Your Supercharged Board & Your Content Calendar





Your Supercharged Board
Dolph Goldenburg reveals his wisdom for revitalizing your board committees; making your board meetings effective; and keeping engagement civil. He’s the author of the book “Successful Nonprofits Build Supercharged Boards.”
My Guest
Your Content Calendar
What belongs in it? Who do you need to help create it? How do you get buy in? And how about resources to help you? Our can-do content calendar committee from the Nonprofit Technology Conference is Laura Norvig from ETR, James Porter at The END Fund and Kivi Leroux Miller, founder of Nonprofit Marketing Guide.
Here’s the transcript
Tony MartignettiHello and welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. I'm your aptly named host. Oh, I'm glad you're with me. I'd grow a faux set if I saw that you missed today's show. Your Supercharged Board. Dolph Goldenburg reveals his wisdom for keeping engagement civil, revitalizing your board committees, and making your board meetings effective. He's the author of the book Successful Nonprofits Build Supercharged Boards. And your content calendar. What belongs in it? Who do you need to help create it? How do you get the buy-in? And how about resources to help you? Our Can Do Content Calendar Committee from the Nonprofit Technology Conference is Laura Norvig from ETR, James Porter at the END Fund, and Kivi Leroux Miller, founder of Nonprofit Marketing Guide. Between those on Tony's Take Two, solitude. We're sponsored by Pursuant, full-service fundraising, data-driven and technology-enabled. You'll raise more money. Pursuant.com. And by WeBeSpelling. Super cool spelling bee fundraisers. WeBeSpelling.com. I'm glad that Dolph Goldenburg is with me. He is Managing Director at the Goldenburg Group. Before consulting, he was Executive Director of an AIDS service organization in Atlanta and an LGBT community center in Philadelphia. He has more than a decade of fundraising experience. Dolph's company is at goldenburggroup.com. Dolph, welcome.
Dolph GoldenburgThank you, Tony. It's good to be on.
Tony MartignettiAnd I have to give you a very, you know, I'm not trying to humble myself and, you know, be in your pocket right away, but I have to apologize because when I first introduced the segment, I called you Dolph Goldberg. But that is not correct. Your name is Dolph Goldenburg.
Dolph GoldenburgNo worries at all. It's a common shorthand for the name.
Tony MartignettiWell, okay, well, but inappropriate shorthand. You have— it's like calling me Martetti. You know, there is that syllable in the middle, so it's Dolph Goldenburg. All right. And you were just recently married, just last month.
Dolph GoldenburgI was, I was. After about 10 years together, my husband and I decided to make it legal, so we had a A very small wedding with just friends and family.
Tony MartignettiOutstanding. And that was up in New England, right?
Dolph GoldenburgUm, it actually was in deep, deep, deep South Georgia. Oh, where did I get New— oh, okay. Yeah, it's the Twin City, metropolis Twin City of Helena-McRae, Georgia.
Tony MartignettiOkay. I don't know where I got Northeast, uh, but New England, but you were exactly opposite, uh, small-town Georgia. Wonderful. Congratulations.
Dolph GoldenburgThank you.
Tony MartignettiAnd congratulations on this book. Why do we need a book on supercharging boards?
Dolph GoldenburgThat's a great question. I had been an executive director for about a dozen years, and what I found as an executive director was that both my work as an ED, but also the organization's mission, was always either supported or made more difficult because of the board. And what I found was that the time that I would invest in board development and the board would invest in its own development always paid strong rewards.
Tony MartignettiYou have an interesting personal journey as to how you came to write the book.
Dolph GoldenburgI do, actually. I had been at a housing aid service organization Gosh, for about almost 5 years or so and realized that I was starting to have a midlife crisis. And so, unlike most people that have a midlife crisis, I didn't have an affair. I didn't get a Corvette. But what I did do was I gave 10 months' notice at my job as an executive director, and I planned an 8-month-long sabbatical. And my plan really on that sabbatical was to think about what What I had done well in my career, what I had done poorly in my career, and then really kind of put all of that down in terms of my lessons learned around board development. And so through that, or during that sabbatical, I sort of traveled the world. I went to Vietnam and Cambodia for 2 months. I hiked around in Peru for a month. I hiked out west for a month. But between each of those trips, I would come back home and I would work on this book, which While it is very short, took about 5 or 6 months to write.
Tony MartignettiAnd it has 10 different areas of, topics of improvement for boards. We're only going to have time to touch on 3, maybe 4, depending on how we go. But, so the message is, you've got to buy the book for the full 10.
Dolph GoldenburgI love that message. Thank you.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Thank you. All right. You're being very gracious here. I messed up your name, I got your wedding location wrong. I can't imagine an interview starting worse, but you're being very kind and gracious. We'll get through it. It can only get much better now. Hopefully I have more of the facts correct.
Dolph GoldenburgYou know, I feel like the interview's going well, so thank you.
Tony MartignettiAll right, I do too, absolutely. All right, let's get started. Rules of engagement. You want to see more civility on boards.
Dolph GoldenburgYeah, and not just civility. Civility is really important, but boards have to sit down and say, what rules are we going to live by? These are not the governing rules. These are not the expectations that every board member should have, but they're really, how are we going to interact with each other? What behavior is okay and is not okay? And civility is a big part of that, but as some other examples, We have all seen the board member who is a naysayer. Whatever comes up, they try to shoot it down. And that's not only unproductive for the board, but it's also really unproductive for that individual board member. Because what ends up happening is every time they open their mouth, people sort of roll their eyes and they just tune the naysayer out.
Tony MartignettiYeah, so the person loses credibility. Right. But now how are we going to deal with this, uh, this gadfly, this naysayer?
Dolph GoldenburgWell, so I believe the first thing we do is we help the board develop its own rules of engagement. And so as an example, what would come out of that is, you know, being the naysayer is not okay. And once the board has generally come to alignment on that— note, I did not say consensus, but actually come to alignment— because, you know, if 90% of the board feels that way, That's probably what it should be. So, you know, so once the board has come to an alignment on, for example, naysaying is not okay, or, you know, or what happens in the meeting stays in the meeting, those types of things, then when people move beyond that and kind of step outside of the rules of engagement, then the board chair or the governance chair can have a conversation with that person and really start to bring them back into alignment on the rules of engagement. Okay.
