How We Got Here


About this episode
It’s the story of the unpredictable trajectory that led to today's U.S. nonprofit sector. How did we come to be what we are? The history is told by Dr. Robert Penna, author of the book, “Braided Threads.” (This originally aired August 3, 2018.)
Here’s the transcript
Tony MartignettiHello and welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. I'm your aptly named host and the podfather of your favorite hebdomadal podcast. It's good to be back home with my studio mic. Should sound much better than the previous couple weeks. Oh, I'm glad you're with us. I'd come down with ichthyosis if you dried me out with the idea that you missed this week's show. Here's our associate producer Kate with the highlights.
Kate MartignettiHey Tony, we have How We Got Here. It's the story of the unpredictable trajectory that led to today's U.S. nonprofit sector. How did we come to be what we are? The history is told by Dr. Robert Penna, author of the book Braided Threads. This originally aired August 3rd, 2018. On Tony's Take Two.
Tony MartignettiTales from the Plain. The overhead bins.
Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by DonorBox. Outdated donation forms blocking your supporters' generosity? DonorBox. Fast, flexible, and friendly fundraising forms for your nonprofit. DonorBox.org. Here is How We Got Here.
Tony MartignettiI'm very glad to welcome, uh, Dr. Robert M. Penna, Bob, back to the studio. He's the author of the new book, Braided Threads: A Historical Overview of the American Nonprofit Sector. He served for 5 years as a consultant to Charity Navigator and also as an outcomes consultant to the World Scout Bureau. Indeed, his last book was The Nonprofit Outcomes Toolbox, which we talked about on this very show. He's presented before nonprofit organizations and associations across the US and in Canada, Poland, Kenya, Saudi Arabia, and Australia. Bob is a native of the Bronx, New York, and he still sounds like it even though he lives in Wilmington, North Carolina. You'll find him and his book at braidedthreads.com. Welcome back, Bob Penna.
Dr. Robert PennaThank you very much for having me.
Tony MartignettiCome a little closer.
Dr. Robert PennaThank you very much for having me.
Tony MartignettiMy pleasure. Thank you again for coming to the studio. This Braided Threads Overview, overview. I think you make the point there's just not enough of an appreciation among those of us in the nonprofit sector for where we came from.
Dr. Robert PennaWell, I think a lack of knowledge about the sector is probably throughout the population, but for those of us that work in it, most people never stop to think about where did it all come from. Like so much else around us, we Americans are notorious for a lack of a historical sense generally. We just kind of accept that, you know, okay, that mall was built for my convenience right before I was born, forgetting about what was there before, be it a farm or God only knows what. And the same thing with the sector. People just accept it for what it is today, even though they don't know the real size or the real dramatic economic impact. And I thought that that story ought to be told. It actually started as what I thought was going to be a chapter in another work, and it got as big as a book. And it was, to me, a fascinating, fascinating story.
Tony MartignettiWhat's the thread that you think is most important? Resiliency. Through the history?
Dr. Robert PennaResiliency. In other words, it has changed. The reason it's called Braided Threads is because it is not one unbroken series of events that took place in sequential order and all in one line.
Tony MartignettiThis is a metaphor really for the history and the strength, I thought.
Dr. Robert PennaWell, both.
Tony MartignettiOf the sector.
Dr. Robert PennaBut there were all these different things that were happening that when they were woven together gave us what we have today. So that's where the title came from. But if you had to pick one thing, I think it's a story of resiliency. It's a story of Before it was a formal sector such as it is today, it still was a movement. It was things that people were doing and it ricocheted off of, reacted to, but also impacted events for over 200 years.
Tony MartignettiYou're clear to point out that it's not a history of nonprofits.
Dr. Robert PennaNo.
Tony MartignettiIt's how the nonprofit sector evolved because of discrete events in history.
Dr. Robert PennaWell, that's why it's called an overview. In other words, I didn't start out with day one and then try to give chronologically month by month, year by year, What I did was I looked at what I thought were the most impactful things that happened during or to the history of the sector, and those were the things I wrote about.
Tony MartignettiNow, I'm not sure if we're going to go strictly chronological. We may. The
Dr. Robert Pennabook isn't actually strictly chronological. There are places where I have to double back.
Tony MartignettiNow, when you were on last time, we talked about Queen Elizabeth, important figure.
Dr. Robert PennaQueen Elizabeth I.
Tony MartignettiBut I know Martin Luther,
Dr. Robert PennaRight.
Tony MartignettiUh, piques your interest.
Dr. Robert PennaI thought—
Tony MartignettiHe's pre—
Dr. Robert PennaBy about '60-ish. Right, his fame— By about '60-ish. Okay, okay. I, I particularly thought it was interesting because if you look at the sector today, it is largely secular, humanist. Not that there aren't religious or religiously affiliated organizations in it, but it is not a religious sector. I mean, generally speaking, not that there aren't religious organizations and affiliations, but it is a very humanistic secular, in some cases you might say liberal, I don't know, uh, movement. And yet its roots were distinctly religious. So how did that break happen? Why did that break happen? Where did it— and personally, I trace it back to Martin Luther and the Reformation.
Tony MartignettiSay more. Well, how so?
Dr. Robert PennaBecause up until then, uh, I mean, again, and this is not to be, uh, focused on just one, you know, ethnicity or religious tradition. This is certainly not to leave anybody else out. All right. But the truth of the matter is that Europe was Catholic ever since, you know, Constantine made it the Catholicism or Christianity, the official religion of the empire in 330 AD. Europe was Catholic. And then comes along Martin Luther and he initiates, along with a few other people, the Reformation. And his biggest point was that unlike where the Catholic Church said it was faith and good works that got you into heaven, Martin Luther was sola fide. Faith alone. Yeah. He split them and he said, you can do all the good works you want, they're not going to get you into heaven. Faith is. And he divided it at that point. And that crack, that infinitesimal hairline crack, got wider and wider and wider and wider. People began to realize over time— maybe they never even articulated it— but became a sense that there were certain things you do because they're right, not because it's an extra 2 points to get into heaven. This tradition had not existed theretofore, and that's why I peg one of the first, first steps towards what we have today, and particularly in the United States, with Martin Luther.
