Donor Retention


About this episode
The challenges are real and widespread: Aging donors; smaller gifts; and abysmal retention rates. Dennis Fois brings strategies and tactics to raise your consciousness and turn things around. Let’s talk about emotional connections, multithreading, and multichannel, just for starters. He’s CEO of Bloomerang.
My Guest
Here’s the transcript
Tony MartignettiHello and welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. I am your aptly named host and the podfather of your favorite hebdomadal podcast. Oh, I'm glad you're with us. I'd be hit with birafringence if you lit me up with the idea that you missed this week's show. Kate, our associate producer, what is up this week?
Kate MartignettiHey, Tony, it's donor retention. The challenges are real and widespread— aging donors, smaller gifts, and abysmal retention rates. Dennis Fois brings strategies and tactics to raise your consciousness and turn things around. Let's talk about emotional connections, multithreading, and being multichannel, just for starters. He is CEO of Bloomerang. On Tony's Take Two.
Tony MartignettiIt's September 11th.
Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by DonorBox. Outdated donation forms blocking your supporters' generosity? DonorBox, fast, flexible, and friendly fundraising forms for your nonprofit. donorbox.org. And by Keela, grow revenue, engage donors, and increase efficiency with Keela, the fundraiser CRM. Visit keela.co to join the thousands of fundraisers using Keela to exceed their goals. Here is Donor retention.
Tony MartignettiIt's a genuine pleasure to welcome Dennis Fois to Nonprofit Radio. He is CEO of Bloomerang. He's had a broad international career spanning more than 25 years, developing and leading high-performing multicultural teams in the technology, customer experience, relationship management, and financial services sectors. He's on LinkedIn and the company is at bloomerang.co. Dennis Fois, welcome to Nonprofit Radio.
Dennis FoisThanks very much for having me on, Tony.
Tony MartignettiPleasure, pleasure. And, uh, where are you, uh, speaking from?
Dennis FoisI'm speaking from Carmel in California.
Tony MartignettiCarmel, California. All right. Uh, and the, the business is in, uh, Indianapolis, isn't that right?
Dennis FoisBloomerang originally started in Indy and as I think a lot of technology companies post-pandemic has ended up all over the place. So we are very much scattered around the US. We are remote. So most of our employees work from home and then we work together when we meet, we have events around that. But I would imagine about 30% of our employees in Indy and the rest outside of Indy nowadays.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Okay. And it sounds like you're intentional about getting the team together in person. Is that, you find that we're digressing from our main topic, but I'm interested and I think listeners are too. You find that important for a virtual team?
Dennis FoisSuper important. And I think you have to be very intentional and deliberate about it. I mean, I'm one of those people that As we all went into the pandemic and we had to do certain things that were just basically necessary, I did want to take some learnings out of it because we did learn a lot. I, you know, I was an office rat before the pandemic, first in, first, last out. And I sort of noticed a few things during the pandemic that were actually very pleasurable. And I think it doesn't work for every company. But if you think, take ours, for instance, we work for small to mid-sized nonprofit organizations. all around the US. What's really cool is that if you have your employees all around the US, you can actually give some time for employees to do something locally. And that opens doors so you can create a better connection. We now have employees everywhere. So if there's a customer, you know, I've got customers here in Carmel. I didn't know that. So now we can connect, we can meet for a coffee. I can do some, I'm actually volunteering some with a local dog rescue. So it creates this sort of more emotional connections. Folks pick up their children from school. It's a, it's a, it adds an interesting layer to your company that, in my opinion, could create a deeper connection with employees and potentially higher retention rates. So I'm not, you know, there is a, there is a shrewd business side to this too, right? That is that employee, we talk about donor retention today, but employee retention is a topic too. Yeah. And Embracing some of the learnings that we've taken away rather than going back to an old model seems to me, it feels like the right thing to do. So we're making it work. But yes, you absolutely have to be very intentional about when you get together and what then you shouldn't be staring at presentations, then you need to make it about human connection. And that requires a lot of thinking. So it's not because we don't really have a good model where we can learn from each other. So we're figuring it out.
Tony MartignettiYeah, we're working it out and you're, I understand, intentional and it's worth investing in clearly.
Dennis FoisFor sure. Yeah, for sure.
Tony MartignettiYeah. All right. All right. Thank you. A little digression. But as you said, yeah, we're here to talk about donor retention. What, well, I think it's pretty widely known that we're doing quite poorly as a sector in donor retention. It's 75% or so of What first-time donors are lost after that first gift, which is abysmal. I mean, it's— to me, it's unsustainable unless you have an enormous acquisition pipeline, which you're spending a lot of money on, which is quite a bit more expensive than retaining. It seems unsustainable. But our— I'll call it our donor mortality rate continues to be very bad. Yeah.
