Put Passion & Fun Into Your Fundraising


About this episode
Ben Cooley brings his energy and warmth as he shares his thinking on intimate donor events; savvy stewardship (Thanking is banking!); your major donor conversations; the critical role of leadership in fundraising; and, a lot more. He’s founder and CEO of Maxwell & Marie.
Here’s the transcript
Tony MartignettiHello and welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. I'm your aptly named host and the podfather of your favorite hebdomadal podcast. We have a listener of the week, Deborah Elizabeth Finn. Deborah is moderator of Mission Based Massachusetts, and she sent a lovely email to the group that she shared with me saying that our 2026 Outlook show overcame her usual skepticism about forecasts. And she deeply respects Amy Sample Ward, our tech contributor, and Gene Takagi, our legal contributor. I should have said, quote, deeply respects them. So we gave her— we overcame her skepticism on, on forecasts and outlooks. She loves our 2 esteemed contributors, and she even told Mission Based Massachusetts That this podcast has, quote, outstanding guests, end quote. She said nothing about the lackluster host, which I'm grateful for. Thank you. Please leave that out. But I do thank you very much, Deborah Elizabeth Finn, for sharing Nonprofit Radio with Mission Based Massachusetts. Sharing it wherever you can, I'm always grateful. Deborah, thank you and congratulations. Thank you. On being our listener of the week. Oh, I'm glad you're with us. I'd be hit with asthenochorea if I saw that you missed this week's show. Here's our associate producer Kate with what's on the menu.
Kate MartignettiHey Tony and Debra, I hope our listeners are hungry for put passion and fun into your fundraising. Ben Cooley brings his energy and warmth as he shares his thinking on intimate donor events, savvy stewardship, your major donor conversations, the critical role of leadership in fundraising, and a lot more. He is founder and CEO of Maxwell & Marie. On Tony's Take Two.
Tony MartignettiActive listening.
Kate MartignettiHere is Put Passion and Fun into Your Fundraising.
Tony MartignettiIt's my pleasure to welcome Ben Cooley to Nonprofit Radio. Ben is the founder and CEO of Maxwell & Marie, a boutique consultancy serving mission-driven organizations worldwide with almost 20 years of experience building, scaling, and leading high-impact nonprofits. He coaches charity CEOs, teams, and boards, supporting them to strengthen fundraising, clarify strategy, grow income, and increase influence. The company is at maxwellandmarie.co, and you'll find Ben on LinkedIn. Ben Cooley, welcome to Nonprofit Radio.
Ben CooleyHey, thanks so much for having me. Really appreciate it, Tony.
Tony MartignettiI'm glad you're with us in Nashville, Tennessee.
Ben CooleyYeah, I know. Some people say to me when they hear me, when I get in an Uber, they go, oh my gosh, I love your accent. Where are you from? I tell them Texas.
Tony MartignettiYeah, I don't know what it is about Americans with the British accent. I don't
Ben Cooleyknow.
Tony MartignettiIs this a holdover from our colonial days? I don't know. Americans love the British accent. Why?
Ben CooleyTony, they do. In fact, I hate to say this, but I'll say anyway, I get free Starbucks because of it. Because particularly in the South, in like Nashville, they're like, oh my gosh, I love your accent. And I'm like, oh, well, what can you give me for free?
Tony MartignettiI don't know. Yeah, you may as well take advantage. I don't know what it is about the British. I mean, I think Italian accents— I happen to— Martignetti, Tony Martignetti. I happen to think Italian accents are beautiful.
Ben CooleyYeah.
Tony MartignettiBut I don't know. Yeah, I don't know what the origin story is for why we are just— I think they're overrated, frankly, British accents. I think it's overrated.
Ben CooleyWell, I have to say I agree with you, Tony.
Tony MartignettiI would think you would.
Ben CooleyBut the problem is I'm going to benefit from it. You know what I mean? I'm one of those horrible people that's like, yeah, it's overrated. Well, I'll still take on the accent.
Tony MartignettiYeah, you may as well exploit the love. Feel the love. 100%. I just don't understand it.
Ben CooleyIt's yearning for probably the days old, isn't it? You know, but there we go. I was once on a podcast and they said that I was in Nashville and they said to me, why are you here? Why, why are you here in America? What are you doing? I said, well, I'm here to make America Great Britain again. And, uh, they, they made me the hat and I've worn that many times just for a joke on a party occasion.
Tony MartignettiI understand. Make America Great Britain again. All right, MAGA. All right.
Ben CooleyYeah, don't do it though. Don't do that.
Tony MartignettiYeah, no, we need to be our own. We are our own. I don't think we have any difficulty showing that we are. We are our own country. We are independent. We're celebrating 250 years of independence.
Ben CooleyCome on, let's go.
Tony MartignettiAll right. So you have some, you have a lot of good thoughts about fundraising, leadership's role in fundraising. But you have some concerns too about very recent press. So share what— I think a lot of people share your concerns, but for a little motivation, share what brings this to the surface for you.