Tony MartignettiAnd now, so, and then Queen Elizabeth.
Dr. Robert PennaQueen Elizabeth.
Tony MartignettiWas important. Yes, very important. Now, if listeners want to go back, you can go back to the June 2016 show. We talked for about half an hour, not all about Queen Elizabeth, but we talked a fair amount about her, more than we're going to today. You could go to tonymartignetti.com, search Bob's last name, Penna, P-E-N-N-A, and that June 2016 show, last time he was on, will appear to you. Okay, please.
Dr. Robert PennaVery quickly, Queen Elizabeth—
Tony MartignettiYou don't have to go too far. We got time.
Dr. Robert PennaOh, okay. Queen Elizabeth in 1601 issued something that was called a Statute of Charitable Uses. And what she did was, and this is not to say I wouldn't say this had never happened before, but she codified it. The idea that things that were of civic and civil benefit could be appropriate targets of charitable giving. What things? Funding of schools, the funding of scholars, the building of bridges, the building of causeways, the ransoming of prisoners. All of these things were in this list. So what was she doing there? She was, A, further secularizing Charity, but B, she was putting into the charitable pot things that theretofore had not been considered charity. Infrastructure. But charity was always personal to help the poor. Now she's moving far away from helping the poor.
Tony MartignettiBridges. Bridges, causeways. Bridges and ransoming hostages.
Dr. Robert PennaAlso putting together a sort of a charitable pot for the dowry for poor maidens.
Tony MartignettiOh yeah.
Dr. Robert PennaOkay.
Tony MartignettiYeah.
Dr. Robert PennaThere were things that today you might call either social engineering or whatnot, but the point is It was no longer the idea that charity always was, always had to be about helping the poor. So first Martin Luther breaks off the idea of these good deeds having nothing to do with getting you into heaven, and then she comes along 60 years later and says on top of that charitable acts can be things that are good for the community and not necessarily what was thought of as personal charity, putting the coin in the beggar's hand.
Tony MartignettiBeyond Martin Luther, religion, the evolution of religion.
Dr. Robert PennaI think it has tremendous—
Tony MartignettiHas been important.
Dr. Robert PennaTremendous, particularly in the United States.
Tony MartignettiWe're probably gonna hit religion a bunch of times, but give us an overview of why you say tremendous.
Dr. Robert PennaWell, I would say 2 reasons. First off, because of the impact of the Puritans. If you wouldn't mind me mentioning another author, Colin Woodard's book American Nations. He makes the point—
Tony MartignettiWhat's his name?
Dr. Robert PennaColin Woodard.
Tony MartignettiOkay.
Dr. Robert PennaAmerican Nations.
Tony MartignettiHe's in your foreword or your introduction?
Dr. Robert PennaHe's in the introduction.
Tony MartignettiOkay.
Dr. Robert PennaAnd he makes the point that there were founding cultures here in the United States. And one of these founding cultures he calls Yankeedom, basically the Puritan culture. And the thing of it is that that had a tremendous impact because their worldview, they were the only ones coming here amongst the settlers, amongst the French, the Spanish, the Swedes, everyone else who came here. who came with this idea of creating a better society. We've all heard that term, the city on the hill.
Tony MartignettiYeah.
Dr. Robert PennaJohn Winthrop, in their Mayflower Compact, was writing this down and was saying that amongst the things we're going to do is every person has to be responsible for every other person. Built into the DNA of that colony and what it became eventually in terms of one of the, I would say, dominant cultures of the United States was this concept that we have a responsibility We're going to
Tony Martignetticome back to Winthrop,
Dr. Robert Pennaone of the
Tony MartignettiNew England Puritans.
Dr. Robert PennaRight.
Kate MartignettiIt's time for a break. Imagine a fundraising partner that not only helps you raise more money, but also supports you in retaining your donors. A partner that helps you raise funds both online and on location, and helps you keep your nonprofit running smoothly. So you can grow your impact faster. That's DonorBox, a comprehensive suite of tools, services, and resources that gives fundraisers just like you a custom solution to tackle your unique challenges, helping you achieve the growth and sustainability your organization needs, helping you help others. Visit donorbox.org to learn more. Now back to How We Got Here.
Tony MartignettiSo let's jump ahead. We may come back. Like I said, we may not stick chronological, but you mentioned Winthrop, New England Puritan. The New England Puritans were different than, in terms of their concept of charity, than the Southern pioneers.
Dr. Robert PennaIt was also, okay, it was also what it had a lot to do with was the way they set their Yeah. If you think of the South, um, the— first off, there was the Tidewater South, the Maryland, Virginia, northern North Carolina. That was one society. But then there was what we came to know, for better or ill, as the South, eventually the Confederacy, etc. That all started in South Carolina. It was a plantation— both of these were actually plantation societies. And these plantations were largely self-sufficient. So amongst the things they didn't do, they didn't worry about having a public school because the rich took care of their own children. They had tutors, or perhaps they sent the children away someplace, but they didn't worry about public schools.
Tony MartignettiAnd the poor didn't matter.
Dr. Robert PennaAnd the poor didn't matter. They didn't need education. Neither white nor black. Yeah, it didn't matter. So all the things that we take now as thinking of their earmarks of society, their earmarks of civilization, They didn't exist down there. Conversely, the first things you did in New England was you— where's the village green? The church is going to be at one end, the Congregationalists, of course. The school is going to be at the other end. Everybody supported it through their taxes. So right there you had a division. This then later was reflected in terms of things like the pieces of civil society that you and I would consider to be charitable efforts. They didn't exist in the South.
Tony MartignettiSince religion is a thread that you— Yes. It's very important. The Congregationalists in that time—
Dr. Robert PennaThey were the Puritans.
Tony MartignettiThey were the state religion.
Dr. Robert PennaIn Massachusetts.
Tony MartignettiOh, just in Massachusetts?
Dr. Robert PennaIn Massachusetts, Rhode Island, Connecticut. As you went further south, it became the Anglicans. In fact, the Anglicans were a minority in Massachusetts. And what became of the— you don't see a Pilgrim Church or a Puritan Church anymore. They became the Congregationalists,
Tony Martignettiwhich were supported by taxes. Taxes.
Dr. Robert PennaTaxes. They all were.
