Skip to content
EP 728February 23, 2025

Prudence In Our Political Environment

Tony MartignettiGene TakagiAmy Sample Ward
Nonprofit Radio
Episode 728
0:00 / 0:00

About this episode

Following from our December episode, “Is It Paranoia Or Prudence?,” Gene Takagi and Amy Sample Ward return with updates from the grass roots on DEI, USAID and other spending freezes, major media capitulation, and information on a potential reincarnation of last year’s H.R. 9495 bill. Most importantly, they share advice and resources on how to cope—and keep your nonprofit in the safest posture. Gene is our legal contributor from NEO Law Group. Amy is our technology contributor and CEO of NTEN.

Here’s the transcript

Tony MartignettiHello and welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. I'm your aptly named host and the podfather of your favorite hebdomadal podcast. Oh, I'm glad you're with us. I'd suffer the embarrassment of metathesiophobia if you changed your routine and missed this week's show. Here's our associate producer Kate with what's on the menu.

Kate MartignettiHey, Tony. I hope our listeners are hungry for prudence in our political environment. Following from our December episode, Is it paranoia or prudence? Gene Takagi and Amy Sample Ward return with updates from the grassroots on DEI, USAID and other spending freezes, major media capitulation, and information on a potential reincarnation of last year's HR 9495 bill. Most importantly, they share advice and resources on how to cope. And keep your nonprofit in the safest posture. Gene is our legal contributor from NEO Law Group. Amy is our technology contributor and CEO of NTEN. On Tony's Take Two.

Tony MartignettiThe activist group I co-host.

Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by DonorBox. Outdated donation forms blocking your supporters' generosity? DonorBox, fast, flexible, and friendly fundraising forms for your nonprofit. donorbox.org. Here is Prudence in Our Political Environment.

Tony MartignettiIt's always a genuine pleasure to welcome back Gene and Amy, our esteemed contributors at Nonprofit Radio. Gene Takagi, Our legal contributor and principal of NEO, the Nonprofit and Exempt Organizations Law Group in San Francisco. He edits that wildly popular nonprofitlawblog.com and is a part-time lecturer at Columbia University. You'll find the firm at neolawgroup.com, and Gene is @GTAK, G-T-A-K. Amy Sample Ward, our technology contributor and CEO of NTEN. They were awarded a 2023 Bosch Foundation Fellowship. Yeah, but what have you done lately? That was 2 years ago. And their most recent co-authored book is The Tech That Comes Next, about equity and inclusiveness in technology development. They're on Blue Sky as Amy Sample Ward. Gene and Amy, welcome back.

Gene TakagiThanks, Tony.

Amy Sample WardI never don't laugh when you say Podfather.

Tony MartignettiI'm glad.

Amy Sample WardIt puts me in such a good mood. You know, we're about to talk about like so many sad trombones, but we started with Podfather. So at least I got a laugh while on mute.

Tony MartignettiThank you very much. I'm glad. I'm glad. And you've heard it many times and it still makes you laugh. That's wonderful. Yes. Yes.

Amy Sample WardAnd can I answer your rhetorical question about as if I have not done anything, which I appreciate in like a, that's a very fatherly way of being like, what have you even done? But a plug that was not on our agenda to talk about today. So I'll just say it and then we can move on with the agenda.

Tony MartignettiGo ahead, anarchist. Yes, go ahead.

Amy Sample WardIs incredible NTEN Community Committee gave feedback and Tristan and I and Afua have refined all that feedback. And then the newest version of the Equity Guide is about to be published, the Equity Guide for Nonprofit Technology.

Tony MartignettiThat's Tristan Penn, name dropping Tristan Penn. Yes. Afua Bruce. Afua Bruce, your co-author on the—

Amy Sample WardAnd then like a whole, you know, couple dozen community members who met previously and gave feedback about, you know, none of the previous equity guide content is like gone. But I think as time continues to change, we always wanted it to be a living resource. And just this latest iteration adds a lot more layers about security, privacy, ownership, you know, thinking about the extent that our decisions around technology kind of weave into so many other either potential challenges we're going to face or, or ways of how we're going to operate, you know.

Tony MartignettiWell, I admire that NTEN is leaning into equity and not, uh, shrinking away from it, leaning in affirmatively with an update to your equity guide. All right.

Amy Sample WardWell, because—

Tony MartignettiThat's part of what we're—

Amy Sample WardWe can certainly get into it, but equity as a word is It's not tokenism. It is because we truly believe an equitable world is possible. If we didn't, why are we here? Why are we doing this work if we don't think that beautiful world is possible? You know, and it wouldn't be beautiful if it wasn't for all of us.

Tony MartignettiRight. And it's trying to achieve something that we may never fully achieve. But

Amy Sample Wardyeah,

Tony Martignettithe journey is Meritorious, valuable, important, worthy. All right, we're gonna, we're gonna get to, uh, I don't know, I don't, I don't know if it's a prior—

Amy Sample WardWe'll get to where we get. Yeah. I

Tony Martignettidon't know if it's a prior restraint on speech, uh, uh, using, uh, with token words that you are not using as tokens. I understand that, but, uh, but we're not, we're not quite there. So I want to, uh, open with, uh, just continuing our conversation from December. We were together in December. We promised listeners we would come back together in February. Here Most of our conversation in December was devoted to House Resolution H.R. 9495, which died in the 118th Congress. So now if it's going to come back, it would have to be reintroduced under a new title, but because 9495 died with the old Congress, but that certainly could happen. Gene, you have some insights into what— What we— what, what, and the potential for a reincarnation of the '94-'95 HR?

