The 5 A's Of Awesome Fundraising


About this episode
It’s a valuable back-to-basics conversation with a bunch of tips you’ve probably never heard. Leading us through is Cara Augspurger from Donorbox.
My Guest
Here’s the transcript
Tony MartignettiHello and welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. I'm your aptly named host of your favorite hebdomadal podcast. And oh, I'm glad you're with us. You'd turn me into a monothalamus if I had to see that you missed this week's show. Here's our associate producer Kate with what's coming.
Kate MartignettiThank you so much, Tony. We have the 5 A's of Awesome Fundraising. It's a valuable back-to-basics conversation with a bunch of tips you've probably never heard. Leading us through is Cara Augspurger from Donorbox on Tony's Take Two.
Tony MartignettiIt could have been the end for me.
Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by Donorbox. Outdated donation forms blocking your supporters' generosity? Donorbox— fast, flexible, and friendly fundraising forms for your nonprofit.
Tony MartignettiDonorbox.org. I love that. I love that alliteration, Kate. Fast, flexible, friendly fundraising forms. Love that.
Kate MartignettiIt sounds cool, but it's not very fun to say.
Tony MartignettiTough.
Kate MartignettiVery tough. Now here is the 5 A's of Awesome Fundraising.
Tony MartignettiIt's a pleasure to welcome Cara Augspurger to Nonprofit Radio. She is a longtime development professional currently serving as fundraising coach for Donorbox and focuses on consulting with nonprofits of all sizes. Her expertise is in coaching, annual fundraising, project management, and communications. She's on LinkedIn, Cara Augspurger with a P. Not a B. It's not Augsburger.
Kate MartignettiNo, it's not.
Tony MartignettiIt's Cara Augspurger.
Cara AugspurgerHi, Tony.
Tony MartignettiWelcome. And the company is at donorbox.org. Welcome, Cara.
Cara AugspurgerThat's correct. Thanks, Tony. Thanks so much for having me. What a warm welcome.
Tony MartignettiPleasure. Pleasure to have you from Noblesville, Indiana.
Cara AugspurgerThat's correct.
Tony MartignettiAnd we're talking about the 5 A's of awesome fundraising. So these are not just— this is not just, you know, lackluster, mediocre type fundraising. We're talking about awesome fundraising.
Cara AugspurgerRight, the 5 A's. You know, our Donorbox team coined the term the 5 A's of awesome fundraising to really introduce the concept and help people remember the cycle of fundraising. So, you know, identify, cultivate, solicit, steward. We just made them a little easier and put an A next to each of them. So we have—
Tony MartignettiOkay.
Cara AugspurgerOh,
Tony Martignettiso it's, so it's the cycle that we're accustomed to.
Cara AugspurgerExactly.
Tony MartignettiBut, uh, all right, so refreshers are important, valuable basics, basics. Lots of people trigger, you know, they'll say, oh, you know, that's just a good reminder, good reminder. So we're gonna, we're gonna share good reminders. Excellent, excellent. So, uh, I'll let you introduce your, your first A.
Cara AugspurgerWell, sure. So we often at DonorBox, we are working with fundraisers who are really, really good at delivering on their mission. They're really, really good at creating innovative programs. But maybe they're struggling to understand some fundraising fundamentals. And so my job is to kind of create ways to make learning those fun and engaging. And so that was the basis around the 5 A's. So first, we attract new supporters to your organization. You know, that would be identification and cultivation. And then we ask them to come alongside you by giving. Then we promptly acknowledge those gifts, right? And then we account for those donations, and we do it again and again and again. So it's attract, ask, acknowledge, account, and again. So those 5 A's, they're not fancy, they're not innovative, they're nothing new, but those are kind of those fundraising fundamentals that successful nonprofits are actively doing and actively incorporating into their communication cadence. to bring donors into the life of the organization and really cultivate that sense of belonging.
Tony MartignettiAll right, so let's, let's focus on attraction.
Cara AugspurgerYeah,
Tony Martignettiwhat, what, uh, what are your reminders there, your tips?
Cara AugspurgerSo, you know, you, you need to attract new supporters to your organization, and then you need to make sure that your organization is attractive to those. So, uh, you want to make sure that you are actively on social media, that you're telling compelling stories of your mission and action, you're showing People ways to get involved by volunteering and things like that. So you're attracting those people. You're, you know, the fundraising fundamentals. So you're cultivating them to your organization.
Tony MartignettiAnd some of those, uh, some of those, uh, attraction mechanisms might be as simple as, right, sign a petition.
