each other. And there, there, I think, should be paths to be able to say, this is what, this is what's right for our community. And again, I'm not trying to like devolve everything down into, into chaos. But I also don't think I could accept the notion that what we have today is working. So I'm, I'm mostly saying it has to be something else and not that I have all the answers. Oh my gosh, if I had all the answers, what am I doing sitting over here holding on to them? You know, like. But, but we need to have the open space to find those answers or create those answers together and say, what could it be like? Versus saying, this is good enough, let's put a policy that says, you know, don't, don't take it or something, and, and that's it.

Kate MartignettiIt's time for a break. DonorBox. Quote, DonorBox text-to-give led one of our more successful fundraising events. A concert. Sharing the keyword, shortcode, and scannable QR code made giving easy for our supporters, and they did give. That's from Josh Young, Executive Director of Hydrating Humanity. DonorBox, helping you help others. donorbox.org. Now back to a post-fellowship conversation with Amy Sample Ward.

Tony MartignettiWho were some of the folks that you were talking to?

Amy Sample WardYeah, good question. Um, it was really a— why I felt really interested in making sure I was talking to a lot of different folks, because as you know, even the NTEN community has, you know, all different kinds of nonprofits' missions.

Tony MartignettiYeah, of course,

Amy Sample Wardpeople of all different departments in an organization, but also consultants and tech companies and foundations and, you know, all these different folks. So I was meeting with, of course, nonprofits themselves, folks who see themselves in kind of a nonprofit technology vein, but also folks who are focused on supporting refugees and connecting them with jobs. And they kind of see that technology has to be part of that, right? But then I was also meeting with think tanks and foundations and folks who are You know, kind of advocating or or resourcing the movement around the internet and on other sides. You know, whether that's giving money or or talking to policymakers and government. So really talk to folks all across that spectrum, and folks in Berlin, folks in Germany, and folks more broadly in the EU.

Tony MartignettiAll right. I think before we we. Talk about some of the folks who said, you know, let's achieve this ideal internet. And, you know, you said let's start yesterday. You— I think it's valuable for you to summarize where you're coming from. What's, what's your sense of, uh, of our internet, our technology space, and, and, you know, its, uh, its utility for, for nonprofits?

Amy Sample WardYeah, I think that I believe all technology, including the internet, should be something that every person, regardless of where they live or whether or not they have a job or how much money they have or, you know, what their interests are, can find a way to be included there, whether they want to help create part of the internet or watch cat videos, you know, whatever they want, that this is really a— this is really something that is for everyone. And I think a big challenge with that today is lack— the lack of certain policies that make it accessible and affordable and available, you know, to all communities.

Tony MartignettiYou know, let's just start with accessibility.

Amy Sample WardRight.

Tony MartignettiThere are pockets of the world and certainly of the United States where the internet is not taken for granted.

Amy Sample WardRight. I mean, there's more than 45 million people in the US who couldn't even have sufficient broadband internet to like be on this Zoom call with us right now, you know. So the idea that— and I'm not saying this is your idea, but I do see out in the media this perception that it's like, other faraway places that don't have the internet. We don't have the internet all over the US too, you know. And even the pandemic has not accelerated real work to address that, you know. But there's also the piece of commercialization around the internet. I think that has, of course, come from a lack of policies that, that made it so that that couldn't be the case. Yeah. And the fact that, of course, commercial companies are the largest lobbyists, and so they are able to make sure that the policies continue to work for them. But, you know, the number of folks who think the internet is Facebook and don't leave Facebook, and that because that's all that they know, that means, again, they don't really see how they are part of shaping or making or engaging in this global resource we have. But also are a victim of, of what that commercialization means, the bubble that Facebook has created, all of the, you know, algorithmic bias and hate that comes from that. Um, so finding ways where both from the actual access point, like communities could own their own networks and have the, the jobs and the profits From managing that all the way up to lots more people creating those apps or those tools. You know, I, I don't think we need to build an internet where every single person in the world would ever use the same app because not every single person in the world needs the same app. Not everyone has the same phone. Not everyone has the same computer. You know, like, we don't need to say that success in technology is when every single person is using it. It's just when every person that it's right for is using it, you know, and building tools or online resources or websites or whatever else that, that aren't viewed as like scale to the X forever and just, oh great, we succeeded. Everyone that needs this tool is using it, you know, and that's good. But that's really not, again, because of the commercialization of so much of the web, that's not how it's How it works right now. That's not the incentive.

