Skip to content
EP 618November 27, 2022

Thought Leadership & Content Strategy

Tony MartignettiPeter PanepentoAntionette KerrValerie JohnsonKatie Green
Nonprofit Radio
Episode 618
0:00 / 0:00

Thought Leadership

Peter Panepento and Antionette Kerr co-authored the book, "Modern Media Relations for Nonprofits." They share their insights on how to build relationships with journalists so you get heard as the thought leader you are. Plus, other media strategies, like crisis communications. This was part of our coverage of the 2020 Nonprofit Technology Conference.

Content Strategy

Now that you're an established thought leader, you need to produce multichannel content that's relevant. Also engaging, actionable, user friendly and SEO friendly. Also from 20NTC, Valerie Johnson from Pathways to Housing PA and Katie Green with The Trevor Project show you how.

Here’s the transcript

Tony MartignettiHello and welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. I'm your aptly named host of your favorite hebdomadal podcast. I hope you enjoyed your Thanksgiving. I hope you enjoyed the company of family, friends, time for yourself as well. Lots of, lots of good Thanksgiving holiday wishes. I hope you enjoyed very much. And I'm glad you're with me. I'd be forced to endure the pain of epidermolysis bullosa if you gave me the blistering news that you missed this week's show. Thought leadership. Peter Panepento and Antionette Kerr co-authored the book Modern Media Relations for Nonprofits. They share their insights on how to build relationships with journalists so you get heard as the thought leader you are, plus other media strategies like crisis communications. This was part of our coverage of the 2020 Nonprofit Technology Conference. And content strategy. Now that you're an established thought leader, you need to produce multichannel content that's relevant, also engaging, actionable, user-friendly, and SEO-friendly. Also from 20 NTC, Valerie Johnson from Pathways to Housing PA and Katie Green with The Trevor Project show you how. On Tony's Take Two. I'm still wishing you well. We are sponsored by Turn Two Communications, PR and content for nonprofits. Your story is their mission. turn-two.co. Here is Thought Leadership. With me now are Peter Panepento and Antionette Kerr. Peter is Philanthropic Practice Leader at Turn Two Communications. Antionette is part of the leadership team of Women Advance and CEO of Bold and Bright Media. They are the co-authors of the book Modern Media Relations for Nonprofits. Peter, Antionette, welcome.

Peter PanepentoGreat to be here virtually, Tony.

Tony MartignettiYes, I'm glad we could work this out among the 3 of us. Thank you, and it's good to know that you're each well and safe in your respective locations. Okay.

Peter PanepentoThank you. Social distancing in full effect. Yes.

Tony MartignettiOkay. Yes, I see no one within 6 feet of you. That's good. Even though you are home. We're talking about thought leadership and media. Let's, let's start with you, Antoinette. We can, we can use our leverage, thought leadership, and use the media to influence those who are engaged with us, our constituents, and even influence policy.

Antionette KerrSo the media needs experts, and nonprofits are on the ground. They're doing the work, and they are the perfect folks to be experts in this conversation. In particular, in emergency, Peter and I talked about earlier about crisis communications. And in a lot of situations, the media is scrambling looking for experts. If you have established yourself as a thought leader, Which is what you should aspire to do. I know that Turn Two does the work in helping people to kind of establish themselves as the thought leader in this conversation. But right now we need people with good information and who can provide great stories, for example, and nonprofits can do that and they can do that work. And that's why the thought leadership conversation is important. Most nonprofits don't see themselves needing to do that, it's not the first thing we think about. We think about fundraising, right? Um, but not necessarily media friend-raising. And so now's the time that you want to have those relationships and be considered as a thought leader.

Tony MartignettiBecause when there's news that relates to your mission, um, your call is more likely to be taken, your email is more likely to be answered if there's That preexisting relationship you mentioned. But if, if everybody in the sector is calling all the, all the media blindly, then it's just sort of a crapshoot whether they answer you or not.

Antionette KerrOr if you think about the media needing, like, you know, going to a crisis example, like the media needing a source or an expert.

Tony MartignettiYeah.

Antionette KerrAnd they don't want to quote the same person. That's, you know, something that I've learned from my media background and training. I've been working as a journalist since 1995, and, you know, one thing that my editors say, you know, don't quote the same person, don't quote the same organization. So in a crisis, people will call big box nonprofits sometimes, and they'll just see them as being the experts for a conversation. And that's why establishing yourself as a thought leader is so important. So someone can say, you know, I'm a unique voice about this. We have an example in our book, Modern Media Relations, where someone who— an organization that worked with children and families involved in domestic violence became very important in the conversation when a professional athlete in Georgia was convicted of family violence. And all of a sudden that person was called upon. Right. to be on radio shows and talk shows, and they became a thought leader, but they'd done the work to position themselves as an expert. And so I know, Peter, you— I know you have some examples as well, but we just kind of dived in there and didn't talk about the whole broad concept of thought leadership.

Tony MartignettiWell, all right. Well, Peter, I was going to ask you, how do we start to build these relationships? You want to— I don't know, do you want to back up what thought leadership is?