Cara AugspurgerAbsolutely.
Tony MartignettiYeah. I mean, it doesn't have to be come in person or something.
Cara AugspurgerNo, of course.
Tony MartignettiWe could have a low lift But something that gets people initially engaged.
Cara AugspurgerYeah, you're building aware— you're building awareness for your organization.
Tony MartignettiYeah. Okay, well, that's another good A, but that's not in awareness. That's like a subset. So I'm not— I don't want to pervert the whole DonorBox, uh, the whole DonorBox theme of 5 A's. Make it 6.
Cara AugspurgerYeah, we don't want 6 A's.
Tony MartignettiNo. Every time you say an A word, I, I'm not gonna say, oh, there's an A. But, uh, awareness is a subset of Attract. Yeah. And being, being attractive. Talk a little more about the being attractive part, how you, you know, how you appeal.
Cara AugspurgerYeah. So, you know, you repeat the cycle and you want to keep your organization attractive to your current supporters. So maybe that's where you introduce a survey or you ask what appeals to them most about the mission. You could engage with them through some newsletters, some good communication about what's going on, or, you know, in person. So you can invite them to coffee, invite them to events, invite them to volunteer. And it's not just about doing those things, it is about staying relevant in the minds of your supporters. You know, we know supporters are supporting fewer organizations these days, dollars are limited, and so you really want to stay in the forefront of your supporters' minds. And so that's where you really just want to keep that communication cadence Um, going throughout the year. You don't want to just go to your donors when you need something. You want to communicate and build relationship and stay in relationship with them.
Tony MartignettiYeah, that is critical. Not only sending solicitations, you know, however many times a year, right? Let's drill down a little bit on the, uh, the surveys.
Cara AugspurgerYeah,
Tony Martignettisurveys. What's your advice around surveys? You know, like length, um, I don't know, time of year. How to get folks to do the survey? You know, what are your tips around those things?
Cara AugspurgerYou know, I think my, uh, my advice to anyone is as, um, personal of the ask as you can make it, I think the more, um, engagement you're going to get around it. So if you could say, hey Tony, I'm going to send you a survey in the mail or in the, you know, in your email, and if you have 5 minutes to really give me some insight into what you see, you know, in the organization, boy, I would really value that. If I could ask you that on the phone, or if I saw you at an event or something like that, you might be more engaged and more apt to complete that survey. So that, you know, and you can even personalize that at a scalable level through some emails, some make your email look really personal through some mail merges and things like that to really make it seem like you're speaking one-on-one to the receiver. So that's how I—
Tony Martignettiso that's a, that's an introductory email. Yeah, in a couple of days I'm going to send you or something like that.
Cara AugspurgerOr yeah, I mean, just however the communication, the communication schedule works out for you. You could even, you know, package it together with the survey link or something like that. But yeah, just as interpersonal as, as possible. So it looks less like it's from the organization and more from the person who's sending it, whether that's the executive director, the communications manager, the development manager, whatever it is. So I think that one-on-one really feeds engagement. But as far as like length, what we're seeing that is working really well is micro content. So short, actionable. You know, I think if people see how far along they are in the steps, you know, you're at step 1 of 5, question 1 of 5, something like that, that kind of keeps people motivated to complete it as opposed to this never-ending survey that never ends.
Tony MartignettiI know, I know. I appreciate the progress bar. Yeah, right. You're 10% or 20% or, right, 1 out of 5 or something. Yeah, I like to know that. I like to know where the end is.
Cara AugspurgerYeah, yeah, absolutely. And I think if you have, um, well-crafted questions, so you've worked with, you know, a board member or your staff ahead of time to determine what is— what's your outcome on this survey? What do you really want to glean from this information? I'm working— I'm on the board for a nonprofit here in the Indianapolis area that works to provide services to people who are a little food insecure. But the foundation— so there's a foundation that's set up to, to kind of resource the food pantry and the services. So there's some confusion right now on, do I give to the church that runs the services, or do I give to the foundation, or whatever? So what we're doing is we're crafting a survey To say, hey, do you understand the difference between the foundation, the church, the food pantry? How does that work? And, and really trying to get to the purpose. Our purpose is clarity around our communication and where to direct people to give money. But we need to work backwards and craft the questions so that they really are short and compelling and impactful and give us the answers that we need. So I think as long as you're, you're really paring down And really honing in on the purpose of the survey, I think you'll be able to draft some short, really, really great questions that'll drive the answers that you're looking for.
Tony MartignettiDo you have a maximum number of questions that you're working toward in your survey?
