PII In The Age Of AI & Balance AI Ethics And Innovation




PII In The Age Of AI
Artificial Intelligence and big data have transformed privacy risks by enabling malicious, targeted communications to your team that seem authentic because they contain highly accurate information. Kim Snyder and Shauna Dillavou explain the risks your nonprofit faces and what you can do to protect your mission. Kim is from RoundTable Technology and Shauna is CEO of Brightlines. This continues our coverage of the 2025 Nonprofit Technology Conference (#25NTC).
Balance AI Ethics And Innovation
Gozi Egbuonu encourages you to adopt Artificial Intelligence responsibly, in a human-centered approach. First, be thoughtful with the threshold question, “Should we use AI?” If you go ahead: Create a thorough use policy; overcome common challenges like staff training and identifying champions; manage change intentionally; and more. Gozi is with Technology Association of Grantmakers. This is also part of our #25NTC coverage.
Here’s the transcript
Tony MartignettiHello and welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. I'm your aptly named host and the podfather of your favorite hebdomadal podcast. Oh, I'm glad you're with us. I'd turn dromotropic if you unnerved me with the idea that you missed this week's show. Here's our associate producer Kate to introduce it.
Kate MartignettiHey, Tony. Our 25 NTC coverage continues with PII in the Age of AI. Artificial intelligence and big data have transformed privacy risks by enabling malicious, targeted targeted communications to your team that seem authentic because they contain highly accurate information. Kim Snyder and Shauna Dillavou explain the risks your nonprofit faces and what you can do to protect your mission. Kim is from RoundTable Technology, and Shauna is CEO of Brightlines. Then— Balance AI ethics and innovation. Gozi Egbuonu encourages you to adopt artificial intelligence responsibly in a human-centered approach. First, be thoughtful with the threshold question: should we use AI? If you go ahead, Create a thorough use policy, overcome common challenges like staff training and identifying champions, manage change intentionally, and more. Gozi is with Technology Association of Grantmakers. On Tony's Take Two.
Tony MartignettiTales from the Gym, an addition to my gratitudes.
Kate MartignettiHere is PII in the Age of AI.
Tony MartignettiHello and welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio coverage of 25NTC, the Nonprofit Technology Conference. We're all together at the Baltimore Convention Center where our coverage of 25NTC is sponsored by Heller Consulting, technology services for nonprofits. Our subject right now is PII in the age of AI, personally identifiable information in the age of artificial intelligence, safeguarding privacy in a data-powered world. Plus, we're adding in the topic— already the show's over. I want to thank you all for coming. We're here all week. Be sure to tip your servers. And we're adding in the topic. A Little More Privacy Please: Diving into Data Privacy. All right, because our guests asked to combine topics, which made a lot of sense. But before I introduce the guests— well, no, let's do it this way. So we have— stand by there. We have first is Kim Snyder. Kim Snyder, I got to take a deep breath before I do Kim's title. I'm going to hyperventilate trying to get enough air, oxygen in. I'm only 140 pounds. I don't carry enough oxygen in my lungs.
Shauna DillavouJust one man.
Tony MartignettiTo carry this title of Virtual Digital Privacy Project and Program Officer. Joshua Pesquet is thanked for that word salad. It's all nouns. It's all one adjective and 12 nouns.
Shauna DillavouSuperfluous.
Tony MartignettiJoshua. You're out. You're out. Anyway, RoundTable Technology. And then Shauna Dillavou, CEO, Brightlines.
Shauna DillavouCEO, Brightlines.
Tony MartignettiDoesn't get any easier.
Shauna DillavouNo. Streamlined.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Also with us, we have a special guest who's going to give a couple of syllables. Let me introduce Miles. Miles, say hello.
SponsorHi everyone, it's Miles with FundraiseUp. Thanks, Tony.
Tony MartignettiMy pleasure. Miles is sponsoring the Hub next door at FundraiseUp. So I thought I'd give him a little— he asked to give a shout out, so I said sure. And they're giving away free socks. That's what FundraiseUp is all about.
Shauna DillavouBe right over.
Tony MartignettiSocks. And what else do you do at FundraiseUp?
SponsorSo we help nonprofits raise more money with AI, and we do that by not using any identifiable information and are completely compliant across the globe.
Tony MartignettiAll right. What a segue.
Shauna DillavouThat's amazing. And not even rehearsed. Miles set us up. Thanks, Miles. Incredible.
Tony MartignettiAll right. You've overstayed your welcome. That's enough, Miles. Later, loser.
Shauna DillavouOkay. Audience rules.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Thank you, Miles. No, thank you. I did invite him after he pleaded. Okay. So we are talking about PII. So Miles, perfect segue, beautiful segue into personally identifiable information. Amy, we're going to do the overview. So I'm going to ask Kim, Virtual Digital Data— Virtual Digital Privacy Project and Program Officer. I'm going to ask Kim Snyder. No, I'm going to— no, I'm hitting it hard.
Shauna DillavouNo, no, own it.
Tony MartignettiSo for an overview, why do we Why did we combine these 2 topics? What are our issues around personally identifiable information and artificial intelligence? Kim Snyder.
Kim SnyderSo they both center on the issue of personally identifiable information. So on the one hand, we're talking about what kinds of regulations exist, how do you manage your data— I'm too far
Tony Martignettiaway. Don't whisper, Kim. Everybody hears you.
Kim SnyderOh,
Shauna Dillavougo ahead. I'm
Kim Snyderwaiting. Um, now you, you edit this.
Tony MartignettiEverything is related to personal— no, don't count on too many edits.
Kim SnyderOh dear. Okay.
Tony MartignettiOr any.
Kim SnyderAll right, so, um, we're talking about personally identifiable information, which for quite a while, for the last couple of NTCs, I've been talking about this here. And for quite a while, it's been about more about regulation. This year, I have to say, it's about having our data out there and vulnerability. And so looking at data management and how do you start to take stock of your data so that it is less vulnerable and the person, the people whose data it belongs to is also less vulnerable. And the other topic, which I'm here with my co-facilitator, um, uh, Shauna, is—
Tony MartignettiWith all the amens and ahas.
Shauna DillavouI'm here, I'm just like, I'm a Hype man. Yeah, in the blood.
Tony MartignettiColor commentary.
Kim SnyderYeah, so talking about how that— what constitutes personally identifiable information, how much that's expanded in recent years.
Tony MartignettiAll right. And Shauna, what's your role at Brightlines? How are you related to personally identifiable information?
Shauna DillavouYeah, yeah. So Brightlines, I founded it 4 years ago. We are a doxxing prevention company. For folks who don't maybe know what doxxing means, yeah, it's—
Tony MartignettiDefine it, please.
Shauna DillavouWhen folks will use your personal information or sensitive information They'll post it publicly, essentially posting your documents. That's where doxxing comes from, with the intent to incite others to do you harm. So there's like a malevolence there, right? I don't usually consider it doxxing if someone posts like a relatively available email address from like a professional setting. I do consider it doxxing when it's your personal email address and the intent is to ask others to hurt you.
