6 Steps Before You Hire


About this episode
Hiring is rampant because turnover is rampant. You have work to do internally, before you go public with your job posting. Andrea Hoffer, from AHA! Recruiting Experts, talks you through her 6 steps. You can download the first chapter of Andrea’s book, “Hire Higher.” We recorded on a bus in the Israeli desert.
Here’s the transcript
Tony MartignettiHello and welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. I'm your aptly named host of your favorite hebdomadal podcast. Oh, I'm glad you're with me. I'd suffer the effects of paraffia if you touched me with the idea that you missed this week's show. 6 Steps Before You Hire. Hiring is rampant because turnover is rampant. You have work to do internally before you go public with your job posting. Andrea Hoffer from AHA! Recruiting Experts talks you through her 6 steps. On Tony's Take Two, lots of opportunities for growth. We're sponsored by Turn Two Communications, PR and content for nonprofits. Your story is their mission. turn-two.co. Here is 6 Steps Before You Hire. It's a pleasure to welcome to Nonprofit Radio Andrea Hoffer. Andrea is a businesswoman with With over 3 decades of experience, she's managed hundreds of employees and knows firsthand the everyday challenges of motivating a team, exceeding customer expectations, and meeting business and revenue goals. Now Andrea's using her experience to help companies recruit, hire, and onboard new team members successfully without wasting time or money on those poor hires that don't work out. Her company is AHA! Recruiting. AHA! They are at AHA_Recruiting and at AHARecruitingExperts.com. Andrea, welcome to Nonprofit Radio.
Andrea HofferHi, Tony. I'm really happy to be here. This is pretty cool.
Tony MartignettiYou're happy and you're surprised.
Andrea HofferI'm surprised, yeah.
Tony MartignettiAndrea and I are on a bus in Israel. We are headed to the Dead Sea. We met at this course called Israel Innovation that she and I are both taking. Along with, I don't know, it seems to be maybe 60 or 70 other people. Most are not from the US. In fact, most are from Latin America— Brazil, Chile, Argentina. But there are also folks from Central America— Panama, Colombia, Costa Rica. There's a woman from Ireland. She makes sure that we know Ireland is in the house every time we have a meeting. Yes. So we're spending a week together traveling through Israel. We've been in We were in Tel Aviv together. Today we left Tel Aviv and came to the Negev Desert, the desert. We visited a kibbutz and now we're on a bus from the kibbutz to the Dead Sea where we're going to stay overnight in hotels. And we are stealing some time on the bus so that Andrea and I can record. Andrea and I can record because we're not sure if we're going to have time any other time. Mm-hmm. There may be occasional interruptions, there's bus noises, and we're on a bus. Welcome, Andrea. Andrea, welcome again.
Andrea HofferThank you.
Tony MartignettiWe are talking about the process of discovery, which is the earliest phase, right? This is the earliest phase of recruiting.
Andrea HofferYes, what you do before you even put a job ad out there, the things you need to think about so that when you do start recruiting, you're looking for the right person.
Tony MartignettiOkay, so we're in an introspective Exercise in-house, we're strictly in-house discovery, and you call this phase discovery.
Andrea HofferYes, we do.
Tony MartignettiWhy is that?
Andrea HofferBecause a lot of it you actually know, but you haven't thought about it. You haven't asked yourself those questions. So you're discovering this about yourself, about your organization, about the people that work for you, and really what you want your work culture to look like, what you want your team to look like.
Tony MartignettiOkay, okay. Now one thing I didn't say in your bio, you are founder and what's your, what do you call yourself at AHA! Recruiting? Founder and CEO?
Andrea HofferFounder and CEO. Founder and CEO. And it's AHA! Recruiting Experts.
Tony MartignettiOh, AHA! Recruiting Experts. Okay, excellent. All right, so you have a discovery process. You have a process for this discovery.
Andrea HofferYes, so we have 6 questions, 6 overall questions that we typically take our clients through, and then there are lots of questions underneath it. to go deeper, but I can talk to you about the 6 December reaching things.
