Skip to content
EP 628February 19, 2023

Talent Development

Tony MartignettiPreeta NayakLindsey Waldron
Nonprofit Radio
Episode 628
0:00 / 0:00

About this episode

With a few practices, you can turn your talent development process into an employee retention tool, a leadership pipeline and a step toward greater inclusivity. Preeta Nayak and Lindsey Waldron, both from The Bridgespan Group, talk through their article, “How Nonprofit Leadership Development Sustains Organizations and Their Teams.”

Here’s the transcript

Tony MartignettiIt's a pleasure to welcome Preeta Nayak and Lindsey Waldron to Nonprofit Radio. Preeta Nayak is a partner in the Bridgespan— we're going to do that again. No, no, no, we can't have that. I can't botch the first 3 words. It's terrible. All right, let's do it again. Bridgespan Group. Do people have trouble with that? Bridgespan Group. No, I don't know why. I don't know why people would. I did. Okay, Bridge Span Group, the Bridge Span Group, the Bridge Span Group. Hello and welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio. Big nonprofit ideas for the Other 95%. I'm your aptly named host of your favorite hebdomadal podcast. Oh, I'm glad you're with me. I'd be forced to endure the pain of necrotizing ulcerative gingivostomatitis if you inflamed me with the idea that you missed this week's show. Talent development. With a few practices, you can turn your talent development process into an employee retention tool A leadership pipeline, and a step toward greater inclusivity. Preeta Nayak and Lindsey Waldron, both from the Bridgespan Group, talk through their article. On Tony's Take Two, Nonprofit Radio 50 Redux. Here is Talent Development. It's a pleasure to welcome to Nonprofit Radio Preeta Nayak and Lindsey Waldron. Preeta Nayak is a partner in the Bridgespan Group's San Francisco office and head of Bridgespan's leadership and community services. She's co-author of the book Nonprofit Leadership Development: What's Your Plan A for Growing Future Leaders? Lindsey Waldron is manager in the Bridgespan Group's Boston office. She worked on the development and facilitation of Leading for Impact, Bridgespan's 2-year consulting and capacity building program for nonprofit executive teams. Bridgespan is at bridgespan.org. Preeta, Lindsey, welcome to the show.

Preeta NayakThank you, Tony. It's great to be here.

Tony MartignettiPleasure to have you both. I don't know who's the expert in which subjects, so, you know, if I call on somebody and then, you know, if you want to pass it off and say, Now, Preeta knows that better, Lindsey, or vice versa. Of course, you know, feel free to do that. It's not— I won't consider it anarchic if you— if the person I ask doesn't fulfill the, you know, fulfill the question. So let's see. Overview. I'll just throw it out and one of you can take it, and then maybe the other wants to contribute something more. What is not going well for nonprofits generally in In talent development? Well, why don't you start us off? There we go.

Preeta NayakYeah, I'll jump in. I'll jump in and name some challenges. And then Lindsey, definitely invite you to jump in as well. I mean, I think let's be clear, everyone in this moment, every organization across all sectors, is facing a set of talent challenges that, you know, that have been precipitated by sort of layers of crises, right? So we had— we experienced COVID and what that meant in terms of the workplace. We've experienced the racial reckoning and the questions that has led us to ask. We Are we— we're facing— is it inflation, recession? Is it both? Are people quiet quitting or are they getting laid off? Like, there's just a— there's just a set of things that is also affecting the nonprofit sector. Now, in particular, I think I would say that for the nonprofit sector, if you're a nonprofit leader, you know, you have historically and probably even today not had the resources at your disposal to really invest in your leaders. We invest first in, you know, in our constituents, in our clients, in the people we're serving, and we put ourselves last oftentimes. And that means we don't have some of the habits we should have, and it means all of these pressures then can hit us harder.

Tony MartignettiWe will.

Preeta NayakSo I know I'm talking about it at a high level there, but I do, I think it's a very real challenge.

Tony MartignettiWe put our own selves last. It's like the founder who doesn't pay themselves for the first 3 years of the nonprofit's existence. You know, we put our— we sort of maybe perpetuate that and we put our teams, our, I don't know, arguably our most important resource, our staff, our teams, you know, last, right?

Preeta NayakYeah. And then, and that might— you can maybe do a sprint that way. Right.

Tony MartignettiYeah.

Preeta NayakBut what is social change? Not a sprint, right? More than a marathon.

Tony MartignettiRight. Cannot— right. Lindsey, please.

Lindsey WaldronWell, just to, just to build on that, you know, I think what— so what that leads to then, that lack of investment, is the turnover and increased rates of turnover that we've, that we've seen. So Bridgespan has done some research. We cite a lot of other research in the, in our article as well. You know, Estimate— we estimate that 1 in 4 senior leaders leaves their role every 2 years, right? So 8 years, you're kind of looking at a whole new, a whole new team, which is, which is just difficult. And we also know that a huge reason for so much of voluntary turnover among nonprofits is for lack of career development and opportunities. Right. Right? So that turnover, that turnover treadmill, that has a real cost associated with it, both a financial cost for our organization, the cost of recruiting hires, the cost of training new people, and it has a cost on the impact side as well. Trying to fill new positions kind of, you know, constrains the amount of impact we're able to have through the programs and services that nonprofits run. So I think that really kind of puts a pin in the problem itself.

