Acquiring Email Leads On Social & Matching Gifts 101, 201, 301





Acquiring Email Leads On Social
This 2024 Nonprofit Technology Conference conversation helps you ensure your email acquisition efforts are targeting those interested in your work. You can incentivize your social audiences so they’ll willingly share their emails and you can measure the success of your acquisition campaigns. Melanie Schaffel from Parkinson’s Foundation helps you get started.
Recorded At
2024 Nonprofit Technology ConferenceMatching Gifts 101, 201, 301
Julie Ziff Sint, Alison Hermance and Mark Doty, also from 24NTC, explain the different types and styles of matching gifts and challenge grants. How do you ethically message and how do you establish your own matching gifts asks? What if you don’t have a matching gift to take advantage of? And more. Julie is with Sanky Communications. Alison is from WildCare. And Mark is at San Francisco SPCA.
Here’s the transcript
Tony MartignettiHello and welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. I am your aptly named host and the podfather of your favorite hebdomadal podcast. Oh, I'm glad you're with us. I'd get slapped with a diagnosis of primary sclerosing cholangitis if you inflamed and scarred me with the idea that you missed this week's show. Here's our associate producer Kate with the highlights.
Kate MartignettiHey Tony, this week we have acquiring email leads on social. This 2024 Nonprofit Technology Conference conversation helps you ensure your email acquisition efforts are targeting those interested in your work. You can incentivize your social audiences so they'll willingly share their emails, and you can measure the success of your acquisition campaigns. Melanie Schaffel from Parkinson's Foundation helps you get started. Then matching gifts 101, 201, and 301. Julie Ziff Sint, Alison Hermance, and Mark Doty, also from 24 NTC, explain the different types and styles of matching gifts and challenge grants. How do you ethically message And how do you establish your own matching gifts asks, what if you don't have a matching gift to take advantage of? And more. Julie is with Sanky Communications. Alison is from WildCare. And Marc is at San Francisco SPCA. On Tony's Take Two.
Tony MartignettiTravel convos.
Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by Virtuous. Virtuous gives you the nonprofit CRM, fundraising, volunteer, and marketing tools you need to create more responsive donor experiences and grow giving. virtuous.org. Here is Acquiring Email Leads on Social.
Tony MartignettiWelcome back to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio coverage of the 2024 Nonprofit Technology Conference in In Portland, Oregon, where we are sponsored by Heller Consulting, technology strategy and implementation for nonprofits. Before we start the conversation, I want to let you know that you may hear sounds of a teardown around us. There's 24 NTC, the archive is being taken down booth by booth around us. Nonprofit Radio perseveres. This is irrelevant to us. We have our own power. I have a generator outside and 50 gallons of diesel fuel, so we're prepared to continue regardless of what happens around the Nonprofit Radio booth. And for our— this is our final conversation of 2024, and it is with Melanie Schaffel. She is Senior Manager of Digital Advertising at the Parkinson's Foundation. Welcome to Nonprofit Radio, Melanie.
Melanie SchaffelThank you, Tony. Thanks so much for having me.
Tony MartignettiIt's my pleasure. Thank you for rounding out our many conversations.
Melanie SchaffelI won't say save the best for last. That's a lot of pressure, but it's breaking down.
Tony MartignettiIt's a little cliché. No, no, no, don't do that to yourself. It is breaking down, but it's irrelevant. And I've been looking forward to this because I think these conversions are important. So, We're talking about acquiring email leads on social. We're trying to convert our folks, right? Take a next step. You're active with us on social.
Melanie SchaffelYou might like us enough on social, yeah.
Tony MartignettiGive a finger, grab a hand. We'd like a little more.
Melanie SchaffelCome over. We've got more things to offer on email for sure. So a lot of the discussion we had was about all the social, email, website, all of our digital channels working in tandem. So we know that there's a lot of people on social that have proven interest in us already. So if they don't know already that we have an email series that they can join, we want to let them know how to easily get into it.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Let's start with identifying who the best prospects are for this upgraded engagement opportunity.
Melanie SchaffelYeah.
Tony MartignettiLet's call it the upgraded— yeah, the EOG. Classic EOG. We always— everyone knows that.
Melanie SchaffelUpgraded opportunity. All right.
Tony MartignettiWho should we be focusing on in our social channels?
Melanie SchaffelSo, an efficient way that we found to focus on the people that are proving interest is to use that first-party data that for us Meta provides. These ads will be right through Meta, right on the platform, and we can upload our lists. We can create lists from different engagements that people are taking on Facebook, whether they're watching our video or DMing us, sliding into our DMs, right? Ending up in our inbox. Yeah. And using that first-party data, just because in this more and more cookieless world that the whole wide internet is joining in on, that the first-party data is key here. So, we want to focus in on that. And a lot of The session also focused on creating lookalikes of those, so people that act similarly to the people that have proven interest to help broaden the reach a little bit wider.
Tony MartignettiBut what is this, creating lookalikes? Oh, yeah. This sounds like something phony. What is this? It does sound— It sounds like scamming and phishing and ransomware. What is this?
Melanie SchaffelIt is my favorite way to sound really impressive to my colleagues when I tell them that this is an option at all. What is it? Meta can create a whole new list based off the way that people act online. They act at least similarly online. And so whether the places they're visiting, the actions they're taking online, based off their emails, based off the list of emails that we provide, Meta can generate a lookalike list. So just people that are acting similarly to the ones we already know like us, and hopefully they like us too.
Tony MartignettiOkay, so these are folks that you don't know, and Meta is finding them, bringing them Well, they're not bringing them to you, but they're identifying them for you? Identifying them, yeah. They're not currently engaged with Parkinson's, but they act like a lot of people who are. That's correct.
Melanie SchaffelIs that it? That's what I'm thinking. Yeah, the algorithm's working in our favor that way.
Tony MartignettiI see. All right, well, I'm glad it has some value for somebody somewhere. That's mildly reassuring, infinitesimally reassuring, but I'm glad it's helping you. All right, so then what might you do? How do you then reach out to those folks?
