Skip to content
EP 735April 14, 2025

Your Improved Fundraising Messaging

Tony MartignettiLynn Bohart
Nonprofit Radio
Episode 735
0:00 / 0:00

About this episode

Do your fundraising messages engage and connect with your donors and prospects? Or do they merely inform? Do you know how to craft an engaging story? And what makes stories so valuable anyway? Lynn Bohart answers all these questions and more, as she encourages you into persuasive writing and core messaging. Her new book is “Raise More Money Through Better Messaging.”

Here’s the transcript

Tony MartignettiHello and welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. I'm your aptly named host and the podfather of your favorite hebdomadal podcast. Oh, I'm glad you're with us. I'd be hit with blepharitis if you inflamed me with the idea that you missed this week's show. Here's our associate producer Kate with the highlights.

Kate MartignettiHey Tony, here's what's up. Your improved fundraising messaging. Do your fundraising messages engage and connect with your donors and prospects? Or do they merely inform? Do you know how to craft an engaging story? And what makes stories so valuable anyway? Lynn Bohart answers all these questions and more as she encourages you into persuasive writing and core messaging. Her new book is Raise More Money Through Better Messaging. On Tony's Take Two.

Tony MartignettiGratitudes, Part Deux.

Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by DonorBox. Outdated donation forms blocking your supporters' generosity? DonorBox— fast, flexible, and friendly fundraising forms for your nonprofit. donorbox.org. Here is your improved fundraising messaging.

Tony MartignettiIt's a pleasure to welcome Lynn Bohart. She has spent 35-plus years in the nonprofit world as the executive director of 3 different hospital foundations. She retired in 2018 and launched her own freelance writing company, writing for nonprofits all over the world to craft case statements, inspirational speeches, web copy, and fundraising appeals. The book she wrote that brings her to Nonprofit Radio is Raise More Money Through Better Messaging. You'll find Lynn's practice at lilddogcommunications.com. Not little, not little, lilddogcommunications.com. And you'll find Lynn on LinkedIn. Lynn Bohart, welcome to Nonprofit Radio.

Lynn BohartThank you so much, Tony. It's good to be here.

Tony MartignettiI'm glad you are. Thank you. Congratulations on the book. It's, uh, it's 2025, right? It's just released.

Lynn BohartYeah, yeah.

Tony MartignettiI know it's a big journey. Congratulations. Long journey. Congratulations.

Lynn BohartWell, I kind of feel like it's a culmination of a career, you know. Um,

Tony Martignettiso that's, that's a perfect, uh, acquaint us with your background a bit.

Lynn BohartWell, you know, with such a long history in the nonprofit world, I mean, I started out as a special events coordinator for the Mental Health Association in Los Angeles County a gazillion years ago, and then decided that I wanted to move up and educated myself by going and sitting down with executive directors of big organizations in LA. And so I moved up to be a development director and then finally an executive director. Wow. And it started— I started gravitating up the West Coast from Los Angeles to Oregon to now I'm in the Seattle area. So, you know, when I retired in 2018, I write murder mysteries as well. So, every— all my friends knew me, also knew me as an author. And I thought, well, I'll just kill people for fun and profit, you know, after I retire. And then I realized, well, that's— That's not a good idea. A really isolating thing to do. My daughter was out of the house by that time, so that's when I, I launched my freelance writing company. And I did a lot of research on persuasive writing, core messaging, things that I hadn't learned when I was in the nonprofit world but wish I had. Um, and so then I, I began writing, uh, for nonprofits, and helping them with core messaging and really focusing more on, you know, who they're— who or what they're benefiting as opposed to, you know, just talking about themselves. So, you know, I finally decided to put it into print sort of as my legacy. And, you know, people can get the book and read up on it themselves. There's a lot of examples in there. And, you know, as I kind of wind down, you know, hopefully the book will You know, stand in my place.

Tony MartignettiLet's talk about persuasive writing and core messaging. You just mentioned them. They are throughout the book. You know, sort of, I don't know if there's really a definition of persuasive writing and core messaging, but, you know, we have, we have plenty of time together, so we don't have to go into detail right now. We're gonna get to a bunch of your 10 lessons and, but just like, give us your sense of your, your What you, what you mean when you say persuasive writing and core messaging?

Lynn BohartYou know, it's funny, Tony, because they're really, in many ways, they're two different things, and yet they're the same. Because persuasive writing has been used for eons, obviously, in the marketing and advertising world. You know, they, they are always, you know, using our, our emotions and our egos against ourselves, you know, you know, talking us into buying things that we don't need. Core messaging, on the other hand, I, I, and I didn't, uh, I don't think I put this in the book, but I actually heard about this when I was working in Oregon, uh, in the, uh, uh, University of Oregon area, actually. And a friend of mine was the executive director of a big arts, you know, performing arts organization there. And I remember she said to me that she'd kind of trained under this guy she thought was a guru in marketing, and he had told her what you always want to do is go for the essence. Mm-hmm. of what you're trying to sell. You know, she really stressed that. I've just never forgotten that. And when I went to begin looking into core messaging, that word essence came up over and over and over again. That core messaging is about, you know, we tend as nonprofits talk about the world around us, you know, all the things that we're doing, all the people that we're helping, numbers and, you know, housing figures or whatever. And it's, and it's, it's getting Getting that funnel down to the very nub of why are you there in the first place? You know, what is the essence of what your organization is doing for the world? I had, you know, in my 35 years in nonprofits, I had never heard that before. As much writing as I had done, as many fundraising appeals and grant appeals and all of that, I had never actually heard that before. And I was just fascinated. Yeah. by that. And the idea, it just made so much sense to me that instead of— let me put it this way. As a fiction writer, one of the things that novelists are taught is something called show, don't tell. And I actually had— I don't know if you remember that, but it's actually— I put it in the book because it's a thing that we're taught that you don't tell your audience that the sun's shining. You show them by creating a description of what— of how the sunlight changes or refracts off, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. And what that does is it draws the reader into whatever you're writing. It puts them in the story. And so I knew that as a writer.