Ben CooleyWell, I mean, I founded an organization, a nonprofit. I grew it, scaled it to tens of millions revenue. I had over 35 offices globally, 12 countries, raised, you know, helped hundreds of thousands of people every year in the program. Right? But so I take that kind of evaluated experience, and now you know sitting with lots and lots of chief executives of other charities that might be smaller, that might be more dependent on one income stream. One of the recent concerns that I've got, and I think everyone's got, is is how governments are reshaping their giving, not only internationally through development funds. You know we've seen that obviously with USAID and with. Other, um, uh, the DFID and the new name for DFID and NORAD and all of the kind of big institutional giving has shifted. Um, but it's happening here federally as well. Uh, there are lots of nonprofits that are heavily reliant on government funding that are now going, actually, uh, we were on that receivership and it was great while it lasted, multiple million dollar, um, uh, you know, kind of contracts over multiple years, but now is the time to diversify your income streams. And they've just recently announced how the shift within— with the Financial Times announced that there's going to be a shift from giving to nonprofits in developing countries and rather actually using the local governments to, to administrate those funds, which means several things actually. The, the way that income is happening now with nonprofits has dramatically changed if you are on the receiving end of governmental funding. And so it's— I, as an expert, one of the things that I did, I, I, you know, like, I'm not just someone in theory that's raised millions. I've been there. I've done fundraising dinners. I've done over myself over 10,000 regular givers. Um, I've, uh, built Christmas campaigns that generated millions of dollars. And, you know, as someone that's been in this space for the last 20 years I so desperately want people to diversify their income streams because I've watched many of my favorite nonprofits that do great work actually suffer and have to lay off, shut down projects because they haven't invested in a diverse income stream and have heavily reliant on one or two of the incomes that they've got.
Tony MartignettiWell, for instance, you mentioned Christmas, like Christmas campaigns that you've run. That leads me to think about the reliance on events generally, you know, being too strong, too much dependence on event fundraising.
Ben CooleyYeah. I mean, a lot of organizations, you know, they do fundraising dinners, they try and raise, you know, try and get 200 people in a room. And Uh, you know, they, they spend $50,000, $60,000, you know, if not more, um, on hosting those people. I, I think things have shifted. I don't think those events work as well as they do. I think they can work. Um, uh, I think if you have the ability to narrate the story well, um, and you're able to demonstrate activity for the organization and ultimately impact, I think they're the 3 things. If I'm looking at a nonprofit, you've got to have a great story, story. You've got to be able to tell what you've done with that, so how many people you've helped, um, and then ultimately what has that help meant, right? I think at fundraising dinners you can raise money, but what I'm seeing more and more locally is, um, through the nonprofits I'm working with just in the last few years, where the real ROI has come is it's actually through small household events where you get like— we've got the winner of Some of my nonprofits that work with me at Maxwell & Marie, um, they, uh, we've organized, um, the winner of Hell's Kitchen, the chef, uh, to come and cook. And it's being able to get the donors into a more intimate setting where you can not just present, but you can actually start work walking alongside these donors. Because ultimately, I'll say this. Yeah. The success of any nonprofit, particularly ones that heavily relies on high net worth individuals, your resources are in your relationships. And if you aren't building relationships, your greatest asset is the relationships that you have. And so these small local dinners are great things that you should be looking at. I used to probably do 20 or 30 of them a year. For, for my nonprofit.
Tony MartignettiI love the, the, your, your summation of that, that your resources are in your relationships. And I think that applies to nonprofits of any stripe, whether you, whether you're cultivating high net worth individuals or more like our listeners in small and mid-sized nonprofits, you don't have those kinds of folks. But the resources are still in the relationships. And I absolutely agree with you too about small events. I love I love sort of not hosting them. I don't host them as a consultant, but I speak at them. And going into someone's home where maybe it's 6 or 8 couples or something like that, you know, or even sometimes it's even just 10 or 12 people. Well, that 12 people is 6 couples. But small like that, you know, those intimate events, you really— I mean, the CEO, Can get, can get to know folks. Maybe you, maybe you bring someone from the program staff, or, you know, who's on the ground. I mean, if it's, if it's at all animal related, maybe you can bring a couple of animals or pets, potential pets, you know, that you really can move people in, in small groups. I'm not surprised to hear you say you have great success with, you know, 30 of those a year.
Ben CooleyYeah. And I think, you know, for me, You know, like I was working with a startup nonprofit, first year of trading, and they did one of these dinners. They got 10 couples together and they raised $50,000, you know, in one night because the founder had such a great narrative and story. And then I think the opportunity from there is then how do you steward those relationships, right? I say this phrase often, thanking equals banking, right? If you want the ability to bank another check, Yeah. It's actually intrinsically linked to your, your donor thanking strategy. And how do you make them feel seen? How do you make them feel like they're not just on a conveyor belt? You know, I remember one time I phoned up, um, uh, like I say, I, I ran quite a large operation, um, and, uh, I, I phoned up a donor that responded to one of the events that we did. We did this tour and we were asking people to give $19 a month. And in that 10-day tour, we got 1,100 people respond to giving $19 a month. And I phoned one of them up. I was like, they'd seen me speak on the platform. I said, I just want to say thank you so much for giving $19 a month. You wouldn't believe the lives that are going to get changed because of your partnership, right? And they were like, what? The chief executive's phoning me up? I was like, yeah, because we're just— it's the heartbeat of our culture. Right? Culture determines what you grow. And if you're not— if you don't, at the top level, demonstrate the gratitude for the raindrops that are coming in, that ultimately collect and make this tsunami of hope, right? If we're not grateful for the raindrops, then actually, what are we— you know, we're not being the leader that we should be, right? And so I was just doing demonstrating to my team and to our donors, you know, uh, the fact that gratitude is at the heart of what we do. It's not, um, entitlement, it's gratitude. And so I phoned this donor up, said, thanks so much. The donor was like, oh my gosh, I can't believe that you phoned us. This is amazing. They said, I feel so bad, I could give way more than $19 a month. Let me go and speak to my wife. I want to just go. We're gonna get beyond this charity because I've never been thanked by the chief executive. I was like, oh my gosh. So he goes back and he comes back to me, phones me up and he says, look, you know, we're not gonna give $19 a month. We're gonna give $19,000 a month.
Tony MartignettiOh my gosh.