Melanie SchaffelSo we're targeting— that's right. So the whole discussion did focus on the lead generation ads that we create right in Meta. The idea behind it is that people are scrolling in their newsfeed when we want them to do an action. A lot of times we don't— they don't want to be taken away from their scroll. They don't want another app to pop up or a browser to pop up. So by keeping them right in the platform, there's a form that pops up from the ad that they can fill out real quick in exchange for a resource that we hooked them in with already and just give us a quick piece of information. A lot of it also, if the user has already approved autofill and whatnot on Facebook, then it kind of just pops in and generates there already. So it's a really fast track to the finish line for the user and they just give us their name, email, We get out of there. They get their resource. Everyone wins.
Tony MartignettiWhat's your resource hook?
Melanie SchaffelSo we've tested— this was like over 6 months. We ran about 6 ads only for about a week each. And we tested different resources each time. A lot of times we focus on things that we know our audience wants and likes based off of SEO, social learning, whether it's a highly trafficked page. Or a resource that's already— that usually performs well and highly engaged with organically on social, things that we know people want, we can kind of hang that like a little carrot on a stick, right? I don't know if that's the saying, carrot for the user, right?
Tony MartignettiYeah, carrot on a stick. Yeah, carrot on a stick. It's usually carrot on a stick, but the carrot on a stick works too. Both. Okay, okay.
Melanie SchaffelSo in our case, maybe exercise content performs super well. I'm at the Parkinson's Foundation, and exercise is really important for people with Parkinson's disease. So they're always looking for what kind of exercise should I be doing or how often. Right. And so if we have a PDF, a fact sheet, something like that, we let them know, like, if you just give us this little piece of information, we've got a PDF on the other side for you.
Tony MartignettiOkay. And you're asking very low threshold, like first name and email?
Melanie SchaffelFirst, last name and email. But yeah. And my last name too? Well, yeah, we're just trying to get to know you. It's like almost a hand-holding. That's right.
Tony MartignettiAll right. Hold my hands. All right. First, last, email. So very low boundaries. I always object and I never fill in the thing. Phone. What state are you in? I even object to state. I mean, I've been asked state. I don't know if I've seen zip code, but I would find that equally annoying. Look, you're just giving me a little PDF or a link to a video or something, or a white paper, for God's sake. You know, I'm not— it's not a marriage proposal.
Melanie SchaffelThat's right. I think we've done lead generation ads where we have asked for state if it's like a volunteer opportunity. We just want to be able to like sort them through to the right person. But for this, we just want you on the email list. And I think there's an opportunity here for people. Uh, we, we can get them in a different welcoming series, right? All the people that joined us through the lead generation ads, maybe we start setting them up in a welcoming series where we get to know them and can ask more intimate questions like, Do you want to join our local chapter? Or, you know, when were you diagnosed? Or different things that might help us get them into the right journey, right? Depending on how specific we might have those options. But yeah, there's opportunity later to get to know them a lot better. And we're just starting off just by collecting their email and we can work with that from there.
Tony MartignettiYeah. Don't, right. Don't ask for everything at the outset. It is, it's a journey.
Melanie SchaffelRight. There's a chance that we'll get like abandoners from there and we just want to, Maximize the efficiency here.
Tony MartignettiRight. Something to the finish line. You said easy sprint to the finish line. Let's get started. Simple. All right. And then we'll take our time. We can get to know you. There's plenty of time. All right. What did you call it that Meta will give you, the people who act like the people you identify?
Melanie SchaffelThe lookalike ads, yes.
Tony MartignettiLocal?
Melanie SchaffelLookalike. Lookalike.
Tony MartignettiYep. Lookalike. They're just called lookalikes?
Melanie SchaffelLookalike ads, yeah. When you upload a list or you create a list, That'll ask you, do you want to create a lookalike? And this is something that even if— so one of the ways too that we try to— what we're after are new emails. We want new people into the database. We've also found that people that we've already had in the database that found these ads, they're finding like new value from this. So it's also okay if new people are seeing this ad, but— Okay. The focus here is trying to grow the email list, grow our email size. So the focus is with that, but in order to kind of exclude the people that we already have, we upload our email list and we exclude that. But when we upload it, Facebook says, do you want to generate a lookalike list of this? So while we're excluding the ones we already had, we can include the lookalike. So it's a nice—
Tony MartignettiAnd you You trust Facebook when you upload these email addresses?
Melanie SchaffelAnd that's— it's not a perfect science, let's put it that way, because hey, maybe you logged in with your Facebook with like an email from 2010, and maybe you don't use that one anymore. So maybe you're on a different one, and that's why it's not a perfect science. With this strategy, about 50% are new in total to our database. Like I said, it's not what we're after is repeating customers, but we are reestablishing value in a different way. So it kind of works out.
Tony MartignettiWell, there's that too. But I was asking about trusting Facebook with the emails that you're giving them. You trust them with that?
Melanie SchaffelWell.
Tony MartignettiYou don't have a choice. Right. I'm sure they— well, do they say something like, well, this is subject to our Privacy policy, which you can go read, it's 79 pages.
Melanie SchaffelI think ultimately, uh, you know, ads in general, digital ads in this world we live in, is like they get a super bad rep a lot of times, and rightfully so, right? Wrongfully using different pieces of information. But as a nonprofit, we're just trying to like accelerate our mission's good. So we're, you know, targeting certain people, but We want— they need our resources, and so we want more people to have them.
Kate MartignettiIt's time for a break. Virtuous is a software company committed to helping nonprofits grow generosity. Virtuous believes that generosity has the power to create profound change in the world and in the heart of the giver. It's their mission to move the needle on global generosity. By helping nonprofits better connect with and inspire their givers. Responsive fundraising puts the donor at the center of fundraising and grows giving through personalized donor journeys that respond to the needs of each individual. Virtuous is the only responsive nonprofit CRM designed to help you build deeper relationships with every donor at scale. Virtuous gives you the nonprofit CRM fundraising, volunteer, marketing, and automation tools you need to create responsive experiences that build trust and grow impact. Virtuous.org. Now back to Acquiring Email Leads on Social with Melanie Schaffel.
Tony MartignettiIs there another way to do this, get these conversions from social besides, uh, targeted ads?
Melanie SchaffelThis is the easiest way to do the in-platform form solution, right? You can do an organic post that sends them to your website where you— it might be parkinsons.org/subscribe or something, right? Where they can put their email in on our website. We have different forms like that.
Tony MartignettiHere's the— you can hear the booths coming down around us, literally, as the carts go out. I hope there aren't bodies in these I can't tell. They have opaque sides.
Melanie SchaffelI've seen a lot of Law and Order. Those don't look like that.