Tony MartignettiWe'll start with the 6 December most important, and maybe some of my questions will evoke some of your sub-questions, etc. Okay,
Andrea Hofferso the first question is really, you know, why does this position exist? What is the main purpose of it? Every position has some reason it exists, and it typically in some way will contribute to the bottom line. bottom line and will contribute to the mission of the company. So it either in some way is going to save the company money or in some way is going to make the company more money, but it's usually even bigger than that. And I have an example I can share to you. Okay. So one example I like to share is an account manager, and the job— we like to break it into job title, job purpose, and then organizational mission. And so the job title of So an account manager could be, the job purpose, to ensure clients' expectations are exceeded. Very, you know, it's very simple. There's no like—
Tony MartignettiVery high level.
Andrea HofferVery high level. No getting this wrong. You know, we tell people, don't worry about getting it right. You're going to start, you're going to tweak it over time, but just put some thought into it so you have direction. So the whole purpose of this account manager's job is to make sure the client's expectations are exceeded. And then as we go through some of these These other questions, these 6 questions, will go a little bit deeper of what that looks like.
Tony MartignettiOkay, okay. Let's reassure folks that this certainly applies to nonprofits. Of course. Your work is mostly— you've done some work with nonprofits and you have a background in nonprofits.
Andrea HofferYes, I started working in higher ed and so I also ran an arts organization. So we were— and it was, you know, that was all nonprofit. And then when I started the company, I I did a lot of consulting with nonprofits in addition to small business.
Tony MartignettiOkay, so this all, everything we're talking about transfers?
Andrea HofferOf course, yes.
Tony MartignettiOkay, otherwise Andrea wouldn't be here.
Andrea HofferI want to make sure you all know that. Yeah, in many ways a lot of these questions of why a position exists or what the mission is of an organization, in some ways it's even easier for the nonprofits to answer because they talk about their mission so much more than business do often. So it is
Tony MartignettiAnd before we go further with— since we're still at the very high level, why does the position exist? Who should be— well, yeah, who should be answering these questions? What's the structure? Do we send around a survey to all the employees? Is it only the employees who are going to work with the person whose position we're filling? Is leadership involved? Who's answering this? What are the logistics of getting these
Andrea Hofferpositions out there? You know, a lot of it depends on how large your organization is. It is. We have done this process with just the CEO or just the leader of, if it's a nonprofit organization. But I typically would recommend getting at least the leadership involved. But if you're thinking, you know, if you can get more people involved in answering these questions and discussing these questions and get as many people's input as possible, the better the outcome, the better you're going to answer these questions.
Tony MartignettiOkay. You like the idea of like maybe the Circulating the questions in advance and then meeting to actually— versus everybody writing their answers, that seems kind of
Andrea Hofferunconventional. Yeah, we actually have that. Sometimes what we do, if the organization agrees and they can get more people involved, is we do a sort of what you just said, like a questionnaire, like a survey, and have each person fill it out separately without talking to each other. Even if it's a small organization, we're just sending it to 4 or 5 people, And then we get them all together and we talk about, well, okay, here are the patterns we saw, here's what everybody's saying, and usually about 70 to 80% is going to be similar.
Tony MartignettiOkay.
Andrea HofferBut then here are the differences, and why do you think this person answered this and that person answered that? And we talk about the gaps, and then a lot of times we're able to bring it together and really come to a— I don't want to say a compromise, but something A consensus. A consensus.
Tony MartignettiAlright, alright, interesting. Alright, so we're at the level, why does this position even exist? Okay, what's next?
Andrea HofferSo the next one is about the outcomes you're looking for, and this drills it down often to metrics. You know, how do you qualify this? And, you know, I know you do planned giving, and if you talk about, say, fundraising, which is kind of an offshoot, bringing money in. There could be the amount of money, the level of money that this position is responsible for bringing in. It could be how much money you want to bring in for different events or for different milestones or deadlines, that type of thing.
Tony MartignettiWhat if it's a program position and they're going to be doing service to beneficiaries, you know, humans in some capacity? Then would it be like your monthly Throughput or number of client hours you spend?
Andrea HofferIt could be retention. It could be keeping people in, keeping volunteers, or keeping how many people attend and come back each time. You know, anything that shows growth, that shows that it's a contribution to the mission overall.
