Skip to content
EP 719December 2, 2024

The Chronicle of Philanthropy Leaders

Tony MartignettiStacy PalmerAndrew Simon
Nonprofit Radio
Episode 719
0:00 / 0:00

About this episode

Stacy Palmer is CEO of the new nonprofit newspaper, and the editor-in-chief is Andrew Simon. We talk about the transition from privately held to 501(c)(3); their plans for growth; the mission, values and priorities guiding them; new content that’s coming; improving mass media’s coverage of our community; the presidential election; potential threats to the sector; and a good deal more.

Here’s the transcript

Tony MartignettiHello and welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. I'm your aptly named host and the podfather of your favorite hebdomadal podcast. Oh, I'm glad you're with us. I'd be stricken with pica if you made me swallow the idea that you missed this week's show. Here's our associate producer Kate with the highlights.

Kate MartignettiHey Tony, here's what's up. The Chronicle of Philanthropy Leaders. Stacy Palmer is CEO of the now nonprofit newspaper, and the editor-in-chief is Andrew Simon. We talk about the transition from privately held to 501, their plans for growth, the mission, values, and priorities guiding them, new content that's coming, improving mass media's coverage of our community, potential threats to the sector, and a good deal more on Tony's Take Two.

Tony MartignettiWith a lackluster host, You get a late holiday wish.

Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by DonorBox. Outdated donation forms blocking your supporters' generosity? DonorBox. Fast, flexible, and friendly fundraising forms for your nonprofit. donorbox.org. Here is the Chronicle of Philanthropy Leaders.

Tony MartignettiIt's a pleasure to welcome this week's guests. Stacy Palmer is CEO of the Chronicle of Philanthropy. Andrew Simon is editor-in-chief of the Chronicle of Philanthropy. You'll find them both on LinkedIn. Stacy, Andrew, welcome to Nonprofit Radio.

Stacy PalmerThanks for inviting us.

Andrew SimonThank you for having us, Tony.

Tony MartignettiAbsolute, absolute pleasure. Um, Stacy, I'd like to start with you. It's been about 2 and a half years. It was June of 2022 we last talked. You had— you were making the transition or had made the transition from privately held company to nonprofit status. You were awaiting the IRS approval of the nonprofit status. That was June of 2022. I know you've gotten that. Bring us up to date on the Chronicle of Philanthropy as a nonprofit.

Stacy PalmerYeah, so we've been operating for 18 months as a nonprofit, and every day we learn something new about what it takes to build an organization. And so I feel much closer to all of our readers and all of the challenges that they face, which I knew would happen as we sort of made this transition. But, you know, we've gotten through our first audit, we're doing our 990, we're doing all of those kinds of things, and we're really trying to figure out how do we reinvent ourselves so that the Chronicle of Philanthropy will be something that serves our audiences really well for decades to come.

Tony MartignettiWhat have you especially learned as a CEO of a nonprofit? Go a little— dive a little deeper into what's been— how much closer you feel to the audience now.

Stacy PalmerYeah. You know, I mean, I'm now actively doing fundraising. I'm working with a board. You know, all of the things that people would tell me, this is a challenge I face, this is something that's wonderful, this is something that's difficult. Now I feel it viscerally every single day. The biggest thing for us has been to technology and how to make sure that we have systems that really help us, you know, show the audience, you know, all the things that they want. We have legacy systems. I think every nonprofit is facing those kinds of problems, and we need to make sure that we move as quickly as we can into new ways of serving our audiences. And that part, it's just taken longer than I would have expected it to, just because it's complicated, um, and it's expensive. And so you need to figure out ways to do that. But, you know, I think the really fun part for us is we often are asking ourselves, how do we think about serving the audience? What do they need? Without having to worry as much about, you know, what our for-profit owners were thinking about. And they were very generous and very wonderful, but they definitely needed to make sure we were making a profit. Now we think about how do we plow that into more services to better serve nonprofits. That's extremely freeing, and that's the part of the nonprofit world that I love.

Tony MartignettiSo it sounds like, uh, Describe as your program work. Yeah, exactly. You're finding it takes longer than you expected. It's costly. There's fundraising against it. Okay. And you've described this as a period of transformation and growth. And how does having hired Andrew as editor-in-chief fit with that?

Stacy PalmerIt absolutely enables it because he brings skills and perspectives that our newsroom didn't have before. So why don't we let him talk a little bit about his background so that you can all know what he brings to the Chronicle of Philanthropy.