Tony MartignettiYeah, the commercialization, the access issues, the cost issues.

Amy Sample WardYes.

Tony MartignettiUh, there, I think probably a lot of or all of Nonprofit Radio's listeners, you know, we, we probably take the internet for granted. You wake up in the morning, you click in, and it's there, right? And your technology is at your, at your bedside when you wake up, although Beth Kanter would tell you that it should not be. You should not have—

Amy Sample WardIt should not be. Yes.

Tony MartignettiNot be. But reality is, it's— if it's not at your bedside, it's, uh, it's in the— just the next room over. It's very close.

Amy Sample WardYeah.

Tony MartignettiAnd, you know, so— and it works 99.999% of the time.

Amy Sample WardExactly.

Tony MartignettiUh, I had someone in, uh, my, my Planned Giving Accelerator course. He is, uh, is in— based in Malawi. He didn't even have stable electricity every night. Right. For him, our meetings were at nighttime.

Amy Sample WardYeah.

Tony MartignettiUm, 3 o'clock Eastern was 9 or 10 o'clock. I think it was 9 o'clock, 9 PM for him in Africa Standard Time. He didn't even have reliable electricity each night.

Amy Sample WardRight.

Tony MartignettiLet alone reliable internet. Um,

Amy Sample Wardright. And I think sometimes there's this misperception— again, not saying that this is your misperception, but More broadly, that folks that aren't online don't, don't know things, right? There's so much that we assume about folks who are not online, and it isn't that they don't still know the news or that they still don't, you know, or that, or that they don't want to be online. It's just that there are so many other barriers in the way that are structural, not, you know, Right. they've never heard of the internet and they don't know what it is. And so access isn't just saying like, oh yeah, well, there was a, you know, we saw this in the pandemic in the first, you know, year especially, like, oh well, we know all these kids aren't in school and all these people need the internet. So we put up a Wi-Fi signal in this field. You can just drive over. Oh, and we're just gonna sit in our car for 4 hours and—

Tony MartignettiYeah.

Amy Sample WardWork and try to do schoolwork. Like, what are you— what— how is this a solution? You know? So there's, there's so much that goes into that. And always remembering that folks who aren't online aren't unaware. They're just experiencing a bunch of barriers that they didn't create.

Tony MartignettiYeah. It creates frustration.

Amy Sample WardYeah.

Tony MartignettiFrustration and anxiety because they're left behind. They know they're left behind. They can't access what they know is available to lots of other people. All right, let's bring it back to Germany, Berlin.

Amy Sample WardYes.

Tony MartignettiSo you met with lots of folks who said, yes, we can achieve this more equitable, more accessible, safer internet. What do they I don't know, what, what do they want to do? Are you gonna— are you coming back with a bunch of partners that you're going to start lobbying and, and policy papers?

Amy Sample WardYeah, I think, I think we definitely were able to, um, build stronger relationships with organizations we maybe knew or even tangentially knew, um, because NTEN is a global organization. There are folks from all over the world that are already in the community, but Just the value of actually showing up at their office and sitting down for an hour, you know, really goes a long way in building trust and relationship. But I think the other piece was having the energy that comes from conversations where people are not disagreeing with the premise of which we're even trying to talk about, but saying like, yeah, we are— no, we already agree. Like, let's get to this part. Yeah. And really validating for folks, no, you're not the only one. Like, I'm from this community that you're welcome to be part of, or maybe you want, you know, know about. But there's this whole NTEN community of people who also think an internet like this is possible and also want to build it. You know, you are not alone trying to like work in your tiny corner and find a way, right? And whatever corner you're in, is needed. We don't all have to do the same thing. We shouldn't all do the same thing, right? Like, you, if, if policy is your thing, go, go work on that. If, you know, supporting refugees transitioning into jobs is your thing, go do that. You know, like, wherever you are in the work is the right place to be. And so those were really, I think, validating and generative conversations, especially for folks who felt like They were being told there was only one way to do this work. And, you know, the only policy recommendations we want are policies that, you know, address AI, for example. Lots of AI conversation this summer in the US and everywhere else in the world, you know. And I kept saying, but there might be applications of technology that are specific to what they think AI is today. Yeah. But wouldn't it be better to write policy about any way that data was being used from, you know, a person, or where— what accountability looks like for when there is harm? I don't care if they used it in an AI garbage machine or they used it in my health records. I should get to have the control, right? So helping folks reframe that It doesn't have to only be a single issue or a single topic like that, that it's all connected. It is all related. All of this technology work is connected, and whatever piece you can work on, please go do it as well as you can, you know.

