Sociocracy & Attract More Donors




Sociocracy
It’s a new form of decision making you might want to try out. Justin Birdsong from Skeleton Key Strategies introduces us to circle structures, domains and aims, and linking roles, as he acquaints us with this more equitable and inclusive, sociocratic decision making method. (Recorded at the 2024 Nonprofit Technology Conference.)
Recorded At
2024 Nonprofit Technology ConferenceAttract More Donors
When your development and communications teams work collaboratively with strong relationships, you’ll draw more donors and increase your fundraising revenue. Our panel shares their strategies. They’re Shannon Bowen with Monsoon Leadership and Emily DiFrisco at the Center for Environmental Health. (Also recorded at 24NTC.)
Here’s the transcript
Tony MartignettiHello and welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. I'm your aptly named host and the podfather of your favorite hebdomadal podcast. This is show number 691. That means we're only 9 weeks away from our 700th show and 14th anniversary. Not that we are wishing the summer months and weeks away, certainly not, but we are close to the big one. Oh, I'm glad you're with us. I'd be forced to endure the pain of pruritogenesis If you got under my skin with the idea that you missed this week's show, here's our associate producer Kate to introduce what's coming.
Kate MartignettiHey Tony, this week we have 2 more conversations from 24 NTC. Sociocracy— it's a new form of decision-making you might want to try. Justin Birdsong from Skeleton Key Strategies introduces us to circle structures, domains and aims, and linking roles as he acquaints us with this more equitable and inclusive decision-making method. And attract more donors. When your development and communications teams work collaboratively with strong relationships, you'll draw more donors and increase your fundraising revenue. Our panel shares their strategies. They're Shannon Bowen with Monsoon Leadership and Emily DiFrisco at Center for Environmental Health on Tony's Take Two.
Tony MartignettiThrough infants' eyes.
Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by Virtuous. Virtuous gets you the nonprofit CRM, fundraising, volunteer, And marketing tools you need to create more responsive donor experiences and grow giving. Virtuous.org. And by DonorBox. Outdated donation forms blocking your supporters' generosity? DonorBox. Fast, flexible, and friendly fundraising forms for your nonprofit. DonorBox.org. Here is Sociocracy.
Tony MartignettiWelcome back to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio coverage of 24NTC. You know what it is. You know that it's the 2024 Nonprofit Technology Conference. You know that we're at the Oregon Convention Center in Portland, Oregon. Beautiful Portland, great food city. And you know that we're sponsored by Heller Consulting, technology strategy and implementation for nonprofits. What you don't know is that I'm now with Justin Birdsong, founder and principal of Skeleton Key Strategies. You're now informed fully. Justin, welcome to Nonprofit Radio.
Justin BirdsongThank you so much, Tony. I'm so glad to be here.
Tony MartignettiPleasure, pleasure. Thank you for joining us for our coverage where we are— you and I are going to talk about equitable governance and consent-based decision-making.
Justin BirdsongYes, sir.
Tony MartignettiAn introduction to sociocracy.
Justin BirdsongThat's it.
Tony MartignettiAll right. I think we better start with a definition of sociocracy.
Justin BirdsongAbsolutely. So sociocracy is a peer governance system that is based on decentralizing power and hierarchical power structures and more equitable distribution of decision-making in organizations.
Tony MartignettiWhat do we say to the CEOs who think they just heard a definition of the word Anarchy.
Justin BirdsongTo a certain kind of CEO with a certain kind of, you know, power-centric mindset, they wouldn't be far off. I think the difference is that it's the opposite of anarchy in the sense that sociocracy actually has really strong process and governance procedures. So it's not that there's no rules of the road, it's that the rules of the road are about integrating all voices, Making balance for dissension and objections to certain kinds of decisions, and making sure that everybody has a voice in the kinds of major decisions that drive either an organization or a team. Or it's also used extensively outside of organizations in more informal kinds of settings like cohousing communities.
Tony MartignettiOh, interesting. Okay. All right. Maybe we'll get to some of those other settings.
Justin BirdsongSure.
Tony MartignettiBut we'll be focused on— our listeners are small and mid-sized nonprofits.
Justin BirdsongYes.
Tony MartignettiSo I think they would be fertile ground for, for your ideas?
Justin BirdsongI think so. I think an important thing I can say right up front is that sociocracy is a really different methodology from most of the kinds of power structures we are used to having, especially in businesses and nonprofits. They tend to be traditionally hierarchical in nature. There's nothing wrong with hierarchy. It's just ultimately decision-making rolls up to a certain kind of level of decision-making, and the buck stops with one ultimate decision-maker. Some smaller nonprofits are a little bit more flat in nature, a little bit more democratic, where sort of everybody gets to weigh in, but there are pros and cons to that as well, because that can make it really difficult to make a decision and to integrate everybody's different perspectives when they are in competition with one another. And so sociocracy attempts to sort of balance the things that are useful about hierarchical methods and flat technocratic-type methods into a consent-based approach where that balances all of those voices and seeks not just to have a sort of one decision maker or a consensus or a majority of decision makers who agree with one thing, but that every single member of a decision-making group will be able to consent to a particular way forward.
Tony MartignettiNow, as you alluded, this is going to require leadership.
Justin BirdsongYeah.
Tony MartignettiBuy-in. We're not going to be able to— we're We're not going to be able to do this without the senior leadership being on board.
Justin Birdsong100%.
Tony MartignettiYou sort of made the case, but let's make it explicit. How would we make the case to maybe to our vice president to bring it to the CEO, maybe our CEO to bring it to the board? Help us make the case.
Justin BirdsongYeah, absolutely. I think it ultimately depends on what the organization is struggling with. So, when organizations, and I think it— I've seen this in a lot of nonprofits, both large and small, is how easy is it to make decisions? And then even if it's relatively easy to make decisions, how bought in are people to those decisions? How easy is it to manage people through change because those conversations may have happened when they weren't in the room, or somebody may be moving forward with something that they think is the right thing, even though they may not feel like their perspectives or objections were heard. And so ultimately, that can sort of slow down or impede the success of a major project or a new initiative. And what sociocracy is designed to do is to level that playing field just a bit while still having an active facilitation role to make sure that everybody is being heard, make sure that when somebody raises an objection that has to do with the effectiveness of the mission or the aim of whatever it is that we're trying to do, that we're able to hear and balance that and incorporate any of those objections through maybe altering the proposal a little bit or saying, we're going to extend the timeline of this so that we can give it a try, but then we're going to commit to checking back in and making adjustments if we need to, etc.
