Skip to content
EP 692May 26, 2024

Strategic Meetings For Teams Of One & Cyber Incident Cases And Takeaways

Tony MartignettiJanice ChanSteve Sharer
Nonprofit Radio
Episode 692
0:00 / 0:00

Strategic Meetings For Teams Of One

As our 2024 Nonprofit Technology Conference coverage continues, Janice Chan returns with the savvy idea of adapting team meeting principles to a team of just one. She’ll have you thinking of yourself as a team leader, rather than one person doing everything. Janice is at Shift and Scaffold.

Cyber Incident Cases And Takeaways

We’ve got good stories about bad actors. You’ll also hear the practical steps your nonprofit can take to prepare for cybersecurity incidents to reduce their impact. And we'll empower you to hold incident prep discussions with your leadership or staff. Steve Sharer, who says "Security is a team sport," joins from RipRap Security. This is also from 24NTC.

Here’s the transcript

Tony MartignettiHello and welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. I'm your aptly named host and the podfather of your favorite hebdomadal podcast. Oh, I'm glad you're with us. I'd suffer the effects of formication if you made my skin crawl with the idea that you missed this week's show. And if you think I said fornication, get your head out of the gutter, close the Pornhub window. It's formication. Here's our associate producer Kate to introduce this week's show.

Kate MartignettiHey Tony, we have Strategic Meetings for Teams of One. As our 2024 Nonprofit Technology Conference coverage continues, Janice Chan returns with the savvy idea of adapting team meeting principles to a team of just one. She'll have you thinking of yourself as a team leader rather than one person doing everything. Janice is at Shift and Scaffold. And cyber incident cases and takeaways. We've got good stories about bad actors. You'll also hear the practical steps your nonprofit can take to prepare for cybersecurity incidents to reduce their impact, and we'll empower you to hold incident prep discussions with your leadership or staff. Steve Sharer, who says security is a team sport, joins from RipRap Security. This is also from 24 NTC. On Tony's Take Two.

Tony MartignettiDelightful, nostalgic women's names.

Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by Virtuous. Virtuous gives you the nonprofit CRM Fundraising, volunteer, and marketing tools you need to create more responsive donor experiences and grow giving. Virtuous.org. And by DonorBox. Outdated donation forms blocking your supporters' generosity? DonorBox. Fast, flexible, and friendly fundraising forms for your nonprofit. DonorBox.org. Here is Strategic Meetings for Teams of One.

Tony MartignettiWelcome back to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio coverage of the 3rd day of the 2024 Nonprofit Technology Conference. We are all together in Portland, Oregon. Nonprofit Radio coverage of the conference is sponsored by Heller Consulting, technology strategy and implementation for nonprofits. With me for this conversation, an NTC perennial for Nonprofit Radio, Janice Chan. You knew she was coming. She's director of Shift and Scaffold. Janice, welcome back to Nonprofit Radio after many NTC appearances.

Janice ChanMany thanks for having me back, Tony. Always good to see you and talk with you.

Tony MartignettiThank you. It's a pleasure as well for me.

Janice ChanTo be here in person with you.

Tony MartignettiIndeed.

Janice ChanNot just on Zoom.

Tony MartignettiWe always— yes. Yes. This year your session topic is Strategic Team Meetings for Teams of One.

Janice ChanYes, indeed.

Tony MartignettiAll right. Before we get into that, I want to talk a little about— I knew that— I remembered, I was reminded that you were studying Japanese. When I read it, I had remembered from previous years. Now you live in Japan.

Janice ChanYes, I have been studying Japanese because my husband and I were realized— not realized, but we had decided to take this job opportunity for him, which was based in Tokyo. And so we're like, all right, we should start trying to learn the language. So, you know, it'd be helpful to live there if we're going to live there. And so, yeah, so we moved about a year and a half ago in 2022. Some delays due to the pandemic, but it's been great so far. And yeah, working at learning the language at the place that I live in.

Tony MartignettiI'm sure living there helps quite a bit. Absolutely. You're immersed. Is English very common or not so much?

Janice ChanYou can definitely get around Tokyo in English. Outside of Tokyo, a bit harder. I think they did a lot of things to prepare for the Olympics when they were supposed to be there in 2020. And, you know, in terms of the train signage and things like that. So

Tony Martignettiyou could get by?

Janice ChanYou can get by.

Tony MartignettiIn the city?

Janice ChanIn the city, actually, Japanese people in school study English for several years, but, you know, studying in school is always a little different than talking to native speakers. So I'm having the experience in reverse of going to class and then attempting conversations and then often just mangling my way through it. But people are very kind.

Tony MartignettiYou're attempting.

Janice ChanI'm working at it.

Tony MartignettiPeople appreciate the outreach.

Janice ChanThey're happy to work with me too, which is nice and really helpful.

Tony MartignettiDo you have children? Did you bring children abroad?

Janice ChanNo, we brought our cat, our 18-year-old grandma cat.

Tony MartignettiOh my, 18.

Janice ChanShe's lovely and sassy.

Tony MartignettiStill at 18?

Janice ChanShe's still sassy. She's more sassy now, I think.

Tony MartignettiWell, I know some sassy 80 and 90-year-olds. Yeah, so it's fitting. So yes, not surprising. All right. And I also want folks to know that if you want to see some beautiful photography, go to shiftandscaffold.com.

Janice ChanOh, thank you.

Tony MartignettiBecause you have one stunning one too. There are several, but the one from the Metropolitan Museum. Oh,

Janice Chanthat was my favorite.

Tony MartignettiThe windows, the reflection, the park is in the background, and that room. Yeah. Is that the Egyptian room?

Janice ChanThat's the Egyptian room.

Tony MartignettiYeah. So there are many great photos at Shift and Scaffold that Janice Took. Yeah, these are yours. Yeah.

Janice ChanThank you.

Tony MartignettiAll right, so let's talk about team meetings for teams of one.

Janice ChanYes.

Tony MartignettiWhat was the genesis for this intuition, this creative burst? Redefinition, that's what I want. Resurgent, redefinition. Defining, redefining one to be a team.

Janice ChanSo, whether— even when I've been in-house, and now I'm an independent consultant, and so I work for myself, but even when I was in-house, a lot of times I was the only person who did the technology, who did the knowledge management, who did the training sometimes. And so, I spent basically my entire career mostly being a team of one. And I, you know, there are certain practices and things that I've done over time that I find really helpful. Right. in that because sometimes I don't always have somebody to bounce things off of. Or sometimes when I do, they have a really— they don't have the same background that I do, right? So, they have a really different perspective, which is useful. But sometimes I'm like, I just got to figure things out for myself. There's nobody setting the strategy. Like, my boss is a development director and I'm doing database management, for example. Right. They're supportive, but they don't actually understand my day-to-day work. And so I need to do a lot of that strategic work by myself. And there were some of these practices I developed over time. And one of them was that I would meet with myself. Sorry.

Tony MartignettiBefore you have these good practices, which we will absolutely get to, when did you start to think of yourself as a team?

Janice ChanAs a team? How

Tony Martignettidid that emerge?

Janice ChanProbably So I remember, I don't know why this sticks in my head so much. I had this phone call with this director at my organization at the time. And I was supposed to help her team with some, and she had a team of like, you know, actual other people. She had about 7 people on her team. And I was the grant writer at the time. And so she was like, Straight to the whole thing. There's, we have some opportunities, there's some partners we talked to. And, you know, I'd love if we could get your help on applying these grants. We have the opportunity to apply for these grants in multiple states, but they're all due at the same time. And she was like, maybe you can get some help from your team. And I was like, listen, I am the team. You are talking to the entire team. I am the grant writing team. So, in addition to my other jobs.

Tony MartignettiSo, it was kind of foisted on you, the redefinition.

Janice ChanYeah, exactly. Exactly.

Tony MartignettiTalk to you, get some support from your team. Yeah. That's fascinating.

