The Smart Nonprofit



About this episode
That’s Beth Kanter and Allison Fine’s new book, revealing the potential of smart technology and artificial intelligence for your nonprofit, and the entire sector. Beth and Allison are with us to share their thinking.
Here’s the transcript
Tony MartignettiOh, I neglected to mention, you'll hear me, you'll hear me do an intro to the show, and then we'll chat uninterrupted, and then I'll do the outro, and then I could say goodbye. Hello and welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio. Big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. I'm your aptly named host of your favorite hebdomadal podcast. Oh, I'm glad you're with me. I'd bear the pain of infraclusion if you made me chew on the idea that you missed this week's show. The Smart Nonprofit. That's Beth Kanter and Allison Fine's new book revealing the potential of smart technology and artificial intelligence for your nonprofit and the entire sector. Beth and Allison are with us to share their thinking on Tony's Take Two: Debunk Those Top 5 Myths of Planned Giving. We're sponsored by Turn 2 Communications, PR and content for nonprofits. Your story is their mission. turn-2.co. And by Fourth Dimension Technologies, IT infra in a box, the affordable tech solution for nonprofits. tony.ma/4D, just like 3D, but they go one dimension deeper. What a pleasure to welcome back Beth Kanter and Allison Fine to the show. Both been on multiple times. Although you, uh, know them, uh, they, they, uh They each deserve their own special introduction. Beth Kanter is an internationally recognized thought leader and trainer in digital transformation and well-being in the nonprofit workplace. She was named one of the most influential women in technology by Fast Company and received the NTEN Lifetime Achievement Award. She's @BethKanter and BethKanter.org. Allison Fine is among the nation's preeminent writers and strategists on the use of technology for social good. She's a member of the National Board of Women of Reform Judaism and was chair of the National Board of NARAL Pro-Choice America Foundation and a founding board member of Civic Hall. Allison is @afine and allisonfine.com. Beth and Allison, welcome back to Nonprofit Radio.
Allison FineThank you for having us, Tony.
Tony MartignettiGreat to be here. Yes, congratulations on the book.
Allison FineIt's very exciting. The response has been tremendous so far.
Beth KanterYeah, so both of our 4th book and 2nd collaboration together.
Tony Martignetti2nd, yes. You've co-authored The Network Nonprofit, if I'm not mistaken. All right, and 4th book for both of you. Congratulations all around. I would actually like to start with the last sentence of the book. If every nonprofit in the sector can transform itself into a smart nonprofit, we can transform the world, end quote. Does anybody want to claim authorship of that particular sentence? Is it possible for co-authors to remember who wrote each, each sentence throughout the book? Not possible.
Allison FineNo, not possible, but I'll just say—
Tony MartignettiSo then, all right, Allison, what does it take to become this ideal smart nonprofit?
Allison FineSo a smart nonprofit, Tony, is an organization that understands deeply how to stay human-centered, and by that we mean putting people first internally and externally. Using the most advanced technology organizations have ever had at their disposal. This, this, you know, family of technologies like AI, machine learning, robots, and so on. And by doing that, Tony, we can stop the incredible hamster wheel of busyness, frantic busyness of organizations just playing a daily game of whack-a-mole with email and telephone and ongoing meetings. Yeah. All of that rote work can be done by the technology, freeing up people to build relationships and tell stories and build communities and solve problems and do the deeply human work that most of us came to the sector to do in the first place.
Tony MartignettiAnd you, you used the word busyness. Now, that was not business, that was busyness.
Allison FineBusyness with a Y in the middle.
Tony MartignettiB-U-S-Y. Yes.
Allison FineOkay.
Tony MartignettiYeah. All right, so there are many considerations for becoming a smart nonprofit and some important roles of leadership that come out in the book. Beth, anything you would like to add to the intro to our conversation?
Beth KanterSure. What Allison laid out so beautifully is the key benefit that nonprofits get from embracing this technology, and that is the dividend of time. And that time can be reinvested either in building better relationships with donors or clients or stakeholders, or else it could be reinvested in the staff to free up time. So we're not so— as you said, the busywork takes up a lot of time, but it also takes up a lot of cognitive overload. And maybe if we had more spaciousness, we would be less exhausted and more inspired and less burnout.
Tony MartignettiYeah, that dividend of time is throughout the book. And we'll accept that hypothesis for now. I have some questions about that, some little skepticism about that. But for now, we'll accept that the dividend of time will indeed accrue to people who work in smart nonprofits and to the organization generally.
Allison FineAre you skeptical that it can be created, or are you skeptical that people will know what to do with it once they create it?
Tony MartignettiNo. Well, I don't want to challenge right off the bat, but—
Allison FineNo,
Tony Martignettiwhy
Allison Finenot?
Tony MartignettiSkepticism that it can be realized, not that people will know what to do if it does get realized. But yeah, well, let's come back to it. Let's leave the hypothesis. As perfectly fair and something to truly aspire to. Because there are, as you say, and as you lay out mostly in the last chapter, there are great places that the sector can go when we realize this, the dividend of time. Let's talk a little about, you know, some of these elements of being a smart nonprofit. Beth, let's stay with you for human-centered. What do you all mean by that?
