Skip to content
EP 681March 10, 2024

Election Year Activities

Tony MartignettiGene Takagi
Nonprofit Radio
Episode 681
0:00 / 0:00

About this episode

In this presidential election year, everything related to politics is prohibited, right? Not so fast. It’s not that simple. There are actions you can take, including lobbying on ballot measures. As long as you follow the rules. There’s no one better to explain those rules than Gene Takagi, our legal contributor. He’s the managing attorney of NEO, the Nonprofit & Exempt Organizations law group.

Here’s the transcript

Tony MartignettiHello and welcome to Tony Martignetti Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. I'm your aptly named host and the Podfather. of your favorite hebdomadal podcast. Oh, I'm glad you're with us. I'd be forced to endure the pain of chronic inflammatory demyelinating polyradiculoneuropathy if you attacked me with the idea that you missed this week's show. Here's our associate producer Kate with what's coming.

Kate MartignettiHey Tony, it's election year activities. In this presidential election year, everything related to politics is prohibited, right? Not so fast. It's not that simple. There are actions you can take, including lobbying on ballot measures, as long as you follow the rules. There's no one better to explain those rules than Gene Takagi, our legal contributor. He's the managing attorney of NEO, the nonprofit and and Exempt Organizations Law Group. On Tony's Take Two.

Tony Martignetti24 NTC is next week.

Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by DonorBox. Outdated donation forms blocking your supporters' generosity? DonorBox. Fast, flexible, and friendly fundraising forms for your nonprofit. donorbox.org. And By Virtuous. Virtuous gives you the nonprofit CRM, fundraising, volunteer, and marketing tools you need to create more responsive donor experiences and grow giving. virtuous.org. Here is Election Year Activities.

Tony MartignettiIt's always a pleasure to welcome back our legal contributor, Gene Takagi. He's the managing attorney of NEO, the Nonprofit and Exempt Organizations Law Group in San Francisco. He edits that wildly popular nonprofitlawblog.com that you should be following, and he is a part-time lecturer at Columbia University. The firm is at neolawgroup.com, and he's at GTAC. It's good to see you, Gene. Welcome back.

Gene TakagiIt's great to be back, Tony. It's great to see you as well.

Tony MartignettiThank you. It's always a pleasure. I don't mind saying it twice. I'll say it a third time. It's always a pleasure. And this one particularly because it's our, uh, what would this be, our quadrennial? Every 4th year. Uh, and you've been on the show for many, many years. We've done this several times in our presidential election cycle. It's time to talk about what's permissible and what's not permissible around political activity. So let's start with the upside that I think a lot of folks may not be aware of, even though we've said it before, but it's been 4 years. To be fair, it's been 4 years since we've talked about this, that nonprofits can do lobbying. And A decent amount of it too.

Gene TakagiYeah, it's, it's so underrecognized, Tony. So I'm glad you're bringing it up. There's a study that came out recently, but it was about the 2017 and 2018 years about how many charities out of the more than a million charities that registered with the IRS and report to the IRS, how many actually report doing lobbying? And it's fewer than 10,000. So that's less than 1% have reported lobbying as any part of their activities. And I think part of it stems from, you know, 501 kind of says in more legalese kind of verbiage, hey, you can't engage in substantial lobbying.

Tony MartignettiYeah.

Gene TakagiYou know, that terrifies, you know, a lot of charities going, oh my God, we can't engage in substantial lobbying. What does that mean? What does substantial mean? And so we better not do any of it.

Tony MartignettiYeah. Right. It keeps everybody away from it completely. It just, and then they just default to nonprofits can't do lobbying.

Gene TakagiYeah, exactly. And, you know, lawyers are not, you know, are a little bit complicit in this as well because, you know, when they're not sure about this thing and if you don't practice exclusively in the areas that, like I practice in, why would you know that? Well, you know, substantial can mean a lot of different things depending upon the test you elect to fall under. So you'd probably say, well, you know, just to be on the safe side, Better not lobbying, but that's actually terrible advice.

Tony MartignettiYeah.

Gene TakagiFor public charities.

Tony MartignettiSo let's debunk this insidious myth.

Gene TakagiYeah, and let's raise up, there's great reasons for charities to lobby, especially right now. I mean, we're at a pivotal time when a lot of rights are up at issue and charities may have like very strong views about those rights, whether it be women's rights or whether it be First Amendment rights or whether it be Environmental rights. I mean, there's just a lot up in the air right now where charities and, you know, charity beneficiaries and charity supporters really have a strong point of view and they're afraid to share it through the charity. So

Tony Martignettilet's add in LGBTQ and trans rights.

Gene TakagiYeah, absolutely. And, you know, we can create a host— a whole list of other rights as well. Charities, you know, span the spectrum of all sorts of things. And so Yeah, you know, when you have something to say, being chilled and in fear of saying it because you don't know whether the law allows you to or not is terrible. So glad you've provided kind of the place where we can talk about it and say, hey, okay, what can charities do? And so the first thing to know about is there's sort of 2 tests. And the default test is if you have done nothing except, you know, kind of reported with the IRS regularly your 990s as you're supposed to do. You haven't made any sort of election to do lobbying or measure lobbying in a different way. It's called the substantial part test. So what does substantial mean? And the best guidance we have on that is like a case from the '50s. So, all right, understandable why people are concerned about it. But

Tony Martignettihey, there's been a lot— Just in the past few months, there's been a lot of talk about going all the way back to Marbury versus Madison.

