The Art & Science Of Fundraising


About this episode
James Misner explains what he sees as the right and left brain activities of your nonprofit’s fundraising. There are relationships and data; stories and metrics; motivations and outcomes; emotions and systems; and, more brain interactions. Your objective is to balance the art and the science. James is CEO of The Kipos Group.
Here’s the transcript
Tony MartignettiHello and welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. I'm your aptly named host and the podfather of your favorite hebdomadal podcast. Oh, I'm glad you're with us. I'd suffer from neuromyelitis optica if I saw that you missed this week's show. Here's our associate producer Kate with what's up.
Kate MartignettiHey Tony, this week it's the art and science of fundraising. James Misner explains what he sees as the right and left brain activities of your nonprofit's fundraising. There are relationships and data, stories and metrics, motivations and outcomes, emotions and systems, and more brain interactions. Your objective is to balance the art and the science. James is CEO of the Kipos Group. On Tony's Take Two.
Tony MartignettiTales from the Train.
Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by DonorBox. Outdated donation forms blocking your supporters' generosity? DonorBox. Fast, flexible, and friendly fundraising forms for your nonprofit. donorbox.org. Here is The Art and Science of Fundraising.
Tony MartignettiIt's a pleasure to welcome to Nonprofit Radio James Misner. He is the founder and CEO of the Kipos Group. Over his career, he has facilitated the raising of hundreds of millions of dollars to support nonprofits. He's a trusted expert in fundraising strategy, staff culture, and implementation. James focuses on small and mid-sized nonprofits engaged in direct service, That's our target audience right here, small and midsize listeners. His company is at thekiposgroup.com. Kipos is K-I-P-O-S. So they're at thekiposgroup.com, and you'll find James on LinkedIn. James Misner, welcome to Nonprofit Radio.
James MisnerTony, thanks so much for having me. I am excited about this conversation, and hopefully we get to share some, uh, Good value and wisdom to the other 95%, the small and mid-sized nonprofit executives out there.
Tony MartignettiThank you for picking up on that. Absolutely. Yes, that's, uh, that's— those are our listeners in the small and mid-sized orgs. So we are talking about the, uh, the art and science of fundraising. I know you want these 2 to work together, not be exclusive of each other. Let's just give a high-level overview. What, what do you see as the art and the sci— versus the science, which they're not working to— of course, when I say versus, they're not working against each other. I know that's key to, to, uh, what we want to talk about, but just define them for us, the art and the science.
James MisnerAbsolutely. Most nonprofits think of this as a problem to solve. We either have to be completely data-oriented, scientific, buttoned up, and rigid. It's on one side. And the other is we have to be free-flowing, we have to be passionate, we have to be iterative and in tune. And most people think of this as a problem to solve, and instead it's really just a tension to manage. And I think the magic happens in nonprofits, especially in marketing and fundraising, when When you blend both of these things seamlessly together, bring the left side of the brain, the right side of the brain together, allow your teams to bring their whole self to work and dive into both. That's what I get excited about, seeing people of both sides of this come together to bring their best to their organizations and to their givers.
Tony MartignettiSo you want this to be a symbiotic relationship?
James MisnerIt has to be.
Tony MartignettiNot parasitic, not one feeding off the other. Symbiotic. They're living together in harmony.
James MisnerIt 100% has to be. Okay, let's think of the, the science side for a second. Okay, science is linear. Think of the scientific method, right? We all learned that, what, in first or second grade? My, my kids are doing it right now. Science starts with questions and observations. So what questions, you know, could a small and mid-sized nonprofit leader be asking? Why are my donors lapsing? Why aren't we raising more money right now? Okay, that's the first step in a scientific process. And then you observe, and then you develop a hypothesis, and then you set up an experiment to measure that hypothesis. Right. And at the end of that measurement period, you then say, hey, was my hypothesis right, wrong? Was it directionally right, directionally wrong? And you hone it as you go. I see a lot of nonprofits skipping that entire thing, especially in the small and midsize space where there's not a lot of capacity, there's not a lot of staff, and maybe the attention span for risk is 2 weeks, and that's not enough time to develop an actual experiment and to measure. And we can dive more into this. On the art side, okay, the artistic process is messy. If anybody tries to linearly create an artistic process, chances are they're not an actual artist. And when you think of art, And you think of, let's just use Renaissance art for a second. Most of it comes out of deep-seated pain and struggle. There's this story, I think Malcolm Gladwell did it on a podcast one time, that the Swiss created clocks, which are precise, and they created chocolate, which is scientific. No great art came out of Switzerland during the Renaissance because it was neutral. They were wealthy. There was no pain or struggle, but the surrounding countries were full of artists. Most nonprofits, especially those who are doing direct implementation, they are dealing with something that is painful. They see kids that are not living until the age of 5. They see refugees on the move from persecution and war. They see kids in the US, be it in Rural Appalachia or in urban centers who are just not thriving into their high school years and into their adult years, you can't, with science and linear processes, describe that story to another human being without being deeply in touch with emotion. And that's the art side of this.