Gene TakagiYeah, and, um, great to be here with both you and Amy. Uh, first of all, um, HR 9495 did die with the last Congress, but that's because it passed so late in, in, in, in the congressional year. So, um, as we entered into the new Congress at the beginning of January, um, things have to be reintroduced under a different name and number and Well, we're likely to see this come back again because it passed the House and it didn't make it through the Senate, but it was not rejected by the Senate. They just didn't have time to deal with it. The Senate also had a majority of Democrats on their roster at that time. But with the change in Congress at the beginning of the year, now the Republicans control both the House and the Senate. And this vote on H.R. 9495 was very strongly on partisan lines. So if it got reintroduced, there's a very possible chance that it gets passed. So it's something just to think about if that possibility still exists. And we can discuss pros, cons, and likelihood and all the rest. But I'll let you tell us where to go, Tony.

Tony MartignettiWell, let's see, in terms of A new bill. Let's see what does develop. It feels likely to me that something will come. So when it does, I guess that's pretty defeatist, but it's what I believe. When it does come, you know, we'll talk about the details of it because it could be changed from what it what ninety four ninety five was. There there may be changes to it, but also important for folks to know. Gene, that there are other methods through which the executive branch in particular can cause trouble for nonprofits based on the funding activities, whether you're funding or even just talking about people who are perhaps under a terrorist-supported organization or supported by a terrorist-supported organization or once removed from. So these— there are some mechanisms that are already out there that exist right today. They don't need to be passed anew.

Gene TakagiYeah, so HR 9495, or whatever its progeny should, should be if it's similar, is not the most draconian of laws, even though it created sort of panic within the sector. There are existing laws on the book that give the executive branch a lot of discretion to really either revoke 501 status from organizations that are Deemed to support terrorist organizations or even act against fundamental established public policy, whatever that may be. And with our executive branch, well, you know, we talk about kind of all of the things that are harming the nonprofit sector and all the communities that the nonprofit sector benefits, which is everyone. Yes, the executive branch has a whole lot of power to do A lot worse even. So this deluge of executive orders and memos and the like, you know, we'll get into, but there are other laws out there that can even be exercised that are more tough. The danger with 94-95 or whatever might come out of it is that it looks like it's a little bit kinder with a little bit more due process than some of the really harsh laws. Yeah. I'm afraid that that could be a tool of use to be able to justify it and scare the sector by targeting a few organizations and then saying, hey, we're going to do this to anybody that goes against us. And that's my general fear.

Tony MartignettiAnd perhaps making it more palatable because it did include due process that other existing regulations don't include.

Amy Sample WardYeah. Could you say though, as you were talking about, you know, I'm just pretending that I'm a listener and not Having access to the mic right now while you're talking. And, you know, the way you were describing the laws that already exist, access to power that is already available to the executive branch, you use the term terrorist organization. Can you, you know, I think a lot of nonprofits would be like, that's not us, like we're safe here. But can you talk a little bit about how that definition is? Or how that term is defined and used or misused?

Gene TakagiSo there are probably dozens of laws that define terrorist organizations in different contexts. This is outside of the tax code, right? So this is— Yeah.

Amy Sample WardNo one's putting on their 990, yes, I'm a terrorist organization.

Gene TakagiBut the fear, I think, and why 94-95 arose in the legislature is, I think, because— not because they wanted another tool to stop terrorism or support of terrorism. I think it arose because there are members of Congress that really did not like that some people were supporting Palestinians in Gaza. And the Palestinians are ruled by Hamas, which was designated a terrorist organization. So Hamas is a terrorist organization in our books and— And just— They've done awful, awful things.

Tony MartignettiAmy, just to your whimsical point, you could have a 990 that mentions support for Palestinians.

Amy Sample WardRight.

Gene TakagiYeah. And so what is the algorithm that they're going to use to say, hey, let's take a closer look at this organization, throw a wrench in their operations, maybe have the right to take away their 501 status? What 9495 doesn't do, which we mentioned in the last show, but I think it's worth reiterating, is it does not stop you from operating. It just takes away your 501 status. So again, a less harsh tool than they already have in the books. But one that might be used because it looks better. And when we talked about due process, Tony, let's put that in quotation marks because there are some outs from some of those due process protections as well. So save it for another show because again, it could get redefined in the new bill.

Tony MartignettiYeah. All right. All right. Cool. Amy, let's go where you led off with the NTEN Equity Guide. We've got a chilling around, a chilling hostility toward diversity, equity, inclusion, belonging, all as illegal discrimination. I mean, if you get into the text of the one order anyway, the one executive order, 14173, talks about ending illegal discrimination. Right. Diversity, equity, inclusion, discrimination. But it's not currently illegal. But I'm not sure that qualification really matters. It's having a chilling effect on websites. I don't know if it's going as deep as mission statements. Maybe it is, Amy, maybe you're hearing some of that. But so, I mean, I'm reading about websites being prophylactically scrubbed of language that the administration deems inappropriate and is hostile to.

Amy Sample WardYeah.

Tony MartignettiAmy, why don't you share what you're hearing from folks?

Amy Sample WardYeah, I think there's, you know, if anyone ever watched Thomas the Tank Engine or read Thomas the Tank Engine, they say all the time, confusion and delay. That is what is happening. So much confusion and delay, right?

Tony MartignettiThat's Ringo Starr, right? Ringo Starr as the station manager. It's Ringo Starr saying that, isn't it? Yeah.

