Beat Back Cyberattack


About this episode
Cyberattacks against nonprofits are on the rise. While you cannot avoid them, you can make them a lot less likely to cost you big money, your data, your reputation, your donors, and your employees. Michael Enos from TechSoup helps us out.
My Guest
Here’s the transcript
Tony MartignettiHello and welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. I'm your aptly named host of your favorite hebdomadal podcast. Oh, I'm glad you're with me. I'd suffer the embarrassment of aphonia if I had to speak the words, you missed this week's show. Beat back cyberattack. Cyberattacks against nonprofits are on the rise. While you cannot avoid them, you can make them a lot less likely to cost you big money, your data, your reputation, your donors, and your employees. Michael Enos from TechSoup Global helps us out on Tony's Take Two. Get in people's faces again. It's a pleasure to welcome Michael Enos to Nonprofit Radio. He is Senior Director of Community and Platform for TechSoup Global. He began his professional career in technology in 1996 and has since led team tech teams at the national and individual office levels in increasing responsibilities. On Mastodon, he's @Michael_Enos@publicgood.social, and TechSoup is where you'd expect them to be at techsoup.org. Michael, welcome to Nonprofit Radio.
Michael EnosIt's great to be here, Tony. Thank you for having me.
Tony MartignettiMy pleasure, my pleasure. Let's Please explain the work of TechSoup. I think it's so valuable. So many billions of dollars of software and hardware transferred to nonprofits. Make sure— let's make sure everybody knows what TechSoup is doing.
Michael EnosYeah, absolutely. I mean, essentially our mission is to help civil society organizations worldwide better leverage technology to create impact in the missions that they serve, and to build communities that then can foster that impact globally. We do that through a number of different ways. We do that by facilitating philanthropy from large tech donors, and most of which are the ones that are just household names. We also do it through courses, services, consultations, And through connecting organizations with each other, and through also through engagements like this where we try to really— through blogs, webinars, and other facets where we help organizations understand how they could use tech and protect their tech to enable and further have impact for their communities they serve.
Tony MartignettiI saw on TechSoup's website today Microsoft Office or Microsoft 365 for $1. So there's an example.
Michael EnosThat's an example, right? And if you were to go to Microsoft for Nonprofits or Google for Nonprofits, for example, the data validation platform that validates organizations worldwide is managed by TechSoup. So ultimately, we do many things, but we're also sort of a, I guess, data vetting partner for a lot of these organizations that want to understand and make sure that their philanthropy is going into the right hands.
Tony MartignettiYou have local Connect groups too, TechSoup Connect groups.
Michael EnosThat's great.
Tony MartignettiYeah, exactly.
Michael EnosThat's right.
Tony MartignettiYeah, you know, I know you're Well, you're Director of Community and Platform. So is that part of your work, Director of Community?
Michael EnosI mean, you know, I support that organization, that wing. We have lots of different areas, and, you know, and in my role, I support them all. Platform is a lot of the— you know, I oversee our enterprise infrastructure and security as one of my fundamental sort of roles. I mean, obviously, with the expansive amount of technology that we have that runs our platforms, that consumes a lot of my time. But also the community side, because of my background working in the Tech for Good space, you know, since, you know, for the, the length of my vocation, you know, I have, I am, I am accessed as a resource for a lot of other groups, including the CONNECT Group, for when they need, you know, to understand, you know, how to, you know, for, for things like this and for, for other things. To, to help our communities. better leverage of the tech that they use. I mean, it's one thing to provide the technology. It's another thing to actually help people, you know, provide them the enablement to be able to use it and optimize it.
Tony MartignettiAre there local meetups? Are the groups going back to—
Michael EnosExactly. There are, you know, communities within that are regional, and that's part of our Connect program. And Eli, the guy who runs that, and the group that runs that are very, very energetic, and it's very community-driven, which is fantastic. And we're sort of an enabler and a facilitator in that work, which is wonderful. And that stems from the early days of us being part of the early groups that were involved with the, you know, Tech for Good space way back when technology was first getting launched, you know, and the internet was first launching.
Tony MartignettiAll very simpatico with NTEN.
Michael EnosExactly, that's right.
Tony MartignettiDifferent types of work. I mean, you know, NTEN doesn't do consulting, which I wanted to ask you about very shortly, but You know, they don't do tech grants necessarily, but all, all very parallel with, with NTEN.