Beth KanterWell, I guess we use another term in the book called cobotting. Really, I like that because it's like figuring out what the machines can do best, the automation technology. There are certain tasks that the technology is really good at doing, and those are things like analyzing large amounts of data and automating kind of rote tasks. But there are— there's stuff in our jobs that humans should do and always do, and that is the relationship building, taking the donors out to lunch. Like you were telling us you took a donor out to a nice restaurant recently. You know, that's not something automation is going to do for you. And being creative, having empathy, making intuitive decisions. And so when we use this technology, leaders really need to understand
Tony MartignettiWhat's the— how can we make sure that we center humans in adopting this smart technology?
Beth KanterWell, I think the first step is to ask to talk to them and get their feedback and their input before you even grab the software off the shelf. It's not about that at all. You really have to start with, you know, what are the points of pain? What are the exquisite pain points that we want to address by adopting this technology? And getting feedback from the end users, whether that's staff, clients, donors, and then setting up a, you know, an understanding of what the journey is, what the workflow is, and where you divide things. And then you begin to go look at software tools and find vendors that are aligned with your values, or technologists that are aligned with your values. And then once you've done that, you can begin to start with pilots and iteration on it before you get to scale. This is so different, Tony, than social media, which both Allison and I have talked to you about, where we're encouraging people to just jump in, experiment. Fail fast. What we're saying with this technology is that it's really important to go slowly and to be knowledgeable and reflective about it.
Tony MartignettiReflective, yes. Reflective is something else I wanted to ask about. You read my mind. Fantastic. Being reflective, Allison, what's that attribute about for the smart nonprofit?
Allison FineSo this is something I'm deeply passionate about, Tony. I don't know if you know, I had a first career as a program evaluator, and it's very, very difficult to get particularly smaller nonprofits who are so busy and so under-resourced to take a step back and not only think about how is what they're doing getting them closer to the results that they want to do, But how can they improve over time? And we need them to understand not only the human-centeredness that Beth just spot on, you know, outlined, but in particular, Tony, how are we making people feel internally and externally about our efforts? Are we making people feel seen and known and heard? Or, and this is particularly important when we talk about smart tech, do you feel like a data point, just, you know, a cog in large machinery that's just getting lost? And we know that feels terrible. Everybody has experiences of feeling— being made to feel small by organizations. And nothing is more important in our work, particularly in the social service and human service areas, of making people feel known and heard. And yet it is just this sticking point for the sector that it is the thing that gets left off. And again, we're back to the busyness of work. So we want people to be reflective of, is this the right technology? Are you solving that exquisite pain point that you had? How are you making people feel? When machines are now doing what only people could do until just a few years ago, you know, through smart tech, and is it solving the problems that you set out to solve?
Tony MartignettiYeah, I admired that idea of reflective because, you know, it's closely related, as you said, to being human-centered, you know, thoughtfulness, and it goes to, like, preparation, too.
Allison FineIt also goes to leadership, right? You have to have a leadership within an organization that isn't so brittle, that they are open to learning about how to improve. And there are too many organizations that are so fearful of being seen as not doing something well that they won't openly and wholeheartedly be reflective about their activities.
Beth KanterAnd it's also about the culture too. And we've used this word a lot, busyness. And when we have a culture of busyness and people are multitasking, And there's back-to-back meetings. They don't have that space to be reflective. That's so required to make the changes that you just read about with the last line of our book, to get to that place.
Tony MartignettiWe're going to talk some about the leadership. You talk about being trustworthy and empathetic. We'll get there. Another attribute you mentioned, Beth, is being knowledgeable, knowledgeable about the tech and I think its limits, too. You'll say it more eloquently than I will.
Beth KanterI think we can both say this. Both Allison and I can say it both eloquently, but I'll kick off with, when we say knowledgeable, And we're saying this to leaders. We're not saying that you need to know how to code, you know, roll up your sleeves and write the code, but you need to understand what goes into the code and whether it's biased, the datasets it's been trained on. And you need— most of the time, a lot of leaders in the nonprofit sector, when it comes to technology, it's kind of pushback, you know, oh, send it down the hall to the IT department. And we're really asking leaders to lean in because there's, you know, All right, well,
Tony MartignettiAllison, explain those, but then maybe you can tell us a story too about—
Allison Fineyeah,
Tony Martignettiabout like the degree to which a leader needs to be knowledgeable.
Allison FineSo we're talking about this family of technologies, Tony, that is very quickly becoming embedded in every single part of organizational life, right? This is not a, you know, a niche technology. you know, fundraising software. Smart tech is going to be embedded in the finances and the back office and the comms and development and in everything. And the idea of having machines automatically pay for things or screen resumes or screen people for services is a fundamental shift in who is doing work and how it's being done, right? So When you understand that premise, you have to have the C-suite leaning into this to understand what it means when your staff is doing different things than they used to do, and when people on the outside are engaging with machines instead of people, right? These are fundamental shifts. So one area— well, 2 I just mentioned that are so important— is if you are automating the screening of resumes. Mm-hmm. Then the assumptions that some programmer put into that system and the resumes that were used to test it for looking for certain kinds of employees with certain kinds of skills are going to be biased. I can tell you that right now, right? They are going to have a bias, and largely that bias is going to be against, you know, people who are Black and brown or, or women.
Tony MartignettiYeah, it's gonna be in favor of white men.
