Board Members Are People Too


About this episode
One size fits all rules may not make sense for your board, especially if you’re embracing diversity and equity in board membership. Judy Levine is a longtime board coach, trainer and consultant, and she led Cause Effective for 17 years. She’s now an independent consultant. This originally aired August 15, 2022.
Here’s the transcript
Tony MartignettiHello and welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. I'm your aptly named host and the podfather of your favorite hebdomadal podcast. Oh, I'm glad you're with us. I'd suffer the embarrassment of pseudocholesteatoma if I had to hear that you missed this week's show. Here's our associate producer Kate with what's up this week.
Kate MartignettiHey Tony, we have board members are people too. One-size-fits-all rules may not make sense for your board. Especially if you're embracing diversity and equity in board membership. Judy Levine is a longtime board coach, trainer, and consultant, and she led Cause Effective for 17 years. She's now an independent consultant. This originally aired August 15th, 2022. On Tony's Take Two.
Tony MartignettiTariffs 101.
Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by DonorBox. Outdated donation forms blocking your supporters' generosity? DonorBox. Fast, flexible, and friendly fundraising forms for your nonprofit. donorbox.org. Here is Board Members Are People Too.
Tony MartignettiIt's a pleasure to welcome to Nonprofit Radio Judy Levine. She has been Executive Director of Cause Effective since 2006, and she has over 30 years experience as a nonprofit management advisor. At Cause Effective since 1993, and as an independent consultant, she has trained and consulted with well over 1,000 nonprofits on issues in fund diversification, Donor engagement, and board and organizational development. Cause Effective is at causeeffective.org. Judy, welcome to Nonprofit Radio.
Judy LevineThank you. I'm pleased to be here.
Tony MartignettiPleasure to have you. I've had your colleagues through the years, Greg Cohen and Susan Comfort, who I know Susan is completely retired now and Greg is mostly retired now. They've been sort of stepping stones to the top. Now we have the executive director. Okay. Is that
Judy Levineall right? Yep, here I am.
Tony MartignettiI'm glad. My apologies. Susan Comfort is someone else. Susan Gabriel is who used to be at Cause Effective.
Judy LevineLong time.
Tony MartignettiSusan Gabriel and Greg Cohen. You're concerned about equity on boards, but at the same time, you know, we're trying to maintain standards, but we want a diverse board. Standards don't always apply to all the, all the different cultures we're inviting in. Help me, uh, set this up.
Judy LevineWell, there's always a fear of the difference, the different, and, uh, then also a fear of, um, acting inappropriately around the different. And those 2 fears, um, sometimes stop a board from real honest an accurate reflection on what's at the table and what's the most appropriate way to support the organization's mission. And especially, you know, ever since the racial reckoning of 2020 and the understanding on nonprofits' parts that they needed to reckon with their own DEIB, diversity, equity, inclusion, and belonging. My sense is that, that, that hap— that reckoning has happened on a staff level at a different, different pace than it's happened on the board level. And some of that has to do with fundraising and people's fear that if they rock the boat, they will not have the fundraising return that they have now. And I'm here to say 2 things. One is that there is plenty of salaried capacity in this country for people of color, although not as much wealth accumulation, certainly generational wealth accumulation. And that's a very real factor. To think that you need to diversify your board, that you need to reach into the client base, which may be true, but is not the only way to diversify your board from the, uh, the group it has always been.
Tony MartignettiOkay, are those the two? That's what— that's number one.
Judy LevineThat's one. Yeah, the other is that yes, you may have to rethink the one-size-fits-all package. And that's been a mantra in our boards, is that everybody has to hold to the same standard, and we know that everybody is the same standard, and we don't want double standards or triple standards. I'm here to help people rethink the idea of universal standards versus standards that make sense for where that person is coming from and what they can, what they can actually bring to the table if they do their best.
Tony MartignettiOkay, let's take the first of those because there's an assumption there that people of color are not going to be able to meet our fundraising expectation. So we're going to have to reduce our board giving to invite folks of color in. But that's just unfair and racist. Yeah. You're not— if you're not finding these folks, then you're not looking hard enough for people who do have the means to meet your board expectation, your board fundraising expectation.
Judy LevineAnd/or you're not looking with the right messengers, and/or you're not understanding why your cause is going to be of deep personal interest just to a person of color. All of those factors have to be there. You can't— you don't ask anybody on the board. You don't ask somebody on the board of an animal shelter if they have no connection to animals. They don't care about animals. You've got to look. So in the same way, you have to understand— let's put it this way. There are legacy charities, the Urban League, you know, very— that There are huge fundraising machines that are people of color-led. There's a sense of the ownership that this is ours.