Tony MartignettiSo you just referenced some of the symptoms of less than ideal decision-making. That we might encounter? Slow processes, people not feeling bought in, anything else that would sort of trigger, you know, maybe we can be doing a better job of and could be more successful at decentralizing our decision-making?
Justin BirdsongYeah. I mean, I think the types of organizations that are drawn to something like sociocracy are also generally doing it from a sort of equity perspective. They're just generally interested in decentralizing decision-making, maybe Making things a little bit less top-down. Organizations that are close to organizing or social justice tend to respond to this type of model because it's about sort of disrupting traditional power structures in a way that just generally appeals to people, while also understanding it's a big shift. Yeah. And sort of putting it into practice is complicated, and it involves a lot of letting go of the traditional sort of Seats and controls of power that people are used to in organizations.
Tony MartignettiHence, the senior leadership has got to be willing to have some fun with decision-making, but make decision-making more equitable.
Justin BirdsongExactly.
Tony MartignettiLess flat, as you already explained. Okay. We need to have a foundation. There's some things we need to learn, like circle structures.
Justin BirdsongYes.
Tony MartignettiSome things. Okay. So, set us up with our foundation.
Justin BirdsongYes. So this is, and this is by the way also how there are bits and pieces that you can borrow from sociocracy, even if your whole organization is not ready to sort of move part and parcel into a sociocratic model. Essentially, the way that we sort of take the hierarchical structure and adapt it for sociocracy is by having a relationship between sort of parent and child circles. Okay. And you can think of the core of those being a general circle, which in most organizations is kind of like your C-suite, your sort of executive leadership and decision makers. And then governing that is a mission circle, which in nonprofits is typically akin to the board, may or may not be all internal folks, but which are trying to make sure that the organization stays aligned with its declared mission and purpose in the world. The general circle is about managing the organization. And then stemming off of that central circle are subcircles, which are equivalent in many ways to teams and departments. And the thing that's a bit different is the model by which these circles are linked. So as opposed to being sort of purely top-down, there's a system of double linking where there's a leader and a delegate that is a member of both every parent circle and the child circle. And part of what that enables is for there to be 2 perspectives that get shared in both the parent circle and the child circle, and that the leader is making sure decision-making happening or influence or questions happening at the parent-level circle are being communicated down to the sub-circle. And then the delegate is doing the same thing in the reverse, making sure that what's happening in the sub-circle is reflected back to the parent circle. And the explicit delegation of power is that rather than all of the decision-making happening at the C-suite level, that executive general circle level, anything within the declared domain and aim, which is an explicit sort of set of standards that get defined when you create these circle structures is, you know, my marketing subcircle has an explicit aim that is about, you know, publicizing and communicating about the role of our organization. And their domain includes potentially things like the website, the email list, anything that falls squarely within the domain of a subcircle. They have the autonomous decision-making power to make decisions and recommendations at that level without necessarily always having to run things up a chain. to a general circle for buy-in.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Well, that's the big shift.
Justin BirdsongYeah.
Tony MartignettiThey have the autonomy, they have the authority, and they also have the responsibility, the accountability.
Justin BirdsongYes.
Tony MartignettiResponsibility for their decision.
Justin BirdsongAbsolutely.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Now, at one point you had said the parent-child and the parent circle and the child circle. That still sounds hierarchical. Is there a better I'm not trying to revolutionize sociocracy. I just— I'm learning about it for the past 9 and a half minutes. But, uh, I don't know. That's— like I said, it still sounds hierarchical. Well, are there different words we can use?
Justin BirdsongUm, I think it's not wrong to say that it is, it is taking the thing that is effective about hierarchy, which is the fact that there are different levels of domain and oversight that are needed when an organization is handling Both high-level strategic and mission-level impact type things, and then all the way down to the weeds of the operations. So I think it makes sense that there's still relationships and gradations of responsibility. Okay. And they are still related to one another in that sort of binary relationship that we can think of as hierarchy. But typically hierarchy stacks power and decision-making at the top. And the farther down in the hierarchy you go, there's less decision-making. And that's explicitly inverted in sociocracy.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Okay. And some decisions do need to go up to the parent.
Justin BirdsongExactly. I mean, there's always the case where a subcircle itself, even though there's a lot of rich process around decision-making and how you get consent and how you integrate objections, there's always the case that a subcircle can't in itself integrate all the objections and make fully consent-based decision, in which case, that's part of the reason why we still have the parent circles. Ultimately, things can be escalated up if they can't be solved at the sub-circle.
Tony MartignettiThey don't have the data, they don't— whatever information is lacking.
Justin BirdsongThey can't resolve the conflict.
Tony MartignettiYeah. Okay. They may not have the relationships to make their decision effective.
Justin BirdsongIt could be that. It could also just simply be that there's opposing viewpoints that are both valid. So when someone has an objection, it first of all really needs to be based on something that is related to the aim and domain. I think this proposal that's on the table, say it's about a certain kind of marketing channel that we want to open up, and somebody may have a really genuine objection that can't be about their sort of personal feelings and preferences, but is about, I genuinely think that us going into TikTok is going to erode our aim. It is going to make us less effective at our aim and domain, and therefore I am going to withhold my consent from our ability to move forward with that. And the group can try to integrate that objection by, again, sort of saying, well, we can try it for a period of time and then check back in. We can amend the proposal and say we're only going to do TikTok for certain kinds of campaigns. There's ways to sort of balance that out, but if group cannot ultimately arrive at consent rather than consensus, full consent from everybody involved, then worst case, that's why you have parent circles to escalate things up to.
Kate MartignettiIt's time for a break. Virtuous is a software company committed to helping nonprofits grow generosity. Virtuous believes that generosity has the power to create profound change in the world. And in the heart of the giver. It's their mission to move the needle on global generosity by helping nonprofits better connect with and inspire their givers. Responsive fundraising puts the donor at the center of fundraising and grows giving through personalized donor journeys that respond to the needs of each individual. Virtuous is the only responsive nonprofit CRM designed to help you build deeper relationships with every donor at scale. Virtuous gives CRM, fundraising, volunteer marketing, and automation tools you need to create responsive experiences that build trust and grow impact. virtuous.org. Now back to Sociocracy with Justin Birdsong.