Tony MartignettiOh, you're an expert. Those are clean. Those are clean.
Melanie SchaffelThat's good stuff.
Tony MartignettiI was talking to a law enforcement expert, forensics. She's also a digital forensics expert. She can find your date of birth.
Melanie SchaffelNot through this ad, though.
Tony MartignettiNo, but she's seen a lot of Law and Order. So, expert. OK. Those carts are clean. There may be forklifts coming around too, so soon. So we may hear backup buzzers. You know, this is a menagerie here, but Nonprofit Radio perseveres. OK. So I was asking about other methods besides digital ads.
Melanie SchaffelYeah, of course, there's the organic way to get people to your website. It's really efficient just to get them right in the platform. I think, you know, there's other social platforms that have similar opportunities to do these lead generation ads, but a majority of our audience is on Facebook, so we're just grabbing them where they are.
Tony MartignettiAnd what age cohort is the largest proportion for you?
Melanie SchaffelWe find a lot of our audience are children of the people with Parkinson's. Oh,
Tony Martignettinot the Parkinson's patients themselves?
Melanie SchaffelThere is a large audience of people with Parkinson's too, but Let's call it like 50, 60-year-old, older adult children of people that are living with the disease later in life.
Tony MartignettiThat's your largest cohort? Yeah.
Melanie SchaffelWe have a lot of caregiver, care partner resources as well, for sure.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Just so folks know what age group we're talking about, you're targeting mostly people 50+.
Melanie SchaffelYeah. We have opportunities for— a lot of people are on Instagram too, and we're also Trying to engage grandparents of people, grandchildren of those living with Parkinson's. There's a lot of really fun fundraising opportunities that we provide for them as well. But the information going right to the source a lot of time, yeah, right in that Facebook opportunity.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Okay. So just drawing from your description, We've talked about how to, how to do this. How about measuring ROI metrics? What do we look for?
Melanie SchaffelSo one of my favorite parts of the lead generation ad is that it hits on all these different points on the marketing funnel, right? We've got awareness. So at the very least, these ads are going to reach people that may have never heard about our brand and the ads that we're creating, the creative part of it, We've got our blue, we've got our logo. So at the very least, we're going to have like a brand awareness moment. Then one step down, we're informing. We're informing that we have this resource, and we're also informing that we're in like the business of sharing resources. So we might get some new followers along the way on top of the reach and the brand and the impressions. And so one and two checked off. Then we're also like converting people to move away from just being like interested to loyal advocates for us as well by joining our email list. So they're working their way down the funnel. Maybe the first time it doesn't hit them and they convert, but it's a series and maybe the second resource we're offering is more appealing to them. So we might get them on the next try. So it's an interesting ad because we're also— we're doing— Yeah. Impressions, brand awareness, reach, kind of arbitrary, but it still counts for something. We've got website traffic. We're going to get people when they click on the resource to get this, they're clicking through to the website itself.
Tony MartignettiRight.
Melanie SchaffelAnd then we're also opening up our email leads at the same time. So it's hitting a lot of pieces at once. What was interesting for this presentation, I went back into each constituent constituent profile and kind of looked at what their journey was since they were served the ad. And we saw enough donations come through after they were served this ad to justify the whole spend of, of our series.
Tony MartignettiOkay.
Melanie SchaffelSo positive ROAS on top of it all. We love it.
Tony MartignettiPositive what?
Melanie SchaffelROAS.
Tony MartignettiOkay.
Melanie SchaffelReturn on ad spend.
Tony MartignettiOh, not return on investment. ROAS, not ROI. Thank you. Otherwise, otherwise you'd be put in jargon jail. Return on ad spend. Yeah, we have— well, it's related to your law enforcement, your law enforcement background.
Melanie SchaffelMy Law and Order. Dun dun. Is that copyrighted? I hope not.
Tony MartignettiNobody listens to the show. It doesn't matter. No, that's not true. That's not true.
Melanie SchaffelIt's not true.
Tony MartignettiUm, okay. ROAS, return on ad spend. Thank you. But we do have jargon jail on Nonprofit Radio.
Melanie SchaffelOkay. You want to stay out of that?
Tony MartignettiYou You skirted it very quickly by defining your jargon.
Melanie SchaffelYes.
Tony MartignettiWhat else can we talk about? We still have a few minutes left. What else did you share with your audience that you should share with Nonprofit Radio listeners?
Melanie SchaffelI also shared how, you know, maybe you don't have the budget right now to invest in an ad strategy. Maybe you and your boss haven't, you know, had that conversation yet. One, The examples and the strategy that we talked about, maybe this is a good opportunity to ask your— the powers that be, the purse, that maybe this is a good opportunity for you to trial, maybe get a little small investment. You never know what the results can turn into. Maybe they'll be super impressed and they give you more of a budget and it kind of opens up your advertising program from there. But even if you're not there just yet, there's a lot of steps you can take For when you are there, like growing your audience now and doing a lot of social listening and seeing what is working in your other channels, like your email, like what are people clicking through, what do people want. You can create more of that content on your website so that when you are ready to launch these ads, you have like the perfect piece of content that will push people over the edge. You can have something ready for them to offer up.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Anything else we can do in preparation to getting the budget for the ads?
Melanie SchaffelI think going back real quick to growing the audience and just kind of doing a lot of organic work, it's just going to help you with that first-party data when we're doing all the targeting and everything. So putting in that work up front is only gonna benefit you more down the line.
Tony MartignettiOkay, okay. Are you okay if we leave it there?
Melanie SchaffelI'm great with that, yeah.
Tony MartignettiWe haven't given short shrift to Nonprofit Radio listeners.
Melanie SchaffelIt felt good, I don't know.
Tony MartignettiOkay, well, I want them to get the full— this was a 30-minute session, or?
Melanie SchaffelIt was a short 30-minute session, just a little me up there, and yeah, a lot of positive feedback. It's been a good week.
Tony MartignettiOkay, well, it'll continue as folks hear you here. She's Melanie Schaffel, Senior Manager of Digital Advertising at Parkinson's Foundation. Melanie, thank you very much.
Melanie SchaffelThank you so much.
Tony MartignettiAs 24 NTC comes down around us, I thank you for being— she's giving a queen's wave to the forklift truck that's going by. I thank you for being with our coverage of the 2024 Nonprofit Technology Conference. Where we have been sponsored by Heller Consulting, technology strategy and implementation for nonprofits. Thanks so much.
