Skip to content
EP 655August 27, 2023

Employee Benefits, For Employees

Tony MartignettiCourtenay Shipley
Nonprofit Radio
Episode 655
0:00 / 0:00

About this episode

We’re examining benefits from the employee’s perspective. What does a minimum package look like? Which extras can you negotiate for? How valuable is your benefits package? Explaining it all is Courtenay Shipley, founder of Retirement Planology.

Here’s the transcript

Tony MartignettiHello and welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. I'm your aptly named host and the podfather of your favorite hebdomadal podcast. Oh, I'm glad you're with us. I'd get slapped with a diagnosis of fascial apsiasis if you infected me with the idea that you missed this week's show. Ordinarily, our associate producer Kate would tell us about the show this week, but this week isn't ordinary. Kate's family, which is my family, is visiting me at the beach this week, plus my wife is here. Let's get the Martignettis and Amy to the mic to share which nonprofit is their favorite and why that's so. We're going to start with my brother Andrew. What's your favorite nonprofit, Andrew?

Andrew MartignettiWell, Tony, when I was 16 and a half years old, I had to give some consideration to my Boy Scout Eagle Scout project as I was feverishly working on merit badges, trying to get everything done. It was posed to me that the St. Jude Children's Research Hospital would be a very good cause for fundraising. So I decided to put together a bike-a-thon in my town, and we raised approximately $300, which back in 1984 was a lot of money. Wow. Well, that was a pretty good amount of money, and it worked out very well. So I believe St. Jude's Children's Research Hospital, a very good nonprofit, and donations were greatly appreciated and worked out very nicely.

Tony MartignettiAll right, congratulations on being an Eagle Scout. You're not— you're not— we never use the past tense. You're still an Eagle Scout. Eagle Scout for life, right?

Andrew MartignettiVery well put.

Tony MartignettiAll right. And, uh, of course, Boy Scouts of America, another nonprofit. All right. Next comes my sister-in-law, Nancy. Nancy, what is your favorite nonprofit and why is that so?

Nancy MartignettiTony, I actually have 2, um, and they're both kind of similar in, in what they do. Uh, the first one is, uh, Bow Wows and Meows Pet Rescue. Um, that is where we got our old dog Hank from.

Tony MartignettiAnd shout out, where is Bow Wows and Meows?

Nancy MartignettiIt's actually in South Carolina.

Tony MartignettiOh, okay.

Nancy MartignettiAnd then the other one is One Love Pet Rescue— I'm sorry, One Love Animal Rescue, and they are out of New Jersey, and that's where we got our current dog Aspen from. So I believe that rescuing is the way to go, and you should adopt and not shop.

Tony MartignettiAdopt and not shop and not kill, of course.

Nancy MartignettiCorrect.

Tony MartignettiAll right, cool. 2 nonprofits. Thank you. Amy, my wife Amy, favorite nonprofit, please.

Amy MartignettiYes, thank you, hubby. Um, mine is ICOMF.org. That stands for International Church of Music, which was founded within the last 10 months by my uncle and myself. It's in Muncie, Indiana. The mission is to provide instruments at no cost to children who are underprivileged so that they can learn how to play music. It will also be— it is a church that we purchased, and so it will be a venue for students to perform so that they can hone their performance skills, perform at no cost to themselves or their group, and also to teach master classes. My uncle has worked in the music industry for almost 50 years and has a lot of contacts through Los Angeles and Just, he knows a lot of good, very good musicians. And so to bring in outstanding teachers to offer master classes at no charge as well.

Tony MartignettiThat's the International Church of Music Foundation?

Amy MartignettiFoundation.

Tony MartignettiICOMF.

Amy MartignettiYes. .org.

Tony Martignetti.org. Thank you.

Amy MartignettiThank you.

Tony MartignettiAll right. And Kate, favorite nonprofit, please.

Kate MartignettiMy favorite nonprofit would have to be Traveling Tutus Incorporated. Their mission is to collect different dance wears, dance shoes, and send them off to dancers around the world who aren't able to afford that kind of stuff. And I— it would have to be my favorite because my passion is also dance. And I was able to actually be an ambassador for their company, and we did like different costume collections. We've done bake sales, and I was able to give everything that I earned and collected to Traveling Tutus. And I was able to look on their Instagram and kind of see where all that stuff really went to. So So that would be my favorite.

Tony MartignettiCool. And they shared with you their impact. You saw the work that was getting done. International Tutus.

Kate MartignettiTraveling Tutus.

Tony MartignettiTraveling, sorry. Traveling Tutus. All right. Thanks everybody. Martignetti family and Amy Drum love nonprofits. Now, Kate, what's on this week's show?

Kate MartignettiWell, Tony, this week we have Employee benefits for employees. We're examining benefits from the employee's perspective. What does a minimum package look like? Which extras can you negotiate for? How valuable is your benefits package? Explaining it all is Courtenay Shipley, founder of Retirement Planology, on Tony's Take Two.

Tony MartignettiNational Make-A-Will Month continues.

Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by DonorBox. Outdated donation forms blocking your supporters' generosity? DonorBox. Fast, flexible, and friendly fundraising forms for your nonprofit. DonorBox.org.