Amy Sample WardThat's like the nice way to put it, of course, right? Like, there's already countless documented actual harms, deaths, delayed or stopped medical interventions. Like, all of these things have come. I'm not trying to downplay it with Thomas the Tank Engine, but maybe make it light enough that we can keep having a conversation, um, because otherwise, like, the reality is super, super hard, and I don't want to deny that. Um, I think we're hearing from a lot of organizations who— and NTEN has had this conversation too— of how do we navigate keeping our staff and our either service recipients or program participants or, you know, beneficiaries of our mission, whatever it is, Safe so that we can continue to do this work. Like, we don't want to stop the work that we do, but, but how do we stay safe enough that we're employed to do it or that, you know, we are able to offer these programs? And, um, I welcome Gene's insights, but I think that question is kind of a recurring theme with maybe answers that are different every day for organizations, right? Like, they're coming up with, okay, today, like, things are a little different. This is what that's going to look like. Yeah. We're hearing from, you know, I think a lot of the websites or service providers that I've at least seen, not that I have a chronicle of the entire internet, despite what you may think, but the folks I've seen doing the most proactive scrubbing are folks either completely reliant or predominantly funded by the government. And so that is less about the language of executive orders and much more about the actual felt Pause or discontinuation of funding, you know, and, and wanting that piece to not be the barrier. And I think there's a lot of arguments that are super valid about not scrubbing that. You know, if you invisibilize community members, you are not serving them in those services because they don't know that it's safe to still get services from you. And maybe it isn't safe to still get services from you. And because we are in a world and we are complex humans, multiple things can be true at the same time. That is true. And I want to create space to say that that is also a potential mechanism for keeping staff and patients safe so that they can continue to operate, right? So it's both troubling and not helpful to invisibilize communities by erasing that language from your website. And also, if that allows you to get funding, so long as you're still serving them and they are safe and protected, You know, it is complex. But I think that's the kind of scenario we're hearing from organizations that they're trying to balance where there isn't a right answer. And, and also none of the answers maybe feel good. But they're trying to, you know, what can you do on your website versus what could you do in your services? I think another place of real worry, and this goes back to conversations Gene and I have had with you, Tony, about 9495 and other powers that many administrations have used to come for organizations. And that is the incredible data that we have been entrusted with as nonprofits, and that, that less of our mission or our services or even honestly our staff, but just The database we have that says these are all the people who needed X, Y, and Z service. That's, that's the thing that's gonna have even more targeting. And so we're also hearing from a lot of folks who, while this is not a new practice for the federal government to come for your list and really want to know who's accessing certain services or benefiting from certain missions, because of the level of rhetoric around the White House right now, I think folks who have had the privilege to not be threatened by that in the past are now thinking about it really for the first time, right? And thinking, okay, what does it look like to create our database where all of the demographic information for say, participants in our programs is anonymized, and we are just never connecting that to individual records. What does it look like to, you know, what, what can we do?

Kate MartignettiIt's time for a break. Imagine a fundraising partner that not only helps you raise more money, but also supports you in retaining your donors. A partner that helps you raise funds both online And on location so you can grow your impact faster. That's DonorBox, a comprehensive suite of tools, services, and resources that gives fundraisers just like you a custom solution to tackle your unique challenges, helping you achieve the growth and sustainability your organization needs, helping you help others. Visit donorbox.org to learn more. Now back to Prudence in Our Political Environment.

Tony MartignettiGene, you're getting a lot of calls, I know, as well. Folks just with generalized concerns or maybe more specific based on their work. But what, uh, what are you able to tell folks? How are you reassuring? Or maybe it's not reassuring, but what are you sharing with folks?

Gene TakagiYeah, I mean, what Amy talked about in terms of the complexity and basically one size doesn't, or one solution doesn't fit everybody's sort of needs. I think one of the first things I talk about is if you're going to make decisions on what you're going to do, whether it be scrub your website or change your programs or change your mission or whatever, or advocate and fight against, you know, What the government is doing. You want to do that on an informed basis. So you want to make sure that you are talking with your communities, your stakeholders. Your board should definitely be involved and assessing kind of the risks and the risk tolerances you might have, what you're threatened with if things go bad, talking about sort of contingency planning. of, of, or scenario planning about what might happen if you were to go on this course and sort of mapping it all out and saying, okay, what is the best direction for our organization? So I think from a governance role, from the board role, that would sort of be my first step is get your board involved and make sure you're hearing from them some pieces of information that you might not have, and, and vice versa as well. Talk to your employees. Talk to your beneficiaries. We talked about having town hall type meetings. You know, that may be a good thing to start out with in terms of being informed. There's so much misinformation out there, and part of it is intentional coming from the government, right? Again, they want to scare the sector as a whole or the sector writ large into compliance with what they're policy aims are. And this is extreme now, but it is kind of— that's how governments tend to operate, you know, generally speaking. And now we're just at a very extreme level of how far they want to get into it. So it is assessing now, you know, those executive orders. Definitely, if you're receiving federal funding, that's discretionary, right? They can fund who they want. And so if they put parameters around that about if you say you have a DEI policy, we're not going to fund you, that places an entirely different risk tolerance on organizations that rely on federal funding. Now, for the organization that doesn't get any federal funding to sort of follow what the organizations that get federal funding and scrub all the DEI off their website, if DEI is a core value and part of their mission, that may not be the right thing to do there for all the reasons Amy said, because you're— Right. trying to fight for your community, including your, you know, your beneficiaries in the future. And if you give up on all of this, and if everybody gave up on all of this, your organization and its mission are going to really suffer, and your beneficiaries are going to suffer, and the ecosystem that you're in, your environments are going to suffer, and communities are going to suffer. So it really is just something to think about. And so for those looking at the executive orders closely, You said the term properly, Tony. The executive orders are going after illegal DEI, and DEI isn't a real thing that you can grab a hold of, right? It's diversity, equity, and inclusion. Well, the words aren't illegal. So what would be illegal? Something illegal would be saying like, we are only going to hire a BIPOC individual to be our executive director. We won't look at anybody else. Right. That is illegal. So if you use race to base a decision on employment, that is illegal. The Fearless Fund issue that I think we have also talked about in the past—

Amy Sample WardThat's what I was going to bring up, yeah.