Tony MartignettiIt goes a lot deeper. It could be your birthday, it could be your address. Could be your wife's or husband's. This is my man right here, Tony. Or spouses or partners.
Shauna DillavouYeah, no, I would argue that PII is an expanded—
Tony MartignettiWere you a doxxing victim? Is that why you started Brightlines? No, I never— nope. You were not?
Shauna DillavouNo, actually, I came out of US intelligence community. I was there as a much younger person and at a different age in the United States. And in terms of our national security, I was a really progressive national security person.
Tony MartignettiWhat did you do?
Shauna DillavouYou know, the whole community. Yeah, the IC community.
Tony MartignettiI'll just say the IC. The international— I mean, the intelligence community.
Shauna DillavouYeah, I don't usually get too granular with that.
Tony MartignettiOkay.
Shauna DillavouBut
Tony Martignettiwasn't it in the session description? Did it say?
Shauna DillavouIt would have said.
Tony MartignettiNo. All right. If it did, then— I'll say what I thought I read.
Shauna DillavouOkay. Yeah, we can talk about that another time. Okay. Well, I— all right.
Tony MartignettiNo, I'm not sure. I'm pretty sure.
Shauna DillavouBut there again, it's one thing when it's like out on the airwaves versus when it's in like a session thing. All right.
Tony MartignettiSo you came from an intelligence community, a national security background?
Shauna DillavouYeah. And at the time when I was there, I was detailed out to the DEA. This might have been what you read, to train them on finding their targets on the US side of the border of drug trafficking organizations. So we were using these same techniques. I was training them in these techniques to find people. We reverse engineered that now 4 years ago after the 2020 election when Folks were going after Ruby Freeman and Shea Moss for just passing a piece of gum while tallying ballots in Georgia.
Tony MartignettiThe Georgia election workers who won a huge— They now have a penthouse in Manhattan. $20 million settlement from Rudy Giuliani— verdict, not settlement, verdict from Rudy Giuliani.
Shauna DillavouYeah, now have the keys to that penthouse.
Tony MartignettiOkay, interesting. So reverse engineer— I see, reverse engineered your prior work. All right. So referring to your session description, how AI and big data are transforming privacy risks by enabling aggregation. So your concern is that the attempts at spamming people— not spamming, but spoofing, phishing— Yep. So granular and so accurate that they look more and more real.
Shauna DillavouTony.
Tony MartignettiThis is a part of our problem, right?
Shauna DillavouHuge part of the problem.
Tony MartignettiOkay. And people and agencies, people are using artificial intelligence, what, to gather this information? Yep. All of it. And then put it together?
Shauna DillavouCollate.
Tony MartignettiCollate.
Kim SnyderOrganize.
Shauna DillavouAnd then threaten? And then produce. So they will— so, Kate, I think we could probably tag team on this. Do you want to do the production part? So what we see is them gathering data. There's a lot of data that's out there about all of us. And I will—
Tony MartignettiYeah.
Shauna DillavouIf there's one point folks take away from me talking today, in addition to my hype madness, it's that this is not your fault. Our clients come to us and they say, oh, if I just hadn't shared so much on public— on social media publicly when I was younger. And it's like, no, no, this had nothing to do with you. Your public records are being scraped by data brokers every day. If you own a property, if you've ever registered to vote someplace, if you have a driver's license, which you have to have if you want to get on an airplane, that data is being sold or scraped. So that's the data that's the source data for data brokers.
Tony MartignettiAll publicly available? Mm-hmm.
Shauna DillavouYeah. Sometimes for free, sometimes for a cost. Yep.
Tony MartignettiOkay. But publicly available. You don't need to be in— Nope.
Shauna DillavouNot an agency.
Tony MartignettiAn intelligence agency to—
Shauna DillavouThere's no kind of legal process to gather it. Exactly. This is why law enforcement officers, like, Certain law enforcement agencies now go around legal process and will just buy data from data brokers.
Tony MartignettiOh, so much easier than defending a subpoena.
Shauna DillavouThan having to prove it to a judge. Exactly.
Tony MartignettiYou have to prove it to a judge, and then if they move to quash the subpoena, you have to defend it.
Shauna DillavouExactly. So AI can now gather data from various sources. So it could be used to scrape these sites. It can then be used to connect data. Let me share a story. We got a phone call. Like a very concerned client. They had just received a phone call themselves from someone who claimed to have photos of theirs, compromising photos from an old Snapchat account. And on the call, they described a photo that this client— that our client knew that they'd taken, right? It was a photo of a room. They were describing a room. Yeah. And the client's like, I remember that room. I remember that poster that they're describing. I think I might have posted it on Instagram at one point. It was public. But how did they get my number? How do they know where I work? And my response was like, this is a scam. Someone scraped— someone bought a scrape of LinkedIn. Maybe they connected that to your phone number. Maybe you have your phone number connected to LinkedIn because you use it for MFA, for multi-factor authentication. They connected that to a handle on Instagram, probably using your face, facial recognition. Oh my gosh. And then they just made this phone call and talked to you about your employer finding out about these photos, which was a bluff because your employer's name is listed on your LinkedIn profile. That's terrifying for her. And Kim has taken it a step further.
Kim SnyderSo you can stitch all this together, right? And you can process all this data at speeds that never were possible before. But you can also use generative tools to create things. So you can easily mimic a style of someone. So you can also— so part of that data that you grab off of LinkedIn or social is somebody's writing style. So you can, you know, generative AI is really great.
Tony MartignettiTone and style.
Kim SnyderTone and style and also events. So if you're posting about events and things happening, you could get an email from your— purportedly from your executive director or a colleague referencing that event. And things that happen and people who were at that meeting. It depends on how public the data is, and then, you know, that can be used as a basis for a, you know, phishing email that is a lot more convincing.
Shauna DillavouOr a phishing phone call.
Kim SnyderYeah, or a phone call.
Shauna DillavouThis person that called our client was a human, but they don't have to be. We've seen cases where EDs are being impersonated, and it's video and it's audio of them that is so convincing to the people that they're reaching out to.
Kim SnyderAnd this is— it's trivially easy to do, right? In our session, in fact, we had, which one is the real Kim? And there were 2 videos of me, and one of them was not me. It was AI me. But that cost me $29 to take that. So it's not inaccessible. These tools used to be— used to be like really hard to do this.
Tony MartignettiAt this point, it'll probably be free or it'll be $0.25.
Shauna DillavouAnd it's like a photo and 3 seconds of audio, and they can make those videos.
Kim SnyderYeah, and you can have me say—
Tony MartignettiYou don't even need me saying the alphabet or— No,
Shauna Dillavouor Kim's title, for Christ's sake.
Kim SnyderOr half of Kim's title.
Tony MartignettiI did say you could swear. I didn't say you could take the name of the Lord in vain. There's a difference. There's a difference.
Shauna DillavouApologies.
Tony MartignettiThere are boundaries. Even on Nonprofit Radio, there are boundaries.
Shauna DillavouThis is a Christian radio show.
Tony MartignettiAll right, I've gotten these. Dear Tony, I know I could have called you at my number or written to you at my address accurately, but I chose this method instead. So now I know they've got my email and my phone and my address, included a picture of my home, which they probably got from Google Maps, or— right? And some kind of Bitcoin scam.
