Skip to content
EP 622January 8, 2023

Gene & Amy's 2023 Outlook

Tony MartignettiGene TakagiAmy Sample Ward
Nonprofit Radio
Episode 622
0:00 / 0:00

About this episode

Our esteemed contributors, Gene Takagi and Amy Sample Ward, reveal what they’re thinking about for the New Year. We’re talking about Twitter, donor advised funds, fiscal sponsorship, and illegal activities. Gene comes to us from NEO Law Group, and Amy is CEO of NTEN.

Here’s the transcript

Tony MartignettiHello and welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. I'm your aptly named host of your favorite hebdomadal podcast. Happy New Year! Happy New Year! I hope you enjoyed your time off. I hope you're looking forward to our new year, and I have more on that in, in Tony's Take Two. Oh, I'm glad you're with me. I'd suffer with salpingum fraxus if I had to hear that you missed this week's show, Gene and Amy's 2023 Outlook. Our esteemed contributors Gene Takagi and Amy Sample Ward reveal what they're thinking about for the new year. We're talking about Twitter, donor-advised funds, fiscal sponsorship, and illegal activities. Gene comes to us from NEO Law Group, and Amy is CEO of NTEN. On Tony's Take Two, take in this new year. What a genuine pleasure to have both Gene Takagi and Amy Sample Ward with me, us together substantively. It's not just a 50th anniversary show. No, this is not the 650th show. This is not July of 2023. Gene and Amy are with us to talk substance together and crosstalk as well. You know them, but they are esteemed contributors and They are due their proper introductions. Gene is our legal contributor and managing attorney of NEO, the Nonprofit and Exempt Organizations Law Group in San Francisco. He edits the wildly popular nonprofitlawblog.com and is a part-time lecturer at Columbia University. The firm is at neolawgroup.com, and he's @GTAC. Welcome to the New Year's show, Gene.

Gene TakagiThank you, Tony. Great to be here, and great to be here with Amy especially.

Tony MartignettiAbsolutely, yes, a genuine pleasure with Amy Sample Ward, who is CEO of NTEN and our technology and social media contributor. Their most recent co-authored book is The Tech That Comes Next, about equity and inclusiveness in technology development. They're at amysampleward.org and @amyrsward. Amy, happy New Year. Welcome to the New Year show.

Amy Sample WardThanks. It, it feels like maybe we'll revisit the intro if you're saying our Twitter handles and then we're about to talk about what's happening over at Twitter. But you know, that's all part of what's to come in a lot of conversations.

Tony MartignettiAbsolutely. This could end up being, uh, Mastodon, uh, handles. We'll see. We'll see about that. Absolutely. All right, we, um, we are going to start with Gene. To talk about, Gene, you're concerned about some legislative potential changes around donor-advised funds.

Gene TakagiYeah, I mean, it's the donor-advised fund area is probably one that most of your listeners are kind of familiar with because they're the fastest growing area of charitable giving. Over $1 trillion now held by donor-advised funds, and that is huge, growing much faster than private foundations. And, you know, they make up some of the biggest charities In the country, I think possibly half of the top 10 may be donor-advised fund sponsoring organizations, and several of those associated with financial institutions. So like a Fidelity or a Vanguard, Schwab, Goldman Sachs, Morgan Stanley. So, you know, there's been some heat about, well, are these really charities? Are they charitable giving? And the answer is yes, they are charities, even though they are associated with financial institutions. Right. But that heat has led up to people going, well, what is the money doing? What is that $1 trillion doing in these donor-advised funds? Are they actually making—

Tony MartignettiAnd this has been percolating for years.

Gene TakagiYeah, it has been.

Tony MartignettiThis began on the Senate— was it the Senate Finance Committee? It was one of the Senate committees. Yeah. This has been coming up for years around the money parked in donor-advised funds and not getting to 501 charities.

Gene TakagiYeah, I think starting with Senator Grassley at the Senate Finance Committee.

Tony MartignettiRight, Chuck Grassley. Yes, right. Yes.

Gene TakagiSo it's been— people have been talking about it, but donor-advised funds continue to sort of go up on this exponential growth curve where they just keep getting used more and more often, oftentimes by, you know, some of the very, very ultra-wealthy individuals. And there's some heat about that too, about why do we have so many ultra-wealthy individuals who can control You know, what charities are doing, who can control our politics by—

Tony MartignettiThat's a whole nother— oh my gosh.

Gene TakagiThat's all part of the same story. But because of that, you know, there's been some pushback and some legislation suggested and now sponsored and introduced. Well, I should say introduced into Congress, but it's not actually been on a bill that has a formal sponsor that's before anybody other than a committee right now looking at it. And that's called the Accelerating Charity Accountability Act. Charitable Efforts Act, or the ACE Act, and that's up in front of some congressional members and a committee right now, and that has all these reforms to donor-advised funds to help sort of mitigate some of those problems of the warehousing of wealth and money not getting out to charities as quickly as some people would like. But there are some, you know, there are pros and cons to what all that involves, but it's good for people to sort of be aware of it.

Tony MartignettiOkay, be paying attention to this. Um, now, when, uh, at least when I was in 6th and 7th grade, we used to learn that an act becomes a bill and a bill becomes law after it's signed. But so thank you for making the distinction. Uh, all right, so, so this doesn't have any sponsors yet. There, it's, it's just, it's proposed, I guess. Is it in a committee?

