Skip to content
EP 610September 25, 2022

In Nonprofits, Do We Trust?

Tony MartignettiGene Takagi
Nonprofit Radio
Episode 610
0:00 / 0:00

About this episode

Public trust in nonprofits is eroding. Why is that, what does it mean for our work, and what can the nonprofit community do about it? Gene Takagi, our legal contributor and principal of NEO Law Group, returns with his insights.

Here’s the transcript

Tony MartignettiHello and welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. I'm your aptly named host of your favorite hebdomadal podcast. Oh, I'm glad you're with me. I'd get slapped with a diagnosis of fragilitas unguium if you nailed me with the idea that you missed this week's show. In Nonprofits Do We Trust? Public trust in nonprofits is eroding. Why is that, and what can the nonprofit community do about it? Gene Takagi, our legal contributor and principal of NEO Law Group, returns with his insights. On Tony's Take Two, this is not planned giving. We're sponsored by Turn Two Communications, PR and content for nonprofits. Your story is their mission. turn-two.co. And by Fourth Dimension Technologies, IT infra in a box, the affordable tech solution for nonprofits. tony.ma/4d. Just like 3D, but they go one dimension deeper. It's always a pleasure to welcome back Gene Takagi. You know who he is, but of course, he— we owe him the introduction that he deserves, but you know who he is. He's our legal contributor, managing attorney of NEO, the Nonprofit and Exempt Organizations Law Group in San Francisco. He edits the wildly popular nonprofitlawblog.com, which you should follow, and he's a part-time lecturer at Columbia University. The firm is at neolawgroup.com, and Gene is @GTak. Gene, thanks for being back. Welcome.

Gene TakagiIt's great to be here, Tony. Thank you for having me.

Tony MartignettiOh, it's always a genuine pleasure. Thank you. We're talking about public trust today. Not only your concerns, but you're seeing evidence of, and I'm certainly reading some things too, about eroding public trust in nonprofits. What are you seeing? What are you thinking about that?

Gene TakagiWell, you know, my first thoughts, Tony, is that trust really is the foundation of good relationships, right? No matter whether we're talking about person to person, person to charity, you know, person to other institutions. And charities, I think, are especially reliant on trust because if you're asking people and groups and organizations to give money to you, they've got to trust that you're going to use that money for charitable purposes, not for personal gain, not for other things, but for the charitable purposes that they want to support. And when trust erodes in our charities, that's really a red flag and sort of a harbinger of things, bad things that could follow. So trust is really important, I think, to talk about. And the study, the most recent study that came out from Independent Sector and Edelman Data and Intelligence found that there's low trust amongst all institutions. So maybe not completely surprising, but less than a third say they trust government, large corporations, and the news media. Yeah.

Tony MartignettiAnd

Gene Takagiso charities, relatively speaking, are better than that in terms of the trust factor, but it's been dropping. Nonprofits as a sector, the trust in nonprofits now is 56%. The rest either are neutral on it or have a distrust of nonprofits. So only 56%, and only 36% trust philanthropy or foundations and grantmaking organizations. So that's really, really low. And women's trust in nonprofits dropped even more. than men. And I think another flag to point out is our younger generations, especially Gen Z, really have a distrust of nonprofits. And with the wealth transfer that's expected from baby boom generation to millennials and to Gen Z, that's got to be alarming to nonprofits. And I think it's just worthy to call out right now.

Tony MartignettiDo you know what that number is among Gen Z, trust in nonprofits? Did the independent sector include that in, in their survey?

Gene TakagiWell, the, the statistic that I, I saw that, that called out to me was 57% of Gen Z Americans say giving directly to individuals makes a bigger impact than giving to nonprofits. So they would rather give to individuals on GoFundMe or another crowdfunding site than to give to a nonprofit. They find that more trustworthy.

Tony MartignettiYeah, there's another dimension to the, to the trust, which is government trusting nonprofits. And you could read government as congressional or, you know, IRS, but, you know, they've— they— the, the, the, the US government has bestowed the charitable deduction So that the money is used for, as you said, you know, for charitable purposes as disclosed in your organizing documents. And if, if I'm thinking more of Congress, you know, if Congress feels that the nonprofit community can't be trusted, you know, we could start to see some erosion of the clawback of some of the, the benefits that nonprofits enjoy— tax-free status, for instance, and the charitable deduction, to name a couple of— Right. Wildly, wildly valuable ones.

Gene TakagiYeah, and that's such a great point because just a few days ago there was news about a case in Minnesota where government funding to feed poor children, there was a huge scandal involving tens of millions of dollars. So

Tony Martignettiyeah,

Gene Takagiit really speaks to if government stops trusting nonprofits or certain government agencies and cuts funding to agencies, how harmful that be to charities and the beneficiaries they're trying to serve.

Tony MartignettiI, I think that one was even worse. I think it was like $240 million worth of, uh, pandemic aid money. Yeah, I saw that in, uh, in Minnesota, supposed to be going to feed children during the pandemic and, uh, and pocketed. Yeah.

Gene TakagiYeah. Um, terrible fact patterns there as well. It's, it's a story worth—

Tony Martignettiyeah,

Gene Takagiworth a read.

