Possible Implications Of The Supreme Court’s Affirmative Action Decision


About this episode
The Supreme Court’s decision this summer struck down college admissions affirmative action programs. Yet it may have repercussions for nonprofits around employment, contracts, grants, and other areas. Gene Takagi gives us his analysis. He’s our legal contributor and managing attorney at NEO, the Nonprofit and Exempt Organizations law group.
Here’s the transcript
Tony MartignettiHello and welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. I'm your aptly named host and the podfather of your favorite hebdomadal podcast. Oh, I'm glad you're with us. I'd suffer the effects of a parapharyngeal abscess if I had to swallow the fact that you missed this week's show. Here's Kate, our associate producer, with the highlights.
Kate MartignettiHey, Tony. We have possible implications of the Supreme Court's affirmative action decision. Supreme Court's decision this summer struck down college admissions affirmative action programs, but it may have repercussions for nonprofits around employment, contracts, grants, and other areas. Gene Takagi gives us his analysis. He's our legal contributor and managing attorney at NEO, the Nonprofit and Exempt Organizations Law Group. On Tony's Take Two.
Tony MartignettiAn old drop.
Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by DonorBox. Outdated donation forms blocking your supporters' generosity? DonorBox. Fast, flexible, and friendly fundraising forms for your nonprofit. donorbox.org. And by Keela. Grow revenue, engage donors, and increase efficiency with Keela, the fundraiser's CRM. Visit keela.co to join the thousands of fundraisers using Keela to exceed their goals. Here is Possible Implications of the Supreme Court's Affirmative Action Decision.
Tony MartignettiIt's always a pleasure to welcome Gene Takagi back to Nonprofit Radio. I know you know who he is, but he deserves to have a proper introduction. Gene Takagi is our legal contributor and the managing editor of NEO, the Nonprofit and Exempt Organizations Law Group. in San Francisco. He edits that wildly popular nonprofit law blog and is a part-time lecturer at Columbia University. The firm is at neolawgroup.com. The blog is at nonprofitlawblog.com. And Gene is @GTak. Welcome back, Gene. It's good to see you.
Gene TakagiGreat to see you too, Tony.
Tony MartignettiThank you. I just realized we both have red t-shirts on.
Gene TakagiWe're matching today.
Tony MartignettiYou're more for— but you wore a jacket over yours. That wasn't necessary. Thank you. I'm just, you know, I'm t-shirt and bathing suit because I live— because I'm on the beach. So I don't put a jacket on. I hope you'll forgive me, my informality.
Gene TakagiIt's a little cooler here in San Francisco. We're in the mid-60s today. So—
Tony MartignettiWell, that too. We're in the mid— You're in North Carolina. All right. So we're talking about the Supreme Court's affirmative action decision and the potential for some implications beyond merely college admissions. Why don't you just set us up with a reminder about that? It was either late June or very early July decision that came out about— Yeah. College admissions was the Students for Fair Admissions versus the Fellows of Harvard University, and then another case versus University of North Carolina. So a private university and a public university.
Gene TakagiYeah, so both cases were treated together, and it was in late June, so early this summer, where the Supreme Court came down with a holding that basically said that in higher education admissions for state universities and for private universities that are state actors, and essentially probably because of the federal funding that they receive. Well, if they use race in their admissions policies of deciding who can get in, whether it's a strict criteria or whether it's a sort of like a plus factor in rating a candidate's qualifications, that is a violation of the Equal Protection Act of the 14th Amendment. So the Equal Protection Act basically says that every person is entitled to equal protection of the laws, and that act is applicable to governments and state actors. And Harvard was brought into the case as an example of a state actor. And so, you know, some people were asking, well, how does this even apply to nonprofits? And well, that's one way that it applied. And it's a little unclear about whether something like federal tax exemption, does that make a nonprofit a state actor in some cases? Really haven't seen that yet. But with the Supreme Court, we're not really sure what the ties are going to be. But there are all sorts of potential applications. Yeah. for nonprofits that, that people are concerned about. And from my perspective, you know, the decision was fairly disappointing but not unexpected.