Kate MartignettiIt's time for a break. Keela. Increase donations and foster collaborative teamwork with Keela, the fundraiser CRM. Maximize your team's productivity and spend more time building strong connections with donors through features that were built specifically for fundraisers. A fundraiser CRM goes beyond a data management platform. It's designed with the unique needs of fundraisers in mind and aims to unify fundraising, communications, and donor management tools into one single source of truth. Visit keela.co to sign up for a coming group demo. And explore how to exceed your fundraising goals like never before. It's time for Tony's Take Two.

Tony MartignettiThank you, Kate. Share, share, that's fair. Who can you share Nonprofit Radio with? I'd be grateful if you would give it some thought. Maybe it's someone you work with, somebody, a colleague, a peer, Somebody you work for, your vice president, your CEO, perhaps your board. I have gotten— I've gotten emails through the years that we stimulated a board conversation, or I shared this show with my board and we were going to talk about it at the next meeting. You know, friends in nonprofits, people you used to work with, assuming you don't hate them still. You know, if they fired you, you're probably not going to share this fabulous show with them. So, all right, so that's out if they fired you. You let that go. Maybe the job before that, the job you didn't get fired from. I hope that you haven't been fired. You haven't been fired that much. Nonprofit Radio is exemplary listeners, so never fired, right? But if in the off chance, all right, so you're not going to share with those folks who let you go, but everybody else you used to work with, folks you used to work with, perhaps I'd be grateful if we could expand the audience a bit. If you could share this show, I believe it's helping you, otherwise you wouldn't be listening. Who else can it help? Who else ought to be listening to Nonprofit Radio? Please share with them. And that's Tony's Take Two. Kate.

Kate MartignettiWe've got beaucoup but loads more time. Let's go back to a post-fellowship conversation.

Tony MartignettiThis is all very interesting because you can correct me if my perception is wrong. Please do. My perception is that Europe is much further ahead of North America. Forget the continent. Yeah, the United States, in terms of data security. There's the, there's the GDPR.

Amy Sample WardGDPR.

Tony MartignettiIn terms of Holding, holding the large tech companies accountable, you know, suing. I see more lawsuits and, and, and successful either settlements or legal, other legal outcomes against Meta, Google. I see more of those. I see—

Amy Sample WardYeah, I think that there, I think that there are, I think there are far more pieces in place in Europe, in the EU.

Tony MartignettiOkay.

Amy Sample WardThan there are in the US. I don't think that they are adequate or, you know, fully functional to the needs of communities and people. And there's still a lot of them that are in flux. You know, the EU AI policies are still being shaped, even though they've been discussed as if like, here's what they'll do and it's great. They're actually not done, you know. So Yes, GDPR is in place, but there's still a lot to be shaped. There's even more to be shaped in the US. But yes.

Tony MartignettiAll right. That's why, I mean, I'm not hearing from you that there's an attitude of complacency, you know, we've achieved. And not that I expected you to say that, but just recognizing that they are further along.

Amy Sample WardYeah,

Tony Martignettithey're, they're, they hold companies, especially the— I'm particularly interested in the company accountability.

Amy Sample WardYeah.

Tony MartignettiAround data usage, algorithms, forced, you know, forced usage, like the way Threads, you have to be on Instagram to use Threads,

Amy Sample Wardright?

Tony MartignettiYou, if you drop one, you lose the other, you know, I don't—

Amy Sample WardYeah.

Tony MartignettiThat, that rubs me that That to me is just unfair.

