Your Partnerships With FGWs


About this episode
First Generation Wealth creators have different values and mindsets than those who inherited their wealth. And FGWs far outnumber the inheritors. Esther Choy’s research helps you understand these folks and how to build valuable relationships with them. She’s president of Leadership Story Lab. (This originally aired May 17, 2021.)
Here’s the transcript
Tony MartignettiHello and welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. I am your aptly named host and the podfather of your favorite hebdomadal podcast. Oh, I'm glad you're with us. I'd be thrown into lateral epicondylitis if you gave me the elbow and told me that you missed this week's show. Here's our associate producer Kate with the highlights.
Kate MartignettiHey Tony, this week it's your partnerships with FGWs. First-generation wealth creators have different values and mindsets than those who inherited their wealth. And FGWs far outnumber the inheritors. Esther Choy's research helps you understand these folks and how to build valuable relationships with them. She's president of Leadership Story Lab. This originally aired May 17th, 2021. On Tony's Take Two.
Tony MartignettiPlease review.
Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by DonorBox. Outdated donation forms blocking your supporters' generosity? DonorBox. Fast, flexible, and friendly fundraising forms for your nonprofit. donorbox.org. And by Virtuous. Virtuous gives you the nonprofit CRM, fundraising, volunteer, and marketing tools you need to create more responsive donor experiences and grow giving.
Tony MartignettiVirtuous.org. Welcome again, Virtuous. So grateful for your sponsorship.
Kate MartignettiHere is your partnerships with FGWs.
Tony MartignettiIt's a pleasure to welcome to Nonprofit Radio Esther Choy. She is president and chief story facilitator at Leadership Story Lab, teaching storytelling to institutional and individual clients who are searching for more meaningful ways to connect with their audiences. She's a contributor for Forbes Leadership Strategy Group, and you may have seen her quoted in leading media outlets like the New York Times and entrepreneur.com. Her practice is at Leader Story Lab and leadershipstorylab.com. Esther Choy, welcome to Nonprofit Radio.
Esther ChoyThank you so much for having me.
Tony MartignettiIt's a real pleasure. Welcome. You have some new research out that we need to talk about, Transforming Partnerships with Major Donors. What are— let's just jump right in and why don't you explain what FGW folks are and tell us a little about the research that you did with these FGW folks.
Esther ChoyFGW folks. Well, I recently published this research report and lucky enough to have really, really good exposure, such as the one you mentioned in the New York Times. Yeah. And there are a lot of surprises about the folks that we generally in the broader society just overly sort of broad and call them the rich people or the wealthy folks or the high net worth individual or the ultra high net worth individuals, as if they all belonged in this monolithic group that they all think, act, believe in the same way. And so I got curious about them after I've taught in this Major Gift Strategy program at Kellogg for a while, wondering why are these people so hard to get? What's— because so many nonprofits are doing amazing and moving and important and urgent work that no one else is doing. So why is it so hard to reach them? So So I dug further in, did a lot of homework, and I interviewed 20 very— they were ultra-high-net-worth folks. And I just asked them questions about how did they get to their wealth? What is it like? Are there any downsides to wealth, having wealth, and so on and so forth, and focusing on philanthropy? So this report, I can talk about any one number of ways. So you tell me, what do you want to most learn about these first-generation wealth creators? Okay.
Tony MartignettiWell, let's, uh, let's start with how big a proportion they are of the, of the wealthy.
Esther ChoyWow, I am glad you start— that's the starting point. Um, that's one of the biggest surprises that I've learned because they are at least 68% Of the, the, the, this massive group that we call wealthy ultra-high net worth, they are, uh, at least 68% of them earned their wealth instead of inherited. Yeah. Now that's a big, this big difference between inherited wealth versus earned wealth. And that means they've traveled an entire socioeconomic class That they did not grow up with. And so some of them, very few of them really make the majority of their wealth in their 30s or even 40s. Most of them are in their 50s and 60s. So we're talking about full-on grown adults with children and maybe even grandchildren by the time they become this wealthy. So it's a very interesting transformation of your life, your community, your social circles, the Things that you worry about or not worry about all happen around starting from the point of 50s and 60s. All
Tony Martignettiright, so they're at least 2/3, maybe even a little more than 2/3 of all the wealthy folks, the way we would describe, as you're saying, high net worth, ultra-high net worth. These are 2/3 of those folks.
Esther ChoyCorrect, at least.
