Skip to content
EP 687April 22, 2024

A Step Back On Artificial Intelligence & Get Your Team To The Next Level

Tony MartignettiBeth KanterPhilip DengKim Truong
Nonprofit Radio
Episode 687
0:00 / 0:00

A Step Back On Artificial Intelligence

Beth Kanter and Philip Deng urge you to consider the ethical challenges your nonprofit should grapple with before fully adopting generative AI in your work. They’ve got advice for an ethical use policy and guidelines for training. Beth is an author, master trainer and facilitator. Philip is CEO of Grantable. Our conversation was recorded at 24NTC.

Get Your Team To The Next Level

“We do our best work when we’re at our best,” says Kim Truong, as she explains how to evaluate your team’s roles and responsibilities, meetings, reporting, and communications. She also reveals what belongs in your Team Ways of Working Guide. Kim is an independent consultant. This is also part of our 24NTC coverage.

Here’s the transcript

Tony MartignettiHello and welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. I'm your aptly named host and the podfather of your favorite hebdomadal podcast. Oh, I'm glad you're with us. I'd bear the pain of onychomycosis if you touched me with the idea that you missed this week's show. Here's our associate producer Kate, back from sick leave, with what's going on this week. Kate, how are you feeling?

Kate MartignettiHey Tony, I am feeling so much better. I'm at like 90% better. But yeah, thanks for checking in.

Tony MartignettiWe missed you terribly for the past 2 weeks.

Kate MartignettiThis week it's a step back on artificial intelligence. Beth Kanter and Philip Deng urge you to consider the ethical challenges your nonprofit should grapple with before fully adopting generative AI in your work. They've got advice for an ethical use policy And guidelines for training. Beth is an author, master trainer, and facilitator. Philip is CEO of Grantable. Our conversation was recorded at 24 NTC. And get your team to the next level. We do our best work when we're at our best, says Kim Truong. As she explains how to evaluate your team's roles and responsibilities, meetings, reporting, and communications. She also reveals what belongs in your team ways of working guide. Kim is an independent consultant. This is also part of our 24 NTC coverage. On Tony's Take Two.

Tony MartignettiLoving donor meetings.

Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by Virtuous. Virtuous gives you the nonprofit CRM, fundraising, volunteer, and marketing tools you need to create more responsive donor experiences and grow giving. virtuous.org. Here is A Step Back on artificial intelligence.

Tony MartignettiYou know, it is kind of nice having a second voice. Uh, we'll see, we'll see about the future. Welcome back to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio coverage of the 2024 Nonprofit Technology Conference. We're all together here in Portland, Oregon at the Oregon Convention Center, and Nonprofit Radio's coverage of the conference is sponsored by Heller Consulting. Technology strategy and implementation for nonprofits. This conversation is with Beth Kanter and Philip Deng. Beth is an author, trainer, and facilitator. Philip is CEO at Grantable. Beth, Philip, welcome.

Philip DengThanks, Tony.

Tony MartignettiNice to have you. Beth, welcome back.

Philip DengYes, great to be here.

Beth KanterI lost count how many times I've been on your show.

Tony MartignettiYeah, many, many NTCs.

Philip DengYeah.

Tony MartignettiAnd Philip, you'll be welcome to come back. Thank you very much.

Philip DengIt's great to be here.

Tony MartignettiThank you. My pleasure. Your session topic, which you unburdened yourself of yesterday, right? It's taken care of. You did your session, is Embedded Ethical and Responsible Use, Generative AI and Nonprofit Work. Philip, why don't you get us started? As our first-time guest, why did you see the need to be concerned about ethics and responsibility around generative AI?

Philip DengWell, I think Beth and I have been talking about the topic for a few months now, maybe over a year. And I think that generative AI— I'll start kind of in reverse— is a transformative technology that is shaping the world every single minute now. And all of these nonprofits, their missions, their clients, this, this all is being done in a generative AI world now. And I think nonprofits in particular have a sort of native inclination to consider things from a perspective of responsibility and ethics. And so I think there's this really important work to be done, uh, led by folks like Beth now for, for quite some time, But to help them figure out how to take these really powerful technologies, these really important tools, and then apply them in ways that are aligned with their missions and most importantly with their values.

Tony MartignettiI'm glad we're having this conversation because it's important to take a step back and evaluate, you know, our values, you know, what our core, what we stand for, what we, you know, the walk that we want to walk. And not be talking about the use cases and, you know, use it as a draft and then it'll be iterative and you'll have a conversation with ChatGPT, et cetera. So that's why I wanted to take a step back. 'Cause Beth, you and I had that conversation in a panel with— it was last June, I believe, with Afua Bruce and George Weiner and— Yeah. Allison. Right, my co-author. The 4 of you, the 4 of you, yes. So we've— and so, I mean, there's value in that. We do need to know what are the best use cases and how best to interact with this, Philip, as you said, absolutely transformative tool. But let's take a step back. Beth, why don't you help tee us off as well?

Beth KanterSure, and I think as we talked and we've been talking, and the reason I wrote the book about it with Allison, published 2 years ago now, because we saw this coming, is that most For most, that we lead with our human-centered values and that we do no harm because there's a lot of potential to do harm given that this technology is working on ingesting a large amount of data from the internet and it's ingested all its biases. And in the ways that we can interact, we can inadvertently, you know, harm people through divulging private information or maybe using it to block people out, people of color out of services. Right. And a whole host of other things, right? And I could give you that whole list, but that's like a college ethics course. But the important thing is that nonprofits need to be aware of it and have a way to navigate through it. And luckily, NTEN's released an ethical framework, TAG, fundraising.ai. And organizations, I think, are overwhelmed. They're concerned. They should be. But they need to be prepared and to move thoughtfully. And so the session that Philip and I did was more, you know, how do we operationalize our values in the context of this technology? As Philip mentioned before, it's something that we're used to doing in this sector, leading with our values, but now we need to apply it to the use of this tech.

Tony MartignettiTo this transformative moment that is only going to become more. It's only going to accelerate, I think. All right, so Beth, let's stay with you. What should we be thinking about, talking about, not just thinking, what should we be talking about consciously at the CEO level? I don't know, maybe at the board level? Help us understand what the issues are that we should be grappling with.