Michael EnosYeah, correct. And, and we, we have a close partnership with NTEN, and, and we, uh, attend the, the events and such, and we've, uh, long been sort of affiliated with, with them and other, and other groups like it, like NTEN. Um, and we have partnerships that sort of expand throughout the, the different tech communities. Um, And we try to be involved globally as well. So there's this sort of, there's the US side of it, but then there's also everything that we're doing outside of the US and abroad, because civil society is international. And TechSoup is really involved with things not just within our own borders, but outside of them globally.
Tony MartignettiAre you going to the 23 NTC? The conference?
Michael EnosMyself? No, I'm not. I know we have some other representatives that are there. I've been to many of those. This year I am not specifically going, but we will have some representatives from TechSoup there.
Tony MartignettiI'm sure. Yeah, and Nonprofit Radio will be there as well. We'll be on the exhibit floor.
Michael EnosGreat, excellent. Oh, that's fantastic. Yeah, well, I'm sorry I'm not going to be there to be in person to meet you.
Tony MartignettiThat's all right. There are others every spring. And I
Michael Enoswill be there virtually, by the way.
Tony MartignettiThat's true. There is hybrid this year. That's right.
Michael EnosThat's right.
Tony MartignettiAnd TechSoup is also consultants to nonprofits. Let's make sure folks understand that too.
Michael EnosYeah, I mean, what we provide essentially, we help organizations connect with other organizations that then provide consultant services. We do some ourselves, but it's very specific to some of the— because we provide a lot of this, you know, what we're doing to scale, so to speak. What we have is we've partnered with other organizations through our platforms to align organizations, depending on exactly what type of consultation they need, to an appropriate sort of resource for them. And that's more— our model in terms of we are sort of a connector. So for example, if somebody needs a specific sort of technology assessment for implementing Microsoft, we may do some, but then if it is more advanced, we may refer them to Tech Impact or an organization that we partner with.
Tony MartignettiUm-hmm.
Michael EnosAnd then they provide that as a service to that organization. And we have other partners like that who provide those similar sorts of services that are more hands-on and direct. than what TechSoup can provide at this moment. And we may expand that more and do some of that more stuff ourselves. And we are developing that in some of our customer success programs. And we do run a lot of sort of in-the-office programs where people could have webinars. And I've spoken at a few of those where we do an in-depth dive of a particular technology so that organizations can learn how to use them.
Tony MartignettiI've always considered the big 3 to be TechSoup, NTEN, and Tech Impact. In terms of technology for nonprofits. And, and all 3 of those, of course, are nonprofits themselves.
Michael EnosSo, right, exactly. Yeah.
Tony MartignettiAll right, let's talk about cyberattacks. Uh, they are on the rise against nonprofits. What, what do you, what are you seeing? We're gonna get into the details, of course, but like overall, general, you know, kick us off. What are you seeing on this front?
Michael EnosWhat we are seeing is a lot more targeted attacks, which is unique because there is, you know, speaking broadly about cyber activity, you know, there is a lot of noise on the internet. There is, you know, just all these robotic sort of, you know, these bots that are flying around trying to find targets. Right? And they are sort of just, you know, I guess they are Doing drive-by sort of evaluations to see of anything, you know, just to see if there is anything that they could get a finger in, or, you know, just to explore and see if there is sort of a, you know, something that they could find in there. What we are seeing now is more targeted attacks, meaning there is a specific purpose to it. Like somebody is like, well, you know what, we think that this is a specific type of organization. They are involved with a particular type of activity.
Tony MartignettiMm-hmm.
Michael EnosAnd we are interested in knowing who is donating to that activity and whether or not we could possibly have access to that information because that might be valuable, or perhaps to the constituents that they are serving because maybe that information is valuable as well, maybe for either financial reasons or political reasons. And so we are seeing a little bit more of that, or perhaps because we really want to cause disruption In critical infrastructure. And one thing that— this is sort of a broader trend in cybersecurity around targets towards critical infrastructure. And myself and others in this space believe that civil society organization data is part of critical infrastructure. And critical infrastructure starts— So, I mean, people are targeting things like, you know, we've heard about the targets on power grids and gas pipelines and such. And, you know, if you think about data that is relative to communities that are specifically vulnerable in certain contexts or, or have access to information about others, then that is critical infrastructure because we need these organizations to function as a society. And so, you know, there could be other actors who say we want to disrupt that particular critical infrastructure for some reason, and that reason could be varied, just like it is for why people would disrupt any sort of critical infrastructure.