Gene TakagiThat has to do with making and enforcing contracts based on race. So that would say, be like, I will only enter into a contract if you are white or if you are Black. Or if you are an Indigenous or Native American person, you can't do that either, right? So you can't make or enforce a contract based on race. Where this gets dicey now is if you say we want to run a program to, you know, address historical and systemic discrimination against a particular race or races. If you structure that as a contract, Like, if you say you can participate in our program, but in return you must do this, if you make it as a contract, which what Fearless Fund had too much contractual language in there, which is why they settled. It would have been bad precedent for the sector. Now, there are other arguments for why that law shouldn't be applied in this way when it was originally created in the 1860s, by the way.

Amy Sample WardRight.

Gene TakagiIt was to protect Black people who were formerly enslaved from being taken away from the right to enforce contracts because you weren't white. That is, it's even mentioned in the statute and now it's being flipped in the reverse discrimination.

Amy Sample WardBut Gene, the other side of that that I wanted to bring up, I'm glad you brought up Fearless Fund. That was one side. And the other side is, was it Last week, time is an accordion. I don't, I don't know, uh, when this happened, but I think it was last week I saw the Missouri AG with a suit against Starbucks saying that the, the Starbucks workforce, which is probably like a million employees worldwide, but probably just looking at the US, is majority not men and majority not white. And so that means it's like, Yeah. It's a proof of illegal DEI hiring or something. But as soon as I said that, my first thought— and Gene, tell me if I should stand down on my anxiety spirals of everything— but my first thought was, okay, well, like, let's take a quick gander at the nonprofit sector's demographics. Guess what are also majority not men? Majority, you know, like, Of course, because they're— that's just the— oh my God. Okay.

Tony MartignettiBecause diversity is a value. And because we're, we're basing our decisions, I'm gonna say like 98.5% of them on, on the content of your character and your credentials, whether formal or informal for the job.

Amy Sample WardWithin the communities that are— yeah.

Tony MartignettiAnd not the color of your skin and your race. All right, so let's— but yeah, Gene, Amy's pleading.

Gene TakagiYeah, so the way it read in the media, at least the media I read, it's a ridiculous lawsuit in Missouri. Totally. I don't know if there's something deeper into that that the news media didn't pick up, but— and you can see I'm CYAing because I'm a lawyer. But yeah, that seems ridiculous, but it does raise actually a great point of state laws can even be worse than federal laws.

Amy Sample WardReminder.

Gene TakagiSo, you know, depending upon what state you're in, I'm in California, so our laws are pretty, you know, okay relative to the federal laws in terms of how hostile or friendly they are to nonprofits. But there are other states where that may not be true, and Missouri might be an example of where there are, you know, state laws that can be used as a basis for attacking a nonprofit. But this is to say that if I were to go into any nonprofit organization and you left me with a few hours to look at their books, I could probably find some sort of violation there. Cleaning up compliance on general things like making sure you're registered with the state, and if you're in multiple states, like figuring out which ones you need to register in, because that is a really easy way to close you down. Without there being any fuss. You just didn't meet the requirements. And yeah,

Tony Martignettiyou have a whole— you have an article on this. We're gonna— let's, let's talk about it in Nonprofit Quarterly. Uh, yeah, it's so— it's right. If they want to, if they want to find something, you're right, Gene, probably 2 hours— well, 2 hours with any person's, uh, tax, tax history would probably incriminate them and, and subject them to to sanction for non-compliance. So, all right, I wanna preface just with your— so folks can find the article, it's in Nonprofit Quarterly. Gene wrote it. So you're looking for the byline by Gene Takagi. It was January 20th, 2025. Nonprofit Legal Compliance in an Unfriendly Political Environment. You find that in Nonprofit Quarterly. Gene, let's tick off some of the things that could easily be much more, well, I don't know, much more troublesome, could easily be troublesome irrespective of what your mission is, what your website says, what values you hold deeply, just fundamental compliance things that, and housekeeping that may not have been paid as much attention to as they should be. And now they ought to be.

Gene TakagiYeah, so, you know, some of the fundamental things are just making sure you're qualified to do business in a particular state. So if you're incorporated in New York, that doesn't give you the right to operate in Texas or in California, right? So a lot of people talk about registration, which is sort of in your sort of corner of the world too, Tony. A little bit, right?

Tony MartignettiMake sure your solicitations are registered in all the states where you're soliciting.

Gene TakagiBut qualification to do business is not specific to charities. It's to for-profits, it's to nonprofits who aren't charities. And it's a different filing. You have to do both. Like, so if you have boots on the ground or you have programs in another state, as long as for lawyers out there you meet minimum contacts requirements, then you have to be qualified to do business there. And that may be a filing with the Secretary of State or someone other than the charities regulator. So the charities regulation stuff is above and beyond that, and you could get shut down for either missing either filing. So to, to Be aware of that. Now, if it's not your state of incorporation, they can only shut you down in your activities in that particular state. But as Amy knows, with our technology now, how do you do that? Like, if you have members and donors in, in some state, how do you shut off one and not the other? And now when we use charitable fundraising platforms like PayPal and stuff, they say, hey, if you are non-compliant in any state, we're shutting you all down because we don't want to get in trouble either. So now that wipes all of your online fundraising through that platform, which can really harm organizations. So that is a big one. So qualifications as well as registrations.