Beth KanterThere's a few things, and I've been having a lot of those conversations. First is educating, understanding what the technology is, and actually getting hands-on on it in a safe way, low-risk cases, so you understand like the limitations of it without just being concerned. It's a double-edged sword here, or I don't know the right metaphor, but it's— there are tremendous benefits, but we want to be careful, right? We don't want to be so scared of it that we don't use it. We need to— we do need to use it, but carefully. So we need to think about this in terms of, you know, humans always in charge. Humans always in the loop, humans making decisions. And I think the most important skill that leaders need to understand is when— where does that human intelligence come in, and where do we let the machine do some of the work, right? It's called cobotting. We've talked about that before. Higher up, what's going to happen as more nonprofits adopt, it's going to free up time. It's not going to disrupt jobs necessarily. changing and automating job skills, which redistributes time. And leaders need to reinvest that time into more mission-driven, important tasks, which are really about relationship building, right? With our donors, within, with the people we're serving. And within that, as staff begins to use this and they have acceptable use policies and we're Taught how to use it well and carefully. And time shifts, they're going to need to be reskilled, right? There's going to be reskilling, and there's going to be an emphasis on soft skills that'll become way more important, like creativity, empathy, communication, interpersonal communication. Those things are going to become all the more important. There's been some LinkedIn data recently. I don't know if you've seen their economic graph. But they actually crunched some numbers related to nonprofit jobs and the use and adoption of AI. And they're saying that 12% of nonprofit job skills will change and 39% will be redistributed. So leaders need to be thinking about this in terms of their talent retention plans.

Tony MartignettiOkay.

Beth KanterTalent retention plans.

Tony MartignettiPhilip, what, what can you add? But please, what, what should we be grappling with?

Philip DengWell, so I think one of the, the things that I've sort of appreciated about, about working together with Beth is that, you know, there's been— there's such a body of work there to consider. And then sometimes what I find myself doing, partly just, you know, to, to make sure that I'm, I'm not getting overwhelmed with all of the information, is to step back and try to come up with maybe sort of memorable or, or, um, tactics to, to see the forest again, uh, when you've lost them for the trees. So where, uh, Allison and Beth coined the term the dividend of time, so basically what you get back from using one of these smart tools, I think one of the, uh, a rough formula that I'm kind of playing around with is that the idea here is to use generative AI to create a dividend of time. And one of the things that I think we have to practice is to use as much of that time as we can, as we can manage to build trust. So, uh, Beth was just talking about how a lot of soft skills and, and relational work is going to become really important. I think, you know, uh, thinking back to before so much of our work happened within the, the digital world, we were out there doing the work and running into one another. And a lot of that relational work was done just as a matter of fact. That's no longer the case when we're sending a lot of emails or having AI write a lot of our communications from now, from now on. So I think what we have to do is be intentional about saying, hey, some of this time that we've gotten back, we actually have to allocate it thoughtfully back to going out into the world and forming these relationships. Because the thing that the AI lacks most of all relative to, to people is the context of our work. There's an incredible amount of data in these models. They are really amazing at certain tasks, but they don't really have any idea of what, what the world is that our work exists in. So that context, I think, is absolutely crucial. And it's actually the understanding of our work paired with, as Beth and Allison say, cobotting. Yeah. That's where the magic really happens, is when you pair your human intelligence, your understanding of the situation, the nuance of your work, and then know how to leverage a really powerful technology like generative AI to do that work more efficiently. And of course, in a, in a human-centered and values-aligned kind of way.

Tony MartignettiYou mentioned building trust. Say more about that. Do you mean trust of the tools?

Philip DengNo,

Tony MartignettiI meant trust between, between us as humans.

Philip DengYeah, I definitely mean between us as humans and between organizations as stakeholders within a community or within a movement. I think if you use AI in a way just to save yourself some time and maybe just throw that time back into more productivity— Beth and I talked a lot about a few cases where folks kind of rushed AI chatbots out into the world, into front frontline situations, really sensitive ones where people in crisis were reaching out at one point and getting a human being, and then all of a sudden they were talking to an AI model and the AI was giving out really, really problematic advice. And that is an instance where the tech was used to save time or money, you know, in terms of human resources, and it harmed the, the very people that the organization was trying to serve. So in that case, it wasn't used to build trust. The time was saved, but it wasn't reinvested in strengthening the relationship between the organization, the community, the stakeholders, the donors. So when I talk about trust, I mean good old-school person-to-person stakeholder trust.

Tony MartignettiBeth, can you share one of those anecdotes?

Beth KanterOf course. Please. I think the one that a lot of people know about because it was Got quite a lot of media attention is the National Association of Eating Disorders, NEDA. And they put what was happening because of the pandemic. There was an increase in eating disorders because if you're by yourself, you're more you know you're more prone to that, right? So and they for many years had a hotline, you know actually humans answering the phone. Yeah. And and what happened was they were. Completely overwhelmed. They went to senior management and said, we need more help. The staff responded, we're going to organize a union if you don't get us more help. And what happened is they put it— they rushed a chatbot out to answer questions of people reaching out for help and pink-slipped a lot of staff. Okay. So first of all, they saw it as a cheap replacement for staff, which is doing harm and we don't— not human-centered. And then it wasn't thoroughly tested. There weren't enough guardrails on it, and it was dispensing harmful information. So So they were in the middle of a media crisis, reputational damage. And I saw an article even a couple months later, they had a bill into one of the state legislators to get more funding to support people with eating disorders. And it was turned down because of the lack of trust based on what happened.

Tony MartignettiYeah. So their community was harmed on a couple different levels. From the firing of some employees, from the poor advice from a chatbot, and the legislative funding was— A

Beth Kanterreputational hit.

Tony MartignettiWas refused, and the reputation as well.

Beth KanterYes.

Tony MartignettiOkay. Disaster. All right. So what do we take away from that? Okay. So, well, don't do those things, but are there larger lessons? Philip, that we can, you can see from that?