Tony MartignettiSo, I mean, it's a complete— you know, this is obviously all pre-Revolution, pre-Constitution, but in that day, we had state religions.
Dr. Robert PennaYes, yes.
Tony MartignettiIn every colony. Some of the northern states.
Dr. Robert PennaEvery colony.
Tony MartignettiOkay.
Dr. Robert PennaNot— you know, including eventually, you know, as things kind got more settled down south, the Anglicans, the Anglican Church of England was the state church. So, for example, Virginia had to deinstitutionalize the Anglican Church so taxes wouldn't go to it anymore. But it did have this thread, Tony, of how religion impacted it. It goes through this whole story because when the ministers no longer were part of the government, so to speak, they had to find a new role. You had other sects Yeah. That came along after the Second Great Awakening, amongst them the Baptists, the Methodists, they were incredibly influential because they had— they didn't have all the formal theology that others had. It was— that's why you would hear a Baptist preacher referred to as Brother Parsons or something, because they weren't ordained ministers in many cases. And because of that lack of formality, number one, they could— they didn't need a church necessarily. They could preach under a tree. But secondly, they also had a much more accessible kind of idea, the way they approached it. And a lot of what we see today came from specifically the Baptists, Evangelicals, and the Methodists.
Tony MartignettiLike what? Like what? What are some of these traditions that are—
Dr. Robert PennaWell, for example, the first nationwide— Survived. The first nationwide charities, if you want to call them, were Bible and tract associations. And they were all run by, funded by and pushed by these Southern evangelicals, Methodists, and Baptists. And that became like the first nationwide charities, the precursors of all the big ones you know today. They were the first ones who were like coast to coast.
Tony MartignettiWhat else? Is there another tradition that you can connect?
Dr. Robert PennaI think another tradition I would connect is the activism of many, many groups. So, for example, going back to the abolition Of slavery, which of course started, of all places, in Boston. Boston was the home of the abolitionist movement. And a lot of the people up there were religiously affiliated. But it is also true that during Reconstruction and whatnot, a lot of the charitable work that was done down there amongst the freedmen, amongst the freed slaves, etc., was done by Northern Methodists and Northern Baptists. So this thread, this But they weren't doing it necessarily for the same reasons that going back to the 1400s, the Catholics/Christians were giving money to the poor. That was trying to buy their way into heaven. This was completely different.
Tony MartignettiThis was a contribution to society.
Dr. Robert PennaExactly. It was like a secular act.
Tony MartignettiTo bring the nation beyond—
Dr. Robert PennaIt was a secular act being done by people who belonged to a particular denomination. In this case, it's interesting to see the degree of do-good. Think back, you know, go back to the anti-war movement during the '60s. How many of those people marching, they were Protestant ministers? Many of them, many of them were Methodist and they were Baptist. This strain never went away.
Tony MartignettiWhat was— I'm jumping way ahead now. We'll come back to the Constitution and separation of church and state, but Ancient Greek, Greece, Rome, Egypt, what was the conception of charity then?
Dr. Robert PennaWell, Egypt— Or
Tony Martignettidoes it vary by empire?
Dr. Robert PennaGenerally speaking, I mean, even in Egypt there are hieroglyphics that have been found and have been translated that roughly say that your place in the afterlife depended upon how you treated people in this life. So you might say there was that kind of strain of charity. In Greece and Rome, Charity was much more what Queen Elizabeth did. In other words, the idea was, particularly in Rome, if you want to get ahead and you want to be noticed— so let's say you're in the army and you want to move into politics, you were high up in the army— you would spend stuff, you would spend money on things that the public could enjoy. Like you would build a public bath, or perhaps you would pay for a temple to Athena, or some small thing of this nature. But the idea was— Right. The charity in those days did— the poor didn't count. The poor didn't exist on anybody's radar screen. You had a totally different perspective of human nature, human value.
Tony MartignettiAnd it was for your own— it
Dr. Robert Pennawas for your own good, for your own good, for your own career, right? Career development, right? It's career development. But the whole idea was you could just—
Tony MartignettiI could spend $400 to go to a conference, uh, then I would have had to build a temple to Athena.
Dr. Robert PennaOr you could today, you could make a big donation to a hospital and put a plaque on the wall with your name. This is a Tony Martignetti wink.
Tony MartignettiYeah, I'd rather build a temple.
Dr. Robert PennaBut,
Tony Martignettium, okay, interesting. All right, thank you. So, so let's go. All right, so now we have, uh, uh, our Constitution, our Bill of Rights, the First Amendment, um, obviously religion— no, no state religion— and, and separation of church and state. So how did these factor into—
Dr. Robert PennaThese factored in, in 3 different ways. Number one, part of those, those The First Amendment is the right of assembly, which the British kept an eye on when they were in charge. Well, now you could formally have— you could have group meetings, you could organize, and you didn't have to worry about perhaps the king's soldiers would come and say, break this up, why are you 6 people gathering here? One of the things that people did was they formed organizations. De Tocqueville wrote back in 1789, 1830-something when he wrote his famous review of America based upon his tour, that Americans were already organizing for virtually everything. You name the thought— music, culture, politics— something that they thought would be done, and Americans were organizing. He has a comment that says, where in England you will find a A person of great wealth or prominence heading up an effort. Or where in France you will find the government doing that, in America you virtually always find it being done by a citizens organization.
Tony MartignettiOh, interesting.
Dr. Robert PennaSo this could have been a— de Tocqueville was here in like the early 20s, you know, first 20 years or so of American independence. I mean, I believe he wrote Democracy in America somewhere around 1834, um, and these were already his reflections, uh, by 1820. The New England area already had over 2,000 of these citizen voluntary organizations. They were the precursors of today's nonprofits.
Tony MartignettiYeah. And how were they structured? What do we know about their organization?
Dr. Robert PennaThey were structured like, they were structured sort of as, you know, an association. They had bylaws, they had officers. What they didn't have was either a legal corporate identity nor did they have any sort of sort of fiscal power because the laws that created what we call today a corporation didn't exist back then.
Tony MartignettiAll right, so we're in the early to mid-1800s. Are they doing their own independent fundraising?