Tony MartignettiYeah, and, and to just emphasize what you said, you know, we're talking about potential implications beyond. So we want to raise people's consciousness about things to watch out for, uh, things to watch out for in the news, things to be aware of, conscious of in your own In your own work, possibly in grant making or grant receiving things like that. So yeah, you know my lawyers are trained to always be learning. You never stop learning as an attorney. My law school learnings are sort of quickly being eroded. By the, you know, what I learned about, what I learned about abortion protection is obviously no longer applicable. And what I learned about discrimination, I remember there were, there was benign discrimination, like, you know, whatever the fishing license or voting or voting or driver's license laws are in your state, you know, that's 16 or 18 or 21, you know, whatever it is, that's, you know, kind of benign. There's, there's this, we're surrounded by discrimination. There's just— they're different types. Some are benign and some are invidious, the hurtful kind. And then there was the sort of corrective or remedial kind, which is what was at issue around the use of affirmative action in college admissions, that corrective or beneficial kind. And I saw in one of the One of the blog posts that you did at the wildly popular nonprofitlawblog.com, Justice Thomas's concurring opinion was— or no, sorry, it was Justice Roberts' main opinion. Eliminating discrimination means eliminating discrimination of all types, for all reasons, for all purposes. So which is a part of the The holding of the case. So, so has, has implications, potential, has potential implications for us.
Gene TakagiYeah. And I don't want to diminish just the impact on, on what this decision, just if we look at it in isolation for admissions in higher education, you know, that has tremendous impact because, you know, Justice Sotomayor said in her dissent, ignoring race will not equalize a society that is racially unequal. And like, that's really true. So you can take a look at the demographics and you can see that there's certain BIPOC groups that have less representation in higher education that can result in less income and wealth equality down the road. So there are huge implications of this just in higher education. But a lot of our nonprofit organizations, or the bulk of them, are not in the education space. Yeah. And even though they might deal on the peripheral with what the impacts of this decision are on higher education, they may have more direct, or maybe feeling more direct consequences, because affirmative action applies as a defense in other types of cases as well, including in the employment context and in sort of contracting cases where organizations enter into contracts with different vendors and whether you can say, I'm going to base the selection of a vendor specifically on belonging to a particular race. And those laws exist, you know, protecting against discrimination in employment and in contract making and enforcing before this Supreme Court holding. And that Supreme Court holding didn't change these cases. But affirmative action was used— has been used as a defense in both those cases, both those type of claims. So there's the question now, if affirmative action is no longer a defense in some of the higher education and admissions cases, will they be a defense in employment cases and in the contracting cases? So there are implications for this that are unknown yet, but the trend doesn't, you know, doesn't seem good. And we're seeing Organizations and wealthy conservative individuals who really want to challenge these laws across the spectrum, finding cases to attack organizations, including nonprofits, and saying, we don't think we're going to allow you to do this again. We're going to sue you and we're going to test it in court and see what happens.
Tony MartignettiYeah. And how many government agencies at all levels of government Have, you know, advantages for minority and women-owned businesses, a preference. You know, you get a step up. It's not the end-all, it's not the sole factor, but you get an advantage if you're a minority and women-owned business, for instance. Those types of preferences you're saying are now suspect at best. Yeah.
Gene TakagiThey could be. I mean, so there are specific carve-outs in the laws that can apply for certain things. But yeah, you know, even if, you know, what if we took Justice Roberts at his words, right? That type of program would not exist either, right? So, you know, equal is equal, and we don't pay any attention to historical discrimination.
Tony MartignettiWe just don't pay any attention to history. We just ignore What's happened to minorities and in the country, and we'll we'll just wait. It's a clean slate. We'll just start with a clean slate. Everybody's equal, which is which is preposterous. You know, given our structures and invidious discrimination in in seemingly benign places, which are not benign, and yeah, we'll just ignore history. All right.