Tony MartignettiUh, let's shift away from the theoretical for a minute. Sure. Tell, tell me a story. Tell me a, a success story of Sociocracy decision-making?
Justin BirdsongSure. So I think one way that I have been able to implement it in a very small way is with some colleagues of mine who were putting together their own sort of strategic plan for their new consulting company. So it's a small, tiny, tiny group, group of 3, and they were looking for some sort of system of power that would enable the 3 of them 2 founders and the sort of first hire underneath them to equitably balance the decision-making power between them, and then also position them to grow as they imagine they're bringing on eventually other staff. How could they do so in a way that continues that same method and doesn't kind of concentrate all of the power and decision-making in the hands of the founders? And so this is actually a really good example of where, you know, we went through the sort of whole model top to bottom. And there were lots of things that they were like, you know, I don't know that we're going to fully adopt that. That sort of feels like in some ways that's impeding us. We might not need quite this level of process and decision-making. But we really, for example, liked the circle structures because it gave clear aims and domains that could be distributed. And it allowed them to then divorce, in some cases, themselves from one of those circles and say, okay, I'm going to step back and let And they have full aim and domain about that. If they need my input, they can come to me because all 3 of them are in the general circle, but I fully trust and delegate all of my trust and responsibility to them. And it's enabled them to understand where they need all 3 of their decisions versus where they can move faster by making autonomous decisions themselves in smaller groups. And I think that's a really important point.
Tony MartignettiAnd how long has this startup been engaged this way?
Justin BirdsongThey are in their 3rd year, and they adopted this early in 2023. So about a year and change.
Tony MartignettiAnd they're still successful? Yeah. Okay.
Justin BirdsongYeah.
Tony MartignettiOkay.
Justin BirdsongThey're finding that it's easier to— again, they can sort of, they can move faster without anybody feeling disenfranchised because there are explicit agreements up front That these 2 individuals are double-linked into this parent circle. They have autonomous decision-making power over this particular domain and aim, if it's operations, if it's product development, etc. And there's no overhead of having to constantly run things back up the chain.
Tony MartignettiI can see how this would make any organization more nimble, I think, more reactive, in a good way. I don't mean knee-jerk reactive, but, you know, like The 3 of us in our circle can huddle and we can make this decision maybe in 10 or 15 minutes, or we might have to wait for the next meeting with the vice president or the CEO, and that's not scheduled for another, whatever, 10 days or something. We can resolve this right now.
Justin BirdsongThat's the best practical application of it, is that it just allows people to move swiftly and it puts into place agreements of, at the time we set up the circle, we imbue it with this trust of like, you're in this circle, otherwise I would be in the circle if I didn't trust you to make the decision. I'm going to delegate explicitly this power, and that allows us all to move a little bit quicker. Plus, it tends to raise this sort of sense of morale because everybody has a voice at the table and has explicit ability to influence whether or not decisions get made and move forward.
Tony MartignettiNow, what is your role in Sociocracy. Are you— is there a certification for teaching this and implementing it for organizations? Skeleton Key, what are you doing around sociocracy?
Justin BirdsongWell, at Skeleton Key, it's mostly a thing that we have imbued in certain scenarios. Like, if we're setting up a kind of committee, we are always kind of looking at, like, power dynamics and what's going to enable an organization to move fast. Sometimes we are calling it sociocracy, like with the group of consultants I was mentioning. Other times it's more like principles of equitable decision-making that we just try to weave in. But there is— there's a number of organizations that do this, but I spent all of last year working in and training with an organization called Sociocracy for All that is an international NGO, but it's based in the US, and their whole mission is about sort of spreading education about sociocratic models, and I trained in their Sociocracy Academy for all of 2023. And that is where I learned a lot of this content and was able to practice it with people all around the world who, again, are using it in some places in the sort of eco-permaculture sort of movement, co-housing movements. There's lots of places where this is being used that are outside
Tony MartignettiOkay. And so now do we have our foundation set? Can we move to the next step of process? There's something called rounds and integrating objections.
Justin BirdsongYeah.
Tony MartignettiSo do we have our foundation set? We do. Have we created— okay. So what does it look like in practice then?
Justin BirdsongAnd so this is where we're sort of, we're in our circles, right? We're in our meetings and we're trying to have more effective meetings. And one of the ways that we facilitate— there's a strong, strong facilitation role at all levels of Sociocracy. And most meetings are run through what are called rounds. And that's essentially whoever's in the facilitator role in that particular meeting, which will often rotate.
Tony MartignettiIt rotates? Okay.
Justin BirdsongYeah. Is going to make sure that every single person in the room or in the circle gets a moment to talk. That's explicit. It takes some of the pressure off. Because everybody knows that at some point they're going to get called on, they're going to get to say their piece, even if they have nothing to say and they can just pass. So it takes some of that pressure off of people feeling like they need to insert themselves.
Tony MartignettiWhen does my chance come? I didn't get a chance yet. The meeting's going to end. I'm not going to— everybody gets an explicit chance.
Justin BirdsongExactly. It also helps to balance voices because then you don't— it's the facilitator's role to make sure everybody's being heard. It's sort of the reasonable—
Tony MartignettiRoughly equally. Nobody's dominating. That's contrary to our purpose here.
Justin BirdsongExactly right. And so we are facilitating things through rounds. And so, for example, when we are making a decision, there will be a proposal on the table. That's the sort of traditional way that we talk about whatever the topic is. The proposal, what is it that we're deciding on? And somebody might— the facilitator would run us through, first is a clarifying questions round. So we're going to go around, everybody gets just a moment to say, is there anything about the proposal you don't understand or need more information about? We can go through that as needed. Once all the clarifying questions are asked, there's a second round that is about reactions. And that's when people can start to say, like, you know, I am hesitant about this, or I actually think this is a really good idea, or, you know, I have some real concerns about this particular proposal as it's articulated. And then that would be followed by an explicit consent round that is literally going around, do you consent to Do you not consent for this? And within that, the sort of range of tolerance of consent, you know, there's going to be people who love it and are like, yes, this is perfect for me. I'm super enthusiastic about this. And then there's other people who are like, this is fine. Like, it works for me. Maybe it sort of falls into this sort of neutral territory. And both of those count as consent. And then the third option is I object, which again, I have something about this proposal. Feel like is going to interrupt or be counterproductive to our aim. So I have an objection. I'm going to clearly state what that objection is. That's that sort of last round. If there are objections, then the group is going to attempt to integrate those objections by potentially extending the timeline, saying, you know, can we modify the proposal in some way that accounts for this, or can we agree to move forward with this proposal as written? But know that we are going to check back in at some specific point and revisit it. And what ultimately we're trying to get people to consent within, to move whatever it is into that range of tolerance of at least being able to say like, okay, this works enough, it's good enough for now.