Tony MartignettiIt is. It's torturous. And then of course, there's always been Charles Grassley. I mean, he's been nipping at foundations and donor-advised funds for years now.

Gene TakagiYeah. And in fact, the whole charitable sector, I think a significant portion of our lawmakers take a consumer protection perspective of we want to protect donors. And not strengthening the nonprofit sector perspective. They want to create laws that will, you know, try to prevent fraud or misuse of charitable funds, as if this is rampant amongst the nonprofit sector, which my position is it is not. But there are certain high-profile cases that hit the New York Times and the Washington Post and all the other newspapers, and there's so much media. Yeah. coverage that focuses on scandals because that's what's gonna sell, right? Yeah. The tweet or the short snippet that people's attention span will actually stop on, it's gonna sell much more if it's a scandal rather than a long-term growth and impact. Even, you know, the great news that child poverty has been really declining in the country, which should be huge news, you know, it gets short shrift compared to some of the big scandals that we hear about.

Tony MartignettiYeah, yeah. And when I name-dropped Charles Grassley, I should have said senator, senator from Iowa, Republican senator from Iowa, Charles Grassley. Yeah, right. It's the scandals that, that's— that get clicks, that sell papers, that get attention. I remember, I'm sure you do, several years ago, there was a scandal among an organization supposedly raising money for Navy veterans. It was like Navy Veteran Foundation or something like that several years ago, but it was very high profile. Um, what was the other— do you remember? I don't mean to put you on the spot. It's okay if you don't remember because I don't. The, uh, the veterans organization that was, uh, accused of squandering, you know, tens of millions of dollars on lavish retreats and high executive salaries. But it had great outcomes. It was funding lots of veterans organizations.

Gene TakagiI think the one you're talking about is the Wounded Warriors Project.

Tony MartignettiThank you. Wounded Warrior. Yes, yes. Right. Wounded Warrior Project.

Gene TakagiYeah. And yeah, it's always difficult looking at an organization through the eyes of the media. About how, you know, how well or unwell they did. So I don't want to create, you know, discuss particular scandals too much other than to say that they create problems for the whole sector. So, you know, that's, it's just something to be aware of, and they're not necessarily reflective of the vast majority of nonprofits out there trying to do good work and help people. Yeah.

Tony MartignettiThe 99.99%, you know, are— that's even higher than the Nonprofit Radio 95%. No, 99.99% of nonprofits are not scandalous. And could many of them be running more efficiently? Yes, but we're not talking about mere efficiency. You know, we're talking about erosion of trust because of high-profile crises or scandals. Malfeasance. Yeah, high profile, not representative. It's time for a break. Turn to communications. They know the nonprofit community and they know PR and journalism. Both partners are former journalists. Peter Panapento, one of the two, worked as senior managing editor at the Chronicle of Philanthropy, and after that he was at the Council on Foundations. So he understands the nonprofit space very well, which means he understands your challenges, understands how important PR and being a thought leader is to your work. And the two of them together know how to build relationships with outlets, not just with journalists, but, you know, also podcasters, Conference organizers. So they understand nonprofits, they understand communications, how to build relationships, and that's what's going to get you heard across all media. So that's Turn2. Turn2 Communications. Your story is their mission. turn-2.co. Now back to In Nonprofits Do We Trust?

Gene TakagiIt takes me to another tangent though, now that you talked about efficiency, Tony, and that's kind of— we've talked about it before, and you've talked about it with the writers of an article or a letter called The Overhead Myth. I don't know if you recall that.

Tony MartignettiSure, that was many years ago. Yes, the CEOs of Charity Navigator, Better Business Bureau, Wise Giving Alliance, and GuideStar.

Gene TakagiYep. Yeah. And, you know, they were saying that we shouldn't, you know, base ratings on a charity in terms of how worthy they are to receive funds from donors simply based on overhead ratio, you know, what their admin and fundraising costs are relative to their programmatic costs. And, you know, those are really wise, wise words that were stated in that letter. But even today, we still see organizations, even high-profile ones, that talk about their low overhead ratio, and it can engender trust in their organization at the expense of trust of other organizations that legitimately have higher overhead ratios, because the infrastructures and, and, you know, the things that they need to do may be completely different. So it's not fair to, you know, compare across the board and across the maturity of an organization. So yeah.

Tony MartignettiAnother very valuable thing to invest in is Is research. Research, uh, maybe in— maybe going beyond research, activating a new program that, you know, that may or may not succeed, but you have to invest up front. You know, that it's annoying, the folks who hold different opinions about wise investment in technology. You know, Uber should be losing money for the first 12 years. You know, because it's investing in the future. Tesla, you know, nonprofit, unprofitable for many years, but, you know, look where they are now. But, but in the nonprofit sector, you know, we don't, we don't allow that, that research and spending on innovation. We consider that overhead, like, you know, like rent, which, well, rent happens to be important too, but, you know, something Something— rent's not a good example, but as sort of frivolous or self-indulgent when it could very well be research and scaling up for a dynamic future.

Gene TakagiOr even things like a living wage. There's a cost to that.