Ben CooleyI was like, whoa. And I said to my team at the time, I said, look, you know, Reality is people don't need to give to nonprofits, but when they feel the feeling of appreciation and you link that with a worthy cause, then they actually— the, the sky is the limit. We can do amazing things because people want— ultimately, once people get successful and they have finance They go to the next era of what they're giving and what their life wants to do, which is success to significance. And so we have to be great orators of the fact that what they're doing is significant.
Tony MartignettiYou know, I like to get into details and like action steps. So after this glorious oration about stewardship and thanking, and I like to use the phrase effusive I like to give effusive thanks. But what are your— so let's drill down to some tips. Stewardship. I mean, how should we be showing this enormous gratitude that we have? What do we need to make sure we're doing?
Ben CooleyRight. You ready? Okay,
Tony MartignettiI'm ready. Listeners are ready.
Ben CooleyI said to the admin team, to the donor, whatever size you are, right, whatever department it is, right, that Within 48 hours, they get a signed letter. I don't mean like just an email. I mean print out a letter that articulates what this is going to achieve, that donation, whether it's for $5 a month, whether it's for $50 a month, $5,000 a month, that they get a letter that's signed by the chief executive, right, within 48 hours. Now, if it, you know, say if I was traveling because I used to travel a lot, And I say the most senior person in the, in the office that's available, right? But within 48 hours, they get that. Within 1 week, they get a phone call that articulates gratitude. Thank you. Link them to what the mission is, right? They then get put on a 6-week campaign trip. I'm sorry, this is too practical. I apologize. But basically, it goes—
Tony MartignettiI forbid your apology.
Ben CooleyYeah. Well, okay, fine.
Tony MartignettiBut practicality is what we want.
Ben CooleyOkay, fine. So basically, week 1, they get just a thank you email that's going to outline a story of a life that's going to be impacted. Week 2 is then going to be introducing them to the organization, the drip feed campaign, right? So it's going to be like, this is what we do, this is how we do it, this is, you know, um, this is the locations that we're in. It gets them— because a lot of people will give Because of a story, but that story doesn't always demonstrate what the organization does. And she over the next two times, it's going to be an about us. If you have an about us video, put that in. If you have something that narrates the program and the impact, then week four. So week two and week three are about us emails, right? Week four is going to be financials. So you're going to demonstrate your financial integrity. You're going to go look at us. We're on, you know, Charity Navigator. We've got 100% score on Charity Navigator. Why? Because we appreciate good governance. We appreciate this. We appreciate that. You know, we've got our right policies in place. It's a relatively boring email, but actually for the people that are not heart givers but are mind givers, right? Mm-hmm. So they're the people that sit in a room and going, well, if I gave you $1 million, what would you do with it? You know, not because you made me cry, here, have all my money. No, it's the people that are like, I want an ROI on this.
Tony MartignettiYeah, these are more cerebral. What percentage of your revenue goes to the program? Exactly. The administration. Yeah. All right.
Ben CooleyThey are the people that have got their donor-advised fund and they are going, I want an ROI on this. Or they are the people that are going to, you know, I don't know if you've heard of this new— I would encourage your listeners to look at them, but like the faith-driven investor movement. I don't know if you've heard of them. Out of Dallas, Texas. And one of the things that they're really pointing people towards is compassionate investment. So basically they're saying, use your donation like it's an investment into your investment portfolio, right? So it means that actually week 4 is really important to those, right? Because they're going to look at it and go, you know, like they want to know, What's the percentage of, um, that's spent on program versus administration? Now, Tony, I just want you to know, to the listeners, I don't agree. I'm one of those people that disagrees with the 80/20 rule, right? I don't think it's possible, particularly for smaller organizations. I don't think it's possible, right? I think that
Tony Martignetti80/20 being
Ben Cooley80% spent on program—
Tony MartignettiThe program, yeah.
Ben Cooley20% spent on fundraising, media, Admin, you know, all that sort of stuff.
Tony MartignettiI don't think that's a hard rule, but I've heard it. Yeah.
Ben CooleyAll right. And so, and then the 6th is then celebration.
Tony MartignettiWait a minute, what happened to 5? Wait, where'd we go? 5,
Ben Cooley4. Did we go 5? We did.
Tony MartignettiOkay, sorry. We did 4 is— wait, 4 is the— no, 3 and 4 are about us.
Ben CooleyYeah.
Tony MartignettiOh, 5 is the cerebral. 5 is for the more cerebral folks, your ROI. Okay, I'm sorry.
Ben CooleyYes. 6 is celebration, right? And it's literally just going organizational celebration moments that you can go with, like, that combines all of those tolls. So it's a 6-week campaign. At the 6th week, then they get a phone call as well, right? And go, we're so grateful. We are so grateful. This, we, you gave 6 weeks ago and you give some form of update of what that donation has done. Yeah. Right? Then they get put into the normal kind of bog standard, and they get a phone call every year, and they get put through. Now, in that seat sweep period, you will find that it's number one, you know, when people give to a regular giving campaign or they give one-off, it's where their heightened awareness of you is, right? So like the husband, for example, might be checking the bank account and going, what's this large donation? Who's this for? You know, well, don't worry. They've been in touch. They've banked us, they've done this. It's the, it's the greatest stress for a non— for a nonprofit when they get regular giving. It's the greatest stress point because it's where the highest amount of canceled, uh, um, regular givers are, is in the first 6 weeks, right? Because you've got the first initial payment being taken, the second initial payment comes out, it's like, do they really want to be in? And the greatest stress for that factor is when you actually do sponsored events. I don't know if you've ever had anyone come on and talk about like when you know, a Christian artist or an artist goes out and does those mass 3,000, 5,000 arenas and they ask for the big boys of, you know, child sponsorship. Well, the greatest risk for those asks or the regular giving is actually in the first 6 weeks. So this kind of adds a kind of story and narrative. They get a phone call at the end and then they get put into thingy. All the while, every single one of those emails, you're saying, thank you so much. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
Tony MartignettiWhat's the leader's role, leadership role in fundraising? The C-suite, maybe the CEO certainly has a role, but board members, let's talk about leadership's role in fundraising.