Tony MartignettiAnd it's actually— You said 68%. I'm just rounding to thirds, but—
Esther Choy68%. I picked the most conservative number, but I've read elsewhere and put that to somewhere 80%.
Tony Martignetti80%. Okay. All right. And everybody you interviewed is first-generation wealth. That's where your research was?
Esther ChoyCorrect.
Tony MartignettiOn those folks. Okay.
Esther ChoyCorrect.
Tony MartignettiSo let's get to know them a little bit. Your research has A nice chart. I like pictures. The first thing I look for in books is pictures. Simple mind.
Esther ChoyMe too.
Tony MartignettiYou're burdened with the host with a simple mind. But you do have these pillars of wealth generation. So let's describe these folks, not all 3. I mean, people are just gonna have to get the research. I'm not gonna quiz you. I'm not quizzing you on block number 4 in line 3 on the— no, we're not doing that. I don't want to go like word by word, because people got to get the research, which is at LeadershipStoryLab.com, right?
Esther ChoyCorrect. Correct. That's the website you can download.
Tony MartignettiYeah, there's an executive summary and you can download the full report as well. Right. So LeadershipStoryLab.com for the full thing, for the full study. But let's get to know these folks a little bit, these first-generation wealth creators. You start by saying they're understated. They're maybe even humble. Are they to the point of being humble and modest?
Esther Choyhumble and modest, and they have a hard time. They have a hard time with the, with the word wealthy. They understand the size of their assets. They understand what they are capable of affording, which is basically anything. But they have a hard time with the label wealthy.
Tony MartignettiYeah.
Esther ChoyAnd they oftentimes think of and regard and never really left their middle class roots. And that's majority of them come from very middle class. You know, they don't want to be flashy, nor do they enjoy flashy things that attract attention. So, you know, make no mistake, they are a part of things that are very, you know, shiny and sophisticated and high quality, but it's not who they are inside. So that's one thing to keep in mind is that But they are very understated themselves. And they often appreciate other people as well as other things that are understated.
Tony MartignettiYeah, you make the point a couple times of saying that they don't identify themselves as wealthy, even though they know that they fit into that category.
Esther ChoyCorrect.
Tony MartignettiOkay. So you sat down and you met these folks, well, maybe not face to face, but you spoke with These people are couples, or how did that all work? It's interesting.
Esther ChoyYeah, so I did all the interviews in partnership with a research firm. And it's all done virtually because it was done in 2020. There was one noted exception where I was invited to her home. And I met all her kids and her husband. And, you know, it's just like the whole family in the background. And it's kind of funny to talk about her family while her family was around. But for the most part, was done through Zoom, one through calls. And then there were 4 people, so 2 couples. I interviewed them at the same time together. And the length just got doubled. You know, it's usually 50 minutes to an hour. And with a couple, we talked for over an hour and a half.
Tony MartignettiAll right. All right. How do you— I'm interested in some of the details. How do you reach out to these folks? How do you get their attention?
Esther ChoyIt's really hard. So the first thing we mentioned, um, in one of the 4 pillars is they're understated, right? They don't identify with the word wealthy. They certainly don't make big advertisement to the world that they are wealthy. And so to find them and to get them to agree to speak on record, although it's anonymous, and to get them to open up and talk about Money and wealth, it's really hard. So I have to rely on a couple of key relationships. One is through one of my alma mater, Texas A&M University, and my friend and colleague, the CEO of Texas A&M Foundation, helped me recruit a few, quite a few of these interviewees. My business partner, who also happens to be a trustee at the University of Cincinnati Foundations and through a couple of my own resources as well as my research firms. So 20 for qualitative studies is sufficient. It's definitely not a lot. 20 people doesn't sound like a lot, but 20 of these type of people and get them to talk about very sensitive topic— Mm-hmm. was— it took quite a bit just to get them to agree to talk to me. Yeah,
Tony Martignettiyeah. Go Aggies!
Esther ChoyWell, thank you.
Tony MartignettiAbsolutely. And what was the median income for these 20 folks or families?
Esther ChoySo at this point, I don't think their income is very meaningful anymore. So where I am, by median, I would refer to their Their net worth. So the net worth, the median range is $50 to $80 million. Although the low, I would put it in the low teens, the highs, I would put them in $150.
Tony MartignettiOkay.