Dr. Robert PennaYes, they were doing— well, they were doing— yes, they were doing subscriptions. They would call it a subscription. They would put out a subscription request and And it was today's fundraising, but they called it a subscription. But the key things in those days were threefold. Number one, they weren't incorporated, so they didn't have a legal standing identity such as people don't like about Citizens United, that whole idea. It didn't exist. Uh-huh. Secondly, they did not have any separate fiscal ability to buy, to sell, to— they didn't. And the third thing was that the officers or whoever was there, the officers were the identity. So if Mrs. Smith or Jones quit or died, very often the operation would fall apart because there was no way to keep it going. It was very, very crucial for them to eventually get this right to incorporate. And one of the most key points about this was that they eventually incorporated under the state laws, the laws of their home states. Mm-hmm. Now, who then controlled them? Did the state legislature, because it chartered them or allowed them to incorporate, control them, or were they independent? And there was a crucial, um, a crucial court case involving Dartmouth University whereby the courts found that even if public money went to these entities, and even if in fact these public entities, these entities were incorporated under state law, Yeah. The legislature couldn't touch them. The legislature could not give them money, but the legislature could not tell them, in this case specifically Dartmouth University, what to do. That independence was crucial because it allowed these organizations to, in many, many, many cases, precede government in various efforts, whether it was schools for the children of freed former slaves, whether it was Schools for, uh, today you'd call it, you know, handicapped, the deaf, the blind. Uh, they would very often create certain— they would call them asylums. Today you might call them orphanages for children. There was one in New York City that was specifically for the, shall we say, um, uh, children of prostitutes who might have been called bastards back then or might be called illegitimate. Nobody— where did these kids go? What did you do with them? And there was a privately funded asylum that was created just for those people, just for those children.
Tony MartignettiFor the poor as well? Yes, very often. Almshouses?
Dr. Robert PennaWell, almshouses, yes, very, very largely funded by these private entities. But very often, particularly in New York City— New York City under Mayor DeWitt Clinton, high school in the Bronx.
Tony MartignettiClinton in the Bronx, yes.
Dr. Robert PennaClinton High. He became— he was governor at one point. He was not only— when he was When he was mayor, he was also head of one of the largest charitable efforts in the city and was even back then, we're talking early, I'm going to say around, I'm guessing here, trying to remember, 1820s, something like that. I don't remember the exact years of his term of office, but the city was already paying what today you would call a nonprofit to run the schools for the poor. So in New York State particularly, this tradition of public money going to a What we today would call a nonprofit to provide a legislatively desirable and socially desirable end. Think about it, Tony. This is 2018. You're almost 200 years later. We're still doing the same thing.
Tony MartignettiYeah, yeah, I love that. Around this period, let's take mid-1800s or so. What's happening in the rest of the country with our charitable sector?
Dr. Robert PennaWell, slavery and the Civil War are percolating. And a tremendous number of efforts, private government efforts, or rather private citizen efforts, were trying to have the slave trade stopped. Because the Constitution originally said that the government could not do anything even to end the slave trade, not slavery, but the trade, for 20 years. So this effort was going on for a long time and it was all being done by citizens, 99% of them up north. A lot of them either spurred by or inspired by the culture of Yankee-dom, which was spreading across the country at that point. I mean, think about it, from the Mohawk Valley to the Ohio Valley, we spread from east to west.
Tony MartignettiYeah.
Dr. Robert PennaAnd this culture came with us. And the number of people who felt that this was a scar on our national character increased. And I mean, you've heard, you know, the Missouri Compromise, Bleeding Kansas. We all know all the things that led up to the Civil War. But what was— while that was going on, there was this tremendous effort to, among other things, abolish slavery, but at the same time, penal reform, reform of prisons. Right. Reform to end— what's the biggest show in New York? Hamilton, right? Hamilton and Burr. Dueling. Outlaw dueling. Also—
Tony MartignettiThese are efforts by the nonprofits? By various organizations.
Dr. Robert PennaOkay. Now, the term nonprofit didn't come along until 1954.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Yeah, we're going to get— well, right. We'll get to the tax exemption. Okay. But by these organizations— penal reform. What else? Can you think of other examples of what they were Well,
Dr. Robert Pennait was very, very interesting amongst these subscriptions today, you know, there's— everybody's familiar with the term 501. Well, that 3 denotes one level of 501. There are actually 29 of them. Yeah. Well, one of them, one of the earliest, was what was called mutual societies, sort of mutual aid or mutual— today there are mutual insurance companies which are nonprofit. They started back then. The idea is you would again have a subscription, and if a fire hit your house, this would pay money to you to get you back on your feet. This was another nonprofit effort that didn't exist. Benjamin Franklin—
Tony MartignettiEvery year— wait, I've got to stop you. Remember Benjamin Franklin? Every year I get my subscriber's check from USAA, a mutual benefit insurance company and now bank. Ben Franklin.
Dr. Robert PennaBen Franklin is credited with founding amongst the first, uh, uh, nonprofit things in the United States, the Volunteer Fire Corps in Philadelphia, one of the first libraries, uh, the Juno Society. These were all— today you'd call them nonprofit efforts, uh, that he founded, uh, in Philadelphia, uh, before the Revolution. So again, this was good, but interestingly enough, not down south.
Tony MartignettiYeah.
Dr. Robert PennaNot down south. Once you started to get towards around North Carolina border, you didn't see it at all.
Tony MartignettiBecause of the plantation economy?
Dr. Robert PennaBecause of the culture.
Tony MartignettiThey didn't have a civic— there wasn't a civic—
Dr. Robert PennaThe civic sense we have.
Tony MartignettiYeah, community sense. Right. It was, this is my plantation, we take care of everything here.
Dr. Robert PennaThis is why 2 of the most revolutionary things that happened down there was Thomas Jefferson's founding of the University of Virginia and North Carolina's founding of one of the first state universities in the country, because that was unheard of down there. It was just unheard of. So all of these efforts, as I say, were primarily northern.
Tony MartignettiWe have about a minute before the break. The tax exemption, I feel like this is a good time. When did that—
Dr. Robert PennaThe tax exemption started way, way, way back because you have to ask about which taxes. So there's probably going to be more than a minute.
Tony MartignettiWasn't religion the first exemption?
Dr. Robert PennaReligion and then also schools and things of that nature. So we'll go back to that.
