Align Your Money With Your Goals


About this episode
There’s a dimension to your budgeting you might be missing: Organizing your budget so you know what impact your money is achieving for you, and you know the costs connected to your goals. Sarah Olivieri returns to help you course correct. She’s the founder of PivotGround.
Here’s the transcript
Tony MartignettiHello and welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. I'm your aptly named host of your favorite hebdomadal podcast. We have a listener of the week, Cheryl McCormick. She's CEO of Athens Area Humane Society in Athens, Georgia. Cheryl is a longtime fan, many, many year fan of Nonprofit Radio. She blogged about the, the podcast once, putting it in her top 5. That was years ago. She's been listening a long time. She was in my Planned Giving Accelerator class, the very first one. In fact, she was the first person to sign up for the very first class. And we finally met in Atlanta, Georgia, just a couple weeks ago. And she was so gracious. She took her afternoon off to meet with me, and we spent hours getting to know each other even better, catching up, learning more. It was just a real pleasure to meet this Nonprofit Radio superfan for many, many years. So Cheryl McCormick, Thank you. Thanks for taking all that time to to to see me. You're our listener of the week. Also, happy Halloween! Now that's a week late. I need an intern to blame because I didn't realize that. I mean, I knew Halloween was coming up, but when I was doing the show, I just didn't realize it was going to be published on Halloween Day, the thirty, you know, obviously thirty first. So. You know, I— you're stuck with a lackluster host. What can I say? I hope you enjoyed your Halloween. Well, I'll leave it with that. I'm doing the best I can without an intern to blame. Hope you enjoyed your Halloween. And I'm glad you're with me because I'd be thrown into arteralgia if you inflamed me with the painful idea that you missed this week's show. Align your money with your goals. There's a dimension to your budgeting you might be missing— organizing your budget so you know what impact your money is achieving for you, and you know the costs connected to your goals. Sarah Olivieri returns to help you course correct. She's the founder of PivotGround. On Tony's Take Two, does this show sound better? We're sponsored by Turn 2 Communications, PR and content for nonprofits. Your story is their mission. turn-2.co. It's a genuine pleasure to welcome back Sarah Olivieri. She has over 18 years of nonprofit leadership experience. She was co-founder of the Open Center for Autism, executive director of the Helping Children of War Foundation, And co-author of Lesson Plan à la Carte: Integrated Planning for Students with Special Needs. As the founder and heart behind PivotGround, Sarah helps nonprofits become financially sustainable world changers. Her company is @PivotGround and at pivotground.com. Sarah, welcome back to Nonprofit Radio.
Sarah OlivieriHey, Tony, it's so great to be here.
Tony MartignettiIt's a pleasure to have you. Thank you very much. And, uh, and thank you for sitting through that longer than usual, uh, intro to the show. I, I, I had to shout out our listener of the week, Cheryl, and then I had to explain why I didn't say Happy Halloween next week— so last week. So thank you for sitting through that. Thanks for sitting through that.
Sarah OlivieriNo problem.
Tony MartignettiNow, you know, I pronounced your name Olivieri.
Sarah OlivieriYou got it.
Tony MartignettiBut do you just say Olivieri?
Sarah OlivieriNo, no, Olivieri. You have it right.
Tony MartignettiOh, wonderful. Thank you.
Sarah OlivieriJust lean into the Italian sound. People think I'm Italian because I kind of have a little bit of that look, but it's actually from the Jewish side of my family. Um, but you know, I'm an honorary Italian with an Italian last name.
Tony MartignettiAbsolutely. And you want to, you want to get every vowel sound in there. So thanks for— thank you for not doing Olivieri.
Sarah OlivieriYou're welcome.
Tony MartignettiLike O-L-I-V-E-I or so. No. You got to get the Olivieri.
Sarah OlivieriOkay, Olivieri.
Tony MartignettiOlivieri. Sarah Olivieri. Yeah, well, the Sarah kind of— I was wondering, Sarah, that doesn't sound Italian. Sounds not really, but I understand. All right, so you got 2 great ones, uh, Jewish and Italian. I, I'm often confused for Jewish people. People— I, I have a look that folks think, uh, is a Jewish look, so I don't mind. We're all suffering under our mothers. That's what it's all We all, we all have the guilt from, uh, from mothers. So Jewish or Italian, we share, we have that, we have that bond. Uh, but let's not, let's not talk about, uh, oppressive mothering. Let's talk about, uh, organizing your budget. Organizing your budget so you know what your money is doing for you so that you're aligned with your goals. What, let's see, high level, what could we be doing better?
Sarah OlivieriYeah, well, first of all, So many nonprofit leaders are not like money people. They don't have MBAs. They're not like— and their budgets scare them. So if you're listening now and you're like, ah, budgets, like, please no, I want you to know that we can make budgeting fun because high level, your budget is like your financial strategy, right? It's a map that tells you how your money can work and how well it is working, right? So if you like things like having more money next year than you have this year, and if you like things like having incredible financial data to tell these amazing stories about the impact you are making and the impact you could be making—
Tony MartignettiYes.
Sarah OlivieriIf you like to have money to pay your staff an equitable, you know, fair market value so that they're not overworked and run down and living in poverty themselves. A budget, not just any budget, is your very, very best friend because it's the thing that if you know how to arrange it will unlock the answers to how you get most of those things. Unfortunately, most people's budgets are not telling them those answers right now. And so hopefully we'll be able to demystify that a bit today.
Tony MartignettiWe absolutely will. Yes, we're gonna, we're gonna achieve that hope. All right, so I should have called this Budget Is Your Friendly Fun— Budget Is Your— Budget Is Fun and Friendly.
