Skip to content
EP 634April 2, 2023

OK Boomer, Move Over

Tony MartignettiGene Takagi
Nonprofit Radio
Episode 634
0:00 / 0:00

About this episode

In only two years, Millennials will make up 75% of the global workforce. Along with Gen Z, these will soon be the majority of your workers, your donors, your volunteers. Think sustainability. Are you engaging them now? Are they fully represented on your board? Gene Takagi talks us through the implications around philanthropy, technology, fundraising, and more. He’s our legal contributor and the principal of NEO Law Group.

Here’s the transcript

Tony MartignettiHello and welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. I'm your aptly named host of your favorite hebdomadal podcast. We have a listener of the week. Core Africa. Liz Fanning, the executive director, is a longtime Nonprofit Radio listener, and Core Africa just announced an investment of $59,400,000 over 5 years from Mastercard Foundation. And I think let's just call it $60 million because the difference is a mere 600,000, which is a trifling 1%. Core Africa, congratulations to you. This is such a testament to the amazing, valuable work of the Core Africa volunteers throughout the continent, the dedication of the staff, and the commitment of the board. Core Africa is going to expand to 11 countries With this new investment. Congratulations, Core Africa. I am so happy for you and happy to make you this week's Nonprofit Radio Listener of the Week. Congratulations. Plus, we have a new sponsor. Oh, I'm glad you're with me. I'd bear the pain of iridoxesis. If I had to see that you missed this week's show. Okay, boomer, move over. In only 2 years, millennials will make up 75% of the global workforce. Along with Gen Z, these will soon be the majority of your workers, your donors, your volunteers. Think sustainability. Are you engaging them now? Are they fully represented on your board? Right. Gene Takagi talks us through the implications around philanthropy, technology, fundraising, and more. He's our legal contributor and the principal of Neo Law Group. On Tony's Take Two, 23 NTC. We're sponsored by DonorBox. Welcome to DonorBox. Thank you. So much for joining the Nonprofit Radio family. Very, very glad to have you. Thank you. With intuitive fundraising software from DonorBox, your donors give 4 times faster. Helping you help others. donorbox.org. Here is Okay Boomer, Move Over. It's a pleasure to welcome back Gene Takagi. You know who he is, but he deserves a proper intro nonetheless. He's our legal contributor and managing attorney of NEO, the Nonprofit and Exempt Organizations Law Group in San Francisco. He edits the wildly popular nonprofitlawblog.com and is a part-time lecturer at Columbia University. The firm is at neolawgroup.com, and he's @GTak. Gene, such a good— such a pleasure to see you. Welcome back. Welcome back.

Gene TakagiThanks so much, Tony. Great to see you as well.

Tony MartignettiMy pleasure, always. Now, when we last talked, uh, we were with Amy Sample Ward, and there was a discussion that included The, uh, the, the potential decline of Twitter and the rise of some alternatives. Are you still @GTak on Twitter? And, and are you any other place that, that I should be acknowledging?

Gene TakagiI'm still active on Twitter. Um, I'm, uh, hedging a little, and, and I'm on Mastodon and Post, but those are, are sort of lightly used. But I, I post daily on all those channels.

Tony MartignettiOkay, so still stick with, uh, still Twitter is the best way to, uh, to reach you, you think?

Gene TakagiProbably. If you want to see most of my content, Twitter is going to be the best way to see it.

Tony MartignettiOkay, okay, stick with that for now. All right, millennials and, uh, and Generation Z, you're, you're concerned about the future for these folks. What, uh, well, high-level view What's concerning you?

Gene TakagiWell, it's less concerned about these folks versus concerned about nonprofits for not engaging these folks, because in a few short years, by 2030, millennials and Gen Z will make up 75% of our workforce. They've just crossed over the 50% barrier, I think, a couple years ago, but within 7 years, 75% of our workforce. That's a huge change in our workplace demographics.

Tony MartignettiYeah. And we're not accommodating these folks. You're concerned about, for instance, board membership, significant employment issues. What would you like to— I'm going to give you the first shot. Let's change things up because sometimes I feel like an autocrat. So what would, what would, what would you like to talk first, uh, talk about first that nonprofits are just not paying sufficient attention to?