Cara AugspurgerI'd like to stop it. I'd like to leave it at 5. I think 5 is a good number. You know, I think if they're quick questions, if it's multiple choice, those would go a little faster than those open-ended. So maybe you'd have a little more wiggle room for some questions there. But I think, you know, too, I think there's always an opportunity for an executive director or someone to step in after you complete the survey and say, hey Tony, those were really great examples you shared in that survey. Would you be open to a conversation to talk a little bit more about what you think? And you know, those opportunities, those touch points are really part of those 5 A's. You're keeping that conversation going and saying, I see you and I value the input that you have into our organization.
Tony MartignettiI think people would be very grateful for—
Cara AugspurgerOh, sure.
Tony MartignettiLike personal follow-up. Now, if you're, if you're sending thousands of surveys, you know, I don't know, uh, hopefully you get more than a dozen responses. Sometimes surveys can do poorly, so you might, you might only get 12 or 15 or 20 responses, and then you can be personal.
Cara AugspurgerYeah.
Tony MartignettiUm, with, with those, with those folks. And look, I mean, you're thanking them in a way for, you know, for being among the small percentage of people who did reply.
Cara AugspurgerOh, for sure, for sure. And what's the old adage that you ask for money and you get advice, but you ask for advice and you get money?
Tony MartignettiYeah, well, that may result indeed, or you might get a new volunteer or something.
Cara AugspurgerExactly.
Tony MartignettiYou'll certainly get somebody grateful after you've like personally followed up and said, you know, your answer to this was important or whatever.
Cara AugspurgerYeah, well, it's an opportunity.
Tony MartignettiYeah,
Cara Augspurgerit's an opportunity for conversation, an opportunity to grow that relationship.
Tony MartignettiAnother thing folks have said is that don't ask for information that you, you can't preserve and, and act on.
Cara AugspurgerOh,
Tony Martignettilike if, like if you're asking a survey question, would you rather we email you or use direct mail or text? Then they give you the answer. You have to, you have to honor their, their answer. Either that or don't, don't ask the question.
Cara AugspurgerYeah, exactly. Yeah. Yeah. If you're not gonna segregate that information into your data and you end up mailing someone who said they only want an email, then it may have backfired on you, the whole process.
Tony MartignettiRight? Then you, you really, yeah. Then you have hurt the, then you hurt the relationship.
Cara AugspurgerExactly.
Tony MartignettiBetter to not even just ask. Yeah. If you don't have the capability for text, don't offer communications, you know, by, by SMS.
Cara AugspurgerYeah, for sure. It goes back to the whole big, big goal that what outcome do you want from the survey?
Tony MartignettiAbsolutely. Very true. As you said at the outset. Right. All right. You feel okay with attract and being attractive?
Cara AugspurgerYeah, I think so. I think, yeah, identify and cultivate and really get them introduced into all that your organization offers. So that is attract.
Tony MartignettiOkay, then you're ready to ask.
Cara AugspurgerOh, you are ready to ask. And I think so many nonprofits think that that ask is exponentially hard and it's an exponential, you know, use of time in fundraising. But really, if you're doing these other things well, that ask gets a lot easier. But it is important to ask. And if you are only telling, you know, stories of impact and, um, you know, really advocating for your cause but you never ask for money, you're missing a big opportunity there.
Tony MartignettiNow, your ask could come in other forms too, right? It might be— now we're talking about something more than, you know, sign a petition, but it could be volunteer.
Cara AugspurgerAbsolutely. Yeah, absolutely. One pitfall I see with that though, Tony, is a lot of times in a fundraising appeal, I think we sometimes as nonprofit professionals are kind of uncomfortable about that ask, and what we tend to do is gloss over it in the fundraising appeals. So
Tony Martignettithat's— yeah,
Cara Augspurgerthese are, hey Tony, can you give me $50 or volunteer or share this email? I think it's really important in a fundraising appeal to have one call to action. And if you're asking for money and for a volunteer and to share the word, guess what? People are going to do the one thing that doesn't cost them money. So if you're asking for money, make sure that that's super clear. And that is the only call to action in your fundraising appeal.
Tony MartignettiYeah, I didn't mean to dilute your fundraising ask. If that's what you're doing, I was just saying, you know, you could be asking for something else that's substantial, which is a gift of time.
Cara AugspurgerOh, absolutely.
Tony MartignettiYeah, but no, I absolutely agree. Don't dilute. Don't— and don't be humble. You know, you— oh, you know, we hate to ask, but could you You know, you have needs. Your work is important and you have needs to, to fulfill that work, to fulfill that mission. Ask with confidence, right?