Kate MartignettiIt's time for Tony's Take Two.
Tony MartignettiThank you, Kate. While I was away for the two weeks doing lots of donor meetings that I talked about last week, I had the chance to talk to two guys. Uh, one, uh, in the airport and one on a plane. Vaughn and Jorge. And they were both very different. Uh, Vaughn is, uh, mid-70s, maybe even, uh, maybe even 80, but still working. Uh, he's from Kentucky and he owns 13 Papa John's franchises. Very interesting talking to this guy. Deep in the baby boomer ages about how work has changed. He cites that labor is his biggest problem, keeping 13 Papa John's franchises staffed in the face of people who just don't show up for work. People don't call and say they don't want to work there anymore. They just don't show up. Often, often. And I've heard that from lots of other folks too. But so just, you know, very interesting talking to Vaughn about how work and attitudes toward work have changed that he's experienced, you know, as a 75, 80-year-old and hiring lots of folks in their 20s or even teens. So teens, 20s, And, and, and 30s is, is mostly where his workforce comes from, but it's actually mostly teens and, and 20s. And then Jorge, talked to him on a plane. So he is about, I'd say he's about 32 or so. And he has an interesting career. He, you know, he works in finance for one of the big tech companies full-time. Hmm. Has a finance MBA, but then he also develops real estate projects. And he, he's on his second one, which is a 32-unit residential building with 2 or 3 commercial units on the ground floor. So, you know, talk about the way career has changed. I mean, here's a guy who wants to be doing something different and is kind of make you— making that transition on his own happen. by re-engineering himself as a real estate developer and all the financing that goes into that, getting loans, getting investors, permits, and hiring the contractor. So, you know, Jorge was kind of exemplifying what Vaughn was telling me about, you know, the way he has seen work and career change. So very interesting conversations. I would, you know, I guess I'm always curious about people. I mean, if they don't want to talk, you know, I'm not the annoying guy who keeps talking to them, you know, even after they put their AirPods in, you know, I'm still talking to them. I don't do that. I ask them to take their AirPods out. No, I just, I just leave them alone. I leave them alone. But, you know, but I'm naturally curious about people. So if they're willing to talk, These 2 guys were quite interesting, Vaughn and Jorge, and how work has changed, career has changed. And that is Tony's Take Two. Kate.
Kate MartignettiI think the coolest part of public transportation is meeting a bunch of different strangers. And like, that's what I miss about taking the Amtrak train just back and forth from home to, to the city.
Tony MartignettiYou used to talk to a lot of folks on Amtrak?
Kate MartignettiI remember one girl, this was my first time on the train alone. I couldn't find a spot and she was getting off at the next spot and she told me to come sit down with her. And then we started talking about college and all this stuff, and she was actually designing public playgrounds for different schools. And like, we just got to know each other in that like 15 minutes that we had together. And like, I really connected with her. It was so— Yeah. It was a good experience.
Tony MartignettiThat's it. Yeah, connections. You're right. You're right.
Kate MartignettiWell, we've got beaucoup, but loads more time. Here is Matching Gifts 101, 201, and 301.
Tony MartignettiWelcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio coverage of 24NTC. It's the 2024 Nonprofit Technology Conference. We are all at the Oregon Convention Center in Portland, Oregon. Julie, Alison, Marc, welcome.
Julie Ziff SintThank you. Thank you. Thanks so much for having us.
Tony MartignettiIt's our— my pleasure. Julie Ziff Sint is Vice President, Account and Strategic Services at Sanky Communications. Alison Hermance is Director of Communications and Marketing at WildCare. And Mark Doty is Director of of Annual Giving at San Francisco SPCA. And we are talking about matching gifts. Your session is Matching Gifts 101, 201, and 301. So we're gonna run the spectrum, not the PhD level. I guess that'll be next year. We're still undergrad here. Oh, you're still— this is undergrad? Yeah. Okay. And you took your senior year off. Indeed. We're not doing the 401. Okay.
Julie Ziff SintCombined it all into 1 hour.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Well, we're going to condense it down even a little more. A little more. Marc, I'm going to start down there with you.
Mark DotyYeah.
Tony MartignettiOkay. What, just generally, just like sort of tee us up, what could we be doing a little smarter, better, generally with matching gifts?
Mark DotyWith matching gifts, 2 things. There's a lot of different kinds of matching gifts. So there's a perception out there that if you're doing a matching gift, you need large amounts of money. You need to double, triple, quadruple it. There's actually a number of different kinds of matching gifts you can do, and they have different uses. So you don't necessarily need a lot of money. You can do what we call a contingent match, for example, where it's—
Tony MartignettiWe're going to get into the details.
Mark DotyYou're going to get into the details? Yes. Okay. So in general, I would say consider doing a match even if you don't have large amounts of money. Make sure you plan it out, and make sure you work with your organization, like your major gift officers and and maybe a communications department to make sure it's well publicized and that you can actually get the dollars for a match.
Tony MartignettiOkay, thank you. Alison, I'm taking from your session description, and Marc started to allude to these different types and styles of matching gifts. Can you— now since he mentioned contingency, is this an okay place to talk about contingency?
Alison HermanceAm I the person to talk about that? I may not be the person to talk about that specifically. It's your brother. No, it is. The thing about matching gifts that I think people really— we want people to take from our session is that they are incredibly effective and they are incredibly something that people get very excited about, both your donors and your team members. So, introducing the concept of a matching gift to your donors is something that's going to inspire their giving and also inspire your team to reach new heights and do better things with your fundraising for your organization.
Tony MartignettiOkay, okay. So let's start to get into some detail then, Julie. Absolutely. I'll try you then. Mark mentioned contingency. Why don't you acquaint us with different types?
Julie Ziff SintYeah, no problem. So most people will think about the standard of all gifts up to $100,000 will be doubled, right? And that's kind of your standard Double match, or you could say tripled, and that's your standard triple match. When you get into some of the other, other types of matches, you can say things like, if we get 50 new sustainers, 50 new monthly donors, we'll get an additional $10,000. That's a contingency match where we have to reach this threshold, and then we're going to get this lump sum of money. It can be a much easier ask, especially when you're asking for a certain number of donors. You don't have to You don't have to give dollars. You just have to be one person. You can also get into different types of matches where if you have the money already in hand, you can say, this major donor has made this donation. Will you step up and match their gift? You can even have a campaign where you ask your donors to create a matching gift fund to then inspire their peers. So there's a variety of different types of tactics and ways that you can use, talk about, and create matching gift campaigns.