Gene TakagiIt's in a committee right now. Okay. The chances are, while I'm not a great prognosticator of what happens on Capitol Hill, and I'm not based in Washington, I will say what I'm hearing from people who are is that it probably doesn't have a good chance of passing right now. So it's unlikely to see changes now, but this is a growing issue, as you mentioned, Tony, that's been percolating for years and just getting more and more attention. provisions of the ACE Act, which is probably— the ACE Act overall is pretty complicated, and we won't go into the technicalities here. That would bore your listeners. Yeah. But it's complicated, and for part of that reason, there's not sort of universal, like, the nonprofit sector all wants this to be passed. No, there's like people on both sides of this issue, and because of that, I think prognosticators who are more informed who suggest that this probably won't pass as is are probably right, but there are aspects of it that could find their way in other bills. So that's sometimes how laws are passed. The donor-advised funds laws passed through the Pension Protection Act.

Tony MartignettiRight.

Gene TakagiAnd you would not necessarily think those are related, but they can slip their way in. So just sort of pay attention to All of these, you know, movements around wealth and power and what that means to our charitable sector and how donor-advised funds are being used. Something just to look at. And there are several organizations who are advocating on either side of this.

Tony MartignettiOkay, cool. All right, we'll pay attention to donor-advised funds. In terms of wealth and You know, 8 individuals controlling or certainly heavily influencing the charitable priorities, that's for— we'll have to do that on another show. Fiscal sponsorship is something else you want us to look out for. Just define it, you know, in its basics so that everybody has the common understanding that we're starting with.

Gene TakagiSo the issue with fiscal sponsorship, while it is also growing very, very quickly, and the nonprofit sector might be aware of it, but sort of the outside world might not really know what that means. And generally what it means is that there are people who have a charitable project but don't have a charity entity with 501 status to run it. They look for another group to either house it Or to give grants to their group, which might be considered a taxable for-profit if they don't have 501 status for some period of time. And that's how fiscal sponsorship can arise. It can arise in different forms, but because it's not defined by law, it's done wrong all the time. So while it's growing— yeah.

Tony MartignettiWhat about new charities that don't yet have their 501? Maybe they've applied, So they've submitted their 1023 to the IRS, but the process may take a long time. Can they also are sometimes benefiting from fiscal sponsors? So they'll get an established 501 to make grants to them until they get their own 501 determination. Is that, is that okay?

Gene TakagiYeah, that's a perfect use of a fiscal sponsor. And fiscal sponsors can act as incubators even if they're not applying for 501 status right away. Even if it's something they'd like to test out and say, is this a viable charitable idea?

Tony MartignettiOkay.

Gene TakagiSo yes, fiscal sponsorship can absolutely run that way. But if it's not structured properly, even if that is the well-intended sort of purposes of everybody involved, if it's not structured properly, you can get into trouble both as an organization. You can end up having a donor who gets denied a deduction. You can get a foundation into trouble who funds it. Structuring these things properly is really important. So as this field advances and evolves, and it's been around in informal ways for, you know, many, many decades, as this field advances, we want— we'd like to see sort of more sort of consistency in operating it in a lawful manner that doesn't endanger anybody and really helps everybody accomplish what they want to do charitably.

Tony MartignettiAnd what about the idea— I mean, if you are incubating an organization, let's say it's, it's a few people, it doesn't really matter, but I'm just trying to take it out of the realm of just one person. Suppose you're incubating a, an idea and you, the community foundation— because they'll often act as community, as fiscal sponsors, community foundations— you think it's a, it's a bona fide nonprofit idea, but And you make grants to it, but it turns out not to be. So they don't get their 501 determination positive. What, what happens then? Is the, is the community foundation liable at all? Or, and what happens to the deductions that were granted to the, to this nascent, now not, now not, not a 501

Gene TakagiYeah, so I don't want to dive too deep into the weeds, but yes, if the community foundation is housing and incubating the project, it's not the same project that is housed in this new entity that is applying for 501 status. That's going to be transferred over into the new entity once it gets its 501 status. So if the community foundation is running an illegal activity, which is maybe another topic we can talk about—

Tony MartignettiIt is. We're going to talk about it. Yes.

Gene TakagiYeah, well, then the community foundation Foundation would of course get into trouble. But if it's a small part of what the community foundation does, which it probably would be, right? It would be maybe like 1% or maybe even less than 1% of the community foundation's overall activities. That's not gonna usually result in anything terrible unless they were doing very terrible things, which is unlikely. But it, you know, it would be different. So an incubator definitely has less risks, and they've got all their insurance and, you know, legal support and accounting support to make sure that it's not running afoul. Right. While it's housed in the community foundation.

Amy Sample WardIf I can say something, Gene, I think as I'm listening to this conversation, and from NTEN has been a fiscal sponsor for many different groups, you know, you also don't have to be pursuing C3 status. It might— the whole purpose of what you're doing could be done. You know, like we've been a fiscal sponsor for a group that was going to hold an event. Once the event was over, they were all done. They weren't— there was nothing to pursue a registration for, you know. So just naming that there's a few nuances in that, in the timeline too, that it may not be that there's ever a application and something shady happened, but also the thing is over. You know, there's a lot of moving pieces.