Ben CooleyWell, I say everyone's a fundraiser, right? And it's entirely true. I think actually some people in the organization, um, probably aren't geared towards fundraising, but they can be geared towards friend-raising. You know, if you go back to that, that, that principle, your resources are in your relationships, right? There are people that can introduce you to people that can elevate, that can, um, that can contribute. But everyone, everyone at least needs to be a friend-raiser. Yeah. But not everyone can be a fundraiser. But I would say everyone's a fundraiser because if they can raise funds, like if they're in the program team, they're a social worker, and they're related to someone who's, you know, got a business that's doing really well, that's giving $10 million away, like, hello, we're here, you know, like, um, but reality is everyone should be looking to grow the database. And I think that's often overlooked, actually. I don't think, you know, because it's Um, but fundraising is actually a metrics game. Mm-hmm. And a lot of, a lot of small nonprofits are going, hey, you know, like, I just wish I had more people. I wish I, you know, had more money. I could do so much more good with this money. And you're dead right, you can. But if you're a smaller nonprofit, I'm talking like sub $500,000, maybe $100,000, $200,000, right at that part, you're doing great. I mean, not many nonprofits get to that stage, right? So good on you. Well done for all of the hard work, the labor that you've put into place. But what I would say to you now is, is do what you can to get as many people to just interact with your organization as possible. Go out and speak anywhere that will have you and have a mechanism to gather their data. Because ultimately, if I'm stood in front of a crowd, right, And I am allowed to ask them to support. So let's say if I get in front of 100 people, if I'm allowed to do a regular giving ask, my methodology, which I now teach, I can get— I've had up to 33% of people give in an auditorium with this methodology, right? So I was in front of 3,000 people in Norway when we launched our Norwegian office, and we got 998 people. Wow. to give regularly. So it's a metrics game. So if you're only getting in front of, as a chief executive, if your diary, or founder, if you're looking at your next 3 months and you've got no speaking engagements, you've got no podcasts that you're speaking on, you've got no activity that you're getting in front, I can pretty much guess what your outcome is gonna be. So ultimately, you have to get busy in front of people to get that 4 to 13% of people to actually sign up to your mission
Kate MartignettiIt's time for Tony's Take Two.
Tony MartignettiThank you, Kate. I had the opportunity about 2 weeks ago to meet with a lot of, uh, staff team members at a client. There are 20 people who I met with a couple of others. We had 20 30-minute meetings in 2 days, and that's a lot. That's a lot. But the value, what came out of it— I learned so much from these folks because I was really listening actively, intently, carefully. I was taking some notes, but I was mostly just listening to their tone. And we were talking about what their goals are within the, within the nonprofit, what they'd like to do, the challenges that they see, ways to overcome those kinds of challenges. It was just reinforcing for me, you know, the value of asking open-ended questions and just letting people talk, and then me listening carefully. I came away with so much insightful, informative, like sort of data that will help me to help that client. So this, this certainly has implications for your fundraising, you know, when you're meeting with folks. So really, I'm just, I think, just reinforcing something you probably already know, how valuable it is just being the listener. The careful listener, the active listener. You come away learning so much, and that is Tony's Take Two. Kate?
Kate MartignettiYeah, usually Uncle Tony is the one talking, so he doesn't get much practice listening.
Tony MartignettiI I it's very good. I listen. I listen as much as possible. I mean, this is Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio. I mean, I do have a role here.
Kate MartignettiRight. Talk show.
Tony MartignettiAssociate producer. Soon to be assistant producer if you keep up this thread. By the way, assistant is below associate. I don't know if you're aware of that. You are aware. Okay. No, no, that was very good. Nicely played.
Kate MartignettiOh, by the way, your brother was laughing in the background. I heard a quick little
Tony MartignettiYeah, well, he's not getting, uh, he's not getting part of the revenue the way, uh, the way you do. There's no, no, no fee for him.
Kate MartignettiWe've got beaucoup buttloads more time. Here's the rest of Put Passion and Fun into Your Fundraising with Ben Cooley.
Tony MartignettiNow, what's this methodology you have that you alluded to that you're teaching? Oh, Tony, you get it. He teases it, but then he doesn't flush it out.
Ben CooleyI do, Tony, get it out of me. Get it out of me.
Tony MartignettiWhat's the methodology?
Ben CooleyRight. So most nonprofits, when they speak at a church, right, or they speak at an event, they'll do the easiest, easiest— because no one likes asking for money. Can we just like kind of like put this principle out?