Tony MartignettiBut it started with religion. Okay, so we tease it together, and you always
Dr. Robert Pennado.
Tony MartignettiOh, thank you very much. Always tease.
Kate MartignettiIt's time for Tony's Take Two.
Tony MartignettiThank you, Kate. I have another tale from the plane about the overhead bins. Regrettably, last week's civility on. Deplaning and how humane and polite everybody is, uh, doesn't quite carry over to the overhead bin courtesy. Uh, it— we're, we're doing some things not very polite, uh, in the overhead bins. For instance, and I'm just seeing this more recently too, like, I don't know, just within the past 6 months even, that— just that recent. Putting small bags like backpacks or a shoulder bag in the overhead bin. That smaller stuff belongs underneath the seat in front of you. That's courtesy so that the overhead bins, which are bigger obviously and can accommodate the bigger bags, that's where the bigger bags are supposed to go. But I'm seeing more people putting smaller bags in the overhead bin and And I'm checking these same people. It's not like they have two small bags. They got one under. No, it's not one under the seat and one in the overhead. They're not using the space underneath the seat in front of them so that they can stretch their legs out and put their feet there. Well, that's not really the way the plane is designed. That's not the most courteous thing to do. So please, your smaller bags use the. space under your seat. And how— I mean, how many people can fit their feet under the— in the— underneath the seat in front of them anyway? Although, well, although maybe in the main section it does get— it can get a little tight, but you're still— it's being discourteous. So please, not the— Not the smaller bags in the overhead bins, the smaller bags in the seat underneath you, and save the space up ahead, up, up over. For the bigger bags. And then when also, when you're putting your bigger bags in, you know, again, just politeness. Put them in so that the top or the bottom of the bag is facing the aisle, not the side of the bag. So don't put it in long ways, put it in short ways so that more people can fit their bag. And even if it'll stand up on its end like a book, if it stands up on its side, That's what I mean, on its side. Then stand it up so more bags can stand up. And then the final thing, you're supposed to check to make sure the bin will close before you walk away, because it may look like your bag fits, but it could be it's a little too tall. The bin is not going to close. If that's the case, then we're just going to have to go. The flight attendant's going to have to find you later on, and you're going to have to end up checking the bag at the gate anyway. You know, planeside anyway. So it's not like you're getting away with something. Just, you know, the courteous thing. Make sure the bin closes so that we don't have a problem later on, right? Delayed flights. Nobody wants that. Delayed flights. Okay. A little bit of a rant, I know. But the overhead bin space, you know, let's be civil. Let's be courteous like we are with the planing, with the, with the, with the deplaning. It works out so well. It's so smooth. Please, we we can carry that over to the overhead bin courtesies. I know we can. That's Tony's Take Two. Kate.
Kate MartignettiSo we talked about this last week. I've never flown, so maybe this is a dumb question. Does each row have their own hubby?
Tony MartignettiNo, it's pretty much a free-for-all, except first class. It'll say. You know, these are for first class bags only. But when it gets really crowded in the back, then they'll use the they'll use the the the first class space doesn't matter. So it's not by row, but sometimes by cabin or you know it's service service or even Delta calls it which experience like is it first class or is it comfort plus? Or is it main cabin? So there might be divided space by service, but no, not by row. We got to get you on a plane. We got to, we got to, we got to get you, we got to get you on a plane. This— I feel bad that you're asking this question.
Kate MartignettiI feel like this is an experience that everyone needs to, you know, like have at some point.
Tony MartignettiWell, yeah, eventually you're gonna get on a plane. It's gonna be just be too far for you to drive or walk.
Kate MartignettiRight.
Tony MartignettiI don't think you're up to walking like 650 miles, but you could drive. You could drive it. All right, we got to get you on a plane. That's, that's all. That's all.
Kate MartignettiWell, we've got beaucoup buttloads more time. Here's the rest of How We Got Here with Dr. Robert Penna.
Tony MartignettiBob Penna's with me. His new book is Braided Threads: A Historical Overview of the American Nonprofit Sector. Just get the book because, you know, we can't do it justice. Of course, you So, if you're interested in how our sector, our community evolved to what it is now, get the book. We're hitting some threads, some braided threads, if you will, but you want the full story. Even Bob mentioned something, I was like, oh yeah, that Dartmouth case. I can't remember it all. Just buy the thing, for Pete's sake. All right. Where were we? See, now I've lost track. I've ranted about bees and sunshine and all this live love. Where were we?
Dr. Robert PennaHelp me out. Well, you also screwed up the whole thing about baseball, but that's another thing. I did? Well, yeah, baseball doesn't have touchdowns. But anyway, that's a different story. We're talking about taxes and tax exemption, and that's what you, you had asked about.
Tony MartignettiTax exemption, yes. Okay, thank you. So it started— religion was the first one. What period are we talking about now?
Dr. Robert PennaGoing, going back to probably the 1600s. The point of the matter is you have to ask what taxes?
Tony MartignettiAll right.
Dr. Robert PennaWhat taxes? Federal government levied very, very few taxes. Before that, the states levied not that many taxes. Most taxes were on property. And very early on, churches were exempted from paying those taxes. Now, it wasn't just the church building. It also became the parsonage. The parsonage where the minister lived. Then if there was another building, a library perhaps. Then schools obviously were not taxed, be they private or be they public. Clearly, public government is going to tax itself, so public institutions like a public school were never taxed. But the idea was that the exemption list grew bigger and bigger. Right. New York State was— obviously this was going on in all states. I happen to have quite an extensive accounting in the book of how the New York State list just kept getting broader and broader and broader and broader. At one point it was interesting because the law was changed to allow organizations that included in their charter or their mission the enhancement of the minds of young people or something. That's how the Y got in, because the Y had tried to get a tax exemption, had gone to court, they'd been turned down, they had to pay the tax bill, but everybody thought, gee, the Y should be in this. The
Tony MartignettiY is very interesting too, in the World Wars.
Dr. Robert PennaYeah, well, that's right in the book, right, that they were also involved.
Tony MartignettiI've heard, yeah, this is in the book.
Dr. Robert PennaI know, yeah. But what I'm saying is that the Y was not really, was not mentioned, or organizations like the Y.