Gene TakagiI so appreciate how you framed that because that goes directly to sort of like the book banning and the history textbooks in Florida and all of that as well. It's the same kind of, you know, same type of organizations and people who are driving those same sort of claims. And nonprofits have to be paying attention because they could be on the other side of those claims.
Tony MartignettiYeah. All right. So let's dig in a little deeper and see what your concerns are about the potential for problematic areas. Employment. You mentioned employment. What should we be conscious of? What should we be looking out for?
Gene TakagiSo there have been some measures by, you know, some organizations that would do things or that would with well-intentioned goals, I think, say, you know, we really would like to have, let's say, a BIPOC leader in place. So, you know, you know, with the succession planning, if our executive director is leaving next year, we would really like to find somebody who is a BIPOC person to lead this organization, because the majority of communities we serve are BIPOC communities. And that might be their rationale in saying, we're gonna go out and we're gonna look for a BIPOC executive director. to be our next executive director. If you're overtly restricting the hiring of an executive director to specific racial categories, that's a violation of employment laws. So Title VI would be those that are, you know, governmental agencies. Title VII would extend out to private employers, including for-profits and nonprofits. And there are all sorts of state discrimination laws as well, right? So if you are You know, if you feel like you can't say, I'm only gonna hire a white executive director, you know, if that feels wrong, you probably can't just say, I'm going to hire a Black or a BIPOC executive director sort of by the same token. So that is something that's just built into anti-discrimination laws. The idea was to help those who were underrepresented and marginalized. Right. from suffering, to prevent them from suffering from such discrimination. But, you know, some people have called it reverse discrimination now. But those, you know, those same principles still apply. Those laws still apply. So if you restrict your hiring and make it a qualifying factor to be, you know, a member of a certain race, that would be illegal. If you use it as a plus factor, that may be illegal. So saying, well, all things being equal, we're gonna hire the person of a certain race. So, you know, that's kind of where, you know, there are some affirmative action defenses in there where we are trying to correct certain systems that might be internal or they might be the product of historical problems. And there were affirmative action defenses allowed in that, but I don't know how strong they're going to be able to hold up Up in light of this opinion. We'll have to see how it gets tested because it's definitely not the same as university admissions, but they're both, you know, facing kind of similar pressures from some of the conservative groups who want to attack that as being discriminatory. So we'll see how that goes in the employment context. But that— let me stop there, Tony, and see if you have any thoughts about it.
Kate MartignettiIt's time for a break. DonorBox. Quote, we've seen incredible results with DonorBox. In the last year, we've boosted our donations by 70% and launched new programs in literacy, health, childcare, and tailoring for our girls. That's Jennings W., founder and executive director of Uganda 1018. If you're looking for a fast, flexible, and donor-friendly fundraising platform for your organization, check out DonorBox, donorbox.org. Now back to possible implications of the Supreme Court's affirmative action decision.
Tony MartignettiThis could apply to board membership too. It might be a very admirable goal because you serve a BIPOC community. So you want your CEO and maybe other senior leaders and your board to be reflective, to be representative of the folks that you're serving in your community. So it's very— it's advantageous. It's admirable. You want to empower folks. Who are among those you're helping. So how do you then frame this so that your board minutes, your board transcripts are not used as evidence against you?
Gene TakagiYeah, so you raise some great issues. The first is board membership and saying, hey, what about asking for only BIPOC board members or Black persons who identify as Black as board members. That's what we're looking for now because our board is all white. Can we do that? And you have to be careful of tokenism, of course, but there's nothing in the laws, anti-discrimination laws, that would prevent that from happening so long as board members are not employees, right, or under contract with the organization. So the anti-discrimination laws are specific to employment.
Tony MartignettiEmployment. Okay.