Tony MartignettiI have an example that is pretty close to home. I own 2 homes in North Carolina, and one of them was affected by that shooting at the electrical substation in— that was in Moore County, North Carolina. And there's a, there's a possible correlation that, that, that attack was to prevent a drag queen show from going on in the little town of Southern Pines, North Carolina, which is served by that substation that got shot at. So, I mean, it sounds like you're saying it's not that far a leap, like from You know, one, one cadre of bad actors uses guns. Another cadre of miscreants could be hackers that are looking for data at that, maybe at that theater, or, uh, you know, among a nonprofit that may have been involved.
Michael EnosExactly. Maybe the attendance list, or the people who are donating to that event.
Tony MartignettiYeah.
Michael EnosAnd so This is the type of data. And like I said, there are different reasons why somebody might be targeting certain data. But these are the— this is like bingo. It's on the nose. This is the kind of stuff that we are seeing more and more of, and we are very concerned about, and why we are really— TechSoup is really sort of launching this effort to help educate organizations on how to improve and understand what cybersecurity means. in this space and how to prioritize it, but also how to sort of get through the sort of complexity of it and find simple ways to knock off low-hanging fruit to make it sort of actually, you know, doable for them with given their budgets and given their constraints that we, a lot of smaller organizations in the space, you know, have generally.
Tony MartignettiIt feels like in our polarized culture, that there isn't a nonprofit mission or category that would be exempt from possible attack. I mean, you know, even feeding, I don't know, feeding the hungry, you know, I could conceive of that being objectionable to some group of people that feels like, why do those folks get food and I don't get food? Or why are they entitled and I'm not? Or, you know, something that seems innocuous. Yeah. and purely beneficial, I, I could imagine another cadre of bad actors deciding that it's, it's, it's worthless, or, or worth— worse than worthless. It's, it's detrimental to our culture for some reason, and wanting to attack it. It doesn't, it doesn't feel like any particular mission would be more vulnerable or less than, than any other.
Michael EnosYou're correct. And one of the other things that has changed in this sort of, you know, over time that I've seen is the availability of the tools to be able to perform exploits. Before, you would actually have to be, you know, pretty well-versed in hacking to be able to do any harm, right? Now it's, you can buy the service. I mean, you could just go to the market on the dark web and just say, hey, you know, I want to buy this, you know, This hacking kit, you know, and, and, and there's YouTube tutorials on how to do it. I mean, it's becoming— and, and these are— and the tools are free and readily available. So what we're seeing more of is not only just this trend of people wanting to— and, you know, and maybe that hasn't changed, it's just that it's more accessible, right? But, you know, of people wanting to, you know— target communities and, and, and, and also try to find valuable data within these communities, but also their ability to do so has become easier. And they're, you know, and, and so you combine those things together, and that's why we're seeing the trends we're seeing. That's one of the reasons.
Tony MartignettiYou no longer have to be a sophisticated computer user. It doesn't take a lot of study. You're saying these things are available for cost or free To cause harm. All right. Yeah,
Michael Enoscorrect. Yeah.
Tony MartignettiAll right, so how do we, how do we break this down for folks in small and mid-sized nonprofits, you know, that, uh, that they can sort of prioritize? I mean, is it as simple as let's start having universal 2-factor authentication for everybody on your teams, or maybe that's passé? Maybe Maybe we're past that now. I don't know. How should we—
Michael EnosYou know, you know, you know, you make a good point. So for example, like the first thing I think people should do is, you know, or what, you know, would be recommended and to think about is to do the basics. Okay. What things like what you mentioned is like, like the multifactor authentication, you know, anti-malware on their clients, keeping things up to date. And, and making sure you have backups of your data. These are sort of the basics, right? And so apart from the basics, though, you know, the next step above that is to then start looking at what we call privileged access management or role-based security. Not everybody needs to have access to everything, right? So, so, so let's say, for example, a system was compromised with somebody's permissions or credentials. Right. Depending on what they have access to, they could only do so much. And so there's a, there's a, there's an important concept in cybersecurity that we call the privilege, the principle of least privilege. So, and that sort of dictates that a person really only needs access to the information that they need to do the role that they're trained to do in their specific function. So if, if somebody is, you know, in IT, somebody who's familiar with IT systems, They understand sort of the complexity involved, and they may have access to privileged systems where they can perform things and have access to that sensitive data, but not the entire organization, right? Mm-hmm. And so we call that privileged access management. And sometimes, especially with today's— as we've moved into the cloud more, when things get fired up and somebody spins up an app in the cloud, they— the cloud apps will generally have some basic role-based permissions like the admin, Maybe a superuser, and then maybe some groups, and then just the regular users. You don't want to give everybody admin rights because then if somebody— that just provides more exposure. These are small things that don't take a lot of time or effort really to just sort of— that's a little bit beyond the basics though because TechSoup for example provides Office 365 or M365 and Google Workspace organizations. And once they are provisioned, the next step is to really go in there and sort of harden them a little bit and lock them down, and to go through those steps and understand what that looks like so that as people start doing things like maybe downloading spreadsheets that contain donor data or customer data, that it's not— Right. Somebody can't accidentally just share that with somebody, you know, outside their organization, or, or that becomes available on the general public internet.
