Inflection Points As Your Nonprofit Grows


About this episode
There’s a nonprofit life cycle with recognizable stages. At each point, you need to align your goals, plans and actions with the stage you’re in. Brooke Richie Babbage, CEO at Bending Arc, puts it all together.
Here’s the transcript
Tony MartignettiHello and welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. I'm your aptly named host of your favorite hebdomadal podcast, and oh, I'm glad you're with me. I'd be hit with pyrexia if you made me hot with the idea that you missed this week's show. Inflection points as your nonprofit grows. There's a nonprofit life cycle with recognizable stages. At each point, you need to align your goals, plans, and actions with the stage you're in. Brooke Richie Babbage, CEO at Bending Arc, puts it all together. On Tony's Take Two, Nonprofit Radio 50. It's my pleasure to welcome for her first appearance on Nonprofit Radio, Brooke Richie Babbage. She is an organizational design and social impact strategy advisor and coach. She hosts the Nonprofit Mastermind podcast and is the founder and CEO of Bending Arc. Through which she supports mission-driven leaders across the country in launching and scaling high-impact nonprofits. Over 23 years, she's been a lawyer, leader, and social entrepreneur at social change organizations throughout the US. She and her work are at brookerichiebabbage.com. Brooke, welcome to Nonprofit Radio.
Brooke Richie BabbageHi, Tony. I'm really excited to be here.
Tony MartignettiIt's a pleasure to have you. Thank you. Thank you for being excited.
Brooke Richie BabbageYeah.
Tony MartignettiYou're in— you're coming to us from Brooklyn, New York. Is that right?
Brooke Richie BabbageBrooklyn, New York. It's where I live and work with my family. Yeah.
Tony MartignettiAll right. There's some TV show I used to watch. We're going back like '70s, '80s. Oh, no, wait. No, no. Earlier than that. It's from The Honeymooners, which was the '50s.
Brooke Richie BabbageBut I actually loved that show.
Tony MartignettiYou love The Honeymooners? Oh, cool.
Brooke Richie BabbageI did.
Tony MartignettiI wasn't watching it in the '50s, not quite that old. But there's a, there's a line Ed Norton says, Brooklyn, USA, garden spot of America. Or no, he says Brooklyn, New York, garden spot of America. That's coming to you from— he's— somebody asked him where he lives or something. And I think he says Brooklyn, New York, garden spot of America. So, all right, you're in the garden spot. Cool. Let's— I want to, I want to get through something, uh, just flesh out something in your, uh, the introduction that I, I read. What does an organizational design and social impact strategy advisor and coach do?
Brooke Richie BabbageI love that you asked that question. Thank you. So most simply put, I help nonprofit leaders figure out The best way to design their organizations. I think that when we talk about growing a nonprofit or leading a nonprofit, you know, doing nonprofit work, it tends to be really high level. And we think, you know, leadership and management and fundraising and all of those are obviously really important. But really what makes the leadership and growth of a nonprofit most effective is when you think about the details of the design, right? And I love that word, the intentional choices You make about who you hire for which roles, which programs you offer in which communities, how often you meet with your board, what you do at board meetings. Those are all design decisions, right? You're sort of constructing or building something as you go. And I think it's really fun, right? In the same way that I, I'm not an artist at all. So for any artists listening, this may not actually be the right sort of analogy, but I think of it. Yeah. Like building, you know, a work of art. You sort of take different pieces of inspiration and you construct something from the ground up. I think designing an organization is very similar. And I've also found that particularly for smaller nonprofits where the executive director or ED like has their fingers on everything, notching down and saying to them Actually, you don't have to think these big lofty thoughts about board growth or board development. Actually, that's just the everyday choices you make about picking up the phone to call your board chair or having breakfast with a board meeting. Those are design choices, and it can make them feel a little more in control of what their organization is becoming. So, that's what I do. I help leaders do that.
Tony MartignettiAnd So the organization is going to develop over time, which goes right into the lifecycle that we're going to talk about. So unlike a sculpture, I mean, a sculpture has to be done at some point. Otherwise, well, I mean, it's a good point. True artists might say it's never done, but that artist is going to be starving for his or her lifetime because they're never going to sell anything because their art is never finished.
Brooke Richie BabbageSo that's right.
Tony MartignettiSo unlike a piece of art, it, it can be changed over time.
Brooke Richie BabbageAnd should be absolutely.
Tony MartignettiIt's a concept. Yes, should design absolutely evolve. Should be intentionally designed.
Brooke Richie BabbageThat's
Tony Martignettiright. Actions, processes, staff. That's right. Over time.
Brooke Richie BabbageThat's right. And I think the key is, and the reason that I include organizational design and not just strategy and growth, is that it can be easy, particularly as organizations are growing quickly. And I work with organizations under two million dollars that are. Trying to grow. So they're going from, say, $500,000 to their first million. And that's a really fascinating time, as you and I have talked a little bit about in our first call. But organizational leaders can look around and feel like their organization is happening to them or around them, right? How did I wind up with this board? How did I wind up with this particular culture? And so reminding them that they actually can make choices, they and their team, they and their board. Right. other stakeholders can make intentional choices gives them some power back and can feel empowering at a time of organizational growth that can really feel disempowering in a lot of ways.
Tony MartignettiAnd you and I are going to flesh out what we talked about in our preparation call today. So I don't want listeners to feel like there's something Brooke is holding back on Nonprofit Radio listeners.
Brooke Richie BabbageNo, they're going to get it all today.
Tony MartignettiAbsolutely. There's nothing that she and I talked about Previously that we're not going to talk about today. We're going to— in fact, we're going to go into quite a bit more detail. So let's do that. So we have these recognizable benchmarks in the lifecycle, and I think it just makes sense to go through the 6 of them. So could you just preview them, you know, high level so folks know what's coming, and then we'll take a step back and look at each one a little more in more detail. But if you just— Okay. Absolutely.
Brooke Richie BabbageYeah. So should I start maybe by just saying what I mean by nonprofit life cycles, like why that's a framework that's helpful, and then talk about the steps?
Tony MartignettiSure. Yeah. Okay. Yeah.