Tony MartignettiNow you mentioned New York State.
Dr. Robert PennaYes.
Tony MartignettiI love this. There's one thing I want to read. This is from 1799, New York State. You cite New York State as sort of representative of what was happening around the country.
Dr. Robert PennaRepresentative. There were variations, but that's very representative.
Tony MartignettiThis is an Act for the Assessment and Collection of Taxes, New York State, 1799, excerpt. I won't read the whole thing, of course. No house or land belonging to any church or place of public worship, or any personal property belonging to any ordained minister of the gospel, Nor any college or incorporated academy, nor any schoolhouse, courthouse, jail, almshouse, or property belonging to any incorporated library shall be taxed by virtue of this act.
Dr. Robert PennaRight. And that list just kept going. And as I said, at one point they amended it to include— I forget the specific wording— was something about the betterment of the minds of young men and women, because there was the YMCA and the YWCA, Young Men's and Young Women's Christian Yeah. So the law was changed and basically what the courts said was that these operations were doing good. They were doing good things and were beneficial to society and therefore society, it was in society's interest but also as just a smart thing to do, we are going to do our bit by supporting them to the extent that we do so by alleviating them from the tax burden. They were still not called nonprofits because that concept came way later. But these organizations, these voluntary— and for a long time it was called the voluntary sector. Ah. Yes, that was the name of it. These organizations increasingly became tax-free. What we know today as the— people call them nonprofits. I'll do this relatively quickly. Yes. One of the last revenue acts of the 1800s included this idea that these kinds of organizations could be— should be exempted from federal taxes. That particular revenue act was found unconstitutional. However, when things started to fall into place, and you'll remember it was the 16th Amendment that made the income tax legal in the United States. When that happened, the recognition that these organizations should be exempt was codified, and it had to be 3 things. Number one, it had to be incorporated as a nonprofit. What does that mean? Does it mean they can't make a profit, they can't make money? No. What it means is that any excess, extra, either has to go back in— well, it has to go back in. They cannot— Keep it.
Tony MartignettiAnd this was contemporaneous with the 16th Amendment?
Dr. Robert PennaYes, well, shortly following that. But what does a nonprofit mean? Does it mean it can't make money? No, that doesn't— that's not what it means. What it means is it can't take that profit and distribute it to partners, distribute it to stockholders, distribute— it has to go back into the pot. That's number one. The second thing is that none of its activities can make money for any of the officers. And the third idea is that the— well, they're all the same. The idea is nonprofit, non-distributory, and doing some sort of civic good. And so very often it was charitable, and there was a charitable, educational, and the list got bigger. Now,
Tony Martignettiillymisenary. I like that word.
Dr. Robert PennaEliot Masoner. Eliot Masoner. That's what they are. Are they Masoner? I believe that is, but maybe you're right. Better check.
Tony MartignettiMaybe you're right.
Dr. Robert PennaRemember, I come from the Bronx, so I have different pronunciation.
Tony MartignettiWell, you were wrong about baseball too, so—
Dr. Robert PennaOur present tax code comes from 1954. That was the first place where they laid out what we have today, this 501 category. Yeah. And where the general exemption from— and originally the idea was that if these organizations made money, they didn't have to pay a corporate income tax on it. Then it became, not legally but in terms of practice, that they are basically free from almost all taxes other than things like excise taxes or taxes on gasoline or something that you pay as part of a bill, which is why the local men's association will go to a restaurant and And they'll have their banquet and they give the owner, here's my tax-free number, and they won't have to pay sales tax on the restaurant meal.
Tony MartignettiYeah.
Dr. Robert PennaOkay? So that's where all that came from. But it was, in terms of its codification, although the roots go back to the 1600s, codification goes back to 1954.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Is that the 16th Amendment? Was that the—
Dr. Robert PennaThe 16th Amendment was 1913. That's what allowed the income tax.
Tony MartignettiPermitted the federal income tax. Right. Okay. Let's— World War I, we saw an expansion.
Dr. Robert PennaYes, yes.
Tony MartignettiWhy?
Dr. Robert PennaWar relief. Well, because there was no functional way for the government to step in. One of the more fascinating things about it was that the— you meant we were talking about the Y. The Y was the first organization to To do what today you think in terms like the Red Cross, you know, POWs, POW camps, uh, you're checking on status, bringing, you know, prisoners. Nobody did that. The government sure as heck didn't, neither the Union nor the Confederate government. It was the Y, the YMCA, that first started this, bringing this service to both sides, to both the Confederates and Northerners. Yeah, yeah. So they were, they were in, uh, in Confederate POW camps ministering, so to speak, to Union prisoners and vice versa.
Tony MartignettiYou say that the Y was the first large-scale service corps.
Dr. Robert PennaReally, you could say that. You can say that. So it comes along in World War I. There was a need for this, but nobody else to do it.
Tony MartignettiThe Y. It was the YMCA initially? Or was it Y— was there a Y—
Dr. Robert PennaNo. Well, there's 2. There's YMCA, Young Men's Christian Association, and the Young Women's Christian
Tony MartignettiAssociation.
Dr. Robert PennaWhich came
Tony Martignettifirst? YMCA. Okay. So, first large-scale service corps and—
Dr. Robert PennaWell, what happened was this. In other words, when World War I started and there was a need, when the Americans got involved, when there was a need to again bring services to this army that was being raised, whether it was outside of Fort Dix or whether it was eventually when the AEF got called Across the other— to the other side, across the pond.
Tony MartignettiAllied Expeditionary Forces.