Sarah OlivieriYes,
Tony Martignettiright? Love your budget. All right, all right. Love your budget. Love your budget. I love how you're— we're going to demystify and, uh, be upbeat about something that could be very, uh, dull if we're not doing it right. So, but I can tell that you're doing it right. You're— you have an infectious enthusiasm around budgeting. Okay, um, where should we start? Should we need to start with vocabulary, or is that—
Sarah OlivieriYeah, I think a teeny bit of vocabulary just to make sure that nobody's kind of getting lost in the weeds, because whenever we talk about budgets, we're starting to bring in a little bit of financial vocabulary, and, um, I don't want any to be lost if we're using that language or if you hear it, right? So,
Tony Martignettium, okay. Yes, plus we have jargon jail.
Sarah OlivieriRight, we don't want to be in jargon jail.
Tony MartignettiI would hate for you to be in jargon jail when you say, you know, net profit or something. Okay.
Sarah OlivieriThat's right. And you know what I want to tell everybody who is ever nervous about budgeting vocabulary is that different people use it in different ways. So my number one tip when it comes to vocabulary, actually what you write in your budget, is define what you mean in the budget because one person's gross is not someone else's gross. And these terms, you know, so you're like, oh, what's gross, right? What's net, right? It's not the same for everybody. And you might find yourself in a disagreement about these terms, um, and you could both be right and both be wrong. So, um, I just encourage you to like really eliminate the jargon and just describe what you're talking about.
Tony MartignettiDefine it, like define it in a footnote or something like that.
Sarah OlivieriDefine it right in the line item. Okay, right, just put it right in the line item. So, um, so first of all, most— a lot of the numbers in the budget are either money-in numbers or money-out numbers, right? So there, now we've eliminated all the jargon, right? Either it's money coming into the bank or it's money going out of the bank. And then we have another set of numbers which are called assets. Got it. And that means assets is the amount of money that you have kind of stored away, right? That it was already put in and stayed in, or things that are worth money. Right? So if you have property that could be turned into money, stocks that could be turned into money, right? All those things are worth money. And so if it's worth money or is money just sitting around, that's your assets. Back to the money in, money out, right? Go ahead. Money in, we have some terms like revenue, gross revenue, net revenue. These are all ways of talking about our money coming in. And usually money going out is a little easier because we talk about expenses typically, and there aren't as many words that we throw around to describe expenses. And then the last kind of category that I'm just going to call measures for today, these are the most important numbers that are usually missing from most budgets. These are the things like percentages in your budget that tell you how the money is working. And that's where the secret is. And luckily for you is most of these numbers, So, smaller numbers are easy for our brains to like look at and think about. And so, looking at percentages, telling this story about how our money is working is really, really important. And we can talk later about what some of those are.
Tony MartignettiOkay. In fact, if the percentages equal more than 100, then we have a problem.
Sarah OlivieriYes, definitely.
Tony MartignettiWe can't have more than 100% of our assets or our expenses. Okay. So, let's talk about percentages. All right. So do we need to distinguish between revenue and gross revenue? You mentioned those 2.
Sarah OlivieriYeah. So at the end of the day, so you're always going to look at all the money coming in in a budget. That's usually what we call top-line revenue because they're usually at the top line of the budget, right? So you want to be thinking about the total amount of money coming in. And then you also want to be thinking about kind of breaking down where the money starts to go out and then how much is left over. So gross and net are terms that describe how much is left over after certain kinds of expenses come out. So what I want to know is what's my top-line revenue, and then after I've paid for my programs, and especially like money that I wouldn't have to spend if I didn't have that program. So I want to know how much is left over after I paid my program expenses. And then I usually want to also know what's left over if I not only paid my program expenses, but also paid my staffing programmatic expenses. Like, how much is left over after that, right?
Tony MartignettiRight, just staff program expenses.
Sarah OlivieriSo all the program expenses and the staffing expenses of the program.
Tony MartignettiStaffing expenses of program, but not staffing of other functions.
Sarah OlivieriNot staffing of other functions.
Tony MartignettiRight, we're not there yet, okay.
Sarah OlivieriAnd then I get this number, some accountants call it contribution margin. A lot of people have never heard that, but basically it almost sounds like—
Tony MartignettiI'm gonna— contribution margin, Anybody says that, I'm putting them in jargon jail.
Sarah OlivieriRight, you're like, jargon jail, right? So, but, but what we're talking about is how much money is left over after everything came in and you paid for all of your programs. How much money is then contributed to the general operating expenses, which you will never ever hear me call overhead. I call them operations. And the language we use in budgeting really matters, right? And we all have heard, but just in case somebody missed it, right? Overhead is a good thing, and the reason is because overhead is operations, and operations are critical to operating, right? No operations, no operating.
Tony MartignettiIt's also investment in potentially future—
Sarah Olivieriyes,
Tony Martignettiessentially future work. Maybe you're reserving for a, for a future ambition, for a future purchase. Maybe you're reserving. So these are all, you know, Yes, it's, it's, it's, it's absolutely operational, but I also see as investment for the future.
Sarah OlivieriAbsolutely.
Tony MartignettiAnd that's essential to your sustainability, for God's sake. So if people on your board are complaining that you have a reserve for something, you know, ask them, well, don't you reserve for future, for future, future recessions? Don't you reserve for future investments and expenditures in, in new markets? So Please, sir, you know, be quiet.
Sarah OlivieriYes, you should have a reserve. And when you get to the very, very bottom, what people sometimes call the bottom line, at some point you're gonna have a number that if you are a for-profit business, you might label it profit, profit margin. Margin, when we hear that word margin, I don't want you to be scared. It just means how much is left after something else was taken out, right? That's all margin is, right? It means we had money in and we took some money out, and then we wanted to know how much pie was left, right? Do we have one slice left?