Tony MartignettiIt takes a new employee like 3 months just to know for sure, you know, where the bathrooms are. I mean, it takes— there's a lot of— there's a learning curve. And so, right, that impacts the services. Very interesting what you said about the volunteer— 40% of voluntary turnover is not feeling like there's opportunity. So basically, like, I'm in a dead-end job. I don't see any advancement here for me, so I'll go somewhere else. Is that, is that it essentially? Putting it crassly, dead-end job?

Lindsey WaldronYeah, or, you know, not feeling an opportunity for professional development, right? Like, not every organization is structured like a professional services firm, like a law firm, for example, that has a clear ladder up. But regardless of whether or not there's you know, a clear upward path at a given organization. I think the point that we try to make in this piece is that there are many ways to grow professionally, whether or not, you know, there's a new role or a specific new job on the horizon.

Tony MartignettiTony, you mentioned law firm, you know, a normal progression like associate, you know, partner, maybe name partner, senior. You know, I practiced law for 2 Well, in some respects they were 2 short years, but really for me they were 2 of the longest years of my life. And I, I, I couldn't stand it because in large measure I was dreading the partnership path because I was looking at the partners, they were all gray-eyed, miserable, divorced from their spouses, estranged from their children. Like, there was the last thing I wanted to do was follow their path. But I know that's, that's not the, that's not the example you were giving, but it Your example conjured some hysteria in me as I recalled not wanting to be like— Oh gosh. I don't want to be like those people. I don't want to advance in this career. If I have to look like those people 15 years from now, I'll be miserable. So I bailed out after 2. Okay. But on to more encouraging talent development progressions and scenarios. They're not all bad in law firms, but a lot of them are outside. So like we're looking for, you know, like transparency, right? We want to— so you cite the article in your article, which we'll give folks a link to shortly, you know, transparency and consistency. We're looking for some bedrock that we can rely on so that we We know there's a future for us in this organization.

Preeta NayakI think that, yeah, I think that's right. And I think that one of the things that because we don't have, you know, the habit of investing in ourselves, investing in our people, or that, you know, it's when it does happen, it tends to be a little bit ad hoc, right? You're sort of a little bit making it up as you go along. And the real— there's sort of 2 challenges there, right? At least, right? One is that you're right, Tony, you don't get— you're not providing anyone with visibility of like, how is this going to happen, right? How will somebody invest in me, right? You just don't know. It's not predictable. The second is, and this is a really important point that we try to make repeatedly throughout the article, is that When you do things in that ad hoc way, inevitably it leads to inequity in the results, right? Inevitably, it's the people who are the least connected, often the most different from people who are in the most senior slots, who aren't gonna get what they deserve, right? Because it's gonna be through some informal relationship, or, oh, Lindsey, you're just like me in this way, and we connect, and then like I give you an opportunity, and if we don't Stop to actually ask ourselves, oh, is everyone— are all the Lindseys getting opportunities? And what kind of opportunities are they getting? And are we systematically having that conversation with everybody? That's the only way you're gonna get to some of the equity goals that I know many of our, many of our nonprofit leaders have rightfully kind of established now for themselves. They've said, we wanna have a more inclusive culture. We want a leadership team that looks different from the team today. But the only way you're going to get that is by creating some systems and habits.

Tony MartignettiYou cite that nonprofits fill the top leadership positions internally at only half the rate that for-profit employers do. So it feels like we're abandoning the people that we know the best, the ones that have worked for us. We're not promoting them. We're doing it only half the rate that companies do it. So we're not like, we're not investing and we're abandoning the folks who seem like the best shot because we know them, they have a history with us, rather than bringing somebody from the outside.

Preeta NayakWell, and the other, the other piece there is that those people from the outside, there, there are moments, to be clear, you should have a mix of hires in your organization. You should have people you're growing internally and you should have But the success rate on external hires is, for all the reasons you would imagine, not as high, right? Because those are people who are to some extent unknown and who don't know you. And so it's not just that you're not giving people internally a chance. You may also then be like, it may take a lot longer to get to a hire that really works.

Tony MartignettiLindsey, was there something you wanted to add there?

Lindsey WaldronNo, just the point that, you know, as, as Preeta mentioned, external hires are kind of less likely to be successful, and they're, they're also more expensive to attract, right? It's like this— the, the cost of turnover and kind of relying, over-indexing on external hires to fill leadership gaps in your organization is, you know, there's a real cost to that, which again, it just like All builds the case for a thoughtful approach to leadership and talent development that, that we outline and are excited to talk about today.

Tony MartignettiOkay, so let's— so we're gonna, we're gonna make improvements in DEI, we're gonna make improvements in retention, we're gonna reduce turnover. Your first idea is craft competencies. Who wants to, who wants to introduce us to crafting competencies? Preeta just pointed to Lindsey. So Lindsey, I guess that means you do. If you had pointed first, uh, Preeta would, but she did. Yeah, you go.