Gene TakagiYeah, and contracting, at least the ones we're talking about today. And I don't know of any that refer to sort of volunteer board positions that would be protective of that. But kind of what else you were talking about is like, well, not all is lost. It's not like, okay, we've got this decision, we've got these laws, and we can't get to solving some of our problems. Let's say our white managerial and executive staff were 99% white males. You know, for us to look for hiring for a little bit of diversity would seem to make sense. But if you tell us we can't use it as a plus factor, we can't use it as a requirement of our next hire, really hamstrings us. So what can we do? And so the all is not lost theory is saying, well, look to other things. So what you can do is you can encourage applicants Who are, who identify with particular race groups. If that's what you want to do, you can encourage them to apply. You can make sure that you've got internal systems that ensures that they're not going to be tokenized. You are going to perhaps recruit in areas or from other sources that provide more candidates that represent the groups that you want.
Tony MartignettiMm-hmm.
Gene TakagiSo all up until saying you must be of this race group or ethnic group to be considered eligible to be a hire, or we're gonna give you a plus factor, we're gonna consider your application more attractive because you're a member of a race group solely for that reason. That's the problem. But in the admissions case, in the Supreme Court case, They— the majority opinion said, hey, guess what? You can't say race is the factor. But in the admissions essay, if you talk about character that was shown in dealing with problems that you had specific—
Tony MartignettiNow on the— now we're on the individual level,
Gene Takagiright? So
Tony Martignettinot the race or community level.
Gene TakagiAlthough race obviously played a factor.
Tony MartignettiIn that individual's life, right?
Gene TakagiExactly.
Tony MartignettiWe're on the personal level.
Gene TakagiYes, you can use that as criteria. So some people say, well, and the majority holding was also clear that, hey, you can't use that as pretext and just say, write whatever you want. And, you know, it's really just about race. But if you really ask them to write something about themselves, and if they want to include something about their race and what they've you know, overcome because of discrimination, past discrimination, that may be evidence of character that you can use in your process. So while that's not a really elegant solution, and, you know, you can use socioeconomic factors, for example, in the admissions policies, that's not exactly the same as race. And we're, you know, trying to deal with race. If that's what we're left with, we, we still can use those tools. So again, you can use tools and other strategies to ensure that you do get a diverse pool, and that may allow you to find the most, you know, person based on other characteristics that ends up being somebody who belongs to a race or ethnicity that you really wanted to, to have in that position in order to Further your DEI goals.
Tony MartignettiAnything else with employment, Gene?
Gene TakagiI would just say employment is probably sort of the biggest risk area. So just be— for organizations, even again, well-intentioned and trying to deal with historic injustices, be very careful in the employment area. So, you know, to the extent you can, Try to get legal help, an employment lawyer. And, you know, for those who are in cities that have bar associations with, you know, volunteer legal services programs, talk with them because I think that this may be a popular area for a lot of local bar associations to provide some pro bono counsel.
Tony MartignettiWe talked a little about contracts, and I know you have concerns about grantees and grantors as well around contracting, around whether these are in fact contracts. Can we move to that arena?
Gene TakagiYeah. And so contracts in general, all nonprofits enter into contracts, right? Or just about all nonprofits enter into contracts. So the law, which is the federal law anyway, and civil rights laws refer to as Section 1981, And Section 1981 generally prohibits discrimination in making or enforcing a contract, and that includes any, you know, enjoying any terms of a contract as well. So if you were to, again, similar to the employment contract, say we will only hire a vendor if they are a member of a specific ethnicity or race, that's going to be in violation of 1981. Okay. So probably for most people that kind of makes sense. But we have seen, you know, especially in the last few years as our social justice efforts have risen with publicity of like some highly charged events that have been so terrible, we have seen movements that said, hey, we really want to increase sort of how we're contracting out with diverse vendors. Right. as well, not just employees. And so people have been saying things like, you know, let's contract out with more BIPOC individuals or more women-owned businesses, or, you know, and they've been looking at different ways to sort of increase their DEI efforts in establishing vendor relationships. And that's something now that you have to be very careful about as well. So again, Yeah. No, just like in the employment context, you can't have a requirement or even a plus factor of saying, you know, if you're a member of a particular race, then you don't qualify for this contract, or you will not— you will be dispreferred for, you know, reasons of selecting a vendor for this contract. So how does this fall?