Brooke Richie BabbageYeah. So basically, you know, as you were saying, organizations continue to grow. They continue to redesign and redesign themselves. And so I talk about— I did not make this concept up. When I talk about nonprofit life cycles, it's a concept that folks discuss that's really about the process by which organizations grow or, depending on the organization, decline through particular changes in their structure, systems, and processes. So, it's a series of phases, recognizable phases along development. And I really like, I like frameworks. I'm a big, I'm a Virgo, total framework person. So, this is really helpful for my brain to say, okay, in the same way that you think about a child or a person developing, we go through these phases, right? And so, you asked what the 6 are, and the 6 that I'm focusing on are the growth phases. There are also 4 stagnation and decline phases that we won't talk about today.
Tony MartignettiYeah, let's not. Let's not. Yeah,
Brooke Richie Babbagewe don't want to talk about those. But so the 6 growth phases are similar to, right, the growth of a person, or I use the growth of people as a way to help people remember them. So the first is birth and launch. The second is infancy, right after birth and launch. The next is childhood. The next one is teenagehood or early growth phase, and then young adulthood or late growth phase. And in a lot of the literature, organizations talk about sort of a growth stage organization or a growing organization. And I actually think that early and late growth stage organizations are different, and I'm sure we'll talk about why. So I separate them out into 2 different stages of development. Okay. And then you have maturity or the zone of maximization, which is, you know, when organizations find their groove. And one thing that I'll say is this isn't necessarily properly linear. And so it's not necessarily that an organization is always in all ways going to be in this, we found our groove, everything's clicking zone of maximization. They may fluctuate. There may be aspects of their organization, like their staffing, Or their board, or their fundraising, or their program design that is more or less developed. So these aren't, you know, you're not sort of trying to get to, like a sculpture, trying to get to and stay in one of the phases. You really just want to be aware of where you are so you ask the right questions.
Tony MartignettiOkay, so you might be maturing in some respects, but not in others. One aspect is holding you back, like maybe your resource development, fundraising. Yeah, yeah. is in childhood, but, you know, like staffing and programmatics.
Brooke Richie BabbageYes.
Tony MartignettiYour board is clicking. So it's in early growth or teenage— Absolutely. Puberty. Yeah. I was hoping— I thought you might call teenagehood puberty, but you didn't want to do puberty.
Brooke Richie BabbageI didn't want to do that. I didn't want to wade into that. No.
Tony MartignettiYeah, it's too complicated. It's too—
Brooke Richie BabbageYeah. It makes— nobody feels good about that word.
Tony MartignettiEverybody hates puberty. Right. That's right. They don't know what's happening to themselves.
Brooke Richie BabbageThat's right. At least some people look back on teenagehood and are like, well, there were certain parts of teenagehood that were exciting, you know?
Tony MartignettiRight. But puberty sucked. So
Brooke Richie Babbageit sucked for everybody. Exactly.
Tony MartignettiAlright, so, so birth and launch. Now, let me, let me— are there— you— I don't see that you put like timeframes, like, so it's not time-bound.
Brooke Richie BabbageNo,
Tony MartignettiI mean, I guess, well, birth and
Brooke Richie Babbagelaunch is
Tony Martignettibirth and launch for like 5 years, which to me seems like an awfully long time to be in a A birth phase, but you're not time bounding them. It's based on where the organization is, not how many years and months have elapsed.
Brooke Richie BabbageAbsolutely. It's not time bound and it's not based on budget is the other thing that I'll say. And I think that's a really good point that you're making, because if you time bind it, then organizations start saying, okay, we've been around for a year and now it's time to move past launch and we should be in infancy. When in fact, I've worked with lots of organizations that have the characteristics of an organization in launch phase, right? They don't quite move out of that for years. And if they don't recognize that, then it's actually something that keeps them stuck. So it's not time-bound, and it's not about how much money you have.
Tony MartignettiAll right, so let's talk about the first one, birth. Birth launch. What do we look like? What, like, what should our goals be? What should we have in mind at this, at this stage?
Brooke Richie BabbageAbsolutely. So the first one is birth and launch, and it's actually the simplest one. It's the one that people sort of recognize the most. The key characteristic here is that you've identified a problem and you're, and you're developing a solution. So usually these are founders. These are people that have no team, you know, maybe volunteers helping them. Tends to be sort of solitary work. And The, the goal here is to clearly define the problem and your solution, right? To move out of this phase, what you want to do is make sure that you have a clear enough picture of what your theory of change is, right? You— what you are going to do in response to this problem. That is how you move out of the launch phase.
Tony MartignettiOkay, what's your theory of change? Is what?
Brooke Richie BabbageSo it's basically the relationship—
Tony MartignettiYou're gonna change the world, not change your organization.
Brooke Richie BabbageNo, how you're gonna change the world. So when I say theory of change, or when we talk about theory of change, it's like we have a mission and we have strategies. Why do we choose these strategies to address this mission?
Tony MartignettiOkay. Okay.
Brooke Richie BabbageYeah.
Tony MartignettiAnd so, so funding, what does that You know, look
Brooke Richie Babbagelike at this phase?
Tony MartignettiYeah, I mean, a lot of listeners have been through this stage, or maybe are in this
Brooke Richie Babbagestage.
Tony MartignettiThey might still— yeah, some are still in. I'm guessing most are— have advanced. But irrespective, irrespective of where they— where listeners are standing, you know, what is— what does funding look like here?
Brooke Richie BabbageSo typically, and obviously everything we talk about here, there are no right or wrong There's not nothing that's gonna be true for everybody, but typically funding at this phase is almost entirely the founder and/or people in the founder's networks. Like my organization was just my friends. Wow. When I started my organization, I basically, you know, I was a poverty lawyer and I decided I was gonna start this organization. And most of my friends from law school had gone into law firms. And so I threw a big party and I basically said, You guys make more money than I do. Here's the mission. Here's the vision. Here's what I'm trying to do. Let's do it together. And that was that was how I started, you know, and and my parents. So between between those people, yeah. So that's usually the funding at this at this stage.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Anything else about birth launch you wanna you wanna you know I know before we move.