Tony MartignettiAre we considering corporate matching gifts here too, or is that something different?
Julie Ziff SintAbsolutely.
Tony MartignettiWe are considering— that's in our 101, 201, 301 portfolio?
Julie Ziff SintSo corporate matches are a little bit different. We're not really going to be talking about corporate matches as Not as much, although corporate matching gifts are certainly very valuable. It's more of an individual technique that is often valuable on the back end. So someone makes the gifting and you say, do you work for a corporation, for an entity that's matching your gift?
Tony MartignettiOkay. Alright, so we're talking here about individual donors doing different types of matches or collectively Okay, go ahead.
Alison HermanceYes, so I was going to say, at my organization, WildCare—
Tony MartignettiI was hoping for a simple-minded explanation. All right, WildCare, what do you do? At
Alison Hermancemy organization, WildCare, there is some confusion between the two ideas of matching. And so you have corporate matching, which is I work for a company and I make a donation, and then I request for my corporation, my company, to match that gift. So that's what we consider corporate matching. You can also have a corporation that gives your organization a gift to be matched. So we're talking about that idea of money that's being donated that will be an incentive for individual donors to match. And so sort of 2 different things with sort of the same name, so a source of confusion for us as well.
Tony MartignettiOkay, no, thank you. I mean, you all have been thinking about this for a long time. I'm a neophyte. Marc, how about you at San Francisco SPCA, what are you doing there around matching gifts?
Mark DotyAround matching gifts, we plan those into our annual planning process. So we will actually sit down and say, oh, we're going to do big campaigns around the holidays. We're going to do a big campaign around the end of our fiscal year. We're going to need a match for those. So we will actually go out to our major gift officers, plan out our timing, say, we're going to need you to secure some matches for us by this date. And then we actually integrate that into actually producing campaigns, which we then promote with the hope that the match is going to inspire more people to give, and when they give, to give more. Yeah.
Alison HermanceAnd indeed it does.
Tony MartignettiOkay. They do work. I mean, otherwise we wouldn't be here. Right. This is a positive. This is upbeat. This is not— Absolutely. Don't do matching gifts. Yeah. There's no question here. Exactly. No, no. Right. All right.
Alison HermanceAnd we were actually just talking about how you never We don't test this because you would never want to give half of your audience something that didn't include the matching gift. They are that successful that you don't A/B test that. We know how well they work. Oh,
Tony Martignettiall right. And our consultant on the team, on the panel, Julie, you agree with that?
Julie Ziff SintAbsolutely. We have done a lot of testing around things like match length, for example. So there are a lot of giving tips.
Tony MartignettiMatch length meaning duration of time? So the duration, exactly.
Julie Ziff SintSo for example, giving 2 A lot of organizations have a match. If you don't have a match on GivingTuesday, you're going to need to think about something really exciting to cut through the match clutter and the match language that other organizations are putting out. But there are now a lot of organizations that have started promoting their GivingTuesday matches before Thanksgiving. We have tested things like that, and when you're, when you're looking at elements like that, that GivingTuesday preview match before Thanksgiving, it doesn't actually work. Okay. You're not going to get a substantial lift on it. So there are definitely times and ways that you want to use your match and promote it to have the most efficacy. But overall, all of the data, both data around the industry and data from our clients where we've done a matching gift campaign versus not a matching gift campaign, or have multiple clients where we can see who has matches and who doesn't, every data point What the data shows is that having a matching gift of some sort is always going to be beneficial for your campaign.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Okay. Alison, what type of different asks do you have? Can you acquaint us with— you started to allude, you made the difference between corporate and individual. On the individual side, what are some of the sample asks?
Alison HermanceWell, we're very lucky at WildCare. We take care of injured and orphaned wild animals, so I have absolutely adorable animals like baby opossums Or baby raccoons or baby squirrels or an animal that's going to be really compelling. But one of the matches that we frequently do is our summer match. And the summer match is to help raise funds for our wildlife babies to help them to grow up healthy and be released back to the wild. And so that gift is— that matching campaign is really, really effective because you can show the benefit of the match for the actual individual animals that are being raised and being treated at our wildlife hospital. So that is a really fun one. Another one that we do is— Julie talked about not making a preview for your Giving Tuesday match, but we do have started doing every year a matching gift fund, which is asking individual donors to contribute to the match, but before the Giving Tuesday actual matching gift goes into effect. So it's building that matching gift fund. And same thing, uh, you know, doing it for the animals, giving the, the care that the animals need, and raising that money to be an inspiration for other donors on Giving Tuesday itself. All
Tony Martignettiright. Now, Julie, let me go back to you. How is that different than what you said doesn't do well pre— uh, pre-Giving Tuesday?
Alison HermanceSuch a good question.
Julie Ziff SintIt is—
Tony MartignettiAll right, finally. We're only 10 minutes in. It took a while, but finally, a decent question. We're only 7 minutes in, so I'll give myself a break.
Julie Ziff SintThese are all excellent questions.
Tony MartignettiOh, thank you very much. Oh, no. So, what's the distinction here?
Julie Ziff SintSo, that is not— you're not previewing a match. You're actually asking people to make a gift to build a match fund, which, it sounds a little bit nuanced, but when you say, in early November, We have a donor who's giving $20,000 to create a Giving Tuesday match, but we know we're going to raise a lot more than that on Giving Tuesday. We need your help to match more money. Will you help us increase the matching gift?
Tony MartignettiOh, increase the match.
Julie Ziff SintAnd then, and then what WildCare does, and it's, it's an incredibly successful campaign, is their broader donor base will actually contribute to the matching gift fund. We have several clients that, that do a similar type of campaign with their mid-level donors where donors who are giving a $1,000+ gift, at a $1,000+ level, will contribute to that matching gift fund. That particular audience type is typically, not always, less focused on making a gift for a matching gift campaign, but they can be really— but they can really help contribute to building a match campaign. So then let's say At WildCare, they would say, okay, now we have a matching gift fund of $42,700. Then on Giving Tuesday, they go back out and they say, we have a matching gift of $42,700. Will you make your gift for this matching gift campaign?