Tony MartignettiYeah.
Judy LevineThat may not be in your board as currently constituted that needs to be opened up.
Tony MartignettiYeah, that's a, that's a holding on to, that's a holding on to power and structures, and not allowing someone who looks different, comes from a different background, into our, our playground.
Judy LevineWell, and it's more than not allowing, it's actually, it's more than just a not doing, it's something that you have to actually do, do. Is to understand how— who makes decisions? Is there an in-group and an out-group? Is there a biding one's time ethos, which doesn't work well when you invite people of color on, and then they have to bide their time, and they're the only ones that are biding their time? And yes, it might be historical that everybody else bade their time years back. Yeah. But people are going to lose, lose, you know, they lose patience. So it means that you have to do much more rapid, um, leadership development, onboarding, and power sharing than your board may be used to.
Tony MartignettiYeah. All right, all right. I, I don't want to derail what, what, uh, what we were intending to talk about, but I just I think it's
Judy Levineall of a piece.
Tony MartignettiI mean, I think it's important to point out the implicit bias that goes along with this, assuming that you're gonna have to lower your standards, basically just assuming you got to lower your standards if you left people of color in. And I
Judy Levinethink it's all of a piece, and it's about who's—
Tony MartignettiThat's gross and erroneous.
Judy LevineAnd who's a guest at the table. And board members, all board members need to be owners, not guests.
Tony MartignettiYeah, yeah. Right. And yes, and not treated like guests. All right. All right. So one of the things you said is that one size fits all is not, is not going to be the right model.
Judy LevineNo.
Tony MartignettiNecessarily. So what, what's, what's an alternative? So if we've got a, if we've got a $15,000 annual give-get board requirement, And 2/3 of it has to be from your personal wealth, your personal assets. So $10,000 from you, and if you want to either give or get the other $5,000, you have an option there, but you have to give at least $10,000 a year.
Judy LevineWell, one of the things I want to talk about that took me, you know, frankly, you know, a while to understand is the role of generational wealth transfer in people's capacity to have disposable income. So that, you know, oftentimes white people come from— they're not necessarily coming from money money, but they're coming from a position of comfort. And so they're not necessarily carrying family members. They're not pulling their family out of poverty along with them. Oftentimes Certainly Black people who are in a— may make the same salary, but they are carrying people in their family. And so you can't say, oh, this person makes X salary and that person makes X salary, therefore they have the same capacity. You only find this out by talking to and listening to someone. And I— A universal give assumes universal capacity. And yes, we say, okay, this gives us a floor and everybody should go over the floor. We all know that people rise to the floor. So the question is, is there a way to help this person get and to change that relationship? And/or is there— what are we— what are— what we are after on the board, someone who is using their connections for the— to the extent— for the organization's behalf. And what comes in is relative to those connections and that capacity.
Kate MartignettiIt's time for a break. Imagine a fundraising partner that not only helps you raise more money but also supports you in retaining your donors. A partner that helps you raise funds both online And on location so you can grow your impact faster. That's DonorBox, a comprehensive suite of tools, services, and resources that gives fundraisers just like you a custom solution to tackle your unique challenges, helping you achieve the growth and sustainability your organization needs, helping you help others. Visit donorbox.org to learn more. Now back to Board Members Are People Too.
Tony MartignettiAll right, so we need to, we need to get to know our board members. And, you know, I understand your point. You know, some folks may very well be supporting, helping other family members, not necessarily out of poverty, but I mean, could be, but not necessarily out of poverty, but They're, they're, they're helping other family members that aren't doing as well as they are.
Judy LevineAnd they're asking—
Tony MartignettiAnd a lot of that can, a lot of that can very well come from the lack of intergenerational wealth through the generations that, that folks of color got screwed out of, essentially. All right. And I still want to go back to the fact that, you know, I don't want to operate under the assumption that you have to lower standards Just to invite folks of color.
Judy LevineI'm talking about lowering standards.
Tony MartignettiOnto your board. Well, lowering fundraising standards.
Judy LevineBut it's not lowering, it's broadening.
Tony MartignettiRight. Well, I don't want to operate on the assumption that you have to lower standards.
Judy LevineRight.
Tony MartignettiThat's what I'm trying to defeat, that assumption. Yeah. Okay. All right. So what about the pushback? Well, before we get to the pushback that you might hear from your white board members about We've been doing this for so long and it's been fine for us, so why can't it be okay for them? Before we get to that, what might some of this look like? What kinds of activities can folks do if they can't meet the— if they're not able to meet the give-get requirement? Are you suggesting rewriting? Do we rewrite the expectations for all board members?