Brooke Richie BabbageI guess the one thing I would say about again moving out of. Birth launch. And just to back up for a second, one of the most— one of the ways to use this whole framework is to try to recognize which phase you're in so that you ask the right questions, right? So that you are focused on doing the right thing at the right time. So it can be really exciting to say, you know, oh, this is my stage of development, right? I'm in a birth stage. Great. We recognize it. But the way the framework becomes helpful is then to say, okay, therefore, what's the strategic objective of this phase? What does it look like? What do we need to focus on to move to the next phase in a healthy way? So, for the startup phase, what it looks like to move to this next phase, right, the goal of this phase, of moving through the next phase, is clarity. Have you clearly defined your problem? Have you clearly defined what you are going to do in response to that problem? And once that's clear, then you start to see organizations move into the more formal startup phase, or infant phase. And I'll also say, a lot of organizations never— we talked about sort of timeboxing this. There are a lot of organizations that don't actually move out of the launch phase.
Tony MartignettiWhat keeps them there? They don't have a sophisticated view of the problem and how they're going to approach it?
Brooke Richie BabbageUsually one of 3 things happens. They can't get that clarity either around the problem or their solution. It sort of stays fuzzy and they just can't launch. They won't. If you don't have that clarity, you're never going to get funding that isn't just your friends and family. You're not going to build a network of support. They can't move beyond that phase because they don't have the clarity to sort of rally support. A second thing that happens is, and this happened a lot during COVID you had people seeing real problems that had always existed, but there was this explosion in new sort of early-stage or launching nonprofits and mutual aid groups also. And what can sometimes happen, which I think is Fantastic, is organizations look and say, oh, we don't actually need to be a separate nonprofit, right? There is a problem that we're working towards. We do have an idea for the solution, but we don't need to build a whole institution here. We're going to partner. We're going to become a program of another organization. We're going to collaborate or form a network. And so that's another thing that happens. And then third, and I am fairly certain that there are people listening for whom this resonates. Yeah. Growing an organization or launching an organization can be really hard. It's a lot of work. And so you just have some people who decide they don't want to do that, right? That's— they will, they will work to fight the problem that they've recognized in some other way, as a board member, you know, joining the staff of another nonprofit. So those are the folks that don't move beyond launch.
Tony MartignettiYeah. Yeah. So you could go from Launch to decline.
Brooke Richie BabbageExactly. Yep. Or failure to launch, just never sort of really launch. Yep, absolutely.
Tony MartignettiYou mentioned, you know, longstanding problems that were brought to the, to the consciousness through the pandemic. I'm guessing you're talking about racial disparities, income disparities, the wealth gap,
Brooke Richie Babbagehealth disparities. Absolutely.
Tony MartignettiHealth, health, absolutely. Education.
Brooke Richie BabbageYeah. These are schisms that have always been there. And so I, I hesitate to say, oh, people started to see problems. They've always been there. But I think they were laid bare in a very unique way.
Tony MartignettiYeah. Yeah, there are certain groups that suffer worse in any— absolutely— than lots of others. And every time there's a crisis, it's brought to our consciousness.
Brooke Richie BabbageAbsolutely.
Tony MartignettiTo the consciousness of people who aren't paying a lot of attention.
Brooke Richie BabbageI was gonna say more to the consciousness. Yeah.
Tony MartignettiYeah, more right now. You mentioned something. This is I would take us down a little bit of a side road, but I'll— I always come— I always come back. I'm usually able to.
Brooke Richie BabbageI like meandering. Yeah, you
Tony Martignettimentioned mutual aid groups. I've just been reading about those. I, I did not know that they exist, they— that they exist and that they really came, uh, they really bounded in, in popularity. And, uh,
Brooke Richie Babbageoh
Tony Martignettiyeah, around the pandemic where, you know, it was this form of giving and uniting and people helping others. That I think, you know, statistics don't capture in terms of giving, you know, giving numbers, whatever GivingUSA does, you know, I'm always skeptical of them anyway, but even more so now. Talk about these, these local grassroots organizations. And then,
Brooke Richie Babbageyes,
Tony Martignettithen there was a database of hundreds of them that was compiled.
Brooke Richie BabbageMutual aid here in New York, Mutual Aid NYC was just amazing.
Tony MartignettiYeah. Say a little more about what sprung up there, these mutual aid. I'm just I'm just reading about it this week. And now you just said it. I would like to make sure listeners know that these exist.
Brooke Richie BabbageYeah, absolutely. So mutual aid groups, loosely defined, are sort of networks of people and groups that come together and organize to provide aid, to provide support to people and to communities where they see the need. And one of the distinctions between say a mutual aid group and a nonprofit is nonprofits are incorporated, right? They're corporations. They file taxes and all of the things. Mutual aid groups are not. They are unincorporated collaborative collectives of self-organizing people.
Tony MartignettiYeah.
Brooke Richie BabbageAnd so they— one of the things that I personally found really exciting and intriguing that emerged more so during COVID around these mutual aid groups is that there's always been this sort of idea, if you want to do mission-based work, if If you want to support your community, start a nonprofit or join a nonprofit, right? So we had this sort of for-profit, government, and nonprofit distinction.
Tony MartignettiYeah, the 3, um, what do we call them?
Brooke Richie BabbageArms or pillars or, you know.
Tony MartignettiYeah.
Brooke Richie BabbageBut the reality is that those are sort of false distinctions, right? And there's a lot of sort of history. I used to teach the history of nonprofit law, so I won't bore folks with that. The distinctions aren't actually necessary. And what I loved about the rise of mutual aid support and action networks of people, unincorporated networks and collaborations, is that people basically said, no, we don't have to get caught up in the institution-building piece. We just want to do the work. Mm-hmm. We— and so we're going to find other ways. And what's interesting, even now at the tail end of COVID is that you're starting to see even more of a redefinition of how social impact work is done. Different forms of nonprofits, hybrid nonprofits, mutual aid groups that are finding ways to get funded even though they aren't 501s. So there's been this really beautiful expansion of social impact work, and I— my entree into it was through coming to understand mutual aid groups and mutual aid works here in New York.
Tony MartignettiI don't know where I was.
Brooke Richie BabbageI
Tony Martignettiregret that I didn't know. I mean, maybe listeners know, and I just, I'm just completely in the dark.