Peter PanepentoSure, I'll start with thought leadership defined, and that's really the process of establishing one's expertise in a specific area and doing it in a way where they are recognized beyond their own organization and their own kind of immediate networks as an expert, as a thought leader, somebody who is driving the conversation and really, really helping people better understand a key issue or a topic. So for a nonprofit or a foundation, a thought leader might be your CEO who— or executive director, somebody who is at the front lines and kind of is in a position where they not only have expertise, but they have some authority in being able to talk with some gravitas about a topic. But in order to kind of establish your credentials there and get recognized, you have to do some legwork beyond just having that expertise. You have to be, you have to be comfortable talking about that topic. You have to, you have to spend some time kind of building the relationships and the, and the, and the larger credibility that you are somebody who has something interesting to say and the expertise to back it up. And the more you do that, and you can do that not just through the media, but through your own channels and through speaking at conferences and all kinds of other things, the more you do that, the more you kind of become somebody who is recognized and is called upon to weigh in on important topics or when news events call for it, or in a situation like where we are now with the COVID-19 response, somebody who can kind of come in and bring a voice of reason and perspective to what's going on around us.

Tony MartignettiSo you have to lay the groundwork. There has to be some fundamentals, and you have to have your gravitas, and you, you need to appear bona fide and be bona fide, not just appear. You have to be bona fide on the topic that you're, that you're an expert in, or the, the mission of, of your, your nonprofit. How do you then start to, when you have that groundwork, How do you then start to build relationships when there isn't really a need for you to be talking about the subject?

Peter PanepentoSure. There are a lot of ways to do that. One is that you start to build some personal relationships with media who are covering these topics. And you can do that either through, you know, somebody on your communications team that helps you, or you can kind of do it yourself. But you can start to show up in their coverage of stories by, by positioning yourself and building relationships with individual reporters, maybe even when they don't need you, by having an informational coffee or call so that they can get to know you and know what you stand for. You can do it by your— through your own writing and public speaking and making those things available and accessible to the media. And you can, you can do it through your own channels too. A lot of nonprofits have blogs. They have, they have their own podcasts. They have different ways where they're positioning their internal experts externally so that they're kind of talking about and establishing their credentials around a subject.

Tony MartignettiThat's your owned media, right? That's your owned media versus earned media.

Peter PanepentoYes, yes. And the value of that is that the more you're kind of demonstrating through your owned media channels your expertise, you're not only building some greater relationships and credibility with your donors and the folks who are already kind of in your network, But you start to show up when people are doing searches or when people are on social media and seeing stories and articles that are getting passed around. If they may see something you've written or talked about shared in another network and it sparks a light for them that you're somebody worth going back to when they need, when they need some, you know, somebody like you to weigh in on something.

Tony MartignettiOkay, Peter, I know you and Antoinette are both former journalists. So I'm going to jump over to Antoinette for what— Antoinette, what do these outreach, I guess, calls and emails to journalists to try to build the relationship, what do they look like? What would you suggest people are saying to try to get the attention to build the relationship? Not when I'm looking to be quoted because there's breaking news. Right. But to build the relationship beforehand.

Antionette KerrDefinitely, totally appreciate it. So full disclosure, I'm a current journalist. Oh, current?

Tony MartignettiOkay.

Antionette KerrYes, so I still work for publications right now.

Tony MartignettiOkay.

Antionette KerrAnd so people contact me on Twitter and social media, which is a new thing. We talk about press releases. I'm a big fan of press releases. Yes, just full disclosure about that, but I still like for people to pitch me on social media, direct messages through Twitter. If I'm using my company profile, it's safe for nonprofits to contact me and say, hey, I have a story. I noticed that you're interested in this concept. It's always great when people know what I'm interested in. Like when they're like, I noticed that you publish a lot of stories. Like right now I'm working on a story, a series of stories about missing and murdered indigenous women. And so when people see, oh, I noticed you're publishing stories about this, and they pitch me on a direct message or through Facebook Messenger even and say, hey, would you consider this story? And here's the angle. Or have you thought about, you know, I've had other people reach out and say, I noticed you're publishing these types of stories about, you know, missing and murdered Indigenous women. Have you considered other stories about violence against women? And it's always a really great connection for me. So I think just kind of knowing what the journalist is interested in is really important, kind of understanding their angle. Sorry, y'all. Understanding their angle and just flowing from there and saying, you know, here's how we fit into this conversation is always a wonderful topic.

Tony MartignettiAnd so So outreach by any of the social channels is fine too. You're talking about Twitter and direct message, Facebook. Those are all— those are all good.

Antionette KerrOh, it's great. Yes. And people tagging me, like, I feel like if a journalist is using their profile in a way that is professional, then you're safe to contact them and tag them in that way.

Tony MartignettiOkay.

Peter PanepentoYeah.