Shauna DillavouShakedown.
Kim SnyderBut how did that make you feel?
Tony MartignettiThe first one, I was a little like, yeah, I was a little nervous. But, but I've gotten— we all have gotten Bitcoin scams in the past. But this one had like, you know, like you're concerned, like that amount of information, had a lot of— yeah, yeah, it had the right data for you. Message. And I, you know, I ignored it with some trepidation.
Shauna DillavouOf course.
Tony MartignettiAnd then like a day or two later, I got another one. And, you know, yeah, I knew I was—
Shauna DillavouThey just kept coming.
Tony MartignettiIt was bullshit.
Shauna DillavouYeah, I saw one of those from one of our threat intelligence partners, someone who swims in this every day, and it terrified him and his wife. Yeah, because it's so close to you. It's why receiving one of those phone calls, or back in the— I would say back in the day, I got really energized around Gamergate, started to try to support the folks who were being targeted by Gamergate. This is back in 2015, and they would describe what it was like to have You know, I sleep with my phone next to my bed and/or under my pillow. And to have that be the stream of all of this, like, directed hate messages, like, you should kill yourself, or I'm going to do this to you, or I'm going to do this to your parents, or whatever the case might be. It's so proximate that technology removes what feels like barriers between you and everyone else. And the issue with doxxing that's so terrifying is that you don't know who it is. It could be anybody. How do you walk down the street? How do you sleep in your home not terrified? You don't know who's coming after you.
Tony MartignettiThank you. I never thought of the power of that.
Shauna DillavouYou bet. New nightmare unlocked.
Tony MartignettiYeah, thank you very much.
Kim SnyderNo, you know how— but Tony, so you get these things because you're—
Tony MartignettiI mean, you're killing me. You're supposed to be reassuring us here on Nonprofit Radio.
Shauna DillavouWell, we'll get to that part.
Kim SnyderWe will get to that part eventually.
Shauna DillavouYeah, we're great at parties.
Kim SnyderBut, but okay, so you're, you know, more public person, you know, Nonprofit Radio, so, so you get these things. It's a lot unsettling and unnerving for you, right?
Tony MartignettiIt was.
Kim SnyderYeah, I'd like— so imagine how, like, a nonprofit staff person who happens to be working in an organization that may be more targeted by malicious actors.
Tony MartignettiImmigrant rights.
Kim SnyderOkay, so one— so your staff member starts to experience this, and this may— this could freak people out.
Tony MartignettiYeah,
Kim Snyderright. So that's who we're thinking about, um, and kind of raising the awareness.
Tony MartignettiOkay.
Shauna DillavouYeah, I mean, these are folks already dealing with some level of cortisol on a regular basis.
Tony MartignettiBecause of their work. Yeah. Because of their mission. All right, I think we've spent enough time on, uh, great motivation.
Shauna DillavouCool.
Tony MartignettiParanoia, fear.
Shauna DillavouWe're always here for that. And for what do we do?
Tony MartignettiLet's, uh, let's Let's transition, uh, not subtly, very abruptly, to what the hell do we do? What do we do? Is it already— is it already too late?
Shauna DillavouNo, it's never too late.
Tony MartignettiI'm sure, I'm sure, Shauna, you're not gonna say it's too late.
Shauna DillavouNo, otherwise you wouldn't have a business. I wouldn't be here. Yeah, well, I also believe it, and I've had those moments. Listen, I live in DC, and DC Health Link had their data leaked and taken a number of years ago, and my child, who had not even turned a year old, had her Social Security number lost in that breach. And I was like, Oh
Tony Martignettiman.
Shauna DillavouShe's not a year old. You know, like, how is this— this is the world we live in, right? And I turned to my partner and I was like, this is just— I don't even know why we bother. And she's like, you can't— you of all people can't have that feeling. It's okay that you do right now, but you have to keep going. No, there are plenty of ways to ameliorate it.
Tony MartignettiLet's get into them. So we're with you. Why don't we start? Go ahead. Sure. And then we'll go to Kim.
Shauna DillavouYeah, I think you can think about this— so the individual as the vector to threat to the organization. That can be reputational, financial threats to the organization. It could make it hard to fundraise if you don't support that person very well. It would harm your reputation, say, or it could make you look illegitimate to your funders, right? So, if you can think about where the risks are to the organization, that's one set of what-to-dos, right? Action items. And I might leave that with you and speak more to the personal. So when it comes to protecting yourself as an individual, there are plenty of ways that you can work to remove your data online.
Tony MartignettiBy the way, Shauna was referring to Kim, not me.
Shauna DillavouOh yeah, no, Tony's not gonna take that part. No, Kim's got that. Kim, I won't try your title. When it comes to the individual, listen, all of us have data out there. Again, it's not our fault. We have lived a life, right? Like, we've done things. It's— I think it's a betrayal of trust in our own local governments that they sell this data, and no one's ever asked us for consent. They've never invited Okay. So what do you do? You can sign up for one of those services that removes your data from data brokers. We consider that like, like taking Advil, right? Like, it's like kind of taking care of some of the pain and some of the symptoms. What we also recommend is like looking back to the source data itself. So if you own a property that you live in, we always recommend that people consider consider moving it into a revocable trust that they don't name for themselves. We've seen too many estate attorneys call it—
Tony MartignettiCall it the Tony Martignetti Revocable Trust.
Shauna DillavouExactly. Yeah,
Tony Martignettiyeah, with address at— yeah, no, but you won't go that far. But yeah, exactly, a different, right, a different name to the revocable trust.
Shauna DillavouThat's it.
Tony MartignettiSo now the ownership is obscured.
Shauna DillavouExactly. And it matters.
Tony MartignettiData that's already out there. Oh yes, from pre-trust.
Shauna DillavouYes. So This is the argument that our estate attorney always gives us, and we have to educate them on this. They'll say, oh, but it's— your name's going to be on the document granting it to the trust, but your name was there before on tax documents. The way data brokers work is that they're constantly pulling this data down and renewing their data set. So when the new data comes down at this address, they want the most accurate, the most recent. They'll overwrite it. Oh, really? So it may be that you lived at that address at one time, but you don't any longer. And if someone's looking for that address, it's not your name on it. So it will get overwritten, especially over time. What we've seen, wildly enough, is that when that piece comes out, it's like a house of cards. When you pull that property record out, the rest of it tends to fall apart. We see our clients less and less on data—
Tony MartignettiSo property ownership is kind of a, uh, a core or a hub to, to other data.
Shauna DillavouYeah, absolutely. Yeah, I think there's some connections happening there with like app user data that's also on an ISP that's connected to the house, et cetera, et cetera. So there are other pieces about that location that create profiles.
Tony MartignettiIs there anything else we can do on an individual level besides the property ownership?