Tony MartignettiOkay. And of course, the naysayers are going to naysay that rule. So your point about alignment, not 100% consensus.
Dolph GoldenburgRight. Right. Okay.
Tony MartignettiWe want to be prepared for the naysayers to naysay the naysaying rule, right?
Dolph GoldenburgYes. I love the way you said that.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Well, I spit it out fast. All right. I'll tell you what. Let's take our— we'll go out a little early for a break. And Dolph, of course, you and I are going to keep talking about the supercharged board revitalizing committees and making meetings effective, so stay with us.
AnnouncerYou're tuned to Nonprofit Radio. Tony Martignetti also hosts a podcast for the Chronicle of Philanthropy. Fundraising Fundamentals is a quick, 10-minute burst of fundraising insights published once a month. Tony's guests are experts in crowdfunding, mobile giving, event fundraising, direct mail and donor cultivation. Really, all the fundraising issues that make you wonder, am I doing this right? Is there a better way? There is. Find the Fundraising Fundamentals archive at tonymartignetti.com. That's M-A-R-T-I-G-N-E-T-T-I. Remember, there's a G before the N. Thousands of listeners have subscribed on iTunes. You can also learn more at the Chronicle website, philanthropy.com. Fundraising Fundamentals, the better way.
Tony MartignettiWelcome back to Big Nonprofit Ideas for the Other 95%. 5%. Dolph, let's hit a few more of these rules of engagement. I don't want this to sound like a battlefield plan or something, but in fact, your first one is the civility rule. So the board meetings should not be a battlefield.
Dolph GoldenburgRight.
Tony MartignettiWorking through committees. We're going to talk a little about revitalizing them shortly, but you've got to work through the structure.
Dolph GoldenburgRight, right. So, so, uh, one of the rules of engagements that boards often come up with is if someone has a great idea, the place to bring that is to the appropriate committee, not to the full board. And then you really let the committee deliberate on that idea, develop a recommendation if it's appropriate, and bring that to the full board.
Tony MartignettiBecause really the full board just doesn't have time to deal with all the, the good ideas that are percolating up. Is that it?
Dolph GoldenburgAbsolutely. The work of a board is done in its committees. And one of the things that I always kind of say, and this is sort of the committee math, if you will, is that if you have got 5 committees that meet between every board meeting for just 90 minutes, what that means is that committee deliberation is 7 hours. Board meetings can't be 7 hours long, but when you have 5 committees, each meeting for 90 minutes, you get more deliberation and you get better recommendations and decisions coming to the board.
Tony MartignettiThere also is an expectation that board members will prepare for committee and full board meetings.
Dolph GoldenburgAbsolutely. You know, nothing is more demoralizing both to senior staff and board leadership than for board members to show up having already received the meeting packet but not having read the reports or reviewed the financials, because then really what happens is the committee reports are just reading what they've already written. What's more, as part of that expectation, that also means there's an expectation on the staff, and that expectation is that meeting packets go out with enough lead time that board members can actually review them.
Tony MartignettiI swear I've been to board meetings where there are members opening their packets for the first time and, you know, they're cramming 10 minutes before the board meeting is about to be called to order.
Dolph GoldenburgRight. And, you know, what those board members often don't realize is that it is painfully obvious in the meeting who read the meeting minutes and the meeting packet and who did not read the meeting packet.
Tony MartignettiIt is. It comes out. You're going to be, you're going to be You're going to be exposed. You might not be called out, but it's going to be obvious.
Dolph GoldenburgRight.
Tony MartignettiAll right. Confidentiality, right? We've got to keep the organization's promises close to us.
Dolph GoldenburgRight. And it's not just confidentiality within, like in terms of inside the organization. So obviously, what is said in the board meeting does not go outside of the organization, but it also does not go to other staff. So, you know, any staff member not present in the board meeting should also not be privy to the deliberations.
Tony MartignettiAnd one more that you have, rules of engagement, whether you have authority to represent the organization. Talk about that one.
Dolph GoldenburgRight. So, you know, so oftentimes there are board members— I should not say oftentimes. Sometimes there are board members who feel that they have the authority to speak on behalf of the organization. Every now and then, in fact, when I started one job as an executive director, someone had actually signed a contract on behalf of the organization. They were not a board member. They did not have the authority to do so, and we had to find a way to back out of that contract. You know, so they also do not have the authority to individually sign a contract unless the board has voted and given them that authority.
Tony MartignettiNow, all these rules should be adopted by the board, right? That's what you were saying earlier.
Dolph GoldenburgRight, right. And I also think that the board should sit down and see and have a discussion and see if there's other rules of engagement that are appropriate for them. And again, to me, these are different from expectations. Expectations are attendance, personal giving. Expectations are a little bit higher level than rules of engagement.
Tony MartignettiRight. And that's another part of your book, expectations. I feel like a lot of guests have covered those, but I've never seen— we haven't talked about rules of engagement and some of these that you're talking about. Like the civility and the naysaying the naysayers. We haven't covered those before, so I like this whole area of the book.
Dolph GoldenburgAnd if I can say, the civility is really a very positive way of saying no bomb throwers. Kind of like naysayers, we've all seen bomb throwers in board meetings, and it's not effective for the board.
Tony MartignettiYou have any— Any bad stories you want to tell?
Dolph GoldenburgOh gosh, you know, I've only been permanent executive director at 2 organizations, so I don't want to get anybody in trouble by telling that story, by telling a story. But I will share with you that I have seen one board where at every single meeting, you know, this person was completely and totally negative, not just being a naysayer, but completely and totally negative about everything. And, you know, was literally throwing, you know, little mini bombs into the meeting to kind of set up disagreements between other board members, and then would just sit back and watch them fight it out.
Tony MartignettiOh, for goodness' sake.
Dolph GoldenburgAnd obviously that's someone who we had to move off of the board.
Tony MartignettiYeah, I should say. Right, right. Totally negative influence. Yeah. Okay. Let's go to our committee structure, revitalizing committees. Why don't you open this one up? How do you want to start with Sure.