Tony MartignettiI still love that alliteration. Fast, flexible, friendly fundraising forms. Oh, sorry. Go ahead.

Kate MartignettiHere is Employee Benefits for Employees.

Tony MartignettiIt's a pleasure to welcome Courtenay Shipley to Nonprofit Radio. She is the founder and chief planologist of Retirement Planology, a consulting and registered investment advisory firm for corporate-sponsored and nonprofit-sponsored retirement plans. She has worked with qualified retirement plans, developed strategies for third-party administrators, and conducted over 10,000 educational meetings. Number 10,001. It's right now. Courtenay is on LinkedIn and her company is at retirementplanology.com. Courtenay, welcome to Nonprofit Radio.

Courtenay ShipleyThank you so much for having me. It's a real pleasure to be here.

Tony MartignettiOh, I'm glad you are. And I didn't— I don't even mean to cut you short too. I mean, I'm saying this is 10,001, but you've already done over 10,000. So this could be number 11,424. We don't know.

Courtenay ShipleyI stopped counting.

Tony MartignettiYou stopped counting. That's probably a good idea. All right. Well, we don't want to stop counting our benefits, our benefits. And we want to look at this from the employee perspective. I'd like folks who are employees to know what they could get, what— whether what they're getting is good or not, things like that. So let's start with what are minimum Bare bones, you know, you're getting something but not a lot, but, but you're getting the bare minimum type benefits package. What, what does that look like?

Courtenay ShipleyOkay. So when you're thinking about your benefits package, think of it in terms of your employer is providing your paycheck, and then they're providing these other benefits that in general are kind of building your fi— your foundation for your financial security in some way. Okay, so you have your paycheck, obviously, as your largest asset, the ability to be able to work. They're providing that. We know that one. The next one that you might not be thinking about is what happens if you have a health issue? Obviously, that's health insurance, right? Or if it's really bad, you can't go to work, you're out for an extended period of time, that's going to be disability insurance. What happens to your paycheck if you're not around anymore and somebody else depends on it? That's where life insurance comes in. What happens if you don't want to work forever and a day for that paycheck? Well, that's where your retirement plan comes in. So that's going to help you build a paycheck in the future from the money that you're saving today, and maybe your employer's contributing too. And so when you think about your, your financial security from that perspective, that's, that's kind of the easy thermometer for seeing You know what, what's good, what's not good, and then everything else after that will fall into a different category for you. For example, maybe you are early on in your career, and you know you're going to need to get some more education to advance, and maybe those tuition type reimbursement programs are going to be useful for you. Maybe you live in a big city. And getting to work is a pain. So there's a, there's a transportation stipend that you're given, or parking on site. My gosh, in the Washington, D.C. area to have parking, what a luxury.

Tony MartignettiRight.

Courtenay ShipleyMaybe you're looking more towards, you've got student loan payments. And we know with, with many nonprofits, if you stay for a certain amount of time, then perhaps you can have your student loan taken care of by the government, depending on if you qualify for all the programs. Um, so that's another thing to be thinking about. Or would they pay something towards your student loan, a student loan payback program? You might be looking at like, do they have discounts with maybe child care providers or someone that can help, you know, you're with your aging parent and, and figuring out what they need to do from a caretaker perspective? And this could be also just building out further on like the health insurance piece. Is there something that's going to help with mental wellness? Is there something that's going to happen with financial wellness? Are these different types of programs? Um, and those could be formal or informal, right? So when you're looking at what they're providing to you, you want to have a list of what's important to you, and then you want to also look at their list and say, what on this list is relevant to me? Right? Because they may have all the benefits in the world, but if it's not something that resonates with you and you know you're not going to use it, well, yay for having great benefits, but what a bummer that you don't get to use all of them.

Tony MartignettiYeah. If you don't have student loan debt or children, then student loan—

Courtenay ShipleyHalf of what I just talked about doesn't matter.

Tony MartignettiRepayment assistance and childcare don't matter. And some places even provide childcare, not just—

Courtenay ShipleyYeah.

Tony MartignettiRight, payments. But some, some larger organizations have on-site childcare.

Courtenay ShipleyThat's usually a very large organization. Yes, for sure.

Tony MartignettiAll right. Or maybe they have an arrangement somewhere. All right.

Courtenay ShipleyYeah.

Tony MartignettiYou mentioned, you mentioned that these— something could be formal or informal. What do you mean by in a more— well, I think we know what— well, go ahead, make the distinction. What's, what's, what are you distinguishing between formal and informal benefits?

Courtenay ShipleySo let's talk about The financial wellness piece. That's an easy one. They may have someone that you can talk to that comes along with your retirement plan, for example, or maybe you call the plan's record keeper to have your, your financial questions answered. Maybe it's a formal program on site where they come every other month and present different topics and also one-on-one counseling. Maybe as a third tier of that, maybe you have access to software Or budgeting software like You Need a Budget or something like that, where you get that for free being a benefit of being an employee there. So from a, this comes along with, or occasionally we do these types of programming, to something that's more formal where it's obvious that they are paying for a third party to provide something for you.

Tony MartignettiOkay. Okay. You mentioned life insurance. Is that a common one? Is life insurance common?