Shauna DillavouAnother big vector is voter data. And I know that's probably not popular in this audience, because a lot of folks believe a lot in the voter file and voter data and using it. And we often see voter data getting used, getting bought, and getting scraped. And so, we will recommend that folks apply for programs in their states called address confidentiality programs or safe-at-home programs. They're always set up with survivors of intimate partner violence in mind, but a lot of the programs are pretty expansive. So, if folks are concerned about stalking or harassment, they can also apply. And that then gives them a proxy address, in some states, like in New York, across all agencies. So, the DMV is now not going to sell your home address and your name, they're going to sell your name and your proxy address together.
Tony MartignettiAnd shout out the names of those programs that you would look for at your state.
Shauna DillavouYep, Address Confidentiality Program, or Safe at Home. If you're interested, the National Network to End Domestic Violence, NNEDV, And TechSoupTV.org has a comprehensive up-to-date list of those programs.
Tony MartignettiOkay, awesome. Kim, before we turn to Kim, I think you're the perfect question— perfect question answer person. You're a person. You're neither a question nor an answer. Not yet anyway. You're just a person with a lot of answers.
Shauna DillavouI hope so.
Tony MartignettiI read once, it's so hard to unforget, you know, to unlearn things, that the value of stolen data is really in the future. Maybe it's more financial, like, so that the bad actor can act without you tying it to a specific event. So my credit card, let's say a credit card number is compromised, it's of more value if it's 3 years old than if it's just a couple weeks, it was just stolen a couple weeks ago. Is that true or is that incorrect?
Shauna DillavouI can see that, I can see that being true. Maybe we've gotten a little bit better, banks and credit cards have gotten better about just reissuing new cards. Websites tend to push you to change your password when they've alerted you that there's a breach. Yeah. So, I think the private companies, more so than government agencies, but private companies, I think, have caught on to that a little bit. And I think there is some truth, if it's not for financial means, but really someone trying to go after you. We call that an ideologically motivated attacker. What we saw—
Tony MartignettiYou talk like a real intelligence officer.
Shauna DillavouThank you.
Tony MartignettiYou used the word vector before.
Shauna DillavouI did. Yeah, this is my background. So what we found with a university, a client that's a university, their students were being targeted. Some of these outside groups showed up to student houses over the summer. The students had already graduated. We'd gotten some of their address stuff removed, the addresses weren't available in connection to their names online any longer. So, what we think happened was that those addresses, that was screenshot and saved. That can happen. Okay. Yeah. So, it's not a perfect fix. However, what if you have one— as an intelligence officer, if you have one data point, say you have that screenshot, but then you have all these other things telling you that Shauna Dillavou no longer lives at that screenshot address, you might show up there, but you're not going to spend a lot of time on it because You can't verify it. You can't confirm it with another source.
Tony MartignettiOkay.
Shauna DillavouMake sense?
Tony MartignettiYes. Thank you. Thank you. All right. Kim, let's turn to you on the organizational level. What, what can we do there to protect ourselves from what's already out there? How do we help nonprofits, small and mid-sized? Those are our listeners.
Kim SnyderAll right. So for many years, the, the kind of mantra has been to verify. Verify, verify, verify.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Thank you very much. That's Kim Snyder and Shauna Dillavou. No, I'm joking.
Shauna DillavouHe's like, I'm done.
Tony MartignettiWe're out of time. No, we're out of time.
Kim SnyderAre we out of time?
Tony MartignettiNo. I'm kidding.
Kim SnyderI'm an only child. I fall for jokes very easily.
Tony MartignettiI wish I had known. Total sucker. I had so many more in mind for you specifically. Talk about a targeted attack. Oh my, talk about a vector. Yeah,
Shauna DillavouI'm one big vector sitting here.
Tony MartignettiI was coming right at you.
Shauna DillavouI could have written that joke.
Kim SnyderNow you're putting this on the airwaves.
Tony MartignettiNow I know how vulnerable you are. Oh man, okay, I got all kinds of advantages. All right, I'm sorry, I interrupted you wildly.
Kim SnyderWhat was I even talking about?
Tony MartignettiAll right, Shauna's dying. Go ahead. Okay, I'm sorry.
Kim SnyderSo we used to talk in cybersecurity world about, you know, verification. Verify, verify, verify. That was The mantra, right? So now we kind of reshape that so that it's vet and verify. So have kind of multiple ways of verifying, especially incoming requests. Anything kind of— trust your spider sense is what I'd say. If something seems a little bit off—
Tony MartignettiLike what? What are we talking about?
Kim SnyderSo if you receive an email, if an email comes and it, you know, it comes If it comes from your development director who's referencing something that you just went to— You
Tony Martignettijust had a previous panel. Or if it comes from accounting. Write a check. We need an urgent check.
Kim SnyderIf any money is involved and it wasn't like completely expected, even if it was a little expected. Actually, I've seen this happen where people got into nonprofit systems and using AI can scan what's going on very quickly. And then target things that are about to happen from kind of—
Shauna DillavouThings that
Kim Snyderare expected.
Tony MartignettiInstinct, gut, right? Use instinct too?
Kim SnyderOkay, use your instinct, but also make it a policy. Make it a process that you just follow. Uncomplicated process for verifying, like any financial transaction needs to be verified, even if it's expected.
Shauna DillavouYeah, absolutely.
Tony MartignettiEven if expected.
Kim SnyderYeah, so you want to walk through that. You just get much, much more deliberate about verification and who is it coming from. And you don't want to—
Tony MartignettiConfirming. Did you send this email? Not replying to the email, but confirming by phone.
Kim SnyderYeah, exactly. You want to do—
Tony MartignettiDid you send this email about this rush transaction or routine transaction?
Kim SnyderYes, so you do it in a different format, right?
Tony MartignettiDifferent channel. Yeah.
Kim SnyderAnd even though the instinct may be email back quickly, but no.
Shauna DillavouNope.
Kim SnyderRight? But then what you do also is create a culture in your organization where that's okay to do, where it's okay to take that extra 30 seconds, minute to verify, to ask someone for their time, to say, I just want to check, did you send this to me? And in that way, it's okay, even if it's the executive director, you can say, did you send this to me? I just want to make sure. And so that that's an okay thing. In fact, that's a good thing to do.
Tony MartignettiNow, we can't— now, there have to be boundaries around this because we can't do it for every message we get. So you mentioned financial transactions. Financial transactions. I'm nervous.
Kim SnyderNo, no, no, not nervous at all. Financial transactions, any kind of initiated correspondence where they're asking you for something or for some information.
Shauna DillavouI saw a scam recently where the— An old employee was trying to be reinstated and wanted to go around HR to IT to get their accounts reset up. Like, I'm coming back, and it was like using the person's middle name, so it was already a little bit fishy, but they went all the way up to the CTO of the company and said, hey, so-and-so, and these people were friends on LinkedIn and like had shared messages back and forth, so the attacker knew this was a personal relationship. Yeah. Hey, so-and-so, I'm trying to get reinstated. I'm devastated. They're telling me I need to go to HR, but, like, I— but IT can do this. I just need to get my account access back up and online. And the CTO is like, nah, bro, you got to go through HR. I can't do anything. Because they had those controls in place. Right. But small— and let's be fair— small and medium-sized organizations don't. Right.
Tony MartignettiI'll save you 20 minutes going through HR. I'll just take care of it now. Yeah. Yeah, that's a mistake.