Gene TakagiSure. Well, I maybe I'll just go without sort of criticizing nonprofits. Let's just like say, why should we as nonprofits engage millennials and Gen Z? Yes, they're going to make up a majority of our workforce, but what else does that mean? Um, and you know, when, when they make up a majority of the workforce, I, I think I'm also saying, and I don't have the studies to back this one up, but I'm also saying eventually It goes to say that they're going to make up a majority of our donors. They're going to make up a majority of the beneficiaries that we're helping. They're going to make up a majority of all of our supporters and our collaborators. And eventually our generation, boomers, Gen X, eventually we're going to kind of be not leading some of these places. Although I saw a really interesting article in The Atlantic a month or two ago That said, people our age, relatively young, Tony, still, still, but—

Tony MartignettiI'm a young, I'm a young boomer. I don't mind. I'm 61. So I'm among the youngest boomers.

Gene TakagiAnd I'm very close in age to you, Tony. And the Atlantic article said that persons our age and even a little bit younger tend to think like we're about 20% younger than we actually are. We kind of resonate with our, maybe not our, sort of calendar date, but we feel like we're, we're a younger group by about 20%.

Tony MartignettiYeah, I agree. I feel even younger than, than 20%. I feel like more like 40.

Gene TakagiYeah. And I—

Tony Martignetti20 years, like, so 20, 21 years younger, what I mean.

Gene TakagiI feel the same way. But it occurred to me in my head that maybe that's why groups of leaders that are thinking about engaging younger people are not placing such importance in it because we think, well, we kind of understand that group anyway. We feel around that age. But when we start to think about it, well, maybe there are some differences and maybe their perspectives and their skill sets and their experiences are gonna really add value to our organizations. Yeah.

Tony MartignettiAnd it's not even maybe. I mean, they will.

Gene TakagiRight, exactly.

Tony MartignettiBut we need to, you know, it's time for us to sort of move aside But yeah, no, it's very interesting, Gene, that, you know, our own self-perception may be confounding the larger, the larger culture, slowly holding, holding back the larger cultural changes. You know, just because I feel like I'm 40 doesn't mean that I have the awareness of technology, politics, the culture that a 40-year-old has.

Gene TakagiYeah, exactly right. And certainly not ones that I can tell you from personal experience, like from my nieces, certainly not those 20-year-olds.

Tony MartignettiYeah, no. Yeah, I'm not even claiming— right, of course, of course.

Gene TakagiI just recall my nieces telling me the smiley face emoji is passive-aggressive when I use that in text messaging. So I have to watch myself in our communications.

Tony MartignettiSo it is. I see. Okay. I had— I have my own anecdote about a story I used to tell that is now deemed misogynistic, but I was telling it for years in professional settings, not just in stand-up comedy, but in professional settings. Yeah. No, you're right. All right, so we have to get past our own self-perceptions and think about the larger culture, economy, nonprofit sector. All right, all right, all right. So help us. Yeah. I don't know. Are we talking— I guess we're talking here to the obstructionists. We're talking here to the boomers, are we? Move aside.

Gene TakagiYou know, a little bit.

Tony MartignettiI think we are. I feel like we are.

Gene TakagiYeah, Dean, especially to the extent that if you're on a board or if you're in an organization where your leadership is dominated by boomers, like ourselves, then, then, you know, maybe we have to think a little bit more about sharing power and authority and other things, and not just to look better, like take a better photograph of our leadership.

Tony MartignettiYeah, right.

Gene TakagiYou know, for all, for all of these specific reasons. So I'll just raise a few right now. The laws change, and if the voting citizenry is changing in demographics. The laws are gonna change to what they want them to change as, you know, within constitutional limits, of course. But even the constitutional interpretation is gonna change as our Supreme Court starts to get younger. And I'll cross my fingers a little bit on that. But, you know, what is charitable? You know, it started off as kind of relief of the poor. That's what's built into our regulations and then kind of expanded into maybe, well, civil rights can be. Yeah. Charitable under 501. And then, you know, it expanded, although it's not even stated in the regulations, the promotion of health being a 501 purpose and protection of the environment. Although I recall I put in an application for a charity maybe 10, 15 years ago where global warming was something they wanted to combat, and the IRS asked, or at least this agent asked, you know, Have you really looked into both sides of that issue? Because maybe if you're just posing one point of view, that it's not charitable or educational at all. So, you know, our ideas have certainly evolved over what is and isn't charitable, and they will continue to evolve with younger people now again making up some of the decisions of these. And if we're not anticipating these changes, then we're going to be reactive. Right. Slow to react possibly, and less competitive in a very increasingly competitive field where philanthropy is also changing, right? What is philanthropy? Is it private foundations like it used to be? We certainly know about donor-advised funds. Yeah, please, Tony.