Tony MartignettiOkay, so I have to be heard.
Justin BirdsongYes.
Tony MartignettiMy objection has to be heard if that's where I start out.
Justin BirdsongPrecisely.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Say a little more about the role of the person who has the dual appointment. They're in the parent circle but also the child circle. Is that the liaison? Is that what you call it?
Justin BirdsongThe leader and the delegate.
Tony MartignettiThe delegate. The delegate has the dual role.
Justin BirdsongYes.
Tony MartignettiDual assignment, let's say.
Justin BirdsongYes. So, the circle leader, which may or may not always be the They're not the circle facilitator, by the way, but they are the sort of designated leader of convening that circle. They may be the one that's calling people together or sort of managing outcomes, etc.
Tony MartignettiLeader, less likely to be rotating? Facilitator rotates?
Justin BirdsongIt's selected, actually. There's a selection process that's similar to the rounds where somebody gets nominated, we discuss qualifications, people can amend their nominations, and then The group decides on who the leader and the delegate are.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Okay.
Justin BirdsongAnd the delegate is another participant who is explicitly not in the leadership role, but they sort of represent everybody else. And so their job is to, again, sort of keep, in some ways, keep each other honest, right? Like if you and I are both in our marketing subcircle and then we have to go up to our general circle because we are double-linked And you're the leader and I'm the delegate. You may be reporting out on something that our decision-making group did in the subcircle, and I'm another perspective. So I can even just sort of qualify sort of what you said. It's like, actually, there's something else I think the general circle needs to know about how that decision was made. We had to integrate this particular kind of objection, and this was the nuance about that. And so it makes sure that there's 2 perspectives being represented. Right. in it in every conversation, which helps, again, sort of make sure that there's no one person's perception or allegiance to a certain kind of outcome that is going to prevail in every case.
Tony MartignettiWhat else should we know? I mean, you have some things that you've suggested about the topic, understanding how it improves equity and inclusivity. I feel like we've talked about that at the outset even, but what else should folks know about this process?
Justin BirdsongI think ultimately the thing to know is that it is a set of tools. And I think one thing is people see it and they may have a really, well, they'll have a really strong reaction one way or the other.
Tony MartignettiYeah, right. It's unlikely to be neutral. You're talking about the neutral in this. Decision-making, but it's not like, it's okay, you know, I could live with it. It's probably going to be, I think, very— it's either very positive or very negative.
Justin BirdsongI think that's exactly the case. Okay. And so, and while that is true, and I think even, you know, a thing that Sociocracy for All, that organization that I was training with, you know, they do implementations of this in organizations and they're frequently unable to move forward because if there's not the kind of buy-in and alignment about the kind of seismic change it represents if you are an existing organization with a traditional hierarchical structure and you're planning to upend that. That is not something to be done lightly. But the thing that I think I want to reinforce is that I see it as not just a monolith, but a whole set of practices and tools and sort of microprocesses that can be used and adapted, especially when you are in an operational or a technological or project project-based kind of role because you are constantly making decisions. In agile projects, technology implementations, you're constantly trying to like get stakeholder buy-in to be level in a certain way and make sure that decisions are soundly informed by different, maybe even competing perspectives. And you want to be able to integrate objections from different stakeholders and project members because they may have something really valid to say, That you may want to adjust a little bit. And so I see it as a whole toolset from which people can learn and take pieces of it that they can implement, even if you're going to do it within a traditionally hierarchical organization.
Tony MartignettiIs it difficult in sort of the delegation of where the authority ends for each circle? I mean, you had said at the outset, there are certain things that are not going to be conducive to this, or the CEO is just not going to give up sole authority over. But say a little more about delineating the boundaries of each circle. How do we define that?
Justin BirdsongSure. It's when you're creating a circle structure of any kind, even if you were going to sort of just do this within, let's say you have a technology department and you have a couple of different teams and you sort of—
Tony MartignettiDifferent teams.
Justin BirdsongYeah. And you want to be able to like adapt this just even within a department. You could sort of— the thing that you do when you're defining it is you first are articulating the mission that unites the whole group together, and then you are delineating the aim and domain. The aim is what we're here to accomplish. And then the domain is the set of things, usually multiple things, that then fall into our responsibilities and oversight. Like, for example, one group may have the domain of the website. Another group has domain over, like, technology infrastructure, network, desktop. Another group has domain over project management and applications, things like that. And so, you define those things at the outset, and you are clear about what does and does not fall into the domain, and you try to make sure Everything is captured somewhere. And then, of course, you know, organic organizations are constantly changing. New things will come up. And when they do come up, it's the job of that parent circle to figure out, okay, whose domain does this fall into? Does this stay with ours? Does it move into one of the subcircles? Or do we even need a subcircle off of that? Do we need a new subcircle that has a clear domain? And that's the way, by level setting right at the beginning about who has— who gets Who decides? Who decides? Everybody decides at the beginning.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Okay, leaving it there? You feel like we gave it adequate coverage?
Justin BirdsongI think so.
Tony MartignettiThank you very much.
Justin BirdsongYeah.
Tony MartignettiVery interesting. Sociocracy. Justin Birdsong, founder and principal at Skeleton Key Strategies. I love that company name too, Skeleton Key.
Justin BirdsongThank you so much.
Tony MartignettiThat's brilliant.
Justin BirdsongI appreciate it.
Tony MartignettiThank you, Justin.
Justin BirdsongThank you, Tony.
Tony MartignettiAnd thank you for being with Tony Martignetti, Nonprofit Radio coverage of 24NTC, the 2024 Nonprofit Technology Conference, where we are sponsored by Heller Consulting, technology strategy and implementation for nonprofits. Thanks so much for being with us.