Dr. Robert PennaRight. Uh, American Expeditionary Forces. Uh, the whole idea was somebody had to do the same sort of thing, and the Y was the first one to step in. The Red Cross eventually joined. The Salvation Army eventually joined. But all of this was being done privately. Meantime, both prior to America's entry into the war and after, there was a tremendous amount of refugee, if you will, victims relief. I mean, you know, war is terrible, whatever war it is, and there's always collateral damage— the people who are displaced, the homes that are destroyed. Well, during war, governments don't stop to worry about taking care of that. They move on. They want to— they have a war to try to win. So who took care of those people? The refugee problem was tremendous. Belgium became, uh, one of the worst sites of it because when the Germans invaded Belgium, the Allies said, well, you have to feed the Belgians, because most of the Belgians' food came from outside. Germans said, no, we're not going to be bothered doing that. We're, you know, feeding our troops. You want to give them food, you give them food. Well, it was a relief effort that began in the United States that started working to bring food to Belgium, but it was not government. It was all private. It was all voluntary. It was all private. It was all what you today would call nonprofit. Before our— and there's actually pictures, one of the few pictures that are in the book— before the war, before the US got involved in the war, when we were supposed to be officially neutral, yes, there were organizations raising money for the poor and the suffering and the widows in Belgium and France. But there were also organizations doing the same thing, directing money to the German Empire that the Austro-Hungarian Empire and Turkey because we were officially neutral. So there are actually a couple of pictures in the book.
Tony MartignettiI would have appreciated more pictures, by the way. I like pictures.
Dr. Robert PennaWell, sorry, next, next book, more pictures. But the whole idea was this entire effort was being done privately. After the war, massive relief effort run by Herbert Hoover. Most of it, not all of it at that point, the U.S. government was committing money, but A great deal of it, you know, I don't know, proportion 60% maybe, was all private.
Tony MartignettiToday's USO was formed by a collection of a bunch of the— a collaboration of a bunch of the organizations you mentioned. The YMCA, YWCA, Red Cross. That's today's United Service Organization.
Dr. Robert PennaRight, right. And that's where it was a coalition that was founded. It was one of the first ever like that, one of the first ever efforts. I mean, there were all sorts of things that happened back then that we Today, for example, you've heard of United Way. Everybody knows United Way. You know where United Way came from?
Tony MartignettiI don't.
Dr. Robert PennaCommunity chest. Community chest. And you know, today most people know community chest as a sort of a space in the card on the Monopoly board, right? Okay. Community chest was local fundraising specifically for disaster, personal tragedy, private relief. So If you lost your job or the factory burned down and 5 people lost their job, Community Chest was the entity in each individual community that they would go to for relief. I mean, maybe if they belonged to a particular denomination, the church might help them out as well, or the temple, or, you know, there's a lot of that. I mean, both, and there's a whole section there on both the Jewish and Catholic specific— Right. Contributions to what we know today as the American nonprofit sector. And that's interesting reading on its own. But this isn't to say that churches weren't involved. But every community, there was no public relief. There was no public welfare. And so if dad died or fell off the roof and broke his leg and couldn't work, there was no unemployment insurance. There was no workers' comp. Right. Very often they went to community chests. Community chests. What wound up happening was one of the transformative events was what we might call cooperative fundraising. If everybody fund— fund-raised, fundraised, whatever the past tense of that is, by themselves, you wound up with competing appeals and they're banging into each other. Well, it actually started I believe it was in Cleveland. It was one of the first ones. I know there was one in Denver. There was one in Detroit. There was one, I believe it was Cleveland.
Tony MartignettiWas this also the Hoover administration where nonprofits complained, where basically they testified before Congress, were basically running over each other, stepping over each other, trying to help?
Dr. Robert PennaOh yeah. Well, also—
Tony MartignettiI forget, was that the Great Depression?
Dr. Robert PennaNo. Yes and no. In other words, What you're talking about was World War II. Oh, okay. Stepping on each other and tripping over. That was World War II. No, what happened was when the Depression hit, sort of the thought was that community chests would step up and community chests tried. They would have, instead of one annual drive, they were having 2 annual drives. They tried 3, but the problem, as we all know, was much bigger than anybody could have foreseen and Their efforts were just not up to the fact that the entire economy crashed, which is why government had to get in. It was obviously FDR. FDR appointed Harry Hopkins to run the relief effort. Harry Hopkins thought that it really should be local government that was doing this. Local government is sitting off on the side. They're very happy not to be involved. Yeah. So what Harry Hopkins did was he said, okay, we're going to do this and it's going to be federal money, but none of the money can go to what today we'd call nonprofits. They got completely cut out.
Tony MartignettiThat was not— right, that was not to punish the nonprofits. No. That was to encourage—
Dr. Robert PennaThat was to force the states to step up. The unwilling states.
Tony MartignettiStates that had not taken on public welfare to do it.
Dr. Robert PennaOr would do it anyway.
Tony MartignettiWe'll give the money to the state, but federal money won't go to these community chests.
Dr. Robert PennaExactly. Right.
Tony MartignettiThey were trying to force the hand of the unwilling, recalcitrant states.
Dr. Robert PennaAnd localities. And localities. But yes, that was Hopkins' idea. Of course, now what did the nonprofits do? I mean, this kind of left them out in the cold. Now you also have to realize that at this point we're talking about community chests, but this was one— this is not to say that the arts efforts weren't going on and people weren't founding zoos and botanical gardens, and a lot of this was originally founded by private garden clubs or a zoological society, but— Right. The nation was in crisis and relief was always from the charitable sector, which is why it was called the charitable. And now they, A, couldn't do it anymore 'cause it was too big a job, and B, the federal money couldn't go to them. Harry Hopkins said no, so they had to reinvent themselves. I mean, I said, you asked me early on, what was the theme? I keep saying resiliency. Yeah. And one of the things that, one of the earliest tests of this resiliency was after the Depression because basically the Fed said, you can't have any more money for you. No more money for you.
Tony MartignettiYeah, yeah.
Dr. Robert PennaSo,
Tony Martignettium, say a little about the, uh, the Jewish contribution to, to what we know.
Dr. Robert PennaI think this is utterly fascinating. Uh, there's a book, I believe the guy's name wrote it was Cahill, Cal, I don't know how Cahill or Cal. It's called The Gifts of the Jews. The Gift of the Jews book is probably 20 years old at this point, but he makes the point that one of the biggest contributions that the Jewish culture, the Jewish religion made to us here in the United States was in fact cultural. It had to do with how human beings were viewed. When the Jewish immigration here started, in large, think about where these people had come from. They were either, you know, they were persecuted They were persecuted in Tsarist Russia. They were persecuted in Poland, which was part of Tsarist Russia. They were kicked out of Spain. I mean, you know, 1,000 years of this. They had an outsider perspective nobody else had, and they brought that here with them. And when they got involved in charity and— they were the ones, they were the biggest allies of the black civil rights movement because their idea that nobody Nobody should be an outsider was central to them, and they brought that to the— you think about today's nonprofit space. We are concerned about the handicapped. We're concerned about all sorts of groups that you might call marginalized or semi-marginalized. Yeah. And this was antithetical to the Jewish worldview. So, to me, whereas a lot of these other charities were taking care of their own, so for For example, there was the Irish Workingmen's Such-and-Such, but you had to be Irish. The Jews said no.