Courtenay ShipleyYeah, I would say that that's a pretty, a pretty common one, either for the, um, for the nonprofit to sponsor, to pay for like a basic benefit. Those are usually very inexpensive, um, on the employer side to, to have a group life insurance program. Um, and it may not be a ton of coverage, so it may be up to $50,000 or $100,000 or something like that. And then the employee often has the ability to buy up So if you do have other people that depend on your paycheck, that could be a really cost-effective way to get extra coverage through work.

Tony MartignettiAnd depending on what level you're working at, you might have different degrees of death benefits. So the CEO might have a half a million dollar policy.

Courtenay ShipleyThat could be possible. That could be possible. Yeah.

Tony MartignettiYeah. What about, what about vesting for these? We— there's— that's the period you have to wait before certain benefits become active.

Courtenay ShipleySo, um, yeah, there's 2 ways. So really, I think what you're getting at is eligibility, right? How long somebody has to wait before they can enroll in the program.

Tony MartignettiYeah. Oh, is it eligibility, not vesting?

Courtenay ShipleyYeah, vesting is more like, uh, portability. So with, uh, like for your, your retirement plan, for example, they may give you an employer contribution or employer match, and if you left right away without having been there very long, your employer contributions might not all travel with you. They might not all be yours to keep. There could be a vesting schedule, so you earn ownership of it over time. But with eligibility, yeah, that's— it's all over the map. Um, I've seen it be as soon as day one when you're hired. I've seen it be staggered, so certain benefits kick in at certain times, like your health insurance starts first, but maybe your retirement isn't until you've been there for one year. I'm seeing more and more employers trying to make that easier from an administrative burden, and also for employees who just want to know how much is going to be missing from their check, right, by the time they put their own contributions in. So I'm seeing that come down as far as the amount of time it takes to be eligible for these types of programs, and also less of the staggering, like, well, you get the health insurance this month, you get the retirement this month, you get the life insurance this month, that sort of thing.

Tony MartignettiIs it fair to include remote work among benefits? I mean, it's not a formal package like you— a nonprofit would hire an insurance company to provide life insurance, but—

Courtenay ShipleyRight.

Tony MartignettiIsn't that fair? Is that a fair conversation to have when you're talking about benefits?

Courtenay ShipleyAbsolutely. Absolutely. We're seeing employees, you know, asking for it. I would It's going to depend on the employer and the flexibility and the amount of work and the type of work that, that you're doing for them. But it's always good to ask, like, where does this need to take place? But there's also the other component of how much does your team need you to be around and how do you use the face time strategically within your organization to help people's careers grow over time? Because a lot of times when we're talking to an employee, it's usually about finances and they're disgruntled. A lot of times it doesn't have anything to do with their compensation as much as just the work environment. Yeah. environment or not feeling like they have a career path. And so being able to attract and retain the talent that you want— benefits are really important, but also kind of that, that how we do work now after coming out of COVID that's a, that's a really big question to answer. How does workflow work? How does work get done? How do people get to move up in their career at your organization?

Tony MartignettiAnd I understand your point, you know, In terms of the remote work, uh, it varies. But are you seeing trends? Are you, are you seeing a willingness to allow a couple days a week out of an office, but maybe not full-time? Or like, where are you seeing employers settling around the, the virtual work question?

Courtenay ShipleyThat— well, it's still kind of all over the place, but I would say that there's a, there's a much higher willingness to I guess if I have to choose a trend, it would be 2 days offsite, 3 days on, or vice versa, at least coming into the office twice a week. Yeah. Okay. Those are, those are probably the most common that we're seeing now.

Tony MartignettiOkay. So if you're asking for more than that, you know, you might not be aware that you might be outside the, outside the norm and, uh, you may not get it.

Courtenay ShipleyYeah.

Tony MartignettiOkay. Okay.

Courtenay ShipleyAt this point in time, I think we'll, you know, we'll see next year's trend will be different probably.

Tony MartignettiOkay. Fair enough. Yeah, absolutely. August of 2023. And in terms of negotiating, what are employers spending on average on benefits in terms of like percentage of salary? Like if you say, I used to hear, you know, an employer adds 30% for benefits, 30% of the comp. The direct cash compensation, they should expect to add another 30% per employee for this bundle that you talked about. Is that still roughly fair that your employer is spending about another third of your salary on benefits, or is that out of date?

Courtenay ShipleyYeah, no, I think that's probably pretty close. That's a great estimate anyway. If you have employers who are trying to make those plans, that's a really good number to aim for. And yes, And, you know, there with nonprofits, everybody's trying to stay under that 20% number for the financial reporting and whatnot for, um, for overhead expenses. And so, um, that also comes into play too with how, how nonprofits want to divide the, the pie out for their overhead.

Tony MartignettiYeah, I, I have a lot of trouble with that overhead. I know, I know, those overhead restrictions. People are not overhead. People are arguably your most Valuable, critical, required resource. That's not— Why we have benefits. Like, that's why we have benefits. Yeah. Not overhead, like the hardware on the doors, you know, that's overhead. Well, we got to replace a latch on the door. That's overhead. We're not, we're not latches and doorknobs and all right. So I don't— but I know there are—

Courtenay Shipley30% number is a pretty good one to aim for. Another, yeah, another thing that Where we see employers fall short sometimes, and employees should take this into consideration, is a total compensation statement. Because a lot of times employers are not necessarily rolling back the curtain on how much these types of programs cost. And so it's important for an employee to know how much extra is being spent, like what's really in their compensation package. You know, these are valuable benefits and they are worth money. So when you're comparing maybe one job offer against another, having that total compensation statement or just even an estimate gives you more information about, you know, the value of your benefits package.

