Skip to content
EP 703August 12, 2024

Get Heard In The Election Season

Tony MartignettiPeter Panepento
Nonprofit Radio
Episode 703
0:00 / 0:00

About this episode

Peter Panepento returns with savvy advice about getting your messages heard through crowded, noisy channels for the rest of this year. He urges you to prepare your messaging, prepare to pivot away from that messaging, and more. Plus, the value of journalist relationships. Peter comes to us from Turn Two Communications.

Here’s the transcript

Tony MartignettiHello and welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. I am your aptly named host and the podfather of your favorite hebdomadal podcast. Oh, I'm glad you're with us. I'd be thrown into dentinogenesis if you tried to gum me up with the idea that you missed this week's show. Here's our associate producer Kate with what's coming.

Kate MartignettiHey Tony, it's Get Heard in the Election Season. Peter Panepento returns with savvy advice about getting your messages heard through crowded, noisy channels for the rest of this year. He urges you to prepare your messaging, prepare to pivot away from that messaging, and more. Plus, the value of journalist relationships. Peter comes to us from Turn Two Communications on Tony's Take Two.

Tony MartignettiHails from the gym. This is Blood and Soil.

Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by Virtuous. Virtuous gives you the nonprofit CRM, fundraising, volunteer, and marketing tools you need to create more responsive donor experiences and grow giving. virtuous.org. And by DonorBox. Outdated donation forms blocking your supporters' generosity? DonorBox, fast, flexible, and friendly fundraising forms for your nonprofit. donorbox.org. Here is Get Heard in the Election Season.

Tony MartignettiIt's a pleasure to welcome back Peter Panepento. He is the co-founder and managing partner for Turn Two, a communications and PR agency specializing in nonprofits, foundations, and organizations serving the the greater good. He began as a journalist, including more than a decade at the Chronicle of Philanthropy, where he advanced to assistant managing editor. You'll find the company at turn-two.co, and Peter is @PeterPanepento on X. He's also on LinkedIn. Welcome back to Nonprofit Radio, Peter.

Peter PanepentoGreat to be back, Tony. It's been a while, but it's great to see you. I've had a chance to share the microphone with you several times over the years. It's always great to do this.

Tony MartignettiIndeed. And our avid listeners will recall that your name, you as a guest, were the answer to one of the quiz questions on our 700th show.

Peter PanepentoWow.

Tony MartignettiYes, our creative producer, Claire Meyerhoff, Brought Claire's quiz to the 700th show, and it was a quiz for it was for me and then all the folks that were with us. This one was directed at me, and the question was which I believe it was five-time guest has initials that would be funny to a kindergartner.

Peter PanepentoThat's why she get that correct.

Tony MartignettiThat's why she's the creative producer. I did get the I did get it correct. There aren't that. Many people who've been on 5 times. And then I thought of PP and I knew it was—

Peter PanepentoYes. Yes. Do I get like a robe like you do when you're a 5-timer on Saturday Night Live or anything like that? Or is it—

Tony MartignettiWell, now this is your 6th one. So yeah, now you have to wait till 10.

Peter PanepentoOkay.

Tony MartignettiThere was— we instituted something for 5 after your 5th. So you didn't qualify on the 5th.

Peter PanepentoI see. So I'll do 10 and then you'll start something.

Tony MartignettiNow you'll have to wait till my 11th. Assuming the timing works out.

Peter PanepentoYes, yes.

Tony MartignettiUh, you'll, you'll get a crystal obelisk, uh, with 10 if the timing, if the timing is right.

Peter PanepentoYes.

Tony MartignettiSo, uh, you have your, uh, biweekly newsletter, your, your turn-to email newsletter that I'm sub— I subscribe to and that I think folks should subscribe to. Where, first of all, let's, let's, let's acquaint folks with how they can get on your newsletter list so they may, they may learn of future nonprofit radio topics.

Peter PanepentoThat's right. That's how I know.

Tony MartignettiThat's how this one came.

Peter PanepentoWhere do they Where do they find a— You can sign up for the newsletter right on our homepage at turn-two.co, or you can reach out to me and I'll gladly get you added there. Our newsletter is called On Message and you get— we try to do weekly, but it's sometimes in the summer it's biweekly, but you get weekly PR and communications advice that's really specifically focused for people who work in the social good space. So it's really geared towards people who are working for nonprofits and foundations and We really try to make it as practical as possible for folks who are wanting to maximize, maximize their communications and PR for their organizations.

Tony MartignettiOn message. Okay. And so I'm sorry, I credited you all with being always biweekly. I thought it was always biweekly, but I read them whenever they come, as often as they come. I read them.