Judy LevineI'm suggesting using that as a starting point, not an ending point.
Tony MartignettiOkay.
Judy LevineThat's a starting point with each board member about their— how it relates to them, to their assets, to their relationships, to their circumstances, and which areas they can go above and beyond in, and which areas they need to pull back from. And everybody's gonna have a different answer to that, those equations. The fact is that there are, you know, I've been on boards with very mixed income levels, and the people who had the higher incomes understood that in order to have a board with mixed demographics, they had to do more weight pulling in the fund gathering.
Tony MartignettiMm-hmm.
Judy LevineThat, that was part of the value system, was that it was not— if they wanted everybody equal, they would have everybody just like them. And if the value system was to have different voices at the table, Then the value system had to be that some people did more direct fundraising and direct giving, and some people did more outreach, and some people did more political conversations,
Tony Martignettietc. Okay. I want to make sure we want to be having these conversations with these individual conversations with potential board members, right? Where before we're in the recruitment process, Before we invite someone to be on a board, or before we accept someone to be on a board, we want to be investigating these things so that they know what to expect, so that they know what the expectations are, and we know what we can expect.
Judy LevineI, I, I, you know, having done a lot of board recruitment, uh, with nonprofits through the years, I would say 2 things. I, I think you have a— before, as you're recruiting, you say, here's the kinds of things that board members are expected to do. And, you know, how do these rest with you? And you'll find out some of them are scary. Some of them are, you know, oh, I couldn't do that. Some of them are like, oh, this— I could definitely do that. I don't know that I would pin someone down to an exact prescription. You're trying to get their temperature.
Tony MartignettiYeah.
Judy LevineBut, you know, it's a courtship process. And so people go above and beyond what they thought they could do when they're really excited by the mission and they're given the tools they didn't know they needed. So in the courtship process, I would put this menu out and say, you know, how does this look to you? How could you see yourself in this? But I wouldn't take that as the last word, because board service should be— people should be going into places that are not comfortable for them.
Tony MartignettiRight.
Judy LevineAnd that's partly the role of the board chair, is to live that by example. is not just to be good at what they do, but to live by example. I tried this and this was, you know, I thought I was going to throw up, but actually I didn't throw up. I did really well at it. And then I tried that and I did throw up. So I, you know, somebody else will do that one from now on. Um, and so I want to be honest with people, but I don't want to pin them down to something they're not being ready to be pinned to. Okay, right,
Tony Martignettiright. But you make a good point about board service being A challenge. You do want folks— I mean, you're leveraging the fact that they love your mission, your work, your values. They stand beside you with that in those ways. You want them to be challenged. You want board service to be meaningful.
Judy LevineYes, and you want them to learn something from it because that's part of what they get out of it. It's not just a happy club, but that they're gaining a different kind of sense of themselves, of what they're capable of.
Tony MartignettiInteresting. Different sense of themselves, what they're capable of. Yes, challenge. That's the challenge. That's the challenge. Go beyond comfort zone. Try this and see whether you throw up or not.
Judy LevineRight, kind of. But I mean, you need to try it with a lot of, um, support and, and with the tools.
Tony MartignettiYeah, yeah, yeah.
Judy LevineThrow somebody into the lion's den.
Tony MartignettiAll right, what about the, uh, the pushback from whiteboard members that, you know, we've been— this has always worked well for us. We've always had this very rigid, uniform giving. Everybody's given the same through these years. Why do we have to now? What's the advantage? Or why should we change now?
Judy LevineOkay, so I need to be polite here.
Tony MartignettiNo, you can be firm. You can be firm and realistic. You don't have to be polite.
Judy LevineI do a lot of counseling of white folks. And I think it's part of our job as white folks to help other white folks to a different place.
Tony MartignettiAll right, so don't be, don't be soft on Nonprofit Radio listeners. I'll, I'll admonish you. Don't do that.
Judy LevineOkay. Um, it's 2022. We know stuff now as white folks that we didn't, that we were able to be blind to for hundreds of years.
Tony MartignettiSort of had the comfort of being blind to.
Judy LevineYes. And, um, we don't anymore. So there's a moral obligation to act differently. Our nonprofit is, is, is here for the public good, and it, it— we believe that to do that, we need to reflect the full spectrum of voices that is that public and/or should be concerned with our mission. That means that we need to have a table That is really welcoming to all those voices, that they're not just here, but they're actually— we're going to share the ownership of this mission. And that does mean that we need to pull apart the stuff that we're comfortable with and that's unspoken, because it's going to be a mystery to somebody who doesn't come from our background and who isn't already part of this.