Janice ChanThe rest of myself.

Tony MartignettiYeah. All right. All right. So, your best practices. These are things you've been doing through the years for yourself, for your— in your work?

Janice ChanYeah. So, a lot of times, often, you know, either at times when I really needed to, say, plan for the year, or I'm about to take on a big project or start something new, or I really wanted to maybe make some changes, Often I would kind of set aside some time and just sort of be with myself, but I would take notes during that time, right? I would have a little like, okay, here's the thing that I want to work on for this hour or 2 hours or something, right? I need to plan out 2024, or I need to figure out how to work with that stakeholder who is, you know, I've got some stakeholders that I have to manage and I'm trying to get them on board. I'm kind of trying to come up with some strategies for that. And I'm kind of sitting down and having a little meeting with myself.

Tony MartignettiWith an agenda.

Janice ChanWith an agenda, because I would be like, wait, what was I supposed to focus on for this hour? Right? And so it's like a little reminder to myself. And I've always been a note-taker. And so it's just kind of a thing that I kept doing. And then I would do it for like planning my week. I would do it for like reflecting on things at the end of the month. And I was talking to someone, and I realized that maybe some other people do it, but not everybody thinks of it that way. And it was really helpful that I ended up just taking things that I sometimes did in meetings with other people. I was like, oh, you know what? This is really helpful to take notes this way, or whatever it is. Mm-hmm. And then I would do that when I was still doing it just by myself. So that's kind of where it came out of.

Tony MartignettiOkay. What else should we be doing with our team of one?

Janice ChanSo, to back it up a little bit, part of— I didn't really think a lot about the practice of meeting with yourself in that I didn't necessarily articulate it. I was just like, oh, this is what you do, right?

Tony MartignettiYou had a to-do list. You certainly had a to-do list, but you didn't think of devoted time. To specific tasks?

Janice ChanWell, I did, but I think I didn't think of it as maybe a thing that other people didn't think of. And I was at— so I also like to do creative writing. I was at this conference last year for creative writing, and I talked to someone and they were like, so I told my new manager that I don't start work before 10. She works from 10 to 7. But I don't start work before 10 because the first 2 hours of my morning are dedicated for writing. That's my writing time. And I realized— so I live in Japan and I work with clients in the US. And so sometimes I wake up really early for meetings. I have meetings at like 6 in the morning, sometimes 5 in the morning. But on days when I don't have super early meetings, you know, I'd still wake up. My body just wakes up at that time now. Right. Hmm. But I would just stay in bed, scroll through my phone or something. I wasn't doing anything with that time. And why would I get out of bed for clients or for other commitments, but I wouldn't do that for myself and for my own work, my own creative writing, et cetera? And I think so recently, the end of last year, I was like, all right, I'm going to really Make this a regular practice. Yeah, and I thought it would be a really interesting session and tool to share with other people at the NTEN community as well.

Tony MartignettiOkay, okay. Other, I don't know, other tactics for making— you say tactics to make time for strategic work as a team of one.

Janice ChanYeah, absolutely.

Tony MartignettiYou gotta take care of yourself. You gotta take care of your team. You've got to take care of your team of one.

Janice ChanExactly. So, I think a lot of this— so, there's tools and strategies, and then there's the mindset. And so, maybe I'll talk about the mindset first and then talk tools and strategies. But I think sort of as that team of one—

Tony MartignettiA decent host would have asked you about the mindset first. You're suffering a lackluster host.

Janice ChanNo, you're totally—

Tony MartignettiYou think the host would ask about the mindset And the culture of the team of one first before you get into the tactics and strategies.

Janice ChanIt's okay. That's why we're here, right?

Tony MartignettiIt's tragic. It's tragic. It's to learn. Yes. We're all still learning.

Janice ChanAnd I think a lot of times where we start is when we want to do something better, we're like, oh, what are the tactics for doing it better?

Tony MartignettiWhat are the 5 tips?

Janice ChanWhat's the technical stuff and not the culture? organizational culture or the mindset, all the internal work that we need to do when we work with people or work with ourselves. And so I think one of the— I don't remember what started it, but last year I had this epiphany one day of like, wait, who's leading my team? Like, nobody's leading my team. Wait, it's supposed to be me and I've not been leading my team. And it was a really big Sort of like flipping the lights switch on in my head. And I think realizing also whether I've been an independent consultant or when I was in-house, right? Yes, I could run around and do all of the things and I would do all the things, but not necessarily in a— I think I assumed that because I was the same person, that it was cohesive and coordinated, right? And it was like in the same, you know, in a unified direction. Right.

Tony MartignettiRight. You're only one person.

Janice ChanRight. So, of course, clearly, right?

Tony MartignettiGoing in the same direction as myself.

Janice ChanI would think.

Tony MartignettiYeah.

Janice ChanAnd then I realized at one point, I was like, I don't think that's actually the case. And part of that—

Tony MartignettiWhat did that feel like? When you felt like you were not going in a unified direction?

Janice ChanI felt really scattered. I felt like, okay, I'm doing these things 'Cause I, it seemed like a good idea at the time, or like you're supposed to post more regularly on social media, or you're supposed to, I don't know, go out and meet people and network and things like that. But I wasn't necessarily doing them all in a unified direction. And I realized that I was doing sort of like the different job functions.

Tony MartignettiYeah.

Janice ChanLike, you know, business development and content development and like, you know, my consulting work and things. And, but I wasn't sort of doing the work to actually unify them intentionally. We understand that. And so part of that was I didn't necessarily think of myself as a team or as a business or as an organization. I just like, I'm just Janice. I'm just showing up and doing the things. And that works. You can get away with that for a time. But I think also, and you see this also in people when they go from being an individual contributor to being a manager, or they kind of step from the, I'm just doing the things that my boss told me to do, to now I have to set the direction, even if I don't have any direct reports. Mm-hmm. And I think Really, I realized that it was— I was kind of lacking that direction and I hadn't made the time or really put into place the practices to do that on a regular basis, that I wasn't leading my own team and that spot was kind of vacant. And I think that's a really big shift, especially in small organizations where a lot of times you just get thrown into like, hey, we need you to do— you're like hired for communications, let's say. And you're the only communications person. Right. And so, you're doing the writing, you're doing the graphic design, you're doing all the digital things, and then you're just fielding whatever people think is your job, honestly, a lot of the time. And there's no— if nobody is trying to make all of that cohesive for, say, your external audiences, right? Yeah. Who's managing the stakeholders? Who is making sure there's a cohesive cohesive strategy, you know, it starts to— you're not as effective for your organization. And some of that is it's easy to get caught up in all the urgent stuff. But some of it is also just, I think that a big part of that mindset shift is we don't respect ourselves as leaders, as teams, in the same way that we respect other leaders and teams, right? Right. So like, you know, this meeting with you, Tony, right? Like we had, there wasn't a time to show up here, right? There was a process, there's things going on. You know, I noticed that I would show up to meetings with other people differently.

Tony MartignettiInteresting.

Janice ChanVersus like, I will reschedule things on myself all the time. And I'm not going to say that I don't still do that, right? But I think just being more conscious of like, okay, I've Pushed aside, pushed aside my time that I set aside to do the strategic work, and I'm putting out fires for other people because they're urgent, you know, and that happens a lot. But I think that the— I think especially, especially, especially in the social impact space, right, a lot of us, like, we want to make things better for other people. We care about other people. Those requests that other people are making are not unreasonable. Right. But it can also be really hard to, you know, especially for those of us who were taught to like put other people first or that we exist for the community, not only for ourselves, right? And that's a very common ethos in the nonprofit space, as makes sense. And also, you know, depending on who we are, I'm a woman, I'm the daughter of immigrants. And so There are a lot of things that when somebody comes to me and asks me for my help to do something, right? Like, I'm like, oh, like, let me figure out how I can help you. And it's easy to keep putting my stuff on the back burner, put my stuff on the back burner. But then that builds up over time. So if you're the only— let's say you're the entire technology team at your organization, you're single team of one. Right. Then if you don't make the time to do the strategic work, your organization's not gonna be able to use technology effectively, strategically and effectively. You know, your organization's gonna be a little bit hamstrung in advancing the mission because you're not carving that time out and you're not respecting the, the time and the energy you need for that.