Dolph GoldenburgYou know, one of the things that I'd said before is that, you know, really an effective board, a supercharged board, does the vast majority of its work through committees. Committees will always have a larger bandwidth and a deeper bench of expertise to deliberate on strategic issues that are facing an organization. As part of that, one of the things that I recommend is that every Committee have an annual plan. So, you know, so they know what they're responsible for that year. Ideally, they'll have 3 to 4 goals for the year, but then they'll also say, okay, if we're going to have, you know, 6 meetings every other month, meeting 1, we want to cover X. Meeting 2, we want to cover something else. Meeting 3— so that way they are always moving the ball forward on these projects. But they're also making sure that what they do is in alignment with the strategic plan And the organizational goals.
Tony MartignettiYou said it earlier, the work of the board is done through the committees.
Dolph GoldenburgRight.
Tony MartignettiOkay. So we need our committees to be effective and revitalized, as you say in the book. Let's talk through some of the essential committees, just in case people are not familiar with what the work of the executive committee is.
Dolph GoldenburgSo, you know, so oftentimes, and let me say that some organizations have just an executive committee. Some organizations have just a governance committee and some have both. And depending on what the structure is, sometimes there's some overlap between those 2 committees. But typically what the executive committee does is it sets the agenda for board meetings. It deliberates or makes decisions on behalf of the board between meetings when absolutely necessary. That should not happen on a regular basis. And then if there's not a governance committee, oftentimes the executive committee is also responsible for enforcing expectations, you know, ensuring that committees are meeting in a timely manner, ensuring that conflicts of interest are disclosed and deliberated and voted on by the full board. But if there is a governance committee, that typically goes to the governance committee.
Tony MartignettiNow, just like the committees are setting a plan for the year, is the executive committee setting a A board plan for the year?
Dolph GoldenburgAbsolutely. Ideally, in its first month of the year, the new executive committee wants to sit down and think about what the strategic plan's goals are for the year, determine which committees can help drive those goals forward, and then work with those committees as they develop their annual plan as well. And I was going to say also, As part of that, and this is going to bleed over a little bit to making meetings effective, the executive committee also needs to figure out what the organization's calendar is, including the board calendar, and make sure that that is in the plan as well.
Tony MartignettiAll the committee chairs sit on the executive committee, right?
Dolph GoldenburgAnd it depends. For some organizations, every committee chair sits on the executive committee. In other organizations, it's just the officers. And, you know, again, to a great extent, it probably depends whether there's a separate governance committee or not.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Okay. So, meaning if you have a separate governance committee, then what, you don't need all the committee chairs on the board, on the executive committee?
Dolph GoldenburgSo, you know, so if you've got a separate governance committee, then you might actually want all of the committee chairs on your executive committee. Because then what they're doing is they're setting the agenda, and they're doing sort of like very high-level board work. But if there's not a governance committee, and the executive committee is also responsible for enforcing expectations, ensuring disclosure of conflicts of interest, you know, those legal obligations that every board needs to be taking care of, you probably want a smaller group of people working on that.
Tony MartignettiAh, okay. So, strike 3 for me. It's a good thing I'm the host of this show, because I misread that one too. Okay. So, all right. Yeah, it's a good thing I'm in charge of the show. All right, let's see what else. Another committee, Finance. Now, is Finance, is this the same as the Investment Committee? On a lot of boards it's called Investment?
Dolph GoldenburgYeah, yeah, so a lot of boards call the Finance Committee the Finance and Investment Committee. Some boards call it the Finance and Audit Committee. But typically, especially in the smaller organizations, the finance committee ends up being responsible for the audit, for investments, and everything that falls underneath it.
Tony MartignettiOkay. And of course, a lot more detail in the book. You just got to get the book. I mean, for goodness' sake. Successful Nonprofits Build Supercharged Boards. Now, the committees that we have, they're all supposed to be meeting in advance of full board meetings, right? I think you recommend a couple weeks before.
Dolph GoldenburgRight, right. So in the ideal world, between every board meeting, all of the committees meet as well, because every committee is in some way responsible for goals in the strategic plan, and it's helping to drive that forward. So if the committees are not doing their work between board meetings, the board meetings are just honestly, you know, do not move the organization forward as much.
Tony MartignettiAll right. Let's talk about the fundraising or development committee. What's your advice there?
Dolph GoldenburgSo in terms of the fundraising committee, I think it is absolutely critical that— and again, this is often for small and medium-sized organizations that either have limited or no fundraising staff. It is absolutely critical that they start their year looking at actual fundraising strategies from the prior year, Determining what was effective, what is an organization— what is it as a committee in an organization they want to do again in the coming year. And, you know, and I also think it is essential that the fundraising committee have a voice in what the board's give-get is going to be. They don't ultimately have the decision, but they should have a voice in that.
Tony MartignettiAnd that goes over to one of the expectations of board members.
Dolph GoldenburgRight. Okay.
Tony MartignettiNow each of these committees needs to have a staff liaison. This is going to get a little staff intensive.
Dolph GoldenburgI am. I am all about every committee should have a staff liaison. And really the role of that staff person is not to run the committee, but it is to help keep the committee on track. And so as an example, the staff liaison would help the chair in putting together an agenda, and sometimes that's a friendly reminder. Sometimes it's being pleasantly persistent, which is a nice way to say kind of nag. But, you know, but to make sure that the chair puts together an agenda and that it goes out. To arrange all logistics for the meeting. So is a room reserved? You know, if you normally have iced tea at your meetings, is there iced tea there? To make sure that The agenda is sent to all of the committee members before the meeting along with any other information that they're supposed to review. And then finally, in the ideal world, your staff liaison also takes minutes at the meeting and then sends those to the chair of the committee to review and approve before they get sent out.
Tony MartignettiWhat about the executive committee? Is the CEO or executive director— are they the staff liaison to the executive committee?
Dolph GoldenburgSo in really small nonprofits, you know, so organizations that might only have 2 or 3 staff members, yeah, then absolutely the executive director ends up serving as the staff liaison. In a medium-sized organization where the CEO or executive director has an executive assistant themselves, they might task the executive assistant with that.