Tony MartignettiIn fact, you talk about sunlight. You have a quote that refers to moonlight. Don't show us— don't tell us the moon is bright. It's shiny. Show it to us in a cracked piece of glass.

Lynn BohartI use that all the time in my writing classes because it's a perfect example of show, don't tell. And, you know, I belong to a writer's group for fiction writing, and even though I know this rule in my head, I mean, it's been drummed into me, they'll find places where they'll say, hey, Lynn, show, don't tell, show, don't tell. So it's something in nonprofit writing that I had It just never dawned on me, even though I knew it for fiction writing, that instead of telling your donors what you want them to know, you need to show them. You need to illustrate to your donors and potential donors what is it you're trying to do for the world? How are you trying to change the world for the better and draw them into it?

Tony MartignettiDon't merely inform.

Lynn BohartThat's the basis of core messaging. It's the why. the organization exists to begin with, and that you want to focus on the why instead of what you do or how you do it.

Tony MartignettiAnd you remind us throughout also to not merely inform. It's just another way of saying what you just, you just said more eloquently. But you— so to do this, you're encouraging us to, to integrate marketing, And public relations and fundraising. So that sounds like a synthesis of where you've been through your career. Talk about why those— all 3 of those practices contribute to much better writing, more, you know, the persuasive writing and the core messaging.

Lynn BohartWell, I think, you know, I make the point in the book that marketers and advertisers, public relations people, they don't need to know anything about fundraising. 'Cause they're not raising money. Fundraisers need to know all of that technically. You know, we, we need to understand public relations. We need to get out and make friends with the community. We need to brand ourselves and all of that. We also need to do— know something about marketing, 'cause basically we're, we're trying— I remember early in my career, I was taught by a national fundraiser that, that came in and, and worked with me that what you're trying to do is change people's spending priorities. Mm-hmm. You know, instead of putting that $1,000 towards the, the boat that they want to buy, you're going to talk them into giving the $1,000 to your organization. And that's what marketers do. You know, marketers are basically selling us on stuff that we don't— you know, they're changing our priorities. They're selling us on stuff that we don't necessarily need, but all of a sudden we want them, or we just, we just can't live without them. And so fundraisers need to know all 3 disciplines. Um, and, and, and I don't think a lot of fundraisers recognize that. I think they, they sort of, you know, they understand public relations, they might have a sense of what marketing is, but they're so focused on fundraising and telling people about themselves, um, that they're not integrating all 3 disciplines.

Tony MartignettiWhat does the public relations Third, uh, contribute. I'm calling them the, uh, the triad, if you don't mind.

Lynn BohartBecause public relations is making friends with people. It's gaining trust, you know. It's, it's, it's presenting you in a, in a, in a way that people trust you, like, like you, and, and kind of want to be part of you. Um, so in, in fundraising, we've all done this without even thinking about it. We do our friend-raising events. I mean, I used to— I used to be on— every time I'd go to a new job, one of the first things I would do is, for that first year, is, uh, you know, create events through my board members, you know, small events in people's homes where they'd invite their friends in and we would just talk about what the found— the— I worked for hospitals, so what the hospital foundation did, you know, how— what the hospital did, how good we were, blah, blah. And you were just out, you know, making friends and sort of, you know, expanding that— your influence, your Circles of influence. So that's the public relations part. And, you know, you're not necessarily asking for money.

Tony MartignettiI had just called that your triad. When I was in the Air Force, I operated nuclear missiles, ground-based missiles.

Lynn BohartSeriously?

Tony MartignettiYeah. Outside Kansas City, in Whiteman Air Force Base in Warrensburg, Missouri. And the United States— this was 1984 to 1989 is when I was in the Air Force. And at that time, we had 6 bases that had ground-launched nuclear missiles. But the nuclear triad was ground-based, submarine-launched, and also airplanes. So this is your nuclear triad.

Lynn BohartYeah, that's a good way to put it.

Tony MartignettiBringing together your triad of marketing, PR, and fundraising. That's the—

Lynn BohartWell, and I think Tony—

Tony MartignettiBohart nuclear triad.