Tony MartignettiYeah, that's fair, right? You want to, you want to know the total. I mean, it's certainly part of total compensation.

Courtenay ShipleyYeah.

Tony MartignettiIt's as much as an additional third. Yep. So,

Courtenay Shipleybut back to my original comment about how, It's important to have in your mind like what, what types of benefits are important to you. The other part of that is using them, because if an— if you say that an employer matching contribution is important in your 401 or 403 plan and then you don't contribute enough to get that match, that's money that you are— that's compensation you are literally leaving on the table.

Tony MartignettiYeah, that's such a big mistake. Yeah, leaving money on the table. But what, what's, what's sort of typical now in terms of Matching. Back when I— back in the dark days of my career, when I was, when I was a, uh, an employee, I would— I can't be an employee anymore. I would be a terrible employee for anybody. But back then, I used to have this very generous one at a university where I think if we, if we contributed 5%, the university contributed 7% or 7.5%.

Courtenay ShipleyOh, wow.

Tony MartignettiOf my salary. So of course, I put the 5% in because you want the max, right? You want— I mean, there's another 7.5% of your salary. Approaching 10% added to your salary each year by your employer. So that was— those were the early 2000s. Yeah, those were late 1990s and early, very early 2000s. So what's more typical now in terms of a match in a retirement plan?

Courtenay ShipleyWell, let's start with how common a match or a what we call non-elective. So thank you for breathing. Here's money in your retirement plan. That is very common. Nowadays. So if, uh,

Tony Martignettiwait, I'm sorry, what's, what, what's very common? Non-elective? What is that?

Courtenay ShipleyOr a non-elective or a match. A non-elective is where you're just receiving the— they're just giving you 3% into your retirement account or 5% or something like that. So what you described a minute ago was having to put something in to get something. So you see both ways, and it's very popular for the employer to be making a contribution. So that's That's one thing to consider is like, is this a good benefits package? If you're getting an employer contribution in your retirement plan, that is a step in the right direction to say, yes, these benefits are decent.

Tony MartignettiOkay. And so while we're on that, right, I'm going to dig a little deeper on that. We'll come back to the broader point. But what's a sort of a typical non-elective contribution, like 1% to 3%? What are you seeing?

Courtenay ShipleyYeah, so, um, I actually pulled this data just in case from the Plan Sponsor, um, Defined Contribution Survey from 2021, um, well, 2021, 2022. So what's most common for, for the, on the smaller side of the nonprofit, um, endowment foundation group is, um, somewhere around 15% usually gives less than 3%. Hmm. On a non-elective. The next most common, the next most common one is to give, it looks like between 3% and 6%.

Tony MartignettiAnd what percentage of that, what percentage of the market is giving between 3% and 6%?

Courtenay ShipleySo for a non-elective contribution, it is about, hold on here. So 30% are giving exactly $3,000 in the smaller space, and then the $3,000 to $5,000 is 15% to 25%, depending on what size. So those are the most common. Once you get above that 5% to 7% mark, it just drops off completely.

Tony MartignettiSo it sounds like roughly, it sounds like roughly 50% are giving Between three and six percent, is that right? Yeah. Okay.

Courtenay ShipleyI'll call it in that range.

Tony MartignettiThree to six, or is it three to five? Three to six?

Courtenay ShipleyIt's three to six. Yeah.

Tony MartignettiOkay. So roughly fifty percent are giving three to six percent. All right. So if you're in the three to six percent, non-elective. Yeah. That's a nice again. That's a nice boost.

Courtenay ShipleyVery competitive.

Tony MartignettiYeah. Get even at three percent. You get an additional three percent added to your salary. So

Courtenay Shipleyyeah.

Tony MartignettiOkay. Okay. So now let's go back. All right. I just wanted to drill down on what what's what what it's looking like. So now. Your bigger point was something that I don't remember now because I made you digress. It's okay. You have a lackluster host. I promised we'd go back. We will. So when I—

Courtenay ShipleyWell, if you want to know what the most common matching contribution is—

Tony MartignettiOh, that's right. The matching part. I drilled down on the non-elective. Thank you. I knew one of them. Okay. So matching, what does those numbers look like?

Courtenay ShipleySo matching is more popular. More organizations offer a match than they do the non-elective. So, um, in the matching space, you'd see that 4% is the most common.

Tony MartignettiOkay.

Courtenay Shipley4% is the most common. And then the next most common thing after that would be 6%. So imagine—

Tony MartignettiHow much, how much do you have to contribute to get the— is it 1 for 1 typically?

Courtenay ShipleyIt's probably 1 for 1. Yeah.

Tony MartignettiOkay. So you give 4%, you contribute 4%, they contribute another 4.

Courtenay ShipleyYeah. Well, if you give 1%, they match you 1% all the way up to 4%. Right. So if you're putting in 4%, yeah, you get the full match.