Amy Sample WardBut yeah,

Tony Martignettithey— not, not to that particular degree that the EU has figured that out. But generally, they seem to be more demanding accountability of the, of the big tech companies.

Amy Sample WardYes.

Tony MartignettiAll right. But, but not— but there's a lot more work to do. I understand.

Amy Sample WardYeah.

Tony MartignettiOkay.

Amy Sample WardYeah.

Tony MartignettiOkay. Is there a, is there a story you can tell about Some NGO or other, other organization or person that feels like, wow, I mean, one that, one that I, um, we got something really good, let me tell you about it.

Amy Sample WardYeah, one that there's no resolution that I have to offer, but I think, you know, this— I want to acknowledge that this is— these are the questions I sit with all the time. This is what my work is around. And I'm not expecting every listener to be like, oh yeah, of course, like nodding along with me. Like, if this is your first time thinking about this because you spend your day on a different topic, that's totally fine, you know. Um, well, and welcome to a new—

Tony Martignettiwelcome to a new conversation. Yeah, welcome to join or just take away from it.

Amy Sample WardYeah, so I was— I wanted to offer this because I think it's a, a way to root these ideas around sovereignty and freedom and safety in a real example. So we're not just thinking of like some future world and trying to root it there, but, but a way to think about it now. And we had the opportunity because another fellow, while I was— who ended just maybe 2 weeks after I arrived, Kamal, he had created this big event and number of meetings and brought a delegation of folks from Tuvalu, island nation in the Pacific. And it was incredible to hear from them and to meet them. But, but really what's happening there and why they came is, you know, island nations are, of course, on the front lines of climate change and the impacts of climate change. As you are, we're recording this as you're hunkering down for a tropical storm.

Tony MartignettiTropical Storm Idalia on my beach. Yes.

Amy Sample WardYes. And What, what came out while we were— while, while the delegation from Tuvalu was actually in Berlin was they were— climate scientists have previously said their home, their land will be unsustainable for living for their community in this century. And that has been updated because of the impacts of climate change and the acceleration of You know the world, and they're now saying within potentially twenty years. And what does that mean for these people? Right? These are these are real people. These are people who are having babies and having jobs and having lives. Right? To not just. Have your world change because of climate change, but literally have your homeland underwater, completely go away. The entire island could be underwater. So part of the conversations with them have been freedom, safety, sovereignty in the internet for a community that cannot say here is our geographic home, um, in the— in this— where that we can live, at least in that geographic home. Um, and so how do we create a digital nation-state? How do we digitize place-based culture and artifacts and customs and dances and, you know, everything else that comes from who you are as, as a community? How do we digitize it when we can now? And what does navigating social services, what does, you know, traveling the world and getting a passport look like digitally through digital governance delivery when you don't have, you know, an address in that country anymore? Yeah. And it's kind of heartbreaking to, of course, think Tuvalu is not the only island nation that will be facing this circumstance. But if you think of this happening in a matter of years, it is everyone's lifetime. It's not, you know, a century from now and you kind of like, oh, let it go. It won't be me, right? This is us.

Tony MartignettiYeah, 20 years.

Amy Sample WardWe are the ones that have to find the path for this, right? And so I think those conversations were really illuminating, and I found it challenging to hear and witness, you know, folks responding to say, to kind of think of all of the many pieces of this and say, well, where do you want to go live? But that's not the question. We're not— that's not the— that's not the top of my question list, right? Right. It is, how are you, the community members in Tuvalu, what things would you need? How would you support the digitization of your own culture, of your own community? What can we do to build the internet that you need? Then how do we build it now so that we can, you know, like you want to build your new database before you migrate your data in, right? You don't just— Yeah. Get rid of the old one and then figure out what to do with the database. It's the same. We need to build that safe and free and sovereign internet now so that we can support the citizens of Tuvalu existing in that internet before they, before they, you know, don't have the, the land of their home. And yeah, just want to offer that as an example, maybe a reminder. That climate change is having immediate and real impacts on folks all around the world, but mostly as an illustration of what it means to think about the future of the internet and the need for, for the internet to work differently on a faster scale than like maybe when Microsoft and Google want it to be different, you know.