Tony MartignettiOkay, all right. Again, that's why mission can be so valuable. Exactly. Because, and you're, as you said, you know, we're talking about mission often. It's the core, it's the reason It's protecting the homeless, it's protecting animals, it's feeding the hungry, whatever our work is, education, etc.
Andrea HofferAnd this is what's going to attract people in the end. I mean, I know I'm jumping ahead, but all of this is what is going to attract people to join your team, to join your organization. And, you know, money of course is important to most people. They have to be able to live, but to many people, People, this mission, knowing how they contribute to the mission of the organization, whether it's a business or a nonprofit, is just as important, sometimes more important than the money factor. And so if you can get this part right and show that connection, you're going to attract more skilled people and more passionate people, and that's what you want at your organization.
Tony MartignettiAnd I see why you say we're jumping ahead, because now we're kind of bleeding into promoting the position of the organization to the And the mission to the right people, but we're still in the discovery phase. But it all interrelates, of course. And so these are valuable introspection questions. Okay, anything else you want to say about that second one before we move
Andrea Hofferon? No, I think you pretty much got the gist of it there. And then the next one is, I like to refer to it as success traits, but what are the characteristics, and this is Yeah, this is specific to the position because we're going to talk about the organizational culture in a moment. Okay. You know, what are the specific characteristics, specific traits that you have seen of successful people in this position or a similar position in the past? And this takes some thought, and we usually— the way we pull it out of people is by stories. I'm a big fan of thinking back and writing down stories, stories of when you I've had team members that were successful in lots of different— it could be small successes, big successes, but I'm always encouraging people to track those things, to write them down, and then also stories of when people weren't successful. And you start to see patterns of the different traits of what would make somebody successful in this particular position. Right. And I'll give you an example. We often will recruit for executive assistants, and we had a couple years ago A few years ago, we had a CEO, and this can apply nonprofit, for-profit, but this happened to be a for-profit company, and she needed an executive assistant, and she had already gone through several. Nobody was successful with it. Right. And one of the things, one of the reasons why she was having trouble finding the right person was her company was very fast-paced. Everybody in the company traveled a lot. And the CEO was absolutely brilliant. She needed somebody who could organize her and be like a million steps ahead of her and used to that chaos and be able to thrive in that chaos. Yeah. So we knew when we were recruiting that those were some of the traits we were looking for. So we had lots of amazing executive assistant candidates who had great skills, but as soon as we talked to them, And learned, you know, that they've been in executive systems, say, in a large organization for, yes, a very busy, you know, senior executive, but it was still structured. They were still used to a lot of structure. Yeah. We knew they weren't going to be a good fit. So we knew what types of success traits to look for. And then, you know, we take that and we drill it down to a couple of sentences so that it really jumps out at the right person. When we're going to look for someone, and so that it's very clear to us when we're interviewing.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Was there any chance that you should have been recruiting for a new CEO in that company? That sounds like a difficult environment.
Andrea HofferWell, actually, there are lots of businesses and even nonprofit organizations that do function in that way. There's still some structure, there's still productivity, but because of the nature of what they do, There is this daily chaos. You just have to find the right way to succeed. And it was also where they were in their history as a company too, with the growth.
Tony MartignettiIt's time for a break. Turn to Communications. Their e-newsletter this week, What a Year in Review Can Do for You, and they talk about the value of a year-in-review article or blog post that you write. They say that it usually only requires a light lift because you just need to spend time summarizing stuff that you've been writing all year long. And of course, you're going to focus on milestones, you know, main achievements, accomplishments, but they also suggest including challenges Especially if you overcame them successfully, because that adds some authenticity, right? And they suggest that a year-in-review can help you, of course, showcase your results. We just talked about accomplishments, achievements. You can acknowledge your key audiences, supporters, loyal customers, donors, your beneficiaries. Right. Any parts of your year in review that you can work these folks in, all the better. Boost morale. It's often easy to forget all the things that you did achieve over the year at the end of the year because it's so busy. So this can help refresh recollections about the good things that happened through the year. So those are some ideas that they have around You can get their e-newsletter, which is OnMessage, at turn-two.co. Turn2 Communications, your story is their mission. Now back to 6 Steps Before You Hire. We have questions 4, 5, and 6?