Tony MartignettiOkay. All right, that's the— Well, we should touch on that there might be program committees also, based on all your programmatic work.
Dolph GoldenburgRight. And the tough thing with program committees, especially when the organization has staff, is to ensure that the program committees are operating at a strategic level and not an operational level, and to make sure that The committee really understands what their role is in that respect. And so an example that I often give is whether a program operates from 7:30 to 3:30 or 8:00 to 4:00 is probably a staff decision, whereas whether or not a program measures its outcomes is a strategic decision.
Tony MartignettiOkay, right. We don't want our board Meddling in the day-to-day operations, hiring and supplies and mundane things like that that are taking away from the board's much higher and much more strategic purpose.
Dolph GoldenburgRight.
Tony MartignettiOkay. All right, let's look at effective meetings. Now you talked about the agendas, the importance of agendas. Anything more you want to say about About how important those are?
Dolph GoldenburgOh, absolutely. So to me, the real point of putting together an agenda is not just to tell everyone that's going to be in the meeting what will happen at the meeting, but it also forces— the act of putting together an agenda forces the person leading the meeting to really think through what their goals are for that meeting and to make sure that what happens in the meeting supports those goals.
Tony MartignettiI like your suggestion of putting time limits on each agenda item. I do that when I— for the few meetings that I conduct. Usually I'm sitting in them, but I'm not leading them. But when I do, I like to put the time limits so everybody sees it in black and white. And I don't know how you feel about this. I appoint a timekeeper. So it's somebody different than me. I'm paying attention to the substance of the meeting. And the flow, but not the exact timing.
Dolph GoldenburgAbsolutely. I always believe there should be a timekeeper. In the ideal world, it's someone different from the person running the meeting. But the other thing on time, and this is something that I'm really adamant about, especially when there's a call-in option or if it's an entire teleconference meeting, is the meeting has to start on time. So, you know, so even if you don't have a quorum, well, you go ahead and you get started. When we delay the start of a meeting, what we're really doing is we're punishing the people that showed up on time and we're rewarding the people who did not show up on time.
Tony MartignettiWhat can we do without a quorum though?
Dolph GoldenburgWell, so there are several things you can do. Like, obviously you can't take votes, but you can start to have some of those strategic discussions So anything that is a report out or just a strategic discussion, you can still do without a quorum. You can't take any votes without a quorum, but you can have those discussions.
Tony MartignettiOkay. And I also think that from day one, your first meeting, you tell people it's going to start on time, and then you actually do start on time. Right. And the latecomers are going to get the message from meetings Right.
Dolph GoldenburgAnd I'll also share with you, especially again when there's a call-in option or if the meeting is entirely by phone, you know, I am all about the meeting starts on time, but also latecomers, you hear the ding, but we don't stop the meeting to reintroduce you, to tell you who is present, to tell you what we have already done, because otherwise we'll interrupt the meeting 3 or 4 times. So the way I tend to, when I run those meetings, the way I tend to ask people calling into phone conferences late, is to wait until they have something to say in a conversation, and then they introduce themselves. And so, for example, they would say, this is Dolph, and I want to add, and then they would essentially say their comment.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Okay. We just have a minute before we have to wrap it up, and let's leave people with the importance of minutes in our minute.
Dolph GoldenburgI'm sorry, the—
Tony MartignettiThe importance of the minutes, the committee and the board minutes.
Dolph GoldenburgYou know, so the minutes are the official record of what the committee has done, as well as what the board has done. And, you know, in the ideal world, someone from the outside should be able to read those minutes and have a good sense of the official action of the organization, as well as its goals Outstanding.
Tony MartignettiWe're going to leave it there, Dolph.
Dolph GoldenburgThank you, Tony.
Tony MartignettiMy pleasure. The book is Successful Nonprofits Build Supercharged Boards. Get the book. There's so much more in it than we could cover here on Nonprofit Radio. I thank you very much.
Dolph GoldenburgThank you.
Tony MartignettiYour content calendar coming up. First, Pursuant, You know who these people are. They have developed tools that help small and mid-sized nonprofits raise the money, raise the money that you need to raise, like Prospector and Velocity. I talk about these time after time because they're helpful and they're perfect for our audience. Even the Velocity tool, which was developed for their internal consultants, Pursuant consultants, running campaigns for their clients. Well, you can get the tool without the consultant. That one is Velocity. Prospector, the one that helps you manage time against goal, full dashboard keeping you on task day after day, week after week toward that campaign goal. Check out these tools at Pursuant.com. Webee Spelling, spelling bees for nonprofit fundraising. This is not the spelling bee you grew up with, probably, because they bring in stand-up comedy, there's dance, there's booze, there's live music, and somewhere in there they squeeze in a spelling bee and fundraising. And not just fundraising that night, but fundraising in advance. So it's— I love this because it's just an unusual fundraising model. I haven't seen spelling bees for fundraising. I got knocked out of a spelling bee once on the word lettuce. Can you believe it? Lettuce. Because in spelling bees, I don't know if they're this formal, but the ones I was in, you couldn't make a mistake. And I said L-U-E-T-T-U-C-E, but it was too late. I had made the mistake. You're out. Out on the word lettuce. That's Killed me. And the winner of that spelling bee won on aeronautics. I could have had the whole thing, but I choked on lettuce. Ever since then, I've only eaten kale. All right, check them out, webespelling.com, and bee is B-E-E. Now, time for Tony's Take Two. Solitude. This is important for you because you work in a giving profession. You're— even if you're back office, you know that your office is giving, your organization is giving, it's saving lives, it's changing the world. This is draining, exhausting work, and you have to take time for yourself. So I strongly suggest, and I hope you did this summer or you will as the summer comes to a close, get time alone. Yeah. Unconnected. No phones, no texts, no email. Disconnected. No Instagram, no Snapchat. Get away. And I urge you a little, a little jovially in my video this week. It is way beyond typical weekly videos. This one even has a cast and crew. So you need to check out my solitude video. Yeah. Solitude with a Cast at tonymartignetti.com. And that is Tony's Take Two. Live listener love. Maybe we'll do it a little concisely this time. Live love going out to everybody who's listening now at this moment. You know who you are, you know where you are. The live love goes out. It goes out every single week, whether we're live or we're pre-recorded. The live love goes out. What follows that? It's the podcast Pleasantries. I am so grateful for all the tens of thousands— tens, 10,000, over 10,000, not quite tens of thousands, but the over 10,000 listeners listening in that time shift, whatever device, whatever time, whatever activity you are engaged in. Pleasantries to you, and likewise affections to our AM and FM affiliate listeners throughout the country. From upstate New York and outside Philadelphia in Lancaster County to Washington and Oregon and California and points in between. Affections to our affiliate listeners on the AM and FM stations. Here's a panel from NTC and we talked about your content calendar. Welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio coverage of 16 NTC. The Nonprofit Technology Conference. We're in San Jose, California at the convention center, and this is also part of NTC Conversations. My guests now are Laura Norvig, James Porter, and Kivi Leroux Miller. We're going to meet them very shortly. First, I have to shout out the NTEN— the NTC swag item for this interview is popcorn from Microsoft. It's Microsoft popcorn, and I have it for you. Thank you. I've heard from our production assistant, Anna— Hannah, who's excellent, that this is very good popcorn. It's great. We're going to add this to the swag pile carefully, of course, because I don't want it disseminated across the pile and making everything oily. But I will take a couple pieces for myself. Microsoft popcorn. Okay. Seated quietly. Closest to me is Laura Norvig. She is a digital media strategist at ETR. James Porter is Associate Director for External Relations at the END Fund. And Kivi Leroux Miller is a founder, the founder of the Nonprofit Marketing Guide, which is at nonprofitmarketingguide.com. Laura, James, Kivi, welcome. Thank you.