Tony MartignettiOkay, let's do it that way. I was going to actually ask you, why did you hire Andrew Simon? But we'll—

Stacy PalmerI'll let him do it and then I can come back.

Tony MartignettiAndrew Simon, why do you believe you were hired? What, what, what have you brought?

Andrew SimonWell, you know, um, in some of the early conversations with Stacy, we both talked about how the Chronicle can really serve its audience by helping leaders see around the corner, right? Understanding the trends, understanding what's happening now in philanthropy, in the nonprofit world, but making sense of it and really helping to guide readers a little bit with our journalism and our reporting about what to expect next. And in previous roles, I've been fascinated with this idea of how can we help readers and leaders see the future. I had a previous job, I was at a business consulting company. We were Doing stories on climate solutions. I, previous to that, I worked at grist.org, a nonprofit news site devoted to climate, climate solutions, climate justice. And in both of those roles, it was similar. It was sort of making sense of the news now and how does that help guide leaders in their decision-making going forward. So I think Stacy and I were kind of excited about the prospect of doing more of that. The Chronicle has certainly done that for years, but the idea of doing more of that and coming into this role Is what really excited me.

Tony MartignettiWell, what are some of the trends that you're looking at? We just, I mean, we just had a presidential election. I mean, that's a wide open question, but take it where you go and take it where you like. And, you know, we'll drill down some.

Andrew SimonI see the post-election world on a few levels. There's certainly helping leaders navigate the changes to tax policy and regulation. There are certainly the missions of many nonprofits, um, that could be under threat. So there's that level. I also think there's a hovering over all this is just uncertainty, really an unpredictable, potentially unpredictable time for leaders, whether you're on the grantmaking side, whether you're a nonprofit leader, whether you're a fundraiser. And I'm wondering how we can help our leaders and readers navigate this uncertainty, right? So I feel like there's uncertainty hovering over all this, right? So we can raise questions about, well, will this mission be affected? What are the ramifications of these tax policies, regulation changes, etc., which is very important. But then how do you navigate the uncertainty going forward?

Tony MartignettiThe Chronicle has an interesting role. Is it fair to say that it's an advocate? for the nonprofit sector community, or is it— is that inappropriate and it needs to remain neutral about its primary readership?

Stacy PalmerYeah, it's a great question. And, you know, obviously we believe nonprofits are incredibly important to society, or else we wouldn't be in this business of covering and serving them and helping them do better. But we also raise questions when they're not doing the kinds of things that society depends on them to do. So, you know, I Somebody once described us as the good friend who tells you when your slip is showing, and it's an awkward expression, but it's sort of the right way to say, you know, I think, you know, it's important to say that we care deeply about this sector. We think it's horribly uncovered. We think that that's one of the reasons it's not as effective as it should be. We think people are terribly fragmented, and it's our role to connect people. You did an interesting blog post sort of talking about the fact that everyone needs to come together as a sector in this time when there there are really big challenges. And, you know, we see already some of the things going on on Capitol Hill, um, where there's legislation, you know, that a lot of nonprofits are allied against. Those kinds of things where people need to come together and defend the rights of nonprofits to free speech and advocacy and those kinds of things. It's really important for them to see themselves in, you know, the pages of our articles so that they all know what's happening. Some will agree, some will disagree, but at least they should be connected to each other, to fact-based information. So that's what we're trying to do. And I think another thing that we're thinking a lot about, um, is how do we fix some of the systems that are broken about the nonprofit world. Um, I will say that, you know, there's been frustration forever about lack of operating support, lack of multi-year grants. We saw some of— in the pandemic, we saw some changes there, but it seems like there's a slide back on the very things nonprofits need. So in those kinds of ways, choosing that we're going to talk about those things You might consider that advocacy, but we think it's just important for us to put a spotlight on things that otherwise wouldn't get the attention.

Tony MartignettiLike, like your slip is showing. Okay. What about the mass media coverage? I don't know who's better to answer this, but you have, you have, you had at least, maybe still do, a fellowship program.

Kate MartignettiYep.

Tony MartignettiTraining other journalists outside the community that, you know, we don't exist only when there's a $500 million fraud foisted on the people by a Veterans Affairs agency. You know, where do we stand on helping mass media better coverage, better cover the sector?