Andrea HofferYes, I'm trying to make sure I don't forget any here.
Tony MartignettiAnything else on number 3?
Andrea HofferNo, I think this is good. And let me just go back to my thing here. So we talked about success traits which are specific to the position, but then you have your core values that are specific to the overall organization. So everyone in the organization, no matter what position they have, live by these core values. And I call them kind of like your default Your guiding principles. And if they're done right, if they're really alive in your organization, then you know that no matter what decisions are being made by anybody in the organization, that they'll be making the decision the way you— Around those values. Around those values, the way they act. And so, for example, one of our core values at AHA! is think like a detective. So we're often kind of putting our detective hats And often the core values do start to come from what's important to the CEO, to the person who's running the company or who started the company. But you want to make sure that they're also important to everybody in the organization, that they like it, they're successful by it, it's natural for them. So when we're recruiting for our company, we're looking for people who are curious, who think outside the box, who put their detective hat on. hat on and don't just accept, you know, you have to do things 1, 2, 3, but there's got to be another way to do it better. And so it comes up in our meetings a lot, you know, when somebody says they have a challenge, did you put your detective hat on? You know, how else can we do it? So that's one of our core values.
Tony MartignettiSince we're in the middle here, we're 3 out of 6, I want to mention, Andrea, you don't have in your bio that you're the author You're the author of Hire Hire.
Andrea HofferI don't.
Tony MartignettiUnless I didn't deliberately cut it out of your bio. No, look, I'm showing her her bio on her phone, which does not mention that she's the author of the book. It says about the author.
Andrea HofferIt's about the author because the bio is on—
Tony MartignettiIt's a piece of a larger PR thing. All right. Still, okay. Well, she's the author of the book Hire Hire. H-I-R-E, H-I-G-H-E-R, which you can get on Amazon. Hire Hire.
Andrea HofferYes, and in the book it's a very practical guide and it does walk through these 6 questions and a lot more, but it goes into more detail about it and how to do it.
Tony MartignettiOf course, we
Andrea Hoffercan't do
Tony Martignettieverything here. We can just scratch the surface, we can't dive deep. If this intrigues you, you've got to get the book. That's the only way to get the full depth. All right, number 4, question 4.
Andrea HofferQuestion 4.
Tony MartignettiOur discovery process.
Andrea HofferSo this is what everybody already thinks they know, right? When you're thinking about, I gotta fill a job, I always see employers say, okay, they have to have this many years of experience in this particular industry, and they've had to have, you know, know this specific software and have this education and all of these skills. And when I go online and I look at job ads, it's usually paint Pages and pages of the experience and skills that they want. That can be a really big mistake. So what I recommend in this area is just narrow it down to the 4 to 6 skills or experience that you absolutely need for the job. And think about—
Tony MartignettiYeah, I see like 13 bullets of— oh my God, I'm not sure. Yeah, oh really?
Andrea HofferYeah, one job I read that I was just bowled over by.
Tony MartignettiI get bored reading it.
Andrea HofferYeah, well, and most candidates Or job seekers won't look at it.
Tony MartignettiI can't possibly— sometimes I wonder if there's anybody who could really— like, they're creating such an ideal that I think they may be scaring candidates away.
Andrea HofferWell, they definitely are.
Tony MartignettiBecause they're intimidated by the prospects of this or the requirements of the job.
Andrea HofferYeah, well, and the interesting thing is there have been studies done between men and women, and men typically, even if they can only do 3 out of 15 bullets on the list will apply, but women, if they can do 14 out of the 15, on average will not apply. They won't. So you end up cutting out a big part of the population. So, you know, we typically recommend between 4 and 6 of the most important. Think about what you're set up to train for. So, you know, if you can bring someone on who has the right attitude, you know they're trainable, make sure you You can train them or you have something, some resources to train them. And then that opens the field for you. And people love training and professional development. That's one of the big things candidates are always asking about. What, how am I going to get growth from this? How is this going to take me to the next level? So that's an amazing thing to offer somebody.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Training, professional development is important, folks. Even more so maybe now in the post-pandemic economy. They want— I guess candidates want to know that the company, the organization, is going to invest in their growth.