Tony MartignettiYeah, good. Exactly. Thank you. Yes. Yeah, I don't like the double standard. We praise it in some industries, but we criticize it in nonprofits. And I'm thinking specifically about investment in the future, and whether that's people or programs or even technology. I mean, technology is a valuable investment. It saves time, it creates productivity, it makes people more comfortable at work, it enables them to work out of an office now and be remote, give them that benefit which so many people are craving now, you know. But these are, these are all wise investments, not, not, um, detrimental overhead.

Gene TakagiYeah, I absolutely agree. And there's a way to do it cheap. You could invest in technology on the cheap, and that might have long-term adverse consequences. Including to kind of the sort of the data protection and the privacy issues that can result. So if you're really thinking ahead and investing in not only just technology just to be sort of more effective and efficient in the short term, but protective of your beneficiaries and your staff and others, your donors, in the long term, then you need to make more of an investment in that. Yeah. And that's another thing where, you know, we lose trust if you, if you sort of blow your, your donor lists that are supposed to be private and, you know, other big companies get a hold of it and start to target your donor base for unrelated things, or even if they're related sometimes but not your organization, and it was due to a slip on your part or your technology and information technology protocols, you can run into trouble. So again, investments have a double-edged sword. They're great. But they can result in, in a loss of trust too, if you're not managing it properly and you compromise people's information.

Tony MartignettiYeah. And also, you know, you mentioned living wage, but investing in people so that people stay with your organization. All right. And that starts with a living wage. I mean, that also impacts on technology, you know, time away, professional development. You know, these are, these are investments in staff that people see and appreciate and make longevity with your organization more likely than, you know, than, than to jump ship every 6 months.

Gene TakagiAnd that builds trust too, right? I'm much more comfortable working with you if you've been with the charity for 10 years, Tony, than if you were hired 3 months ago and there's always a different person I'm talking to as a donor.

Tony MartignettiAbsolutely. Yeah. All right, you have some insights into what we as a community, or hopefully even individual nonprofits, can, can start to think about, take to their CEOs, take to their boards. This is always where you excel, Gene.

Gene TakagiWell, the first steps are kind of simple. You know, it's be compliant yourself, make sure your own house is in order. So we can sort of raise all of the issues with where you can lose trust with organizations. But even though 99.9% of the organizations are well-intentioned, I can't say that 99.9% of the organizations are compliant. So working to make sure you're compliant, working to make sure that the tone is set at the top with a strong board of directors that is actually providing direction and oversight, and not just simply helping you, you know, with fundraising and otherwise just rubber stamping the decisions of the leaders. I think it really is important that the tone be set at the top of the organization through the board of directors.

Tony MartignettiA tone— say more about the tone.

Gene TakagiSo the tone of placing the importance of a trusting relationship with our beneficiaries, with our employees, with our other stakeholders. I think that's really important, and that should be reflected in policies. So it's not good enough to say, you know, this is what we believe in. So the, you know, one of the hot topics today is a board sets a diversity, equity, and inclusion policy.

Tony MartignettiYeah.

Gene TakagiBut if that policy just sits on the shelf and that's the end of the discussion of it, and there are no actual changes or action plans attached to that, that's going to maybe harm the organization more than help it. So The tone at the top means a board that is doing its role in moving that organization forward and focusing not only on doing good work and metrics for programmatic success, but on building trust within and outside of the organization.

Tony MartignettiAnd that CEO-board chair, CEO-executive committee, if the board has an executive committee relationship, is key to this. I mean, they, they all, whether it's 2 people or the CEO and a committee, you know, need to be, uh, so, you know, committed to the same— not only the same mission, but the same, uh, strategy for getting there, you know, the same commitment to the things that you're talking about. This needs to be a, a unified working group at, at the top between the CEO and the board leadership.

Gene TakagiYeah, it's absolutely critical, Tony. I agree. There is, however, sort of another dimension to this which adds complexity, and that's kind of the feeling amongst particularly younger generations again, and why there's a little bit of distrust, is too much power focused on the top of an organization without sort of distributing leadership and the right to participate in this, you know, the bigger decisions of the organization being dispersed throughout the organization and getting input from beneficiaries about, you know, how the organization should evolve or move forward in furthering its purpose. If we're not really thinking about getting other voices in it, and particularly if our boards are not very diverse, Mm-hmm. that's gonna engender more distrust as well. with, with an organization and its leadership. So while what's happening at the top level and the relationship between the CEO and the chair of the board is critically important, it is really important to also make sure that leadership authority and power is being dispersed down through the organization and that the board actually can listen to directly input from some of the staff. And we shouldn't create like a wall between board and staff completely. You know, that there's a little bit of new thinking on that, 'cause the old ways, it's like the board should not micromanage, right? We should not interfere with staff decisions. Yeah. Which is partly true, but it doesn't mean that we create a complete block so the board members don't see the staff members and the staff don't see the board and they just don't know each other. So there is a sort of, A balance there that needs to be taken.

Tony MartignettiCan we, can we say a little more about that in terms of examples of how this could be done? Like, you're— so you're talking about staff, but also the beneficiaries of the, of the programmatic work. Uh, is this, um, like— I mean, certainly beneficiaries could be members of the board, or is it more an advisory committee? But then To your point, you know, you don't want it to just be a committee that the board doesn't listen to, the CEO doesn't listen to. You know, how can we, uh, actually execute on, on some of this in terms of staff and, and beneficiaries?