Stacy PalmerThat's a really important part of our mission. So every year we take on 4 newsrooms that we work with intensively over the year. We partner with people in our newsroom who can help them do an excellent job of learning how to cover the field. And we're really trying to help them focus on, you know, who are the nonprofits and foundations that are serving their communities? What are they doing? What's happening? What would happen if they disappeared? And to really better understand that. So, you know, to be sure, some of the fellows we've done have found some fraud and abuse in their communities, and they've reported on that. But we encourage them to look more deeply about what's going on and to show that, you know, 1 out of every 11 Americans works for a nonprofit. That means the people who are reading their content, listening to them, if it's, you know, on broadcast networks, you know, those are the kinds of folks that, you know, really want to understand how nonprofits work, what the threats are to them, what the opportunities are. And it's— we should cover it just like we cover business or any other sector. So we try to argue that we would love to expand this program. So one of the things we hope as a nonprofit that we can do is draw ever more attention in this time when local journalism is suffering. A great way to attract audiences is to cover nonprofits. That's what readers and listeners and viewers all want to know about is who's solving problems in their communities, and it's the nonprofits.

Tony MartignettiAndrew, then are these fellows working with you on the editorial side, right?

Andrew SimonWell, they're editorial fellows, so they certainly work in their respective newsrooms throughout the country, but What we do is our editors and writers will work with them, mentor them, review their stories, help them bring larger concepts to life. And then we also, as a matter of fact, I think we have one of these sessions today. We record, Tony, where we'll, we'll have, we'll share our expertise in a kind of learning session where we'll, you know, share tips on investigative reporting or collecting datasets and hopefully help guide the fellows in those types of ways.

Tony MartignettiI see. All right. So they remain in their In their respective—

Stacy Palmerthey're in their newsrooms. Yep.

Tony MartignettiOkay. Okay. Yeah. Data. I mean, there's a, there's a trove of data about the nonprofit sector that I think doesn't get the attention that, that folks, the journalists need to know about what's out there, what the government collects, what some of the agencies collect.

Stacy PalmerYeah. So one of the fellows is actually working on a project to try to figure out where the most charitable cities are, which is a vexing thing to do. We've done those kinds of projects too, but the data is not ideal for being able to ask those questions. But we're really trying to figure out what makes certain communities stand out. Why is there more philanthropy in them? And then on the flip side, why are there philanthropy deserts, um, and what can be done about that? So, you know, that's one of the ways that we're training them to use data. And of course, we do the very basics, like making sure everybody can, you know, glean information from the 990s, you know, make sure they really understand how to read them, those very basic things.

Kate MartignettiIt's time for a break. Imagine a fundraising partner that not only helps you raise more money but also supports you in retaining your donors. A partner that helps you raise funds both online and on location so you can grow your impact faster. That's DonorBox. A comprehensive suite of tools, services, and resources that gives fundraisers just like you a custom solution to tackle your unique challenges, helping you achieve the growth and sustainability your organization needs. Helping you help others. Visit donorbox.org to learn more. Now back to The Chronicle of Philanthropy Leaders.

Tony MartignettiAndrew, I'd like to pull on the thread a little more about the presidential election, Project 2025. I mean, there are some nonprofits that are specifically named in the document, like National Public Radio, Public Broadcasting System, PBS, you know, named, called out to be defunded. That's right. Planned Parenthood should have its Medicaid funding withdrawn as long as they're providing abortion care. What's the role of the Chronicle in making this clear? I don't know, playing the role of the good friend, but seeing that some of the good friends are under explicit threat. Where's the Chronicle fit there?

Andrew SimonSure. Well, it goes a little bit back to this theme of uncertainty, and it's not to say that some of these threats shouldn't be taken seriously or aren't real, but again, hard to know if and when some of these changes would happen. I think our role is to try to identify the ways in which nonprofits can stay financially healthy and stable again through, through tough times. You know, it's why we have multiple reporters dedicated to fundraising. It's why we have multiple writers talking about leadership and navigating hard decisions in volatile times like this. Not to say that this is not perfectly analogous, but certainly there was COVID-19 not that many years ago, and this was before I got to the Chronicle, but this was the newsroom coming together with our nonprofit intelligence team, which I know that's a wonky title, but that's our unit that's really devoted to, you know, helping leaders in a professional development capacity. So, you know, the team just got together and tried to again help figure out, okay, under these unprecedented, really challenging times, what should fundraisers consider? How do leaders navigate and lead their organization? What does the remote workplace look like? So there will be certainly new challenges in this era. And again, it's not to say that the next era is exactly like the coronavirus era. And yet these could be challenging, volatile times. And I think there are certain themes that we can cover that should be able to apply to most nonprofits, not all. One of my big reflections of this role so far is the variation in size and scope and mission of nonprofits is so vast that we, we do— we are thoughtful and need to continue to be thoughtful about not offering one-size-fits-all solutions, that we do need to gear our coverage Around just, you know, as best we can around that huge variation of nonprofits. But nonetheless, we are looking for trends and things that, again, we think should be of interest to at least the majority of the readership.