Tony MartignettiAll right. So let's dive in a little deeper on how these 2 work together. I think we should probably talk in more detail about each of them and then put them together in this symbiotic relationship. You started with the science side. So let's approach that. Let's drill into some detail. What are the elements of the scientific side of fundraising that we're later gonna put together in this symbiotic relationship with the, with the art side. And we're gonna, we're gonna see, we're gonna see fundraising. We're, we're approaching fundraising nirvana, right? Is that right? Yeah. Is that where we're, is that where we're, is that our objective when we put these 2 together?
James MisnerLet's just call it up into the right growth.
Tony MartignettiAnd, uh, okay. Yeah. Up into the right growth. All right. All
James Misnerright. Let's dive into it. So the first thing, you have to have an observation. Most people would observe, especially right now in our climate, that they are not growing like they would want to grow. So then let's ask some questions and develop a hypothesis. I think a reasonable hypothesis for most small and mid-sized groups would be we need to do better major donor cultivation. Okay, so then let's set up our experiment. What do we believe would lead to better major donor cultivation? It's not just measuring the number of meetings. It's not just blasting out emails. We've tried that all before. So let's say it's a really great donor development process. Okay. that we then measure. So let's figure out that process. First, you need leads, okay? So how do we find them? Probably 3 or 4 main ways. We get referrals from our existing major donors, or we look in our small and mid-size portfolio and do a well screen and say, hey, we think these people could become major donors. So we measure that. How many do we actually have? Well, then what do you need to do after that? You actually need to meet with them and qualify them. So let's do that. Set up those meetings, qualify them. The goal there is to figure out, hey, could they become a major donor or no? If the answer is no, it's fine, you know, move on. Don't waste your time. You don't have that much time, uh, if you're a small and mid-sized nonprofit. So ask them questions about what they're passionate about. Don't just tell your story, uh, to them. Uh, ask them questions, see how they respond. And at the end of that conversation where they probably talk 80% of the time and you About 20% of the time. If they're still in, great, they qualify. Then let's journey with them. Send them great content, bring them to the site, engage them with other major donors in community. If they're still there, eventually you earn the right to ask a question. Does it seem good and right to you that I could bring, next time we meet together, a proposal for how you could deepen and expand this work that you seem to care so much about? You've done all that, right? Chances are they're gonna say yes. You bring the proposal and you get to measure each step of that. And this isn't short. This isn't a 2-week experiment. This is a 6, 9, 12-month experiment to see, hey, does measuring this hypothesis actually work? And the end result is dollars go up and to the right, they stay flat, or they decline. But by measuring it, you get to see each step along the way. Is it the process that's broken? Is it how we communicate in each step of the process? And you get to dissect it. But if you follow a process like that, 8, 9 times out of 10, it's gonna work. That's the scientific side of doing it. And you hear a lot of people that say, hey, you can't measure meetings anymore. That doesn't work. I say that's crazy. You have to measure something instead of just the end result, but you can't end there. You need to add the art side. Into this for the true magic to happen.
Tony MartignettiLet's do that actually. You know, let's deal with a couple different points. Science, art, science, art. Instead of what I had proposed a few minutes ago, let's talk all about the science and then let's talk all about the art and then put them together. So I think it's more, it's easier to follow. So where, I mean, I've been doing planned giving fundraising for 27 years, but I want you to explain what you see as the, the art of the, the relationship side.
James MisnerYep. Okay.
Tony MartignettiWhat, where, where, how do you— we talked about the art, the science, some of the science side. How do you— how does that contrast with the, the relation, the, the art side of the, the relationship?
James MisnerLet's talk about the art side. When you're in that qualifying meeting with a giver, If you're only thinking about your numbers and your metrics and you're not attuned to what that person is feeling and thinking, it doesn't matter what your numbers show. You're not going to make progress with it. You're going to have to attune yourself to what painful thing are they dealing with in their life. Did their kid just leave for college and they became an empty nester and their emotions, you know, are all over the place right now? Did a parent Just pass away. That's the art side. No amount of numbers and metrics are gonna tell you how to engage with that. When you ask them, hey, what do you long to see changed in our world?
Tony MartignettiHmm.
James MisnerNo numbers or metrics are gonna tell you how to respond to that. You're gonna have to be empathetic. You're gonna have to experience a little bit of that longing, of that pain, of that desire to see something changed in the world. with them to be able to engage appropriately. In your space, Tony, you're talking about planned giving. Some people don't like to have conversations about the end of their life. Not that planned giving is just that, but that's a big component of it. If you're not using art, using emotion attuned to, hey, this person is really uncomfortable talking about end-of-life decisions right now, you're just gonna offend them. Yeah. Who cares if your numbers are in the right space? Another part of this is storytelling is so important. People give to a story, broad, big narrative stories, and storytelling is an art. I don't care how many meetings you have and how many, you know, conversations you track in your metrics. If you can't tell a story, Human to human, either across a Zoom call or across a coffee table, you're never gonna build the, the real human connections that cause people to make big giving decisions.