Andrea HofferYes, that they're going to invest in their growth, that there's opportunity to move up. But even if there isn't opportunity to move up, because sometimes certain organizations just— it just doesn't have that, is there opportunity to learn something new? There are lots of ways to keep people passionate about what they're doing and wanting to stick around even if it's not a huge bump in pay and a huge title. That's not always what's most important to people.
Tony MartignettiOkay. What do we have
Andrea Hoffernext? Okay, let's see. Did we go— we went through 5 already, right? We went through 4. Okay, we talked about results. So why do people stay at your organization and why do they leave? You know, that often we don't even ask ourselves that, and that is probably a question for your current team. You know, what is it that they really enjoy about working there? Is it the mission? Is it that you do a lot of things together as a team? Is it the pay? Is it the professional development? There could be lots of different things. Sometimes, which is very big now, it's the flexibility. You know, if they're— Absolutely. They can come in at different hours, or, you know, is there work from home? Is there a hybrid? That's of course very big right now. What is it that keeps them and what is it that drives them away? And that often could be like, you know, you, you made a comment when I talked about that example of the CEO and the kind of the chaos. Yeah. Some people thrive in that. By your comment, it sounds like that would probably drive you away. Yeah. So be very clear about what your environment's like and put it all out there. Sometimes people will ask me, well, shouldn't I make it sound really great? Only if it's true. Be authentic and find out what is true.
Tony MartignettiOtherwise you're misleading the candidates.
Andrea HofferExactly.
Tony MartignettiIf it's a chaotic environment and a lot of flexibility is needed and it's hard to work through a weekly plan that you might put together on Monday or the Friday before, then reveal that because the person's going to leave in a couple months when they realize that It's not the predictable week-after-week pattern that you made it sound like, or that you just told me explicitly that it is. Right. All right, so if we're at why do people stay and why do people leave, look, people could be leaving because of leadership, difficult leadership. But now we're having leadership answer the survey. Here's where the leaders' answers, the C-suite answers, they diverge from the worker answers.
Andrea HofferThat is very true.
Tony MartignettiYes. And who in the C-suite is going to be willing to admit that they are the reason or contributing to the reason that people leave?
Andrea HofferThat's going to be a tough one. You know what, you would be surprised that I have met a lot of leaders over the years, both in nonprofit and for-profit, and I have met leaders who recognize where their challenges are. And sometimes they'll say, I need to hire somebody to fill that gap for me. I met with a leader a couple of weeks ago who said that. He said, you know what, I know I'm not good at managing people, at keeping the team motivated, at checking in with them and making sure they're supported. So I need to hire somebody to help me with that, or that, or to kind of fill that gap. So a lot of them will, especially now, because it's even more important. Because we as a society, after the pandemic, are demanding You know, to be recognized, to be respected, to have leaders who are going to contribute to our growth. So I think that more and more leaders are, even if they have to be banged on the head a little bit with it, I think they're recognizing the importance of that and that they need to do that if they want to retain a team at
Tony Martignettiall. Okay, you're finding that people are realizing
Andrea HofferWell, and it couldn't
Tony Martignettibe.
Andrea HofferMost of the people I meet—
Tony MartignettiBe careful. You should watch your hair on your left side too.
Andrea HofferOh, okay. There
Tony Martignettiyou go. Just in case it's brushing. So that was Andrea. Andrea, sorry. I know I've been calling you Andrea for half a week now, and now we're recording and I keep saying Andrea. Andrea was touching her mic, but we're on the fly here. That's what that noise made.
Andrea HofferWe're in the middle of the desert.
Tony MartignettiYeah, I imagine you heard. All right, anything else?
Andrea HofferI thought we went through everything.
Tony MartignettiThat's a very good one. Why people stay and why people leave.