Tony MartignettiGene, let's talk about even more fundamental adhering to your mission, adhering to your, your originating documents, your articles of incorporation, your bylaws. Are you running the organization the way your bylaws say? All right, so I ticked off a couple. Your board. The duties of care and loyalty are— as your book— so I'm glossing over because I'm not the practicing attorney that Gene is. So, but I'm not qualified to go any deeper. I'm a good, you know, like, I'm a good surface scratcher. That's just— no, in a lot of things, that's true. But Gene, please help me, get me out of this morass that I just got myself into. Some of the more basic things about your your work and your originating documents that you need to be adhering to.

Gene TakagiYeah, so articles and bylaws, really important because a lot of organizations have really old articles and bylaws that they haven't been looking at. Their mission statements or their practices may have now changed from what the bylaws or the articles originally contemplated. That could be a reason for shutting you down or for removing your board members and having it replaced maybe by a receiver. who sides with whatever the state priorities are. So you could find your organization and its control, who controls that organization, changed because you're not compliant. So again, an easy way to say we're going to shut you down, not because of your policies, we don't have to go there. We're going to shut you down for you didn't follow your articles and bylaws. Your articles say you only operate in, you know, ABC County, but now you're in EFG County as well. Like, you're operating against the law. We're shutting you down. So be very, very careful. I know, again, some states would not even think of that, like, would not think to do that, but other states may not.

Amy Sample WardWell, and Gene, I've been on boards of other organizations where, because those are quite important documents. There's this preciousness to the bylaws that they can't be touched. And, you know, the response I got when I said, well, we can just take a vote and change our bylaws, was like blasphemy, right?

Tony MartignettiNo, you can amend your bylaw. You can amend your bylaws. Just, just follow the bylaws, uh, just follow the amendment procedure in the bylaws, right? Is that right?

Amy Sample WardRight. But I mean, you know, NTEN, as a nonprofit ourselves, for example, every 2 years we are making sure, is this document reflective of how we want to be operating, right? And really looking through it. So I don't know, Gene, if you want to say something that, like, to Tony's point, comes from you and not from me. But yes, like, go change your bylaws. Don't just hear the feedback of, like, make sure you're in compliance. Right. But also update them, make them something you want to be in compliance with.

Gene TakagiI love that, Amy, and the regular, you know, schedule that, that NTEN is looking at. I do, I am concerned with a lot of nonprofits can't really afford a lot of legal help. A lot of pro bono help doesn't understand this area very well. The bylaws can seem a little overwhelming to boards who don't understand all that legalese in there,

Amy Sample Wardright?

Gene TakagiSo I'm a little cognizant of that. There are certain areas though where you should just look and you can tell, are we in compliance or not? How often are we meeting? How many board members do we have? Are we really having elections as they are supposed to happen and not just letting board members stay on because we like them?

Amy Sample WardRight.

Gene TakagiSo,

Amy Sample Wardand you don't need a lawyer if— I mean, you could— I would advocate that you still have a lawyer look at it. But if the only thing in your bylaws you were changing was our board is whatever, 7 to 12 members, and now you realize you really want more board members and you're changing it from 12 to 20. You're not changing the terms, you're not changing anything else. Just change those 2 numbers, take a vote formally at your next board meeting, and like, great, now you have updated. You know, I don't want folks to feel like you're not smart enough or you're not qualified to review those and want to make changes.

Gene TakagiYeah, I hate to be sort of the proponent of something I heard Elon Musk say, who has all of your individual tax records, as I was thinking when you mentioned that, Tony. But you don't want perfect to be sort of the—

Amy Sample WardThe enemy of good here.

Gene TakagiYeah. So you just have to be very, very careful of that. And as a side note, Elon said that about saying we're spending $50 million of USAID money on condoms for Hamas. So And then he said, I might not—

Amy Sample WardThat quote is not generally attributed to him. Like, certainly been around. Yeah.

Tony MartignettiJust like, all right, let me get us out of the morass that the rabbit hole you two just entered. All right. So now, Amy, you do make a very good point. The point that we're all making is just be consistent. Your documents and your true operations need to be the same. So if the bylaws are out of date, work on amending. You don't have to change the way you're operating. Just get the bylaws up to date with, you know, now you're meeting 4 times a year instead of the 3 times a year that your bylaws say.

Amy Sample WardRight.

Tony MartignettiAll right. All right.

Amy Sample WardWell, and just, can I make a technology point about that consistency too? This came up last week when I was presenting at the Alabama State Association, State Nonprofit Association. summit and talking about data and policies in a place where there's not that consistency between maybe privacy policy you have and how staff manage the database or, you know, data from programs, place, whatever the scenario is, and really inviting listeners to put on the calendar a good hour in Tomorrow or in an upcoming day to look at all the data that you're collecting and say, do we need to collect all of this? It's a lot of work to protect your data, and it is less work if you have less data, right? And so if you're never— if you're never gonna need one of those fields, or you know that you're really only looking at, say, per our conversation here, demographic data for the whole year, once a year, you can either stop collecting things or collect it differently or store it differently. That already sets you up to make it safer and, and more protected. And so thinking about not just do we have a privacy policy, do we have a data retention policy, like please make sure you have those types of things and, and that you're practicing them, but also looking at those just like your bylaws and saying. Yeah. Gosh, this privacy policy was written when we were formed in 2005 and like is irrelevant to us now. We need to update these policies. And with that, we need to update our, our practices and how we actually operate. Because there is a lot that would be at stake if, if your data was compromised or subpoenaed or whatever. And so even these kind of practical pieces help that. Yeah.

Gene TakagiI, I agree 100%. And just as an example, like, if—

Amy Sample WardPhew, the lawyer signs off on what I said. I feel like I did it right, you know.