Gene TakagiSo there are a lot of different ways that it might be done, and there's no one right way for, you know, for all organizations. But getting other voices involved can be done in, you know, through committees, as you suggested, but they can't just be advisory. If you're really gonna disperse power, you have to give them some power, even if they're not made up of only board members. And some people call any committee that is not composed of only board members, they call them advisory committees. And because of the name, they think that they can only give advice to the board, but they don't have any management authority. But that's not true. You can give these other committees management authority the way you can give a CEO or CFO management authority. Mm-hmm. The board can delegate authority down to these other committees, these non-board committees as well. So that may be one way of getting power dispersed through the organization. That committee might be made up of some employees, some beneficiaries, and maybe there is a pipeline so that some of the other people that you'd like to put onto a board, but you might not know very well, or you might not have enough experience in certain things that you'd like to have them develop more knowledge of the organization and the work before they're possibly a strong candidate for joining the board. But that could be a vehicle or an on-ramp to being a board member as well. And again, creating a more diverse and stronger board with diverse perspectives and understandings of what the organization does and who it impacts. So I think there are definitely ways, and we've seen this in other models as well, some that have worked with some organizations and same models not working with other organizations. Holacracy is sort of one example of that. What is that?

Tony MartignettiJargon jail. Holacracy?

Gene TakagiHolacracy is a form of management where there are still remnants of hierarchy, but a lot of decision-making is made in kind of circles. And circles might be employees, they might be employees and others, and circles have certain autonomy over their body of decision-making. So you might have a circle based on HR issues. So it's not just one person with the final say, it's this circle or a group. In the law, we would just call it another committee. Yeah. But in Holacracy, they're all circles. And this was used by some high-profile for-profit companies and some nonprofits. Some had success with it, some didn't. There are other models out there as well. Not one size will fit all, but again, there's an administrative cost to trying to implement new models. But new models are maybe the way that we want to go, and there are movement organizations all over the place that are impacting how nonprofits and for-profits are to be governed and managed. And we should be listening to some of these forces that are out there because they will gradually shape what we're doing. You can see this by younger people not sticking with employment as long as they were, the Great Resignation and stuff. If you feel powerless within an organization, or if you don't feel the organization is representing what you want your employer to be doing, they may not stay. And having a little bit of say in what the organization is doing, even if it's just the starting points, because you can't jump from point A to, you know, to the ideal point in one step, it's going to take a long— Right. a long time to get there, but just to seeing that progress may be a sign to somebody to, to say, I'm going to stick around here and find out.

Tony MartignettiAll right, creating vehicles for, right, people's voices to be heard. Um, and you're right, it's, it's incremental, but just the, just the showing of some progress, some initiative to, uh, Opening up the leadership, opening up strategic decision-making could be, it could be, uh, you know, valuable to folks, right? And encourage them to, to stay versus looking for someplace that's more inclusive.

Gene TakagiYeah, you know, if your CEO doesn't trust the board, or if your employees don't trust the CEO, how are you going to expect donors and your beneficiaries to trust the organization? So it really— trust has to be built throughout the organization.

Tony MartignettiIt's time for a break. Fourth Dimension Technologies. Are you seeing technology as the investment that it is? Not as an expense, but an investment in your sustainability, your staff productivity, your staff happiness, satisfaction? An investment in your donor relations through your CRM database. It's an investment in your organization's work and its future. That's what technology— that's the way technology ought to be thought of. And Fourth Dimension, 4D, For short, can help you make those investments wisely so that you're not squandering on something you don't really need. Like maybe your backup is sufficient, but you need the multifactor authentication installed, etc. So, you know, they can help you think through smart technology investments. That's it. 4D. And you know where the listener landing page is to check them out? It's at tony.ma/4d. Fantastic. /4D, which by the way is just like 3D, but they go one dimension deeper. Let's return to In Nonprofits Do We Trust? What else do you see, Jean, as things we can think about besides this sort of distributed— I'm calling it distributed leadership, or maybe you called it distributed leadership. Yeah.

Gene TakagiSo other things, maybe some simple tips: guard private data. We talked a little bit about it before with technology. If you've got data that you're promising that will be kept confidential. Make sure you're guarding that. Be careful about automating and depersonalizing interactions with technology as well. Like, we could have a sort of a voicemail for everybody and, you know, hit 1 if you want to do this, hit 2 if you want to do this, and completely not let any donor speak to any individual without, you know, spending an hour on the phone. That may not be seen as something that would build trust. So we have to be careful of our uses of technology there as well in our communications. Yeah. If you're going to say something, don't talk the talk if you're not going to walk the walk, right? So don't make promises that you're not going to keep. Well,

Tony Martignettithat, for an example of that, is a DEI policy.

Gene TakagiRight, exactly.

Tony MartignettiWritten and never, never executed, or remains written once and never evolves.

