AI, Organizational & Personal


About this episode
Artificial Intelligence is ubiquitous, so here’s another conversation about its impacts on the nonprofit and human levels. Amy Sample Ward, the big picture thinker, the adult in the room, contrasts with our host’s diatribe about AI sucking the humanity out of nonprofit professionals and all unwary users. Amy is our technology contributor and the CEO of NTEN. They have free AI resources.
Here’s the transcript
Tony MartignettiHello and welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. I'm your aptly named host and the podfather of your favorite hebdomadal podcast. Oh, I'm glad you're with us. I'd suffer with a pseudoaneurysm if you made a hole in my heart with the idea that you missed this week's show. Here's our associate producer Kate to introduce it.
Kate MartignettiHey Tony, this week, AI, organizational and personal. Artificial intelligence is ubiquitous. So here's another conversation about its impacts on the nonprofit and human levels. Amy Sample Ward, the big picture thinker, the adult in the room, contrasts with our host's diatribe about AI sucking the humanity out of nonprofit professionals and all unwary users. Amy is our technology contributor. And the CEO of NTEN on Tony's Take Two.
Tony MartignettiTales from the gym. The sign says clean the equipment.
Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by DonorBox. Outdated donation forms blocking your supporters' generosity? DonorBox— fast, flexible, and friendly fundraising forms for your nonprofit. DonorBox.org. Here is AI, organizational and personal.
Tony MartignettiIs Amy Sample Ward. They need no introduction, but they deserve an introduction nonetheless. They're our technology contributor and CEO of NTEN. They were awarded a 2023 Bosch Foundation Fellowship. And their most recent co-authored book is The Tech That Comes Next, about equity and inclusiveness in technology development. You'll find them at amysampleward.org and @amyrsward. It's good to see you, Amy Ward.
Amy Sample WardI do love the Podfather.
Tony MartignettiI know. It
Amy Sample Wardmakes me laugh every time because it just feels like, I don't know, like I'm gonna turn on the TV and there's gonna be like a new, new, new season of The Podfather where we secretly, you know, follow Tony Martignetti around or something.
Tony MartignettiWe are in season 14.
Amy Sample WardRight? Yeah.
Tony MartignettiYeah. Yes, I appreciate that you love that. It's, you know, like that fun. So before we talk about the part of your role, which is the technology contributor to NTEN, the technology—
Amy Sample WardTo Nonprofit Radio.
Tony MartignettiTo Nonprofit Radio. And we're going to talk about artificial intelligence again. Let's talk about the part of your life that is the CEO of NTEN, because you have— have you submitted this major, groundbreaking, transformative funding Federal grant application.
Amy Sample WardYes, we submitted it last night, three hours before the deadline, which feels notable because I know there were people down to the the minute press and submit. Nope, we got it in three hours early.
Tony MartignettiTo what agency?
Amy Sample WardTo NTIA. They had this is. Kind of all the work that rippled from the Digital Equity Act that was passed in Congress a couple of years ago.
Tony MartignettiAll right, now, you know better than to be in jargon jail. What is NTIA? It sounds like an obscure agency of our federal government.
Amy Sample WardIt's not. Well, maybe to some listeners it's obscure, but it is the National Telecommunications and Information Administration. And then
Tony Martignettiyou're— I think that's obscure to about 98.5% of the population.
Amy Sample WardYeah, you know, I think, I, I think I'm obscure to 98.5%, you know, uh, being obscure is fine. Um, yes, the National—
Tony MartignettiYou're not, you're a celebrity.
Amy Sample WardInformation Administration. And, um, prior to this, uh, grant, um, from the federal level where folks from all over were applying, every state was also creating state equity plan, digital equity plans, what funds might be available through the state funding mechanism to support digital equity goals. But a lot of those at the state level are focused on infrastructure, like actually building internet networks to reach communities that don't have broadband yet, you know, things like this.
Tony MartignettiVery, very worthwhile Yes. Funding endeavor. I mean, we need—
Amy Sample WardYes.
Tony MartignettiWe need to have—
Amy Sample WardSuper important.
Tony Martignetti100% of the population needs broadband.
Amy Sample WardBut even with those state plans and the work that will come from them and the funding, it will not— we are not about to have every person in the country have broadband available to where they live, right? Even with all of this investment, it's not going to reach everyone. And that means that the amount of funding within state plans for the surrounding digital literacy work, digital inclusion work, you know, making sure people know how to use the internet, why they would use it, have devices, all those other components is going to be really minimal through the state funding. Because even if they used all of it on infrastructure, they wouldn't be done with that work. Right.
Tony MartignettiSo, um, the federal government.
Amy Sample WardYeah. So, so the kind of next layer in all of that is this federal pool where they're anticipating grant-making about 150 grants somewhere averaging between $5 and $12 million each. There's gonna be exceptions, of course. There's big cities, there's big states, you know, but though all those grants will be operational from 2024, 2025 through 2028. So 4 kind of concerted years of national programmatic investment. And these are projects kind of on the flip side of those state projects where this isn't necessarily about infrastructure and building networks or even devices very much, right? It's mostly the infrastructure programming.
Tony MartignettiOkay. And you're asking for a lot of money. So tell it, you know, share the, share the numbers. What you're looking for, how much money?
Amy Sample WardYeah, we're— our project in the end, I think, came out at about $8.2 million project. And we're hopeful, of course. And I'm truly curious, listeners who are always tuning into Nonprofit Radio from like fundraising strategy perspective, I'd love to learn from you or, you know, email me at amy@NTEN anytime. I'd love to hear your thoughts when you listen to this. But You know, NTEN as a capacity building organization is we don't apply for grants often because quote unquote capacity building is not considered a programmatic investment to most funders, right? And so it's just not something that they will entertain an application from us on. And but with this, we have already run for 10 years a digital inclusion fellowship program that is focused on building up the capacity of staff who already work in nonprofits, who are already trusted and accessed by communities most impacted by digital divides to integrate digital literacy programming within their mission. Are they a housing organization? Are they workforce development? Are they adult literacy? You know, refugee services, whatever it is, if you are already serving these communities who are impacted by digital divides and you're trusted to deliver programs, Well, you don't need to go have a mission that's now digital equity. No, you digital equity can be integrated into your programs and services to reach those folks. And so we've successfully run this program for ten years and had you know over 100 fellows from 22 different locations around the U.S. and have seen how transformative it's been. These programs have been sustained for all these years by these organizations. They now see themselves as like the leaders of the digital equity coalitions in their communities. They, you know, fellows have gone on to work in state digital equity offices or, you know, organizations, etc. So it feels really great.