Tony MartignettiYeah, no, before we, before we advance there, because that is a rich topic, the different forms of philanthropy, but sticking with You know, regulations. What what is a charity? What what is charity? You know that all that all depends on the the our our political leaders. You know, recognizing that there's because I'm basing it on you know U.S. code and U.S. regulations promulgated by the by the the different departments of of the federal government and and state governments. You know those are all promulgate promulgated by. legislatures and— and I don't use this pejoratively— bureaucrats, you know, public service workers in government. And if— you know, I see the politics being especially slow to change. I don't know what— I don't know what the average age is of a U.S. senator or U.S. representative, but I'm certain it's not— I'm certain it's not in the 40s. I'd be very surprised if it's in the '40s even.

Gene TakagiYeah, I agree. So our political system may be the slowest sort of the sectors to sort of change, although a lot of them are responsive to money, right? And we've been talking in kind of fundraising fields about the intergenerational transfer of wealth, the greatest ever in, you know, in the history of recorded civilization.

Tony MartignettiYeah, I mean, okay, so right, so the boomers do have some value. Leave us your money. Leave your money behind. We need to execute. We need that wealth to execute change.

Gene TakagiAnd, you know, as the boomers sort of age out, the money is just being transferred into younger generations. And with that money, now they're going to influence political power as well. I'm a little cynical on this, but yes, money will sort of make changes or result in changes in the law, including in terms of what is charitable. And just started to give you a hot topic. When we talk about relief of the poor and civil rights being charitable, I don't think that providing reparations to historically discriminated against or oppressed groups is considered charitable. But will that change over time? Yeah. I don't think selling solar energy at market rates is considered charitable to the general public, but will that change over time? I think these things can change fairly rapidly within a generation. So these are things that organizations need to pay attention to.

Tony MartignettiIt's time for a break. Stop the drop with DonorBox. How many potential donors drop off before they finish making the donation on your website? You can stop the drop And break that cycle with DonorBox's ultimate donation form. You add it to your website in minutes. No coding required, no batteries required. When you stop the drop, potential donors become donors with a 4 times faster checkout and more convenient ways to give from leading payment processors, apps, and popular digital wallets. There's no setup fees, no monthly fees, and no contract required. And this is amazing— you will be joining over 40,000 U.S. nonprofits. DonorBox, helping you help others. donorbox.org. Now back to Okay Boomer, Move Over. Interesting. Those are 2 really interesting ones, reparations and alternative energy. Why did you— why did you— I'm digressing a little bit. Why did you specifically say selling solar energy at market rates?

Gene TakagiWell, you know, I think again, when we're talking about relief of the poor, we're also sort of expanding that into economic development in you know, historically disadvantaged areas. So, you know, blighted areas, areas that need sort of more economic development. Bringing solar into those areas at sort of a low cost may stimulate economic development as well as have sort of the environmental benefit that solar can bring. That would probably qualify as charitable even now. But if you start to sell it at market rates and go into expensive neighborhoods and tell people to convert their, you know, their energy sources or to, you know, buildings, first-class buildings in downtown, and saying, hey, change your energy source as a charity, that might have a tremendous impact on climate change and other things. If we could get big companies to change and put into their buildings, if charities could influence that, that might have a huge impact, but it probably wouldn't be considered charitable right now.

Tony MartignettiI see. Okay, okay, good. I'm glad I asked. All right. All right. Yeah. Reparations. It is kind of easy to see that in 10 years that reparations to African Americans, Asian Americans, Latin Americans, that subject could be on the table for charitable— as a charitable purpose.

Gene TakagiYeah, 10 years ago it was really not even in the discussion outside.

Tony Martignetti10 years ago, no, but 10 years from now.

Gene TakagiExactly.

Tony MartignettiI mean, I think we're in— I think the next 10 to 15 years are going to be considerable political upheaval, cultural upheaval. I mean, there's a— I don't know, maybe because I'm living in it, so I'm experiencing it as more volatile. And I don't mean that pejoratively, more revolutionary than the transfer of wealth and power and prestige from other generations to ours. I don't know, maybe because I'm the one surrendering the power, maybe I see it as more of a cultural shift than— Yeah. than the past. Maybe the past has been significant as well.