Gene TakagiYeah, great point.

Tony MartignettiWell, you know, Amy, what did you look for, uh, if you do in deciding to sponsor?

Amy Sample WardWell, folks approach us. We haven't, you know, gone out saying we would love to be a fiscal sponsor. It's because it's not, you know, NTEN isn't set up— there are organizations, of course, who that's like their mission is to fiscally sponsor organizations. But when we have been approached and folks have asked if we can essentially extend our organizational privilege to enable their work, the things that we look for are if there's any sort of document or organizing agreement for the people involved on the other side. Again, because they might not be trying to be an organization, but we want there to be accountability That that we can come back to, that they understand how much money they're likely to bring in and how they're going to spend it, and that NTEN's books aren't going to end up with some $10,000. We can't do something. You know that there's really a plan for what's coming in and what's going out, and that they understand the options that exist for either becoming on payroll with us, not being on payroll, being a short-term contractor, because NTEN already has staff and. 8 different states. But what does that look like if we were bringing someone on for a longer term and they needed to be on payroll in a state we're not in? So we just have those conversations with them, but we have a standard agreement for fiscal sponsorship that we send to folks when we're having those relationships. And, you know, separate bank account, separate P&L, like all of that.

Gene TakagiLet me add just one more thing that some, sometimes it's all about creating what some people would call a commons. So these projects never want to leave, but they find the efficiency of centralizing kind of administrative and back-office resources, and fiscal sponsor takes care of your legal filings and your tax filings, your insurance, and multiple projects just want to stay there forever. So that, that's a use of the fiscal sponsor, a perfectly acceptable use of the fiscal sponsor as well. As long as it's structured properly. So structuring properly would be maybe my main point in this, is that oftentimes people think, oh, I've seen somebody else do it, let's do it the same way. That may not work. They may be using the wrong example. So the National Network of Fiscal Sponsors, NNFS, they've got a good sort of model of how this can be done properly.

Tony MartignettiThey have a book too, don't they, Gene?

Gene TakagiThe book is actually from Greg Colvin and Stephanie Pettit called Fiscal Sponsorship: 6 Ways to Do It Right. And it's, I believe, the only book out there. And it's really good and not terribly expensive. So if you're a fiscal sponsor and you're not quite sure about what you're doing, buy that book.

Tony MartignettiOkay. Fiscal Sponsorship: 6 Ways to Do It Right. Very, very aptly named book. I like it. Okay. Yeah. And there are also implications for the donors, right? If this is— if it's not created and implemented correctly, Gene, the— can the donors get like their charitable deduction clawed back or something like that?

Gene TakagiYeah, they could get it denied by the IRS because if the donor directs their donation to an entity that's not a charity— so if they're telling the fiscal sponsor, you must give this money to this project that's a separate entity.

Tony MartignettiYeah,

Gene Takagiwell, with a different bank account. The donor doesn't get a deduction. Fiscal sponsor may have been aiding and abetting tax fraud. So problems there. So they've got to be careful.

Tony MartignettiOkay. For your donors too. All right.

Gene TakagiYeah.

Tony MartignettiAnd on the, on the illegal activity side, what, what's your— what are your concerns there?

Gene TakagiSo as a lawyer, of course, any illegal activities are a concern, but Well, there's

Tony Martignettiillegal and there's

Gene Takagiillegal. Actually, that's a really good point. So one of the things that the IRS looks at is like, are you a 501 organization if you're conducting illegal activities? And they use the question that you asked basically, Tony. There's legal and there's illegal. So if you are engaging in, you know, civil disobedience to a small extent to advocate your perfectly appropriate charitable purpose and mission, you're probably not gonna expose your 501 status to, to being revoked for that reason. If you're committing a little bit of bank robbery, well, that's probably gonna get you out of the 501 status, right?

Tony MartignettiWhy do it? Wait, I mean, why, why do anything financially fraudulent for like $1,500?

Amy Sample WardRight? There's not a little bit of bank robbery. Like, I want the whole safe or nothing. Yeah, no, no.

Tony MartignettiRight, right.

Amy Sample WardYou know?

Tony MartignettiI mean, if I'm gonna, if I'm gonna compromise my reputation and risk myself being in prison, I mean, I'm doing this for at least a million and a half or something, you know. I mean, let's make some decent money at it, for Pete's sake. Well, I'm not risking everything for $50,000.

Amy Sample WardNo, I want the gold bars. I want— why want everything, you know?

Tony MartignettiRight, right.

Gene TakagiSo here's how a lawyer is crafty about this.

Tony MartignettiI mean, like, let's go all in. I

Gene Takagimean, the lawyer will say, we are all in, in terms of how much money we're gonna steal. But 99% of our staff time is spent on real stuff. It's only 1% of our time that's spent on robbing the bank. Right.

Tony MartignettiIt was a, it was a tiny percentage of my time. I mean, it was just a few phone calls, a couple of texts. I mean, some—

Amy Sample WardIt was really not difficult. Did not take a lot of time.