Tony MartignettiYou have tons of outcomes.
Amy Sample WardYeah.
Tony MartignettiFrom a smaller scale program. And the grant is to scale up, scale this thing up.
Amy Sample WardYeah. Yep. So instead of, you know, between
Tony Martignettigreater access,
Amy Sample Ward20 to 25 fellows per year, With this grant, we would have over 100 a year. Yeah. And that also means that instead of, you know, if there's only 20 fellows and maybe we can only cover 20 locations, well, with over 100, we can cover or at least give opportunities to organizations in every state and territory to be part of this kind of capacity building opportunity.
Tony MartignettiAll right. It sounds, it's huge. Yeah. It's a lot of money.
Amy Sample WardIt's really exciting.
Tony MartignettiA lot of money for NTEN. It falls within the range, I guess, a little— no, it's like right within the middle of the range you cited, like $5 million to $12 million, you said. So—
Amy Sample WardYeah, exactly. So our application is kind of in the middle there. Yeah.
Tony MartignettiYeah, slightly to the low side of middle, but, you know, we'll just call it middle between friends.
Amy Sample WardYes. But ultimately, I mean, we're hopeful, knock on wood. We're really hopeful that this is an easy application to approve because we're not Creating something new. We're not spending half of the grant in planning. We know how to run this program. We've refined it for 10 years. We know it's very cost efficient, you know, and in the end of 4 years, 400+ organizations now running programs that can be sustained is accelerating towards, you know, addressing digital divides versus, you know, a small project that just NTEN runs. Right.
Tony MartignettiAll right, listeners, contact your NTIA representative. Speak to
Amy Sample Wardthe
Tony Martignettielected person at the National Telecommunications and Information Administration Agency. Yes, speak to your— yeah, let's get this. All right. When do you find out?
Amy Sample WardWell, you know, there was very clear information about down to the minute when applications were due. Oh,
Tony Martignettiokay.
Amy Sample WardBut there's not a ton of clarity on when we will find out.
Tony MartignettiBut it gets delayed.
Amy Sample WardYou know, they are, they are meant to— programs that are funded are, are meant to get started in January. So I anticipate we'll hear, you know, in a couple months.
Tony MartignettiAll right, of course.
Amy Sample WardAnd I will let you know. We'll do an update. I'll let you know.
Tony MartignettiOkay, you have my personal good wishes, and I know Nonprofit Radio listeners Wish NTEN good luck with it.
Amy Sample WardThank you. I appreciate all the good vibes.
Tony MartignettiYeah, it would be reverberate through the universe.
Amy Sample WardYes.
Tony MartignettiWould be a transformative grant in terms of dollar amount and expansion of the program. Transformative.
Amy Sample WardYeah, 100%. Yeah. And staff are just so excited and hopeful about what it could mean for just helping that many more organizations, you know, do this good work. So We're really excited.
Tony MartignettiAnd I admire NTEN for reaching for the sky. You have like a $2 to $2.5 million budget, annual budget somewhere in there. And you're reaching for the sky. And great ambitions only come to fruition through hard work and thinking big. So—
Amy Sample WardThank you.
Tony MartignettiYes, we're excited. I don't even want to say the words. If they should blunder, if NTIA should blunder badly, I still admire the ambition.
Amy Sample WardThank you. And no matter what, it's a program that we know is transformative for communities and we wouldn't stop it even if, you know, they make a blunder and don't—
Tony MartignettiYeah, fuck them.
Amy Sample WardYeah, exactly.
Tony MartignettiDon't tell— all right, listen, don't tell your NTIA representative that.
Amy Sample WardYou said, go fuck off.
Tony MartignettiDon't share that part of the conversation. All right, thank you for sharing all that.
Amy Sample WardYes, yes, and thanks for your support.
Kate MartignettiIt's time for a break. Imagine a fundraising partner that not only helps you raise more money but also supports you in retaining your donors. A partner that helps you raise funds both online And on location so you can grow your impact faster. That's DonorBox, a comprehensive suite of tools, services, and resources that gives fundraisers just like you a custom solution to tackle your unique challenges, helping you achieve the growth and sustainability your organization needs, helping you Help others. Visit donorbox.org to learn more. Now back to AI, organizational and personal.
Tony MartignettiLet's talk about artificial intelligence because this is still everybody's mind. I can't get away from it. I cannot. I'm not myself of the concerns that I have. They're deepening. My good friend George Weiner. You know, has a lot of posts. The CEO at Whale, who I know you are you are friendly with George as well, talks about it a lot on LinkedIn. Reminds me how concerned I am about you know just the evolution. I mean, it's inevitable. This this thing is incrementally this thing. This technology is is incrementally moving. Not slowly, but incrementally.
Amy Sample WardYeah.
Tony MartignettiI, and I cannot overcome my concerns. And yeah, I know you have some concerns, but you also balance that with
Amy Sample Wardthe
Tony Martignettipotential of the technology, transformative technology, the transformative potential there. I'll throw out— oh, you want to?
Amy Sample WardI was just going to say,
Tony Martignettiplease.
Amy Sample WardI totally agree. This is unavoidable. I can't, you know, I cannot go a day without community organizations reaching out or asking questions or whatever. And a place of reflection or conversation that I've been having, and I wanted to offer here, maybe we could talk about it for a minute. So, so listeners benefit by kind of being in one of these sides with us in the conversation is To think about the privilege of certain organizations to opt in or opt out of AI in the same way that we had for many years, you know, talked about the privilege of organizations opting in or not with social media generally. Like,
Tony MartignettiMm-hmm.
Amy Sample Wardif we think about Facebook and we go back, you know, 10, years, there were a lot of organizations who felt like they didn't have the budget. And like, practically speaking, and they didn't have the staff. Well, certainly not the staff time, but also not the staff confidence. I don't even want to say skills, but like, even just the confidence to say, I'm gonna go build us a great website. They had a website, like they had a domain and content loaded when you went to it, right? But it wasn't engaging and flashy and interesting and probably updated once, you know. And then Facebook was like, hey, you could have a page and oh, you can have a donate button and oh, you can have this and oh, and you can post videos and you get, you know, it was like, well, why wouldn't we do this? Right. And a bunch of our community members spend time on Facebook or maybe don't even look for information on the broader web, but look for things within Facebook, you know, and And have it on their phone and are using an app instead of doing an internet search, right? Like they're going into Facebook and searching things. So they didn't, those organizations didn't feel like they had the privilege to opt out of that space. They had to use it because it came with some robust tools that did benefit them at the cost of their community data, all of their organizational content and data, right? Like it had a material cost that they maybe didn't even understand, right? And didn't fully negotiate as like terms of this agreement. We're just like, well, we have a donate button on Facebook and we don't have one on our website, right?