Kivi Leroux MillerThank you, Tony. Thank you.
Tony MartignettiKivi, welcome back.
Kivi Leroux MillerAbsolutely. Good to be here.
Tony MartignettiContent calendars and you, creating communications harmony. That is your seminar topic. Let's start in the middle, James. What do you think nonprofits are not getting quite right, could do better about content calendars? Or maybe it's even just having one, I don't know.
James PorterRight, yeah, well, it starts off with just having one. I think a lot of the problems stem from, first of all, not knowing what you want or what you need. There are a lot of tools out there, and so something that I wanted to get across was that you can try things, and if they don't work, that's okay. But I think one of the biggest problems is just not realizing what you need and what you want. And if you Do you need something for more long-term planning? Do you need something for day-to-day project management? Do you need a tool that's going to be everything, or do you just need to fill in gaps with some of your existing tools? There's a whole host of other problems, but I think step one is just really trying to figure out what you want and what your organization needs are.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Laura, anything you want to add at this overview point?
Laura NorvigWell, I know I think sometimes people struggle with, as James said, trying to make your calendar maybe do too much. And you want to keep it simple. One of the other things people experience is getting people to actually use the calendar. So keeping it simple can help.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Okay. Kivi, anything to get us started, kick us off?
Kivi Leroux MillerI think people know they need to plan, but then they don't have time to plan. And so they run around and And don't feel strategic, feel too busy, feel like there are too many priorities, but then they don't give themselves a chance to stop and think. And the editorial calendar really is a way to stop and think and be more strategic.
Tony MartignettiOkay. And the editorial calendar is the same, that's our content calendar, right? Same thing. Okay. Okay. All right. So let's, let's, let's get started with what should be in one. I don't know, Kivi, you want to kick us off? What, some ideas of what should be in your content calendar?
Kivi Leroux MillerSo in order for it to be an editorial calendar, there are 3 pieces. One is the communications channels you're sending out your content in. The second piece is the timing behind that, when things are going out. And the third piece is the messaging, what you're actually talking about. So it's what you're talking about, when you're talking about it, and in which communications channels. You have to have those 3 things, or in my mind, it's not an editorial calendar.
Tony MartignettiOkay. James, you're doing a lot of nodding.
James PorterYeah, I would also add to that, that it's important to also have who is responsible and who's the driver for these things, and for our content calendar anyway, because if you have a lot of people using it, you need to know who to go to to ask questions about that item, who's going to be in charge of posting it. So I think it's also important to have that. And then I also would add that Making sure somewhere, maybe it's not in your exact tool, but we like to put it in our tool, is to also include your audience so that you know for each item in your editorial calendar who the audience is going to be.
Tony MartignettiThat's the who, right? Yeah. Who the message is, that particular message is for. Yeah.
James PorterBut to be very specific about it. And so we, you can even do it, split it out by channels so that if you have different audiences on different channels, but the, the, for For me, it's very important to be specific about the audience.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Okay. Laura, anything you'd like to add about what belongs in our calendar?
Laura NorvigI think those are pretty much the basics, and then we sometimes layer on top the pushing out to social, and so you could use your calendar as a tool to track. So again, the channels, but yeah, tracking them, Twitter and Facebook. As well as a blog post or newsletter.
Tony MartignettiOkay, okay, very good. What— yeah, so we're developing a calendar that's got each message or each campaign. I mean, does it have— it has our campaigns and then it also has messages within the campaign? Is it that granular?
Laura NorvigI think that's going to depend on your organization. And you know, whether that's the way you message is through a long campaign. And that's one of the things Kivi talked about was the long-term planning. You can stretch the campaign out over time, but that's not going to fit all orgs, I don't think.
Tony MartignettiYeah. Okay.
James PorterYeah. And I would just add that for us, it does include every message. So for example, we had a campaign around Giving Tuesday that was a video campaign, and we had a different video being pushed out every day. And so each one of those messages was individually posted on the editorial calendar along with what channel they were being pushed out through.
Tony MartignettiEvery day for how long? How long before Giving Tuesday did you start?
James PorterThere were 5 videos, and then the whole campaign we started— you got to tease it, let people know things are coming. So yeah, it was about a week in total for the campaign.
Tony MartignettiOkay. All right. Anything else you want to say about what belongs? That covers it? Okay. I like the idea of making sure somebody's responsible for each item, right? You've got to know who to talk to. Without responsibility, this calendar is not going to get accomplished.