Gene TakagiYeah, you know, and it's interesting. So, you know, if you were to look up articles on engaging millennials and Gen Z, you know, they'll mention like different perspectives, but they'll also mention something like they've got a greater passion for social justice and things of that nature. And, you know, I agree to some extent that that is true. I think we can see that. But then when I think back, You know, to the sort of the older boomers and, you know, the hippies in the '60s. Well, maybe everybody when they were younger was just a little bit more into, you know, the environment and social justice and racial justice. And as you age, you know, again, taking a little bit of a cynical viewpoint, and certainly not to sort of overgeneralize, but as a big broad group, you know, you become a little bit less, a little bit more resistance to radical changes. You know, especially if you're in a comfortable situation, you're privileged enough not to have to worry about it in your own life. The changes that you're pushing for maybe were not as radical as when you were in your 20s. And I think you see that throughout the world, some major social movements led by sort of college-aged kids or young adults. And they're the ones that are putting it all on the line.

Tony MartignettiYour exact point has been driven home to me lately, because I've been watching a lot of Woodstock videos on YouTube. And I'm thinking, you know, when they're showing the audience, you know, first of all, it's fantastic, because I'm watching Jimi Hendrix and the Grateful Dead. And, but, you know, when they're panning into the audience, I'm thinking, are these folks, the folks who were sitting there in the in the muck, you know, they're now in their 70s and 80s. That was— Woodstock was August of 1969. So if you were 20, 25 or so, you know, you're, you're, you're into your 70s. And, and if you were a little older, you're into your 80s. Uh, talk about, yeah, perspective shifting from, from, from when you were in your 20s and 30s.

Gene TakagiYeah. And, you know, we're the same people, but You know, life, life changes and our perspectives change. And even though we identify with some of the perspectives that younger people bring, we— they're still different, you know, as we sort of admitted at the start of it. And so, yeah, just so many changes that they have a different feel for, or that they place with a different importance in terms of— And climate change is maybe a classic example of Climate change may not do as much to an 80-year-old in terms of their personal life, but to a 20-year-old, climate change may completely impact their adulthood and, you know, whether they are below the water where they live or— so, you know, obviously they're gonna have a greater incentive to ask for more radical change. Yeah. You know,

Tony Martignettiwell, hopefully these, these folks, the, the older boomers and the World War II generation, I mean, hopefully they're thinking of their ancestors, uh, coming. Um, no, ancestors are in your past. They're thinking of their, their heirs and, and children and grandchildren. I, I mean, at least the ones I, I talked to, I, I think are considering those, you know, considering the future.

Gene TakagiYeah, I think— I'm sorry, Tony, go ahead.

Tony MartignettiNo, finish your point. And then I want to drill down a little more to a little more detail. But go ahead, please make your point.

Gene TakagiSure. I was thinking that it had been sort of a customary thought amongst older generations to want things better for your kids, that your kids would have a better life than you. But I think right now we're kind of in the generation, the kids' generation that are coming up, like the Gen Zs. Where that probably is not true, at least economically. At

Tony Martignettileast economically. Yeah, yeah, you're right. We're not. No, I agree. All right, so you started to talk about different forms of philanthropy that, I don't know, I'll call them Ms and Zs for millennials and Gen Z. I know in your blog post you call them younger people. I'll call them Ms and Zs, but different forms of philanthropy like donor-advised funds, LLCs, We're right there. They're engaging a lot differently than direct gifts to 501 nonprofits.

Gene TakagiYeah, I mean, which places nonprofits, charitable nonprofits, the 501 organizations in a place of competition for dollars. So it's something again that nonprofits need to understand. Well, what is the value proposition they offer? Because I'm a really staunch advocate of nonprofits being something very, very special and very different from a social enterprise that's a for-profit. And social enterprise actually was a co-opted term. I think social enterprises used to refer to nonprofits like Goodwill that were engaged in sort of earned income revenues, but now it's sort of been co-opted by the for-profit sector of for-profits that do social good or social enterprises when that's sort of a primary reason for their operation and their existence. So, you know, these models are changing, and millennials and Gen Zs are saying, you know, we're a little bit more sector agnostic in terms of doing social good. We could put it into a private foundation, but we probably don't want to. We might use a DAF because it's temporary and we don't have to throw everything into it. What about an LLC like Mark Zuckerberg and Priscilla Chan, like the Chan Zuckerberg Initiative, the Emerson Collective, which is Steve Jobs' widow's charitable vehicle or philanthropic vehicle. So those are LLCs, and you can go into a whole show about that. GoFundMe is sort of an alternative to giving to charities. A lot of people, especially in the millennial and Gen Z age, think giving directly to a beneficiary is the way to go, bypass charity. C4s. We saw the Patagonia founder, Yvon Chouinard, decide I'm going to give— leave much of my wealth to a C4, and I'll do it now. There's planning reasons to do that, with gift and estate tax deductions being much more valuable to someone like him than an income tax deduction. When you're like a tech entrepreneur and you're not taking much of an income, but you have enormous amounts of wealth in stock that have not been liquidated yet, so you're sitting on tons of money, but you don't have much of an income tax benefit from giving a donation. Right. This volunteer work and giving data. Data is now, you know, a huge asset and a very valuable one that we're understanding. And personally, we're giving up our own data to a lot of sort of I accept, you know, websites that all of a sudden get to use our data. And I know new laws are coming into that, but volunteering your data can also be an important thing that we have to think about. And so philanthropy and how we think of Giving is changing rapidly, and there was a big change in the law just a few years ago in the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act that left itemized deductors that can take— get a tax benefit from charitable contribution. It moved from something like 34, 35% down to like less than 13%.