Tony MartignettiGive an example of something margin. Flesh that out, please.
Sarah OlivieriSure. So we just talked about contribution margin, right? That's how much money is left after we took out program expenses and program labor, right? So if we take out all of our expenses, program expenses, labor expenses, operating expenses, everything, what's left at the bottom is also our margin. Some people call that net, but some people put net somewhere else. That's just the total amount of money that's left over after all of our expenses. Now, we need that money. And I want to reframe the way we think about that bottom line, because people get like really focused on that bottom line. Obviously, you, you don't want to be leaking money every year, year after year. However, it is okay to have less than nothing left over 1 or 2 years if you spent that money. Right. To invest in something that's going to bring in more money in the future, right? Not everything pays off in one year, right?
Tony MartignettiNew staff, right?
Sarah OlivieriNew staff or building a fundraising department, right? So if you don't have a fundraising department—
Tony MartignettiThe people.
Sarah OlivieriRight. The people. So some people are making money, some people aren't. So then at the very bottom, I want you to realize that, you know, kind of a rule of thumb I use is if the money left over needs to be at least equal to inflation, which on average is 3%. So if you don't have 3%, and what do we have to define our terms? I'm always telling people define their terms. So this is where we get into those measures, right? So percentage is the amount of money that's left over, our margin, right at the very bottom.
Tony MartignettiYes.
Sarah OlivieriAnd what percentage of that, of the total revenue that came in, right? So if total revenue came in was $100,000, Right? We want it, and we have $10 left. What percentage, you know, is $10 of, you know, $100 or $100,000, whatever? So, and you know what, you don't have to know how to do the math because any spreadsheet will do it for you. And I have a template that we can give away where the formulas are already in there. So, um, So, but that way we, we want that bottom, bottom number to always be at least 3%. 3% is the new zero.
Tony MartignettiIt's time for a break. Turn to communications. They sent their biweekly e-newsletter, On Message, this week, and it had something that I think is interesting. It's called 3 Under-the-Radar Targets for Your PR Pitches, and the 3 that they suggest are association publications, trade and professional associations, Eager to hear about news regarding one of their members or latest advancements in the field. Alumni publications and hometown newspapers. If your pitch is mostly about an individual, consider sending it to alma mater publications and hometown newspapers. And the third is e-newsletters. They say you likely have a few of these in your email inbox right now, like Morning Brew, Good Good Good, and The Skimm. These folks publish daily and offer the opportunity to get your news delivered to lots of loyal readers. And they make the point that, you know, this is not the New York Times or the Washington Post or even the Chronicle of Philanthropy, but you'll get some coverage. Right. You'll get some exposure and you can use the content, repurpose it on your social channels. So link to it that way also and maybe on your blog as well. So it's some coverage, right? I mean, it's not the end-all, be-all, but it's 3 things that sort of are, as they say, under the radar. And that is turn 2 communications. Clearly, your story is their mission. Turn-to.co. Now back to align your money with your goals. Folks, in our high inflation period right now that we're living in 2022,
Sarah Olivieriyeah,
Tony Martignettifolks may ask, well, should it be higher now? Should it be 8 or 9%, or should it just be sticking with like 3 to 4 because that's the average over over a long term and you don't have to worry about an annual fluctuation up or down. How should that be?
Sarah OlivieriSo I think, you know, you can go either way. Certainly if we're going to have high inflation for a while, I'd be wanting more money left over, right? But overall, I want you to be trying to not have zero, right? You, if you have, so 3% is the new zero. That means you're just treading water. You want to be, or, you know, if we're at 5% inflation, you just, and you're at 5%, you're just treading water. So you really want to be probably, and it will vary per organization, I would want to be at least 10 to 15%. So that means I now have money to invest in next year. Right? So if I want more money next year than this year, I have to increase my operations around how I raise money, which means I have to put money into the money-making machine so that it can make more money. Right? Your fundraising function is a money-making machine. Right. And the fuel is money. You put money into the machine, you put a dollar in and you get $1.25 out or $1.50 out, or maybe it's even better, you get $2 out, right? But if you don't feed the money-making machine money so that there are people to run it and materials and all the stuff you do to fundraise, you won't have more money than next year.
Tony MartignettiAll right. All right. Now, some folks are going to say, so I just have to get this little thing out. So you want— so you want us, rather than treading water, you want us to be doing a strong breaststroke?
Sarah OlivieriYes, right? Doesn't that sound better?
Tony MartignettiI just felt like extending your metaphor. Yes, that's right.
Sarah OlivieriOr even go for the butterfly if you feel like it.
Tony MartignettiOh, you could do the butterfly. That would be— that would be outstanding. Now some folks will say, well, but the, the, the, the only way to— well, there's— there are 2 ways to increase your margin At the end of the year, either increase revenue through feeding the fundraising machine or cut expenses.
Sarah OlivieriYeah.
Tony MartignettiBut now if you start getting into cutting expenses, what do you— you know, are we just cutting paper clips or are we cutting staff, which could be very detrimental?
Sarah OlivieriYeah.
Tony MartignettiCutting back on properties where we have outreach, you know, that could be very detrimental. So I just put words in your mouth. So— No, no.
Sarah OlivieriSo I, I like to take all of my expenses And kind of mark them in my budget according to 3 categories. I like to be silly. I use 3 icons. I use a heart icon, which means this expense is creating an impact. I use a money bag icon to say this expense is generating money, right? And then I use a picture of a toilet bowl to say this money just goes out the door and it doesn't make impact or money, right? And some things make impact and money, and we want a lot of those. If you have an organization that all of your expenses are making impact and money, you're probably very, very healthy financially. So all the ones with the—
Tony MartignettiThat would be a money bag that's heart-shaped.