Laura NorvigYeah, we actually go to the level of kind of the process planning, so not only who's maybe writing a blog post, who's going to edit it, who's going to copy edit it, who's going to post it, who, you know. So down to the core.
Kivi Leroux MillerIn our session, there were a lot of nonprofits that only had one person in their communications department, however. So in that kind of situation, you know, you don't need to write your name on every single box, right?
Tony MartignettiWell, that could be a message for the CEO. That's right. Exactly. That, look at all this. My name is next to all this. How do you expect me to achieve this? All right. Who is involved in adopting this calendar? Because we need to make sure that the organization is going to accept it, that there's going to be buy-in, but they need to be a part of the process. I would think that makes it a lot easier to have them accept it. So, Kivi, let's start with you. How do we start to get this thing— well, at what stage do we bring others in?
Kivi Leroux MillerRight. So I think it is going to vary from organization to organization, and in the session we did talk We talk a lot about getting buy-in from program staff because they're often the source of the content. That's where the really good stories come from. And getting their buy-in as content creators, really seeing themselves as communicators, is really important. But then it's also important to get the executive team involved because they're the ones that really need to set the strategy for the messaging. And lots of times there's a lot of conflicting priorities, too many priorities, too much going Really a lot of mixed messaging. And in those situations, it's really up to the management team to provide some direction.
Tony MartignettiYeah.
Kivi Leroux MillerBut, you know, those are oftentimes for communications directors relationships that have to be built over time. And so I always urge a communications department to just do it, do it themselves, and do it to manage their own workload. And then hopefully over time, you're really making it a much more organization-wide tool.
Tony MartignettiOkay. How does it work with Within your organizations, getting the organizational buy-in. Yeah.
James PorterGo ahead, James. Yeah, I would just say that I think you can get people's opinions, but it really matters the most of the people who are going to be using it the most. On the day-to-day, those people have to be the most comfortable with it and really be the most okay with it. So yeah, it is important to get buy-in from other people, but it can also be a problem when you have an existing tool that is there already, and you have new staff coming in, and the new staff say, okay, this tool doesn't actually work for me. So something that I mentioned in the session that I thought was important was that to do periodic check-ins, and maybe every 6 months you kind of a gut check and ask the staff who are using the tool, is this tool still working for us? Do we need to add anything to it? Do we need to consider changing it? Because Just because you're using it doesn't mean it's working. So I think it is also important to have kind of periodic check-ins to make sure that it's doing what you need it to do.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Laura, how's it working in your org?
Laura NorvigWell, that, yeah, that's one of the things we talked about in the session was not being afraid to change your tool if it's just not working. And sometimes that's a little hard to do. As I was saying, we work in an org where SharePoint is kind of designated by IT, but it really was working for us. So I did have a small enough content team that we just kind of went rogue and we're using our own solution with Trello.
Tony MartignettiTrello? Oh, yeah, just using Trello. All right.
Laura NorvigYeah.
Tony MartignettiAny other online resources that you want to share for creation of your editorial calendar?
James PorterI mean, I'm a Trello fan myself. I've also used Basecamp before.
Tony MartignettiBasecamp?
James PorterYeah, Basecamp. Yeah, Basecamp has been useful. And something I mentioned in session 2 was that I thought it was useful to, for me anyway, to have in one place both a project management software and a content calendaring, which Trello can do as well to certain degrees, you know. Sure. But it starts getting messy when you have lots of systems and lots of tools. So the more you can integrate things or just have one tool that can do most There's no one tool that can do all. But, uh, so that's why I liked Basecamp for having the project management and then also a more robust calendaring.
Laura NorvigI've seen a lot of organizations use Google Calendars very successfully because you can layer them, which you can do with SharePoint too, but there can be pain points. Layer them?
Tony MartignettiHow do you mean?
Laura NorvigSo you could have separate calendars, but then you can have a view where they're rolled up and you can see all of the calendars. together. So maybe you have, you know, one of your silos, if you have a siloed organization, development or something, and maybe program staff, and they're each working on their own calendar with either ideas or posts they're actually writing. And then the editorial staff can see them both together, get a bigger picture.
Tony MartignettiOkay. See all the conflict points. Right.
Laura NorvigSee, do you have too much content, too little?
Tony MartignettiYeah. Okay. All right. Where else should we go with our content calendar? You know, we have a good another 10 minutes or so together. What else should we be talking about?
Laura NorvigWell, I definitely think in this session the buy-in was still a big issue. I don't know, Kivi, what did you think?
Tony MartignettiLike audience members were having trouble with having— getting buy-in? Yeah. What?
Kivi Leroux MillerI think that was a big one as well as the too many priorities and not enough So, you know, I really encourage people to just do it themselves. If they're not getting direction on what the limited number of messages should be or what the strategy really is, I say go ahead and you decide as the communications director. And believe me, you'll get feedback if you do something they didn't like. Yeah. But it's better to go ahead and provide some of that internal leadership from sort of managing from the middle than to keep kind of floundering.
James PorterYeah, and I think it also can be very tempting to say, okay, we have this editorial calendar, and that's our strategy, but it's, it's not. Having an editorial calendar isn't a strategy in and of itself. So we did talk about long-term planning and needing that strategy. So the editorial calendar needs to be informed by strategy, but I think you can fall into the trap that you have the editorial calendar, you've put everything on it, but then you forget about the strategies. Okay, so then you go over and you do the strategy, and it doesn't match with your editorial calendar. So I think that was a problem that came up in that those 2 things, planning and strategy, aren't always hand in hand.
Kivi Leroux MillerI would also just add that there was a fair amount of angst in the room about people feeling like planning then resulted in this rigid system that they couldn't then produce any timely content within. Oh. And so, you know, what I always tell people is, you know, practice the rule of thirds. So a third of the calendar should be original curated content. Another third is you repurposing your original and curated content. And then you leave a third of your calendar open because you know stuff is going to come up. You may not know what it is, but something's going to come up. So don't overplan, but make sure you do have strategy built into that original content in that third and in the repurposed content in that second third.
Tony MartignettiOkay.