Tony MartignettiYeah, around 10.

Gene TakagiYeah, so there's just tremendous changes that can happen very, very quickly. And charities need to understand that. And again, younger perspectives may be on top of some of this news that older generations may not be following as closely, at least some of them.

Tony MartignettiAnd you're right to characterize these absolutely as competitors to our traditional 501 nonprofits. And so you wanna know what your competition is doing. what these different forms are, are there, you know, are there ways that you can leverage some of them? You know, maybe it is a subsidiary or some kind of an affiliate relationship. But, you know, the knowledge is among the M's and the Z's.

Gene TakagiYeah, I agree, Tony. These are not only competitors, they often can be collaborators. And allies. But you do need to understand kind of the relationships, the multiple relationships that you're gonna have with these different types of entities and how that will impact who your supporters are, who your donors are. As your donor base or as your, you know, subscriber base or as your membership base, as they start to age, are you engaging more younger people? So for sustainability over the future, even if that was like our ultimate goal is to make sure that we have an organization. Right. in the future, you've got to engage the younger people that are going to be running this show in a few short years.

Tony MartignettiNow, some folks may say, well, I can just— if I want to learn about these things, I'll just engage a baby boomer attorney, and he or she will explain, or they will explain the— will explain this all to us. And then we'll— but, but you're not, you know, that's the— that's, that's not what I agree with. But I could see a cynical view. Well, I'll just hire an older attorney. They understand LLCs versus B Corps. And well, you know, the, you know, the older advisors may very well understand the intricacies of, you know, creating one. But the creative side of how you can integrate it into your work, if you can, you know, that takes someone who's got a different perspective. And I think that's I agree with you. I mean, that's the younger perspective, you know, how to creatively integrate, not just the nuts and bolts of how to LLC versus, you know, engaging a crowdfunding platform, you know, etc.

Gene TakagiYeah. And I think when we talk about negotiating deals with other parties, you know, have, you know, if we're not speaking the same language and customs and don't have that same type of comfort, And talking with the younger generation, you know, something can get lost. And on their side, if they don't have that comfort talking with an older generation, if it just doesn't mesh quite as well as when they're talking with a peer in their age group or within sort of a generational group, that can affect the negotiation. And, you know, whether the deal gets done or whether they go with a competitor or whether they, you know, ask for more things because they trust you less. So just— Yeah. You know, getting more people involved. And if you are going to engage millennials and Gen Z, I really want to make the point that it isn't about just adding a few people in certain positions. It is really an understanding and an investment that you need to make. It's something where you have to empower people, not just sort of tokenize them or trivialize their importance. You really have got to give them positions of responsibility. And you've gotta open up your own culture to sort of embrace the additional sort of cultures and perspectives they can bring. So it really can't be just like, okay, we'll add like a senior manager or we'll add a board member that's, you know, 32, that, that'll solve our problems.

Tony MartignettiYeah. All the, well, all the caveats that you and I talked about when we've talked about diversity, equity, and inclusion.

Gene TakagiYep.