Tony MartignettiSo, yeah, I think it's smart to do the 4% because your employer will give you the max, whatever your max happens to be. If they will match it, you know, if they'll go to 6%, look, you're getting more than a 5% increase in compensation. It's not direct cash compensation. It's in your retirement plan, but they're still taking money out of their pocket and putting it into yours.

Courtenay ShipleyRetirement is a long way away. Um, most of the time you're going to need to save between 10 to 15% is what we always recommend, because that usually gets most people mathematically on track for retirement. So if you're coming in and you're putting in 4 and they're putting in 4, you're almost there, you know. So it's getting you— it's nudging you the right direction to get you halfway.

Tony MartignettiYou're about halfway.

Courtenay ShipleyAll

Tony Martignettiright. All right. Okay. So I want folks to know, you know, if their, if their benefits are, are crummy, if they suck, I want people to know that they, you know, maybe can get negotiate for more. I mean, if you're, you know, if you're at an if you're at a nonprofit and you're looking for a raise and your employer says no, raise is not we don't have the cash. Well, what about the benefits? Can we tinker with the benefits a little? You're I'm I'm the max is now four. Well, they may have machinations to go through, right? Their their plan may their plan may not allow an increase, but there are other benefits. You know, we're not talking only about retirement. You could start. Negotiating around your healthcare policy, healthcare plan, or your disability, or the life insurance, or the transportation stipend, or the tuition reimbursement, or the parking, or the student loan debt, the debt repayment. So, you know, you can— if your employer says no, no raise this year, well, can we tinker with the benefits a bit, right?

Courtenay ShipleyDid you just ask for your birthday off?

Tony MartignettiExactly. We didn't even talk about days off. We didn't even talk— we didn't talk about days off. Thank you. That's a great one. What, what are standard days off? What should we be getting? What does it look like?

Courtenay ShipleyThat's all over the place, unfortunately. I don't have really good statistics on all of that, but I would say that, um, you know, the longer that you've been in an organization, the more vacation days you typically earn. That's a, that's a trend that we see. Um, walking in, uh, you know, having no longevity with the company, you're going to get far less. And there we are seeing a trend towards just days off versus having to specify, is this a sick day? Is it a vacation day? So giving a little bit flexibility about the combination there. There's also the ability to accrue hours as your longevity increases with a— so accruing, you know, 8 hours over this period of time, you know, if you've worked this long, you get this many vacation days, that sort of thing.

Tony MartignettiThere's also the carryover. What are you allowed to carry over from year to year versus— hopefully you're not losing vacation time or days off, please. Please don't lose. I mean, it's paid time off.

Courtenay ShipleyYeah.

Tony MartignettiAnd so that's another— that— and since you, you said the birthday, that, that's right in line with what I was thinking in terms of negotiating. All right, I can't get a raise. Can I get an extra week off next year? That's a week of unpaid time. I mean, paid time that you get to take off. That has value. That's valuable. That's— You're lessing— you're working one week less. for the same amount of money because the employer said no raises for next year. So can you negotiate around time off?

Courtenay ShipleyOne of our very creative clients decided that— you mentioned the time off that expires, and so they allowed people to instead, who are going to lose it, be able to take that, turn it into cash, and put it towards their student loans. So that was a creative way that they You know, they help them out that way. Now, there's some tax implications. There's some tax implications. But overall, like, this is a nice— this— that was a nice gesture for sure. Like, don't, don't lose everything. Don't lose these days. Get some cash value for it.

Tony MartignettiRight. So that, that was income. I guess they had to report that. They had to report that. Correct. Transfer as income.

Courtenay ShipleyYeah, they did.

Tony MartignettiAll right. All right. So be it. But But days off, if you can get an extra week off next year, that's not— you don't have to report that. That's not a taxable event, an extra week off. But you're working one week less to get the same amount of money. So you're— that— consider that a raise, right? It is a— it's a raise.

Courtenay ShipleyYeah, absolutely.

Tony MartignettiDays for the same amount of money. I got a raise. So, you know, be creative about your negotiating. Don't just accept, okay, no raises next year. Fine. Yeah.

Courtenay ShipleyIf you're talking about leadership too, um, a lot— we've, we've had some of our clients that are trying to attract new executives in either CEO, CFO, HR, uh, CHRO, that sort of thing. Um, there is another benefit.

Tony MartignettiWait, we have, we have jargon jail on Nonprofit Radio.

Courtenay ShipleyBig time.

Tony MartignettiThe jargon jail. CHRO, what the heck is that?

Courtenay ShipleyChief Human Resources Officer. Oh,

Tony Martignettiall right, all right. Well, it blew past me, so I'll bet I'm not the only one. All right, CHRO. All right, you're out of jail. You're out of jargon. Thank you.