Esther ChoySo just give you— give our listeners a sense as well of what we're talking about. Like by, well, you know, millions is like a lot of zeros. You know, at some point it's just like my mind can't keep them all in one place. According to the Fed in 2020, the top 1% of the US folks have $11 million. So these are all, you know, sort of the top 1%er.
Tony MartignettiYeah, $11 million for the 1% even. Right,
Esther Choyright.
Tony MartignettiThat's like mid-teens to 50 or so was roughly the The median net worth.
Esther ChoyExactly, exactly. But then if you think about the 1% of 300 million people in the US, that's 3 million, 3 million people. And that is about the size, if you put them all in one city, all in one location, they're just below New York City, just below New York, just below Los Angeles. But just above the city of Chicago. So 3 million people, that's a lot of people.
Tony MartignettiOkay. And, and you estimate conservatively that of those 3 million, 68%, uh, are first generation. They earned their wealth versus inherited. Okay.
Esther ChoyCorrect.
Kate MartignettiIt's time for a break. Open up new cashless in-person donation opportunities with DonorBox Live Kiosk. The smart way to accept cashless donations anywhere, anytime. Picture this, a cash-free onsite giving solution that effortlessly collects donations from credit cards, debit cards, and digital wallets. No team member required. Plus, your donation data is automatically synced with your DonorBox account. No manual data entry or errors. Make giving a breeze and focus on what matters— your cause. Try DonorBox Live Kiosk and revolutionize the way you collect donations in 2024. Visit donorbox.org to learn more. Now back to your partnerships with FGWs.
Tony MartignettiLet's go back and get to know these folks a little bit. They're entrepreneurial, no surprise, but tell us what does that mean for the way they think about themselves and the way they might think about their philanthropy?
Esther ChoyYeah, so in the most literal sense, they are, were entrepreneurs. That's how they created, most of them created their wealth. And with a few, less than 20% of them had a Very lucrative corporate careers. And entrepreneurial also means that it's a mindset. It's the lenses in which they apply all things through. So it could be the way that they would like their children or grandchildren to approach, you know, if I wanted to study abroad even, and, you know, I need additional funding. Well, how much you think about it as what untapped opportunities might there be out there for you in the country that you want to study, but it's not currently fully leveraged. But entrepreneurial could also mean to— as they think about nonprofit, as they really think about how they want to leave their social impact and how they want to fully make sure that their philanthropic dollar is put to good use, that also applied and compatible with their middle-class values. So it's— It's, it's, it's up and downside, right? Sometimes something just can't be measured. Sometimes nonprofits are run by people who are philanthropically minded and socially minded, and they don't necessarily have the same sort of business acumen as well as fear competitiveness that these donors tend to have and embody. And so the, the downside of having that entrepreneurial mindset is that sometimes it creates clashes and if, you know, at the very least disagreements on, is this really the best use of the precious dollars that your organizations have? Sometimes there's no straight black and white answer, yes and no. So that's what I mean by entrepreneurial.
Tony MartignettiAnd, and what else? What, what comes next in those 4 pillars?
Esther ChoySo the 3rd is free. And I truly— it seems like a very simple, no-nonsense, and, and, and we're like, oh, we live in a free society. But I think the truth of the matter is that a lot of people aren't free. They're not free to pursue whatever they want. They are under certain professional career obligations or financial pressures, and they are A
Tony Martignettilot of options.
Esther ChoyYeah, exactly. And that's why a lot of career counselors ask mid to even late career folks, you know, what would you do if money is not an issue, right? I've heard that question asked a lot in career counseling because a lot of people are under that pressure. But these FGWs, they are not. And for them, it's oftentimes for the first time is, wow, now it's not a theoretical question anymore. I really don't have to worry about money. Okay, so now what? What do we do? And so a lot of them pursue experiences. A lot of them want the same thing for their children and grandchildren. They pursued 3rd, 4th, 5th careers that they've always are interested, intrigued by, know that they're not very good at, And know that they probably may not, may or may not be able to make a ton of money with, but they pursue it anyway. So it's that sense of freedom that I think a lot of people, as long as they have to still worry about saving for retirement, saving for making sure you can pay your mortgage and things like that, it's really hard to wrap your mind about. And then these folks are just sort of fully embracing.
Tony MartignettiThey want their children to understand that having a wealth of options doesn't just come— it comes from hard work and devotion, which is what they devoted their decades to. So they want their children to understand that that doesn't just happen for everyone.