Lindsey WaldronNo, I got it. Well, so I think, you know, the first, the first question is, well, what, what's a competency? That was kind of a big, a big word. So just to break it down, we talk about competencies. At the end of the day, they are kind of a unique set of skills and capabilities that people need to perform You know, and develop in their work today, and, and to develop in order to be successful in an organization going forward. So a competency could be something like strategic thinking or communication, or, you know, data analysis, analytics, mission orientation. There's, there's a whole number, and we kind of outline some of the more popular competencies that we've seen in our work with nonprofits over the years. But the idea is, you know, there's such— there can be such value in, you know, as a nonprofit leadership team, distilling the set of competencies. It shouldn't be an endless list, but say, you know, what are the top 5 or the top 10 that matter most for the people in your organization, right? It's really critical that, you know, folks in our organization are able to bring an equity mindset to this work. So what does that actually mean? Let's start there. Spell it out, right? And name that as a competency we want people to invest in developing. Or, you know, ability to communicate with our clients, with people we serve, with funders, with policymakers. That is a critical competency. So what does good look like on that dimension for people in our organization? So the process of kind of naming the skills and capabilities that are critical for people in our organization to develop. In order to promote our mission, advance our work. That in and of itself, you know, we found both with our clients and at Bridgespan, right, to be a really, a really valuable exercise that kind of lays the foundation for this approach to talent development.

Tony MartignettiPreeta, you, you distinguish between core competencies and leadership competencies. Why don't you flesh those out for us?

Preeta NayakYeah, I think one of the things that, you know, Lindsey mentioned that it's valuable to name together as an organization a relatively small set of competencies that you're trying to build in all your employees, right? At the same time, we recognize that there are going to be a set of folks who may be taking on broader leadership or more complex challenges for the organization, and they may need to have an additional and slightly different set of competencies that they have to grow into as well. And so we encourage teams again to just think, still try and keep lists short. You'll see in the article we name some of the most popular, but, but also recognize that, yeah, There are some things as you take on more that, that you may need to build additionally to what beyond the core competencies, and those are the leadership. We call them leadership competencies. You could call them all sorts of things, but, but we, we distinguish between core, which is something that, you know, everyone in the organization you would hope would grow on, and leadership, which would be for a subset of folks taking on more complex tasks.

Tony MartignettiAnd it's important— let's just stay with you, Preeta. It's important to recognize that the competencies today may be very different than the competencies that we need, both core and leadership, in the future. Although I would think especially leadership would change. But if we're going to look ahead, I think it was— well, it was one of you who said earlier, you know, what got us here— basically what got us here is not what's going to get us ahead. You didn't— you said it more eloquently. Whoever said it said it more eloquently than I just did. But what got us here is not going to work for the future. So we gotta, we gotta be looking ahead to competencies as well.

Preeta NayakYeah, absolutely. And this is where I, I'll just name, you know, Lindsay and I have both had the opportunity to be in, I don't know, hundreds of leadership team conversations where the— where, where folks are sitting together and actually trying to wrestle with this question of like, Oh yeah, what are— what is it we mean by leadership or talent in our organization? What are the competencies we want to name? And those are really energizing conversations, right? Because to your point, Tony, you realize like you don't— you're not trying to, you know, just name what you do now. You're trying to think ahead, like what are— what is the organization we may be in the future? And who— what does that mean we're gonna need in our staff and in our leaders? And You know, some of that's gonna be the same. There's some things that you wanna continue, but some of it's gonna be different. And that, that can be a really exciting conversation. I think the other thing is that what's, what's often fun about those conversations is you can just have a, you know, I think, Lindsey, you, you, you, the, I think you said strategic thinking or strategic mindset. Like, you could actually just like even sitting together with others and being like, well, when I mean, when I say that, when I say someone's being strategic, this is what I mean. And then like you'll realize that like you're not always even speaking the same language.

Tony MartignettiYeah.

Preeta NayakAnd actually one of the most important things about competencies is actually then going one layer more to describe them and describe them in like observable ways. Because that means then like, Tony, when you join my team and I say, look, I want you to be more strategic, a lot of times people will like walk away and be like, God, I don't even know what Preeta meant. What is she talking about? But instead I have to say like, so here actually is what I mean, Tony. Like, I mean, when, when a problem comes your way, I want you to, I want you to show me that you can break it into pieces and, and tackle that piece, piece by piece with, with your staff, right? That's what being strategic means. And that's the kind of language you need in these competency definitions so that everybody can kind of say like, oh, that's what I need to do. That's what this organization needs. Yeah. It's really powerful.

Tony MartignettiPreeta, trust me, you would not want me working on your team. I would be a terrible employee of any company. I wouldn't, I wouldn't, I wouldn't even get, I wouldn't even get hired. I would just, I would probably just not even show up for the interview. I would, I would book it and then just to prove that I'm independent, I wouldn't show up. I wouldn't even—

Preeta NayakThen you're right. There are some core competencies that were— that you're missing out on.

Tony MartignettiI have core arrogance. I think that's, that's my arrogant— is arrogance one of the core skill sets, one of the core competencies?

Preeta NayakWe— it has not been frequently named. It has not been frequently named.

Tony MartignettiNot frequently. It's very diplomatic of you. Thank you. Um, all right, let's, uh, so Lindsey, let's go to— was there anything else about crafting the competencies from anybody that, that, uh, we didn't talk about you think folks should know?

Preeta NayakOh, I will say, I will, I'll name one more thing, which is just that a mantra we have in the competency sort of list process is don't let the perfect be the enemy of the good. So do not be the organization that spends 6 to 12 months trying to identify your competencies. That's 6 to 12 months that you have not been developing those competencies in your people, right? Because you've been worrying about the words. Yeah. that you're using. I'm not saying words don't matter at all, but like, you know, get most of the way there and try it, and then you can always come back and adapt your list if you need to. So yeah, don't let the perfect be the enemy of the good.

Tony MartignettiLindsey, you, you wanna introduce us to co-creating professional development plans?