Gene TakagiIf ICE, you know, comes and visits your nonprofit organization and demands sort of records of individuals who benefited from your organization's services, and, you know, you have data going back years that you have no need to keep And all of a sudden you're turning all of that over. Think what harm that could be doing to your communities. It doesn't matter whether they actually end up, you know, having anybody that's relevant to ICE, but they could just terrorize the people that you're trying to serve.

Amy Sample WardAnd I think, you know, a common— when I've brought up an example like that, or, you know, maybe you do pro bono legal clinics and you have this whole many years record of who's come To those clinics, you probably don't need that. But I, I hear the, the pushback or the question from a lot of different nonprofit staff saying, yeah, but like, how— we don't want to delete that. We want to know, okay, in 2010 we had 100 people, but then by 2014 we were serving 500 people. Great. You don't need to know that it was Gene Takagi at this address in California that was one of those 100. You just need to know that there were 100, right? Or maybe you want to know that it was Client A who lived in California versus Client B who lived in Colorado. Great. But, but again, you, you don't need all of that data probably. And the more of it you can get rid of or not even collect in the first place helps in the situation Gene's talking about when someone comes in and says, hand it over. Yeah. What are you really having to hand over then? You know, okay, well, here's a list of counties. Godspeed to you. You know.

Kate MartignettiIt's time for Tony's Take Two.

Tony MartignettiThank you, Kate. I co-host a nonprofit activist group. We are the Nascent Nonprofit Activist Group. We met once in December. We met again in February. We're going to try to keep up a meeting a month. There's about 40 people or so who joined the meetings, about 65 on our email list. And we're talking about the issues that Gene and Amy and I are talking about on today's show. So if you'd like to be more activist than just listening and dealing with this on your own, We're supportive. There's a lot of crosstalk. It's not all one-directional talk. We are helping each other and we are going to be— after these 2 meetings now, we've had sort of informational. We had a guest speaker who I'm probably going to have on the show in the next few weeks. And so if you would like to be part of our supportive activist group, it's very easy. Just email me, tony@tonymartignetti.com. I need your— just, I need your name and email. And you can also use the contact page at tonymartignetti.com. I'm co-hosting this group with Beth Kanter and Jay Frost. They have both been on the show multiple times. You may know them in their own work as well. So the 3 of us are co-hosting this, the nascent nonprofit activist group. Please join us if you think that we can help you and if you have something to contribute to the group. That is Tony's Take Two. Kate.

Kate MartignettiI don't have much to add this time other than I think it's really cool to see these conversations popping up. Um, with, you know, the new administration and all the change that's going on and the uncertainty. Um, I mean, even in classes, we're actually sitting down, putting aside the curriculum for a second, but in our education course, we're having these conversations in class, trying not to keep it political, but I think having that conversation is so important. Yeah.

Tony MartignettiIt is. It's also supportive so that, you know, you know, in your class, you know that you're not the only one having concerns. I mean, you're in an education curriculum and the Department of Education is at risk. That, that, that can be very troublesome. Yes. Department of Education sets standards, spends billions of dollars on public education, etc. So yes, just in terms of support, knowing you're not the only one with concerns. And then also this activist group is, you know, we're activists. So we're not just going to support each other, as important as that work is. We're going to start taking some actions. I don't know if it's going to be calls or letter writing or emails or what we're going to do. We don't know yet. But it's important to not only support each other, but also take action.

Kate MartignettiWell, we've got beaucoup buttloads more time. Here's the rest of Prudence in Our Political Environment with Gene Takagi and Amy Sample Ward.

Tony MartignettiLet's go a little more, uh, focused to our colleagues who do foreign aid.

Amy Sample WardYeah,

Tony Martignettiuh, foreign development, uh, international development work affected by the USAID freeze. There's also an OMB freeze. These are in different states of litigation. There are orders issued by judges against these freezes, but the orders don't seem to be being followed by the administration. Or we're not sure. Gene, what are you hearing specifically from the community development, you know, foreign aid work?

Gene TakagiWell, it's really harsh, right? And so I think estimated over 50,000 US jobs lost, over 100,000 worldwide jobs lost because of some of the freezes and cuts. Understandably, there are, you know, existing contracts that nonprofits had agreed to in the past for which they've delivered services and not gotten paid yet, but through grant programs where the funding has stopped. So, you know, it's really, really a harsh time now where organizations are laying off people, they're cutting off programs, and they're really scrambling to find out how are they going to keep you know, advancing their mission where they are largely dependent upon federal funding. And federal funding is perhaps one of the largest sources of funds for the charitable sector, right? It's not foundation funding. It's much, much larger than foundation funding. So it really is important to understand that philanthropy can do a little bit. They should probably do more, but they don't have the capacity to fill the gap that the federal funding has. So USAID, you know, especially, I think there's just a lack of knowledge from people to understand, well, what USAID is. It's not just giving money away to foreign countries. There are like national interests, security interests, disease prevention, prevention of wars. There's a lot that— of reasons why USAID was formed and why we want to have good foreign relations.

Amy Sample WardAnd And it's not just medical, which I've heard a lot of folks feel like USAID is just like a health piece.

Tony MartignettiIt's growing democracy.

Amy Sample WardIt's everything, you know.

Gene TakagiFighting terrorism.

Amy Sample WardRight.

Gene TakagiSo yeah, that's— I mean, that is sort of the big problem now. And when you have somebody who's almost acting as an executive in Elon Musk, again, just to Point him out again, announcing the intention to shut down USAID despite the court orders. So, you know, apart from all of the funding cutbacks and the job losses, are they going to really kill USAID? Are they going to kill the Department of Education? Like, what happens when we lose these things? How easy will they be to replace? And what are we going to do without this? It's There's going to be a lot of suffering. So it's— organizations are going to have to figure out, well, in this environment, what are we going to do?