Peter PanepentoWe're a little slower in the summer, so I think it is.

Tony MartignettiOkay. It was biweekly now. All right. So that's very, that's very gracious of you to say. Thank you. Saving me, and one of the recent ones that you wrote was about crisis communicate. Well, was about not crisis communicate. It was about getting your message heard in our really presidential election cycle. There's nine. We're recording. I believe there are fewer than ninety days left until November fifth. A lot. So there's a lot of messaging around that, obviously, which could be valuable. We could talk about that. There could be hooks there for you. But just, you know, in a crowded media landscape, which is, I think, now typical— to me, it's above average from what it was over, I don't know, well, you've now— you and I have known each other for about 14 years. I think the level of communications, the level of attention grabbing, uh, by all media and all channels, you know, has, has increased. There are, there are more, there are more places that want our attention, and then that's amplified by the presidential cycle that we're in. And nonprofits still have important messages that need to be heard.

Peter PanepentoAbsolutely. It— I think you're absolutely right that it's becoming increasingly hard or difficult for us to be able to get our messages heard given the amount of noise that there is out there. And if you think about what has already happened in this presidential election season, you know, we've had an assassination attempt, we've had a, you know, criminal convictions, we've had Joe Biden, you know, doing his bombshell, you know, dropping out of the race. We had the fallout from the first debate. If you had tried to get all of this into an episode of the West or season of The West Wing, you would have been told you were jumping the shark.

Tony MartignettiYeah, right. The Republican convention and the Democratic convention is coming up in a couple weeks,

Peter Panepentoright? Yeah, that hasn't even happened yet. Yeah, when this is being recorded. So, and in each— and all of these things just create so much noise in the media and in social media that it becomes really hard for nonprofits that are vying for the public's attention to get their voice heard. You have to, to really be ready to kind of roll with the punches, capture opportunities that happen, but also be really willing to kind of scrap your best-laid plans in the wake of bombshell news as it happens. It really requires you to be both prepared and adaptable at the same time.

Tony MartignettiYou had 4 major points in the on-message email that I received that stimulated me to email you and say, let's talk about this on Nonprofit Radio. And your first one is to create a new or review your crisis communications plan. You and I talked about crisis communications plans years ago,

Peter Panepentoright?

Tony MartignettiSo we'll hit a couple of those points. But why, you know, why is that essential now in our extra crowded media landscape?

Peter PanepentoYes, it's really important for organizations to have a crisis communications or rapid response communications protocol or plan because things are happening so quickly, you need to really be equipped to get your message out quickly or make a decision about getting a statement out, you know, and be able to do it in a way where you can respond while the news is fresh. So a lot of organizations will kind of wait for something to happen. They'll have a discussion about whether they need to put a statement out. They'll have to get it reviewed by, you know, the executive director and/or board of the organization. And by the time they do all of that, they've missed the moment. It's been, you know, days have passed by the time you've kind of gone through all those steps and you've either missed the moment or you've gotten run over by what's happened.

Kate MartignettiIt's time for a break. Virtuous is a software company committed to helping nonprofits grow generosity. Virtuous believes that generosity has the power to create profound change in the world and in the heart of the giver. It's their mission to move the needle on global generosity by helping nonprofits better connect with and inspire their givers. Responsive fundraising puts the donor at the center of fundraising and grows giving through personalized donor journeys that respond to the needs of each individual. Virtuous is the only responsive nonprofit CRM designed to help you build deeper relationships with every donor at scale. Virtuous gives you the nonprofit CRM, fundraising, volunteer marketing, and automation tools you need to create responsive experiences that build trust and grow impact. virtuous.org. Now back to Get Heard in the Election Season.

Tony MartignettiThe moment can last like 12 hours,

Peter Panepentoright? Right. Yes.

Tony MartignettiAnd then, and then the media has moved on and nobody's gonna be interested.

Peter PanepentoThat's right. That's right. And, um, so we really advise having a, a rapid response protocol in place where you have a clear set of steps that you take in response to some too fast-moving news. You kind of know who's equipped to do what. You've game planned some scenarios, and you even have some key messages prepared ahead of time so that when that moment strikes, you know exactly what to do. You can pull things together quickly, and you can get the approvals you need so you don't miss the moment. So that, that's the first thing we recommend everybody do at your organization, and if you have one already, That's a wonderful thing. It's probably smart for you to revisit that a couple times a year, make sure everything's up to speed, that your messages are clear and in good shape, and that, you know, all the key people who are part of that protocol know their roles and have kind of done some prep work ahead of time and are kind of ready and practiced and ready to go.

Tony MartignettiYeah, because a part of that is going to be who the spokesperson or people are.