Esther ChoyYeah, I'm glad you bring up children. Across all 20 of them, even though the ages ranges from late 40s to a few 80s. They all worry about their kids, even though their kids have all grown up, or they have worried about their kids or have regrets about the way that they raised, the ways that they've passed on their assets to their kids. And the funny thing is that they did not tell me, oh, I have so-and-so I really can confide in, or I know these professional resources that I can go to, and all of them are just kind of like, I hope I'm doing the right thing. In fact, I know I haven't done the right thing. But then talking to peers, surprisingly, was not an option across any of them. And so although they're free, But this taboo topic of money and wealth have prevented them from really searching for the right answers at the time when decisions had to be made. So children, it's a constant universal worries, especially for people with wealth. We've seen from studies after studies that, for example, substance abuse tend to affect children from families with means disproportionately higher than those who are not from a family with means.
Tony MartignettiI wonder if there's some tension for them, because they're not comfortable talking to those who inherited their wealth, or even just other wealthy people, because they don't— they don't identify that way. But then they're not comfortable talking to those folks that they knew, when they were struggling in their careers and before their great success, their great financial success, qualify that because success can have lots of different levels to it, but before their great financial success, because they don't want to appear overbearing to their non-wealthy friends who they know from high school and college and maybe professional school or whatever. So they're, they like caught in the middle, like they don't have valuable personal relationships to leverage and count on in, in, in times like when they're questioning what to do with children and, you know, sort of existential questions like that.
Esther ChoyYeah, so this is another downside of being entrepreneurial. Another way to call someone very entrepreneurial is what, you know, he's, he has a can-do spirit, she has a can-do spirit. So if you can do, you can do it yourself. You don't need to count on other people to help you. You can pull yourself up by the bootstrap. So that's one. And 2 is, again, the subject of wealth tends to be taboo. In fact, the Brookings Institute economist Isabel Sawhill made this really apt observation, and she said that people rather talked about sex than money. Mm-hmm. And money than class. So first-generation wealth creators have traveled across classes. And so that makes it really hard for them to say, you know, I don't know what's the right way. If we do— if we travel, is it wrong for us to buy business class or first class? And what are your middle-class friends going to say? Oh, poor Tony, poor Esther. You're struggling with questions like, should you travel in business versus first class?
Tony MartignettiYeah.
Esther ChoyAnd it's not something that a lot of people, first of all, empathize with, and second of all, have the right context to give sound counsels. And what about professional coaches and counselors and whatnot? I didn't actually cover in the report. I chose to exclude it and just in favor of focusing on nonprofit and fundraising, but their experience with wealth management advisors are very mixed because it's an industry that has a lot of conflict of interest. There are some really, really good—
Tony MartignettiLet us in on something that didn't make the report. This is great. Nonprofit Radio, you gotta let us in on the backstory. What— say a little more about these, the trouble they've had, the mixed results. Mixed results. I'm sure some have been— some results were fine, and some relationships are fine. But say a little more about what didn't make the final report there.
Esther ChoyI cut a whole section off, just because I think it might be detrimental to getting people to read it when it's beyond a certain length. So, this whole section that I cut off was on how they view advisors, counselors and things like that. And indeed, you know, 2 words to describe the entire section is that it's very mixed. Some have great experience. Some on the other end of the extreme is they thought the people they interacted with is just— the advice weren't very good or too obvious, or that again, they can do it themselves. Why do I need to pay you so much money to tell me something I know already? Hmm. And by the way, that is somewhat parallel to their experience with fundraisers. So I don't want to just put the hammer on wealth advisors and tax advisors and whatnot, because this idea that, oh, we know you're wealthy, we know what you can do with your money, either for the benefit of yourself as well as for me or my organizations, that really changed. Yeah. the dynamic of the conversations as well as the services, how service is rendered, and this to their— relative to their expectations. So that's why it's not very helpful, I think, just to come off and list a bunch of things that they're not happy with without being able to say what would be helpful. So I just removed the whole section, and also in favor of keeping it a readable length.
Kate MartignettiIt's time for Tony's Take Two.
Tony MartignettiThank you, Kate. I'd be grateful if you would rate and review the show on whatever podcast app you're using. Uh, we're a little, a little low on reviews, recent, recent reviews, uh, and ratings. So I hope you would give it a 5 stars. Uh, certainly Nothing below four, I would think. But five is best. Five is best. And if you could do a little review, I know it takes a little time. You know, it takes a few minutes. I understand that. I'd be grateful if you could rate and review the show wherever fine podcasts are heard. Wherever you're listening, please do. Thank you very much. And that's Tony's Take Two. Don't forget to rate and review. No, look at the little jingle. Tony's Take Two. Rate and review. Kate.