Tony MartignettiYeah, Peter, anything you want to add to—

Peter PanepentoYeah, I think that— I think Antionette is dead on about making sure, though, that when you do that, you are— you are— you're not coming with something that's off the reporter's beat or off of what you know is what they cover or the type of story they cover within that beat. You could spend a lot of effort reaching out to every journalist you see on Twitter about your specific cause, but if they don't cover your cause, and it doesn't relate to what they do, then they're probably either going to ignore you or start to block you because you're kind of almost spamming them. So it's important to be targeted with who you reach out to as well and make sure that you understand that journalist and their work before you do your outreach and come at them with a pitch that they don't necessarily want. So yes, I think it's really important to do a bit of that homework upfront. And respect that journalist's time. And if you do that, and if you come at them with something that is actually on, on their beat and is of interest to them, then I think you have a much greater chance of getting their attention and getting them to want to follow up with you and help further the relationship beyond that initial pitch.

Tony MartignettiOkay.

Antionette KerrAnd Tony, can I share a pet peeve? Like, 2 pet peeves, actually. If I write about a nonprofit and they don't share the story on their own social, it's just, it's heartbreaking for me. A lot of times I have to fight for these stories to appear and I have to fight with an editor to say, this is why this is newsworthy, this needs to be here. And then the nonprofit really doesn't share the story. Right. And I think, well, you know, I don't write for my own, you know, just for it not to be shared. And then the other thing is I love when nonprofits support stories that aren't related to their particular story. So I'll start noticing, like one thing, Kentucky Nonprofit Network, for example, before they ever shared or were involved in anything that I was involved in, they started sharing things or liking things that I would publish as a reporter. And I didn't know anything about them, but I thought that was interesting so that when they pitch something, then you're more likely to notice it because as a reporter, you're more likely to notice because you feel like they're really genuinely interested in the conversation. Even if it doesn't apply to them, you're still interested.

Tony MartignettiAntionette, where are you writing now?

Antionette KerrI am writing, working on a piece for Guardian. I am for The Guardian. I am writing for Women Advance, which we have our own network. And then I write for Halifax Media Group publications. So I'm on the regional circuit doing all the fun things.

Tony MartignettiOkay. Halifax is Nova Scotia?

Antionette KerrNo, Halifax is a media group in the United States.

Tony MartignettiOkay. Okay.

Antionette KerrThey own a series of— they own regional newspapers across the country. So

Tony Martignettilet's talk a little about crisis management. You want to— can you get us started with how you might approach crisis communications, Antionette?

Antionette KerrI thought that was Peter's question. No, I'm

Tony Martignettijust kidding.

Antionette KerrNo, I'm just kidding. Crisis communications. I think actually Peter is a really great person to talk about this. My crisis communications conversation really Has shifted with what we're going through. So I don't want to make it so unique to our current situation. So I'll let Peter start and then Peter, I can back you up on it if that's okay.

Peter PanepentoSure, I'm happy to do that. Yeah, so with crisis communications, it's really important to not wait until the actual— you're actually in a crisis to put your plan together. It's really important to, to have a protocol that you've set up when you're not in the middle of a crisis, if possible. To really kind of put together some protocols for not only what you're going to say, but who's going to say it and how you're going to communicate during that situation. So what does that protocol look like? One is that you upfront, you designate who your spokesperson or spokespeople are going to be ahead of time, and you spend some time ahead of that coaching them up in terms of what some of the key messages for your organization are, regardless of what the crisis might be. Some things that you would broadly want to try to reinforce and kind of a mood and a tone that you're going to want to take with what you're talking about. Do that first. Second is that you would really want to have a system in place for how you activate that, for how you activate your crisis plan and your crisis communications. So that essentially means that you want to You want to make sure that you know kind of who, who needs to sign off on what you're going to talk about, who you're going to be involving in your decisions on whether you need to put out a statement, who, how you're going to communicate in what different channels. The more you can make those decisions ahead of time and have your structure in place, the better equipped you are to actually respond during a crisis situation and be able to get a and accurate and positive message out in a situation. And often crises are not— they're crises because they're not expected, but you can be planning ahead so that you are able to react quickly and authoritatively during that situation.

Tony MartignettiYou're compounding the crisis if you're not prepared.

Peter PanepentoAbsolutely.

Tony MartignettiNow you're scrambling to figure out who's in charge, Who has to approve messages? Where should messages go? All, all which are peripheral to the, to the substance of the problem.

Peter PanepentoAbsolutely. And in today's world where crises can really mushroom, not only in the media but on social media, the longer you're allowing time to pass before you're getting out there with, with your statement and your response to it, the worse The worse the situation gets for you. So you really need to position yourselves to be able to respond quickly, to respond clearly, and to respond accurately. And, and it's important to note that, you know, that planning ahead of time is really critical, but what you say in the situation is also critical too. You do want to make sure that you communicate truthfully. That doesn't necessarily mean that you, you—

Tony MartignettiReveal everything.

Peter PanepentoReveal everything, exactly.

Tony MartignettiYeah, you still have—

Peter PanepentoBut that the information that you do, that you do reveal is accurate. It's not going to come back to bite you later. It's not going to mislead people.

Tony MartignettiTalking about complicating the, complicating the crisis if you're lying or misleading. It comes back. I mean, people investigate, things get found out. You've—

Peter PanepentoAbsolutely. And I've, and I've, and I was—

Tony MartignettiAlgorithmically— Expanded your problem.