Philip DengYeah, another thing that I was thinking of when you were speaking with Beth earlier was one of the ways that I advise leaders that are contemplating bringing AI into their, to their toolkit is to come at it from a sense of, of playfulness, a stance of playfulness. You know, a lot of people do pretty dangerous things for fun. You know, if you're mountain biking or rock climbing or skydiving, we do a lot of stuff that you know, is fast-paced and there are real risks involved. But because we're in this mindset where our senses are heightened, we're very aware of danger and failure, but also motivated in a way that is honestly kind of enjoyable. I think it's a really great place to start just as a mental framing for taking on this task of learning about generative AI. Some of these technologies are really fun to play with. I mean, if you've interacted with the language models or the image generators, if you do it in a safe way, in kind of a sandboxed way, like Beth was saying, where you aren't starting off with anything sensitive or mission critical, you're doing it in a way to honestly play around and explore the limitations of the tool, doing so with sort of a playful mindset, almost the child's mind, as Some people say, I think it's a really great way to make yourself attuned to the risks, the rewards in sort of a game-like format, but also to reframe failure. If you don't get it at first, if you don't get the right result in a game, what you do is you try again. It's the next round. It's the next shot. And kids just get back up and try again. And I think that's a really, really good way to become very aware of generative AI, to know what it is, to feel it and become fluent. So I often tell people, think about that or watch a kid playing. Think back to memories of learning a sport or an instrument or some kind of art that you have. I don't think it's terribly different from that. So it feels different. And we oftentimes speak about this really powerful tech in terms that are overwhelming or sort of difficult to relate to. But at the end of the day, I think that the people that I see excelling, a lot of them, I think a disproportionate number, are having fun. And I think the reason that they then get so good is because there's a nice feedback loop there. So that's what I tend to tell people.

Kate MartignettiIt's time for a break. Virtuous is a software company committed to helping nonprofits grow generosity. Virtuous believes that generosity has the power to create profound change in the world and in the heart of the giver. It's their mission to move the needle on global generosity by helping nonprofits better connect with and inspire their givers. Responsive fundraising puts the donor at the center of fundraising and grows giving through personalized donor journeys that respond to the needs of each individual. Virtuous is the only responsive nonprofit CRM designed to help you build deeper relationships with every donor at scale. Virtuous gives you the nonprofit CRM, fundraising, volunteer, marketing, and automation tools you need to create responsive experiences that build trust and grow impact. virtuous.org. Now back to A Step Back on Artificial Intelligence with Beth Kanter and Philip Deng.

Tony MartignettiI love the, uh, I love the idea of having fun with it, treating it like a sport

Philip Dengsafely.

Beth KanterYeah,

Tony Martignettiyeah, yeah. Um, you all have advice around, um, an ethical use policy. And guidelines for training, practical tips and examples and processes. Who wants to start with some of the practical tips, strategies, tactics for ethical use policy?

Beth KanterSure. So let's just break down quickly what's in an ethical use policy. So there's 4 sections. There's our values, and that should be the easy part, right? Most nonprofits I know have a value or vision statement, and it's kind of relating that to the use of the tech. The next step are norms. How are we going to use it? What and where are we not going to use it? Right. And those are things like thinking about the use cases and not just the use cases and the tools, but about— there is a continuum of risk with different types of use cases. At the lower end of the spectrum, we have individual use to do a task like a writing task or create an image or analyze some data, right? So it's understanding what are the potential risks. And I think one big one is if we're interacting with public generative AI writing tools and models, ChatGPT, Copilot, you know, what's our point of view about putting data into those, right? Where are we going to put— we've got to be careful, We're not going to put any personally identifiable information into the prompt that then goes into a public model, like someone's email address or, God forbid, their Social Security number. There's another principle about, like, what is confidential information, right? Like, do you want to be uploading someone's performance evaluation with that person's name?

Tony MartignettiAs an example of our organizational tone,

Beth KanterRight,

Tony Martignettiexactly. Written in this tone, and here's their performance evaluation. Right. You just bring up a very good sort of tactical thing that your prompts are part of its learning universally. Right. And it's not only— this is not a private conversation between you and ChatGPT.

Beth KanterWell, with public models, right? The free public models, that's where we start. But if you have an enterprise model, And you're using your own data, then that's safer. Okay. Okay, that's a different story. So it's understanding that difference. And also, you know, you can redact, right? Think of it. This comes from Rachel Kimber, great person to follow on LinkedIn. Like, maybe you do have some information, you redact the organization's name, and you redact the person's name so that there's no association of it. You could get a summary. So that's lower risk, individual task. Move to the middle, we have it for internal purposes like internal communication, HR, operations, financing. There are medium-sized risks there. One example, let's say someone in HR uses a generative AI tool to write the employee handbook, right? And they fall asleep at the wheel. They proof the first paragraph or 2 and say, this is fine. And they— it's there, you know. A couple years down the road, there's a sexual harassment issue, and they go to the employee handbook and, oh, this doesn't protect anybody. So you really need to audit the output from it. You can't trust it. It makes stuff up, makes facts up.

Tony MartignettiIt's hard to believe, and that's the medium risk. We're still in the middle of the spectrum.

Beth KanterRight. It does that at the low risk too. We get to the high risk, and we do what we described before. Before, we're having it on the front line interacting with our stakeholders. And I think that's where we need to have at the board level, we need to have a data privacy governance, you know, discussion. We need to have— we need to operationalize that. And if we're testing something that is running on a large frontier model like OpenAI's ChatGPT or whatever, we need to have the appropriate guardrails in place, right? to prevent it from going off the grid and, you know, preventing and providing information that's potentially harmful or excluding people from our services.

Tony MartignettiPhilip, anything you want to add? Is there more about the ethical use guidelines?

Philip DengI think in general, there are a number of really great frameworks coming out. NTEN has one that just came out yesterday. I'm part of Uh, a group, uh, fundraising.ai, that's the website, um, that's also coming up with ethical and responsible use frameworks, uh, for this sector in particular. I think what I would just say is the important part is to have the continuing conversation. And when you have a reputable framework, that framework is a tool to guide that conversation, to make sure that you're being systematic and thorough. Um, I think what it's What it's going to come down to, though, is a posture of the organization that you understand that this is a tool that can help, but that the seriousness of the work, which was there long before AI, demands that you approach it with care. And so everybody in the organization needs to be looking for the risks, the benefits, kind of just being aware. And then when something seems Uh, beneficial, get together and have that conversation using the framework to say, okay, this is what we want out of it, but let's go through this framework. Let's assess it step by step and see if there are risks that we can spot as a team, and then to, to make the appropriate course correction. So the frameworks are a tool for the continuing conversation, which is going to have to continue because every time one of of these new step-up models gets released, there's an incredible new amount of landscape that we have to analyze because these models are gaining capabilities so quickly. So it really is changing what it means. I mean, the terminology itself is almost a placeholder, and we really have to go out there and have our eyes open and understand what is generative AI in 2024. It's going to mean something different in 2025, I think.