Kate MartignettiThat was a very beautiful jingle. But yeah, don't be afraid to rate and review and let us know what you're thinking of the show.
Tony MartignettiNot only don't be afraid, please go ahead and do it. Absolutely. Take the next step.
Kate MartignettiGo do it. Do it. Well, we've got beaucoup but loads more time, so let's return to your partnerships with FGW. All right,
Tony Martignettifinally, these folks are lone rangers. What does that mean?
Esther ChoyWe touch upon it a little bit where we, you know, they are part of this new class of wealth. They're like immigrants in some way. By the way, I really wanted to recommend a few books, not just mine, that really helped me round out my understanding. So, this whole idea of Think of first-generation wealth creators as immigrants. They have migrated from a different class altogether and enter into this world where the beliefs, the values, and oftentimes even language are foreign to them. And although it's great, this is paradise. They often find that there are tricky conditions. Some even would say because their native-born children and grandchildren don't understand the privilege— privileges that they were born and then have gotten accustomed to. And the cliché or the adage or however you want to call it, shirtsleeves to shirtsleeves. Rice paddies to rice paddies. Wealth does not last past 3 generations, and they know that. And so when you think about this special land of paradise— again, by the way, this is a— I learned it through the book called Strangers in Paradise by James Gruntman— their native-born children and grandchildren Statistically speaking, will be deported back to harsher land where the first generation have migrated from.
Tony MartignettiReally?
Esther ChoyAnd, um, and here's the kick, Tony. I, I just, I, I just found it fascinating, and this is why I can talk about this, you know, forever and ever. Mismanagement of their wealth, taxes, And inflations and bad investments. All of those are more of— and just the natural delusions from, you know, the couple to children to grandchildren, right? All of those reasons are reasons for wealth not being able to last past 3 generations. But you will probably— I've never found any one cases or example or family where the story basically is, well, Grandpa and Grandma gave it all away to charity and left nothing to us. That's why we're poor again. You know, that just doesn't happen. And so what might— I think what I really want to focus on, I think the opportunities for nonprofit is that what might there be a different way to think about the conversations that you have with these donors where— Yeah. You help them solve a problem, or maybe many problems, and then you also help yourself solve a problem. By the way, I'm getting like way, way, way— this is a problem when we have no script. I'm getting like way away from the Lone Ranger questions.
Tony MartignettiThat's okay. I'm going to bring you back, but that's all right.
Esther ChoyBut I think I'm getting to the whole thing.
Tony MartignettiThis is Nonprofit Radio. No, no. So you're not— what you're saying is still valuable. Don't Don't second-guess yourself. It's great.
Esther ChoyWhat I'm getting at is that it's lonely to be first-generation. It can be lonely to be a first-generation immigrant, except that most immigrants have somehow found other immigrants and they talk, they share notes, they commiserate, they help each other out. But first-generation wealth creators are a particular type of immigrants where For all the reasons that we've talked about, they don't actively look for help, nor was real quality help readily available.
Tony MartignettiOkay, cool. Interesting, really fascinating analogy, analogizing them to immigrants. Did you, did you put any of them together since you met 20 of them and got to know them? So these folks that are Feeling lone, feeling lone, I don't know, lonely. I'm just using a word. I'm not saying they're lonely in their lives. Maybe they are, but they're lone rangers. Did you, did you put any of these folks together and say, look, you know, I met, I met so-and-so like 2 or 3 weeks ago, and she was saying the same thing that you're saying, you know, why don't the two of you talk, or would you be interested? You know, did you put any folks together to help them commiserate at least, or maybe even help each other, maybe at best help each other?
Esther ChoyI think I would I would if I were asked, but with these 20, because of the promise of confidentiality, I don't share their names or contacts with anyone. But I have done webinars since then where I was asked, so how do you find these people? And then if, if they ask me, then I will help.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Okay. Well, I'm like a connector. So, I was thinking, you know, if I could get her permission, would you like to talk to her? Because the two of you are saying things that are really identical, and maybe together you could help each other.
Esther ChoyAs well as having very similar questions. And this is where I was getting at the opportunity part, because they've asked questions like, how much and when should I pass my asset to my kids and grandkids?
Tony MartignettiHmm.