Tony MartignettiSignal messages. I mean, you know, it was like a half an hour and, you know, we— and then we executed. So it's such a small percentage of my time, really. Why are we even bothering with this?

Gene TakagiAll right, exactly. So that's the— there's illegal and there's illegal, exactly as you framed it. But I think now why the illegalities doctrine, as lawyers like to call it, is trending a little bit is because we have some things that are considered illegal that some things that some states or jurisdictions are saying, well, no, that's not illegal. And just sort of an example is Cannabis. Well, cannabis could be legal in some states. It could be legal for medical purposes, but in some states it's illegal for recreational purposes. In other states it's illegal, and federally it's illegal, right? So that creates just all these weird dynamics. Can we have a 501 organization where we're a cannabis dispensary for medical purposes? We're doing it for charitable purposes. Can we do that? And the answer there is kind of no right now. If it breaks federal law, if that is the purpose of the organization. And so now we're not talking about activities now, but if that's the purpose of the organization is to break federal law, then you can't get 501 status. And you can't, if you have 501 status and you change your mission, you can't keep it. So something to look at in terms of cannabis organizations.

Tony MartignettiEven if it's legal, even if it's legal in your state.

Gene TakagiRight, because 501 status is a federal tax-exempt status.

Tony MartignettiRight.

Gene TakagiSo

Tony Martignettinow that could change.

Amy Sample WardAnd that's for the mission of the organization. But what about a national organization based in DC because they're a big HQ, they have their annual event in Oregon, and the gala where in Oregon Cannabis is, is completely legalized for recreation, etc. And, you know, the silent auction table has like a cannabis care package. Is there— they're registered in DC, the event is in Oregon. What's— what are the layers there?

Gene TakagiSo the activities may be judged by what particular state they're in, although the sale of cannabis would always be sort of FDA sort of Under FDA rules as well, right? So you could always get charged with a federal crime on that, which is always the tough part. But just from the federal tax exemption standpoint, it's kind of, again, if it's activities, if it's doing it as an activity, that's one thing. Whereas, is it illegal? You know, a little bit illegal, maybe. And they're probably not gonna really enforce or try to take away 501 status because of one event in Oregon where it's legal under state law. But if that's your purpose is to say, hey, we don't care what the federal law is, this is what our purpose is, which is contrary to federal law, that can get you in trouble. So that's the cannabis thing. But the study of cannabis or the study of psychedelics, certain psychedelics that might become approved federally, and Tony, as you were saying, cannabis could change as well. Mm-hmm. The study of it or the policy around it, that might be a perfect 501 purpose either in the scientific realm or the charitable or educational realm, but a little bit of gray area in all of this. But I did want to introduce one more area of illegality, and that is regarding abortion, because that is another really hot topic since the Dobbs decision by the Supreme Court, right? So that allows basically the states to decide whether abortion is illegal or not, and some states are really strict about what they think would be illegal around abortion. So funding people to get an abortion, which what a charity might do, they might not perform the abortion, but they might provide funding. And sometimes it's just funding to their own employees to be able to access abortion in a state that allows it. That can be illegal under state law as well. So now how does the, you know, that affect the 501 status?

Tony MartignettiEven just funding an employee Yeah, making it an employee benefit. Oh,

Gene TakagiI think a law firm in Texas— this varies amongst different states, Tony. So Texas is one that's been pretty tough and in my opinion, just terrible about the laws that they've used. And some of these laws go back decades. They're old laws that were ruled unconstitutional before, but now after the Dobbs decision, they're sprung back into life. And so, yeah, even funding employees to be able to access abortion clinics in other states could be illegal under those states. And—

Amy Sample WardYeah, after Dobbs, you know, there was like this wave of companies, especially for-profit companies, but I'm sure nonprofits did it too, you know, saying like, trying to, I think, in the spirit of making clear their values, But clearly not thinking about the practicalities, you know, making these announcements. We will always fund our staff having access to this healthcare, you know, even if you have to travel or whatever. But like, to Gene's point, that isn't very straightforward. It could be if it's known explicitly that that's what you're funding. It could be illegal if you're an organization in Texas, but also it requires disclosure that's already making vulnerable a vulnerable staff person, right? Yeah. A reimbursement, which a number of folks we've seen say policies for reimbursement of travel. Well, now there's like a paper trail of where you went and, and how much it cost. And, you know, like, instead thinking about policies that say, hmm, there may be harder things happening. We're increasing your health benefit by this, you know, percentage of dollars just in, you know, like there have— we have to think about the actual users here and not just

Tony MartignettiInteresting point too about the paper trail, because Texas again is one state where people who aid and abet abortion can be, can be what, sued, I think, right? Or it could be—

Gene TakagiCorrect.

Tony MartignettiRight. It could be sued. So, so if there's that paper trail that Amy's talking about, that mentions where the person went and maybe what relative may have helped them, or, you know, I mean, that those documents, that evidence could all be used when— if somebody nefarious inside the organization wants to get some people in trouble, you know, that evidence could all be used against them. Yeah.

Gene TakagiAnd all

Tony Martignettiright, well, yeah, I know, well-intentioned, but maybe not so well thought out, but it's, it's hard when, when something so, so disastrous happens, you know, people want to rush to the aid. Like, you know, just like individuals who give to tsunami victims and hurricanes, you know, like employers and CEOs want to rush to the aid of their employees when they feel that there's a, a, a, a something grievous happening to, to them potentially. Yeah, it's hard.