James PorterYeah, I think that's really important. So I used to work for the International Rescue Committee, and they deal with man-made and nature-made disasters. And so you always needed to have that flexibility in your calendar. So even if it was a big women's-themed campaign in the spring that you have been planning for 6 months, you need to be able to have a little bit of room within that messaging to be flexible if a tsunami happens or an earthquake happens or, you know, there's famine somewhere. You need to be able to quickly pivot to needs that you need to react to right away without jeopardizing And a good content calendar, as Kivi said, will leave room for those things.
AnnouncerLike what you're hearing on Nonprofit Radio? Tony's got more. On YouTube, you'll find clips from his stand-up comedy, TV spots, and exclusive interviews. Catch guests like Seth Godin, Craig Newmark, the founder of Craigslist, Marc Ecko of Ecko Enterprises, Charles Berman, the founder of the ETR, Best from donorschoose.org, Aria Finger of dosomething.org, and Naomi Levine from New York University's Heiman Center on Philanthropy. Tony tweets too. He finds the best content from the most knowledgeable and interesting people in and around nonprofits to share on his stream. If you have valuable info, he wants to retweet you. During the show, you can join the conversation on Twitter using hashtag nonprofit radio. Twitter is an easy. way to reach Tony. He's @TonyMartignetti, M-A-R-T-I-G-N-E-T-T-I. Remember, there's a G before the N. He hosts a podcast for the Chronicle of Philanthropy. Fundraising Fundamentals is a short monthly show devoted to getting you over your fundraising hurdles. Just like Nonprofit Radio, Tony talks to leading thinkers, experts, and cool people with great ideas. As one fan said, Tony picks their brains and I don't have to leave my office. Fundraising Fundamentals was recently dubbed the most helpful nonprofit podcast you have ever heard. You can also join the conversation on Facebook where you can ask questions before or after the show. The guests are there too. Get insider show alerts by email. Tony tells you who's on each week and always includes links so that you can contact guests directly. To sign up, visit the Facebook page or tonymartignetti.com.
Cristine CroninI'm Cristine Cronin, president of NYCharities.org. You're listening to Tony Martignetti, Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%.
Tony MartignettiHow do you deal with the case where you've got your calendar and the organization is not respecting it? I don't know, is this the buy-in? But other teams are saying, no, no, I need this now. Or something comes up from above, comes down from above, that is now impinging on your ability to keep up with your own calendar. You know, but you respected my calendar when I showed it to you 6 months ago, but now you're ignoring it for this other administrative thing, or for this program problem, or this fundraising problem. But what— you're dissing my calendar. What do we do? Well, I think you have to be able to say, Stop dissing my— stop beating up my calendar.
James PorterWhat do we do, Laura? What do we do?
Laura NorvigWell, I think one of the things we talked about was showing people the process of what it really takes to roll out communications, to kind of push back on that last-minute-itis, because there is a process and it needs to be followed. So unless it's It's an emergency coming directly from the CEO, you know, it's like, step off.
Tony MartignettiI have other— I can't make that a priority now. We can talk later.
Laura NorvigI mean, it's a process of education, you know, so you've got to make yourself heard.
James PorterYeah, I would agree with that. I think the more outside players can understand how much time something takes, how much time it takes to post a blog, Or to edit a photo or something that they— the content calendar maybe doesn't do a great job of articulating that, like how much lead time you need to get X product up. No, I'm sure it doesn't. So it might be very tempting to say, oh, well, you've got this big, you know, 4-day hole between item 1 and item 2. Let me put something between those 2. No, I need those 4 days to get item 2 done. So I think the education You have to be able to say, no, I need the 4 days. I cannot do that, otherwise item 2 will not get done. So I think content calendars are not good at that. So that's where the education piece comes in.
Laura NorvigAnd James, you also talked about reinforcing it in face-to-face meetings. So if you have like a regular staff meeting where you can very quickly go over the calendar, then it's, it's going to start to become more clear.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Make it public often.
James PorterOh yeah. And we go over So we have a communications meeting once a week, and as part of that meeting, we review the content calendar with somebody from our program staff as well so that they're aware of what's going on.
Kivi Leroux MillerYou know, sometimes you do need to check what's in the plan, right?
James PorterYeah, you do.
Kivi Leroux MillerSo I think in those situations, you just need to be very clear in articulating the trade-off. So if you're going to bump something you've been planning for something that's more timely, you need to actually say, hey, we're bumping This is what we need to do. Are we rescheduling it, or are we completely throwing the work out?
Tony MartignettiThere's an implication here. Right. And there's a trade-off to that. This was originally planned for this reason. There was a purpose for this, and this is what is not now going to be fulfilled.
Kivi Leroux MillerRight. And sometimes you can use it later. You know, if it's more sort of evergreen in nature, you just bump it down a month. Other times, you know, it's lost work. But those are strategic decisions that you have to make. And that's where, again, Again, having some executive understanding of the communication strategy is important to help the communications team really make good decisions in those situations, because they do come up all the time.
Tony MartignettiAll right. When are our boundaries respected, right?
Kivi Leroux MillerYes.
Tony MartignettiLike I said, stop dissing my calendar. All right. So you guys spent a little— you all spent a lot of time in your session. What more should we be talking about? We have another like 4 minutes, 4 or 5 minutes. What else, whatever we talked about, or what more detail maybe about something we didn't cover in sufficient detail? Come on. How'd you do 90 minutes together? What'd you do for 90 minutes?
Laura NorvigWell, we turned it back on the audience quite a bit and had them tell us more about what the challenges were they were facing.
Tony MartignettiDo you want to share some of those challenges that we haven't talked about?
James PorterYeah, sure. A little more detail?
Tony MartignettiGo ahead.
James PorterYeah, one of the challenges was also just time, straight up. We don't have enough time. So something that can happen with a content calendar, which I mentioned when I was talking, was then you have to schedule into your schedule the time to put things on the content calendar. So it becomes another task on your list. You know, there's another half hour of my time, when especially for nonprofits that don't have a huge communications staff, it almost seems like it's just another thing that you have to do, and there's only 2 of you, and you need to get everything else done anyway.
Tony MartignettiI was thinking even just one.