Kate MartignettiIt's time for a break. Imagine a fundraising partner that not only helps you raise more money, but also supports you in retaining your donors. A partner that helps you raise funds both online and on location so you can grow your impact faster. That's DonorBox, a comprehensive suite of tools, services, and resources that gives fundraisers just like you a custom solution to tackle your unique challenges, helping you achieve the growth and sustainability your organization needs. Helping you help others. Visit donorbox.org to learn more. Now back to the art and science of fundraising.
Tony MartignettiI agree. I think my flaw is probably I'm more of the art and the human side of fundraising and not enough of the Metric scientific side. So I hear you. We do have to measure. We have, and, you know, with different clients, I have KPIs and things like that that I'm responsible for. But I still probably, it's just, it's the reason I entered nonprofit fundraising and planned giving specifically is because I love the relationship work. So I, I tend to default to, to the more of the art. So this is valuable. This is, this is valuable for me. All right. Let's, let's talk a little more. Let's go back to the science side now again. Another, you know, you, you talk about sustainable revenue engines. Let's, let's, you know, what, what are we, what are we talking about there? What are we measuring there back on the science side?
James MisnerYeah. Let's just talk about the, the most horrible number I think that exists in the nonprofit fundraising space right now, and that's retention rates. You know, on average right now, every year, between 40 and 45% of donors stay year to year with their nonprofit, which means that more than half actually stop giving to a nonprofit. Okay, that on the science side, that should blow people's mind. That's like a showstopper right there.
Tony MartignettiWe've had guests talk about even as high as 75%.
James MisnerWe've had some clients that have come in that only keep 20% of their donors every year. Okay. What in the world? We need to analyze that and figure out what the heck is going wrong. Okay, so we need to measure that and then figure out how do we fix this and see if we can't get that. If it is, you know, 20%, 25%, let's get that to 30%. Let's get that to 50%. Let's get that to 70%. Because if you're churning through your donors over and over and over again, that is not helpful. That is not sustainable. So the science side of that is, okay, well, why are they leaving? What's the hypothesis? And for most organizations, your hypothesis should come down to, we're actually not letting these people know where their money is going and what good it's doing in the world. I'm engaging with a client right now And I actually got them as a client because my family gave to them. We have an adopted kid. This is a foster care organization, foster care adoption organization. We gave to them and it wasn't a small gift. It was a good mid-size, you know, mid-level gift. I got one letter letting me know where the money was going, just one. And they're literally 2 miles down the street from my house. So I called them up and said, hey, I would like to keep giving to you, but I need to know what you're doing with the money. They had other donors, hundreds, that weren't professional fundraisers and didn't have 20, 25 years in this space. I went in and I analyzed their data. They were sending 4 communication pieces a year. 4. You know how many times my kids' school texts me when they have a half day so I don't forget to pick them up? It's something like 11 or 12. Wow. If I can't remember to pick my kid up after 2 text messages, how the heck am I gonna remember your nonprofit from 4 communication pieces a year?
Tony MartignettiTalking about a good-sized major gift too.
James MisnerYeah, for them it was a high-level, mid-level gift, you know, for that organization. And sadly, that is more the norm than I think any of us in this space would like. So we need to go in and fix that. That's the science of, okay, What's our communication cadence? How are we, uh, how are we building this out? What content do people actually desire? Um, and you do that through interviews. You do that through asking, uh, them. Uh, and on the art side, some of these people are probably pretty ticked off that they took your 10 grand and didn't do anything with it.
Tony MartignettiWait, go back a sec. Asking them, asking them what? What, what, what are, what are we surveying? What are we asking them in conversations?
James MisnerYeah, so if 80% of your donors or 50% of your donors are leaving, you need to go back and actually have a serious conversation with your high net worth givers. It needs to be face-to-face if they're willing. With your small and mid-sized donors, probably a survey and saying, hey, we think we goofed. We think we messed up here. We need to, you know, understand how to get better. Can you help us get better? Because we all care about this thing. Yeah. And ask specific questions. Uh, why did you stop giving? Did we communicate with you enough? When we did communicate, was it the right type of communication? You know, we need to ask that kind of stuff to our donors and own we don't always do things right.
Tony MartignettiYou're even suggesting surveying folks who are no longer donors, who left.
James MisnerAbsolutely. How, how scientifically would you figure out what caused them to leave unless you asked them?
Tony MartignettiYeah.
James MisnerAnd for a person to leave, I do think, and this is the art side, that probably an apology is needed. I think we did something wrong here. That's where you get into the art and the empathy and the pain, because people don't give just because they have spare money lying around. People give because they want to see something changed in the world, and they're deeply passionate about the areas that they give to. So if As a nonprofit, you've done something wrong. You need to, you need to own that. And that's art, not science, in terms of how you own that mistake.
Tony MartignettiYou also can, on the science side, can be surveying your, your existing donors. You know, how do you want to be contacted? What do you want to hear from us from about? Are you interested in our events or you're not? Can we send you solicitations? And how should we do that? Do you prefer postal mail, texting, you know, email? Or do you just want to do it on your own calendar? You know, do you want reminders? You know, these are the things that can also be surveyed. And then, of course, the all-important, not just follow-up, but the honoring of the preferences.