Gene TakagiAnd I want to say we haven't heard the last on this. These laws are going to be changed and challenged for years. But right now we're not in a very good place. But wrapping it back into a 501 package, can the IRS take away your tax exemption because you do some of these things? And then we get back to your, well, is it an activity that's illegal or is it really illegal? And my feeling is that The IRS is not going to judge on the violation of state law unless the state has actually made that determination by a court ruling. So you can't— you might be able to sue somebody and say, well, you know, they violated the state law, but if there's no court ruling that says that, the IRS is not an arbiter of whether somebody has broken state law or not. So they will not take away 501 status for just a complaint. that somebody is violating these rules, even though factually that might be the case. And nobody's not, you know, admitting that that's not true. But the IRS is probably gonna want to lay low on the whole abortion topic, is my feeling about it. But the illegality doctrine— and there's a similar doctrine called the public policy doctrine, which was first introduced for racially discrimination. Right. which was federally allowed, right? And Bob Jones University used that as, you know, admission criteria or other sort of policy criteria. And the IRS said, no, we're gonna take away your tax exemption for that, even though it wasn't inconsistent with law, but it broke federal public policy. So there's a related doctrine to illegality that's a sort of violation of public policy. But these are all things that charities just start to need to know and think about, because one day it may pop up right in their neighborhood, and they'll be thinking, about maybe we should have advocated a little bit harder in advance of that and tried to make a difference.

Tony MartignettiInteresting contrast between the 2 examples we're talking about, cannabis having been illegal all along and now slowly becoming legal, and abortion having been legal for the past 50 years, now slowly becoming illegal. All right, Gene, thank you very much. Love it. It's time for Tony's Take Two. Take in your new year. Welcome to your new year. I am always optimistic at the beginning of a new year. I cannot help it. It doesn't matter if we're in a pandemic or an economic recession in 2009. I, I'm I'm always optimistic at the beginning of a new year. It's in my DNA. So it's a year of opportunity. If 2023 was terrific for you, and I'm talking personally and professionally, if it was a bountiful year, it was a successful year for you, however you define that, congratulations. I'm very happy for you. I'm glad. Yeah. that your 2022 was what you wanted it to be. Outstanding. If your 2022 wasn't, if it was something less than you would have liked, again, personally and professionally, don't let that hold you back for the new year. Your past doesn't define your future. Your 2022 doesn't constrain what you can do in 2023. Literally each day, week, month, you've got the whole year of opportunities, new chances to excel. So don't let the past hold you back. If your last year wasn't up to what you would like it to have been. You've got a whole new year of opportunities. Welcome to your 2023. Take it in. Embrace it. That is Tony's Take Two. We've got beaucoup, buttloads more time for Gene and Amy's 2023 outlook with Gene and Amy. Amy, Twitter. What the hell?

Amy Sample WardSpeaking of a little bit of illegal. No, I'm kidding.

Tony MartignettiWhat the hell? Yeah, well, immoral, immoral and unethical to begin with. Exactly. The new CEO, Elon Musk. But what the hell do we do with our, with our Twitter accounts? And we all 3 of us here have one. Nearly every nonprofit, let's assume, has one. What— we sort of have a sense of the landscape. What's your advice?

Amy Sample WardYeah, I mean, I think to sum up my feelings, I would say like, down with Twitter and long live the internet. But what that means to me is a lot longer, you know, I think The decision about whether your organization should use Twitter or not is the same today as it has been every day since 2007 or whatever when it launched, right? Like, there's always been, I think, the need to consider if a tool you're using that is not yours, you don't get to own it, it is always permanently going to be someone else's tool, right? You're just a visitor there. If it's values match your expectations, if the community is there, like all those same questions that we've talked about for years are still the same questions. We've talked about for years as new platforms launch. You know, but I think what happens is organizations hopefully do ask those questions when they join something, and then it's like a closed discussion. And what I would love to see is that organizations re-ask those questions every day on these platforms, right? I would love to say the conversation isn't about Elon Musk, because I would like to never have a conversation about Elon Musk. However, he's really making the conversation about him by taking up a lot of the space and making the decisions, right? Yeah. Even today, suspending the account that was like a bot that just posted when his jet went places, and now that's been suspended. You know, it's like, okay, there's, there's just so much going on there. The issue to me isn't what has Elon tweeted or what has he done, and more, is it a platform that has the capacity to be safe for your users in your organization? Well, not if every single member of those safety teams has been fired. Right? Is it a platform that's going to be reliable? Because maybe you're using it to communicate in real-time situations, updates, etc. Maybe not when the, again, teams that support the reliability and uptime of the tool have been fired. So if it is meeting your needs, if your community is still really active there, if it feels like it's a good fit, I'm not gonna say empirically there's only one answer to using any tool. Is it a tool that NTEN is using anymore? No, it doesn't meet either the reliability or the values piece that we expect. We've seen tons of community members, board members, organizations, you know, post their last tweet, and some of them it's like, a very sad goodbye. And for others, it's find me on LinkedIn. Here's, here's my profile, right? And for others, the last tweet didn't even know that it was the last tweet. It just was the last tweet. And then there weren't anymore. You know, it wasn't a sign-off. It just kind of ended. But I'll say all that and pause and then, and, and hear your thoughts. All

Tony Martignettiright. So what, you know, the concerns about safety, reliability, these teams having been fired. What about just taking a wait and see what might replace them? I mean, it's still— we still are now January. Well, we're like 2 months into his— 2 and a half months or so into his ownership. Should we wait? Well, and I should say we're recording in mid-December, so it may not even— it may emerge by the time this comes out in early January.