Lynn BohartOne of the things that I've learned by working with, you know, organizations all over the world is that there's a lot of trepidation by nonprofits to, um, you know, I want to say step on toes, but it's— that's not really the proper term. They're really— a lot of, uh, fundraisers are afraid to push too hard. You know, they're— the, um, the idea of of talking somebody into something kind of makes them step back. So what they end up doing is just talking about themselves as fast as they can and getting as much information in there as they can in the hopes that that's going to change whatever, you know, change your decision or your thoughts about them and, you know, convince you that they're worthy of your dollars. So the concept of persuasive writing, because marketers Marketers have known this for a very long time, and I, I swear to God, they just use it against us mercilessly. Um, and the big national nonprofits— you saw some of the examples that I used in the book— the big nonprofits, they hire marketing firms. So you see, you know, the, the, you know, the ASBCA, some of those big organizations put big money behind that, and, and they just They just pull on your heartstrings in those national ads, and they must work because they've been doing it for decades. And small organizations tend, for some whatever reason, shy away from that.

Tony MartignettiWell, it's a matter of budget, uh, often. Yes. But, but we— but they have your book now. We, we have, we have raised more money through better messaging. So We're no longer at a disadvantage. We— that's right, we are listeners in small and mid-sized nonprofits.

Kate MartignettiIt's time for a break. Imagine a fundraising partner that not only helps you raise more money, but also supports you in retaining your donors. A partner that helps you raise funds both online and on location so you can grow your impact faster. That's DonorBox, a comprehensive suite of tools, services, and resources that gives fundraisers just like you a custom solution to tackle your unique challenges, helping you achieve the growth and sustainability your organization needs. Helping you help others. Visit donorbox.org to learn more. Now back to your improved fundraising messaging.

Tony MartignettiYou have 10 lessons in the book. We're not going to have time to go through all 10 because that wouldn't be fair to you as an author. People need— if you want the full 10 lessons, you got to get the book, which is an easy read. It's a pleasant read. It's concise, but it's packed with lots of ideas. that's what attracted me to it when I, when I started reading it. One of your lessons is to— and this is very consistent with what you've been saying already— reach for the reader's heart. Reach for the reader's heart. So let's, let's talk about the, the engaging, the connecting, the emotion, right? Leading with emotion. What do you, what do you— Well,

Lynn Bohartokay, so emotion—

Tony MartignettiYeah, Lynn, don't pick up your book. Come on. You

Lynn Bohartknow, I was gonna look for the quote because—

Tony MartignettiYou know this off the top of your head. Oh, okay.

Lynn BohartThe quote is from Galloway, who, who read Talk Like— who wrote Talk Like TED. Great book, by the way, because the TED Talks obviously just got huge almost like overnight. You know, it's more than a decade ago now. But so he wrote this book. He studied dozens of really popular TED Talks, and he narrowed— he realized that number one, they're based in stories. The TED Talks are all the really popular ones. In fact, when you go to do a TED Talk, you have to practice the TED Talk in front of the TED Talk people. And they base them on story because we as human beings reach for story, right? And stories typically have emotion connected to them. That's how emotion draws us in, and that's what imprints. Yeah. The stories on our brain. I knew that from my fiction writing as well, that emotion— you build emotion, especially with the 5 senses, as much as you can into your writing. Because again, you're drawing your reader into whatever you're writing, and you're making them part of it. So I talk a lot about emotion in the book because it seems so natural to me now. When we're talking about nonprofits that are, um, you know, finding houses for homeless people or food for people who live in food deserts or whatever it is, that our stories in the nonprofit world are packed with emotion. And yet I would challenge you to just spend an hour just Googling nonprofit organizations around the country and and reading through some of their, the main pages of their websites, you'll see very little emotion. It's almost all facts and figures. It's all the nonprofits talking at me when you get there. And so I, I, I try to use multiple examples in the book as to why really dipping your toe into emotion will make a difference. People will start to listen to you, you know, I talk about the 8-second attention span in the book, which is shocking to me. But, and Tony, you're old enough to know when US— I blame like USA Today when that newspaper came out and instead of having lengthy stories, remember it was little snippets of stories on the front page. You know, they would grab your attention and that's all you really would have to read. You wouldn't have to go into the rest of the story. Well, we've gone from that to the internet, to cell phones, to, you know, Twitter, to X. You know, we live in this soundbite world where if something doesn't grab our attention in the first probably 5 seconds now, we're gone because our attention span just isn't there. And so one of the best ways to grab somebody's attention and hold it is to use emotion because that's what we react to.

Tony MartignettiAnd you say reach for the reader's heart. Say a little more about that.

Lynn BohartWell, Maya Angelou— Maya Angelou is the one who said, you know, the people will— they won't remember what you've said to them, but they'll remember how you've made them feel. And it's Gallo— I was trying to remember his quote off the top of my head, but he says basically that you should be reaching for the reader's heart. And most people, most writers forget the heart part. So in the book I say, don't be most people. Um, I think, um, if somebody— there, there are people in this world, I have people in my own family that have probably never given a dime to a nonprofit organization, even though I, I worked in the nonprofit world for 35 years. There are people that just— that's not who they are. It's not how they're built. If it doesn't affect them personally, they're— they just don't make donations. Fortunately, there's Hundreds of thousands of people in our country that aren't built like that, and they want, they want to support their community. They want to make a difference.

Tony MartignettiYeah. And so there are, there are many millions.