Kate MartignettiIt's time for a break. Virtuous is a software company committed to helping nonprofits grow generosity. Virtuous believes that generosity has the power to create profound change in the world and in the heart of the giver. It's their mission to move the needle on global generosity by helping nonprofits better connect with and inspire their givers. Responsive fundraising puts the donor at the center of fundraising. And grows giving through personalized donor journeys that respond to the needs of each individual. Virtuous is the only responsive nonprofit CRM designed to help you build deeper relationships with every donor at scale. Virtuous gives you the nonprofit CRM, fundraising, volunteer, marketing, and automation tools you need to create responsive experiences that build trust. And Grow Impact, virtuous.org. Now back to Strategic Meetings for Teams of One with Janice Chan.

Tony MartignettiIt's interesting, really, the realization that you treat others better than you treat yourself. Essentially, you treat others' work more importantly And more respectfully than you treat your own. It's common in the sector. Putting off your own time, putting off your own tasks. Yeah. Yeah. Minimizing your own needs. Right.

Janice ChanIt only affects me.

Tony MartignettiFor the good of the other. Right. It's just, yeah, I'll get to it. You wouldn't do that for somebody. You wouldn't procrastinate like that. You wouldn't put off the work of others. that you might have been asked to do, or that, you know, as an individual, as a solo consultant, you realize you need to do. You wouldn't do that to your clients or to your organization where you're a team of one. You wouldn't do that, but you'll do it for your own stuff.

Janice ChanYeah, absolutely.

Tony MartignettiSo we need to shift that around. This is the mindset that we're talking about.

Janice ChanThis is the mindset. And, you know, and some of that I just completely lost my train of thought. That's all right.

Tony MartignettiThat's all right. That's right. I think, well, you made the point and I just was underlining it. All right.

Janice ChanAppreciate that.

Tony MartignettiSo how about some of the other things that you do besides have agendas for your solo time? What are some other tips?

Janice ChanYeah. So a lot of the things that are about running effective meetings, And I know we all have this joke about meetings that should be emails, but I think there are times when it's important to— when the meeting is the right tool, when you're making a decision, you're trying to get alignment, or you're doing something where dialogue is essential to moving forward with care, often, you know, to building relationships and maintaining trust. And so, A lot of the things that are crucial for effective meetings with other people are also useful when you're by yourself meeting with yourself. The agenda, taking notes, keeping track of decisions that were made, keeping track of the action items, you know, not just in the notes, but hopefully in whatever project management tool or however you normally keep track of your action items. I would say the big difference when you're meeting with yourself is, of course, there's not, you know, in most meeting notes, at least the way I take them in a group, I note down like who is attending the meeting, right? Like there were people we invited to the meeting. We've made sure there was somebody from finance and someone from programs and someone from fundraising or whatever. And when you're meeting with yourself, you're like, oh yeah, like I don't need to. It's just Janice, right? Right. And something that I find helpful that's different for meeting with yourself is to think about the different roles that you need at that meeting. Because I— this is— so this is a pet peeve I have of meeting in meetings with other people where they're like, okay, we finished the agenda for, let's say, the project status update or whatever. Actually, this is the same group of people that You know, for the data working group. So, could we just, like, throw that in right now? Right? And then you're like, I—

Tony MartignettiThat's a total mind shift.

Janice ChanYeah, it's a total mind shift. I didn't prepare. I, like, I'm not ready. Like, and also now this was, like, an hour-long meeting that was going to finish faster. And now you've just, like, messed with my head because now we're going to be here for an hour and a half. Right? And so, and I think not part of respecting yourself, right, is to not do that to yourself either. And so being clear about what is the purpose of this meeting. We use different meeting types for different purposes, right? It's very different that we're like a strategic planning meeting and a project planning meeting and a team general team weekly meeting should not look and feel the same. You're not doing the same thing. Right. things. And similarly, when we're meeting with ourselves, let's not do that to ourselves either. Yeah. And so naming those roles, like who needs to be there. So, you know, if I am the communications team, and I am the writer, and the graphic designer, and the digital person, and also the communications director leading the team, Right? Are all of the— have all of those roles been represented in that time and space? And even if it's like something simpler, like as an independent consultant, right? Is it consultant me? Is it business owner me? You know, or at a more basic level, is it decision maker me or implementer me? Because if it's only implementation, that's just like me writing the report. It's not I'm not making decisions. This is not a meeting. I'm just working on something. So I think calling attention to those is a key difference that I would say for meetings with yourself.

Tony MartignettiI like the idea of different roles because I think it helps make you accountable for the different areas of responsibility that you have. And not only areas of responsibility, but individual tasks that you have. Absolutely. The business development person is going to come down on the writer who hasn't done a blog post for 6 weeks.

Janice ChanYes.

Tony MartignettiRight? So I see an accountability role.

Janice ChanYeah, absolutely. I love that, calling that out.

Tony MartignettiAnything else you want to share about this? Yes, okay. Oh, please. Yeah.

Janice ChanSo, I think there are a lot of different— like, let's be real, right? We only have so many hours in the day. But more importantly, we only have so much mental energy and mental capacity for things, right? And so, part of that, you know, it's some tools and tactics for protecting your time. It might be things like no meeting Tuesdays, or it might be the last Friday of the month is always dedicated to strategic work. So I think some of it is like making time and actually putting it on your calendar to do that work, right? Um, and it's helpful if like your whole organization does

Tony Martignettiit. And put it in the calendar.

Janice ChanPut it in the calendar.

Tony MartignettiThis is your— this is, this is important time.

Janice ChanExactly.

Tony MartignettiJust like you would do for a meeting with 3 other people.

Janice ChanRight. So, if you need, you know, sometimes life happens, you need to reschedule, but reschedule it. Don't just like cross it off the list and then never come back to it.

Tony MartignettiYeah.

Janice ChanAnd, you know, there are also other things that, you know, I think that the time thing is one thing, right? There's only so many hours, but that's also more, a little bit more straightforward in some ways. It's much harder to protect your mental brain space to do strategic work. So for example, like, I'm an introvert. I like people. I love hanging out with people at NDC. And also, like, at the end of the conference day, I go back to my hotel room and I'm like, I just need some quiet time for a little bit.

Tony MartignettiYeah.

Janice ChanBut also, I know that at the end of the day, like, I can expect of myself to do strategic work, right? Like, maybe I reply to emails or something, but I'm not going back and, like, planning out some major initiative at night. Because it's not realistic of where, how tired my brain is. And so I think that's harder because that's also individual, right? What works for one person isn't going to work for another person. And so some of that is figuring out what you need to be able to get into that, to have that spaciousness to do the strategic work and to figure out, you know, how to ask for that for your team. Mm-hmm. Um, and, you know, that could be things like— it could be things like the No Meeting Tuesdays or working from home instead of working in the office. But it could also be things like, you know what, I need to go for a walk. I need to actually— when I'm doing this type of work, I need to not be at my regular desk. I need to be in a physically different location so I can get into a different mindset than my day-to-day putting out fires at the office. Sometimes it might be just like, you know, knowing that your team knowing that, like, hey, the first hour of my day every day, that's like, I do not take meetings, right? Like, I'm working, but I do not take meetings so that I can make sure I do the important work, whatever it might be. So it's really helpful to ask Make sure that you're asking your boss or your team or your colleagues for that and making that clear. But in doing that, you're also modeling that for other people as well.

Tony MartignettiAs you honor yourself.

Janice ChanExactly.

