Overlooked Consequences Of A.I. & How To Preserve Your Humanity


About this episode
There’s a broad temptation we each face, to enlist Artificial Intelligence tools in all nonprofit and personal decisions. Some people have intimate relationships with A.I. bots. At what cost? Jacob Ward has spoken to psychologists, mediators, venture capitalists, and others on this question. He shares his research learnings to help you and your nonprofit determine A.I.’s boundaries. Jacob is a veteran journalist formerly with NBC News, reporting for Nightly News, The TODAY Show and MSNBC.
My Guest
Here’s the transcript
Tony MartignettiHello and welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. I'm your aptly named host and the podfather of your favorite hebdomadal podcast. Oh, I'm glad you're with us. I'd be forced to endure the pain of clinocephaly if you hit me over the head with the idea that you missed this week's show. Here's our associate producer, Kate, to introduce it.
Kate MartignettiHey, Tony, here's what's up. Overlooked consequences of AI and how to preserve your humanity. There's a broad temptation we each face to enlist artificial intelligence tools in all nonprofit and personal decisions. Some people have intimate relationships with AI bots. At what cost? Jacob Ward has spoken to psychologists, mediators, venture capitalists, and others on this question. He shares his research learnings to help you and your nonprofit determine AI's boundaries. Jacob is a veteran journalist, formerly with NBC News, Reporting for Nightly News, The Today Show, and MSNBC. On Tony's Take Two,
Tony MartignettiAir Travel Civility.
Kate MartignettiHere is Overlooked Consequences of AI and How to Preserve Your Humanity.
Tony MartignettiIt's a pleasure to welcome to Nonprofit Radio Jacob Ward. Jacob is a veteran journalist covering the intersection of technology, Human Behavior and Social Change. He's currently reporter in residence at the Omidyar Network, writing about cutting-edge innovation and pioneering forms of restraint, and a strategic advisor on the deployment of AI for companies large and small. From 2018 to 2024, he was technology correspondent for NBC News. Reporting for Nightly News, the Today Show, and MSNBC. He's @byJacobWard in all the social networks. @JacobWard, welcome to Nonprofit Radio.
Jacob WardThanks, @TonyMartignetti. Appreciate your time. Yeah, appreciate you having me.
Tony MartignettiAnd thank you for that glorious pronunciation. You said Martignetti. Thank you.
Jacob WardYou know, I speak a tiny bit of Italian thanks to a semester trying to be a chef in Italy. I thought I was gonna get— I thought I was gonna break free and be that guy. Turns out that was not my path. And so here we are together, and I speak terrible Italian, but I know how to say Martignetti. So that's good.
Tony MartignettiAll right. Well, you know, maybe, you know, restaurant Italian since you were studying to be a chef.
Jacob WardThat's right.
Tony MartignettiWhat happened? What happened to the culinary career? Why did that—
Jacob WardI wasn't brave enough at that time to wander into an Italian kitchen and And with my terrible Italian and my 6'7 frame, I'm a 6— I'm a very tall dude. Yeah. To wander into these cramped little kitchens and say, what do you want to do with me? It was not my— I just didn't have that gene yet. Or I didn't have that gene. I didn't have that muscle developed yet. And so it just took me a little while. It took— it turns out that 10 years of being a television correspondent will beat that right out of you. So I wish I could go back and try again. But yeah, that was not my path, it turned out.
Tony MartignettiAll right. Well, you took a vastly different path. Journalism, reporting, research, and you've been focusing for a long time now on artificial intelligence. You had some forecasts, I don't know, predictions of the frenzy that we now find ourselves in, but years ago. We'll get to some of those from your book. Right. Give us an overview of your thinking, though. You're concerned about overlooked consequences, right? People rushing in, institutions rushing in. Overall, we have a full hour together. But, you know, give us, give us an overview of what you're finding.
Jacob WardThe overall thesis that I am pursuing is that AI, I think, is going to do to some really fundamental cognitive and social abilities what Google Maps has done to our sense of direction. I think that the prosthetic outsourced decision-making system that AI, I would argue, pretends to be is the perfect way of ensnaring an ancient decision-making system that we all use the vast majority of the time that loves to let other things, make decisions for it. And as a result, the point I've been trying to make for the last decade is that our brains and our society are totally unprepared for what this technology is going to do to us. You know, and I wrote this book, as you mentioned, to try and articulate that. I thought I was like 10 years early, Tony. And then the book came out about 9 months before ChatGPT did. And since then, I've been watching my thesis come to life.
Tony MartignettiAll right. The book is The Loop: How AI Is Creating a World Without Choices and How to Fight Back. Since we're talking about the book, we may as well get into the book.
Jacob WardSure.
Tony MartignettiIt's just your concern is that it's, well, you say in a summary that it will amplify our good and bad human instincts. And these things are happening without us realizing.
Jacob WardRight, right, right. So I basically spent several years doing a PBS documentary series called Hacking Your Mind. And that was a crash course in the last, like, 60 years of behavioral science. We got to go all over the world and talk to these experts in all these different areas of human behavior. And their message over and over and over again was we make most of our decisions unconsciously. And the way in which we make those decisions is incredibly programmatic. It's very easy to predict— not easy, but very predictable. And it turns out very manipulatable. Right. We are very malleable. And the upshot of that for me in my day job was to also be looking at all of these companies that I was speaking to, you know, as a tech correspondent who were using at the time primitive versions of AI. This is pre-transformer models, which is the technology that made ChatGPT possible. You know, where people using sort of human reinforced learning kind of stuff, very sort of early versions of the AI that we now use so widely. And I just thought to myself, wait a minute, this is a Perfect pattern recognition technology. It's going to pull patterns out of huge tranches of data that a human being could never really analyze otherwise. All it does is find patterns in many cases without even being able to explain what that pattern is, just that this is the, you know, one that it can't even describe, but it can predict. And I thought, wait a minute, that is a, this is a really dangerous combination because This is not a technology being built by universities. It's not even a technology being built by the military as past big knowledge innovations have been. This is one entirely being built inside for-profit companies that are going to be under incredible financial pressure to make their money back from the investment. And so I just worried, you know, as much as, and I go into the book many times, into many examples of here are places that it could do fantastic things. And your listeners, I think, are in a realm that could be absolutely transformed in a positive way by this. Yeah. But unfortunately, the way this thing is going to get packaged for revenue by the companies that make it, I think very often it's going to wind up amplifying the worst parts of our, or at least the most sort of primitive parts of our decision-making system. You know, what the kids call the lizard brain. And so that, that is fundamentally what the book is about, is if we let the market run wild with this stuff, it's going to wind up turning us into an ancient version of ourselves that we, that we've worked really hard to get away from. Yeah. And I, and I feel like I'm seeing that playing out in real time here.
Tony MartignettiLet me take a step back just to pull on something that you, you said that I've always wondered about. What, what is it that brought us ChatGPT from the previous iteration that you described as more primitive? What, what, what technology, or I don't know, what, what was it that enabled ChatGPT to emerge?