James MisnerYeah, when you ask somebody something and they tell you what they prefer and you don't do it, you don't follow through on it, you know, talk to your partner or your spouse, hey, what would you like to do this weekend? And they tell you and then you completely ignore it and go do something else. It's not a great weekend. Same with your givers. If they say, hey, I want to be contacted this time, I want one meeting a year, remind me via text message, my email inbox is too crazy. You have to follow through and do it, which means you need to have your systems built efficiently in the backend, which is more of a scientific, you know, thing than an artistic thing. And then honor what people have told you.
Tony MartignettiI always think of related to that, asking what someone's birthday is, you know, if they're gonna share their birthday, or you might just ask birth month, you know, but if you're asking for any kind of birthday info, then the presumption is that you're gonna remember their birthday or their birthday month. So you need to do that. You need to have a system in place that sends you a reminder a week before everybody's birthday that you're gonna send a card or the day of that you're gonna, you're gonna call them if they're, if they're well enough known that you, you can place a happy birthday call. You know, if you're gonna, if you're gonna survey those things, like you're saying, you know, you need to, you need to, you need to follow through on what you're asking about. It just, it feels empty to ask someone's birthday and then ignore it.
James MisnerThen never do anything with it. That's right.
Tony MartignettiWhat was the point? Yeah. All right. Let's, let's, this is, I'm enjoying this now, this compare and contrast, the, the science with the art. What else? Tell us some more about the science side. The, the, as I, as, as I, the, uh, relationship, you know, default guy, the art default guy, would say, uh, the cold hard, the cold hard scientific, uh, side. Share some more of that side.
James MisnerWell, let's talk about, um, teams, okay? And how teams can, can, uh, bring the art, art and the science together.
Tony MartignettiOkay.
James MisnerOne of the most important functions that I think as a, you know, Chief Revenue Officer that I've ever hired for is, you know, the development coordinator. Okay. People call it different things, but this is kind of the grease at the elbow position that makes sure everybody's putting their information into the CRM, that's giving you your weekly and your monthly reports as a leader. These hires are deeply scientific people. The best one that I ever hired, people called him, I won't share his name, but they had a nickname for him that was close to robot just because the guy was so, you know, is very robotic in terms of how he does stuff. It was the most valuable position that I've ever hired for because like you, Tony, I also gravitate towards the art side, the relational side, the engagement side. With people. I needed a development coordinator to show me what true north was scientifically. I am horrible in CRMs. I need someone to sit down and, you know, tell me to input my information. Most major gift officers are. I needed someone to do the calculations of year-over-year fundraising. This is before, you know, every CRM had that automated, you know, into it. Right. He needed to be that true north for the rest of the team and to have the hard conversations sometimes about, hey, we're not doing so well right now. We're not actually meeting our metrics every month. We need to figure out how to solve this. On the other side, because I am more art like you are, if you leave every donor meeting and you are an artist and you feel, oh my goodness, they're judging me and I didn't do that right, and 'Cause artists are sometimes, you know, that way. You need the data people, the science people to say, actually, your numbers are trending in the right direction. You're getting your meetings, you're asking the right questions, the gifts are coming in. Hey, it's not all about you and how you feel right now. On the flip side, the art people sometimes need to tell the data people, hey, I'm with the person. I know we want a big gift right now, But someone passed away in their family or their kid's going through an addiction crisis. I need you to lay off me right now on the numbers because I'm dealing with a real human right now and I'm helping them and adding value and guiding them through this situation. And hey, number one, it's the right thing to do. Number two, it's going to pay off, but not for a year or two. So I need you to calm down, you know.
Tony MartignettiYeah.
James MisnerScience guy. When you bring those 2 things together on the team and there's mutual respect and the leader facilitates that mutual respect, really wonderful things start to happen and people begin to appreciate different giftings and abilities on a team that are usually kind of, you know, butting heads with each other.
Tony MartignettiI want to pull on a thread that you said sounds like it was transformational for you, that the development coordinator you hired helped you find true north. What were you looking for in a development coordinator when you were making this hire?
James MisnerOh, this is a great question.
Tony MartignettiFinally, finally. All right, we're half an hour in. Finally, a great question. All right.
James MisnerYeah, um, this is, uh, great because I was unprepared for it. Numbers, when they're not interpreted by people who are numbers people, can tell you any story you want to tell. We've all been there, right? When you're doing the development meeting, you're with your staff, and Well, the numbers got pulled the wrong way and no one's entering stuff in the right way. And oh, I didn't know. So your numbers get messy. I needed someone to cut through all that noise. I could manage the relationships with the team. It was a, you know, 40, 50 person team at the time. But I needed someone to actually do that backend work so that we sat down to have the real meetings. the individual one-on-one performance meetings, the team debrief meetings, that we didn't spend 90% of the time complaining that the numbers and the data wasn't right. So I needed a person to come in and operationalize all of that for me. And I often encounter heads of fundraising that are one or the other. They are the systems people. Let's build the machine. Or they're the one that's out there and they're managing the top 50 donors. It's very hard to find a senior leader that has both of those things together. So if you're the science, data, build a system, build a machine person, you need some really strong, high EQ people around you who are gonna go out there and deal with the other humans that make the magic happen. If you're like me and you, Tony, and you like to be out there, you like to be engaging with individuals, you need someone behind the scenes to be building the machines and making sure all the cogs are turning at the same time. It's very hard to find people who can live in both spaces. Usually you can bungee to both spaces for a few hours, but you're in one space just because of how you are and how you were created and designed in your upbringing. And you really need to get support for yourself. I know that's hard for our audience, small and mid-sized people, But it works when you get that right.