Tony MartignettiYeah,
Ben Cooleythat no one really likes asking for money. And if you do, good on you. You're not part of the— like, you know, you're not part of the norm, right? Um, so particularly founders, they feel embarrassed of the fact that they are asking for money, because often some of that money is going towards their salary, or, you know, it's covering some of the expenses, and they feel embarrassed by it. And I get that. You know, I had a mentor of mine that, um, developed a charity called Christians Against Poverty, right, in the UK. And they pride themselves of getting over— I think there were over 25,000 regular givers. He sat me down one time, and he went— I— the first thing I ever did Right, was I got 5— I booked an arena in England. I got 5,884 people to my first event. And then I did a regular giving ask and it absolutely sucked. I got hardly anyone give, right? And he sat me down after this. He went, you suck. I'm like, thanks, bro. I really appreciate the encouragement. He said, no, what you need to do is you need to stand on a platform and tell people, I'm going to ask you for money, but I really am really bad at this. So can we just all agree I'm bad, but the mission that we're doing is worth this ask, right? So most nonprofits take the easiest out, right? And they go and they say, okay guys, so please could you give? And if you just want to head back at the back table, I've got some flyers, you know, maybe you could give 4%, the maximum. I've got— by the way, I've done hundreds and hundreds and hundreds of these events. You know, I was— I'm not joking, right? I had At any point in time, I had 70 trained speakers going out in churches and speaking in churches every Sunday. 70 trained speakers, right? So like, I've aggregated all that data. 4%. If you send people to a table, this is what's going to happen. There's going to be a massive queue at that table, right? And they're going to go, then probably about 7 people are going to be able to speak to you because one person wants to tell you that they are really moved by your charity and oh my God, you know, like, and 7 days later you're still talking to that same person, right? And if you've got a British accent, it's longer. I don't know why. Anyway, so you'll get 4%. So if you've got 100 people, that means 4 people are going to give to you. If you've got 200 people, that's 8, right? Then the next thing is this. If you're brave enough, you go and speak to the event host or the church pastor or whoever it is, right? And you say, can we put the giving envelopes on the chairs, right? Well, you've just increased it to 9% by doing that, right?
Tony MartignettiYeah.
Ben CooleyYou go, hey, give now and everyone get the flyer. Oh my gosh. Now, as I'm telling this story, fill it out, right? That's 9%. Now, if you want to get over 13%, It's going to be hard, and I'm not gonna lie, this is not made for the, like, for the faint of heart. I just want you to know this, right? QR codes, I'm not a big fan of. Every organization I've dealt with in the last 3 or 4 years that does QR codes, what happens is people get out the phone, they scan the QR code, and then they get a text from their daughter or from thingy, and they get distracted into work, right? Yeah. I don't like that methodology. Might work for some, but I've not seen it with any of our clients, right?
Tony MartignettiAll right.
Ben CooleyAnd so, and, and even at high net worth individual dinners, I don't rate it, right? Still in America, you guys have got something called checks. Like, we got rid of those in the 1980s, guys. It was unbelievable, you know what I mean?
Tony MartignettiYou live in Nashville, Tennessee. What we—
Ben CooleyI know, sorry. I still use GEX and I, I still every time I have to Google how to fill it out. Anyway, so
Tony MartignettiGoogle how to fill it out.
Ben CooleyYeah, yeah, right. So 13%, if you want to get above 13%, this is what you do, Tony. This is what you do. And it's awful. You need volunteers for this. You need to be so organized, right? You basically, you pass the buckets down. You go, I'm gonna give you— I'm gonna do a regular giving ask right now. I'm gonna ask to partner with us on a monthly basis, we're going to have the team pass the buckets down the rows. This is not to put anything in, but this is actually to take the form out. Now, I used to run an anti-slavery organization, right? It's— and it's almost like you are taking someone's life out of slavery right now. And now it adds a component to this because you get the decision psychology of giving, right? Is you get the decision when the bucket's passing, are you going to pass by on this opportunity? Or are you going to be the person that's going to be the person that helps? And so suddenly, psychologically, you've just triggered them into not only themselves thinking that, but now they're also thinking everyone else knows that I'm not taking it out. And so you get a higher percentage. And then what happens is you fill out the form normally, and then you pass the buckets back. So it's like Super organized team behind it.
Tony MartignettiWhat are they taking out of the bucket? A
Ben Cooleymonthly regular giving form?
Tony MartignettiYeah, a monthly sustainer, a sustainer giving commitment. And then, and then they pass it back somehow.
Ben CooleyYeah. And then, and then once you finish, you often play a video of a life being transformed. And then you get back up and you say, right, we're going to pass back the buckets and you're going to put the envelopes in like you are putting your name, your family's name in there saying, I'm in it to end it. Come on, are you with me? Say amen.
Tony MartignettiOkay.
Ben CooleyAnd then you get— you'll get a lot higher. And that, that's what— it's interesting, it's why I'm so passionate about fundraising, because a lot of people put the energy into curating these events or these Christmas campaigns, but if they just had a little bit higher thinking or a little bit of a different technique, then actually they could go from one one organization I work with was doing a Christmas campaign. They literally raised $20,000 in their Christmas campaigns. They're now hitting $200,000, $300,000 because they're just tweaking it and doing different things. But those different things have different results.
Tony MartignettiWhat's with Maxwell Marie, your company? Who are— do they exist? Who are Maxwell Marie? Or they exist? Or they— what? Yeah, it's me and my wife. She
Ben CooleyMy wife started a nonprofit and I started one. And so, we decided that we would do all of our experiences that we've done. We would put them together into a boutique consultancy. We don't work with a lot of organizations. We just work with a few that we think that we can more than double in a, you know, 2 or 3-year
Tony Martignettiperiod. Well, where's your wife? She's not— why didn't you pitch you and your wife talking as guests?
Ben CooleyMy wife, you should have her next time, but she is way better looking than me. And we have 10 children. So she's currently holding the 10 children back from invading this podcast right now. So yeah.
Tony MartignettiSo you have 10 children in one house? In one house?
Ben CooleyYes, sir. Yes, sir. Dang. Yeah, it's a lot. I
Tony Martignettiwould say. Yeah.
Ben CooleyIt's 20 years old all the way down to 7 months old.
Tony MartignettiAll right, congratulations on the, on the most recent birth. All right, I can understand why— all right, I can understand why your wife's not with us. Yeah, you need actually professional help, not, not this. So who are— but who are Maxwell and Marie?