Gene TakagiYeah.

Tony MartignettiSo in the 17— no, It was 17— late 1700s.

Gene TakagiIt's very old.

Tony Martignetti18. Yeah, I didn't look it up. But so, you know, that like when, when the Supreme Court reporter was, was Granch. Granch, remember that? All right, now I'm getting a little in the weeds of law school stuff. But the— before, hundreds of years ago, there was a reporter that used to do the Supreme Court opinions, and the name of that reporting volume was Cranch. So it just sounds like, you know, it just sounds like something from pioneer days. Cranch. Anyway, so the 1950s, you know, that's pretty recent compared to Marbury v. Madison and Cranch.

Gene TakagiIt is. But then, you know, just what's happened over the last 5 years has been like an event. So, but I think we can kind of rely on it for, you know, a rule of thumb. Like if you spend more than 5% of your total budget on lobbying, you're probably safe. Any more than that, you might be crossing the line. This is under the substantial part test.

Tony MartignettiTotal budget. So you said total, total

Gene Takagibudget? Yeah, so, or total expenditures. So let's say you, you spent $100,000, and if you spend $5,000 of that $100,000 on lobbying, you're probably safe. Um, the better way to look at that is probably not just a percentage of your expenditures, so it's Percentage of the resources that are going into it. So if, if you know, five percent of your total resources expended—not just money but volunteer time and everything else—if it's more than five percent, you might have some issues with the substantial part test. The IRS isn't really enforcing on this very hard. I would say they're actually very poorly enforcing this. They're openly non-compliant, especially churches out there that are saying, "Go ahead, sue us." Or take us to court. We want to go— we want to take this to the Supreme Court anyway and see if there is a constitutional basis for, you know, this political campaign intervention prohibition, often referred to as the Johnson Amendment. But, you know, it is what the law says right now. So more than 5%, maybe you have an issue there. Be careful.

Tony MartignettiOkay. And again, it's 5% of total resources expended.

Gene TakagiYeah, I would

Tony Martignettisay that's your total resources, not your— not your— not just your budget.

Gene TakagiI, I would say that is the better way to look at it. Okay. So you're right. Okay.

Tony MartignettiOkay.

Gene TakagiUm, the case in the '50s, total expenditures only. Um, so now the other way to, to do— to measure lobbying and whether it's substantial or not is the way that we recommend the vast majority of charities to choose. And it's something called the 501 election. And I know we've talked about this before as well. So by electing the 501 expenditure test, it means that lobbying isn't measured on all the facts and circumstances. So it's not like a complete resource test of like how much of your total resources, which involves a lot of thinking, right? Volunteer time and like— Yeah. Your office space and like all of that.

Tony MartignettiYeah, yeah, yeah.

Gene TakagiSo the expenditures test says, well, it's too hard to do all of that. So if you elect this, and it's a very, very simple form, it's about half a page long, and it's basically name and check the box and address. So it's super simple. If you elect it, then you have strict sort of requirements of what is substantial and what is not substantial. And so it's very clear and it's just based on expenditures. And in this test, you're allowed to expend up to 20% of your first $500,000 in expenditures on lobbying, and it's not considered substantial. So not 5%. Now we're talking about 20% of your first $500,000, and this is on your exempt purpose expenditures or your mission-related expenditures. So it doesn't include things like investments and stuff. So On your mission-related expenditures, you're allowed to spend 20% of your first $500,000, 15% of your next $500,000, 10% of your next, 5% of the remaining, up to a total cap of $1 million in lobbying, which you'll hit at about the $17 to $18 million range of mission-related expenditures. You're gonna, you're gonna hit the limit based on those formulas at about $1 million, the $1 million cap at about $17 to $18 million of mission-related expenditures. Okay. That is not substantial. So that's a pretty generous amount of lobbying that's allowed.

Tony MartignettiYeah, this is right. Right. This is, this is a good bit. Now, we, we didn't say the name of the form. It's the— it's IRS Form 5768.

Gene TakagiCorrect.

Tony MartignettiAnd super simple. 5768. And it is, uh, it's— you left out one little item. You have to put the end of the tax year that you want the election to choose to be for. But it's so simple. It is like, it's like a third or a half It's, I think 2/3 of the page is the instructions and 1/3 is the election. It's just, it's, it's a name, address, end of the tax year, and your signature.

Gene TakagiAnd it's, and what's great about it too is you can elect on December 31st for it to apply retroactively for that whole year. So you can make your decision last moment and say, hey, we want to fall under this expenditure test. We don't like to Think about all the facts and circumstances. We're a charity that has less than a $17 or $18 million annual budget. Most of the listeners here probably fall into that category.

Tony MartignettiYes.