Allison FineExactly, because that is what employment looks like. Those are the questions we use. Those are the expectations that we have, and the programming was done most likely by a white man. So if you don't know what to ask the creator of that software that you've just bought that is going to, quote, save you a ton of time looking at resumes, but also screen out people of color and women, then you've just done an incredible disservice to your organization. And the same if you are providing housing services or food services to people in need. The same kinds of biases are going to be found in these systems, right? This is a systems problem. And that's why, as Beth was saying, this is not a technical problem. This is not something where you say, go IT guys, go find us a good product. You know, they're not looking out for your organization's interests in equity. That's what leadership is for, right? Setting those moral standards, setting that compass, and making sure that your values are aligned in everything you do and how you do it as an organization.
Tony MartignettiYeah, you, you both are very clear in the book that this is a leadership issue, not a technology issue.
Allison FineThat's right. That's right. That's right.
Tony MartignettiIt's time for a break. Turn to communications. They have another interesting newsletter this week advocating for the use of clichés. Their argument is that clichés shouldn't be ruled out entirely, but used judiciously. Like, not— don't go overboard either. Whatever you think about clichés, my point is they're thinking about them.
Speaker DThey're thinking about how best to communicate Your story, because your story is their mission. turn-to.co. Now back to The Smart Nonprofit.
Tony MartignettiAny stories? Can we tell a story at this point, Allison?
Allison FineSure. There are social service agencies around the country that were using smart tech systems to provide food assistance. And only after the system had been in place for several years, Tony, did they find out that it was literally leaving out Black people from the system. In the opening chapter of our book, we talk about a screening tool. Right. Called VI-SPDAT.
Beth KanterSay that 3 times fast.
Allison FineI didn't
Tony Martignettiknow. I just kept saying it, VI-SPDT.
Allison FineYeah, yeah. VI-SPDAT, that was programmed by a white man with very good intentions that unintentionally was leaving Black people out of getting priority housing in hundreds of communities around the world for years before the social workers finally got heard saying, We know this tool doesn't work. We're on the ground, we're using it. It is not screening people correctly because the questions were biased against people of color who have so much trouble getting into public systems.
Tony MartignettiYou, uh, you have 3 caveats sort of that, uh, that you, uh, you make very clear, and bias is one of them. So we've just talked about that. Um, responsible use. Is another, another of the 3. Beth, can you, can you talk to what you're thinking about responsible use and sort of thinking through problems?
Beth KanterSure. It's kind of like taking a Hippocratic oath that you will do no harm, right? So the example that Allison just laid out, obviously there was harm done by keeping people, screening people out for important services. So it behooves nonprofits to do something that we call threat modeling. I know it's a big scary term and word, and it comes from internet cybersecurity, but it's actually—
Tony MartignettiThat didn't frighten me. Threat
Beth Kantermodeling. Okay, well, it might frighten some people. We've had that reaction, but it's just basically—
Tony MartignettiNonprofit Radio is very savvy listeners here.
Beth KanterAbsolutely.
Tony MartignettiThis is a higher echelon audience than your customers.
Beth KanterRight, of course you're always—
Tony MartignettiOther podcasts, so please. Threat modeling is not intimidating to us.
Beth KanterOkay, so threat modeling is actually having a brainstorm of all the possible things that could go wrong if you implement this technology. What harms could be done to the end user if they were given— let's say you have a bot, right? And in fact, the Trevor Project is an example of an organization that did this threat modeling. They wanted to They had a problem. They had— you're familiar with the Trevor Project, right?
Tony MartignettiExplain, explain what it does.
Beth KanterOkay, so they provide counseling to LGBTQ youth, you know, through text and online phone, if you will. And so they're dealing with kids who are in crisis and a whole, you know, continuum of issues. And they have counselors that There who are volunteers, but they're trained in this very specific, very sensitive type of counseling, especially when young people are coming to them in crisis. And so, so the problem was, you know, they needed to scale and get more counselors in there so they could help more clients. And so they decided that they wanted to use a bot, which is, you know, automated response. We're all familiar with bots, you know, buy a pair of sneakers online or trying to make a doctor's appointment and you encounter a bot. And so rather than replace the counselors on the front line with this technology, that wouldn't be human-centered. It could be potentially dangerous, especially with a sophisticated self-learning bot, which could learn through, you know, and learn through interactions and say the wrong things. And that could be devastating to an end user who's in crisis. But what they decided to do was to use the bot for training simulations. So they took data from real conversations, stripping all privacy information, and they used this to train their bot, which was a highly sophisticated software that was self-learning. But they said that this bot will not be on the front lines with anybody. It will only interact with— for training simulations. So what this did was free up a lot of time from the staff in terms of delivering trainings. To more quality control, so they were able to get more counselors on the front line. It's an example of being human-centered, but it's also an example of that dividend of time and repurposing it and also making sure it's doing no harm.
Tony MartignettiYeah, and that responsible use. Okay. The other caveat you have, so you have 3 caveats: bias, responsible use, And privacy, talking about ethical standards. Who's, uh, who's, who's most interested in talking about privacy? Allison Fine raised her hand first.