Peter PanepentoAbsolutely. And you'd be surprised how many times when I was a journalist that people, if they had just come clean and kind of gotten the truth out there right away, they may have taken a short-term hit, but their lives would have gone on fine after that. But the more you try to obfuscate or lie about the situation or try to spin it in a way where you're kind of hiding the truth, the worse your situation is going to get. So be, be in a position to be as transparent and clear and accurate as possible with that first statement, knowing that in some cases you might have to say, you know, we don't know. Right. But we'll follow up when we do know, because sometimes a crisis situation is one in which— speaking of one we're in now, we don't know all of the different twists and turns the COVID-19 situation is going to take. So, but rather than trying to speculate, or in some cases, as we've seen some public figures do, try to spin this one way or another, rather than just saying, here's the situation, here are our concerns, here's what we know, here's what we don't know, it compounds the situation. And in some cases, it can be dangerous to people.

Tony MartignettiYeah. Antionette, you want to back up a little bit?

Antionette KerrI did. So the— I think the statement— I love how people are putting forward these COVID-19 statements, and I think we need to have more statements like that. I mean, these statements are demanding and people feel like that, but I'm like, we could do more of that. We could have statements as nonprofits on issues, on public issues, public concerns, and Things that are emerging and urgent for people, I think about in the eastern part of North Carolina, 'cause Tony, I know you're in my home state.

Tony MartignettiI am in eastern North Carolina, yeah.

Antionette KerrHappy to have you here. And when we have hurricanes, when we have issues like that, if nonprofits would put out statements like they have with COVID-19, if they felt like they needed to say, here's where we are, here's what we do, here's what we have to offer before, during, after, and just update them. You know, I feel like this crisis has brought forward a level of communication and helped people to see the necessary level of communication that we need to have. Mm-hmm. But we don't have that all the time as nonprofits, and people are looking for that. So I feel like in the eastern part of North Carolina where we had You know, 100-year hurricanes within 3 months of each other that didn't think would happen. You know, what if people— what if people made COVID statements like that? I mean, what if people— and so I'm just going to start calling them COVID statements, Peter. I don't have a better term for it. But what if we felt like we needed to make these types of statements when there's an emergency? Interesting.

Tony MartignettiAll right. Thank you. Thank you. Antionette, I'm going to ask you to wrap up with something that you said, which is contrary to a lot of what I hear. You said that you are a big fan of press releases.

Antionette KerrI am.

Tony MartignettiCould you take us out with your rationale for why you're a big fan of them? I've heard that they're pretty much obsolete.

Antionette KerrFrom a journalist?

Tony MartignettiI don't know, from a commentator. Guests I've had. All right.

Antionette KerrI believe that. I believe that. Um, so yes, because I've been reading press releases for a long time, and I feel like the who, what, when, where, and how gets me past that part of it. Then I can ask you all the interesting questions. So if you can give me that in a way that I can cut and paste, and I will not butcher someone's name like Miss Beltoni.

Tony MartignettiAll right, Martignetti is more at risk.

Antionette KerrIt might be a challenge. So we can get all of that out of the way. But a good press release gets me excited as a journalist. It brings me into the conversation. And if you aren't excited about your press release, I can probably tell on the other end. So let's just write a good press release.

Tony MartignettiAll right, thank you. We're going to leave it there. That's contrary advice, which I love hearing. All right. That's Antionette Kerr, part of the leadership team of Women Advance. and CEO of Bold and Bright Media, and also Peter Panepento, philanthropic practice leader at Turn Two Communications, and they are co-authors of the book Modern Media Relations for Nonprofits. Antionette, Peter, thank you very much for sharing. Thanks so much.

Peter PanepentoThanks for having us, Tony.

Tony MartignettiPleasure. Stay safe, and thank you for being with Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio coverage of 20NTC. It's time for a break. Turn Two Communications. Well, as you heard, lots of ideas about the relationships, the relationships that will help you be the thought leader that you want to be, that you ought to be. Relationships leading to thought leadership. Turn Two Communications. They'll help you do it. Your story is their mission. turn-two.co. It's time for Tony's Take Two. I am still thinking about you and wishing you well. I hope you had recovery time over Thanksgiving. If you're in Giving Tuesday, I hope you'll be happy with your results, or you are happy, depending when you listen. If you are, if you did, congratulations. Thank you. Celebrate what you achieved. Take that victory lap. You deserve it. If you're not so happy, keep your head up. You know that you did the best that you could. Don't let it drag you down. You have other successes that are going to be coming, and you'll be celebrating those. So don't let a disappointment drag you down going forward. You have all my good wishes for your year-end fundraising this week and continuing. That is Tony's Take Two. Here is content strategy, which by the way, we have beaucoup buttloads of time left for. Welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio coverage of 20NTC, That's the 2020 Nonprofit Technology Conference. My guests now are Katie Green and Valerie Johnson. Katie is Digital Giving Manager for the Trevor Project, and Valerie Johnson is Director of Institutional Advancement at Pathways to Housing PA. Katie and Valerie, welcome.

Katie GreenHi. Hello. Thank you for having us.