Tony MartignettiAnd, and so many of the nations, peoples, communities that are suffering most from climate change are contributing nothing, contributing de minimisly to climate change. They're not responsible at all. The industrial nations are, which are more hardened and more capable and have greater infrastructure. And what are we doing to these other folks and how can we help them to help themselves? I mean, yeah, you make me think of just like, how would they get a driver's license? Yeah. Or who voices it? How do I vote in the next election when I don't— there's no polling place because there's no physical location anymore.

Amy Sample WardRight.

Tony MartignettiJeez. All right. Yeah. All right. Well, that's a provocative case. Thank you. Yeah. Thank you. What else do you want us to know about?

Amy Sample WardWell, one thing I thought would be interesting to you and interested in maybe your take or observations Like, I'll offer a little reflection and interested in your hot take. But I met with foundations while I was there and asked about, you know, what's a big priority in philanthropy here? What are the conversations? And folks named a challenge that I think we all have some feelings about in the US as well, which is minimum spend-out by foundations. In Germany, there's— Minimum spend-out. There is no minimum spend out. So there's many foundations that didn't spend any money, that did not give any grants in a certain year, and that organizations really feel the challenge of that because they don't— what do we even do? Like, are we even, you know, working with you? Are we trying to get money from you? So that was a big issue. And the other big conversation that felt— and people named, you know, I think the US is more ahead of us on this, but Some foundations starting to have conversations of general operating support instead of project-specific funding, and what that requires of them. There was a lot of folks saying, like, but then what do we put in the grant agreement? What do we expect for the reporting? And I was like, you know me, I was like, why do they have to report? You know? But they weren't asking the questions of, you know, why don't we trust our grantees? Or why have we never done this until now? You know, they were asking very procedural questions like, well, what's the form say? You know?

Tony MartignettiYeah, the minimum spend. I like it here in the US. Unfortunately, a lot of foundations consider the floor to be the ceiling, so they'll spend their 5% and they met the burden. the regulation, and so they consider themselves completed.

Amy Sample WardYeah.

Tony MartignettiAnd, you know, I don't know, you know, I see a lot of them, I see a lot of conversations on LinkedIn about how things ought to be different. And, and, you know, occasionally I'll attend webinars where some, you know, foundation CEO panel, you know, they're talking about what they're doing anecdotally to overcome The minimum spend being a ceiling and funding tech as just— it just belongs in everything, right? I mean, if the people are using Word and Excel, they're using technology in their work. And I hope there aren't many nonprofits that are still using index cards and, you know, dog-eared, you know, written pencil spreadsheets. Like, I I used to do social research on Carnegie Mellon in the late 1980s or early 1980s. 1984, I graduated. So, you know, but, you know, that's all anecdotal. I mean, somebody writes a lofty LinkedIn post, you know, I don't know whether it really hits home with the majority of big, you know, the biggest foundations that we could all name off the top of our heads. Yeah. That control, you know, access to probably 80% of the foundation capital or something. You know, there's probably 20% of the cap— 20% of the nonprofit foundations are holding 80% if you follow that 20/80 rule. Right. You know, is that— are those LinkedIn posts and those webinars, you know, are they trickling to those kinds of folks? And are they actually, you know, are these real conversations? Are these heartfelt sentiments?

Amy Sample WardYeah,

Tony Martignettia lot of times. Or, you know, is this, um, placating, you know, platitudes, lofty, lofty, uh, academic-type conversations that, that don't result in real change? So, right, you could sense my cynicism. Uh,

Amy Sample Wardwell, and I, I want to name also the piece that you said in there about technology. You know, I did ask funders, how are you funding technology? Do you have a, you know, tech capacity building portfolio? Is that something that you fund directly? Do you give every grant, you know, a line item for technology? You know, what, what are you doing? And I didn't— there weren't many foundations that had a technology, you know, portfolio or focus or, or grantmaking space. A lot of what I heard was, oh well, you know, it's 2023, technology is in everything, so we just know that it's all of our grants. I said, oh, okay, so it must be you have like a technology budget in every grant to support the tech. And they're like, well, no, because it's just, you know, part of doing their work. We know they're using technology, but

Tony Martignettiit's just there. Yeah, well,

Amy Sample Wardright. And I said, right, so if technology is part of everything, then it's nowhere. If it's everywhere, it's nowhere to you, you know. Yeah. And we— you actually need to be providing the support for these organizations To give you this massive report on all of their data, you know, like, yeah.