Tony MartignettiAnd your team.

Janice ChanYes. Yes. There's nobody else to advocate for you. You go out and do it. You know, I mean, if you've— if that team leader role has been empty, that means there's no one else. That means you need to step into that role. So, you know, I told people in the session, give yourself that promotion already if you haven't.

Tony MartignettiHow about we leave it right there? That's perfect.

Janice ChanWonderful.

Tony MartignettiGive yourself that promotion if you haven't. She's Janice Chan, director at Shift and Scaffold, shiftandscaffold.com. Always a pleasure. I hope to see you 2025. You think you might come, come back?

Janice ChanThat's the hope. I hope— I'm hoping I will see you all in 2025.

Tony MartignettiBaltimore.

Janice ChanYeah, my old, my old home city.

Tony MartignettiIt'll be a little closer for you.

Janice ChanYeah, absolutely.

Tony Martignetti5 hours closer. All right, your old home city. That's right, you've— Baltimore.

Janice ChanI used to live in Baltimore for many years.

Tony MartignettiAll right, so look forward to seeing you. I know you'll have a good topic. I don't have to say have a good topic. I appreciate that. You will. You will. All right.

Janice ChanThanks so much, Tony.

Tony MartignettiMy pleasure. Thanks for sharing, Janice. And thank you for sharing in our conversation about teams of one. Where we're sponsored by Heller Consulting, technology implementation and strategy for nonprofits.

Kate MartignettiIt's time for a break. DonorBox. Open up new cashless in-person donation opportunities with DonorBox Live Kiosk, the smart way to accept cashless donations anywhere, anytime. Picture this, a cash-free onsite giving solution that effortlessly collects donations from credit cards, debit cards, and digital wallets. No team member required. Plus, your donation data is automatically synced with your DonorBox account. No manual data entry or errors. Make giving a breeze. And focus on what matters— your cause. Try DonorBox Live Kiosk and revolutionize the way you collect donations. Visit donorbox.org to learn more. It's time for Tony's Take Two.

Tony MartignettiAlice, Antoinette, Bernice, Charlotte, Constance, Deirdre. Thank you, Kate. These are some of the delightful names that I've kept on a personal list for years now of women in their 70s, 80s, 90s, and there's even one who was 100 years old on the list. And I just, I just get nostalgic over names that are so uncommon now. I mean, these are women who were born in the 1930s and '40s. So not surprisingly, you know, names change, of course. But I don't know, the names just move me. And so I've been keeping this personal list. And I did, I posted some of it on LinkedIn. And I Thought I would share some of it today. The you know it's it's the names, and but it's also the women's stories. You know, growing up in the 1930s, 1940s, 50s in the United States, what that was like. You know, education-wise, for some some women went on beyond high school. A lot did not. Some women went on to marry and have families, and some did not. So it's, you know, it's the combination of the stories, and I guess the richness of the stories makes me love their names as well. And just as I said, you know, get nostalgic for these names that we just don't see anymore, like Geraldine, Gertrude, Gussie, Hazel, Jacqueline, Lenore. Lottie, Mabel, Marlene, Maxine, Minnie, Myrna, Ophelia, Penelope, Rochelle, Selma, Veronica. All right, I've got a lot more on my list, but that's just a sample of Names that I find delightful, and I get nostalgic about them. Have you got any? If if if you want to contribute your mom's name or your grandmother's name, or maybe your own name, let me know. Love to hear it. Tony at TonyMartinetti.com. Let's see if the names you know are on my list. That is Tony's Take Two. Kate?

Kate MartignettiI would like to add Carmela, both with one L and then one with 2 L's.

Tony MartignettiYes. All right, so share why the name Carmela is important to you.

Kate MartignettiBecause I had a great-grandmother— you might know better than me, but But that I'm, you know, my name is, my first name is Carmela.

Tony MartignettiWell, I know that, but listeners, listeners could very well not know that your name is Carmela Kate Martignetti. Carmela, and then Kate is, is short.

Kate MartignettiYes.

Tony MartignettiWhich I never understood. I don't know how Kate is short for Carmela.

Kate MartignettiBecause I have a—

Tony MartignettiCarmel. I could see Carmel. What?

Kate MartignettiI have an Aunt Kate. But I have like a grandmother Carmel.

Tony MartignettiRight. So

Kate Martignettithey're two

Tony Martignettidifferent— they're two different women. So how does— because Kate is not your middle name.

Kate MartignettiNo, it's not. Anne is my middle name. Like, great-grandmother Anne.

Tony MartignettiRight. Well, there's your great-grandmother Anne, who was my grandmother, right? This Carmela was on your other side, on your mom's side of the family. I didn't know. I didn't know Carmela. I don't know. I'm happy to call you Kate. Although, you know, I often call you Carmela as well, because nobody else does. So I like to be different. And I think it's a beautiful name. But Kate being short for Carmela, I don't know.

Kate MartignettiIt doesn't—

Tony Martignettino, it's been 21 years. It's never made sense to me.

Kate MartignettiWell, we've got beaucoup, but loads more time. Here is Cyber Incident Cases and Takeaways.

Tony MartignettiHello and welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio's continuing coverage of the 2024 Nonprofit Technology Conference in Portland, Oregon. We are all convened at the Oregon Convention Center in downtown Portland, and Nonprofit Radio is This episode is sponsored at the convention— at the conference by Heller Consulting, technology strategy and implementation for nonprofits. With me now to have a conversation is Steve Sharer. He is CEO and co-founder of RipRap Security. Steve, welcome to Nonprofit Radio.

Steve SharerYeah, thanks for having me.

Tony MartignettiMy pleasure. Have you done your session?

Steve SharerI have done my session. We were the first— in the first session on the first day.

Tony MartignettiAll right. So you set the bar high.

Steve SharerI tried.

Tony MartignettiI feel bad for the presenters that came after you.

Steve SharerOh, thank you, thank you.

Tony MartignettiAnd we just met a few minutes ago, and I already know that you set the bar high, gave quite a challenge to the presenters that succeeded you. Your topic is cyber incident preparation and what we can learn from real-world incidents. So it sounds like you are bringing some stories that we all are glad that did not happen to us. Maybe these are major headline stories. I don't know. Maybe these are some of the big ones, but we can take some things away.

Steve SharerYeah, exactly.

Tony MartignettiOkay. Okay. Why did you feel the need for this session?

Steve SharerYeah, so I run a cybersecurity consulting company that's focused on mission-driven driven and purpose-driven organizations and helping them improve their cybersecurity. And one of the key ways that we start working with new clients is that they call us and they say, hey, my house is on fire. We've experienced an incident. We need help. And so, we go and we help them. And when we go in and we've never met them before, and they don't— they've not really prepared for an incident, the incident is much more severe. Right. incurring a lot more losses. They have a lot— it's all very— it's all much more stressful, and the chance of recovery is lower than if they had prepared ahead of time to deal with an incident. All right. And so the talk is all about how organizations can prepare ahead of time to make it less stressful, to make it cost less to respond to an incident, and really reduce the impact of incidents that happen to the organization.

Tony MartignettiOkay. I don't think I've I've thought about that, or I haven't heard it said that way, that you can make it less impactful, less of a crisis by preparing. What I've heard is you should prepare because you can— while you can never eliminate the possibility, you can greatly reduce the possibility of being attacked, having an incident yourself. But you can actually make it less of a crisis.

Steve SharerExactly.

Tony MartignettiWith preparation. Okay. Excellent. Excellent. Are we just going to share a bunch of unfortunate stories and take away lessons from each one? Yeah, yeah.

Steve SharerIs that the best way? Yeah, maybe we can talk through some of the best practices, and I can weave in some stories here and there.

Tony MartignettiOkay. Okay. So why don't we start with some of your best advice?