Tony MartignettiAnd what's the advantage to the organization? Let's make it explicit to doing this.
Judy LevineWe are living our values in our governance, and if we're not, that's pretty, um, compromised. Um, so one is congruence with organizational values and what we're here to try and carry out. Um, the second is sort of more robust conversation and decision-making because there are different points of view at the table, because it's not people with— it's not an entire crew with the same assumptions. And frankly, you'll have more interesting conversations, and it'll be a more interesting club to be part of. That's not why to do it, but it's a side product.
Kate MartignettiIt's time for Tony's Take Two.
Tony MartignettiThank you, Kate. We're going a little different this week, uh, because a subject I know about is in the news a lot— tariffs. I know about it because it's one of the few things that I remember from my economics degree at Carnegie Mellon University in 1984. So I've forgotten a ton of Micro and macroeconomics, but tariffs stayed with me, and they're in the news a lot. And the media doesn't seem to explain them fully. So I would like to take a minute to do that. Tariffs. What's a tariff? A tariff is a tax on goods that the United States imposes on goods that are imported. into our country. And of course, you know, other countries impose tariffs on goods that are imported into their countries. But, you know, we're talking about it from our perspective. But our government might do this to help an industry. Like, suppose you wanted to help the wine industry in the United States. You might put a tariff on wines that come from maybe France and Italy and Spain or something like that. Or if we want to help the— Right. washing machine industry or the auto industry. We might put tariffs on washing machines that come from maybe China or Mexico, wherever they might come from. Same with cars. Could be just certain countries, or we could say putting a tariff on all of the cars that come into the country from whatever country they come from. We might not pick individual countries. We might just say all the, all the cars that come into the United States. are getting an additional tax, a tariff, because we want to help our US auto industry, right? So it's kind of protecting industries. That's why they're used. And they're also sometimes used for punishment. If we're angry at another country, we might impose a tariff on that country's goods. What that does is, whatever the reason that we impose them, it raises the cost of these goods. Because there's an extra tax added to them. And so that hurts the, that hurts the goods, that hurts the companies that are bringing the goods into the country, right? So these tariffs are imposed on the companies, right? I mean, we might pick a country, but the tariff really is paid by the, by the, by the company that makes the good and ships it into the Into the United States, and who pays the tariff? This is the part that I don't see explained adequately in the media. We pay the tariff. We, the consumers, pay the tariff. It's a tax that's added to goods, and companies routinely increase the cost of their goods that are imported into the U.S. to reflect the cost, the increased cost. To them, because the, the tariff is now going to cost them more money. So they pass that cost on, that additional tax on to us, the people who pay to buy the goods, the washing machines or the wine or the car. A tariff is not paid by the foreign government, whether whatever government— Italy, Spain, France, China, wherever, wherever we're imposing a tariff on imports from. That government is not paying the tariff. We're paying the tariff, and then the money gets paid back to the United States government from the companies that make the goods that are tariffed and that are imported into the US. Okay, so the US government does get money. That's the tariff, but we're the ones paying it. We pay it to the company that make— made the goods, and then they pay the tariff to the United States. So like lots of things, the ultimate cost of these gets passed down to us, the consumers. And of course, we have nowhere to pass it on to, do we? We, we can't pass it on. There's no passing the buck beyond the consumer. So I just want everybody to understand. Yeah. Who is paying tariffs? When the United States government gets tariff money, where's it coming from? It's coming from us, the consumers. And that's Tony's Take Two. Kate.
Kate MartignettiThat was Tariff 101 with Professor Tony Martignetti.
Tony MartignettiUh, I don't know about professor. No, like, uh, adjunct, adjunct lecturer. Adjunct lecturer for a half, uh, for like 20 minutes on tariffs. Maybe I could, maybe I could expand it a little bit. So like 1/3 of one lecture, adjunct lecturer Tony Martignetti.
Kate MartignettiI wish all my lectures were that short in school.
Tony MartignettiThat insightful is what you mean.
Kate MartignettiInsightful. Well, you put a lot of information in a short amount of time, and I think a lot of professors could learn how to do that as well.
Tony MartignettiThat may be. Yeah, I— right, I'm not particularly verbose unless I'm having some fun with, uh, verbosity and, and, uh, wordsmithing. But, uh, otherwise, yeah, I'm— I think I'm pretty, pretty to the point. Yeah.
Kate MartignettiWell, we've got beaucoup buttloads more time. Here's the rest of Board Members Are People Too with Judy Levine.
Tony MartignettiAll right, so that sort of answers, uh, dumbing down. You know, we're not, we're not, we're broadening.