Tony MartignettiYou're saying you, you're saying you know that they use it. It's ubiquitous. That doesn't mean it's free.

Amy Sample WardRight, right. And the training to use it well is certainly not free, you know.

Tony MartignettiYeah.

Amy Sample WardYeah. So I felt just as, you know, head against the wall as As I normally do.

Tony MartignettiYeah, you didn't have to go to— you have to go to the Bosch Fellowship for that degree of frustration.

Amy Sample WardExactly.

Tony MartignettiBecause it saved the Boschers a lot of money there. Um, no. All right. You know, so yeah, I don't have an answer. I just have— I have cynicism. I have a lot of questions, you know.

Amy Sample WardYeah.

Tony MartignettiIs real change happening? Is it better now in 2023 than it was in 2000? Yeah, I think we've progressed. But, but not far enough. And, and new issues are emerging, you know, now there's— Right. On the— we're in the midst of just scratching the surface of artificial intelligence. And,

Amy Sample Wardright,

Tony Martignettiyou know, your co-author, Afua, was on a panel with George Weiner and Beth Kanter and Allison Fine. And, you know, we talked for 60 or 70 minutes about the implications, the risks, the opportunities too, you know, but the inequities, uh, right, you know. So that, that's emerging now. So how are foundations reacting to that? What are they reacting,

Amy Sample Wardright?

Tony MartignettiYou know, it's, it's a lot of times it feels like the, the, the parallel or the analogy is that, you know, how slow government is to react to changes in, in the culture, in society.

Amy Sample WardYeah.

Tony MartignettiYou know, equivalently, foundations feel to me slow to react to what's on the ground among their grantees.

Amy Sample WardYeah, yeah, yeah. And I, you know, maybe as a closing thought, want to name that I don't think that even in an equitable world, it's a, it's a world where Nobody gets upset, where harm doesn't exist, but it's a world where there's a path for accountability for that harm, right? It's not that, that perfect isn't real. Perfect doesn't exist. We're not gonna go to some future equitable world where, where nothing bad happens. You still fall or you still, you know, get in a car accident maybe, or, you know, whatever it might be. But, but there's places to get care and reconciliation and support and restitution and all of these other pieces, right? There's, there's ways for us to be in relationship and work through things together. And I think there's— it came up in some of my conversations, you know, folks thinking like, I'm just so rosy-eyed, I'm gonna get— oh, we're just gonna have some perfect world, you know? And I think the way that you know you are free is when you have not been Right? The way you know you are safe is because you have been unsafe. The way that you know that you are sovereign is because you had to say, hey, there's some accountability that needs to happen because you were not honoring the sovereignty, right? So conflict is always going to exist as soon as there are 2 humans. You know, there will always be conflict. It's just finding a world where we, we have the infrastructure and the mechanisms for us to manage that and, and be safe and free and sovereign together in the world. So as we think about how do we, how do we fund for that world, how do we build an internet for that world, how do we pursue our nonprofit missions for that world, I think it's the same. It's both saying there will always be some needs and how many of them can we eliminate so that we are able to really be happy and fulfilled and, and supported. So I think, yeah, I just wanted to name that I don't— I'm not looking for some perfect utopia that doesn't exist, but, but a place where— I mean, how many communities today feel like something horrible happened because of content on Facebook and they have a way to do anything about that? I don't think a lot of communities feel like they have anything they can do about that, you know, or you know, they experience threats or hate speech online, do they feel like they have any way to, to do something because they experience that? I don't, I don't know many communities who feel like they have a way to do that. You know,

Tony Martignettithere's a lot, there's a lot wrapped up in that. There's obviously, um, you know, a lot of that comes from the, just the inequities of, of capital. You know, if we bring it back to foundations and fund and grantees, as long as the foundations 20% of the foundations control 80% of the capital that's available through private foundation funding to nonprofits. The nonprofits are always going to be at the beck and call of the grantors. And if the grantors are slow to change, then the redress is slow.