Tony MartignettiThe introspection is important. You need to know where you fall, what your skills are, you know, as you said, how you're wired, and either hire an employee or employees or get help on a consulting basis with the other side, the, you know, the scientific, the numerical, the analysis, If you're more the relationship side.
James MisnerThat's, that's 100% right. One of my, uh, bosses at one point in time, gosh, I was probably in my 20s, pulled me aside and said, here's your Achilles heel, and you're gonna have this for the rest of your career. You run really fast. And it's good because we were in the humanitarian space and you need to run fast when things are happening. You need to hire a world-class process person to help everybody else catch up with where you're running as a leader. He was absolutely right. And even in our company, I need that today because I'm still running fast. Uh, it's just who I am, and I need a process person, you know, to come behind me.
Kate MartignettiIt's time for Tony's Take Two.
Tony MartignettiThank you, Kate. This week it's Tales from the Train because I've done some Amtrak travel lately. And it reminds me that Amtrak is so much more comfortable, more pleasant travel experience. So if you have the option, I would urge you to look at Amtrak as a possibility for travel instead of flying. Now, I know in a lot of parts of the country you can't. I'm near the Northeast Corridor, and when I was up in New York and I was traveling from there, so— Yeah. You know, between Boston and Washington, D.C., I think that's 80% of the trips and the revenue that Amtrak gets because it's the most populated part of the country that they serve. So I know it doesn't make sense in, in a lot of other parts of the country, but just consider it because when you're on Amtrak, you always get wide seats like first class. These are first class with seats. They're comfortable. Big, there's legroom. There's never a middle seat. Amtrak doesn't have three seats on one side. It's always two and two. There is never a middle seat that you get stuck with. Every Amtrak seat has a plug power. You don't have to worry about seat belts. You don't have to put a bag under the seat in front of you. All the luggage goes overhead. But there is room if you want to have a bag at your feet. There's a lot more room than airplanes. Some of them even some. Some cars even have footrests. That seems to be kind of on and off. I'm not sure how you know, but occasionally there's footrests that fold down. The aisles on trains are wider than the aisles on planes. You have a cafe car that you can walk to anytime. You don't have to worry about seatbelt signs coming on and the pilot saying, we're in turbulence, so now you can't get up. You can get up anytime you like. Yeah. Use the bathroom, go to the cafe car. Um, you don't have to check luggage unless you have really like 4 or 5 pieces or something that you— more than you can carry. But pretty much, I, I really don't even know what the luggage policy is on Amtrak. It seems to me if you can carry it on, you can bring it with you and put it in the overhead. And then a lot of cars have storage space at the, at the end of, uh, the car also for extra. But I think it's pretty much whatever you can carry. You're welcome to bring it on. So you don't have to worry about like 2 bags only. And, um, and then also arrival. When you take Amtrak, you arrive downtown. Think of, think of where Moynihan Train Hall is in New York City, uh, where Union Station is in Washington, 30th Street Station in Philadelphia, uh, the Wilmington Station, the Joe Biden Station in Wilmington, Delaware. These are the ones I know best. Oh, but also Boston. I've been up to Boston. Um, not Back Bay, but Boston, Maine. These stations are downtown, so you don't have to— a long Lyft or Uber or shuttle to get to where you want to go if you're going downtown. It's not like you're 30 miles away because that's where the airport is. You arrive downtown. So consider it. Okay, that's a, that's a long thing on Amtrak, but think about it because especially arriving downtown, you might save time even though trains go slower than planes. But the time you spend in traffic getting to the airport, and then you have time you wait in the airport because you got to be there early for security, obviously, and then the travel time back from the airport to where you might need to go, if it's in the center of a city, you might actually save time or it'd be equivalent on Amtrak and you'll have a much more comfortable ride. Okay, that's enough on Amtrak. And that is Tony's Take Two. Okay. Kate, frequent Amtrak rider. You used to take Amtrak all the time from New York City down to Wilmington to get home, right?
Kate MartignettiTo get home for Thanksgiving, Christmas, and then I think right before our spring break. So I took it a good maybe borderline 20 times.
Tony MartignettiYeah.
Kate MartignettiAnd that was all in the span of 2 years.
Tony MartignettiRight, right.
Kate MartignettiI thought it was awesome. I mean, It was— everyone was really quiet too because it was kind of nighttime when I would ride, um, and everyone was respectful. It might have been a little bit crowded at some points, um, when I would take coach. It would be kind of hard to find a spot, but that's also because I went during the holidays. Um, but if—
Tony MartignettiWe talked about that once. You have to be— you have to just be a little assertive and ask people,
Kate Martignettiright,
Tony Martignettimay I sit here when they have their luggage. Or their pet, you know, sitting on another— on a seat. But, you know, planes can be crowded. Planes can be crowded too.