Tony MartignettiI'm so glad we're having this conversation to step back. And I realized as you were speaking, Philip, I'm sorry, I fucked up. You were only in 2 out of 4. You said there were 4. I moved on. We were only on number 2 of your 4 items. At least I realized. I'm sorry, I threw you off the rails there. No, but I— and then I said, you know, and then I deferred to Philip. So I apologize for that. We're only on number 2 of your 4 elements of the policy.

Beth KanterRight. For organizational acceptable use.

Tony MartignettiYou were very gracious in not saying, Tony, you're fucking up. No,

Beth Kanterbecause you told me not to swear anymore. No,

Tony MartignettiI didn't. No, I didn't. No, you said fuck sharks. And I said, you could say that.

Beth KanterRight. And I almost said shit, but I didn't say it. Today? Yeah. I said ChatGPT makes up shit. I said stuff.

Tony MartignettiI didn't stop you.

Beth KanterYou're editing this out, right?

Tony MartignettiNo, no, no, probably not. No. In New York City once, you were talking about— I remember that, right? Fuck sharks.

Beth KanterYeah. So now we can say fuck sharks.

Tony MartignettiWell, that, or I'm admitting that I fucked up.

Beth KanterOh, okay.

Tony MartignettiSo let's continue with the 4 elements that belong. People listening are probably thinking like, why did the guy move on after she's only on number 2? Why did he move to Philip when— Beth is only halfway finished.

Beth KanterValues. We talked about values, right? We talked about norms, do's and don'ts, and that's where we talk about use cases.

Tony MartignettiYeah, that's where we were.

Beth KanterRight. We were

Tony Martignettion the spectrum

Beth Kanterof use cases.

Tony MartignettiWe completed the spectrum. We're at the most risky, the forward-facing, the outward-facing. That's the most risky, requires the most testing, the most guidelines around the boundaries around the use.

Beth KanterRight. And that's what's called guardrails, right?

Tony MartignettiYes.

Beth KanterRules like don't fall asleep at the wheel, read the output and check it.

Tony MartignettiIs that just the first 2 paragraphs of the HR policy?

Beth KanterYeah. Don't fall asleep at the wheel and don't disclose personally identifiable information or whatever comes up through your organization's conversation. And then the other piece kind of relates to what Phil was talking about earlier is the playbook, right? How do you share information within staff about prompts or what you're learning? So that's an important piece. And there was something actually that—

Tony MartignettiWait, say a little more about that. Wait, say that one more time because I'm only hearing this the first time. Say that last sentence again.

Beth KanterOkay. So there, I call it the playbook section. Yes. Right? So there's a lot, you know, sharing knowledge and skills on staff so that there's a shared playbook and it could Maybe a Google Doc, right, where people share, I tried this prompt, it produced a really great fundraising appeal. I had to work with it, but here it is if somebody else wants to try it. So that kind of ongoing learning is really important. There was something else while Phil was talking, but I forgot it with the fuck sharks thing. It

Tony Martignettijust went out of my head. Ah, see, I derailed you. All right. Well, we had fun. It was worth it. It was worth it, and it may very well come back to you. What's the board's role? Beth, you mentioned the board, but just kind of in passing. What's the board's role here, and that the CEO should be bringing the board in for conversations about what?

Beth KanterAbout 2 things, all right? I think, you know, while we in this sector understand responsibility, and ethical use. We don't necessarily have that expertise on all boards of nonprofits. Hospitals do because possible hospitals have to navigate ethical situations, right? So they might have ethicists on their board. So it's also important to think about maybe we want to recruit some board members with that type of expertise, with a grounding in ethics. And we probably also want to bring some board members in who have an understanding of the technology. And we also want to be Having some governance-level policy discussions leading to our policy around that as well. It's not just something that happens on the staff level. And for senior leaders, it's not something that gets punted down the hall to the IT department. It should, you know, leaders need to be thinking about it as well.

Tony MartignettiYeah, yeah, right. It's systemic, right? It doesn't belong in the IT department. The idea of recruiting ethicists, or I guess if not that, bringing a consultant to help guide the discussion, facilitate the discussion, raise the issues that we're all talking about here. Because board members are not, you know, they may be all in or they may not even be paying attention, depending on their work status. They may not be paying attention to artificial intelligence. So the issues need I don't know.

Beth KanterI'm finding, at least with the—

Tony MartignettiGo ahead.

Beth KanterThe boards that I've been brought in to speak with, and maybe, Phil, you've also seen this, that it's either they're really concerned about it and never put their hands on it and have all these perceptions or misperceptions about it, and that might be holding them back, or they want to move full in and move fast.

Tony MartignettiThis is transformative. We need to change with the world or we're going to be left behind.

Beth KanterYes. Yes. All right.

Tony MartignettiYou know what else? Uh, we have a couple minutes left. What else did you talk about in your session that we haven't covered in as much detail? I don't know, maybe other cases, or—

Beth KanterWe talked about the dance floor and the balcony.

Tony MartignettiOkay, go ahead.

Beth KanterOkay, so, um, this comes from the, the Leadership Lab at Harvard, um, that leaders have to have the balcony view, which is seeing ahead, the big But you also need to get on the dance floor and get in, you know, get into those steps. So, so from a leadership perspective, you need to think about the ethics, responsible use, move slowly, know the use cases, all the things we've been saying. But you also need to put your hands on it as well and really understand, do it playfully, make the time for experimentation. Right. And I think that's a mind shift in our sector, you know, to make— having the time to actually experiment and learn. And that's the kind of shift that our cultures are going to go through if we free up time, that we're going to be— we're going to make space for innovative thinking and make time for experimentation because hopefully we will release some of the busyness in our business cultures and make space for that.

Tony MartignettiOkay. And that is typically the promise of new technologies, that there's going to be There's going to be extra time, there's going to be greater productivity. But, well, your point was let's not apply it directly to productivity. Let's apply it in relationship methods, relationship building, things that humans do uniquely that I don't know, maybe I'm being risky here, but I'm presuming that robots will never be able to do. Bots, artificial intelligence will never be able to have the depth of relationships that we have human to human. And is that— you think that's a risky statement? Anybody? Am I— you think we'll get there? So not that I aspire to it, but I mean, I like to think that there's some things that separate us from artificial intelligence.