Jacob WardYeah, so late 2017, early 2018, Up until that point, you, in order to use what was at the time the cutting edge of AI, that was stuff that they would refer to as machine learning, neural networks, you had to do a kind of training system that was very specific. And like, if you imagine that you're, you're a ro— you've got a robot that you need to teach how to go into a sandwich shop. Right. and follow the rules properly, right? What you would have to do back then is say, okay, look, here's the shop. Okay, there's a line of people. You wanna stand at the back of the line. Don't go behind the counter where the food is. You gotta stand in that line. Okay, then once the next person steps forward, you step forward. And in each case, you need a human being to reinforce what's the right and the wrong choice in that process. And it's very laborious, as you can imagine. You need it at the time. Right. thousands and thousands of paid people on an Amazon-run platform called Mechanical Turk that would do the training to make that possible. Then along comes 2017, 2018, something called a transformer model. And what a transformer model made possible was to pour all of the people who've ever stepped foot inside a sandwich shop and gone through the process successfully. You can pour all of those people into a computer. Wow. all of that data into the top of an enormous funnel. And at the bottom of that funnel will come out a set of cogent rules about what's most likely to happen. After I've stood in the line for a second, then the guy— you step to the front and that's when you order the sandwich and you hand over the cash. These patterns emerge from the machine observing all of this data. And that funnel capture system means you can— Yeah. Take, you know, every star in the sky, every photograph of a mole that might turn into skin cancer, right? You can pour these things into the funnel and it will, at the bottom of that, without having to be taught piece by piece what's the right answer, it'll come up with these shorthand rules for making choices about this stuff. Fantastic. Amazing. The problem, of course, is it can't very often— usually it can't really explain how it's making those choices. Yeah. And our brains are very quick to assume that this thing is then an expert in sandwiches, an expert in stars, an expert in skin cancer, when in fact all it is is an incredibly, uh, uh, excellent pattern recognition system. That's literally all it does. And so the problem is that we tend to anthropomorphize that into thinking, oh, this thing can be— Hmm. an astrophysicist or a therapist or my girlfriend. And that's the moment that we've sort of entered now.
Tony MartignettiTalk about girlfriend. I mean, there's the company Friend.
Jacob WardOh, yeah.
Tony MartignettiI was in the New York City subway. I saw ads for Friend, you know, I'll ride the subway with you. Friend.com or .co, whatever. But, you know, just, I'll walk through the park with you. Yep. Whoo! I don't know. We make it to Friend.
Jacob WardYeah, this is the thing, right? This is the other side of it is that You know, so there's a very famous story in my world of a researcher in the 1960s named Joseph Weizenbaum. And he was at MIT. He was German-born and a very interesting guy. And he was playing around with a system that he had built that was basically a teletype machine that could mirror what it received back at you in written form. And he was trying to figure out, okay, what he wanted to do was play with how will humans react to this? If I can make a lifelike conversational system. How will humans respond to this? And he was trying to figure out what's the best way to dress this up so people will play with it. And he dressed it up as a therapist. He made it into a Rogerian therapist, which at the time was the fashion in therapy. And Rogerian therapy is the kind where, you know, you say to me, Tony, you know, oh, my wife is driving me crazy. And I say, your wife is driving you crazy. And you say, oh, well, you know how women are. And I say, tell me how women are. Right? It just is just, it is the easiest kind of mirroring back and forth. Well, Weizenbaum sics this thing on his secretary first. And the story is that within 5 minutes, she turns around and he's watching over her shoulder. And he said, and she says, I need you to leave the room. And he says, oh? And she says, I'm about to volunteer stuff that I don't want you to see. You know, we're having a private conversation here. Within a few years, the American Psychological Association was predicting the end of human therapy. Carl Sagan was on TV talking about going into a phone booth to talk to your therapist, right? Yeah. The frenzy about this thing became so fevered that Weizenbaum quit the field. He was so disturbed by what he had built that he said, I'm out. And he wrote this great book about human, how humans basically are not ready for this stuff. And then he quit the field and he spent the rest of his life, he died in the '90s, as a, like a climate activist in his native Germany. And I tell that story to young entrepreneurs. Everybody kind of knows this story now. It's sort of like a famous parable in Silicon Valley. But back when I was first telling it to kids who are, you know, right out of a business school or in one of these incubators we have out here, all that they would always say, they'd laugh when I said he walked away from the field because they'd say, well, but he had a great minimally viable product, which is the term that people use.
Tony MartignettiAn MVP, minimally viable product.
Jacob WardAn MVP, right? You need that prototype to get your funding, right? He said, he had a great MVP. He could just have gone forward, right? And I'd have to be like, hey, you guys, that's not the point of the story. The point is not that this is market fit. The point is it's too good at simulating what humans want out of this stuff. And, you know, cut to last year, in the fall of last year, the incubator that Sam Altman, the creator of ChatGPT, the founder of OpenAI, he used to run this incubator called Y Combinator. Half of those kids coming out of there in this like 2 dozen companies that come out of there each year, each session, half of them were therapists, therapy companies, right? And because there's such clear market need, right? And so Friend, I haven't looked at this thing you're describing, but right, whether it's just sort of a solution for loneliness or an answer to the mental health crisis that young people are in right now, people just think, oh yeah, let's sic this thing, this LLM system on that because there's market fit. And the lesson of, you know, of my career has been, We need to be thinking about other things than just market fit.
Tony MartignettiWell, his concern that humans are not ready for this. I'm not sure we're any more ready now. 20, 30 years later, it sounds like 30, 35 years later than when he left the field. Yeah, Friend, I did just a little bit of digging. It's a necklace you wear. It looks like an amulet to me. You wear it around your neck everywhere and it hears everything that you hear.
Jacob WardYes.
Tony MartignettiI don't know if it has a visual capacity. Yes. But it hears everything. It hears everything you say.
Jacob WardYeah, I spent some time with this. And the thing that is reflective about this, I can't remember if it's this or another one, but this amulet is this sort of, you know, amulet, AI-powered amulet is a thing. There was a company called Humane that tried to make a pin that was going to be this. And Sam Altman and this guy, Jony Ive, who was one of the main designers at Apple under Steve Jobs, they're now teamed up. Jony Ive's company got bought by Sam Altman, and they are, in theory, creating some kind of new form factor for AI that everybody expects will be something like A pin, a necklace, you know, something like that. And the thing is, right, the—
Tony MartignettiI'm shaking my head. Listen to this. Yeah, I see you.
Jacob WardYeah, yeah, ladies and gentlemen, Tony is definitely shaking his head right now because, but this is the thing, right, is that like, you know, we are of a generation that has heard some, you know, knows some things about surveillance going wrong and knows some things about profit motive going wrong, right? But the generation of kids that are building these systems, and I don't remember if it's Friend or another one of these, but I remember listening to one of the founders of one of these companies talking about it. And, you know, there's just this sort of like college freshman's idea of what, you know, a sort of the sociological impact of this thing.