Dennis FoisYeah. Yeah, it's, if this was a business, we would be out of business, right? I agree with you entirely. The statistics are a little paralyzing at times, I feel. And I would say, and sometimes there's a lot of sort of negative communication around it. There's some folks getting very stressful about it. I would say in part, it's also down to execution, right? So what I mean is, if you see your organization in one, one half of the organization is about heart, is what you care about, what you're passionate about. But the other part of it is the brain part, which you do need to run it as an organization. And what we are seeing a fair amount of in the small to midsize, say from $250K to $25 million, up to $25 million.
Tony MartignettiHmm.
Dennis FoisThat is, it's really not really approached and run like a business, you know, as a business, the moment you've acquired your first customer, this is the first donation, you would be fighting tooth and nail to retain that customer. We all know that it's much cheaper to retain existing customers. So it's bizarre to see. But then I started sort of digging in because, you know, you get to ask why. Well, why is it? It's not that it's been 30% and it's 70% now. It's been structurally like this for a very, very long time. You know that better than I do even. And so why, why is that? And we don't really have great answers. But for me, it comes down to a lack of establishment of emotional connection. I think that ultimately why most of us give is because there's a level of feeling associated to it. It's not a transaction for most people to donate, whether it's a small donation or a bit. There's a feeling, whether it's a feeling to make yourself feel good or whether it's altruistic philanthropy, whatever the feeling is, it's about feeling. And when you think about that and then you ask yourself, I say, okay, what am I doing to help that person get more connected to my organization? That's where it starts to unravel real quick. So Capital campaigns are about transactions and numbers. When we, and it's very knee-jerky, you know, when we're, when the numbers are low, we'll run a big campaign and it feels a little bit like a transactional approach. Well, thanks very much. Our course was to raise so many thousands. We did it. We did the goal. Yay, celebration. But we're forgetting the basics. Let me give you one which I found shocking statistic. You and I experienced this. You think that saying thank you when somebody's donated would be pretty common practice, right? So I've just donated in whatever form and receiving some form of thank you. I'm not even talking about the most impactful way of doing. I'm just talking about thank you in a way, an email, whatever. It, when you look at it, the statistics are pretty bad. So we look at this because we work with our prospects and customers about how, where can we improve? some things. If I give you sort of an aggregate number, saying thank you within, say, the first 2 weeks of a donation happens in less than 13% of cases.
Tony MartignettiNo,
Dennis Fois13%.
Tony MartignettiWhat, 2 weeks? It's supposed to be 24 hours. 24 hours for a perfunctory. And then maybe there's a follow-up. You know, I like to see a follow-up call or handwritten note or something. But The perfunctory should be 24 hours. You're saying 2 weeks and it's fewer than 13%?
Dennis Fois13, 1-3.
Tony MartignettiYeah.
Dennis FoisAnd then if we lengthen the time to 30 days, at which point I don't even remember what I've done to be honest with you. But then that number goes up to 18%, 1-8. So it's, it's a crazy number if you think about, if you set that number up against 75% first-time donor retention rate issues, right? And you say, say, but we never say thank you. To me, rather than looking at really structural societal economic reasons for why things are the way they are, we should really start to look at, are we doing absolutely everything we can to establish an emotional connection? And frankly, if you miss a thank you, Yeah, yeah, it sort of feels like you've got a— you had a false start, right?
Tony MartignettiYeah, no, you've blown the opportunity if you're responding with even a perfunctory thank you. As I said, I like to see 24 hours, but within 48 hours, you're going out to 2 weeks and it's only 13%. And what is that? I've never heard it that low, that Awful. What is that based on? That's Bloomerang clients?
Dennis FoisYeah, we look at prospects. So we, I'll give, I gave you sort of an aggregate number. Some folks are much better at it than others, but you'd be surprised. It's certainly not in a high, it's never in the high 80% or something like that. And there's always a reason, right? People say I didn't have whatever address or there's always some reason, but there's also no reason because if you and I would be running a business, There's always a way to say thank you to someone, right? So it feels to me there's plenty of, you know, hurdles that we can keep up with. I didn't have the right email address, didn't have the right phone number, or something happened. I didn't do it, whatever. But it's structurally super bad and it's always in the low single-digit percentage across the board. In fact, we often engage with prospects like that when we look at sort of They might have other systems or other tactics. And as they're looking for another system, they want to also improve the processes, right? And we often do these sort of assessments where we, that's what we do. We actually make small donations on behalf of us and we sort of see, we track what happens. And that's how we get that information. And
Tony Martignettiif you're not responding within 24 hours, I think it looks like you just don't care. Talk about grabbing someone from the heart first, you know, to give them a feeling, a warm feeling. Anything more than 24 hours looks like your gift doesn't really mean too much to us.
Dennis FoisRight. Right.