Beth KanterYes.

Tony MartignettiAre there?

Beth KanterYes.

Tony MartignettiAre there reliably? 10 years from now?

Beth KanterWell, that's the thing. That's why sometimes I don't always like to read all the futurist essays.

Tony MartignettiI was being risky. Yeah, I don't know.

Beth KanterLet's check in 10 years from now.

Tony MartignettiFor the time being, we are uniquely positioned. We can say that, right? In 2024 and probably 2025, I think we're uniquely positioned to have relationships. So that's where the time ought to go in the things that we're uniquely qualified to do.

Beth KanterExactly.

Tony MartignettiMore office productivity is the point that both of you made.

Philip DengI would maybe come at it from another angle as well, that we have never maybe appreciated how important human choice is. And I think one of the things that differentiates this technology from the software that we've been using for decades now is that increasingly it's making decisions. I mean, that really is One of the hallmark, uh, you know, distinguishing features of these intelligent systems. More and more, they are making choices for us. If they write something for us, they're literally choosing every single word, and then, you know, we edit it. But a lot of decisions, tiny, tiny little decisions, are being made by these smart systems. And I think what we have to really come to appreciate and not take for granted anymore is that the human choice, the decision-making power and responsibility that we have in the world, in our teams, in our organizations, in our communities, that's really what I think we need to focus back on and say, how do we choose to use this technology in the right way? Because once we do, the technology is going to start making choices for us. So human choice. Uh, I think is maybe one of the things that, that I'll be meditating on a lot for the next, uh, the foreseeable future here.

Tony MartignettiI'd like to leave it right there. That's a great step back. Thank you. Thank you.

Philip DengCheers.

Tony MartignettiThat's Philip Deng, CEO of Grantable, and with Philip is Beth Kanter, author, trainer, and facilitator. Philip, Beth, thank you. Thank you so much.

Philip DengThanks, and

Tony Martignettifuck sharks. Appreciate it. I appreciate it. Fuck sharks. Did you just say fuck sharks?

Philip DengI might have. I might have said that. I hope you don't hear from the shark folks. I actually like sharks.

Tony MartignettiThank you for sitting through this, uh, this raucous, uh, provocative session, uh, where we are sponsored by Heller Consulting, technology strategy and implementation for nonprofits. Really, thank you very much.

Kate MartignettiIt's time for Tony's Take Two.

Tony MartignettiThank you, Kate. I've been enjoying a week and a half, and I have another several days of meetings with my client, Visiting Nurse Service of New York in New York City. And just, you know, as I think about all these meetings or as I'm having them, I'm just reminded How much this is the real joy of, for me, planned giving. But I think for any type of individual fundraising, it's just the getting to know people. It's being curious about people. Of course, we're talking about the work that VNS Health does, but I always make sure we go deeper than that. And it's me getting to know the person. Yeah. All these meetings are with folks in their 70s, 80s, and 90s. Most of them, nearly all, are women. And it's just getting to hear their stories, you know, what they did in their careers, what their husbands did, because most of them are widows, what their children are doing, where they used to live, what was school like. What was growing up like? You know, these are the, this kind of, you know, deepening of understanding of people that is really a joy in individual fundraising. So I hope that you have relationships at that level. It doesn't have to be about planned giving. That's, you know, that's the work I do. So those are the conversations I'm having. I just find it really sort of uplifting having all these meetings over breakfasts, coffees, lunches, a couple of dinners. But a lot of folks those ages this time of year don't want to go out at night. So it's not too many dinners, but I hope you're enjoying relationships like that because they are The real heart of individual fundraising is getting to know people and working with people on that level. And that is Tony's Take Two. Kate?

Kate MartignettiI think we really take for granted the face-to-face connection that we make with people, you know, by storytelling or Just getting the wisdom from anyone, really, not just the older generations.

Tony MartignettiYeah, I think you're right. And we, you know, we obviously lost it during the pandemic. I see more people getting back to face-to-face, in-person events, meetings. And I, and I hope folks are, are open to that and not just open to it, but, you know, looking for it, seeking it out. Because I think, you know, that just, it's human connection and virtual connection can only go so far. It's, it's just, it's not the same thing. Not even, not even close.

Kate MartignettiFor sure. No, I completely agree with you. But anyway, we've got beaucoup, but loads more time. Here is Get Your Team to the Next Level.

Tony MartignettiWelcome back to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio coverage of the 2024 Nonprofit Technology Conference. We're coming to you from the Oregon Convention Center in Portland, Oregon. We're sponsored at 24 NTC by Heller Consulting, technology strategy and implementation for nonprofits. With me for this conversation is Kim Truong. Hi. independent strategic communications campaigns and operations consultant. Welcome to Nonprofit Radio, Kim.

Kim TruongHi, nice to meet you, Tony.

Tony MartignettiYou got a big portfolio there.

Kim TruongIt is a mouthful.

Tony MartignettiStrategic communications campaigns, not stopping there, that's only 2 out of 3, and operations consultant.

Kim TruongIt's true. I've played around with the title many times. It's like, how do I explain to people what I actually do?

Tony MartignettiIs there a company name? That you can compact all that into, or have you— or no?

Kim TruongPresently just Kim Truong Consulting.

Tony MartignettiOkay.

Kim TruongYeah, letting the name speak for itself.

Tony MartignettiSimple, but it's simple, but it says it.

Kim TruongYeah.

Tony MartignettiAll right. All right. Your session topic. Have you done your session?

Kim TruongI did do my session yesterday.

Tony MartignettiAll right. Congratulations. So that's over. So we can recap a little bit.

Kim TruongPerfect.

Tony MartignettiIt is Work Smarter, Not Harder. Easy tips. Easy. That's an important qualification. Easy tips, she promises, to get your team to the next level. All right, um, what was the genesis for the session? What brought this topic to you?

Kim TruongOh, um, this is funny. Um, honestly, I kind of ended up at NTC on a whim. I quit my job last July 2023. I met up with an old boss, um, and She mentioned to me, I was telling her about some of the things that I've been doing around project management, strategic operations, just helping, you know, folks at my old company get to the next level, managing their team, you know, ironing out some of the issues. And she said, you need to do this with nonprofits. Like, you need to go to NTC and you need to present on this. And, you know, I don't know if I have much expertise to share, but sure. I applied to be a speaker. Here I am. It's my first NTC, and it really does already feel like I'm coming home to the topics and the people that I care about. So that's really the genesis of this.