Ben CooleySo it's Maxwell's my, uh, third name, um, Marie is her second name.
Tony MartignettiAh,
Ben Cooleyokay. And so we kind of had that, uh, and, you know, I've kind of through that that, you know, we've been able to help not only with fundraising, you know, we help with coaching with fundraising, but I've launched other brands that kind of— I've launched a company called goodbookkeeping.com, um, which helps nonprofits with their bookkeeping. Um, uh, because one of the things people ask me, how did you do it? You grew to tens of millions revenue. And I was like, I understood my numbers. I mean, my, my number 2 was a former CFO of the 13th largest company in the UK, and so our numbers were right. Not only was I good at telling stories, but what most nonprofits don't realize is is their finances are telling a story too, and they have to narrate those through their 990s, through how they get their their. I mean, I literally we had a a nonprofit just recently come to us. They lost a million dollar donor. Because of their Charity Commission, uh, their Charity Navigator score.
Tony MartignettiYeah, yeah. No, I've— yes, I've heard things like that. Also just disclosing finances to donors who, you know— yeah, we're doing donor conversations.
Ben CooleyYeah,
Tony Martignettijust sharing what the, what the numbers are like, but even if it's a hard reality. Yeah, even maybe even more so if it's a hard reality that you want your You want your investors to be aware of that you're— this is a down year, or you've had a couple of down years. Yeah, you know, and but the mission is still important, the, the team is still outstanding. Yeah, the giving has not been there, and, and here's what we're doing to turn things around. And part of that is having this conversation with you.
Ben CooleyThat's absolutely true. You know, one of my favorite conversations with a donor, Tony, was, um, a guy that that founded a very, very large, um, uh, car rental company, right? It's, um, and, uh, he said to me, Ben, I'm just wondering why this year's finances don't look as strong as last year's. He said— I said, oh, and that's because every time I meet with you, you only give me $10,000. If you gave me $100,000, it would change it. He went quiet.
Tony MartignettiDid he up his giving?
Ben CooleyOh yeah, of course he did. I was not able to— All right. Yeah.
Tony MartignettiAnd, uh, how about Nashville, Tennessee? How did you land there from— I don't know, where, where are you from in, in UK?
Ben CooleyI'm from a little town called Yarmouth. I moved to Manchester, which was where my headquarters was. But, um, uh, I, um, I actually took over a nonprofit in, um, So part of— I've built this thing called the 7 Pillars of a Sustainable Nonprofit, right? And it goes through the 7 income streams that you need, right? Once you get to $10 million, you can do something called merger and acquisitions, right? And so I, I did— I started doing merger and acquisitions. One of the ones was in Nashville, Tennessee. And so I knew Nashville. When COVID happened, I thought, let's move here. Yeah. And I love— I am a massive fan of America. So like, I know like British people are gonna hate me right now, but I'm telling you right now, America is where it's at. And I love it. And love the— not only I love the business environment, I love the people and I love the culture. I just think it's amazing. It's not small things.
Tony MartignettiOutstanding. So you've been here just what, 5, 6 years?
Ben CooleyYeah, yeah, but I've worked here since 2013.
Tony MartignettiWhat about the hat collection behind you? Uh, listeners, you can't— you don't have the benefit of the video, but, um, Ben has, uh, I don't know, 6, 8, 10 hats hanging on the wall behind him. Yeah, this is his Zoom background. My Zoom background is this sign that says professional Zoom background, which is put on with painter's tape, and I've written in the word professional, and I didn't leave enough space, so it gets That's my background there. But why— what's the hat collection?
Ben CooleyWell, it's just because I've got a really pretty wife that just wears beautiful hats. So, um, it's a very sudden— she's American, so it's a very sudden thing to have lots of hats on, like cowboy— no, I don't think they're quite the cowgirl hats on there.
Tony MartignettiMaybe one is like a cowgirl hat. Yeah, yeah, no, yeah, they're wider brims and flatter brims. All right, so these are your— does she wear them? Oh
Ben Cooleyyeah, she wears them. Yeah, oh yeah, definitely. She wears— she, you know, she's got the kind of, uh, the Southern charm. Um, it's, it's mildly annoying to her really because, you know, um, they'll often say if we're in a drive-through, they'll say, oh my gosh, I love your accent. And then they go, are you from there too? And she's like, no, I'm not. And she— and they're like almost disappointed. They're Oh,
Tony Martignettiright.
Ben CooleyYou're just one of us.
Tony MartignettiShe's just got a flat Southern— where's she from? What state is she from?
Ben CooleyWell, she's a Navy brat, so she's from everywhere.
Tony MartignettiEverywhere. All right. So she does not have a— she doesn't even have a Southern accent. Yeah.
Ben CooleyNo, she doesn't. She just has what I would call a standard American accent. But she, she started a nonprofit in Uganda, and she, she runs an organization that actually is brilliant because it's the only organization in the world that faces this one issue a neglected tropical disease called jiggers. And so she, her team, she has about 80 staff out in Uganda that remove jiggers from people's feet and then put some— make shoes for them. So she's made 360,000 pairs of shoes in the last 5 years for children in—
Tony MartignettiOutstanding. What's the name of the organization? Shout it out.
Ben CooleyIt's called Sole Hope. S-O-L-E-H-O-P-E.
Tony MartignettiSole, like a sole of a shoe. Sole Hope.
Ben CooleyYeah, she's way better at marketing than me. She's the genius there.