Kate MartignettiIt's time for a break. DonorBox. Open up new cashless in-person donation opportunities with DonorBox Live Kiosk. The smart way to accept cashless donations anywhere, anytime. Picture this: a cash-free, on-site giving solution that effortlessly collects donations from credit cards, debit cards, and digital wallets. No team member required. Plus, your donation data is automatically synced with your DonorBox account. No manual data entry or errors. Make giving a breeze and focus on what matters— your cause. Try DonorBox Live Kiosk and revolutionize the way you collect donations. Visit donorbox.org to learn more. It's time for Tony's Take Two.
Tony MartignettiThank you, Kate. A couple of days ago, I was on the beach. Uh, I just sat myself down. It's Still not warm enough to go, you know, sit for 6 or 8 hours under an umbrella. Not quite that warm yet. We're getting there. But I was just out walking and I decided to sit down and there was a little infant, I'd say 2, 3 months old or so. And she was being held by— I'm not sure it was mother or grandmother. I think it was her mother. And The, the— so the mother was facing the, the, the sand and the dunes and the houses, and she had her baby facing out, uh, to the ocean. And this little infant was just so captivated by, you know, the vast ocean, I guess the waves. And she was just like serene. And, uh, they were like 20 feet away or so, you know, it's not, not really that far. And, you know, the baby wasn't fussy, just calm. And I don't know, I don't know, I don't know if babies think. I don't know what, I don't know what infants think about. Do they even have the capacity to think? Or what are they, what, I don't know what they're doing in their minds, in their brains. But she, she was just so calm on her mom's shoulder, over her mom's shoulder. And I was just thinking, oh man, that The ocean. And, you know, she could feel the breeze and maybe smell the salt, although she doesn't know it's salt air. She just knows it smells a little different than, than her house, unless her mother cooks with a lot of salt. But all the senses from a little infant, from like a 2 or 3-month-old infant. And I was thinking just how unusual it must be for her, the wonder, you know, and just sort of seeing it through the infant's eyes too. I was enjoying it myself. Especially like more than usual that, that afternoon. But just, you know, through an infant's eyes, the world, or in, you know, and just the ocean for the first time. Ooh. It was, it was, it was really moving. It was really something. And it went on for many minutes. The baby was just captivated. We can all be captivated by life, see the world through infant's eyes. Now and then. And that's Tony's Take Two. Kate?
Kate MartignettiI would love to go back in time and look at the world through like 5-year-old Kate's eyes, because I'm sure it was so much more colorful and bright and just exciting. And I really like didn't take anything for granted, you know, at that age. Right,
Tony Martignettibecause so much was new.
Kate MartignettiYes.
Tony MartignettiLike this little infant watching the, watching the ocean and hearing the waves. And, uh, yeah, you know, we get a little jaded, so take time to smell the roses.
Kate MartignettiWe've got beaucoup but loads more time. Here is Attract More Donors.
Tony MartignettiWelcome back to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio coverage of the 2024 Nonprofit Technology Conference. We are all together in Portland, Oregon at the Oregon Convention Center. Nonprofit Radio is sponsored by Heller Consulting at 24 NTC. Heller does technology strategy and implementation for nonprofits. With me for this conversation— conversation, like I'm 14, my voice breaks— Are Shannon Bowen and Emily DiFrisco. Shannon is founder and CEO at Monsoon Leadership, and Emily DiFrisco is Senior Director of Communications at the Center for Environmental Health. Shannon, Emily, welcome.
Shannon BowenThank you. Thank you for having us.
Tony MartignettiGlad to have you on Nonprofit Radio. So we're talking about your session topic. Have you done your session yet?
Shannon BowenWe just did it.
Tony MartignettiYou did it. All right. You're fresh off the stage, so all the questions Maybe we ask some about some of the questions that came up. Your session is Full Court Press: Harness Development and Communication Teams to Attract Donors. All right, sounds like we're breaking down silos. Emily, let's start with you. Why do we need— I think it may be widely known, but I want to make it explicit. Why do we need this session?
Emily DiFriscoWe need this session because it's never been more clear that there are silos. You can absolutely collaborate and work together to achieve your shared goals. So we had a lot of fun in our session taking a lot of questions from folks who were learning just how to collaborate across the teams and how to really achieve their goals.
Tony MartignettiShannon, what happened? Why are we in this situation? Development and communications, they seem like ideal partners. Why are we siloed? What happened?
Shannon BowenIt's hard for humans to work together in general, so that's just across the board. But Emily and I worked together at Center for Environmental Health, and really we harnessed all of the different vehicles to connect with our donors. So not just donor emails, but also using social media, website pop-ups, you know, earned media, everything to really attract new donors and engage at a deeper level with our existing donors. And so we really wanted to share that story because it is actionable and you can do it today at your organization.
Tony MartignettiAlright. So how we got here is just human nature?
Shannon BowenWell—
Tony MartignettiIs it that easy? I don't know. What happened? What happened to the— they seem like symbiotic partners.
Shannon BowenI think that sometimes people put a lot of pressure on development because you've got to bring in the money and you're paying for people's salaries. And so sometimes in organizations, it's like, oh, well, development is more important than communications. But really what Emily and I saw is they are part and parcel working together to increase the brand reputation, and that brings in your major donors. So really, instead of working in opposition, coming together and co-collaborating on campaigns can increase your impact exponentially, which is what we did at CEH.
Emily DiFriscoYeah, and sometimes there can be a little turfiness. Yeah. As Shannon mentioned, you know, between communications and development, but we really valued each other's expertise, respected each other's expertise, and that really set the tone for collaboration for our teams as well.
Tony MartignettiOkay. All right, Emily, let's stay with you. How do we start to break down the silos? How do we start to collaborate, see each other as equal partners? What do we do?
Emily DiFriscoYeah, it starts with communication, with setting up meetings, brainstorming together, creating campaigns together, really soup to nuts sit together and work on something. in a collaborative way instead of having, oh, my team is working on this, your team is working on this, and never the twain shall meet. Really collaborate from the get-go and you will have a stronger campaign.
Tony MartignettiMeeting together.
Emily DiFriscoYes.
Tony MartignettiThat's important.
Emily DiFriscoYes.
Tony MartignettiYeah. All right.
Shannon BowenAnd co-strategizing from the beginning and then sharing success at the end. So it's not just development going and presenting to the board. You're bringing communications along and saying, hey, we did this great campaign together.
Tony MartignettiI've never seen that. I mean, I always see development presenting.