Tony MartignettiThat's very touching too. Your first NTC.

Kim TruongYes.

Tony MartignettiYou feel so comfortable.

Kim TruongYes, I do.

Tony MartignettiIt's a great community. It really is. It's a welcoming, supportive community. You know, folks living their values. I mean, we certainly see that at NTEN, with NTEN living their values of equity,

Kim TruongExactly, exactly.

Tony MartignettiYeah, yeah. Smart use of technology, but also the conscious use.

Kim TruongAbsolutely, for good, right? Maybe not necessarily for growth.

Tony MartignettiIndeed. Yeah. All right. So should we just start talking about some of the easy tips?

Kim TruongLet's dive in.

Tony MartignettiOkay. Okay. Where do you like to start?

Kim TruongWell, I always like to say that, you know, the basis of a really well-functioning team is how you staff the work and whether or not you are using your individual staffers and team's capabilities, their strengths, to the best of your team's ability. So, you know, one of the practical ways in which you could operationalize this and that I recommend it to folks is simply to put together a roles and responsibilities matrix, right? And when you put together a roles and responsibilities matrix, you're identifying not just the role. I think a lot of times people start with just the role that folks are supposed to take on a team, and then they don't actually quantify the responsibilities that are in the activities, the weekly, daily activities that are associated with those roles. Mm-hmm. So, making sure that those two are aligned. So, that's the first thing I, you know, I flagged. The second thing is, once you notice that those two things are aligned, you then want to match them up with your staff's, you know, existing personality traits, work personality traits, as well as, you know, the hard skills that are required in that role to be successful. And once you do that audit, you have a clearer picture of the gaps that remain and whether or not you need to train folks, you need to hire people in, and how folks can work with each other.

Tony MartignettiOkay, so you're seeing the gaps between the skills that are needed and the skills that exist? Is that—

Kim TruongYes.

Tony MartignettiAm I oversimplifying?

Kim TruongNo, that's great. And then also how those skills or the activities you take on because you have those skills complement each other in a team, right? Because you don't want folks to stepping on toes, right? Let's say you've got, you know, 2 people who write social copy, right? Or, you know, 2 people have been asked to write social copy. Maybe you want to split the 2 and have someone write a press release and someone write social copy instead so folks aren't stepping on toes. But all of this can be illuminated in a roles and responsibilities matrix and help you make better decisions about how to manage your team.

Tony MartignettiOkay.

Kim TruongYeah.

Tony MartignettiOkay. What else we got?

Kim TruongWell, that's just the first.

Tony MartignettiYeah, I know. And

Kim Truongthen the second thing is a— I love the word matrix. I use it a lot, and I probably need to stop. But the second thing is just making sure that you use the time that you have with your team effectively. So that's coming up with a recurring meeting cadence that you codify in a meeting matrix. That's the second one. And then making sure that each of those meetings comes with an agenda that everyone— like a standing agenda that doesn't change every week, but covers the general main topics that everyone needs to, you know, be read in on, or be aware of, or action on. And then once you have these agenda templates available and folks see them every week, and it's just a standing agenda template, you're actually creating accountability and ownership over some of the pieces that, you know, someone who's maybe more entry-level on a team might be uncomfortable sharing, right? So it's, um, when you create a standing agenda, it creates predictability, it creates regularity, it makes people feel confident. Um, it, uh, also reduces a lot of the anxiety that folks have when they're like, oh, I don't know when we're gonna meet. Right. You know, or I don't know when we're going to talk about that, right? Just put it right into the standing agenda. And it also helps to reduce a lot of the Slack and email noise sometimes, right? You know, sometimes we're trying to do a lot of work, especially if you're managing a team. You've got lots of things that you need them to do, but you're pulling them into these meetings all day, right? Let's simplify a lot of that and, you know, maybe meet just twice a week and folks know that during those times, Like, you get a chance to ask, you know, your team lead all the questions that you need to ask. So it's just creating this predictability in the way that you use your meeting time and how often you meet goes a very long way in keeping your team running well and keeping your team feeling at ease and empowered in doing their job.

Tony MartignettiWhat are some of the things that belong on that standing agenda?

Kim TruongOoh, well, Depends on when you meet and what the purpose is of each meeting. But I'd say, you know, for example, if it's the start of the week meeting and you just want to make sure that, you know, everyone's on the same page at the beginning of the week, then I would say a couple of things. The first is you want to make sure that any updates you hear from leadership or at the C-suite level that are relevant to your team are shared in that team meeting. So anything that Anything that people need to know so that they can do their work for the rest of the week should be shared. So any important updates. Action items. Sorry, not action items, but like tasks, right? Mm-hmm. If there's something that you need to get done that week, you want to start there. You want to have that conversation in that meeting, and you also want to share how, you know, if you say, okay, I want you to write the first draft of this communications plan, right? You want to actually use that meeting to explain, okay, well, this is what I want out of it. These are the goals, these are the audiences, these are the tactics. And then the last thing is, you know, actually discussing and recapping those action items at the end of that meeting. So people walk out and they know, this is my remit for the week, right? So that's one type of meeting I would say is really valuable, and that's how I'd run that meeting, you know, every week. Another meeting that's really valuable is a risks meeting. People don't like the term risks. Yeah. I think, you know, to them it signals looming problems, but I think what's really great about having a risks meeting and the fact that it is a looming problem is that it's looming. It's not actually a problem yet. It's not actually an issue yet. And when folks get into the habit of regularly identifying and logging risks super early, a lot of the times they'll resolve it within 2 or 3 weeks before those risks actually become issues that derail your team dynamic, your team progress, your delivery against a certain timeline or deliverable. All

Tony Martignettiright, so deal with it while it's a risk and before it becomes a crisis.

Kim TruongExactly, before it becomes a crisis.

Tony MartignettiHave you seen examples of that where folks have, teams have successfully dealt with risk, like you're saying, maybe over a couple weeks or maybe even a few months? And then they just feel better. I mean, there may be other— there certainly are other risks. There's always something out there, but it put their minds at ease over something that had been looming, but they never had dealt with. Have you seen instances of that?