Judy LevineYeah.
Tony MartignettiWe're broadening, and there are advantages. What would you say to folks that are the advantages to them personally, learning, learning, learning about, learning from folks with different backgrounds?
Judy LevineThere is an incredible gift to be had to be able to listen. I'll say this personally as a white person working in a diverse environment. It is humbling and awe-inspiring to be in a place where you can really hear from people who didn't— who aren't just like you and have them change your mind. Yeah. And open your mind. That's what you gain by being in a diverse environment. And not only will you make better decisions for your nonprofit, but you will learn more and be a kinder person who in and of itself understands the way you interact with the rest of the world in a different way.
Tony MartignettiFolks, if you want to see a diverse team, then pause the podcast and go to causeeffective.org, go to their team or staff page, and look at the pictures of the staff at causeeffective.org. And then of course, come right back and press play again. Don't start browsing, you know, don't go to amazon.com too. Just look at causeeffective.org and you'll see an enormously diverse team there. All right, so, you know, anything more you want to say about why this is worth it for the organization or for the people? Yeah.
Judy LevineUm, we live in a diverse world. I mean, you know, no matter where you are, um, we, we live in a world, in a country certainly, and in a world with lots of different kinds of people from lots of different kinds of backgrounds that bring a lot of different things to the table and that are really interesting to interact with. Um, what better way to interact with them than in the support of a cause you love? So that there's, you know, you're all putting your, you know, shoulder to the wheel together. Um, it, it gives you your life spice to be doing this in a way that's not homogeneous, and your organization itself will be stronger.
Tony MartignettiYeah, in the ways you just, you talked about a few minutes ago. Yeah. You have some ideas about, uh, how to do this, uh, sort of efficiently and shave some, some time off what— Well, one
Judy Levineof the things that,
Tony Martignettiyou know, process might take—
Judy Levinewe all know that executive directors, well-run boards, executive directors are behind them at kind of every step of the way. Um, but in boards that really take off, there's board-to-board conversation that the executive director kind of monitors but is not part of every conversation. And so, and when that happens, it's because there are— there's not just a board cheerleader, but there are mini leaders. So there are leaders of governance, or there might be a leader of onboarding, or there might be a leader of You know, there's different ways to chunk it up so that there's leadership, which leadership leads to ownership. And so part of your job as the board liaison, whether— is to understand what that web of relationships is and could be, and then to do, in essence, what we call, you know, HR staff development, but with board members. So you ask them to take on certain things, and then your job is being a coach, not being a doer.
Tony MartignettiWe're talking about the CEO executive director now?
Judy LevineYes. Yeah. And the development director also.
Tony MartignettiDevelopment. And working closely with the board chair. I mean, it's gonna help enormously to have a culturally sensitive board chair.
Judy LevineYes. I send board members, especially white board members, to trainings, and not just what is DEI, but to real immersive, you know, 1 or 2-day trainings about the— how this culture rests on— has rested on racial injustice. I say, if you're going to be part of this organization, you need to have this basic understanding, and we need you to do this 2-day training, and here's, you know, How to pay for it. Um, because there's a basic understanding of that that really shifts in those kinds of very immersive trainings. I'm not talking about a 2-hour what HR does at a large corporation.
Tony MartignettiYeah.
Judy LevineUm, and you know, we've just said these are our values and you have to really get it if you're going to be part of this team. I would certainly do that with board leadership, that this is a journey and this is part of the— and, and we want the board to be part of this journey, and we need the board leadership to start it out. And if the board chair won't do that, you do a succession plan. It's not like you kick them out right away, but ultimately your board's not going to progress until you have somebody at the head of it for whom this is the air they breathe. Hmm. Now, you can have a chair and a president. You can have an honorary chair and an honor— you know, there are all kinds of ways to move people to the side that don't, you know, kick them off this planet. But ultimately, you need to have someone who does, who breathes this stuff, and who you don't have to explain why this matters. And then it's deeper than going to a training to understand what implicit bias exists.
Tony MartignettiRight, one of those 2-hour trainings. Okay, say a little more about joyful board service, what we can aspire to.
Judy LevineI, you know, I get this so often where board members, the boards that we're working on, they're niggling, they're going after, you know, Do I have, you know, is it 2,000 or 3,000? What do I have to do? That's the question. As to what, as to, you know, it's like I'd like to get away with as little as I can, and it's an imposition on me. As opposed to I will do everything I can. I may not be successful at everything, but I'm going to give it a shot because this mission matters so much. And if I can help it. God willing, I'm going to. And there's— when people are at the table with that attitude, there can be a joy at both delivering yourself and seeing other people deliver and celebrating that. Um, and you can build that in. You can build in celebrations. You can build in, you know, balloons for somebody when they hit a certain mark. Um, you have to build in not just Um, the actual dollars, but you can build in, they made thank you calls and they never talked to anybody before. You know, there's all kinds of ways to build in a sense that I can do, be part of the fundraising process, which then builds more courage for the next step. But it doesn't happen unless you think about it.