Brooke Richie BabbageI was. Well, I think a lot of people are.
Tony MartignettiIf I had known about these during the pandemic, I mean, I would have given them voice. I would have had— there's a woman who compiled a national database, sort of state by state, of the mutual aid groups. You're talking about the New York Association of Mutual Aid Societies? I wish I had known about them during the pandemic. I don't know where the hell I was.
Brooke Richie BabbageI think a lot of it was my— the first thing I did, you know, I work with these nonprofits leaders through my programs and everything. And when COVID hit, I just started getting emails and phone calls and texts from people in my network. What are we doing? Like, how do we address these problems? And I started hosting these weekly strategy and action calls, these national Yeah. Calls on Zoom where people, executive directors, could just show up and talk to each other. Um, and I was just listening to what was coming up in these calls. And so every week, sometimes multiple times a week, there were dozens of executive directors, sometimes the same group, sometimes not, just showing up and saying, here's what we're seeing, you know. And a lot of these organizations were partnering with mutual aid groups. So that was how I came to understand the, the role they played in the ecosystem, was just being on these calls every week, listening to people, and kept coming up. And then I sort of, you know, did a spiral deep dive research, you know. Yeah.
Tony MartignettiNow it sounds like they were— they sprung up, they were agile. They know the needs of the local community.
Brooke Richie BabbageAbsolutely.
Tony MartignettiHowever they're defining community, whether it's state, that's right, or county, or even just town, you know, they know the needs, they know the levers of power.
Brooke Richie BabbageAbsolutely.
Tony MartignettiIn the community, however that they define. Yes, they can. They can. I mean, within a week, they could be serving people.
Brooke Richie BabbageThat's right. Very responsive.
Tony MartignettiWait for their to submit their 1023 and exactly the IRS with their exactly report and you know eight months later you know we're halfway through the pandemic you know within yeah it's very exciting
Brooke Richie Babbageyeah
Tony Martignettithank you thank you for fleshing that out and I don't
Brooke Richie Babbageabsolutely
Tony MartignettiI regret that I didn't know more well so now
Brooke Richie Babbagenow you do
Tony Martignettithe pandemic yeah
Brooke Richie Babbageand they're not gone so they're
Tony Martignettistill doing very important
Brooke Richie Babbagework
Tony Martignettiyeah. Actually, you know, that's a— that's right. You're right. They're not gone. We should be doing a show on mutual aid groups.
Brooke Richie BabbageThat would be awesome.
Tony MartignettiYes. All right. All right. It's coming. Okay, infancy. Let's move on. We have— at this stage, we're going to be— we're going to be 100 years old. And we're going to be 2 hours into the show and the show is going to die. But the show is going to die before the— before we reach maturity.
Brooke Richie BabbageI could talk about this stuff for
Tony Martignettidays. Maximization. I know. No, it's my fault because I digressed. But let's move to infancy. Okay, what do we look like here? What are we— yeah, what's our capital look like? What are our goals?
Brooke Richie BabbageYeah, so this phase is usually still mostly the founder, and organizations that shift into the startup phase have some kind of legal status at this point. So they may be a 501. There are a lot of B Corps, right, hybrids, but they have a structure that houses The work. And so, this initial distinction between the founder and the work of the founder and the institution that needs to be built, it starts in the startup phase. And I think that's really important to highlight because as organizations grow and develop, that distinction between the founder or the leader and the institution becomes more important. And so, it really starts here, right? Funding isn't for just the salary of— Right. The founder. The funding is there's overhead, there may be rent, right? There may be other team members, there may be stipends for program participants, etc. So the goal of and I I always distinguish there's sort of five considerations in each stage. Like what's the goal of this phase of development? What do we need to focus on? How are we designed? And then you you mentioned capital, right? Where's the money coming from? What does funding look like? What are our strategic objectives? And what does our team look like? These are sort of the 5 dimensions of questions or considerations to ask yourself at each phase. And so for this phase, the goal is really proof of concept, right? How can we take this theory of change, these strategies, or the programs or the activities, the work that we're doing, and demonstrate to people Other than our closest connections, that there's a there there, right? That these strategies are actually going to help move us in the direction of the mission. That's what I call proof of concept. And so there's— you mentioned being agile and nimble. There's a lot of program design experimentation. The design tends to be very organic and responsive. You have maybe a small team of people sort of out in their community or in their world doing work and iterating very quickly. So it's— Yeah. It's a phase that's marked by a lot of energy. Things are changing very quickly. Also really limited funding. So startup funding can be really tough. I happened to start my organization in New York where I actually think accessing startup funding was a little easier than some other communities. I— a lot of the organizations in my accelerator program are not in New York, and the startup phase can be hard to get funded because Most funders look for proof of concept. They want to see that, you know, what you're doing is actually working. So the goal of this phase is really proof of concept in large part so you can get funding and stakeholders, etc.
Tony MartignettiI'm seeing big leadership challenges. Oh yeah, we're only, we're only in the second stage. Yeah, you know, proof of concept, uh, big changes, hiring staff, uh, rent. You know, there's, as we progress There's enormous challenges to leadership. Is one person— do you see that much? I mean, is one person capable of taking an organization as CEO, from founder and remaining CEO through maturity? Is that that much?
Brooke Richie BabbageI have to tell you, we could do a whole other podcast conversation on that question. Do I personally think one person should do it all? No, I don't. And this is coming from somebody who's started and founded multiple organizations. All of which had one ED or one CEO, and that was me. I think that this institution building piece is massive. And I think that the idea of one person holding the responsibility for the hiring, the strategic vision, the resource development, the co-governance with the board, it's a lot. And the biggest challenge that the that the leaders that I work with have is the sense of overwhelm, the sense of constantly juggling so many balls. It's a lot. It's
Tony Martignettia struggle.
Brooke Richie BabbageYeah. And I think you're right to highlight, it starts here, right? Once there is an institution, right, once there's this formal legal structure, there's an organism that must be supported and built and held by someone. There's a really interesting movement Towards different models of leadership, of shared leadership, that was not common when I was coming up. You know, 20-some-odd years ago, you had an executive director and they were at the top and they were in charge. And I think there's been— there are really great conversations happening more and more, and I think more funding for and support for models of shared leadership, co-leadership. One of the organizations that I worked with had this really interesting 4-person leadership team. So there was no one executive director. They each sort of had their sphere of influence and they made decisions. Now there's management and leadership challenges inherent in that also, but people are really experimenting with this. How do we hold this work?