Tony MartignettiAvoiding tokenism, you know, giving real authority. You know, levers of power, not, not just a, a hire here or a, or a board member there. It's time for Tony's Take Two, 23 NTC. Big, big thanks to Heller Consulting. They're sponsoring Nonprofit Radio at the conference, the Nonprofit Technology Conference hosted by NTEN. We will be together in booth 424. Heller Consulting, Nonprofit Radio, me, all 3 of us sharing booth 424. I'll be capturing lots of interviews from the smart speakers at NTC, and you should think about it too. Think about going. You can go hybrid. You heard Amy and me talk about it last week. It really is a very, very good conference. I mean, you can go virtually, virtually. It's a very good conference, smart speakers, it's fun, it's just, it's a very worthwhile conference to go to. You will learn. And of course we know that this is not only for technologists, but I'm repeating from last week. So all the info is at NTEN.org. Thank you again, Heller Consulting, for sponsoring Nonprofit Radio. At the Nonprofit Technology Conference. Thanks so much. That is Tony's Take Two. We've got beaucoup buttloads more time for OK Boomer, Move Over with Gene Takagi. I'm taking pleasure in saying— I'm sweeping myself aside. Move over. Let's talk some about the Employment, employment changes, you know, the sensibilities that, that the, the M's and the Z's bring.

Gene TakagiYeah, and I think that's, that's really hitting us right now, because I think no matter what sector we're in, we realize that employment has changed as a result of the COVID pandemic. We're finding out, well, where, where do workers want to work? How do they want to work? What is of most importance to them? And it's not just sort of the the data that we hear, you know, from each other. But there are actual studies, and I'll just point to one, the Deloitte 2022 YZ Global Study. And, you know, that's a study by the, you know, the big accounting firm, and they found out what we probably already know, but cost of living is of tremendous importance to these younger generations. work-life balance, learning organizations, and what the organization— how— what they're sort of— not only their viewpoint, but how they operate and its social impact and its environmental impact and its sort of investment in diversity, equity, inclusion. Those are things that matter to those younger generations in terms of— in their choice of work, in terms of how long they might stay. at a particular company. And, you know, those are things again, nonprofits are competing now. Younger people are also moving from job to job faster than some older generations are used to, whereas, you know, if we go older than us, Tony, a lot of people just worked one job their whole life. And that is certainly not true anymore, and it's even less true now for the younger generations. So if we're competing constantly for employees, what do we know and understand what they want and need and consider important?

Tony MartignettiAnd what they perceive about us as a place to work. There's, you know, there's Glassdoor and those types of sites. But, you know, the research is so much easier to do. And even when they're— when someone is talking to you about potentially working for you, They're, they're taking a lot more clues, you know, than just how much vacation time do I get, you know, what, and, and what's the, what's the medical insurance like, you know, time off, flexible work locations, culture, you know, that's, and culture is a very, you know, that's a very amorphous thing, but folks are sussing it out. As they're interviewing you and they're talking to you. And, you know, if they're only meeting people who are 60 and over as they're interviewing, that in itself says a lot about the culture at the institution.

Gene TakagiYeah. And I'll just sort of add, even younger generation controlled companies that, you know, and I'll just use some of the big tech companies that are laying off like huge amounts of people right now. That's a cultural thing that people will remember. So if you're quick to lay off and you're still like providing very good returns for your shareholders, that may be something employees are going to sort of take into account in terms of whether they would go back to, you know, the same company or whether they would tell their friends to work in that company. And they're much more savvy about our companies greenwashing or sort of social good washing and saying, you know, talking the right, you know, talk, but not really walking, you know, that walk. So I think, again, nonprofits really need to know what their competitive edge might be in terms of attracting workers and keeping workers because they're dedicated to social good, but also what You know, the issues might be if they're not sort of promoting the same type of values in their culture and not just sort of, we're a great organization for the environment, but we're terrible to our employees. Like, you've got to really make sure your values match.

Tony MartignettiWhere else would you like to go, Gene? What do you want to talk about?

Gene TakagiYou know, I was thinking just a few other Quick points. You know, management and governance, I think, are also changing, and that sort of goes with how employees, you know, want to be managed, want board of directors to sort of govern organizations. I, you know, our laws and the old and older structures are very hierarchical. You know, the board of directors sits at the top of the organization. They're ultimately in control of all management and direction of the organization's affairs. They delegate it down to a CEO or an executive director, and the executive director then is responsible for all the employees, and there's all these hierarchies of, you know, who gets to be responsible for whom. And I think younger generations are much more into distributed leadership. And it's possible to set up some systems within the law. The law is not completely sort of inflexible about this. Right. But you've got to set it up in the right way. And so there is a balance of what some of the older people can tell you about the restrictions that are involved, but where the younger people could say, hey, these are the things that we really need. We don't want just sort of one person dictating everything about the organization, or a board that doesn't know our day-to-day business coming in and making huge changes that affects all of our work, you know, work lives. We need to have a voice in this, and this is— these are ways that we want you to consider it. So again, that's—

Tony MartignettiWhat does that look like, Gene? It's a model of distributed leadership.