Amy Sample WardHello from the past when you're listening to us.

Tony MartignettiShould we— so should we wait and see what—

Amy Sample WardYou totally can. You know, I think what's— I think something to think about is that there is no clear timeline for what wait and see means. There has not been a, we've fired all of these teams that provide the reliability of the tool and the safety of the tool, or at least the illusion of safety of the tool. And we'll be hiring for those teams on X date. That's not been the process, right? So that's not to say posting your last tweet includes deactivating your account and leaving and everything, right? It could just be maybe you stop using it. It could be like NTEN has done. We don't put money into the tool, so we don't buy ads, we don't promote things. Right? So we're not investing in what it is.

Tony MartignettiYeah.

Amy Sample WardAnd the account's open. We still have a notification set so that if a community member chooses to like tweet at us and say, hey, how come I can't find this about the conference? We still see it and could provide that customer service, right? But it's not a place that we are spending our time, spending our dollars, spending our energy. Even if you could still find the NTEN account, right? And I think that's a place that for us feels like we haven't walked away from the community or whatever parts of the community are still on the platform, but we have made clear our stance is that this is not a place that feels worthy of that investment, right?

Tony MartignettiWhat have you done personally with @AmyRSWard?

Amy Sample WardI already use Twitter so inconsistently. Like, there's one day where I just see 5 things and I'm like liking everybody's tweets and replying to people, and then I like accidentally go 5 weeks without tweeting just because I, you know, I wasn't, I wasn't logged in or I wasn't looking at things. I don't know that I have tweeted recently. I don't have, I don't have even in my tab purgatory of my 2 screens, I do not have Twitter open anywhere. I think the place— it's really interesting. The place that Twitter started out for me is kind of where it has returned to, of very hyperlocal. Like, there's so many Portland folks that I don't otherwise see because I never leave my house, or, you know, they don't work in nonprofit tech, so I wouldn't otherwise connect with them, but I could still see them on Twitter. I think that's a place where it started out, and I still want to know what the replacement is. Of course, I've had lots of conversations with folks who are like, well, where should we go? And we can talk about that. But I also would encourage organizations to remember that you probably are already in more places than just Twitter. You know, you, you probably do already have a LinkedIn page, or if not, pretty easy, because your employees probably have LinkedIn profiles and, you know, set up Some space there. And most importantly, out of all of this, again, you and I have talked about this, but I really wanna make clear in the midst of this kind of Twitter, what is social media anymore conversation, that you never owned any of that data. You never owned those pages. You never owned those profiles. You never got to control them. You do control your website. You do control your email list. Make sure that you are building up that list, that you are communicating with people directly in channels that you can directly message to, because that's no matter what happens, Twitter returns and is a place of utopia, you still won't own it, right? And you will own your list, and you will own your website, and making sure that you're, you're really thinking about spending your time and money and staff time in those places.

Tony MartignettiThat's really valuable, you know, basic but valuable reminder to cherish and build on what you do own. Yeah. Your site, your list. Yeah.

Gene TakagiI think there are, you know, some difficult equity considerations in Twitter's value as well. So beyond what the owner, who's also the only board member, That's a best practice,

Amy Sample Wardright, Gene?

Gene TakagiSpeaking of— So beyond him, there's the consideration of, well, where are the folks you are serving? Where are they at? Is there a virtual town square where they're at? Because many may be on Twitter and they may still be there, and for you to give them messaging, that might still be important. So I'm not I'm on— I'm still on Twitter and conflicted about it, but I don't want to be judgmental about charities that decide to stay on Twitter because that may be still a really important way for them to reach out to their audiences. And for the audiences, I don't want to be judgmental of them either because there are a lot of people who are not privileged to be able to access a lot of other technology and other platforms. They might, you know, find Twitter super easy, and, you know, that's what they have. And I'm not yet willing to say we're just gonna leave Twitter to become this, you know, white heterosexual male-dominated platform, and Elon and his bros can do whatever they want with that without any pushback from other, you know, perspectives. Yeah.