Tony MartignettiDo we have— I'm saying we, I'm a member of the Chronicle of Philanthropy. Is there a Washington, D.C. reporter? Are we able to cover what's, you know, what's happening Around, you know, discussions around the, the sector in, in Washington?

Stacy PalmerYeah, you know, we started off being based here, um, and so for many, many years when we were under the Chronicle of Higher Education, all the reporters worked from the Washington, D.C. area. Um, we had a couple that, you know, were able to be in other places, but for the most part we were all here. So we start with a really strong base of covering Washington. I will say though that there's a— was a point where I had a lot of the reporters focused on Capitol Hill, um, and the White House, the IRS, doing all those kinds of things. Um, and so there would be different people assigned to all of those things. But as the federal government sort of pulled back on doing very much that was interesting, um, for nonprofits writ large, Some of— and I would assign the best reporters to those beats, and they would come up to me and say, there's not enough to cover. Can I please have something else to cover in addition to covering what's going on in terms of policy? So we're, you know, in one of those pendulum shifts now where we're going back to the people who had the expertise in covering it. But— and I think now we're really, you know, given some of the things that, you know, the Trump administration, that J.D. Vance has said about, you know, where nonprofits are going to be, you know, really in the sights of possible legislation. We're in a heavy period, and I'm thrilled that we have expertise that people cultivated long ago. But it really does come sort of in and out. And I think where we also need to pay a lot of attention to is, you know, state and local politics is going to become even more important. And that's an area where, because we're small, we haven't spent as much time. So I think that's one of the areas where we're going to need to grow.

Tony MartignettiI see the need. And yeah, I hadn't even thought of, right, state and local. I mean, so much is being pushed down to the states and a lot of issues. I'm concerned. You know, I'm just personally and professionally, I'm concerned about our sector and pieces of it that have missions that are in the sights of the

Stacy Palmernew

Tony Martignettiadministration and Project 2025.

Stacy PalmerYeah, it goes beyond that. You know, so regardless of what your politics are and what you care about the missions, the fact that we're talking about pretty serious federal budget cuts of any kind. I mean, nonprofits get more of their revenue from government than they do from anything else. And so, you know, I think that if any of those things go through, the sector could be in a pretty difficult period. So that's especially the way we're watching it is, you know, um, not even just, you know, obviously there are particular missions that are in the target, but really anybody that gets funding from government entities. Yeah. could be at risk financially. So that's why when Andrew was talking about helping navigate uncertainty, make sure people know how to lead and fundraise, it's incredibly important. We were founded soon after the Reagan administration was leaving office, and that was a time when there was a burst in professional fundraisers being developed because there were all kinds of budget cuts and organizations needed to double down on their private fundraising. So I— and that will never make up for how much the government provides, but it's gonna be crucial in these next few years, I think.

Tony MartignettiSo what am I missing, Stacy? I mean, when I see the GivingUSA report each year, it's like individual giving is 75 or 76% of overall giving to nonprofits. But you're saying government—

Stacy PalmerBut that does— that's just private giving. If you look at the budgets of nonprofits

Tony Martignettiand

Stacy Palmerlook at like the Urban Institute kind of study, so colleges, hospitals, social service agencies, that overall budget shows that most of the finances are through some kind of a government subsidy. And people don't think about it that way. We think of nonprofits and we think of the private giving side, and that's usually important. And for some groups, you know, that's 90% of their income, but for others, it's a much smaller portion.

Tony MartignettiOkay, thank you. All right, all right. All right, maybe a little lighter, a little lighter topic. What about What are we going to be seeing priority-wise in terms of other content, webinars, podcasts? I don't know, Andrew, is that on the editorial side or is that not? I don't know.