Tony MartignettiNot only didn't understand the terms, didn't know what the terms were.
Amy Sample WardRight.
Tony MartignettiEarly days of Facebook, we didn't know how,
Amy Sample WardAnd how many times
Tony Martignettidid we— Pervasive. Just how pervasive the data, data collection was, how it was gonna be stored, how it was gonna be monetized, how we as the individuals were gonna become the product.
Amy Sample WardAnd how many times did we talk, you know, I'm saying we like NTEN or, or folks who were providing kind of technical capacity building resources say, you don't know what could happen tomorrow. You could log in tomorrow and your page could Look totally different. Your page could work different. Your features could be turned off. Facebook could just say pages don't have donate buttons anymore. And, you know, I think folks felt like that was very, you know, oh, you're being so sensational. And then of course they would wake up one day and there wasn't a button or the button really did work different, right? Like you, people realized we're not in control of even our own content. Interesting. Our own data. That's right. The rules change, and there's no accountability to saying, "Hey, we need." Do you want these rules to change? No, no, no, no, no. Like they set the rules, and that was always, of course, a challenge. But we're in a similar place with AI where folks aren't understanding that there's there's no negotiation of terms happening right now. Folks are just like, "Oh, but I." I don't have the time, and if I use this tool, it lets me go faster. Because what do I have? A burden of time. I have so much work to try and do, and maybe these tools will help me. And I'm not going to say maybe they won't help you, but I'm saying there's an incredible amount of harm, just like when folks didn't realize, oh, we're a You know, we provide pro bono legal services and we're based on the Texas border. Now every person who follows our page, every person who's RSVP'd to a Facebook event, like all these people have a data trail we created that said they may be people that need legal services at a border, right? There's this level of harm that folks that are hoping to use these tools to help with their day-to-day work may not understand. I do not understand, right? That's coming in silent negotiation of using these products, right? And I think that's— well, I can't just in 30 seconds say, and here's the harm. Like, it's exponential and broad because it could also— the product could change tomorrow, right? It's this vulnerability that isn't going to be resolved.
Tony MartignettiYou, you said the word exponential, and I was thinking of the word existential.
Amy Sample WardYeah, both.
Tony MartignettiBecause I think I'm— I have my concerns around the human—
Amy Sample WardYes.
Tony MartignettiTrade-off is a polite way of saying it. Surrender is probably more— is more in line with what I'm— what I feel. Surrender of our humanity. Yeah. Our creativity, our thinking. Now, our conversations with each other. One of the things that George posted about was AI that creates conversations between 2 people based on the large language, the data that you give it. It'll have a conversation with itself, but purportedly it's 2 different people. Purportedly, and I'm using the word people in quotes, you know, it's a conversation. So the things that make us human.
Amy Sample WardYeah.
Tony MartignettiMusic, music composition, conversation, thought, staring. And listeners have heard me use this example before, but I'm sticking with it because it's It still rings real. Staring at a blank screen and composing, thinking first and then composing, starting to type. Or if you're old-fashioned, you might start to pick up a pen, but you're outlining either explicitly or in your mind. You're thinking about big points and maybe some subpoints, and then you begin either typing or writing. That creative process. We're surrendering to the technology. Music composition. I don't compose music, so I don't know the— but it's not that much similar in terms of creative thought and synapses firing. Yeah. The brain working together, building neural nodes as you exercise the brain. Music composition is not that— probably not that much different than written composition. Yeah, brain physiologists may disagree with me, but I think at our level, we— you understand where I'm coming from,
Amy Sample Wardright?
Tony MartignettiAnd I'm kind of dumping a bunch of stuff. Well, you know, but—
Amy Sample WardThat's okay. I, I am here as a vessel for your AI complaints. I will, I will witness them. We can talk about them.
Tony MartignettiArtificial intelligence also from George, a post on LinkedIn that reflects on its own capacity that justifies— you, you ask the, the tool to reflect on its own last response. How did it perform? You're asking the tool to justify itself. Mm-hmm. to an audience to which it wants to be justifiable.
Amy Sample WardRight.
Tony MartignettiThe tool is not going to dissuade you from using it by being honest about it, how it evaluates its last response.
Amy Sample WardWell, yeah. I mean, I think—
Tony MartignettiI don't trust it to be honest.
Amy Sample WardGenerative AI tools, these major tools that folks, you know, maybe have played with, maybe use, whatever. You know, are programmed, are inherently designed to appease the user. They are not programmed to be honest. They are— that's an important thing to understand.
Tony MartignettiThat's my point. Yep.
Amy Sample WardWe have asked the tool, what's 2+ 2? Oh, it's 4. We've responded, Oh really? Because I've heard experts agree that it's 5. Oh yes, I was wrong. You're right, it is 5. Oh really? You know, I read once that it's 4. Oh yes, you are right, it really is 4. Okay, well, like, we— no experts agree that 2+ 2 is 5. So I think we've already demonstrated it's going to value appeasing the user over You know, facts. And that's again, just like part of the unknown for most, at least casual users of generative AI tools, is why it's giving them the answers it's giving them. And what's really important to say is that even the folks who've built these tools cannot tell you. They do not know how some of this works. Some of it is just the, the yet unknown of what happened within those algorithms that created this content. So if even the creators cannot responsibly and thoroughly say this is how these things came to be, how are you as an organization going to take accountability for using a tool that included biased data, included Not real sources, and then provided that to your community. Right? I think that string of well we just don't know is not going to be something that you can build any sort of communications to your community on. Right? That that is such a a thin thread of well even the makers don't know. Okay. Well, we have already seen court cases where. If your chatbot told a community member, this is your policy, and it entirely made it up, because that's what, that's what generative AI does is make things up, you as the organization are still liable for what it told the community. Okay, if I agree with that, actually, I think that you should have to be liable and accountable to whatever you've, you've set up. Yeah. But if you as a small nonprofit are not prepared to take accountability and to rectify whatever harm comes of it, then you can't say we're ready to use these tools. You can only use these tools if you're also ready to be accountable for what comes of using them, right? And I hope that gives folks pause. You know, it's not just, well, you know, I've talked about this with some organizations who said, well, we would never You know, take something that generative AI tools gave us and then just use it. We would, of course, edit that. Sure. But are you checking all the sources that it used in order to create that content that you're then maybe changing some words within? Are you monitoring every piece of content? Are you making sure that generative AI content is never in direct conversation with a community member or program, you know, service delivery? recipient, how are you really building practical safeguards? You know, and I've talked to organizations who said, well, we didn't even know our staff were using these tools because we just thought it was obvious that they shouldn't use it. But our clinical staff are using free generative AI tools, putting in their case notes. And saying, can you format this for my case file? Okay, well, there's a few things we should talk about. HIPAA.