Gene TakagiSo the 501 election just makes things simpler and allows you to lobby safely within the tax law limits that you're allowed to without jeopardizing your 501 status. And now you can go ahead and fight Including lobbying, which doesn't mean paying a lobbyist, right? It means stating your position on your website on a particular bill saying, hey, this law should change, or we need this new law, or we need a budget increase that requires our city council to approve this, like, budget. That's legislation as well. So if you have a position on it, it's lobbying. Charities should not be afraid to lobby. Like, You can lobby, and the limits are fairly generous, especially if you take that 501 expenditure test. The form is available online, 5768, as you said, super simple. And if you don't like it, let's say you grew to, to become a $50 million charity next year and you don't like that $1 million cap anymore, you can elect out of it just the same way you elected in. So it's super simple. Yeah. Same form.

Tony MartignettiYes, same form to elect out if you bust that limit or that rough expenditure number. The other thing you mentioned casually, I want to emphasize, this includes local lobbying, local issues. This is not only our biggest national issues like First Amendment and reproductive rights. This could be a local council thing.

Gene TakagiAbsolutely.

Tony MartignettiLike a budget. Now, lobbying, can that be— now I'm spilling over. Now, can that be— it's not candidate advocacy, right? Not getting into supporting candidates or denouncing candidates. This is all about issues. This is issue lobbying.

Gene TakagiYeah.

Tony MartignettiYeah, we're going to get to candidates. We're going to come to candidate, mostly prohibitions, but some things as long as they're Anyway, I don't want to spoil the— I don't want to take away your info, but we're going to get to candidates very shortly. But this could be very local issues, like you said, like a budget.

Gene TakagiYeah.

Tony MartignettiOr a zoning thing.

Gene TakagiYeah. Anything that's going to appear by a legislative body that appears in the law, you can comment on existing law. You can ask for a change on that. You can propose a new law or back a new law that's coming out. You don't have to hire a lobbyist. It might just be a communication out that you put on your website. That's lobbying. It's probably really low cost if you're going to tweet it or—

Tony MartignettiYeah. Email campaign, print mail campaign if you want to go to that extent. Yeah, this is all well within what's allowed, well within your purview. And just take the 501. Now, do we have to know what 501 says? Does that matter? Do we have to go into what 501 says or just fill out the form?

Gene TakagiYeah, so just know that you're electing to measure your lobbying under the 501 expenditure test. That's basically what it says. So you're electing to measure lobbying not on an all the facts and circumstances test that the IRS and then the court would have to apply if you ever, like, argued about it.

Tony MartignettiAh.

Gene TakagiJust strict numbers, and you know what the numbers are. You fill them out, so you'll know exactly what happens. And even better, If you don't make the election and you, you use the substantial part test, the 5% rule of thumb test, if you are ever examined by the IRS and you cross that threshold, they can revoke your 501 status for crossing that threshold in one year.

Tony MartignettiMm-hmm.

Gene TakagiUnder the 501 election, that doesn't happen. There may be a penalty tax applied to you in, in any given year, but you actually have to, to to exceed that cap over 4 years. And oh,

Tony Martignettithat's significant. Okay. Okay. Well, you did say the IRS is not actively enforcing this. Not that they're never going to, but they're not being very proactive about it. But still, you get, you get a 4-year window under the 501 test versus just a 1-year window in the facts and circumstances, which is limited to only 5% too.

Gene TakagiYeah, there is an added wrinkle though to the 501 test.

Tony MartignettiOh, here it comes now. All right, read the foot— you gotta always read the footnotes. All right, now what?

Kate MartignettiIt's time for a break. Open up new cashless in-person donation opportunities with DonorBox Live Kiosk, the smart way to accept cashless donations anywhere, anytime. Picture this. A cash-free onsite giving solution that effortlessly collects donations from credit cards, debit cards, and digital wallets. No team member required. Plus, your donation data is automatically synced with your DonorBox account. No manual data entry or errors. Make giving a breeze and focus on what matters— your cause. Try DonorBox Live Kiosk and revolutionize the way you collect donations in 2024. Visit donorbox.org to learn more. Now back to election year activities.

Tony MartignettiGene and I just had technical difficulties, which means since he lives in a big city and I live in a suburban beach town, my Wi-Fi just cut out. So Our sound is not going to be as good as it was because now we're recording on my phone. But as you know, nonprofit radio perseveres through these minor technological letdowns. We— these things, these things don't trouble nonprofit radio at all. So we're still gonna— we're gonna continue. Gene was, uh— Gene, I'm just gonna let you pick up. Go ahead.

Gene TakagiTerrific. And we know charities have resilience as well. So under the 501—

Tony MartignettiVery good.