James PorterYeah, no, we had a lot of people. We did a little poll and said, how many of you are a team of one? And it was maybe like a third or so of people who were just by themselves. And so I think time was a big thing, but I think that a content calendar can actually give you back some time because it helps you plan longer term if you're going to use it that way. And so you then don't have to constantly be thinking, well, what am I churning out next week? What am I posting on Facebook on Friday? Because you know already. You've already done it. So yeah, it can take time to do, but it can also make you use your very precious time better than you would without it.
Tony MartignettiAll right. So you think it's worth it? It's worth doing it for the one-person shop.
James PorterYeah, I think it's worth it for the one-person shop because it just, it kind of keeps you accountable for what you're doing rather than every day saying, what am I posting today?
Laura NorvigYeah, one of the things I shared was that I originally used to do a lot of winging it, and I had a certain kind of a series of Facebook posts that I wanted to do, and every Monday I was sitting down and thinking of one. And then when I kind of laid it out in a spreadsheet, it was like, you know what, I can plan like 10 of these and schedule them in advance, and now I don't have to think about it again. So thinking ahead in a calendar kind of way actually did end up saving me time.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Is it worth, if you don't feel you can put every, you know, every Facebook post into a content calendar, having your bigger items? All right, we know there's gonna be a press release required for this announcement, and we know there's gonna be something coming out of the Board of Trustees meeting this month. And, you know, so maybe just putting the biggest items there. Maybe not the day-to-day, but at least you got something down, right? You got a framework, Kivi, to work from?
Kivi Leroux MillerYeah, so like a lot of people will just do their blog posts and their email, assuming that they're going to repurpose all that into social. And so they don't talk about every single thing they're going to talk about on Facebook. Same thing with video, that tends to be a little more production-heavy. And so if you're doing video, you kind of want to treat that almost like a blog post in terms of the production schedule to give yourself the time to do it. But you're right, those bigger chunks of content are usually what goes on the calendar, and then a lot of people just sort of in their daily work process know that that's going to go out on Facebook or Twitter or whatever social channels they're using.
Tony MartignettiOkay. All right. Laura, why don't you wrap us up with a final motivation, why this is worth doing?
Laura NorvigWell, it's going to help you see the big picture, and it's going to help you navigate your daily to-do list as well. And I think it's just going to keep you more confident that you're staying on task and hitting the themes you want to hit for your communications.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Thank you very much. Laura, James, Kivi, thank you.
James PorterThank you. Thank you, Tony.
Tony MartignettiThey're Laura Norvig, digital media strategist at ETR, James Porter, associate director of external relations at the END Fund, And Kivi Leroux Miller, founder of the Nonprofit Marketing Guide and also author. And you're listening to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio coverage of 16NTC. Thank you so much for being with us. Next week, design on a budget and communications mythbusters. If you missed any part of today's show, I beseech you, find it on tonymartignetti.com. We're sponsored by Pursuant. Online tools for small and mid-sized nonprofits, data-driven and technology-enabled, Pursuant.com. And by WeBeSpelling, super cool spelling bee fundraisers, WeBeSpelling.com. Our creative producer is Claire Meyerhoff. Sam Liebowitz is the line producer. Gavin Dahl is our AM and FM outreach director. The show's social media is by Susan Chavez, and our music is by Scott Stein. Be with me next week for Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. Go out and be great. Thank you.
AnnouncerWhat's not to love about Nonprofit Radio? Tony gets the best guests. Check this out from Seth Godin.
Seth GodinThis is the first revolution since TV, 1950, and Henry Ford, 1920. It's the revolution of our lifetime.
AnnouncerHere's a smart, simple idea from Craigslist founder Craig Newmark.
Craig NewmarkYeah, in sites or in presentation or anything, people don't really need the fancy stuff. They need something which is simple and fast.
AnnouncerWhen's the best time to post on Facebook? Facebook's Andrew Noyes knows.
Andrew NoyesTraffic is at an all-time high around 9 AM or 8 PM, so that's when you should be posting your most meaningful posts.
AnnouncerHere's Aria Finger, COO of dosomething.org.
Aria FingerYoung people are not going to be involved in social change if it's boring and they don't see the impact of what they're doing, so you've got to make it fun and applicable to these young people. Otherwise, a 15 and 16-year-old, they have better things to do. They have Xbox, they have TV, they have their cell phones.
AnnouncerAmi Dar is the founder of Idealist.
Ami DarIt took 2 or 3 years for foundation staff to sort of deign to add an email address to their card. It was like, it was phone, this email thing is weird, and plus why should I give it away?
AnnouncerCharles Best founded donorschoose.org.
Charles BestSomehow they've gotten in touch kind of offline, as it were, and they'll do exchanges of
AnnouncerMarc Ecko is the founder and CEO of Ecko Enterprises. You may be wearing his hoodies and shirts. Tony talked to him.
Marc EckoYeah, you know, I just, I'm a big believer that it's not what you make in life, it's, you know, it's how you make people feel.
AnnouncerThis is public radio host Majora Carter.
Majora CarterInnovation is in the power of understanding that you don't just, you know, put money on a situation and expect it to heal. You put money on a situation and invest it and expect it to grow.
AnnouncerAnd savvy advice for success from Eric Saperston.
Eric SaperstonWhat separates those who achieve from those who do not is in direct proportion to one's ability to ask others for help.
AnnouncerThe smartest experts and leading thinkers are on Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%.
I love our sponsors!

Pursuant
Do you want to find more prospects & raise more money? Pursuant is a full-service fundraising agency, leveraging data & technology.

We Bee Spelling
It’s not your 7th grade spelling bee! We Bee Spelling produces charity fundraiser spelling bees with stand-up comedy, live music & dance. It’s all in the video!

More Episodes from 2016 Nonprofit Technology Conference
View All



Master Google AdWords & Master Your Decision Making
with Jason Shim, Mark Hallman, Karin Hedetniemi, and Jayme Nelson



Don't Burn Out In 2017 & Personalized Video
with Paul Loeb, Michael Hoffman, and Jono Smith





Grow Your Sustainer Revenue & Protect Your Donors’ Data
with Allison Weston, Chrissy Hyre, Sabra Lugthart, Tracey Lorts, and Joshua Allen