Tony MartignettiAnd 30 days, you may as well not, I don't know. Yeah, to me, after 2 weeks, you might not even bother. You've already blown the relationship unless, I don't know, unless you call with a Some kind of catastrophic story, you know, which is not likely. You've blown it. You've blown the opportunity.
Dennis FoisYeah, completely. And we often get a little bit of setback when you sort of look at it and say, hey, am I supposed to say thank you? Like, do I? What does it matter if I say automated email, for instance, as a thank you to everyone? That's not very personal. It's not very emotional. And I agree. But if you'd start by saying thank you to your first-time donors and have different means to engage with your retained donors, that would be a good start. You can't tell me that you are experienced, you have so many first-time donors that you can't deal with the volume like that. That seems, that seems like a, that's a very high bar to achieve. That's not what we are seeing, right? So I think if you just narrow it down and say, just hit the notes I had. I was engaged. I had a charity rally where we had sort of a thing with old cars and this was to support a local dog rescue. And we did a bunch of things like auctions and stuff like that and we made a donation. And it was so amazing that the following day I got a voicemail. So they didn't get with me, but that voicemail was fantastic. It was just a voicemail from the executive director. It was just like It was just a very nice warm, I heard the voice, it made me feel super good. I thought I did the right thing. Yeah. And now there is a, you know, a typical newsletter that follows. I actually read that newsletter now, right? Because I'm, I've got something there. Actually, I love that lady. I love how passionate she is about making sure that these dogs end up in the right homes and how deliberate she is about all of that. And she's got me like they've got me. I want to do more. And I thought it was as simple as just dropping me a voicemail. She didn't even try to call me. It was just a voicemail straight into my inbox. But because it was a voicemail and not an email, it was much more personal. And I'm pretty sure that day, maybe from that event, let's just be generous, say that she had 5 or 6 new donors, right? New first-time donors. Is it really that hard to To send five thank yous. I don't know. Seems like it's seems like it's doable.
Tony MartignettiNow you've you've mentioned this dog rescue a couple times now, so why don't you shout them out properly?
Dennis FoisNo, I can't. I can't because there's multiple. Oh oh oh oh! All right.
Tony MartignettiYou're a big. You're such a big dog lover. You can't shout out the. All right.
Dennis FoisAll right.
Tony MartignettiAll right. Well, we know we have to.
Dennis FoisThanks for the opportunity though, Tony. But I think I'm gonna get it. I'm gonna get it wrong somewhere with someone. Okay. It's a very small town.
Tony MartignettiAll right. We know we have a dog lover.
Kate MartignettiIt's time for a break. DonorBox. Quote, DonorBox text-to-give led to one of our more successful fundraising events, a concert. Sharing the keyword, shortcode, and scannable QR code made giving easy for our supporters, and they did give. That's from Josh Young. Executive Director of Hydrating Humanity. DonorBox, helping you help others. donorbox.org. Now back to donor retention.
Tony MartignettiSo with automations, I mean, this— you give a gift, you have to provide an email address and, and/or a phone number so you can send them email or a text Again, this perfunctory, you know, within 24 hours. I just don't see any reason why with automations that are pretty standard, right? You should be able to send an immediate perfunctory.
Dennis FoisTechnology problem. It's not a technology problem. There are no technological hurdles here. I mean, systems might be difficult to use and what have you, but you can— it's not rocket science. Once you've done it once, you can figure it out. I think the You know what? It's the way I think about it, which is fascinating. I think we have three big challenges that we need to think through. They're gonna be pretty structural. We've got aging donors. We've got declining small donations. So from gifts up to $100 and from $100 to $500 are down across the board, and we have a very hard time retaining first-time donors. Those are the three like big. Themes, if you can call them that, or headwinds, whatever you want to call them, that we need to think through. Okay, these are gonna be here for a while. How do I respond to those? Right. And the bizarre thing is that because we have aging donors, we need to think about our donors as a whole. We need to think about, okay, how do I tap into younger donors? How do I tap into How do I broaden my connection to household and not have a singular donor within a household? So you need to think about that. And it's remarkable then that when we're presented with an opportunity to have a first-time donor, that we, we, we wouldn't be obsessed about retaining these donors in some way, either by— and if, and if the friction is around the donation. Yeah. I'd rather take a small recurring donation over a haphazard first-time donation. So there are strategies too. So we have all the tools in place. It's just that it's almost like we are applying principles that we have applied for years to today. But today things are really starting to accelerate. So when we think of, you know, frankly dying donors and not being part of estate planning and such. We really need to think about tapping into different generational side. Now that generation, you have, then you have other questions, which is, is email the best medium, etc., etc.? But there is an amazing opportunity there, in my opinion, to tap into because we are getting the first-time donors in. We are getting them. So it's not like the next generation is not generous. It's quite the opposite, actually. The generation that we all love to hate, the Gen Zs and the millennials are extraordinarily driven by impact and doing good for the world. They are probably one of the most in tune generations. We're just not connecting with them. And their retention rates will continue to show what they're showing if we're applying these types of methods here. So it's a fascinating challenge.