Allison FineYes, I did. Um, so this is not a new issue, right? We've been dealing with, uh, digital privacy, um, for a long time, but as a sector, uh, haven't really ever gotten our arms around it, Tony, right? In that we as a sector have just subscribed to, I think, We think the lowest expectations from the commercial side, which is you try to get as much personal data as you can, right? You ask for those emails and you leave. You might let somebody unsubscribe from a newsletter, but you don't delete their emails, right? And a much, much more ethical model we feel is in the European Union, the GDPR. I can't remember what that stands for, but the idea is that the people, the consumers, constituents, donors, volunteers are in charge of their data, and they get to tell us how they want to be engaged with us, right? They get to tell us that they want to be forgotten entirely from our systems.
Tony MartignettiThey
Allison Finedon't want to be on any of our lists. They don't want to be in our systems. And that flipping over of the model, we think, is very in keeping with being human-centered, right? It's very in keeping with the values that we're trying to imbue in this whole concept of smart nonprofits, right? That we shouldn't fear asking people what the value we provide to them is, right? Do we provide enough value in having their email for them to want to stay with us? Or are we just churning through, again, as we said in the beginning, churning them through systems like they're cogs in a great big machinery? We think smart tech is going to generate even more data than the last 10 years of digital tech, which is astonishing to think about, kind of mind-blowing to think about.
Tony MartignettiYeah, because I think, didn't you cite 90% of the data that we have has been collected in the past 2 years?
Allison FineYeah, yeah, it is remarkable to explode. And so we need to be— we need to raise the bar on our ethical considerations on the use of data and the relationship that we have with our constituents. They need to trust us more. The fact that the nonprofit sector, along with other sectors, the degree of trust is going down, Tony, is is not good, and we ought to hold ourselves to higher standards of privacy and data protection.
Tony Martignetti2 weeks ago, Gene Takagi and I talked about that exact subject in a show that I called In Nonprofits Do We Trust? It was just, it was just 2 weeks ago. It's time for a break. Fourth Dimension Technologies. Your tech is an investment.
Speaker DInvest wisely. What's the state of your office infrastructure? Should you give remote or hybrid employees tech allowances or just give them the equipment outright or both or neither? How's your disaster recovery plan? How's your backup working? 4D can help you with all these investment decisions. Check the listener landing page, tony.ma/4D. Great. Just like 3D, but, you know, they go one dimension deeper. Let's return to the smart nonprofit.
Tony MartignettiDo we know what the impact has been on business coming out of the GDPR? Has it had the devastating effect on business that the business community in Europe was claiming when they were lobbying against it or trying to, you know, trying to weaken it. Do we know— I'm putting you on the spot— do either of you know whether that's had such a devastating impact on European business?
Allison FineNo, it's been fine. And look, companies, commercial companies here have had to put more effort into privacy issues when they do work in the European Union.
Tony MartignettiYeah.
Beth KanterAnd in California.
Allison FineYou know, California, Beth, California are holding people to the same standards, uh, now. Um, but it hasn't had a huge negative impact on business.
Tony MartignettiYeah,
Allison Fineyou know, it's fine.
Tony MartignettiOkay, right. Okay. Now this, uh, this smart tech, uh, artificial intelligence we're talking about, this is widely used commercially, right? I mean, isn't this, uh, uh, I don't know, fundamental to Amazon, Google, the 24-hour chatbot that Beth mentioned, you know, you see a little bot 24/7. The likelihood of that being a live person at 4 in the morning is very, very small. This is ubiquitous in the commercial sector, isn't it?
Beth KanterYes, it is. But I think we're at this point— Allison likes to call it the heel of the hockey stick— where it's going to— the cost of this technology has come down. It's becoming democratized, and it's becoming more accessible to nonprofits of all sizes. All right, so you don't have to be NASA to use this.
Tony MartignettiAll right, now to keep yourself out of jargon jail, you're gonna have to explain the, uh, the hockey stick on a graph metaphor. So go ahead, tell us what X and Y are and why it looks like a hockey stick.
Beth KanterOkay, it's, uh, okay, so imagine a hockey stick, right? Or I should do it this way. I'm, I'm looking at my Zoom. Well,
Tony Martignettinobody can, nobody can see your hands.
Beth KanterWe all know what happened, but we all know sophisticated enough to know what What hockey sticks look like? It basically shows, and this happens with technology, is that, you know, early adopters use it because it's very expensive, experimental, it's unproven. And as the technology improves and the cost comes down and it becomes more accessible to consumers and to small businesses and to organizations, the adoption rate starts to skyrocket. So it goes up. So you see sort of a flat line and then a steep hill or steep mountain increase.
Tony MartignettiSo X is time and Y is technology adoption?
Beth KanterYes.
Tony MartignettiOkay.
Beth KanterYeah, you're better at charts than I am.
Tony MartignettiOkay. Well, you invoked the metaphor of the hockey stick. You got to be able to stand behind it now.
Beth KanterOh, I guess I should.
Tony MartignettiAll right.
Allison FineIt's not just nonprofits adopting this now, Tony. I would say that it's all medium and small-sized organizations in every sector that now has available to them technology that they couldn't afford just a few years ago. And that's what the difference is. The technology isn't brand new; it's just become very affordable for smaller organizations. However, as I mentioned before, just because it's available and just because it's affordable doesn't necessarily mean it's the right stuff to grab off the shelf. And that's the part—that's that's the impetus for us to write this book. You need to know what you're grabbing and using.
Tony MartignettiYeah, the availability to. Small and mid-sized shops, I think, is through— is throughout your book. Um, you— let's tell another good story, the, the one with the, uh, uh, the repurposing of the school bus routes to deliver food instead of drop off children during the pandemic because children were no longer going to school. So they repurposed school buses to drop off meals. Who, who knows that story best?