Tony MartignettiSo how do we execute some of these things that are, that are more advanced, you know, beyond the, the backing up, uh, the multi-factor authentication? All right, so if you move into privileged access management, we need a— we, we either have a CTO, which most listeners probably don't, or We need some outside help?
Michael EnosNo, actually, I think that a lot of these, you know, cloud-based applications will provide guidance. The good news is, is that they have an interest in protecting and wanting you as a customer, as well as, you know, the fact that it's a shared data model. And so the better that they do in terms of providing information about how this works, the better, you know, the people who use that product is going to benefit from it. And so generally in these, you know, and these things aren't— if you have somebody who is at least responsible for the deployment of the technology, and they don't have to be an advanced computer scientist to do the work of the cloud app, then somebody should be sort of designated within the organization to ensure some of the basics about the way data is handled. And, you know, getting to one of the next points I wanted to bring up, one of the most important things to understand for an organization is what data do they have, where does it live, and what is the value of it? What is sensitive and what is the value of
Tony Martignettiit? All right, Michael, before we—
Michael Enoswait,
Tony Martignettibefore we move to what's our data inventory, I want to emphasize this. I want to emphasize the value of being in the cloud. So there is, there is value to using, uh, you know, CRM databases that are cloud-based versus server-based at, in your office anymore.
Michael EnosCorrect. And for so many reasons. And, you know, uh, and, and moving to that topic, because a lot of the, the ways that systems are oftentimes breached is because of things we mentioned earlier such as they are not patched. There is not very good perimeter security on them. These things are taken care of for you, and they are not backed up regularly. These things are taken care of for you in a SaaS application if it is a robust SaaS application like the kind that TechSoup provides. And so when we go to vet an offer that is going to be in our marketplace, We go through the diligence to ensure that this is going to be a product that will serve the test of time and actually will be robust in the requirements necessary for an organization to protect their data. And so that leads to also making it more— making it a little bit easier for organizations to then lock down their cybersecurity because they don't have to have experts come into their— Right. closet or their data center and do this configuration and do all these updates that are very technical on their firewalls and all the hardware and everything all the time in their own infrastructure. It can be managed within the cloud by people who are not necessarily have that sort of, you know, the Cisco CCNA sort of certification.
Tony MartignettiAll right, thank you. I just, I wanted to drill down a little further on that.
Michael EnosAbsolutely. No, very good point.
Tony MartignettiThe value of, from a security perspective, the value of the cloud. All right, so let's go to what you were headed to. Like your data inventory, what do you have? What do we need to be— what do you want us to think about there?
Michael EnosYeah, so, you know, data is not— all data is not created equal, so to speak, right? So we have data that is just things like, you know, my notes when I'm, you know, talking in a meeting or something like that, okay? There's nothing valuable with that. It's, you know, generally not containing anything that's sensitive. It's sort of my notes from a meeting. Okay, now if that is something that, you know, maybe I don't want to share, but it's not something that, you know, if a hacker were to look at it, they'd say, well, I can't sell this, and it doesn't contain anything that's gonna— I can do any harm with, right?
Tony MartignettiWell, it might depend. It might depend who's leading the meeting. You might have different— you might have different sets of notes depending on who's leading your meeting. Correct. You might be commenting on the Commenting on their, I don't know, their capacity. I mean, not to suggest that people—
Michael EnosOkay, so for example, yeah, you're right. So for example, if it's a—
Tony MartignettiWell, no, I'm actually having fun with you. Like if somebody at TechSoup was not a very good speaker or supervisor, you know, then those notes you might not want in the public domain. But if the person is carrying their weight and they're generally a good employee, you know, you'd have a brighter set of notes that You wouldn't feel bad about getting exposed. That was my, right, my point. I guess I wasn't, I wasn't coming— I was coming across so dry. It was, it was desert. It was desert dry.
Michael EnosNo, no, no. I'm glad you brought some, some light into it.
Tony MartignettiOkay.