Tony MartignettiI wonder if some of the problem with connecting with the millennials and Gen Z is that the leadership are baby boomers and they're not listening to their own millennial and Gen Z employees, or they're not even seeking the advice of those younger folks about how to connect the younger donors. Again, emotionally, I think if you start with the heart, the brain follows. Yeah. So you had that heartfelt, genuine, sincere voicemail, just a voicemail, and it's drawn you in. And that's so that's an example. So they're not they're not taking the advice, and I think these boomers, of which I'm one, a young one, a very very very very very very very very young boomer, but I am just barely a baby boomer. You know, the generation is not taking the advice of younger folks, seeking the advice of younger folks about how to connect with. younger folks. And that, and that be— they are your future planned giving donors. Planned giving is what I do. Fundraising consulting strictly in planned giving. So if you want to have that pipeline of long-term, you know, the, the ultimate, the ultimate gift for a lot of people is in their estate plan. If you want to benefit from that ultimate giving, you need to be treating these folks well from the, from the jump, from that first 24 hours that we're talking about, and, and then beyond. I, you know, we've, we've We've broadened beyond the initial thank you. But, you know, that's, I mean, that's a, again, back to a business. I mean, that's how a business maintains a pipeline of customers. Well, you know, you have, we have to have a pipeline of prospects.
Dennis FoisRight.
Tony MartignettiThroughout the age spectrum, throughout, on all the different ways of giving, monthly sustainers and major and people who give just once, once a year or give just to a particular program, just give around the gala if we're, suffering an event like that. I don't wanna get into the difficulties of event, major event fundraising, but, you know, we're just not, we're not, you're right. We're not creating, like, thinking of it like a business and we're not treating our pipeline of prospects and donors appropriately. So,
Dennis Foisyeah, you know what strikes me as, because it, I can imagine that it's, listen, it's hard. There's a million things to do. You're resource constrained. It's, there's a, there's high stress involved with fundraising, but there seem to be some opportunities to rather than try and figure it all out on your own. There's dozens and dozens of millennials that want to do volunteer work. And instead of doing, letting them do volunteer work on your core nonprofit cause, why don't enlist them to help you With the communication and using social media, and just the there's so many of these of that generation is so in tune with it. But what I'm seeing over and over again is we recruiting them for helping them with the local dog rescue. I had a conversation with them. I said, "I noticed that one here." This is why I've been a very long time donor of, and they what I noticed is hey. I get all these lovely updates about dogs that need a home and placements, but I hardly ever see what happens after. And the real reason why, like, why I care is I want to make sure that those dogs go to the right place. And I believe in your ability to do that. And that's why I, I'm prepared to sort of help out. But the story that I really want to see is a happy dog in a happy household. But I never see those stories. Yeah, occasionally there's one in the newsletter. But you're placing like So many dogs, and and then the penny dropped, as we would say, is why don't we get some? There was a volunteer, like it was a there was a girl that was sort of helping with the shelter and you know helping to take care of the dogs and getting them ready, you know making them look good for for these for the visits. And she was very very skilled at social media. She was on Instagram. She was on this and it. And she sort of said, well, now why don't we just get these new families to record a little short video on their iPhone after, you know, a couple of days in the home, like the first week, you know, the first week with Fluffy. And it needs to be a very like badly shot video, not produced. It is what it is. Doesn't matter. And then they said, well, what do we do with the video? You just give that video to me. I'll take care of it, she said. And it was wonderful. And within a, honestly, within a week, I think it turned into this whole thing that now they basically say, hey, as part of the placement of the dog, we need you to give us an update on how it's going. And that update is a simple little video they send it to it that now goes on the social page that gets connected to the newsletter, goes on the website. And now there's a whole different audience that they're tapping into. And these dog stories are starting to do the rounds now. What did that cost? Not very much. Would a baby boomer be very good at executing that? Probably not. But you don't have to, like, you can use volunteers in different ways that you can use volunteers to help you with reach. And in fact, it might actually be more helpful because that generation probably connects better to their own than sort of a grumpy old boomer or young boomer telling a grumpy—
Tony MartignettiNow you added grumpy. That was not fair.
Dennis FoisI was referring to myself.
Tony MartignettiAll right. Well, you take that on yourself. Fine. I didn't think about grumpiness. You threw that in. You tried. All right. Yeah, just, you know, use the talent that you have, whether it's volunteer, it's on your team, maybe it's a consultant. You know, what you're describing sounds precious. The production value is meaningless.
Dennis FoisYes.