Tony MartignettiOkay. And then what, what do people have to do to qualify for their gift to— for you to get the $42,700? I'm missing something.
Alison HermanceWell, it's kind of— you don't necessarily You don't necessarily have to have it be a challenge or a contingency. It can simply be that we have this money, we want you to help us match it. It's not that you must—
Tony MartignettiOh, okay. Help us match what we've already earned.
Alison HermanceHelp us match what we've already earned. And it's— those are sort of 2 different types of matches. You can have a challenge match, which is essentially, if you don't do this, we have to offer to give the money back.
Tony MartignettiRight.
Alison HermanceAnd that's one type. And you hear that a lot on NPR. Fundraising, exactly. But it seems to be exactly as effective to say, we have this, will you match it? Will you bring us this funding? Yeah, and I think that's a common misconception about matching gifts.
Tony MartignettiOkay, so you might— okay, go ahead, Julie.
Julie Ziff SintOftentimes what happens is when you have a matching gift campaign or a matching gift effort, you're not really relying on the gifts to bring in the match. You actually want to have a matching gift such that you will absolutely hit it and your matching gift donor has already committed to it. Mmhmm. So if your matching gift donor says, I'm going to make a $100,000 gift, you say, I'm going to create a matching gift campaign with the specifications and the timing and the length and the channels where I think I'm going to raise $130,000, so I'm absolutely overreaching that $100,000. And I'm absolutely going to have that money in hand. So that you're raising money on the match doesn't actually, is not actually necessary for the gift, for the matching gift to come in. Mmhmm. And I think that's one of the biggest misconceptions is, for the general public, is it really isn't a fundraising tactic. It's a strategy that we all do and that we all know in this industry. But when you look at folks who are outside of the industry, they don't necessarily realize that this is a tactic that isn't actually meaningful. That when— if you give your $100 gift to an organization that says your gift will be tripled, it doesn't actually mean that they're going to be getting an additional $200 because of your $100 gift. It means that they have this money in hand, or pledged, or committed, and that you're— they're using that to inspire that giving.
Tony MartignettiMarc, can you share with us, uh, some specific asks that you do around matching gifts at, uh, San Francisco SPCA?
Mark DotyYeah, actually, most recently we, uh, basically did what's called gamification of a match.
Tony MartignettiGamification?
Mark DotyGamification. Like root word game.
Tony MartignettiOh, like gamma, not gamma radiation. No, we're not radiating.
Mark DotyIncredible Hulk.
Tony MartignettiWe're not radiating the animals or anything.
Mark DotyNo, exactly.
Tony MartignettiGamification.
Mark DotyGamification. And this is where we try to turn We introduce a lot of mini goals and ask donors to help us achieve those goals, like you might find in a lot of apps or anything else. But what we did was, for Giving Tuesday, sat down and said, okay, we need to raise this much money. That actually corresponds to the amount we spend for, in a full year, on our mobile vaccine clinics, where monthly we go out and vaccinate about 400 to 500 animals in the space of a few hours. So we actually set down and messaged to donors, hey, we need to fund 12 months worth of this mobile vaccine clinic. Will you help us do it? We've got matching funds. Every dollar you, you donate will be matched as well. And then kept them updated over the course of Giving Tuesday to say, hey, we've matched, we've achieved 4 months. Can you help us get to 5? We're at 6 months. By 11 o'clock, we're saying we're at 11 months. Can you help us get over to that 12 months? And just introduced a lot of little goals to ask donors. to help us match, um, match their gifts and get to that goal.
Tony MartignettiI love the, uh, I love the time, you know, the time challenge. Yes. Adding a sense of urgency, right? Absolutely. We're at 11 months. Help us get to 12, for God's sake. Don't leave us hanging with 11/12ths.
Julie Ziff SintOkay. You often do find that that deadline is what's so critical. You can ha— you can message as much as you want, but 3 weeks out from a deadline, you're never going to have quite the same sense of of urgency as saying, our deadline for this match is tonight at midnight. Really? And I honestly, I have no idea why people are sitting at home on December 31st at 11 PM making their donations, but there are so many people who decide that that is their moment.
Tony MartignettiDon't we all wait for the last minute for things? I mean, pretty routinely. I mean, I know I do. You know, I have a 2-week— I have 2 weeks and then I'm doing it the night before. I don't know. I just, I think that's our nature. I want to I want to get to something that comes directly from what you just said, Julie. What if gifts come late? What kind of policies do we have? Do we bend the rule, or what's best?
Julie Ziff SintIt's a terrific question. We actually recently—
Tony MartignettiAnother one. Oh, thank you.
Julie Ziff SintYou have a lot of these. I'm sorry. All
Tony Martignettiright.
Julie Ziff SintYou're a pro at this, Tony.
Tony MartignettiGo ahead, please.
Julie Ziff SintWe had this conversation recently with one of our clients. They are based in New York. They have an international presence and an international donor base, both across the US and internationally. And they had a matching gift deadline at mid— and we had countdown clocks. We had all sorts of things saying, get your gift in before midnight on the matching gift deadline. And one of the staff members said, is it midnight Eastern? Is it midnight Pacific? What about our donors who are in Dubai? Right. Um, and so, fun question. Um, so a lot of the tactics that we can implement technologically actually allow us to let that, that, that deadline, that exact 11:59 PM, uh, be catered towards the recipient's home schedule.
Tony MartignettiOkay.
Julie Ziff SintAnd so, uh, countdown clocks on emails, search engine marketing ads on lightboxes, we can actually direct all of those to the recipient's time zone. At the same time, most organizations are going to have some fluidity around it, and so if a donor calls you up at 3 AM, God forbid you're answering the phones at 3 AM, but if you get that message at 3 AM from the donor that says, I just got in my gift, will it count? You just say yes. Just say yes. Always say yes.
Alison HermanceYou don't want to say no to the donor. Exactly.
Tony MartignettiSo we are flexible. Yeah, flexible. Everybody agrees.
Alison HermanceWell, and you also can set those policies based on your own needs within your organization and be fluid about them within your own parameters. So, it's— there's not some hard and fast, like, overarching rule about matching gifts. It's within your own organization that you can determine that.
Tony MartignettiOkay.