Tony MartignettiIt's time for Tony's Take Two, Nonprofit Radio 50. That is the coupon code that will get you 50% off Planned Giving Accelerator. The course starts early March. We will be done together by Memorial Day. So it's a 3-month course. You'll spend an hour a week with me and your peers in— In the course. The Zoom meetings, and they are meetings, not webinars, so everybody can talk to everybody else and you can interrupt me without having to put a question in the chat. It doesn't work like that. Just speak up and everybody helps each other. That— the peer support is incredible. Um, it's all about launching planned giving at your nonprofit. That's what we're working on together. I'm making planned giving for you easy, accessible, and affordable for small and mid-sized nonprofits. If this at all sounds interesting to you, you can check out the accelerator at plannedgivingaccelerator.com. You'll see that the general public is getting 40% off the full tuition. You use Nonprofit Radio 50. 50. No spaces. Maybe that's obvious. I don't know. No, for a coupon, it's probably not obvious. NonprofitRadio50 with no spaces will get you 50% off the full tuition through February. Good through this month. So there you go. You're entitled. It's all at plannedgivingaccelerator.com. That is Tony's Take Two. We've got beaucoup buttloads more time for inflection points as your nonprofit grows with Brooke Richie Babbage. Let's advance to childhood.
Brooke Richie BabbageSo childhood is where, just like a child, this is where the organization begins to walk and talk on its own. So there's more meaning. Wholly separate from the founder, or it should, right? So this is an indication. Have you moved into the child? Have you moved out of the startup phase? There's more stability. Organizations are still figuring out what it means to be an institution and to separate the work from the founder. But this is where you might start to actually see a small staff, right? That not just volunteers. Often there's some, you know, combination of independent contractors, maybe some part-time people. One, maybe 2 full-time people. A lot of times this is where the founder will start to pay themselves. It's really interesting to me how many founders make it all the way through and you're not— yeah, you're nodding all the way through the start phase and choose to divert funding to other things. But right around now you start to actually have salary lines, you know, in your budget. You're also going to have more regular fundraising. So the childhood phase often marks the beginning of Meaningful external fundraising, meaning it can support salaries. There's some separate program funding. And because your fundraising is— your resources are going up, your expenses are also going up. So you have more robust programming, you're investing more in institution, you'll start to see overhead, etc. And transitioning out of this phase, remember we talked about sort of what's the strategic question to ask to move beyond. Mm-hmm. Transitioning out of this phase really requires a focus or emphasis on intentionality. So the hallmark of the childhood phase is, you know, you have this small child who can stand on their own 2 feet. They're like, you know, wobbling a little bit, but they're standing there. Small team, a little bit of fundraising, the pieces are there. And so to transition to this next phase, you have to start to say which of these pieces, and this is the organized organizational design. Mm-hmm. piece. Which of these pillars that we've started to, you know, or anchors we've started to put down are working? Which ones are the right ones? Do we have the right team? What should our work look like over the next year? This is when you'll start to see organizations actually have a long-term strategic plan, a 3 or 5-year plan, as opposed to just a sort of each year we're doing this. You'll have a strategic fundraising plan. That's not just throwing spaghetti against the wall. It's, oh, but wait, do we want to have one event or 2 campaigns, right? They start to be more intentional about leaning into what's working.
Tony MartignettiHow about the board? Where's the board at in childhood? Like, this is— to me, that sounds like the toddler phase. You said beginning to walk in childhood. So where's the board at? Maybe I shouldn't call it the toddler stage. I'm not trying to rename your stage. No, I love it.
Brooke Richie BabbageChildhood toddlers.
Tony MartignettiChildhood. Childhood word. It's yours. I'm not trying to rename.
Brooke Richie BabbageI mean, I'll tell you, we my youngest son just turned five and we still call him the baby. So you know, it's all you know, it's all words. But
Tony Martignettium, all right. Where's the? It's all relative.
Brooke Richie BabbageYeah. So your board is still it's not a true what we call governance board. This is still gonna be a hands-on working board and. Most often what you see in this phase is most of the sort of authority and decision-making will still actually sit with the executive director. You still have executive directors running or co-running board meetings, rallying board members as troops. Even though boards are moving out of the startup phase, which is highly hands-on, you're still going to have a board that most often looks to the executive director for direction and doesn't necessarily see themselves as holding any sort of Co-governance authority or autonomy.
Tony MartignettiAll right. They might be more hands-on still in—
Brooke Richie Babbageyes,
Tony Martignettiball— in small ways, like the board will take on this event or something like that.
Brooke Richie BabbageExactly, exactly.
Tony MartignettiWe'll help with the mailing, you know. That's right. Be more ministerial, uh, functional than, than strategic and—
Brooke Richie BabbageStrategic and forward-looking. Absolutely.
Tony MartignettiGovernance. Yeah. Right.
Brooke Richie BabbageThat's right. And I think one of the ways that that often shows up is, you know, a startup board often are like staff, right? They do all of the things.
Tony MartignettiYeah.
Brooke Richie BabbageIn a childhood board, they're not staff anymore, but they're still more responsive than they are proactive. They will show up when called as opposed to saying, hey, as board members, we will proactively take on this role, this responsibility. That tends to come later.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Okay. Now, now we're moving into the puberty, puberty phase.
Brooke Richie BabbageYeah, puberty phase. You are going to insist on calling it puberty.
Tony MartignettiNo, I'm not insisting. Teenagehood. It's teenagehood. It's early growth. The hormones are raging.
Brooke Richie BabbageYeah.
Tony MartignettiWhat's happening to us now?