Kim SnyderOr we don't have a— we don't have a process. We don't have any clear guidelines that we give to people, for all requests would need to go to HR.
Tony MartignettiI thought of another potentially nefarious request. Sure. Send your logo. I need a high-def of the logo. You know, the JPEG I have is not good. I need a high-definition logo. That could be to produce a check.
Kim SnyderSure.
Tony MartignettiThat could be to make a spoof website.
Kim SnyderYep.
Tony MartignettiOkay. I mean, but it seems innocuous. Send a logo. Yeah,
Kim Snyderit's very easy to spoof a website, right? So, you know, check, also check where it's coming from, right? So, you know, I've had an organization where there were 2 spoofed, there were spoofs on both ends, a spoof of the funder, a spoof of the grantee.
Shauna DillavouCan you tell us more about that story? It's a really good one.
Kim SnyderSo yeah, so they got into to an organization's, um, you know, Microsoft environment.
Tony MartignettiAsk the questions here.
Kim SnyderI'm sorry. Whoops.
Tony MartignettiGo ahead. Uh-oh, turn off the mic. Mic 3.
Shauna DillavouTony's like fired.
Tony MartignettiMic 3, zero. Dillough. All right, go ahead, Kim.
Kim SnyderSo, um, anyway, it's late in the day. It's like 2:30. And I'm thirsty.
Tony MartignettiYeah, we're late in the day. It's all right. It's not— it's, it's Well, it's almost 3 o'clock.
Kim SnyderYeah, I've been going since 10 nonstop. Anyway, all right. So the organization had someone get into their systems for a very short time, but in that short time, they were able to tease out some information. Again, this is— AI can help with this kind of analysis, short, you know, can analyze a lot of data that it can grab very quickly and identified some upcoming financial transactions. Which were rather large. And so, in order to kind of trick the person to sending to the wrong place, they set up fake websites. Fake websites for the foundation, fake websites for the grantee, and domains, not websites, domains. And so then they had emails coming back and forth, you could hardly see the difference.
Tony MartignettiYeah.
Kim SnyderAnd so the real people, the real people were communicating with the bad actor on both sides, and the money got sent to the wrong place. Okay.
Tony MartignettiDid they recover it?
Kim SnyderYeah, that was a— that was actually— no, they did
Shauna Dillavougreat.
Kim SnyderBut, but it was— that was a— that has a happy ending, but not necessarily.
Tony MartignettiAll right, we started with Shauna, so we're gonna end with Kim. Great. Uh, give us— oh no, we started with Kim. You did the overview.
Shauna DillavouOh shit. Okay.
Tony MartignettiWell, I'm not— Shauna, your mic is down.
Kim SnyderBut that was one—
Tony MartignettiShe still gets through. She talks and laughs so loud you hear her over Kim's mic. No, I didn't. I did not turn her—
Kim SnyderBut one more thing before we— unless we're totally out of time. Don't shoot the messenger. So create a culture. This is another thing that any size nonprofit can do, where if something happens, if you click on that thing, if you did that thing that you feel like, ugh, that was really dumb. Right? Make it okay to report that.
Tony MartignettiYeah, report yourself.
Kim SnyderAnd you don't get in trouble, and there's no shame and blame because it happens.
Shauna DillavouWe all do it.
Kim SnyderYeah, the no-blame kind of— we encourage you to, you know, say it.
Tony MartignettiYeah, call yourself out.
Kim SnyderYeah.
Tony MartignettiAll right.
Kim SnyderAnd there's no punishment. You know, some organizations, like, they don't want bad news. All
Tony Martignettiright, we're gonna leave it there. Okay. Okay. All right, that's Kim Snyder, Virtual Digital Privacy Project and Program Officer at RoundTable Technology, and Shauna Dillavou, CEO.
Shauna DillavouNailed it. CEO.
Tony MartignettiBrightlines. Thank you, Kim. Thank you, Shauna.
Shauna DillavouIt's a pleasure.
Tony MartignettiShauna laughed her ass off. I'm sorry.
Shauna DillavouYeah, I had a really good sense of humor.
Tony MartignettiAll right, I love it. And thank you for being with a, well, whimsical, I'm not sure covers it, raucous maybe? At one point anarchical because there was a question that I did not answer session. Thank you for being with us at 25 NTC for this episode sponsored by Heller Consulting, technology services for nonprofits. Thank you. Virtual Digital Privacy Project and Program Officer.
Shauna DillavouThat's good.
Kate MartignettiIt's time for Tony's Take Two.
Tony MartignettiThank you, Kate. A new Tales from the Gym episode just happened this morning. This very morning, I was minding my own business, as I do, on the elliptical, and overheard two women talking. One lives here permanently. And the other one who said her name, Sandra Lynn, she lives in North Carolina, but not here in Emerald Isle. She lives in the Raleigh area. Like, that's about 3 and a half hours, 4 hours away, roughly. And she was lamenting, Sandra Lynn was, that she can't live here full-time. House prices are high. Right. And she also still has her mother and her father-in-law. So her husband's father are still both alive. And so she needs to stay in that area. But she was, you know, looking forward to retiring here sometime, but lamenting that she couldn't live here now. And that got me thinking as I was on my 6th or 7th interval on the elliptical. I do 8, do 8 episodes, well, 8, not episodes. What did I just say? 8 intervals. I do 7 intervals of a minute, take a minute in between, and then the last interval is 2 and a half minutes. I was toward the end and it got me thinking, listening to Sandra Lynn, that I'm grateful that I do live here full-time, permanent. This is my home. And that, you know, it's that there are other people who don't live here who wish they could, you know. So, you know, I add, I have a long list of gratitudes, but I don't specifically say grateful that I live here in Emerald Isle full-time. So I'm going to add that to my gratitudes that I do every Like I've told you, every 2, 3 times a week, I'm adding gratitude that I live here in Emerald Isle full-time, in this beautiful place, and I have the ocean across the street. Your own gratitudes. I hope you're, I hope you're doing your gratitudes out loud at least a couple of times a week. That is Tony's Take Two. Kate.
Kate MartignettiYou do sets.
Tony MartignettiWell, sets are for yeah. Now that's different intervals. Intervals on an elliptical. You do a minute hard and then a minute resting, and then a minute hard and a minute resting. It's called high intensity interval training. H I I T. High intensity. It just means you do intervals of things like you sprint. Yeah, I don't run. I'm on an elliptical, but you might sprint. And then walk and then sprint and then walk and sprint and walk. Those are called intervals. Sets are like you do 3 sets of 10 if you're, if you're on a weight machine or something like that. Or maybe pushups might be 3 sets of 10 or something like that. I don't know. They seem to be a different— well, I think the interval is because you're still active. You're just resting in between the high-intensity intervals.
Kate MartignettiGotcha.
Tony MartignettiDoes that make sense?
Kate MartignettiYes. And I am grateful that you have a beach house. Yeah, because you get to—
Tony Martignettiyeah, you get to visit and, uh, mosey around and, uh, what is the word I'm looking for? Uh, not schmooze, but, uh, you get to, uh, I don't know.