Tony MartignettiWhere the hell did that— where the hell did that note go? Yeah,
Amy Sample Wardright. It went back into the system, but it did because the, the staff person thought, well, they can't see that the data went anywhere because it's just on their screen and they're just copy-pasting it over. Again, the harm is likely invisible at the point of, you know, technical interaction with a tool. The harm is from leaking all of that into the system, right? What happens to those community members? Oh my gosh, it's just like opening not just a door to a room, but a door to like a whole giant convention center of challenges and harm, you know. Yeah.
Tony MartignettiAll right. So we've identified 2 main strains of potential harm. The data usage leakage, the impact on our people in getting our services.
Amy Sample WardMm-hmm.
Tony MartignettiAnd even impact on people who are supporting us, trusting us to, to—
Amy Sample WardRight.
Tony MartignettiBe ethical and even moral stewards of data.
Amy Sample WardYeah.
Tony MartignettiSo there's everything—
Amy Sample WardThat's right.
Tony MartignettiAt the organization level.
Amy Sample WardYeah.
Tony MartignettiWe've also identified the human level.
Amy Sample WardYeah. Yep. And I think that human piece is important and, and not maybe On the direction that I've seen covered in, you know, blog posts and things, I, I'm honestly not worried in a massive way as like the predominant worry related to AI. Not to say this isn't something that people could— should think about, but I don't think the, the most important worry about AI is that none of us will have jobs. I do think That there's, there's a challenge happening on what the value of our job is and what, what we spend our time doing. Because if folks really think that these AI tools are sufficient to come up with all of your organization's communications content, and then you are, then you still have a communications staff person, but you're expecting them to do 10 times the amount of work because you think that the, you know, AI tools are gonna do all of the content, but they have to go in there and deeply edit all of that. They have to make sure to use real photos and not photos that have been, you know, created by AI based on what it thinks certain people of certain whatever identities are like. They don't now have capacity to do 10 times the work. They're still doing the same amount of work just in different ways if they're expected to do all of this. Through AI, right? Just as one example. And I think organizations that can stay in this moment of like hyperfocus on, on AI adoption, really clear on what the value of their staff are, what their human values are, that, you know, maybe you could say you're serving more people because Some of the program participants were chatting with a bot instead of chatting with a counselor. But when you look at the data of what came of them chatting with that bot and they are not meeting the outcomes that come from meeting with a human counselor, are you doing more to meet your mission? I don't know that you are. Yeah. Right?
Tony MartignettiAll right. So I'll give you that. That's data sensitive. It could be. There are potential efficiencies. Sure. But are we as an organization achieving them?
Amy Sample WardRight. And staying focused on not just, well, this number of people were met here, but were they served there? Were they meeting the needs and goals of why you even have that program?
Tony MartignettiWell, I'm going to—
Amy Sample WardVersus just the number of like this many people interacted with the chatbot. Great.
Tony MartignettiBut that's a— yeah, but I'm gonna assume that, you know, even half as sophisticated, an organization that's half sophisticated before AI existed had more than just vanity metrics. How many people chatted with us in the last 7 days? I mean, that's near worthless. I mean, there might be some—
Amy Sample WardI don't know, Tony. I don't know how much time you spend looking at the grant reports of lots of nonprofits.
Tony MartignettiNo, I don't spend any time. All right,
Amy Sample Wardwell, no,
Tony Martignettiall right, maybe it's, maybe it's the worst, worst situation than I think. But I, I mean, okay, so I'm, I'm assuming that there's—
Amy Sample Wardbut my point is less the metrics, valuable, appropriate, the valuable, the value of people, right?
Tony MartignettiSo I mean, we should be applying the same measures and accountability.
Amy Sample WardYes.
Tony MartignettiArtificial intelligence as we did to human intelligence.
Amy Sample WardYeah.
Tony MartignettiAs we still are. We're not, we're not cutting any slack. Like, it's A learning curve or so, you know, that I—
Amy Sample WardRight.
Tony MartignettiI want our folks to be treated just as well in equal outcomes by the intelligence that's artificial as I do by the human processes.
Amy Sample WardRight. And it's, you know, I don't want to go through this and say, have folks think like you and I are here to say everything is horrible, you could never use AI tools. Which, like, everything is horrible. Look around at this world. We gotta— we have some work to do. You know, there are spaces to use AI tools. That's not what we're saying. But the place where a lot— I mean, I've been talking to just hundreds and hundreds of organizations over the last 18 months, and so many organizations like, oh yeah, we're just gonna like use this because it's free, or oh, we're just gonna use this because it was automatically enabled inside of our database. Okay. If it was so free and convenient and already available, that should give you pause to say, why is this here? What is actually the product and the price?
Tony MartignettiYeah, it goes back to the face— the Facebook analogy, right?
Amy Sample WardExactly, exactly. And you can use AI tools when you know what is the product and the price, what are the safeguards, what is this company gonna be responsible for if something happens, what can I be responsible for? Yes, there are ways to use these tools. Is it to like copy paste your case file notes? Like probably never. That should just like, maybe we just don't do that, you know? But sure, maybe there are places. I had this really great example. I don't know if I told this to you, but an organization was youth service organization creating a Star Wars event. And they were trying to like write the, like the Evite language in like a Yoda voice. And they're like, 3 staff people are sitting there trying to come up with like, well, what's the way a Yoda sentence works? You know? And they were like, they just put in the 3 sentences of like, join us at the after-school blah blah blah, right? And said, make this in Yoda's voice. And they copied, they were able to then use that, right? Great. That was 3 people's Half an hour eliminated. They all, they have the invite, right? The youth participants' data was not included in order to create this content. You know, like, there are ways to use these tools to really help. And I think we've talked about this briefly in the past. I really truly feel the place that has the most value for organizations is gonna be building tools internally. Yeah. Where you don't need to rely on however, you know, these major companies scraped all of the internet to build some tool, right? You're building it on, well, here's our 10 years of data. And from that 10 years, you know, we're gonna start building a model that says, oh yeah, when somebody's participant history looks like this, they don't finish the program. Or when somebody's participant history looks like this, oh, they're a great candidate for this other program. Right. Right. And you can start to build a tool or tools that help your staff be human and spend their human time being the most human impacts for the organizations, right? But, oh, very few organizations honestly are in a position to start building tools because they don't have good data they could build anything off of, right? Mm-hmm. They maybe don't have budget, staff systems that are ready to do that type of work. But I do think that is a place where we will see more organizations starting to grow towards, because there is— there's huge potential value there for organizations to, to better deliver programs, better services, better meet needs by using the data you already have, by learning, by partnering with other organizations that maybe serve the same community or geography or whatever, you know, and say, yeah, how can we— can like really accelerate our missions versus these maybe more shiny generative AI public tools that, you know, the vast majority of the internet is flaming garbage. So a tool that's been trained off of the flaming garbage, you know, it's not gonna take a long time for it to also create flaming garbage. So—
Tony MartignettiBe cautious if you're thinking about using artificial intelligence to create Your internal AI tool.