Mark DotyAnd one of the things you can do is actually plan a strategy around people not making it in in time. One of the reasons we know matches work is if you look at hour-to-hour donations, The minute that match ends, you see donations drop off like a cliff. So people really are giving up to the last minute. But one thing you can do is follow up and say, hey, we're going to do a small mini-match for those people that missed it. And that can be a very effective tactic. Yeah. So on Giving Tuesday, we've actually sent out a smaller match the next day and said, we have a little extra money. If you missed it, please give again. Very effective. For our large end-of-campaign calendar year, uh, uh, month-long match, uh, we'll actually plan in January to send out direct mail and email that says, in case you missed it by the end of the year, here's a small— smaller follow-up match just for those guys that didn't give, so people don't feel bombarded again. Very effective tactic. Works very well.
Tony MartignettiExcellent. So it sounds very humane and gracious too.
Mark DotyYes.
Tony MartignettiIf you missed it, you know, if—
Julie Ziff SintYou still have more opportunities to give just money.
Tony MartignettiRight. Right. You do. Even if you're worse than procrastinating, like you blew the deadline, you didn't just wait until the end of the deadline, you blew it, there's still a chance for you.
Julie Ziff SintThere are still puppies and kittens and baby squirrels and baby opossums that need help.
Alison HermanceThat need you.
Tony MartignettiExactly. One of your session objectives, how to apply matching gift tactics across each channel. We haven't talked about specific channels. Marc, let's keep with you. What do you do across channels?
Mark DotyThis is an important part of keeping your organization looped in on what you're doing with a match, and we will actually sit down and have people from marketing communications, we'll have people from development, we'll have the major gift officers, and we'll all talk about, we're going to be having this match, what can everyone do in their channels to support this match and support this effort? And we'll have a group conversation about what we'll be talking about, what the messaging will be and get everyone on the same page. And then everyone is sort of in charge of going off and executing in whatever it is they do, whether that's the website— we will get it on the website. If we're on social, we will get it in social. We will put it in our DM and email appeals as well. If we have newsletters going out, it will go in the newsletters. Our MGOs will again be talking to people about what the match is about and will they support it. So we just get everyone on the same page, and that way everyone in the organization that's in charge of some kind of communication, um, can, can communicate that out in whatever, whatever they're working on.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Yeah. We, uh, we have Jargon Jail on, uh, Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio. Now, you didn't— no, you didn't really transgress. I mean, you mentioned MGOs and DMs, but I think people understand. Major Gift Officers. Yes, our Gift Officers. I mean, those are, those are basic, but I'm just alerting everyone that we do have Jargon Jail here, and I I'd hate to see anybody imprisoned. Not wrongfully. It would be rightfully imprisoned. But you don't get a jury. It's just me. But no, you were fine because DM, everybody knows direct mail.
Alison HermanceI was going to say—
Tony MartignettiAlison, do you want to add to—
Alison HermanceI do, yeah. One thing that's interesting about—
Tony MartignettiMulti-channel?
Alison HermanceMulti-channel, yeah. That's interesting about the campaigns is you do have different timing for the different channels. And so you obviously have your direct mail pieces that go out significantly in advance and there's a much longer tail, a much longer time for those to have been effective. And then you would have the modal that goes up on your website, which usually corresponds with the time that your direct mail is hitting mailboxes, in case people open the letter and then go to your website.
Tony MartignettiHold on, what's a modal? Oh, sorry.
Alison HermanceYes, I'm doing jargon. That's the pop-up thing that shows up on your website when you open up a website and something pops up in front of you. That would— that's what's called a modal. And there's a link on that that would go to a donation page.
Tony MartignettiSo we don't call them pop-ups anymore, or lightboxes?
Alison HermanceWhy do we call them modals? I learned that from you.
Tony MartignettiLightboxes, popups? Am I ancient?
Julie Ziff SintA popup, technically speaking, a popup is different technology. A lightbox and a modal are interchangeable.
Tony MartignettiOK.
Alison HermanceI did not know that.
Julie Ziff SintYeah. The technical term— I consider one of my key roles in my company being translating between our developers and everybody who doesn't speak developer speak. Which I don't. But a modal is the technical way that a lightbox is coded. Yes. And so a modal and a lightbox are the same thing. You can say either one. Popup is a little bit of a different story, and that gets blocked by popup blockers and all of that sort of thing.
Tony MartignettiSo, Alison, you're fine. I'm fine too. Excellent. Excellent.
Julie Ziff SintNo one is in jail. None of us are in jail.
Tony MartignettiAppreciate that. My language is not ancient anyway.
Alison HermanceWell, I love this because I just learned something new as well. So lightbox, modal being the 2 things that pop up. Exactly. So you would have that corresponding That would correspond with the time that your direct mail piece hits people's mailboxes. And then you would also have an email campaign and a social campaign that usually start and run on a faster schedule. You would want that to be closer to the deadline and be able to send those messages out. So you are getting, you know, people often participate with your organization's communications on many levels. And having that same messaging, the same images, The same compelling ask that goes with the match coming both in your mailbox, also on the website, also on your social feeds, and also on your email is a very, very compelling and effective way to raise donations. And having that match with the timeline just makes people jump in with both feet and donate and donate more. It's wonderful.
Julie Ziff SintYou had asked about what happens when people make their gift after a deadline as well. Direct mail has an extremely long tail. So it's very common that people will, I mean, people will hold on to direct mail and then send a check 2 years later. I don't understand that.
Tony MartignettiI've seen that. I do planned giving fundraising. Yeah. I've seen 2 years, yes, I'll, send me information on including you in my will.
Julie Ziff SintIt's wild. But so what we do when we're promoting a matching gift is direct mail, we actually won't promote the deadline. So you just don't list the deadline. You can put it in very fine print at the bottom. Nobody's going to read it anyway. That's fine. Whereas when you're looking at the digital channels, you're going to have your countdown clocks and you're really pushing the deadline and increasing your frequency as you approach that deadline.
Tony MartignettiOkay. And people don't get tired of this?
Julie Ziff SintShockingly, no.
Tony MartignettiWeirdly, no. Alison, Marc? No, they don't? Nope. Especially as you're increasing the frequency, as Julie said, when you get closer to the deadline?
Alison HermanceNo, it seems to just inspire them, and you will have people that give again. When they see the countdown clock, when they actually—
Tony MartignettiThe same challenge?
Alison HermanceThe same challenge, yeah.
Tony MartignettiOkay.