Michael EnosThe, the, um, yeah, the types of data that, you know, we think about when we think about the difference between data privacy and data protection, to me they're very linked, right? So we have a responsibility to protect people's data and the privacy of their data, but also to protect the security of That data. And so, you know, fundamentally speaking, generally in organizations in the sector, there's going to be some, you know, information that's sensitive or may have some value. And if we identify that, and identify where that lives, and then focus our energy on securing that, making sure that that data is backed up, and testing access to it, That's, that's, you know, if you have limited resources, that's the place to really focus your attention. And then the other stuff is great. I mean, and using robust tools like we provide in our marketplace such as Box for document repositories or even SharePoint, those can all be really configured for any type of data, like even my notes from, you know, that, you know, or my supervisor's notes about me or your notes about me can be actually secured. Right. You know, in a very robust way or shared. And one of the things we're seeing, for example, especially with document collaboration software, it's very easy to share things. They make it very easy to share with anybody, right? You just
Tony Martignetticlick the little icon with the arrow pointing up. Yes.
Michael EnosAnd it always says like share with anybody with links, you know. Yeah. You know, and so if you, if it's something like, oh, you know, Oh, somebody just sent me, you know, or they told me to put in my, you know, take a picture of my passport or something and stick it in here, right? And somebody in the human resources once said, oh, I'm just going to share this link and make it copy to everybody. Now everybody has access to your passport, potentially everybody has access to your passport photo and ID. So, you know, these are the things that we just have to sort of like start thinking twice, which brings me up to my next point. Okay. Security awareness within organizations. Cybersecurity awareness. I cannot stress enough how important it is for organizations to have a cybersecurity awareness program within their organization. This— these programs don't cost a lot of money. They don't take a lot of time, and they go a long ways to prevent an internal mistake that could lead to something. 80%
Tony MartignettiWhat does this cybersecurity awareness program look like?
Michael EnosSo essentially, so for example, they're usually conducted on point of like orientation for an employee that comes into an organization and they go through a video, you know, provided by a platform like KnowBe4, which is in our marketplace. And they go through a video and they go through a quiz. And what they do is they sort of go through this, this methodical sort of, you know, course to teach somebody about phishing, about sensitive data, about ways that people try to get access to information either through cell phone phishing, through text phishing, through email phishing, or through other means to— or even on Slack to say, to try to fool you into providing some information Hmm. That they can use. A huge trend in this arena is what we call impersonation phishing. It's a specifically targeted phishing email that looks like it's coming from somebody within your organization such as your CEO, your CFO, or the human resources director asking you to provide or update your banking information. And it's very carefully cracked Crafted. It looks just like that, and you really have to do a lot of due diligence to really go through there and say, oh, did this really come from our CEO?
Tony MartignettiYeah, it's gotten really tricky. Haven't there been cases where like a spoof email like this says, you know, wire $50,000 to this vendor account? You know, we're over— the payment is overdue, we need to wire this payment ASAP. And, you know, of course it goes to the bad actor's account. Isn't there stuff like that? It looks like it's like the treasurer saying send a wire or the CEO saying make a payment.
Michael EnosThat's right, exactly. And if you have an organization and people haven't been trained to recognize that if somebody's asking you for something and it's something of value, double-check it and to contact that individual in a different channel and say, Did you really need me to send $50,000 in this wire transfer? I just wanted to check if this actually came from you. There's other ways that they teach you in these orientation platforms or in these security awareness platforms to check the email headers and these simple things. But essentially, that's the gist of it, and that's why security awareness training is so important, so people are on their toes when they're actually doing their work.
Tony MartignettiDo you recommend then ongoing training? You talked about orientation training.
Michael EnosYeah, so essentially there's an orientation training and then You know, most organizations will have it mandatory that they do an annual training, and this is just as a refresher course. And also things change. So, you know, the space changes. Sometimes people are doing it now because of the trends more often, like every 6 months. And then specifically for people who are in jobs where they are doing data handling for— let's say they are doing data processing. They work in the donor services program or something where they are managing sensitive data all day long. Right. There'll be specialized courses for people who are actually dealing with data on a day-to-day basis. So that's a little bit more involved in terms of actually how to understand. And that goes into things like don't download, you know, a CSV file onto your computer and stick it onto a, you know, a thumb drive on your computer or transport it, or, you know, don't, you know, send it, you know, via email to a coworker. And these sorts of things are very specific to handling sensitive data.
Tony MartignettiOkay, interesting. Yeah, so even, even just emailing internally from employee to employee can be risky?