Kate MartignettiI can pretend that it's my beach house. Yeah,
Tony Martignettiyou can for a week. Yes. But then, uh, then I'm very happy to say goodbye. After a week.
Kate MartignettiLove you too. Sorry. We've got beaucoup buttloads more time. Here is Balance AI Ethics and Innovation.
Tony MartignettiHello and welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio coverage of 25NTC, the 2025 Nonprofit Technology Conference. where our coverage is sponsored by Heller Consulting, technology services for nonprofits. With me now is Gozi Egbuonu. Gozi is Director of Programs at the Technology Association of Grantmakers. Gozi, welcome to Nonprofit Radio. Awesome, thank you for having me, Tony. Pleasure, you're welcome. Your session is AI Strategy for Grantmakers. Strategy for Nonprofits: Navigate Ethics and Innovation. We have plenty of time together, but can you give me a high-level view of the topic and the session that you did?
Gozi EgbuonuSure. So the session was really spearheaded by Beth Kanter, and it basically provides a balcony view of where we are in the sector in terms of AI adoption, ethical, responsible AI adoption in the nonprofit philanthropy sector. And so we really start with what we found in the Technology Association of Grantmakers State of Philanthropy Tech Survey that we did in 2024. In that survey, we found what many grantmakers are currently doing with AI as far as, you know, are they testing, are they experimenting, has anyone rolled it out enterprise level, which is, you know, at the organization-wide level. And what we found is that— I mean, which mirrors quite what we're seeing in the nonprofit world, is that most folks are not using AI in terms of, you know, anything that's crazy, you know, innovative at this moment. It's really just kind of, you know, meeting summaries, you know, taking notes, that sort of thing. And so, and but in addition to that, we found that while 81% of folks are using AI— sorry, while— oh, sorry, 81% are using AI, but only 30% Sure. Have AI use policies. So you're using it, but you don't have any guardrails. You have no way to tell your teams or your staff, hey, this is what we don't put into the AI, this is what we do put in. So you're really running the risk of having your information potentially used in a way or trained an AI model that, um, you know, could potentially put your members at risk, your grantees at risk, whatever the case is for your organization. And so with that little bit of an overview, it basically came down to the importance of AI experimentation and really starting slow, starting at the very base level, working with your teams to kind of talk through, should we use AI? If we did use AI, what would that be for? So thinking about the use cases, the business, um, the business use, like what would be the business case for it? And then, you know, assembling a nice team of folks, you know, as advisors or experimenters and champions at your organization To really kind of help you all start doing that experimentation in a safe and low, kind of like low-risk way. And then from there, really defining whether or not AI is your next move. And then once you do decide that AI is the next move, you want to move into that next level of the AI maturity, which Beth, you know, covers really, really well. You know, you go from that exploration to discovery and then you move into experimentation, then ultimately enterprise. eventually. But what we're finding is that most folks are not there yet. They're still very much in experimentation.
Tony MartignettiThe early stage.
Gozi EgbuonuVery early stage. And you get to kind of get to see a case study of it through the work that Luana did at her organization, United Way Worldwide.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Well, we don't have Luana with us, but you can provide a lot of context, a lot of detail. Absolutely. As you said, you could talk. All right. Are we— do you know, it might not be part of what you surveyed, but was there even intentionality around should we— the should we use question, or did it just kind of happen because people started hearing about it and using ChatGPT?
Gozi EgbuonuWell, you know, with one of the questions that we did on the survey, we found that like there's quite a few folks that are using it in what we call shadow use or shadow AI, which is basically you're using AI, but your organization doesn't know you're using it.
Tony MartignettiI see. All right. So that's not intentionality at the organization level?
Gozi EgbuonuNo. No.
Tony MartignettiI would say not.
Gozi EgbuonuNot. Yeah. So we really want to encourage the intentionality, which is don't start using the AI unless you all have that collective organizational conversation of, is this something that we should be doing? Is it useful? Is there a business case to go with it? Is it relevant? Does it make sense? Is it safe for our organization? Does it align with our ethics? And then consider going into experimentation.
Tony MartignettiOkay, let's explore that question a little bit now in 2025, because I suspect in '26 NTC, we won't be asking the threshold question, should we use? So what belongs in the conversation if we're at the stage where, well, individuals may be using it, but we don't know, or if nobody's using it and we're trying to decide enterprise-wide, you know, is there not— we're not even at the, is there a use case? Like, but should we, should we explore it? What goes into that conversation?
Gozi EgbuonuSure. Um, again, that, you know, really thinking about the business case. So when you're having that conversation about should we use AI, then you have to think about what would be the specific usage of it, right? So Say you're the finance team and you're considering using AI. What would be the benefit of using AI versus doing this, doing the, the workflow or process that you currently have and you're thinking of having AI do? So you really kind of have to have that conversation, like an in-depth conversation about the process that you're doing right now. Is there anything wrong with it? Are we losing anything? Could we gain productivity, time in our days and our schedules if we were to move to using AI to do this one process or this one, this one workflow. Then at that point you think about, okay, maybe we do get a benefit out of it. Now that we get a benefit out of it, what are some of the things that we have to be concerned about now that we have a benefit? Is it that now we don't want to make sure— we want to make sure that any financial information that could be sensitive to any of our donors or their, their personal information, do we not want to have that being able to be, you know, used in the AI model or whatever system that we're using? So, you know, you start with, here's how we do things, here's how AI could potentially benefit, and then you move into that conversation. Okay, if we did, what are some of the risks and concerns? Really thinking through all of them as much as you can. We know that you can't think for every single possibility, but as much as you can kind of write it out and map it out as a group with several folks in the room, the better that you are at being able to say yes or no on moving on with AI as that potential new solution.
Tony MartignettiOkay. goes into this intentionality is a usage, a use policy. You're, you're, you know, you want us to be thinking about ethical uses. Okay. What, what are the, what are the ethical concerns? How can you, how can we talk through those?
Gozi EgbuonuWell, you know, one of the key ethical concerns is that we know that most AI models that exist now, including OpenAI, were trained on the internet. And we know the internet can be
Tony Martignettiwildly biased.
Gozi EgbuonuWildly biased, filled with lots of terrible things.
Tony MartignettiAnd not only biased, but misinformed.
Gozi EgbuonuMisinformed.
Tony MartignettiDeadly wrong. Dead wrong. Yeah. All right.
Gozi EgbuonuYes. Complete nonsense in a lot of cases. And so if you're using these OpenAI sources that have been trained on the internet, then you have to be really careful about deciding to use it against, say, your theory of change. So if you're an organization that is serving Um, vulnerable populations, groups that are already kind of under attack, whatever the case is. Do you want to have AI making or informing your decisions related to work that you're doing with these vulnerable groups? More than likely no, because the AI may choose to do things that are more in line with a group that is biased, that may have, you know, maybe unethical. And so you want to make sure that whatever you're using the AI to do, that it isn't putting the organizations and the people that you support and serve in harm's way. So really thinking through, hey, if we're going to use it in this way, maybe we need to use it in a way that does not put these groups in harm. Maybe we just focus on using it internally, like folks do for their meeting notes, because that's a very low-risk thing. Whereas if you're, you know, inputting, you know, decisions about whether or not to continue funding an organization or trying to measure or not whether or not their impact is aligning with your organization's missions and values, some of those, those questions are not as clear-cut as yes or no. Whereas an AI that is trained on purely just wanting to see impact, purely wanting to see a return on investment, which is not always the case of what happens in philanthropy, then you really have to take a step back and say, is this the most ethical decision to go forward, could we be putting organizations in harm?