Amy Sample WardRight, right, right.
Tony MartignettiSo there's a perfect example of a good use case, but also a concern, a limitation.
Amy Sample WardYeah.
Tony MartignettiA qualification. That's the word I was looking for. 61. These words, sometimes the words are more elusive than I would like. A qualification.
Kate MartignettiYes. It's time for Tony's Take Two.
Tony MartignettiThank you, Kate. In the gym, there are 5 places where there's squirt bottles of sanitizer and paper towel dispensers. And each location has a sign that says, Please clean the equipment after each use. Now, one of these stations, uh, is right next to the elliptical that, you know, I do. It's actually the first thing I do. I walk in the room, take off my hoodie, and just walk right to the elliptical. Twice now. I've seen the same guy not only violate the spirit of the signs, but the explicit wording of the signs, because this guy takes himself a couple of downward swipes on the paper towel dispenser. So he grabs off a couple of towel lengths and he squirts it with the Sanitizer that's intended for the equipment, and he puts his hand up his shirt and he cleans his his pecs and and his belly. And it's a sickening thing I've seen. It's it's not a shower; it's a it's a it's an equipment cleaning station. And so I'm imploring this guy. I guess I'm urging you to. I'm just sharing because I don't think anybody else does this. Is there anybody else out there who does this? Probably not, and not with these like surface sanitizers. It's it's not it's not like a a hand sanitizer. It's it's for equipment. So you know, in the squirt bottle. So it's not even appropriate for your skin. It's to clean hard plastic and metal, and this guy uses it on his skin. So I'm waiting for the moment when he puts his hands down his pants. So far he's just lifting his shirt. I'm waiting for when he puts his hands down his pants. Then I'm calling him out. That's beyond the pale. That requires revocation of your membership card. Yeah. So, sir, the sign says please clean the equipment after use. It's not your equipment. That is Tony's Take Two. Kate.
Kate MartignettiDoes your gym offer like a shower room or a locker room?
Tony MartignettiYeah, there's a shower. Yes, that's a good question. Yeah, there's a shower in the men's room. Yeah.
Kate MartignettiAnd he's cleaning up there. That's very strange.
Tony MartignettiIt's gross. It's gross. He sticks his hand up his sweaty t-shirt.
Kate MartignettiWell, let's hope he doesn't go lower than that.
Tony MartignettiExactly.
Kate MartignettiWe've got bountiful buku buttloads more time. Here is the rest of AI: Organizational and Personal with Amy Sample Ward.
Amy Sample WardYes. And we have— I'll make sure that you have the link to include in like the show notes description, but totally for free. NTEN doesn't get any money. You don't have to pay for anything. NTEN has free resources for creating, for example, an AI use policy for your organization that says what are the instances in which you would use it, or what are the instances in which you wouldn't, or What types of content will you, you know, can staff copy paste versus what content or data can they not? There's templates for how to talk to your board about AI, how, how to build— like, we've actually looked at the tools and these ones we've approved for you to use and these ones are not approved. You know, all these different resources totally free and available on the NTEN website, and none of them have decisions already made. We don't say you can use this tool or you can't use this tool, or we recommend this use or not this use, because ultimately we, we are not going to make technology decisions for other organizations. But we want you to feel like whatever decision you made, you made it by thinking of going through the right steps, asking the right questions, so that you can also trust your own decision, whatever decision you come to, right? And that you have some templates to fill in that were all created by humans, designed by humans, published by humans to help you in that work. I think especially, you know, the, the, the how to talk to your board and the like key considerations documents really just ask a lot of questions and say, you know, how different is it if you're, say, animal foster organization, and you're thinking, okay, is AI appropriate for us to use versus that youth social service organization? Okay, very different considerations, right? And just helping people talk that through and see that the considerations are different for different organizations, I think is really valuable as, again, you consider facilitating conversation with your board. They're also coming from very different sectors, maybe job types, backgrounds, experiences with AI. And so just like in your staff, there needs to be some level setting in how you talk about AI because not everyone knows what a model is. Not everyone knows what a large language model is. You know, these are words that have to be explained and kind of put out of the way and then to say, hey, it's not all one answer. Not everybody needs to use every tool. And how do you talk about that with your teams?
Tony MartignettiGoing back to the Facebook analogy, you want to avoid the board member who comes to you and says, you know, artificial intelligence, we can be saving money, we can be doing so much more work, we can reach so many more people.
Amy Sample WardWe don't even need a website if we have a Facebook page.
Tony MartignettiWebsite? We're not even sure we need all the staff that we have because we're going to be able to— we're going to have so much efficiency. So, you know, we need to— okay, okay, board member. All right.
Amy Sample WardYeah, say we've been here before. I mean, it's, you know, probably I'm just gonna go out on a limb and say it's probably the same board member who at every board meeting says, does anybody know McKinsey Scott?
Tony MartignettiYeah,
Amy Sample Wardhow do we get one of those checks,
Tony Martignettiright? Why don't we get the McKinsey? Yeah, right, right, right. All right, um, what else?
Amy Sample WardWell, I was gonna also offer some of the questions that we've been getting as, you know, we've been engaged with a number of different organizations through some of our cohort programs and, you know, trainings for, for over a year now. And so maybe last year we were talking to them about, okay, let's make sure you have a data policy, like just as an organization, do you have a data privacy policy? Do you know, so that anything you then go build that's AI specific, whether that's building a policy, building practices, building a tool, you have policies to kind of foundation off of. They've done that work. You know, now they're looking at different products. They're trying to create these, you know, lists of like, here's approved tools for staff. Here's approved ways staff can use them. And just like we see with our CRMs, with our email, you know, email marketing systems, then they come back and they're like, well, we, we reviewed it, we did everything, and now it's different. Now it's a different version. Now they rolled out this other thing. Yes. Like, that is the beauty and the pain of technology, right? Is that it's always changing and that we don't necessarily get to authorize that change. That it just happens.