Gene TakagiSo distributed leadership may be delegation from, let's say, from the board down to the CEO and the CEO down to groups of employees, and where the CEO is always going saying, you're responsible for this, you have the ultimate say on this, I'm not going to veto you as long as it's, you know, within what our accepted framework is. You get the ultimate say in this. And if the executive director is questioning it, you know, it's not the best business choice, they're not going to overrule if that's the basis of it. If it's unlawful or something, the executive director figures that out, then of course they would have the power to overrule it. But it's not gonna just be one person's business judgment. It's gonna be groups. And that can work well, and that can also work terribly in a not great way. Yeah. As well, but younger folks are more attuned to that type of, you know, leadership model. We have to think about how it might work and how to fine-tune it in a way that is acceptable and works well for an organization, and it's, you know, and its board of directors as well, to be comfortable with that.

Tony MartignettiAnd that could even be something on a rotating basis.

Gene TakagiYeah, it can, it can be. But, you know, it actually, you know, one of the sort of big pros about this is it gives collective thought. to something that's important where a lot of people get to put input that are intimately involved with that decision. Boards are sometimes somewhat removed 'cause again, they're not in the day-to-day, but this group of employees might actively day-to-day be heavily involved with that particular issue. And to give them decision-making authority may feel them, you know, I'm gonna use an old term, but gives them ownership over the organization. They feel like they're empowered and the organization is part of them and they are part of the organization. And that feeling is something I think that people desire. And again, management styles, governance styles are changing, or— and the desire for more collaborative and distributed leadership is really a big force that I see coming in the next 10 to 20 years.

Tony MartignettiHow about fundraising? Fundraising, sustainability, You know, you started to touch on both of those, uh, our, our donor base. And I'm the guy who's, uh, I'm the evangelist for planned giving. But we have to also acknowledge, I mean, look, the baby boomers are not all dead. You and I are living testament to that. So there is still value in planned giving fundraising. But our older folks donors are being replaced by younger donors.

Gene TakagiYeah, and I actually think so. You know, some charities are focused on planned giving with older donors, but millennials are kind of— they're in their 40s now. This is a prime time to have conversations with millennials who are, you know, who've, you know, been privileged enough to have some wealth to think about in terms of giving to charity. And they have all this competition, as we mentioned. They could You know, give it to GoFundMe or whatever form of DAF, you could try to develop that relationship now with them. And if you can develop and use the same tools that you engaged older folks and use some of those tools and bring in some of your younger folks that you've previously engaged to be working for the organization as well, so that they can have these discussions with donors who are their peers in age. And I think that is very valuable. So the, you know, fundraising—

Tony MartignettiI'd like to just put a point on it so that folks who know me and have heard me speak, you know, don't think that I'm a hypocrite. You know, in all the training I do, I'm talking about launching planned giving. And in launching planned giving, I think your time is best spent with folks who are 55 to 60 and over because they are the most likely to include you in their long-term plan. I'm typically talking about wills, and they're most likely that— they're the most likely folks that will keep your gift in their will versus someone in their 30s and 40s who is going to live for another 50 years or so. That's, you know, that's a long— that's a long time to be in someone's will. So in launching, I think the time is best spent talking to folks who are, again, roughly 60 and over. But in out years of a program, planned giving program, I can certainly see value in talking to folks in their 30s, 40s, and doing that with peers. As you're suggesting, there's just a shared experience when, you know, a couple of 30-year-olds are talking to each other versus me as a 61-year-old consultant or even frontline fundraiser talking to someone half my age about putting the organization in your will.

Gene TakagiYeah, and I agree with your point, Tony. When you have limited resources and you're starting or initiating a planned giving program, The age set that you gave makes the most, you know, sense for you. But it is another point just to say, think about engaging younger people, and on both sides, on the staffing side and volunteer side, as well as on your donor side. And, you know, think about groups that you can develop long relationships with. So when you want to finally, you know, if you're constantly engage with them for the next 30 or 40 years, you, you really feel that gift is going to be fixed. But yes, they could change their minds at any time. So it sort of demands that you make sure that you strengthen that relationship year after year versus not, you know, giving them any touches at all and in the way they like. So that might be using gamification, social media, like other ways that they want to be engaged. You'll have to find not the way that you feel is easiest or cheapest to engage. With your group. You have to find what do they want, how do they want to be engaged.