Mark DotyWe see that as well, yeah.
Tony MartignettiOkay, all right, outstanding. We're busting potential misconceptions. We still have some time left. What else do you plan to talk about in your session that we haven't, or a little more detail that you want to provide?
Julie Ziff SintI think one of the things that I think is really interesting is what happens when you don't have a match. And that is something that Anytime. It's valuable to have matching gifts. You don't want to have a matching gift for every single campaign, but most organizations in an ideal world, you have a few matching gift campaigns over the course of a year. But on these key days like Giving Tuesday or 12/31, most organizations, most of your competitors who are hitting people's inboxes have a matching gift campaign. And there are always a few organizations that don't. And so I think that that is an important thing to think about is what happens when you don't. So for some of those campaigns, we often will fundraise around tangibles. We work with an organization, Habitat for Horses, out in Texas that this past year on Giving Tuesday, we were raising money for a new rescue trailer. Last year on Giving Tuesday, we raised money for a batwing mower. Wow. I didn't even know what a batwing mower was, but it is really valuable.
Tony MartignettiWait, so don't leave us all hanging.
Julie Ziff SintOh, a batwing mower.
Tony MartignettiWhat the hell is a batwing mower?
Julie Ziff SintIt's a mower that has those off-board things so it can mow a very wide path.
Tony MartignettiOh, okay. Wide path mower. It's a wide mower.
Julie Ziff SintBut when you're a horse rescue, you need a lot of mowing capacity. And so we could run this campaign that really gave people a tangible and a goal, even though we didn't have a matching gift. Or we work with GLAAD, which works on LGBTQ issues. And this past Giving Tuesday, they didn't have a matching gift campaign. And we had a really terrific campaign. Our creative team did a bang-up job on it. But the whole— What was the goal? I'm not sure if I'm allowed to say it. The whole theme of the campaign was, it's time to give an F.
Tony MartignettiYou can say that. Oh, we've had people say fuck. Okay, great.
Julie Ziff SintSo the campaign was, it's time to give a fuck. And we replaced the U in fuck with the heart from the Giving Tuesday logo.
Tony MartignettiFantastic.
Julie Ziff SintAnd it worked really well. And so, if you have an organization where you can't— where you don't have a matching gift campaign, but you— where you don't have a matching gift available, but you have a tangible or a goal or Leadership allows you to curse across all of your direct marketing channels. There are different ways that you can break through the clutter.
Tony MartignettiAll right. This is swearing for a good cause. I love it. Absolutely. It's fine.
Alison HermanceI wanted to say, actually, on that note, the opposite problem is, I know a lot of organizations— Not swearing enough. Not swearing enough, 100%. No, one of the opposite problems would be something that my organization certainly deals with in that I wouldn't want to necessarily fundraise every time for the batwing mower, which I've never needed in my life, but because once you put a specific thing into your fundraising, that means that fundraising becomes restricted unless you're very careful with the language. Yeah. But one of the things that I love and my organization loves so much about matching gifts is the match gives you that specificity. It It gives you that goal without having to restrict the gifts that are coming in in any way. It has that same psychology of, oh yeah, I want to give $20 for the batwing mower. That sounds amazing. But instead of having to say it's for the X-ray machine or it's for specifically opossum formula or whatever, you are saying it's for this monetary goal and this time goal. Right. same psychological benefit of, this is something I want to contribute to, this is something I want to be part of, and this is a goal I want this organization to reach. And that's, I think, one of the main reasons that matching gifts are so powerful.
Tony MartignettiOkay. And I think, just so we know that there is hope in case you don't have a matching gift. 100%. There is the tangibles as Julie described. Yeah, Marc.
Mark DotyAnd I think one takeaway from this, and it's important to keep in mind, is to just stay creative with your matches. I have seen so many conversations where it's like, well, we'd like to do a match, but we don't have sufficient funds to double or triple or quadruple what people are giving. There's a whole lot of different ways to work with matches. We had a small match come in and it was just $10,000 and it was like, well, what can we do with that? Yeah. So we did a challenge grant and actually brought in 100 new sustainers just by sort of shifting it and saying, Let's just do number of sustainers instead of dollars. We can absolutely use that money. And we did. And it was very successful. So stay creative. Think of creative ways to get the message out and what you can do matches around.
Tony MartignettiThank you. And for a lot of listeners, $10,000 may not be such a small match. Not at all. That may be impressive for them. All right. I kind of want to let Marc kind of bookend us. We opened with Marc. We'll close with Marc. Is there anything else? Anything else? Anybody? Okay. We're going to wrap it up then. Terrific. Good luck on your session. Thank you so much, Tony.
Mark DotyThank you.
Alison HermanceIt's going to be a fun session.
Tony MartignettiYes, it will. And this is a little preparation for you. A
Alison Hermancelittle preview.
Tony MartignettiThey are Julie Ziff Sint at Sanky Communications, Alison Hermance at WildCare, and Mark Doty at San Francisco SPCA. Thank you for being with Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio coverage of 24 NTC, where we are sponsored by Heller Consulting, technology strategy and implementation for nonprofits. They're our boothmates. And thanks so much for being with us.
Julie Ziff SintThank you. Thank you.
Mark DotyThank you.
Kate MartignettiNext week, prompt engineering and getting the most from your current tech. If you missed any part of this week's show,
Tony MartignettiI beseech you, find it at tonymartignetti.com.
Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by Virtuous. Virtuous gives you the nonprofit CRM, fundraising, volunteer, and marketing tools you need to create more responsive donor experiences and grow giving. virtuous.org. Our creative producer is Claire Meyerhoff. I'm your associate producer, Kate Martignetti. The show's social media is by Susan Chavez. Marc Silverman is our web guy, and this music is by Scott Stein.
Tony MartignettiThank you for that affirmation, Scotty. Be with us next week for Nonprofit Radio. Big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. Go out and be great.
I love our sponsors!

Virtuous
Virtuous gives you the nonprofit CRM, fundraising, volunteer, and marketing tools you need to create more responsive donor experiences and grow giving.

More Episodes from 2024 Nonprofit Technology Conference
View All


Exploit Conflict & Intuition To Make Better Programs & Products
with Drew Nelson, Cassi Johnson, and Eve LaCivita




Use Your Tech To Enable Generosity
with Jamie Mueller, Peter Genuardi, and Natania LeClerc