Amy Sample WardRight.

Tony MartignettiIt's slow in coming. It's inherent in the inequities of the financial, the capitalization. You know, in terms of communities, you know, there's always— I mean, there's a legal redress, but a lot of these things that you just talked about, you know, the bullying and just oppression from technology companies, I mean, there's no real legal redress to that. Right. There's only— there's redress to specific wrongs. You know, they breached their contract. Right. This person committed, I don't know, the digital assault. I'm calling that— that's not the legal term, but committed a digital assault. So, all right, so I have a cause of action, either criminal or civil. Right. But those causes of action are narrow, and we're talking about bigger issues that—

Amy Sample WardRight.

Tony MartignettiThere aren't mechanisms for redress.

Amy Sample WardRight.

Tony MartignettiAll right.

Amy Sample WardThanks for having that conversation, so unlike our usual ones.

Tony MartignettiYes, I hope—

Amy Sample WardI appreciated the space to get to cover lots of things.

Tony MartignettiAbsolutely. I mean, it's not always, you know, tactical about what to, you know, how to use, uh, GPT-4 Plus in, in, in you, in your next fundraising campaign.

Amy Sample WardUh,

Tony Martignettiit's, it's not all about that. So I, I think it's, uh, it's refreshing.

Amy Sample WardYeah,

Tony Martignettiactually just talk about some things that are resolvable, but for which resolution is slow in coming, uh, difficult to achieve, but nonetheless, nonetheless a lofty pursuit, a, a needed pursuit, right? We never give up. We never—

Amy Sample WardAnd maybe some questions or ideas that, you know, folks listening could go apply to their own work that is about a different topic too. I would love to hear if folks do that, you know.

Tony MartignettiThe little feedback I get from listeners, which I'm not complaining about, I understand podcast listening is an animal that isn't given much to feedback, at least at the level I'm on. Joe Rogan may get a lot of feedback, but, you know, and The Daily may, but in any case, is that, you know, I took this and brought it to my CEO or I brought it to my board. You know, we opened a conversation. Uh, I asked people to listen. I sent the link to the board so that— yeah, those conversations happen. Yeah. Yeah.

Amy Sample WardGood.

Tony MartignettiAll right. Yes. Uh, a lot of space for a different, uh, a different kind of conversation. Amy Sample Ward, they're the CEO of NTEN. They're our technology and social media contributor. If you want to be in touch with them, they're at amysampleward.org. Uh, and Amy, @AmyRSWard. And, uh, maybe we should add the Bosch Fellowship to your, to your bio officially for next time.

Amy Sample WardYeah, exactly, exactly. Thank you so much for having me, Tony.

Tony MartignettiMy pleasure. Good to talk to you, Amy. Thank you. Thank you. Bye.

Kate MartignettiNext week, donor retention with Bloomerang CEO Dennis Foy. If you missed any part of this week's show,

Tony MartignettiI beseech you, find it at tonymartignetti.com.

Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by DonorBox. Outdated donation forms blocking your supporters' generosity? DonorBox. Fast, flexible, and friendly fundraising forms.

Tony MartignettiOh,

Kate MartignettiI can't say it. I can't do it.

Tony MartignettiYou can. Fundraising forms. See, it's a fabulous alliteration, but it's, uh, it's a little tough to say. I know. All right.

Kate MartignettiFast, flexible, and friendly fundraising forms for your nonprofit. donorbox.org.

Tony MartignettiWoo!

Kate MartignettiAnd by Keela. Grow revenue, engage donors, and increase efficiency with Keela, the fundraiser CRM. Visit keela.co to join the thousands of fundraisers using Keela to exceed their goals.

Tony MartignettiYes. Fundraisers, not frundraisers. Okay, sorry.

Kate MartignettiOur creative producer is Claire Meyerhoff. I'm your associate producer, Kate Martignetti. The show's social media is by Susan Chavez. Marc Silverman is our web guy, and this music is by Scott Stein.

Tony MartignettiThank you for that affirmation, Scotty. Be with us next That's it this week for Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. Please go out and be great. Thank you.

Nonprofit Radio