Gene TakagiAnd if you have a campaign to engage in a particular you know, program and you don't raise enough money, and so that program never runs, you better be explaining this to your donors of why that happened and the possibility that that might happen when you start fundraising for it. So don't just say, oh, you know, after the fact when they complain, that said, well, we didn't raise enough, so we used your money for other things. That's not going to engender trust. Remember, your mission and your beneficiaries don't exist in a vacuum, right? So it's not just about your organization, and if your numbers go up, whatever metrics that you use, financial performance or number of beneficiaries served, whatever they are, you shouldn't look at it as a silo. You should be looking at the entire ecosystem in which you are participating, and that would be, you know, open up things like environmentalism. Right. Like, you might not think environmental— your organization is not an environmental organization, but if climate change continues and creates hardships that, you know, scientists are predicting, it probably will have an impact on your mission and your beneficiaries. And so to sort of think just, you know, outside of that silo, you want to be thinking about what your impact of your decisions will be, not only on your organization and beneficiaries, but on your allied organizations and on the broader community, and what will that do to trust as well?

Tony MartignettiSo a lot of these ideas, a lot of what you're saying, could be, you know, germinating in an advisory committee. You know, how could we look differently at, at our contribution to climate change, and what climate change means to us in the future, for our, for our, for our people and for our work? But also, what could we be doing right now, you know, Even if we're not an environmental organization siloed, as you're saying, you know, we still have an environmental impact. So what, what contribution to minimize climate change or reverse climate change can we make, as well as planning for the future? You know, those kinds of conversations can come out of these advisory committees that are comprised of staff and beneficiaries. I mean, these are the folks that— Right. Live the mission day to day.

Gene TakagiYeah, I love that idea too, Tony. Sometimes the board may not have or feel that they have the bandwidth to sort of discuss these sort of broader issues, and they're a little bit more focused. So having the help of an advisory committee on an issue like climate change for a non-environmental organization or an organization whose mission is not focused on the environment, I think that would be great.

Tony MartignettiYeah, and I want to reiterate your point, which I had never thought of. Advisory committees can be granted policymaking authority and change within the organization. So whatever that looks like, you know, you can bestow that authority.

Gene TakagiYeah, absolutely. And you can give them a budget to even sort of to live with this.

Tony MartignettiPutting money behind it. Yeah, money talks. That's a, that's a big step. Granting them a budget, granting them some, granting them authority to make change, that's empowering an advisory committee. All right.

Gene TakagiI think, you know, one area of trust that we haven't spoken of yet, but maybe why I, as a lawyer, am talking about these things and you're not getting it from another consultant, is that the laws can also impact trust, and nonprofits have to decide whether they want to set a position on certain laws. And some of the things that I'm thinking about is the deductibility of charitable contributions. So we've had an above-the-line contribution where non-itemizers could deduct as well because of COVID but that was just temporary. And now there's sort of a push for, well, we should make a charitable contribution deductible to all taxpayers and not just about the 10% of taxpayers who itemize, who tend to be, you know, have a little bit more wealth, or some, in some cases, a lot more than those who don't itemize.

Tony MartignettiIs it that small? The proportion of taxpayers who itemize is around 10%?

Gene Takagi10 to 13% is what I'm hearing.

Tony MartignettiOh my gosh. Okay.

Gene TakagiSo, um, again, you know, part of trust and distrust has to do with concentrations of power and wealth, right? And when the 1% or the 0.1% controls so much policy, control the leadership of pivotal organizations in all sectors and in government, there's going to be a distrust of institutions. Again, that, you know, one-third of people distrust big institutions.

Tony MartignettiYeah.

Gene TakagiAnd, you know, that concentration of wealth and power is the reason why. So laws that sort of enforce that— so if we just give, you know, deductible— make tax benefits to richer people who can deduct or who can itemize their deductions and not to others, that may feel really unfair to the public and another reason for distrust. So will your organizations— even though tax policy is probably almost no organization's mission, it has an impact. And so it may be something that organizations want to take a look at. And there are organizations like Independent Sector, the National Council on Nonprofits, and others who The Tax Policy Center that, that can explain this a little bit, but you may want to take a look and see if you want to put a position on it. And one of the things that I also think engendered distrust is when the media misreports the law. And one area where they've misreported it is a lot of media say charities can't lobby, and that's just not true. So charities can lobby on things like You know, the, the above-the-line deduction, and, and on other things as well. And there are just certain limits that apply, but they're often generous. So learn a little bit more, and we can build a stronger sector.

Tony MartignettiWell, you and I have talked about the, the lobbying limits on previous shows. Is it, is it safe to say that the law hasn't changed over the past I don't know, 2, 3 years maybe since you and I have talked about this.

Gene TakagiYeah, the law hasn't changed.

Tony MartignettiOkay, so, so at tonymartignetti.com, you can search Gene Takagi, you'll find many episodes that he's on. And one or, one or two are about the lobbying limits. I think, I think the last time may have been 2020, when the pre-election— so we may— well, with the, with the election in late the election in late 2020. So we may have done something like in mid-2020 or so on the lobbying exemption, or— well, that's not the right phrase— the limits of lobbying. And you make the— you just said, you know, they are generous in some cases. It's not that it has to be a de minimis proportion of your budget or something.

Gene TakagiYeah,

Tony Martignettithe loss is too much detail.