Andrea HofferYeah, I mean, you could spend a lot of time on that. You know, it's so funny, I actually met with— often I will run masterminds or be in masterminds with other organizational leaders, and there was one woman who her business is growing very Very quickly, and she said, I'm so overwhelmed. I'm like, what are you overwhelmed with? She said, I'm overwhelmed with the employee engagement piece. I feel like there's so much I need to do to show my employees I care and to keep them happy and successful, and I've been told, like, you know, there's so much out there and it's just, there's so much more. Yeah. hearing now. So I was like, you don't have to do everything right away. You know, just check in with your team regularly. That's probably the most important thing is checking in, see how you can help them and make sure they know you're being authentic, you're being sincere, you truly want to hear if there's a challenge.
Tony MartignettiEmpathetic.
Andrea HofferYeah, empathy.
Tony MartignettiSome empathy, some humanity.
Andrea HofferYeah, which this leader is naturally empathetic. So I said, really, you just need to be you. She had a counseling But I told her to just start with 3, you know, 3 things that—
Tony MartignettiWe're gonna pause while we have an introduction. Oh, an explanation.
MichaelThe city of Arad, what it's famous for— I don't
Tony Martignettiknow, maybe we should include
Michaelthis. People who have asthma, okay, who have problems with breathing, they come to Arad because the air here is very, very dry and it's very good for people People who have problems breathing and lungs problems. Now, the Dead Sea is also part of, I would say, medical tourism. And now look, we are starting to go down to the Dead Sea. Arad is like 400, 500 meters above sea level. The Dead Sea is 425 meters below sea level, so we're going now 800 meters down. Wow.
Tony MartignettiAll right, so there's a little bit about the Dead Sea and how far below sea level it is, courtesy of our guide for the week, Michael from Denmark. It's time for Tony's Take Two. We are at the beginning of December, which of course is most likely a very important month for you regardless of how you perform, how your organization comes out, tomorrow is another opportunity to grow. So I'm urging you to shed, let go how it goes today, this week. You have another day tomorrow, you have another week, and you have the one after. So regardless of how you and your nonprofit do even this year. 2023 is another opportunity full of 365 days. If you do great this year, 2022, fantastic. If you don't, 2023 is another new full year. Your past doesn't define your future, and you have many opportunities to grow each day, week, month, year. That is Tony's Take Two. We've got beaucoup, buttloads more time for 6 Steps Before You Hire with Andrea Hoffer. We were talking about the reasons why people leave, the reasons why people stay. And I was saying that I think that's valuable introspection, even apart from a hiring process. I just think this is valuable. I think it's valuable to think about these things. Is there anything more that you want to add on?
Andrea HofferNo, not onto that. And I agree, it is very important. And sometimes we do all this work with clients to find them the best candidate, or what we think is the best candidate. candidate. And what we have learned over the years is that we also need to do work with the employers on how to set the new hire up for success and, and keep them happy and help them with success ongoing. Right. Because we're seeing— we started doing a survey of our— the people we placed last year in 2021. We placed 165 people, and we have been reaching out to them at different points, like 30 days in, 60 days in, 90, a year, to find out, you know, did they feel like the recruitment process was professional, was it a good representation of where they were going, and then what was, you know, what is it like at the company, and what we're hearing What we're hearing a lot of is, I wasn't really— I'm generalizing here, but I wasn't really set up for success. I wasn't given the resources I needed to be successful, or sometimes it wasn't as described, which means we didn't get the correct information from the employer. Right. Because what also seems to happen sometimes is the employer— things change quickly in organizations, and sometimes they change the position. So they might not change the position title, but then they change the expectations around the position, and that's not what was, you know, sold to the candidate. No. So if that— and sometimes that happens and it's nobody's fault, it's just how the organization, the direction is moving. And I always recommend just be upfront with your new hire and talk to them and figure out, is this still the right fit for you and how can we work with you so that it can be the right fit and maybe there's somebody else in the organization where it's a better fit and you can put this person in a position that will work for them.
Tony MartignettiBut at least be upfront. Exactly. And be talking about these things. All right, so we kind of melded a couple of these together so I want you to just read through 1 through 6 so it's just clear that we've Okay, so
Andrea Hofferthe first one is, why does the position exist? Next, what are the results or outcomes needed from this position? And I think we just grazed over that one. And one of the things I do want to mention that I didn't mention earlier related to that question is I'm a big fan of results.
Tony MartignettiI even asked you if there were more, if there was more you could say about that one.