Steve SharerSure. So I think the primary thing that you want to do is when you're preparing for an incident is really ensure that you have really good buy-in from your stakeholders inside your organization. People that are working in the marketing and communications portion, senior leadership, members of the board, so that they're involved in the planning and the preparation process, so that when you do have an incident, they're not caught by surprise. This is not the first they're hearing about how to deal with an incident. And so, you know, we tend for organizations that have not prepared, we end up spending a lot of time trying to brief the senior leadership and the board about what happening, and they're very nervous, and they don't let the people responding to the incident have time to actually respond to the incident.

Tony MartignettiAnd part of what they don't have in place is a management plan for this crisis.

Steve SharerExactly.

Tony MartignettiRight? I mean, if it's become public, now we have a PR issue. So who's the public-facing voice? Is it our— is it a Is it a crisis communicator that we knew we would hire in an emergency, or are we scrambling for that? Should it be the CEO? Should it be the board chair? Exactly. Should it be the chief technologist, if we have one? Our audience is small and mid-sized nonprofits, so the likelihood that they have someone devoted to tech is off and on. Certainly not 100% don't. But a lot don't. So, who should even be the voice? And then what should we be saying? Exactly. How much should we be telling the public and our stakeholders? So, all right. So, we need to have a plan in place as well as managing the expectations, like you're saying, of the board. Exactly. The C-suite.

Steve SharerRight.

Tony MartignettiAll right. All right.

Steve SharerYeah.

Tony MartignettiAll right. What else?

Steve SharerI think another important thing is really clearly define roles and responsibilities of who's going to be involved and when When should they be involved in an incident? Right. So, you touched on it already, is when do we bring in the CEO or the board to talk with the public on our behalf? Or, hey, when does it make sense to not have them do that? Who is responsible for taking the operational steps to respond to the incident, the hands-on keyboard, very technical investigation that goes along with responding to an incident? What third parties do you need to bring in, depending on the type of incident? Do you need to bring in your web development team if you've outsourced the web development team because the website is having an incident. Yeah. But you wouldn't need to bring them in maybe if you're having a ransomware attack on one of your, your computers, right? They're not probably the right people to bring in. So you really want to make sure that you're involving all the right internal first-party and third-party people and assigning them roles, specific roles and responsibilities, so that you know, hey, we need to do this thing. We need to go talk to this person who's directly responsible Okay, yeah. Who's

Tony Martignettigoing to speak? And then, who's going to speak to— are there, aside from the public, if this involves donor data, volunteer data, who's going to speak to those groups? What do we say to them? How do we reassure them?

Steve SharerExactly.

Tony MartignettiYeah, I'm getting chills. I mean, my synesthesia is kicking in, actually. I really did. I just got chills thinking about— because I'm not a CEO of a nonprofit. This is— I'm a one-person entrepreneur. It's not going to happen to me, most likely. But to put myself in that position and to try to figure that out, and now maybe we've got press calling perhaps. I mean, I'm kind of thinking worst case. The press is calling. What do we say to them? If you say no comment, that sounds bad. Do you not respond at all? Exactly. And then they'll just say, well, was not immediately available for comment. Maybe that's better. I don't know. They don't want to have to, and then it's a crisis.

Steve SharerRight, it's a crisis. Yeah, and the whole planning—

Tony MartignettiYou deal with these? I mean, you get called in on these?

Steve SharerYeah, we do.

Tony MartignettiLet's take a worst-case scenario. I mean, how do you walk in and manage the— I'm going to make it even worse. Do you get called in by organizations you've never talked to before?

Steve SharerYes, and that's the most stressful.

Tony MartignettiRight, you don't know anybody.

Steve SharerRight, we don't know anybody, we don't know their technology, we don't know much about them.

Tony MartignettiWhat do you do?

Steve SharerWe, you know, we, you learn real quick. Uh, you, you ask a lot of pointed questions, and you figure out who the right people to have in the room are, because we find that there tend to be too many cooks in the kitchen when we show up, right? There's too many people involved, and they're causing more, uh, rotation and more work to be generated than really what there needs to be. So we, we really focus on, hey, who are the key people we need to bring in, and then the people that are kind of excluded from that group, say more senior leadership, we promise them, hey, we're going to give you an update every hour, or every 3 hours, or every day, so that they know what to expect when they're going through an incident, that they should, okay, at 3 o'clock, someone's going to come and brief me on what's going on and tell me what are our next steps, right? So we keep everything really communicative. And what that also prevents is, we also tend to go in and serve as a bit of a firewall between the upper leadership and the board and the very technical people, in terms of blocking and managing access to the people that are trying to do the hands-on keyboard work, so that they're not disrupted by someone saying, oh, I need an update. I need an update.

Tony MartignettiThe board chair is calling. Exactly. And now I can't deal with the crisis.

Steve SharerExactly.

Tony MartignettiWhew, man. How do you— that was like promotion for RipRap Security. How do people find you in that kind of crisis? Again, an organization you've never talked to before.

Steve SharerYeah, so it's a lot of word of mouth. It tends to be, you know, who knows an organization that can help us? Um, and, you know, there are a lot of organizations that can help, but there are not that many organizations that are equipped to work with nonprofits that are attuned to their needs and the types of data and stakeholders that they're working with. And that's why we like to work with these mission-driven organizations, is because we have a lot of experience experience there, and we really can feel like we help them because we've responded to incidents, all sorts of incidents, with all kinds of different nonprofits and other mission-driven organizations.

Tony MartignettiOkay. All right. Let's take it down a notch now from that worst case, like somebody you never heard of before, and they never heard of you, and they're calling panicked, right? I mean, they are panicked. All right. We can remove ourselves from that situation. Let's go back to some of your Your advice for preparing?

Steve SharerSure, sure. Yeah, so I think the next thing to really understand is you got to really understand what your capabilities are. What about incidents and managing incidents are you realistically going to be able to handle on your own? Do you have a very technical person that's going to be capable of doing the analysis and the investigation to figure out how the attacker got in, where the attacker is, what the attacker is doing, or do you need to make sure you go find somebody to help you do those things. I mean, the reality is most organizations, they don't have a person like that.

Tony MartignettiBasically, it's forensics.

Steve SharerForensics.

Tony MartignettiInvestigation forensics. Yep.

Steve SharerDeep digital forensics. And, you know, we, unfortunately, we've come in, in a lot of cases where our nonprofit partners, they think they can rely on some existing third-party relationship that they've got, say, their IT managed service provider or their web developer to help them address the incident, but incident response is like a pretty specialized set of capabilities.

Tony MartignettiThis is not website development.

Steve SharerRight. So you want to certainly include those people in the incident response, but you really need to know you have someone that can help take you through from beginning to end, from identifying that the incident has happened all the way through recovery, to help you through that whole process. And though Understanding who's on your team, who's responsible for what, and really making sure that there's clear lines and expectations is really key to making sure that you can successfully recover.

Tony MartignettiCan we launch into one of our unfortunate stories?

Steve SharerYeah, yeah. We worked with one organization. They're about a 100-person company. It's

Tony Martignettia nonprofit?

Steve SharerIt's a nonprofit, yeah. Uh-huh. And, uh, what happened to them is that they, uh, they didn't have multi-factor authentication configured for, uh, their, their email, and, uh, an attacker was able to gain access to the emails of the CEO, the COO, and the CFO. And the attacker sat for months watching emails come in and out of these 3 mailboxes, and they were able to understand what it— what, what is the process this nonprofit uses to get new vendors onboarded? What is the process for the vendors providing the bank account information for how to pay the vendors? What's the process for when a vendor needs to send an invoice to the nonprofit for the work that they've done? And what they were able to do—

Tony MartignettiSo they're lurking. They're lurking.

Steve SharerThey're watching.

Tony MartignettiThey're lying in wait. I went to law school. Well, I used to be— I used to practice law. They're lying in wait. Exactly. You would say, this is what makes it a first-degree murder, lying in wait to Yeah. Versus heat of passion.