Tony MartignettiOh, great.
Jacob WardYou know what I mean? It just—
Tony MartignettiSo much insight as an 18, 19-year-old.
Jacob WardYeah. And so that idea that sort of, You know, and the thing obviously I hope we get into in this conversation is one of the things you learn as a young software person is that scale solves your problems. So you're trying to ship a minimally viable product as quick as you can and grow the number of users as fast as you can, not just for revenue purposes, but also because that's your quality assurance system. That's your way of catching bugs and getting rid of them. So the more people using your thing, The more bugs will get ironed out and the better the product becomes in theory. Well, that contrasts very dramatically with how hardware works. If you are the Ford Motor Company and you have a bug in the F-150 you're building and you ship, the more of those that you ship, the more you are compounding your problems. You have that many more trucks you've got to fix, right? And I am, I have sort of come to developed this theory that while AI people are all trained in that software idea where if we just ship enough of these amulets, we'll work it out, I actually think it's more of a hardware problem because we are the hardware. And the more you build onto somebody's habits of, you know, something problematic, I think the more we're going to see those effects compounded by scale. So I really worry about this, this move fast and break things assumption, which, you know, I've— I still have people in Silicon Valley say without irony, moving fast and breaking things is how we do things right. You know, that's the best way to do it.
Tony MartignettiWe're talking about the broken things being human beings.
Jacob WardYeah. And that's the problem, right? Is I think we're in— we're poised to break some of the basic circuitry of human interaction and human cognition. And I worry about that.
Tony MartignettiMaybe I'm beating this further than Should, but listeners know that they suffer with a lackluster host. Just last week, the New York Times had a profile of 3 adults who have intimate relationships with some— with an AI large language model. One of them has married. One of them claims that they have intimate sex. That's their phrase. All right. It's not mine. Intimate sex with their AI partner. One of them isn't AI is herself an AI researcher, right, inside an AI incubator. And one of them has married his or her— I don't remember what— AI companion. I mean, we're talking about intimate marriage and intimate sex with—
Jacob WardThat's right.
Tony MartignettiWith something that is an artificial entity.
Jacob WardYeah. And before your listeners start to scoff at the idea that these are, you know, that these people must be deranged or, you know, this, that, or the other. There's instances again and again, and they're all anecdotal for the moment, but they're beginning to get locked in for some real quantitative study of people with no history of any kind of mental health trouble, no documented history anyway, right? Falling deep into delusional thinking about these systems. And I would argue, like, one of the ways that I've been trying to sort of parse my thesis as the, as statistics are coming to light, is thinking broadly about the umbrella of what I'm, of what people are sort of calling informally AI psychosis. And I'm trying to subdivide that into these different categories. And the one that you're describing, this attachment category, is a really big one. So people are just, in the same way that, that, you know, as I'm going back and forth with a Claude or a Gemini or a ChatGPT, and I've come to believe over time that this system Because it occasionally interjects some stuff that shows some memory of past conversations with me, I begin to think, man, this thing understands me. It gets me. It knows me in this fundamental way. There's a sort of benign version of that in which you are sort of under that misconception as a product user, and it is just sort of like smoothing your experience with the product. The extreme version of that is what you're describing, where people truly come to believe that these systems are a synthetic soulmate. Yeah. They, you know, are supplanting a lack of human contact in their lives, you know, all that stuff. And I would say this plays into multiple things. Like, you know, first of all, there's a loneliness crisis in this country, not to mention half of the country holds 98% of the wealth and the other half holds 2%, right? So there's a huge swath of human beings in this country who simply don't have the time for human attachment, really. Like, you know, I've talked to, I talked to a woman who, who treats her AI chatbot as a, as a boyfriend, you know, and you ask her about the details of her life. She sleeps 5 hours a night. She works 2 jobs at the airport. She's got no time to create an attachment with somebody. Meanwhile, and this is the problem, right? And this is part of why I called my book The Loop, is that all of these effects seem to compound one another.
Tony MartignettiYeah. Yeah.
Jacob WardAs we get into a world in which people are used to only a hypersexualized, always available chatbot, intimate experience, how are those people going to form real connections with other people, right? Who aren't always on and not always sexualized and not perfectly tailored to your desires as a product. And so my, you know, I just think we are, you know, so just to— sorry, you cut me off here, Tony, I might have gone too long. But a couple of weeks ago, I think it was 3 weeks ago now, OpenAI actually released some numbers. Yeah. showing how often, how prevalent the instance of what you are describing is among their users. They were doing categories like excessive emotional attachment, mania and psychosis, and suicidal intent. And they were showing the numbers of people who are exhibiting all those kinds of things. And, you know, it's a— it's problematic for many reasons. First of all, it's a— it's an internal study. Second of all, they don't show it over time. So they're not showing whether the numbers are going up or down. Right. And we just got to kind of, you know, this is not independent researchers. This is their release. So we don't get to see, we don't get, nobody else is checking this stuff out. But they say that 0.15% of users, for instance, are openly discussing suicide, talking about their intent, talking about how they might do it, you know, seeking advice essentially. And the chatbot is trained in theory. Right. To catch that, push them to dial the national crisis line. You know, there's, there's some stuff that it's supposed to do, but they say it's not perfect. There's many cases in which that's not the case. And we've seen some, some, some families filing suit on that basis. 7, I think 2 weeks ago, 7 different families filed suit in California alone. Now, 0.15% of the total users That's 800 million weekly users. This is the fastest growing piece of software in history, right? 800 million weekly users, 0.15% of that, that's about 1.2, 1.3 million people every week openly discussing suicide. Now, the national rate of suicide attempts on an annual basis is in the single digits, or I think it's actually attempts is like 0.6%. So this is a much smaller number than that. Yeah. National incidence. But this is, but that's an average, the 0.6%, sorry, an annual average, 0.6%. 0.15%, the number of people in ChatGPT, that's weekly. That's weekly, right? Mm-hmm. So the thing that this shows me, right, is that not only are people forming these very powerful and deep attachments to these systems, they are, there's a, A, you know, a kind of, like the question ends up being like, is this just a reflection of society? And therefore it's not, you know, a company's fault that society's statistical significance, you know, statistical instance of this bad thing is happening. That was the argument the social media companies made for years. Or, you know, at the same time, you've got the company talking about trying to make, you know, OpenAI literally saying, we want this thing to be an emotional companion. Yeah. Not just a productivity tool, right? They're building it to be your friend because that is the best way to get you to use the product. So this is this moment in which, in which, you know, I talked to some people and they say it's not their— they don't have any responsibility for this. This is just how humans are. I have other people saying they have a deep responsibility for this because they are specifically playing on human attachment, this fundamental need.
Tony MartignettiAnd that goes back to your title, The Loop.