Peter PanepentoThat's right.

Tony MartignettiYou suggested having messages that are ready, which clearly you may need to tweak based on what it is that's stimulating this move, this need to get into the media, but having something to start with. But who's going to release them? And in what form? Is this social media post? Is this a press release? Is this calling the reporters that hopefully we have relationships with? I mean, what form does it take and who are the people who are doing the work?

Peter PanepentoThat's right, and and it really helps to game out some of those scenarios and know who's going to be your spokesman, who's going to be the person who is putting messages out on social media or by email, and even how to decide how to do that. We've done this with a number of organizations, put these plans together, and the thing we tend to do is is put together almost a matrix. You know, if this happens, here's what we'll do. Here are some of the key messages that we'll want to pull from, and and here's how we'll how we'll you know. what channels we'll use and what way we'll actually deploy the message based on what's happening. And you can game some of this out ahead of time and say, all right, this type of thing is something we would respond to on social media. Here's who needs to be involved. Here's who needs to make the final decision on it. And just having that in place saves you so much time when actual situations arise.

Tony MartignettiWhat could be some triggers that would

Peter PanepentoWell, one would be news that affects your organization or is about your organization. So let's say you're an organization and there's a rumor spreading on social media about one of your key employees or about one of your key donors. You'll want to definitely get the word out quickly about what's true so that a rumor or some You know, conversation that's happening about you doesn't grow legs and become, become a story. In the political realm, it might be one of the political candidates making a major policy statement about your— something that relates directly to your cause and wanting to make sure that you kind of come out and talk about what type of policies you think are important to make sure that you're, you know, accurately and actively being a spokesperson or a champion for your cause. So if, if one of the candidates comes out and says that they want to, you know, bring back the charitable tax deduction for, for anybody who files their taxes rather than just itemizers, there might be something you want to say there. If one of— if you're an environmental nonprofit and one of the candidates says that, you know, we should just go back to, to to the old days of not having the EPA, you'll certainly want to have something to say about that too. So, you know, having, having some key statements in place, um, that really validate what you stand for and, and, and how you would respond in certain situations can help you respond quickly in situations like that.

Tony MartignettiUsing that energy example makes me think of fracking. But, but I think it really— it had like a 6-hour moment And, you know, it was one of the candidates, maybe it was, I think it was Kamala Harris, said something she had in the past. She was completely opposed to fracking, wanted to have a nationwide ban when she was running for president in that cycle. And but now she's, her position has evolved. So if you had something to say about fracking or energy policy, you know, if you saw a hook, You had to act fast because it was not a major— it wasn't like the assassination attempt, but it was in the news.

Peter PanepentoRight.

Tony MartignettiHer position, some people call it flip-flopping. She would say she evolved. It doesn't matter. Fracking was in the news for a while. So if that's related to you, because you're in Virginia or Pennsylvania and maybe your population is affected by fracking adversely or positively, maybe the revenues The stream of revenue from fracking has been valuable for your population in southeastern Pennsylvania. Right. You know, so you want to— but it wasn't a long cycle before fracking was out of the news and then it was old.

Peter PanepentoYeah, that's exactly true. So, you know, being ready for when those situations arise so you can capture the moment is really important. And it can be for even bigger things that have longer news cycles. When the Roe decision came down, by the Supreme Court, I think it was 2 years ago now, the nonprofits that were ready to respond quickly to that and had something in place were the ones that were getting a lot of the media opportunities because they had already articulated, they had their statements and what they were going to say and their spokespeople ready to go and equipped with what to say. So when that decision came down, they weren't scrambling. They, you know, they were able to pull from, well, if this decision comes down, here's what we're going to say, here's who we're going to reach out to, here's how we're going to deploy that message. And they were the ones who were, you know, on television and putting out statements on social media that were getting a lot of attention then too. So it can be for something unexpected like, you know, fracking, you know, being an issue coming out of one of the campaigns, or it can be kind of a major policy or court decision that, you know, that really connects closely to your cause.

Tony MartignettiAnd something that, you know, is coming.

Peter PanepentoRight.

Tony MartignettiWe knew there was going to be a decision about abortion in the United States.

Peter PanepentoThat's right. So you could prepare ahead for that. You can't prepare ahead for everything that a candidate's going to say, especially—

Tony MartignettiRight.

Peter PanepentoA brand new Democratic candidate where we don't know a lot about what she talks about, and a Republican candidate who can really say anything at any time. So, but knowing like what you'll say if your cause does end up in the news, regardless of whether it's a positive or a negative statement from one of the candidates can really help you capture that opportunity.

Tony MartignettiAnd before we move on, I want to apologize to the Pennsylvania residents. Southeastern Pennsylvania is Philadelphia, so there wouldn't be fracking there.