Beth KanterYeah, so you're, you're talking about, uh, researchers at Carnegie Mellon University, and you're talking about Pittsburgh school system.
Tony MartignettiOkay.
Beth KanterYeah, United Pittsburgh School District or whatever it's called. So this was at the very beginning of the pandemic when we were in the shutdown, and kids that are in schools that are in poorer areas relied on the school lunch program to get their meals, right? And so if schools were shut down and students were telecommuting, they had no way to get this food. So they used a machine learning algorithm to re-engineer the bus routes routes to take the food to the kids in the most efficient way. It's really interesting how during the pandemic, you know, there was a little bit of a silver lining. I know it's awful, but there was this silver lining for some nonprofits to really push and to innovate. And I think food banks in a way were forced to do this. There's another example in Boston of the Boston Food Bank completely automating its inventory and stocking to become a lot more efficient. And at one point, they even were experimenting with having robots come in and stock the shelves because most of food banks' volunteers are older, and they were told not, you know, during the very early part of the pandemic, not to, you know, come in because it could be dangerous to their health. And that's also a great kind of idea, story, use scenario to think about to do the threat modeling that we were talking about earlier. So let's just say— Yeah. For example, food banks say, oh, let's bring in the robots and have them stock the shelves, you know. So, but you also have to think about that volunteers who are coming in to do this type of work, those were their lifeline in terms of— How are they gonna feel?
Tony MartignettiRight.
Beth KanterYeah, how are they gonna feel? And how are we gonna redesign the volunteer job? And how are we gonna encourage them to come back in and make them feel safe and welcome into the food bank?
Tony MartignettiAnd that's right, unless they feel useless and replaced by machinery. And this is all the organization thought of us, and now they— now it's just a bunch of metal replacing us, metal and plastic parts. So yeah, all right. Also being human-centered, reflective.
Allison FineBut that's also— that's the dividend of time, Tony. If you can say, all right, we used to have these, uh, you know, 2 dozen volunteers who came in and were stocking shelves all the time. And now we've automated that task. What is it that these, you know, lovely people who want to help could do that would be so, you know, deeply human-centered, as you say, and, you know, improve our relationship with our clients? Maybe they could be calling clients. So what else do you need? You know, what else is happening for you? Or just saying hello to somebody, right? I mean, there are all sorts of Wonderful human things that those people could now do if they want to, um, that they never had the time to do before. That's the— that's where this is again a leadership issue of really thinking about how do we want to use our human capital in the next chapter of organizational development.
Tony MartignettiOkay, thank you. That's an excellent example of the dividend of time. We're, uh, we're about half an hour in or so, so let me, uh, Let me try my, my skepticism out on you. That we— I've heard this before, that there was going to be— there were promises of increased productivity and increased time. I'm thinking of smartphones. Yeah. We're going to give us more time, and they certainly made us more productive, but I don't, I don't, I don't see studies saying that we have so much more time. I see that time being Absorbed. Now, you might say, well, maybe I'm making your case for you, that time being reallocated unthoughtfully, unwisely. But I don't, I don't see people walking around feeling that they've got so much more free time since the widespread adoption of smartphones.
Beth KanterYeah.
Tony Martignetti10 years ago or so. Yeah. Another video conferencing, you know, whatever, Teams, Zoom. I hear more about Zoom burnout than I do about feeling that I've got so much more time available because I don't have to go to meetings, I don't have to go to the office. Um, you know, so those are a couple of— the paperless office, that was another— the promise of the paperless office was going to be so much, so much more efficient for us, and I think that was going to save us time because we wouldn't have to file papers, and it was going to save office space because we wouldn't need storage. And these promises, um— I'm not gonna sound like a whining 60-year-old, but these promises have not come to fruition in the past.
Beth KanterSo I'll take one. I'll tackle the Zoom fatigue thing, and then Allison can kind of relate it to smart tech. So—
Tony MartignettiCurmudgeonly, I guess I should say. It's not whining. I don't want to sound like a curmudgeonly 60-year-old.
Beth KanterOh, well, you're not a curmudgeon and you never whine.
Tony MartignettiOh, well, thank you.
Beth KanterSo if you take Zoom fatigue, right? And that came from Stanford University. And basically what is causing it is the flight-or-fight response that's going on in our bodies when we see the grid. I mean, there's some ways to mitigate it, but what happened is, is that nonprofits, like many businesses, all of a sudden were forced to pivot to becoming remote distributed teams. We'd never really worked like that. So the idea was, oh, let's just all make it a Zoom meeting. Let's just take everything we did in person and just plop it online. What happened, because everybody was doing this, there was— we didn't really evaluate how do we collaborate effectively? What do we need? What can we do like asynchronously so we can make use of our synchronous or real-time experience so we can make meetings shorter? There's research from Microsoft that shows that if you have stacked back-to-back meetings without taking a break, your level of stress just stays the same throughout the day. And so if organizations were reflective and knowledgeable and kind of prepared, they would have looked at it and said, okay, so let's look at how we can, you know, stick to a culture of maybe a 20-minute meeting with a 10-minute break in between, or have a Zoom number per day that we know that we're not going to schedule more than X number of meetings, which would then think to how do we rethink our work? Right. So it's not just the technology. That's true. The technology doesn't create the dividend of time. It's a combination of the technology with thoughtful leadership, reflective leadership, as we've been saying, that can then change the culture.