Gene TakagiAnd under the 501 expenditure test that we're recommending to most charities, there are a couple wrinkles. So one of the wrinkles is, is that there's 2 types of lobbying: direct lobbying, where you're contacting a legislative body directly and asking for a change in the law or introduction of a new law, And grassroots lobbying, when you're telling your public to contact a legislator or legislative body to change the law. And so in grassroots lobbying, there's going to be some sort of call to action. It's gonna be the charity expressing a particular view on a specific piece of legislation with a call to action to the public. Without that call to action, it's not even lobbying. So you can do all of that you want. You can actually express a view on a particular piece of legislation and not give any sort of message to the, to the public about who to contact, or, you know, provide the information, the contact information of the legislature, which is sort of implied call to action. You can include none of that, but just say, hey, this is the way our charity feels about this piece of legislation, period. That's not even lobbying for purposes of the expenditure test. So another good thing to note of advocating your point of view. But if you do decide on the 501 expenditure test, Note that the grassroots lobbying limit is 25% of your total amount of lobbying. So if we said 20% is your cap on your first $500,000 on exempt purpose or mission-related expenditures, so $100,000 of that $500,000 is safe. Well, then $50,000 would be the amount that you could do of grassroots lobbying of that $200,000 limit that you have. So 25% cap on the grassroots lobbying expenditure. And as I said before, under the substantial part test, if you don't make this election, if you exceed the amount in one year, you can lose your 501 exemption, although that's very, very unlikely based on sort of very poor IRS enforcement on this issue right now. But under the 501 expenditure test, your measurement— you can get hit with a penalty tax of 25% of the excessive amount of lobbying if you lobby excessively. But you will not get your tax-exempt status, your 501 status revoked unless you exceeded the lobbying limit for a 4-year period, and you have to have exceeded it by more than 50%. So there's a huge benefit to this 501 expenditure test election. 5768 is the form number. We really urge most public charities to file that election.

Tony MartignettiAbsolutely. Yeah, I can see the big advantages versus the cloudy, much less generous facts and circumstances. Okay, do the 501 like Gene just urged you, beseeched you even. Do the 501. All right. So where do you want to go from now? The lobbying From lobbying, where should we go?

Gene TakagiSo let's talk about what's sort of maybe at the outset say, well, what you can't do, which you alluded to in the beginning, Tony, is you can't endorse or support a candidate for a public office. So you can't engage in electioneering or public campaign political intervention. So none of that is permissible. But what is neither lobbying nor this political campaign intervention is stuff like making available nonpartisan analysis, study, or research, or examining broad social, economic, and similar problems if you do it in a nonpartisan manner, but really focusing on the issues. You know, if you don't refer to specific legislation and you want to state your views on whether it be climate change or women's rights or LGBTQ+ rights or anything, you don't mention legislation, it's not lobbying. And if there's no call to action, it's not grassroots lobbying. So there's a lot of things that you can do. And maybe the last exception that I'll mention, and there are many others, but the last one I'll say is if you're communicating to a non-legislative body like an executive branch official, the president, the mayor, the governor, that is generally not lobbying when it's, you know, regarding implementation of regulations or policies, because those are not done by a Those are done by an administrative agency, and lobbying has to do with legislation.

Tony MartignettiOr if you're sending this information to your constituents.

Gene TakagiYeah, a lot of times that may not be lobbying as well when it's to your membership. It's when we talk about constituents and it gets a little bit iffy about whether that might be grassroots lobbying under the 501 expenditure test or just lobbying period under the substantial part test, the default test.

Tony MartignettiOh, so the distinction is whether you have a call to action or whether you're just sending something neutral, like you said, you know, just a report about a subject. Is that the difference? This is a call to action?

Gene TakagiYeah, that's probably the primary difference. There's a little bit of differences between when we talk about sending communications to members versus to the general public. But in either case, yeah, if you don't include a call to action, you're probably safe and not engaged in lobbying.

Kate MartignettiIt's time for Tony's Take Two.

Tony MartignettiThank you very much, Kate. 24NTC, it's the 2024 Nonprofit Technology Conference hosted by NTEN, and it is next week. I'm very grateful to Heller Consulting for sponsoring us at 24 NTC. We're gonna be sharing a double-wide booth with Heller. I'll be there capturing lots of interviews, but already more than 20 already scheduled. All these smart tech folks, but not technical tech folks, right? We all, we know this is the conference and certainly the interviews that I capture for us, not, not over-the-top tech, not even, not even Not even top tech, just user, user-friendly tech. That's what we talk about. So we'll have all these interviews playing over the, the coming months from the conference. If you're gonna be there, I hope you will come see us on the exhibit floor, which they're calling the Archive. No, not the Archive. It's the Arcade, not the Archive. The Archive is in the past. This is the arcade, forward-looking. There's going to be— I know there's ping pong, there's skee-ball. I know I specifically asked about skee-ball. You got to love skee-ball. I used to play skee-ball with my grandfather, Kate's great-grandfather, in Asbury Park, New Jersey, which he used to call Raspberry Park. Lots of stories about Raspberry Park. Anyway, there's going to be skee-ball in the arcade and other games as well. We're going to be in booths 607 and 609, Nonprofit Radio and Heller Consulting side by side. All the smart folks at Heller, you know, with their outstanding Salesforce, Blackbaud, Microsoft consulting, they find you the right tech solution because they're broad in lots of different platforms. And then they do the implementation for you. That's Heller Consulting. Again, thankful to them for sponsoring us at the conference. Please come by, see us if you're gonna— if you're there in Portland. I neglected to say this is all happening next week in Portland, Oregon. Very nice city. I'm going to spend a couple of extra nights because great, great food scene there with their food trucks. That's 24 NTC. And that is Tony's Take Two. Kate.