Jacob WardYeah.
Tony MartignettiThe more affection and attachment you feel, the greater your reliance and the closer you'll get.
Jacob WardThat's right.
Tony MartignettiTo the artificial LLM tool.
Jacob WardThat's right. That's right. Now, I, you know, I want to point out here, right, that like the vast majority, as we've seen in the numbers, the vast majority of people are not, you know, coming to believe this thing is a synthetic soulmate.
Tony MartignettiYeah.
Jacob WardRight. But I would argue that—
Tony MartignettiSignificant numbers.
Jacob WardA significant number are. And I think anybody, and this includes me, who misapprehends what this thing is, right? Who comes to believe that it knows more than it does, or that it is somehow, you know, a brainstorm partner, or, you know, it can be your sort of, you know, your consigliere in some way. That's, that is itself, I think, a kind of psychosis that we are all falling into. And what we're seeing, right, already in the studies, for instance, so on an institutional basis, we're already seeing that it's flattening the kind of creative thinking that you want out of a group of people. This is one of the things that I've been really bothered by. You know, if you look at, there was Nature Human Behavior this year came out with a story, I mean, a study called ChatGPT Decreases Idea Diversity in Brainstorming. Yeah. And what they found is that when you compare a group of people who are looking at a thing on Google to, you know, or in conventional sort of web searching, to a group of people who are using ChatGPT for brainstorming, the number of ideas and the language around that ideas flattens out in this really particular way, in a measurable way. Just you get less ideas out of the group because everyone's kind of relying on the same thing. People have also found this to be true in writing about— Wharton just did a study that showed that if you ask a group of people to write advice on health and wellness, and they, and you let some of them use Google, and you let some of them use an LLM, it's the same deal. The Google writers, and I can't believe I'm here defending Google search results, right? You can imagine 10 years ago I might've been saying something else, but like, you know what I mean? Like, this is where we're at. The Google search result people, they came up with a much wider variety of ideas, and their language around it was more nuanced and interesting and subtle and diverse, right? Whereas the ChatGPT people, it was just much more inane, much more the same. Yeah. You know, and so it's that flattening that I worry about. Even if we're not talking about fully losing your marbles in the— with this stuff, it's still eroding something.
Tony MartignettiYeah.
Jacob WardAnd important.
Kate MartignettiOn Tony's Take Two. That's not right.
Tony MartignettiIt's time for—
Kate MartignettiIt's time for Tony's Take Two.
Tony MartignettiThank you, Kate. I've been doing some travel lately. I was flying to Thanksgiving for about a week or so, and actually I'm flying tomorrow. That's why I'm in a hotel tonight. That's why I don't sound like my usual high-quality studio self. You get not only a middling host, but I also sound middling. So it's— so the two— so now everything's equal. It's not a middling host with a good quality mic, it's a middling host with a laptop mic, which is a middling lackluster mic. So everything's, everything's, uh, on par as— well, not as you'd expect, but everything's, everything's equivalent this week. But the air travel, that's what I wanted to talk about. I find folks are generally very civil and decent and humane to each other as we're all flying together. And even over Thanksgiving holiday, which is the going and coming are the 2 of the most heavily air-traveled days in the US. I'm pretty sure the Sunday after Thanksgiving, which is when I flew. back is the most heavy— is the heaviest flying travel day in the country. And people are still very decent to each other, patient for boarding, helping the elderly or short folks with overhead bin space, getting the bags up there, changing seats if 2 family members aren't seated together because, I don't know, Some reason the algorithm didn't put them together or whatever. You know, people surrendering seats, I saw that. And deplaning, you know, just patient, waiting your turn, you know. So, you know, I mean, I know there are exceptions. We've all seen the pugilistic passenger videos and people are battling each other in the aisles or have to be dragged out in zip ties or duct tape or whatever by police. Yeah, I've seen those. I've seen those. So that I— Yeah. But overall, I find people, even in the busiest air travel days, just like I said, decent to each other, civil, humane. So that's wonderful. That's wonderful because, you know, people could be posturing to get off the plane early because they got to get somewhere, get to their connection, you know, whatever. I don't see a lot of that. I hardly ever see it. Hardly ever. So that's good. That's good. Air travel civility. We're doing well. Let's keep it up. Do your part. Do your part to be civil. And that's Tony's Take Two. Kate?
Kate MartignettiSince I've never been on a plane, I can only go off what I see on social media. So what I'm hearing from you, it sounds like you're pretty lucky with your—
Tony MartignettiNo, it's not that I'm lucky. It's that those fighting passengers, those belligerent passengers are the rare exception. But that's the ones that make the social media, you know, a routine flight with everybody being humane, civil, courteous, polite. Nobody's gonna watch that. Nobody's even gonna record that. That would be 2.5 or 3 hours of total boredom. Nobody's gonna watch that. But the 8 seconds where there's a flare-up on one and one in I don't know, it's probably one in like 100,000 flights. I mean, there's, there's tens of thousands of flights in the U.S. every single day. So don't, don't judge by social, uh, what you see in the social networks. We got to get you on a plane, uh, you know. Yeah, I'm what, 22, right? 22. Never been on a plane? Yeah, we gotta fix that. I gotta fix that for you or something. I'll just fly you somewhere and then we'll have lunch and fly back or something. We gotta
Kate MartignettiWe've got beaucoup but loads more time. Here's the rest of Overlooked Consequences of AI and How to Preserve Your Humanity with Jacob Ward.
Tony MartignettiWhat I believe it's eroding— I've been saying this for a long time because we've had many shows on artificial intelligence— uh, is creativity, basic creativity. I, I, I think when When you're looking at a blank screen in Word and you need to fill it, that is the most creative— or you need to get started filling it. That's, I think, the most creative act in writing. You're not relying on any external source. You're relying on what you know to write about the topic that you're tasked with.
Jacob WardRight.
Tony MartignettiVersus
Jacob WardHow very last century of you, Tony.
Tony MartignettiPardon
Jacob Wardme? How very last century.
Tony MartignettiVery last century. So quaint. Isn't that crazy?
Jacob WardIt's so quaint, right? Typing? What are you talking about? Right.
Tony MartignettiVersus using one of the large language models to write you the draft and you become the copy editor, or maybe you even become the managing editor, but give yourself another— you're editing another thing's initial draft. That, I think, is seeded the most creative act in writing or composing music. Right now, right, there are certainly— there, you can compose music in these, in the— with these tools.