Lynn BohartYes, thank you. Um, so the best way to tap into that is to reach for their heart, and you reach there for their heart by using emotion. Um, I, I use another example in the book that I, um, very early in my career went to a webinar— or excuse me, it wasn't a webinar back then. There was no web. It was an actual seminar by a guy who wrote newsletters. He was a very big newsletter guru, and he's, and he's made the comment to the group that people only read what they're already interested in. And I remember just fighting that, thinking, that's not true. I read tons of stuff that I'm not interested in. And then I realized, well, yeah, textbooks and insurance forms, and, you know, but if I was sitting in a doctor's office and the only thing sitting there was an auto mechanics magazine, would I read it? No. I wouldn't even pick it up. So I say, and I use the example in the book that, you know, if you don't have sleep problems, if you saw an article that said, you know, all the benefits of getting better sleep, you probably wouldn't pick it up. But if it was how to improve your sex life by getting better sleep, or how to lose weight by getting more sleep, you are 100 times more likely to pick up that article. So I think it's I think it's the first lesson of the 10 lessons in the book where I say, when you sit down to write about your organization, think about how you can write in a way to appeal to more people rather than just talking at people and telling them what you want to know. Turn that around in a way that they're going to connect with you. Because I don't— I mean, I know myself, I was a one-person shop for a long time. You know, when that newsletter was coming out, I was like, okay, God, I got to sit down. I got to do this article. I'll do a volunteer spotlight. I'll do, you know, boom, get it out. Oh, fundraising appeal, year-end appeal, boom, boom, boom, get it out. We don't have a lot of time sometimes to sit down and really think through who's my audience this time? What do I really want to hit? What are the points I want to hit? And what do I want them to do at the end? Okay. Okay, so how am I going to do that? What emotion am I going to reach for? We don't take that time to do that. And what I'm suggesting is, if you can, it'll make a difference. The more donors that you can engage with what you're reading— and remember that 8-second attention span— if they don't read in the first headline or the first couple of sentences something that grabs their attention, because remember, they're only going to read what they're already interested in.

Tony MartignettiYeah.

Lynn BohartAnd engages them, they're gone.

Tony MartignettiAnd I've heard many times that you, you grab people in the heart and then the brain will follow. You— it's very consistent with what you're, you're advising. Lead with emotion.

Lynn BohartYep.

Tony MartignettiOkay. Can you— do you remember the story of, uh, this brief in the book, but it, it struck me, uh, as significant? Uh, Susan Howlett, she, she revised her core message Yeah. Do you— can you, uh, can you share that?

Lynn BohartI can't really expound on that. It was in her book, and I, and I remember—

Tony MartignettiI don't mean— no, but every, every listener hasn't read the book. But I—

Lynn BohartWell, it was the concept. Yes, it was the concept that she was working for an organization, um, you know, that helped, uh, families basically, that where the children had, had suffered from abuse. And it was the concept— I do stress this in the book— where how many times have we all gone to a fundraising conference and you don't know a lot of people there, you on the elevator and somebody says, oh, what do you do?

Tony MartignettiSure.

Lynn BohartWe always come back to what do we do? And that's how she answered the question. Somebody asked her that. It was like, well, we do this and we do that and we do— and then, then somebody said, okay, now answer that from the basis of core messaging. And she, and she said something to the effect of, I, I help 4-year-olds, you know. Um, yeah, I have it.

Tony MartignettiI have it for you.

Lynn BohartOkay, good.

Tony MartignettiUh, she refined it to, I make life safe again for 4-year-olds who've been raped.

Lynn BohartYeah. And, you know, that punches you in the gut. Talk about emotion. But, but in one sentence, you don't almost have to ask her anything else.

Tony MartignettiYeah.

Lynn BohartYou know exactly what she's doing.

Tony MartignettiIt's actually hard to follow up, you know, with a question.

Lynn BohartYes. No, I know.

Tony MartignettiYou don't need it. It doesn't require a follow-up, except to say, How moving it is.

Lynn BohartWell, my example in the book of the Children's Institute of Learning Differences, CHILD, this was an organization I had worked with a lot with when I ran my community foundation. And they had a luncheon right after I retired. And I, and I was thinking, you know, I'm going to go, but I'm going to be really stringent on how much money I give. And the gal who's the executive director had a panel of parents. Now, these are kids that are kicked out of public school. Because they have severe learning disabilities. They're the kids that can't sit still. They're vocally boisterous. They even can get into fights and they're not controllable. And Child Is a School, they literally, their goal is to get them back into public school, not necessarily to graduate them, but to help them manage their behavior so they can fit into the public school system. And these parents talked about their kids and it was really interesting. And then the last woman said, I want to tell a story. And she just—it was short. She just said, "My son Tristan last year got invited to a birthday party by one of the kids at Child." And she said, "We were all excited. Went to the party," and she said, "I was standing with the moms," and and she said, "I I said to them, 'You don't know what this means to us because Tristan has never ever been invited to a birthday party before.' There was about." 200 or 300 people in the room, and you could hear a lot, you know, these, these reactions. And I immediately doubled my gift. I was very familiar with what they did. But that story finally, that brought it home to me. That was like, oh, I, I get it now. I get it. Every kid wants to be like everybody else.

Tony MartignettiYou make the, you make the point that we've all been the last chosen for basketball. Etc., you know. Yeah.

Lynn BohartAnd so suddenly, even though I didn't have a child that had to go to that institute for learning differences, I understood what it meant to have a child that did have to go and, and, and didn't fit in. And, and, you know, your heart just bleeds. Talk about heart. Your heart just bleeds for them. So, you know, if you can, if you can tap into that as the fundraiser for an organization, whether it's for kids, animals, The planet. It doesn't really matter. You, you, you might have to stretch a little bit to find that essence of what I was talking about, but it's there.