Amy Sample WardI hope, Tony, let's make a 2023 resolution that Gene and I get to do more shows together because it brings up such a good— just hearing you share that, Gene, and I agree with everything. As always, let the record reflect, I always agree with Gene and I am always doing legal activity. Is the version of this from a few years ago about Facebook, right? And there's some really unique And important differences between the, the Twitter options available, just like because of how the platform works versus Facebook. You know, Twitter is public by default. You don't have to have a Twitter account to go see what an organization had been tweeting about. Here's some information, or here, right? Versus Facebook, which is a very like within the world of Facebook. The data trail that that creates is very different, right? Organizations could say, Despite the hellscape, we're staying in Twitter and we are, to loop back to the previous conversation, an abortion fund. And we are gonna make sure that we are sharing information. No one has to interact, no one has to like ask us for it, but we're putting this information out right in a place where people maybe find it in a search. On Facebook, doing that or saying, here's our upcoming fundraiser to raise funds for abortion funds. Everyone who RSVPs for that event and has a Texas address has just created a data trail that is likely very problematic for them, right? And the organization maybe didn't even understand that's what was happening, right? So they are very different platforms, very different ethical dilemmas for sure. But what they mean for you as an organization staying there and what kinds of compromises you might be creating for already vulnerable communities are very

Tony MartignettiIf we, if we should decide to go elsewhere, uh, let's, let's talk about— and you, well, you mentioned, you know, you may want to put on Twitter that you can now find us on—

Amy Sample WardYeah.

Tony MartignettiWe're going to talk about Mastodon, and, uh, there's another one, Post. Um, but you may want to just alert folks that your activity has moved, you know, over. Or, or like you said, find us on LinkedIn, or, you know, we're very— we're still very active on Facebook, you know, Instagram, maybe, you know, maybe our channel, you know, whatever you want to. I think you want to let folks know what you've decided without just disappearing.

Amy Sample WardAnd, and yeah, and like, you probably should have those links on your website. So have updating your bio to say You know, visit our website and find the channel that works for you or something. You know, you don't have to, you don't have to write that farewell letter as your last tweet with every link to every site, right? But making sure that you do think about what a user is going to see if they do try to look you up and have the bio be updated or whatever. There, there are a lot of folks talking about Mastodon.

Tony MartignettiYeah,

Amy Sample Wardthese other platforms. I'm— I have accounts on them. You are welcome to find me. I'm not posting a bunch there or anything, but, um, you know me, I like to just see how tools develop. So I've had accounts on both of those. And, um,

Tony Martignettiyou're more— you're more altruistic than I am. You like to see how the pro— how the— how the, uh, the platform develops. I just want to grab the name Tony Martignetti Before, for somebody else who's been on my show. I've had Tony Martignetti, the other, another Tony Martignetti on my show. Um, he never had me on his show, come to think of it.

Amy Sample WardWell, there is as of today no other Amy Sample Ward, so—

Tony MartignettiRight, and there's only one Tony Martignetti, but, but I'm not posting, but I wanted to grab the, uh, grab the real estate. But I did it for more selfish reasons. You

Amy Sample Warddid it altruistically. I mean, I think that And as is true with a lot of social media platforms that have been financed by and developed by the privileged communities of tech development, that's who's mostly on those platforms already, right? Even though they're very different, Mastodon is, you know, kind of like, what's the open source values, whatever. I haven't seen a lot of that. Yeah. post trying to be more about like, what are you really thinking? And like content-focused. It's mostly screenshots of tweets, so it feels a little, a little, a little bit of whiplash. But I wouldn't say that it's bad if you are like Tony and you were like, but there's so many organizations with our acronym, like we want the handle. Go for it. Yeah. But don't go fill the account with content as if you are present there. Just, just sit on the, the handle, you know, because once you have a complete profile, well, now it looks like you are trying to post there and people don't know how to interact, right? Just—

Tony MartignettiYeah.

Amy Sample WardHold it, reserve it in your name, put the password in LastPass, you know, but, but don't, don't— like I've always said, NTEN doesn't have an account on these platforms, even though I just said that I do and a number of staff do, because You, you aren't gonna use an individual-first platform as an organization well if you haven't been an individual first to, to actually know how it works. Pretty good. What's the ins and outs of this tool? What are the norms? Mastodon works a little bit differently than folks may have experienced, where you are, in order to even create an account, you have to pick kind What, what server you want to be associated with. That changes what name, it changes your default kind of newsfeed. So there are a lot of things that you aren't going to know out of the box for your organizational profile. You're going to need to play with it. And they're— all these tools are developing a lot faster as they see hundreds of thousands of new users, you know. And I think, again, back to the values point, They are also experiencing the challenges of lots of users, right? Post said that it only took 6 days before they had to take swastikas down. So what is it? What are the platforms doing? What are the values there? How are they moderating or managing content safety users before you say, oh yeah, let's have our organization profile there?

Tony MartignettiI did see A nonprofit power user and very popular person, of course, Beth Kanter. She's active on Mastodon. She didn't just— she didn't just take an account, but she's actively moved there, posting lists of other nonprofit folks to follow that, you know, that she follows. So that another— another drop, another name, Jay Frost. I see he's there. Yeah.

Amy Sample WardYeah.

Tony MartignettiUm, so I mean, that's just, that's just 2 people, uh, but Beth in particular happens to have many hundreds of thousands of followers, right, or had on, on Twitter. Um, so it's pretty monumental decision to, to leave that kind of, uh, um, that kind of largeness and, and go to something where, you know, you're now, you're now You now have zero followers on, on day one. So that's a significant decision.

Amy Sample WardYes.

Tony MartignettiUm, so I, I've seen— and there's some other folks too, but those, those, those are the ones that come to mind that, that have made the move there and, and are active and actively encouraging others to come.

Amy Sample WardYeah, yeah.

Tony MartignettiAll right.