Steve SharerExactly.

Tony MartignettiThis is lying in wait.

Steve SharerExactly. Yeah, and attackers will maintain access for a long time in an organization to really learn about them, in the same way that I learn about an organization when I'm trying to work with them, right? I want to profile all the activity and understand how to make them more secure. Did

Tony Martignettiyou used to be a bad guy? Did you come over to the other side?

Steve SharerNo, luckily not.

Tony MartignettiYou're not Abagnale? No, no.

Steve SharerCatch Me If You Can? That's not you? Not my style.

Tony MartignettiFrank, Frank Abagnale. Yeah, yeah, yeah. All right.

Steve SharerUm, and so what happened was that the, the attacker understood this payment flow and this vendor approval process and was able to issue their own invoices, or they were able to issue their invoices to this nonprofit. The nonprofit was just paying them. Just, they said, okay, this is approved, everything looks fine. They posed as the CFO and the COO to, like, give the approvals, sending email on their behalf, and giving the approval stamp. Oh, man. And just hundreds and hundreds of thousands of dollars just walked out the door over a 6-month period. And no one, no one realized, right? So, there's, you know, the, there's the aspect of, hey, you should have had multi-factor authentication configured to protect those accounts, so the attacker couldn't even get in from the beginning. But there's also the side of, hey, what is your, what is your vendor approval and vendor invoice approval process look like? And how could an attacker use that process and take advantage of it to issue their own invoices and get the money sent to their own account? So there's a bit of a traditional cybersecurity and IT portion of this incident and how to recover from it, and as well as a more financial process and accounting process that we help them improve to make it less vulnerable to these kinds of attacks. That's great.

Tony MartignettiOnce the crisis is over, then make it less likely to happen again.

Steve SharerExactly.

Tony MartignettiSo, that money was never recovered?

Steve SharerWas never recovered.

Tony MartignettiYeah. Do nonprofits typically cooperate with law enforcement, or would they rather just let it go, make it go away, and end the nightmare?

Steve SharerYeah. It's about 50/50, we find. There are some nonprofits that have a an obligation to report something like that, if they're working with, say, health data or something like that, really something truly sensitive. A lot of organizations, we talk with them about that, of like, hey, you know, it's worth reporting this. Like, you're not going to get in trouble for being attacked. You know, it's— and I— We almost always recommend going to talk with law enforcement. We almost always recommend that we submit the the technical indicators of the attack, like how the attacker— what the attacker did, how they did it, to the federal law enforcement authorities so that they can go and cross-analyze that information and try to help more people and try to, in some rare cases, go and track down the attackers and do things like make arrests and disrupt the operations.

Tony MartignettiRare cases, though. Very rare. But, okay, so at least contribute to the FBI's Exactly. ...forensics.

Steve SharerCorrect.

Tony MartignettiOK. And then maybe not pursue prosecution. Well, it doesn't sound like prosecution is very likely.

Steve SharerNo, not very likely.

Tony MartignettiAll right. All right. Can nonprofits participate like that, anonymously?

Steve SharerYeah.

Tony MartignettiSo that the FBI is not going to reveal the identity?

Steve SharerYeah. You could go to your FBI field office that's in your state or your city and go and make these reports if you need to. There's a federal cybercrime task force that has a forum open that we use pretty regularly. If you wanted to submit something anonymously, you could do that through that manner.

Tony MartignettiOK. OK. And do you do the forensics? Can you figure out how they got in, what they did? You can?

Steve SharerYeah. Yeah. So, we— kind of the process and the workflow of the incident is, after we get called, or we see that there's a potential incident happening, We start in the stage called identification. We're really trying to profile what the threat is, what they're doing, start to understand what the impact is, so that we can go start taking steps to say, hey, let's make a plan for how we're going to contain the attacker. So the attacker cannot— we want to essentially put a force field around what they currently have access to and start to limit their ability to escape out of and pivot. Okay. pivot away and gain more access to the environment.

Tony MartignettiOkay.

Steve SharerSo, after we are able to contain them, we work to eradicate their presence. So, we remove access to accounts. We will pull computers from desks and erase them and reformat them. We've done a lot of work.

Tony MartignettiThis is when the attacker knows now that they're being surveilled.

Steve SharerTypically, yes. Yeah, yeah. We'll look under cabinets. behind desks, up in the drop ceiling, and in closets to make sure there's no computers or devices that are hidden in those areas that the attacker is maybe using to gain some physical access to the organization.

Tony MartignettiOh, really?

Steve SharerThat happens? It happens,

Tony Martignettiyep. There's sometimes there's physical access?

Steve SharerCorrect, yeah.

Tony MartignettiOh my God, that's, uh, it's even creepier.

Steve SharerIt's way creepier, yeah.

Tony MartignettiWhere have they been?

Steve SharerRight.

Tony MartignettiOkay. Have you seen that?

Steve SharerYeah, we've seen that. Yeah. Yeah.

Tony MartignettiDamn. So is that a disgruntled employee?

Steve SharerCould be a disgruntled employee. Could be an attacker that, you know, they're wearing an orange vest, and they have a tool bag, and they walk right in. You know, there's a lot of these ways to, you know, just kind of waltz in and— Yeah.

Tony MartignettiWith Verizon. Right. We want to optimize your Wi-Fi. Exactly. We've seen evidence of degraded signal. Right. We're very proactive.

Steve SharerExactly.

Tony MartignettiCome on in. Right. We'd all love—

Steve SharerWho would say no?

Tony MartignettiWe'd all love higher-performing Wi-Fi. All right. Oh my gosh. Physical presence, man. Okay. Um, all right. So the takeaways from that. Let's just, just go a little more detail. Sure. Yeah. That's a, that's a bad story. A couple hundred thou— a couple hundred thousand dollars.

Steve SharerA couple hundred thousand dollars. Yeah.

Tony MartignettiOkay. What do we take away from this?

Steve SharerSo what we take away is that you really have to To understand the impact of the incident, to really understand what are the goals of the attacker. Is it opportunistic? Are they being specifically— is the organization being specifically targeted? We're finding these days it's more opportunistic, of like the attackers are not specifically targeting an organization. They're just sort of hoping they get into any organization. A question we get from a lot of nonprofits and any organization that we work with on an incident is like, Yeah. You know, and, and it's unfortunately like, it's almost impossible to say, right? Um, and, and they're like, who would do this to us? I'm like, well, it could be anybody, right? It's— these people are all around the world, you know, it's hard, they're hard to track down. Um, even, even for the government, it's hard to track these, these people down. And so we kind of help redirect that energy, and it's like, okay, you know, we're— we may not be able to tell who did it or why they did it, but let's get you to a better perspective. Let's get you to a better place, because what we end up doing after we're able to remove the attacker is we help to work to help the organization recover and get back to business as normal. Now, most organizations that do this on their own without any help, they sort of kick the attacker out, and then they just go back to doing business as usual. Without fixing the underlying issue. underlying reason the attacker got in in the first place. And that's a tough thing to come back, or to return to somewhere, or to get called in later and say, we thought we had it under control.

Tony MartignettiWhat are they thinking? They're just— we won't get struck by lightning twice?

Steve SharerExactly right. You know, if you're not gonna—

Tony MartignettiPretty risky, right? Yeah. Hope is not a strategy.