Sarah OlivieriThat's right. Or you can put 2 icons in the one, you know, in line. Now, if you start labeling the money bag line items as your revenue-generating expenses, if you want more money next year or the year after or tomorrow, You need to increase your revenue-generating expenses. If you decrease your revenue-generating expenses, what's going to happen?
Tony MartignettiDecrease your revenue.
Sarah OlivieriLess revenue. Right? So I think, and once the, those words are so powerful because watch somebody try to cut a revenue-generating expense once it's labeled like that. Right? They're not going to do it. Now all of a sudden it makes perfect sense. And I saw this mistake happen at the beginning of the pandemic. I'll never forget the first time I sent out an email to my list at the beginning of the pandemic. I got back all of these autoresponder emails of people who were gone because they had been fired. So many nonprofits cut their fundraising staff.
Tony MartignettiYeah, I remember.
Sarah OlivieriYeah. That's like cutting off your own feet, right? You need to increase. And as True with many, many disasters. You know, it turned out the pandemic was actually quite a good time for fundraising. All of my clients did better financially, not worse, and they were investing in revenue-generating expenses in a time when they were going to need more revenue.
Tony MartignettiYeah, it was a short time— it was a short-term panic, uh, and unfortunately there are organizations that— well, and For-profit as well, corporate as well, that reacted panic-wise, you know, knee-jerk. And, and that, I think, in the, in the medium to long term, that hurt all those, all those who did that. Yeah. All right.
Sarah OlivieriRough times. Well, let's get back to fun things like budgets. So here's a big tip when it comes to layout, right?
Tony MartignettiYour fun friend, remember that.
Sarah OlivieriMy fun friend, budget.
Tony MartignettiYeah, not a mere friend. This is one of your fun friends. Okay.
Sarah OlivieriYeah.
Tony MartignettiUm, yes, we're back to budget. All right.
Sarah OlivieriSo maybe I'll just— a little PSA, a little budget advocacy to take us into happy times is I want your budget to be for you, right? The IRS has a version of your numbers that they want to see, and if you get grants, foundations may have a version of a budget that they want to see, but First and foremost, I want you to feel that your budget, the way it's laid out, is a tool for you, the nonprofit leader, right? That's what it's there for. This isn't just something we need to throw to other people. And yeah, you can have somebody rewrite it so it satisfies somebody else, but I want you to really love it as the tool for you and lay it out the way it starts to tell you a story.
Tony MartignettiAll right, PSA for budgeting.
Sarah OlivieriThat's right.
Tony MartignettiYay, love your budget. Yes, PSA. Budgets, budgets are Budgets are people too.
Sarah OlivieriThat's right. So one of the ways I like to get my budget telling a better story that I don't see anybody doing, and it's so simple, is I like to take all of my fundraising revenue and expenses, because your fundraising function is kind of like a business inside a business, right? And I like to move it to the very, very bottom of my spreadsheet. So I have revenue that comes from programs at the top, and then I take out the expenses from the programs, and then I take out the operating expenses, and then I get the true cost without fundraising of my nonprofit. And it might— it very well may be negative. It kind of depends if it's appropriate for your nonprofit to be generating funds from its services. I do, by the way, count restricted grants that are for a specific program as program revenue, right? Because if you didn't have the program, you wouldn't have that revenue. That's how I kind of divide the line. And then, so I get this, this is the true cost. So my nonprofit is negative $200,000 to run all of our programs, right? So we now know, now we have our true fundraising goal. Our true fundraising goal is, you know, $200,000 plus 3%.
Tony MartignettiMinimum. Yeah, well, right, minimum.
Sarah OlivieriMinimum, right? And now, because have you ever been in front of a budget I bet you've seen this, Tony, where like, you know, you've seen various versions and they're just kind of like monkeying with the fundraising numbers at the top. It's like a game to make the bottom number go zero, right? Like, it's not necessarily based in reality. I've seen that happen on lots of boards, you know, budgets being presented to boards. So now we have the true, you know, fundraising goal and the true cost of running our nonprofit. Without fundraising. And then I have this little section where I have fundraising money in, revenue you could call it if you want, but we have the amount of fundraising money coming in. This is unrestricted money and the amount of money going out, right? So what is our fundraising staffing costs? What are our marketing expenses, communication expenses all around fundraising? And then I see how much is left over, right? My fundraising margin, if you will, right? This is so— this is Do I have $200,000 coming out to match my bottom line? Or let's say if we have $200,000 at the bottom, we want $300,000 out of fundraising. So now I know if it's going to be enough, right? And what do I do if I want more fundraising money? I got to put—
Tony MartignettiYou got to feed the machine.
Sarah OlivieriYou got to feed the machine. You got to put dollars in the machine. And then I also, there's, this is where those measures come in. And it's harder to talk about these over the radio, but That to $300,000 out, I want to make sure that that's a healthy percentage of how much I put into the machine, right? So I want to know, is my machine working well, right? Do I put a dollar in and get a dollar out, or do I put a dollar in and get 50 cents out? Now, the truth is, unfortunately, people measure this in different ways. So there isn't like, you know, an industry norm that's really well calculated for you to assess on. But certainly, If you're putting a dollar in and getting a dollar out, you're not fundraising, right? That's zero. That's a total sum of zero. Right. But what I really want you to watch then is year over year or even month over month, is that percentage increasing? So maybe I put a dollar in last year and I got $1.50 out. And then this year I put a dollar in and I got $1.75. $0.75 out. And then next year I put $1 in and I got $2 out, right? So double your money is always pretty good. I like to benchmark against some other things like what's the average return on investment, right? There's another jargon term, right? Just means return is how much money comes out of the machine, right? So your return is, I put $1 in and my return is $2 out. So I compare that to the stock market. You know, would we be better off just putting money in the stock market on average? Compared to our fundraising department? Can they beat the average? I'd say they should be able to beat the average. Otherwise, just don't have a fundraising department and invest in the stock market, right? So you can kind of benchmark around some other things, but really you want to be investing in and making a healthier and healthier money-making machine. And that percentage says how healthy you are.