Tony MartignettiNow, you can control what a model is trained on. Yes. But that requires something proprietary, right? You have to pay a developer to create that. I don't know what it's called, a small language model. I don't know what it's called, but something that's trained only on your own data, your own website, maybe your own documents that you provide it. But that requires a fee and a developer.
Gozi EgbuonuExactly. It can cost. It can be expensive. The other option is if you don't want to go the route of creating your own AI, you do a paid version because we know the free versions of AI, specifically I'll talk about OpenAI, there's not a whole lot of freedom or flexibility in turning off the settings to prevent it from training the model on the data that you input. And so in that case, you definitely need a use policy because some folks would probably just be like, I really need to, you know, analyze all of this data on all of the groups that we served in this, you know, community that is already really, you know, under attack or potentially in harm's way. And then now you're putting that information into the AI to have it, you know, into the free AI to start doing its analysis. And now the AI has all of these people's information and can now use it to provide it to other people who may That's
Tony Martignettian unmitigated disaster. You've shared data that— and now it's gone.
Gozi EgbuonuIt's in the world.
Tony MartignettiYeah, there's no control.
Gozi EgbuonuNo.
Tony MartignettiAll right, so yes, great, enormous intentionality, care. What if we don't have a chief technology officer, chief information officer? You know, it's an executive director, CEO, and maybe a decent-sized staff. I don't know, 35, 40 people, but they still don't have a chief technology officer. How do we ensure the intentionality and care that you want us to?
Gozi EgbuonuYes. There's a couple of ways, and I think—
Tony MartignettiGood. Oh, good.
Gozi EgbuonuI think at the core of it, you don't have to have a CTO, and even yourself, you don't have to be a technologist. I would never classify myself as a technologist, but we can— there's ways to find training. There's plenty of training. NTEN has fantastic training for AI certifications for professionals in the nonprofit sector. And I'd love to share that NTEN and TAG are teaming up, and we will be offering one for philanthropy professionals very soon. And so these are opportunities, very, you know, relatively easy ways for people who don't have that technical background to learn about the AI itself, get themselves familiarized with, you know, what they need to be doing to protect themselves and their staff, ways that they can start to experiment in a safe, you know, safe space. So, and there's plenty of also free tools, free education. I will, you know, even though I've talked about OpenAI a lot, OpenAI just announced their OpenAI Academy, which has all free resources and tools for learning how to utilize AI. For anyone. And so there are plenty of free resources out there and people online, you know, there's plenty of folks on LinkedIn that I see on a regular basis that are sharing information and providing some guidance for nonprofit leaders as well as folks that are just not technically inclined. So there's ways that you can kind of upskill and train yourself to understand how to use AI even if you don't have that technical experience in-house.
Tony MartignettiSay a little more about this partnership, can you? About between NTEN and its TAG, Technical Association of Grantmakers.
Gozi EgbuonuYes, Technology Association.
Tony MartignettiPardon me, Technology Association of Grantmakers.
Gozi EgbuonuThank you. Yeah, so I don't have a whole lot of details to share, but essentially, if you've used any of the great training and certification resources on the NTEN website, we are essentially trying to make a parallel version of that same professional certification for nonprofit leaders using AI for our foundation leaders. And so you can expect really kind of a similar learning process, but however, it'll be tailored to some of the different functions and needs that we find at the philanthropy, you know, at foundations versus what you would see at a traditional nonprofit.
Tony MartignettiOkay. So, I'm sorry, it's intended for foundations?
Gozi EgbuonuYeah, foundation leaders. Yeah, for foundation professionals, I should say.
Tony MartignettiOkay. All right. All right, what goes— so thank you. You know, that's important ethical considerations. Anything more on ethics? Because then I want to talk about the policy, what belongs in your use policy. But is there more about ethical concerns? I think we covered it. Okay, enormous. I mean, if you're exposing your data and it's gone, it's out there. Like you said. All right, our use policy that only 1/3, so 30-some percent, have, although 80-some percent are using AI. Yeah, what goes into this use policy?
Gozi EgbuonuThe use policy essentially just outlines what you and your teams should be thinking about before you ever use any AI. So it's kind of that no-go or go kind of conversation. So, If it's sensitive data, if it's information related to any of your members that you just wouldn't want anyone to have outside of your organizational members, probably wouldn't want to put it into an AI system. So it just kind of outlines, you know, essentially guardrails for teams and staff to understand how to best utilize it. And I think some folks are also, you know, thinking about the environmental impacts of using AI are really now making sure that their data use policy or the AI policy policies are also, you know, having folks be ethical about how they're using and when they're using AI, right? So, you know, if it's to do something that could take you probably about the same time that the AI does, don't use the AI. If you're just, you know, just tossing anything, any old thing in there, asking questions all day, probably also not a very useful use, good use of AI. You really want to think about AI very strategically. Yeah. and intentionally, right? You want to make sure that if you're going to the AI, it's for something that you know it's going to save you significant amounts of time. One of the things that I often will use AI for is drafting, you know, large descriptions for events. That takes me sometimes hours. If I give it to AI, it can do it for me in seconds. And the key to—
Tony MartignettiDescriptions of events?
Gozi EgbuonuYes. Like, so we have webinars, events that we have on our website. Yeah. So, you know, I, I don't want to say they're talking about all the learning that you're going to get out of it and the objectives and this and that. And so AI, I've trained, I have like a GPT that is based on kind of like my voice that I provide it like, hey, here's the prompt, here's what I'm kind of looking for. It provides me a draft and then I use that draft and I manipulate it how I want. And so you really want to make sure that, you know, when you're prompting the AI or you're using the AI, it's, they've measured it, I think one prompt uses as much energy, I think, as like an entire city. Like, it's crazy. It's like, like, it— don't quote me on that, but— It's enormous. It's enormous. There's quite a bit of energy. And I can actually, actually share a link to, um, one of the stats that came out about it. There's a researcher that's been sharing a lot about it, um, and she was just interviewed by, uh, I believe it was Dr. Joy Buolamwini, on, uh, by the, um, the AI Justice, uh, group that she, she leads, um, and So there's a lot of it. There's a lot of energy being used. So if you're going to use it, you want to make sure that it's for something that you don't need to— you want to learn prompting, good prompting, so you can get what you need out of it. And then you can make— you can, you know, refine it and make it better. Sometimes you may have to go back in and ask the AI to refine, you know, what it did. But you really do want to keep it to a minimum. You don't want to be using AI constantly because the energy use and the impact on the environment is extreme, extreme.
Tony MartignettiThat gets over to the ethical concerns. As well.