Kim TruongI mean, I see that every day in our work once you start identifying and codifying a lot of those risks. But I think a really good example probably is During the 2020 census when I was working at my old organization, company called Fenton's, the US's— one of the US's oldest social impact communications firms. Had an amazing experience there. One of our clients was the California Community Foundation, and they were working on a 100-organization get-out-the-census campaign in Los Angeles County. Mm-hmm. It's one of the hardest— it is the hardest to count region in the United States. Just super diverse, lots of languages, lots of barriers to actually getting an accurate count. And a lot of those, when you're trying to reach a lot of those communities, like, you've got to go right into the community. You've got to reach to talk to them. You've got to knock on doors, right? What do you do when the The world goes virtual and shuts down, right? When during the 2020 COVID crisis, right? So it was amazing because we started to see, you know, one of my vice presidents, now he's a senior vice president at Fenton, you know, he could see the writing on the wall, right? And you could see we're gonna have to pivot to virtual strategies. Soon, right? Because it was— Nobody's going to be opening doors.

Tony MartignettiNobody's opening doors.

Kim TruongNo one's going to grocery stores. No one's going to grocery stores.

Tony MartignettiNot even opening doors to their grandparents.

Kim TruongExactly.

Tony MartignettiCertainly not a stranger.

Kim TruongExactly. No one's out in the community. And so what we ended up doing was we had to completely pivot, and we pivoted early, which allowed us to actually take, you know, resources like the funding that we might have allocated to door-to-door canvassing or Or allocated to, you know, ads at bus shelters or ads at, you know, in grocery stores, right? We pivoted a lot of that into virtual tactics where you can actually just reach folks right on their phones or, you know, as they're scrolling through at home or they're in front of the TV. So we completely pivoted. Yeah. Oh, we also did a lot of like peer-to-peer texting. So, you know, you couldn't to a peer in person about getting out the count, but you could text them about it, right? So we were able to identify that the crisis was coming and it was going to come early. And as a result, we were able to reallocate funding and resources and our activities accordingly. And I think if we had waited a little bit too late, we would have wasted a lot of money and resources.

Tony MartignettiWhen you were talking about the meeting matrix, you mentioned the meeting cadence. I'm sure you can't say how often should a team meet. That depends on the size of the team, the responsibilities of the team, the experience of the team, the comfort of the team. Yeah. All right. But what about engaging virtual virtual team members in meetings where some folks are not virtual. You know, some are in— it's a hybrid meeting. Somebody's— some half a dozen are in the office and 3 or 4 are virtual. Mm-hmm. You have strategies for engaging those virtual folks so that they don't feel left out? I mean, they're one dimension on a screen in the meeting room, and meanwhile the other, you know, the dozen people or so are chatting pleasantly among themselves and essentially ignoring the one dimensions.

Kim TruongSee, it's interesting because I've had a couple of conversations about hybrid situations at Enten and at NTC right now, and I think the consensus— there isn't really a consensus on it, but there's a reality in which, to be completely honest, that the conversations—

Tony MartignettiI want you to be honest with Nonprofit Radio listeners.

Kim TruongOkay, perfect. Don't hold back. There is a reality in which the conversations that you are having virtually, if other people are in the room, you know, in person, the conversations you're gonna be having with them are just simply not gonna be as rich. Like, that's just what I've noticed so far. And, you know, in talking to a lot of folks at, at NTC, you know, folks are saying, you know, I think it sometimes it just makes better sense. Like, all the conferences that they've been to over the years, especially after COVID, they've been most successful when they are all virtual or all in person. The hybrid ones are challenging to facilitate. So I guess I don't have a great answer for that, but it is, I think, just caveating that with the reality, right, that the conversations you have are probably just not going to be as rich.

Tony MartignettiYeah. And consciousness-raising Yeah. You know, you bring in those folks whenever you can. It's just, and I've been on the virtual side.

Kim TruongYeah.

Tony MartignettiIt feels a little excluded. It's nothing intentional. It's just that there, it's not the same experience.

Kim TruongYeah.

Tony MartignettiThat's just it. You know, you're not there.

Kim TruongYeah.

Tony MartignettiYou're not there. You're there virtually, but that's not there.

Kim TruongYeah. When other people are in the room.

Tony MartignettiWell, other people are in the room. Not when it's all virtual.

Kim TruongYes, that's it.

Tony MartignettiThat's a different dynamic. How do you get your hand up? You know, get your voice heard, make sure everybody speaks. And that's a different dynamic.

Kim TruongYeah.

Tony MartignettiYou know, I'm talking about the hybrid meeting. Yeah, it doesn't feel so good on the virtual end.

Kim TruongNo.

Tony MartignettiOkay. Well, at least you're honest. I mean, there isn't really a great answer. It's just not the same. So that's— you have to be intentional to bring the team together, you know, whatever, semi-annually, however, quarterly. Yeah. So that, so that the virtual folks do feel included, just maybe not in the interim meetings. Yeah. But they don't feel excluded 100% of the time.

Kim TruongYeah, I think I would feel irresponsible saying, you know, you can make the experience amazing because, you know, there are just nuggets of conversations you have by the water cooler or when you go to happy hour after or something that just enriches the conversation you simply can't have when you're virtual.

Tony MartignettiAgain, but that's why you need to be intentional. About bringing the team together in person. I guess to me, if I was a CEO, at least annually, but even that doesn't feel like enough, but semiannual. Obviously there are budget constraints around that too, but it's a challenge. I mean, everybody's struggling with it, I think still.

Kim TruongYeah.

Tony MartignettiI mean, things are emerging. We have emerged and models have emerged. I'm just not sure that they're as successful as they could be in some cases. And I think some of these choices we've made.

Kim TruongYou were kind of getting at it, but I think you wanted to ask, or you kind of assumed, you know, there probably isn't like a strict hard and fast rule for how often, you know, teams should be meeting. And I would agree, you know, I think it really comes down to the needs of the organization. But what I will say is is paramount, is creating that predictability, creating that regularity. You might not meet as an all-staff except for once a year, but maybe you have a quarterly virtual, you know, 3-hour meeting, you know, strategy meeting every quarter, right? Right. And that's something that people look forward to. They're aware it's happening. That's when you're going to get to strategize. That's when you get to bring it into the—

Tony MartignettiThat's the bigger picture meeting.