Peter PanepentoYeah, it would probably be more central or western Pennsylvania.

Tony MartignettiYeah, central. Instead of southeast, I probably meant northwest, northeastern, northwest, northeast or central, northeast or central Pennsylvania. All right. I'm sensitive to the listeners in Pennsylvania. I understand. And plus, I went to law school in Philadelphia. You remember how northwest Pennsylvania was.

Peter PanepentoYeah, I think it's all good. Yeah.

Tony MartignettiAnd I went to law school in Philadelphia, so I know there's not fracking on Broad Street or around Rittenhouse Square in Philadelphia. All right. Anything else? Anything else on crisis communications, creating it or reviewing it?

Peter PanepentoI just think it's important to take the time to do that. And, you know, even if you're a small organization, just knowing, you know, who gets the call when something happens or knowing that you might have to have a consultant on call in certain situations, you know, gaming that all out ahead of time just puts you in so much better position when, when real situations arise.

Tony MartignettiOkay. What's your next point?

Peter PanepentoWell, the next point is being ready to pivot. You know, most organizations plan out what they're planning to do with their communications and PR efforts a bit ahead of time. It could be that you're scheduling, you know, Social media posts a week or two in advance. It could be that you're, you know, you're targeting a certain date on a calendar for a major announcement. And when you plan those things out, you're doing it kind of taking into effect what you know is going to happen on the calendar. You may peg it to a certain holiday. You may peg it to a certain milestone or an anniversary that you're having with your organization. But, you know, when unexpected news happens, you really run the risk of either getting those carefully planned messages drowned out or having them seem very tone deaf if they come out at the wrong time. So it's really important, even if you're planning things out well in advance and you feel like you have everything buttoned down, to really be paying close attention to what's happening in the news and being prepared to, you know, hit pause on that scheduled social media message for a few days until, until, you know, a situation that might seem insensitive to be posting about passes, or, or holding off on a planned news announcement, or even just completely, you know, rethinking the way you're communicating about something based on what's happening in the news. So if you were a nonprofit that had that had social media posts out about voting or civic engagement or anything related to anything even remotely political the days following the President Trump assassination attempt, for instance. Yeah. It was— you run the risk of it either seeming insensitive or just getting drowned out by what's happening out there. So it's really important to just, you know, not just think about what's happening in the news as a news consumer, but as, uh, what does this mean for our communications?

Tony MartignettiI think, yeah, the assassination attempt is an excellent example. Uh, any, any of these, uh, think of, uh, President Biden stepping aside, you know. So if you had anything that was like critical of the administration, you know, it seemed like that would, that would be a bad 48 hours or so to In which to release it.

Peter PanepentoThat's absolutely true. And I even think back to Tony, an example from when you and I were working together on the Planned Giving Accelerator. We had a meeting, I think the first meeting planned on January 6th, 2021. And once we saw what was happening in the world, we were like, well, there's no way anybody's gonna wanna sit in on a meeting on this day.

Tony MartignettiThat was the first meeting of our first class. Yeah, it was exactly right. And you let me know what was happening. I didn't know. And we got a message out quickly. The class is canceled. You know, we'll be in touch because of what's happening in Washington, D.C. Yeah, yeah, exactly right.

Peter PanepentoSo prepare to pivot. All right. Yeah, be prepared to pivot and be ready to move quickly if you have to. So it wouldn't, it wouldn't have been a very engaged class on that first day. I don't know.

Tony MartignettiRight. I hope I didn't hesitate. I didn't hesitate, did I?

Peter PanepentoNo, you didn't at all.

Tony MartignettiI didn't push back and say, no, it's, it's an auspicious occasion. Is this something important? Is this Martignetti Planned Giving Accelerator? I can't— no, I didn't.

Peter PanepentoI think once you— I think once— because you were busy preparing for that.

Tony MartignettiI was preparing, right? But once I went to CNN or something, I saw the, you know, people crawling up the walls of the Capitol. No, of course. Yeah.

Peter PanepentoYeah. As soon as you knew what was happening, you knew it was time to hit the road. Yeah.

Tony MartignettiWe were on the phone. You didn't have to bring me along. We were on the phone together. Yes. All right. Prepare to pivot. Okay. Key messages. Even though you may have to change your messages, you alluded to this earlier, but let's flesh it out. Having some messaging ready.