Jacob WardAnd the thing to understand, right, is that, is that the product that it puts out, just because it's mimicking a thing, this is the thing that I— this is a— this is the need to hold 2 concepts in in one argument that I've really struggled with in my work is, on the one hand, I'm saying this thing is just a parrot. On the other hand, I'm saying its ability to parrot language and music and art and the rest of it is good enough to tickle the part of your brain that likes music and art and the rest of it. It's good enough to make your brain go, oh, this is good music, or this is convincing writing. I mean, the studies that we've seen already on, for instance, politically persuasive writing, has shown that LLM-generated stuff is better. It's more effective than human-generated stuff. Now, this is because it's a pattern-based system and it's done the analysis. You know, it can't tell you what the analysis is, but it's done the analysis. And so the thing that I want people to not get confused about is just because it is a simulation of life, you know, a simulacrum, doesn't mean it's not going to be incredibly effective. And so What I think we're going to wind up in, the thing we're going to have to defend for ourselves is the term I keep coming back to because it's a very bad word in Silicon Valley is friction. The pointless friction-filled act of sitting at a blank screen and writing something or sitting with a blank piece of paper in front of you and writing something. That's— it's less efficient. It's not even going to produce good enough work, right? My 12-year-old was just the other day saying, Man, I hate using ChatGPT for images because the images it puts out, I find myself thinking, man, I really wish I could create an image as good as that. But I don't, but I don't, I like making images. And so I'm going to just keep doing it on my own. Right. And may, you know, my 12-year-old for president, like, I just think she's so smart about that. Right. But this is the thing is that the market's not going to reward the way we used to do it. It's going to reward the new way. Because it's effective, because it's efficient. And so we're going to have to, I think, push back against that a little bit if we want to protect some long-term goals we have for ourselves as a species.
Tony MartignettiProtect humanity. I mean, I think this is what makes us human is the creativity. You're talking about flatlining when brainstorming groups have a large language model, like, base to start at. To me, that's antithetical to brainstorming. Yeah. You're all supposed to bring your own individual perspectives, and no idea is eliminated at the first phase. You're not supposed to all start with a common— the only common level is we're all human, and we all bring our multiple experiences to this topic that we're brainstorming about and perspectives, and we contribute them until, you know, until we've run out of time, and then we start to parse them down. But you're not supposed to come with a common basic, a common foundation to a brainstorming session.
Jacob WardRight, exactly. Exactly. It's not necessarily about the efficiency of it. I absolutely agree with you. Here's the other part of it, right? Is that like—
Tony MartignettiI need a glass of wine. I need a glass of wine desperately. I know. I know. Because it'll take the edge off this.
Jacob WardI ruined, I ruined so many parties, Tony.
Tony MartignettiNo, no, no.
Jacob WardThis is invigorating. You know, so here's another thing I would say, right? Here's another 19th century concept. You were talking about Microsoft Word. Let's like think about pre-Zoom life. Right. So, so one of the researchers that I spent some time with and really was blown away by is this, she's, she is a European and American, she holds appointments in both places. Beatrice de Gelder is her name. And she studies basically, she used to be thought of as kind of a crank by a mostly male research world who didn't like the ideas that she was playing around with. And what she was playing around with was the idea that started with something that came up in the first in World War I, and then she refined, was the idea that people whose visual cortex has been damaged, that the optic nerve, you know, between— the optic nerve connection between your eyes and your brain has been damaged, cut off in some way. In World War I, it was typically by some kind of horrible trauma. Now you can study people who've had it cut off by a stroke, a lesion. She studies these people, and she'll do things like— so they come in and they're blind. They're blind, you know, they have canes, the whole thing. And she, early in her research, put one of them into a hallway because she'd been striking out with every other experiment. She put him into a hallway and put this little obstacle course in front of him because she noticed he just moved in a weird way for a blind guy. And they take his cane from him and they say, can you walk to the end of the hall? And he— and they don't warn him about the obstacles. He walks toward the first one. He turns sideways, scoots past it, turns the other way, scoots past it. This is a blind man. Right? He gets to the end of the hallway and she said, and they rush up to her, to him and gasp and say, how did you do that? And he says, do what? He has no conscious memory of having done it or of any of the mechanical stuff he needed to do with his brain and his muscles to make that happen. So, de Gelder then, after that, begins playing with new experiments around the same kind of person. And she starts rigging up faces, their faces with a bunch of little sensors and then seating them in front of a big screen on which she will show— Right. Huge human faces grinning or frowning or masks of pain or masks of fear. And then she'll ask these people, what do you, what do you see? And they're sitting in front of this huge grinning face and they'll say, are you kidding? I keep telling you, I'm blind. I can't see anything. What are you talking about? But the sensors on their face, when you register that when you show them a smiling person, their face starts to smile back. Hmm. You show them a frowning person, their face starts to frown back. There is a non-optic nerve way we are catching emotions from each other and transmitting them, which is how we are able to escape danger, right? Snake comes in the room, my face freaks out. I make the face that I would make with a snake. You're on your feet and out the door before you even, you know, you know, we don't even have a conversation. You don't ask me like, what kind of snake is it? Right? We are out of there. And what she and all of these researchers that have come since have shown is that sitting together physically, there is so much stuff being passed back and forth between us, stuff that they can measure, if not directly observe. And so I think like the idea that we have created this vastly more efficient system that lets you and I speak to each other from 3,000 miles apart, and I'm thrilled that we are, right? But if you're— but the assumption that this is as good As you and I sitting together in person and making up ideas, right? We are so— the products are so far out in front of actual scientific understanding of what's valuable in human connection. And that is a thing I am bothered by. And no one wants to pay any money to hear about.
Tony MartignettiWell, people don't have to pay money to listen to, to hear about it here.
Jacob WardYeah, well, that's right.
Tony MartignettiNo, absolutely. We need to Keep our— I get— I'll go back. Keep our humanity. Yeah. Remain conscious that this is a tool. It's wildly helpful, but it's not— it's no substitute for being IRL, right? In real— being person to person, any more than friend is a substitute for intimate sex with someone that you're intimate with.
Jacob WardYeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
Tony MartignettiIt's our humanity. All right, look, I need a bottle of wine now. But I do wish we had a chat over this, chat about all this over a bar, at a bar. You talk some, you think a good bit about social media moderation. What we're all facing there. Why don't we, let's talk about how we're being Guided, led, controlled. I don't know which, which verb you, what kind of verb you prefer, but what's happening to us in the, in the social networks?
Jacob WardWell, I mean, one thing that we, we saw, you know, in the, in the social media era was the capacity for human beings to sort of tailor their information diet to as tight a little bubble as possible, right? And typically that bubble was was defined by how many other people you could find that were interested in that same kind of bubble, right? Could you subdivide somebody's interests in a conspiracy theory or, you know, Kashmir or whatever else, right? Could you put those people into a bucket and find enough other people that also fit into that bucket? That's the essential task of social media as a business. Well, now you don't even need other people. Right. The problem with AI that, you know, another of the difficulties with AI is that your information diet suddenly is just you. And yet it gives you enough of a feeling that you are connected to something larger than yourself, which was what the social media made possible, the feeling of connection with something larger than yourself. Now suddenly a chatbot is going to give you that capacity, that feeling of having tapped into something without anyone else having, uh, being involved in it, right? I mean, now, this is, of course, you know, not taking into account the fact that, right, these companies are trying to draw from actual, you know, ground truth, you know, reporting and whatever, whatever else, right? But, but in terms of what the, what the technology is capable of doing, it is capable of giving you the impression that you are tapped into something larger than yourself when it's just you by yourself. And so I definitely worry about the, you know, if we thought the information bubble problem was bad in social media, I think it's going to be even worse in this case because of that kind of isolation.