Tony MartignettiI know there's programs being cut, you know, people abroad sent home, or there's no funds to send them home.

Amy Sample WardYeah.

Tony MartignettiYou know, we've, we've seen the stories.

Gene TakagiYeah.

Amy Sample WardI think it's also— Amy, anything to add? Yeah, I was just going to add to Gene's Point. And I don't hear you saying this, you know, without any support, but I think as a nonprofit, you know, representative here, when I hear, okay, nonprofits are going to have to like try to figure out what do we do in this climate, it's not a one-to-one. Many organizations can't just say we're going to fill this hole that, that is presented by USAID being forced to stop because we don't have, to your earlier point, Gene, contracts in place that say we then get to be the vaccine recipients or we get to be the arbiters of grain. Like, those organizations don't have in place the administrivia that allows us to then step in, which is— Right. Really, just as we were saying, that could be used against us as nonprofits if we don't, you know, have our stuff in order. The, the dismantling or even temporary pauses of components of our government is actually a whole network of contracts and relationships and, you know, collaborative agreements. And so I think Nonprofits do, of course, have to think about what do we do now because of this, but we can't maybe fool ourselves into thinking, oh yeah, we'll just like step in and be them because we can't replace all, all of those agreements or contracts or relationships. We're actually thinking more about what do we do with the fallout because of this and not how do we become the replacement of this, you know. Just to like maybe make it sound worse, I guess, is my point. But—

Gene TakagiHey, when you mentioned grain too, um, Amy, I was thinking about the US farmers that are losing, um, I think tens, maybe even hundreds of millions of dollars of purchases from the US government to feed other countries or to deliver that food out that will hurt our agricultural economy here as well. So, you know, even for the administration, you know, its supporters who were many from rural areas and farming communities are, you know, getting screwed, maybe not directly, but indirectly through these things as well. And there just has to be a bigger understanding.

Amy Sample WardWhich is a domino, right? That means more people in that community needing maybe the support services that other nonprofits were already providing to folks, you know. And it's in— I know it's so different, but I do keep finding myself coming back to a lot of the hard feelings of 2020 when it's like, oh my gosh, organizations across the sector were already operating at maximum and like, you know, quote unquote, now more than ever our missions are needed. And here we are again at this place where, oh my gosh, it's How do we serve more people? How do we make sure we still have staff to do that? Because the need continues to have this exponential growth feeling, if not actual, you know, number.

Tony MartignettiThere's also a national security dimension to this that we've promised to deliver whatever type of aid, whether it's I've mentioned, you know, helping build your democracy in Romania, or whether it's feeding in the African nations or healthcare. You know, we've made these commitments and now we're just literally just walking away. We can no longer do what we were doing 2 weeks ago. Hmm. So you're on your own. The US has screwed you. So there's that. There's just our perception in the world, how we're perceived in the world, and who's going to fill that void? Right. I think some of our deepest adversaries, like China, and China specifically, particularly because of their wealth and reach. But there's also a possibility of some Terrorist organizations filling a gap on a small, much smaller scale.

Gene TakagiEspecially when you promised people who were helping you fight terrorism that you would allow them to bring themselves and their families into the country after they delivered that help, and then now breaching that promise and saying, no, you can't come in here anymore.

Tony MartignettiYeah. It's heinous. It's cruel.

Gene TakagiYeah.

Tony MartignettiAll right. We got to take a turn. To media. Amy, you have some thoughts about, you know, when I suggest the topic of major media capitulation.

Amy Sample WardYeah.

Tony MartignettiEven before the election, the Washington Post refusing to endorse any candidate, the Los Angeles Times, same, USA Today, same. And then since the election, CNN, settling a very questionable lawsuit for $10 billion based on what words George Stephanopoulos used. And it looking potentially like CBS may settle something also very, very questionable about the way they edited a teaser

Amy Sample WardYeah,

Tony Martignettiversus the fuller interview if you watch the show. I mean, you know, commercials are made to be short and, and video is edited for commercial, for short purposes. And but yeah, the likelihood that CBS may settle that, uh, so I hear major media, major media cave again.

Amy Sample WardMajor media are already part of the corporate industrial complex. And so So while I would love for them to do better and be better, am I surprised? No. What I feel is a really important, um, happening that we should care about even more so than like those completely disappointing but maybe anticipated, you know, choices. Um, When other journalists have not stood with the AP and the AP has been blocked from briefings, that is the backbone of getting reliable, direct information from our federal government out to people. Right. And all of that because the AP said the established name of this waterway. Yes.

Tony MartignettiThe Gulf of Mexico instead of Gulf America. So they were banned from a White House event. This is why I believe what you're getting to in the media, in the nonprofit community, we all have to support all of our sectors, all of our missions, all of our work so that when Trump—

Amy Sample WardBecause it's not a race, right? There's not one trophy. So if we do not stand together as nonprofits or as journalists, You know, we all will lose it. I mean, I think Gene made this point earlier, right? Like nonprofits benefit everyone. Good journalism benefits everyone. We need, we need sunlight on that information and we need it to be, this is directly what was said, right? Which is what the AP is providing and is especially providing news information access to under-resourced communities where they do not have their own journalists, they do not have their own media bodies. And so they are just receiving literally that AP wire and reporting what's happening. And so if we let that crumble, again, just as, as other nonprofits, if we start saying, okay, well, I don't know what a good example would be here, but like, I know in a lot of especially smaller or distributed kind of rural communities, United Ways are often the organizations who are the only ones with the capacity to do kind of data aggregation on any regular schedule, right? And say, this is the state of social services in our tri-county area for the, you know. Mm-hmm. And then so many nonprofits don't have the capacity to do their own field research. And so they write grant applications using the United Way's data. It's, it's very similar to, in my mind, I think. And if we don't stay standing together, we all will lose. And so I think it's just really a beacon to me right now of that. Okay, well, I don't support that. That can— that is not— Right. Giving me any good signs about the state of journalism or reporting and information in our system. As nonprofits, we cannot replicate that. If, if, if we are not gonna stay together, like, all of the pieces, all of the components can't, can't be successful, you know.