Peter PanepentoRight. So in those fast-moving situations, if you are somewhat prepared with what you're going to say, you know, if candidate A says, you know, something that relates to your cause or candidate B does, or even if something's happening in the world that relates to your cause, if you have some key points that you have already vetted, worked through with your team, that you kind of have in your back pocket and ready to go in a fast-moving news situation, it can be really helpful in terms of you being able to get something out quickly. And often those messages can really be an affirmation of what you stand for as an organization, what you think is the best course of action to make sure that you're Ensuring that your mission is achieved and even working through how to make statements in a nonpartisan way while still kind of validating what you stand for. If you can spend some time working through those in advance, having those in your back pocket or, you know, not physically in your back pocket, but somewhere on your hard drive where it's something that your executive director, your board, everybody's had a chance to weigh in on, When a situation does arise, you can pull from that, play a little bit of Mad Libs with kind of filling in the blanks of what's happening and get a statement out very quickly.

Kate MartignettiIt's time for a break. Imagine a fundraising partner that not only helps you raise more money, but also supports you in retaining your donors. A partner that helps you raise funds both online and on location. So you can grow your impact faster. That's DonorBox, a comprehensive suite of tools, services, and resources that gives fundraisers just like you a custom solution to tackle your unique challenges, helping you achieve the growth and sustainability your organization needs, helping you help others. Visit donorbox.org to learn more. It's time for Tony's Take Two.

Tony MartignettiThank you, Kate. I've got another tale from the gym. I go to classes once a week. Usually I like to work out just by myself, quietly do my own thing— elliptical, floor work, Pilates, push-ups— by myself. But I do go to a class Once a week, each Tuesday. And in my very first class, you know, I walked in, it was— first of all, it was all women. I was the only guy in the room. And I saw, you know, everybody had their stuff, like, you know, they had water bottles. I had a hoodie on. People had like light jackets, you know, whatever, all lined up along the wall. So I went over and I put my little pile, took my hoodie off, put my little pile of hoodie and my keys and my little ID card for the gym. You know, I put that all in a pile next to somebody else's pile right alongside the wall. And I went and got some weights because the woman who runs the class was announcing you're going to need weights. So I was going over to get the weights and then I came back. And the woman who, uh, was— who belonged to the pile that was next to mine started to talk, you know. Hello, she said. Hello, you know. She didn't ask my name. I remember that. She— but hello, you know. You look new to the class. Yeah, I'm the only guy in the class, so I guess I am new to the class. She said, okay, well, I'll just move my stuff. I said, oh, I said, okay, just move your stuff. What? It's not— I don't care if it's touching my stuff. Is that your concern, that it's— that the, the 2 piles are, are, uh, I don't know, commingling? They're, they're having some kind of intercourse? What, the piles are touching? They just can't have this? What, maybe I have bed bugs in my hoodie? What do you mean? You'll— I'll just move my stuff, she says very curtly. After being kind of pretty cordial, you know, she was friendly. Well, I'll just move my stuff. That was it. Well, well, I'll just move my stuff. Okay. What? I can move my stuff. I just, I see, I see piles along the wall, so I stuck. Well, this is where I work out. I said, well, okay. I didn't know. I didn't, I didn't know that the pile delineates your space, Mrs. Blood and Soil. I didn't call her that. I didn't say that. I didn't know that that would demarcated your Your turf. You know, you can work. You could. You can work out here. That's your place, and I can see how it's important to you. It's a big room. It's like a big fitness center room. You know, it's I don't know a couple thousand square feet. No wood flooring. It's not like there's boxes or anything with your name or a little chalk line where you write your name or something. You know, and there's weights on one side, and there's the balls. You know, the big the big flexi whatever those big balls are. There's A bunch of those along another wall. You know, it's a big room, a couple thousand square foot room. Your spot, your turf. So I said, okay, you can have your spot. It's my first time. I didn't know. I moved my stuff over a little bit so they wouldn't be overlapping the piles. And then I worked out. I did the class for an hour, you know, one step over from her spot. So we We worked out together. I gave her her turf. I was like, what? You know, be gracious and kind, right? Be embodying a good, a good spirit and friendly to neighbors and welcoming. I work out here. All right, fine. So that was my first class. I still go to the class. She's still in her special spot. I'm not, I'm not anywhere near that. I don't need to be, you know, like week after week. I've raise my heart rate by having turf wars with Mrs. Blood and Soil. So, you know, I, I go somewhere else. I work out in another spot. And if somebody gets there before me, or, you know, I— there's no spot. It's not like my spot or her spot. It's just first come, first serve. All right. I think you get the idea. That was Mrs. Blood and Soil. But I still go to the class every Tuesday. I just work out on the other side of the room from her. And that is Tony's Take Two. Kate,

Kate Martignettithe entitlement. Yeah, astonishing in some people.