Lindsey WaldronYeah, sure. This is a fun one. You know, the way that we introduce the concept of an effective professional development plan is through kind of a really fun example, which is by asking, you know, nonprofit leaders that we work with, let's reflect on how you learned how to ride a bike for the first time, right? And Tony, if I asked you that question, right, assuming you know how to ride bike, what did that look like?

Tony MartignettiWell, my mom and dad would take me out, and I had a bike with— well, started with a tricycle, right? You start with a tricycle. And then we got— I graduated to a bike, and they would put training wheels on it. Of course, it had training wheels. And they would kind of hold the handlebars, one of them with me as I rode, even with the, even with the training wheels in the beginning, I think. And then eventually the training wheels come off and mom and dad are left behind and I bike away.

Lindsey WaldronYeah. And now here you are, a bike rider. No, it's a helpful, like what you just described is a very kind of active an involved process of you kind of learning while doing right, with people kind of by your side, you know, making sure you don't like fall too hard and coaching you along the way. And I think that's a really helpful kind of picture to keep in mind as we think through, well, how do people learn? How do we expect people to kind of grow and develop some of the competencies that we just developed? And it's not by just reading about it. It's not by attending a training on how to ride a bike or by watching a video. And I think I elevate that contrast because what we often see, like many nonprofits are guilty of this, is, you know, an expense budget that's kind of tied to training and development. And more often than not, like that You know, the default is, well, attend this training online or go to a seminar or kind of like learn about it, read about it, which is fine and which is necessary to a certain extent, but that's not going to help you develop the skill. And so there's a body of research that has kind of resulted in a framework called the 70-20-10 around how people learn, which is that 70% of learning happens on the job. It happens while doing. It happens while you're kind of pursuing that stretch assignment, right? 20% of learning really is kind of anchored in thoughtful coaching, mentoring, and development, right? So Preeta, for example, giving me pointers along the way, the, the work that your parents were doing, right? Kind of coaching you along the side, holding the handlebars, making sure that you knew what you were doing. Giving you tips, you know, and then there is a role for kind of learning through reading, through more formal training, but that's really, you know, closer to 10%. And so it's, you know, that, that mindset, that allocation of how I think through how I want to develop myself, how I'm going to kind of become better on some of these dimensions that we, that we name as organizations, those competencies that matter. I think we, we encourage and we, we even include a template in our set of resources around like a development plan that kind of brings to life this 70-20-10 approach. And the great news is this, right? I mentioned before, a lot of organizations out there, they have a training and expense budget, right? But that's really, at the end of the day, that's kind of like the 10%. So much of learning happens on the job. So if we could invest more in thoughtfully developing those stretch opportunities that Preeta alluded to, kind of at the beginning of this conversation. Um, that's great. That's the most effective way people learn, and it's also one of the, the least expensive ways to kind of teach our people, to mentor them through more of an apprenticeship model.

Tony MartignettiWell, so how do we develop— and we're supposed to co-create these, right, between the manager and the person who reports to the manager, co-create the plan— but how do we make the plan when we don't know what the, what the opportunities are going to be for the 70% part of the 70-20-10 rule? How are we going to craft up— I mean, we don't just create opportunities to see the person succeed or not. I mean, how do we, how do we develop a plan around something that's uncertain for the future? The, the 70% part, the on-the-job part.

Preeta NayakWell, if I can jump in, Lindsey, I'll just say, I mean, no, you're not sure of everything that's coming, but you know a good amount of what's coming, right? So if you're, you know, you know, in particular, I mean, it obviously will vary by competency, right? Let's remember that, right? You're picking, you're decided in advance together, you know, what you're going to do. There are these 2 or 3 competencies maybe that you're gonna really focus on. Well, let's say it is about communications. It was one that, that Lindsey mentioned earlier. Well, you might not know all the big presentations that are, that are gonna come up in the next year, but you know that there's, you know, there's the annual staff gathering. There's the— there's, you know, there'll be at least a couple of updates to the board. You know that, you know. Yeah. You have a sense of what's coming, right? And so you can— you— and then you can together look for those opportunities. So the other thing to know is that if we agree you're going to work on communications, Tony, we might pick out a couple of things that we think are going to be opportunities in the next couple of months. But then we should also revisit this plan at least once a quarter and say like, okay, what, what opportunities came up and what might be coming up in the next quarter? Yeah. So that you can continuously be updating it, right? You can't plan out a year ahead. Can't plan out a year ahead.

Tony MartignettiEspecially for the, uh, the arrogance-building skill set. No, we do— those are going to be particularly, particularly hard to come by, but, uh, but I'll fight for them anyway. Um, let's flesh out the, the coaching and mentoring part a little bit. The 20 in the 70-20-10, that I think— I don't know, it feels like sometimes It's left to sort of, you know, people kind of find a mentor on their own, might be in the company. Maybe, maybe you're saying ideally it should be in the, in the organization, or, or— but it's, it's left to too much informality, and it's left up to the mentee to go find somebody who will mentor and coach them. I, I think you want it to be much more formalized in the organization, don't you? Lindsey, go ahead, Lindsey.