Gozi EgbuonuExactly. Because it's— yeah, so yeah, you're, you're just really, um, basically telling your teams, here's the— here's what we expect out of you when you're using AI, and these are the things that could result in consequences if you don't follow this policy.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Um, what else? Anything more about the policy? What, what belongs in there?
Gozi EgbuonuUm, you know, I think the, the key thing is like, you know, making your teams aware of the types of AI that are provisioned, because that's another thing. Some organizations have taken the decision to block certain AIs that they don't want you using, or even turning off certain AI functions in their current tech stack. So you want to make sure that it's really outlined very clearly, the types of AI that are in use. Okay. And also, it may— you You may want to include something in there about how you communicate your use of AI to your teams or other people outside of your organization. So, kind of a nice little bucket of what's internal, external, and then also where can you go with AI and where should you not go.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Including disclosures to the public. Yeah. Why would there be some platforms that are ruled out?
Gozi EgbuonuWell, because, you know, one of the things that I've seen some members talking about within, you know, the TAG space is that there are some AI that do not allow you, or some systems that do not allow you to turn off the AI function, meaning that you don't have any control of how that AI is taking your data that you have in that tech stack or that tech tool.
Tony MartignettiOh, you don't have control? Oh, no. Oh, all right.
Gozi EgbuonuYeah. And in fact, there was actually a conversation about specifically a DAF platform that actually made this clear to many, many of our members who use it. And so that is something that you really have to be concerned about, is do you have any level of control? If you don't have any level of control in how the AI is using your data in that system, there are organizations that would likely say this isn't— this is not a system that we would allow you to use.
Tony MartignettiOkay. All right. It's a good example. Um, what else came out of the session? We still have a couple more What else did you talk about in the session that, uh, that you can share with us?
Gozi EgbuonuYou know, one of the great things that we did was we did these scenarios, um, that Beth put together about, you know, what are some of the things that you would say if you're in a situation when— where, you know, say for instance, uh, your organization is really excited about using AI, they want to jump headfirst, and they just want to start using AI without, you know, and they, they basically just want you to start Rolling it out and get your teams on board. And so in that scenario, we really talked through all of the processes. You know, first of all, that first conversation that we talked about, like should we even use AI? That didn't happen, so that needed to happen. The other part is also, you know, how fast do we want to roll things out? What are some of the different change management principles that we should be thinking about as a team that could make AI adoption more beneficial and successful? So really, you know. Starting slow, but really starting at the very beginning of like, should we or should we not? Like, that should be your— because truthfully, many organizations do not need AI. It's true. I mean, it's just the reality. Some organizations will never probably need to use AI, and then there's a whole lot of them that probably will. So that question of like, should we do it, has to happen first. Um, and I think—
Tony MartignettiAnd if you're doing it on your own as a rogue, stop. Do it on your own time. You want to practice on it, do it after hours and on weekends.
Gozi EgbuonuExactly, exactly. Not on our computers, not on our systems. Yeah, yeah. If you— and that's actually one of the things that, um, you know, we've seen a lot of our members and foundations, and I think Beth has also seen with, you know, some of the work she's done in the, in the sector, is that a lot of foundations are now trying to just get to the staff and say, hey, look, we know that you're using— can you just tell us? And trying to make that trust, build that trust with each other. And I think that's going to be really That would be a good way to help prevent a lot of the issues.
Tony MartignettiAll right, let us know, but then stop. No, there's no repercussion for reporting yourself, but only— well, only up to what you report. After the report date, you're liable. All right, stop it.
Gozi EgbuonuExactly.
Tony MartignettiOkay, going rogue. All right, anything else? Oh, questions? Any provocative or— Memorable questions that came from the audience?
Gozi EgbuonuI'm trying to think. Um, no. Well, you know, the one that had come up was just, uh, you know, there was a, there was someone at the front that had asked about, you know, AI hallucinates. And that was, and, you know, should you hallucinate? It hallucinates. Yeah. And the person was basically saying, you know, be careful using it as an organization because it could give you answers that are just factually wrong. Yeah. And so, you know, our response was like, yeah, you're right, AI does hallucinate. But that's why it's incredibly important. And I, and I didn't even say this myself, but at the beginning, which is if you use AI, you always want to make sure that it's for something that you have a certain level or high level of expertise or knowledge about. So, you know, if I'm asking asking it to write descriptions for me. I know about the event details, so then I'm not just going to let the AI write a description and let it go and put it on the website. Sounds good. Yeah, that sounds good. I'm gonna put it— no, you review it. You make sure that the details it's including are correct. If there's any statistics or numbers that are being used, you can go and verify those data. So if you're ever using AI for anything, you should always have a human in the loop. There should be someone that's able to verify the information, especially if you're someone that's not knowledgeable in that Specific thing that you ask AI to do.
Tony MartignettiYou need someone who is
Gozi Egbuonuexactly
Tony Martignettieither that or it's going to be written at such a high level that it's maybe not has no value.
Gozi EgbuonuExactly, exactly.
Tony MartignettiAll right, all right. How about we leave? Are you okay leaving it there? You feel like we covered this?
Gozi EgbuonuI think we did.
Tony MartignettiOkay, all right, all right. Gozi Egboono, Egboonu, Egboonu, Gozi Egboonu.
Gozi EgbuonuPerfect.
Tony MartignettiDirector of Programs at Technology Association of Grantmakers. Gozi, thank you very much for sharing all that.
Gozi EgbuonuThank you for having me, Tony.
Tony MartignettiMy pleasure. And thank you for being with Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio coverage of 25 NTC, where we are sponsored by Heller Consulting, technology services for nonprofits.
Kate MartignettiNext week, 2 25 NTC conversations to help your fundraising events. If you missed any part of this week's show, I beseech you, find it at tonymartignetti.com.
Tony MartignettiAnd now that DonorBox is gone, I miss our alliteration— fast, flexible, friendly fundraising forms. Uh, I missed that. All right, well, I am grateful to DonorBox though for 2 years of sponsorship. Very grateful. Grateful. There's another gratitude. I'm grateful to DonorBox. Now that they're not a sponsor anymore, I'm grateful to them. No, I, I've been grateful. I just haven't said it.
Kate MartignettiOkay. Our creative producer is Claire Meyerhoff. I'm your associate producer, Kate Martignetti. The show's social media is by Susan Chavez. Marc Silverman is our web guy, and this music is by Scott Stein.
Tony MartignettiThank you for that affirmation, Scotty. Be with us next week for Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. Go out and be great. Thank you.

More Episodes from 2025 Nonprofit Technology Conference
View All
Your Emergency Marketing Plan & Your More Diverse Board
with Sarah Allen, Julia Molinaro, Michelle Shen, and Jonathan Meagher-Zayas

MDEDNNPut The Fun In Fundraising & Adopt New Software
with Sarah Angello, Dinesh Nadar, Melissa Dickinson, Evelyn Dickinson, and Nikki Neuen




Inclusive & Engaging Virtual Meetings & RFP: Request For Partnership
with Tiffany Ferguson, Akailah Jenkins McIntyre, Kylie Aldridge Ogden, and Ashley Stagg