Gene TakagiYeah, the loss is insubstantial, which scares the majority of charities away from doing any of it. But, um, it turns out it can be fairly generous limits to engaging in lobbying.

Tony MartignettiOkay. Um, and the, the point that you made before that, uh, I was going to say something about that too. What— sorry, what, what did you say right before you were talking about the, uh, The, the permissibility of some lobbying activities. You made a point.

Gene TakagiUh, deductible contributions above the—

Tony MartignettiOh yes, thank you. The last thing we want is for donating to charity to be perceived as, uh, as an elitist activity that only the, only the top— now you're saying whatever, 10 or 13% of, of the population can, can give because they're the only ones who get the advantage Because they're the only— they're the ones who itemize their deductions. The last thing we want is for donating to charities to be perceived as an elitist activity.

Gene TakagiYeah, absolutely, Tony. And with, you know, with our current tax policy, how it works, um, and I don't want to get too complicated with that, we are seeing a shrinking middle class. I don't think there's anything denying that. People, most people have less discretionary income. So If we look at the fundraising statistics now, or the giving statistics, we see that even if giving goes up, giving from kind of the middle class and smaller donors has shrunk. Mm-hmm. And quite significantly. And it's the people that have put in huge contributions that have made up for that. So the Mackenzie Scott, you know, with I think $13 billion over the last few years. They're making up for that, but that can change the way nonprofits run if it's all about, again, elite, wealthy, powerful individuals who make the big contributions that then have the ear of the boards of these organizations that then talk about policy and they create policy or advocate for policies that keep that dynamic in existence. So it is problematic.

Tony MartignettiIt's time for Tony's Take Two. My latest video on LinkedIn is This Is Not Planned Giving. It's short, under 2 minutes. I give you an example of what is not planned giving and remind you what planned giving is, how simple planned giving is when it's done right, when you start with simple gifts by will. But I've got kind of a lighthearted back way of looking at it through what planned giving isn't in the opening. So, latest video on LinkedIn. You'll find me on LinkedIn. My name is Tony Martignetti, by the way, in case that has escaped you. And it's my latest video there. Okay. That is Tony's Take Two. We've got beaucoup buttloads more time for In Nonprofits Do We Trust with Gene Takagi. Look at this dark potential that people look at the United States as, all right, the wealthy control government because of dark money and, and the Citizens United decision in the Supreme Court. Wealthy control business because only wealthy people start and/or run businesses and grow them, and only white males have the access to capital to start businesses. And then the perception that the wealthy control the nonprofit sector, you know, and the wealthy control the media. You know, this is all very A very detrimental, very dark, cynical way of looking at the, at the country, but I'm not, I'm not sure that we're that far away from it.

Gene TakagiYeah, I agree, Tony. And I think past generations, you know, including ours, you know, we've always kind of done better than our parents. Our parents were lucky enough to put us in that position. But the younger generations now, economically, and maybe, you know, health-wise and mental health-wise, they may not be doing as well as their parents overall. Yeah. And they're questioning kind of the system because of that. And we maybe didn't question it because our generation did better than our parents in those terms. But now there is just legitimate questioning of, do we need to change these policies and these dynamics and these power structures? And, you know, organizations have a say in this and Use your voice. Get, get people to vote. Maybe that'll be my, my, one of my big messages: vote.

Tony MartignettiVoting is fundamental too, although, you know, in a lot of states that's being eroded. It's becoming more difficult, although in a lot of states it's easier too. You know, another thing that comes to mind when, you know, you're talking about the generations below them, the boomers not doing as well as the one before them. The FDA just yesterday recommended mental health screening at regular doctor visits, like an annual health checkup for everybody under 65. And they had been considering this policy, this recommendation— it's just a recommendation to the medical community— From, from, for years before the pandemic. This is not, this is not pandemic-related recommendation. They had been considering this for years before the pandemic, that there's a lot of stress and anxiety among the population under 65. And 65 is basically the baby boomer cutoff.

Gene TakagiYeah,

Tony Martignettiwithin a couple of years.

Gene TakagiAnd then, you know, as, as you noted, this was even before COVID that they've been advocating for this. And now with COVID and the mental health issues that are sort of go along with not just the disease, but the isolation that many are experiencing. And long COVID, which is sort of an underappreciated, underrecognized problem in disabilities, may be creating more disabled Americans than anything since, you know, World War II, I think would be the last one. It's just, it's mind-blowing.

Tony MartignettiAnd all this does contribute to a decline in trust in all institutions, and nonprofit— the nonprofit community is a major institution in the country. So, you know, that's, that's how this is all related to what you and I are talking about. I want to make that connection explicit, that anxiety among the population creates anxiety for nonprofits and, and, and distrust and disbelief in In nonprofit work, whether that's justified or not, perception is reality.

Gene TakagiYeah, I agree, Tony.

Tony MartignettiAll right. I don't know. So we had, we had said one of the things we were going to talk about is what happens if, what happens if this continues? I mean, I already painted a pretty dark, cynical scenario. Is there anything more you want to say around, you know, what What the implications are if, if the community doesn't start to help itself?