Kate MartignettiMy dad loves skee-ball. Every time we go to an arcade, it's always skee-ball. And like, he'll use my tickets because him and I go off together. He'll use my tickets to just play skee-ball. That's it.

Tony MartignettiWell, I, I have the origin story for that. I assure you it goes back to our grandfather, Grandpa Martignetti. Taking us to skee-ball back when the balls were made of wood.

Kate MartignettiYes, yes, yes.

Tony MartignettiAnd a play was a dime. You put your little dime in, dime for like, I think it was a dime for 9 balls.

Kate MartignettiOh, I wish it was still that. It's like a dollar now.

Tony MartignettiOh my God. Wooden balls. I guess they were not hypoallergenic like the plastic balls are anyway. But wood balls, I'm sure of it. It was 9 plays for a dollar. No, 9 plays for a dime. You pull that metal handle back and those wooden balls go come crashing down in a row. And then you, then you do your play, try to get, try to get the ball in the center for the maximum points. So that's why, that's the story why your dad loves skee-ball.

Kate MartignettiWell,

Tony Martignettilet's carry on. What do you say?

Kate MartignettiWe've got beaucoup but loads more time. So let's return to election year activities

Tony MartignettiIt's a question of doing it also, aside from the call to action, doing it in a nonpartisan way. Like you said, you know, objective research on an issue, right?

Gene TakagiYeah. So I mean, we can always do this in a partisan way. That can now mean that it may not be lobbying, but it could be political campaign intervention that 501s are not allowed to engage in. So If we, like, say, focused on a wedge issue, like abortion, let's say, and we didn't talk about it, you know, for most of the period of time in question until just before an election, and then we started to talk heavily about that and tell people to really, you know, vote where their conscience lies without saying a particular candidate, but mentioning abortion rights. Right. Yeah. You know, if that was kind of the wedge issue between, you know, candidates, and that's the only time that we brought it up, that might be seen as prohibited, you know, political campaign intervention or electioneering.

Tony MartignettiOkay. So now we're going broader. You know, what's your typical communications about this issue? And like you said, if this is your first time and We're in an election season. It's, it's, it's gonna— that's gonna weigh against you versus something that you discussed routinely with your constituents.

Gene TakagiYeah. And that's gonna sort of apply to a number of different activities that might ordinarily be done, you know, regularly by an organization. But if it's not done regularly and it's only timed with an election, and it's really— the intent was to influence that election by picking a particular wedge issue or highlighting a particular issue just before the election, that can get organizations into trouble. Although again, the IRS enforcement on the whole electioneering issue has been pretty weak.

Tony MartignettiOkay. All valuable. All right. You can even host a debate, right?

Gene TakagiYep. There are definitely charities, 501 public charities that are not allowed to engage in electioneering. That host candidate debates. Now, they've got to organize that in a neutral, nonpartisan manner, including inviting all of the viable candidates. Now, not everybody might accept that invitation, and that doesn't necessarily mean that you can't hold the debate. But yes, if you do it in a neutral, nonpartisan manner, it can be done. And I think, you know, many of us are probably familiar with like the League of Women Voters. And others that organize some of the presidential debates. So it is something to be aware of, that it is a possible thing to do on a local level as well.

Tony MartignettiOkay. Yeah, right. This all applies locally too. So, I mean, we're in a presidential year, but think broader than just 2024. Okay. Okay. What about, uh, there's, uh, there's an issue around if you, uh, criticize the actions, uh, of an incumbent that's running, like Joe Biden.

Gene TakagiYeah, so, you know, it's always a little bit tricky when we talk about an incumbent when they're also running for office, right? So again, the timing may matter. But if we're criticizing the incumbent based on their actions taken in that capacity, so if we criticize Joe Biden on actions he's taken as president, that's different from criticizing his stance in areas which he's campaigning on or which the other party may be campaigning on in terms of opposing his candidacy. So yes, you can continue to criticize an incumbent's action. If you've been doing that all along, that really helps. If you only time it before the election and And it looks like the reason for doing it was to influence that election, then maybe that could cross the line. So you have to think about it in those terms. It becomes a little bit weird too when you have the other candidate who was formerly the President of the United States as well, right? So are we criticizing him for his actions taken when he was president, or has that been so long ago that that's not really anything we're doing other than to influence the coming election? So it gets a little bit dicey when we look at that through a certain lens. But, you know, let's talk not about the Biden-Trump candidacies, but let's just talk about some local mayor or governor. I'm sure all of us can criticize the actions of our executive branch officials from time to time, of our elected officials. In the state. So yes, you can continue to criticize them. Probably again, you, you know, if that criticism was really just part of what is connected with your charity and not just for, for, for, you know, purposes of influencing their candidacy in a, in a later election.

Tony MartignettiAnd let's go to the next step. What about somebody who's a candidate, but you're hosting them For non-candidate, non-election type issues, a conversation, a debate, a panel, let's say panels probably more likely, but it doesn't have to do with their election. They happen to be a candidate.