Emily DiFriscoYeah.
Tony MartignettiThe development outcomes.
Shannon BowenExactly.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Alright. What else can we do?
Emily DiFriscoYeah. I mean, I think communications serves a vital role in the organization and just having— communications needs to have the humility and respect of the development team when they approach the development team to understand that fundraising for the organization is so hard. It is so challenging. So sometimes communications folks can get kind of a little bit set in their ways, and just really from the get-go valuing fundraising and really just putting your best foot forward and valuing that expertise will set you up for success.
Tony MartignettiWhat if development and communications are both under the same, let's say, vice president? Is that— that's not sufficient? I mean, you still— still the 2 teams should be meeting together. I mean, I can see a scenario where they don't, even though they're under the same vice president.
Shannon BowenExactly. I actually am also a Chief Advancement Officer for an organization in Seattle, and so I oversee development and communications. And still, even within that, you need to bring everybody together to say, okay, how are we using each vehicle to achieve our goals? And so we're not just, oh, we're only going to send print appeals, we're only going to send email appeals. How are you incorporating social media? How are you incorporating video? Or I currently work with genetic scientists. We're talking about podcasting because they don't really like to be on camera. You know, I think that we have to be creative about those different mediums to increase the brand recognition, but also to talk to the donors about the content that they're interested in. And really it's coming together, brainstorming, that we get our best ideas.
Tony MartignettiAll right. And that's a great transition to another one of your learning outcomes from your description, expanding social media. As well as earned and traditional media. Yeah. Who speaks to— okay, is that yours?
Emily DiFriscoThis is my favorite topic, is press and media. I still believe it's the best way to reach the most amount of people. When you have a piece in the New York Times or the San Francisco Chronicle or the Chicago Tribune, you know, you're reaching millions, tens of millions of people at once. So it's very important to develop in your communications team a robust press and media strategy. Develop that calendar and then keep some of it flexible for breaking news. And then work with your executive director, your program directors, your science director, whomever you have at the organization who's really moving and shaking, and come up with a way that you can develop news for your organization. And you can use one of the fancy platforms that there are to pitch journalists, like Cision or Meltwater. There's other ones as well.
Tony MartignettiIs it hard? Help a reporter out, HARO. Is that still a thing?
Emily DiFriscoYeah, I think it is.
Tony MartignettiHARO is still there? Yeah, I think so.
Emily DiFriscoBut you can also be scrappy about it and build your own press list using an Excel spreadsheet. That's a possibility too. Build relationships with journalists that way. And then when you have a press release ready to go, you pitch the journalist and you make a splash with that news and try to connect it to current events. And then once you have that piece that you landed, then You can approach your development team and say, hey, we're in the San Francisco Chronicle today on the front page. And that is so validating for donors and for board and for everyone who cares about your organization's mission.
Tony MartignettiYou said something that I want to flesh out a little bit. Have a relationship with journalists before you're pitching.
Emily DiFriscoYeah.
Tony MartignettiBefore there's a news item, news hook related to your work. Say a little more about Developing that relationship, you know, like building the well, digging the well before you're thirsty.
Emily DiFriscoYeah.
Tony MartignettiYou know, building the relationship before you want to pitch the journalist.
Emily DiFriscoThere's so many ways to do it. You can follow journalists you like on Twitter who are reporting on issues that your organization works on. You can tweet at them and say, hey, thank you, I read your piece, it was great, would love to connect with you. You can build that press list, as I mentioned. And you can proactively share with them the work your organization is doing. In our session, we talked a lot about virtual town halls. Yeah, basically a fancy phrase for webinar. And you can invite journalists to your webinars. Invite them to your virtual town halls. They might write about your work. At the very least, they're going to get educated about the work your organization is doing. So all of those are things you can do to build relationships with journalists.
Tony MartignettiOkay. And to the extent that there's still local journalism, which is not nearly what it was 10 years ago, that includes local journalists, not only the New York Times and the San Francisco Chronicle and the Chicago Tribune.
Emily DiFriscoAbsolutely. We just had Fox News come out to our office in Oakland yesterday. They came out at like 7 PM and interviewed our CEO about a report that we launched yesterday. So local journalism is still alive and well, although it has, you You know, as you said, there's been some setbacks, but you can still reach local journalists and they'll still report on the work your organization is doing.
Tony MartignettiOkay. All right. So your earned and traditional media. Social media. Shannon, do you want to flesh out social media a little bit?
Shannon BowenI'd actually love to hand this over to Emily because she has an amazing hot-off-the-press story about TikTok.
Emily DiFriscoYeah. So we released this toxic fashion report yesterday. We have tested a lot of consumer products for toxic chemicals, and we found over the period of the last 10 years high levels of lead in purses and other accessories at Ross and Burlington stores. So of course we've sent them legal notices, but it's kind of like a persistent problem. So we released this report yesterday detailing kind of our results and the legal actions that we've taken. And we did a TikTok video on it, which we didn't expect to get a lot of traction because it's really like kind of a slide carousel with music. And as of today, it's reached over 300,000 people. So social media, there is, is still a wonderful way to reach people.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Is there a broader lesson that our consultant from Monsoon wants to extrapolate from the The TikTok breaking news?
Shannon BowenWell, I think that you have no idea which of those 300,000 views is going to be your next major donor. And major donors are looking for causes that resonate with their values. And they're looking out in the world, they're watching TikTok. And we had an experience at Center for Environmental Health where we had out of the blue an email to our info@ceh.org, started connecting and talking with them, and they turned into a $300,000 over 3 Yeah. Or a donor. And you just never know who is, who is reading, who is watching, but you have to find a way to engage them and bring them in. And then once they're there, using all of your communication strategies to steward the donor and bring them even closer and increase that gift. And so I really think that all development directors should be savvy in communications and be open and willing to new communication channels like TikTok. You know, Twitter was the hot thing 5 years ago, and now we know it isn't. So you got to be open to LinkedIn, TikTok, all the different ways that people are engaging now, because it could shift and you don't want to be left behind.
Tony MartignettiNow, these were 2 anecdotes that both called up the number 300,000. You're not making this up, are you?
Shannon BowenNo, no.
Tony MartignettiCoincidence?
Shannon BowenI guess it's just our lucky number.
Emily DiFriscoI guess so.