Tony MartignettiAnd just before you make your, your follow-on point, I just want to remind folks that Section 1981 is by no means new. This is Reconstruction era.
Gene TakagiYeah.
Tony Martignetti1865 or '64 or something, or probably '65. '65 or '65 or '66 was Section 1981 to give freed slaves the All the benefits of contracts. And the statute even says all the benefits that white people enjoy, something like that. It's in the text of the statute. So this is nothing new, is my point.
Gene TakagiYeah. So well over 150 years old now. And it's something that you have to pay attention to. Again, affirmative action has been used in the past as defense in 1981 claims, we're not exactly sure how that's gonna pan out. But I wanted to give you a specific example 'cause we talked about it, or you alluded to it in the beginning, about grant agreements. And so as lawyers, we kind of learned like what a contract means, right? And it basically is there are more than one party to a contract and they agree, they make some mutual promises, and they each provide each other with some sort of value. Lawyers call it consideration that goes back and forth. And if you have those elements, then you're in a contract. So the question now is, what is a grant agreement? Is a grant agreement a contract? Is it 2 parties? Yes. Are they mutually agreeing on a bunch of terms and things? Yes. Now, is there value being exchanged on both sides? Now, that's where there's an issue. So most people think of a grant as a gift, right? We even filed it in our 990s. We we lump them all in as gifts and grants and donations. And so if a gift, if it's a gift and there's not value coming back, then maybe it's not a contract because there's not that equal, or it doesn't have to be equal, but there's not that exchange of value. Yeah. On the other hand, there are like provisions in grant agreements that say, well, you must do this with the grant monies and you must give us results. You know, show us what the results are of those things. And if you don't, if you don't use those monies for those things, you have to return it to us. And those terms start to look a little bit more like contract terms, right? Are we making a gift for a restricted purpose, which is a very valid argument? Yeah. Or are we making a payment to get something done, not for maybe for the funder, but getting something done out in the community or producing something because the funder wants that to happen? So really they're paying for it and you're delivering it. Is it more like a contract or a gift?
Kate MartignettiIt's time for a break. Keela, Increase donations and foster collaborative teamwork with Keela, the fundraiser CRM. Maximize your team's productivity and spend more time building strong connections with donors through features that were built specifically for fundraisers. A fundraiser CRM goes beyond a data management platform. It's designed with the unique needs of fundraisers in mind and aims to unify fundraising Communications, and donor management tools into one single source of truth. Visit Keela.co to sign up for a coming group demo and explore how to exceed your fundraising goals like never before. It's time for Tony's Take Two.
Tony MartignettiLongtime listeners— oh, thank you, Kate. Thank you. Longtime listeners will remember that this show used to be in a studio in New York City because I used to livestream the show every Friday. I'm pretty sure it was Friday at 1 PM, from 1 to 2, and then from then I would start my weekend. Uh, and Sam Liebowitz was the producer of the show. He owned the studio where we used to do the show every Friday afternoon. And guests would come to— ideally, they would come to the studio. And Sam had the idea of putting some what are called drops into the show. And they're essentially commercials, but for the show. It's like a testimonial, we would call it, a testimonial for the show. And this is one of the early— Oh, wow. drops that, that we used in a bunch of shows. Sam inserted into a bunch of shows. He would put them in, in post-production. Let's see if you, uh, if you recognize anybody in this.
GinoLively conversation, top trends, sound advice.
CarmelaThat's Tony Martignetti, Nonprofit Radio, and I am his niece Carmela.
GinoAnd I am his nephew Gino.
Kate MartignettiHow about that?
Tony MartignettiKate, you recognize anybody in that?
Kate MartignettiThat is so cute. We sound so tiny.
Tony MartignettiThat's you and your brother. And Carmela, I— we have this strange thing going on now because on the show I always call you Kate, but off stage or off mic, I, I call you Carmela, which everybody else calls you Kate, but I use Carmela because I think Carmela is a beautiful name, and that's your your name is.
Kate MartignettiIt is a beautiful name, and I'm very thankful to have it. It's just a really long name if I'm writing like my name on a piece of paper for school. It's just it's too long.