Cara AugspurgerAbsolutely. Absolutely. Um, fear-free fundraising is, is kind of the approach I take there. You, you need to know what you do, why you do, why it's important, um, what you're doing differently than anyone else, and be really, really proud of that. And when you kind of have those things ingrained in To your thought process, why do you care? Then it's much easier to communicate that to other people, and you don't feel like you're tap dancing around it all the time.
Tony MartignettiAnd and you don't want to take for granted that that people understand all that, you know, because you work in it day in day out, week after week, etc. Yeah, but but everybody else doesn't.
Cara AugspurgerYeah, absolutely. Yeah, absolutely.
Tony MartignettiHave you seen any any good asks lately that you can? You can share?
Cara AugspurgerWell, we're, we're getting ready for the biggest ask of the year, right? The year-end fundraising season is always a good one. Um, you know, I help a lot of organizations really learn the art of appeal writing, and so, um, I'm excited to— I actually have a live in-person workshop with a lot of new fundraising professionals in about 2 weeks, and so I'm excited to work with them through that process and see what they come up with. Um, but as far as good asks lately, gosh, they're all over the place. Um, we have a, a nonprofit that we work with called, uh, Maya's Hope, and I actually just saw on LinkedIn before I got on this call they had a really clear, compelling ask to become a monthly donor at $10 a month. And what they showed was a picture of a boy in Ukraine And what he received— he has special needs and his mom is unable to work right now, has 2 young children. They live in a war zone, right? But what $10 a month provides for him— there was a photo of it and it was some diapers and some hard-to-get medication for his, you know, for his situation. And it was saying for $10 a month, you can give this mom peace of mind that her son is going to get what he needs for the month. Because you give to this organization. You put the, the materials in this mother's hands and relieve her burden and, you know, relieve the, the pain that her son is going through because you give to this organization. And it was just such a clear, compelling ask. It really stuck in my mind, and I saw it really just a few minutes ago.
Tony MartignettiIt's personalized.
Cara AugspurgerYeah, it was.
Tony MartignettiIt was. It's the mom. It's her son.
Cara AugspurgerYeah. And, and, you know, and I think that their target demographic, I think a lot of their donors are probably mothers, um, who are kind of feeling those same things about their kids. And so they have a— it's a woman-run organization, and I think they have a lot of female donors who just really feel the, the tug at the heartstrings and understand when they give a little bit, another mom might have some relief.
Tony MartignettiMaya's Hope is an example that we've cited in Some of our sponsorship messages with Donorbox because they, they have incredible— I forget what their percentage of increase was when they, when they moved to the Donorbox platform, but I don't know if it was the 400% one or it was the 267% one or whatever, but they've been cited in our, in our messages for you.
Cara AugspurgerOh, good. Yeah, I actually, I meet with them once a week, and so my, my meeting with them is this afternoon, so I'll be sure to mention that to them that, that you're noticing them. They'll be very happy about that.
Kate MartignettiIt's time for a break. Donorbox. Quote, I regularly experience how Donorbox's easy setup and UltraSwift Pay fast checkout deliver what we need. Donorbox allows us to focus on why we do this, our clients and their needs. End quote. That's from Jenny N., a board member and recurring donor at Organic Soup Kitchen in Santa Barbara, California. DonorBox, helping you help others. donorbox.org. It's time for Tony's Take Two.
Tony MartignettiThanks, Kate. I had a rough experience, harrowing experience, Earlier this week, it was just, uh, 4 days ago, I was in a car accident. My car was totaled, totally smashed in the front. Uh, it's totaled. I walked out of it. Uh, my, my steering wheel airbag went off, my head hit it, and I I smelled this acrid burning smell, and I heard hissing. I quick, you know, checked myself. I unbuckled my seatbelt, and I was able to just get out and walk. Remarkable. Could have been— it could have been a lot, a lot different. There were 4 cars involved, and there was someone who was not as fortunate as I was. He was Had to be extricated from the car by the fire department with those jaws of life, and they bandaged his head, and I could see there was still blood coming even through the bandages. I could see, and he was taken away on a stretcher in an ambulance. He was the worst hurt. You know, it just, it just could have been a lot worse. Obviously grateful that I was unscathed, not even a nosebleed. My glasses didn't even bend hitting the airbag. Makes me think of my father-in-law, who's no longer living because he was an automobile engineer. Cars are engineered to absorb impact with crumple zones in the front and the back. I needed the one in the front. That's what saved my life. You know, but crumple zones and safety zones and airbags and the sensors, and that's, um, that, that's a credit to my father-in-law and all his colleagues in automotive engineering. And it makes me think about how, how close I came and just makes me grateful for Scientists, engineers who make our lives safer. That was just this week, and that is Tony's Take Two. Kate,
Kate MartignettiI'm glad you're with us, Uncle Tony.