Courtenay ShipleyThank you so much. All right. So when you're trying to attract that talent and those people have— there's not as many of them and they're hard to find and, you know, they're hard to retain. And so that's where we've seen some pretty creative negotiation as well. I don't know who's listening and if they're in that type of leadership role, but being able to negotiate, well, help me pay off my grad school loans. You know, if I stay around in 3 years, then I get $10,000 towards that loan. Or if, you know, I wanna save more for my retirement, I'm trying to play catch-up 'cause I've had a long career, but I haven't been as good a saver as I should have been. I'd really like to have a 457 plan and be able to have extra money going towards my retirement. Now, the 457 is a really important nonprofit benefit because they're the ones that get to have it. It can only cover about 10 to 15% of the total population of the employees that are there, but it's basically a way to save more for retirement. Yeah. So the funds are at risk if the nonprofit does go out of business, it'd be subject to creditors. But that's, you know, if you're the one who's helping run it, make sure that doesn't happen, right?

Tony MartignettiYeah, but we're on the employee side. So the 457.

Courtenay ShipleyYeah.

Tony MartignettiIs it not a very common benefit or it is common?

Courtenay ShipleyNot all the time, no. It seems to be forgotten by many nonprofits. So if you are an employee who's walking into a situation where you have access to one of those, that's a pretty forward-thinking organization.

Kate MartignettiIt's time for a break. DonorBox. Quote, I regularly experience how DonorBox's easy setup and ultra-swift pay, fast checkout, deliver what we need. DonorBox allows us to focus on why we do this: our clients and their needs. End quote. That's from Jenny N. A board member and recurring donor at Organic Soup Kitchen in Santa Barbara, California. DonorBox, helping you help others. donorbox.org. It's time for Tony's Take Two.

Tony MartignettiThank you, Kate. It's still August, and that means it's still National Make-A-Will Month. Yes, every August, National Make-A-Will Month. And I use this month to remind nonprofits that wills, charitable bequests, same thing. They mean the exact same thing. Gifts in wills, charitable bequests, that's the place to start your planned giving. Always launch with the simplest gift, the most popular gift, gifts in wills. And I've been posting on LinkedIn all month. By the end of the month, I'll have all of my 18 reasons why wills are the place to launch your planned giving. Like the one that says that it's by far the most popular gift, as I already mentioned, and how easy it is for your donors, how easy it is for your staff, that it helps you build endowment, it ensures your sustainability. So there's like 5 or 6 ideas right off the top of my head. The full 18 are on LinkedIn. They will all be there by the end of next week. And for a lot of you listening weeks after, if you go to my LinkedIn, you'll see all the 18 reasons why wills are the place to start your planned giving fundraising. I hope you are enjoying the, the mass celebration around National Make-A-Will Month. We can almost— can't contain the excitement. Around National Make-A-Will Month for those of us who are celebrating the holiday. That is Tony's Take Two. Kate.

Kate MartignettiWe've got boo-hoo buttloads more time. Let's get back to Employee Benefits for Employees with Courtenay Shipley.

Tony MartignettiWhat kinds of details? I mean, we've talked some about the details like vesting versus What was the eligibility? Thank you. Yeah. So what other, what other like details should we be drilling down about? I mean, so, you know, we talked about retirement planning a good bit, but what other detail type things are like devils in the details we should, should we be thinking about?

Courtenay ShipleyI think you should be thinking about ease of use and getting help. I think those are 2 important parts. So when you get a whole bunch of benefits that are thrown at you, Do you really want to sit there all day and read? No, you want it, you want it to come with a person, or you want it to come with at least a chatbot or something to help answer questions. Everybody's different. They're going to use benefits slightly differently. And so it's important for you when you're choosing between your different healthcare packages or your different offerings to be able to have somebody that you can, you can ask. So I think that that's a very important thing to be looking for is who's going to help me make these decisions. Back in the day, Go ahead.

Tony MartignettiYeah. Support.

Courtenay ShipleyYeah, that is support. Yep. So I think support is very important.

Tony MartignettiAnd are you, are you meaning support in the nonprofit or support from the provider that offers the life insurance or the disability, etc.?

Courtenay ShipleyI would say it could come from either way, but probably more commonly from the provider.

Tony MartignettiOkay. From the provider.

Courtenay ShipleyAll right. But hopefully, hopefully when the nonprofit has chosen these types of benefits, they've, they've figured out a way to get help to their employees. That's a big cultural difference. I think that if you are looking at your benefits package, your compensation package, the offer that's coming to you, and you see that they have the ability for you to talk to people to help you make decisions, that's going to tell you a lot about their culture right there, that they care about you as an employee. So I think that's very important.

Tony MartignettiAnd the other was ease of use.

Courtenay ShipleyEase of use. So how How did they? How do they put all these disparate systems together? Your benefits package is not going to be provided by the same provider. Do you have a website where all of the documents are housed? Do you have videos on on one page? Is there a portal? What what makes your life easier? Do you have to go to six different phone numbers if you need to get help, or you need to submit a claim, or you need a you have a question answered about something? So how has How has the nonprofit put this together to make it easy for you to access it? That counts for something.

Tony MartignettiFor sure. What about other, uh, other benefits that, uh, you might be able to negotiate for? Things we haven't talked about, uh, like little special things that you've seen that folks have— folks might be able, like I said, able to, to Weedle the, uh, their nonprofit or their potential employer. You know, one of two situations: might be at a nonprofit, or it might be weighing offers now or, or in the future, uh, weighing competing offers. What, what other things have you seen folks— I hesitate to say get away with, but, you know, get, get access to— that might not have been offered, uh, you know, in the first round?