Tony MartignettiInclusive.
Dr. Robert PennaInclusive.
Tony MartignettiExcellent. Thank you. The Jewish tradition.
Dr. Robert PennaI just cannot emphasize that enough because, I mean, truly today, if you look at the whole core of the nonprofit mission, it is inclusivity. And I personally feel that without the incredible Jewish influence that Particularly here in New York. And New York became kind of like one of those centers of the nonprofit world. It still is. I cannot emphasize enough how strongly I believe that that worldview, that thread truly, truly helped imprint what we have today.
Tony MartignettiYou've got to get the book because there's some things we're not going to be able to— There's a lot more. The Great Depression, Kennedy's New Frontier, and then Johnson.
Dr. Robert PennaJohnson and the Great Society.
Tony MartignettiAnd then Johnson's War on Poverty.
Dr. Robert PennaWe have what, 3, 4 minutes?
Tony Martignetti5. I want to talk about the future too.
Dr. Robert PennaOkay, well then I'll do very quickly. Let me just do Johnson. Johnson set us on the road that we're on now.
Tony MartignettiWar on Poverty.
Dr. Robert PennaRight, the Great Society, War on Poverty. We are today farther down that road, and that road has been fancied up. You know, there are curbs where maybe there didn't used to be curbs. There's a newer pavement, nicer pavement than originally, but it's the exact same road. What Johnson did was he said, we are going to take federal money and we are going to change poverty. We're going to eradicate whatever his goal was. But it wound up that it wasn't the government that was doing it. It was government money going to community action agencies and to nonprofits. Right. Now, we don't have time now to go to talk about what happened to nonprofits during the '50s between World War II and— Yeah, we don't have time. Get the book. Just get the book. Well, I have the book. Oh, you mean they should get the book?
Tony MartignettiTalking to the 13,000 who are joining this conversation.
Dr. Robert PennaThey should get the book.
Tony MartignettiI hope to God you have a copy of it.
Dr. Robert PennaThat's a different story. Anyway, but the whole point was that—
Tony MartignettiIt was hard for me to get one.
Dr. Robert PennaLBJ set us on the road that we're on now, and my feeling, and maybe There are people in the sector who would argue, you know, this is my theory, is that basically things have not really changed in direction, they've changed in degree. Now the nonprofit sector is not just the partner of government, it's dependent upon the government. I mean, look what happened to the sector during the Depression. It wasn't that individuals stopped giving. Individuals, even during the worst of the Great Recession, were giving. Corporate was down to Corporate's not that big. It was government money. The sector today is very, very reliant on— so again, Johnson set us on the road that we're on now, and we are just farther down it and very much deeper into it.
Tony MartignettiI want to look forward. You cite generational change and technology change as our biggest opportunities and challenges.
Dr. Robert PennaI think 2 of I think 2 of the 3 biggest things, because we end the book on what's happening in the future. That's the last third or 25% of the book. I think the 3 biggest things that are impacting the sector, and the sector is largely unaware of it, is number one, the growth. We are adding 50,000 a year. In 1990, there were a couple hundred thousand nonprofits in the United States. Today there's over—
Tony MartignettiThere's a startling chart in the book, one of the pictures.
Dr. Robert PennaI drew that myself.
Tony MartignettiDramatic rise.
Dr. Robert PennaNow there's over 1.76 million. Actually, nobody, as Lester Salomon, who's one of the sages of the sector, says, nobody really knows how many there are. And it's because there's no registration, there's reporting. That's a different story. So the growth, this can't just go on, 50,000 new ones a year, even given 3 to 4% Talk
Tony Martignettiabout technology
Dr. Robert Pennaand donations. Secondly, technology. You talked before about making online donations easy. That is changing the paradigm between donors and organizations such that we've never seen before. You and I are of an age when we still remember March of Dimes going door to door, right? That is over.
Tony MartignettiThose little canisters.
Dr. Robert PennaCanisters. But think about it now. We are making it so easy For online or text, but we're also making it very easy to give uninformed donations because it's impulse, it's on the second, and it's right there on your finger. Yeah. The third thing is the generational change. We're already seeing the statisticians and the demographic— demographers are already seeing a great, great, great change in terms of values and behavior amongst the millennials and us, but not just us, also the generation right behind us. These 3 things churning are— have the power to totally change the nonprofit sector as we know it over the course of the next 15 years. And all I'm saying is we as a sector should be aware of these things and be prepared for what could happen and maybe try to steer the ship instead of just being a cork bobbing along where the tides and the winds take us where they will.
Tony MartignettiJust get the book, for God's sake. Bob Penna, Braided Threads. Braided Threads: A Historical Overview of the American Nonprofit Sector. You'll find Bob and his book at braidedthreads.com. Thank you very much, Bob.
Dr. Robert PennaThank you.
Kate MartignettiNext week, Veronica LaFemina with Your One-Page Strategic Plan.
Tony MartignettiFinally, get Veronica on.
Kate MartignettiIf you missed any part of this week's show—
Tony MartignettiI beseech you. Find it at tonymartignetti.com.
Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by DonorBox. Outdated donation forms blocking your supporters' generosity? DonorBox. Fast, flexible, and friendly fundraising forms for your nonprofit. donorbox.org.
Tony MartignettiFast, flexible, friendly fundraising forms for your nonprofit. Love that. I, I, uh, such a brilliant alliteration.
Kate MartignettiIt's so much fun to say, like, week after week. Our creative producer is Claire Meyerhoff. I'm your associate producer, Kate Martignetti. The show's social media is by Susan Chavez. Marc Silverman is our web guy, and this music is by Scott Stein.
Tony MartignettiThank you for that affirmation, Scotty. Be with us next That's it this week for Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. Go out and be great. Thank you.
I love our sponsor!