Tony MartignettiYeah, thank you.
Kate MartignettiWe've got beaucoup buttloads more time now. Back to. The 5 A's of Awesome Fundraising with Cara Augspurger.
Tony MartignettiAnything else on, on the ask?
Cara AugspurgerWell, you know, I think so much effort is spent on thinking of that first gift, um, but I think it's just as important to really earn that second gift. And so that is actually a really great segue into our next A.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Oh, I just— I thought of one. Okay, before we get to— before we get to this, to the next A, uh, acknowledge. Um, in, in writing, you know, if you're, if you're doing whether it's digital or print, I, I hate to see the asks buried in a, in a dense paragraph.
Cara AugspurgerYou
Tony Martignettiknow, make it— I think make them stand out. Now again, don't be, don't be shy and, and humble in your asks.
Cara AugspurgerYeah,
Tony Martignettimake sure that it's clear somewhere.
Cara AugspurgerYeah, what we really encourage, um, people to do— so we teach appeal writing, and what we encourage people to do is start with their direct mail letter as an anchor of their communication series around their ask. And in that direct mail letter, what we have them do is make sure that you can understand if you only read the bolded parts of the letter, that that actually tells the whole story. So you have the, um, the problem. So, and I mean, I'm going to use this, this Maya's Hope example again. So, um, Mom doesn't know what to do. Son is in need of medication. So you know throughout you're telling a narrative, but but that is that's the problem, right? And then you talk about how the organization can help with that. Oh, but Maya's Hope provides these materials, and then you put your call to action in for ten dollars a month. This child can get what he needs, and mom gets peace of mind. So if you if you In the whole narrative of the letter, if you bolded those pieces, the, the reader would be able to really understand what the problem is, what your solution is, and how they can help. And then what we do is encourage people to take that anchor piece. A lot of people don't even do direct mail, but I think it's a good idea to even start by writing it. And then you can syndicate that direct mail letter into an email or an email series and some social media posts to follow up with that. So you're really taking, um, a story and using it as a fundraising campaign for a short period of time and really curating all of your communications around that, that anchor piece.
Tony MartignettiDo you have advice around, uh, maximum length of, uh, I mean, clearly, you know, emails should be shorter.
Cara AugspurgerYeah.
Tony MartignettiBut, but, uh, uh, you know, maximum length for a direct mail, you know, print piece?
Cara AugspurgerWell, you know, Mal Warwick is kind of like the, you know, the official go-to for me for direct mail writing, and Research says longer is more compelling. 4 pages. I've never in my life sent a 4-page appeal letter.
Tony MartignettiYeah.
Cara AugspurgerBut they say, you know, the research says the longer the better. I've received some in the mail, but no, I tend to stick to a front of a page and a back of a page and insert a response device and a carrier envelope and a return envelope. So that's the package I usually like. Um, I think a lot of people think that you have to, you have to just limit the length of a mailed letter to just the front of the page, but I think you can go a little longer.
Tony MartignettiOkay. All right.
Cara AugspurgerEspecially if you're telling a good story. I mean, it's all about storytelling and, and really keeping the donor engaged. If you, if you're writing well, the donor will turn the, the donor will turn the page and keep reading.
Tony MartignettiAcknowledge. We almost, we almost got there. You teased it. Now we're into that important acknowledgement. I know you're gonna say that acknowledgements should come fast.
Cara AugspurgerYeah. So earning that second gift, right? We know that acknowledgements need to be prompt and personalized and really make an impact. You want the reader to understand that you are so grateful for their support. So that sincere gratitude. So prompt, personal, sincere gratitude that really goes a long way.
Tony MartignettiI love sincerity, you know, and you don't have to be long to be sincere, genuine, heartfelt in your, in your gratitude.
Cara AugspurgerAbsolutely. And I think, I think, you know, I think that's something that we as people are really craving right now, that authenticity, that sincerity. I think that we're living in such a fast-paced life, and we have all this AI and all this tech around us that when we get something sincere and authentic, Um, it really stands out to us.
Tony MartignettiI'm a big fan of handwritten notes.