Andrea HofferI think I gave you the opportunity. Where are the bots? My brain's not as fast. You
Tony Martignettican only use that excuse so many times.
Andrea HofferOh, okay. No, so I'm a big fan of result-oriented job descriptions, and so, and that means, you know, writing the job description for the results that you're looking for. So I, you know, so I think this question is really important, and sometimes Sometimes you can get a really great candidate from a different industry who has accomplished something very close to what you're looking to accomplish from this position. So the more clear on what you're looking for, what, you know, what we always ask, what would give this person a great performance evaluation in 90 days? What would they have accomplished for you to say A+ for them in the first 90 days? Right. And then different segments. of, you know, the next timeline. Okay. So that— I just wanted to make sure I covered that. So the next question is, what skills and experience are needed to do this job successfully? What are specific traits— we call them success traits or attributes— that make a person successful in this position? What are the specific behaviors that fit in your organizational culture? We were talking about core values. And then lastly, why do team members stay with you and why do they leave?
Tony MartignettiOkay, thank you. What about salary— now we're jumping outside of discovery, but you and I talked earlier when we were getting to know each other about salary range disclosures in job descriptions, which is becoming so much more important. New York State just passed a law that requires Yes. I thought I had seen that in Oregon too. I might be mistaken about that. You hadn't heard of that one, but at least we know New York State has passed that law and other states are considering it. And just, it's just, it's a movement apart from whether it's legal or not, legally required or not. Right. Share your opinion on disclosing salary or a range in a description.
Andrea HofferIt's always been a best practice, and now in many states, like you mentioned, Tony, it's a law. And I think at some point it will probably be a law in just about all states. Okay. The reason for it— there's several reasons, but one of the main reasons that it's become a law in a lot of states is because in the past there's been a lot of bias and discrimination when it comes to pay. When you think about how women have been paid, or different cultural groups or backgrounds.
Tony MartignettiYeah, people of color.
Andrea HofferExactly. And so if you are not transparent about your salary, and you then— because I hear this a lot from employers— well, I don't, I don't know what I'm gonna pay, we'll see what the person made before. Well, all that's doing is contributing to the bad, the uneven, inequitable pay from the past perpetuating.
Tony MartignettiThat doesn't seem like a good idea.
Andrea HofferRight, so what you need to do is think about what can you pay, what do you think the return is for this position that your organization can afford, and what is it worth for the value that's going to be contributed, and create a range there, and don't make the range $100,000. I usually recommend— $100,000 to $200,000. I mean, I've seen sometimes too, exactly. I usually recommend, you know, maybe a $10,000 range, maybe a $20,000 range, not much more than that. And, and you can decide based on what that particular person you're hiring is, is gonna bring, how much training you need to give them to get them them up to speed. The other thing is it just wastes your time if you're not transparent up front. It wastes the job seeker's time and it wastes your time because everybody will look at the job and have different thoughts on what it's going to pay. Right. So I may have applied for the job thinking that it's going to pay $100,000 and you're only planning to pay $40,000, and if, and if we don't get to that until like the 3rd interview, well, we've wasted so much time, and it just frustrates both of us. Yeah, um, so that's
Tony Martignettiright, because no candidate is going to ask about salary in the first interview. Well, maybe, maybe not even in a second if they know there's another coming,
Andrea Hofferright? And less candidates are going to apply for your job if they don't know what the pay is, because they're afraid they're going to waste their time, and they often feel Like, because you're not being transparent with that, you might not be transparent with other things as well, so you might not be the right employer for them.