Lindsey WaldronYeah, yeah. Well, I was, I was just kind of observing, observing Preeta's like head nodding. And I think, you know, I think that is ultimately the goal. And then I think that it speaks to kind of like the third piece of this puzzle that really makes it all work is making sure that your supervisors, your managers throughout your organization are kind of taking ownership over their team's development. are kind of stepping into that role of coach so that my team of 2, my team of 5, my team of however many, I'm aware of what they're working on, right? I'm thinking about what opportunities I can help create for them and with them. And I'm, and I'm actively kind of coaching them through, providing, providing constructive feedback on what they're doing well, on what they need to, to improve. And so often it's the case that me in a supervisor role, I could be that coach. I should be a coach to my, to my teams, those I'm supervising. And at the same time, it may be that, you know, there's a, there's a certain competency that I'm really focused on developing, and my current supervisor isn't the right person to support me on that, right? So there, there are certainly opportunities where I might seek outside counsel. an expert on a certain topic to help coach me on something like public speaking, for example, on, on data analysis, or, or something like that. Or I may, I might, I may seek out coaches from folks within my organization that don't directly supervise me. So it's not kind of a one-size-fits-all situation. There are kind of different avenues. And at the same time, I think it's our, our perspective that that talent development often hinges on an organization's ability to kind of equip and hold their management, their supervisors accountable for developing their teams. Does that make sense?

Tony MartignettiYeah. Yeah.

Lindsey WaldronPreeta, anything you'd add?

Preeta NayakOh, I, you know, honestly, I just keep imagining Tony like learning to ride this bike and his parents at his side. And as you were describing, I was thinking to myself, I guess we should all, whatever that competency is that we're trying to develop, whatever that skill is, we should be asking ourselves, who's going to be like those parents who trusted Tony enough to get him a bike, right? To put him on the bike, but then who he trusted enough that if he was going to fall, they would be there to help him, right? Like, it's like you're going to kind of asking that question of yourself with, as you're building the skills, is who are those people? And it's probably not just one person, right? It's probably a set of people you go to under different circumstances. But it's that environment of management support that I think the best kind of like talent-rich organizations have created. They've created that environment.

Tony MartignettiYou all are making me picture my little block on Orient Way in Rutherford, New Jersey, where I learned to ride a bike. There were too many there. There were too many trees, you know, because the trees upend the sidewalk slabs. So it's all bumpy, and it wasn't it wasn't it wasn't a good environment. But you know, it's where I grew up. Orient Way, Rutherford, New Jersey. I hope they've repaired the sidewalks in the past 55 years or so. It's time for Tony's Take Two. Nonprofit Radio 50. for the Planned Giving Accelerator. It's the redux. It's a reminder that you can get 50% off Planned Giving Accelerator tuition by using the code NONPROFITRADIO50. The Accelerator, the class begins in early March and you'll be done with it, with me. We all together will be done By Memorial Day. So no impact on your summer. March, April, and May, we'll spend an hour a week together. You'll meet with me and all your peers in the class, and I will step you through launching planned giving at your nonprofit. There's no homework from week to week. There's incredible peer support. We share challenges as well as successes together. The outcomes are incredible, like $4 million from a small humane society in Georgia and $2 million from a community development organization in Oregon and 5 new board gifts from another small organization in— New York. Also in Georgia, a child development agency. So lots of, lots of good outcomes. Your outcomes can be just as good. It's all, it's all available to you. It's at plannedgivingaccelerator.com. You'll see how to proceed and you'll get the 50% off with nonprofitradio50. Any questions about the accelerator? Naturally, you ask me, tony@tonymartignetti.com. That is Tony's Take Two. We've got the buku. We've got buku buttloads more time for talent development with Preeta Nayak and Lindsey Waldron. What about the idea of not leaving this to the mentees? Like, The organization should be assigning, or how do we? But it might the leadership might not know who the best mentor is for somebody. How do we? Are we leaving it to the mentees to go find their own, or what? How we how do we formalize this but not make it overburdened over overbearing? I'm very interested in this mentor mentor relationship. Maybe I never had a mentor as an attorney. Maybe that's why I. I dreaded promotion. I didn't want to be like those people. Maybe I didn't have a good mentor in the law firm. How do we help folks not have the same crushing defeat in their career that I had?

Preeta NayakI don't know whether we're going to be able to manage that, Tony, but I would—

Tony MartignettiI'm unmanageable. That's what I told you. You don't want me to work for you. Trust me, exactly, you just said it, I'm unmanageable. But for the other folks who are manageable, how do we help them get the right mentor?

Preeta NayakI would actually— one question I would suggest even before that is like, is actually trying to just get a sense of who has someone that they're relying on, that they're able to turn to. And again, these development plans are an opportunity to ask that question. Who's got me? And who doesn't?

Tony MartignettiOkay, that helps.

Preeta NayakWho doesn't? Because I think that, like, you may not— it may not be that big a stretch. It may be a small set of people who don't already have the connections they need that you can then focus your energy on. And so I think just the other thing I'll just name is I think generally when organizations, for-profit, nonprofit, ask this question, They do find that the folks who are often left out are those who aren't— haven't traditionally been in that employment space. You see women who don't— who often are lacking a mentor, people of color. And so, you know, again, some areas where you can kind of double down and focus if other folks are— seem like they're doing okay.

Tony MartignettiAll right, I see. So we can use these at least quarterly check-ins To, uh, which we're gonna get to, the current check-ins. All right, so then the remaining— we got 70-20-10. The remaining 10% is formal. Lindsey, like you said, go to a webinar, seminar, go to attend a conference. That's the 10% that's— I mean, we need to budget for that because there is a role, I would think, especially in, in developing a, like, a new competency that maybe an early stage of developing a, a lacking competency skill set. Yeah. You know, hearing, hearing, listening to a webinar or going to a conference on it might be very valuable. So we need to budget that also.