Cara AugspurgerYep. I just wrote about 15 last night for a fundraising campaign I'm working on. So yeah, I feel it. I, I'm a big fan of them too. I love receiving them. I love sending them. Um, I know it's a lot of work. I have, I have organizations that I work with. They're like, I don't have time for that. Well, there are ways you can, you can modify it. You can do, um, a mail-merged email that looks like it just came from your, your inbox, and you can really be like, hey, I just saw donation come in, I, I really wanted to let you know right away, um, what this will do. And, you know, you can, you can really be a little creative. You can even print some acknowledgments, hand sign them, and write a little note on them. Um, I received an acknowledgment from an organization the other day where it was actually written and signed by a volunteer, and that's okay. I think that those kind of things are just fine. I think you just really need to acknowledge that gift and We know that, um, that, you know, I think donor retention is down right now. I think a lot of people are saying, I'm losing donors and I'm losing donors. Um, and I think acknowledgments are the key to that donor renewal. You know, I mentioned earlier, a lot of organizations focus on that first gift, um, but really earning that second gift is what's important, and that's where acknowledge comes in.
Tony MartignettiYou just gave a lot of good tactics for For, for handwritten or, or something very close to it. Another one is that it's a terrific activity for a board. Board members, you give them a list of 15 or 20 and they can either— they could do it in a board meeting or they could take it home with them. You just give them the stationery, take it home with them. I'm sure they'll be happy to mail them.
Cara AugspurgerYou know, make a phone call. They can make a phone call. Yeah,
Tony Martignettiabsolutely.
Cara AugspurgerLeave a voicemail. Yeah. Give them a little script that, you know, most, most calls go to voicemail anyway. Just give them a little script that they can leave in a voicemail. And, and that's really impactful. Um, what, what always helped me when I, um, was in a role, I was in a, um, director of development role, and my primary responsibility was acknowledgments. And what I did is I blocked out the last hour of my day on Tuesdays and Thursdays, and I made that my handwritten note, uh, time. Yeah. And so I went through the, I went through the reports, I made sure that they got, um, notes, but I built it into my schedule. And then it was just part of my day and part of my routine for the week, and then I got to go home feeling like I actually accomplished something, right?
Tony MartignettiFor anything that's, that's important.
Cara AugspurgerYeah.
Tony MartignettiYou know, you have, you have to make the time. You're not gonna find it. Listeners may have heard me say that if you've been listening a while. You're never gonna find the time. You're gonna make it.
Cara AugspurgerSo you have to make it. Yeah.
Tony MartignettiIf handwritten notes are important to you, an hour a week, 2 hours a week.
Cara AugspurgerYeah.
Tony MartignettiDelegate it to your board. Delegate it to volunteers. That's a great idea. You know, it's— people are going to be thrilled to get a handwritten note because I, I agree with you that we are thirsting for some, some more personal contact coming out of the pandemic when we were, we were prohibited from having personal contact. And, and you're right, with artificial intelligence, uh, growing in popularity, to get something that you know is genuine, authentic. Mm-hmm. Um, or even the substitutes that you mentioned, you know, if you can— if you can't do the literal handwritten note, the ways you mentioned to come close, you know, something that's, that's email that, that sounds genuine.
Cara AugspurgerYeah. Um, and again, yeah, I think, I think when it comes from the individual, not the organization, that adds just a little more impact. Um, it makes it seem a little more authentic and Yeah, I, I think that one-on-one is where the relationship grows.
Tony MartignettiAnd then if you want to follow with a more formal letter that, you know, maybe says, you know, the, uh, gives your tax deductible— tax deductibility disclaimer, if you want to include that, you know, that could follow several days later or a week later.
Cara AugspurgerOh,
Tony Martignettiabsolutely. After the, after the, the, the phone message from the board member or the volunteer or whoever.
Cara AugspurgerYeah.
Tony MartignettiSo, you know, you don't have to incorporate it all in one. And well, how do I sound genuine if I also want to put a tax disclaimer in?
Cara AugspurgerYeah, absolutely.
Tony MartignettiAnd the disclaimer message could be automatic, but the, the first thank you could be genuine, sincere, and handwritten, or a phone call.