Courtenay ShipleySo the, um, If they have the ability to ask for a health savings account, there's only certain types of health insurance policies that go with it, the HSA-eligible programs. It used to be called high deductible, but that's kind of a misnomer when you start to do the cost analysis. But the thought is that you can put money aside into the HSA. That money can stick with you throughout your time. You can continue to fund it. You can use it to pay your healthcare expenses. You can keep it rolling until you get to retirement. Mm-hmm. and use it then. It's a triple tax-free benefit. So it's tax-free going in. You don't, you know, the, it comes out pre-tax from your check. It sits in there, it can grow, it can be invested. That's all tax-deferred or never to be taxed. If you take it out for healthcare reasons, it comes out tax-free. Yeah. So that's an awesome benefit. If they haven't considered it, you could try it, you know, and you're saying, I want more benefits. That's one of the ways that you might be able to negotiate maybe after you're already employed there or something to be looking for. So that's, that's nice, a really nice benefit. If you want to use it, it's a great option. And you don't see that everywhere. This is a little special.

Tony MartignettiOkay, that's the HSA, the health savings account. Is that the same as flex spending?

Courtenay ShipleyNo, flex spending is a really nice benefit, but that's the use it or lose it. So you have to use it within the calendar year on certain types of expenses. The HSA, you'd never lose it. You just, you can use it to pay for healthcare expenses. And there's a list of them on the IRS website that is always being updated, but you just keep rolling it. forward. So,

Tony Martignettiokay,

Courtenay Shipleyyou can accumulate a pretty darn good balance in there.

Tony MartignettiAnd the flex spending you have to use within the year.

Courtenay ShipleyYes.

Tony MartignettiUm, what else? Um, pardon me?

Courtenay ShipleyThat's also a nice benefit to have, the FSA. Yeah.

Tony MartignettiUm, HSA. What else?

Courtenay ShipleyUh, 529 college savings plan.

Tony MartignettiOh yes, explain that. I've seen those. What do those look like?

Courtenay ShipleySure. So that's, um, that's going to be for folks who have kids More, more than likely. However, it's for education, so it really could be for anybody if you want to start saving something for going back to grad school or something like that later in life. The— it's money that is set aside and it grows without any tax implications as long as you use it for education expenses down the road, then it comes back out tax-free. Employers technically could make a contribution to it if you— if There's access to that. So that could be something. And it's really designed to help with school, like of some sort. So that could be private K through 12 schools, room and board, tuition, things like that. Also higher education. So like I was saying before, more of the undergraduate and graduate degrees.

Tony MartignettiSo that can be, that can be for anybody. That can be for yourself. Children. Yeah, it could be grandchildren, nieces, nephews. And

Courtenay Shipleyyou, you can change the beneficiary. You can change the beneficiary. So if you have somebody who doesn't go to college in your family and you want to use the funds, you can just change your— the beneficiary to you. So there's, there's a lot of flexibility with it. It's a nice, it's a nice tool that can be used in, in several ways, but mainly you do pretty well if it's for education.

Tony MartignettiAll right, and those are the 529.

Courtenay ShipleySo having a, um, a payroll-deducted 529 plan. That's a— so it comes straight out of your check. It's real easy. Um, there's also, uh, and like I said, the employer can make a contribution to the 529. That would be extra special. So that could be something maybe.

Tony MartignettiOkay, so then, you know, you gotta— you have an exemplary package.

Courtenay ShipleyYeah, that's not—

Tony Martignetti529 plan if your employer is contributing a percent or 2 to it, right? Okay, that's— okay, this is— we want to know, do our benefits suck? Are they middling or are they exemplary? It's important to know. You want to know where you stand. That's right.

Courtenay ShipleyAlso on the subject of education, the tuition reimbursement, I think I mentioned that earlier. A lot of them will have a tuition reimbursement program. You could also look at, will they pay for certificates for certain skills or conferences or other types of things that help you with your career long-term, make you a more valuable employee?

Tony MartignettiProfessional development. Is there, is there a budget for professional development? Can I get more Professional development dollars. No, there's no raise this year. No raise for next year. All right. Well, how about professional development? Can I get $2,000 to go to a conference?

Courtenay ShipleyYeah, I think it's perfect. Right? That's a great way.

Tony MartignettiOr to use some other way. I was just thinking of conferences because people are trying to get out more now that we can. But can I get, can I get some professional development money?

Courtenay ShipleyOkay.

Tony MartignettiYeah, it's great. Courtenay, what else? What else?

Courtenay ShipleyUm, well, I want to point out that that's kind of a win in both directions. If they go and get a certificate, that makes them a more valuable employee to the nonprofit. Like, that's the win-win for everybody, right? You've got more skills, they've got more skills that you have. Um, I think the

Tony Martignettilast— The CHRO should recognize that,

Courtenay Shipleyright? Exactly.

Tony MartignettiCHRO should know.

Courtenay ShipleyUm, other student loan programs, like a student loan payback program, would also be extraordinary. on the, on the list of benefits. So if they're going to give you $50 a month towards your student loan or something like that, that's a, that's a big deal. That's a huge deal, as a matter of fact.

Tony MartignettiSo, okay. Meaning it's kind of rare?