Tony MartignettiIt's a pleasure. It's good to, good to talk to both of you and Glad to know that you're each safe and well in Brooklyn and suburban Philadelphia. Glad you're with us. Your NTC workshop was Content Strategy for Donor Engagement: From Tactics to Testing. Let's start with you, Katie. What, what did you feel was the need for the session? What are nonprofits not getting— doing so well that they could be doing a lot better?

Katie GreenYeah, so we had the session this morning, same time as we originally had planned, which is great. We were able to give it virtually. And I think what a lot of donor content strategy is missing is simply structure. I think a lot of people don't know where to start and they're intimidated by it. And we, Valerie and I, provided some real-life examples on how you can achieve a donor content strategy that does get you closer to your revenue goals. However, the tone of the presentation changed a little bit given how the world has come to be, our new reality. So we did talk a little bit about the crisis and what it means for fundraising and what it means for content strategy under a tight timeline, knowing that things are changing at a really rapid pace. So really just structure and storytelling are the things that we talked about in this morning's presentation, which will be available for viewing later. We're going to have a recording available for those who weren't able

Tony MartignettiLet's start with part of the— a good strategy is using personas, user personas. Can you kick us off with that, Valerie? How do you start to identify what a persona looks like and what's their value?

Valerie JohnsonAbsolutely. So a persona is really like a profile or a character sketch of someone. Someone that you need to connect with and understanding their motivations and goals. So it's a way of segmenting your audience, and rather than sending all of your messaging out into the ether, trying to tailor that messaging to a specific demographic or a specific group of people. So for Pathways to Housing PA, we're actually still developing what our personas look like. We have an idea of what it looks like, but we want to dig some more into the research and analytics side of things to to see who exactly is supporting us right now and what ties they have in common to help us build those profiles. I think Katie might be a little bit further ahead of us in developing those personas, so I'm gonna toss it over to her.

Katie GreenYeah, so user personas are something I've been doing throughout my career. I worked in an agency before I came to The Trevor Project, so I was able to get a lot of industry knowledge on how we create user personas and user journeys. But what we did when we started looking at our end-of-year campaign for last year at the Trevor Project, we made sure we carved out some time to conduct a little bit of an audit of what our donors were looking like. Where were they coming from? What could we track? What couldn't we track? We found out we had a lot more questions than we did answers. So in order to get user personas, something that's really important is tracking and understanding where people are coming from and where their first and last clicks are. So because of our ability to use Google Analytics and source code tracking protocol, we did get a lot of tracking during end of year that will improve what our user personas look like going into future campaigns. But now we're going to be able to better tell what is actually inspiring people to give. What is the moment where they're actually clicking that donate button? What is the first thing they're seeing that's starting their relationship with the Trevor Project? So that's cool. Yeah.

Tony MartignettiWhat are, what are the pieces of a persona? How granular do you get? Is it where they live to what they read, or what? Yeah, give us some like depth of this thing.

Katie GreenAbsolutely. So the main important piece of a persona is to know what their needs are. So you can have a persona that's as general as, this is a donor, they need to know how to give. That's a persona. But what you'd like to do is get a little bit deeper in being able to tell what the values of that persona are. What's the name? What's the age? What's the characteristics? What are the opportunities? Really, you know, I like to create fake names and really go into it. Use stock imagery so that you can try to connect with who this person might be. You're really giving a face to a name and a value to a person. And you want to look at what donors are looking like. So for example, for The Trevor Project, we have a lot of One-time, first-time donors. And we have a lot of people who come in, they give their first gift, and I'm trying to find where they're dropping off, right? What is causing that? So I maybe create a persona that is a one-time user that's not really convinced they want to give again, a one-time donor. They may be young, they may be like within our demographic, which is under 25, the youth that we serve with our crisis services and suicide prevention. Services. So you can get as granular as making a name and an age and a demographic and a location and what devices they're using. I think that's a big one. Is this person usually on their mobile? Are they usually on desktop? What channels do they typically like to look at? Twitter, you can get as granular. Email. Are they just looking at your website? So, you know, it should get as detailed as you can, but I would encourage people to get really creative with it. If the more details you're able to get, it's just a more clear picture of a donor that you're looking to target. Just make sure it's someone you actually want to target and not someone you're going to be— that wouldn't actually be coming to you. Like maybe Bill Gates isn't going to be coming to a nonprofit's website to donate, but you can look at what those specific donors might look like that are more realistic for your campaign.

Tony MartignettiOkay, right. You're basing it on what's realistic, not what your aspiration is.

Katie GreenYeah, to a degree. I mean, I think you can be aspirational, aspirational in some facets of what you're doing. I just think it has to be somewhat grounded in, you know, a realistic approach. We do get asked, I get aspirational myself when I'm creating donor personas when, you know, I am looking for major gifts. I am looking for people who are willing to process a $15,000 credit card charge and there are people out there that do that. So when I do my donor Personas, they may not be the number one target of my campaign, but I do want to consider what those people are interested in as well so that I can personalize content for them to the best of my ability.

Tony MartignettiOkay.