Andrew SimonYeah, I can certainly speak to multimedia and, you know, Stacy may be able to talk a little bit more about, you know, webinars and that unit. We're excited about meeting readers where they are. You know, I think Stacy already alluded to the fact that, you know, yes, there are some challenges as we transition to being an independent nonprofit organization. But with that comes opportunity. So it's interesting, we had a discussion yesterday among the leadership team, and it's sort of like we, we know we want to use different multimedia tools and channels to reach our audience, but we also want to become more sophisticated in understanding of, you know, what are the tools that will reach them most effectively, right? You know, is, is there a hunger for podcasts? Is there a hunger for short social videos, right? So There's a sort of a measure of work of saying, yeah, we, we want to meet readers where they are, but how do we do that? And what are the most effective ways we can reach readers in that way? So it is exciting, though. We, we do have— hopefully I can say this publicly— we do have a podcast underway, which Stacy might be able to talk a little bit more about, which we're extremely thrilled about. We have begun experimenting a bit more with video, particularly on social media. We have a terrific social media manager who's really willing to experiment and guide us in those ways. We want to do small things or things that seem small, as for example, have our writers just, you know, go on camera and talk for 60 seconds about the great reporting that they do. It's something that other publications do. So I think it's sort of starting kind of seemingly modestly in these ways and experimenting again, seeing what resonates with our audience, and then hopefully leaning in more to what we learned is effective.

Tony MartignettiI had the honor of hosting Fundraising Fundamentals for the Chronicle. For about five years, when back when Peter Panepento was your web editor, Stacy, and that that was always fun. A little short form, short form podcasting, ten minutes every two weeks or maybe once a month.

Kate MartignettiIt's time for Tony's Take Two.

Tony MartignettiThank you, Kate. You would have thought that last week I would have said. Happy Thanksgiving. That's a pretty natural thing to say during the week of Thanksgiving. But I didn't, I didn't say it because I didn't think of it because we record the week before. When you have a lackluster host, this is what you end up with, a late Happy Thanksgiving holiday wish. You deserve better. I, you do, you do. I wish the host was better. Yeah. We're stuck with lackluster. I hope you enjoyed your Thanksgiving, took some time for yourself, time to relax, rejuvenate. There's a whole 4th quarter coming up. Well, we're in the midst of the 4th quarter, the, the tail end of the 4th quarter coming up. I hope you took some time for yourself, your family, your friends. Happy Thanksgiving. Happy Thanksgiving. Late. That is Tony's take two.

Kate MartignettiKate, we hope you enjoyed your turkey. Well, we've got beaucoup buttloads more time. Here's the rest of the Chronicle of Philanthropy Leaders with Stacy Palmer and Andrew Simon.

Tony MartignettiWhat about you know professional development? Opportunities through the, through the Chronicle? What, what do you see there?

Stacy PalmerYeah, that's a really important part of what we do, and we see our role as in very much helping nonprofits do their jobs better. A lot of our webinars focus on fundraising, but we're branching out into doing more things on leadership. The podcast that Andrew mentioned is going to be focused on leadership, and I'm going to talk to terrific leaders about the ways that they overcome the challenges that they face. And I'm eager to have listeners of this podcast share any ideas and thoughts about both topics and guests and those kinds of things as we feature them. So I would say the next big area that we'll get into, you know, has to do more with leadership. We're really concerned about the fact that, you know, we did a survey that found that a lot— nonprofit leaders love their jobs, but they're really frustrated in them. And, you know, many of them are planning to leave their roles in the next 2 or 3 years, and about a third of them are thinking about leaving the sector altogether. That's a brain drain we can't afford right now. We need to groom more leaders. I've talked to people who say that they offer, you know, co-leadership opportunities sometimes to younger colleagues, and the younger colleagues look at them and say, I would never want that job. Why would you think that anybody would want that job? It's not a good job. You know, that's really damaging to the sector when great talent doesn't even think that leadership of a nonprofit is the kind of role they want So we see ourselves as helping to deal with that problem. So I think you'll see a lot more from us on that topic.

Tony MartignettiAndrew, you reported on that, the leadership transition. I think it was just earlier this month. Can you pull on that a little more? Talk about the next generation and the exodus of the existing?