Tony MartignettiOkay, three syllables versus one. So all the all the rest of the world, all the rest of the family and the world use just one syllable Kate. I go with Carmela off off mic. But so. I think, uh, you know, I think you sound like 9 and Gino 7 or so. He's 2 years younger than you. To me, you sound like around 9 and 7.
Kate MartignettiYou might be right. I was thinking more 12 and 10, but I really don't remember how old we were. But I like remember sitting in the dining room, you setting up the microphones and having a headset and being like, wow, this is so cool. I'm on my uncle's podcast. Like, this is the coolest thing ever.
Tony MartignettiYeah, I had the— I brought my audio gear, mics and headsets for everybody. Yes, absolutely. This is, this is no second, uh, second-rate 2-bit operations.
Kate MartignettiNo, no, no, this is professional.
Tony MartignettiAbsolutely. Nonprofit Radio. We were sitting at your dining room table. Yeah, in your— yeah, in your, in your— is that— was that in the current home or was that the previous home?
Kate MartignettiYeah, I think this isn't— it was in the current home.
Tony MartignettiIt was? Okay, okay, you remember that. All right. Yeah, I don't know, I, I should have a date on the file, but I, I I can't find what date it was. It should be dated with at least a year, but I can't find that. Kate and Gino, and I am your— I love that. I am his niece Carmela, and I am his nephew Gino. All right. Kate and Gino from the old days when Sam Liebowitz at the studio used to put the drops in for me in post-production. Oh, that's right. Anything else you remember about that?
Kate MartignettiI remember like trying to put the dogs in the crate so they weren't running all over cords and stuff.
Tony MartignettiLet the dogs out! Who let the dogs out?
Kate MartignettiAll right.
Tony MartignettiRight, exactly. All right. So that's a that's an old an old drop from the from the olden days. Well, I still have to see if I can find out what year that was. All right. But thank you. And that is Tony's Take Two. Go ahead, Kate.
Kate MartignettiWe've got just about a buttload more time. Let's go back to possible implications of the Supreme Court's affirmative action decision with Gene Takagi.
Tony MartignettiSounds like a good idea. And what you're, what you're delivering may very well be a promise, or you're, you're promising to deliver. You, the grantee, are promising, and a promise has value. Promise can be that exchange, that consideration. So it can be an exchange of money from the grantor and promise from the grantee. That's, that's value. Again, your point, not necessarily equal. They don't have to be equal. They can even be de minimis on one side. So promises are valuable and can be that exchange of consideration that you're saying is an element of a contract.
Gene TakagiYeah, that's, that's right, Tony. So I don't think we've seen this litigated yet. So we don't really know what the argument is going to look like. We have an idea of what the argument will look like. We don't know how, how the court would treat this. We've certainly seen kind of de minimis value in other extensive contracts being enforced and saying, well, Well, that's good enough. But there is kind of this long history of grants being recognized as gifts and federal and state laws saying that, hey, if you're going to make a grant or gift as a charity to another organization, you have to have some steps to ensure that it's actually being used for charitable purposes. And private foundations have even more laws that, that say you have to exercise expenditure responsibility, which is all sorts of due diligence procedures and provisions in the grant agreement itself that must be included. Right. in order to make a gift. So is that contract, or is that just saying, hey, comply with the laws so we can make this gift to you? So yeah, there's some more nuanced academic arguments that, that, you know, people can make about this, but we're starting to see the attack, right? So we're now starting to see people go, hey, on a contract, if you, if you're making grants, And you're saying these grants are only to BIPOC-led organizations or Black-led organizations. That's not uncommon, right, Tony? I think we're seeing quite a bit of that. Yeah. Now that can get attacked, and it could always have been attacked, but I think the Supreme Court holding has shown that, oh, if you want to attack it and somebody were to raise it up the appellate level to, you know, to the Supreme Court level, Or appellate courts might just say defer and say, this is so much similar to the rationale in the Students for Fair Admissions case that we are going to just say that this is a contract and this is sort of a violation of 1981. So that's kind of the concern there with grant agreements is, are they contracts? Are they worded like contracts? And, you know, maybe one of the steps that some grantmakers can take if they want to be careful about that is to try to make more unrestricted grants and not have so many conditions tied to the grant. So not so many promises coming from the other side, right, Tony? So to sort of minimize what the value might look like that's being returned, but still sort of complying with the laws that require that the grantees spend the money properly. So one strategy anyway, there are going to be others, and I don't want to discourage people from, you know, looking to make grants to BIPOC-led organizations, but they have to be careful on how they word it. And so just like with the employment context or the admissions context for that matter, it's recruiting your vendors from different places. You can really seek to diversify the pool of applicants that come because it could be very unequal in how we've approached vendor relationships in general, which might be just friends of board members or, you know, people we already know or do business with. And that might be the same people that have always done business with the organization when it may not have been so focused on DEI efforts.