Cara AugspurgerAnd there are some ways you can blend the two. I know, um, DonorBox, you can customize your donation receipt so you can warm up that language that they get right away when they make an online donation. You can add in a little story or a video Um, you can really warm that up. I like to use the analogy. I think a lot of people are confused. I'm glad you brought this up, Tony, because I think a lot of people are confused about the difference between a donation receipt and an acknowledgement. And so I like to use this analogy. So your donation receipt is like the receipt you get, um, at the grocery store. It's very transactional. It says, um, you know, you purchased this item on this date for this much money. Where an acknowledgement is like a thank you note to your favorite aunt because she sent you a birthday gift. And so you would never say, dear Auntie, thank you for the sweater valued at $49.95 that you mailed on August 15th. No, you would never say that. You would say, wow, thank you so much for your generosity. That's my favorite color. I'll wear it all the time. And then I think there's a big pitfall too. A lot of people will ask for a second gift in their acknowledgement, you know, hey, thank you for, for giving $10. Would you give us $10 a month? No. And use that analogy then as your, as your litmus test. You would never say, dear Auntie, thank you for that sweater. Can you send me some jeans and some shoes to match it? No, you would never do that. So if you kind of use that as a litmus test of what you're sending out, I think that that's, that's usually what I do in my mind anyway.
Tony MartignettiThere's another opportunity to ask for the follow-on gift, to ask for the gift to be a sustaining gift monthly.
Cara AugspurgerSure,
Tony Martignettiyou have other chances at that. Don't, don't blow your, your gratitude time on, on— talk about diluting. Now you're diluting your thank you with a, with a second ask. And it's just rude. Just like we said, don't dilute your ask. Don't dilute your, your gratitude with a, with a second ask or a request for anything. Yeah.
Cara AugspurgerYeah,
Tony Martignettijust make it a straight thank you and touch the person, uh, touch the person again at another time.
Cara AugspurgerSure. Yep, absolutely. And like I said, if you're doing those other things well, if you're— if you are acknowledging and you're showing that you're accountable for those donations and you're, you know, continuing to make your organization attractive, when you do ask for that monthly gift or whatever is next, they might be, you know, raise their hand a little faster and say, yeah, I'm in.
Tony MartignettiIndeed, indeed. Give them the chance, right? Let them, let them maybe self-identify too. All right. Yeah. All right. All important. Uh, we're at— we're up. Well, go ahead. You, you announced this one. You teased them at the beginning, but you can announce our 4th awesome A.
Cara AugspurgerOur 4th A is account. And so that would also fall under stewardship in that, you know, typical fundraising cycle. But this is where you're showing impact for your gift. And we know this is important because donors say they stop giving because they believe that their gift won't really help or the money won't be used. And so that's where you have to account for that hard-earned money that your supporters give to your organization. So show the impact, show the, the numbers of people you've fed, or the number of shoes you've given away, or the animals you've saved. Tell stories of how Life change happened because someone gave. And so that's what I mean by account. It's as easy as just showing a little impact. It could be numbers, it could be stories, it could be anything that really gets that point across and keeps people wanting to learn more about how their gift went to work.
Tony MartignettiThat Maya's Hope example you used kind of incorporated the two into, into ask and also account. You know, by showing what the impact would be for your $10 monthly gift.
Cara AugspurgerFor sure.
Tony MartignettiDo you have another example maybe of, uh, uh, of a, of an impact, an account that, that stays with you?
Cara AugspurgerYeah, you know, there's always, you know, nonprofits do a good job of kind of some year-end annual reports that maybe you get in the spring or after the fiscal year, and that's not really what I'm talking about. Um, you know, I just got an, an an email from a nonprofit I support, and it said in a very informal term, you know, in a very informal tone, y'all really stepped up because you gave, you provided money for this many teens in this program, and you helped dig a well at this site in Africa, and you did this, and you did this, and you did this. And it was about 6 bullet points of what I did, and I know that my whatever, my $25 I gave or whatever didn't do all those things, but it addressed it. It said corporately, because you gave, these things happened. And so I think those are— that's just a really quick, easy— in my inbox, it took me 2 minutes to read it or less. But that stuck in my mind and I was like, yeah, okay, my money went to work and it did all these things. That's really amazing. So that's what I mean by account. It doesn't have to be a large You know, overly processed brochure mailed, you know, that kind of thing. It can be stories of impact. It can be one-on-one. You know, I'm sitting across you from coffee and, and I want to tell you about somebody who came through our door and was hungry or thirsty and how, you know, how we helped them. It's as easy as that. That's account.
Tony MartignettiAnd you distinguish it from the, the annual report. And that is, yeah, impact report.
Cara AugspurgerYeah, and that— I mean, I think that that's important too. That's a really great way to show, um, in a very large format how to, you know, you're accounting for those donations that are entrusted to you. But that's intimidating for so many nonprofit professionals to think, oh, I have to knock out an annual report. It's important, you should do it, but throughout the year, use these little opportunities to show, um, that you're accounting for those donations. Yeah.