Valerie JohnsonYeah, the other thing to keep in mind is diversifying your donor base. So in looking at who's giving to Pathways to Housing right now, they're mostly middle-aged, college-educated white women who prefer Facebook and giving on a desktop, which is Fine, and that's definitely one category of people that you would want to be supporting you, but Philadelphia is an incredibly diverse city. So if those are the only people that we're getting to with our messaging, then we really need to think about diversifying our strategies to build new donor profiles for people who don't all look the same.

Tony MartignettiOkay, and then once you have a bunch of personas and profiles, I mean, it sounds like you could have 10 or 12 really different ones, different, yeah, different characteristics of people, different types of people that come to you. And like you said, Katie, even people who leave, you know, you want to capture them back. So, so once you have these, Valerie, then you're trying to communicate to them. But how do you, how do you turn your communications into targets to these personas?

Valerie JohnsonSo you really want to think about building content specifically for that persona. So you might be doing a campaign that you want to hit a couple of different personas with, but you're going to tailor that campaign specifically to each persona and deliver the message to a specific segment of that campaign. So if you're going to do a mailed campaign, you want to think about how you're putting together that letter and what you're writing into the letter and how you're addressing the donors for each of the different segments or each of the different personas that you've put together to really help craft a message and inspire them specifically to donate.

Tony MartignettiOkay, right. Like Katie, like you were saying, you know, yet, you know, what's important to them. But that stuff is— this is very amorphous to try to, you know, it's not just what do they give and how much do they give and what time of year do they give, you know. What's important to them? What do they value? This is, this is difficult stuff to suss out.

Valerie JohnsonYeah, one thing our co-presenter said this morning, Marcus, was that donors are smart and they're savvy. And with the advent of the internet and all of the various channels that you can communicate with people now, they know what they want and they know what they want to hear from you. And if they're not hearing from you what they want, they're going to go find someone else who's going to provide that information and communicate to them the way they want to be communicated with. So Fundraising and marketing for nonprofits right now looks very different than it did maybe 10, 15, 20 years ago, and donors know what they want now.

Tony MartignettiOkay, so it's worth your trying to suss out all this amorphous information as best you can. Okay, Katie, is there anything more you want to say about personas before we, we move on to being multichannel?

Katie GreenLet's go on to multichannel. I could talk user personas all day.

Tony MartignettiAll right, all right. Is there anything— I don't want to leave anything important out though for nonprofits. No, I

Katie Greenthink we've covered the main points.

Tony MartignettiOkay, what's important about— well, I think we all know why to be multichannel, but how to coordinate those messages? What's your thinking there?

Katie GreenYeah, I can jump in here. So I think what people often don't do is they don't coordinate messages cross-channel at the right time. That's what I've been seeing a lot with just my industry research. I mean, I'm always looking at what everybody's doing in the space because I want to be part of the best. But they say, they being what I've heard at multiple conferences, is that there's a rule of 7, right? So as a non-donor, let's say I'm scrolling through Facebook, I need to see an ask 7 times before I'm actually likely to give. So if you're seeing that ask 7 times on Facebook, that means it's 7 posts. That's kind of a lot. And that's going to have to be spaced out through a certain amount of days, weeks, months even. So if you're just increasing all the channels that you're presenting that message on, so let's say I'm seeing it on Facebook, I'm seeing it in my email, I'm seeing it on my Instagram, I'm getting a paid ad for it because I liked it on Facebook. Hmm. That's going to shorten the window of which I see 7 points of that call to action. So I'm going to be more likely to give if I'm seeing it in a wider spectrum on the digital space than I am in just one channel. So making sure that you're saying similar things, but that are custom to what the channel is providing. Like social media has, like paid ads have a certain amount of characters you can use. So making sure it's optimized for what channel you're using, but still with the common thread is really important for increasing your conversion rate.

Tony MartignettiOkay. Now it's a little clearer to me why I see so many ads for the pickpocket-proof slacks. I see them across all kinds of different channels. I'm not— I'm hardly on Facebook anymore, but I see them when I go to websites and I'm reading articles. And because one time, I don't know, I swear it was like 3 years ago, I was browsing through these like CIA-approved slacks with 14 pockets and it's all supposed to be pickpocket-proof or something, as you know, the $200 slacks or whatever they are, you know.

Katie GreenTrying to get you 7 times.

Tony MartignettiI've been seeing the ads ever since, yeah. And I don't know, I'm not even sure that if I bought them the ads would stop. Maybe—

Valerie JohnsonThey wouldn't.

Tony MartignettiIs it sophisticated enough? No, it's not, right? They would keep on, right? Because now your brother needs a pair or whatever. All

Valerie Johnsonright.

Katie GreenYep.

Tony MartignettiValerie, anything you want to, you want to explain about multichannel and how important it is to reinforce and be consistent?

Valerie JohnsonI think the biggest thing for me is if you're starting from scratch and you're really trying to develop content and put it in the right places, you really want to be thinking about who your audience is on those channels. So for LinkedIn, the messaging that you're putting out is going to look a lot different than what you're putting out on Facebook. Most people use Facebook recreationally and they use LinkedIn for professional relationships. So the type of information that someone is seeking on LinkedIn or more likely to respond to on LinkedIn is a lot different than what they're more likely to look for or respond to on Facebook. So for us, we make sure all of our job listings go up on LinkedIn and all of our industry-specific information goes up on LinkedIn just to kind of show our expertise in the area, but when we're posting to Facebook, we're talking more directly to people that we know are supporters of us and want to do tangible things to support us. So the messaging is different, even though the information is really the same.