Tony MartignettiSo very narrowing. So, right, you're raising consciousness. And I feel like talking about contracts, we've ventured into a little bit of nonprofit radio law school about consideration and the bargain for exchange. But we did it, we did it in simple terms. Easy, I think so. But everybody gets a, everybody gets one CLE credit for listening. This, lawyers, you get one continuing legal education credit for listening to today's This episode. Um, any other areas? What, what else, what else concerns you, uh, about, uh, discrimination and, and places where we should be conscious?
Gene TakagiUm, so I'll give you maybe just a couple more examples of some dangerous areas or areas of concern, and then I'll try to end with something a little bit more Positive. So on the concerning area in Missouri, the Attorney General there directed all colleges to immediately stop considering race in scholarships. So not— that wasn't admissions-based, but just on scholarships. Lots of nonprofits give scholarships and fellowships for that matter, and other sorts of grants to individuals. Are those kind of now going to be attacked in some states? In Missouri, in Kentucky, the university's president suggested that his institution should do the same thing, the Kentucky University's president. So, you know, this is going around. The same person or organization backed by the same person who funded the lawsuits in the affirmative action cases.
Tony MartignettiYeah, there's also admissions.
Gene TakagiYeah, so they've also attacked the Fearless Fund, which is an equity fund that was aimed at helping BIPOC entrepreneurs. I think that was based in Georgia. I'm not positive about that.
Tony MartignettiSay the name of the fund again.
Gene TakagiFearless Fund. So it's not a nonprofit fund, but it could have been. But it was looking to specifically raise equity for, you know, BIPOC-led organizations or businesses. And that's being attacked. Same group also attacked 2 law firms for fellowship programs that were targeted at BIPOC. individuals and raising diversity as part of their DEI program. So you can probably see all of the— just the statements and the rhetoric coming out about DEI programs and, you know, some people attacking DEI programs in general. That's, you know, on the positive side. That's— DEI programs are not attackable kind of all in general. You can certainly have a goal to increase diversity, equity, and inclusion. That certainly can be a value of your organization.
Tony MartignettiYeah.
Gene TakagiAnd eliminating prejudice and discrimination is a valid 501 purpose in the regulations. So all of that is just, you know, is to say there are ways to deal with some of the bad news that are coming out of the court systems and laws that I don't think are very good for racial justice and social justice. There are ways to deal with it. They're not perfect, and we'll continue to find ways to advance racial equity and social justice. But you want to make sure, especially for organizations that can't, you know, afford to be on the forefront of saying, hey, attack us, we want you to take us to court, and we will you know, fight the battles for you, you know, like the ACLU and the Anti-Defamation League and like those that are experienced and have resources to be able to handle that type of litigation. You just have to be really careful that you're not attacked and that, you know, defending that diverts all of your resources away from getting the job done for your beneficiaries that you want. And so to really be careful of that.
Tony MartignettiBut it's important to underscore that these are still very valid and accepted charitable purposes.
Gene TakagiAbsolutely.