Tony MartignettiAnd if the margin is not where you want it to be, I mean, there are other reasons to have fundraising outreach.
Sarah OlivieriSure.
Tony MartignettiBuilding long-term relationships with corporate funders, individual donors, ultimately hopefully leading to planned gifts. So there are, there are reasons why, as you had said earlier, in the, in the short term, your margin may be negative on fundraising. You're, you're working to turn that around as relationships grow. Whether institutional or individual, uh, as maybe events grow. Hopefully you're not too event dependent.
Sarah OlivieriBut if you measure those events, probably their margin is, you know, their percentage is probably much lower than your other activities.
Tony MartignettiYeah, it gets hard. Events get hard to measure. Then you, you should be measuring the staff time that goes into the events. And
Sarah Olivieriabsolutely,
Tony Martignettithat's where, you know, your bake sale type events are not Not sustainable, uh, not certainly not going to sustain your nonprofit. Um,
Sarah Olivieriyou know,
Tony Martignettiand I think— okay, so just, you know, I just wanted to flesh out a little bit what you said. You know, you may as well be, be in the stock market if your, if your fundraising margin is zero, but you're building towards something.
Sarah OlivieriYes, absolutely.
Tony MartignettiMuch, much more robust than you're, you're working with now in the, in the immediate term. Okay.
Sarah OlivieriAnd probably you can make your fundraising department work way better than the stock market, especially in the long term. And that goes back to your budget being for you. It does not have to just be an annual budget. In fact, I always encourage organizations to be looking at least 3 years into the future, right? Like, real life doesn't function on the calendar year, right? Like, real life things develop over time, and they don't have to fit into that 12-month box. That's for the IRS, right? But your real budget should really consider, like, when is a reasonable expectation for us to be seeing that money coming back? When we, you know, it takes the— you put the money in the machine, it's not instantaneous. And some things like, you know, you used to do planned giving, right? Planned giving has a really long timeline. You put the money in the machine. Yeah. And it might take years. It might take 10 years, 20 years, but you could put a dollar in and get like $200,000 out, right? Like, absolutely huge.
Tony MartignettiMillions. Yes, absolutely. Um, let— I, I want to get to connecting your, your, your— connecting your goals to you, to your budget, but, but I want to make sure, is there anything else that we should talk about around You know, organizing the budget and seeing the impact of your money before we get, you know, specifically to goals?
Sarah OlivieriYeah, I think just that, you know, just like we talked about, right, that, that percentage margin, right, that's the, the percentage of money that's left over compared to how much came in, is a number you can use over and over in your budget. That's the number that tells you how well is this working, right? So if you want to know, you know, maybe you have 3 programs and you want to know, you know, How good is each program at making money, right? And they don't all have to make money because we're primarily trying to make an impact. But you can then take, say, how much money, you know, does this program bring in and subtract all the program expenses, including the people, and then say what percentage of the money left over compared to the money that it brought in, right? And then you can say, okay, out of these 3 programs, Program A is great at making money. Program B is so-so at making money. And Program D just eats money. It doesn't bring in any money. It's always in the negative, but that's okay. And then like what we're about to talk about measurement, but we might then say, well, Program A is good at making money and it's good at making an impact. So let's do a lot more of Program A.
Tony MartignettiYeah.
Sarah OlivieriProgram B is so-so at making money. And you know what? It's also so-so at making an impact. Maybe we should Consider getting rid of it, right? If it's not really doing either. And Program D, maybe it's gushing money, but it makes such a big impact. You're like, this is totally worth it for the impact, and we can make up the difference with our fundraising.
Tony MartignettiWhy do you go A, B, D?
Sarah OlivieriOh, I don't know. A, B, C. I'm getting over from COVID I may still have a little brain fog, right? You know.
Tony MartignettiAll right, so you remember, all right, so that's because you're a numbers person. Not a, not a letters person. Not alphabet. The alphabet, we'll work on, work on the ABCs in another, in the next show.
Sarah OlivieriAll right.
Tony MartignettiOkay, let's connect all this to our goals.
Sarah OlivieriYeah,
Tony Martignettibecause that, it seems to me that's something that you, you seem to emphasize, that folks are not, not aligning the two. Your budgeting with your, your costs with your goals.
Sarah OlivieriYeah, so one is like You know, if you can measure your money and how well you're making money, right? Where are you able to make money either in programs or through fundraising? You can line that up now, right? Do you want to expand a program, right? So that's a common goal, right? We want to expand Program D, my favorite, or maybe Program C, right?
Tony MartignettiYeah, bring C back. Bring back C.