Tony MartignettiOkay, okay. Again, yeah, consistent, but consistent, but, but different, maybe different format even. Okay.

Valerie JohnsonYeah.

Tony MartignettiI mean, there's, there's other formats, you know, content papers, white papers. Again, depending for the right, you know, for the right channel. Research. Do either of you use media working in, working through thought leadership in developing thought leadership in media, media relationships?

Valerie JohnsonA little bit.

Tony MartignettiYeah?

Valerie JohnsonYeah, so there's a local media outlet here in Philadelphia called Generosity, and they are focused on nonprofits and social enterprises and people who are making positive impact in Philadelphia. So they're super open to having folks guest post or write op-eds for them. So we've utilized that outlet a couple of times. Actually, just last week, our CEO wrote an article about the opportunity for kindness in the era of coronavirus. So it's something that she actually wrote to communicate to our staff members and let them know what our stance on, you know, moving forward was going to be. And we thought it was something that would be beneficial not just to our staff but to the community at large. So we passed it along to them, they posted it as an op-ed, and that gave us a little bit more bang for our buck for something that we had already written.

Tony MartignettiYeah, okay, okay. Katie, are you doing much with earned media?

Katie GreenI am not. The Trevor Project is, but Katie Green Is not doing that.

Tony MartignettiOkay,

Katie Greenokay. Our comms team handles that.

Tony MartignettiOkay, let's talk about some, some analytics. I mean, how do we know whether we're being successful and where we need to, where we need to tweak or pivot? Katie, can you get us started?

Katie GreenAbsolutely. So analytics is very hard for a lot of nonprofits because it's such a scientific Based skill set. And, you know, that's something that when I first came on to the Trevor Project is the first thing I implemented was our source coding protocol. It's so important to know where people are coming from that you can actually optimize. But we A/B tested and continue to A/B test absolutely everything. We do it through our website, we do it through email, we do it through our paid social, and To see how things work, I think really we just test absolutely everything. Things you think you know, you don't. And that's what I keep learning through testing is what you think works today won't work tomorrow. And we retest everything. A time of day test, for example, isn't gonna— for a send for email— isn't gonna be the same after daylight savings. It's not gonna be the same as the seasons change. And it's particularly not the same now that everybody is stuck at home. So, you know, there Testing and optimizing, really what you know is working, it just requires retesting, reoptimizing, and testing literally.

Tony MartignettiCould you, could you give some more examples besides time of day, examples of things you test?

Katie GreenOh, absolutely. So on our website we tested, we have a little call-out box with questions on our donate form. We tested the placement of that. Is it better to have it right up next to the form, underneath? Directly on top, so it's the first thing people see. So we test placement there. We test what photos we use a lot. Does a photo of somebody looking sad versus somebody looking more celebratory and happy? We test a lot of pride imagery because we serve LGBTQ youth. We want to see if pride imagery actually helps get our word out there. We test colors a lot because our brand color is orange, which can be very cautionary, but We see— you'd think that, oh, it's your brand color, of course everybody's going to always respond to it, but that's not really the case. Like sometimes they like our blues and our purples and our greens when it comes to CTA buttons. Gosh, I mean, I could tell you every test we've ever run, sender tests, using graphics versus photos on the website, you know, the size, the width, the height of our lightboxes, the width of our donation forms, the amount of buttons we have. It just— the list goes on and on.

Tony MartignettiI heard one that just made me think of just one small example of what— riffing off what you just said— was testing the text inside a button.

Katie GreenYeah.

Tony MartignettiInstead of just donate or like review or something, you know, be more explicit about what the action is that you're asking for instead of just a single word, a little more descriptive.

Katie GreenYeah, testing CTAs is something that we do a lot. Just to give people some ideas, I think one that can be really helpful when it comes to fundraising is seeing how your donors react to the word give, and the word support, and the word donate. So it's all the same thing. We're asking you to support our mission, to give to us, and to donate, but those 3 words have very different feelings when you're reading them on your screen. So that's one of the biggest tests. Okay. We ran. But yeah, I would recommend always testing the CTA when you have a new one, especially.

Tony MartignettiWas it, was it ActBlue that, or Change.org? I think maybe it was Change.org started calling it chip in. Could you chip in?

Katie GreenI think that's ActBlue. It sounds like classic ActBlue to me.

Tony MartignettiOkay. So Valerie, can you talk us through some metrics? You're the Director of Institutional Advancement, what, what numbers do you look for to decide how you're doing?