Tony MartignettiThe reduction, elimination of discrimination, you know, elevating people of lower, you know, underserved populations, etc. I mean, these are all still very valid charitable purposes.
Gene TakagiAnd yeah, I would encourage funders to double down on their efforts to help these marginalized groups and organizations that are helping these marginalized groups, because they may not all have the resources to be able to fight off other groups that decide that they want to attack some of the things that they're doing. And helping to educate organizations as well, really, really helpful. So for community foundations and other capacity-building organizations that are giving advice, Yeah. To nonprofits in general. Yes, there are some organizations that can sort of take the courageous ground and take risks with respect to some of these issues. But there are other organizations that, you know, really their beneficiaries are reliant on them to continue their service— services, and they just have to be a little bit more careful. And if it just takes a little wordsmithing, to be careful in their documents, then, you know, they can really be helped by that.
Tony MartignettiInteresting point about, you know, scholarships too, because they're, they're so widely used. You know, it's not just their own. My sense of the, the race-based affirmative action, affirmative admissions was that, you know, that's at schools that have the luxury of getting, you know, maybe hundreds of applicants for each spot or something, you know. So they, so they were previously, you know, had some spots designated, to put it simply. But scholarships are at probably every institution, regardless of how many applicants they get per, you know, how selective they can be. Scholarships are So widely used. So it's not just large institutions that, you know, it's that it's another instance of it, you know, trickling down to smaller institutions. The implications trickling down. All right. Did you want to leave us with something uplifting and positive? Well, now we, you know, we did say these are still valid charitable purposes. Don't abandon your work. We're not, you know, we just— I invited Gene to raise consciousness. You know, you need to just be more alert now than you were. Although, as we said, Section 1981 has been around since the 1860s. So that's— there's nothing new around the contracting conversation. But Gene, what do you want to leave us with? Something even brighter than that?
Gene TakagiWell, there have been some foundations that have been doing really good work and individual sort of donors who have really been supporting the efforts of racial justice and social justice organizations. And they are saying that this is a bump in the road, and they will find ways to continue focusing on advancing their racial justice and social justice goals. And I'm hoping that sort of everybody who believes in those goals continues to like really be supportive of them and helping others who are in the same sort of have the same set of values to deal with these bumps that we are experiencing in the road with some of the Supreme Court decisions and finding ways to move forward. It's not time to sort of move back or just become completely defensive. It's time to act and act in a way that sort of continues to advance what we want in our country and in our world.
Tony MartignettiGene Takagi, you need to read and subscribe to his nonprofit law blog where he's the editor and follow him @GTAC. And if you need the services of An attorney, uh, should your clients need to be in California? No, they don't need to be in California. No, right, Gene? No, you have, you have clients, you have clients nationwide. I know that. I never— I withdraw that question because I know the answer. If you need help with, uh, the law and legal issues and you're a nonprofit organization, I would unqualifiedly suggest you look at, uh, Neo Law Group. Doesn't matter where you are in the country. Thank you very much, Gene. Always a pleasure. Thank you. Thanks for sharing your thoughts.
Gene TakagiSo much appreciated, Tony. Thank you.
Tony MartignettiAll right, bye. Till next time.
Kate MartignettiNext week, Brian Saber returns with his new book, Fundraising for Introverts. If you missed any part of this week's show,
Tony MartignettiI beseech you, find it at tonymartignetti.com.
Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by DonorBox. Outdated donation forms blocking your supporters' generosity? DonorBox. Fast, flexible, and friendly fundraising forms for your nonprofit. donorbox.org. And by Keela. Grow revenue, engage donors, and increase efficiency with Keela, the fundraiser's CRM. Visit keela.co to join the thousands of fundraisers using Keela to exceed their goals. Our creative producer is Claire Meyerhoff. I'm your associate producer, Kate Martignetti. The show's social media is by Susan Chavez. Marc Silverman is our web guy, and this music is by Scott Stein.
Tony MartignettiThank you for that affirmation, Scotty. Be with us next week for Nonprofit Radio, Big Nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. Go out and be great. Thank you.
I love our sponsor!