Tony MartignettiYou talk some about forms of restraint.
Jacob WardYeah.
Tony MartignettiThis sort of gets us to, you know, how to preserve our humanity.
Jacob WardWhat do we do? What do we do? Yeah.
Tony MartignettiBut let's, you know, let's start to move to brighter, you know, we do have control.
Jacob WardHere's some stuff we can do.
Tony MartignettiWe are still humans. We do still have humanity.
Jacob WardWe do.
Tony MartignettiYou call it forms of restraint, which I find interesting.
Jacob WardTalk about that. So I'm playing around with a new book concept. And I, and I, I got to find a day job before I can afford to write this book. But I, but I, the book is called Great Ideas We Should Not Pursue. It's based on something my grandfather used to say. He'd say, that's a great idea. Let's not do that. And it's a kind of mantra that I knew I was onto something when I, you know, I'd say it to founders here in Silicon Valley and their heads pop off. People just hate that phrase here. And so I think I'm onto something because you're clearly, clearly if it makes them nuts, there's something there to explore because it's so antithetical to the moment we're in, right? What, not pursue a thing that you could do? Like not go for market fit? Yeah. Why wouldn't you do that? Well, here's one place in which, for instance, you're going to need to do something kind of nonsensical as an organization that I think maybe your listeners in particular might, might benefit from. So you're going to inevitably have some company, maybe there'll be an evangelist inside your organization or on your board who says you should implement AI immediately to wipe out your costs when it comes to the entry-level work. that you've until now relied on recent college grads to do, right? The filing, the, you know, the customer service, the receptionist role, that kind of thing. You're not gonna need it because the AI can do it. Well, here's the thing, the long-term problem that that is gonna create, and people much smarter than me have already been publishing on this topic. Yeah. So the effect of that is going to be wiping out those first and second jobs that kids get out of college at these organizations. And let's say you cut to like 6 or 7 years from now when you would typically be promoting that first or second job occupant into that third level role. Maybe now they're going to manage somebody, right? Maybe now they're going to be outward facing and really speak for your organization in public. Right. Right. They're going to have to have developed the soft skills. One of the misconceptions that I think even the makers of these systems are operating under is that somehow we will carry forward, you know, and this is funny for people who really are eschewing college and saying you don't need a university degree and education isn't really necessary, all that stuff, right? No. What they, I think, have failed to recognize in themselves, the assumption that you're gonna carry forward the critical thinking and the socialization that education gives you in theory. And as a result, you're gonna be in a position where nobody's qualified for your third level, you know, that third job for that first management position, whatever it is. And so the friction, right, the blank screen piece of Human-preserving illogic that I think your listeners should maybe consider is you're going to need to find another way to train somebody up in that role. So even though you're going to have somebody saying, listen, you can take it off your balance sheet, the being a customer service person, don't do it. Use the technology if you feel it's ready for it, but you need to save that money because what you're going to need to do is bring somebody in just out of college and put them in a kind of, I don't know, we could call it an apprenticeship, a residency, something where they're in your organization learning the ropes. Yeah. Learning the place, learning to be reliable and professional, learning to be the kind of person you're going to value in a few years and bring them up in that role. One of the things that you could conceivably do with that person, for instance, is give them an enormously more creative set of responsibilities. You could say, listen, I need you to be coming up with the weirdest ideas you have, right? I need you, I need your weirdest thoughts for how we're going to like break through on TikTok or your weirdest thoughts on how we should, you know, assemble a youth advisory committee or, you know, whatever. But like, The market logic and the sales pitch of these companies is going to be, you don't need this stuff anymore. But I think instead that the illogical and absolutely crucial role of somebody leading an organization is going to be, keep that budget, save that budget, and use it to make your people better. Because if you don't, this technology is going to rob you of those people just when you need them in a few years.
Tony MartignettiAnd you mentioned this, I'm just, I guess, reinforcing that it's not just the, like, the intellectual part of the work, but it's the socialization. It's the socialization to your organization's culture that someone who starts and works their way up over 4, 5, 6 years isn't going to have when they come in day one. Absolutely. And they're leading a team now and they have to, they have to understand the culture and the team and the substantive work.
Jacob WardI think that's absolutely right. The socialization, the, the, the self-discipline. I mean, I was talking to a guy the other day who I was at a dinner party and he, and he, he was lamenting that his daughter doesn't want to be a lawyer or an engineer. She wants to be an artist. And I said, I don't know, man, have you seen what's going on with lawyers and engineers right now? Like, I don't know that your kid would actually do much better in that market at the moment. And if anything, I found myself thinking, man, if you actually, you know, again, you can hear my love for my 12-year-old. She's like Björk. She just like, creativity comes out of her and she is driven by that creativity to be fairly disciplined about her output. She really, you know, she just did the NaNoWriMo, the write a novel in a single month thing in November. It's a writing event. Yeah. in which you try and bang out a novel in a single month. You know, she sat there and banged that thing out, you know? And to my mind, like I said to him, I was like, a prolific and disciplined creative person could be in fact the most valuable kind of professional in the future. 'Cause everything else in the market is gonna tell you, you don't need that, right? But if you can actually generate real self-discipline and real organization to your creative thinking, that's the one thing I think that could, that the market won't be able to take away from you or, you know, or that will still be really really powerful and valuable in the market. So I just hope that your listeners, like everybody, will just think about like, how do we protect that rather than fall for this line that, oh, you can operate a, you know, I mean, Sam Altman at the beginning of 2024 said to a podcaster, Alexis Ohanian, he said that he and his buddies, his tech CEO buddies, have a bet going as to when we will see the first one-person billion-dollar company. Wow. Right? That's their vision. It's not freeing your time and making you more creative. It is pillars of wealth, you know, towers of wealth where no one else gets a job. And that doesn't feel to me like, like what we should be working toward.
Tony MartignettiThat's dystopian to me. Yeah. Pillars and silos and one person.
Jacob WardIf one person builds, so one, each person has a building, then they can, With that kind of wealth, there's only so many buildings you get to have, you know. Yeah, that's right.
Tony MartignettiI don't know where we're going to get a building after the tech bros buy all the land, buy all the real estate. Where do the rest of us— Well, you know, we found out— this is also quaint, I suppose— we found out during COVID what jobs are truly important. to our functioning, to our survival. Now, I live in a little beach town in North Carolina. The ocean is across the street. So I'm one tier of one row of houses away from the beach. And to me, it was the garbage men, the food store workers, my local food store, restaurant workers. Hmm. In my town, it's so small, we don't have delivery. You have to go pick up. But they were hopping the meals out into the parking lot in bags. You couldn't go in the restaurant.