Tony MartignettiOkay, all right. And just let's kind of wrap up with what you are seeing in our sort of trends, maybe one or two things that you want folks to know about, you know, in this post-pandemic hiring environment
Andrea Hofferthat we find ourselves? People are looking for their passion. They're looking for not just the passion connected to the mission that, you know, the company— that is a big part of it— but they're looking for a place they can call home. They're looking for flexibility. They're looking for an environment environment that they're happy to go to work, and it doesn't matter the level of the position. Pay is also important. They want to be paid what they feel they're worth, and because pay has— we're seeing a big trend in increase of pay, you know, jobs that have paid one amount for decades are now We've seen large jumps in them. Mm-hmm. But then I've seen where candidates have been willing to take a pay cut if it means they could work from home or they could have more flexibility, or it's something that they truly believe in. And I have seen a great trend of candidates, of job seekers who have left or actually even gotten laid off during the pandemic from high-paying, high- pressure jobs that are now saying they want a job in a nonprofit, in something that they truly believe in. And they usually have a specific type of nonprofit or type of mission that they, you know, they have in mind because it's something important to them specifically. I'm not saying that there isn't any one— No, but for them— But for them individually. And so I think the pandemic has really— it's created this thing in all of us where life's short, right? Like, I want to just do something. I want to be contributing in a way that, that works for me on both my time and what, what's important to me. Okay. And I think that's important as you go out and recruit people and as you work with people as well, to keep that
Tony MartignettiA lot of us have heard from people who want to, want to now give back, and that was even pre-pandemic, but I think the pandemic accelerated it. People being more reflective about their career because the pandemic made people question their own mortality. In the early days of the pandemic, we didn't know if you were 30 if it could kill you, or if you were 75 if it could kill you, or if one was at greater risk than the other. We didn't know. Right. We are really questioning a lot of things in life, and obviously career is enormous. So, you know, we see so much about nomads now, digital nomads traveling the US, traveling the world.
Andrea HofferSelling their homes.
Tony MartignettiYeah, yeah, and moving and working from completely different time zones and completely different hemispheres, right? Because they want to have a richer life, but they still need to make some money, so they're They're happy to work from wherever if you'll allow it.
Andrea HofferRight, and that's the other thing. If the type of position you have available, if you're able to think maybe a little outside the box and make it either a hybrid or remote or add some of that flexibility in, that is so important to people now. And they, because of the pandemic where they saw companies and organizations did it out of necessity, they won't take, oh no, we don't do that here, as an answer. Then there's a, then they're saying, you know, then that's not for me. Yeah. Plus, as things started to let up just a little bit during the pandemic, it was still pretty early on, the question I got over and over again from candidates was, What will happen with this position if we end up having to shut down again, if we have another pandemic? Oh, interesting. I haven't been hearing as much the past year, but that first year I heard a lot because they do not want to be laid off again. You know, they wanted— so you might want to think about that as well. It's not just because they want the flexibility, they also want that security that they know if
Tony MartignettiOkay. We're in the, we're in the Israeli desert, the Negev. We're descending, as you heard.
MichaelSo now we passed sea level, okay?
Tony MartignettiYeah, now we're down.
MichaelGoing 425 meters.
Tony MartignettiOur tour guide, Michael.
MichaelStill down underneath sea level, okay? The most lowest place in Israel. That's the Dead Sea. Now the lights that you see on the other side, this is already another country. This is Jordan. The border between Israel and Jordan is exactly in the middle of the Dead Sea.
Tony MartignettiI should have said that Michael is originally from Denmark but lives in Israel and is a tour guide here. So with Andrea Hoffer, founder and CEO of AHA! Recruiting Experts, aha_recruiting and aha-recruiting-experts.com. Andrea, thank you so much. Real pleasure.
Andrea HofferThank you, Tony.
Tony MartignettiThank you for doing this on a bus in the Israel desert.
Andrea HofferIt was fun. Thank you. Something different. Very different.
Tony MartignettiThank you for hanging in with the weird sound this week. I know it's up and down and it's crackly. I really wanted to capture the conversation with Andrea. We were sitting side by side, and how many shows do I get to record in the Israeli desert. And, and plus you got to learn about the desert from Michael. So thank you. I know it's weird this week. Thanks very much. Next week, Trathen Heckman with his book Take Heart, Take Action. I know last week I said he'd be this week. I need an intern. If you missed any part of this week's show, I'd be We're sponsored by Turn 2 Communications, PR and content for nonprofits. Your story is their mission. turn-2.co. Our creative producer is Claire Meyerhoff. The show's social media is by Susan Chavez. Marc Silverman is our web guy, and this music is by Scott Stein. Thank you for that affirmation, Scott. Thank you, Marc. Be with me next week for Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. Go out and be great. Thank you.
I love our sponsor!