Lindsey WaldronYeah, for sure. Like a concrete example we use in our organization at Bridgespan, which is we're focused on strategy, right, and operating effectiveness. But a lot of, you know, folks that come into our organization like need a pretty solid, like quantitative background, because a lot of our, you know, we use a data-driven approach, right? But if I've never opened Excel, Microsoft Excel, for example, it's going to be hard to just start doing immediately. And so there are so many tutorials kind of online, in person, around like, what are the basics, right? How can I invest, again, not 100%, but like 10% of my capacity to just kind of familiarize myself with this thing? Understand the basics, get my bearings, and then start to apply that learning on the job.

Tony MartignettiYeah, I should have asked you earlier. So you're suffering under a lackluster host who's unmanageable, lackluster, arrogant. See, these are all the traits you don't— all the reasons you don't want me working for you, Preeta. You don't want me in the Bridgespan organization. You know, what's the, what's the basis for the, the conclusions that you drew? What this is all based on? Lindsey, you referenced hundreds of conversations, but was this a survey, or was this intentional research, or it's just organically gained over time? What, who wants to talk to why you have the credibility in this space to help us?

Preeta NayakI can talk a little bit about the path because, Tony, you actually mentioned at the top of our time together the book I had written with a colleague, Plan A, right, on developing future leaders. And that was over a decade ago that we wrote that. And we did— that was research. That was talking with folks in the field who are leadership and talent development experts to understand What are the best for-profits and nonprofits doing to create leadership pipelines? We then have like a set of general practices to anchor our work in. And then building on that, we have then worked with— I think we are now probably at over 200 teams we've worked with in cohorts to apply these principles. And that's where we got the reps and refined it and where like some of these stories that you see even in the article come from. So, so it's been a— we've tried to take our own medicine, so to speak, like we did the 10% desk research, but then we wanted to apply it in the field and like actually just understand what's going on and what's hard, you know, what, what's easy on paper, hard to do in practice, what kinds of tools might help, that sort of thing. Anything else you'd add, Lindsey?

Lindsey WaldronI think we've also, like, in addition to coaching those nonprofits right around the country, around the world at this point, we also are learning within our organization, right? So, so a lot of like the structures that we, that we discussed, we're kind of trying to like eat and breathe. Ourselves. So I, I have a development plan, right? 70-20-10. I revisit it twice a year, actually, with my mentor. We talk about it. I talk about my strengths, my weaknesses, you know, where I need to, where I need to develop, what that could look like to kind of reach the next level within, in my career at the organization, whether or not really that means a new role, so to speak. I know that I'm kind of growing. Regardless. And, and so that it, you know, it, it kind of motivates me to, to stay at this organization because I know I'm constantly learning. I know there are people who are investing in me, and I have clear insight into what it takes to be successful in our organization because we've kind of spelled out those competencies. We've, we've made what is often implicit explicit. for everyone in our organization, right? Not just the folks that kind of are proactive in seeking it out.

Tony MartignettiAre you supposed to be revisiting your plan at least quarterly? I thought you said you're only doing it twice a year.

Lindsey WaldronI'm— oh, I will say I have development conversations, and we'll get to this next, right? I have development conversations with my supervisors and with those I supervise, you know, every couple of weeks or so.

Tony MartignettiRight? So

Lindsey Waldronregularly we're talking about like, what am I doing well? Where do I need to improve? And we kind of have this framework of the competencies we care about to kind of reference.

Tony MartignettiOkay, just want to make sure you're not violating your own

Preeta Nayakpolicy.

Tony MartignettiI mean, I can't have lessons from a bunch of hypocrites, but okay, you're not hypocrites. Okay, okay. What were you saying, Preeta? I'm sorry, I was He's talking.

Preeta NayakNo, I was just— unmanageable.

Tony MartignettiI, I talk over my manager. It's terrible. He's unmanageable. I get him out. Get him out. He's unmanageable. Sorry.

Preeta NayakI was gonna say it's a feedback-rich environment. And, and Tony, I'm— maybe that's another reason why you would not, you would not, you would not want to be with us, because we would be telling you regularly what we love and what you can do better. How's that?

Tony MartignettiYes, what I can do better. It's again very, uh, very tactfully put. Thank you. There are expletives that could substitute, but you used the tactful way. Let's tell a story. Preeta, you mentioned, yeah, you have 3 examples for each of the 3. You know, we have craft competencies, co-create professional development plans, and then we're gonna get to consistent development conversations, those check-ins. Tell a story. Somebody— this is worth talking about. Sure. The professional development plans. Your, your, your example was, uh, Shakti, if I said it right. Shakti Sustainable Energy Foundation, which I love. Shock, Shakti and energy going together. I, I don't know if they intended that when they, uh, created their foundation, but I like it. Who wants to tell the story about, uh, Shakti and their professional development plans?

Lindsey WaldronYeah, I'm happy to. I'm happy to kick us off.

Tony MartignettiUm, yeah, give us a little story here.