Tony MartignettiYou have a whole section in the book devoted to what we're talking about now, which is how to craft the engaging story. And you talk about, of course, one of your lessons, use emotion to get people to give— express feelings in your writing. Can you say a little more about feelings? Well, evoking feelings. Yeah,

Lynn BohartI'll use the example of, um, the Clothes Bank example I have in there. When I was doing a core messaging workshop for them and they couldn't get beyond— when they were looking for the essence of what they did, they couldn't get beyond, well, we just, we give out clean clothes to homeless people.

Tony MartignettiBecause everybody needs— because everybody needs clothes.

Lynn BohartYeah. And I, and I kept at them. I kept, I kept drilling down on the emotion, the emotion. And finally, one of their board members popped, hyped up and said, no, no, wait a minute. We don't just give out clean clothes. We restore a person's dignity. That was another one of those aha moments. It was like, yeah, dignity. That's emotion. That's the kind— when you look for that kind of core feeling that we all want, we want to be safe, we want to be secure, we want to have a dignified life. There's so many things that are basic to human nature. And if so, if you can tap into that for whatever it is that your organization does, I just think you're going to be ahead of the game.

Kate MartignettiIt's time for Tony's Take Two.

Tony MartignettiThank you, Kate. I've got a part deux to gratitudes from last week. And as I was listening back, I just realized that something very simple, but I encourage you as you're saying out loud the things and the people in your life who you are grateful for, That you actually say the names of all the people, not just categories. And I just, I thought this was important enough to emphasize. So it's not just, you know, I don't just say friends, family, you know, I list out the family members by name. Same with friends. Yeah. Clients, people I know in the, you know, in my professional network who I'm grateful for. So just a little, um, little expansion from last week. Say the names of the people as you're expressing gratitude for all those folks who are in your life either loving you or supporting you. Um, I list everyone except my brother. I leave him out. That would be Kate's father. But aside from that, I list all the names. I say the names routinely. And I encourage you to also. That is Tony's Take Two. Kate?

Kate MartignettiDad, do you want to say anything about Uncle Tony leaving you out of his daily gratitude affirmations?

Tony's brotherWell, I'm sure he's very grateful for having a brother such as myself. Loving, caring, forgiving.

Tony MartignettiThere's nothing to forgive.

Tony's brotherYes, yes, Podfather. Yes.

Kate MartignettiWell, we've got beaucoup buttloads more time. Here's the rest of Your Improved Fundraising Messaging. I'd

Tony Martignettilike to go a little personal. You know, how did your— you talked about your background. How did you come to this recognition? Is it all from, you know, recognizing what marketers do? And, oh, by the way, did you— do you know the book The Hidden Persuaders by Vance Packard?

Lynn BohartI don't.

Tony MartignettiOh, it's old. I read it years, decades ago, but it's about the psychology behind Advertising and marketing. Okay, purely on the corporate and commercial side, it's it's revealing. It's it's not very uplifting about tactics. You know, it's not these are not it's not going to make you feel good about the advertising profession. Now again, this is decades ago, but it's called The Hidden Persuaders. You can you can imagine where he's going. So yeah, so you know in your own in your own life, your own work. What's the, you know, sort of what's the synthesis that brought you to distilling this? You know, because now you're in, you know, you're in your own core message.

Lynn BohartYeah, right.

Tony MartignettiYour core message is write about your core message, you know, find your core message. Your core message is find your core message. Do persuasive writing. Say a little, say more about, you know, what brought you to this

Lynn BohartI think it's a combination of both my fiction writing and my professional life. When I did the research, you know, I spent that first year of my retirement researching, reading these books. I read another book that I quote in this book called To Sell Is Human by Daniel Pink. And, and he, you know, it's funny because even though, again, these— it's a sales book, you know, um, he's talking about basically the same thing, that idea that, you know, the 1% drives the 99%. You know, the essence of what your organization and why it's there is driving everything else that you do. And yet we talk about everything else that we do. Instead of the 1%. You know, it's— those kinds of things just hit home with me. Um, and, and I thought, why didn't I know that when I, when I was, you know, in my career? Um, I was like everybody, and I, I said this in the book, and I do kind of blame grant funders for this because you write grants and they're constantly asking you for the numbers. Give us the numbers. And so we tend to do that. We tend to fall back on talking about ourselves, putting the organization up front as opposed to putting the beneficiaries of what we do up front. And so, and especially when I, when I started writing for organizations, I mean, I actually, I had the, the opportunity to write fundraising appeals for a gal who runs a nonprofit in Thailand. She teaches elephant trainers how to be more humane in training the elephants. I just thought— it just hit me how many people in this world are doing just fantastic work. I mean, things that I would have never even thought about, but they don't know how to write. They don't know how to express what they're doing in a way that would grab and hold somebody's attention. And I think that's what kind of hit home for me.

Tony MartignettiHow did your fiction writing contribute?