Tony MartignettiCelebrating small successes, that's, that's a terrific idea.
Judy LevineYeah, and you want to build in this, this sense of— from— for every board member so that they are looking for ways to celebrate each other. Hmm. So it doesn't just come from you, the CEO, it doesn't just come from the board chair, but that they're trying to help each other up that ladder.
Tony MartignettiYou like to see board members, uh, Socializing outside? I mean, I, I can presume your answer, but I want you to say it. Socializing outside, outside the, the board meetings?
Judy LevineI, I, I, I do, but I also am realistic. Um, I don't think it's necessary for them to be personal friends. In fact, I've been on boards with people who are personal friends, and it's tough, um, because then they kind of talk about things outside, and there, it becomes factions. You certainly don't want, uh, relatives on the same board, that I'll tell you right now. Not just married, but brother and sister replaying the, you know, the childhoods. You know, I've seen it all.
Tony MartignettiI can see in your face, and it sounds like you've been there.
Judy LevineYes. Siblings. I don't guess— I think that people have to like each other.
Tony MartignettiYeah.
Judy LevineAnd I think you need to have some social places. You know, it's been hard.
Tony MartignettiDon't they need to get to know each other outside the board?
Judy LevineBut that's different than Um, or outside
Tony Martignettitheir board service. I mean, maybe not, maybe not necessarily.
Judy LevineTo me, that's part of their board service.
Tony MartignettiOkay.
Judy LevineUm, that part of their board service is understand, you know, it's team building.
Tony MartignettiAnd the organization can facilitate that, right? I mean, can't we have— can we host drinks or dinner after a meeting?
Judy LevineYeah. Um, it's— that's one of the things that's been much harder in Zoom. Um, my board, you know, Cause Effective itself is a nonprofit, and they had a board dinner once a year. Like they used to have at my house. And one year I had the flu and they had it at my house anyway, and I just went to bed and they, they stayed up till like midnight and cleaned up after themselves and left. That we miss. So we have a game night now once a year on Zoom. Because it's once a year, everybody comes and they do all kinds of like 3 truths and a lie and all kinds of stuff. But it's not quite the same. We did have an outdoor picnic this summer. And about half the board came.
Tony MartignettiYeah.
Judy LevineIt's hard. You know, that's the hard thing is now getting people out of their shell because we're all used to now doing everything by Zoom or going to work and coming home and, you know, scurrying home. What Zoom has that I haven't quite figured out is that time before meetings, that time in the middle of meetings, you know, Those kind of times at the after-meetings, those kinds of times when people would talk to each other about their kids.
Tony MartignettiYeah, right.
Judy LevineBuilding that in. What we've done some of is in the— you have to do it in the middle of the meeting because people run out at the end of the meeting and they won't come early no matter what they say. You know, 2 board members will come early.
Tony MartignettiRight.
Judy LevineBut if you break into smaller groups in the middle of the meeting, even if it's only dyads or triads, And give them something to discuss. Um, you know, one of my provocative questions is, how does your birth order affect, um, the way you take on leadership? Which gets into all kinds of personal background. It assumes strength, and it gets people talking to each other. So having a section like that in the middle of each board meeting Can help people to start to bond. And then obviously changing the, you know, changing the groups up.
Tony MartignettiYeah.
Judy LevineAnd making that group— a hint, make those small groupings deliberate. Don't just leave it to the Zoom universe to deliver the development.
Tony MartignettiYeah, you can either make them random or you can assign people to be with, with other, with other people. And the assigning is, is much better. Yeah. Yeah, I've done that in some of my trainings. What else? What else do you want to touch on around this, this equity and equity in boards and, and inviting folks in and joyful board service? Welcoming—
Judy LevineNotion of enlightened self-interest, which I think it has to do with understanding the Uh, the meaning of your cause to people who are not directly affected by it. So, you know, when we're teaching fundraising, we'll say, um, okay, you don't fundraise just for the people who have direct interest to your cause, because that's your clients, and if you could raise your money from them, that would be earned income and you wouldn't be a nonprofit. But you can't raise money from people who have no connection to your cause. Because it doesn't make sense to them. Why are they going to align on it? And that's the same thing with board members. You can't ask board members to fundraise if you— they don't feel connection to cause and/or to audiences that don't feel connection. But you have to find the enlightened self-interest, which is myself as a member of this city, this neighborhood, this grouping, that I care about children having a head start. That's why you'll often find like a mom's group in Westchester, a suburb of New York that's fairly wealthy, most of it, will take on fundraising for a program in the quote-unquote inner city because they understand the meaning of this work for children, even though it's not their children. And the reason I'm bringing this up is because that's where the ownership comes in, the sense that It's on to— it's up to me to make a difference for this, and that this matters to me even though it's not my personal experience. And I think that's group conversations. It's conversation in the courtship process, and then it's group conversations at the board level to keep that fresh. And it has to be deliberate because it's— the board service devolves into finance monitoring.