Sarah OlivieriLet's bring C back. So Program C, we love Program C. It's helped 400 people this year and we really want it to be helping more like 4,000 people by in the next 3 years, right? So we want to expand that. So in order to expand that, we need to, you know, how much money are we going to need to expand it, right? And it always costs more to grow than to maintain, right? So if we're expanding, I'm always thinking extra money, extra money, not just the cost to run it. Of course. And then we can say, okay, how do we, you know, is this going to generate money as it goes to fund itself, its own expansion, or do we need to sign Simultaneously be boosting up, you know, improving the fundraising machine so that it can fund this expansion. So now you have kind of— you've connected the finances to the goal, and you can start to make decisions like, okay, I don't just need to— right? If you just said, oh, I'm gonna write a grant and pay for the expansion of this program, well, that always sends off red flags for me because I'm like, that program If it— I need to know first, if it's not going to pay for itself 100% and its own growth, then I'm going to get the grant, I'm going to launch the program, and then the grant's going to end and the program's going to be in trouble, right? So I know that while the grant might be icing on the cake, I really need to invest in boosting up my fundraising machine, making it more effective, efficient, feeding it more money. I need to be putting money in there so that I can now expand and have another program. So every time— I like to call them mission pie, right? Those are your programs and your money pie. That's your money machine. So every time you want to make more mission pie, you probably also have to grow your money pie capabilities. And so a lot of people don't do that. And then we get like huge programmatic operating costs. And we don't grow our fundraising capabilities simultaneously. So that's one example.
Tony MartignettiIt's time for Tony's Take Two. I think this week's show sounds better. Am I in both of your ears this week instead of only your left ear, or both speakers if you're on your desktop instead of only your left speaker? Pretty sure that I am. And I am sorry about the past many weeks. In August, I upgraded Audacity, which is the program that I use for post-production, like adding intro and outro and these Tony's Take Twos and sponsor messages and cheap red wine. Of course, you gotta, you gotta add cheap red wine, right? That all, that all gets added at the end, uh, later on in post-production so that I'm not interrupting what I hope is a valuable conversation with guests, right? No interruptions. I add the stuff later. And something changed in the new version after I upgraded Audacity. I knew what was wrong. I knew it didn't sound right, but I couldn't figure out what the problem was. And then finally I researched and I, I Duh. Experimented, and I did find the problem. So now the music is in both ears, the talk is in both ears, and the problem is fixed. And now things are back to normal. Uh, it had been quite annoying, I know, to listen in one ear, but those days are over. We're, we're, uh, we're now in November. And the technology— well, the technology hasn't advanced. The user has caught up with the technology. That's what's happened. So that was annoying as shit as I was listening to it, and I was frustrated, but the frustration is in the past. Brighter days now, starting in November. That is Tony's Take Two. We've got beaucoup But loads more time for Align Your Money with Your Goals with Sarah Olivieri. Share another.
Sarah OlivieriAnother is around, yeah, around how we tell our donors and ourselves how good of an impact we make and whether or not it's the best way to do it, right? So this is where you're in your budget and in the template I have, it's fully laid out like this. You want to have kind of a separate tab Hold on, let me stop you.
Tony MartignettiLet's make sure we get this out. Where, where can listeners find the template?
Sarah OlivieriWe will— let me see if I can tell you the link right now. Um,
Tony Martignettiis it at pivotground.com?
Sarah OlivieriIt's at pivotground.com. And I may have—
Tony MartignettiYou just click resources or something like that?
Sarah OlivieriYeah, if you click, um, free resources from the home page, if you're following along, um, and There are, um, a few places we can— that you'll see have several resources.
Tony MartignettiThat's good. Okay, what's the template called that we—
Sarah OlivieriThe template is the Ultimate Nonprofit Budget.
Tony MartignettiThe Ultimate Nonprofit Budget. It's at pivotground.com and click on free resources.
Sarah OlivieriYep.
Tony MartignettiOkay, we needed that. We need that little parenthetical. Okay, please, please continue. I want to make sure folks can find this. Okay.
Sarah OlivieriRight, so let's say, you know, Let's deal with Program C again. We'll give it some more love. Yeah. And we've started to measure its impact, right? And this is tricky, right? There is not a direct correlation oftentimes, especially in human services measuring impact. We're kind of triangulating. It's not like, oh, X number of people served. Well, how well did you serve them, right? Was this like a life-changing service or was this like a you're not homeless last night kind of service, right? But however way you can measure it, and you can measure it in multiple ways, how many people you served in a day, in a week, right? You can now then take those program costs and say, you know, divide them by how many people you served and find out how much it costs to serve one person. And the math is all in the template, so I don't want people to get like nervous about math, but—
Tony MartignettiOkay.
Sarah OlivieriThere's lots of examples. So, um, now we know—
Tony MartignettiFolks may be, uh, maybe a little uncomfortable with math, but they definitely have their alphabet down.
Sarah OlivieriThat's right, which I clearly— I'm good with the math, just not with the alphabet.
Tony MartignettiNonprofit radio listeners, very savvy, very savvy group that we have. We have the ABCs down. We've mastered that. Yeah, recently, but we've mastered it.
Sarah OlivieriGood for you.
Tony MartignettiAnd I say we, I'm including myself in this.
Sarah OlivieriThat's right.
Tony MartignettiWe've mastered the alphabet. We, we can, we can rely on that baseline.
Sarah OlivieriI love it.
Tony MartignettiOkay.
Sarah OlivieriSo let's say, you know, it costs, you know, $500 to serve one person for one day.
Tony MartignettiNow
Sarah Olivierithere's a few things we can do with this number. One, we can tell a fundraising story like, hey, it costs $500 to serve one person for one day. How many people do you want to save? Right? Like, do you want to save one person, half a person, right? And we start— I actually just had this conversation with a client the other day. They help victims of domestic violence and the real costs of supporting somebody to leave their house. Often it's women who are leaving with an average of 2 children and leaving everything behind and now have a giant legal battle ahead of them, as well as rebuilding their entire life from scratch. The cost to save a life of a victim of domestic abuse is very, very high. It's in the many hundreds of thousands, right? Mm-hmm. So you can start to get a grip on what Does the impact you're trying to make cost? So, but besides telling a donor story, you can, and I really think you should, start asking yourself, is there a way we can get the same result with spending less money? Right? Because if we can do that, then we can get that result more and more and more. That's how we begin to scale. That's how we begin to say, okay, Last year, $100,000 could get this amazing result for 100 people. This year, the same $100,000, because we've changed the way we've designed to get the same result, now serves 150 people. Right? Isn't it better to serve 150 than 100, as long as the result is just as good? I'm certainly not suggesting we like—
Tony MartignettiRight.