Tony MartignettiAll right.
Allison FineYeah. And let me, let me, let me build on that, Tony. So we have an entire generation of digital technology that was intended to make us go faster. Right? That was— that's what it has done. We are at a point now we're checking your email on average 74 times a day is, quote, normal, right?
Tony MartignettiWe've gone from, uh, I don't know, let's see, uh, fax to email to texting to, to, to, um, um, Slack.
Allison FineWe, we, we get that. This technology, smart tech, AI automation, is not that technology. It is a fundamentally different kind of technology that's intended to do things instead of people, not to have us do more. But as Beth just said, it's only going to do that if we implement it thoughtfully, right? If we end up in the same place where we are checking on the bots 74 times a day, shame on us. Yeah. The stuff has the potential to relieve us of so much administrative rote work that just eats up everybody's day. And if we can cobot well and have the bots do what they're supposed to do and the people do what they, they're supposed to do, we can actually rehumanize work. But as you know, we're just at the beginning. Yeah. of this process. A lot of this is theoretical, and that's again is why we wrote this book. Instead of jumping in and grabbing the stuff and adding it on to your existing busyness, franticness culture, we need you to stop and think and figure out how to do this well.
Beth KanterYou know, there's some research that's from MIT Sloan School that looked at the effectiveness of this technology and And where it is effective is if people don't just focus on the efficiency of it. That is to, okay, wow, we can get all of these tasks done way more efficiently because people aren't cutting and pasting from different spreadsheets, but we're not going to fill up people with more work to do. So it's not to go faster, it's really to be more effective. And so if this technology can be implemented and it can kind of relieve some of that stress and pain of overload, then that has an impact on morale and people feeling good about where they work. And there is a synergistic impact that the study found that where efficiency and kind of effectiveness work together. So there's— so that can have more, you know, people feel better about their work, they do better, they get better results, they're less likely to quit. Yeah. There's less likely to be turnover, and the organization moves forward in a, in a better way with better outcomes.
Tony MartignettiRight. Okay. All right. And that's, that's if, if it's adopted with leaders consciously being human-centered, knowledgeable, reflective, prepared.
Allison FineYeah.
Tony MartignettiAnd we're going to get to trust and empathy. All right. Well, yeah, you may have moved me from skeptic to cautious optimist.
Beth KanterOkay.
Allison FineWe'll take it.
Beth KanterAll
Tony Martignettiright.
Beth KanterWe'll take it. I was gonna say, what are you still— what are you still a little skeptical about?
Tony MartignettiYou know, the history. The history has not borne out that leaders have adopted the new technology reflectively, thoughtfully, and preparedly. It's just— so I'm just basically—
Beth KanterThey need to read our book.
Tony MartignettiPardon me?
Beth KanterThey need to read our book. They never had one.
Tony MartignettiNow it's 2022. Now they have the book. They didn't have it when we went from fax to email or email to Slack or email to text and text. All right. All right. No, no, it's okay. Um, so leaders, please, uh, keep listening. It's time for Tony's Take Two: Debunk the Top 5 Myths of Planned Giving. That's my free webinar coming up. It's Tuesday, October 18th at 10:00 AM Pacific, 1:00 Eastern. I say free webinar, but it's not free for everyone. It's free for you because you're going to use checkout code TONY, T-O-N-Y. Couldn't be simpler.
Speaker DI think you have to put it all in caps too. I'm not sure about that part. Do it all in caps to be safe.
Tony MartignettiSo I'm going to be talking about debunking these insidious, pernicious top 5 myths of planned giving. I hate them. I loathe them. They are loathsome. That's why I loathe them, because they keep people away from planned giving. Like the one that says planned giving is going to ruin all your other fundraising.
Speaker DIt's going to take away from your annual gift and your major annual giving and major giving.
Tony MartignettiDebunk. We're going to debunk that and 4 others as well. So join me. Very simple to sign up, of course. You go to our gracious host site. We are thoughtfully hosted by NP Solutions. So you go to npsolutions.org. You click workshops. You'll find me in the list. And then when you're checking out, use that code TONY, do it in all caps, and it'll be free for you. Not for everybody, but for you.
Speaker DI hope you'll be with me. Let's debunk these hateful top 5 myths. That is Tony's Take Two. We've got beaucoup, buttloads more time. For the Smart Nonprofit with Beth Kanter and Allison Fine.
Tony MartignettiLet's talk some about the leadership. It's perfect. So you mentioned the 3 things I really want to talk about: trustworthy, empathy, and curiosity. And I have to get this in. If you had an H, then you could have spelled out TECH: trustworthy, empathy, curious,
Beth KanterHigh-minded. Human-centered.
Tony MartignettiHuman-centered. You need tech. You got the TEC in the book. I was looking, where's the H? All right. What does it look like for leaders to be trustworthy, to adopt trust? Who's the best? Who's the most trustworthy explainer of trust? I don't care, it could be either one.
Beth KanterI'll take empathy. Okay, trust.
Tony MartignettiAll right, Allison, trust is yours. We got to go in order, and then if we can come up with an H, uh, human-centered. But that, you already have that in the, in Becoming a Smart Nonprofit. That's, that you already covered that one. So
Allison Fineyeah,
Tony Martignettimaybe you can come up with another one. Um, so Herculean, heroic, heroic or Herculean. All right, trust. Allison, why is this trust important?