Tony MartignettiOkay, anything else, uh, accounting-wise?
Cara AugspurgerWell, acknowledge and account, make up stewardship. Good stewardship means donor retention, right? So that's, that's the end goal— donor retention. You want those donors to come back for their second gift and their third gift.
Tony MartignettiYeah, because we know that acquiring a new donor costs us so much more than retaining. And, uh, yeah, our retention rates are very poor, right? Like,
Cara Augspurgeroh, for sure,
Tony Martignetti20% or something. I mean, 80% of donors leave after the Oh yeah,
Cara Augspurgeryeah.
Tony MartignettiOr 17% is our retention rate or something. It's very, very pitifully low.
Cara AugspurgerSo for— yeah, you're bringing in 10 donors and 8 of them are turning around and never coming back. But the statistics show that if you have repeat donations, so those people who give second, make their second gift and third gift, their retention rate is closer to that 60% level. So those are the kind of numbers that you really want to, to report on. You really want to keep your eye on as you are growing your nonprofit. creating your fundraising strategy for the year.
Tony MartignettiAnd that's our, uh, again, right, our, our 5th, our 5th, uh, A of awesome fundraising is again, repeat.
Cara AugspurgerAgain, yeah, repeat. It's, it's just repeat. So as you repeat the cycle, you know, you're focusing not only on attracting new donors, right, but making your organization attractive to your current supporters. So you're engaging them, you're inviting them, you are starting that conversation and just keeping that conversation going, and you keep that cycle going year over year. We have, um, one woman who runs, um, an organization who's in our fundraising coaching, and she shared with me that they have an organizational commitment to ensure that any supporter receives at least 2 communication touchpoints before they're asked again. So that is just a framework that you can have as part of your organizational practices and really just kind of keep that in the back of your mind. So if you're not over-asking. Um, now there are seasons that are very ask-heavy, like year-end fundraising. You might feel like you're really, really asking a lot during that time of year, and that's okay. Just make sure that you're balancing out your communication touchpoints throughout the year so that they're not all ask-heavy.
Tony MartignettiYou'd probably like to see an annual plan.
Cara AugspurgerYeah. Oh, absolutely.
Tony MartignettiCommunications marketing plan.
Cara AugspurgerAnd when you're mapping out that plan, keep those 5 A's in mind and just make sure that you're, that you're plugging touchpoints Anything
Tony Martignettielse, Cara, you want to, uh, want to leave us with? Could be, could be outside the 5 A's of awesome fundraising if, if you like. Anything? Uh, yeah.
Cara AugspurgerI say, you know, now is really the best time to shore up some of those good fundraising practices, to really, um, take time to say, okay, what am I doing right now? Have I done a good job of, you know, making sure that I'm doing a good job of you know, accounting for the donations people have given to me? Have I taken time to say thank you? And now is a really good time to really assess that and make up for a backlog if you haven't, before we get ready for that year-end fundraising. So that will help your organization stand out in your supporters' minds when it's, when it's time to ask again. But I think now is a very important time to really make sure. That you're aligned for all that's ahead in the coming months.
Tony MartignettiCara Augspurger with a P, not with a B.
Cara AugspurgerNope.
Tony MartignettiShe's the fundraising coach for Donorbox. You'll find her on LinkedIn. You'll find the company, of course, you know, because they're graciously sponsoring Nonprofit Radio. You know that the company is at donorbox.org. Cara, thank you very much for sharing. Thanks so much.
Cara AugspurgerOh, it's been such a pleasure, Tony. Thanks so much for having me.
Kate MartignettiNext week, we don't know, but it'll be a good one. If you missed any part of this week's show,
Tony MartignettiI beseech you, find it at tonymartignetti.com.
Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by Donorbox. Outdated donation forms blocking your supporters' generosity? Donorbox. Fast, flexible, and friendly fundraising forms for your nonprofit. donorbox.org.
Tony MartignettiI love that alliteration. And by the way, when I said tough, I didn't mean tough for you to say. I meant too bad, you gotta say it.
Kate MartignettiToo bad you have to say it. Try saying it 5 times fast. Fast, flexible, and friendly fundraising forms for your nonprofit. Our creative producer is Claire Meyerhoff. I'm your associate producer, Kate Martignetti. The show's social media is by Susan Chavez. Marc Silverman is our web guy, and this music is by Scott Stein.
Tony MartignettiThank you for that affirmation, Scotty. Be with us next week for Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. Go out and be great. Thank you.
I love our sponsor!