Brooke Richie BabbageYeah, so the growth stage organizations are often lumped together. Right? We talk about sort of growing organizations. But like I said, I think they're actually 2 phases. And when you actually pay attention to those 5 sort of questions that I talked about, you know, what are the goals, what does fundraising look like, etc., you start to see sort of early growth phase, like teenagers, where the organization is stable and walking. There's some intentionality, and they're really focused on scale, right? You mentioned hormones. They are sort of full steam ahead, you know. Yeah. I was just joking with my husband about being a teenager and learning to drive and getting my first car. And I just, I would drive half a block to the store, right? There's just like this energy, there's constant forward movement.
Tony MartignettiWhich has changed a lot, by the way.
Brooke Richie BabbageOh, yeah.
Tony MartignettiI'm hearing about teenage kids who don't really don't care about their driver's license anymore.
Brooke Richie BabbageOh, no, I was, that was like the biggest thing in my life.
Tony MartignettiYeah, no, for me too. I couldn't wait to get my learner's permit.
Brooke Richie BabbageYeah, yeah.
Tony MartignettiDriver's license. But today's, today's teenagers, it's not, it's not that big a deal. And I'm not talking about urban, I'm talking about—
Brooke Richie Babbageyeah,
Tony Martignettistories from friends. I don't have children, so I don't, I don't know from— this is the guy with no kids pontificating about children. So take it for what it's worth, which is probably nothing. But what I hear from my friends who do have children is the driver's license, like the permitting and the licensing, it's not that big a deal anymore.
Brooke Richie BabbageFascinating. I can't, can't tap into that because that was such a big deal for me and all of my friends.
Tony MartignettiYour kids, your kids are not there yet, I guess.
Brooke Richie BabbageNot even close. I have an 8-year-old and a 5-year-old. Yeah. And they're New York kids. So that's— there's also just a different relationship to driving, I think, in New York.
Tony MartignettiIf you're in an urban— yes, if you're in a big city like New York.
Brooke Richie BabbageYeah, I was a Midwestern kid. So everybody, you know,
Tony Martignettisuburban, suburban Jersey. I mean, that was the freedom. That was The freedom.
Brooke Richie BabbageExactly.
Tony MartignettiThe first time I could go out without a chaperone or something, or the first time I was allowed to babysit.
Brooke Richie BabbageThat's right.
Tony MartignettiIt was huge. It was huge. I couldn't wait. Right on the birthday.
Brooke Richie BabbageA mark of autonomy and independence.
Tony MartignettiAll right. I don't think it's that way. And from what I hear, it's not that way anymore. All right. Anyway, I'm sorry. We digressed into the driving. But you're— let's take it. Let's take it from the traditional way. That you are starting, you, you got your learner's permit.
Brooke Richie BabbageThat's right. And so you're like really excited to move forward. So the early growth phase is just growth, it's scale, and it's a really fraught time. So this is often, and I know I said there was no sort of budget assigned, but a lot of the organizations that I work with, like I said, are, you know, late 6 figures and are in this, we want to grow. There is a need in our community. There is, you know, a need around our issue and we aren't meeting it fast enough. We wanna hire more people. We need to grow our board. We need to do more. And this intentionality that they built during the childhood phase, the systems that they started to build, they're like, we want to stress test them, right? So we are adding more programs. We are adding more people to our programs. We are growing. There's more robust fundraising. So we're bringing in more money. Mm-hmm. And this juggling act can get really chaotic during this early growth phase because the addition of new team members, you know, one of the biggest conversations that I have with folks is they'll come into my accelerator program and they'll say, I have the money to grow, right? So we've raised this money to expand in this way. Who do I hire to do what? I've never had to think about a staffing structure. I've never had to think about salaries in any way that was equitable. I just sort of paid people what we had, and now I actually have to have some kind of, you know, policy around it. I've never— my board has never had to review an audit, and now they do, right? So this phase is marked by tremendous growth and increase, increased impact, increased staff, and an attempt— you talked about leadership challenges— an attempt by
Tony Martignettileaders to keep up. The rubber hits the road at this stage. For leadership, either you're going to be able to bring this organization further, or you're not the right one.
Brooke Richie BabbageThat's right. And so one of the really important strategic growth focuses here, right, to nail this phase and be ready for the next one, is really actually around leadership, right? If in childhood, it was around systems and stability and intentionality, here, it's very often that the executive director has to begin to change their style of leadership, their definition of leadership, and their own skill level. Whereas before, being an effective leader— and I, again, I'm generalizing here— but in the childhood phase, it's we're hands-on. I meet with my team all the time. We have a small but mighty group. We make our decisions together, sort of all hands on deck. That's a really different leadership style and set of skills than Uh, more differentiated staff, where maybe you have a leadership team and people that report to them, not directly to you, where you have board members that are now starting to join that are calling you and saying, hey, what's happening with the audit? What's happening with the strategic plan? Where you start to have these other— this other way that you need to sort of show up as a leader. And that is often a big challenge. That's— we talked about this inflection point. That's one of these, you know, I have a training that, that says what got you here won't get you there. This early growth phase is where I came up, like why I say that.
Tony MartignettiWhat, yeah, what, what got you here won't get you there. Sounds like the, the passion is not going to be sufficient anymore.
Brooke Richie BabbageNope, not at all.
Tony MartignettiPassion might have gotten you through childhood. But it's not going to get you through teenagehood. And into young adulthood.
Brooke Richie BabbageThat's right. It's not gonna get you into young adulthood. And I, I like that we were talking about driving because this idea of, you know, you could crash, right? You could go so quickly and not actually master, not master, build your skills around things like, you know, paying attention to financials. This is a big one that comes up during this phase that up until now, the nature of funding was sufficient that, you know, I have EDs that are just like, I look at our bank account. Once or twice a week, and I have a good sense of our money. So that's not actually financial management, and that's okay if you have $200,000 and one staff person and it's all programming. But once you have different funders, multiple salary lines, some overhead, maybe some restricted funds, you actually have to pay attention to your financial infrastructure. Just as an example, that's a different skill set. That's a different allocation of your time in the week and making that shift. If you don't, just like a teenager can run themselves into the ground, the organization can run itself into the ground. And so you definitely see organizations at this phase not, not make it out of the early growth phase. They just get stuck in this sort of overwhelming chaos.
Tony MartignettiYeah, it's perfect. Let's move on. Young.