Steve SharerNo, it's not a good strategy. Yeah. If you don't lock your front door, you know, it's kind of like, if it happens again, shame on you, right? It's like, you gotta take the time. And so, We work with the organizations to say, hey, how did the attacker get in? What are the things that we can do to close that method of access in the future? What are the other security capabilities that you can put into place, the policies, the technology, and what people need to be involved to make it so that you're prepared for the next time? And then what we always recommend, and this is a thing that a lot of organizations skip as well, is we have a very lengthy lessons learned session. The lessons learned sessions are really critical because you really want to bring in all the stakeholders from dealing with the incident after everything is done, while everything is still fresh in your mind. You want to start understanding, what did we do good? What did we do really well in the incident? Okay, we communicated. We bought pizza for everybody so no one had to leave the office. Simple things like this, right? Mm-hmm. What didn't we do well? Okay, well, it turns out the attacker was in the network for 6 months, like that we should have known 5 months or 5 and a half months ago, you know, things like that. And then what we recommend is giving specific— having specific action items with specific due dates assigned to specific people so that things get followed up on, and that every time you have to step through this process, you're improving a little bit more, you're reducing the impact of future incidents, and you're just better prepared for the next time that it happens.

Tony MartignettiWhat's the proportion that you see that nonprofits take that proactive step after the crisis to mitigate the likelihood and the impact of a future crisis?

Steve SharerUm, these days, the rate is much higher than it used to be. 5 years ago, we wouldn't have seen many follow through unless they're quite a large organization, but people feel the pain, and people see this in the news all the Yeah,

Tony Martignettithey see major corporate— Southwest, Yahoo.

Steve SharerExactly. Healthcare providers, pipelines, right? It's always in the news. So people are a lot more aware of it. They want to have the conversation. It's less of like, oh no, we're totally secure. Nothing can ever happen to us, sort of just like hoping that nothing happens. But they want to engage more deeply and say, like, what do we really need to do? You know, what are the foundational things we need to put in place that we just don't have.

Tony MartignettiOkay. Okay. How'd you come up with RipRap Security? What's the significance of that?

Steve SharerYeah. So, uh, riprap is a type of shoreline protection on, like in a bay or on a river. That's, it's, it's all rocky and it protects the shore.

Tony MartignettiErosion patrol, like erosion control. Yeah.

Steve SharerYeah.

Tony MartignettiLike those rock, exactly. Those rock sort of not really rock walls, but little rock islands or mounds.

Steve SharerExactly.

Tony MartignettiIs that riprap?

Steve SharerThat's exactly right.

Tony MartignettiAll right. So, So you're protecting the nation's coastline. That's right. Like our Coast Guard. That's right. Our silent warriors.

Steve SharerThat's right. We're not quite as seaworthy, I think, but yeah.

Tony MartignettiYou get nauseous?

Steve SharerSometimes.

Tony MartignettiAll right. Let's see. Being able to hold incident preparation discussions, leadership. Well, we talked through a lot of that. Have you seen— I feel like I'm speaking to law enforcement. About crime trends in the nonprofit community. Have you seen ransomware?

Steve SharerRansomware is a common one. You have seen that? Yeah.

Tony MartignettiYou got a ransomware case story you can tell?

Steve SharerYeah, we deal with these a little bit less these days than we used to. Honestly, the fact that people are— more organizations are more fully remote means that the ransomware has trouble spreading to other devices on a network. Mm-hmm. So that definitely is a nice thing to work from home or work remotely. But we've had cases where we worked with one— this is one company. They're quite small. And they're a 50-person manufacturing company that we worked with. And they called us up one day, and they said, hey, we're having this ransomware incident on our production floor. They made metal machine parts. Their production floor, everything is encrypted by ransomware. All the business side of the network was encrypted. Everything was fully offline. They sent out most of their employees home, and they're just, you know, they turn the lights off, right? They're like, what do we do?

Tony MartignettiYeah.

Steve SharerAnd so we're there, we're trying to understand. We've identified obviously that there's ransomware. We're trying to understand, you know, what it is, how they got in. And the IT director comes in, he's like, great news, I have backups. Like, oh, this is great. No one ever has backups, right? Because if you've got backups, you can restore the data, you can get back to normal, no problem. So he stored them at his house in a little safe in his house, brought them back. He takes them out of the box and the, the, the backups are— they're a week old, so it's not ideal, but a week ago is better than nothing. Yeah. Or 2 weeks. Um, and he opens the box, it's like an old-timey, like, lunch crate, metal lunch crate, and they're tape drives. And tape drives are, uh, like almost like a cassette deck, um, but they're, they're, they used to be used very frequently to store a large amount of data. But the downside is they're very slow to help move data on and off those tape drives. So I'm like, okay, all right. So he's gonna say, oh, I'm gonna go restore the data to get us back up and running. He comes back a couple hours later, he's like, it looks like this is gonna take 14 days. Wow. to restore our data. I'm like, that's a long— that's a really long time. And so ultimately, the leadership of the organization decided to pay the ransom because it was going to cost them less. I think it was $400,000 or $500,000. It was going to cost them less to pay the ransom to unlock the computers than it was for them to be down for 2 weeks. And that's a hard choice for an organization to make.

Tony MartignettiRight. Yeah, we're paying the bad guys.

Steve SharerExactly.

Tony MartignettiBut it's a business decision.

Steve SharerIt's a business decision.

Tony MartignettiDo you see— are these foreign actors? Not, not this one specifically, but do you see a lot of foreign actors as the bad guy when you can identify? Maybe, maybe sometimes you can't even identify where in the world they're located.

Steve SharerYeah, yeah, it tends to be pretty geographically spread. Um, you know, the— there, there is a whole business model and, and business life cycle for these ransomware attacks. So an organization So, uh, one, one malicious organization will go and they'll perform the initial, um, exploitation of a, of an organization. So they'll go in, they'll get access to a computer or an account, and they do that tens of thousands of times, and they'll, they'll collect all these logins, and then they'll sell them to ransomware attackers. So there's almost— they're almost like a data broker providing these account credentials and this access to the ransomware attackers. And then the ransomware attackers will go and they'll install the ransomware on the computers that are associated with these accounts, and they'll just see who calls them back. And so there's this whole ecosystem of, hey, you know, the attackers know, like, they need to be pretty quick to respond to their customers' email, right? Their victims' emails. Yeah. Otherwise, people aren't going to trust that they're going to provide the key if they get paid. And so we tend to see So they're good

Tony Martignettion customer

Steve Sharerservice.

Tony MartignettiThey're great at customer service. Oh, definitely. Because there's hundreds of thousands of dollars at stake. Exactly. They're good models of customer service.

Steve SharerThey're great communicators. Yeah, some big corporations could learn a lot.

Tony MartignettiPromise we'll get back to you within 15 minutes.

Steve SharerThat's right.

Tony MartignettiYeah, yeah. Uh, crypto— are they, are they typically paid in cryptocurrency?

Steve SharerTypically paid in crypto. Yep. Um, and they, they have a variety of, um, different cryptocurrencies that they're using, almost as many as you can count.

Tony MartignettiYeah.

Steve SharerUm, and they take pretty significant steps to— once you've paid them, they typically give you one address to send the money, the, the, the digital currency to. And from there, it's almost immediately, um, essentially like chopped up into smaller chunks and sent out to, you know, potentially hundreds of other, you know, digital currency and cryptocurrency accounts. So it's very difficult to trace,

Tony Martignettiuh,

Steve Sharerthat, that kind of, that kind of

Tony MartignettiHave you seen a case where the ransom was paid and the key was not provided? The encryption key wasn't provided?

Steve SharerWe've seen where the attacker has provided the wrong decryption key by mistake.

Tony MartignettiEmail them back?

Steve SharerEmail them back. You made a mistake. They made a mistake. The customer service is great.

Tony MartignettiStill, customer service. They got back to you.

Steve SharerThey got back to you.

Tony MartignettiYeah, so you don't have to go through a gateway or anything, 800 Correct. Just go right to the principal, and then they provided the correct key?

Steve SharerCorrect.

Tony MartignettiOK.

Steve SharerNow, you do have to be careful, right? We don't recommend paying the ransom. Not necessarily. Not necessarily. But if it's a business decision, you do have to be careful, because the Department of Treasury and law enforcement agencies, they're very closely tracking these ransomware attackers. And what they do is they've placed some of these cryptocurrency wallet addresses on the sanctions list. So the same sanctions list that has Russian oligarchs and, you know, Chinese hackers.