Kim TruongExactly. And it's on the calendar. People are aware. Yeah. So I'd say, like, creating confidence in how you use your meeting time is really more valuable than, you know, all the bells and whistles of an in-person meeting, or all the bells and whistles of, like, a virtual meeting. Like, just get the basics right first, you know?

Tony MartignettiOK. All right, cool. Yeah. More tips?

Kim TruongOh my goodness. Um, what— let's see. I talked through, uh, the ways of the roles and responsibilities, uh, matrix. I talked through the meetings, um, the risks. Oh, you know, I think a really great tool that folks can use is any kind of infrastructure tool documentation that your team feels like is the master hub. And when I say master hub, it just means it's this one key resource that you redirect folks to over and over and over again. It's probably got to be a little bit more robust than your Slack channel. Um, for certain teams, you know, a Google Docs with your running notes, with your roles and responsibilities, your project plans could be sufficient Especially if you're on a smaller team. And then, you know, if you're on a bigger team, cross-functional team, you might want to invest in a dedicated project management tool like Asana or Trello or ClickUp. But I wouldn't necessarily, you know, jump to a tool to solve, you know, some team management problems right away. I think just really, especially if folks are, for example, if folks on your team have low project management tool literacy, right? It just makes more sense to get them comfortable with the most basic Google Sheets or basic trackers in Google Docs to start, right? So you really got to evaluate your needs. But the key tenet here that I'd emphasize is just redirecting folks to this one place, keeping it updated every week, right? So that everyone knows this is where you go to get your information.

Tony MartignettiOkay. Shared. I mean, that becomes part of a shared culture even. Exactly. Expectations, you know, everything that that document covers, everybody knows that they can rely on that. It's a common resource.

Kim TruongExactly.

Tony MartignettiCulture. It's pretty simple. Yeah. Yeah, but important to talk about.

Kim TruongYeah.

Tony MartignettiAll right. All right. You had something in your session description about codifying best practices in a simple Team Ways of Working Guide. That sounds related to what we just talked about. Is that essentially— is that it?

Kim TruongYeah. So the Team Ways of Working Guide, and when I did my presentation, I essentially split up the tools that I was recommending in 2 different categories. There are foundational operational tactics, tools, resources that you want to use that simply maintain the function of your team week by week. So that's the foundational operations. And there are project-specific tools that you want to use, right? And so for the project-specific tools, that's when we get into work plans. That's when we get into, you know, who is the manager, the owner. It's called the MOCA matrix: manager, owner, consultant, helper, approver on a specific project, on a specific deliverable. But you need the basic foundation. You know the matrix? Yeah, I know the matrix. It's actually from the Management Center. I can't take credit for that. Okay. Um, but you need the basic foundation in place before you can activate for these different big projects, right? And so, um, the Ways of Working Guide is such an example, and that to me is the baseline. Like, you codify, this is who's on my team, this is what they are responsible, this is how we work together, This is how often we meet. So all the resources that I mentioned are in that ways of working guide. All the resources that I mentioned that are foundational operational resources, not necessarily project-specific resources, are in that ways of working guide because it sets both the expectation, but it also sets a, um, a culture as well for how you're going to work together. And that's, that's not project-specific. That is about managing your team. Yeah.

Tony MartignettiAll right, Kim, so why don't you leave us with some final motivation and uplifting thoughts about, you know, these easy, these easy tools for getting your team to the next level?

Kim TruongYeah, I would, you know, I think I started my presentation saying this. The 2023 report from the Center for Effective Philanthropy, I think they say 63 or 68% of nonprofit leaders, you know, they're really concerned with burnout. And I think that has only been exacerbated by, you know, the economic downturn, COVID-19. Folks really need the services that folks in our nonprofit sector are providing. And I think when we do mission-driven work, we feel this need to just, you know, spend all the time that we can and like work the long hours that we need to because our work is so mission critical. It's so important. And I think the biggest thing I'll say is social impact does not have to come at the expense of our well-being. We do our best work when we are our best. Mm-hmm. And when you are a manager, a team leader, a department leader, you have the responsibility— you have the opportunity, but honestly also the responsibility to set that team culture around well-being. Around operational excellence, right? And so, that's what I would really encourage every nonprofit middle manager, department leader to walk away doing. You've got 4 or 5 tips, 4 or 5 tools you can use to really set your team up for success and improve their well-being. That's it.

Tony MartignettiKim Truong, independent strategic Strategic communications, campaigns, and operations consultant. I'm going to make sure that folks understand that the 3 legs of your tripod, the 3 legs of your stool, the 3 sails of the 3 masts on your schooner, the 3 tines on your fork. I don't know. Make sure everybody knows you got a big portfolio. All right. Thank you very much for sharing. Thank you.

Kim TruongThank you so much for having me, Tony.

Tony MartignettiAnd thank you for being with our coverage of the 2024 Nonprofit Technology Conference hosted by NTEN, where we are sponsored by Heller Consulting, technology strategy and implementation for nonprofits. Thanks for being with us.

Kate MartignettiNext week, Matching Gifts 101. 201 and 301. If you missed any part of this week's show,

Tony MartignettiI beseech you, find it at tonymartignetti.com.

Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by Virtuous. Virtuous gives you the nonprofit CRM, fundraising, volunteer, and marketing tools you need to create more responsive donor experiences and grow giving. Virtuous.org. Our creative producer is Claire Meyerhoff. I'm your associate producer, Kate Martignetti. The show's social media is by Susan Chavez. Marc Silverman is our web guy, and this music is by Scott Stein.

Tony MartignettiThank you for that affirmation, Scotty. Be with us next week for Nonprofit Radio. Big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. Go out and be great. Thank you.

Nonprofit Radio

More Episodes from 2024 Nonprofit Technology Conference

View All
Drew NelsonCassi JohnsonEve LaCivita
EP 699July 15, 2024

Exploit Conflict & Intuition To Make Better Programs & Products

with Drew Nelson, Cassi Johnson, and Eve LaCivita

Carlos Morales
EP 698July 7, 2024

Improve Your Communications With AI

with Carlos Morales

Jamie MuellerPeter GenuardiNatania LeClerc
EP 697June 30, 2024

Use Your Tech To Enable Generosity

with Jamie Mueller, Peter Genuardi, and Natania LeClerc

1 / 4