Tony MartignettiAll right, all right. Just skeptic in me. Okay, I'm sure you're being Very truthful for nonprofit radio listeners. I mean, you wouldn't lie. You wouldn't lie at all. I never would lie. Scout's honor. All right. Yes. Were you a Scout?
Shannon BowenI was a Girl Scout for a long time.
Tony MartignettiYes, I was. All right, good. Then you're honored.
Shannon BowenI sold a lot of cookies.
Tony MartignettiThen Scout's honor counts. Otherwise, it would have to be a pinky pledge. Scout's honor counts. Anything else you want to say about media, whether social, traditional, earned?
Emily DiFriscoI think social media is still a great way to showcase your organization. Okay.
Tony MartignettiYeah.
Emily DiFriscoAnd what we do at CEH is we have a comprehensive editorial calendar. We keep some of it flexible, and we do different strategies across different platforms. LinkedIn is growing really quickly right now, so is TikTok, Instagram a little bit. So definitely diversify your strategy across social media. The news is very hard, it's very depressing. Our work is sometimes challenging, so I always encourage I really encourage social media strategists to celebrate the wins. So when you do have a piece of good news or you are part of some legislation that passes, you know, really celebrate that on social media and you will find that those are some of the most highly engaged with posts that you create.
Shannon BowenAnd I'll also add that in our session we talked a lot about email strategies with donors and segmenting your list and really talking to your donors in different ways and different places.
Tony MartignettiYou're holding out. You're holding out on Nonprofit Radio listeners. Glossing over.
Shannon BowenHere we go. So when I came to CEH, there had been a 2-year vacancy in the director of development role, so our donors hadn't heard from us. So the first thing we did is we set up a what we called our 3 Things email, and this was a monthly email from our CEO to our major donors. It came from his name, it looked like a normal email, to the point that people would respond back and be like, oh, it's so great to hear Hey, here's how you're doing. Here's my, my wife out there. And it's like, oh, this is the development team. Okay,
Tony Martignettiall right. But it looked like it was, it was fresh off his email.
Shannon BowenExactly. And we had huge engagement with it. And we actually ended up— we were writing a story about, uh, toxic chemicals and exercise bands. You wouldn't think that's how you're going to get back one of your biggest lapsed donors, but we did. And she wrote back and said, oh, I'm using this brand, blah blah blah. We had it tested by our toxics team wrote back to her. Not only did she come back as a lapsed donor, but then she, for the first time ever, introduced us to her family foundation, and we got a second gift from her family foundation. And it was all because of this email and the interaction, the opening the conversation through that email. And so we really believe in the power of segmented emails, talking in different voices, providing different content that all aligns with your brand but really speaks to the donor.
Tony MartignettiAnd how does this align our bigger purpose of bringing together, what do you say, harnessing the development and communications teams?
Shannon BowenWell, and I think that's because we would repurpose content from the communications team and we would hear, oh, this is what's hitting really big on social media. This is what reporters are really interested in. And we would tailor that content to the major donors based on what was hitting. And lo and behold, it would engage in conversation. And our donors would say, hey, I want to hear more about that report. You know, how did you guys even think to test lead in purses? You know, and so I think it's like if you don't know the data of the other team, you don't really know what your audience wants. And we need to deliver the content that our audience is actually interested in. So you got to entertain too.
Tony MartignettiPurses and exercise bands.
Shannon BowenWell, that's— and socks. We did a whole safe
Emily DiFriscosocks campaign and clothing, high levels of BPA in all of our workout clothing, sports bras, leggings, shirts, shorts. Yeah, so this is one of the issues that we're tackling with our public interest litigation, telling companies, get the BPA out of the clothes.
Tony MartignettiOkay. We still have more time together. You did a, what, a 60-minute session, right? So we're not fleshing out some things. We've only been talking for about 15 minutes. We're not Fleshing out some things that you did for your live session.
Shannon BowenWell, I think one thing that we talked about is really about validating your brand, that there are a lot of people that are tackling the same issues that you are, and you also have a great mission, but you really have to validate your brand to attract top donors. And so using earned media, using virtual town halls where you're, you're CEO in line with other stakeholders, that builds trust of your brand and validity that you are actually the right person to be delivering this mission, that all increases the dollar amount that you're going to get from donors. So you really have to be thinking about all of these things working together to validate your brand, because there's a lot of great missions, there's a lot of great organizations, but why are you the right person to do this work? And that's what's going to get a new major donor or a larger gift from an existing donor.
Tony MartignettiWhat were some of the, some of the questions that you got?
Emily DiFriscoWe got so Yeah,
Tony Martignettiokay. Share some.
Emily DiFriscoLet's see. We definitely talked a lot about virtual town halls. People were very excited about that topic and exactly what Shannon was just saying about bringing together different stakeholders to kind of validate your brand. We talked a lot about press and media coverage and talked about how you don't have to have a huge budget and you don't have to have a super comprehensive plan. You can get started just sitting sitting down with your executive director, your program directors, your science director, whomever you have who's really moving and shaking at the organization, and create a piece together. And what you want to do for that is think about what the work your organization is doing, what, what's happening, what has changed, because that's what reporters want to talk about, is what has changed in your organization or what has changed in the work. And then connecting it to current events, what's going on in world that's connected to your organization's work. And then you can write an op-ed together.
Tony MartignettiThat's those news hooks we talked about.
Emily DiFriscoYeah, and you can pitch it to different reporters, or you can publish it on your website. You can publish it on LinkedIn. And that's a way of really driving thought leadership forward.
Shannon BowenAbsolutely. We also had an interesting question about how many staff we had, and who's actually watching the metrics, and who's reporting back the metrics. Why we were inspired to do this session is we both have small teams. So Emily had 2 staff and I had 3 staff, and it really just takes a dedicated portion of one person's time to look at the metrics and to discover the gems. I told a story of I had a staff who would look at who opened and who clicked on the emails, and she brought it to our team and she said, hey, there's this donor that's been— they only give about $500, but they're opening and I was looking at everything, and when I looked at them, they're actually a producer in Hollywood. Maybe we should reengage them. Guess what? We did, and it turned into a $10,000 donor. And so by having someone just take a minute and look at those, bring that data back to the team, you can actually optimize your process and get a bigger result. And so, you know, we're not a huge shop. We're small shops, but we just kind of work smarter, not harder. And really by working together.