Tony MartignettiAnd this goes back to traditional lessons of fundraising that we want to be relational, not transactional. So you need to be relational with this upcoming cohort of generations, the Ms and the Zs, because they are your future— they're your future major donors if they're not now. They're your future planned giving donors. They're your future volunteers in retirement. I mean, you, you want to be this, and this goes to the sustainability as well. You know, you, you want your mission to survive. You need to have a pipeline of donors, uh, that are not all 65 and over.

Gene TakagiYeah. And I'll kind of relate fundraising to technology as well, because, you know, our technology will dictate in some ways how we decide to fundraise. Like now we've got, you know, We went from letter, you know, paper and pen sort of solicitations and in-person contacts to, okay, emails. And now emails are sort of— we're getting to a post-email phase of like text messaging or, you know, and other forms now of communication. And how will that impact fundraising, crowdfunding, and other sort of platform-type fundraising is now sort of encountering new legal barriers or restrictions or limitations, California being one of the first ones with laws that came into effect this year and regulations that will come into effect next year. And that, that's usually a harbinger of things to come in other states as well. So the laws are gonna change, the types of fundraising vehicles are going to change. Nonprofits would be really wise to engage some millennials and Gen Z to understand where these things may go and how these, you know, laws might be influenced in terms of advocacy and making sure that, you know, one bad actor is not creating a whole bunch of restrictions that are gonna impact like a lot of other charities that should never have been bothered by this.

Tony MartignettiArtificial intelligence. understanding what it is, what its uses are, what the boundaries are. We've, we've seen some institutions make big mistakes. There was a, there was a college that reacted to the shooting at Michigan State University with a, with a, with a ChatGPT email. And then, and it was disclosed because they didn't even think to take out the disclaimer that said, created by ChatGPT, you know, and, and what— I can't remember what college that was. That was not Michigan State. They were— it was a college reacting to the Michigan State shooting and doing it very badly. I think it was Vanderbilt University, one of the colleges at Vanderbilt University. And it was even a DEI officer who sent the email. Yeah. So, you know, not even thinking about, you know, inclusive language on our own, but relying on artificial intelligence. So, you know, the boundaries of artificial intelligence, the creative uses of it, you know, concerns about deepfake AI, you know, that stuff is all relevant and it's coming. I mean, it's here. It's here now. It's not coming. It's here. And if you want to capitalize on it appropriately, I think it pays to have folks who understand it best, and they're probably not 50 or 60 years old.

Gene TakagiYeah, and I agree with you 100%. And again, wrapping this back around to charitability, um, fake news, um, is it charitable to distribute fake news? Is that just a viewpoint? Is what we considered fake news 50 years ago something that actually is something that we think is generally acceptable now? And isn't charity supposed to be an incubator for these new ideas and changes? So it's tricky. But again, we want to have multiple perspectives on this, not just sort of one generation's perspective on this or just older generations' perspective on this. We need to have the younger generation's perspective because ultimately they're going to be the ones that control that law.

Tony MartignettiThat feels like a pretty good place to leave things. Is there anything else? But I'll give you a last chance. Anything we haven't talked about that you want to? We have time if there's something else You want to engage on?

Gene TakagiMaybe just my last thought is for all the generations to respect kind of what we all have to offer. And this is not meant to be a criticism of older generations. It's really meant to say, let's be more engaged as multigenerational organizations for sustainability, for understanding, for perspectives, and Just to do our jobs in a way that aligns with our values and is as effective and efficient as possible.

Tony MartignettiGene Takagi, our legal contributor, managing editor of the wildly popular Nonprofit Law Blog. You'll find that at nonprofitlawblog.com. His firm is at neolawgroup.com. And Gene is @GTAK, G-T-A-K. Gene, thank you so much for your wisdom.

Gene TakagiAlways a pleasure, Tony. Thank you.

Tony MartignettiAnd mine. Next week, Matt Scott returns with his new book, The High-Growth Nonprofit. If you missed any part of this week's show, I beseech you, find it at tonymartignetti.com. We're sponsored by DonorBox. With intuitive fundraising software from DonorBox, your donors give 4 times faster. Helping you help others. donorbox.org. Our creative producer is Claire Meyerhoff. The show's social media is by Susan Chavez. Marc Silverman is our web guy, and this music is by Scott Stein. Yeah! Thank you for that affirmation, Scotty. Be with me next week for Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. Go out and be great. Thank you.

Nonprofit Radio