Jacob WardRight.
Tony MartignettiPostal workers, I still needed my mail. Technology, I don't want to go too far, but I needed my technology infrastructure.
Jacob WardSure.
Tony MartignettiI needed my spectrum to be working. I mean, I think that's— I don't know, maybe I'm missing one or two things, but the people who are actually doing the work.
Jacob WardYeah, right, right, right.
Tony MartignettiI would've been fine if Wall Street had shut down and my money would've gone in a bank and it wouldn't earn as much, but I'd still be surviving. I'd still be— if I have the garbage being picked up and if I can go buy food, Then I can still survive quite well without Wall Street functioning.
Jacob WardWell, and this is the thing is that it's not clear to me, you know, that the vision— so, you know, the folks making these technologies, the people who are at the top of the Magnificent 7, as the big companies are called, right? They really seem to believe, and I think they really believe in their heart of hearts, that there is a utopia coming. In which, you know, made possible by AI, in which we eradicate cancer and we, you know, and everybody gets to be a watercolorist in their garden, kind of. And I just think that there are multiple problems with that. One, the math just doesn't quite work out on everybody getting to relax all the time. Two, culturally in the United States, especially, and especially in Western democracies, we don't like to just let people hang out. We really are allergic to the idea of paying people for free time. 3, there's something called the Jevons paradox. William Jevons was a 19th century British economist who came up with this paradox where we were burning coal more efficiently than ever, and yet we were burning more of it than ever. And it's come to be used to describe basically any case in which you use something more efficiently, you wind up using more of it. And I think that's gonna be true of free time. of just our time in general, that if you, if you give somebody the opportunity to work as hard as 10 people, then they're going to end up having to work as hard as 10 people. It's not that they're going to get 1/10, you know, have to work 1/10 as hard, you know, only a 10th of the time. That's not how it works.
Tony MartignettiYeah.
Jacob WardAnd
Tony Martignettiwell, we saw that play out with the, with the free time that we were all going to get from smartphones because they were going to make us so much more, so much more productive. We're going to have plethora of free time. I haven't seen any more free time. I see—
Jacob WardNow you can't get away from it.
Tony MartignettiMore hours.
Jacob WardThat's right.
Tony MartignettiAnd working in environments where I didn't previously work.
Jacob WardThis is the reason I go camping all summer. Yeah.
Tony MartignettiProductivity filled those, those additional illusory hours.
Jacob WardThat's right. That's right. And so, you know, I just think that the— what these folks seem to believe can happen I don't think is actually something that we culturally or economically are prepared to actually make possible. And, you know, so the founder of Anthropic, he was just profiled on 60 Minutes the other night and in an interview with Axios this year, he said a really interesting thing where he basically said the truth of this, I'm paraphrasing here, but basically the truth of the matter, he said, was essentially This technology might make it possible for us to cure cancer and make and create vast riches. And we might have 20% unemployment. Basically, that was his, that was his thing, right? And I admire him saying that out loud. Like, I'm glad that he's, that he's making that warning. I'm not sure why a guy who knows that keeps plowing ahead on making the technology, but okay. But I think there's—
Tony MartignettiNo, because he's not in the 20%.
Jacob WardWell, that's correct. That's right. That's right.
Tony MartignettiHe'll eventually— he aspires to be in the 0.001%.
Jacob WardYeah, talk about towers of money. That's why. That's right. And, you know, I think that we, this, it is going to require a fundamental renegotiation about the value of human beings. You know, that's going to have to do with, with both a sense of purpose, right? It's my daughter saying, I like to draw a thing, even though it's not as good as, as what ChatGPT makes, right? A feeling of purpose and accomplishment. And GDP is, you know, your, your productivity. Yeah. I think we're going to have to divorce our financial value from our productivity at some point. And I don't know, I don't think we're on the path to that. Like, I don't think we're very good at that in this country. But, but that's what I think this technology is going to sort of force on us because we can't all work 10 times as hard for 1/10 the money. That's not going to work.
Tony MartignettiLet's focus more on, on some, some forms of restraint. So if you can do If you can share one more on an institutional level, and then I'd like to spend a few minutes on restraint in individual personal restraint. But if you got one more for one more that you can share on the, on the nonprofit level?
Jacob WardWell, on the nonprofit level, I really just think that, that what you have described several times in this conversation is the right thing to think about, which is that you have to protect the Awkward, open, creative tasks, even if the technology is saying, oh no, don't worry about it, I'll take care of that. And so, you know, we're seeing, I think the best companies thinking about this stuff now are recognizing we're not gonna cut our costs yet. We're gonna hold off on that. This is not, unfortunately, the majority of these companies. Majority of these companies are just going ahead and cutting costs even before they know whether AI can fill in. But the smart companies, I think, are saying, okay, we have these tools. In theory, it's going to automate this set of tasks. Let us, as a result, hand that time back to people, right? If we're really going to buy this idea that this technology is going to free us up and let us become a better version of ourselves, We have to enact that. We have to enact that. You can't say—
Tony MartignettiI'm wildly skeptical about that.
Jacob WardI know. Yeah, me too. Me too. But if in theory, I don't have to, you know, spend as much time doing a travel booking or spend as much time making up a calendar of events or whatever the thing is, right? Then the expectation I think should be that that person gets to spend that saved time Doing something that, you know, that is long-term thinking, that is, you know, cultivating some creative priorities, that is connecting with other people in a way they don't normally get to. And so while the promise of this stuff in theory is to save you work, I think especially as the leader of a nonprofit, you're actually going to have to do a little more work in the short term to think, okay, if I could give each my people 20% of their time back, what would I want them to do with that time? And getting that air traffic control system built, I think, is the institutional, is the short-term institutional thing before you start saying, I don't need this person, which is what all these companies are going to try and convince you is the answer.
Tony MartignettiAn example of that could be sabbaticals.
Jacob WardYeah. Now you're talking.
Tony MartignettiAdditional time off, like 4-day. I mean, there is a national, there is a Yeah, the 4-Day Workweek. National Organization for a 4-Day Workweek, a 4-day, 32-hour workweek, not a 4-day, 40-hour workweek. Right. 4-day, 32-hour workweek. I've had guests on who have implemented that in their companies and with great success. Amazing. 32-hour, 4-day workweek. So, those, you know, those types of, you know, right, that's capitalizing on those types of those claims, promises, you know, that's when people start to see that the technology really does work for everyone.
Jacob WardWell, that's right. And that's how you get—
Tony MartignettiAnd that's an egalitarian—
Jacob WardThat's right. And that's how you get people to use it in a smart and creative way. You get them motivated to use it in a way that is beneficial. If you instead say to them, yeah, you're going to work twice as hard now, because I expect you to using these tools. That's where you get people not using them well, perhaps using them to, you know, plagiarize and, you know, create, you know, create reports based on fictitious studies and all that stuff, you know what I mean? So I feel like the best behavior with AI is going to be made possible by what you're describing there, Tony.