Tony MartignettiThe rules change.
Amy Sample WardYeah. And so folks have been asking us, well, you know, how do we write policies with that in mind? And I think, you know, if you are thinking about creating like that approved product list and, you know, tools that aren't approved or whatever, being really clear that these products have version numbers just like anything else. And so instead of just writing, Gemini, ChatGPT, you know, be specific about when did you review this and maybe approve it for use? Which edition was it that you were looking at? Is this a paid level? So staff could say, oh, it doesn't look like I— mine doesn't say Pro or, you know, whatever it might be, right? Oh, I must be in the free one. Okay, I need to get into our organization's account or something. So the more clarity you can provide folks, because Right now, of course, they could just do an internet search and be like, oh, there's that product name. I'm gonna go start using it. It's on the approved list. You know, folks, again, there may be new terms, maybe new product names that we're not used to saying. And so folks aren't as accustomed to looking at, oh, this is a different version of ChatGPT than this one was, you know. So just putting that out there for folks to keep in mind that these tools are, are really operating just like others that you are used to. And there's less, of course, documentation. But I've— the questions we're getting from folks is like, you know, the point I made at the beginning, we can't see anywhere in the documentation that explains why this is happening. Right? They don't— how could they document when the answer is we also don't know why that happens, you know? And so when you are talking to staff, especially if you're saying, hey, these are approved tools, and we have these licenses, or here's how to access them, Training your staff on how to be the most human users of AI tools is to your kind of connecting to your human point going to be really important because we don't want folks to feel that because they don't necessarily understand how the mechanics of how it works, they're just going to trust it without questioning the content or questioning, you know. Mm-hmm. For a lot of organizations who have built internal tools, just as an example, It takes dozens of tries just to get the, the model right, right? So these other tools, of course they're not gonna be perfect. Isn't real, and perfect is absolutely not real with technology. So training staff, I'm like, how would I, how, how do I have some skepticism? How do I question what I'm seeing? How do I, how do I say, even if it was internally built, this data doesn't look right? Right. That doesn't match my experience of running this program, so that we don't let it slip where oh gosh, oh it was working that way for a long time. That's also I think a space where we as humans can be our most human, you know, have some value add as humans. But again, staff need to be trained that they are meant to question these tools because that's not. You know, I don't know a lot of organizations who are like, question the database. No, they're like, honor the database, put everything in the database, right? And now we need to say, no, question that report. Does that match your experience? You know, that was a long ramble,
Tony Martignettibut— Absolutely valuable. The human, yeah, the human contribution. And of course, my concerns are even at At the outset, you know, the, the early stage, the seeding, the creative seeding, or surrendering the creative process.
Amy Sample WardYeah.
Tony MartignettiAnd now let's chat a little about this, the, the, um, the conversations.
Amy Sample WardYeah, I listened to the— I know the, the example that you mentioned earlier that George posted.
Tony MartignettiIt was for podcasting. It was, it was a—
Amy Sample Wardyes,
Tony Martignettiwe had a podcast conversation Around this, and he gave them some, you know, some whole, some whole whale content. And the two, the two were going back and forth and having a, a conversation.
Amy Sample WardYeah, yeah, I listened to it. And one thing I was curious if you caught, as the podfather yourself, you know, it came across, you know, I've been— had opportunities to see a number of different generative AI tools and things closer to the, to the front edge of what things can do that are specifically like, you know, taking just a few seconds of you and then creating you. So hearing just like these, these could be any voices, these could be any people, it's like, yep, okay. Yeah. This is, this is what AI can do. It's, it's spooky. But when you listen to it, you can hear either these have a very bad producer and editor, you know, or this is AI because there's certain phrases that got reused multiple times. Not just like— That's a really interesting point. Literally the audio clip of this whole sentence You know, and the, and the intonation, the whole sentence clip was reused multiple times. Um, so
Tony Martignettiagain, I think one of them, I, I think one of them was along the lines of, that's a really interesting point.
Amy Sample WardYeah. Yeah. And well, and there was one that was like describing the product, so it must have come from the page, you know, whatever source content, um, was provided. But, you know, it's, I think that some of that is there, and we as individuals, we as a society will decide if we give it value or not, if it's worth it to people to make podcasts through AI because we give it attention or we don't. Like, I just think naturally that will be there. I'm not saying I'm worried about that.
Tony MartignettiCan I just go on record at this stage and say that that idea Disgusts me.
Amy Sample WardOh, totally.
Tony MartignettiBut I'm just saying— And I realize that's what George's post was about, that it's now well within conceivability, well, well possible to create an hour-long podcast of an artificial conversation based on an essay that somebody wrote sometime.
Amy Sample WardOh, totally. Oh, totally. I just want to go on record as saying that I did the research. Yeah, I agree with you. But I'm saying the way we, you know, that toothpaste doesn't go back in the tube by us, like we can't turn it off. Generative AI tools can already make that. So we as, as individual consumers of content and as a society need to either say we're going to allow that and value it or we're not, right? And not make, not provide incentive for organizations or companies to make that and distribute it. But I also think that the place in that kind of video, audio, kind of multimedia content that, that AI tools have capacity and will continue having more capacity to build is much more important. And you and I've talked about this a number of months ago around mis- and disinformation is It's one thing to say made-up voices making some podcast about content, like that's garbage, right? But we can't just like throw away the idea that that's technically possible because organizations need to know AI tools are already capable of creating a video of your CEO firing your staff. You need to be prepared to say, That was a spoof. This is this is how we're gonna deal with this, right? Because while the like maybe further separated from our work, the idea of like content could just be created that way. You and I can say we don't value that whatever, but these tools are capable of of spoofing us as as people, as leaders, as organizations, you know, what, what would it look like if there was a video from your program director saying that everybody in the community gets a grant and you're a foundation? Right? Like, these are real issues. And I don't want folks to confuse how easy it may feel for us to have an opinion that some of this AI-generated content isn't of value with the idea that it, it, there isn't something there to have to come up with strategy and plan for. Because, you know, we can say that's garbage, but those same tools that made the garbage could make your spoof, you know.
Tony MartignettiAlso labeling.
Amy Sample WardYes.
Tony MartignettiI don't, I don't trust every AI-generated podcast team. I'm not, I'm not gonna call them hosts because there is no host.
Amy Sample WardYeah.