Esther ChoyIt's dealt with by, um, with wealth advisors on a very case-by-case basis. And I think that should be, that's the way it should be done. But what's really sorely missing is, well, how do other families handle this? Right? To your questions of, well, there are other people like me, what do they do? Because they're in my boat. So, as well as questions like, how do I get in sync with my spouse? And then they also have questions on like, how do you truly vet a non— a nonprofit? You know, and how do you help not my— you know, the nonprofits that you support become more efficient? And they are aware that not coming off as because I'm a donor, I give money and— Right. You should do what I tell you to do, things like that, you know, that productive relationship with nonprofits. So there are endless questions like this that they can talk about, not just commiserate, although commiserating is great too.
Tony MartignettiAll right. I think you could be a connector, a major connector. And I notice— I'll leave that there. That's— but, you know, the title of your research is Transforming Partnerships with Major Donors. So So let's, let's transition to some of those opportunities. You talked about problem solving that could be mutually beneficial. How do— how would a fundraiser CEO approach someone with that, with that kind of opportunity?
Esther ChoyYeah, yeah. So I want to break it down to 3 steps.
Tony MartignettiI want to break it down. 1, 2, 3. Okay, 1, 2, 3. You got a 3-step process. Okay.
Esther ChoyYeah, well, yeah, okay, you can call it a 3-step process, but it's—
Tony MartignettiYou just did.
Esther ChoyYou said you—
Tony MartignettiI didn't invent it, you made it up. 3 steps. Okay.
Esther ChoyI think the first thing is you have to really think about the questions you ask them, and, uh, oftentimes how curious, how respectful, how informed you are, are all sussed out by The kind of questions you asked. Are your questions mostly really at the end of the day self-serving? Or are you only focusing on very narrow aspects of the donors? Or are you really broadly interested in problem solving? Now here's another thing that entrepreneurs like to do. They like to solve problems. And oftentimes they take the same mindset towards nonprofit. Am I really giving to organizations that are going to solve real major problems in a sustainable way. So that's the first thing, is the questions that you ask. And then 2 is reading. Once you really find out about what you could learn from the donors, is then really being able to pair what your nonprofits have to offer and that Structure it in a way as well as frame it in a way that fits the mindset of, well, oftentimes these folks are very busy. They know they need to do something, but they're very busy. So how is it— how do you make it easy for them, in other words? And then the last thing I would say is it would With how do you acknowledge them, right? It sounds really obvious, right? You know, there's stewardship program, there are people involved in thanking donors, but what I've found is that people found— people thought there's not enough thank you or there's too much thank yous and they're not thanked through the right medium. And so We're not talking about, you know, $10, $20, where there are maybe hundreds and thousands of them and you can't manage them one by one and customize it. But with major donors, it's absolutely worth it to make sure that it's customized to their preference and needs. So questions, the way that you frame, as well as the acknowledgement part.
Kate MartignettiIt's time for a break. Virtuous is a software company committed to helping nonprofits grow generosity. Virtuous believes that generosity has the power to create profound change in the world and in the heart of the giver. It's their mission to move the needle on global generosity by helping nonprofits better connect with and inspire their givers. Responsive fundraising puts the donor at the center of fundraising and grows giving through personalized donor journeys that respond to the needs of each individual. Virtuous is the only responsive nonprofit CRM designed to help you build deeper relationships with each donor at scale. Virtuous gives you the nonprofit CRM fundraising, volunteer, marketing, and automation tools you need to create responsive experiences that build trust and grow impact. Virtuous.org. Now back to your partnerships with FGWs.
Tony MartignettiAnd the, the acknowledgement or the stewardship is interesting. You say somewhere that these folks have a hard time understanding the name on a building, you know, why people find that appealing, why some donors find that appealing. So a brick-and-mortar— in fundraising, you know, a brick-and-mortar recognition would not necessarily be appealing to them. But finding out what is appealing comes from, you know, maybe this 3 steps is sort of iterative, right? I mean, if you're starting to get near something promising, you want to be finding out too about what they would like in terms of acknowledgement.
Esther ChoyYeah,
Tony Martignettiyeah. How would you like to be recognized? What's important to you?
Esther ChoySo I have a friend of mine who advised nonprofits with operations like this. And She helped one of them. She said, you know what, why don't you just ask?
Tony MartignettiYeah.