Andrew SimonSure, absolutely. Yeah, we had a writer, Alex Daniels, do a recent cover story on the— transition at many foundations in leadership. And it's— we're in a moment of change. It's pretty indisputable, right? Whether it's JPB, the Ford Foundation, Hewlett, foundations of that size, and then, you know, other foundations too that may not be kind of quite as reputable as those, but still really important foundations in the space. And yeah, what Alex realized in his reporting is that this next generation of leaders, they're often people coming directly from the nonprofit world, right? They're not necessarily coming from academia or the corporate sector. So they've lived the daily lives of what it's like to lead a nonprofit and work in a nonprofit. They're often women. They're often people of color, women of color, which also represents a shift just in the demographic, but also in the ideas and the innovation that they could bring to, to some of these entities. So So it really feels like a big moment of change, and it speaks to something I'm really interested in as I've gotten into this role, is, as we alluded to earlier, about kind of seeing to the future. I think even outside of foundation leadership, you know, what is the future of the sector? Who's going to be calling the shots? What are the biggest challenges they are facing, right? Where— what are their work backgrounds look like? As Stacy just mentioned, How does the sector prevent burnout, right? How does the sector support these leaders? And again, now going into an era of potentially more unpredictability, how does this next generation kind of thrive and not, you know, meet some seemingly insurmountable challenges, right? I think the burnout is real and some of the other things that Stacy mentioned. So I would say it's personally exciting that that shift is really exciting, but there are real challenges that these young leaders will have to confront.

Tony MartignettiIt's an interesting tension. You know, with the election is based on, you know, make us great again. Like we're going backwards to some time that's undefined. And, you know, I don't know how many decades or generations back, but yet we're talking about a new generation of leadership, you know, looking forward. I see some— I see a tension there. Yeah. I don't know. Maybe that's just A general, you know, threat or concern of the community. But I see tension between moving backwards and looking forward.

Kate MartignettiThere was—

Stacy PalmerI think there are some nonprofit leaders who, having been through the first time Trump was elected and all the, you know, having survived the pandemic, they were already pretty worn out. And so this idea of going through it again, that's why I'm really worried about a number of departures that we're seeing. So, you know, one of the things that we found in our survey too was that, you know, the problems of polarization is what's really hitting nonprofits hard. You know, it used to be that when you asked people what their problems were, it was about, you know, making their budgets, raising enough money, worrying about their staffs. And those are still big problems, but now they're really trying to figure out how to deal with a divided country, sometimes divided workplaces. So that's just added another challenge. Yeah.

Tony MartignettiWhat else should we talk about that I, that I, uh, I haven't asked you about? What, what, what does— what do you each want to share about, uh, the Chronicle going forward, the transition? Please, I can't, I can't anticipate everything.

Andrew SimonNo, well, you know, I want to go back to a question you asked earlier because I, it— I think it was a 2-part question. I think you were asking sort of What do you see coming down the road, both related to the election results and maybe not so much? So I feel like I answered the first part, but not the second part. There are trends and shifts in the sector that are really interesting that we we've been covering already, but we'll continue to cover. So and some may be related to the administration, but not so much. You know, for example, technology and AI and. What are nonprofits learning about the technologies, right? There's a lot of hope. There's a lot of promise. There's a lot of excitement. There's a lot of really interesting applications, you know, from fundraising to organizational efficiency and operations. But then there's fear, which is justifiable. There's risks. So how do nonprofits navigate AI and other technologies too? For example, cybersecurity, right? So So that is a thread and a story we'll be covering. There's certainly the future of race-based grantmaking and DEI efforts at nonprofits. This one does feel like it could be tied to, again, this next era, whether or not it's directly to the administration or not, but certainly in this new world that we're in. Mm-hmm. What does that look like, right? If you're a nonprofit and you're, say, working specifically What does that look like? What if you're an entity who's interested in supporting your own DEI efforts, and yet it feels like maybe the funding is starting to dry up from grantmakers in that area because of the DEI backlash? You know, that is a real issue and storyline that, again, I think, you know, multiple nonprofits will be confronting. I also think it's— and I'm learning more about this as I learn more about the sector, The effect of Melinda French Gates and Mackenzie Scott, right? This— their unrestricted giving. I think with Mackenzie Scott, a little bit more mystery in terms of the process there. With Melinda French Gates really leaning into gender equity, women leadership, it's all really fascinating to have these 2 high-stakes players who have really burst onto the scene We know our readers are really interested in their moves. We have the receipts to show it, and it's for good reason. You know, they're really 2 power players in the space right now. So there's something interesting emerging there, both with respect to their approach to giving and how they give, and then also following the issue areas and the missions in terms of where their dollars go.