Lynn BohartBecause obviously, if I can't grab— if I can't grab your attention as a reader, I've lost you. And if I don't hold your attention, I've lost you. I was reading a book just recently. I write mysteries, right? That's mostly what I read. I was really excited about this book, and I got into 3 to 4 long chapters of this book, and all it was was what we call exposition. They were telling me about the character and what the character had done and the character's backstory, telling me about them. And I stopped, and I wrote them a really bad review. And I remember, this is just like 3 weeks ago, And I remember thinking, you know, how many nonprofits do that? You know, they're constantly telling you about themselves. And I had— I just made a presentation about this book to a group of nonprofits up here in, in the Seattle area. And one of the gals asked me, she said, um, and it's a— it's an organization that I've worked with before, and they— so they're, they're better at core messaging than a lot of other people. But she asked about their newsletter and she said, you know, We often put our fundraiser up front in the newsletter, you know, that it's coming up and we need volunteers, or we, you know, people can sign up or whatever. And she said, what do you think about that? She said, is that something we should lead with? And I said, I wouldn't. I don't read your newsletter to find out. I mean, I'm sitting— I'm not sitting with bated breath wondering what fundraising things you're doing right now. Right. And she, and she immediately, you could just see the look on her face like, yeah, you're probably right. So I said, no, I would lead with, um, they do birthday parties for homeless kids. I said, with your, your birthday parties and, and, you know, a testimonial from a mom or something that couldn't afford a birthday party and you helped, you know, whatever. And then down below you've got your fundraising stuff. So even just a simple thing like that to reverse how you're talking to your donors. I think can make a big difference. Lead. This is where it's lead with your heart.

Tony MartignettiTalk about emotion and dignity, homeless children, because everyone deserves, every child deserves a birthday party.

Lynn BohartYeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

Tony MartignettiYou have a bunch of hooks. Lots of hooks. You like hooks, even on envelopes. You go to the point of hooks on envelopes. Talk about hooks because you're just saying, you know, we got to grab people and hold them. One way of doing that is hooks. What are these hooks all about?

Lynn BohartSo this is where I was able to really marry my— because I taught fiction writing for a long time through one of the local colleges, and writing hooks was a segment that I always taught. And again, when I launched my writing company in my retirement, My daughter keeps asking me, by the way, when I thought you were going to retire.

Tony MartignettiYeah, you've perverted the definition of retirement.

Lynn BohartYeah, yeah, my second career, second or third career. Um, hook— hooks are a big thing in fiction writing. So again, since I write murder mysteries, I usually, I usually begin with the murder. I kill somebody off right in the first page. That's a hook, right? Doesn't have to be that dramatic. Fiction writers will often start out with just a really clever sentence, or in writing some even fundraising things, I've started open with a joke. The idea is that you need to grab people's attention right from the beginning, because if you just— again, if your whole first paragraph is just blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, Blah blah blah blah blah blah. You know they're never going to go past that. But if you hit them with some some dramatic statistic, you know about whatever it is that you do that that most people don't know about, especially you know you've got kids or animals or some something like that, man that grabs people right away. And then you can get into you know talking more about how you've you know, you change these people's lives or save these animals or whatever. Um, so the hook can be a sentence, it could be a paragraph. In fiction writing, it could be a whole chapter, you know, that you could use as a hook. But the idea being, again, is that you're grabbing people's attention. And so I even have a little section, I think, in this book about even after you've been writing You still need to find ways to keep those readers engaged. I will often ask a question in the middle of what I'm writing. Why is that important? Because we as humans naturally, we see a question, we think we have to answer it. And I do it in speeches. I do it in the middle of a speech because, and I've seen audiences react to that.

Tony MartignettiYou do it throughout your book too. There are quizzes in the book. Yeah, you do it throughout the book.

Lynn BohartYeah, it just brings people back because we all drift. Let's face it. Yeah, we all drift.

Tony MartignettiIt's something of a— I don't know, would you call it a pattern interruption? Yeah, a question in a seminar or webinar. People aren't expecting it, right? And it brings them back.

Lynn BohartYeah. Well, and because— and I think I mentioned this in the book— that our brains are sort of We're not only wired for story, we're wired for change. We, you know, we react to things that are a slight disruption. And a question is a slight disruption. You're right. It's like something, oh, wait a minute, huh? What?

Tony MartignettiRight.

Lynn BohartIt's almost like, did I miss something? You know? Okay, now maybe I better pay attention again.

Tony MartignettiYeah, I better come back. Yeah, that's the pattern interruption. This is very parallel, your advice, to public speaking,

Lynn BohartYeah,

Tony MartignettiI've done stand-up comedy. Uh, you know, you, you open with your best short joke. You know, you want to, you want to grab them quickly. You know, you don't open with, hello, uh, wait, can everybody hear me? Is, is, you know, uh, okay, so here's what we're gonna cover, here's our agenda.

Lynn BohartYeah, yeah, you're not supposed to do that anymore.

Tony MartignettiNo, you're turning people off. You know, you can get to that, but you haven't, you haven't grabbed them.

Lynn BohartYeah.

Tony MartignettiUm, So, and I have something that I use when I open webinars and, you know, but yes, you wanna, I think in speaking, you wanna show some humanity, some empathy for the audience where they are. And there are, there are many ways to do it. I'm sharing my, my, my thinking about it, but—

Lynn BohartWell, I'll tell you, Tony, that—

Tony MartignettiDon't open with, can everybody hear me okay? Am

Lynn BohartI muted? Or thanks for having me today.