Michael EnosYes, it can be, especially if it's— and, and there's— because, for example, if— because that's actually— it's going to stay within that email store wherever that is located, and it's, um, if it's unencrypted, it's going to be— it's going to be encrypted during transit, for example, um, and, and encrypted at rest. But if somebody else had access to got access to your email server or privileged access to your system, they could potentially go in and take over that account, log in as the CEO, and then have access to the data and actually browse emails for— and actually do queries and look for credit card information or look for email addresses, and then they could potentially find information about donors or constituents that's sensitive.
Tony MartignettiIt's time for Tony's Take Two. It's time to get back in people's faces again. Last month I did an in-person, live, face-to-face, in-person training on Long Island. I was in New York City for several days. What a joy. What a pleasure. What a difference and improvement You know, over virtual trainings. I mean, look, Zoom is— I'm all flustered. Zoom is necessary, and I'm not saying necessary evil. It's a part of the culture, whether it's Zoom or Teams or Google Meet, you know, whatever. Virtual meetings, they're just a part of our lives now, no question about it. But Don't make those the default. If you have the option to get back in front of people in person, I urge you, choose that option. You know, I could have passed on the opportunity to do the, the in-person training, but I didn't want to. I didn't want to. Donor meetings too, while I was in the city. Face-to-face meetings again, coffee, lunches. It's just so much better, so much more real than anything virtual can offer. Um, I had a meeting, uh, lunch meeting just about 10 days ago or so with someone from Heller Consulting, which is going to be Team Heller. They're going to be our 23 NTC sponsors at the Nonprofit Technology conference coming up in Denver, and the woman who works for Heller happens to live within 45 minutes of where I live in North Carolina. So we got together for a real lunch. We had lunch together over the same table. Remarkable. You know, it's— yeah, more real, authentic. I urge you, if you can meet someone in person, Instead of virtual, do it. Do it. It makes the world of difference. It's time to get back in people's faces again. Don't make virtual your, your default. If there's another way first, I urge you to do it. That is Tony's Take Two. Thank you, Tony. We've got beaucoup buttloads more time for Beat Back Cyberattack with Michael Enos. Talk about not preserving data that you don't need to preserve, like credit card numbers, full numbers for instance, or dates of birth, or, or other things that aren't necessary for you to preserve? Isn't there, isn't there value in trimming down sensitive data that you don't really need?
Michael EnosYes, and, and one of the principal aspects of data handling is anonymization of data. So, you know, there's, there's transactional data that happens, and oftentimes, for example, when Credit card things are processed nowadays. You'll usually use a payment processor. So, you know, hopefully you're not actually, you know, that server that's actually storing that information is not on your box anymore. Because there's, you know, you know, you can use an API on your website and then it happens somewhere else and they take care of all that stuff for you. So if your systems were hacked, they wouldn't have access to the credit card data.
Tony MartignettiYou're talking about like a PayPal. Or
Michael EnosBraintree, or one of these types of services. Right. Exactly. And so those go to those payment processors and they manage all that, which is great because then it reduces the amount of exposure on your ecommerce site or fundraising donation site. And if you are using a donation software program like DonorPerfect or one of these sites, that's what they are doing as well. Because they want to use— because you really have to have the best-in-breed technology to be able to make sure that that stuff gets— that that's really super secure, and they have higher standards and compliance standards by which they attest to. However though, let's say you are doing an email list to your constituents. You are going to need some marketing data, so you are going to need to know who to send this information to, but you don't need everything about that individual. You don't need things like that are really— I mean, you may need the basics, but you should be using a marketing provider that is secure, and you should transfer— get that information to them in a secure way. And you should ensure that if that individual wants to opt out— and all these things should be in an organization's privacy policy so that people understand how their data is being used if they sign up for a newsletter or things of that nature. However, I think your point specifically, oftentimes Reports about, you know, activities, engagement, you know, that go into reports for executives or for things that are put into a PDF or in another format, the data should be anonymized. So the only thing that's there is, you know, aggregated information about, you know, the engagement. And not all— they shouldn't be able to drill down and see, oh, who is this exact individual? Now if they need to know, if they want a donor report about, you know, I want to know exactly to see who are the top donors and such, you know, there should only be limited people within the organization who have access to that data to be able to see that information. That goes back to my other point about privileged access management. There are going to be some— there's going to be some reason why people aren't going to want to know specifically about, you know, who's engaging with the communities. And also, oftentimes on the client level, we need to know that the people who are providing services to communities need to know exactly who these individuals are and more sensitive information. And that's what I was talking about earlier about, you know, understanding where that data lives and only having as much as you need to fulfill the function of that, you know, whatever you're doing. Um. And having that, you know, and making sure that's really locked down. When I worked in the food— when I worked in the food and security sector, We had people going out in the communities and helping sign them up for, you know, CalFresh, you know, essentially benefits, you know, for people to get, you know, government assistance. And they'd have to collect really sensitive information. But what they did is they had ways to securely transmit that information to the local human resources agencies so that it was all encrypted. Right. It was protected. And then once we transmitted that, we didn't have access to it anymore.