Kate MartignettiBut yes, I like Amtrak and I like that my feet— it's on the ground. I'm not up in the air.
Tony MartignettiYeah. Okay. You made me think of one other thing. The quiet car. Every Amtrak train, at least in the Northeast Corridor, has a quiet car. It's usually the second to last car from the rear. And there you're not allowed to have cell phone conversations. You— if you're, if you're talking to your seatmate, you need to whisper. And they're pretty good about enforcing it too. Quiet car. But it's just one car in the whole train. It's like 8 cars or 10 cars in a train. One is the quiet car. So sometimes I opt for the quiet car if I know I don't have to make any calls or anything.
Kate MartignettiYeah. Oh, I like that. I haven't been in one yet, but I like the concept of it. Well, we
Tony Martignettigotta get you back on the train, but yeah. All right,
Kate Martignettiwe've got beaucoup buttloads more time. Here's the rest of The Art and Science of Fundraising with James Misner.
Tony MartignettiIs there more, uh, is there more, uh, science and art that we can, we can, uh, compare and contrast?
James MisnerI, I think we can, but let's talk about how these can come together. Um, would that be okay, Tony? Yeah.
Tony MartignettiYeah.
James MisnerYeah. One of the things I'm always struck by is in Jim Collins' book, Good to Great. I just listened to an episode of your podcast from November, and you guys were talking about Jim Collins in Good to Great. One of the greatest things he talks about is the power of the and, and that organizations and companies are often saying, hey, we have to choose A, Or we have to choose B. And that is often a false dichotomy. And I think we're talking about this in the fundraising space. You get CEOs and heads of fundraising who say, we have to be this, we have to be scientific, we have to be buttoned up, it has to be metric-driven. Or do you have people on the other side just, hey, wind me up and let me go tell stories? Those are false choices. And Jim Collins says that leaders who bring out the best of A and leaders who bring out the best in B are the ones who actually thrive, and they're the ones that actually grow their organizations. And I think in the nonprofit space, you see this happen all the time. You have a CEO who comes up through the program side, and they bring all the science and the monitoring evaluation and just wanna slap that onto fundraising. Right. Without bringing out the emotional storytelling art side. Or you have a CEO come up through fundraising and marketing who forgets all the monitoring evaluation and auditing and accounting. Especially in small and mid-sized nonprofits, we need to say, let's get the best of A and the best of B and bring these together. So we're not making a false choice. We're managing the tension instead of choosing between 2 things that are Falsely dichotomized against each other.
Tony MartignettiOkay. The power of the and.
James MisnerThe power of the and.
Tony MartignettiAll right. So let's— this is our up and to the right fundraising objective. This is where we want to be, where the two are coming together. Let's say more about, you know, systems, Maybe you have some examples of teams that are excellent at both.
James MisnerYeah, there's a team that I've gotten to work with for the past 10, 15 years or so, on or off. They have mastered this. They've mastered it. They spent years becoming world-class storytellers. How did they do that? You don't become a world-class storyteller by accident. You become a world-class storyteller by deeply figuring out the emotional hooks in a story that are gonna cause people to respond to it. That was the art side. Well, how did a team of 50 people get really good at it? They brought the science side in, they practiced their storytelling, and they still do to this day every single week. No one goes to a major giving meeting without practicing their story And having it evaluated by at least 3 other people inside the organization.
Tony MartignettiOh, really? Oh, they do these like role play— well, not role playing, but you're rehearsing. You're rehearsing.
James MisnerThey rehearse. They rehearse and they get that feedback. The leader of— the current leader of that team jokes, I don't care if you figured out the best wine or the best croissants to bring to that meeting. You could show up with Dasani water for all I care, but you will practice your story. Before you go in, and there's beauty in that because other people can critique it in a safe environment and say, "Hey, you forgot to ask a powerful question at the end. You're gonna have a hard time transitioning from this story into a conversation afterwards." Oh my goodness! You forgot this hook. I heard that story the other day in another meeting, and you you forgot this detail that's really gonna. Make it sing. What this team noticed is as they implemented a process to get better at storytelling, donors started responding more.
Tony MartignettiMm-hmm.
James MisnerZeros got added to gifts as they went. The art and the science coming together. Another great example of this is I love mid-level fundraising programs. People forget, you know, they're mid-level donors, but I think mid-level donors are really fun in the future. of most nonprofit fundraising programs. The science can tell you what your zone of opportunity is. Hey, we have this many people who we think can give between $1,000 and $10,000, normal, you know, mid-level range, and there's nothing there. The art side comes in and figures out what kind of community do these people want to come together. There's another team that I've worked with for the past 2 years. They built a wonderful mid-level program. And the interesting thing that happened was their mid-level program has actually stayed flat. It hasn't increased in revenue. It hasn't decreased in revenue. But you know what's happened? Their major gift program is off to the races. They, through great art, through great questions and conversations, figured out exactly what their mid-level audience wanted. And then they built the science side. How do we get our high Uh, higher annual fund small donors to be into mid-level? And how do we bump up our mid-level people into major? The science—
Tony MartignettiWhat is some of the— what they did for the mid-level community that they created?