Allison FineSo organizations are making a bond with people in their communities, right? We are asking them to come along on a journey with us, to be clients, to be donors, to be volunteers, to engage with us in some way. And trust is the stuff that's sticking us together, right? It is social capital. It is thinking that an organization has your best interests at heart, not just their best interests at heart. And I feel like for 20 years, so many organizations have been going, moving so quickly on this hamster wheel, advised by people who make a lot of money off of transactional fundraising and transactional engagement online. And have lost sight of the fact that unless and until people out there trust that you are doing the right stuff in the right way, nothing else matters. And we're all trying to scale way too quickly, Tony, without really understanding the fundamental DNA of making sure that we are entirely values-aligned from what we want to do to what we're actually doing to the outcomes. Yeah. And again, you know, Beth and I feel so strongly that the nonprofit sector is such an incredibly special place, right? We are the epicenter of the world for, you know, providing human services and doing advocacy work. And it is such incredibly brave, difficult work. And yet we still have a ways to go. In asking the leadership of organizations, both C-suite and the boards, to raise the bar, to be more transparent, to ask more questions about how they're doing, to measure their outcomes, to take care of their people internally and externally better. And so that's why we put trust so high up on the scale of what we want organizations to be focused on.
Tony MartignettiI think leaders feel when they're falling short in the aspirations that you just described. I think folks feel it. It's just— but they're on that hamster wheel and it's hard to take that step back and acknowledge what you're feeling and be introspective as an organization.
Allison FineLet me describe something though that's really important, Tony, that we as a sector don't talk nearly enough about. And that's what Beth and I call the leaky bucket in fundraising, right? So year 1, you get 100 donors. By year 2, you're down to 25 of those. You've lost 75% of those donors because you're so busy filling up the bucket again because you lost 75% the year before. And all you're doing is this transactional fundraising, the email, the direct mail to fill up the bucket again. All of the measures of fundraising success are front-loaded, right? Of did we hit those revenue targets for this year? Very few organizations are really focused on donor retention and how to increase it. It's never been at a board table for discussion that I've been at in many, many years, many, many organizations of being on the board. Yeah. And that is where the panic comes in, and it feels terrible to staff. And, you know, my heart just goes out to all of those people who are in a panic about hitting those revenue numbers, knowing that what they're working with is hemorrhaging donors every single day. And that's where, you know, just in my heart of hearts, Tony, I just want everybody to stop. Just stop and take a step back and figure out How to improve your relationship with donors more so they stay longer with you and you're not in this panic every day.
Tony MartignettiAllison, we're going to come back to you for curiosity. Beth, let's talk about empathy.
Beth KanterSure. And I think the empathy needs to be turned within first before it gets turned outside to the donors to solve what Allison was just talking about. But so empathetic leadership means the ability to understand the needs of others and being aware of their feelings and thoughts. And unfortunately, it's viewed as kind of like a soft skill, and it's not always linked to performance indicators, right? And so I think it's really important, especially with what we've been through in the pandemic. Yeah. That organizations really need to have clear expectations with their managers to lead in a way that is supportive of employees and that supports and contributes to their overall well-being. And they can do that and still get work done. And I think that, like, don't get me started on well-being, but well-being has to be put center and it has to be raised up and given as much importance as fundraising metrics. Or other financial metrics, especially given what we've been through. And so this includes checking in, training people to like actually observe on their staff and making sure that they're, you know, caretakers for each other's well-being. And it's, you know, like a one-on-one check-in isn't just about, hey, where's that report? Where's that proposal? But it's also how people are feeling, what their energy is like, what their job experience is like, what could be improved. Which gets us closer to that conversation around technology. So the types of skills and competencies that make for a culture of care and empathy are, you know, self-awareness and self-regulation, adaptive skills, active listening, coaching with powerful questions, observing for signs of burnout, being able to give and receive feedback in a way that doesn't cause stress. Disrupting microaggressions, inclusive facilitation, having those difficult conversations. You know, sometimes we're just too nice, but there's ways to have those conversations that aren't devastating. And genuine perspective-taking, being able to see it from other people's points of view. And it doesn't— I don't think that makes us weaker. I really think it makes us stronger.
Tony MartignettiAbsolutely.
Beth KanterYou know, it's not a bunch of one, you know, reaction When I wrote the, um, you know, the Happy Healthy—
Tony MartignettiHappy Healthy with Eliza Sherman.
Beth KanterYeah, right. We get the, you know, that's a bunch of hippie crap. It's not.
Tony MartignettiYeah, I didn't say that when I talked to you.
Beth KanterNo, you didn't say that. Of course you wouldn't say that. You're too smart.
Tony MartignettiOh, thank you. Well, you hardly know me, but thank you. I'll take it anyway. Um, no, a lot of what you're describing too is vulnerability, and I, I think vulnerability is a sign of is evidence of confidence that you're, that you're strong enough to be vulnerable, where lots of people think it's a sign of weakness, that you're showing, you know, you're, you're showing your human side. And, you know, that I think that's terribly misguided. All right, if we're gonna, we're gonna, if I'm gonna keep you not beyond our allocated time, let's go to Allison for, for curiosity.
Allison FineWhy is it important?