Tony MartignettiIt's the substance and You know, they probably now, you know, or they will soon have scores of these videos that they can repurpose on Instagram, TikTok, Mastodon, YouTube, their own site, of course, links in newsletters, you know, a compilation of, you know, 30-second videos or something. And that's the impact that a lot of people want to see. And especially, well, Donors really, I think, across the age spectrum are much more cognizant of impact, much more interested in impact. But I think younger folks are even more so. Dennis, let's talk some more about some tactics of drawing in, making that emotional connection, getting the heart and letting the brain follow.
Dennis FoisYeah. A couple of things on that. I think we, we as an industry rely very heavily on email and I'm not so sure that's a great idea. I think email is useful and helpful, but I don't know about your inbox, what that looks like. Mine looks pretty challenging. I've got a work one and I've got a private one and I take a deep sigh in the morning when I have to sort of make weed my way through whatever, you know, irrelevant stuff. It starts with deleting a whole bunch of stuff, and hopefully I haven't deleted too much. So email is challenging to get attention, number one. And two, it's actually not easy to make email create sort of reinforce or establish an emotional connection because you have to be actually quite good, quite good with words. And that's a high bar, I think. There are some science out there about how you should write. I mean, the TLDR is just always write about these stories. So the more of these stories you have to your point on impact, the more you should do it. But relying on email alone and then thinking that you have done it, I think is a pretty big mistake. I think you have a— I like email as a— you mentioned a couple of ideas of things like a newsletter or an update. So something that we basically is periodic. So, hey, we're here, this is what we've done. That's great. That's wonderful. But I much prefer that folks, and we're starting to see that experiment with different media and voice, for instance, is still very much underutilized. So people are not really using voice. There was actually an email that came in for someone that just recorded a blurb like they had, like it was like a Zoom like we're doing now today. And they included that Zoom into it, but there was no video, it was just voice. And they were just telling, there was an update of the month, but they said we're gonna try something different. We're gonna, I'm gonna, so the executive director spoke on the Zoom. I thought that was nice. So that was unusual. So I had a voice, I had them talk. There was a bit of a funny moment. So you can hear them laugh as they said that. I had plugged it in my AirPods as I was walking. So easy, I don't have to really You know, be concentrated on my on my desk to read it all. So I thought it was a great, great way to use it. Video is still very underutilized. We all you know how it is. It's not that difficult anymore to to have the video. You can still use your email to send it. And so I think when it comes to tactics, that we have to be careful not to rely on one and just set it and forget it, right? So you basically say, oh yeah, I am communicating with my donors. I'm sending them an email. Email. I send a newsletter every month. Yeah, you know, is that the bar? Like, is that— what is the latest? What is the late— what have you tried? What other things have you tried? Do you know whether they open it and read it? Do you have that? Because nowadays we know, right? We have a pretty good idea of whether folks read it or not. And then what do you do with that information? You just continue sending stuff. The other question I have, so that's one thing is about the tactics is don't rely on a singular tactic. Just Set some sort of a goal that every year or every quarter of it, whatever is feasible, you try something new and see if it sticks. Just stick it and stay with it for a few months, but just try it, try it. The other thing I would say is as much as there's a reliance on the medium, email, phone, video, whatever, there's also a reliance on the recipient, which is who we're sending it to. What I find, there's a concept in business that's called single threading, which is never referred to as a positive thing. It's a bad thing. Single threading. Okay. What it means is that you're basically, when you're trying to connect with an account, with a prospect, it's usually a business. And when you're single threaded in the account, it means that you're only speaking with one contact in that organization. And you know that a decision usually has to make with multiple people. And very often, even if there's a CEO, a CEO would want to make sure that her team is consulted, etc. So whether these folks are making, whether others are making the decision or influences is irrelevant. It's very rare that one person calls all the shots. It's much more common that multiple people have to engage, be engaged, consulted, and informed.
Kate MartignettiIt's time for a break. Keela. Increase donations and foster collaborative teamwork with Keela, the fundraiser CRM. Maximize your team's productivity and spend more time building strong connections with your donors through features that were built specifically for fundraisers. A fundraiser CRM goes beyond data management platform. It's designed with the unique needs of fundraisers in mind. And aims to unify fundraising, communications, and donor management tools into one single source of truth. Visit keela.co to sign up for a coming group demo and explore how to exceed your fundraising goals like never before. It's time for Tony's Take Two.
Tony MartignettiThanks, Kate. This week's show gets published on September 11th, The anniversary of the day that changed our country, changed the world profoundly. We all remember where we were. I was an employee. It was the dark days of employment for me at St. John's University in Queens, New York. And St. John's is up on a hill. We could see downtown Manhattan. So it was in a distance, but we could see it happening live. We were going between watching live and for real and watching on TV, you know, more close up, of course. But everybody's got their story of September 11th. And I think we should just use the anniversary as a time to remember, to Keep in mind the victims, the immediate victims this week, and also not only the ones who died that day, but those who are still dying from their service there and from exposures. Let's just remember those folks this week. That is Tony's Take Two. Kate.