Gene TakagiYeah. So let's say it was a— I'll just pull out an example. I'm not sure that if I can Come up with an actual name here, but let's say it's a rocket scientist, right, who happens to be running for office. But the charity wants to invite them because they're a science museum, and he has sort of a background in a particular initiative that the science museum has taken. And he is, you know, a very highly recognized person in the public, so that would be a great draw. And he can talk intelligently about the subject matter at hand. Might be every right of that charity, that museum, to invite that candidate, not as a candidate, but in his rocket scientist capacity to speak to the public. And if he's not talking about the election, and you've got to sort of sometimes when you invite them, you have to talk to them about it because they may not know the 501 charity rules and this prohibition against electioneering. So you've got to make sure that they don't speak about their candidacy or the election. And the charity might even want to put a disclaimer up there, you know, when inviting him or when introducing him to the to the audience that, hey, we've invited this person. We are not stating any position on the upcoming election, but we've invited him because he's this, you know, famed rocket scientist, and we'd love for him to speak with you about the science on our initiative. So that, that is okay.

Tony MartignettiOkay. Okay. We should probably move to what What's not allowed in— because we talked about what you can do as long as you do this on a nonpartisan basis. What are some things that are not allowed around the political campaign intervention?

Gene TakagiYeah, so here's— and I'll speak of it in 2 ways. So what's allowed and then what makes it wrong. So a voter registration drive or a get-out-the-vote drive, those are really common for charities to do. Mm-hmm. They're A-okay unless you're doing it in a partisan manner, right? So you're only going out to do the voter registration drive if the voters are, you know, siding with your preferred candidate. And if that's the way you conduct the voter registration drive, then it is partisan political campaign intervention and could cost you your 501 status. So that would be prohibited. Same thing with like a candidate questionnaire or voter guide. If you designed it or distributed it in a manner that was partisan, so you're getting the answers that you want and using it as election materials, then that would be prohibited political campaign intervention. If you had kind of a candidate and you said, you know, we're going to score you on all of the issues that matter to us, then that could also be political campaign intervention when you're just scorecarding a candidate just timed with the election. Now, that's different from scorecarding an incumbent if it's not timed with an election. But when you're scorecarding candidates timed with an election, really difficult. Mm-hmm. If you ask a candidate to take a pledge, so you say, hey, pledge to support our environmental platform, Even though you're not saying we'll support you if you do that, even without that, that might be enough to say, hey, that's still electioneering. If

Tony Martignettieven if you, even if you offer that pledge to all the candidates.

Gene TakagiYeah, even if you offer it to all the candidates, because if some pledge to back your platform and some pledge will not pledge that, then that's seen as a message that you're giving to people who are looking at that. That communication that you, you highlight after about who has backed your platform and who hasn't. It's kind of seen as tacitly influencing that election either by, you know, promoting or opposing a particular candidate.

Tony MartignettiI see. Okay. Okay. What else? What else should we be aware of? So avoiding—

Gene Takagia big one is, for me anyway, is the selective use of space or resources. So in one sense, you know, a lot of charities will go, well, we don't allow any of our political candidates or any political candidates to use like our space. So, you know, we're not going to, you know, worry about that. But what if you invited somebody to speak to your, you know, to your audience about kind of the issues? I said it would be okay if they're not doing it in their other, you know, capacity as an expert in some other area. But what if they were doing it kind of as a candidate and you allowed them to, you know, to speak on the issues, but you didn't invite others to speak on it, that would be a problem. And maybe even more of a common problem is one of the assets of a charity are its emails, right? So if you have, you know, gene@charity.org, that's the charity's email address. You know, it's my professional email, but it wouldn't be my email in terms of I wouldn't own it if I, you know, You know, if I wasn't, you know, together with the charity anymore. If individuals who are certainly allowed to engage in, in, you know, supporting, endorsing, or opposing candidates for political office in their individual capacities, but if they're using staff email to do it, that becomes a problem. If they're using staff time or staff events, which they use as a platform, To engage in their individual sort of First Amendment rights to engage in political activity, that's a problem because they're using organizational resources. They can do it on their own time. And you might see sometimes in newspapers, people will put the name of the organization they're with. They might even say like their position, president of Charity X endorsing this candidate. You'll see there's going to be an asterisk there that says, that the titles and affiliations of the individuals are provided for identification purposes only. So it's not an endorsement by the organization. So that's really important to make sure that individual staff members or board members are not using organizational resources, including emails, to engage in political activities that are, that are otherwise prohibited to the charity.

Tony MartignettiHow would you judge this one? Let me give you a hypothetical. Mm-hmm. An employee drives a nonprofit vehicle to a rally or anything where they're going to be expressing their political opinion, but use a rally. So they drive it, they park it, and then they walk a few blocks to the rally. What do you think about that?

Gene TakagiCan't do it. I mean, it would be, it would be, again, the IRS rarely enforces this anyway. Yeah. Okay. It is the law, but it would be, it would, you know, it would probably not come to the, the, the charity's attention. But if it did, they would have to hold the employee accountable for that. So it's not saying you've got to terminate somebody, but you probably should have a policy that says something like, you cannot use organizational resources, including our vehicles, including your email address, to support or oppose any candidates for public office. You've got to use your own resources and your own time for that.