Gene TakagiWell, maybe on a more micro-looking basis, it just means for, for a charity, they're gonna experience diminished fundraising. Not everybody gets Mackenzie Scott, Jeff Bezos money, right? Most of them are relying upon a pool of donors, many of which are aging. And may age out of their donor pool, and a shrinking, again, middle class, shrinking discretionary income for many people, meaning less donations. We might see more direct giving to individuals as people are saying, well, I don't trust charities overall. I'd rather just give to my friends who say, you know, somebody is in need, as crowdfunding sites just continue to grow. in importance and also in power as well. And that's just gonna be to the detriment of, you know, beneficiaries of our charity. So again, in that micro level, we make less money, people trust us less, our employee retention is less, our donor pool is shrinking, and we can help less people even as the need for our services increases. So that's kind of the dark— Hmm. side look of it. We can try to be the nonprofit that stands out and, you know, is the trustworthy nonprofit from a public perception standpoint. That's good. But again, don't see yourself in a silo. Lift yourself up with all the boats in the water and really try to strengthen the nonprofit sector where you can. And advocating on some of the laws that make things more fair, I think, is a good start there.

Tony Martignettiadvocating. Maybe there's a way of partnering with other organizations. Not, not in all, in all things. I don't mean a legal formal partnership, but, uh, you know, if there's, uh, if there's a way of working together for an event or, uh, or some kind of advocacy, you know, that we've had shows on, on the, the values of that and how to do that. So that everybody, you know, so that it's not seen as a zero-sum within your community, that if someone else, if some other organization is benefiting, then you're losing. That, you know, that's not the way to look at the world and at nonprofit support. We all could be, or a couple of organizations together could be Rising together.

Gene TakagiYeah, I'll add that the, that independent sector survey, the Edelman Data and Intelligence Survey that we mentioned at the start of the show, also has some tips on building up trust within the sector. So it's not all a dark outlook. It's just encouraging people that the importance of this is very, very high. So let's go out and actually make things happen so that that dark outlook doesn't happen.

Tony MartignettiWithin Independent Sector, Gene, what's the, what's the name of the— you're saying Edelman Data?

Gene TakagiYeah, I think they contracted out with Edelman, E-D-E-L-M-A-N, Data and Intelligence. And their 3rd annual report— this is an annual report— is available on the Independent Sector website.

Tony MartignettiOkay, thank you. Edelman, E-D-E-L-M-A-N.

Gene TakagiCorrect.

Tony MartignettiOkay. Okay. You mentioned the 501s a little bit, but there have been a couple in the news very recently, most recently the Patagonia company's sort of evolution into a new nonprofit, a new 501. nonprofit, the Holdfast Collective.

Gene TakagiYeah, so the founder of Patagonia and his family, remember, they were the principal owners of Patagonia, and they decided to give up ownership of the company. But they gave it not to a charity, but to a 501 organization. It's called a social welfare organization. And for listeners who aren't maybe familiar with it, you probably are familiar with many 501 organizations themselves, like the NRA, Planned Parenthood, the ACLU, Sierra Club. So these are advocacy organizations that have kind of charitable-like purposes, but are— can engage in unlimited lobbying and can engage in electioneering or political campaign intervention, supporting political candidates and political parties, as long as that's not their primary activity or purpose. So this is sort of the source, or one of the big sources, of where dark money comes in. Tony, that you mentioned with the Citizens United decision before, a donor that wants to support a candidate but stay hidden from public view about their support of the candidate, rather than giving directly to the candidate, could give to a 501 organization, and the organization can get their monies into the candidate, and the donor that is disclosed is the C4 organization, not the donor to the C4 organization. So that's how you can create dark money. And with the Patagonia case, it's very clear who the donor was, so we don't expect that to be the dark money that we're as leery of. Mm-hmm. But it's still, you know, a huge gift, which, you know, for somebody who believes in the environmental movement, I think is a great gift. But news media are misreporting it, or some news media are misreporting it as kind of something that doesn't get a tax benefit because a donor doesn't get an income tax deduction for giving to a 501 organization the way they do if they gave to a charity. But there are other tax exemptions that apply, like a gift tax exemption or an estate tax exemption. So this gift is overall saving Mr. Chouinard, the owner, and his family probably somewhere in the realm of $800 million in taxes. So it is not completely a no-tax-benefit transaction. Again, this is not to disparage them for taking advantage of a system that allows for these gifts to go with, with some tax benefits, but it's not just the income tax deduction that matters in donations. There are For very wealthy people like billionaires, the gift and estate tax exemptions, which can be 40%, right? So it can be very, very high, higher than income tax. They matter. And so that's something to be aware of, that this is a very wealthy person who gave up much of the ownership share, I guess all of his ownership shares, to this 501 organization, except really importantly, 2% of the gift, overall gift, was given to a trust that's not a nonprofit.

Tony MartignettiYeah, those are the voting— those are the 2% of the voting that are the voting shares,

Gene Takagiright? So because they're in control of that trust with, with some close advisors, um, they've not given control up of Patagonia, right? They still can control Patagonia. Um, and again, They're taking advantage of existing law, what it allows, but it allows billionaires to not give up control of their company, get an $800 million tax benefit for giving, or, you know, $3 billion to a 501 organization that could spend nearly half of it on endorsing political candidates. So it's kind of an interesting tax system. Yeah.