Lindsey WaldronYeah, Shakti is an organization based in India that we supported through a version of this process, through this kind of offering that we deliver for cohorts of nonprofits. And our main point of contact was actually an HR professional who had been doing this work for, you know, over a decade, but was still new to this framework of 70-20-10. And so, you know, worked with his leadership team, with his CEO, to develop a set of competencies, as we discussed, right? They went through that process with some Bridgespan support, were able to articulate what matters, and then focus first on developing, you know, that what we often see with the organizations we work with is they— you don't roll it all out at once. Right. That would be really hard. But often first, you know, the— it's the work typically of the executive team, of the leadership team, to align on what competencies matter most in their future leaders.

Tony MartignettiYeah, you make that point that leadership has to set the example.

Lindsey WaldronExactly. Leadership has to set the example. So once they've done that, then they kind of, you know, they start to walk the walk. And this HR professional who was in a leadership position He, he provides the example, which we highlight in the article, around a competency that he was working on, which was improved communication, right, and public speaking. And so he named that as something that he needed to develop. It went on his development plan, you know, and in this case, he actually sought out somebody who was not his kind of like direct supervisor or direct boss. I'm forgetting exactly who it was, but say it was a board member, right, who he admired, who had a very strong, concise, and effective communication style. And he sought out that individual as a mentor. And what they would do is check in again, like every quarter, to kind of review and assess, how am I doing? How am I progressing against this really important skill? Yeah. skill that will help me grow in this role, that will help me be successful as a leader within this organization. And so that's just one example. And I think, you know, you point to a piece that we name, like, you leader, you have to lead by example, right? Because this is the type of thing, as Preeta mentioned up front, like, it's easy not to invest in talent, right? It's easy to focus all of our attention on the programs we're running, on the services we're offering, on the clients that we are serving. Because those needs never, never stop, right? It's— and so the, the grind of just our day-to-day is, it's real. But taking the, the time and discipline to pull up and reflect on our own learning, our own development, our own professional growth is critical. And so if a CEO or a director of HR can find the time to do that, can be candid and transparent about their growth areas, right? Everyone has growth areas. Yeah. Right? Even the CEOs of the top companies out there, nobody's perfect. We're all growing, right? That in turn kind of helps make visible to others throughout the organization that like, oh, if the CEO or the director of whatever department has time to do this and is taking charge of their professional development, then I can do that too. And that helps create this kind of culture of learning, development, of feedback.

Tony MartignettiCompletely contrary to the Jack Welch at General Electric style of management, who— I know everything, I am perfect, I have all the answers, just, just come to me. But he's, he's long been— his theories anyway, I think, have been debunked. All right. Thank you. Good story about Shakti. Yeah, it's interesting that he chose a board member too, to To help. I mean, he went to a volunteer leader, you're saying?

Lindsey WaldronYeah. And it can't— I mean, that's the, that's the point. I think it's, you know, I think an organization can play a role in kind of making those connections, like the mentor match, so to speak. But I think it, you know, it also requires— there's a role for kind of your supervisor or manager to play, and there's also a role for each individual. to play in taking ownership over their professional development and growth, right? So I might say, oh wow, like, Preeta is so awesome at the way that she engages clients, right? And I really, I really want to learn from, from her. So, you know, I— to have the agency to kind of reach out and seek, seek out mentors that spike on some of the skills and dimensions I care about, you know, is very much like, that's Totally possible. There's nothing preventing me from, from doing that. And if you kind of like create the culture within your organization that that is, you know, that that happens, that that is the norm, that people are receptive to that, um, I think that that can enable great things.

Tony MartignettiSo Preeta, let's talk about what we've, we've alluded to a couple times, the, the, uh, the third, third recommendation, consistent development conversations, these check-ins.

Preeta NayakYep. Yep. I mean, I was just, I was just thinking, as for, you know, for folks who are listening to this, you know, there, there, there's value in the whole system. There's value in putting in place these competencies and development plans and, and all of that. And, you know, there's also a question of like, well, what could I do as an individual tomorrow? Right? What could I start doing? And I, and, and I think actually the important— there's a lot, because at the heart of all of this is regular conversation between a manager and a direct report or someone in their sort of network about where is it you're headed? What are the skills you're trying to build? And how do we make sure you're actually getting effective opportunities to build it? Right? And those effective opportunities are probably going to be on the job. And so that— and it's the regular conversation, right? So I had a conversation just yesterday with a— for 30 minutes with a mentee, a relatively new mentee, someone I've just been chatting with regularly for a couple of months. And, you know, we spent most of the time just kind of getting to know each other and then talked about one particular problem that was on his mind. And it was 30 minutes, and we'll do it again in a month, you know. And it's a— it's just a little bit of a muscle you start to build. And then in 6 months, I will— we will know a lot about each other, and there will be a lot of space for that hard moment for him to pick up the phone or send the chat or whatever he needs to do. Because, because those moments you can't really schedule, can you, right? Those are, those are, those are unscripted, right? So, so I just think it's that muscle that gets everybody comfortable with like sharing feedback, sharing ideas, celebrating the wins, you know, sometimes like having a good cry, whatever it is, that it's that pattern that I think really sustains that the relationship. But then actually, if you have a web of those in an organization, it really

Tony MartignettiAnd, and so your point earlier was that the, the formal check-ins with, uh, with, with the, the supervisor, those should be at least quarterly. But, but mentors, you're saying, you know, mentors, mentees, I mean, that can be on the fly, as, as ad hoc as needed, or, you know, maybe could, could also be scheduled too.