Tony MartignettiAnd I think taking some of the potential bad outcomes to an extreme, I think that's what leads to the marginalization of large swaths of our population who then look to a person or a technology to lead them to— that promises them retribution. That's right. You've been wronged by— I'll be generous and put it in the tech now. You've been wronged by the technology over these years, and I will right that. Yeah. I will give you your voice back. I hear your grievance and retribution is coming when I'm in power. I mean, I don't think that's such a far stretch from sort of the disenfranchisement and frustration that we see for other reasons now. Mm-hmm. I think technology could lead us to that To a continued frustrated population.
Jacob WardYeah.
Tony MartignettiLet's go to the individual. On the individual side, restraint, restraint. Let's— I want to leave folks with things that they can think about and either doing or think about doing for themselves to break us free of everything we just spent, you know, 55 minutes talking about.
Jacob WardRight. Well, one thing I feel I always want to sort of say before offering advice on how one can change their behavior as an individual is that I don't think I don't think it's up to you, you individual, to push back against this tide. I do think it's a tide. And I think that some forces much larger than us are going to have to go to work on this problem for some balance to come out on this. I'm a big fan of some of the, you know, I think lawyers go a long way in making change in this country. The reason that you and I are not smoking cigarettes, you know, in this conversation and that we drive a car with an airbag system right there.
Tony MartignettiAnd the seatbelt.
Jacob WardYeah, that's lawyers.
Tony MartignettiYeah.
Jacob WardSo, so I'm a big fan of the American liability regime for that reason. And I think some stuff is coming to help with this, with these things that are going to be helpful. But in the meantime, I think that first of all, from a, just from a personal perspective, keep getting this technology to explain its limitations to you. I think any prompt you put in there that says, explain to me what you can and can't do is a very helpful way of just reminding yourself, oh, this thing is just mimicking language. This is not a guru. This is not an expert. This is just a parrot, a really good parrot, right? That to me is a really important, just sort of refresher. You can even set some of these LLMs to remind you of that stuff, right? It'll ask you, you know, well, what kind of personality would you like me to be. And you can, you can make it as smooth and as fun to play with, to talk to as you want to. But I would argue better to make it, to have it keep reminding you about what it is and what it isn't, you know, make it not as much fun to sit with that thing. And as a result, you know, make it, you know, you can even use it to tell you, okay, that's enough for a little while. I think you need to build an hour into your day where you're literally doing nothing. Because this is the other thing that we're, you know, that we were already in this situation with smartphones, but we need to get back to a world in which you are preserving a little chunk of your day in which absolutely nothing is going on to just get your brain the chance to get back to its normal state. You know, for my money, I really like, for instance, Yeah. It's going outside, not just to get the sun on you, but also so that your eyes have to see something that's more than 30 feet from you. If you can get your eyes to focus on a distant horizon object, as a former New Yorker, this was always the challenge. Can you find an avenue where you can look at something that's more than 30 feet?
Tony MartignettiLook down a street instead of across.
Jacob WardYeah, you need an avenue rather than a street. You know, the, the, the protecting of your brain's calm, creative space, driving without any stimulation other than what's in front of you on the wheel. That's how you're going to get your brain back to a sort of a healthier place. And then the last thing I would just say is, and this is true in social media too, I do a lot of work speaking to educators and school groups and so forth. And my, I helped, I was part of a group that pioneered something pretty restrictive digital rules in our schools here in Oakland. But, you know, one of the things, one of the lessons is use it to go get what you need. And then when it brings it back to you, turn it off. So don't, you know, when it brings the research back to you, read that research. Don't just let it then summarize that research for you and keep going. Right. The system is going to be, is going to constantly ask you, what else can I do for you? What else? What next? What next? Right. Don't fall into that trap. Instead, you've got to turn away from it, right? So that it is not the intellectual equivalent of the passive feed, which was social media, right? Social media changed what was once a you go and get what you're looking for model into a just sit here and swipe and we'll take care of the rest kind of model. And so using it to go get a thing or, you know, fetch you what you need and then turning away from it, I think is as close to a mentally healthy interaction with the system as you can do at the moment. I don't claim to have the answers to this because this is, like I say, this is the perfect hack for our brains, I think. And so the idea that human beings have to be somehow responsible for this, It reminds me, like, I'm a former drinker. I don't drink anymore. And, you know, when the liquor ads say drink responsibly, it makes me crazy because there's no such thing for me. Right. And I think that we're going to find that in many areas of cognition and interaction, there's no such thing as using AI responsibly. But for the moment, you got to start trying to make up those rules for yourself. And those are a couple that I follow.
Tony MartignettiWell, you and I could talk about this over a couple of Cup of coffee and tea.
Jacob WardYou can drink. I actually— instead of a bar. I love to watch other people drink. I just can't go to the bar. That's right.
Tony MartignettiAll right. Jacob Ward, veteran journalist. You'll find him at @byjacobward in all the social networks. The book is The Loop: How AI Is Creating a World Without Choices and How to Fight Back. Jacob, thanks very much for sharing your research, your thinking. Vibrant conversation. Thanks so much.
Jacob WardTony, I really appreciate you being here. I'll just shameless plug, I run a newsletter called The Rip Current at theripcurrent.com. If anybody wants to hear me rant like this on a regular basis, that's, that's where we're at. So thank you so much, Tony, for this time. I really appreciate you.
Tony MartignettiMy pleasure. Thank you.
Kate MartignettiNext week, that's a very good question. What's certain? It'll be our last show of 2025.
Tony MartignettiTalk about lackluster host. Can't even come up with a show for the next following week. It's unbelievable.
Kate MartignettiHorrible. If you missed any part of this week's show,
Tony MartignettiI beseech you, find it at tonymartinetti.com. Tragic, actually, is what it is. Tragic. Tragic.
Kate MartignettiBut your— but your intro today was nice and, uh, I heard like the echo, because without the mic you don't have the, uh, what's it called, like the sound. You know how your really good mic, it takes away like all the extra sound out here?
Tony MartignettiYeah, the ambient, the ambient noise.
Kate MartignettiYes. Well, when you went to do your intro today, I heard all of it.
Tony MartignettiRight.
Kate MartignettiHello, hello, hello, hello.
Tony MartignettiRight. So what does that have to do with not having a— knowing what show is going to be next week?
Kate MartignettiI don't know. I had a point to it.
Tony MartignettiAll right, we, we got to get you on a plane. That's the problem. You never, you never have done air travel. You're confused. All right.
Kate MartignettiOur creative producer is Claire Meyerhoff. I'm your associate producer, Kate Martignetti. The show social media is by Susan Chavez. More Marc Silverman is our web guy, and this music is by Scott Stein.
Tony MartignettiThank you for that affirmation, Scotty. Be with us next week for Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. Go out and be great.