Tony MartignettiAnd and not even you know, I mean an older woman who should know better. She's she's an adult. She's quite fit. I have to give her that. She's very fit. I don't know if she looks a little older than me. Sixty-five, maybe seventy or so. You know, somebody who shouldn't be, yeah, feeling entitled, having wars over—

Kate MartignettiLike, you're new to the class. You would think that— I mean, if your stuff was genuinely on hers, I think there's a different way to approach it and be like, could you move your stuff? Because your stuff is on my stuff. But if you're— but the way that she said it is so entitled. And the fact that she's like in a class is very embarrassing. Like, go home and work out if you can't be around other people like that.

Tony MartignettiI think that's very savvy advice for this 65 or 70-year-old.

Kate MartignettiYes. My blood is boiling. Well, we've got just about a buttload more time. Here's the rest of Get Heard in the Election Season with Peter Panepento.

Tony MartignettiYou'd want to know what, what format the, the statement is going to be. Again, like I would say, is it a press release? Is it an email? Social posts, you want to think through what the channels are going to be with being prepared to pivot on that as well.

Peter PanepentoAbsolutely. Absolutely. So yes, so here's, here are a few points we would make for a news release. Here's a few things we would do in a social media or, or kind of email statement. Um, and, you know, you can almost have some of these things templated and ready to go where you can, you can fill in some key details. And make sure you're ready to go. We even went so far with an organization we're working with right now that has a— the founder of the organization is getting rather advanced in years. And we worked with them to prepare what we would do if something were to happen to her and they needed to get something out about her passing. Mm-hmm. So we've gone ahead and written kind of a templated news release, a statement for the website, some social media copy. To help them prepare for, you know, for if and when that happens. And we've, you know, she's been part of the vetting process on that and has seen what is being said. It's kind of like writing your own obituary ahead of time, but it allows the organization to make sure that they are announcing that news on their terms, that they're explaining clearly what would happen in that situation and what the plan is for the organization moving forward, and also honor her legacy at the same time. So you can almost game out some situations that may impact your organization, whether it's something political or even something like that where, where you might have to unexpectedly announce, um, you know, uh, you know, somebody no longer being with the organization or, or passing away. And, um, by taking that— those steps ahead of time, you, you really put yourself in a position to kind of own your own narrative in those situations.

Tony MartignettiWas this woman amenable to that Absolutely. Did you have to be pulled along a little bit? Like, no? Explain the value? I mean, she recognized it?

Peter PanepentoNo, she's a very self-aware leader and I think understands that. But, you know, and, you know, even if you're not actively involved in the day-to-day operations anymore and you're the founder of the organization and still engaged, I mean, that's a major event for that organization. And she was open to it. I don't know, you know, personally how she felt about it. Felt about it. But I do know that she recognized the value of doing that. And the staff and board at that nonprofit, I think, feels very comforted knowing that, you know, Father Time is undefeated. It's going to hit all of us at some point, that this is, you know, that they will be prepared to communicate with their supporters and with the public about what happened in a way that she is comfortable with and has signed off on already. And that You know, the organization is also comfortable with too.

Tony MartignettiI kind of like the idea of contributing to my own obituary. After a life of selfless sacrifice and enviable success, the— no, I like the idea of contributing to my own obituary. I'm starting to write it now. Okay. And your final piece of advice from, from the On Message newsletter?

Peter PanepentoYes, and that is to be ready for November 6th and beyond. I don't think anybody, regardless of where they are on the political spectrum, thinks that this is a minor election. This is an election that has a lot at stake, and there are a lot of potential eventualities with it, regardless, you know, depending on who wins and which party controls the Senate and the House and everything else. It's very hard to predict right now. But very likely, depending on your cause, people are gonna wanna hear from your organization on November 6th or November 7th, and with what the stakes are for the outcome of this. And so it might be helpful for you to game out a few different scenarios and be able to talk about what it means for your organization and your cause. So, you know, depending on which presidential candidate wins and which candidate or which party controls each house of, or chamber of the, of, of Congress. Um,

Tony Martignettiand even, even at the state, state level.

Peter PanepentoEven at the state level, and especially at state and local level for a lot of organizations, um, whatever happens on Election Day will really impact the work that you're going to be doing and, um, the impact that it's going to have on the people that you serve. So

Tony Martignettiit could be your local school board.

Peter PanepentoAbsolutely.

Tony MartignettiPlanning board, your mayor and council election, any of those. Any of those things on the local level as well?