Preeta NayakYeah, I mean, I like— I'm a huge fan both in my professional and personal life of the recurring, the recurring appointment. You know, set the recurring appointment, have it for the half an hour monthly. You may end up canceling it or not using it, but like put it in there. And, and I, I, I just really encourage everyone to be doing that with the, with the advisors in their life, whether they're formal managers or, or mentors or something else.

Tony MartignettiDo you have any other action steps, or for either of you? I love stuff that people listen on a Tuesday and they can think about it Wednesday and then they implement on Thursday. What, anything else from either of you that we can act on immediately? Start taking action steps? No, this is all 100% theoretical. There's no value in the—

Preeta NayakI— Yeah, no, I think that, I mean, the simple sort of thought exercise I would encourage people to do is like, if you download, there's a 70-20-10 template. We'll share the materials, but you could probably make this yourself. It's not rocket science, right? It's a couple of, what are the couple of skills or competency areas? You can use our list or you can come up with your own or Google. There's sort of plenty of banks online available. Yeah. And then what do you think the 70-20-10 is gonna be for you in the next few months on that thing? What's the activity you're gonna do? What's the coach you'll have? Do it for yourself as this first step, and then share it with your manager. Or maybe— or actually, even better, share it with the person you manage, right? Let them know how you're thinking about this, and maybe their wheels will start turning too. So I know that would be a

Lindsey WaldronWell, I think just, you know, I feel like most of the people— I imagine a lot of folks listening, like, they may not have a set, a very, like, clear, explicit set of, like, what are the qualities and characteristics and skills I need to develop to be great at my role in my organization over the long term? And if that doesn't exist, that's the first That's step is to start thinking about that. Yeah. okay. I think, I think just kind of carving out some time for some self-reflection on, you know, what, what are the assets that I bring to my role, to my organization? How can I build on those? What are some things that I'm, that I'm working on, right, that I need to continue to develop? And then, you know, that becomes, you know, the— That becomes in large part the focus of my development plan. But again, it shouldn't be like— we want this to be an asset-based approach, right? So like building on strengths. This is all— I think one of the lines going through my head that I've, you know, started to appreciate, you know, at this point in my career is just this notion that feedback is a gift, right? Yeah. It can be easy to get defensive. It can be easy to think like, oh, what am I not good enough at? What am I doing wrong? But at the end of the day, like, creating this culture of feedback is so critical because it helps us grow as individuals. How am I going to get better if I don't know kind of where I need to grow? Mm-hmm. So I just keep kind of thinking about that, like, self-reflection, I think, is Is really a critical piece of this process.

Tony MartignettiSelf-reflection, introspection. I like introspection. It doesn't do me any good, but I like— I think it's an admirable thing to spend time on. Where can we get the article? So, 'cause there are a lot of links to other research, other articles, there's 2 other stories. Where can we read the article?

Lindsey WaldronYeah, well, it's available on our website, right? www.bridgespan.org.

Tony MartignettiRight.

Lindsey WaldronAnd, you know, we're really excited actually because it's— we're kind of in the process of developing a new space on our website that houses all, like, not just this article, but all of the nonprofit knowledge we've collected over the years. On areas such as talent, on financial sustainability, on strategy, on organizational effectiveness. And so our goal at Bridgespan is to kind of disseminate these tools, these resources, which are all free, as far and as wide as possible so that, you know, nonprofit leaders across the country, around the world can pick them up and apply for them, like what is most useful. So go to our website.

Tony MartignettiSo, okay, so is there a spot at bridgespan.org that, uh— oh, someone just, uh, politely put it in the chat, I guess was Preeta, while, while Lindsay was, uh, was talking. Oh, so bridgespan.org/insights and then /library. All right, we'll put it in the show notes.

Preeta NayakI was gonna say, it's unfortunately a bit of a mouthful of a URL, so Okay,

Tony Martignettiwe'll include it. I feel like craft competencies, co-create professional development plans, consistent development conversations— those are the 3 tenets of the article. I don't know, 3 C's. If you had— if you could tease out 4 more C's, you could do like the 7 C's of talent development. Wouldn't that be clever? 7 Cs of Talent Development. And there's a Bridgespan Group, so the bridge is spanning the 7 Cs of Talent Development. If you could tease out 4 more Cs, I, you know, I would, I would recommend it. But at this point, there are 3. Pardon me?

Preeta NayakWe can come back with the next 4 Cs.

Tony MartignettiYeah, so we'll do a follow-on with the, with the remaining 4 Cs. Now, these are very— 3 very valuable Cs, and they are, uh, Preeta Nayak, and Lindsey Waldron. Preeta is a partner in the Bridgespan Group's San Francisco office. Lindsey Waldron, manager in the Bridgespan Group's Boston office. And the company— the organization, pardon me, is at bridgespan.org. So Preeta, Lindsey, thank you very much. Thanks for sharing all this.

Preeta NayakThank you.

Lindsey WaldronThanks, Tony.

Tony MartignettiGlad to have you. Next week, managing your nonprofit for resilience with Ted Bilich. If you missed any part of this week's show, I beseech you find it at TonyMartinetti.com. Our creative producer is Claire Meyerhoff. The show's social media is by Susan Chavez. Marc Silverman is our web guy, and this music is by. Scott Stein. Yeah, you are! Thank you for that affirmation, Scotty. Be with me next week for Nonprofit Radio, Big Nonprofit Ideas for the Other 95%. Go out and be great!

Nonprofit Radio