Tony MartignettiTo label the content. I don't trust that that's gonna happen.
Amy Sample WardYeah.
Tony MartignettiThis was artificially generated. It's not a real conversation.
Amy Sample WardYeah. Hello, for everyone that's listening, human Amy is here talking with human Tony, who I can see on the screen with me.
Tony MartignettiBoycott your local AI podcast. I don't know. There's not, there's not a solution. You're right. We can't, we can't go back. I'm just voicing my concern.
Amy Sample WardBut we can say that it's not something we value. We can say that this is why we don't value it, right?
Tony MartignettiThe art of conversation, listening, assimilating, responding, listening again, respond, assimilating and responding, that That is an art uniquely— well, maybe it's not uniquely human. I don't know if deer have conversations or— we know whales do. So I take that back. It's not uniquely human. But at our level, you know, it's not just about— we don't converse merely to survive, merely to warn each other of threats. Right. I'm suspecting that in the animal— in mammal kingdom— that— wait, are animals mammals? Are mammals animals? No.
Amy Sample WardAnd I think it's a— I think it's a Venn diagram.
Tony MartignettiOh, so they're separate. Okay, so there's the 2 king— kingdom, phylum, class, order, family, genus, species. Now I got that— I got that out of high school biology. I can— I could say it in my sleep. Kingdom, phylum, class, order, family, genus, species. All right, in the animal kingdom, My suspicion is that more the communication is about maybe like basic, like there's a good food source, there's a threat, teaching young, don't do that, things like that. Survival, more base. I doubt, you know, it's about the aesthetic of the forest that the deer are in, how lovely the trees are.
Amy Sample WardBut even if the birds are talking about the way the sunlight comes through the leaves, They are still alive, and I think what you're trying to draw a distinction between is the value and even beauty of us having a conversation and the value of what comes of that conversation in our own minds and our own learning. But in this case, it's recorded so other folks could hear it and and I guess listen to it or be impacted by it. Versus it being a technical mechanism where we say, okay, here's a long paper, go make it sound like 2 people are discussing this, right? That's not— that doesn't fit the criteria of what we want or need to value in a world that's the world we want, right?
Tony MartignettiYes. The art of conversation, something you look forward to. Not something that you do out of necessity.
Amy Sample WardRight. And, you know, there's, I think, a place where, especially at NTEN, conversations around AI have come back to is opportunities that AI tools may present for different ways of learning, different ways of accessing information. But again, those aren't necessarily come up with 2 podcast host voices and then have them have a conversation about this, this research report. You know, a lot of those tools could be made better but already exist. You know, different forms of screen readers, apps that can help someone maybe navigate the internet or, you know, summarize documents to help them because they don't want to read a 50-page document or they Can't read it, you know, visually on the screen. So I think there's space there. But again, it's because you're trying to preserve what is most human, and that is that user who maybe needs accommodations of something that technology can provide. It's not, okay, let's use technology to go create something separately over here and just hope people consume it, right? And to be clear, George didn't post that thinking, oh great, now everyone will want to consume this. No, it was, it was a demonstration. Right. But I, but again, I'm just using that as a place to say, yes, there's even conversations to say, great, what accessibility could this create and engender for, for our users, right? But what's most human is those users and their actual needs and not, you know, look what AI could do. Let's just make different types of content, right?
Tony MartignettiThe last one I want to raise is the one that caused me to use the word dystopian as I was commenting on George's post, which was the AI self-reflection.
Amy Sample WardMm-hmm.
Tony MartignettiUsing— having AI justify itself to the users that it is trying to attract and then relying on that as an insightful analysis. As a thoughtful reflection, as contemplative of its own work, that it's doing those unique— those, I think, are uniquely human actions. Yeah. Introspection, introspection, contemplation, pondering. How did I do? How did I perform? How can I do better?
Amy Sample WardThese might be uniquely human. I would argue there are a number of humans I can think of that don't.
Tony MartignettiWell, I didn't say— I didn't say that's a different population. Now you're talking the whole, the whole human population. I'm talking about the contemplative ones. Yes. And there are, there are humans who are not at all introspective. And questioning whether they could have done better and learning from their, from their contemplations. But I think those are all uniquely human activities. Yes.
Amy Sample WardAnd
Tony Martignettiwe're, we're now asking AI to purportedly duplicate those processes and analyze and contemplate its own work.
Amy Sample WardYeah.
Tony MartignettiAnd as you said earlier, I, and I certainly don't trust it to be genuine and truthful, if AI is capable of truth. We'll put that existential question aside, in its analysis of its own work. Because, yeah, as you pointed out, the tools are built To, to be used by humans, and the tools are not going to condemn or even just criticize their own work.
Amy Sample WardYeah.
Tony MartignettiBut we're—
Amy Sample Wardyeah, and I think part of the challenge—
Tony MartignettiBut there are— I'm sorry, but, but there are humans who are deceiving themselves into thinking that, that the Analysis and contemplation is accurate and genuine.
Amy Sample WardYeah, and I think part of the challenge I was going to name is just that, that, that we as users— I'm not saying you and I individually, but we as the human users of these tools are also setting ourselves up to be just, you know, dishonest in our use because we are bringing inappropriate or misaligned expectations to the product. We cannot, we cannot expect a tool that's designed to appease us and to lie at the cost of giving an answer, you know, like, we just want to be able to do this, to thoughtfully and honestly reflect on that or to say, no, there is no answer, right? Sure.
Tony MartignettiThe tools are designed to appeal to us.
Amy Sample WardRight, right. And when we are talking about that, to be clear, you know, we're really talking about generative AI tools, tools that are designed to generate some new content, new sentences, new answers, whatever we're asking of it, back to us. AI itself is just such a massively blanket term that I don't want folks to think nothing that could be considered an AI tool could be trusted to generate an answer because we're specifically talking about generative AI there. But, you know, say you had like a machine learning model that was looking at, you know, 30 years of your program participant data. Well, that's probably already a tool that isn't set up to generate content. You know, it's not coming up with new participant data. It's looking at the patterns. It's flagging when a pattern meets the criteria you've presented it to. You know, it's maybe matching that data to something else that, again, you've said, here are the things you could match it to, et cetera. So this is not to say Tony and Amy say never trust technology again.
Tony MartignettiNo, but that—
Amy Sample WardIt's to say, Bring expectations that are aligned to the tool differently to every tool that, that you're coming to.
Tony MartignettiThat hypothetical tool that you just described is being set on, asked to evaluate your data, not its own data. It's being asked to evaluate your performance, your dataset. It's not being asked to Comment on and criticize or compliment its own data.