Courtenay ShipleyYes, it's rare and it's super helpful because if you think about just looking at how your debt works and paying off extra every month, it reduces the life of the loan. It saves you massive amounts of, of interest payments over the life of the loan. So That is a— that's one that we really like. Now, there's mixed feelings, of course, about student loans and, you know, should we— should, should they be wiped out? You know, there's— that's been kind of a political side to

Tony Martignettiit. Yeah. Is it equitable because there are populations who never can't afford college or higher ed? Right.

Courtenay ShipleyYep. But, but at the end of the day, it's an attraction and retention tool. So I think employers should consider it.

Tony MartignettiRight. Right. Okay. Okay. Anything else we could be negotiating for if we feel our benefits are on the lackluster side or you exhausted it? If that's it, you know, that's okay.

Courtenay ShipleyI think lunch and learns on different topics are probably another good one. Could you bring in a speaker about XYZ? That's, that's kind of an easy one for employers to, you know, if you want more knowledge, if that's what you're after, have somebody come in and speak on a certain topic. Or negotiate a discount for us for XYZ product. So we've seen, we've seen that happen sometimes where, um, even if it's just the coffee shop next door and you get 5% off or something, that's, that's a bit, that's nice.

Tony MartignettiOh, it's something local, something, uh, something local.

Courtenay ShipleyAll right.

Tony MartignettiYeah,

Courtenay Shipleybecause if you think about it, I mean, most nonprofits are, are heavily, um, involved in their local area. So, you know, can they leverage that to also provide more benefits for their employees?

Tony MartignettiOkay, okay, excellent. Think on the local level too. All right, all right. Um, what else, what else do you want folks to know about from the— again, you know, of course, the— from the employee perspective, that, uh, way— maybe ways of negotiating, or what else, what else would you like folks to know about?

Courtenay ShipleyWell, I think when you, when you go to negotiate, it's always important to recognize The benefits, the compensation, all of that is going to vary based on how large your employer is, their budget, right? The different constraints that they may have from outside, where they're located. So it's important to remember that you want to have the value conversation about how you're a valuable employee, and that's why you're asking for these additional benefits. I think that's an important thing to remember. Because the— it's easy to say yes to an employee who's very valuable, right? It's kind of a no-brainer.

Tony MartignettiSo you need to make the case. You need to make the case of your value, whatever value it is you bring, expertise, experience, non-formal— doesn't have to be formal education. We're not talking about that necessarily. Just, you know, what, what's the— what's your value as an employee? Not just what do you do, but what do you bring that somebody else can't bring?

Courtenay ShipleyYeah, or what, what great work have you done that's made things a lot easier for everybody? Or, or what, you know, what are you bringing to the table? Because I— when we're, when we're in conversations with folks, you remember that I do corporate retirement plans. And so when we're talking with, with people, a lot of times it's centered around their money and I just need to make more. And it's like, well, Okay, but don't forget that they're employing you to do a job, and so they, they have an easier time when your performance reviews are great. So that's just something to keep in mind of what moves the needle, what's important to the organization, what fits within their culture when you go to ask for things. So I think that's important to think about. And also don't If you're, if you're comparing 2 benefits packages, you know, we have clients that just can't afford to do amazing things, but they do good things. And the opportunity to work there is still great, and the culture is great. And even though you may not make as much money in the long run, the experience that you get or the, um, the cause that they serve is, is worthwhile. And so I think that's one extra level that for-profit entities and for-profit employees don't have to think about as much, because a lot of the nonprofits really do make a great difference, and they are, um, they're a different type of work environment. So that's also something that has value to it that I don't think we, we think about sometimes.

Tony MartignettiYeah, absolutely true, right? The benefits are just one component, one, one variable among many when you're weighing whether you want to stay working where you are. Or whether you're considering different options that you may have, you know, a couple of different offers. The benefits are just one variable, and certainly the quality of the work, the culture, equity issues, you know, these are all— those are all variables as well. All right. All right. How about we leave it there then? You feel okay? Yeah.

Courtenay ShipleyI do. Do you?

Tony MartignettiAll right, I do, but I'm not the expert. You

Courtenay Shipleyare. Fair enough.

Tony MartignettiExpert feels good. All right, Courtenay Shipley, you'll find her on LinkedIn. You'll find her company at retirementplanology.com. Courtenay, thank you very much for sharing your expertise. Thanks a lot.

Courtenay ShipleyThank you so much for having me. I really appreciate it.

Tony MartignettiMy pleasure.

Kate MartignettiAmy Sample Ward returns with reflections on their Bosch Fellowship in Berlin. If you missed any part of this week's show,

Tony MartignettiI beseech you, find it at tonymartignetti.com.

Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by DonorBox. Outdated donation forms blocking your supporters' generosity? DonorBox: fast, flexible, and friendly fundraising forms for your nonprofit. DonorBox.org. Our creative producer is Claire Meyerhoff. Thank you, associate producer Kate Martignetti. The show's social media is by Susan Chavez. Marc Silverman is our web guy, and this music is by Scott Stein.

Tony MartignettiThank you for that affirmation, Scotty. Be with us next week for Nonprofit Radio. Speak nonprofit. Nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. Go out and be great. Thank you.

Nonprofit Radio