Valerie JohnsonWe look at a lot of things. So we're looking at the click-through rates on our emails and on our posts, who's actually reading to the bottom and clicking the links that we're providing. We're looking at how many people are interacting with things that we're posting on social media and whether they are enjoying it or not based on how many people are interacting with it. We do a lot of surveys too, so talking to our donors directly and asking them what kinds of things they want to see, what kinds of things they don't want to see. I know Katie is doing a lot more with metrics than we are, so this is my friendly reminder to smaller nonprofits where there is just one person trying to do all of this. You don't have to recreate the wheel. So you can look at an organization like the Trevor Project that does have the staff who can look at all of these things and do all of these testing and all of the metrics and see what's working best. And they say imitation is the sincerest form of flattery. So you can look at what they're doing and then borrow it. So for an organization like me that has a smaller staff, we're doing a little bit on our own, but we're also looking a lot at what other nonprofits are doing and assuming that they're taking the time to test things. And we're kind of, you know, copying what they're doing because it's obviously successful for them.

Tony MartignettiHow do you learn from them? Do you just create a relationship? Build a relationship and then ask what kind of metrics do you look at?

Valerie JohnsonSometimes, and sometimes it's as simple as going to the Trevor Project website's donate page and seeing where they place things and what they name their buttons and what giving levels they're putting up there. Because, you know, you're never gonna be exactly the same as another organization, so you definitely wanna take a look at who you're using as an example and use someone who's doing similar work or in a similar location to you. But at the end of the day, there's only so much you can learn through testing, and after that, gonna have to dive in and do something. So if you don't have time for the testing, you can do a quick search of what everybody in your industry is doing and kind of take it from there instead.

Tony MartignettiKatie, since everybody's stealing from Trevor Project, what— what I assume you knew Valerie was doing this.

Katie GreenI didn't, but it's such a compliment.

Valerie JohnsonIt's because you do a great job. That's why we're looking at you.

Katie GreenOh gosh.

Tony MartignettiWhat do you want to add about

Katie GreenMetrics. I think I just want to reiterate Valerie's point that there are so many nonprofits where one person is doing this. I'm the only person on the digital giving team. I'm the first person they've ever hired to do digital giving. I'm still a team member of one, but, you know, I do have the support of a very large marketing team that helps me with creating all of the tests that we do. And anyone can tweet me, email me, whatever. If like any nonprofit ever wants to connect, I'm always an open resource. But metrics are increasingly important, just critical to donors' content strategy. So

Tony Martignettisince you're offering yourself as a resource, do you want to share your email and/or your Twitter? You don't have to give your email if you don't want to.

Katie GreenYeah, maybe Twitter is probably the best way to reach me because I'm trying, I'm trying to learn how to tweet more. As a digital person, I feel like I need to do that. It's @KatieSueGreen, like one word. So it's K-A-T-I-E-S-U-E-G-R-E-E-N. Katie Sue Green. Green just like the color, no E at the end.

Tony MartignettiRight. Okay, okay, thank you. So Valerie, you want to, want to wrap us up? Some, some parting thoughts about content strategy?

Valerie JohnsonSure. Since I am kind of representing the smaller organization here, I just want to remind everybody that you You're doing everything that you can, and it's— everything that you're doing is important. So don't try to do everything at once. Really pick one thing to focus on and get to a point where you're doing that well and comfortably before you try to add more. Listening to a podcast like this or going to a presentation like the one that we did this morning is overwhelming in the number of things that you could be doing, and it makes you feel like you're not doing enough, but you are. And Just tackling those small hills one at a time is much, much easier than trying to climb the mountain.

Tony MartignettiThat's very gracious, very gracious advice. Thank you. Thanks very much. That was Valerie Johnson. That is Valerie Johnson, Director of Institutional Advancement at Pathways to Housing PA. And with her is Katie Green, Digital Giving Manager for Trevor Project. Thank you very much for sharing, each of you. Thanks so much. And thank you for being with Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio coverage of 20NTC. In 2 weeks, Trathen Heckman with his book Take Heart, Take Action. Next week, I'm working on it. If you missed any part of this week's show, I beseech you, find it at tonymartignetti.com. We're sponsored by Turn Two Communications. PR and content for nonprofits. Your story is their mission. turn-two.co. Our creative producer is Claire Meyerhoff. The show's social media is by Susan Chavez. Marc Silverman is our web guy, and this music is by Scott Stein. Thank you for that affirmation, Scotty. Be with me next week for Nonprofit Radio, Big Nonprofit Ideas for the Upstart. 95%. Go out and be great.

Nonprofit Radio

More Episodes from 2020 Nonprofit Technology Conference

View All
Michelle FrechetteAmanda GormanYvette ScorseChristopher WallaceTaylor ShanklinSerrie Fung
EP 509October 4, 2020

SEO For Your Fundraising Campaign & Rebrand Vs. Refresh

with Michelle Frechette, Amanda Gorman, Yvette Scorse, Christopher Wallace, Taylor Shanklin, and Serrie Fung

Dennis MillerLoree LipsteinTracy Shaw
EP 507September 20, 2020

Your Leadership Pipeline & True Consultant Love

with Dennis Miller, Loree Lipstein, and Tracy Shaw

Julia CampbellMisty McLaughlinJustin BirdsongKacey Crawford
EP 504August 31, 2020

Get Heard In A Time Of Info Fatigue & Digital Marketing Policies

with Julia Campbell, Misty McLaughlin, Justin Birdsong, and Kacey Crawford

1 / 6