Peter PanepentoYeah, absolutely. So I think it's really important to think about, like, you know, what, you know, what A scenario or B scenario will mean for your organization or your cause and, and what you're going to be asking people to do. It could be a cause to raise more money. It could be a call to advocate for, you know, for, you know, some aspect of your cause. It may be a cause to celebrate, but, you know, and say the work isn't done. We still have to do X, Y, and Z in the months ahead. But really thinking about, um, how you're going to respond to that, to, to the results of that, and having some things queued up and ready to go can again help you, um, you know, own your own message in those situations. If, if there are things that you want to ask people to do, especially if it's raising money, the faster you can do that and capture the moment, the more successful you're going to be.

Tony MartignettiAnd also, I think if you're not heard from Right after the election, uh, you, you risk being irrelevant.

Peter PanepentoYes.

Tony MartignettiLike, whether these people have nothing to say about, you know, they're not going to think of it right away, but then 2 weeks later when you, when they do send a message related to whatever it is you, you finally got around to sending, it's like, well, well, didn't they have anything to say about the election outcomes? I mean, the local, the local school board, you know, and, and they, uh, and they advocate for, they advocate for, for children, or they advocate for, uh, free pre-kindergarten universal or, you know, whatever, you risk being just kind of, like I said, irrelevant,

Peter Panepentoleft out of the conversation.

Tony MartignettiYeah. Or leaving yourself out.

Peter PanepentoRight. Right. So, yeah, there are real opportunities in the, in the months ahead to think about what you want to say in November. And, you know, I think it'll be impossible for us to predict who's going to win X, Y, and Z at this point. And in most cases this year, it's very close everywhere. But you can be ready with, with whatever message you want to get out there, depending on the outcome, by taking some steps now. And, you know, I think about a lot of the progressive organizations right after the election in 2016. A lot of them were in mourning and were not putting— we're not saying anything. And it took them, in some cases, weeks to be able to weigh in and mobilize people. And that was wasted time for them.

Tony MartignettiMm-hmm. Let's talk about something that you and I have talked about in the past, but it's been a few years. It's all related to all of what we're talking about today is the value of having relationships with journalists that are, that are longstanding, not just when you need the person, but, you know, how to build those relationships. Well, let's start with just the value of knowing some journalists in advance of when you have something to say. Yeah.

Peter PanepentoRight, right. It's really important, regardless of whether you're a local organization or a national organization or something in between, to really identify what journalists are covering the topics that most intersect with your organization or your cause, and making sure that you're taking steps to cultivate them and let them know that you're a resource for them, because it's really valuable in 2 ways. They're ready to— they're going to be more receptive to covering something significant that's happening with your organization or that you're looking to announce. And B, it provides an opportunity for when the journalist is looking for an expert to comment on a specific topic, for you to— for you or your executive director, your board chair, whoever is your biggest spokesperson, for them to reach out to you. when they're working on something and, and get you to weigh in on it and share your expertise with them. If, if you're interested in, in, in reaching people and, and, and persuading people about whatever cause you work on and/or just getting visibility, cultivating those relationships is really important. And by cultivating those relationships, I don't mean just sending them a press release 3 times a year with like— Yeah.

Tony MartignettiYeah.

Peter PanepentoAnd not engaging them otherwise. It often can involve you reaching out to them, telling them a bit about your work or a story that you think is important, but then asking, you know, what are you covering? What's of interest to you? How can I be helpful to you? And starting to build some rapport and a relationship with them so that they take your call or they open your email when you send something to them. And And and that you're top of mind for them when they're looking for something.

Tony MartignettiYou pulled a car talk. You remember that show on NPR, Car Talk?

Peter PanepentoYes, yes.

Tony MartignettiYou did. You did number one and B.

Peter PanepentoYes, I it was funny. I was I was halfway through saying that, and I was like, did I use one or A? Ah,

Tony Martignettithe car talk guys used to do that all the time. Yeah, one and B. Don't worry about it. No. So you're you know I mean you're a ten plus year journalist. So So reassure us that journalists are open to conversations before we have— that they're open to having relationships.

Peter PanepentoYes, they are. Journalists are like you and me.

Tony MartignettiJournalists are people too.

Peter PanepentoThat's right. That's right. And they also get bombarded with a lot of pitches and press releases and emails, kind of like you and I do every day, like where all of us do every day, where It's a bunch of stuff that's not relevant to you, right? It's clear that the person that's sending this to them doesn't know what they cover, doesn't even know what beat they're on. And when you're drowned with hundreds of messages like that every day, when somebody actually does take the time to say, you know, hey, I've paid attention to what you cover, here's a story I think you might be interested in that actually relates to what you cover. Mm-hmm. And if it's not, you know, I'm here to find out what is valuable to you and provide you with some insights and resources to help you get it. That stands out, first of all. And second of all, it is something that gets noticed by that journalist because you're not just throwing and trying to pitch them all the time. You're actually taking the time to find out what that journalist needs. When you take that step, you know, they may not respond the first time, but if they see that you're genuine and that you actually are paying attention to what they're doing, oftentimes they'll start a conversation with you and it turns into something really useful. You know, as a journalist, you want to have, you know, some vetted people that you can turn to when you're on deadline or an editor gives you a story that you're, you know, that's on a topic that you don't cover every day. To be able to say, oh, the executive director at the local food bank really knows her stuff, and I can reach out to her and get a read on what's happening here. And, you know, once you have that list of go-to sources, it becomes very easy for the reporter to get their job done.