James MisnerThey were the most transparent organization I've ever seen in their mid-level communication. They told their mid-level donors exactly what they were going to get. Hey, we built this community for people like you. Here's what people like us are. You know, you give between $1,000 and $10,000 a year. There are this number of you. There's— I forget the number— 792 of us together. We're gonna report to you more. We're gonna ask you less. They literally said that. We're gonna tell you where your money's going, and we're gonna ask you for money fewer times a year. Within 6 months, they were off to the races. People just ate it up. They loved the transparency. And we— they did a President's Weekend as part of a capital campaign a while ago, and half the room was from their mid-level program, now graduating from giving $10,000 to, you know, high 5 figures, low 6-figure gifts because somebody just said, I'm gonna tell you what's happening here. I'm gonna tell you exactly what we need. I'm gonna stop bugging you with, you know, annual fund type appeals, and I'm gonna ask you when it really matters. And people ate it up, Tony. They ate it up.
Tony MartignettiWhat was the work of that organization?
James MisnerThey were in the humanitarian space. So they were doing, you know, global poverty alleviation, conflict zones, and refugees.
Tony MartignettiOkay. All right. So sort of build up that program, they sounds like they asked a lot of questions about, you know, what you would want from the community. What do you want as a mid-level donor? How can, you know, how can we make this experience more valuable for you, more meaningful, make your giving not— make your giving more impactful for you? And it sounds like folks came back with, you know, we'd like to know more about where our dollars are going.
James MisnerYeah, they sent out a very simple, you know, almost envelope-sized survey. It was a postcard. It was very low tech. And it was checkboxes, mail this back to us. They had something like a 40% response rate to that. It was really wonderful. And people told them exactly what they wanted to hear about. You know, when you're working in disaster zones and with refugees in the US, you start to wonder, what do people, you know, really want to hear about? The donors just told them. And they tagged it for them. So these people got refugee stories, these people got, you know, disaster response, conflict zone stories, and Something like 80% were just like, we like all of it. Just keep telling us all the stories. The other great thing that happened, and this is so important for small and midsize organizations, is by telling that broad story, people stopped designating their gifts. Right. They started giving more money and they started giving it unrestricted or semi-restricted, which gave that organization degrees of freedom that they had never imagined before. All because they asked and 80% said, we like it all. Okay. So when you give, these, you know, 3 or 4 things happen. Their unrestricted revenue went through the roof.
Tony MartignettiWhat else can we talk about around bringing these 2 together? You know, you mentioned systems. Using, again, putting the science together with the art, using systems to move donors along.
James MisnerYeah.
Tony MartignettiIn relation, you know, throughout their spectrum of giving.
James MisnerYeah. Let's talk about how they got annual fund givers to become mid-level givers and then mid-level givers to become major givers. Chronicles of Philanthropy actually wrote up a case study 2 or 3 years ago on this organization because they were so good At the at the science side of it.
Tony MartignettiSo what then? What's the name of the organization? Shout them out.
James MisnerOh yeah, so it's World Relief, global humanitarian organization based in the Baltimore Washington region. Karen Bryant at the time was their mid-level director. She's moved on and now is at a climate change organization. But great, great, great leader. What they did was they set up. a system, a quarterly system, where anybody that gave a single gift of $500 or more would be flagged in the system for the mid-level team to actually reach out and thank, because they had a hypothesis that if you're giving a $500 first-time single gift, you probably have more money to give, which, you know, 9 times out of 10 is usually true. And then what they did every quarter is they actually invited those people to explore and join the mid-level program. They did a direct mail and phone call, very simple campaign. Hey, we have something for people like you that we think that would actually really increase your experience with us. And they told them exactly what it was. They invited them to it. It was the simplest thing in the world. And you know what? People were like, yes. There were a few things here that made it sing, quote unquote. First was it happened quick. The systems in the backend flagged it quickly, and you weren't waiting 6, 9, 10 months till somebody forgot about you to invite them into something. They were thanked really quickly, and within 90 days they were invited to the next thing. Okay, that's really important. If somebody gives you a gift in December, of 2024 and you don't do anything to try to engage them until September of 2025, you've already lost them. They've moved on to the next thing. You need to be quick with this. And it worked dramatically. The next thing that they did is they would continually research using DonorSearch and other, you know, wealth screen engines, their mid-level portfolio. And the mid-level team identified the top third of people that they thought had significant future potential for the organization, and they would start to treat them like major donors. They wouldn't just throw 'em over to the major donor team, but they would do the birthday calls, the handwritten notes. They would invite 'em to some special events. So they got used to having one-on-one attention. Because many mid-level donors, if you go from, hey, uh, we're getting emails, we're getting newsletters, we love this community and the quarterly, you know, online events, and hey, do you want to have coffee? That jump is so hard for them because they don't think of themselves often of being people of, of, of means, of wealth. Uh, so they started to condition or train their mid-level donors to expect that. And then what they did, and this is the brilliance of this art and science coming together, is 4 times a year they would identify the people that they were— they thought most likely to become major givers, and they asked them if they wanted to become major givers. They would say, hey, we're actually looking for 10 or 15 people from this mid-level community to come up and do more with us so that we could do X, Y, and Z in our program space? And they let them raise their hands. And every time they did it, they had more hands raised than they needed at the time.