Tony MartignettiEven though Even though it's Monsoon Consulting, you're not enormous? You're not creating tidal waves and tsunamis?
Shannon BowenNo, just little lightning bolts.
Tony MartignettiAll right.
Shannon BowenYeah.
Emily DiFriscoYou can create a tidal wave with a few amount of people.
Shannon BowenThat's true. That is true. Well, our 300,000 on TikTok today. There you go.
Tony MartignettiOh, that was just today? That much breaking news?
Shannon BowenYeah, that just happened.
Tony MartignettiThat breaking. All right.
Shannon BowenYeah.
Tony MartignettiAll right.
Shannon BowenSo it didn't make it to our slideshow because it just happened.
Tony MartignettiIs there any more, any more questions that came that you think could be instructive for us?
Shannon BowenI think there was definitely some people that just felt really frustrated, you know, that they want to do things this way, or they want to try new ideas, and the other team member doesn't want to. And I think that Emily and I are both early adopters of technology. We're both really open-minded, and it's like you have everything Everything is moving so fast right now. You have to be open to new technologies and new ways to communicate with your donors. And if you do things, the same thing over and over again, you're going to bore your donors and you're going to see attrition. And so I think that just one of the main takeaways is be creative, take risks. You talked about an idea that failed. Mm-hmm. And you have to be open to failure to be able to be successful. And I think that both of us have that same ethos and we brought that to our teams. And that's why we could create so much success in a short amount of time. You know, while I was there, our development team brought in close to $1 million over our goal. We could not have done that without the support of the comms team and all of their creative ideas and immersing our donors in this message that what we're doing is important and vital and urgent. And that's where I feel like you're missing out if you're not harnessing your communications team. You're missing out on the bigger ripple effect you I'm
Tony Martignettidying to leave it there because that was a beautiful closing. However, there's a story that you teased, a story of a failure that's instructive.
Emily DiFriscoDefinitely.
Tony MartignettiWhy don't you tell that story, Emily?
Emily DiFriscoYeah, so sometimes your op-ed that you craft, that you spend so much time on, does not get picked up. So we have had, you know, an op-ed on the front page of the San Francisco Chronicle, and then there was another time that we We spent a lot of work on an op-ed on the very sexy topic of leaded aviation gas. I know, people are falling asleep already. Ooh. So this is actually a big problem because in the small little municipal airports where the small aircraft are flying, a lot of leaded aviation gas is released and then the folks living in that area have high blood lead levels. So we wrote this op-ed about this California airport and how the children living nearby had blood lead levels on par or worse than those in Flint during the height of the lead poisoning crisis. Hmm. So we had a lot of facts and figures and a lot of solutions. It talked about our litigation kind of making, you know, unleaded aviation gas more prominent and prevalent. And nobody bit. We pitched it out a bunch of different places. And nobody bit, but it was okay because what we ended up doing is posting it on our blog and kind of made lemonade out of lemons, and that page has been one of the most viewed pages on our website. So it all worked out in the end, even though we failed along the way to place the op-ed.
Tony MartignettiOkay, okay. How about we leave it there then?
Shannon BowenSure, sounds great.
Tony MartignettiA good willingness to share a failure that Resulted in a highly viewed page and also Shannon's 2 minutes ago, very good wrap-up. Good job, Shannon. Which I was very tempted to end there, but I wanted to hear the story. You can't tease the story off the hook.
Emily DiFriscoDon't end with failure though.
Tony MartignettiNo, but that's why I wanted to—
Shannon BowenBut it wasn't a failure. It was the most read page on the blog. It was a well-read page. And a LinkedIn article, which, you know, really harnessing all the LinkedIn tools is a great way to reach your audience.
Emily DiFriscoRight. And I don't think people should be afraid of failure because if you're trying new things, you will fail. And you should embrace it and learn from it. And it's going to be— it's going to work out.
Tony MartignettiEspecially something that's outside your control, like whether a newspaper accepts your op-ed or not.
Emily DiFriscoExactly.
Tony MartignettiBut if you don't try, you're certainly not going to get published.
Emily DiFriscoRight.
Shannon BowenAnd then you balance that with things you can control— your blog, hosting your own virtual town hall, hosting your own panel event. You can control those things. So yeah, you have some percentage of stuff you're throwing out into the world and hoping it sticks, and the other half you're actually controlling and making sure it fits within your strategy.
Tony MartignettiThat's Shannon Bowen, founder and CEO at Monsoon Leadership. With her is Emily DiFrisco, Senior Director of Communications at the Center for Environmental Health. Shannon, Emily, thanks very much.
Emily DiFriscoThank you.
Shannon BowenThank you so much. This was wonderful.
Tony MartignettiI'm glad. Thank you.
Shannon BowenYeah.
Tony MartignettiAnd thanks to you for being with Nonprofit Radio's coverage of the 2024 Nonprofit Technology Conference, where we are sponsored by Heller Consulting, technology strategy and implementation for nonprofits.
Kate MartignettiNext week, more from 24 NTC with Strategic Meetings for Teams of One and Cyber incident cases and takeaways. If you missed any part of this week's show,
Tony MartignettiI beseech you, find it at tonymartignetti.com.
Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by Virtuous. Virtuous gives you the nonprofit CRM, fundraising, volunteer, and marketing tools you need to create more responsive donor experiences and grow giving. virtuous.org. And by DonorBox. Outdated donation forms blocking your supporters' generosity? DonorBox. Fast, flexible, and friendly fundraising forms for your nonprofit. donorbox.org.
Tony MartignettiFast, flexible, friendly fundraising forms. Love it.
Kate MartignettiOur creative producer is Claire Meyerhoff. I'm your associate producer, Kate Martignetti. The show's show Our social media is by Susan Chavez. Marc Silverman is our web guy, and this music is by Scott Stein.
Tony MartignettiThank you for that affirmation, Scotty. Be with us next week for Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. Go out and be great.
I love our sponsors!

Virtuous
Virtuous gives you the nonprofit CRM, fundraising, volunteer, and marketing tools you need to create more responsive donor experiences and grow giving.

More Episodes from 2024 Nonprofit Technology Conference
View All


Exploit Conflict & Intuition To Make Better Programs & Products
with Drew Nelson, Cassi Johnson, and Eve LaCivita




Use Your Tech To Enable Generosity
with Jamie Mueller, Peter Genuardi, and Natania LeClerc