Tony MartignettiOkay. It's a resource. I agree. Right. If an email is a resource, then certainly a vehicle would be. All right. I just wanted to— I thought maybe if you parked it a few blocks away, I thought maybe it might make a difference.

Kate MartignettiIt's time for a break. Virtuous is a software company committed to helping nonprofits grow generosity. Virtuous believes that generosity has the power to create profound change in the world and in the heart of the giver. It's their mission to move the needle on global generosity by helping nonprofits better connect with and inspire their givers. Responsive fundraising puts the donor at the center of fundraising and grows giving through personalized donor journeys that respond to the needs of each individual. Virtuous is the only responsive nonprofit CRM designed to help you build deeper relationships with every donor at scale. Virtuous gives you the nonprofit CRM, fundraising, volunteer, marketing, and automation tools you need to create responsive experiences that build trust and grow impact. Virtuous.org. Now back to election year activities.

Tony MartignettiYou got some other things that we need to, we need to avoid around the political campaign intervention.

Gene TakagiYes. You know, I would say another common thing is websites and social media, right? So social media on an organizational sort of account, got to be careful. No electioneering on those accounts. So whether it be Twitter or X, whatever you want to call it, Facebook, TikTok, whatever, if it's the organizational sort of account and you're promoting the charity on it, it's not your individual account. You have to make sure that your individual sort of political endorsements or oppositions are not on that account, are not used on that social media account. On the charity website, there's kind of this one-link rule, meaning that if the charity links to another website, the charity is actually responsible for the content on that other website, not in terms of whether it contains an electioneering message or not.

Tony MartignettiOh, oh, that's all right. That's harsh.

Gene TakagiSo you have to pay attention. So the general idea behind the rule is that, you know, I think any regulator would see past the ruse of saying, hey, we don't endorse political candidates, but link here and this will take you to, you know, one of the political party platforms, right? And not the other. So, and they wouldn't want you to say, oh, you know, that's just a link that's not on our page. We just included the link which has no, you know, electioneering message on it. Well, the one-link rule would say, no, you're responsible for the content on that other page. But you're right, it could be harsh because sometimes that link is to a 501 organization. And that 501 organization is allowed to engage in some political campaign activity so long as it's not their primary activity. But if it goes to the page of the 501 that has the political campaign sort of intervention message on it, Then the charity could be held responsible for it. And again, that would be a violation of the political campaign intervention rule. All

Tony Martignettiright. All right. You're responsible. You're responsible for other people's content when you link to it in this arena.

Gene TakagiI would be careful. I would say that there's probably less likelihood of any enforcement if it's something that is not intended to be an evergreen thing. So if it like is, Like a tweet and that link changes over time. I don't think anybody's going to go back and say 2 years ago you linked to this and now this link contains this electioneering message. I don't think that's the way it would be enforced. But if it's on your, your sort of active website and the link at the time that you created, you know, that website and, and published it had electioneering messages on it, then I would be a little bit concerned that that would be a violation of the rules.

Tony MartignettiYou mentioned, you were explaining about employees, you know, not allowed to use any of the organizational resources. What about employees wearing a hat or a button during, I don't know, during staff time, during an event? Staff time meaning working hours, you know, and they're in their office. Yeah. Doing it, not working hours and they're at home, but working hours and they're in their office or it's an event and they've got their election gear on.

Gene TakagiYes, I think that's a really sensitive area, right? Because we each have our First Amendment rights and we're each— I absolutely want to say individually, as individuals in our individual capacity, we have every right to endorse or oppose a candidate. for public office, every right to do so. But I said we shouldn't use organizational resources to do so. So what happens if you show up and you're wearing a Vote Blue or Vote Red or MAGA or whatever hat or t-shirt on and you go to work? Well, I think to the extent that you are representing the organization at work, especially if you have Any interface with the public, that would be a reason for a charity employer to say, no, that's in violation of the rules. This isn't, you know, a violation of your First Amendment rights. We're just saying, as an organizational representative to the public or to the public that we're serving, you cannot send that political message out because that looks like it's a political message being sent by our charity. So I think that is where you would enforce it and say, You can't do it. Now, if they're at home on a Zoom meeting with other employees, I have—

Tony MartignettiThat's a good one. That's a good one. Not public.

Gene TakagiYeah, I haven't seen any guidance on this. I would still feel slightly uncomfortable about it, but I wouldn't want to have to go to court to fight about that either. And I'm not sure that anybody would really care. But yeah, what if another employee said no, that, you know, I didn't want to see that and that has traumatized me? We're not, you know, we're not thinking about election-related materials. And, you know, does that, you know, give them the same authority to say, you know, everybody of this particular viewpoint should die on their t-shirt? Like, that's a First Amendment right to wear. Like, you could walk out to an amusement park to wear it. Right. I suppose, but Disneyland would probably throw you out, and maybe a charity employer would have the right to say, no, you can't wear that on the Zoom meeting either.

Tony MartignettiOkay. Okay. Anything else we haven't covered or you want to cover in more detail? This is our quadrennial chance.