Brooke Richie BabbageYeah. So, so if they Right. If they make it through the early growth phase into the late growth phase, what's happened is they have gotten comfortable with scale, right? The organization. So the key characteristics here are the organization is growing. It has figured out how to calibrate staffing or capacity with funding. The right— they've right-sized their programs. They feel like they're growing in a way that can be held and sustained. Right. And now the question for late growth stages, how do we make sure that this growth that we're experiencing is still anchored in our values and mission? So sometimes in order to grow, you have organizations that take on funding and they look up and they're like, huh, so we have all this funding for this program that looks great, but I can't remember why we started that program, right? Or we have 13 programs and everything feels scattered. Yeah. And I don't really know that they're all rooted in like why we started to do this to begin with. And so the goal here is learn to stay stable amidst growth, right? How do we make sure that we're anchored in our growth?
Tony MartignettiIn the, in the mission.
Brooke Richie BabbageIn the mission and the values. Absolutely. Absolutely. And so for the executive director or the leader, the strategic focus here is To fully transition into this mature organization, right? Full adulthood. How do I work on the organization, not just in the organization? How do I get out of the weeds? How do I actually delegate to and rely on a leadership team or whatever the structure is? How do I rely on the systems we've set up so that my role is bringing in new resources, forming new partnerships? It's visioning, it's generative, it's strategic.
Tony MartignettiWhat does the board look like here in late growth?
Brooke Richie BabbageSo ideally, at this point, the board functions more as thought partners, ambassadors, and cheerleaders. They are being leveraged as resources out in the world, right? So if you contrast this with the startup phase or the early— or the childhood phase where the board was still looking really inward, right? Hands-on working board. What you start to see here in a A healthy, growing, mature governance board or governance body. There are a lot of organizations now that are moving away from a traditional governance board, and they have a governance team or a governance body. But the group of people that play that role is they are ambassadors. They are taking what they're getting from inside the organization, the mission, the work, the passion and understanding of what the organization does, and they're going out into the world as cheerleaders, as strategic advisors. And bringing resources back into the organization. So there's a shift to facing outwards. And ideally, you have board members that are proactive in that facing outwards. You know, they're leveraging their resources, their networks, etc. So you start to see that shift right around here.
Tony MartignettiExplain the distinction you made between a governing board and a governance body.
Brooke Richie BabbageIt's not really— yeah, it's not a hard distinction. It's— they're similarly to some of the conversations that folks are having around leadership, shared leadership, different models of co-leadership. I'm seeing a lot of similar conversations around non-traditional governance. And so, whereas in a traditional structure you have, you know, these organizations and it has a board, a governance board, right? Board of directors. There are a lot of organizations that are rethinking what that body is called and how it works and what its relationship is to the organization. So, one example is an organization that I'm working with now is thinking about— they've had a traditional board for about 11 years, and they are thinking of actually separating fundraising and resource generation from community accountability and active governance. So reviewing the financials, making sure the audit's okay, there's some core governance responsibilities That a board has. But one of the concerns they felt they were seeing, or they have, is that their board, their traditional board, felt really separate from the community that they serve and are working in. So there was this like hierarchy that had been created. And so they're playing around with a governance team, which is going to be a larger, less structured— so no officers. No committees, no standing committees. Group collective of people who play different roles, primary among which is creating a feedback loop of accountability to the community that the organization serves.
Tony MartignettiYeah.
Brooke Richie BabbageAnd so they're just, they're not calling it a board. I am very early in my learning about this, but I do think they're really, really cool conversations. There's an organization, Change Elemental. That on their blog, they actually underwent a complete overhaul of their governance board, and they now have a governance team, and they mapped the process on their blog. It's a really great read. I highly recommend it.
Tony MartignettiAnd what's that organization again? Say it again.
Brooke Richie BabbageIt's called Change Elemental. Change Elemental.
Tony MartignettiAll right.
Brooke Richie BabbageYeah. So that's that's late growth phase. Yeah. Maturity.
Tony MartignettiSo maturity.
Brooke Richie BabbageMaturity is. A stable organization. It has good systems, it has good bones, it's mission-aligned, right? So, this rooting in the values and mission is solid, and it's having a good impact. I think the best way to think about this sort of mature zone of maximization is we've hit our stride, right? We have the right people in the right roles. We have the right systems. People understand their jobs. Our board's functioning. Right. Obviously, right, the nuts and bolts are going to be messier. But largely speaking, when you look around and the right pieces are working the right way, you've hit the zone of maximization. And you made a point earlier that there may be aspects of your organization that hit maturity while others don't. You may look and say, our board is nailing it. They are thought partners. They are active. They are engaged. They are ambassadors. We— this is really great, but the team, the staff, I'm still— I feel like we don't have, you know, role clarity. We're not really nailing it there. That's okay, right? So there's a sort of maturity in one area and perhaps teenagehood or still growth phase in another. And being able to recognize that means that as a leader, as a team, you can pinpoint where to focus. You're not sort of looking globally and saying, oh, our organization still needs to grow. No, actually it's the team. That you want to focus on, or it's the fundraising that you need to focus on. So that's this phase. It's, it's really stable. And what's exciting about this phase is that the goal becomes deepening of impact. The institution is solid. And so now you're thinking, how do we do better? Right? How do we meet the needs of more or in a deeper way? This is when you'll start to see organizational leaders think about things like thought leadership. Mm-hmm. Right. Which is this like jargony way of saying, how do we build, take this sort of point of view or expertise that we have as an organization doing good work and help other people see this point of view? Mm-hmm. Like, understand, like, how do we leverage our expertise for the benefit of other people who care about this work? So that's essentially thought leadership. You'll see executive directors more external to the organization, sort of out building partnerships, et cetera. And so they can do that at this phase because the institution is stable, right? Because they have a team holding top, as a friend of mine calls it, right, doing solid strategic and vision work. They have the systems, etc. So they can be out in the world, essentially bringing more people into an institution that is really good.
Tony MartignettiAnd also sharing with, with the outside world what their learnings have been.
Brooke Richie BabbageWhat we're learning. Exactly. It's a really exciting, exciting time.
Tony MartignettiThat is thought leadership.
Brooke Richie BabbageYeah, yeah. So that's, that's sort of that final stage. Stage.