Kate MartignettiYou reminded me of a saying I once heard. They're gone, but never forgotten.
Tony MartignettiYes. Yes.
Kate MartignettiLet's go back to donor retention with Dennis Fois.
Dennis FoisSo you want to become multi-threaded to increase your odds of success. In my opinion, the same is true for a household. If you solely rely on the first contact that you ever had, that is the donor that has actually made the donation, but you know that they're part of, or you might not even know that they're part of a household, and you're not making any efforts to deeper connect and create more contacts in that household organization, you're missing a big, big, big trick and a big opportunity. Because I think that the more we can establish an emotional connection at the household level, the higher the chances that things make sense as part of estate planning. This is a long-drawn process, but being simply relying and only communicating to a singular donor, in my opinion, is a risky affair. And so doing events whereby partners or children are involved, do whatever you can. You obviously can't ask who else is in your household, give me their email addresses. Understand, but there's not, but you could make events deliberately and purposeful designed to bring the family together, to bring them all in and then start to collect data as part of that event, right? Uh, I don't see a lot of that.
Tony MartignettiYeah. Yeah. It's consistent with your first idea is not be singular channel, you know, be multichannel, uh, be multithread.
Dennis FoisExactly.
Tony MartignettiYeah, I see that play out a lot in events where there might be a couple there. Again, I do planned giving, so the events I'm going to are usually for older folks, not necessarily planned giving age, but planned giving prospect age. And there are a lot of couples, whether married or partnered, And I see a lot of conversations with one person in the couple. And it's usually the male in a traditional hetero couple. And the female is largely ignored. But whatever the couple dynamics, it's a mistake to just be talking to the one person. Because you want the support, you want the buy-in of the couple. It just makes things so much smoother. You reduce any contention around giving that might be playing out in the home that you have no idea about. So don't talk to one person to the exclusion of the other person in the couple.
Dennis FoisRight.
Tony MartignettiI see that a lot. And I bet in-person events, right? That's a mistake.
Dennis FoisThat's a big mistake. And I bet, Tony, that it's, if you were to go back, even if they've spoken or connected in some way, I bet that if you go back and look at the database and say, let's say the Fois household, and we had a nice conversation with me and my wife, that when you look back at the database, my wife's contact information is not in that database.
Tony MartignettiRight? Right.
Dennis FoisSo because it's, again, none of these things happen with one conversation that like, it's very rare. I mean, that's magical when it happens. It's wonderful. But it's usually, it takes time, it takes repeated connections, interactions over a long period of time. And so the best chance we have is if we broaden our reach, but not just broaden our reach, we're constantly trying to find new people all the time. To your point, this big funnel machine. But if we can expand within our existing donors, we absolutely improve our retention rates. And the reality is, if you improve your retention rates by sort of 10% or so, you triple the lifetime value over time over your donor base. So it behooves upon all of us How do you improve retention rates? Well, it's not just constantly talking to the same person and sending them more stuff. That's, that's, that's, that's, you know, that, that has a diminishing return. So, and I feel that we probably need to talk more in industry about it and share ideas or how others are doing it and talk more about these tactics because I feel that some of the, some of the nonprofit organizations that we talk to want to do it. They're not afraid of experimenting, but sometimes sort of lack the applicable ideas because the industry has started to become quite academic. How we talk about things, you know, theoretical concepts and big numbers and scary numbers and frankly paralyzing numbers at times, like doesn't inspire me to act, right? And I think we maybe need to do a slightly better job as an industry. And I think you do that with your— Yeah. Things like your podcast where you get deeper into things and just try ideas that I can sort of, you know, walk away with. Give me 1 or 2 ideas that I can do tomorrow then, and I can at least, I can sort of figure out whether it works. So it might work for some, it won't work for others. But if you don't try, you don't know. And the reality is there's no one approach that will work for everyone, but relying on email alone And only talking to your donor is a guaranteed, guaranteed path that sets you to become part of the statistics. Yeah, because that's basically how they've been built.
Tony MartignettiOn the wrong end. Yeah, yeah, it's shallow. It's not a heart-to-heart connection. You know, as you were speaking, I was thinking, you know, when you call, If the non-primary donor answers, do you just ask for the donor? Or do you say, oh, hello, you know, and wouldn't it be great if you could hearken back to when you had the conversation at the last event with that other person? Oh, it was such a pleasure to meet you, you know, or do you just say, you know, oh, hi, can I speak to Dennis? You know, that's a turnoff. It's perceived by both people in the couple. It may not ever be spoken about, or even worse, it might be, but it's detrimental in either case. It's just, you know, it's fundamental respect for people.