Stacy PalmerYeah, I think what's so exciting about watching them is, you know, for years and years and years, we've had covers that say, you know, philanthropy's not paying enough attention to women donors. Where are the women donors? Going to start giving in a big way. Um, and so many women have been influenced by what they're seeing from Mackenzie and Melinda. And Melinda Gates has also made deliberate attempts to make sure that other women are giving, um, and, you know, doing matching grants and other kinds of things. So I think we're going to see a really big new era in which women play a much more important role in big philanthropy. So that should shift things, um, in a really fascinating way for us to watch.

Tony MartignettiThat's interesting, Stacy. So women, non-billionaire women, are feeling empowered.

Stacy PalmerYes.

Tony MartignettiBy the Mackenzie Scott and French Gates work?

Stacy PalmerAbsolutely. You know, and, you know, one of the things that Melinda French Gates did was offer some matching grants to women who were affluent and, you know, encouraged them that if they channeled more of their giving to women's causes, she would match it. Well, that kind of thing unlocks a lot of interest because all of a sudden women with And so I think that's really important for people to see and say, wait a minute, there's somebody else who thinks that these causes really matter. I think we all know the role model effect is incredibly important in philanthropy. So, you know, seeing that people are doing things, seeing how they can change the world through their gifts is incredibly important. So we shouldn't look at it just as, you know, the billions of dollars that Mackenzie and Melinda have, even though they're huge, but it's their impact on other women that, you know, is incredibly important. And we also know from the research that Women influence more than men, you know, what the children in the family do. And usually men listen to what the women in the family are saying about the causes that they want to give to and those kinds of things. So, you know, I think this movement is going to have a lot of ripple effects.

Tony MartignettiAndrew, well, first, thank you for answering the second half of my question, which I obliterated and forgot about. So I'm a podcaster, not a journalist. What— say a little more, would you, about artificial intelligence? We've had several shows on this. We've had folks from NTEN like Amy Sample Ward, but also authors like Afua Bruce. You know, say a little more about what you're looking at, what you're thinking about around AI and nonprofits.

Andrew SimonSure. The first thing I would say is, for those who are listening, please do follow the work of Sarah Hershander, Rashida Childress. They, they're 2 of our reporters who've been covering AI pretty closely, at least in recent months. And I'm sure we've had reporters before I got here on that beat as well. It's, you know, it's been interesting. Again, in certain cases, some of the technology companies have been directly trying to, you know, I think with seemingly with the right intentions, help you know, support and underwrite AI experimentation with nonprofits, right? So that does feed again some hope and optimism that AI can help certain nonprofits operate more efficiently, innovate. So there's excitement there. But as I alluded to before, there, there are the risks that come with AI. There's the fact that it's not a perfect technology yet. So I think that's an interesting tension too, right? That where we have technology companies and those who are creating the technology, you know, really encouraging it, the use of it for nonprofits and the implications there. And then on the fundraising side, there was a recent story about an AI fundraiser, you know, to the point where there's an avatar that a potential donor sees and is interacting with and helps them guide— helps guide them through the note to the donation process. And there's just something that's interesting and wacky and even a little scary about that, right? And yet, is this where we're going with fundraising? Is this where nonprofits are going to go? Will this be the future? I think it's a question at this point, but a fascinating one.

Tony MartignettiOh, as an over-the-top relationship fundraiser, I, I, it's, it's hard. It's a question. I know you're not answering, you're asking. You're asking a question, but even the question hurts me. And I work in planned giving, so I work with folks in their mostly 70s, 80s, and 90s, you know, and the thought of them being guided by, I don't know, a fundraising avatar is, I mean, these are folks writing checks, you know, and not even credit card. They don't trust online even, you know, just a simple putting my credit card in an online form. Yeah. All right. Anything else that you want to leave us with, either of you?