Tony MartignettiWow. What, what else were they enticing them with? What were— was there more of an enticement or was it all just program related? You know, if, if 15 people join us at the, at the major donor level, You know, we can do this with humanitarian—
James MisnerThat was the main hook because the message for mid-level was, hey, we're going to ask fewer times and tell you more. So these people started really to get deeply engaged with the organization. But there was also a communal enticement. You know, we need 15 of you to do this. And hey, when our staff come from overseas, We're actually going to get you together either in person or on Zoom so you can meet these people. Hey, when we are in your city, we're going to show up and we're going to have lunch and coffee and dinner. This is going to become a big part of your life, what we do together. So there was that communal aspect. I've never been a big fan of some of the tchotchke type incentives for givers. Hey, get a book. Join this club, you know, those types of things. Get, you know, elbow time with the CEO. Givers like community with other givers is what I found. People like to be with people that care about the same things that they do, and the other things just naturally happen. But you don't have to sell them on it. You sell them on the impact because people give through your organization to make a difference in the world. They don't give to your organization.
Tony MartignettiYeah, through to make the difference that you're— that they want to see.
James MisnerAbsolutely.
Tony MartignettiAll right, this is excellent. Um, wrap it all up, you know, leave us with, uh, inspiration for putting together the, uh, the art and the science so we can have that, that, uh, that growth that we're all looking for.
James MisnerYeah, I want to end by talking about leadership. Okay, I think the nonprofit space has a crisis of leadership. We've all talked about the great resignation after the pandemic. We've talked about burnout a ton. There's new studies out, you know, even, you know, Q4 of 2024 about just the next wave of nonprofit leader resignations. But in the fundraising space, this does not happen. by accident. Okay? It takes a leader to bring these things together and to create the conditions for team members to bring their best, whether it's on the art side or the science side. This just won't happen by accident. A leader needs to know that they have the responsibility to create the conditions for success for every team member, whether it's a database an analyst or a frontline fundraiser to bring their best every single day. And I see people abdicating that responsibility more and more as the world gets more and more stressful. So in ending, teams that grow, teams that move up into the right, the, the 2% of nonprofits that eventually break $1 million in revenue, it doesn't happen by accident. It happens because a leader says, I'm actually going to do something different now. I'm going to ask the harder questions. I'm going to invest in my team. I'm going to create the art side of this organization and storytelling and questions and EQ. And I'm going to create the science side of this organization and invest in data and systems. And I'm going to make sure through my leadership through how I model this, that these people start working together more. Every year we talk about not enough nonprofits are breaking that million-dollar barrier or that $10 million barrier. And I don't think that bigger is better, Tony. Okay? I think that bigger just means that you're better funded, that you figured the funding side of things out. I see so much innovation happening in the small and midsize space That I want this community of people to develop those leadership skills, to bring the best of art and science together so they can move the needle and change some of these problems that have been plaguing our country and our world for decades, if not generations.
Tony MartignettiJames Misner, founder and CEO of the Kipos Group. Tell us what Kipos is. K-I-P-O-S. What, what's the Yeah. What's the— what's the— yeah, what's the Kipos Group about? Where's that from?
James MisnerYeah, Kipos Group is the Greek word for garden. During the pandemic, my kids and I planted over 1,000 plants in our backyard because we were bored, uh, and we got into gardening. And within 6 months, people were stopping by to take pictures in our yard, you know. Um, and so when I started this company, I wanted to create something that helped People grow something beautiful, and gardens are beautiful, and they provide, you know, food for you if you, you know, grow vegetables and fruit and stuff. So we want to help people grow beautiful things in their nonprofits. So that's where the Kipos Group came from.
Tony MartignettiJames Misner, you'll find the company at thekiposgroup.com. You'll find James on LinkedIn. James, thank you very much. Thanks for sharing your thinking.
James MisnerThanks, Tony. It was great to be here with you today.
Kate MartignettiNext week, Amy and Gene return to share what they're looking at for 2025 on our last show of 2024.
Tony MartignettiCan you believe this? Last show. It's next 2 weeks after that. We have next week and then next 2 weeks after that, we're off. Woo!
Kate MartignettiIf you missed any part of this week's show,
Tony MartignettiI beseech you to find it at tonymartignetti.com.
Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by DonorBox. Outdated donation forms blocking your supporters' generosity? DonorBox. Fast, flexible, and friendly fundraising forms for your nonprofit. donorbox.org.
Tony MartignettiOoh, that alliteration. Fast, flexible, friendly fundraising forms.
Kate MartignettiOur creative producer is Claire Meyerhoff. I'm your associate producer, Kate Martignetti. The show's social media is by Susan Chavez. Marc Silverman is our web guy, and this music is by Scott Stein.
Tony MartignettiThank you for that affirmation, Scotty. Be with us next week for Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. Go out and be great.
I love our sponsor!