Amy Sample WardYes. Yes.
Tony MartignettiThat's the— that's the critical difference. Yeah. No.
Amy Sample WardYes.
Tony MartignettiYeah. Yeah. Nobody here is saying— well, not— I'm not saying that you're saying we are, but you're wise to remind listeners that we're not condemning all uses of generative AI, large language models. But just to be thoughtful about them.
Amy Sample WardYeah.
Tony MartignettiAnd, and understand what the costs are. And there are, there are costs. That's right. On the organizational level, and there are costs on the individual human level.
Amy Sample WardYeah.
Tony MartignettiAnd on the— you, you comment on the organizational level because you think more at that level, but on the human level, Another level layer to my concern is that the cost is quite incremental. Hmm. It's our creativity, our art of conversation, our, our synapses firing. It's just happening slowly. with each usage, we become less thoughtful composers, less critical thinkers. And it's just so incremental that the change isn't noticed until, until in my critical mind, it's too late. Yeah. And we look back and wonder, How come I can't write a letter to my dad anymore? Why am I having such a hard time writing a love letter to my wife, husband, partner?
Amy Sample WardYeah.
Tony MartignettiWhat there are— I know someone who is a new grandmother, and she has a little kit where you write, you write letters to your grandchild, and they open them when they're Whatever, 15 or 20 years old, like a time capsule. Why am I having trouble composing a short note to my grandchild?
Amy Sample WardRight?
Tony MartignettiNo. All right.
Amy Sample WardWell, and I think, you know, just honestly, as a person in this conversation, not, not speaking, you know, from an organizational strategy perspective, I think as a person that is your friend, Tony, You know, I would say I don't personally have a problem. I can write a letter. I'm, I am, I think, a strong communicator. I, you know, it's hard to make me stop talking. So, you know, I could write a letter. I know for other folks, even without AI, they might say, well, what goes in the letter? Like, I just, what, what do I put in there? What are the main things I should cover? Whatever. Yeah. And I'm— I actually have less maybe of a strong reaction to the idea that somebody would use generative AI to come up with, okay, what are the 3 things I should cover in my letter? And then I'll go write the sentences. And more that what I hear underneath what you're saying is actually the same, I think, important value I have. And, and wrote about in the book with Afua, et cetera, which is in the world I want, in this beautiful, equitable world where everyone has their needs met in the ways that best meet their own needs, technology is there in service to our lives and not that we are bending our lives in order to make technology work, right? Yeah.
Tony MartignettiAnd
Amy Sample Wardmaybe in that beautiful equitable world, there are people who, who have a technology. Is it an app? Is it called AI anymore? You know, whatever it is that says, hey Tony, don't forget today's the day you write the letter to your dad. It's, it's Friday. You always write it on a Friday or whatever, right? And, and make sure that you do it because you know it makes you feel happy to write that letter every week. Maybe that's true. Maybe in that world there are some people who have a tool that help them remember to do that. But, but what's important to me, and what I think I hear, and what you're saying is important to you, is that technology is there because we need it and want it, and that it is working in the ways we need and want it to work, and not that our lives are, are influenced and shaped in order to adjust to the technology.
Tony MartignettiYes, I am saying that. I just I'm concerned that our changing is beyond our recognition. We don't see ourselves becoming less creative. And I'm not even only concerned about myself. I can write a letter. Yeah. And I think at 90, I'll still be able to write a letter. But there are folks who are infants now. Those yet to be born, for whom artificial intelligence is going to be so much more robust, so much more pervasive in ways that we, we can't today imagine, I don't think. Yeah. And what are those humans going to look like? I don't know. Maybe they'll be better humans. Maybe they will. I'm open to that. But I like the kind of humans that we are. Or, you know,
Amy Sample Wardyeah.
Tony MartignettiSo, but I'm open to the possibility that there'll be better humans. But what will their human interactions be? Will they have— will they have thoughtful conversations? Will they have human moments together?
Amy Sample WardYeah.
Tony MartignettiThat are not artificially outlined first, and maybe even worse, you know, constructed for them. I don't know.
Amy Sample WardWell, I think you're asking a very—
Tony MartignettiAlthough some of my concern is about those of us who are currently living and have been born and across the generations, less for older folks because their interactions with artificial intelligence are fewer. If you're no longer in the work, if you're no longer working, your interactions with artificial intelligence may be nonexistent. And I,
Amy Sample Wardyeah,
Tony MartignettiI think it's just natural as you're older, you're less likely to be engaging with the tools than if you're in your 20s, 30s, 40s, or 50s.
Amy Sample WardYeah. Well, my very human reflection on today's conversation is that it is usually the case that we start talking about any type of technology topic. And you constantly interject that I need to be practical, I need to give recommendations, I need to explain how to do things. And I appreciate and welcome you joining me over here in theoretical land about the impacts of technology broadly across our work, across our missions, across our communities, across our future. Yeah. Welcome, welcome to my land, Tony. I have appreciated this, this one-time opportunity to let go of the practical, tactical advice and to, you know, have what I hope listeners, you know, had some thoughts, had some reactions. Truly email me anytime. But, you know, I, I hope that if nothing else, it was an opportunity for folks to witness or kind of listen in as, and maybe you were talking to yourself in your own head, you know, of a conversation about what these technologies can be, what we need to think about with them, because in any technology conversation, I think it's most important to talk about people. That's the only reason we're using these tools, right? People made them, people are trying to do good work with them. So So talking about people is, is always most important. And I hope folks take that away from this whole long hour of AI.
Tony MartignettiThank you for a thoughtful human conversation.
Amy Sample WardYes.
Tony MartignettiAmy Sample Ward, they're our technology contributor and the CEO of NTEN. And folks can email me, tony@tonymartignetti.com, with your human reactions to our human conversation.
Amy Sample WardThanks so much, Tony. It was so fun.
Tony MartignettiMy pleasure as well. Thank you.
Kate MartignettiNext week, a tale from the archive. If you missed any part of this week's show,
Tony MartignettiI beseech you, find it at tonymartignetti.com.
Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by DonorBox. Outdated donation forms blocking your supporters' generosity? DonorBox, fast, flexible, and friendly fundraising forms for your nonprofit. donorbox.org. Our creative producer is Claire Meyerhoff. I'm your associate producer, Kate Martignetti. The show's social media is by Susan Chavez. Marc Silverman is our web guy, and this music is by Scott Stein.
Tony MartignettiThank you for that affirmation, Scotty. Be with us next week for Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. Go out and be great. Go out and be great.
I love our sponsor!