Dennis FoisWell, I agree, respect, but also sound business mind, right? If you want to, like, if it's a good business practice. So there's the head and the heart that comes together. If you were to think that anytime that you connect with someone, the donor, but you get somebody else on the phone as a prospecting opportunity, that might be the right mindset, you know, because that's how you treat a new event when you, when there's new families and new folks coming in, it'd be all over those, right? To tell the story and why you started the organization. The same is true for this prospect with the big benefit that it's a warm prospect. It's not a cold prospect, right? Because there's a connection. So if you think about how do I increase donation sizes? How do I become maybe part of recurring giving? Those are the situations where that happens, where both partners have an emotional connection with the cause and stimulate one another to say, hey, this is something we really want to support as a family. Now that always leads to more sustained and higher donations versus being one of the 2 partners that support it because it's their charity of choice.
Tony MartignettiYeah. Other thoughts, Dennis, about tactics that folks can at least experiment with?
Dennis FoisYeah. Well, so what if, what has been pretty successful, this might be a little sort of personal, but what has been successful here locally, it was actually quite interesting. So we, there are these groups of people that get together for hobbies. In our case, I'm part of a club that likes Old cars. So old people and old cars come together once in a while and they do, they take whatever excuse on there is to sort of drive these things. And, but we wanted to add a little bit of more depth to it. So we started to seek out whether there were interesting nonprofit organizations around us that we could support somehow. So to make these, so we would basically say, Hey, as part of this drive, there is a cost to the drive and that this cost was basically fundraising. So we would raise through these drivers a donation and we would then have that money go to a charity of choice, right? One that we would say, hey, this month we're gonna support this. What I found remarkable is that very few nonprofit organization had identified that a lot of these events were happening. I've got a local tennis club. There's a local, there's a very, very big car community here in Carmel and Monterey. It's just a thing. So everybody that lives here knows that. But what I found staggering is that it was actually hard work for us to find. We actually had to seek out nonprofit organizations and explain that we wanted to do some events. And then once we had that, people were very generous and said, oh, we come over and speak, we can say a few things about what we said we will do. And we would attach an auction, a little auction or something around to just make sure that these are affluent people. So, you know, making donations is, is a, is not a high friction situation. But what I found remarkable and a missed opportunity, which we're now making more available, is tap into these communities. So, you know, there are in Indy, it's the same in Indianapolis, there's a lot of communities that have certain themes that folks that get together, a lot of them would be very happy supported causes. And so what I'm seeing—
Tony MartignettiPardon me, but these are essentially giving circles.
Dennis FoisThey are. Yeah.
Tony MartignettiI had the evangelist for giving circles, Sara Lomelin, on the show just within the past 6 weeks or so. So, you know, whether it's a car club or a bunch of folks who meet once a month, in someone's, in rotating homes, you know, or it's some other, some other organization that's willing to do fundraising and granting. You're essentially talking about giving circles in your community.
Dennis Fois100%. That's a wonderful way of putting it and talk about building a funnel and building connection into your community. And they very often become repeat themes, especially if there is an emotive connection with the individual. If the executive director does a good job at presenting, being there, telling the story of the organization, you know, you're— I would say it's almost guaranteed there'll be some sort of successful. So it's really worth doing. But again, it's about being proactive and seeking those out, making an effort to actually find out what is around me. That seems to me, I was blown away. It's now become a thing with us. So every month there's something that sometimes there's twice a month or something. But what is also interesting is that most of us end up giving to the ones that we are really connected with, right? So there is the event itself that produces us. But some of us actually get, we had a lady that had a very traumatic situation with her husband and a child, and a child had a disease that was very difficult to cure. And it sort of inspired her to create an organization, a nonprofit organization to help folks with, with us in a similar situation. And she, when she told her story, I, most of us couldn't keep it together, to be honest. So, It just becomes like a different level of connectivity and accountability. And so I know I want to help here. This is crazy. There's no support from healthcare. This is sort of underrecognized. These people are all out on their own, actually, with a little bit of money, a lot can be done. So you start to connect the dots and say, what I can actually have a real impact here. And help to make a situation better. I can fund if I can fund this lady, people's life will change. And when you get to that sort of level of this is where my money or time can go, and this is the impact it can achieve. I wouldn't. I mean, I'm reluctant to say donor for life because we know that that's a difficult thing. But that's that level of connection that no email in the world, no phone in the world can can hope to achieve. And so. If you're not out there connecting with an audience like that, new circles, you're making it yourself very hard, I think, to find these people that are, that are then spreading the word because I then talk to others about it. So we know how that all works, right? So I would say those are still very underutilized ideas. So this, the, this idea of using multiple channels of communications. expanding within the families, sort of the multithreading thing that we're talking about and exploring the circles rather than treating individuals as transactions. We have a lot of room for improvement when it comes about executing and doing good, better, best on those. And so in a way, the statistics that we talked about are not that surprising because frankly, if you'd run a business, In the way we are running as an industry, nonprofits, these are the statistics that you would get. It's like fast in, fast out.