Tony MartignettiYeah.

Lynn BohartYou know, that's another one.

Tony MartignettiWe'll get to that.

Lynn BohartI'm so pleased to be here.

Tony MartignettiRight, but you're wasting your opening seconds.

Lynn BohartYeah, yeah. Well, I would also argue that, um, I, I did this my last 3 years, uh, running the community foundation I ran. We had a big dinner every year, and we back then were not trying to raise money. We were raising awareness about the community foundation, and we were, we were trying to engage the people in the room into becoming more community aware and getting involved in the community in whatever they the way they wanted. And the very first year, at the end of my talk, I asked everybody in the room to raise a finger. And I have a photo of this where people are all sitting there with their fingers up. And I said, all right, I want you to repeat after me. I promise— 400 people said, I promise to do one good deed. They all said that this weekend. And they all said that. And then I finished by saying, I don't care if you just give the woman behind you with 4 screaming kids in her cart at the grocery store, let her you know, cut in line in front of you. If you write a check to your local nonprofit or you volunteer, I don't care what the good deed is. You've just promised to do one good deed. The next year, I, when, when I gave my talk, I said, how many of you did that? Half the room raised their hands. So obviously there was new people there too. Doing something like that, um, again, is a disruption. It's, it's anytime you can, you can draw that audience in to actively doing something. The next year, I actually had the waitstaff bring out little cups of Kool-Aid because I gave a talk on getting involved in the community. And they passed out these little cups of Kool-Aid. And I said, okay, now I want you all to drink the Kool-Aid. And we did. You know, they don't forget that.

Tony MartignettiRight.

Lynn BohartSo if you can, even when you're just writing, if you can think of things that are are different than what you've done before, whether it's asking a question, telling a joke, telling a story, um, you know, you're going to make an impression on those people and they're going to remember it.

Tony MartignettiAnother one of your tips is use the second person. You, you get prolific with you. Share the, share the, the value of that, the importance of you.

Lynn BohartWell, obviously we're, we're talking to donors and potential donors. We want them to join us. We want them to become part of the collective you, right? So if, if you're just talking at them like, you know, they're just anybody out there in the world, you have not engaged them. But if you can say to them, you know, with your support, or you become part of the family, or, you know, your, your gift, everything that's you, you, you, you're drawing them in. When I, I had several people read the book before I published it, and one of my friends is a major gifts officer up here, and she's the one that added on the list of reasons why people often don't give is because they don't know, they've not been informed as to what difference their gift will make. I thought, boy, that's good. That's really good. And that's part of that you, it's making them part of your family and that they're involved. Yeah. Is critical to your success in the essence of what you do. Again, so many organizations say critical to our success, right? No, it's not about you. It's critical to you helping, you know, 15% more kids read during the summer so they don't fall behind. They, you know, in September they're up there with everybody else, you know, or Whatever it is, that's how you should be talking with your donors.

Tony MartignettiI'm holding up my, uh, my finger. I'm pledging one. I'm pledging I am going to name this episode consistent with— I'm going to put your, your something. It's going to be something like Your Improved Messaging or Your Improved Writing or something, because I, I do that a lot with naming episodes. And not every single one, but as I'm, as I'm naming episodes and as I'm Writing the descriptions of episodes, you know, instead of donors, your donors.

Lynn BohartYeah.

Tony MartignettiSometimes if I'm writing for clients or if I'm writing something on LinkedIn, the donors. No, take out the and say your. Your. Yeah. As you said, you're bringing the person in. It's now second person. It's it's it's a collective. It's your. It applies to you, not some third party unnamed. The donor.

Lynn BohartOne thing I did used to do is I used to send out a letter to new donors saying. Welcome to the family, you know, to our family of donors, uh, in an effort to make them feel like, okay, they're— you're part of us now, you know, we're all, we're all a family, and look, look at what we're accomplishing together, you know.

Tony MartignettiI love the you, and, and you have my pledge. There's my fingers up.

Lynn BohartOkay, there we go.

Tony MartignettiWatch for the title of this episode. It's gonna, it's gonna have you in it. You or your, uh, another tip you have, right? Writing effective calls to action. You know, share your tips for effective—

Lynn BohartI, I would have to say that I probably was one of the greatest, um, uh, I didn't do that so well in my career.

Tony MartignettiRight.

Lynn BohartYou know, I, I had to study up on this because, um, you know, you— I knew enough to say, okay, here's what we're all about, here's all the people that we're helping, and your support would really make difference. And that'd be kind of it. I didn't know about repeating the call to action, you know. I didn't know about creating that sense of urgency that you should have. I didn't know about adding emotion into it. Um, when I was writing, it was probably mostly about whatever organization, you know, because I worked for hospitals a long time, you know. I would talk about all the people's lives that we'd saved, or— but it was, it was so general that nobody could really relate to it. So calls to action, um, uh, in fact, the Better Fundraising Company, which I quote in there, and I have a, I have a graphic from, from them. I've talked to them, you know, while, while I was writing this book. They're, they're a great organization. Uh, they're a consulting organization, but you can go to their website. They've got some free articles and, you know, graphics and stuff on their website. And they have a, they have a video on how to write the call to action, which is something I would encourage people to, to go read. Because I was probably the— one of the things that I always seemed to do was, together we can make a difference, instead of asking for the gift. Right. You know, you know, make your, your gift today or write your check or what. I, I always softened it because that's what I was— that's how I was taught, you know, that you kind of blur it. You don't want to— you don't want to just come out and ask for the money. You want to kind of make it soft. And yeah.