Tony MartignettiYeah. What about vetting vendors? You know, if your office is using a mailhouse, you know, some of the data that you just talked about for mailing, I can't think of other examples of vendors that could be— well, events could have— event management might have some sensitive data. How do you vet your vendors to make sure that they're taking appropriate actions to prevent theft, phishing, you know, to defeat the— or at least you can't defeat them, but at least minimize the threats. How do you check these third parties that you're working with?
Michael EnosWell, you know, that's a big part of my role at TechSoup. So whenever we work with it, whenever we're going to be using a new product or app or something like that, it's my job to go in and actually check. Sure. And organizations, these application providers will provide on their site, or they should, and if they don't, you shouldn't use them. But most of them will provide on their site access to their information security program and what they do, where their data is located, what they do to protect it, their compliance levels, their certification levels, whether they do audits, whether or not they do penetration tests. And what type of— and everything to that order. And that should be vetted by somebody before they onboard an app. And we do this all the time. We use a lot of different apps at TechSoup, north of 100. And so every time we onboard one for some utility within the organization, we make sure that they meet the standard. And we actually, since we are a third-party vendor for other people, they ask the same for us. Mm-hmm. So a lot of the work I do as well is to report out periodically to all the people who are using our platform to facilitate their data to organizations. And what's TechSoup's information security program like? So this creates transparency, but it also helps people understand what the risks are, which helps when you are in a situation where you are needing to go and advocate for resources to institute a cybersecurity program.
Tony MartignettiI want to ask you about the board's role in all this, but is there anything more that you want— before we get to the board, anything more you want to talk about threat minimization policies? Anything we haven't covered that you want folks to know about?
Michael EnosYeah, I think that one of the things that is, you know, that we haven't mentioned yet is preparedness for a cyberattack. An incident, essentially a security incident response plan. This, you know, is another thing in that sort of list of 5 that an organization should understand. If you have a situation where your data has been breached— and one thing I do want to do is to describe quickly, even though it's kind of a dry topic, is there's a difference between a security incident and a security data breach. Okay. A security incident could be something as innocuous as somebody just knocking off your website and taking it down with a DDoS attack. Now that sounds innocuous because it's just— I mean, it doesn't sound innocuous because it's disruptive because nobody can get to your website, but nobody's taken the data. And as soon as that denial of service attack is stopped, your website may be still functioning. But that's an incident. Now, a data breach is different because now you've got to do a couple different things. You've got to, number one, find out how the breach occurred, which you should also do in case of the DDoS attack. But above that, you also need to then understand how to respond to, you know, what data was breached, what's the scope of that data, and who are the individuals, and what's our plan to reach out to those individuals and notify them about the breach. And what is our policy around that? And who do we have to include in terms of communications internally and legally and, and to provide that transparency? Because for a number of different reasons. Number one, it is the, it is the right thing to do. And number two, because it actually helps build trust within, within communities. Because if people understand that, you know, these things happen, and they have happened to some very, very large organizations, right? We, we know about these these really large breaches. But the more transparent they are, the more the consumers or the constituents who use those products think, gosh, they really responded well to this, and they acted immediately, they communicated appropriately, and they remediated what happened, and that was the responsible thing to do. And you don't want to be doing that in the middle of a breach. So having a plan Upfront helps during that process because otherwise it's just too much at one time.
Tony MartignettiAll right, everything all at once. The plan is going to lay out who's in charge, right? Who makes what kinds of decisions, um, who to notify,
Michael Enosright? And, and what's the playbook, essentially?
Tony MartignettiYeah, like, I mean, it could even, it could even break down to needing a remote place to work. I mean, does it go that far? Or because we're hopefully in the cloud, we don't— like if our physical infrastructure gets compromised, do we need to go offsite? And what's the technology? What are the technology capabilities in our offsite work location?
Michael EnosWell, that's actually a little different. So we usually talk about that in terms of business continuity plan.
Tony MartignettiOkay.
Michael EnosSo, and, and that would be the same sort of plan you would enact in case of a natural disaster or something like that. I mean, is, is a business continuity— and, and that's far exceeding the scope of what we could discuss today, although I'd be happy to discuss that at some point. No, no, let's not, let's not.