Tony MartignettiYeah,
Dennis Foisit's a classic bad business model. Like,
Tony Martignettiyeah, Bloomerang wouldn't survive that way.
Dennis FoisNo, no, no, no, my board would swap me out real quick.
Tony MartignettiYou had clients, you had clients for a year and 77% of them stayed only that long. Yeah, loyalty. You know, it's all the heart, loyalty, connections, speaking from the heart, respecting people. And then, yeah, you know, and so I speak kind of altruistically or maybe not academically, but altruistic and lofty. And, you know, you remind us that it's also all good business. It's all good business to think of the partner as a prospect, to have folks telling their own story in a simple iPhone video with low production value from the home with dim lighting and the sound is cutting out and the children are in the background. But the newly placed dog Pet is barking wildly. And that's the, you know, that's the impact.
Dennis FoisPerfect.
Tony MartignettiThat's perfect. It's, that's the, those are the moments that are sincere and genuine, connect with our hearts and end up being good business.
Dennis FoisYeah, I could not agree with you more. And that head and heart thing, I think When we, when our organizations get larger, nonprofit organizations get larger, you, it's okay to think of a part of it as a business. It's okay actually, because the more effective the organization becomes, the greater the impact you can achieve. At our company at Bloomerang, we have often sort of struggled with that balance where you sort of say, well, is it all about growing revenues? Is that basically the mark of success for us? Or how do we measure impact? But the reality is you should not pit those 2 things against each other because if you could see fundraising volume or revenue, you could see that as fuel and you need fuel. We need fuel. So you wouldn't shortchange yourself for making sure like you feel really good, you've done this wonderful thing, but it doesn't scale. Because it requires you to do it over and over. It can't scale. But now you're not putting fuel in that tank, and we we have to have fuel because the more fuel we have, the greater the impact that we can achieve. The more resource. So the problem is that we have in this in this industry is difficult for us to attract and retain talent. So as much as we have a donor retention problem, look at the employee retention problem that we have in this industry. And if you become more successful at creating scalable and repeatable initiatives, because you're experimenting, you're trying things, you're making these emotional connections. We can attract high-quality people into the organization that can sort of sustain and increase that momentum. So I often, when we talk about this, it feels like, yeah, but you can't run a nonprofit organization like a business. And I said, well, why not? Why not? You know, if you, I, at some point, I'd like to work in an organization like this. But you better believe it that I'm gonna be very intense in the work. I'm not gonna sort of be relaxed because I work in a nonprofit because I'm gonna be super intense if we're wasting money or if we are not following up on things or something goes out that is a little bit half-baked and it's not a high standard. Like, why, why wouldn't those things apply? Isn't that what makes things better? Like striving to better standards, doing something, trying something different. Growing as an organization. So I think we have to destigmatize the brain part in this industry and say that it's okay to pursue growing as an organization because that growth allows to achieve far greater impact than the individual that started the organization ever thought was imaginable. So growth has to be part of the objective of the organization.
Tony MartignettiDennis Fois, I'd like to leave it there.
Dennis FoisThank you, Tony.
Tony MartignettiAnd I, I uncategorically agree with you about perceiving our organizations as businesses. Uh, I, I, I, I, I take it a step further and say I think it's essential. We don't, we don't lose our heart. We don't lose our mission. The two are not mutually exclusive. We can, we can pursue our missions And our values as well as think of ourselves as a business. That's not zero sum.
Dennis Fois100%. 100%.
Tony MartignettiDennis Fois, F-O-I-S. He's CEO of Bloomerang. You'll find Dennis on LinkedIn. You'll find the company at bloomerang.co. Dennis, thank you very much for sharing your thinking. I appreciate it.
Dennis FoisHuge thanks for the opportunity, Tony. Really enjoyed it. Thank you.
Tony MartignettiMy, my pleasure. Thank you.
Kate MartignettiNext week, Donor Dominance with Ian MacQuillin. If you missed any part of this week's show,
Tony MartignettiI beseech you, find it at tonymartignetti.com.
Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by DonorBox. Outdated donation forms blocking your supporters' generosity? DonorBox, fast, flexible, and friendly fundraising forms for your nonprofit. donorbox.org.
Tony MartignettiI love that alliteration.
Kate MartignettiAnd by Keela. Grow revenue, engage donors, and increase efficiency with Keela, the fundraiser's CRM. Visit keela.co to join the thousands of fundraisers using Keela to exceed their goals. Our creative producer is Claire Meyerhoff. I'm your associate producer, Kate Martignetti. The show's social media is by Susan Chavez. Marc Silverman is our web guy, and this music is by Scott Stein.
Tony MartignettiThank you for that affirmation, Scotty. Be with us next week for Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. Go out and be great.
I love our sponsor!