Tony MartignettiAnd you're helping them.

Peter PanepentoYeah, absolutely.

Tony MartignettiI have a personal story that is an ideal example of what you're talking about. Stephanie Strom at the New York Times used to have the nonprofit beat when that beat existed in nationally, internationally known papers. She had it at the New York Times and I reached out and we actually, we ended up having coffee.

Peter PanepentoMm-hmm.

Tony MartignettiAnd through the years, she called me. Sometimes I wasn't quoted, but I was happy to help her on background about some nonprofit fundraising issue. But there were times when she did Quote me, and so, and that that's a major you know the major outlet of the New York Times years ago. She's she's long since there's no nonprofit beats anymore that I'm aware of, and she's long since left the New York Times. But you know that was and that was just on the strength of doing what you suggested. We we this was this was before I met you, so I was not using your wise counsel. I had the I had the Almost equally wise counsel, not, not nearly as wise as your counsel, uh, counsel of another person who, you know, we, we looked at her stories and what she had done and crafted an email, and I followed up by phone, and we ended up meeting for a coffee.

Peter PanepentoRight, right. It's, it's almost the same as if you're a fundraiser, you know, really making sure that you're getting to know your top prospects, right?

Tony MartignettiThat's a perfect analogy. Yeah. Yeah, absolutely. Being persistent, pleasantly persistent. And you don't know where that relationship is going to go. And that's what ended up happening with me. And same with your donors. That's a very good analogy. Absolutely.

Peter PanepentoExactly that. And often they're not going to cover exactly what you want them to cover. But if they are covering something that connects to what you're doing and they see value in talking to you, you're going to get a lot of value out of that, even if it's not You know, hey, you, you know, you're, you're not covering the press releases I'm putting out, but you found something else that's really, that's really valuable that my organization can provide. Um, that, that, you know, being included in that kind of coverage when it's not something that you're pitching yourself, it can be incredibly valuable to you.

Tony MartignettiSo propagate the, uh, the journalist relationships because they, they, they, they can be enormously valuable. And they don't have to be on a national scale. Your local Local outlets.

Peter PanepentoAbsolutely. One thing that we advise a lot of people about is don't worry about the, you know, reaching the biggest number of people. Make sure you're reaching the people that matter most to you. So if you're a local nonprofit, you know, being covered regularly in your local paper or on local television is way more valuable to you than being, you know, included in some national story once, right? So, you know, really be mindful of like, Where are your donors? Where are the people who you need to be advocating for you? What— and, and, and what journals there are the ones that are, are covering the topics that, that you care most about, and, and really focus your efforts there.

Tony MartignettiOkay, if we leave it there. All right.

Peter PanepentoI'm great if we leave it there.

Tony MartignettiPeter Panepento. The company is Turn Two Communications. They're at turn-twocommunications.com. You'll find Peter at, uh, @ppanepento on X and also on LinkedIn. Peter, thank you for a valuable conversation. Thank you for helping our listeners.

Peter PanepentoThank you, Tony. Always a pleasure to, to join you, and, uh, and glad we can, we can cover this timely topic, uh, before we get too close to the election.

Tony MartignettiAbsolutely. Yes, great value.

Kate MartignettiNext week, the responsive nonprofit with Gabe Cooper. If you missed any part of this week's show,

Tony MartignettiI beseech you, find it at tonymartignetti.com.

Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by Virtuous. Virtuous gives you the nonprofit CRM, fundraising, volunteer, and marketing tools you need to create more responsive donor experiences and grow giving. virtuous.org. And by DonorBox. Outdated donation forms blocking your supporters' generosity? DonorBox. Fast, flexible, and friendly fundraising forms for your nonprofit. donorbox.org. Our creative producer is Claire Meyerhoff. I'm your associate producer, Kate Martignetti. Marc Silverman is our web guy, and this music is by Scott Stein.

Tony MartignettiYeah! Thank you for that affirmation, Scotty. Be with us next week for Nonprofit Radio, Big Nonprofit Ideas for the Other 95%. Go out and be great.

Nonprofit Radio