Tony MartignettiYes, why is curiosity a valued trait for leaders?
Allison FineYou know, the world is moving really fast, Tony, and we have a lot of organizational leaders who think tech is not their thing, right? Tech is for somebody else. And it can't not be your thing if you're running an organization right now. It's too important. Threaded throughout everything that your organization is doing, and you can't just lean back. You need to lean into it, and to do that, you need to be genuinely curious about— in our case, for smart tech— what is this stuff and why is it important and how is it different from the last generation of technology, and what could we actually accomplish if we didn't spend 3 quarters of our day responding to emails? What is possible out there in the world? And, you know, my heart breaks for so many of the nonprofit folks that Beth and I talk to who have such good intentions and are so deeply unhappy with how stressful their jobs are, or how unrecognized they are by the C-suite, or how pressurized they feel. So it is just— innately important for organizational leaders to be genuinely curious about where do we go from here, right? The world broke 2 years ago in so many fundamental ways. The, the political economic stress of this moment is wearing people down, but we can't stay here, Tony. We need to go somewhere, and we genuinely believe That the family of technologies we call smart tech creates an opportunity to be different in the future, to make work joyful and much more meaningful and rewarding. And you can only get there if you're genuinely curious and engaged in understanding the technology.
Tony MartignettiAnd I think curiosity and empathy are interrelated too.
Allison FineThat's right.
Tony MartignettiCuriosity about your people, as Beth was, for all the In all the ways Beth was describing.
Allison FineThat's exactly right.
Tony MartignettiAll right. Um, I don't suppose the— Beth, I don't suppose you, uh, on the fly came up with an H for— to spell out tech, uh, for us, did you?
Beth KanterWell, human-centered, but we are— Yeah, but we— yeah, but centered—
Tony Martignettiyeah, you have that one already.
Beth KanterHumility, maybe? Humility.
Tony MartignettiHumility. Humility is a good one. There you go.
Beth KanterOkay, so let's riff on that. Humility.
Tony MartignettiIn the second edition You can add humility and spell out tech.
Beth KanterRight, and then we'll footnote it and say suggested by Tony.
Tony MartignettiOh, thank you. Yeah, humility, right? Isn't that simple? Yeah, related to being empathetic. Yeah, leaders don't need to know everything, do they?
Allison FineOh gosh, no,
Beth Kanterno.
Allison FineListen, we've, you know, the reason why we wrote The Network Nonprofit, Tony, was to take that idea of the hierarchical model of leadership and organizations out of the equation and say, the point is somebody else in your network has the answer. You don't have to have the answer yourself. You just have to know how to go about getting it right. And, and that of flattening your organization and your worldview is so important to being able to survive all the uncertainties of what's happening right now.
Tony MartignettiSince we started with Alice and Beth, I'm going to let you wrap us up, please. There's so much more in the book. There are use cases, you know, we didn't— the book, we can only scratch the surface here. You got to get the book. That's the point. They talk about increasing program capacity, fundraising, back office automation, including a lot of talk about human resources. Um, you just, you got to get the book, which is, uh, The Smart Nonprofit. But Beth, why don't you leave us with, uh, inspiration and wisdom?
Beth KanterOkay. Um, we've been through a lot. The sector's been through a lot. I mean, the world's been through a lot in the last 2-plus years, uh, with the pandemic and, um, accompanying other crises, and as Allison has outlined, and I think we are like at a precipice where we could just either go down the rabbit hole of, you know, a human capital crisis and spiraling out and people leaving the field and organizations just, you know, stopping business and, you know, leaving lots of people who are vulnerable who need their services. I mean, that's— we can't go there. We have to pivot. And I think that smart tech is part of the tools that can help us get there. But again, they're tools. Yeah. They also need this empathetic leadership that we've been talking about, and who can also steer and change the culture to put people first. And I think if we can have all of these things together working for the organization, the smart tech plus the culture plus the leadership, we'll be able to move forward in a post-pandemic world with much better outcomes. With happier staff, with staff doing a better job, with donors feeling seen and heard and wanting to, you know, write bigger checks, if you will, with clients who are receiving the services that they need, and we're on a path to a better world. It's not gonna be easy, but we believe that nonprofits can do this.
Tony MartignettiThat's Beth Kanter, @BethKanter and BethKanter.org. Co-author Allison Fine, @AFine and AllisonFine.com. The book is The Smart Nonprofit.
Speaker DYou can find it at either of their 2 sites. Beth and Allison, thank you so much. Thanks for sharing.
Beth KanterThank you so much, Tony.
Allison FineThanks for having us, Tony.
Speaker DGenuine pleasure. Next week, Eric Saperston returns after many years. Let's talk about waking up excited and going to bed fulfilled. If you missed any part of this week's show, I beseech you, find it at tonymartignetti.com. We're sponsored by Turn 2 Communications, PR and content for nonprofits. Your story is their mission. turn-2.co. And by Fourth Dimension Technologies, IT infra in a box, the affordable tech solution for nonprofits. tony.ma/4d, just like 3D, but they go one dimension deeper. Our creative producer is Claire Meyerhoff. The show's social media is by Susan Chavez. Marc Silverman is our web guy, and this music is by Scott Stein. Thank you for that affirmation, Scotty. Be with me next week for Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. Go out and be great. Thank you.
I love our sponsors!