Tony MartignettiOh yeah, if it's right, if it's allowed to.
Judy LevineDiscussions about why the mission matters, to whom does the mission matter beyond just the direct recipients, are very inspiring, and they give your board members personal You know, nurturing, and the tools to go out to their contacts with different kinds of language. And you will often find, you know, I'm looking for areas in which different people can be experts, not just the people who have a lot of board experience, or who are, you know, longtime experienced fundraisers. But that people with different points of view can have the position of being an expert. And this is where you will find points of view that your classic cabal has not thought of.
Tony MartignettiConversations. Yes. I love how you pause and, and think through and then make your next point. I've Just in talking to you for, uh, 40 minutes, whatever, 35 minutes, I've learned, all right, give her a couple— give her a couple beats because, uh, she's got— she may very well have more to say. I love your— the way you reflect. I, I, I don't have that gift. I tend to be more, more impulsive, and I, I spew everything out in one shot.
Judy LevineWell, that's why you're on the radio and I'm not.
Tony MartignettiInteresting.
Judy LevineTotally. You know, I want to— having served on a board—
Tony MartignettiYou've been on multiple boards.
Judy LevineNot that many, because I take it really seriously.
Tony MartignettiYeah, but it's been more than one.
Judy LevineYeah. And then being an executive director myself and being a consultant to boards gives me humility about the possibility of board service. And I feel like people who are only on staff have expectations and anger when board members don't meet their expectations, whereas I'm trying to say it's human nature to triage. The kind of people who will agree to be on a board are often Fully committed. I don't want to say overcommitted because you commit to what you commit to. And it makes sense for them to do what they have to do and not more, because there's always something else calling on their time, let alone, you know, the idea that they might want to play golf or read a book. If you do that, if you understand it, that that's rational human behavior, then you don't get as angry at people. Right. You manage them.
Tony MartignettiThat everyone's going to triage, that they're gonna, they're gonna assess their priorities, and they're gonna, and they're gonna act accordingly.
Judy LevineAnd it's up to you to have a dialogue about that. It's not that you, you know, there's something wrong with letting people slide or something, but it's, um, it's understanding and helping them understand how to fit in with all the different priorities of their life.
Tony MartignettiRight. And where does this mission fit in among your priorities?
Judy LevineRight. You know, it's why I, when groups do board member contracts or whatever they call them, I suggest that there actually be calendars in there so that somebody can say to you, I can't do that in June because my twins are graduating high school. In which case we say, you know what, we're gonna take you off of that and we're gonna take you off of May so that you can have a very— because they're not gonna do it anyway.
Tony MartignettiYeah.
Judy LevineAnd then they just stop returning your phone calls.
Tony MartignettiRight.
Judy LevineOr they don't respond to emails. So having respect for all the different pulls rationally on board members' time and life and energy.
Tony MartignettiYeah.
Judy LevineAnd then helping them understand how to fit this in. All
Tony Martignettiright, let's give you— I want to give you a chance to talk about Cause Effective because it is a nonprofit. It's a consultancy for nonprofits. They're advisors, consultants. What's the breadth of the work and how do you work with your client nonprofits?
Judy LevineWell, you know, I'd say We are 40 this year. We are about to celebrate our 40th anniversary.
Tony MartignettiCongratulations, 4 decades.
Judy LevineAnd I'd say that the common theme throughout has been changing how organizations are resourced, changing the balance of money and therefore power in the sector. And it's both increasing it and increasing it so that it's not just that the most well-resourced nonprofits get more resources, but that it's nonprofits that are located in disenfranchised communities, and the people who work there and, um, uh, and volunteer there are able to raise the money they need to further those causes, um, and to govern themselves. Because to me, governance is integrally a part. It's more than just raising money, but if you don't have a, a governance structure that works, you're not going to have a fundraising structure that works on the voluntary level. And that's where you get to organizations where the staff fundraises, but the board doesn't, and the volunteers don't. So we have, we work, we do a lot of cohort work where we're looking at, say, development directors of color, and we help working with them over a 6-month period of time in a particular program that we have to help them really address the barriers to their being successful. And not only to talk about it, but to actually address it. Um, we— so we do a lot of individual coaching with, with, um, executive directors who maybe haven't come up through fundraising. And but, you know, you need to do it. If the ED is not part of the fundraising structure, the organization's only gonna get so far.