Tony MartignettiLet's talk about your coaching. You do a lot of coaching of CEOs, maybe other C-suite as well, but about major donor conversations. I was kind of alluding to it when I was talking about individual conversations, you know, investment types of conversations, not necessarily high net worth. Let's not focus on high net worth individuals, but major donors. Maybe they give at the $5,000, $10,000, $15,000 level, $20,000 maybe, but they're not necessarily high net worth. They're just enormously generous. What's your advice around those one-on-one conversations?
Ben CooleyWell, number one is have them. Don't avoid it.
Tony MartignettiDon't be afraid of them. Don't be afraid.
Ben CooleyBecause look, I mean, um, I, I think this is really important to tell, is that, um, is that they are wanting something from the relationship too, right? And if you can figure that out, you know, I talked about success to significance. Often the people that are in that point, you know, they're— I'm part of this organization called Halftime, which was started by a guy called Bob Buford.
Tony MartignettiSorry, Scott, say it again.
Ben CooleyHalftime.
Tony MartignettiHalftime.
Ben CooleyYeah. And it's basically to help leaders that have done something with their life figure out why it all happened and how to make sense of it and, you know, what to do with it and how to steward that success to significance. And I think where for me is number one, make sure you make available the time. And by the way, you probably have more capacity for those relationships than you think. I mean, I, I had 14 direct reports, I had 12 countries, I had hundreds of staff, hundreds and hundreds of staff in my organization, um, but I still managed 80 relationships. Wow. That were my significant relationships. Some of them, it all depends on where they were in the— this— I didn't just categorize them as like, this person's a billionaire, so he's my friend. And now, you know, I've grown the charity and the nonprofit larger, these people drop off and I'm gonna palm them off. It was, it was actually born out of relationship. And, um, but number one, you can probably manage more than you think you can. Yeah. Right. And number 2 is they don't mind you kind of scheduling things. Like, so for example, they know if you're gonna run this well, hey, they're gonna touch base with me once a month just to give me an update personally or a text. But where it gets really— where you get really good results is that you go beyond the organization into actually being a former friend for them and that you check in with them. Look, I, I said this to— I say this to my team often, right, that a lot of people that have the ability to drop $5,000, $10,000, they're in leadership somewhere on the spectrum or ownership of a business. And often that means that they're isolated Right? And they don't have people to talk to. And so these sorts of connections that you can do are mega. I'll give you one example. So I used to, you know, I used to try and meet up with coffee. I used to text people. I used to write to them. I used to do, you know, meet, you know, meet for lunch. I always used to pay, by the way. I never used to let them pay because a lot of the high net worth individuals that I would, or you know, major donors or whatever the terminology of that. When I was a small charity and I did it out of my basement, someone who gave me $500 was a high net worth individual to me, do you know what I mean? So the definitions change. But, um, but, um, uh, I used to, uh, I used to write to this one guy, right? He was someone I was trying to approach. I met him once and I said, I want— I actually want to help this. I want— I want to be friends with this guy as well as I'd love him to support. He came from wealth, but he started his own company from scratch. And I used to— I set up a Google alert to watch whenever his business got mentioned or had any success. And I used to write him a handwritten card.
Tony MartignettiVery smart. Yeah.
Ben CooleyAnd I said, well done. I'm really proud of you for this achievement. He never responded. I did it for 7 years and he never responded to a text, a phone call, Or, or anything. And I admire your commitment.
Tony MartignettiI, I— doing it for 7 years and not getting a reply. Yeah, you kept it up. Okay,
Ben Cooley7 years. Well, he was on— it wasn't just because he was on the up and up. I knew at one point in time this guy would need me because I just— I need— I know these people are, uh— I don't mean this in a self-inflated way. I don't hear that. Don't, don't hear that I'm being I just knew me and him could— when our first interaction, I knew we had something that we could be friends with. And, um, 7 years later he phoned me up and we're best of friends. And, uh, he's— what, his business is over a billion revenue? But like, he is just such a good human being and he's given tremendous amounts to charity. But it took 7 years of persistence that he knew I wasn't just I had integrity in it, and I firmly believed in him. I thought he was going to do great things with his life, and he did.
Tony MartignettiLet's talk more about these relationships. Yeah. Stewarding them, managing them. You're committed to them. I would call them professional friends.
Ben CooleyYeah.
Tony MartignettiI mean, you're treating them as friends, but there is a professional relationship to it. You can be helpful to them in their giving. They can be helpful to you through their giving, maybe through their companies. So, that's how I would characterize it. But let's talk more about that. You know, what advice you give your CEOs for managing these relationships?
Ben CooleySo, I mean, this is one of the major things that I do. With my life right now is I sit with chief executives and I tactically go through it with them, right? And I have a team that does this because number one, they're all unique, you know, and you've got to do some research on, on the individuals, find out what, what their giving factors are, what motivates them. But my number one thing is this, is I would not ask them all the time. In fact, I probably got to a point where I would ask them every couple of years, maybe potentially, to give. Because what I didn't want to do was to make it transactional. I would make it, I would make it an authentic friendship. And then where I would get them involved is that I would invite them to do a challenge with me. Wow. So, um, a challenge that I raised, I think, I think over a million dollars in the early stages of when, like, that was probably double my revenue, right, was I built these relationships and I invited them to do a challenge with me because I was like, we're friends, let's do something together that in— it gets, um, you excited, me excited, and also gets more people engaged, right, in the mission. And so, um, we rescued a girl that was trafficked from Latvia, uh, to Southampton, England. And, um, and so I, I got them involved in the conversation, include them in the conversation. So there was a group of 5 of us. One of them was a major celebrity in the UK, one of them was a high net worth individual, and we were going, right, like, this girl was trafficked from Latvia to Southampton. What could we do to raise money so that we could name one of our new locations after her. Because one of the things I did was every location was named after one of the people that we rescued or we helped, right? So the first, um, one that came out into Bradford, England was called Emma's Hub, after the first girl that we rescued called Emma. The second one that we were going to launch was Zoe's Hub, after Zoe, who was trafficked from Laos. So we were discussing, how are we going to do this? Number one, be inclusive, right? Don't just tell them what you need. Actually, don't just do push-down leadership. Actually invite them in to problem solve with you, right? So I was like, we need to raise a million dollars. How are we going to do it? And so one of them around the table said, I know what we should do. We should do a marathon. And I was like, no, marathons are from the devil, bro, right? And so like one of them was like, hey, we should do a we should do a cake sale. And I was like, we're not going to raise a million dollars from a Cake sale, bro. And then one of us had an idea. We should cycle from Latvia to Southampton. And I was like, yes, right? So at that point in time, I've got to say to your listeners, right, I thought Latvia was next to France, right? Now, if you want to get out on that, it's not next to France. No, it's next to Russia. It's 2,715 kilometers.