Tony MartignettiI don't want to panic folks. Okay. All right.
Michael EnosAll
Tony Martignettiright.
Michael EnosYou
Tony Martignettigot me focused on, you got me focused on like, uh, I don't know, natural disasters and, uh, and, and terrorism. All right. Right, right.
Michael EnosSo,
Tony Martignettibut
Michael Enosyeah, okay, all right. So, so one of the things that boards' role, right? So organizations nowadays are— let's put it this way— cybersecurity is becoming and is becoming as important as sort of financial security within an organization. The 2 are becoming linked together. An organization— and so for many years, as we all know, 501 organizations in the US are generally bound to having a financial audit annually, right, that then they report to the board, and the board makes sure that, you know, there's been a financial audit to ensure that the funds are used judiciously. There's oversight and governance over these matters. Cybersecurity is becoming as important as financial security because the two are linked together. If there's a— Because it could affect it. If you have a ransomware attack, it could affect the viability and the business sustainability of an organization. So it's a very serious matter. It's becoming a very, very serious matter for organizations to then think about cybersecurity as a compliance issue, not just a nice-to-have. And so helping our boards understand that this has shifted From a situation where, oh, well, you know, nobody is going to attack a nonprofit, and if they do, our data isn't very important. Things have shifted, right? So I think recently there was a community, one of these cities, for example, an entire city has been locked down for days because of a ransomware attack, and so nothing can function within in the city because, you know, that's going to affect everything within the city, not just their continuity, safety of people, but also it's going to have a financial impact. So cybersecurity is becoming more like a compliance issue and a governance issue. And so I think if boards understood that, then they would understand the need to prioritize and to put provide funding and resources for those within the organization, whether that— if it's a smaller organization, either that the CFO or the COO or even the CEO to then say, look, we need to carve out some resources to be able to understand our risk. And the best way to do that would be to do a third-party risk assessment. And with somebody to come in and actually do an evaluation and say— because they'll come in and do, you know, and come in and say, hey, look, these are the You know, we come in and, and these people are vetted. They are, this is their job, and, you know, they are safe to work with. And they will go in and say, this is where you really need to be. These are the critical things. These are the, you know, not important things. And these are the nice-to-haves. And they will, they will lay it out for you, and then you can develop as part of your strategic plan as an organization, just like it should be part of your business plan. It should be linked to the business plan because First, the strategic plan for the organization, and then the funding, the budgets, resources, the resource planning, and all these things should then be baked into the operational strategic plan for an organization. That's where we're going in the sector.
Tony MartignettiOkay, it belongs as part of your, your strategic plan, your business plan. All right.
Michael EnosYeah, and that's where I think that it's It's just like I said, I think where a board comes in is to help understand that so that they could then authorize and oversee and ensure that an organization is doing this work. And it's hard work because, you know, you may have limited resources. Where are we going to carve, where are we going to carve this out? And However, the good news is that there are people who want to fund this. There are grantmakers who would be super happy to be able to say, look, I'm going to help. I'm going to do a capacity impact grant to this organization to help improve their cybersecurity because of these trends that we are seeing. And so, and then you can use that as a mechanism to possibly help fundraise. to offset some of the funding so it doesn't have to come out necessarily of your operational costs.
Tony MartignettiOkay, there are foundations that will fund this.
Michael EnosYeah.
Tony MartignettiYeah. All right. All right, we're gonna leave it there, Michael. Thank you.
Michael EnosOkay.
Tony MartignettiMichael from Montana, Michael Enos, Senior Director of Community and Platform.
Michael EnosIt's been a great pleasure. It's been a great pleasure, Tony. Thank you for having me.
Tony MartignettiOh, my pleasure too. Thank you. Senior Director of Community and Platform for TechSoup Global. He's on Mastodon @Michael_Enos, at publicgood.social, and TechSoup, where you'd expect him to be, techsoup.org. Next week, I'm working on it, and I assure you that there will be a show next week because this is show number 630, and I've been producing a show every week for 13 years, close to. I assure you there will be a show next week. I just, uh, don't know what it'll be about. But don't bet against me because there is going to be a show. You're not— you're going to lose if you bet against there being a show next week. If you missed any part of this week's show, I beseech you, find it at tonymartignetti.com. Our creative producer is Claire Meyerhoff. The show's social media is by Susan Chavez. Marc Silverman is our web guy, and this music is by Scott Stein. Thank you for that affirmation, Scotty. Be with me next week for Nonprofit Radio, Big Nonprofit Ideas for the Other 95%. Go out and be great. Thank you.