Tony MartignettiAll right, so now your work becomes a lot clearer, I think, because you, you can work with organizations and leadership to, you know, not necessarily like pinpoint you're at this stage, but your board is over here and your funding is up there. And but leaders that want to advance or feel stuck You know, you can, you can help them look strategically, introspectively.
Brooke Richie BabbageYes.
Tony MartignettiWhere, where the institution is and where it wants to be and—
Brooke Richie BabbageAbsolutely.
Tony MartignettiBridge that gap.
Brooke Richie BabbageAbsolutely. I think one of the words that I hear most frequently from organizational leaders is— so I work with leaders of 2 programs. One focuses on Launching, right? Launching and early and, and birth and childhood. And the other, most of my work is with the early and late growth stage organizations. So organizations that are trying intentionally to scale, and usually from 6 figures to early 7 figures. And the word overwhelm comes up in every conversation. It's just overwhelming. There's, I don't know how to prioritize. I don't know what to do first. Hmm. Of all of the things that I have to do, and so most of what I do is as a thought partner and also not sort of emotionally connected, so it's easier for me to see the chessboard. Is help them figure out the right thing to focus on at the right time. Right? What is your stage of development? What should your goal be? And what is the The strategic objective that you want to achieve so that you're ready to move on to the next phase. And I always say to people, it doesn't make sense to be focusing on the strategic objectives of being a teenage organization if you are a child, right? Or, you know, or if you're an infant like that, that it's going to frustrate you. It's going to be overwhelming if you have a hands-on board made up entirely or almost entirely of your friends and family. Mm-hmm. And you are trying to get them to be a proactive, highly skilled governance board. That leap skips a bunch of phases. And so, a lot of the challenges that the leaders that I work with are navigating is that they look around at other organizations, again, at their budget size, or maybe, oh, that organization is also 7 years old, and they try to reverse engineer or sort of pace themselves against these other organizations. And when we start to work together, One of the things that happens most commonly at the beginning is they realize, oh, we're not there yet, right? So I, I shouldn't be trying to raise a million dollars from individual donors yet. I don't have any major donors. There's some phases that you're missing, and so that clarity can sometimes help bring on some calm, right? You don't have to worry about the million-dollar major donor yet. You're not there. How about we build your major donor base. How about we clarify who your donors are and develop a system for getting in front of them? And then that will move you to the next phase and the next phase, etc. So that's most of what I— that's the organizational design that I help with.
Tony MartignettiYour work reminds me of something that a friend of mine who's a consultant often says. He's Laurence Pagnoni. I wish he pronounced his name Pagnoni, but he doesn't. He pronounces it Pagnoni.
Brooke Richie BabbageAlas,
Tony Martignettithat we should, we should all sort of personally and professionally be aspiring to a better set of problems.
Brooke Richie BabbageOh, I love that.
Tony MartignettiYeah, I do too. Yeah. So yeah, you know, we're always going to have headaches and problems, but yeah, but they become, they become more sophisticated, more refined.
Brooke Richie BabbageThat's right.
Tony MartignettiHe says, you know, a better set of problems to solve. I, I like that too. Uh, yeah. Seems to capture these different stages.
Brooke Richie BabbageAbsolutely.
Tony MartignettiSort of everything we just talked about.
Brooke Richie BabbageAnd I think we don't, you know, beat ourselves up as leaders if, you know, if we define being a successful leader as solving all the problems, right, or not having any problems. Well, then that job's gonna suck because—
Tony MartignettiRight, that's never gonna
Brooke Richie Babbagehappen. That's never gonna happen. But instead, I really like this, right? If, if the goal is, what's the next best set of problems that I'm aiming for? It gives us honestly permission to fail forward, which I think is really important.
Tony MartignettiYeah, yeah, very good. All right, Brooke, I feel like— I
Brooke Richie Babbagefeel like we covered it all. This was great.
Tony MartignettiWell, okay. Yeah, not, you know, not to be frustrated with where you are.
Brooke Richie BabbageYeah.
Tony MartignettiBut to, to be introspective about where the problems are and what it takes to get you advancing.
Brooke Richie BabbageAbsolutely. I, um, I posted on LinkedIn last week that if I had a tagline, it would be growth with intention. And I think that both in life and definitely as a nonprofit leader, This idea that growth can be fraught. It is fraught. There are always challenges. There are growth edges. There's relearning. There's unlearning. There's a lot that goes into growth itself. And I think a lot of the overwhelm, the burnout, the fear, the insecurity, the uncertainty, all of the things that nonprofit leaders all experience— and I've been there, so I know— those can be reduced if we just lean into intentionality. Yeah. Right? If we, if we say, hey, what's happening? What do we like that we're doing? What don't we like that we're doing? What questions should we be asking? Right? That, that intentionality can help us drown out the noise, right? The things we don't actually need to be focusing on, the things that we, we don't need to be comparing ourselves to. So I think that that can be really helpful. And that's, I think, why I like doing organizational design and Strategy work, because I find that that comes fairly easily to me, the sort of seeing the, the order, the, the throughline. And when I'm able to help other leaders gain some of that clarity, there's, there's really a calm, right? There's a, there's like a deep breath that people are able to take. And I remember some of the toughest days as an executive director and having people help me with that. Yeah. so that I could take a deep breath was really transformative. So that's what I try to do for folks.
Tony MartignettiGrowth with intentionality. Yeah. Brooke Richie Babbage. You'll find Brooke and her work at brookerichiebabbage.com. Brooke, thank you so much. Really insightful, valuable. Thank you.
Brooke Richie BabbageThis was a great conversation. Thank you for having me, Tony.
Tony MartignettiOh, my pleasure. I'm glad you loved it. Next week, leadership development with 2 folks from the Bridgespan Group. Seems to parallel very, very well with what Brooke and I just talked about— leadership development. If you missed any part of this week's show, I beseech you, find it at tonymartignetti.com. Our creative producer is Claire Meyerhoff. The show's social media is by Susan Chavez. Marc Silverman is our web guy, and this music is by Scott Stein of Brooklyn. Thank you for that affirmation, Scotty. Be with me next week for Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. Go out and be great. Go out and be great.