Tony MartignettiYeah.
Judy LevineUm, and board members, a lot of board consulting, um, especially now with boards that know they need to diversify and don't really Like they know they need the composition, but they don't, they don't necessarily know that they need to act differently to have different people in different seats. We do everything from, you know, 8-hour retreats on Zoom, maybe 6 hours, to year-long coaching engagements, to what we call deep dive transformation, which is a lot of times people come to us and say, well, my board won't fundraise. And we get in there and we start talking to board members, and we find out there's all kinds of reasons. It's not just that they don't know how to ask for money, but it's that there's not financial transparency. There's not a real partnership between staff and board. There's not peer-to-peer accountability on the board. There's an inner group of 3 board members who do everything and everybody else slides. You know, there's all kinds of reasons that we will help We will actually go in and help address. We say that that's a symptom— my board won't fundraise— and there are, you know, many, many causes of that. And we will— we— one of the things we're known for is that we will go in and address the cause. We're not just gonna do the tactics. We also do a lot of fundraising consulting for groups that have had a lot of government support or a lot of foundation support, and know they need to diversify, and they don't necessarily have, you know, a Lincoln Center board. Mm-hmm. But it is very possible that people around the country or world will care about what they do and will back it up and want to make it happen. If they, you know, for one of the things I say is that in fundraising, the one thing that's, that's limited is time. There's only 24 hours and maybe 1 second, or maybe now 2 seconds in a day. And so you need to make choices that are smart with how you spend your fundraising time. Money is not the limiting factor, but time is. And so we'll help groups really understand what are the likely avenues and how to structure the resources they have to reach those.
Tony MartignettiDid days get longer? What's 1 or 2 seconds?
Judy LevineIt actually— they did make a ruling and there's like, they added a second or something.
Tony MartignettiOh, I didn't hear about that. I've been squandering my 2 seconds a day. Well, for how long have we had this? How long have we had these longer days?
Judy LevineGo look it up.
Tony MartignettiSix months?
Judy LevineYeah. I don't know how many seconds that is. I can't do the math that fast.
Tony MartignettiNo, but six months is 180 days times two seconds, 360 seconds. That's a good six minutes. I've I've I've I've I squandered. All right. I'm gonna try to get it back right now by cutting you off. No. No. All right. Thank you for explaining, and thanks for a frank conversation. Yeah, we don't. You know, for our— for Nonprofit Radio white listeners, we're not going easy. I mean, you have to have honest conversations. So thank you.
Judy LevineYeah, I think this has been some of the— you know, I've been in this field for 30 years, and this has been some of the most rewarding and deep work. It's not surface. It really addresses, you know, I had to go back to everything I assumed from my childhood on. And understand that there are different realities. And that it's not that I can go back and change it, but I can change my behavior going forward so that I further a different kind of future.
Tony MartignettiShe's Judy Levine. She's the executive director of Cause Effective. You should have already been at their website because you would have seen their diverse team when I suggested take a pause and then you came back. But if you haven't been there, or if you don't remember where it is, it's at causeeffective.org. And Judy Levine, thank you very much. Thanks for sharing.
Judy LevineThank you. It's great to have this kind of conversation.
Tony MartignettiPleasure.
Kate MartignettiNext week, Professor Russell James returns with the right words and phrases for fundraising. He got sick and couldn't record for this show.
Tony MartignettiI know, you believe that? You believe the guy? He comes up with— he comes up with, uh, I lost my voice. No, we'll, we'll have him next week.
Kate MartignettiIf you missed any part of this week's show,
Tony MartignettiI beseech you, find it at tonymartignetti.com.
Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by DonorBox. Outdated donation forms blocking your supporters' generosity? DonorBox. Fast, flexible and friendly fundraising forms for your nonprofit. donorbox.org.
Tony MartignettiI love that alliteration.
Kate MartignettiOur creative producer is Claire Meyerhoff. I'm your associate producer, Kate Martignetti. The show's social media is by Susan Chavez. Marc Silverman is our web guy, and this music is by Scott Stein.
Tony MartignettiThank you for that affirmation, Scotty. Be with us next week for Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. Go out and be great. Thank you.
I love our sponsors!