Amy Sample WardYou know, and I, and I think, not to put Gene on the spot, I know this isn't what you were prepared to, to talk about, but I think we saw this with Facebook. And, you know, Facebook had its own rules about how they would kind of pursue this. But these new, these new platforms will have to have their rules too. And that is organizations who don't necessarily have a registered trademark but are very clearly like the United Way of Portland or something, you know, and then somebody went on there and created that account already, right, and is trying to sit on it. Twitter has experienced, you know, People sitting on accounts and then people needing to have access to them and saying, that's actually my name or my organization's name, or, you know, people that sit on the URLs of like World War III. Oh, now there is one. We need that URL, you know, whatever. So that will— there will have to be a course, whatever that course may be, for resolution on that. I also, I just don't want people leaving the conversation feeling like They need to spend the next 2 hours finding these platforms, requesting an account, and trying to sit on their organization's name themselves. Like, if you want to, you can, but don't feel— that's not the takeaway here.

Tony MartignettiYeah, don't do it. Don't do what Tony Martignetti did.

Amy Sample WardOr just don't feel obligated that you have to.

Tony MartignettiYeah,

Gene TakagiI'm sitting on a Post account, Tony, and I'm active on Mastodon. As well. So yeah, I think it's going to be a tricky thing. But for organizations, if you do find somebody using your name, you may want to bring it up and challenge that use. Talk to a lawyer about that, especially if they're putting anything in that misrepresents your organization. If they're acting like they're spoofing your organization and putting out some content that's not true or bad for you, make sure you put a stop to that.

Tony MartignettiI guess there are people who would do that and just hope to make some money at it. Like,

Amy Sample Wardthere's definitely money to be made.

Tony MartignettiI mean, if I get

Amy Sample Wardaccounts, you

Tony Martignettiknow, if I get like Ford Motor Company or Tesla or something, you know, I'll be happy to sell it to you for $150,000, or, well, $1.5 million seems to be my price.

Amy Sample WardSo, I mean, we see that with URLs already, right? People just buy lots of URLs waiting for somebody create a product called like the Oreo Slushie. Great, now we invented it. We need to buy that URL from you, you know.

Tony MartignettiAll right.

Amy Sample WardWe're all in the wrong business. Let's just go buy a bunch of URLs instead.

Tony MartignettiNo, it's

Amy Sample Wardnot.

Tony MartignettiAll right, um, Amy, anything more we should talk about Mastodon? Oh, I did want to just clarify for folks because you mentioned Mastodon, you have to select a server. It's really just, to me, it's a community.

Amy Sample WardSure.

Tony MartignettiBut there are only about 10 of them. It's not like there's a knitting community and a rock climbing and a soccer, you know, it's not like that. Not yet. Right.

Amy Sample WardBut I don't wanna use the word community and have folks get to that first page and see the word server and have no idea where the word, you know. Right. But yes, you're right. You are kind of choosing the space that's your entry point into the world of Mastodon.

Tony MartignettiAnd there is one with a social good label to it.

Amy Sample WardYes.

Tony MartignettiSo like, so Beth Kanter is @bethkanter.socialgoodsomething. Yes. It's like you said, it affects your, your name, affects your screen name, your, your handle, your ID. Yeah, yeah, yeah.

Amy Sample WardUm, I— the, the only last thing that I'll add in our final minutes here is a very long time ago, people have been like OG listeners. Um, you know, we used to say Well, how would you know what social channels your users are on? And, you know, I've talked about having in your own website for your user profiles, or in donation forms, wherever you might be getting feedback from folks, not that they have to put their URL in, but just a checkbox like, oh yeah, we do. I have a Facebook account, and an Instagram account, and a whatever, you know, whatever it might be. Make this as an opportunity to go check those lists. And say, maybe we should add Mastodon, or maybe we should add Post, or we should update what options we're actually providing so that you could notice, oh, there are a lot more people now here. Maybe it's worth us looking at that platform, right? So if you're doing some year-end data cleaning, look at your, at your profile forms or your feedback forms where you might say what tool, you know, what other channels are you on, and add some more of these. Yeah.

Tony MartignettiAmy Sample Ward, CEO of NTEN. For the time being, she's at— they are @AmyRSWard. And Gene Takagi, principal attorney at the NEO Nonprofit and Exempt Organizations Law Group. For the time being, @GTAC, but also you'll find him on Mastodon and Post. Hey, Tony. Amy, thank you. Gene, thank you very much.

Amy Sample WardThanks so much, Tony. I really do want to do shows together with Gene.

Tony MartignettiNo, I concur. Yes, that's, uh, I think that's a good idea. Well, let's, uh, make sure we do another couple of these this year.

Amy Sample WardPerfect.

Tony MartignettiAll right. And again, Happy New Year. Next week, Erica Mills Barnhart on common communications conundrums. If you missed any part of this week's show, I beseech you, Find it at TonyMartignetti.com. Our creative producer is Claire Meyerhoff. Show social media is by Susan Chavez. Mark Silverman is our web guy, and this music is by Scott Stein. Thank you for that affirmation, Scotty. Be with me next week for Nonprofit Radio: Big Nonprofit Ideas for the Other 95%. Go out and be. Be great.

Nonprofit Radio