Tony MartignettiOh, yeah, through FinCEN.

Steve SharerExactly, through FinCEN.

Tony MartignettiThe Financial Crimes Enforcement Network. Exactly. Department of Treasury. I know about FinCEN.

Steve SharerExactly.

Tony MartignettiSo, so what's the, what's the caveat there?

Steve SharerThe caveat is that you could potentially be in sanctions violations by paying one of these ransomware hackers, um, if it's a, if it's a tracked, sanctioned, uh, uh, cryptocurrency. Damn, it's double victim. It's heavy. Yeah, it's heavy.

Tony MartignettiThe Russian hacker or the, the Indian hacker and the Treasury Department are both after me, right?

Steve SharerWhere do I turn? It's not a good position. No, you want to call your lawyer for sure.

Tony MartignettiAll right, that's a, that's a great caveat. All right, so what can we take away from this, uh, this lesson learned this particular ransomware account at the manufacturer?

Steve SharerYeah, so I think the key thing is make sure you have ongoing current backups. And a lot of organizations, they'll set up backups like in this story, or they say, okay, we're taking backups every week, that's probably fine. But the downside was they never tested it, right? They never verified that the data was complete, and they never made sure that they understood how long it was going to take them for them to recover that. If they had known, they would have probably chosen a different way to back up, because it doesn't cost that much more these days to not back up on a tape drive, say.

Tony MartignettiOK. OK. Where in the world are these bad actors clustered? Are there parts of the world— like, I mean, I mentioned India and Russia, but I'm not a cybersecurity professional. Where are these— can you say, generalize, Yeah,

Steve Sharerso they tend to be pretty geographically spread. Okay. Um, you know, the reality is that it's no longer that hard for someone to gain the skills that are necessary to do— to perform some of these attacks. And we're seeing more and more of these organizations of very young people going out and committing these types of crimes, and, you know, ultimately being successful in a lot of cases. And so, you know, YouTube is great for learning all sorts of things. You can learn how to hack and do all these things on YouTube and by research. There's a lot of great information out there. Um, but the reality is, like, it's, it's almost impossible to know who's doing this in a lot of cases, right? Okay. Either the attackers are using all kinds of intermediaries and bouncing their communications off other computers all around the world, and it's very tricky to, to really track them down unless you're FinCEN or a large government organization.

Tony MartignettiOkay. Okay. Is there truth that if you're a victim of a hack, let's say it's your credit card, your credit card company says that not only your credit card number, but your address, and maybe your date of birth or something, you know, was— may have been compromised, and they'll typically give you They give you 1 year. In one case, I saw 2 years, which doubled, but still, my question gets to the value of all this. Sure. 2 years of credit monitoring and suspicious monitoring alerts and things like that. But I've also read that the real value comes longer from the incident because it's harder to track back to where it happened, what the source of it was. Like 3 to 4 or 5 years later, your birthdate hasn't changed. Your address might have changed, but a lot of people's addresses haven't, so they'll use what they've got, and they'll get lucky in a lot of their ill-gotten file. So, is that true, that the longer the time, the more valuable your data is on the, I guess, on the dark web, in the black market?

Steve SharerYeah, and I think it speaks mostly to the fall-on-impact. impact that can have, right? If someone steals your data, that's— and there's a big breach, that's one thing. But that data gets repackaged and sold to a variety of other people on the, on the dark web. And, and the reality is that most people, they're not going to be able to pay attention that long, right? They can't change some of these core things about them, like their phone number or their Social Security number. Yeah. You know, some of these things. So you really have to be mindful all the time. And really watch your accounts and really understand, like, what is the impact here, you know?

Tony MartignettiBeyond the 1 year of credit monitoring that they'll give you. I just don't— I mean, yeah, sure, I'll take it. I'll sign up for it, but I don't see the value because I— all right, so my— what I've read is accurate. Correct. The longer the time, the more valuable, actually. Correct. And the more likely that it'll be used after 1 or 2 years. Exactly. From the incident. All right. We've got a little more time. You want to tell us one more story and some lessons from it?

Steve SharerYeah. Yeah. So, I mean, we have, you know, we've told a lot of, like, kind of dark stories, you know, but there are bright spots, right?

Tony MartignettiOkay. Oh, good. All right.

Steve SharerSo, you know, we come in a lot of times, come in an organization, they're having an incident, we work with them, we really, we help, you know, kick out the attacker, and the leadership, they really get it, right? They really want to understand. They really want to learn because, you know, we hear things at conferences and read about online and hear on the news that all these bad things are happening, but it's not until you really feel it and you're really in it that you're like, okay, this is— I understand this, you know? And that's a hard lesson to learn, certainly. Yeah. Um, but we, in a lot of cases, have been able to say, hey, here's how you fix the underlying root cause that caused the incident, but, you know, here are another 10 things that you could do that are low effort, low cost, very minimal business impact that you can do to really reduce the chance that this is going to happen again. And it's those organizations that tend to understand that security and IT and operations and the success of their organization are all very deeply linked, and that it requires— it's not just like an activity for IT to be worried about or security to worry about. It's a whole— security is a team sport. Everyone has to be involved and be a stakeholder. The reality is that attackers, they're going to target the CEO and the leadership of the organization when they're trying to get in. And so, by bringing all those people all together, it leads to better outcomes to have them involved and have that buy-in in a continuous way.

Tony MartignettiOkay. Okay. So, is there a bright story?

Steve SharerYeah. The short story is that they were able to kind of plug the holes that they had and go on this journey where they were able to modernize their IT stack and their tools that they're using and their processes, you know, really embed security very deeply into that, and were able to reduce the likelihood of these kinds of incidents happening again. Okay. And we're in a spot where we can watch the attackers attempt these types of attacks, and that's what we really want, so you get early warning that there's an attempt happening. We can take some additional steps without having to wait 6 months to learn that you've been compromised for 6 months.

Tony MartignettiSteve Sharer, thank you very much. He's CEO and co-founder of RipRap Security. Thank you for sharing, Steve.

Steve SharerThanks for having me.

Tony MartignettiExcellent. Thank you. And thank you for being with our coverage of 24NTC, the 2024 Nonprofit Technology Conference, where we are sponsored by Heller Consulting. Technology strategy and implementation for nonprofits.

Kate MartignettiNext week, more 24 NTC goodness with intergenerational communication and the four-day work week. If you missed any part of this week's show,

Tony MartignettiI beseech you. Find it at tonymartignetti.com.

Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by Virtuous. Virtuous gives you the nonprofit CRM, fundraising, volunteer, and marketing tools you need to create more responsive donor experiences and grow giving. virtuous.org. And by DonorBox. Outdated donation forms blocking your supporters' generosity? DonorBox. Fast, flexible, and friendly fundraising forms for your nonprofit. donorbox.org.

Tony MartignettiDonorBox. It's obvious. Well, who else would it be? It's DonorBox.

Kate MartignettiOur creative producer is Claire Meyerhoff. I'm your associate producer, Kate Martignetti. This show's social media is by Susan Chavez. Marc Silverman is our web guy, and this music is by Scott Stein.

Tony MartignettiThank you for that affirmation, Scotty. Be with us next week for Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. Go out and be great.

Nonprofit Radio

More Episodes from 2024 Nonprofit Technology Conference

View All
Drew NelsonCassi JohnsonEve LaCivita
EP 699July 15, 2024

Exploit Conflict & Intuition To Make Better Programs & Products

with Drew Nelson, Cassi Johnson, and Eve LaCivita

Carlos Morales
EP 698July 7, 2024

Improve Your Communications With AI

with Carlos Morales

Jamie MuellerPeter GenuardiNatania LeClerc
EP 697June 30, 2024

Use Your Tech To Enable Generosity

with Jamie Mueller, Peter Genuardi, and Natania LeClerc

1 / 4