Tony MartignettiIt's one of the Balkans.
Ben CooleyThousand miles away, right? By that time, back— this is back in 2000 and, uh, 2015, I guess, right? I guess. Anyway, and so one of the celebrities that had hundreds and hundreds of thousands of followers, like, literally just tweeted out, we're doing this, right? We're gonna cycle from Latvia to Southampton, right? The next week, before we'd even arranged how we were gonna do We were, and we were on national news, national in the UK, right? So this momentum was building, and there's nothing like— I want to say this, this is a side note. If you're taking notes, remember, note takers are history makers, right? Momentum is what you need to demonstrate, right? In America particularly, people give to what is successful and is moving forward. If it feels stagnant, And it feels like you're losing all the time. Please, sir, can I have some more? That's Oliver Twist, right? But they end up going, oh man, I don't want to be giving to these people. I want to be giving to things that are successful. I want to give something that has momentum. So you need to be a great narrator of momentum. We're going to be doing this. So this challenge was our momentum builder. We had over 115 people join us on this cycle, right? We cycled from Latvia all the way through Latvia, all the way way through Lithuania. I didn't even like cycling. I hated cycling, right? Well, we had major companies sponsor us. We were on like radio shows, TV shows. By the time that we got to England, we were doing 2 conferences in a day cycling and then getting off, doing sometimes 130 miles, getting off, speaking at a conference, cycling again, speaking at another conference. We— I mean, the momentum was insane. Right? But that's what got high net worth individuals involved, where they were writing big checks because they weren't just feeling, oh my gosh, they want money from me. They wanted to be included. They wanted to be part of the story, and they wanted to fulfill feel that feel the momentum of doing something with their life. So yes, meet them for coffee. Yes, give them updates. Yes, tell them about your need, but include them in the problem of your nonprofit and. Get them to do something with their life, their skill, their passion for it. And guess what happened because of that? Then lots of people heard about us, our database grew, and that people were like, this is a fun charity. So then a few years later, we cycled from, um, from Cambodia to Vietnam, and I had, I think it was 40 people fly out and do it with us. It was amazing. Make it fun. Right? There's a reason why there's fun at the beginning of fundraising, and and this is really important if you're a leader of a nonprofit, right? I just want you to know this, right? I don't know if you've ever seen Winnie Pooh, Winnie the Pooh, right? But no one in the history of ever wanted to follow Eeyore, right? Oh, we'll never change. Oh my gosh, it sucks to be good. It's so hard. Nonprofits, the governments are changing that. We're never gonna be. All I wanted to do was. Change your life, but it's just poor me. Now they don't want to follow that guy. They're following Scott Harris that's done Charity Water, that's told them that they can do extraordinary things with their life. They're following Gary Haugen from IJM that's actually talking about how do we mend fractured, broken justice systems, and we can do something extraordinary. People want passion in their life, and they want to be told they're doing a good job, they're having a significant part to play, and they're celebrated all the way through.
Tony MartignettiI wish we could get guests who were more enthusiastic, you know, more passionate, more interesting. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. We struck the bottom here with Ben Cooley. No, I mean, it's amazing. All right. There's brilliance buried in all that passion. I wish you could see his arms are flailing. He has to keep fixing his hair because it's falling on his face because he's moving around so much. Ben Cooley, outstanding. I admire, of course, I admire your enthusiasm, your passion, and the valuable advice you bring to listeners. So thank you.
Ben CooleyMy pleasure. Thank you for having me.
Tony MartignettiCEO of Maxwell & Marie. You'll find Maxwell & Marie at maxwellandmarie.co. Connect with Ben on LinkedIn. I already sent you a connection request. I hope you're not going to refuse it.
Ben CooleyI will not.
Tony MartignettiThank you, Ben. It was a real pleasure. What a great way to kick off the week too. We're recording on a Monday. Thank you so much, Ben.
Ben CooleyGod bless you. Thank you.
Kate MartignettiNext week, monthly giving with Dana Snyder.
Tony MartignettiIndeed, Dana Snyder was supposed to be this week. Yep, that's a whole Host, host. I wouldn't say quite a host mistake. It just so happened that Ben came in quicker than Dana. Dana will indeed be next week.
Kate MartignettiIf you missed any part of this week's show,
Tony MartignettiI beseech you find it at TonyMartinetty.com.
Kate MartignettiOur creative producer is Claire Meyerhoff. I'm your associate producer, Kate Martignetti. This show's social media is by Susan Chavez. Marc Silverman is our web guy, and this music is by Scott Stein.
Tony MartignettiThank you for that affirmation, Scotty. Be with us next week for Nonprofit Radio, Big Nonprofit Ideas for the Other 95%. Go out, And be great. Thank you.