Sarah Olivieri—chimp on results just to save money. That's not what we're talking about. But, but we really want to ask that question, like, you know, and just like we compared to the stock market, right? Like, is this help we're providing that costs this amount of money? What else could we do for that money? You know, does this really make sense? Is that a really good amount of help? And, you know, there's, um, I think they're called GiveDirectly. They're a nonprofit that just gives cash. They serve poor communities, I think, around the world, and they're very good at measuring this kind of thing, and they're always comparing If we're trying to solve this problem, like starving children in this community, is it more effective to open a soup kitchen and start feeding the children? Or is it more effective to just give their parents cash or give the kids cash? Right? And again and again, you know what they find is just giving people cash free and outright, no restrictions, solves the problem just as well, if not better. For less money than building a whole program. But if you don't know those numbers, you're not going to have that answer. There may be an easier way, there may be a better way, but you're not going to know that if you can't start measuring this kind of thing.
Tony MartignettiThat's also where investment in technology might be able to make a difference for you in terms of, you know, the way you're scheduling, uh, the way you're intaking. You know, maybe, maybe your intake folks, to use your client example of domestic violence victims, maybe your intake folks would be better served with tablets than paper, or, or laptops than tablets, or, you know, or, or phones than laptops. So investment in technology may help. Investment in processes or redesigning processes. So that takes time. That's That's a lot of introspection. That's a lot of time, because again, you know, you don't want to— you don't want to diminish the impact, and you don't want to treat your— certainly your beneficiaries as anything less than people deserving respect. So I'm not saying hand them a tablet, but there may be process ways, technology ways, maybe different staff organization. Yeah. But, you know, it takes introspection to try to reduce friction, reduce costs, and keep impact the same.
Sarah OlivieriAnd that's where you then get all of your, you know, I like to call it kind of like your tactical, your tactics related to your goals. So the goal is, you know, so I break goals down into like, what's the outcome that we don't have control over? And then the kind of related goal that we do have control over. So if the outcome goal is we want to now see if we can serve 150 people instead of 100 without spending any more money, and then the thing that you do have control over, well, let's test, let's set a goal to test new technology. Let's set a goal to test new processes. Let's set a goal to work with a consultant to improve the way we do intake. And then let's see if these things start to have the, the total impact that we are hoping for. I had that with a large client, human service organization. They had like 45 different programs, and they had no central intake process or process to kind of move people between their different programs. They were a mental health organization, and a lot of people needed to go from one service to another. Like maybe first they needed addiction recovery, and then they needed peer support. Right. And housing support, and then they needed job support, right? So they really needed to be taking a journey, but they didn't have a way to take people on a journey. It was just kind of a free-for-all. The person had to be their own guide. And so we kind of really went through with a fine-tooth comb, how do people come in? What service are they coming in for? And then how do we begin to take them on this journey so that— because the more people who go on a complete journey, the better the result is, right? That's how we go from making somebody just not homeless last night to making a lifelong impact for someone who now is in stable, consistent housing, has a job, and has become self-sufficient and is able to manage their mental health and whatever other issues, um, on an ongoing basis.
Tony MartignettiYeah. Yeah. Let's talk. You've identified some, but let's identify some of these important metrics. Like, let's kind of— I don't mean summarize because we're not necessarily finishing, but I'd like to put them all in sort of one place where people can say, well, these are important metrics for me versus not so much, versus more vanity or less important. Can we identify some of those?
Sarah OlivieriYeah, I think, you know, all the metrics around how good are we at, right? The metrics that answer how good are we at. So for you, whatever question you want to ask of your budget, right? The budget is like, you know, the secret genie. You want to ask it, how good are we at making money? How good are we at serving, you know, People, how, you know, how efficient are we at it? So, um, to kind of summarize, to give you the answers, the budgetary answers, where to find those answers really is how good are we at making money? Well, you can find that answer per program by taking the income and all the expenses out and then seeing the percentage that's left over, right? And the dollar amount, right?
Tony MartignettiMm-hmm.
Sarah OlivieriHaving $100,000 left over Maybe it's good, maybe it's bad, right? But if we look at percentages, then we can really compare year over year. So we may not know if it's good just by looking at one year, but if it's improving year over year, then we can say, oh, improvement is good. We know that that's good, right?
Tony MartignettiWe can then also— That's as a percentage of what we're spending on the program.
Sarah OlivieriRight.
Tony MartignettiSo the percentage— As that percentage.
Sarah OlivieriExactly. So the percentage that you're spending Of the total amount that's coming in. That's where we look at percentage. How good are we at fundraising, right? You just look at the total fundraising income, subtract out the fundraising expenses, and say what is left over, right? So we can say, how good are we improving? Then we're going to look at that percentage year over year. We can look at that percentage and compare it to other things in the world that make money. And then we can also look at the total dollar amount and answer the question of Are we— is our fundraising machine making enough money to cover our expenses?
Tony MartignettiRight, making enough. Yeah,
Sarah Olivieriright, making enough. So not how good is it, but is it making enough? That's where we start to look at the total dollar amounts. Is it enough? Is it enough?
Tony MartignettiSubsumed in what you just described is the, the often cited cost of raising a dollar.
Sarah OlivieriYes, yes. Now, you know, the nonprofit space likes to use that amount, and I think it's helpful because it's kind of very tangible, like, oh, You know, what is your cost to raise a dollar? But I like it less for 2 reasons compared to the percentage method.