Tony MartignettiWe can also be sources of information, reliable data to the extent that we can, even if it's within our own local community. At least we can be reliable, we can footnote, we can provide information about it. And it may just be about our work, but we can be reliable sources. Totally. And of course, there are some nonprofit journalism outlets But, you know, that's a very small percentage of the 1.5 million or 1 to 1.8 million, depending whether you count foundations or not, nonprofits in the US. So, but each of us can be scrupulous about our own, our own data reporting.

Gene TakagiYeah, I think it's so important now as well, because we don't all just collect news from our major, major media sources, right? A lot of us relied on Twitter before, for example. A lot of us relied on just television shows like The Daily. So it's about understanding how things that we thought were going to be more transparent and put more sunlight, like Twitter, led to the Arab Spring or helped facilitate the Arab Spring. That has rapidly changed, right? Twitter is completely different now. And looking for supporting those news media, social media that are more aligned with how we think in terms of being fair. And I should just sort of also say that the nonprofit sector is as diverse as the for-profit sector in that the Federalist Society is the nonprofit sector, right, Pardis? So whether we just say the nonprofit sector as a whole needs to do something, we are divided in our sector as well as to what we believe is fair and what we believe is true. But I do think there's just more commonalities than partisan big corporation and billionaires tell us what our commonalities are. I think we have much more in common with what we want, but the media that's being controlled by the industrial complex is

Tony MartignettiAmy, you want to leave us with, with your final thoughts for a minute or 2, and then we'll— I'll turn to Gene and we'll close.

Amy Sample WardI think my only final thoughts from our conversation today are one, 2 things. It is very hard. So You know, if you haven't had a good cry yet today, this is your moment. Like, I see you. It's really fucking hard. And you're not alone, right? Like, there— not that you— NTEN would answer all of your questions, but there are so many intermediary organizations, whether that's a state nonprofit association, you know, organizations like NTEN that are on a specific topic like technology, but there's so many resourcing organizations. Yeah. that exist to enable you to not figure all this out by yourself. And don't fall into the trap that I think is, is very clearly laid for all of us to think we are in it alone, because then we're not resourced, we're not supported, we don't have a lot of faith in ourselves, right? And then we don't maybe grow some power. So don't fall into that trap. Don't think that you are alone. Find whatever resourcing organization or, you know, collaborative or coalition or whatever you want. But don't try to have all the answers yourself because like we're all broken humans that definitely don't know what all the answers are. So know that it is super hard, but you're not alone and we'll figure it out. Tony will answer your questions. And Tony is one of those resourcing people or hubs. But that's, that's, I think, all I can say to wrap it up.

Tony MartignettiAll right. Well, Gene, before we turn to you, I already know what I'm going to say on Tony's Take Two for this show, which is going to be an infomercial for the nascent nonprofit activist group that you both joined us for the first meeting. We've only had one other meeting since, and if folks want to join us there, they will have by now already heard my explanation of what we're doing and how to join us on Tony's Take Two. So that's my parting. And you are not alone. And there is— I can recommend a group because I'm co-hosting it that will prove to you that we're in this together. Gene?

Gene TakagiI echo everything both of you have said about collaboration. Now is the time to join those who have similar values, um, who value your mission. Um, talk to your funders as well. Um, get them aligned with what the stories are of, of what problems you may be going through and what solutions you might have to, to suggest. Um, keep your boards engaged. Keep your staff and beneficiaries engaged so you, you're acting together and be really informed as you go through this. This is a period and things are constantly changing. So just sort of to know your adaptability, value that, and make sure that you are allocating risk as well as your resources. So when you're— when you have talked about risk tolerances, you've got to decide where you're going to sort of be more risk tolerant and where you're going to be more risk averse. And on the simple compliance stuff, be risk averse. Like, make sure you're compliant.

Tony MartignettiGene Takagi. You, you want legal assistance, legal advice, a legal resource, uh, in our, in our time? Follow nonprofitlawblog.com. You'll find Gene at GTAC. Amy Sample Ward, You'll find them on Bluesky as Amy Sample Ward. Thank you very much, Gene. Thank you very much, Amy.

Amy Sample WardThanks, Tony.

Gene TakagiThank you, Tony. Thank you, Amy.

Amy Sample WardBye, y'all.

Gene TakagiBye.

Kate MartignettiNext week, Julia Campbell returns for a social media chat. If you missed any part of this week's show,

Tony MartignettiI do beseech you, find it at tonymartignetti.com.

Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by DonorBox. Outdated donation forms blocking your supporters' generosity? DonorBox. Fast, flexible, and friendly fundraising forms for your nonprofit. donorbox.org.

Tony MartignettiI love that alliteration.

Kate MartignettiI knew it. I knew you were gonna come in. Ah,

Tony MartignettiI thought maybe you would say, no, he's not gonna do it again this week.

Kate MartignettiNo, I knew it. Our creative producer is Claire Meyerhoff. I'm your associate producer, Kate Martignetti. The show's social media is by Susan Chavez. Marc Silverman is our web guy, and this music is by Scott Stein.

Tony MartignettiThank you for that affirmation, Scotty. Be with us next week for Nonprofit Radio, Big Nonprofit Nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. Go out and be great. Thank you.

Nonprofit Radio