Esther ChoySo he did. He created a survey through SurveyMonkey. And they have more than a handful, so they can't just call them up and ask them individually. So he created a survey, and he got over 70% response rate, which is really, really good, right, if you were for survey. So the survey basically centered around 3 things. How would you like to be thanked? How often would you like to be thanked? And through which medium do you most prefer to be thanked? And it's not only do they have really good feedback, but it's such a positive gesture from the nonprofit to the donors saying, Hey, we actually admit we don't know, but we care and we should. We know what we don't know and we care. And now we really would like to learn more from our donors. And that truly is a practical, helpful, informative, donor-centric step to take. And by the way, her name is Lisa Greer. She also has an incredibly helpful book called Philanthropy Revolutions. So it's a mix of It's a mix of memoir, it's a mix of research because she told her story, but she also has interviewed over 100 principal gift level donors, and the last mix of how-tos. So it's super helpful.
Tony MartignettiHow does Lisa spell her last name?
Esther ChoyG-R-E-E-R. Lisa Greer.
Tony MartignettiWhat else, what else can you tell us, Esther, that in terms of approaching these folks, how might you get— I have a question for— I have a little more specific question. How about you get their attention?
Esther ChoyOh yeah, I know getting the first meeting, it's like 50 or 60 or I don't know, 70% of the work just being able to get in the call. I think everything matters in the smallest amount of space, which is if you have no other ways to reach them, what do most people do? Emails. And so make sure that your subject line is the most attention-grabbing as well as intriguing possible. way to get people's attention. By the way, I have a— I don't know if I can memorize the 4 personas off the top of my head. Oh, actually I do. I have it right in front of me. What is it? My colleague, Scott Mordell, he is the longest-serving CEO of YPO Global. Young Presidents' Organizations. So these are a lot of the highly concentrated first-generation wealth around the world, 30,000 of them around the world. He actually put their philanthropic tendencies in 4 ways. The idealist is the first one. Those are the ones who want to make a true impact, long-lasting impact, solve societal problems. Right. Another one is called the legacy leader. Those are the ones who really love to leave, make sure their name lasts generations and generations, that they are getting credit for the big impact that they made.
Tony MartignettiMm-hmm.
Esther ChoyThe third one is called the model citizens. And those are the ones that look around and understand what is the highest and highest of highest level of service, and they want to be there, and their philanthropic effort reflects that. And then the 4th one is called the busy bigwig. That's the ones who are busy, extremely busy, and yet they know they should do something, but they don't know what and how. And so back to your questions of how do you get their attention? I think you should first by starting with having a point of view of Of these 4 possibilities, which one is this person most likely going to be? And then once you have a persona in mind, then it's a lot easier for you to craft a message with a subject line that is most intriguing and attention-grabbing for you. I, I get, despite Despite what my clients and friends and colleagues know about me, I still get these extremely bland and generic email messages that are, you know, if you just replace the logo of the nonprofits, that would fit anybody at all. Yeah. And so that would be the first thing I think about is have a persona in mind. Even if you're wrong, it's okay. Even if you're wrong, at least you have a point of view about that person. But the upside is that even if you're not 100% right, just having the personal— that persona is going to help you speak to that person as if you know a lot about them already.
Tony MartignettiAre you all really only going to get to them through an introduction, or like somebody has to give you their email? Or, I mean, there's not a directory of first-generation wealth creators, is there? Now, I know yours was— obviously, yours was anonymous, but like, is there a— I don't know, is there a directory or something that simple? I don't know.
Esther ChoyThat's a really interesting question.
Tony MartignettiOh, it's basic. Basic is what I major in. Basic.
Esther ChoyThat's a really, really interesting question. I love the way you you think about things, Tony. Not only isn't there one, they really know how to hide their wealth.
Tony MartignettiYeah.
Esther ChoyYou know, they believe in stealth wealth, not only because of the way they live their lives, but they know how to put things in, all things in trust. And so everything comes through a different name. And data can help. The right kind of data can And data enriching as well as data matching. I don't know a ton about it, but I know enough because there's another company that I co-founded that, like, that's all we do. Because in the old ways, how do you get names of donors? You ask your board. You ask who did
Tony Martignettiit. Yeah, well, that's how you start. That's how a small organization starts. But then now, I mean, now we have social media and you can have a campaign and see who gives to that. And then you do some research on those folks to see who might have the capacity to do more. And then you expand your relationship even with the others who may not have capacity but have willingness.
Esther ChoyBut see, I think there's a lot in your current database that is not being fully utilized.