Andrew SimonI would say a word about The Commons and that body of work. It's a project that started back in April, and a lot of credit to Stacy Palmer, senior editor Drew Lindsay, and others on the team for getting it off the ground. And the intention of The Commons, it was really for The Chronicle to take a A close look at polarization, philanthropy's role in it, both in the solutions that are available, but also has philanthropy been detrimental? Has it been causing, inciting polarization in any way? So really asking some hard questions around, again, philanthropy's role in polarization, but also talking about ideas and solutions and what's happening that is helping to bridge divides. And in this current moment, we're hoping that it really provides value to our readers, right? I mean, Stacy, you feel free to chime in here. Back when you launched the commons, I imagine there was thinking about, well, what does an X administration like, what does a Y administration look like? And then also the calculus of being, we might be facing polarization regardless of the election outcome. And certainly here we are. And I'm sure our readers are reading about this notion of a resistance And there are real questions around, you know, will funders support a resistance? I say that in quotation marks. I mean, some are using that word, some are maybe not using that word. Will some be a little more hesitant to fund a resistance? I think there's some emotional drain right now from some members of the resistance. So there are just some fascinating questions about democracy efforts, polarization efforts. Will they continue to receive support? And yet the vibe, for lack of a better word, is that it's still tense right now. I don't know that polarization is going away anytime soon. So I just would encourage readers to not just follow the comments, but contribute ideas, write us notes, tell us what you think. We received a really interesting letter in one of our first post-election reaction pieces, which wasn't so specifically about the comments, but I think it captures the spirit of the comments where Our election— one of our election reaction pieces had the terminology was progressive nonprofits are, you know, really terrified because of the results and conservative ones are celebrating. And there was this powerful short letter from a nonprofit leader saying, I don't know, I don't call myself progressive and I don't call myself conservative either, right? That there are organizations working somewhere in between and What, what does the election mean for us? You know, we, we, we're, we're sort of feeling a little nervy too, and yet I wouldn't call our mission progressive per se. So it's just, it's a long way of saying that I think polarization, it, it's here. Um, it's vexing for, I think, both grantmakers and nonprofits, and we're here to hopefully help, uh, leaders, you know, guide them through it.

Tony MartignettiWhat's the structure of the commons? Is that something folks can participate in? I'm not familiar with it.

Stacy PalmerSo it's a special section on our website that you can see on the navigation bar that collects all of the opinion articles, deeply reported pieces. We do something called LinkedIn Commons in Conversation. You know, right after the election, I talked to Joel Goldman, the head of Democracy Fund, who's working on these issues. Right after Thanksgiving, I'll be talking to Judy Rudruff about the series that she's been doing, Americans at a Crossroads. So, you know, we have all kinds of things happening in the commons focused on this issue of, you know, how can nonprofits play a role in healing divides of all kinds, not just politics, geography, race, gender, age, all of the things that are dividing this country. And when we started the commons, we knew that, you know, it was a little bit dangerous to launch it in April only because we were afraid that it would suggest that it was just a project for the election. And we knew this country is so divided that this is going to be a very long-term effort that nonprofits and foundations need to work on. So we're committed to doing that. We very much welcome ideas from the audience. There's a LinkedIn newsletter that people can sign up for, in addition to a special edition once a week that comes out in our Philanthropy Today newsletter. All of that's available free to people to be able to sign up for and circulate. But that's, I think, an expression of how we see ourselves as a nonprofit now that we're more actively engaged in tackling some of the big problems that are facing the field. and saying, here are the tools and solutions to deal with them. So, you know, what we're looking at too is, you know, what is the next commons? What is the other topics that we'll go into, um, with a deep dive? Um, so we welcome suggestions on that too.

Tony MartignettiAnd if our listeners want to make suggestions, where do they do that?

Stacy PalmerUm, best thing is to write to Andrew or to me. Um, I'll give my email address first. I'm stacy.palmer@nonprofitradio.org.

Andrew Simonandrew.simon@philanthropy.com. And then we also have a general letter to the editor type inbox. I believe it's editormail@philanthropy.com. So any of those places are great.

Tony MartignettiOkay, we have direct lines to the, uh, the CEO and the editor-in-chief. All right, I want to thank you both. Thanks very much.

Stacy PalmerThank you so much for your interest. We appreciate it and for all the work you do for the sector.

Tony MartignettiOh, it's, it's, it's a pleasure. A, a, a labor of love.

Kate MartignettiNext week, the art and science of fundraising with James Misner. If you missed any part of this week's show,

Tony MartignettiI beseech you,

Kate Martignettifind it at tonymartignetti.com. We're sponsored by DonorBox. Outdated donation forms blocking your supporters' generosity? DonorBox Fast, flexible, and friendly fundraising forms for your nonprofit. Donorbox.org. Our creative producer is Claire Meyerhoff. I'm your associate producer Kate Martignetti. The show's social media is by Susan Chavez. Marc Silverman is our web guy, and this music is by Scott Stein.

Tony MartignettiThank you for that. I got that permission, Scotty. Be with us next week for Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. Go out and be great. Go out and be great.

Nonprofit Radio