Tony MartignettiYeah, that's unfortunate.

Lynn BohartYou got to ask for the money,

Tony Martignettiright?

Lynn BohartYeah.

Tony MartignettiWhen I'm writing solicitation letters for clients in planned giving and I'm writing to a, you know, the letter is going to be read by maybe thousands of people. You know, I call out the solicitation. Would you consider— I underline it. Would you consider including the charity in your will? And then I take your advice and I repeat it at the end. Thank you for considering. Thank you for all your support. Through the years and for considering a gift in your will. And sometimes I'll use the PS to reinforce. So

Lynn Bohartit's— And see how I would even change that now is to say at the end, you know, because you're thanking them for considering, because obviously with planned giving, that's what they're doing, to say, but when you, when you make that change in your will, this is the difference you'll make. So you could, you could, you could punch it up even once more at the end to say, you know, even a $10,000 gift in your will could do this or whatever. So that, so you're bringing your, it's like you're bringing home the bacon. I like bacon.

Tony MartignettiPlus you just gave me a free consultation.

Lynn BohartThere we go.

Tony MartignettiWhich, uh, listeners, if you buy the book You can get a free coaching call from Lynn. Of course, I cannot reveal how you do that. You're gonna have to get the book to take advantage of the opportunity for a free coaching call with Lynn.

Lynn BohartAnd there's also a companion workbook that I have a way for them to get free because I realized that when I used to do the core messaging workshops, these were 3 to 4-hour workshops. I obviously can't do that this way. So, I created the companion workbook that has exercises in it. That, you know, they can sit down with their key leadership team and, you know, spend a couple hours, you know, a couple different meetings going through to get to their core message or practice some of the writing techniques, writing hooks, things like that. So the companion workbook is worth it, I think, to get.

Tony MartignettiSo leave us with some messaging inspiration.

Lynn BohartPlease. You know, I think that I spent a lot of time in my career. I loved— I had a great career, but I didn't like the fundraising aspect of it. Asking for money is hard. And I think I had a friend who was a major gifts officer in the hospital realm, and he told me once, he said, you know, if I wasn't raising money, I'd be selling cars. He loved He loved getting out there and asking for money. I would argue that there's probably a lot of fundraisers that were more like me. They loved, they loved doing the work. They loved helping people and making a difference in the world. But asking for money is, is hard for a lot of people. So I, I would encourage people to, to read the book and recognize that the messaging, you know, is to change how you're thinking about the messaging. Yeah. And that you're asking for money and you're extracting money from people. The message is— your core message is how you're changing the world, the difference that you're making in people's lives. Focus on that, and I, and I think it will come much easier to you because that's what you care about. Um, you know, again, the Better Fundraising Company has a graphic now I use in a PowerPoint that says donors, um, want outcomes, not process. They're interested in outcomes, not process. And if we can focus on the outcomes, I, I think it just makes me much more excited to talk about what the nonprofit is doing. And, and then when I was thinking, okay, I got to get money out of them, I got to write this to get money out of them. So I think if you can make that flip, that switch And get excited about sharing the message of, of what you're doing to change the world. Um, I not only think you'll feel a lot more, um, confident and encouraged to do what you have to do, I think your results will be better.

Tony MartignettiLynn Bohart. Yeah, you know what, since you, uh, mentioned your nonfiction writing a couple times, you, you have You have an author website, which I don't have in front of me. I do. Yeah, share that with listeners in case they want to check out your novels.

Lynn BohartI should say I have 11 mystery novels and a couple short story books on Amazon. So my author website is www.lynnebohart-author.com. So that's all about true crime and mystery. If you're interested in that, have some fun.

Tony MartignettiAnd Lynn's book that we're talking about over on the nonfiction side is Raise More Money Through Better Messaging. You'll find Lynn's practice at Lil Dog, L-I-L, lil dog communications dot com. You'll find Lynn Bohart on LinkedIn. And Lynn, I thank you very, very much for sharing all this.

Lynn BohartThank you. This is This is fun. It was it was enlightening even to me, so I appreciate it a lot. It's great to meet you as well.

Tony MartignettiThank you very much. Enlightening. We're at Nonprofit Radio. We're not only enlightening the listeners; we're enlightening the guests.

Lynn BohartYes,

Tony Martignettiit's a milestone. Thank you. It's been a pleasure.

Kate MartignettiNext week, we'll pick a winner from the archive. If you missed any part of this week's show.

Tony MartignettiI beseech you, find it at tonymartignetti.com.

Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by DonorBox. Outdated donation forms blocking your supporters' generosity? DonorBox— fast, flexible, and friendly fundraising forms for your nonprofit. donorbox.org.

Tony MartignettiI love that alliteration.

Kate MartignettiOur creative producer is Claire Meyerhoff. I'm your associate producer, Kate Martignetti. The show's social media is by Susan Chavez. Marc Silverman is our web guy, and this music is by Scott Stein.

Tony MartignettiThank you for that affirmation, Scotty. Be with us next week for Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. Go out and be great.

Nonprofit Radio