Tony MartignettiWell, that may be for some folks. Yeah. And well, because we're talking about stealth wealth. I mean, Yeah, that's certainly possible. These folks live modest means, at least outward. 20 years ago, there was the book, The Millionaire Next Door. That's essentially what we're talking about. There are more zeros now, and there are more of them, and we're in a more financially mobile society now than we were 20 years ago. But the concept is the same, that there are these hidden families of wealth that may very well be in your database. Then it was the millionaire next door. Now, it's the millionaire in your— it's the ultra-high net worth in your database.
Esther ChoyYeah. And when you go back to the questions, the way that you ask questions of when you have an opportunity to talk to your A donor directly, as well as the way that you ask questions about your databases that can really help you look for hidden millionaires, billionaires right in front of you, right in front of your eyes. I wouldn't be surprised that there are already, but you aren't— you're not even aware that you're pretty close. When Lisa and I Because of our shared passion about this topic, and she's really doing it full-time. I'm doing this, this is because this is my baby. You know, the first time she wanted to make a principal gift to her local hospital, she budgeted for $2 million for her hospital, and it took the hospital 7 months To pay attention to her. And $2 million isn't a small amount for that hospital. It is definitely a major amount.
Tony MartignettiPart of that may be latent, uh, unconscious sexism. I've, I've heard this from women. I do planned giving fundraising, but I've heard this many times from women just ignored when they, they made explicit overtures, not just subtle hints, but explicit overtures, you know, I want to do this. I want to remember the organization in my estate plan. And, you know, ignored, repeatedly ignored. So unfortunately, what you're describing with your friend Lisa is— I don't think it's so uncommon.
Esther ChoyYeah, yeah.
Tony MartignettiI think there's some— I think there's just unconscious latent sexual— not sexuality, sexism bias in fundraising. And money is left on the table as a result. Aside from the morality of that misunderstanding.
Esther ChoyYeah, yeah. So it's— I haven't seen quantitative research on just how frequently that happened, but that's Lisa's from her research, from her personal experience, from your experience. So I think there are actually plenty of money within reach of nonprofits that that they probably have missed, but they didn't know they have.
Tony MartignettiWe're gonna leave it there. It's perfect. Now you have opportunities. And I know that our conversation has stimulated thinking about how to find these folks and how to transform your partnership with them. Esther Choy, the research is Transforming Partnerships with Major Donors. I'll give the full title: Aligning the Key Values of First-Generation Wealth Creators and Fundraisers in the Age of Winner Takes All. You get the research at leadershipstorylab.com. That's where Esther's company is, Leadership Story Lab, and also @leaderstorylab. Esther Choy, I want to thank you very much.
Esther ChoyTerrific. Thank you. This is such an invigorating conversation. Thank you for the opportunity.
Tony MartignettiAnd thanks for saying you were glad that I asked the question. You were one of the generous, generous guests. I'm glad you asked that. I got, I got chills. Thank you, Esther.
Kate MartignettiNext week, publish your book, thought leader.
Tony MartignettiAnd you can blame me here. I thought that was going to be this week's show. I blundered, just had it wrong. You'd think more attention would go into these things, but made a mistake. Definitely, it will be next week's show. Uh, short of, uh, natural disaster or illness or death, uh, it'll be next week's show.
Kate MartignettiIf you missed any part of this week's show,
Tony MartignettiI do beseech you, find it at tonymartignetti.com.
Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by DonorBox. Outdated donation forms blocking your supporters' generosity? DonorBox. Fast, Fast, flexible, and friendly fundraising forms for your nonprofit. DonorBox.org.
Tony MartignettiLove that alliteration. Love it. Fast, flexible, friendly fundraising forms. All right, sorry, I just had to get that in.
Kate MartignettiAnd by Virtuous. Virtuous gives you the nonprofit CRM, fundraising, volunteer, and marketing tools you need to create more responsive donor experiences and grow giving. Our creative producer is Claire Meyerhoff. I'm your associate producer, Kate Martignetti. The show's social media is by Susan Chavez. Marc Silverman is our web guy, and this music is by Scott Stein.
Tony MartignettiThank you for that affirmation, Scotty. Be with us next week for Nonprofit Radio. Big night. nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. Go out and be great. Thank you.
I love our sponsors!

Virtuous
Virtuous gives you the nonprofit CRM, fundraising, volunteer, and marketing tools you need to create more responsive donor experiences and grow giving.