Tony MartignettiAnd if you consider that, you know, supportive of a liberal progressive cause, because the Hold Fast Collective, the new C4, is devoted to the ill effects of climate change and trying, you know, reversing climate change, impacting climate change. So if you consider that a left cause, then there's an example on the right side, with, uh, Mr. Barsid and the, the Marble Freedom Trust, another 501.

Gene TakagiYeah, and that is led by Leonard Leo, who may be the person most responsible for the changing of our Supreme Court, and therefore the decisions, um, that on, on things like abortion might be largely attributed to Mr.

Tony MartignettiLeo. He's a fundraiser and, uh, activist and very well-connected guy in conservative circles.

Gene TakagiYeah, and used to be executive vice president of the Federalist Society, whose, you know, mission was to change the composition of the Supreme Court. So I don't think that's controversial. That's just what their goal was, and they were very effective at achieving that goal. But this $1.6 billion, kind of same thing. There are some tax benefits that go along with it. There's no income tax deduction. And Mr. Seed passed away. I think this was given after his death. But another big contribution to an organization led by somebody who has immense influence and now a huge war chest that can be used for political activities. Again, the primary activity cannot be political campaign intervention. But some people believe, or many people believe, that means 49% of the funds can be used for political campaign intervention. And that's kind of the source of dark money. Although again, in this case, we do know where the donor came from. Mm-hmm. So it's not dark in that way in terms of hidden donors, but it's still donations that didn't go directly to the political candidate. It went through a 501 first, get the tax benefits for that. Which his heirs, I guess, would appreciate. And the impact of that again is, is that, well, in both cases, very wealthy people are able to keep control with people who they trust or their family members of their money to be used for political purposes. They can't use it for themselves to, you know, to buy huge houses and boats, but they can use it for things that were very important to them. But that means for people like us and most of your listeners, Tony, it's like, what influence do we have compared to that individual who gave billions of dollars to influence political elections? And, you know, what, you know, did— can we change our Supreme Court sort of composition the way that they're able to do?

Tony MartignettiYeah.

Gene TakagiProbably not by ourselves. So it It again is, is a reason why people go, hey, these are nonprofits that they're using to do this. I don't trust nonprofits. This is what they're used for. And charities kind of get lumped in because the ordinary, you know, people, the layperson doesn't know the difference between a 501 and 501 organization.

Tony MartignettiRight. Yeah, and that's right. And it's, it's, if it's mentioned in a, in, in press coverage, you know, it's mentioned in passing that It's, it's an organization that's distinguished from, from, uh, charities, uh, but, you know, it's like, it's like a sentence or two, you know. It's, it's never, it's, it's never a focal point. So your point is correct that people just lump them all together.

Gene TakagiAnd dark money flows through nonprofits, right? And that's why we shouldn't trust nonprofits.

Tony MartignettiSo the wealthy control government and they can— and politics, and they control business. And media and nonprofits.

Gene TakagiYeah, that's, that's what we, we're finding more and more is the case. But we're trying to, to change policies and change minds about this so that we can see that the impact of the 99.9% out there is actually even bigger than the impact that we've mentioned about a few individuals. It just has to be organized, and nonprofits are a way to do that.

Tony MartignettiWell, that's a pretty good way to close. Probably we should have closed with what our community can do, but you're suffering the lackluster host, so you can rewind to that section and then fast forward. You can end with that if you want to. But Gene, you know, always thank you, you know, sort of reality, but also wisdom and inspiration. And not only ethereal pedagogical inspiration, but, you know, ideas that we can act on. So thank you. Thank you.

Gene TakagiThank you, Tony. And your closing statement is actually always the greatest ending. So I'm looking forward to hearing it.

Tony MartignettiOkay, all right, thank you, Gene. Next week, let's see what develops. And why, why do I even say, uh, next week if I don't know what's coming up next week? But we're here, we are, we're talking about trust, and part of that is transparency. So I'm being transparent that I don't know what next week's show is going to be. I know what the one 2 weeks from now is going to be. We're going to have Beth Kanter and Allison Fine talking about their new book, but I can't promise that for next week because, well, that would be a lie and that's going to breach the trust because they're not on next week. Next week, uh, it's up in the air, but trust me, it'll be— trust me, that's conclusory. Just trust me. No, I hope you trust Nonprofit Radio. Thank you. I'll find something good. If you missed any part of this week's show, I beseech you, find it at tonymartignetti.com. We're sponsored by Turn 2 Communications, PR and content for nonprofits. Your story is their mission. turn-2.co. And by Fourth Dimension Technologies, IT infra in a box, the affordable tech solution for nonprofits. tony.ma/ 4D, just like 3D, but they go one dimension deeper. Our creative producer is Claire Meyerhoff. The show's social media is by Susan Chavez. Marc Silverman is our web guy, and this music is by Scott Stein. You're a natural! Thank you for that affirmation, Scotty. Be with me next week for Nonprofit Radio, Big Nonprofit Ideas for the Other 95%. Here it is, Gene. Go out and be great.

Nonprofit Radio