Gene TakagiSure. So, you know, maybe talking about what is educational. Like, we're allowed to educate the public if we wanted to educate the public on climate change. Is that okay?

Tony MartignettiYeah, you mentioned, for instance, you mentioned voter guides.

Gene TakagiYeah, so, you know, we could have a voter guide, or maybe we're just having educational materials, just articles on our website or on our blog, and we, we have promotional activities about that. We hold conferences about it. We Do you know seminars or trainings about it? Can we do all those things? And of course, I think we know the answer is yes. There are a lot of organizations that are holding conferences and seminars on climate change. But when is it wrong to do that? And it's interesting. I think with climate change and the overwhelming scientific appeal. Opinion that climate change and human cause of climate change is a real thing, that that's not an issue. But it once was. I once got asked by the IRS agent who reviewed an application for 501 status about an organization sort of educational material about climate change, and they said, well, is this a full and fair exposition of all of the facts? Are you considering both sides? Because that's what educational means under 501. And I, I didn't think that was appropriate of that particular IRS agent even back then. But maybe 50 years ago, maybe that would have been a legitimate question when the scientific community wasn't as aware of those things, and maybe it could be seen as more of a wedge issue between candidates and a reason to promote one candidate over the other based on, you know, opinion rather than supported facts. And so educational activities, of course, charities should be you know, supporting their mission with educational communications out there. If, if it's gonna help them advance their mission, that's what they should do. And if they aim it at candidates, if they're aiming it at all candidates, I think that that's a fair thing to do as well. Now, if you're aiming certain educational communications only at the candidates that the charity leaders prefer in, in one way or the other, Now you may be engaged in sort of, again, this partisan viewpoint. You're providing resources to one candidate and not to others, even though you might think that, well, they're not going to read it or they're not going to agree with it anyway. The fact that you're not giving them the chance to use those resources, even if to attack them, might be seen as preferential and partisan and therefore a violation of 501.

Tony MartignettiOkay. Yep. There again, you're being biased. You said, you know, partisan. You're not doing it objectively. You're not doing it across the board. You're being selective.

Gene TakagiYeah. I think, you know, one other thing I wanted to sort of let the audience know about it is that there are other laws besides the 501 sort of tax exemption laws That can apply to lobbying or political activities. And so it may be a matter of taking a look at some of your state or local law resources on lobbying or political activities, as well as knowing the tax laws. And there's one great source right now that was just recently made available in all 50 states and DC. It's called State Law Resources Nonprofit Lobbying, and it's from The Alliance for Justice Boulder Advocacy. So the Alliance for Justice has a 501. They also have a 501 organization, which we didn't really talk about too much other than to say that they're allowed to engage in some political campaign intervention activities as long as it's not their primary activity. Well, there are organizations that have both the 501 and the 501 organization. They're at arm's length. Right. But they are affiliated. Alliance for Justice is one of those organizations, but their C3 has provided us some great resources, educational resources, nonpartisan, that talk about state law resources on nonprofit lobbying and go over not only the tax laws that we talked about, but some of the political and election laws that, that apply as well on the state level. And again, local laws may also apply. So you just want to check out those resources if you're going to. Yeah. Engage in significant lobbying or political activities.

Tony MartignettiGene, say the name of that resource again, the title of it.

Gene TakagiSo it's from the Alliance for Justice and it's called State Law Resources: Nonprofit Lobbying. State Law Resources: Nonprofit Lobbying. And there's a different guide for each state and for, for the District of Columbia.

Tony MartignettiYou know, we love free resources. Excellent. Okay. You feel like we've given this sufficient coverage until 2028?

Gene TakagiYeah, uh, other than to say go out and advocate for your mission, um, and make sure your boards are supporting that advocacy as well. You can do a lot more than you think.

Tony MartignettiGene Takagi, there you have it. You'll find him at Nonprofit Law Blog, which is nonprofitlawblog.com. And you'll find him, you'll find Gene at GTAK, G-T-A-K. Gene, thank you so much. Thanks for sharing your wisdom.

Gene TakagiThanks, Tony. It's always great to be on.

Kate MartignettiNext week, the generational divide. We thought that would be this week, but things don't always work out as planned. If you missed any part of this week's show, I beseech you, find it at tonymartignetti.com.

Tony MartignettiYou notice how I have Kate say, we thought this would be next week, so kind of, kind of makes it sound like it's her fault. Notice I didn't give the explanation. It's not her fault, but, uh, notice how I set her up that way.

Kate MartignettiWe're sponsored by DonorBox. Outdated donation forms blocking your supporters' generosity? DonorBox, fast, flexible, and friendly fundraising forms for your nonprofit. donorbox.org. And by Virtuous. Virtuous gives you the nonprofit CRM, fundraising, volunteer, and marketing tools you need to create more responsive donor experiences and grow giving. virtuous.org. Our creative producer is Claire Meyerhoff. I'm your associate producer, Kate Martignetti. The show's social media is by Susan Chavez. Marc Silverman is our web guy, and this music is by Scott Stein.

Tony MartignettiThank you for that affirmation, Scotty. Be with us next week for Nonprofit Radio, big nonprofit ideas for the other 95%. Go out and be great.

Nonprofit Radio