Tony MartignettiOkay.
Sarah OlivieriBecause it's hard to do the reverse math. So if I said like, hey, Tony, like if my cost to raise a dollar is 75 cents, how much money do I need to put in the money machine if I want $250,000? Like it's just not easy math, right? So It starts to get easier if you look at percentages. Also, the for-profit world doesn't really use cost to raise a dollar. They use the percentage return on investment. And so if you want to, because there's lots of other ways to make money, so if you want to compare how good your way of generating money is to another way of generating money, like if you really are asking, like, do we— Yeah. invest in our fundraising machine or do we invest in the stock market? Right? That might be a real question at some point, and, or not for all of your money, but for part of your money. And you then, you know, need to have apples to apples, right? And so the percentage is the kind of apple that the for-profit world uses to talk about how good are we at making money. And so it's easier to compare. Does that make sense?
Tony MartignettiYes, it does. Yeah. Also, you gave me long enough to calculate that, uh, if it costs 75 cents to raise a dollar and we want $200,000, we would need to put $150,000 in.
Sarah OlivieriWell, good.
Tony Martignetti3 quarters. Um, okay, other, other metrics? This is where we are, metrics. But yes, yeah, things we should know. Yeah.
Sarah OlivieriSo, um, so we covered how good are we at doing this. Is it enough? Right? And then when you get into per program, how much does it cost to make a unit of impact? Right? So one person, and I recommend you maybe even kind of, when I think about, you know, it's hard to measure impact at nonprofits, but most recently I kind of like to break it into like levels, right? Low-level impact helps somebody for a few days, medium-level impact, like made, you know, a year-long type of change, and then high-level impact, like life-changing, and you could have multiple levels. And so you might want to kind of break your levels of impact into that. But how much does it cost to make one unit of impact? That's one metric. And then is that good, right? Is that— can we do better than that? And that's where we need to compare the cost year over year.
Tony MartignettiMm-hmm.
Sarah OlivieriAnd we also need to look at metrics where we want to think about, are we able to scale this up? Are we able to grow this dramatically? So you mentioned bake sales earlier. Bake sales are highly profitable typically, right? Like people donate all the food, all the labor, you know, as long as your staff, you know, if it's like a, you know, PTO type bake sale and you get to keep all the profit, right? Cost is almost zero. Profit is almost all that money that comes out. That's your profit. That's the margin.
Tony MartignettiIf everybody's a volunteer, sure.
Sarah OlivieriIf everyone's a volunteer. But if you were to scale up a bake sale to the size of a county fair, Not everybody can be a volunteer. You now have to have security and ticketing and a special location that can handle all those people. All of a sudden, our profit, the money coming out of the machine, comes way, way, way, way, way, way down because bake sales are not scalable. You can't grow it to a large amount. You can't just say, you know, $1 in gets me $2 out. Now I'm going to put in $100,000 and get $200,000. No, no. Not if your fundraising machine is a bake sale. Your fundraising machine will break if you try to put $200,000 in. So you want to be mindful as you look at how good are we at making money with our money machine. You want— and this is same for delivering an impact. You want to be mindful of, would this work if we put 10 times as much in, right? Or if we grew it 10 times as big, would it break?
Tony MartignettiMm-hmm.
Sarah OlivieriOr would it work? Right? Would we sink the ship? Would we break the machine? Would we overwhelm it? Or would it work? And you can ask the same question about your programs, right? You're able to serve 100 people now. Well, what if 200 people showed up at your door? What if 10,000 people showed up at your door? Could you, would you just, you know, 10 times as much or, you know, however many times as much of what you use to serve people, right? If you just scale up your machine, will it still work? Not always, right? So you want to be mindful, and you may see as you track your budget that how well something is working is getting worse. And you're like, but we're doing more and more. Why are we getting worse at making money? Let's say. And that's because the thing— your machine needs some tending to, because your machine is not designed, you know, to go that fast. It's not designed to work at that level. And so that's another thing we have to be mindful of.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Anything else that we haven't talked about that you want folks to know about our new fun friend, our budget?
Sarah OlivieriYou know, I think just, you know, in summary, right, the answers of is this good, are we improving, is it enough, it's the same kind of calculation Over and over again. And that's why I want you— what I want you to take away is it's not like we have to do a bajillion different kinds of fancy things with our budget. It's the same type of math, and it's those same types of questions, but those are very, very powerful questions. Is it enough? Is it getting better? Is it the best thing we could do, right? Those are things that your budget can tell you, and we're basically using the same kind of formulas, the same calculations again and again and again. So it's, it's simple. Once you've done it a couple times, you'll start to see, oh, I can apply this here and I can apply this there, and it becomes relatively easy.
Tony MartignettiSarah Olivieri, PivotGround. Uh, the company is @PivotGround and at pivotground.com. You'll find her template and other resources at pivotground.com. when you go to free resources. Sarah, thank you very much. Terrific.
Sarah OlivieriYou're so welcome.
Tony MartignettiI have a new fun friend.
Sarah OlivieriNot me, the budget.
Tony MartignettiMy budget. I have 2. Well, you're, you're a longtime fun friend.
Sarah OlivieriYes.
Tony MartignettiThank you again. Next week, corporate funding with Lori Zoss Kraska. If you missed any part of this week's show, I beseech you, Find it at tonymartinetti.com. We're sponsored by Turn 2 Communications, PR and content for nonprofits. Your story is their mission. turn-2.co. Our creative producer is Claire Meyerhoff. The show's social media is by Susan Chavez. Marc Silverman is our web guy, and this music is by Scott Stein of Brooklyn. Thank you for that affirmation, Scotty. Be with me next week for Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. Go out and be great. Thank you.
I love our sponsor!


